24

Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    6

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured
Page 2: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

Perspectives on Magic

Scientific Views on Theatrical Magic

Peter Prevos

ThirdHemisphere

Publishing

Page 3: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

c Peter Prevos (2013)

Third Hemisphere Publishing, Kangaroo Flat, Australia

thirdhemisphere.net

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0

Australia License. You are free to Share—to copy, distribute and transmit the

work under the following conditions:

b Attribution: You must attribute the work in the manner specified by the author

(but not in any way that suggests that they endorse you or your use of the work).

a Share Alike: If you alter, transform, or build upon this work, you may

distribute the resulting work only under the same or similar license to this one.

ISBN 978-0-9875669-1-1 Paperback

ISBN 978-0-9875669-2-8 eBook

Typeset in LATEX

Edited by Marissa Van Uden — MarissaVu.com

Cover design by Pair of Aces Design — PairOfAcesDesigns.com

Cover photo Vincent Giordano — Dreamstime.com

Page 4: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

Contents

Preface vWHY THIS BOOK?

Acknowledgements xWHO HELPED ME WRITE THIS BOOK?

1 Introduction 1WHAT IS MAGIC?

2 The Science of Magic 12HOW DOES MAGIC RELATE TO SCIENCE?

3 The Art of Magic 23IS MAGIC A PERFORMANCE ART?

4 Magic Networks 37WHAT IS IT LIKE TO BE A MAGICIAN?

iii

Page 5: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

iv

5 The History of Magic 54WHAT ROLE DID MAGICIANS PLAY IN THE PAST?

6 The Power of Magic 70WHAT IS THE PRACTICAL USE OF CONJURING?

7 The Magic of Teaching 81WHAT CAN WE LEARN FROM MAGIC TRICKS?

8 The Deception of Magic 97HOW CAN WE BE SO EASILY BE DECEIVED?

9 The Future of Magic 112WILL MAGIC BECOME OBSOLETE?

10 Epilogue 124WHAT IS THE SCIENCE OF MAGIC?

Bibliography 134

www.magicperspectives.net

Page 6: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

Preface

WHY THIS BOOK?

For as long as I can remember, performing magic has been a partof my life. To be more precise, I am an occasional conjurer anduse sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being areal magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy inthe Netherlands. I devoured books from the local library, collectedmagic sets from the toy shop, and constantly attempted to amazefriends and family. My passion for magic was unrelenting in thoseearly years, and I showed magic tricks to anyone who was interestedand, in my enthusiasm, also to those who were not. I performedin many local talent contests and at family birthday parties and evensome paid performances. Magic was, however, not the career I choseto follow.

After completing an engineering degree I took on a job that al-lowed me to travel to exotic places where communication was of-ten complicated by language barriers. In those situations, magictricks and balloon animals were the perfect tool to overcome thesebarriers and make instant friends. Soon after I started my careerI achieved my personal goals in engineering and began a degree

v

Page 7: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

Why this book? vi

in philosophy to study the mysteries of existence. Because of allthe serious thought involved with this study, I became disillusionedwith the triviality of magic. I was no longer able to see the meaningof conjuring beyond the mundane trickery and clichés employed bymagicians.

Much of magic has a “look at me” aspect, and it can be anegocentric performance art. In retrospect, I was disillusioned be-cause at that time I did not have sufficient insight to move beyondthe stereotypes. As such, I replaced my passion for magic with apassion for philosophy and completed a degree in this subject. Itwas only years later that I realised that my interest in philosophywas actually strongly related to my interest in magic, and that magicis an inherently philosophical performance art. I read some books onthe history of magic which described the connection between magictricks and divination and other esoteric practices. I began to realisethat the ancient shaman, the tribal philosopher, was also a conjurer,a master of sleight-of-hand.

A magic performance is in essence a theatrical experience thatchallenges reality as we know it, which is an inherent philosoph-ical quality. Magic challenges the mind in a way that no otherperformance art can. My passion was rekindled when I discoveredthe works of Jay Sankey, Tommy Wonder, Eugene Burger and JeffMcBride, some of the magicians that inspired me the most. Theirwork displays a passion and a philosophical understanding of the-atrical magic that takes it beyond mere trickery. Reading their booksand watching their videos renewed my enthusiasm for this quaintperformance art.

I still occasionally perform magic shows, but now my main in-terest in magic stems from what it can teach us about ourselves andabout the world around us. My passion for academic research has

www.magicperspectives.net

Page 8: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

Why this book? vii

never waned, and at the time of completing this book I am a PhDcandidate at La Trobe University in Melbourne, researching organ-isational culture and customer service. Being a graduate studentprovides me access to the ivory tower of academia and its immenseknowledge networks. During my research I discovered an article byprofessors Terence Krell and Joseph Dobson from Western IllinoisUniversity, advocating the use of magic tricks to teach theories oforganisational behaviour. This started me on a quest to establish anannotated bibliography of scientific and professional literature re-lated to conjuring. To my pleasant surprise I uncovered a vast num-ber of journal articles and scholarly books that discussed magic frommany different perspectives. Studying magic scientifically started atthe end of the nineteenth century with psychology experiments. Thelast few decades there has been a renaissance of scholarly researchinto magic, with publications in many different fields of science.

The idea to write this book came to me when I discovered thatanyone not formally associated with academia can be charged morethan thirty dollars to purchase a short article from an academic jour-nal. This places access to much academic knowledge outside thereach of most people. It is unfortunate that the collective knowledgeof the world is locked up behind ironclad copyright contracts andis not available freely to the taxpayers who funded much of thisresearch. Another motivation to write this book is that science issometimes just as esoteric as magic. Scientific knowledge is of-ten shrouded in an obscure language that is only comprehensible tothose initiated in its traditions, and each field of science is a subcul-ture with its own language and methods. The main purpose of thisbook is to unlock the literature on theatrical magic to non-scientistswho are interested in this ancient performance art. My objective inwriting this book is to show that theatrical magic has much to offer

www.magicperspectives.net

Page 9: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

Why this book? viii

beyond frivolous entertainment. This book is an attempt to unlockthe professional and scientific literature on conjuring for those withan interest in deceptive theatre.

In order to provide a broad understanding of the art of conjuring,this book contains the collective musings of a wide range of pro-fessionals and academics, including teachers, psychologists, occu-pational therapists, mathematicians, and sociologists. Magic tricksare used by health care professionals to aid them in rehabilitationprograms, by teachers to illustrate principles of science, and by psy-chologists to better understand how the mind works. Magic researchalso provides a unique perspective on cultural history, and in recentyears there has been a steady stream of scholarly works interpretingthe role of magicians in society. Studying this extensive collection ofliterature about magic has uncovered many interesting insights intomagic, its past, present and possible future as a performance art.

Given the variety of scientific subjects covered in these pages,this book is also an enquiry into the nature of science itself. The re-search described in this book shows that there is no such thing as the

science of magic but that artful deception can be investigated frommany diverse angles of human enquiry, ranging from the humanitiesand psychology to software engineering and nursing. My journeythrough the wide variety of literature available on this subject taughtme that only a multidisciplinary study can provide a meaningfulunderstanding of a social phenomenon such as magic. Each fieldof intellectual endeavour provides a unique perspective on magic asan art form, as a psychological curiosity or as a means to achievepractical goals beyond entertainment.

In contrast to most other books about magic, this book does notcontain any descriptions of how to perform magic tricks. There areno explanations of new ‘moves’ to make a card change from black

www.magicperspectives.net

Page 10: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

Why this book? ix

to red, no ‘sleights’ to make a coin disappear, like is usually the casein books about magic. One chapter is dedicated to why magic trickswork, but not discuss any details on how they work. This book hasbeen written for both experienced magicians and people with onlya passive interest in magic. My aim is to provide magicians witha deeper understanding of their craft and to inspire them to keepevolving the performance of magic. For people with only a passiveinterest in magic, this books aims to provide insights into a quaintperformance art that is generally surrounded in secrecy and muffledby clichés, without breaking the magician’s code.

Magic and science have in common that they both are drivenby questions. The inherent nature of scientific research means thatwith every answer many new questions arise. It is my hope that thisanthology of the existing literature on the science of conjuring willraise new questions and spawn further research into this fascinatingperformance art.

Peter Prevos, Kangaroo Flat, May 2013.

www.magicperspectives.net

Page 11: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

Acknowledgements

WHO HELPED ME WRITE THIS BOOK?

This project has taken me almost four years to complete and wouldhave been impossible to publish this book without the help of oth-ers. I owe a gratitude to the many scholars in different fields thathave taken the effort to publish papers and books on a niche subjectsuch as theatrical magic. I also need to acknowledge the manyanonymous subjects of experiments conducted by psychologists andoccupational therapists. They are the unsung heroes of some of theresearch described in this book.

My magician friends from Melbourne and overseas have beenvery supportive during this long project, and although many mayhave wondered whether this book would ever be published, theircontinued interest is what sustained my motivation to keep workingon this book. Thanks to Tom Stevens for his permission to useone of his Facebook updates. Also, a special mention for Alexde la Rambelje, who gave me invaluable feedback on my thoughtsabout magic and let me use his university thesis on the theatricalaspects of magic performance. The invaluable feedback providedby magicians Nicholas, The Honest Con Man, Johnson, Gary Co-

x

Page 12: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

Who helped me write this book? xi

hen and Brendan Croft, all from Melbourne, and Tony Barnhart, acognitive scientist and magician from Phoenix, and Fritz (with a Z)from Amsterdam, kept me motivated to continue working on thisproject. Also a word of thanks to my wife Sue, who was so kindto proofread the text and had to endure conversations with me frombehind a laptop screen.

This book was edited by Marissa van Uden, my secret weaponin completing this project. It is only through her insightful feedbackand critical reading of my drafts that I was able to transition an oth-erwise tedious annotated bibliography into a readable book. Lastly,my thanks to Susan Hobbs of Pair of Aces Design for her patiencewith me in designing the cover for this book and the artwork for theassociated website.

www.magicperspectives.net

Page 13: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

Chapter 1

Introduction

WHAT IS MAGIC?

The magician introduces three cups and three balls. Using a magicwand, he commands the balls to dematerialise from his bare handsand rematerialise under the cups. The balls seem possessed by super-natural powers as they appear, disappear and penetrate solid matterat the mere whim of the magician. This supernatural choreographyends with pieces of fruit appearing under the cups where the ballsonce were. The spectators applaud after witnessing this ancientmiracle. Although they are impressed and entertained, a naggingthought lingers in their minds: How did he do it?

Among the spectators is a group of university colleagues whoreflect on what they just experienced. They enjoyed the show asmuch as everyone else, but they have very different questions thanthe rest of the audience. The psychologist wonders how it is possiblethat his mind was so easily deceived by the performer. How can it bethat we are tricked to be seeing something that contradicts our com-

1

Page 14: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

What is magic? 2

mon sense view of the world? The psychologist’s friend, a professorin humanities also enjoyed the show. She wonders how the fruitappeared under the cups, but also ponders the cultural significanceof magic and the reasons it has remained popular for millennia andacross different cultures. Her husband, who works as an occupa-tional therapist at the local hospital, is also an amateur magician.He contemplates the incredible hand-eye coordination and musclecontrol required to perform the trick he just saw, and he wondersif magic tricks could be used in occupational therapy. Meanwhile,another magician sitting in the back of the room has a very differ-ent perspective. Although she is fully aware of how the performerdirected the attention of the spectators and used sleight-of-hand tocreate the illusion of magic, she was nevertheless impressed and en-tertained by the performance, in particular by the flawless executionof the Vernon Wand Spin and other technical manoeuvres. She iseven more impressed by how the performer was able to hold thespectator’s attention with his beautifully executed choreography andenthralling presentation.

I I I I

This anecdote illustrates how the performance of magic tricks canhave very different meanings to different spectators, depending ontheir personal perspective. It also shows that the question of how

a magic trick is done and what specific techniques have been usedto create illusions is only one of many questions that may be raisedin the minds of the audience during a magic performance. In thefollowing chapters, we will explore the many facets of conjuringand discuss the many questions raised by scientists and professionalsfrom diverse areas of expertise. But before we can delve into theirresearch, we need to define what it is that magicians actually do andreview the different interpretations of what constitutes magic.

www.magicperspectives.net

Page 15: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

What is magic? 3

The relationship between magic and science is a complex one.On the one hand they are considered each other’s opposites, whileon the other hand they can be seen as stages in a continuum of humanknowledge. The word ‘magic’ is usually reserved for anything thatcontradicts what we consider to be the laws of nature. Some adopta less confrontational view and think that the difference betweenmagic and science is related to a lack of knowledge. This confusionis as least partly created because the word ‘magic’ can be used indifferent ways. The meanings of words, especially those ingrainedin the cultural fabric of society, evolve as the values that underpin theculture change. Magic is, in the words of philosopher Walter Gal-lie, an essentially contested concept: terms that describe a complexaspect of humanity (such as ‘culture’ and ‘religion’), that are ladenwith value and whose meanings can be debated at length without afinal definition ever being agreed upon.

There are three ways of looking at essentially contested conceptssuch as magic. The dogmatic view places magic in diametricalopposition to science. A belief in magic is usually seen as a rejectionof science and vice versa, thinking scientifically as a rejection ofmagic. This is the view of many scientists who use the term ‘magicalthinking’ to refer to theories that are contrary to the principles of sci-entific thinking, such as astrology and homoeopathy. In the sceptical

point of view, no claim to truth is made, and magic and science areseen as equally subjective personal perspectives. It should be notedthat the philosophical use of the word ‘scepticism’ in this context isdifferent to that used by the many sceptic societies. In philosophicalscepticism, all claims to truth are considered equally invalid, bothmagical and scientific. The popular sceptic societies, such as theCommittee for Skeptical Inquiry or the Skeptics Society, are notphilosophically sceptical as they only question paranormal theories

www.magicperspectives.net

Page 16: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

What is magic? 4

and assume the primacy of science. However, neither the dogmaticview nor the sceptical view is insightful regarding the relationshipbetween magic and science. Both lead to either diametrically op-posed views, where one side aims to annihilate the other, or to ni-hilistic views devoid of all meaning. Gallie’s third option, an eclectic

view of magic, gives credence to both magic and science as validaspects of the human experience and as ways to make sense of theworld. In this interpretation, magic and science don’t compete witheach other but are complementary world views. The eclectic view ismore productive because using value judgements for either scienceor magic prevents a full understanding of magic as a phenomenonof human culture. Magic has always been an integral part of humanculture; it still plays an important role and will, despite advancesin science, continue to do so in the future. What is perceived to beeither magical or scientific will, however, change continuously alongwith cultural perspectives.

The discourse on science versus magic is complicated by the factthat the word ‘magic’ itself is deceptive. This simple word can beused to describe different aspects of the human experience. Theword ‘magic’ can refer to either the theatrical illusion of magic orsupernatural magic. The often paraphrased definition of a theatricalmagician by the nineteenth-century French conjuring legend JeanEugène Robert-Houdin illustrates this duplicity: “A magician is anactor playing the role of a magician”. This quote has been citedby numerous magicians to remind themselves that showmanship istantamount in a good magic act. However, if it wasn’t for the doublemeaning of the word ‘magic’, this sentence would be a tautology:a statement that explains nothing. It would be like saying that ascientist is an actor playing a scientist. The magician seems to beboth a pretender and a real magician, both the deceiving conjurer and

www.magicperspectives.net

Page 17: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

What is magic? 5

the powerful wizard. A more precise version of Robert-Houdin’sdefinition can be found in an 1877 translation of the phrase by En-glish magician Professor Hoffman: “A conjurer is not a juggler; heis an actor playing the part of a magician”. Before the eighteenthcentury, before science became the dominant source of knowledgein Western culture, the word ‘magic’ was reserved for the ‘dark arts’or witchcraft. The terms ‘juggling’ or ‘legerdemain’ were used todescribe the performing of innocent conjuring tricks by entertainerspretending to be magicians. As the belief in the metaphysical foun-dations of magic began to wane, so did the distinction between su-pernatural and theatrical magic, until eventually the words ‘juggling’and ‘legerdemain’ faded from the English language, with respectto references to magic. The more specific terms, such as ‘conjur-ing’, ‘legerdemain’ and ‘sleight-of-hand’ are still used in theatricalmagic circles, but rarely used in common language. The distinctionbetween the entertainer and the true magician has, however, beenmaintained in other European languages. For example, the Dutchword ‘goochelaar’, which has the same origin as the word juggler,is used specifically for a person pretending to be a magician to en-tertain people. The English language is unfortunately burdened withusing the same term for wholly different concepts.

The contemporary uses of the word ‘magic’—referring to eithertheatrical conjuring or supernatural magic—are quite distinct fromeach other, and the proponents of each type of magic form theirown subcultures. Theatrical conjurers tend to meet in magic clubsand share their secrets through conventions, books and more re-cently through video and on-demand Internet videos. The believersin supernatural magic also enjoy meeting regularly to share infor-mation. Modern day witches organise themselves in covens andtheir community has spawned a cottage industry of instant spells,

www.magicperspectives.net

Page 18: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

What is magic? 6

instruction books and courses on how to control your life throughthese forces. Although both subcultures are based on the idea ofmagic, they are quite distinct from each other. One major differenceis that conjurers tend to be sceptical of supernatural explanations.Research conducted by Peter Nardi, emeritus professor of sociologyand regular author on conjuring-related matters (not to be confusedwith a magician of the same name) showed that magic performersare more sceptical about the existence of magical phenomena thanthe general public, and by extension even more sceptical than thosewho follow New Age beliefs.

If a conjurer is an actor playing the part of a magician, thenwhat is it that magicians claim to actually do? Attempts to definemagic in strict terms have not been very successful, and there existsa myriad of theories explaining what magic is. According to theanthropological view a belief in magic is the belief that supernaturalforces can be invoked by a qualified person (such as a shaman ormagician) through the power of spoken words or the appropriateactions, usually performed as part of a ritual. Magic in this sensecontrasts with scientific theories. Science is deeply rooted in thephilosophy of cause and effect and focuses on material causes thateventuate without interference of the scientist. Science is an imper-sonal and passive philosophy, while magic is based on active humaninteraction with metaphysical powers. It is in this aspect that magicand science seem diametrically opposed.

An alternative view was proposed by English science-fiction wri-ter Arthur C. Clarke, who considers magic and science as parts alongthe same continuum of human experience. He expressed this suc-cinctly in his Third Law of Prediction, which states that “Any suf-ficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic”. InClarke’s interpretation, the demarcation between magic and science

www.magicperspectives.net

Page 19: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

What is magic? 7

is not a fixed point; rather, it moves depending on the level of sci-entific knowledge of the person experiencing the magic. The ThirdLaw carries in it a presumption that magic will be increasingly eclip-sed by science as the level of knowledge about the universe in-creases. All magic is, in this sense, reduced to science that hasnot yet been made intelligible. For example, appliances that arecommonplace in a contemporary house, such as a vacuum cleaneror microwave, would most certainly seem magical to a housewifeof the nineteenth century. The Third Law portrays an optimisticview of science in the sense that it will progress towards a completeexplanation of the world around us. However, Clarke is wrong toplace magic and science along the same continuum. Magic is notin opposition with science or an extension of science, because theyboth seek answers to different questions. Supernatural magic is abelief system that aims to provide answers to questions related tothe meaning of things, while science is a system of knowledge thatseeks to explain things, their origins, functions and so on. Magicprovides an answer to the question ‘why?’, while science providesexplanations and answers to the question ‘how?’ Science and magicare, as such, not incompatible with each other but complementaryaspects of the human experience.

The position one might take in the discourse of magic versusscience does not actually matter. Magic, as a supernatural occur-rence, might or might not exist factually, it most certainly exists ina cultural sense. For those with a belief in magic it is a vehicle toprovide meaning to their lives. The key to understanding magic as ahuman phenomenon is neither to explain magic as an alternative toscience nor to discount it as irrational nonsense, but to understand itas an integral phenomenon of human existence. By viewing magicas a normal part of human culture instead of a physical phenomenon

www.magicperspectives.net

Page 20: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

What is magic? 8

that needs to be explained, we can form a much richer understandingof social reality. Magic provides the hope that the unrelenting andunpredictable forces of the natural world can be overcome. In thissense magic shares a purpose with science and technology, in thattheir purpose is also to make the world more understandable andcontrollable.

I I I I

Besides the duplicitous meaning of the word ‘magic’ as either asupernatural occurrence or a form of entertainment, the word is alsoused for something that causes astonishment, even when obviouslycaused by explainable physical processes. Magician Paul Harris seesastonishment as our natural state of mind; he associates it with achild’s mind-set in which there is little knowledge of the world andeverything is magical. This mind-set is the reason that performingmagic tricks for children below four years of age is difficult: theydo not perceive the presented reality as special because, to them, thewhole world is already magical.

The word ‘magic’ is often used in advertising to communicatethat a product has properties beyond what can normally be expected.Numerous gadgets, such as self-inflating balloons, cloths with aston-ishing absorption rates and numerous others, are called ‘magic’ bymarketers because they possess properties that appear miraculous.A search in the American trademark register reveals thousands ofentries that use the word ‘magic’. For example, a company produc-ing herbal nutritional supplements uses the name Jungle Magic™to communicate the idea that their herbs have properties beyond theregular garden herbs, and a series of cooking appliances sell underthe name of Cook Magic™. Using the word ‘magic’ in the brandingof products and services taps directly into the human desire for amagical world where mundane activities can be undertaken almost

www.magicperspectives.net

Page 21: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

What is magic? 9

effortlessly. Just as primal cultures believe magic can help to ensurea bountiful hunt, modern day marketers use magic in their hunt fornew consumers.

Another range of products in this category are ‘magic’ toys de-signed around natural processes that seem magical to the casualobserver. For example, levitating rings that use magnetic repulsionto defy gravity, or a set of concave mirrors that creates the illusionof a coin that is so realistic people try to pick it up. English physicsteacher David Featonby laments this use of the word ‘magic’ in thesecases. He writes that it hides the fact that these so-called magicaltoys are based on known principles of physics: “Take the mysteryout of physics, but leave the wonder”, is his advice. Featonby dis-tinguishes between two types of magic: the first is sleight-of-handand trickery, or conjuring; the second is hidden science, which relieson the audience having no full grasp of the science involved. Giventhat most people are not aware of the science behind the illusions—or do not experience similar effects in their daily lives—the toys areconsidered magical because they cause astonishment. For practisingmagicians, however, there is no difference between these two typesof magic: both sleight-of-hand and hidden science are consideredvalid methods of creating the illusion of magic.

The final way the word ‘magic’ can be used is to describe thequality of an experience. Watching films or plays or walking ina forest can be ‘a magical experience’, meaning that these expe-riences have an ephemeral quality, a feeling that only poets canreconstruct in words. Magicians may try to invoke this feeling intheir audience through their theatrical performance. For example,Australian magician Raymond Crowe creates a mesmerising displayof shadows on a projection screen using nothing but his hands anda spotlight. Although no deception is used to hide the method by

www.magicperspectives.net

Page 22: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

What is magic? 10

which the shadows are created, the audience often describe seeinghis performance as a “magical experience”. He also uses mimeto enhance the magical illusions that he crafts on stage. Crowemasterfully manipulates a ball to create the illusion that it is floatingwhile never really letting go of the ball with his hand. Through hisperformance, Crowe emphasises the narrative of a floating ball thattries to escape from him, not the impossibility of the method. Crowe,who calls himself an ’unusualist’ instead of a magician, expressedthe magical nature of his art in a lecture to a group of magicians inLas Vegas: “The older I get, the more I like magic that is not a trick”.

I I I I

Magicians use the word magic in all four of the previously describedinterpretations: to describe their performance art as well as to in-dicate the supernatural world they are simulating. Magicians notonly create the illusion of magic in the supernatural sense of theword but also create a sense of astonishment through their theatricalperformance and provide audiences with experiences that have amagical quality. In this book the words ‘magic’ and ‘conjuring’ areused interchangeably in the context of theatrical magic, which is thecraft of creating illusions. Theatrical magic is the performance artwhich blurs the boundaries between magic and science. Althoughspectators are most often placed in the frame of the scientist and askthemselves how the magic is performed, as a performance art magichas the ability to shift those questions to why it is possible that theyhave occurred.

The following chapters of this book cover the work done by themany scholars who have written about theatrical magic in an attemptto better understand magic as a performance art itself and how theperformance of magic tricks helps us understand human behaviour.The essence of science is asking questions, and in this book some of

www.magicperspectives.net

Page 23: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

What is magic? 11

the answers to the questions that can be asked about theatrical magicare described. Is magic a performance art or simply a playful form ofdeception? What is it like to be a magician? What role did magiciansplay in society of the past? What is the practical purpose of magicand what can we learn from magic tricks? And, the question mostoften asked by scientists, how it is possible that we can be so easilydeceived?

The answers to these questions not only provide a range of per-spectives on magic, they also provide an insight into the diversity ofthe sciences. This books shows that there is no such thing as the sci-ence of magic. There is no single science of magic but rather variousscientific perspectives on magic, and these perspectives leave manyquestions still left unanswered. The final question asked in this bookis about the future of magic itself. Will magic slowly disappear astechnology renders all miracles common, as predicted by Clarke’sThird Law of Prediction, or will there always be a role for peoplewho are able to entertain through artful deception?

www.magicperspectives.net

Page 24: Perspectives on Magic...use sleight-of-hand and other forms of deception to feign being a real magician. I started adding magic to my life as a schoolboy in the Netherlands. I devoured

When people watch a magician create illusions, thequestion that is most pressing on their minds is: howdid he do it?. This is not the only question that canbe asked of a magic performance. A psychologistmight ask why it is possible that the mind can bedeceived, occupational therapists are interested inhow performing magic tricks can help people withphysical disabilities and sociologists research thesubculture of magicians.

This book explores the questions that scholars fromdifferent fields of science have asked about theperformances of magicians. For magicians this bookprovides new perspectives on their performance art.For people with a passive interest in magic, thisbook provides an insight into a quaint performanceart that is normally surrounded in secrecy andclichés.

Peter Prevos is a social scientist and engineer whoalso dabbles in magic.

magicperspectives.net