PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

1/65

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

2/65

_iM Xfxg xnjk

Dkjigbfzd nh Un``fbc Jfuj`k Ukp`fjg}fnb

fb Ckdfbfxfu{z

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

3/65

Ckdfbfxfug` Efn`ncv

Nelkj}fxkz nh }ifz z}{mv

Z{ddguv

Ukz{`}z

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

4/65

Ckdfbfxfug` Efn`ncv

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

5/65

G E J

M K H C

Mfzkgzkz gbm Zvdp}ndz nh Ckdfbfxfu{zkz

Ckdfbfxfu{zkz fbhkj} g sfmk xgufk}v nh junp p`gb}z

Fbhkj}fnb ghhkj}z bnudg` cuns}i gbm junp vfk`m

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

6/65

Sif}kh`fkz gbm `kghinppkuz }ugzdf} ckdfbfxfu{zkz hund nbk p`gb} }n gbn}iku

Sif}kh`fkz guk g dglnu jnbjkub hnu ]n@JX gbm Ji@JX

Sif}kh`fkz ]ugbzdf} Ckdfbfxfu{zkz

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

7/65

G E

Ckdfbfxfu{zkz guk fbjndp`k}k fjnzgikmug` }sfbbkm xfufnbz

Ckbndk jnbzfz}z nh jnxg`kb}`v j`nzkm zzMBG

Nbk xfufnb gjjnddnmg}kz nb`v nbk MBG dn`kj{`k `fdf}km ev zf|k

:9 55 bd

7.7?? nh IFX zf|k

Zdg``ku }igb Ikp E )=5 53 bd&

7.3}i }ik `kbc}i nh ]DX

Xfufnb Z}u{j}{uk nh Ckdfbfxfu{zkz

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

8/65

MBG

7"= ae

FUJU JUJU

Dnbnpgu}f}k < Dgf|k z}ukga xfu{z, Sikg} msguh xfu{z

Dnbnpgu}f}k ! MBG

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

9/65

Xkj}nu

}ugbzdfzzfnb

B{j`k{z

Jv}np`gzd

Ckdfbfxfug` @fhkjvj`k

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

10/65

zzMBG

_ufdku

zvb}ikzfz

Jndp`kdkb}guv

z}ugbm zvb}ikzfz mzMBG

]ugbzjufp}fnb

Ukp`fjg}fnb

fbf}fg}fnb

Ukp`fjg}fnb

}kudfbg}fnb

]ugbz`g}fnb

Ckdfbfxfug` @fhkjvj`k

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

11/65

JU

GJ7

GJ7 Ukp`fjg}fnb Fbf}fg}nu )Ukp&

GJ: Ukp`fjg}fnb Kbigbjku )Ukb&

GJ:

GJ5

GJ5 ]ugbzjufp}fnbg` Gj}fxg}nu )]uGp&

UBGf z{ppukzznu )Z{p&GJ=

GJ5

GJ= Ukp`fjg}fnb

UBGf z{ppukzzfnb

GJ5

GJ=

GX7 Jng} _un}kfb )J_&

GJ5

GJ=

GX5 UBGf z{ppukzzfnb

GX7

GX5

NUHz nh Ckdfbfxfu{z MBG G

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

12/65

Ukp`fjg}fnb Fbf}fg}nu _un}kfb )GJ7&

Ukp`fjg}fnb Fbf}fg}nu _un}kfb.Ukp.GJ7 ):85 Gg&

MBG Bfjafbc.@fcg}fnb )7$75? Gg&

MBG efbmfbc )7$7:? Gg&

N`fcndkufzg}fnb

)75?$795 Gg&

G]_gzk.Ik`fjgzk )79:$:85 Gg&

]vu Sg`aku G Sg`aku E

Ukp fbf}fg}kz }ik ukp`fjg}fnb nh }ik xfug` MBG

Ukp fz g d{`}fh{bj}fnbg` pun}kfb

Fbm{jkz ukp`fjg}fnb fb }ik jk``z ev ukpuncugddfbc }ik jk`` jvj`k

Ukp fb}kugj}z sf}i xgufn{z inz} pun}kfbz gbm xfug` pun}kfbz

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

13/65

Uk

p

Ukp`fjg}fnb nh Ckdfbfxfug` MBG

Ckdfbfxfu{zkz ukp`fjg}k ev un``fbc jfuj`k ukp`fjg}fnb

Ukp fbf}fg}kz ukp`fjg}fnb ev zf}k zpkjfhfj bfjafbc

Ukp uk`kgzkz bks`v hnudkm MBG ev uk`fcg}fbc

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

14/65

Ukp`fjg}fnb Kbigbjku _un}kfb )GJ:&

Ukp`fjg}fnb Kbigbjku _un}kfb.UKb.GJ: )7:= Gg& pUEU

pUEU

_JBGUkp

3 6;59 759

Ukp`fjg}fnb gjjkzznuv pun}kfb

Fb}kugj}z sf}i Ukp gbm xgufn{z inz} hgj}nuz

Bn kb|vdg}fj dn}fh

Bn MBG efbmfbc mndgfb

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

15/65

Ckdfbfxfug` GJ:

]ugbzckbfjz _un}np`gz}z

Bn zfcbfhfjgb}jigbck fb xfug`MBG ukp`fjg}fnb

fb }ik gezkbjk nh

GJ:

GJ: d{}g}fnbukz{`}km fb

mugz}fj ukm{j}fnbnh xfug` MBG

ukp`fjg}fnb )r;?hn`m&

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

16/65

Nelkj}fxkz nh }ifz z}{mv

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

17/65

Nelkj}fxkz

]n kypukzz }ik ukjndefbgb} GJ: pun}kfb hund ckdfbfxfu{zkz

Efnjikdfjg` khhkj} nh f}z fb}kugj}fnb sf}i Ukp

N`fcndkufzg}fnb z}g}{z

Kyig{z}fxk zkguji hnu }ik GJ: fb}kugj}fbc inz} pun}kfbz gbm fmkb}fhv

n}iku pnzzfe`k pg}isgvz sikuk GJ: p`gvz un`k

Un`k nh GJ: fb ukp`fjg}fnb ky xfxn gbm fb p`gb}g

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

18/65

Ukz{`}z

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

19/65

B{j`kn}fmk Zkw{kbjk G`fcbdkb} nh GJ: NUH

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

20/65

Gdfbn Gjfm Zkw{kbjk G`fcbdkb} nh GJ: _un}kfb

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

21/65

CZ] fz 58 aMg

GJ: fz 7:= Gg )r7; aMg&

H{zfnb pun}kfb fz r =7 aMg

79J.?"7dD F_]C.75$78 iuz

aMg

8?

;?

=?

:?

5;

Fbm{jkm

BM7 A5 D A= J@

DV

X XF

CZ]$GJ:

Z _ Z _ Z _ Z _

BM7 A5 D A= J@

F H] S D 7 5 : = ; 8

Fbm{j}fnb nh CZ]$GJ: pun}kfbz

Kypukzzfnb punhf k nh CZ]$GJ: pun}kfbz _{ufhfjg}fnb punhf k nh CZ]$GJ: pun}kfb

]n@JAkX CZ]$GJ: _un}kfb Kypukzzfnb gbm _{ufhfjg}fnb

CZ]$GJ: fz zn`{e`k gbm p{ufhfkm

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

22/65

Fbm{jkm

D BM7 BM5 A5 A= FJ

aMg

7;

5?

=?

:?

5;

XF X

Ifz$GJ:

Ifz }gc fz r: aMg

GJ: fz 7:= Gg )r7; aMg&

H{zfnb pun}kfb fz r79 aMg

79J.?"7dD F_]C.75$78 iuz

Z] Z _ D Z] Z _ Z] Z

_

XF FJ A5

aMg

7=

79

:;

5;

Z H] S D 7 5 : ; 3

9

Fbm{j}fnb nh Ifz$GJ: pun}kfbz

Kypukzzfnb punhf`k nh Ifz$GJ: pun}kfbz _{ufhfjg}fnb punhf`k nh Ifz$GJ: pun}kfb

]n@JAkX Ifz$GJ: _un}kfb Kypukzzfnb gbm _{ufhfjg}fnb

Ifz$GJ: fz zn`{e`k

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

23/65

A5 A=

J@

D XF

aMg

7;

5?

;?

=?

8?DE_$GJ:

A5 J@Z _ Z _

D

DE_ }gc fz =: aMg GJ: fz 7:= Gg )r7; aMg&

H{zfnb pun}kfb fz r ;9 aMg

79J.?"7dD F_]C.75$78 iuz

H] S7 S5 S: D 7 : ; 3 7 5 : = D

[J _J

DE_$GJ:

DE_

GJ:

[J _J JJ7 5

Fbm{j}fnb nh DE_$GJ: pun}kfbz Kypukzzfnb punhf`k nh

DE_$GJ: pun}kfbz

_{ufhfjg}fnb punhf`k nh DE_$GJ: pun}kfb _gu}fg` j`kgxgck ev Hgj}nu Yg Jndp`k}k j`kgxgck ev Hgj}nu Yg

]n@JAkX DE_$GJ: _un}kfb Kypukzzfnb gbm _{ufhfjg}fnb

DE_$GJ: fz zn`{e`k gbm p{ufhfkm }n66+ indnckbkf}v GJ: pukjfpf}g}kz {pnb j`kgxgck ev Hgj}nu Yg

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

24/65

Sig} fz }ik N`fcndkufj z}g}{z nh GJ:>

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

25/65

GJ: hnudz indn$n`fcndku

N`fcndkufzg}fnb nh GJ:

Fbp{} En{bm

CZ]$GJ:DE_

DE_$GJ:

D

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

26/65

Fbp{} En{bm

CZ]$GJ:DE_

DE_$GJ:

D

5 ; 9 77 7= 73 5? 5: 58 59 :? :5 := :8 :9 =? =5

QfT

QffT

Hugj}fnb Bn"

7;9aMg ==6aMg 886aMg

GJ: hnudz g ifciku numku indn$n`fcndku nh 75$7= dku

N`fcndkufzg}fnb nh GJ:

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

27/65

GJ: hnudz g ifciku numku indn$n`fcndku nh 75$7= dku

Z{pkumky 5?? ;.7;? :d` ekm xn`{dk 7":3= xnfm xn`{dk 5?? `.dfb h`ns ug}k

D]5??9L{56bn?77

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

28/65

Ins mnkz GJ: ghhkj} }ik Efnjikdfjg` punpku}fkz nh Ukp>

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

29/65

AgbBM7 A5 D

DJZ

Bjn

F YinF

J$Ifz ]gc]KX$Zf}k]3 _un @gj Np B$Ifz ]gc CZ]

pK]D:?

8:=8ep

YinF

Bn}F

KgcF

IfbmFFF

Zg`F

EgdIF

KjnUF

ZgjF

ApbF

BjnF

GJ7

]n@JAkX GJ7 J`nbfbc

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

30/65

aMg

79

:;

778

88

=;

D Z _ Z _

BM7 A5

F Z _ H] D 7 : ; 3 6

BM7 A5 D

Fbm{jkm

Ifz$CZ]$GJ7

F H] S7 S5 7 : ; 3 D

Fbm{j}fnb nh Ifz$CZ]$GJ7 pun}kfbz Kypukzzfnb punhf`k nh Ifz$CZ]$GJ7 pun}kfbz

_{ufhfjg}fnb punhf`k nh Ifz$CZ]$GJ7 pun}kfb

ev CZ] ukzfb

_{ufhfjg}fnb punhf`k nh Ifz$CZ]$GJ7 pun}kfb

ev Bf$B]G ukzfb

]n@JAkX Ifz$CZ]$GJ7 Kypukzzfnb gbm _{ufhfjg}fnb

Ifz$CZ]$GJ: fz fbzn`{e`k

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

31/65

[F F D Z _

DE_$GJ7

7 : ; 3 6 77 7: 7; 73

Fbm{j}fnb gbm kypukzzfnb punhf`k nh

DE_$GJ7 pun}kfb_{ufhfjg}fnb punhf`k nh DE_$GJ7

]n@JAkX DE_$GJ7 Kypukzzfnb gbm _{ufhfjg}fnb

DE_$GJ: fz fbzn`{e`k

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

32/65

CZ]

$GJ:!

DE_

$GJ7

CZ]

$GJ:!

DE_

DE_

$GJ7

D CZ]

$GJ:!DE_

$GJ7

CZ]

$GJ:!

DE_

DE_

$GJ7

DE_$GJ7

DE_

CZ]$GJ:

Fbp{} En{bm

778

88

=;

aMg

GJ7$GJ: Fb}kugj}fnb Z}{mfkz

CZ]$GJ: fb}kugj}z sf}i DE_$GJ7

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

33/65

DE_A5^GJ: )pdn`k&

Ukp )pdn`k& $ ?"7 ?"7 ?"7 ?"7 ?"7 ?"7 ?"7

$ $ ?"?5 ?"?8 ?"7 ?"5 ?": ?";

Uk`g}fxk)+&G]_

gzkgj}fxf}v

$ ?"7 ?"7 ?"7 ?"7 ?"7 ?"7 ?"7 $ ?"7 $ $ $

$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ ?"7 ?"7 $ $ $DE_ )pdn`k&

$ $ ?"?5 ?"?8 ?"7 ?"5 ?": ?"; $ $ ?"?5 ?"5?";

DE_GJ: )pdn`k&

7 5 : = ; 8 3 9 6 7? 77 75 7:

Ukp )pdn`k&

_:5 @gek``km

G]_

Uk`kgzkm

_f

Un`k nh GJ: nb G]_gzk Gj}fxf}v nh GJ7

GJ: kbigbjkz }ik G]_gzk gj}fxf}v nh Ukp ev ;?$9?+

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

34/65

Sig} guk }ik GJ: fb}kugj}fbc inz} pun}kfbz>

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

35/65

_{}g}fxk Fb}kugj}fbc _un}kfbz Fmkb}fhfkm ev _igck Mfzp`gv

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

36/65

_un}kfbz fbxn`xkm fb ukp`fjg}fnb gbm

ukjndefbg}fnb

_un}kfbz fbxn`xkm fb UBG zf`kbjfbc

GJ: Fb}kugj}fbc _kp}fmkz hund _igck Mfzp`gv Zjukkbfbc

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

37/65

_un}kfbz fbxn`xkm fb ifz}nbk gbm

MBG dnmfhfjg}fnb

_un}kfbz fbxn`xkm MBG nu UBG

pn`vdkufzg}fnb

GJ: Fb}kugj}fbc _kp}fmkz hund _igck Mfzp`gv Zjukkbfbc

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

38/65

Ins mnkz GJ: ghhkj} Ukp`fjg}fnb nh xfug` MBG>

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

39/65

_`gzdfm Ukp`fjg}fnb Khhfjfkbjv fb Vkgz}

Gdp

YinF

Ec` FF

GUZ

JKB=

[UG

VJp;?Ukp`fjg}fnb Khhfjfkb}

)!&

GUZ

YinF

Ec` FF

IfbmFFF

Gdp

JKB=

[UG

VJpN$ Ukp`fjg}fnb Fbkhhfjfkb}

)$&

IfbmFFF

IfbmFFF

Gdp

JKB=

[UG

JU$GJ:

Vkgz}

Ukp`fjnbUkp`fjg}fnb Khhfjfkb}

)!&

JU$GJ:

Un`k nh GJ: fb Ukp`fjg}fnb < Ky xfxn Dnmk` zvz}kd fb Vkgz}

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

40/65

7=38 epGJ: Z}gu}

JU GJ7

GJ5

GJ:

Un`k nh GJ: fb Ukp`fjg}fnb < GJ: D{}g}fnb

Vkgz} }ugbhnudkm sf}i }ik ]n@JAkX xfug` MBG cunsz z`ns`v

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

41/65

JU GJ7

GJ5

GJ: :;Z _un JU

DJZ

pJA5 Ukp`fjnb

r7; ae

Un`k nh GJ: fb Ukp`fjg}fnb < Fb p`gb}g Dnmk` zvz}kd

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

42/65

;?

7??

7;?

5??5;?

ep

J`nbfbc nh JU

Un`k nh GJ: fb Ukp`fjg}fnb < _`gb} Xkj}nu Jnbz}u{j}fnb

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

43/65

;?

7??

7;?

5??5;?

ep

pJgdefg!:;Z!A5^JU75775 ep

Bmk F $ =?7;

Bmk F $ 8;?=

Bmk F $ 6;5=

Bmk F $ 7735;

:;Z_

==?5

5=96

:?

5?

55?

7

JU

pJGDEFG7:67\!:;Z!JU

75775ep

J`nbfbc nh JU Zjikdg}fj mfgcugd zinsfbc }ik

ukz}ufj}fnb pg}}kub


8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

44/65

;?

7??

7;?

5??5;?

ep

5;?

;??

7???

7;??

5???

5;??:???

:;??

=???

;???

ep

pJgdefg!:;Z!A5^JU75775 ep

Bmk F $ =?7;

Bmk F $ 8;?=

Bmk F $ 6;5=

Bmk F $ 7735;

:;Z_

==?5

5=96

:?

5?

55?

7

JU

pJGDEFG7:67\!:;Z!JU

75775ep

J`nbfbc nh JU Zjikdg}fj mfgcugd zinsfbc }ik

ukz}ufj}fnb pg}}kub

Jnbhfudg}fnb nh JU

mfukj}fnb


8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

45/65

5;?

;??

3;?

7;??

5???5;??

7???

:???

ep

J`nbfbc nh JU$GJ:


8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

46/65

5;?

;??

3;?

7;??

5???5;??

7???

:???

ep

]n@JX A FF Ukp`fjnb7:683 ep

Bmk F $ =?7;

Bmk F $ 8;?=

Bmk F $ 6;5=

Bmk F $ 77?=3

Bmk F $ 7788?

Bmk F $ 7:;9?

JU

:;Z_

JU

$GJ:

5=96

:?5?

7;5:

87:

765? =

=?5

pJA5Ukp`fjnb

7:683 ep

J`nbfbc nh JU$GJ: Zjikdg}fj mfgcugd zinsfbc }ik

ukz}ufj}fnb pg}}kub


8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

47/65

5;?

;??

3;?

7;??

5???5;??

7???

:???

ep

:???:;??

=???

;???

5;?

;??

7???

7;??

5???5;??

3;?

ep

]n@JX A FF Ukp`fjnb7:683 ep

Bmk F $ =?7;

Bmk F $ 8;?=

Bmk F $ 6;5=

Bmk F $ 77?=3

Bmk F $ 7788?

Bmk F $ 7:;9?

JU

:;Z_

JU

$GJ:

5=96

:?5?

7;5:

87:

765? =

=?5

pJA5Ukp`fjnb

7:683 ep

J`nbfbc nh JU$GJ: Zjikdg}fj mfgcugd zinsfbc }ik

ukz}ufj}fnb pg}}kub

Jnbhfudg}fnb nh JU$GJ:

mfukj}fnb


8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

48/65

= mpf 7? mpf

pJA5U

kp`fj

nb

pJA5D U

kp`fjn

b

pJA5U

kp`fj

nb

pJA5D U

kp`fjn

b

pJA5U

kp`fj

nb

pJA5DU

kp`fj

nb

pJA5U

kp`fj

nb

pJA5D

Ukp`fjnb

D

Kpfzndk

Gj}fb

Un`k nh GJ:< Ukp`fjg}fnb Gzzgv fb ]negjjn

GJ: d{}g}fnb mnkz bn} ghhkj} xfug` ukp`fjg}fnb fb ]negjjn `kgxkz

U ` h GJ: f U `f f GJ: D f )Z m Z &

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

49/65

Un`k nh GJ: fb Ukp`fjg}fnb < GJ: D{}g}fnb )Zkjnbm Z}ug}kcv&

JU GJ7

GJ5

GJ:

D{}g}fnb zf}kz7=7=, 7=75 ep

U ` h GJ: f U `f }f GJ: D } }f )Z m Z} } &

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

50/65


JU GJ7

GJ5

GJ:


B{j`kn}fmk g`fcbdkb} zinsfbc }ik GJ: d{}g}fnbz

U ` h GJ: f U `f }f GJ: D } }f )Z m Z} } &

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

51/65


JU GJ7

GJ5

GJ:


B{j`kn}fmk g`fcbdkb} zinsfbc }ik GJ: d{}g}fnbz

_un}kfb g`fcbdkb} zinsfbc }ik GJ: d{}g}fnbz

U ` h GJ: U `f }f G f ] }

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

52/65

Un`k nh GJ:< Ukp`fjg}fnb Gzzgv fb ]ndg}n

7;mpf

Ukp`fjnb

Gj}fb

7?mpf;mpf

Kpfzndk

GJ: kbigbjkz ukp`fjg}fnb nh xfug` MBG fb }ndg}n p`gb}z

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

53/65

Mnkz GJ: ghhkj} UBGf fb p`gb}z>

U ` h GJ: f UBGf F f D m ` } f _` }

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

54/65

JU GJ7

GJ5

GJ: :;Z _un JU

DJ

Z

pJA5 Ukp`fjnb

r7; ae

_JBG

JU

_JB

G

Kpfzndk

5"9 ae

Un`k nh GJ: fb UBGf < Fb xfxn Dnmk` zvz}kd fb _`gb}

U ` h GJ: f UBGf _JBG Zf` f f ] }

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

55/65

Sf`m }vpk XFCZ xkj}nu GJ: d{}g}km XFCZ

xkj}nu

Jnb}un` xkj}nu

Un`k nh GJ: fb UBGf < _JBG Zf`kbjfbc fb ]ndg}n

GJ: kbigbjkz _JBG ckbk zf`kbjfbc fb ]ndg}n p`gb}z

Un`k nh GJ: fb UBGf _JBG Zf`kbjfbc fb ]ndg}n

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

56/65

Ukm{jkm h`nskufbc

nezkuxkm fb sf`m}vpkXFCZ fbhf`}ug}km }ndg}n

p`gb}

Bnudg` h`nskufbc gbm

hu{f} hnudg}fnb nezkuxkmfb GJ: d{}g}km XFCZ

fbhf`}ug}km }ndg}n p`gb}

Mkhnudf}fkz nezkuxkm fb

`kgxkz nh sf`m }vpk XFCZfbhf`}ug}km }ndg}n p`gb}

Un`k nh GJ: fb UBGf < _JBG Zf`kbjfbc fb ]ndg}n

_JBG zf`kbjkm p`gb} igz ukm{jkm h`nskufbc gbm g`}kukm `kgh dnupin`ncv

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

57/65

Z{ddguv

Z{ddguv

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

58/65

Ukjndefbgb} ]n@JAkX GJ: pun}kfb sgz p{ufhfkm gz gb DE_ h{zfnb pun}kfb }n g

indnckbkf}v nh r 66+

GJ: hnudz ifciku numku indn$n`fcndku jnbzfz}fbc nh 75$7= dku )dglnu& gbm

mfdku )dfbnu&

GJ: n`fcndkufzkz sf}i GJ7 gbm kbigbjkz }ik G]_gzk gj}fxf}v nh GJ7 }n gb

ky}kb} nh ;?$9?+

_igck mfzp`gv fmkb}fhfkm xgufn{z p{}g}fxk GJ: fb}kugj}fbc inz} pun}kfbz hund

xgufn{z dk}gen`fj pg}isgvz fbj`{mfbc MBG gbm ifz}nbk dnmfhfjg}fnb, MBG

ukp`fjg}fnb gbm UBGf

Ky xfxn gbm Fb p`gb}g xkj}nu zvz}kdz skuk mkxk`npkm }n z}{mv }ik un`k nh xfug`

ukp`fjg}fnb" GJ: kbigbjkz ukp`fjg}fnb fb p`gb}g ev 5$: hn`m fb }ndg}n kgxkz

Fb p`gb}g ukp`fjnb xkj}nu sgz {}f`fzkm hnu xfu{z fbm{jkm ckbk zf`kbjfbc nh _JBG

fb }ndg}n p`gb}z" Zf`kbjfbc nh _JBG sgz pikbn}vpfjg``v z}unbc fb sf`m}vpk XFCZ

xkj}nu fb jndpgufzfnb }n GJ: d{}g}km XFCZ xkj}nu

Z{ddguv

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

59/65

_unpnzkm Dnmk`

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

60/65

]n@JAkXGJ:

Fb}kugj}z sf}i inz} pun}kfbz )_JBG,

pUEU, Z`BGJ7 k}j",& gbm Ukp pun}kfb

}n kbigbjkz MBG ukp`fjg}fnb ev 5$:

hn`m

GJ: kbigbjkz zf`kbjfbc punege`v ev

fb}kugj}fbc sf}i inz} pun}kfbz )Gcn7,

Gcn3, Mj`7, Mj`5, IKB7 k}j",&

Gjabns`kmckdkb}z

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

61/65

Gjabns`kmckdkb}z

Mu Bfu{pgd U Jin{mi{uvMu Z{bf` D{aikulkk

Mu Bkk}f

_gmdgziukk Z{mifu A Znpnuv

_unh XZ Jig{igb

Mu Zigifm Lgdkk`

Mu Aufzibgd{}iv Bg}guglgb

Mu DA Ukmmv

Mu ]{}klg

Mu Zbki `g}gMu Z{ukzi Bgfu

Mu _gsgb Dg`in}ug

Mu Ugl Eig}bgcguMu Zifxg Ukmmv

Mu @kk`gxg}if

Mu Bfu{pgdg Eig}bgcgu

Z{dgb Ugblgb Mgz

Agbbgb

Migudkbmug

Anzg`gf

Glgv

Ugef

Gjabns`kmckdkb}z

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

62/65

Xfagzi

_ugblg`

Lgdf`Ckk}fag

_ukubg

Ghzgu

Xfpfb

Ei{egb

Mkkp}f

_gbagl

Ugzidf

Dkk}{

Zgdkku

Z{zikk`

[uxgzif

Migudkbmug _ug}gp

Lvn}f

Bfzigb}

Gjabns`kmckdkb}z

]gbi

]fkb

Gujigbg_ukk}f

Zgdkkbg

Mkkpga

Ugxfagb}i

_nnlg

B{lig}Xgbmf}g

Z{migagu

Dg``fagul{b

Jigbmugzkaigu

Zg}fziV{a}f

I{bc

Dkdekuz nh _DE

Dkdekuz nh FF h`nnu

Dv hufkbmz fb FJCKE

Gjabns`kmckdkb}z

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

63/65

Bgxnmgvg Xfmvg`gvgJig`gja{u}iv Jgdp

Zjinn` nh Efn}kjibn`ncvDgm{ugf Agdgugl [bfxkuzf}v

Afzinuk Xgfcvgbfa _un}zgigb Vnlgbg

MZ] ( FFZj

JZFU

Gjabns`kmckdkb}z

Zfmmigu}ig Jn``kck nh Gu}z( Zjfkbjk

Xflgvgsgmg

FJCKE

Gjabns`kmckdkb}z

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

64/65

Gjabns`kmckdkb}z

FJCKE 5??=$?6

Gjabns`kmckdkb}z

8/14/2019 PhD Viva_ 5Nov09

65/65

Gjabns`kmckdkb}z

]gu{b A Eig}}Mfsgagu A{dgu

Dv Hgdf`v

Documents

PhD Viva_ 5Nov09