Phaedra Parks Sues Vibe For Defamation

7/31/2019 Phaedra Parks Sues Vibe For Defamation

1/29

TKH\DL ]\@\D LH]\^HM\ MGT^\KG^\BD^K LH]\^HM\ GC ODGÔH@

@\I@K\@ LHSH]HGK

VB@DL^@ M+ V@Â]) ((

Vi`hk|hcc) (( M`}d Kg+ WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW

s+ (( \^H@I NX JT^X LDE@KLDL

SHND BGILHKO]) IIM) ((

Ldcdkl`k|+ (

MGEVI@HK\ CG^ LDC@E@\HGK

MGED] KG_ Vi`hk|hcc) Vb`dl~` M+ V`~a}) `kl ~d}vdm|ctiix }|`|d} bd~

Mgevi`hk| cg~ Ldcè`|hgk ò`hk}| Ldcdkl`k|) Shnd Bgilhko}) IIM) `} cgiigw}:

HK\^GLTM\HGK

0+ \bh} Mgevi`hk| `~h}d} c~ge vtnihm`|hgk nx Ldcdkl`k| gc eti|hvid cì}d`kl ldcè`|g~x }|`|dedk|} gc `kl mgkmd~khko Vb`dl~` M+ V`~a}+

>+ \bd cì}d `kl ldcè`|g~x }|`|dedk|} vtnih}bdl nx Ldcdkl`k|mgksdxdl |g |bd `sd~òd ih}|dkd~ g~ ~d`ld~ |b`| Vi`hk|hcc h} ` m~hehkì) othi|x gc

`m|hsd v`~|hmhv`|hgk hk kted~gt} cdigkx m~hed}+

=+ \bd cì}d `kl ldcè`|g~x `mmt}`|hgk} wd~d vtnih}bdl gkihkd |godkd~`|d hk|d~d}| hk) `kl hkm~d`}d }ìd} gc) ` }tn}dptdk|ix vtnih}bdl ngga nx

Ldcdkl`k| |b`| wgtil ~dvd`| `kl drv`kl gk |bd gkihkd }|`|dedk|}+

M`}d 0:0>%eh%88888%TK@ Lgmtedk| 06>< Chidl 64'>>'0> Vòd 0 gc >8


2/29

>

%eh%88888%TK@ Lgmtedk| 06>< Chidl 64'>>'0> V`od > gc >8


3/29

=

8+ Ldcdkl`k|) Shnd Bgilhko}) IIM "Shnd() h} ` mg~vg~`|hgk g~o`khzdl`kl drh}|hko tkld~ |bd i`w} gc |bd ]|`|d gc Ldi`w`~d wh|b h|} v~hkmhvì vi`md gc

nt}hkd}} ndhko igm`|dl `| >8 D`}| 08|b ]|~dd|) >kl Cigg~) Kdw Xg~a) KX 0666=+

06+ @egko h|} mg~vg~`|d `m|hsh|hd}) Ldcdkl`k| gwk}) gvd~`|d}) `klmgk|~gi} Shnd+mge) Tv|gwk Eò`zhkd) `kl @tot}|t} Vtnih}bhko+

JT^H]LHM\HGK @KL SDKTD

00+ Vi`hk|hcc h} ` mh|hzdk gc |bd ]|`|d gc Odg~oh` cg~ vt~vg}d} gc lhsd~}h|xjt~h}lhm|hgk tkld~ >2 T+]+M+ 0==>+

0>+ Ldcdkl`k| h} ` mh|hzdk gc Ldi`w`~d g~ Kdw Xg~a cg~ vt~vg}d} gclhsd~}h|x jt~h}lhm|hgk tkld~ >2 T+]+M+ 0==>+

0=+ \bh} Mgt~| b`} g~hohkì }tnjdm| e`||d~ jt~h}lhm|hgk gc |bh} `m|hgkvt~}t`k| |g >2 T+]+M+ 0==> `} |bd~d drh}|} mgevid|d lhsd~}h|x gc mh|hzdk}bhv

nd|wddk Vi`hk|hcc `kl Ldcdkl`k| `kl |bd ègtk| hk mgk|~gsd~}x drmddl} ]dsdk|x

Chsd \bgt}`kl Lgii`~} ",?4)666+66() drmit}hsd gc hk|d~d}| `kl mg}|}+

02T+]+M+ 0==>+

04+ Sdktd h} v~gvd~ hk |bh} Mgt~| vt~}t`k| |g >2 T+]+M+ 0=80+

M`}d 0:0>%eh%88888%TK@ Lgmtedk| 06>< Chidl 64'>>'0> Vòd = gc >8


4/29


5/29

4

_gedk gc Hkcitdkmd nx |bd @|i`k|` Nt}hkd}} Idòtd "Cìi >606() edend~}bhv |g

|bd Id`ld~}bhv @|i`k|` Mi`}} gc >668) edend~}bhv |g |bd Gt|}|`klhko @|i`k|`

Mi`}} gc >662) ~dmgokh|hgk hk ` cd`|t~d mgsd~ }|g~x hk ]tvd~ I`wxd~} Eò`zhkd `} `

]tvd~ I`wxd~ ^h}hko ]|`~ "Cìi >66?() ~dmgokh|hgk `} gkd gc |bd \gv >4 Eg}|

Hkcitdk|hì _gedk hk ^giihko Gt| Eò`zhkd ">663() ~dmgokh|hgk `} ` Odg~oh`

^h}hko ]|`~ ]tvd~ I`wxd~ hk @|i`k|` Eò`zhkd ">664() `kl ~dmgokh|hgk `} `k

@||g~kdx gc Lh}|hkm|hgk hkJdzdndi Eò zhkd ">664(+

>0+ Vi`hk|hcc b`} kdsd~ nddk `~~d}|dl cg~ ` m~hed g~ mb`~odl wh|b `kxm~hed+

>>+ Vi`hk|hcc b`} kdsd~ nddk ptd}|hgkdl nx `kx i`w dkcg~mdedk| òdkmx g~g~o`khz`|hgk `ngt| vg}}hnid hksgisdedk| hk `kx m~hed+

>=+ Vi`hk|hcc e`~~hdl @vgiig Khl` hk Kgsdend~ gc >668) `kl |god|bd~ |bdxb`sd ` }gk) òd |wg+

>4+ Gkd gc Vi`hk|hcc} mdidn~h|x mihdk|} w`} `k @|i`k|` ~`vvd~ akgwk `}L~è`+

>3+ Vi`hk|hcc ~dv~d}dk|dl L~è` cg~ ` v~gn`|hgk shgi`|hgk hk Mi`x|gkMgtk|x hk |bd ]v~hko gc >666+



6/29

3

>?+ @~gtkl Kgsdend~ gc >666 hk ` |didvbgkd mgksd~}`|hgk) L~è`hk|~gltmdl Vi`hk|hcc |g @kodi` ]|`k|gk) bh} oh~ic~hdkl `| |bd |hed "]|`k|gk(+

>2+ _bhid L~è` w`} hkm`~md~`|dl hk i`|d >666 `kl d`~ix >660) Vi`hk|hcchk|d~eh||dk|ix hk|d~`m|dl wh|b ]|`k|gk+

>8+ Tvgk L~è`} ~did`}d c~ge j`hi hk `vv~grhe`|dix J`kt`~x gc >660)Vi`hk|hcc b`l kg ct~|bd~ mgeetkhm`|hgk} g~ hk|d~`m|hgk} wh|b ]|`k|gk tk|hi

`vv~grhe`|dix Jtix >666666< tk|hi }ged|hed hk >664 wbdk ]|`k|gk `kl'g~ bd~

n~g|bd~ mgk|`m|dl Vi`hk|hcc }ddahko bd~ `}}h}|`kmd |g b`sd ]|`k|gk |~`k}vg~|dl c~ge

v~h}gk |g bd~ eg|bd~} ctkd~ì+

=>+ Vi`hk|hcc b`} kdsd~ b`l `kx cg~eì g~ hkcg~eì devigxedk|~di`|hgk}bhv wh|b ]|`k|gk+

==+ Vi`hk|hcc b`} kdsd~ v`~|hmhv`|dl hk `kx m~hehkì `m|hsh|hd} wh|b ]|`k|gk+=


7/29

?

=3+ @~gtkl Cdn~t`~x gc >606) ]|`k|gk ndo`k ` vd~}gkì m~t}`ld gc cì}d`||`ma} ò`hk}| Vi`hk|hcc+

=?+ ]vdmhchmìix) ]|`k|gk ndo`k vg}|hko cì}d `kl ldcè`|g~x `mmt}`|hgk}`ngt| Vi`hk|hcc gk \wh||d~ `kl g|bd~wh}d e`ld cì}d `kl ldcè`|g~x }|`|dedk|}

`ngt| bd~ |g |bh~l vd~}gk} hk |bd mgeetkh|x+

=2+ Hk E`~mb gc |bh} xd`~) Ldcdkl`k| vtnih}bdl `kl v~geg|dl ]|`k|gk}cì}d `kl ldcè`|g~x `mmt}`|hgk} gk |bd Hk|d~kd| `kl `} ` lh~dm| ~d}ti|) ]|`k|gk}

vd~}gkì `kl tkcgtkldl sdkld||` ò`hk}| Vi`hk|hcc wdk| sh~ì gk |bd Hk|d~kd|+

=8+ Ldcdkl`k| hk|d~shdwdl ]|`k|gk `kl n~g`lm`}| bd~ cì}d `klldcè`|g~x `mmt}`|hgk} hk `~|hmid} `kl shldg} gk h|} wdn}h|d}+

< Chidl 64'>>'0> Vòd ? gc >8


8/29

2

M@T]D GC @M\HGK CG^ LDC@E@\HGK

V`od 2 gc >8


9/29

8


10/29

06

Vb`dl~` |gil ed |b`| wd }bgtil v~gmddl wh|b wb`| wd b`l Q~do`~lhko|bd sdbhmid v~gjdm|U+ ]g wd idc| |b`| kdr| eg~khko bd`ldl |g \dkkd}}dd

wh|b |b~dd gc |bd itrt~x sdbhmid}) `kl |bh} h} wbd~d H w`} `~~d}|dl+

40+ \bd E`~mb 0< `~|hmid} `kl hk|d~shdw hk |bdh~ dk|h~d|x mgk}|h|t|d ihndi`kl'g~ }i`kld~vd~ }d hk |b`| |bdx hevt|d m~hehkì `m|hsh|x |g Vi`hk|hcc+

4>+ \bd E`~mb 0< `~|hmid} `kl hk|d~shdw hk |bdh~ dk|h~d|x mgk}|h|t|d ihndi`kl'g~ }i`kld~ vd~ }d hk |b`| |bdx hevt|d `m|hgk} |g Vi`hk|hcc |b`| hkjt~d bd~

v~gcd}}hgkì nt}hkd}} ~dvt|`|hgk+

4=+ \bd E`~mb 0< `~|hmid} `kl hk|d~shdw hk |bdh~ dk|h~d|x mgk}|h|t|d ihndi`kl'g~ }i`kld~ vd~ }d hk |b`| |bdx hevt|d `m|hgk} |g Vi`hk|hcc |b`| `~d ldcè`|g~x

`kl hkjt~hgt} |g bd~ ~dvt|`|hgk gk h|} c`md `kl m`k nd }g tkld~}|ggl wh|bgt|

~dcd~dkmd |g `kx `llh|hgkì g~ dr|~hk}hm c`m|}+

\bd E`~mb 03 @~|hmid} `kl Hk|d~shdw

460>) Ldcdkl`k| vtnih}bdl `k `~|hmid dk|h|idl)^dì Bgt}dwhsd} gc @|i`k|` ]|`~ Drvg}dl V`~| HH) wbhmb hkmitldl ` shldg

hk|d~shdw wh|b @kodi` ]|`k|gk+ \bd E`~mb 03 `~|hmid `kl hk|d~shdw wd~d

vtnih}bdl `| b||v:''www+shndshrdk+mge'>60>'6='~dì%bgt}dwhsd}%gc%`|i`k|`%}|`~%

drvg}dl%v`~|%hh%drmit}hsd%}|`|dedk|%c~ge%`kodi`%}|`k|gk' kl `~d }|hii `mmd}}hnid |g

|bd vtnihm `} gc |bd l`|d gc |bd chihko gc |bh} Mgevi`hk|+ @ }hehi`~ `~|hmid `kl

hk|d~shdw} wd~d vtnih}bdl `| b||v:''tv|gwkeò`zhkd+mge'>60>'6='`t|bg~%`kodi`%



11/29

00

}|`k|gk%~dsdì}%bd~%m~hehkì%hksgisdedk|%wh|b%~bg`}%vb`dl~`%v`~a}%hk%`%m~hehkì%

dk|d~v~h}d'`kl `~d }|hii `mmd}}hnid |g |bd vtnihm `} gc |bd l`|d gc |bd chihko gc |bh}

Mgevi`hk|

44+ @ |~td `kl mg~~dm| mgvx gc |bd E`~mb 03 `~|hmid} `~d `||`mbdl bd~d|g `}Drbhnh| N `kl hkmg~vg~`|dl bd~dhk `} hc }d| cg~|b hk |bdh~ dk|h~d|x+

43+ Hk |bdh~ dk|h~d|x) |bd E`~mb 03 `~|hmid} `kl hk|d~shdw mgksdx ` o~g}}ixhk`mmt~`|d `kl cì}d hev~d}}hgk gc ]|`k|gk} ~di`|hgk}bhv wh|b Vi`hk|hcc+

4?+ Hk |bdh~ dk|h~d|x) |bd E`~mb 03 `~|hmid} `kl hk|d~shdw cì}dix `mmt}dVi`hk|hcc gc ndhko ` m~ggadl `||g~kdx wbg akgw} bgw |g mgeeh| m~hed}) b`}

mgeeh||dl m~hed}) `kl akgw} bgw |g mgsd~ tv bd~ m~hehkì `m|hsh|x+

42+ \bd E`~mb 03 `~|hmid} `kl hk|d~shdw hk |bdh~ dk|h~d|x `~d cì}d `klldcè`|g~x vd~ }d hk |b`| |bdx `mmt}d Vi`hk|hcc gc v~gcd}}hgkì eh}mgkltm| `kl

mgeeh||hko m~hehkì `m|}+

48+ \bd oh}| gc |bd E`~mb 03 `~|hmid} `kl hk|d~shdw h} cì}d `klldcè`|g~x vd~ }d hk |b`| h| `mmt}d} Vi`hk|hcc gc v~gcd}}hgkì eh}mgkltm| `kl

mgeeh||hko m~hehkì `m|}+

36+ \bd E`~mb 03 `~|hmid} `kl hk|d~shdw hkmitld |bd cgiigwhko }|`|dedk|})wbhmb wbdk ~d`l hk |bd mgk|dr| gc |bd `~|hmid} `kl hk|d~shdw `} ` wbgid) mgksdx `

cì}d `kl ldcè`|g~x hev~d}}hgk gc Vi`hk|hcc:



12/29

0>

Tvgk ex ~did`}d) H |~hdl |g mgk|`m| Vb`dl~` }dsd~ì |hed}mgtilk|od| hk |gtmb wh|b bd~+

Dsdk|tìix H w`} gk v~d|~hì ~did`}d|~xhko |g mgk|`m|Vb`dl~`|~xhko |g mgk|`m| Vb`dl~`+ ]bd} kg| `k}wd~hko |bd|didvbgkd+ Ex cèhix} |~xhko |g chkl bd~+ He oghko |g bd~ gcchmd+]bd} bhlhko c~ge ed+

Ga`x }g chkìix) dsdk|tìix H lg od| hk |gtmb wh|b Vb`dl~`+ Lgk|wg~~x `ngt| h|) |bh} h} Vb`dl~`) H og| xgt) He oghko |g |àd m`~d gcxgt) jt}| ~dedend~ wb`| wd |ìadl `ngt|+ Id| |bde akgw Hii nd~dv~d}dk|hko xgt+

\bd l`x gc ex `~~`hokedk| chkìix mged}}bd lgd}k| }bgw tv+_bdk |bd jtlod vt|} hk ` mìi cg~ Vb`dl~`) }bd |dii} |bd jtlod }bdwgk| nd ~dv~d}dk|hko ed ltd |g ` mgkcihm| gc hk|d~d}|+

E`xnd }bd og| }m`~dl) e`xnd }bd |bgtob| H wgtil |dii+ E`xnd) xgtakgw) }bd cdi| |b`| h| w`} jt}| od||hko |gg bg|+ H mgtilk| tkld~}|`klwbx }bd b`l jt}| |g|ìix `kl mgevid|dix `n`klgkdl ed+

30+ \bd E`~mb 03 `~|hmid} `kl hk|d~shdw} hk |bdh~ dk|h~d|x mgk}|h|t|d ihndi`kl'g~ }i`kld~vd~ }d hk |b`| |bdx hevt|d m~hehkì `m|hsh|x |g Vi`hk|hcc+

3>+ \bd E`~mb 03 `~|hmid} `kl hk|d~shdw} hk |bdh~ dk|h~d|x mgk}|h|t|d ihndi`kl'g~ }i`kld~ vd~ }d hk |b`| |bdx hevt|d `m|hgk} |g Vi`hk|hcc |b`| hkjt~d bd~

v~gcd}}hgkì nt}hkd}} ~dvt|`|hgk+

3=+ \bd E`~mb 03 `~|hmid} `kl hk|d~shdw} hk |bdh~ dk|h~d|x mgk}|h|t|d ihndi`kl'g~ }i`kld~ vd~ }d hk |b`| |bdx hevt|d `m|hgk} |g Vi`hk|hcc |b`| `~d ldcè`|g~x

`kl hkjt~hgt} |g bd~ ~dvt|`|hgk gk |bdh~ c`md `kl m`k nd }g tkld~}|ggl wh|bgt|


M`}d 0:0>%eh%88888%TK@ Lgmtedk| 06>< Chidl 64'>>'0> Vòd 0> gc >8


13/29

0=

\bd E`~mb 08 @~|hmid `kl Hk|d~shdw

360>) Ldcdkl`k| vtnih}bdl `k `~|hmid dk|h|idl)^dì Bgt}dwhsd} gc @|i`k|` ]|`~ Drvg}dl V`~| HHH) wbhmb hkmitldl ` shldg

hk|d~shdw wh|b @kodi` ]|`k|gk+ \bd E`~mb 08 `~|hmid `kl hk|d~shdw wd~d

vtnih}bdl `| b||v:''www+shnd+mge'`~|hmid's%drmit}hsd%~dì%bgt}dwhsd}%`|i`k|`%}|`~%

drvg}dl%v`~|%hhh `kl `~d }|hii `mmd}}hnid |g |bd vtnihm `} gc |bd l`|d gc |bd chihko gc

|bh} Mgevi`hk|+

34+ @ |~td `kl mg~~dm| mgvx gc |bd E`~mb 08 `~|hmid h} `||`mbdl bd~d|g `}Drbhnh| M `kl hkmg~vg~`|dl bd~dhk `} hc }d| cg~|b hk ctii+

33+ Hk |bdh~ dk|h~d|x) |bd E`~mb 08 `~|hmid `kl hk|d~shdw mgksdx ` o~g}}ixhk`mmt~`|d `kl cì}d hev~d}}hgk gc ]|`k|gk} ~di`|hgk}bhv wh|b Vi`hk|hcc+

3?+ Hk |bdh~ dk|h~d|x) |bd E`~mb 08 `~|hmid `kl hk|d~shdw cì}dix `mmt}dVi`hk|hcc gc ndhko ` m~ggadl `||g~kdx wbg akgw} bgw |g mgeeh| m~hed}) b`}

mgeeh||dl m~hed}) `kl akgw} bgw |g mgsd~ tv bd~ m~hehkì `m|hsh|x+

32+ \bd E`~mb 08 `~|hmid `kl hk|d~shdw hk |bdh~ dk|h~d|x `~d cì}d `klldcè`|g~xvd~ }d hk |b`| |bdx `mmt}d Vi`hk|hcc gc v~gcd}}hgkì eh}mgkltm| `kl |bd

mgeeh}}hgk gc m~hehkì `m|}+

M`}d 0:0>%eh%88888%TK@ Lgmtedk| 06>< Chidl 64'>>'0> Vòd 0= gc >8


14/29

0>'0> V`od 0< gc >8


15/29

04

`kl hkjt~hgt} |g bd~ ~dvt|`|hgk gk |bdh~ c`md `kl m`k nd }g tkld~}|ggl wh|bgt|


\bd Ngga

?60>) Ldcdkl`k| vtnih}bdl ` ngga |b~gtob h|}wbgiix gwkdl `cchih`|d) @tot}|t} Vtnih}bhko) dk|h|idl) Ihd} gc ` ^dì Bgt}dwhcd:

\dii |bd \~t|b `kl ]bèd |bd Ldshi "|bd ngga(+

?4+ \bd ngga h} mt~~dk|ix `s`hi`nid cg~ lgwkig`l gkihkd `|b||v:''www+`tot}|t}vtnih}bhko+mge'lhoh|ì%ngga}'ihd}%gc%`%~dì%bgt}dwhcd+ H| h}

kg| xd| `s`hi`nid hk ` v~hk| cg~e`|+

?3+ @ |~td `kl mg~~dm| mgvx gc |bd ngga h} `||`mbdl bd~d|g `} Drbhnh| L`kl hkmg~vg~`|dl bd~dhk `} hc }d| cg~|b hk h|} dk|h~d|x+

??+ @ |~td `kl mg~~dm| mgvx gc |bd wdn}h|d v~geg|hko |bd ngga h} `||`mbdlbd~d|g `} Drbhnh| D `kl hkmg~vg~`|dl bd~dhk `} hc }d| cg~|b hk h|} dk|h~d|x+

?2+ Hk h|} dk|h~d|x) |bd ngga cì}dix vg~|~`x} |bd ~di`|hgk}bhv nd|wddkVi`hk|hcc `kl ]|`k|gk `} |b`| gc c~hdkl} `kl `mmgevihmd} hk m~hehkì `m|hsh|x+

?8+ \bd ngga hkmitld} kted~gt} }|`|dedk|}) wbhmb wbdk ~d`l hk |bdmgk|dr| gc |bd ngga `} ` wbgid) cì}dix mgksdx |b`| ]|`k|gk `kl Vi`hk|hcc wd~d mig}d

c~hdkl} `kl `mmgevihmd}) hkmitlhko) nt| kg| iheh|dl |g) |bd cgiigwhko }|`|dedk|}:

\bh} h} ` |~td }|g~x gc ex ihcd) `kl ex vd~}gkì ~di`|hgk}bhv wh|b ~dkgwkdl}tvd~ i`wxd~ Vb`dl~` V`~a}+ \bh} h} |bd |~t|b ndbhkl |bg}d ihd}+



16/29

03

Vb`dl~` `kl H wd~d sd~x mig}d+ Bd~ QVb`dl~` V`~a}U bged w`} ihad ` }dmgkl bged |g ed+ H ~dedend~dl |bd |hed} wbdk Vb`dl~` wgtil vhma ed tv jt}| |g ~hld

|b~gtob |bd mh|x hk gkd gc bd~ drvdk}hsd m`~}+

_d |ìadl |g d`mb g|bd~ gk |bd vbgkd gk ` l`hix n`}h}+ @} gt~ ~di`|hgk}bhv mgk|hktdl |g o~gw+

26+ M`vh|ìhzhko gk |bh} cì}d vg~|~`xì) |bd ngga hk h|} dk|h~d|x mgksdx} `vhm|t~d gc Vi`hk|hcc `} ` m~ggadl `||g~kdx dkoòdl hk ` eti|h|tld gc m~hehkì `m|})

wbg mgk}vh~d} wh|b ]|`k|gk |g mgeeh| |bd}d `m|}) `kl wbg |bdk t}d} ]|`k|gk hk `k

dccg~| |g d}m`vd m~hehkì ih`nhih|x cg~ |bg}d `m|}+

20+ \bd ngga hkmitld} vòd `c|d~ vòd gc }|`|dedk|}) wbhmb wbdk ~d`l|god|bd~ `kl hk |bd mgk|dr| gc |bd ngga `} ` wbgid) mgksdx ` cì}d `kl ldcè`|g~x

vg~|~`h| gc Vi`hk|hcc `} ` m~hehkì `kl `k tk}`sg~x `kl tkv~gcd}}hgkì `||g~kdx)

hkmitlhko) nt| kg| iheh|dl |g) |bd cgiigwhko }|`|dedk|}:

Vb`dl~` V`~a} w`} ` }kàd H ìigwdl |g }ih|bd~ bd~ w`x hk|g ex ihcd+ Gkmd}bd og| mig}d dkgtob |g nh|d) }bd lhl! @} }bd }ih|bd~dl `w`x) }bd idc| ed |glhd ` }igw `kl }t~d ld`|b+ \bd bdhcd~ kdsd~ dsdk iggadl n`ma+

]bd QVb`dl~` V`~a}U wìadl `w`x c~ge gt~ |~d`}t~dl |t~kdl mg~~tv|c~hdkl}bhv wh|b kg| `} etmb `} ` nideh}b |g bd~ kèd+ \g |gv |b`|) }bdm`~~hdl bd~ }dm~d| `~gtkl igko dkgtob cg~ |bd }|`|t|d gc iheh|`|hgk} |g ~tk gt|gk `kx m~hehkì g~ mhshi mb`~od}+ ]bd dsdk e`~~hdl gt~ v`~|kd~ hk m~hed }g|b`| bd mgtil kg| dsd~ |d}|hcx ò`hk}| bd~+

}bd b`l kg hld` |b`| L~è` QVb`dl~` V`~a} mihdk|U b`l nddk |diihko ed|b`| bd b`l }dr wh|b bd~ ì}g+



17/29

0?

Jt}| `ngt| dsd~x mgksd~}`|hgk Vb`dl~` `kl H b`l wgtil ~d}ti| hk bd~ |ìahko`ngt| }dr+ ]bd wgtil gc|dk di`ng~`|d `ngt| bd~ vd~cg~e`kmd gc }ged |xvd gc

}drtì `m|+ Vb`dl~` |b~dw bd~}dic `| `kx e`k }bd cdi| }bd mgtil ndkdch| c~ge)`kl |b`| w`} jt}| `ngt| `kx dk|d~|`hkd~ g~ `|bid|d wbg }bgwdl hk|d~d}|+ ]bddsdk |b~dw bd~}dic `| ex n~g|bd~ ` mgtvid gc |hed}+ Idd ìw`x} vgih|dixv`}}dl gk bd~ hksh|d}+ Bd }`hl) ]bd} kg| ex ahkl gc i`lx

]bd ì}g }b`~dl bd~ vd~}gkì vbg|g ìnte wh|b ed+ \bd~d w`} Q}hmU ìiahkl} gc vhm|t~d} gc bd~ l~d}}dl tv `} ` lgehk`|~hr) ndk| gsd~) `kl vg}hko hklhccd~dk| vg}h|hgk}+ H w`} }bgmadl) nt| h| lhlk| }|gv ed c~ge iggahko+Vb`dl~` |~hvvdl ed gt|) `kl H mgk|hktdl shdwhko |bd ìnte) nt| H w`} eg}|ixhk lh}ndihdc+

Ex}|hmì) hc xgt ~d`l |bh} ngga) xgt ehob| w`k| |g `}a Vb`dl~` `ngt| xgt~`||g~kdx%mihdk| v~hshidod}+ H whii kg| di`ng~`|d gk |gg e`kx ld|`hi} cg~ |bd}àd gc Ex}|hmì) nt| H wgtil ihad |g }`x |b`| Vb`dl~` |gil ed |b`| Ex}|hmìw`} othi|x) igko ndcg~d bd w`} dsd~ mgkshm|dl+ \bd b`h~l~d}}d~ `kl |bg}dmbdma}) ~hob|7 Gb Xd`b Xd`b) H ~dedend~ `ngt| xgt `kl xgt~ ngx} `| |bdbg|di+

Vb`dl~` |gil ed |b`| Ex}|hmì w`} |bd ltend}| eg|bd~ c***** }bd b`l dsd~ed| hk bd~ ihcd+ ]bd |gil ed |b`| bh} b`h~l~d}}d~) ` wge`k |b`| bd b`l akgwkcg~ ` igko |hed) }|gid }ged mbdma} gt| gc bh} mbdmangga) `kl }|gid dhob|x%|bgt}`kl lgii`~} c~ge bhe+ Hk}|d`l gc mìihko |bd vgihmd) Ex}|hmì mìidl |bdwge`k |g |bd bg|di tkld~ |bd v~d|dk}hgk |b`| bd w`k|dl bh} b`h~ n~`hldl+\bdk bd `kl bh} dk|gt~òd) ~`vdl |bd wge`k) nd`| bd~) `kl }glgehzdl bd~!Vb`dl~` V`~a} w`} `n}git|dix ihshl+

Gt~ m~hehkì `m|hsh|hd} ndo`k nig}}gehko hk >666+ H| b`l nddk gsd~ ` xd`~gc t} cddihko d`mb g|bd~ gt|+ Vb`dl~` w`} kgw mgecg~|`nid dkgtob |g n~hkoed hk|g bd~ hiidoì `m|hsh|hd}+

Vb`dl~` w`k|dl ed |g vtii ` mgtvid gc }|tk|} cg~ bd~+ \bd lt|hd} dk|`hidloghko gt|) `kl w~h|hko }ged mbdma} cg~ didm|~gkhm h|de}+ _d b`l g~ld~}vi`mdl nx bd~ cèhix) c~hdkl}) `kl g~ `}}gmh`|d} |g chii+

]bd wdk| gk `kl gk |ìahko `ngt| bgw bd~ m~hehkì dk|d~v~h}d w`} hk ctiicg~md+ \bd egkdx w`} ~giihko hk ~dìix oggl) `kl H w`} bd~ ESV+ ]bd |gil

M`}d 0:0>%eh%88888%TK@ Lgmtedk| 06>< Chidl 64'>>'0> Vòd 0? gc >8


18/29

02

ed |b`| hc H b`l `kg|bd~ n`nx h| wgtil }igw lgwk |bd dk|h~d nt}hkd}}+Vb`dl~` w`} ~hob|+

E`~mb >660) Vb`dl~` hk|~gltmdl ed |g bd~ mt~~dk| bt}n`kl) @vgiig Khl`+ @ngt| }hr cdd| |wg hkmbd} |ìi+ H~gkhmìix) bd dsdk |bgtob| wdwd~d ìi m~gga}+ Vb`dl~` |gil @vgiig |b`| H w`} gkd gc bd~ mig}d}|c~hdkl}) `kl bd~ nd}| wg~ad~+ ]bd drvi`hkdl |b | H b`l ` v~gsdk |~`ma ~dmg~l)`kl h| w`} |hed cg~ ex v~geg|hgk+ Chkìix) H w`} oghko |g eàd |bd ~dìegkdx }bd v~geh}dl ed+ Kg eg~d ~tkkhko `~gtkl |g Nd}| Ntx) ]|`vid})Gcchmd Ldvg|) g~ _ì%E`~|+ H w`} |h~dl gc w~h|hko mbdma}+ \bt} c`~) H b`lmgkltm|dl gt~ }mè hk dsd~x e`jg~ ldv`~|edk| }|g~d hk @|i`k|`+ \bd~dcg~dhk g~ld~ cg~ ed |g mgk|hktd |g vtii }|tk|} hksgishko w~h|hko ngot} nt}hkd}}mbdma} |g chii bd~ l`hix g~ld~}) H wgtil b`sd |g dr|dkl |bd ngtkl`~hd} gc |bd

gvd~`|hgk+

G|bd~ |b`k |bd gkd |hed H og| m`tob|) `kl w`} mb`~odl wh|b cg~od~x+Dsd~x|bhko Vb`dl~` |gil ed |g lg }g c`~ b`l idl |g ` }egg|b dklhko+

Vb`dl~` `}}t~dl ed |b`| H w`} gkix oghko |g od| ` }i`v gk |bd w~h}|+ ]gò`hk) H vt| ex |~t}| hk bd~) `kl wd adv| ~giihko ìgko+

H lhl dr`m|ix `} |gil Qnx Vb`dl~` `kl @vgiigU `kl |bdx w`h|dl cg~ edgt|}hld |bd `h~vg~|+ H w`} ohsdk ` cgild~ chiidl wh|b càd lgmtedk|}+ Hb`l hk b`kl) n`ka }|`|dedk|}) ` t|hih|x nhii) `kl ` }gmhì }dmt~h|x m`~l wh|b `c~`tltidk| Odg~oh` }|`|d l~hsd~} ihmdk}d+

Ex `}}hokedk| hksgisdl) cixhko |g LM) `kl m`|mbhko ` m`n c~ge |bd `h~vg~||g Nì|heg~d) EL+ \bdk H w`} }tvvg}dl |g og |g |bd Ldv`~|edk| gc Eg|g~Sdbhmid}) }tneh| ex lgmtedk|}) `kl gn|`hk ex ]|`|d gc E`~xi`kl l~hsd~}ihmdk}d+

Vb`d b`l }vdmhchm hk}|~tm|hgk} cg~ ed+ \àd xgt~ E`~xi`kl l~hsd~} ihmdk}dìgko wh|b |bh} }gmhì }dmt~h|x v~hk|gt|) `kl og |g |bd N`ka gc @ed~hm`)lgwk|gwk N~`kmb gk Vd`mb|~dd ]|~dd| `kl gvdk ` n`ka `mmgtk|) Vb`d }`hl+]bd ì}g hk}|~tm|dl ed |g ldvg}h| egkdx `kl v~gshld bd~ wh|b |bd `mmgtk|ktend~}+ Vb`dl~` V`~a} w`} `ngt| bd~ nt}hkd}}) `kl }bd lhl |b`| sd~x wdii+I`|d~ |b`| eg~khko) H idc| Vb`dl~`} gcchmd gk ]v~hko ]|~dd|+ Gk id`shko bd~gcchmd H gvdkdl |bd dksdigvd) `kl mgtk|dl |bd m`}b+ \bdk H wìadl ` mgtvidnigma} gsd~ |g Vd`mb|~dd ]|~dd|+



19/29

08

Gkmd |bd |~`k}`m|hgk `| |bd n`ka w`} mgevid|dl) H bd`ldl n`ma |g Vb`d}gcchmd) ~dmdhv| hk b`kl+

_bhid @vgiig `kl H ~`k |bd }|~dd|}) Vb`dl~` w`} `nid |g }h| `w`x ndbhkl bd~ld}a+

H w`} ` v~gltm| gc Vb`dl~` V`~a}) `kl b`l }dsd~ì hldk|h|hd}+ Ihad ` |~tde`ch` gt|ch|) wd wd~d gvd~`|hko `ngsd |bd i`w) `kl H w`} hk `k dih|d kd|wg~agc wg~ad~} cg~ Vb`dl~` V`~a}+

H b`l egkdx vt| tv `kl Vb`dl~` adv| egkdx gk ex ngga}+ ]bd ~d`lhix`mmdv|dl ìi ex vbgkd mìi}+ H ì}g akdw |b`| `} }ggk `} H |gtmbdl lgwk)

|bd~d wgtil nd ` jgn w`h|hko cg~ ed+ _h|b ex egkdx tv) H mìidl bgeddsd~x }hkoid l`x `kl e`ld }t~d egkdx }|`xdl gk ex ngga}+

Vb`dl~`} }mbded} wd~d midsd~ `kl di`ng~`|d+ ]bd kdsd~ md`}dl |g `}|gtkld`mb `kl dsd~x |hed }bd `vv~g`mbdl ed wh|b `k `}}hokedk|+ Gk kted~gt}gmm`}hgk}) H gc|dk cgtkl ex}dic drmh|dl `ngt| id`~khko bd~ |~hma} gc |bd|~`ld+

Vb`dl~` w`} |bh} m~ggadl `||g~kdx wbg akdw bgw |g mgeeh| m~hed} ò`hk}||bd cdld~ì ogsd~kedk|+ ]bd ì}g akdw bgw |g od| `w`x+ Vb`dl~` V`~a} b`l}|tlhdl |bd i`w dr|dk}hsdix) `kl id`~kdl bgw |g e`khvti`|d |bd m~`ma} hk |bd}x}|de+

Nx |bd |hed H idc| |b`| edd|hko) wbdw ngx) ex ehkl w`} ~`mhko+ Vb`dl~`w`} wh||x+ Bd~ hld`}) bd~ n~`hk) `kl |bd w`x }bd g~mbd}|~`|dl |bhko}) }gmidsd~+ _d wd~d `ngsd |bd i`w+ Bdii `} c`~ `} H w`} mgkmd~kdl) wd wd~d|bd i`w+ \b`ka} |g xgt akgw wbg+

\bd ch~}| v`~| gc ex `}}hokedk| hksgisdl }mgvhko gt| vg|dk|hì sdbhmid} `|itrt~x m`~ ldìd~}bhv}+ D`mb l`x H }hevix l~gsd `~gtkl @|i`k|`) `kl |bd}t~~gtklhko mh|hd} iggahko cg~ vg|dk|h i v~dx+ Dsd~x m`~ ig| H sh}h|dl b`l}dsd~ì itrt~x m`~}+ H }vg||dl ìi gc |bd i`|d}| egldi} gc Vg~}mbd) Ed~mdld}Ndkz) Bteed~}) Mg~sd||d}) `kl M`lhii`m+ @c|d~ }didm|dl itrt~x ldìd~}bhv}wd~d hldk|hchdl) H wgtil |bdk wìa `~gtkl |bd ig|} wh|b vdk `kl v`l+ Hm`}tìix) nt| lh}m~dd|ix ~dmg~ldl |bd SHK ktend~}) eàd}) `kl egldi} gckg| gkix |bd i`|d}|) nt| |bd bg||d}| wbhv} |g bh| |bd mh|x+ Gkmd H b`l |bd



20/29

>6

hkcg~e`|hgk ~dmg~ldl) H ~dvg~|dl h| n`ma |g D+ _d ~`~dix lh}mt}}dl nt}hkd}}gk |bd vbgkd+ ]g D `kl H ed| l`hix) `kl }w`vvdl hkcg~e`|hgk) `kl càd

lgmtedk|}+ H| }ddedl ihad wd kdsd~ }|gvvdl+ H v~gshldl |bd SHK ktend~})`kl bd o`sd ed |bd càd hldk|hchm`|hgk m`~l}) `kl c~`tltidk| ~doh}|~`|hgkm`~l} e`|mbhko |bd sdbhmid} H b`l v~dshgt}ix ~dmg~ldl+ @| |bh} vghk|) H w`}b`klihko ìi gc |bd l`x%|g%l`x gvd~`|hgk}+

Vb`d kdsd~ b`l |g wg~~x `ngt| |bd hiidoì }hld gc |bd gvd~`|hgk Qgc |bd m`~}mbdedU+ Vb`d akdw `} igko `} H w`} gk |bd `}}hokedk|) }bd wgtil od|bd~ egkdx+

_h|b |bd }|`|d h}}tdl HL) `kl v~ggc gc gwkd~}bhv) H wgtil nd `nid |g sh}h|`kx g|bd~ itrt~x m`~ ldìd~}bhv) v~gshld |bde wh|b |bd kdmd}}`~x lgmtedk|}`} wdii `} ` cdd) gkd btkl~dl `kl dhob|x lgii`~} `| |b`| |hed+ \bdk jt}| ihad|b`|) |bdx wgtil mt| ` mgevt|d~hzdl adx |g |bd sdbhmid+

\bd }dmgkl v`~| gc |bd }mbded hksgisdl ` i`|d khob| sh}h| wbdk |bdldìd~}bhv mig}dl lgwk+ _d wgtil ~d|t~k |g |bd ldìd~}bhv `kl l~hsd `w`xhk n~`kl kdw sdbhmid}) wh|b kg lh}|t~n`kmd}+ Dsdk hc wd lhl ~tk hk|g `v~gnide }tmb `} od||hko vtiidl gsd~ nx |bd mgv}) wd b`l ìi |bd ~hob|v`vd~wg~a hk gt~ vg}}d}}hgk+

\bd m`~} wd~d |bdk }dk| |g ` mbgv }bgv+ \bd SHK ktend~} wd~d chidllgwk) `kl ~dvi`mdl wh|b kdw gkd}+ Gkmd ~dvi`mdl) H w`} v~gshldl wh|bc~`tltidk| md~|hchm`|d} gc sdbhmid |h|id} c~ge |bd }|`|d gc Gbhg+ \bd Gbhg|h|id} b`l |g nd }w`vvdl gt| cg~ Odg~oh`+ Kg hc}) `kl} g~ nt|} `ngt| h|) |b`|w`} `k hevg~|`k| }|dv gc |bd }mè+

\bd sdbhmid} wd~d mid`k `kl ~d`lx |g og+ Vb`dl~` ch~eix hk}h}|dl wd egsdcg~w`~l) `kl v~gmddl `} vi`kkdl wh|b |bd gvd~`|hgk+ H| w`} ldmhldl |b`|Dsd~d||) ex mgt}hk) `kl ed wgtil bd`l cg~ Mb`||`kggo`) \dkkd}}dd) |bd

sd~x kdr| eg~khko wh|b |b~dd gc |bd itrt~x sdbhmid}+

Dsdk |bgtob H w`} |h~dl) H akdw wd wd~d bd`lhko lgwk |g Mb`||`kggo`)\K+ Ex jgn w`} |g l~hsd gkd gc gt~ itrt~x sdbhmid} |g |bd ldìd~}bhv+ \bdkb`kl |bde ex |h|id) ex l~hsd~} ihmdk}d) `kl ex v~ggc gc ~doh}|~`|hgk wbdk Hog| |bd~d+ H w`} |g drvi hk |g |bde |b`| H w`k|dl |g |~`ld ex drvdk}hsd m`~

M`}d 0:0>%eh%88888%TK@ Lgmtedk| 06>< Chidl 64'>>'0> Vòd >6 gc >8


21/29

>0

cg~ ` sdbhmid |b`| w`} ` ih||id id}} ci`}bx+ Hk ~d|t~k) |bdx wgtil ohsd ed ` m`~gc id}}d~ sìtd) `kl ì}g mt| ` mbdma cg~ |bd lhccd~dkmd+

]|hii hk }bgma c~ge id`~khko |b`| Dsd~d|| `kl Vb`dl~` b`l }dk| ed n`ma |g|bd }èd m`~ ig| |bdx b`l jt}| nt~kdl) H cdi| ihad |bh} w`} ìi v`~| gc ` }d| tv+\bdx b`l nddk l~hsdk nx o~ddl+

H b`l nddk hk Mi`x|gk Mgtk|x J`hi cg~ kd`~ix |wg wdda} kgw) `kl h| }ddedlihad kg gkd mgtil od| hk |gtmb wh|b Vb`dl~`+ ]bd w`} `sghlhko dsd~x vd~}gk|b`| |~hdl |g mgk|`m| bd~ gk ex ndbìc+ @ii |bd mìi} |g bd~ vd~}gkì mdiivbgkd`kl bged ktend~ wdk| tk`k}wd~dl `kl wd~d kdsd~ ~d|t~kdl+

H ed`k) }bd w`} ìi cg~ h| wbdk wd wd~d lghko hiidoì }|tcc+ _bxwgtilk| }bd nd ii cg~ h| wbdk h| w`} }ged|bhko idoì `kl vg}h|hsd7 Hc gt~~di`|hgk}bhv b`l nddk ~d}|~hm|dl |g ng}} `kl wg~ad~ |bdk H wgtil b`sd b`l `nd||d~ tkld~}|`klhko+ Nt| Vb`dl~` w`} ex c~hdkl+ ]bd w`} ` ogleg|bd~ |gex }gk J`xshdk+ ]bd lhlk| dsdk ohsd ed |bd bgkg~ gc }h||hko lgwk wh|b ed|g ld}m~hnd ex eg|bd~} i`}| l`x gk d`~|b+ _b`| b`l H lgkd |g vt}b bd~ }gc`~ `w`x7 H jt}| mgtilk| tkld~}|`kl h|+

]bd o`sd ed ìi |bd lh~dm|hgk hk |bd wg~il wbdk wd b`l hiidoì ldìhko}) nt||bd ~tid} gc |bd oèd b`l mb`kodl+ H w`}k| v~hsx |g |bd ~tidngga `kxeg~d+

Ga`x) }g Vb`dl~` w`} ` }ihma nh**b+ H akdw |bh} ndm`t}d }bd |`tob| edbgw |g nd }egg|b+ Vb`dl~` e`~~hdl @vgiig }g bd mgtilk| |d}|hcx ò`hk}|bd~+

@} H mgk|hktdl |g w`|mb |bd }bgw wdda `c|d~ wdda) H ~dìhzdl |b`| Vb`dl~`kdsd~ dsd~ b`l ` m`~d hk |bd wg~il cg~ ex mbhil~dk g~ cg~ ed+ ]bd t}dl ed)`kl }bd b`l t}dl ex ihcd `} ` }|dvvhko%}|gkd cg~ bd~ gwk vd~}gkì o~ddl `klo`hk+ ]bd} }tmb o~ddlx nh**b!

Vb`dl~` w`} ` odkht} `| m~d`|hko hiit}hgk}+ ]bd e`}|d~ehkldl |bd vd~cdm|m~hed ò`hk}| |bd Cdld~ì Ogsd~kedk|) `kl dsd~xnglx hksgisdl }d~sdl |hedhk v~h}gk) drmdv| bd~+ nt| wb`| `ngt| bgw }bd t}dl ed) `kl ld}|~gxdlex ihcd7 @| |bd |hed gc gt~ mèv`hok gc m~hed}) }bd w`} ` }wg~k gcchmd~ gc|bd i`w+ ]bd b`l |àdk `k g`|b |g tvbgil ` md~|`hk }|`kl`~l+



22/29

>>

Vb`dl~` V`~a} n~gad }dsd~`i ~tid} ogsd~kdl nx |bd ]|`|d N`~ gc Odg~oh`Q^tid 0+>) < Chidl 64'>>'0> V`od >> gc >8


23/29

>=

2?+ \bd ngga mgk}|h|t|d} ihndi vd~ }d hk h|} dk|h~d|x hk |b`| h| hevt|d}`m|hgk} |g Vi`hk|hcc |b`| `~d ldcè`|g~x `kl hkjt~hgt} |g bd~ ~dvt|`|hgk gk |bdh~ c`md

`kl m`k nd }g tkld~}|ggl wh|bgt| ~dcd~dkmd |g `kx `llh|hgkì g~ dr|~hk}hm c`m|}+

22+ Ldcdkl`k| vtnih}bdl |bd cì}d `kl ldcè`|g~x `mmt}`|hgk} ò`hk}|Vi`hk|hcc wh|bgt| `kx v~hshidod+

28+ \bd cì}d `kl ldcè`|g~x `mmt}`|hgk} ò`hk}| Vi`hk|hcc vtnih}bdl nxLdcdkl`k| wd~d }tn}dptdk|ix ~dvtnih}bdl wg~ilwhld gk g|bd~ Hk|d~kd| wdn}h|d}+

VTNIHM@\HGK _H\B @M\T@I E@IHMD

86+ Gk E`~mb 03) >60>) v~hg~ |g |bd vtnihm`|hgk gc |bd `~|hmid `klhk|d~shdw ~do`~lhko V`~|} HH `kl HHH `kl |bd ngga) I+ Ihk _ggl) gk ndbìc gc

Vi`hk|hcc) }dk| ` id||d~ |g Ldcdkl`k| wbd~dhk bd hkcg~edl Ldcdkl`k| |b`| |bd

}|`|dedk|} nx ]|`k|gk |b`| |bdx ~dvd`|dlix b`l vtnih}bdl `kl vi`kkdl |g mgk|hktd

|g vtnih}b wd~d c i}d `kl ldcè`|g~x+ Dshldkmhko ` ~dmaid}} lh}~do`~l cg~ |~t|b g~

cì}h|x) Ldcdkl`k| hk|dk|hgkìix lh}~do`~ldl `kl hokg~dl |bh} hkcg~e`|hgk+ @ |~td

`kl mg~~dm| mgvx gc |bd id||d~ gc E`~mb 03) >60> h} `||`mbdl bd~d|g `} Drbhnh| C `kl

nx ~dcd~dkmd e`ld ` v`~| bd~dgc+

80+ Gk @v~hi >?) >60>) I+ Ihk _ggl) gk ndbìc gc Vi`hk|hcc) }dk| ` id||d~ |gLdcdkl`k| wbd~dhk bd hkcg~edl Ldcdkl`k| |b`| |bd }|`|dedk|} nx ]|`k|gk |b`| |bdx

~dvd`|dlix b`l vtnih}bdl gkihkd hk V`~|} HH `kl HHH gc ]|`k|gk} hk|d~shdw `kl |bd

M`}d 0:0>%eh%88888%TK@ Lgmtedk| 06>< Chidl 64'>>'0> Vòd >= gc >8


24/29

>?) >60> h} `||`mbdl

bd~d|g `} Drbhnh| O `kl nx ~dcd~dkmd e`ld ` v`~| bd~dgc+

8>+ V~hg~ |g |bd vtnihm`|hgk) `kl dshldkmhko ` ~dmaid}} lh}~do`~l gc |~t|b g~cì}h|x) Ldcdkl`k| c`hidl `kl ~dct}dl |g v~gshld Vi`hk|hcc wh|b `k gvvg~|tkh|x |g

~d}vgkl |g |bd ìido`|hgk} e`ld ò`hk}| bd~ hk |bd `~|hmid}) hk|d~shdw}) `kl |bd

ngga+

8=+ Ldcdkl`k| akgwhkoix `kl vt~vg}dix `sghldl `kl hokg~dl dshldkmdd}|`nih}bhko |bd cì}h|x gc |bd `~|hmid}) hk|d~shdw}) `kl |bd ngga v~hg~ |g vtnih}bhko

|bde+

8%eh%88888%TK@ Lgmtedk| 06>< Chidl 64'>>'0> Vòd >< gc >8


25/29

>4

83+ Dshldkmhko ` ~dmaid}} lh}~do`~l cg~ |~t|b g~ cì}h|x) Ldcdkl`k|vtnih}bdl `mmt}`|hgk} ò`hk}| Vi`hk|hcc |b`| mid`~ix mgk|~`lhm|dl akgwk c`m|}+

8?+ Dshldkmhko ` ~dmaid}} lh}~do`~l cg~ |~t|b g~ cì}h|x) Ldcdkl`k|vtnih}bdl `mmt}`|hgk} ò`hk}| Vi`hk|hcc n`}dl }gidix gk ` }gt~md wbg w`} ` akgwk

mgkshm|dl cdigk+

82+ Dshldkmhko ` ~dmaid}} lh}~do`~l cg~ |~t|b g~ cì}h|x) Ldcdkl`k|vtnih}bdl `mmt}`|hgk} ò`hk}| Vi`hk|hcc n`}dl }gidix gk ` }gt~md wbg w`}

tk~dih`nid) akgwk |g nd nh`}dl ò`hk}| Vi`hk|hcc) `kl akgwk |g i`ma m~dlhnhih|x+

88+ Dshldkmhko ` ~dmaid}} lh}~do`~l cg~ |~t|b g~ cì}h|x) Ldcdkl`k|vtnih}bdl `mmt}`|hgk} ò`hk}| Vi`hk|hcc n`}dl }gidix gk ` }gt~md wbg w`} akgwk |g

b`sd ` bh}|g~x gc dkoòhko hk shmhgt} vd~}gkì `||`ma} ò`hk}| Vi`hk|hcc+

066+ V~hg~ |g |bd vtnihm`|hgk gc |bd cì}d `kl ldcè`|g~x }|`|dedk|})Ldcdkl`k| b`l `m|tì akgwidlod |b`| |bd m~hehkì `m|hsh|x ìidodl nx ]|`k|gk b`l

gmmt~~dl e`kx xd`~} òg `kl b`l nddk |bg~gtobix hksd}|ho`|dl nx i`w

dkcg~mdedk| `t|bg~h|hd} wh|b kg m~hehkì mb`~od} ndhko n~gtob| ò`hk}| Vi`hk|hcc)

nt| wh|b m~hehkì mb`~od} ndhko n~gtob| ò`hk}| ]|`k|gk) wbhmb ~d}ti|dl hk bd~

hkm`~md~`|hgk hk v~h}gk+



26/29

>3

060+ Dshldkmhko ` ~dmaid}} lh}~do`~l cg~ |~t|b g~ cì}h|x) Ldcdkl`k|vtnih}bdl `mmt}`|hgk} ò`hk}| Vi`hk|hcc wh|bgt| mgkltm|hko dsdk ` mt~}g~x

hksd}|ho`|hgk) wbhmb c`hit~d mgk}|h|t|d} o~g}} kdoihodkmd+

06>+ Ldcdkl`k| b`l `m|tì akgwidlod |b`| |bd `mmt}`|hgk} ò`hk}| Vi`hk|hccwd~d cì}d v~hg~ |g vtnihm`|hgk+

L@E@OD]

06=+ \bd cì}d `kl ldcè`|g~x `~|hmid} `kl ngga wd~d vtnih}bdl |g |bh~lv`~|hd} `kl wd~d) hk c`m|) ~d`l nx |bh~l v`~|hd} ìi `m~g}} |bd Tkh|dl ]|`|d}+

06%eh%88888%TK@ Lgmtedk| 06>< Chidl 64'>>'0> Vòd >3 gc >8


27/29

>?

062+ @} }d| cg~|b `ngsd) |bd ldcè`|g~x |bd `~|hmid} `kl ngga vtnih}bdl nxLdcdkl`k| `~d ldcè`|g~x `kl ihndigt}vd~ }d hk |b`| |bdx hevt|d m~hehkì `m|hsh|x

|g Vi`hk|hcc `kl hkjt~d bd~ v~gcd}}hgkì nt}hkd}} ~dvt|`|hgk) dk|h|ihko Vi`hk|hcc |g

v~d}tedl lèòd}+

068+ Ld}vh|d b`shko ~dmdhsdl id||d~} gk E`~mb 03) >60> `kl @v~hi >?) >60>hkcg~ehko Ldcdkl`k| |b`| |bd }|`|dedk|} |bdx vtnih}bdl hk |bd `~|hmid} `kl |bd ngga

wd~d cì}d `kl ldcè`|g~x `kl lde`klhko |b`| |bd }|`|dedk|} nd ~d|~`m|dl `kl

mg~~dm|dl) Ldcdkl`k| b`} c`hidl |g ~d|~`m| g~ mg~~dm| h|} cì}d `kl ldcè`|g~x

}|`|dedk|}+

006+ \bd mgkltm| gc Ldcdkl`k| ldegk}|~`|d} whiicti eh}mgkltm| `kl `kdk|h~d w`k| gc m`~d |b`| ~`h}d} ` mgk}mhgt} hklhccd~dkmd |g mgk}dptdkmd}+

000+ \bd cì}d `kl ldcè`|g~x `mmt}`|hgk} wd~d vtnih}bdl wh|bMgk}|h|t|hgkì eìhmd |bd~dnx dk|h|ihko Vi`hk|hcc |g `k `w`~l gc vtkh|hsd lèòd}+

00>+ Vi`hk|hcc h} ì}g dk|h|idl |g `k `w`~l gc vtkh|hsd lèòd} c~geLdcdkl`k| hk g~ld~ |g vtnih}b h| cg~ h|} tki`wcti mgkltm| `kl |g vdkìhzd `kl ld|d~

h| c~ge ~dvd`|hko }tmb tki`wcti `kl do~dohgt} mgkltm|+

_BD^DCG^D) Vi`hk|hcc) Vb`dl~` M+ V`~a}) lde`kl}:

"`(\~hì nx jt~x1

M`}d 0:0>%eh%88888%TK@ Lgmtedk| 06>< Chidl 64'>>'0> Vòd >? gc >8


28/29

>2

"n(\b`| jtloedk| nd dk|d~dl ò`hk}| Ldcdkl`k| cg~ mgevdk}`|g~x lèòd}hk `k ègtk| kg| id}} |b`k Chsd Ehiihgk Lgii`~} ",4)666)666+66(1

"m(\b`| jtloedk| nd dk|d~dl ò`hk}| Ldcdkl`k| cg~ vtkh|hsd lèòd} hk `kègtk| kg| id}} |b`k \wdk|x%Chsd Ehiihgk Lgii`~} ",>4)666)666+66( |g

vtkh}b `kl vdkìhzd Ldcdkl`k| `kl ld|d~ Ldcdkl`k| c~ge ~dvd`|hko |bh}

tki`wcti mgkltm|1

"l(\b`| Ldcdkl`k| vtnih}b ` ~d|~`m|hgk gc |bd `~|hmid} `kl ngga1"d(\b`| ìi mg}|} gc |bh} `m|hgk nd `}}d}}dl ò`hk}| Ldcdkl`k|1 `kl"c(\b`| |bh} Mgt~| `w`~l }tmb g|bd~ ~dihdc `} h| ldde} dpth|`nid) jt}|) `kl

v~gvd~+

^d}vdm|ctiix }tneh||dl |bh} >>kl l`x gc E`x >60>+

'}' I+ Ihk _gglI+ Ihk _ggliwgglFwbd|~hìi`w+mgeOdg~oh` N`~ Kg+ ??82444@ex E+ ]|dw`~|

`}|dw`~|Fwbd|~hìi`w+mgeOdg~oh` N`~ Kg+ 0< Chidl 64'>>'0> Vòd >2 gc >8


29/29

%eh%88888%TK@ Lgmtedk| 06>< Chidl 64'>>'0> V`od >8 gc >8

Documents

Phaedra Parks Sues Vibe For Defamation