22
PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS FROM ALGAL OIL CONSUMED IN GELCAP AND LIPOSOMAL BEVERAGE FORM OVERVIEW OF STUDY RESULTS JULY 9, 2019

PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

PILOTSTUDYOFUPTAKEOFLONGCHAINFATTYACIDSFROMALGALOILCONSUMEDINGELCAPAND

LIPOSOMALBEVERAGEFORM

OVERVIEWOFSTUDYRESULTS

JULY9,2019

Page 2: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

OVERVIEWOFSTUDYRESULTS

PILOTSTUDYOFUPTAKEOFLONGCHAINFATTYACIDSFROMALGALOILCONSUMEDINGELCAPANDLIPOSOMALBEVERAGEFORM

Background:

Longchainomega-3fattyacids(EPAandDHA)asnaturaltriglyceridesfromoilyfishareessentiallycompletelybio-available,estimatedat90–95%.Thefatemulsiondropletsfromthisformareaboutonemicronindiameter

Dietarysupplementformscomeasnaturaloiltriglycerideorinare-esterifiedformastheethylesterorastriglyceridesenrichedinEPAandDHA.Severalfactorsaffecttheavailabilityoftheomega-3fromthesesupplements,includingthespecificmolecularform,whetherornotconsumedwithfood(andthefood’sfatcontent),andthemannerandextentofdispersionoftheomegainthesupplementmatrix.Inaddition,thereissignificantvariabilitybetweenindividuals.

StudyDesignforOmega-3TriglyceridesfromAlgalOil(uncontrolled)

HMRI(Pasadena,Dr.MichaelHarringtonPI)recruited31studyparticipantsonconsent#27197foralongchainfattyacidplasmaPKstudy.Allparticipantswerehealthynon-obeseadultswhowerenottakingomega-3supplementsorprescriptionmedications.Withinformedconsent,individualsparticipatedinan8-hourstudyandwererandomlyallocatedtooneofthetreatmentgroups,eachwiththesameoverallquantityofDHA/EPA.Onegroupreceivedaliposomepreparation,theothercommercialGELCAPS.Thetwogroupswerefoundtobematchedbyage,sex,andBMI.Theycommencedthestudyafteranovernight(12h)fastat8am.Afterabaselineblooddraw,theywereallgivenalowfatbreakfastat9am,followedbylunchatnoon.

Thefollowingprocedurewasemployed:

• Intravenouslineinserted• 2mLofvenousbloodatbaseline• Drinkliposomebeverage(nof15)orswallowgelcap(nof15).• Combined(EPA+DHA)dose900mgineachcase• ThealgaloilinbothformswasDSM“Life’sOmega45”• Hourlybloodcollectionsof2mLto8hours• Separateandaliquotplasmasamples,into100ulcontainers,andfreeze(-80C)• Assayfattyacidsbyextraction,derivatizationandGCMS

SummaryofResults

Figures1and2showallthedataforincreaseabovebaselineforEPAandDHAconcentrationsinplasmainug/ml.Theleftportionofeachchartshowstheliposomeformdataandtherightportiontheresultsforgelcaps.Thearrowineachpanelshowsthedivisionbetweengroups.Eachparticipantisrepresentedbynineconsecutivedatapoints(baselineto8hours)startingwithafattyacidconcentrationchangeof

Page 3: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

zero;dataareshownconsecutivelywitheach“hump”inthecharteffectivelyshowingresultsforoneindividual.Ofthe31individuals,datawereanalyzedfor28,fourteenineachgroup.Baselineplasmasampleswereinadvertentlypooledforthreesubjectsandplasmalevelchangesrelativetobaselinecouldthusnotbeevaluated.Thechartsshowthesesubjectsasbaseline(zero)valuesforalltimepoints.Astrikinglyanomaloushighearlyvalue(bothDHAandEPA)wasobserved,andconfirmed,foronegelcapsubject.Insomeanalysesthisvaluewasexcluded.

AnalysisofpercentchangeoverbaselineforthetotalofEPA+DHAisshowninFigure3forthegelcapandliposomegroups.Dataareshownasmeanwithstandarderrorastheerrorbar.Forcomparison,peak(Cmax)dataforLovaza(purifiedethylesterformfromfishoil),dosedat3.6gEPA+DHA,isshownattheappropriatetimepoint(6hours)Harrisetal(2103),asisacalculatedfour-foldlowervaluefor0.9gdose.Withnumerouscaveats,adosecorrected(arithmetic)crossstudycomparisonsuggeststhealgaloilgivesbetteruptake(Cmaxratio)byaboutafactorof3ingelcapsandbetweenfourandfivefortheliposomalpresentation.

Forabsolute(ug/ml)increasesinEPAandDHAinplasmatheaverageddatafortheindividualsineachofthetwogroupsareshowninFigures4and5(meanwithSEMerrorbars).Theliposomalformshowsabouta35%enhancementforEPAandalmost80%enhancementforDHA,whetherassessedbyCmaxorAUCto8hours.

Evenintheaverageddatacharts,itisclearthatthereisamorerapidappearanceoftheEPAandDHAinplasmafromtheliposomalpresentation.ForindividualsubjectsthelinearregressionanalysisofinitialslopeforEPAandDHArisetoCmaxinplasmaareshowninFigures6and7,withaveragesshownasthedashedline.Allratesareshownasug/ml/hour.ForEPAandDHA,respectively,therateofappearanceis1.4andalmost3timesgreater.Inthisanalysis,thenon-responderswereexcludedfromeachgroup–theseindividualsarereadilyapparentinFigures1and2.Notrevealedbythesegraphsisthelagtimeseenforsomeofthegelcaprecipientsforwhomanysignificantriseinplasmadoesnotbeginuntilhour2.Thislagis,however,visibleinplotsofthepercentchangeoverbaselinefor(EPA+DHA)forindividuals.TheseareshowninFigures8and9thatincludeexpandedplotsfortheinitialuptakeperiod.Changeoverbaselineattwohoursislessthan10%for6of14GelCapconsumers(andlessthan20%for10ofthe14).Incontrastfortheliposomegrouponlytwoindividualshadalessthan10%risebytwohours(andthreelessthan20%atthesametimepoint).Whilethe10%and20%thresholdsarearbitrary(butrelatetotheCVofabout10%fortheassaymethod),thefractional“delayed-response”toomega-3dosingisaquantitativeindicatorofthecleardifferenceinlagseenforthedifferentdosageforms.

Overall,thereisnocorrelationofuptakewithage,sex,weightBMIetc.Whilethisstudyonlyhas14individualsineachgroup,thedatahintatadependenceofpeakplasmalevelandAUC(8hrs)onthebaselinetotalfattyacidlevelinindividualsconsumingtheliposomalform.Suchadependenceappearsessentiallyabsentforgelcapconsumers.Figures10-13.Thismayreflectanatural(baseline)digestiveefficiencyfortriglyceridesthatcorrelateswithhigherbaselinefattyacidlevels.Thatefficiencyispotentiallyimmediatelyaccessibleforprocessingthehighlydigestibleliposomepresentationofomega-3triglycerides(inthenaturalmoleculardispersioninphospholipids).Itdoesnotfactorintodigestionof

Page 4: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

thegelcapsforwhichtriglyceridesarriveintheduodenuminmuchlargerfatemulsiondropletsinchyme.

AsshowninFigure14,baselinetotalfattyacidlevelswererandomlydistributedbetweenthetwogroups

Context

Thereisverylimitedinformationaboutthequantitativeextentofuptakeforomega-3supplements,i.e.fractionofthedosegiventhatisabsorbed.ThekeystudiesarebyLawsonandHughes1988(a)whousedlinseedoilasaninternalstandardfor“naturaluptake”.Thoseauthors’workincludedassessmentoftheeffectofahighfatmeal(44gfat)consumedwiththeomega-3productLawsonandHughes1988(b).DatafromthosestudiesarereferencedtotheCmaxforlinseedoilas100%,butthenaturaluptakeofdietaryfatisknowntobebetween90%and95%.ThedatafromLawsonandHughesarepresentedinFigure15below,correctedto92.5%uptakefordietarytriglycerides(illustratedhereforsalmon).TheadditionoffatapproximatelytriplesuptakeforethylesterformsofEPAandDHA.ForthetriglycerideformhigheruptakeforbothEPAandDHAisseeninthelowfatcase.However,foradditionoffattheEPAuptakeapproachesthatseenfordietaryfatswhereastheDHAuptakeislargelyunchanged.Theadditionoffatispresumedtostimulatethedeploymentoflipases,bilesaltsandphospholipidstoboostdigestion.Ethylestersareknowntobelessreadilycleavedthantriglyceridesbypancreaticlipasesandthusshowahigherresponsetothisdigestiveboost.Forthetriglycerides,susceptibilitytoenzymatichydrolysishasbeenpostulatedtorelatetodifferentialpositionaldistributionofEPAandDHAonglycerol,aswellasapotentialeffectoftheadditionaldoublebondclosetotheesterlinkageforDHA.

Thereareotherstudies,someathigherdoses,thatsuggesttheethylestersandtriglyceridesgivesimilarplasmaincreasesfortheselongchainfattyacids.TheassumptionweuseisthatinthemoderatedoserangeweandLawsonandHugheshavestudied(lessthan1.7gramEPA+DHA)thetriglyceridesprovideaboutthreetimestheplasmariseasethylesters.ApplyingtheratioforindividualCmax(EPAandDHAabsoluteincreaseoverbaseline)forliposomes(vsgelcaps)fromFigures4and5providestheprojectedextentofliposomaluptakeforboththesefattyacidsasalmostthatofdietarytriglycerides.ThealternativecalculationusingratiosofpercentincreaseoverbaselineofcombinedEPA+DHAtotheethylesterdataofHarrisetal(2013)(Figure3)givesconsistentEPA+DHAcompositeresultsforgelcapsandliposomesshownbythegreenverticalarrowsinFigure15

Conclusion

Itisnotnecessarytotakehighpotencytriglycerideformgelcapswith300+caloriesoffat(a44gfatmeal

=1.25ozbutter!)fornatural,dietarytriglyceride,uptakeofEPA.Further,theliposomescanimprove

DHAuptakeinawaythatevenahighfatmealcannot.Theliposomalbeveragecanprovideessentially

naturaluptakelevelsofbothlongchainomega-3fattyacidswitharelativelyrapidrisetopeakplasma

levelsafterconsumption.

Page 5: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched
Page 6: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

Figure1:ChangeinEPAconcentrationinplasma–alldata

Page 7: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

Figure2:ChangeinDHAconcentrationinplasm

a–alldata

Page 8: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

Figure3:Percentchangein(EPA+DHA)inplasm

a

2.9x

4.7x

Page 9: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

Figure4:AbsoluteincreaseinEPAinplasma

Page 10: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

Figure5:AbsoluteincreaseinDHAinplasm

a

Page 11: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

Figure6:EPArateofincreasetoCmaxinplasm

a

Liposom

es:GelCaps1.44x

Page 12: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

Figure7:DHArateofincreasetoCm

axinplasmaAllratesareshow

nasug/ml/hour.

Liposomes:GelCaps2.95x

Page 13: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

Figure8(a):RateofuptakeGelCap(EPA+DHA)percentincreaseinplasm

aoverbaseline

Page 14: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

Figure8(b):expanded-initial3hoursAtt=2hours:6/14show

<10%changeoverbaseline

10/14show<20%

changeoverbaseline

Page 15: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

Figure9(a):RateofuptakeLiposomes(EPA+DH

A)forindividuals.

Page 16: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

Figure9(b):expandedAtt=2hours:2/14show

<10%changeoverbaseline

3/14show<20%

changeoverbaseline

Page 17: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

Figure10:GelCapsAUCvsbaselinetotalfattyacid

Page 18: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

Figure11:GelCapsCmaxvsbaselinetotalfattyacid

.

Page 19: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

Figure12:LiposomesAUCvsbaselinetotalfattyacid

Page 20: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

Figure13:LiposomesCm

axvsbaselinetotalfattyacid.,

Page 21: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

Figure14:Baselinetotalfattyaciddistributionbygroup

Page 22: PILOT STUDY OF UPTAKE OF LONG CHAIN FATTY ACIDS …Dietary supplement forms come as natural oil triglyceride or in a re-esterified form as the ethyl ester or as triglycerides enriched

Figure15:Bioavailability.,