Upload
james-cook
View
232
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
1/382
{00255828;1} 1PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Francis Malofiy, EsquireFrancis Alexander, LLC280 N. Providence Rd. | Suite 1Media, PA 19063T: (215) 500-1000; F: (215) 500-1005
E: [email protected] for Plaintiff
Glen L. Kulik, Esq.Kulik Gottesman & Siegel LLP15303 Ventura Blvd., Suite 1400Sherman Oaks, CA 91403T: (310) 557-9200; F: (310) 557-0224E: [email protected]
Attorney for Plaintiff
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
MICHAEL SKIDMORE, as Trustee forthe RANDY CRAIG WOLFE TRUST,
Plaintiff,
v.
LED ZEPPELIN; JAMES PATRICKPAGE; ROBERT ANTHONY PLANT;JOHN PAUL JONES; SUPER HYPEPUBLISHING, INC.; WARNER MUSICGROUP CORP., Parent ofWARNER/CHAPPELL MUSIC, INC.;ATLANTIC RECORDING
CORPORATION; RHINOENTERTAINMENT COMPANY,
Defendants.
Case No. 15-cv-03462 RGK (AGRx)
Hon. R. Gary Klausner
PLAINTIFF SUPPLEMENTALEXHIBIT LIST
TRIAL: JUNE 14, 2016
TIME: 9:00 A.M.
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 1 of 383 Page ID#:6527
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
2/382
{00255828;1} 2PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Objections
Date Date
Adm.Description Id.
AUDIO
EXHIBITS
1A
Audio Exhibit1: Dazed andConfused byLed Zeppelin(1969)[207A]
Defs: general objection, as to the
entire Joint Exhibit List, thatplaintiff has insisted upon theinclusion of material not properly orreasonably considered an exhibit fortrial, has failed to identify whatdocuments or recordings he isreferring to, and has otherwise notcooperated in the preparation of aproper Joint Exhibit List. As to thisspecific exhibit: Defs MIL # 5, FRE407, 408, 401-02, 403, 404; failure
to identify/provide expert testimonyas to claimed use, FRCP 26(a),26(e), 37(c)(1).
2A
Audio Exhibit2: Dazed andConfused byJake Holmes(1967)[208A]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
3A
Audio Exhibit3: Whole LottaLove by Led
Zeppelin(1969)[409A]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony as
to claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
4A
Audio Exhibit4: Muddy
Waters YouNeed Love(1962)(10
seconds 28seconds)[209A]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
5A
Audio Exhibit5: The Small
Faces YouNeed Loving(1966)(25
seconds 48seconds)[210A]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,
401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
6A
Audio Exhibit6: Live
performance ofLed Zeppelin
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 2 of 383 Page ID#:6528
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
3/382
{00255828;1} 3PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
playing FreshGarbage
(1101969)[206A]
7A
Audio Exhibit7: Stairway to
Heaven (0seconds 25
seconds)
Defs: failure to identify whetherrefers to officially released version
or plaintiffs recreated versions,which are irrelevant, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, & lack foundation, MIL# 4, failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4); entire,officially release version is relevantwork.
8A
Audio Exhibit8: Taurus (45seconds 1minute, 13
seconds)
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 1002.
9A
Audio Exhibit9: 8 measures ofStairway fromnote 1 of the
acoustic guitar,repeated
multiple times[42A]
Defs: failure to identify whetherrefers to officially released versionor plaintiffs recreated versions,which are irrelevant, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, & lack foundation, MIL# 4, failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4); entire,officially release version is relevantwork.
10A
Audio Exhibit
10: 8 Measuresof Taurus from
note 1 of theacoustic guitar,
repeatedmultiple times
[43A]
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE 401-02, 403, 1002.
11A
Audio Exhibit11: 8 measuresof Stairway and
Taurus playedtogether fromnote 1 of the
acoustic guitar,repeated
multiple times[44A]
Defs: as to Taurus, Defs MIL # 3, #4, FRE 401-02, 403, 1002; as toStairway, failure to identify whetherrefers to officially released version
or plaintiffs recreated versions,which are irrelevant, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, & lack foundation, MIL# 4, failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4), entire,officially release version is relevantwork.
AUDIO
EXHIBITS
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 3 of 383 Page ID#:6529
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
4/382
{00255828;1} 4PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
COMPRASIO
N AUDIO
12A
Audio Exhibit12:Acoustic
Defs: failure to identify audioexhibit and what works recorded; asto Taurus, Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE401-02, 403, 1002; as to Stairway,
failure to identify whether refers toofficially released version orplaintiffs recreated versions, whichare irrelevant, FRE 401-02, 403,1002, & lack foundation, MIL # 4,failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4); entire,officially release version is relevantwork.
Guitar
13AAudio Exhibit
13:Bass
Defs: failure to identify audioexhibit and what works recorded; as
to Taurus, Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE401-02, 403, 1002; as to Stairway,failure to identify whether refers toofficially released version orplaintiffs recreated versions, whichare irrelevant, FRE 401-02, 403,1002, & lack foundation, MIL # 4,failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4); entire,officially release version is relevantwork.
14AAudio Exhibit
14:Drums
Defs: failure to identify audioexhibit and what works recorded; asto Taurus, Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE401-02, 403, 1002; as to Stairway,failure to identify whether refers toofficially released version orplaintiffs recreated versions, whichare irrelevant, FRE 401-02, 403,1002, & lack foundation, MIL # 4,failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4); entire,
officially release version is relevantwork.
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 4 of 383 Page ID#:6530
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
5/382
{00255828;1} 5PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
15A
Audio Exhibit
15: Electric 12Strings
Defs: failure to identify audioexhibit and what works recorded; asto Taurus, Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE401-02, 403, 1002; as to Stairway,failure to identify whether refers toofficially released version or
plaintiffs recreated versions, whichare irrelevant, FRE 401-02, 403,1002, & lack foundation, MIL # 4,failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4); entire,officially release version is relevantwork.
16AAudio Exhibit
16: ElectricPiano
Defs: failure to identify audioexhibit and what works recorded; asto Taurus, Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE401-02, 403, 1002; as to Stairway,
failure to identify whether refers toofficially released version orplaintiffs recreated versions, whichare irrelevant, FRE 401-02, 403,1002, & lack foundation, MIL # 4,failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4); entire,officially release version is relevantwork.
17AAudio Exhibit17: End Guitar
Defs: failure to identify audioexhibit and what works recorded; as
to Taurus, Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE401-02, 403, 1002; as to Stairway,failure to identify whether refers toofficially released version orplaintiffs recreated versions, whichare irrelevant, FRE 401-02, 403,1002, & lack foundation, MIL # 4,failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4); entire,officially release version is relevantwork.
18AAudio Exhibit18:Les Pauls
Defs: failure to identify audioexhibit and what works recorded; asto Taurus, Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE401-02, 403, 1002; as to Stairway,failure to identify whether refers toofficially released version orplaintiffs recreated versions, whichare irrelevant, FRE 401-02, 403,1002, & lack foundation, MIL # 4,
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 5 of 383 Page ID#:6531
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
6/382
{00255828;1} 6PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4); entire,officially release version is relevantwork.
19AAudio Exhibit19: Recorders
Defs: failure to identify audioexhibit and what works recorded; as
to Taurus, Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE401-02, 403, 1002; as to Stairway,failure to identify whether refers toofficially released version orplaintiffs recreated versions, whichare irrelevant, FRE 401-02, 403,1002, & lack foundation, MIL # 4,failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4); entire,officially release version is relevantwork.
20AAudio Exhibit
20: Slide
Defs: failure to identify audioexhibit and what works recorded; asto Taurus, Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE401-02, 403, 1002; as to Stairway,failure to identify whether refers toofficially released version orplaintiffs recreated versions, whichare irrelevant, FRE 401-02, 403,1002, & lack foundation, MIL # 4,failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4); entire,
officially release version is relevantwork.
21AAudio Exhibit
21: Solo
Defs: failure to identify audioexhibit and what works recorded; asto Taurus, Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE401-02, 403, 1002; as to Stairway,failure to identify whether refers toofficially released version orplaintiffs recreated versions, whichare irrelevant, FRE 401-02, 403,1002, & lack foundation, MIL # 4,
failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4); entire,officially release version is relevantwork.
AUDIO
EXHIBITS
RE-
RECORDING
OF TAURUS
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 6 of 383 Page ID#:6532
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
7/382
{00255828;1} 7PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
22AAudio Exhibit22: Acoustic
Guitar
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE 401-02, 403, 1002.
23AAudio Exhibit
23:Cello 1Defs: Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE 401-02, 403, 1002.
24A Audio Exhibit24: Cello 2 Defs: Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE 401-02, 403, 1002.
25AAudio Exhibit25: Cymbal
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE 401-02, 403, 1002.
26AAudio Exhibit
26: FluteDefs: Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE 401-02, 403, 1002.
27AAudio Exhibit
27: HarpsichordDefs: Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE 401-02, 403, 1002.
28AAudio Exhibit28: String Bass
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE 401-02, 403, 1002.
29A Audio Exhibit29: Viola
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE 401-02, 403, 1002.
30AAudio Exhibit
30: ViolinsDefs: Defs MIL # 3, # 4, FRE 401-02, 403, 1002.
AUDIO
EXHIBITS
ALEXANDER
STEWART
31A
Audio Exhibit31: Stairway to
Heaven(album)
32AAudio Exhibit32: Taurus
(album)
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 1002.
33A
Audio Exhibit33:Taurus Liveat Ash Grove(7/10/1967)
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, 802.
34A
Audio Exhibit34: Taurus Live
at Ash Grove(7/31/1967)
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,
403, 1002, 802.
35A
Audio Exhibit35:Taurus Liveat Ash Grove
(8/8/1967)
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, 802.
36AAudio Exhibit
36:TaurusDemo
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, 802.
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 7 of 383 Page ID#:6533
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
8/382
{00255828;1} 8PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Recording(8/1967)
37A
Audio Exhibit37: Taurus
Live atKaleidoscope
(4/5/1968)
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, 802.
38A
Audio Exhibit38: Taurus Live
at The TimeCoast
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, 802.
39A
Audio Exhibit39: Taurus Live
at Acoustic(1996)
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, 802.
40A
Audio Exhibit40:
Combination Acoustic TaurusSynced to STH
SR Part A,played over
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, #4, FRE 401-02, 403, 1002, 802.
Master SR ofSTH
41A
Audio Exhibit41:Acoustic
Taurus Syncedto Master SR ofSTH Part A
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, #4, FRE 401-
02, 403, 1002.
42A
Audio Exhibit42: Stairway
Acoustic PartA [9A]
Defs: Defs MIL #4, FRE 401-02,403, 1002.
43A
Audio Exhibit43: Taurus
Acoustic PartA [10A]
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, #4, FRE 401-02, 403, 1002.
44A
Audio Exhibit44:Combination
Acoustic TaurusSynced to
Master SR ofSTH (Part A),played over
Acoustic
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, #4, FRE 401-02, 403, 1002.
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 8 of 383 Page ID#:6534
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
9/382
{00255828;1} 9PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Stairway (PartA) [11A]
AUDIO
EXHIBITS
REBUTTAL
OF MATHES
45A
Audio Exhibit45: Mathes
Audio ExhibitTempo Matched
- Stairway
Defs: failure to identify and produceaudio exhibit and what worksrecorded; as to Taurus, Defs MIL #3, # 4, FRE 401-02, 403, 1002; as toStairway, failure to identify whetherrefers to officially released versionor plaintiffs recreated versions,which are irrelevant, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, & lack foundation, MIL# 4, failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4); entire,
officially release version is relevantwork.
46A
Audio Exhibit46: Mathes
Audio ExhibitTempo Matched
- Taurus
Defs: failure to identify and produceaudio exhibit and what worksrecorded; as to Taurus, Defs MIL #3, # 4, FRE 401-02, 403, 1002; as toStairway, failure to identify whetherrefers to officially released versionor plaintiffs recreated versions,which are irrelevant, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, & lack foundation, MIL
# 4, failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4); entire,officially release version is relevantwork.
47A
Audio Exhibit47: Mathes
Audio Exhibit
Tempo Matched- STH & Taurus
Defs: failure to identify and produceaudio exhibit and what worksrecorded; as to Taurus, Defs MIL #3, # 4, FRE 401-02, 403, 1002; as toStairway, failure to identify whetherrefers to officially released versionor plaintiffs recreated versions,
which are irrelevant, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, & lack foundation, MIL# 4, failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4); entire,officially release version is relevantwork.
51AAudio Exhibit
51: TaurusDeposit Copy
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 9 of 383 Page ID#:6535
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
10/382
{00255828;1} 10PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
(by Mathes)
52A
Audio Exhibit52: Taurus
Recording (byMathes)
Defs: failure to identify and produceaudio exhibit (Mathes provided onlyone audio recording of Taurusdeposit copy, listed above); FRE401-02, 403, 1002, & lackfoundation, MIL# 3, # 4, failure tocomply with FRCP 26(a)(2), (e) &(b)(4) .
53A
Audio Exhibit53:Combined -Taurus Deposit
Copy andTaurus
Recording (byMathes)
Defs: failure to identify and produceaudio exhibit (Mathes provided onlyone audio recording of Taurusdeposit copy, listed above); FRE401-02, 403, 1002, & lackfoundation, MIL # 3, # 4, failure tocomply with FRCP 26(a)(2), (e) &(b)(4).
54A
Audio Exhibit54: Stairway to
Heaven (byMathes)
Defs: failure to identify and produceaudio exhibit (description does notmatch audio recordings provided byMathes); to the extent plaintiff refersto another of plaintiffs audiorecordings, failure to identify andproduce audio exhibit, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, & lack foundation, MIL# 4, failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4).
55A
Audio Exhibit55: Combined -Taurus Deposit
Copy andStairway toHeaven (by
Mathes)
Defs: failure to identify and produceaudio exhibit (description does notmatch audio recordings provided byMathes); to the extent plaintiff refersto another of plaintiffs audiorecordings, failure to identify andproduce audio exhibit, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, & lack foundation, MIL# 3, # 4, failure to comply withFRCP 26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4).
56A
Audio Exhibit
56: Combined -Taurus
Recording andStairway toHeaven (by
Mathes)
Defs: failure to identify and produceaudio exhibit (Mathes provided onlyone audio recording of Taurusdeposit copy, listed above); FRE401-02, 403, 1002, & lackfoundation, MIL # 3, # 4, failure tocomply with FRCP 26(a)(2), (e) &(b)(4).
57AAudio Exhibit57:Combined
Defs: failure to identify and produceaudio exhibit (Mathes provided only
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 10 of 383 Page ID#:6536
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
11/382
{00255828;1} 11PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Taurus DepositCopy and
one audio recording of Taurusdeposit copy, listed above); FRE401-02, 403, 1002, & lackfoundation, MIL # 3, # 4, failure tocomply with FRCP 26(a)(2), (e) &(b)(4).
TaurusRecording and
Stairway
to Heaven (by
Mathes)
VIDEOEXHBITIS
DEMONSTRATIVE GUITARPERFORMAN
CE
58ASTH
Composition
(Hanson)
58.1AT Deposit -Bass Clef(Hanson)
58.2A
T Deposit -Bass Clef - STH
Composition(Hanson)
58.3AT Deposit -Treble Clef(Hanson)
58.4A
T Deposit -Treble Clef -STH
Composition(Hanson)
58.5A
T Deposit -Bass Clef -Treble Clef(Hanson)
58.6A
T Deposit -Bass Clef -
Treble Clef -STH
Composition(Hanson)
58.7A
T Deposit -Bass Clef
Arpeggio(Hanson)
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 11 of 383 Page ID#:6537
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
12/382
{00255828;1} 12PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
58.8A
T Deposit -Bass Clef
Arpeggio - STHComposition
(Hanson)
59A
T Deposit -
Bass ClefArpeggio -Treble Clef
59.1A
T Deposit -Bass ClefArpeggio -
Treble Clef -STH
Composition(Hanson)
59.2A
T Composition
(Hanson)
59.3A
T Composition- T Deposit -
Bass Clef(Hanson)
59.4A
T Composition- T Deposit -Treble Clef(Hanson)
59.5A
T Composition- STH
Composition(Hanson)
59.6A
T Composition- STH
Composition -T Deposit -Bass Clef(Hanson)
59.7A
T Composition- STH
Composition -T Deposit -Treble Clef(Hanson)
59.8A
T Composition- STH
Composition -T Deposit -Bass Clef -
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 12 of 383 Page ID#:6538
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
13/382
{00255828;1} 13PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Treble Clef(Hanson)
61A
Audio Exhibit61: Taurus
Deposit Copy(by Ferrara)
62A
Audio Exhibit62: Taurus
Recording (byFerrara)
Defs: failure to identify and produceaudio exhibit (Ferrara provided onlyone audio recording of Taurusdeposit copy, listed above); FRE401-02, 403, 1002, & lackfoundation, MIL # 3, # 4, failure tocomply with FRCP 26(a)(2), (e) &(b)(4).
63A
Audio Exhibit63:Combined -Taurus Deposit
Copy andTaurus
Recording (byFerrara)
Defs: failure to identify and produce
audio exhibit (Ferrara provided onlyone audio recording of Taurusdeposit copy, listed above); FRE401-02, 403, 1002, & lackfoundation, MIL # 3, # 4, failure tocomply with FRCP 26(a)(2), (e) &(b)(4).
64A
Audio Exhibit64: Stairway to
Heaven (byFerrara)
65A
Audio Exhibit65:Combined Taurus Deposit
Copy andStairway toHeaven (by
Ferrara)
Defs: failure to identify and produceaudio exhibit (description does notmatch audio recordings provided byFerrara); to the extent plaintiff refersto another of plaintiffs audiorecordings, failure to identify andproduce audio exhibit, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, & lack foundation, MIL# 4, failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4).
66A
Audio Exhibit66: Combined -
TaurusRecording and
Stairway toHeaven (by
Ferrara)
Defs: failure to identify and produce
audio exhibit (description does notmatch audio recordings provided byFerrara); to the extent plaintiff refersto another of plaintiffs audiorecordings, failure to identify andproduce audio exhibit, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, & lack foundation, MIL# 3, # 4, failure to comply withFRCP 26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4).
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 13 of 383 Page ID#:6539
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
14/382
{00255828;1} 14PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
67A
Audio Exhibit67: Combined Taurus Deposit
Copy andTaurus
Recording andStairway toHeaven (by
Ferrara)
Defs: failure to identify and produceaudio exhibit (description does notmatch audio recordings provided byFerrara); to the extent plaintiff refersto another of plaintiffs audiorecordings, failure to identify and
produce audio exhibit, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, & lack foundation, MIL# 3, # 4, failure to comply withFRCP 26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4).
70A
Combination:Taurus DepositCopy (Mathes)
Stairway toHeaven DepositCopy (Hanson)
Def: such a recording has never beenproduced to defendants; FRE 401-02, 403, 1002, & lack foundation,MIL # 3, # 4, failure to comply withFRCP 26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4).
71AAudio Exhibit71: TaurusDeposit Copy(by Hanson)
Def: such a recording has never been
produced to defendants; FRE 401-02, 403, 1002, & lack foundation,MIL # 3, # 4, failure to comply withFRCP 26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4).
72A
Audio Exhibit72: Taurus
Recording (byHanson)
Def: failure to identify and producerecording; FRE 401-02, 403, 1002,& lack foundation, MIL # 3 & #4,failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4).
73A
Audio Exhibit73: Combined -
Taurus DepositCopy and
TaurusRecording (by
Hanson)
Def: failure to identify and produce
recording; FRE 401-02, 403, 1002,& lack foundation, MIL # 3, # 4,failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4).
74A
Audio Exhibit74: Stairway to
Heaven (byHanson)
Def: failure to identify and producerecording; FRE 401-02, 403, 1002,& lack foundation, MIL # 4, failureto comply with FRCP 26(a)(2), (e)& (b)(4).
75A
Audio Exhibit
75: Combined -Taurus Deposit
Copy andStairway toHeaven (by
Hanson)
Defs: such a recording has neverbeen produced to defendants; FRE401-02, 403, 1002, & lackfoundation, MIL # 3, # 4, failure tocomply with FRCP 26(a)(2), (e) &(b)(4).
76AAudio Exhibit
76: Combined Taurus
Defs: such a recording has neverbeen produced to defendants; FRE401-02, 403, 1002, & lack
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 14 of 383 Page ID#:6540
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
15/382
{00255828;1} 15PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Recording andStairway toHeaven (by
Hanson)
foundation, MIL # 3, # 4, failure tocomply with FRCP 26(a)(2), (e) &(b)(4).
77A
Audio Exhibit77: Combined
Taurus DepositCopy and
TaurusRecording and
Stairway toHeaven (by
Hanson)
Defs: such a recording has neverbeen produced to defendants; FRE401-02, 403, 1002, & lackfoundation, MIL # 3, # 4, failure tocomply with FRCP 26(a)(2), (e) &(b)(4).
78A
Stairway toHeaven
RerecordingMix (Audio
Exhibits 12-21)
Def: such a recording has never beenproduced to defendants; FRE 401-02, 403, 1002, & lack foundation,MIL # 4, failure to comply with
FRCP 26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4).
79A
TaurusRerecordingMix (Audio
Exhibits 22-30)
Def: such a recording has never beenproduced to defendants; FRE 401-02, 403, 1002, & lack foundation,MIL # 3, # 4, failure to comply withFRCP 26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4).
DEPOSITION
S
80
Deposition of
Jimmy Page(01.07.2016)(Transcript)
Defs: a deposition is not an exhibit;
contains material inadmissible underFRE 401-02, 403, 407, 408, 701,802 and 805, & within MIL # 1, 2,3, 5, 11, 12, 14; failure to complywith LR 16-2.7 and, as a result,deprives defendants of opportunityto object to proffered testimony;improper use of deposition.
[Page]
80DDesignation ofJimmy Page
80M
Deposition of
Jimmy Page(01.07.2016)(Mini)[Page]
80V
Deposition ofJimmy Page
(01.07.2016)(VIDEO)[Page]
Defs: a deposition is not an exhibit;contains material inadmissible underFRE 401-02, 403, 407, 408, 701,802 and 805, & within MIL # 1, 2,3, 5, 11, 12, 14; failure to comply
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 15 of 383 Page ID#:6541
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
16/382
{00255828;1} 16PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
with LR 16-2.7 and, as a result,deprives defendants of opportunityto object to proffered testimony;improper use of deposition.
81
Deposition ofJohn Paul
Defs: a deposition is not an exhibit;contains material inadmissible under
FRE 401-02, 403, 407, 408, 701,802 and 805, & within MIL # 1, 2,3, 5, 11, 12, 14; failure to complywith LR 16-2.7 and, as a result,deprives defendants of opportunityto object to proffered testimony;improper use of deposition.
Jones(01.08.2016)
(Transcript)[Jones]
81V
Deposition ofJohn Paul
Jones(01.08.2016)(VIDE)[Jones]
Defs: a deposition is not an exhibit;contains material inadmissible underFRE 401-02, 403, 407, 408, 701,802 and 805, & within MIL # 1, 2,
3, 5, 11, 12, 14; failure to complywith LR 16-2.7 and, as a result,deprives defendants of opportunityto object to proffered testimony;improper use of deposition.
82
Deposition ofJay Ferguson
(01.13.2016)(Transcript)[Fergus
on]
Defs: a deposition is not an exhibit;contains material inadmissible underFRE 401-02, 403, 407, 408, 701,802 and 805, & within MIL # 1, 2,3, 5, 11, 14; failure to comply withLR 16-2.7 and, as a result, deprives
defendants of opportunity to objectto proffered testimony; improper useof deposition.
82V
Deposition ofJay Ferguson
(01.13.2016)(VIDEO)[Ferguson
]
Defs: a deposition is not an exhibit;contains material inadmissible underFRE 401-02, 403, 407, 408, 701,802 and 805, & within MIL # 1, 2,3, 5, 11, 12, 14; failure to complywith LR 16-2.7 and, as a result,deprives defendants of opportunityto object to proffered testimony;
improper use of deposition.
83
Deposition ofMark Andes
(01.15.2016)(Transcript)[Andes
]
Defs: a deposition is not an exhibit;contains material inadmissible underFRE 401-02, 403, 407, 408, 701,802 and 805, & within MIL # 1, 2,3, 5, 11, 14; failure to comply withLR 16-2.7 and, as a result, deprivesdefendants of opportunity to objectto proffered testimony; improper use
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 16 of 383 Page ID#:6542
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
17/382
{00255828;1} 17PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
of deposition.
83V
Deposition ofMark Andes
(01.15.2016)(VIDEO)[Andes]
Defs: a deposition is not an exhibit;contains material inadmissible underFRE 401-02, 403, 407, 408, 701,802 and 805, & within MIL # 1, 2,3, 5, 11, 12, 14; failure to complywith LR 16-2.7 and, as a result,deprives defendants of opportunityto object to proffered testimony;improper use of deposition.
84
Deposition ofBruce Pates
(01.22.2016)(Transcript)[Pates]
Defs: a deposition is not an exhibit;
contains material inadmissible underFRE 401-02, 403, 407, 408, 701,802 and 805, & within MIL # 1, 2,3, 5, 11, 14; failure to comply withLR 16-2.7 and, as a result, deprivesdefendants of opportunity to objectto proffered testimony; improper useof deposition.
85Deposition ofRobert Plant
(01.29.2016)(Transcript)[Plant]
Defs: a deposition is not an exhibit;contains material inadmissible underFRE 401-02, 403, 407, 408, 701,
802 and 805, & within MIL # 1, 2,3, 5, 11, 12, 14; failure to complywith LR 16-2.7 and, as a result,deprives defendants of opportunityto object to proffered testimony;improper use of deposition.
85V
Deposition ofRobert Plant
(01.29.2016)(VIDEO)[Plant]
Defs: a deposition is not an exhibit;contains material inadmissible underFRE 401-02, 403, 407, 408, 701,802 and 805, & within MIL # 1, 2,3, 5, 11, 12, 14; failure to comply
with LR 16-2.7 and, as a result,deprives defendants of opportunityto object to proffered testimony;improper use of deposition.
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 17 of 383 Page ID#:6543
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
18/382
{00255828;1} 18PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
86
Deposition ofMichael
Skidmore(02.05.2016)(Tr
anscript)[Skidmore]
Defs: a deposition is not an exhibit;contains material inadmissible underFRE 401-02, 403, 407, 408, 701,802 and 805, & within MIL # 1, 2,3, 5, 11, 14; failure to comply withLR 16-2.7 and, as a result, deprives
defendants of opportunity to objectto proffered testimony; improper useof deposition.
87
Deposition ofWilliam
Ruhlmann(02.08.2016)(Transcript)[Ruhlm
ann]
Defs: a deposition is not an exhibit;contains material inadmissible underFRE 401-02, 403, 802 and 805, &within MIL # 1; failure to complywith LR 16-2.7 and, as a result,deprives defendants of opportunityto object to proffered testimony;improper use of deposition.
87A
RuhlmannInterviewCassettes(Audio)
Defs: contains material inadmissibleunder FRE 401-02, 403, 404, 407,408, 701, 802 and 805, & withinMIL # 1, 5.
87AT
RuhlmannInterviewCassettes
(Transcript)
88
Deposition of
Jeremy Blietz(02.09.2016)(Transcript)[Blietz]
Defs: a deposition is not an exhibit;contains material inadmissible underFRE 401-02, 403, 802 and 805;
failure to comply with LR 16-2.7and, as a result, deprives defendantsof opportunity to object to profferedtestimony; improper use ofdeposition.
89
Deposition ofDavid
Woirhaye(02.10.2016)(Transcript)[Woirh
aye]
Defs: a deposition is not an exhibit;contains material inadmissible underFRE 401-02, 403, 802 and 805;failure to comply with LR 16-2.7and, as a result, deprives defendantsof opportunity to object to proffered
testimony; improper use ofdeposition.
90
Deposition ofAlexander
Stewart(2016.05.17)(Tr
anscript)[Stewart]
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 18 of 383 Page ID#:6544
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
19/382
{00255828;1} 19PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
90V
Deposition ofAlexander
Stewart(2016.05.17)
(VIDEO)[Stewart]
91
Deposition ofErik Johnson(2016.05.18)(Transcript)[Johnson]
91V
Deposition ofErik Johnson(2016.05.18)
(VIDEO)[Johnson]
92
Deposition of
Kevin Hanson(2016.05.18)(Transcript)
[Hanson]
92V
Deposition ofKevin Hanson(2016.05.18)
(VIDEO)[Hanson]
93
Deposition ofBrian Bricklin(2016.06.10)(Transcript)[Bricklin]
93V
Deposition ofBrian Bricklin(2016.06.10)
(Video)[Bricklin]
94
Deposition ofMichaelEinhorn
(2016.05.19)(Transcript)[Einhorn]
94V
Deposition ofMichaelEinhorn
(2016.05.19)(VIDEO)[Einhorn]
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 19 of 383 Page ID#:6545
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
20/382
{00255828;1} 20PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
95
Deposition ofRobert Mathes(2016.05.27)(Transcript)
[Mathes]
95V
Deposition ofRobert Mathes(2016.05.27)
(VIDEO)[Mathes]
96
Deposition ofLawerence
Ferrara(2016.05.27)(Transcript)
[Ferrara]
96V
Deposition ofLawrence
Ferrara(2016.05.27)
(VIDEO)[Ferrara]
97
Deposition ofMichael Ware(2016.05.31)(Transcript)
[Ware]
97V
Deposition ofMichael Ware(2016.05.31)
(VIDEO)[Ware]
98New MusicalExpress Article
[Page][D98]
Defs: Defs MIL # 2 & # 5, FRE 401-02, 403, 404, 407, 408, 802, 805.
99V
BBC Interviewwith Jimmy
Page (minutes1:13
to1:25)[VIDEO][Page]
Defs: reserve right to play otherportions of the interview.
99T
Transcript ofBBC Interview
with JimmyPage
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 20 of 383 Page ID#:6546
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
21/382
{00255828;1} 21PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
100A
Taurus andStairway to
Heaven Sound
RecordingMash Up
Def: such a recording has never beenproduced to defendants; mash-upsare inherently misleading and not anaccepted musicological practice andis, instead, a musical trick; Cottrill v.Spears, 2003 WL 21223846 at *9
(E.D. Pa. May 22, 2003); FRE 401-02, 403, 702, 1002, & lackfoundation, MIL # 3, # 4, failure tocomply with FRCP 26(a)(2), (e) &(b)(4).
101PlaintiffsAmendedcomplaint
Defs: Defs MIL # 1, # 2, # 3, # 5, #8, #14; FRE 401-02, 403, 404, 407,408, 701-05, 802 & 805; assertionsas to substantial similarity barred byfailure to timely provide expertdisclosures as to relevant work
(1967 transcription), FRCP 26(a),26(e) & 37(c)(1).
103 Recorder Defs: FRE 401-02, 403.
104Headley Grangelayout Drawing
[Page}
104A
HeadleyDrawing with
Roberts
Drawing [Plant]
105
Stairway toHeaven SheetMusic (Flames
of AlbionMusic |
1972)[Page]
106Howard MylettArticle [Page]
Defs: FRE 901, illegible, 401-02,403, 802, 805.
107A
Take 1 Stairway to
Heaven
[AUDIO][Page][D107]
108A
Take 2 Stairway to
Heaven[AUDIO][Page]
[D108]
109ATake 3 -
Stairway to
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 21 of 383 Page ID#:6547
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
22/382
{00255828;1} 22PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Heaven[AUDIO][Page]
[D109]
110A
Take 4 -Stairway to
Heaven
[AUDIO][Page][D110]
111A
Take 5 -Stairway to
Heaven[AUDIO][Page]
[D111]
112A
Take 6 -Stairway to
Heaven[AUDIO][Page]
[D112]
113A
Take 7 -Stairway to
Heaven[AUDIO][Page]
[D113]
114A
Take 8 -Stairway to
Heaven[AUDIO][Page]
[D114]
146Plant Crash
Article[Page][Jones][D146]
157
Zig Zagreprinted in
Guitar WorldInterview withJimmy Page
[Page][D157]
Defs: Defs MIL # 2, FRE 401-02,403, 802, 805.
160
Zig Zagreprinted in
Guitar WorldInterview withJimmy Page
[Page][D157]
Defs: either duplicative of Exh. 157or not produced; Defs MIL # 2, FRE401-02, 403, 802, 805.
160A
Zig ZagInterview withJimmy Page
[AUDIO][Page]
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 22 of 383 Page ID#:6548
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
23/382
{00255828;1} 23PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
[D160]
160T
Transcript ofZig Zag
Interview with
Jimmy Page
161A
Master SoundRecording ofStairway to
Heaven[AUDIO][Page]
Defs: failure to identify recordingplaintiff is referring to.
162A
Master SoundRecording ofTaurus Part
A[AUDIO][Page]
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, #4, FRE 401-02, 403, 1002.
163A
Combination AcousticRecording of
Taurus SyncedMaster SoundRecording ofStairway toHeaven (by
sessionmusician),
played over
Master SoundRecording ofStairway to
Heaven[AUDIO][Page]
Def: failure to identify and producerecording; FRE 401-02, 403, 1002,& lack foundation, MIL #3, # 4,failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4).
164A
AcousticRecording ofTaurus (by
sessionmusician)Synced to
Master ofStairway toHeaven Sound
Recording[AUDIO][Page]
Def: failure to identify and producerecording; FRE 401-02, 403, 1002,& lack foundation, MIL #3, # 4,
failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4).
165A
AcousticRecording ofStairway toHeaven (by
Def: failure to identify and producerecording; FRE 401-02, 403, 1002,MIL # 4, failure to comply withFRCP 26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4).
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 23 of 383 Page ID#:6549
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
24/382
{00255828;1} 24PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
sessionmusician)
[AUDIO][Page]
166A
AcousticRecording ofTaurus (by
sessionmusician)
Synced Exactlyto Master
SoundRecording of
Taurus Part A[AUDIO][Page]
Def: failure to identify and producerecording; FRE 401-02, 403, 1002,& lack foundation, MIL #3, # 4,failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4).
167A
Combination Acoustic
Recording of
Taurus Syncedto Master
SoundRecording ofStairway toHeaven (by
sessionmusician),
played overAcoustic
Recording of
Stairway toHeaven (by
sessionmusician)[AUDIO]
[Page]
Def: failure to identify and producerecording; FRE 401-02, 403, 1002,& lack foundation, MIL #3, # 4,failure to comply with FRCP26(a)(2), (e) & (b)(4).
200
Book - Get theLed Out by
Denny Somach(p.19)[Page]
Defs: Defs MIL #2, # 3, # 5, # 6,FRE 901, 401-02, 403, 404, 407,408, 802, 805.
201
Recorder (as
played byJones)[Jones]
Defs: FRE 401-02.
202Hohner Piano(as played byJones) [Jones]
Defs: FRE 401-02.
203
Photos of LedZeppelin II
Album Coversand Vinyl
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404.
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 24 of 383 Page ID#:6550
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
25/382
{00255828;1} 25PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
(Original)[Jones]
204
Photos of LezZeppelin II
Album Covers
and Vinyl(Remastered)
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404.
205A
Spirits FreshGarbage
Performance(Feb. 3,
1970)(7:58)[AUDIO][Jones
]
Defs: FRE 901, 401-02, 403; failureto identify/provide expert testimonyas to claimed use, FRCP 26(a),26(e), 37(c)(1).
206A
Led ZeppelinPlaying Fresh
Garbage (2:51)[AUDIO][Jones][6A]
Defs: FRE 901, 401-02, 403; failureto identify/provide expert testimony
as to claimed use, FRCP 26(a),26(e), 37(c)(1).
207A
Dazed andConfused (Led
Zeppelin)(1969)[AUDIO][Jones
][1A]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
208A
Dazed andConfused (JakeHolmes)(1967)[
AUDIO][Jones][2A]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony as
to claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
209A
You Need Love(Muddy
Waters)(1962)[AUDIO][Jones]
[4A]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
210A
You NeedLoving (The
SmallFaces)(1966)[A
UDIO][Jones][5A]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),
37(c)(1).
211A
Babe I'm GonnaLeave You
(JoanBaez/Anne
Bredon)(1962)[AUDIO][Jones]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 25 of 383 Page ID#:6551
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
26/382
{00255828;1} 26PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
212A
Bring It OnHome (Sonny
Boy WilliamsonII)[AUDIO][Jo
nes]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
213ANever (MobyGrape)[AUDIO
][Jones]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,
401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
214A
Hat's Off to RoyHarper (Led
Zeppelin)[AUDIO][Jones]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
215A
Shake 'em on
Down (BukkaWhite)[AUDIO
][Jones]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure to
identify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
216A
Nobody's Faultbut Mine (Blind
WillieJohnson)[AUDI
O][Jones]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
217A
Bron-Y-AurStomp (Led
Zeppelin)[AUDIO][Jones]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
218A
Waggoneer'sLad (Bert
Jansch)(1966)[AUDIO][Jones]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
219A
BlackWaterside (BertJansch)(1966)[
AUDIO][Jones]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
220A
WhiteSummer/BlackMountain Side(LedZeppelin)(
1969)[AUDIO][Jones
]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 26 of 383 Page ID#:6552
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
27/382
{00255828;1} 27PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
221A
Howlin Wolf Killing Floor
(1964)[AUDIO][Jones]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
222A
Traveling
Riverside Blues(Robert
Johnson)(1937)[AUDIO][Jones
]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
223A
The LemonSong (Led
Zeppelin)(firstthree
seconds)(1969)[AUDIO][Jones]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
224A
Jesus Make UpMy Dying Bed
(aka In MyTime of Dying)(Blind Willie
Johnson) (1927)| (misidentifiedas Jesus GonnaMake Up MyDying Bed)
[AUDIO][Jones
]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
225A
Jesus GonnaMake Up My
Dying Bed(Josh White)(misidentifiedas Jesus MakeUp My Dying
Bed (aka In MyTime of
Dying))(1933)
[AUDIO][Jones]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
226A
How ManyMore Times
(LedZeppelin)(1969)
[AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 27 of 383 Page ID#:6553
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
28/382
{00255828;1} 28PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
227A
No Place to Go(aka How Many
MoreYears)(HowlinWolf)(1959)[A
UDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
228A
Rosie (AlexisKorner BluesInc.)(1967)[AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
229A
Steal Away(Alexis KornerBlues Inc. &
RobertPlant)(1968)[A
UDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
230A
The Hunter(Albert
King)(1967)[AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
231A
Bring it onHome (Led
Zeppelin)(1969)[AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
232A
When the LeveeBreaks Breaks
(LedZeppelin)(1971)
[AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
233A
When the LeveeBreaks
(MemphisMinnie &
Kansas JoeMcCoy)(1929)[
AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
234A
Custard Pie(Led
Zeppelin)(1975)[AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
235A
Drop DownMama (Sleepy
JohnEstes)(1935)[A
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 28 of 383 Page ID#:6554
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
29/382
{00255828;1} 29PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
UDIO] 37(c)(1).
236A
Want Some ofYour Pie (Blind
BoyFuller)(1940)[AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure to
identify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
237A
In My Time ofDying Bed (LedZeppelin)(1975)
[AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
238A
Boogie with Stu(Led
Zeppelin)(1975)
[AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony as
to claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
239A
Ooh, My Head(Ritchie
Valens)(1957)[AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
240A
Nobody's Faultbut Mine (LedZeppelin)(1976)
[AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),
37(c)(1).
241AWhite Summer(Yardbirds)(196
9)[AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
242A
She MovedThro the Fair
(DavyGraham)(1963)[
AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
243A
The Girl I LoveShe Got LongBlack Wavy
Hair (LedZeppelin)(1969)
[AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 29 of 383 Page ID#:6555
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
30/382
{00255828;1} 30PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
244A
The Girl I LoveShe Got Long
Curly Hair(Sleepy John
Estes)(1927)[AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
245A
Watch YourStep (Bobby
Parker)(1961)[AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
246A
Your Time isGonna Come
(LedZeppelin)(1969)
[AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
247ADear Mr.Fantasy
(Traffic)(1967)[AUDIO]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,
401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
250
Lyrics andMusical
Comparison ofPrior Art andLed Zeppelin
Songs
Defs: such a recording has neverbeen produced to defendants, FRCP26(a), 37(c)(1); Defs MIL # 5, FRE407, 408, 401-02, 403, 404; failureto identify/ provide expert testimonyas to claimed use, FRCP 26(a),26(e), 37(c)(1).
300Spirit Show
History[Ferguson]
Defs: FRE 901, 602, 802, 805.
301Spirit Gig
Listing[Ferguson]
Defs: FRE 901, 602, 802, 805.
302Spirit CD -Topanga
(69)[Ferguson]
302A
Spirit CD -Topanga (69)
[AUDIO][Ferguson]
303
Spirit CD -Valley Music
Theatre(12/31/1970)(Di
scOne)[Ferguson]
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 30 of 383 Page ID#:6556
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
31/382
{00255828;1} 31PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
303A
Spirit CD -Valley Music
Theatre(12/31/1970)(DiscOne)[AUDIO
] [Ferguson]
304
Spirit CD -Valley Music
Theatre(12/31/1970)(Di
scTwo)[Ferguson]
304A
Spirit CD -Valley Music
Theatre(12/31/1970)(DiscTwo)[AUDIO
] [Ferguson]
305
Poster Northern
California Folk-Rock Festival
[Ferguson]
Defs: FRE 901, 802, 401-02, 602.
306
Spirit CD - TheForum
(12/12/1970)[Ferguson]
306A
Spirit CD - TheForum
(12/12/1970)[AUDIO][Ferguson]
307
Spirit CD -MammothGardens
(6/5/1970)[Ferguson]
307A
Spirit CD -MammothGardens
(6/5/1970)[AUDIO][Ferguson]
308
Spirit CD -Cincinnati,
Ohio (Unknownvenue)(Late
1970)[Ferguson]
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 31 of 383 Page ID#:6557
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
32/382
{00255828;1} 32PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
308A
Spirit CD -Cincinnati,
Ohio (Unknownvenue)(Late
1970)[AUDIO][Ferguson]
309
Spirit CD -Whisky A Go
Go(11/1/1970)[Fer
guson]
309A
Spirit CD -Whisky A Go
Go(11/1/1970)[AUDIO][Ferguson]
310
Spirit CD -
MammothGardens
(2/1/1969)[Ferguson]
310A
Spirit CD -MammothGardens
(2/1/1969)[AUDIO][Ferguson]
311
Spirit CD -Civic Center(Baltimore,
MD)(10/3/1969) [Ferguson]
311A
Spirit CD -Civic Center(Baltimore,
MD)(10/3/1969)
[AUDIO][Ferguson]
312
Spirit CD -Center Arena
(Seattle,WA)(5/22/1970
) [Ferguson]
312A
Spirit CD -Center Arena
(Seattle,WA)(5/22/1970
)
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 32 of 383 Page ID#:6558
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
33/382
{00255828;1} 33PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
[AUDIO][Ferguson]
313
Rock Concertis Real Groovy
Rocky
Mountain NewsMusic Critic[Ferguson][D13
6]
314
Atlanta Pop-Greatest
Musical FairEver The
Hurricane(7/11/1969)[Ferguson][D202]
315
Atlanta PopFestivalAnnouncement[Ferguson][D12
5]
Defs: FRE 802.
316
Seattle PopFestival Poster
[Ferguson][D136]
Defs: FRE 802.
317
Sylvan RockFlows Smoothly
Seattle PostIntelligencer(7/29/1969)[Ferguson][D117]
318Seattle Pop
Festival Poster[Ferguson]
Defs: FRE 802.
319
TexasInternationalPop FestivalPoster and
News Articles[Ferguson]
Defs: FRE 802.
320Spirit Poster for(12/26/1967)[Fe
rguson]
321
Robert PlantCrash Article Melody Maker
(2/7/1970)
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 33 of 383 Page ID#:6559
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
34/382
{00255828;1} 34PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
[Ferguson][D146]
322
Poster for SpiritConcert w/Mandrake
Hornsey TownHall [Ferguson]
Defs: FRE 901, 802, 401-02.
323
Spirit Article -Shindig!
(2009)[Ferguson]
Defs: FRE 802, 401-02, 403.
324
And ShesBuying a
Lawsuit toHeaven BlogPost [Ferguson]
Defs: MIL # 3, FRE 901, 802, 401-02, 403,
325
WikipediaArticle on HowMany More
Times[Ferguson]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
326
WikipediaArticle on
White Summer[Ferguson]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
327
Spirit, Procol
Play Concertsin LA Times(4/17/1969)[Fer
guson]
Defs: FRE 802, 401-02, 403, as toInternet posting re lawsuit, claims,Defs MIL # 2, # 3, 5.
328
News Articlesfrom Bruce
Pates[Ferguson]
Defs: FRE 802, 401-02, 403.
329Seattle Pop
Festival Poster[Ferguson]
Defs: FRE 901, 802.
330
Sounds LikeTeen Spirit by
TimothyEnglish
[Ferguson]
Defs: Defs MIL # 2, # 5, FRE 407,408, 401-02, 403, 404, 802.
331
SkidmoreEmails to Jay
Ferguson(8/28/2015)[Fer
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 401-02,403, 404, 802.
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 34 of 383 Page ID#:6560
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
35/382
{00255828;1} 35PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
guson]
332
SkidmoreEmails to Jay
Ferguson(5/29/2015)[Fer
guson]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 401-02,403, 404, 802.
333Spirit Demo
Cassette[Ferguson]
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 404, 1002, 802.
333A
Spirit DemoCassette
[AUDIO][Ferguson]
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 404, 1002, 802.
334
Spirit Cassette -Whiskey A Go
Go Show
[Ferguson]
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, 802.
334A
Spirit Cassette -Whiskey A Go
Go Show[AUDIO][Fergu
son]
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, 802.
335
Spirit Cassettes- Filmore West
and Boston[Ferguson]
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, 802.
335A
Spirit Cassettes
- Filmore Westand Boston[AUDIO][Fergu
son]
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, 802.
336Spirit Cassettes
Filmore West[Ferguson]
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, 802.
336A
Spirit Cassettes Filmore West[AUDIO][Fergu
son]
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, 802.
337 Cassette AsLong As I haveYou [Ferguson]
Defs: FRE 401-02, 403, 1002, 802.
337A
Cassette AsLong As I have
You[AUDIO][Fergu
son]
Defs: FRE 401-02, 403, 1002, 802.
338 Time Circle Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 35 of 383 Page ID#:6561
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
36/382
{00255828;1} 36PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
(Spirit)(Disc1)[Ferguson]
403, 1002.
338A
Time Circle(Spirit)(Disc 1)[AUDIO][Fergu
son]
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, 802.
338.2Time Circle(Spirit)(Disc2)[Ferguson]
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, 802.
338.2A
Time Circle(Spirit)(Disc 2)[AUDIO][Fergu
son]
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 1002, 802.
339
Time CircleNotes
[Ferguson][D137]
Defs: Defs. MIL # 3, FRE 802, 805.
340All for One
Contract[Ferguson]
Defs: FRE 401-02, 403.
341
LetterCanceling All
ForOneContract
[Ferguson]
Defs: FRE 401-02, 403.
342Subpoena to Jay
Ferguson[Ferguson]
343
CD JayFerguson
Interview withBruce Pates
Summerland,CA (June 28,
2000)[Transcript]
Defs: FRE 602, 802, 401-02, 403.
343A
CD JayFerguson
Interview withBruce Pates
Summerland,CA (June 28,
2000)[AUDIO][Ferguson]
Defs: FRE 401-02.
344[DVD] CDImage 1stAtlanta Pop
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 36 of 383 Page ID#:6562
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
37/382
{00255828;1} 37PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Festival[Ferguson]
344V
[DVD] CDImage 1stAtlanta Pop
Festival
[VIDEO][Ferguson]
345
Pop MusicFestival WithExtras Bringsout the Youth -
NY Times(7/7/1969)[Ferg
uson]
346
TexasInternational
Pop FestivalPoster, Picture,
and NewsArticles
[Ferguson]
Defs: FRE 901, 802, 401-02, 403.
347
Ode RecordsRecordingContract
(8/29/1967)[Ferguson]
348
TaurusCopyright
Registration[Ferguson]
Defs: FRE 1002.
349
DaveWaterbury
PhoneCall[Transcript]
[Plant][402]
Defs: Defs MIL # 1, 11, FRE 802.
349A
DaveWaterburyPhone Call[AUDIO]
[Plant][402A]
Defs: Defs MIL # 1, 11, FRE 802.
350Posters and
Concert Tickets[Andes]
Defs: as to 350-4 to 350-14, FRE802, 901, 401-02, 403.
351Subpoena forMark Andes
[Andes]
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 37 of 383 Page ID#:6563
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
38/382
{00255828;1} 38PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
352
Bruce PatesDocument forSpirit Setlist
from(2/1/1969)[And
es]
353
Stairway toHeaven: SongRemains Pretty
Similar byVernon Silver
[Andes]
Defs: Defs MIL # 2, # 5, FRE 407,408, 401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
360Subpoena Bruce
Pates [Pates]
361
Letter to EdCassidy andNotice from
Hollenbeck(6/30/1971)[Pat
es]
Defs: FRE 401-02.
362
SongwriterContract
(8/29/1967)[Pates]
Defs: this is Cassidys songwritercontract, which is not relevant; FRE401-02, 403, 404.
363Vintage Guitar
Magazine[Pates]
Defs: FRE 401-02.
364Cds and List of
Songs
Defs: as to 1st CD, Defs MIL # 3,FRE 401-02, 403, 802, 901; as to 5thCD, FRE 401-02, 403, 802, 901,1002; as to 6th CD, Defs MIL # 2, #5, FRE 407, 408, 401-02, 403, 404;failure to identify/provide experttestimony as to claimed use, FRCP26(a), 26(e), 37(c)(1); as to 7th CD,FRE 802, 901.
365
Email on TexasIntl. Pop
Festival Filesfrom Francis to
Peter [Pates]
Defs: FRE 401-02; to the extentplaintiff means to refer to the audio
files transferred, seeobjections toExh. 364.
366
GoldmineMagazine with
RandyInterview
[Pates]
Defs: FRE 802, 901, 401-02, 403,404.
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 38 of 383 Page ID#:6564
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
39/382
{00255828;1} 39PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
367
Spirit CD Civic Center
Santa Monica,CA (9-29-
1967)[Pates]
Defs: as to 1st CD, Defs MIL # 3,FRE 401-02, 403, 404, 802, 901,1002.
367A
Spirit CD
Civic CenterSanta Monica,
CA (9-29-1967)[AUDIO][Pates
]
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 404, 802, 901, 1002.
368
Led ZeppelinCD Whisky A
Go(1/5/1969)[Pate
s]
Defs: FRE 401-02.
368A
Led Zeppelin
CD Whisky AGo
(1/5/1969)[AUDIO][Pates]
Defs: FRE 401-02.
369
Spirit CD Live at theTroubadour
(12-6-1975)[Pates]
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 802, 901, 1002.
369A
Spirit CD Live at theTroubadour
(12-6-1975)[AUDIO][
Pates]
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 802, 901, 1002.
370Quinn Messageto Bruce Pates
[Pates]Defs: FRE 401-02.
371Quinn Messageto Pates on (4-
30-2002)[Pates]Defs: FRE 401-02.
372
Quinn Messageto Bruce Pates
on YahooGroups [Pates]
Defs: FRE 401-02.
373Spirit Album
[Pates]
Defs: this deposition exhibit is aphotocopy of the back of the album;to the extent plaintiff intends to referto the audio recordings on thealbum, Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 39 of 383 Page ID#:6565
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
40/382
{00255828;1} 40PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
403, 1002.
374Bruce Pates
Post on YahooGroup [Pates]
Defs: FRE 401-02, 802, 602, DefsMIL # 5, FRE 407, 408, 401-02,403, 404; failure to identify/provideexpert testimony as to claimed use,FRCP 26(a), 26(e), 37(c)(1).
375
Bruce PatesComment onTeamRock
[Pates]
Defs: FRE 401-02, 802, 602, DefsMIL # 5, FRE 407, 408, 401-02,403, 404; failure to identify/provideexpert testimony as to claimed use,FRCP 26(a), 26(e), 37(c)(1).
376
BruceComments onArticle (12-12-2015)[Pates]
Defs: FRE 401-02, 802, 602, DefsMIL # 5, FRE 407, 408, 401-02,403, 404; failure to identify/provideexpert testimony as to claimed use,FRCP 26(a), 26(e), 37(c)(1).
377Note from
Randy to Bruce[Pates]
Defs: FRE 401-02, 403, 802.
378Postcard Notefrom Randy toBruce [Pates]
Defs: FRE 401-02, 403, 802.
379Postcard Notefrom Randy toBruce [Pates]
Defs: FRE 401-02, 403, 802.
380
Note to Brucefrom Bernice
Pearl(1991)[Pates]
Defs: FRE 401-02, 403, 802.
381Bernice and theGuys Note toBruce [Pates]
Defs: FRE 401-02, 403, 802.
382Note fromBernice to
Bruce [Pates]Defs: FRE 401-02, 403, 802.
383
Note fromBernice to
Bruce
(1991)[Pates]
Defs: FRE 401-02, 403, 802.
384Led ZeppelinCollectors
Edition [Pates]
Defs: Defs MIL #2, # 5, FRE 407,408, 401-02, 403, 404, 802; failureto identify/provide expert testimonyas to claimed use, FRCP 26(a),26(e), 37(c)(1).
385Marshall Berleand Bruce PatesExchange (May
Defs: FRE 401-02, 403, 802, 602.
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 40 of 383 Page ID#:6566
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
41/382
{00255828;1} 41PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
2014)[Pates]
386
Email ChainBetween Jayand Bruce
Pates, 6/16/15
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404, 802; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony as
to claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
387
Ferguson andPates Email
(June2015)[Pates]
Defs: Defs MIL # 2, # 5, FRE 401-02, 403, 404, 408, 802.
388
Wikipedia LZNorth American
Tour (68-69)[Pates]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404, 802; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
389
Yahoo GroupMessage Between Dave
and Bruce[Pates]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404, 802; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
390Spirit Poster
[Pates]Defs: FRE 401-02.
391Jay and BruceEmail from (9-14-2014)[Pates]
Defs: Defs MIL #1, # 5, FRE 407,408, 401-02, 403, 404, 802; failureto identify/provide expert testimonyas to claimed use, FRCP 26(a),
26(e), 37(c)(1).
392
Transcript ofPhone Call
between FrancisMalofiy
andTracyLongo [Plant]
[403]
393Photograph ofGuitar Case
394
Photograph of
Guitar
395The Last Randy
CaliforniaGuitar
400
Stairway toHeaven Sheet
Music(Superhype
Music |
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 41 of 383 Page ID#:6567
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
42/382
{00255828;1} 42PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
1972)[Plant]
401-02
School of RockMagazine Led
Zeppelin
Edition Bonham Article[Plant]
Defs: Defs MIL # 2, FRE 901, 802,
805.
402
DaveWaterburyPhone CallTranscript
[Plant
Defs: Defs MIL # 1, 11, FRE 802;duplicative exhibit.
402A
DaveWaterburyPhone Call
Transcript[AUDIO][Plant]
Defs: Defs MIL # 1, 11, FRE 802;
duplicative exhibit.
403
Tracy LongoPhone CallTranscript
[Plant]
Defs: Defs MIL # 1, 11, FRE 802.
403A
Tracy LongoPhone CallTranscript
[AUDIO][Plant
]
Defs: Defs MIL # 1, 11, FRE 802.
404
2004 RobertPlant Interviewon NPR withTerry Gross
(22:10 to25:46)[Plant]
Defs: Defs MIL # 2, #5, FRE 401-02, 403, 404, 407, 408, 1002, 802.
404A
2004 RobertPlant Interviewon NPR withTerry Gross
(22:10 to25:46)[Plant]
Defs: audio recordings not producedby plaintiff despite agreement to doso; 26(a), 26(e), 37(c)(1); MIL # 5,
FRE 407, 408, 401-02, 403, 404.
404T
Transcript of2004 Robert
Plant Interviewon NPR withTerry Gross
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 42 of 383 Page ID#:6568
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
43/382
{00255828;1} 43PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
405A
Dazed andConfused (LedZeppelin)(Clip)[AUDIO][Plant
]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
406ADazed and
Confused (JakeHolmes)(Clip)[AUDIO][Plant]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,
401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
407A
Babe ImGonna Leave
You (LedZeppelin)(1969)(Clip)[AUDIO]
[Plant]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
408A
Babe Im
Gonna LeaveYou (JoanBaez/Anne
Bredon)(1962)(Clip)[AUDIO][
Plant]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
409A.A
Whole LottaLove (Led
Zeppelin)(ClipA)[AUDIO][Pla
nt]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
409A.B
Whole LottaLove (Led
Zeppelin)(ClipB)[AUDIO][Pla
nt]
409A.C
Whole LottaLove (Led
Zeppelin)(ClipC)[AUDIO][Pla
nt]
410A
You Need Love(Willie
Dixon/MuddyWaters)(Clip)[AUDIO][Plant]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
411A
You NeedLovin (The
SmallFaces)(Clip)[AUDIO][Plant]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 43 of 383 Page ID#:6569
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
44/382
{00255828;1} 44PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
412A
Communications Breakdown
(LedZeppelin)(1969)(Clip)[AUDIO]
[Plant]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
413A
NervousBreakdown
(EddieCochran)(1958)(Clip)[AUDIO]
[Plant]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
414A
Since Ive BeenLoving You
(LedZeppelin)(Clip)[AUDIO][Plant
]
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),
37(c)(1).
415ANever (MobyGrape)(Clip)[AUDIO][Plant
Defs: Defs MIL # 5, FRE 407, 408,401-02, 403, 404; failure toidentify/provide expert testimony asto claimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
450
Stipulation toOrder andOrder for
SubstitutedJudgment to
Create andFund Revocable
Living Trustand Execute a
Pour-Over Will(Probate Code
Sec. 2580(b)(5)) and
(13))
[Skidmore]
451Randy CraigWolfe Trust[Skidmore]
452
FirstAmendment toRandy CraigWolfe Trust
(February 26,
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 44 of 383 Page ID#:6570
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
45/382
{00255828;1} 45PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
2002)[Skidmore]
453
SecondAmendment toRandy Craig
Wolfe Trust(February26,2002)
[Skidmore]
454
ThirdAmendment toRandy Craig
Wolfe Trust(February 26,
2002
[Skidmore]
455
FourthAmendment toRandy CraigWolfe Trust
(February 26,2002)[Skidmore
]
456
FifthAmendment toRandy Craig
Wolfe Trust(February 26,
2002)[Skidmore]
457
Certification ofTrust Existenceand Authority
[Skidmore]
458Royalty
Statement[Skidmore]
Defs: FRE 401-02.
459Royalty
Statement[Skidmore]
Defs: FRE 401-02.
460Royalty
Statement[Skidmore]
Defs: FRE 401-02.
461Alice Cooper
Interview[Skidmore]
Defs: FRE 401-02, 802.
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 45 of 383 Page ID#:6571
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
46/382
{00255828;1} 46PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
462
The Rock andRoll Hall ofFame and
Museum, TheJimi HendrixExperience
Biography[Skidmore]
Defs: FRE 401-02, 802.
463
'The Doctor ofRock and Roll,'
an Interviewwith Al Kooper
[Skidmore]
Defs: FRE 401-02, 802.
464
Rock'n'rollConfidential,
Walter Becker,One Half of the
Steely DanSuperbrain Defs: FRE 401-02, 802.
Talks Dylan,Psychology and
The Blues[Skidmore]
465
Obituary:Randy
California
[Skidmore]
Defs: FRE 401-02, 802.
466
RandyCalifornia onHendrix and
Jimmy James &The BlueFlames
[Skidmore]
Defs: FRE 401-02, 802.
467
Jimmy James &The BlueFlames, 1.
Bright Lites,Big City; 2. I'ma Man ..
[Skidmore]
Defs: FRE 401-02.
468
Email (Monday,November 10,2008 6:54:51
PM)[Skidmore]
Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,403, 802, 602.
469 Skidmore Defs: Defs MIL # 3, FRE 401-02,
Case 2:15-cv-03462-RGK-AGR Document 242 Filed 06/14/16 Page 46 of 383 Page ID#:6572
7/26/2019 Plaintiff Supplemental Exhibit List (Skidmore v. Led Zeppelin "Stairway to Heaven" lawsuit)
47/382
{00255828;1} 47PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
SupplementalDocumentProduction[Skidmore]
403, 802, 602.
470
Skidmore
SupplementalDocumentProduction[Skidmore]
Defs: Defs MIL # 8; FRE 802; DefsMIL #1, # 5, FRE 407, 408, 401-02,
403, 404, 802; failure to identify/provide expert testimony as toclaimed use, FRCP 26(a), 26(e),37(c)(1).
475
Subpoena toTestify at a
Deposition in aCivil Action[Ruhlmann]
480
BarneyHoskyns, Led
Zeppelin IV(2006) (book)
Def: MIL # 2, #5; failure to identifyportion to be offered; FRE 401-02,
403, 404, 405, 407, 408, 702, 802,805, 901.
481Light and
Shade, by BradTolinksi (book)
Def: MIL # 2, #5; failure to identifyportion to be offered; FRE 401-02,403, 404, 405, 407, 408, 702, 802,805, 901.
482V
Origin ofSpecies LedZeppelin: A
Critical Reviewof the Bands
Roots andBranches(DVD)
Def: MIL # 2, #5; failure to identifyportion to be offered; FRE 401-02,403, 404, 405, 407, 408, 702, 802,805, 901.
483VLed Zeppelin:
The UntoldStory (DVD)
Def: MIL # 2, #5; failure to identifyportion to be offered; FRE 401-02,403, 404, 405, 407, 408, 702, 802,805, 901.
484VLed Zeppelin1969 (DVD)
Def: such a DVD has never beenproduced to defendants; FRCP26(a)(1), (e) & 37(c); FRE 401-02,403, 1002, & MIL # 4, #