22
Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005. EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005. EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005. TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; 1 Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005 C alifornia Louisana Texas 0 1 2 3 Pounds ofO SHA Em issions per1000 B arrels R efined OSHA carcinogens = 188 compounds known or likely to cause cancer

Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

  • Upload
    devlin

  • View
    47

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005. OSHA carcinogens = 188 compounds known or likely to cause cancer. Percent of Total US Refining Capacity and Total US OSHA Carcinogen Emissions Related to Petroleum Refining (SIC 29) 2005. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Citation preview

Page 1: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

1

Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

California

Louisana

Texas

0 1 2 3

Pounds of OSHA Emissions per 1000 Barrels Refined

OSHA carcinogens = 188 compounds known or likely to cause cancer

Page 2: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

2

Percent of Total US Refining Capacity and Total US OSHA Carcinogen Emissions

Related to Petroleum Refining (SIC 29) 2005

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

California Louisana All other states Texas

State

Perc

ent Capacity

Emissions

Page 3: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

3

Shell Pounds of OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

(by State)

0.2

0.21

0.22

0.23

0.24

0.25

0.26

0.27

LA CA TX

OSH

A E

mis

sion

s pe

r 100

0 B

arre

ls R

efin

ed p

er D

ay (p

ound

s)

Page 4: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

4

Shell Facilities FACILITY STREET ADDRESS CITY COUNTY STATE MOTIVA ENTERPRISES LLC CONVENT REFINERY FOOT OF SUNSHINE BRIDGE LA HWY 44 CONVENT ST JAMES LA

MOTIVA ENTERPRISES LLC NORCO REFINERY 15536 RIVER RD NORCO ST CHARLES LA

SHELL OIL PRODUCTS US - MARTINEZ REFINERY 3485 PACHECO BLVD MARTINEZ CONTRA COSTA CA

SHELL OIL CO - DEER PARK REFINING LP 5900 HWY 225 DEER PARK HARRIS TX

Page 5: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

5

Valero Pounds of OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar

Day 2005 (by State)

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

LA NJ CA TX OK TX TX TX TX

OSH

A E

mis

sion

s pe

r 100

0 B

arre

ls R

efin

ed p

er D

ay (p

ound

s)

Page 6: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

6

Valero Pounds of OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005 (by State)

FACILITY STREET ADDRESS CITY COUNTY STATE ZIP CODE

EMISSIONS PER 1000 BARRELS/DAY

VALERO REFINING NEW ORLEANS LLC 14902 RIVER RD NEW SARPY ST CHARLES LA '70078' 0.1315047

VALERO REFINING CO - NEW JERSEY 800 BILLINGSPORT RD PAULSBORO GLOUCESTER NJ '08066' 0.2528938

VALERO REFINING CO CALIFORNIA BENICIA REFINERY 3400 E SECOND ST BENICIA SOLANO CA '94510' 0.337559

VALERO REFINING - TEXAS L.P. 1301 LOOP 197 S TEXAS CITY GALVESTON TX '77592' 0.3789217 VALERO REFINING CO OKLAHOMA VALERO ARDMORE REFINERY

HWY 142 & E CAMERON RD ARDMORE CARTER OK '73401' 0.4643842

VALERO REFINING - TEXAS L.P. CORPUS CHRISTI WEST PLANT 5900 UP RIVER RD

CORPUS CHRISTI NUECES TX '78407' 0.7579862

VALERO REFINING - TEXAS L.P. HOUSTON REFINERY 9701 MANCHESTER HOUSTON HARRIS TX '77012' 0.8591187

VALERO THREE RIVERS REFINERY 301 LEROY ST THREE RIVERS LIVE OAK TX '78071' 0.9539757

VALERO REFINING TEXAS LP CORPUS CHRISTI EAST PLANT

1300 CANTWELL LN

CORPUS CHRISTI NUECES TX '78403' 2.2342543

Page 7: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

7

ExxonMobil Pounds of OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005 (by State)

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

CA IL LA MT TX TX

OSH

A E

mis

sion

s pe

r 100

0 B

arre

ls R

efin

ed p

er D

ay (p

ound

s)

Page 8: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

8

ExxonMobil Pounds of OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005 (by State) Exxon Facilities

FACILITY STREET ADDRESS CITY COUNTY STATE

EMISSIONS PER 1000 BARRELS/DAY

EXXONMOBIL OIL CORP - TORRANCE REFINERY 3700 W 190TH ST TORRANCE LOS ANGELES CA 0.1955505

EXXONMOBIL OIL CORP JOLIET REFINERY INTERSTATE 55 & ARSENAL RD CHANNAHON WILL IL 0.2099193

EXXONMOBIL REFINING & SUPPLY BATON ROUGE REFINERY 4045 SCENIC HWY BATON ROUGE EAST BATON ROUGE LA 0.4223717

EXXONMOBIL BILLINGS REFINERY 700 EXXONMOBIL RD BILLINGS YELLOWSTONE MT 0.4484064

EXXONMOBIL OIL BEAUMONT REFINERY E END OF BURT ST BEAUMONT JEFFERSON TX 0.4994323

EXXONMOBIL REFINING & SUPPLY BAYTOWN REFINERY 2800 DECKER DR BAYTOWN HARRIS TX 0.730579

Page 9: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

9

ConocoPhillips Pounds OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005 (by State)

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

LA NJ OK LA IL TX WA TX

OSH

A E

mis

sion

s pe

r 100

0 B

arre

ls R

efin

ed p

er D

ay (p

ound

s)

Page 10: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

10

ConocoPhillips Pounds OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005 (by State)

0.9020465'77463'TX BRAZORIAOLD OCEANSTATE HWY 35 AT FM 524CONOCOPHILLIPS CO SWEENY REFINERY COMPLEX

0.8723065'98248'WA WHATCOMFERNDALE3901 UNICK RDCONOCOPHILLIPS CO FERNDALE REFINERY

0.7192719'79008'TX HUTCHINSONBORGERSTATE HWY SPUR 119 NCONOCOPHILLIPS CO

0.683875'62084'IL MADISONROXANA900 S CENTRAL AVECONOCOPHILLIPS CO WOOD RIVER REF INERY

0.6311971'70669'LA CALCASIEUWESTLAKE2200 OLD SPANISH TRAILCONOCOPHILLIPS CO LAKE CHARLES REFINERY

0.5865132'74601'OK KAYPONCA CITY1000 S PINE STCONOCOPHILLIPS CO PONCA CITY REFI NERY

0.183782'07036'NJ UNIONLINDEN1400 PARK AVECONOCOPHILLIPS CO BAYWAY REFINERY

0'70037'LA PLAQUEMINESBELLE CHASSE15551 HWY 23CONOCOPHILLIPS CO - ALLI ANCE REFINERY

EMISSIONS PER 1000 BARRELS/DAY

ZIP CODESTATECOUNTYCITYSTREET ADDRESSFACILITY

0.9020465'77463'TX BRAZORIAOLD OCEANSTATE HWY 35 AT FM 524CONOCOPHILLIPS CO SWEENY REFINERY COMPLEX

0.8723065'98248'WA WHATCOMFERNDALE3901 UNICK RDCONOCOPHILLIPS CO FERNDALE REFINERY

0.7192719'79008'TX HUTCHINSONBORGERSTATE HWY SPUR 119 NCONOCOPHILLIPS CO

0.683875'62084'IL MADISONROXANA900 S CENTRAL AVECONOCOPHILLIPS CO WOOD RIVER REF INERY

0.6311971'70669'LA CALCASIEUWESTLAKE2200 OLD SPANISH TRAILCONOCOPHILLIPS CO LAKE CHARLES REFINERY

0.5865132'74601'OK KAYPONCA CITY1000 S PINE STCONOCOPHILLIPS CO PONCA CITY REFI NERY

0.183782'07036'NJ UNIONLINDEN1400 PARK AVECONOCOPHILLIPS CO BAYWAY REFINERY

0'70037'LA PLAQUEMINESBELLE CHASSE15551 HWY 23CONOCOPHILLIPS CO - ALLI ANCE REFINERY

EMISSIONS PER 1000 BARRELS/DAY

ZIP CODESTATECOUNTYCITYSTREET ADDRESSFACILITY

Page 11: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

11

Citgo OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per

Calendar Day 2005 (by State)

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

LA TX

Page 12: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

12

Citgo OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005 (by State) Citgo Facilities

Facility Street Address City County State

EMISSIONS PER 1000 BARRELS/DAY

CITGO PETROLEUM CORP 4401 HWY 108 WESTLAKE CALCASIEU LA 0.630264574

CITGO REFINING & CHEMICALS CO LP EAST PLANT 1801 NUECES BAY BLVD CORPUS CHRISTI NUECES TX 0.946188982

Page 13: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

13

Pounds of Total Benzene Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

California

Louisana

Texas

0 1 2 3

Pounds of Benzene Emissions per 1000 Barrels Refined

Page 14: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

14

Percent of Total US Refining Capacity and Total US Benzene Emissions Related to

Petroleum Refining (SIC 29) 2005

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%

45%

50%

California Louisana All Other States Texas

State

Perc

ent

Capacity

Emissions

Page 15: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

15

2005 Benzene Emissions (lbs) per 1000 Barrels Refined per Day by Firm and State

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

Conoco Valero Exxon Shell

Firm

Ben

zene

Em

issi

ons

per 1

000

Bar

rels

per

Cal

enda

r Day

(p

ound

s)

CA

LA

TX

Page 16: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

16

2005 Benzene Emissions (lbs) per 1000 Barrels Refined per Day by Firm and State Conoco Facilities

FACILITY STREET ADDRESS CITY COUNTY STATE EMISSIONS/1000 BARRELS/DAY

CONOCOPHILLIPS CO LA REFINERY WILMINGTON PLANT 1660 W ANAHEIM ST WILMINGTON LOS ANGELES CA 0.012615

CONOCOPHILLIPS CO SANTA MARIA FACILITY- REFINERY 2555 WILLOW RD ARROYO GRANDE SAN LUIS OBISPO CA 0.012707

CONOCOPHILLIPS SAN FRANCISCO REFINERY 1380 SAN PABLO AVE RODEO CONTRA COSTA CA 0.126172

CONOCOPHILLIPS CO LAKE CHARLES REFINERY 2200 OLD SPANISH TRAIL WESTLAKE CALCASIEU LA 0.175244

CONOCOPHILLIPS CO STATE HWY SPUR 119 N BORGER HUTCHINSON TX 0.57067

CONOCOPHILLIPS CO SWEENY REFINERY COMPLEX STATE HWY 35 AT FM 524 OLD OCEAN BRAZORIA TX 0.863114

Valero Facilities

FACILITY STREET ADDRESS CITY COUNTY STATE EMISSIONS/1000 BARRELS/DAY

VALERO REFINING CO CALIFORNIA BENICIA REFINERY 3400 E SECOND ST BENICIA SOLANO CA 0.2039

VALERO WILMINGTON ASPHALT PLANT 1651 ALAMEDA ST WILMINGTON LOS ANGELES CA 0.051701

VALERO REFINING CO LOUISIANA HWY 105 S KROTZ SPRINGS ST LANDRY LA 0.165856

VALERO REFINING NEW ORLEANS LLC 14902 RIVER RD NEW SARPY ST CHARLES LA 0.074045

VALERO REFINING - TEXAS L.P. 1301 LOOP 197 S TEXAS CITY GALVESTON TX 0.088799

VALERO REFINING - TEXAS L.P. CORPUS CHRISTI WEST PLANT 5900 UP RIVER RD CORPUS CHRISTI NUECES TX 0.47432

VALERO REFINING - TEXAS L.P. HOUSTON REFINERY 9701 MANCHESTER HOUSTON HARRIS TX 0.634428

VALERO REFINING TEXAS LP CORPUS CHRISTI EAST PLANT 1300 CANTWELL LN CORPUS CHRISTI NUECES TX 1.763265

VALERO THREE RIVERS REFINERY 301 LEROY ST THREE RIVERS LIVE OAK TX 0.887549

Exxon Facilities

FACILITY STREET ADDRESS CITY COUNTY STATE

EMISSIONS/1000 BARRELS/DAY

EXXONMOBIL OIL CORP - TORRANCE REFINERY 3700 W 190TH ST TORRANCE LOS ANGELES CA 0.125899 EXXONMOBIL REFINING & SUPPLY BATON ROUGE REFINERY 4045 SCENIC HWY BATON ROUGE EAST BATON ROUGE LA 0.113718 EXXONMOBIL OIL BEAUMONT REFINERY E END OF BURT ST BEAUMONT JEFFERSON TX 0.127301 EXXONMOBIL REFINING & SUPPLY BAYTOWN REFINERY 2800 DECKER DR BAYTOWN HARRIS TX 0.189107

Page 17: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

17

Shell Facilities

FACILITY STREET ADDRESS CITY COUNTY STATE EMISSIONS/1000 BARRELS/DAY

MOTIVA ENTERPRISES LLC CONVENT REFINERY FOOT OF SUNSHINE BRIDGE LA HWY 44 CONVENT ST JAMES LA 0.029706

SHELL CHEMICAL LP ST ROSE FACILITY 11842 RIVER RD LOT 2 SAINT ROSE ST CHARLES LA 0.035467

SHELL OIL PRODUCTS US - MARTINEZ REFINERY 3485 PACHECO BLVD MARTINEZ CONTRA COSTA CA 0.035743

MOTIVA ENTERPRISES LLC PORT ARTHUR REFINERY 2100 HOUSTON AVE PORT ARTHUR JEFFERSON TX 0.040721 MOTIVA ENTERPRISES LLC PORT ARTHUR TERMINAL W END OF 7TH ST PORT ARTHUR TERMINAL PORT ARTHUR JEFFERSON TX 0.062831

SHELL OIL PRODUCTS US LOS ANGELES REFINERY 2101 E PACIFIC COAST HWY WILMINGTON LOS ANGELES CA 0.074459

MOTIVA ENTERPRISES LLC NORCO REFINERY 15536 RIVER RD NORCO ST CHARLES LA 0.116532

SHELL OIL CO - DEER PARK REFINING LP 5900 HWY 225 DEER PARK HARRIS TX 0.21089

Page 18: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

18

25 Largest US Benzene Emitters (SIC 29)Petroleum (2005)

0

20000

40000

60000

80000

100000

120000

140000

TX TX TX TX TX LA TX LA LA TX TX TX TX TX TX TX TX LA TX TX LA TX LA TX LA

State

Benz

ene

Emis

sion

s (p

ound

s)

Page 19: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

19

25 Largest US Benzene Emitters (SIC 29) Petroleum (2005) Greatest to Least (1–25)

Facility Address City County or Parish or County Equivalent State

1 LYONDELL-CITGO REFINING LP 12000 LAWNDALE AVE HOUSTON HARRIS TX

2 BP TEXAS CITY REFINERY 2401 5TH AVE S TEXAS CITY GALVESTON TX

3 DELEK REFINING LTD 1702 E COMMERCE ST TYLER SMITH TX

4 CONOCOPHILLIPS CO SWEENY REFINERY COMPLEX STATE HWY 35 AT FM 524 OLD OCEAN BRAZORIA TX

5 FLINT HILLS RESOURCES LP - WEST PLANT 2825 SUNTIDE RD CORPUS CHRISTI NUECES TX

6 CONOCOPHILLIPS CO - ALLI ANCE REFINERY 15551 HWY 23 BELLE CHASSE PLAQUEMINES LA

7 VALERO REFINING TEXAS LP CORPUS CHRISTI EAST PLANT 1300 CANTWELL LN CORPUS CHRISTI NUECES TX

8 CITGO PETROLEUM CORP 4401 HWY 108 WESTLAKE CALCASIEU LA

9 CHALMETTE REFINING LLC 500 W ST BERNARD HWY CHALMETTE ST BERNARD LA

10 CITGO REFINING & CHEMICALS CO LP EAST PLANT 1801 NUECES BAY BLVD CORPUS CHRISTI NUECES TX

11 ALON USA BIG SPRING REFINERY IH 20 AT REFINERY RD BIG SPRING HOWARD TX

12 EXXONMOBIL REFINING & SUPPLY BAYTOWN REFINERY 2800 DECKER DR BAYTOWN HARRIS TX

13 TOTAL PETROCHEMICALS USA INC. - PORT ARTHUR REFINERY HWY 366 & 32ND ST PORT ARTHUR JEFFERSON TX

14 MARATHON PETROLEUM CO LLC 502 10TH ST S TEXAS CITY GALVESTON TX

15 CONOCOPHILLIPS CO STATE HWY SPUR 119 N BORGER HUTCHINSON TX

16 VALERO THREE RIVERS REFINERY 301 LEROY ST THREE RIVERS LIVE OAK TX

17 SHELL OIL CO - DEER PARK REFINING LP 5900 HWY 225 DEER PARK HARRIS TX

18 EXXONMOBIL REFINING & SUPPLY BATON ROUGE REFINERY 4045 SCENIC HWY BATON ROUGE EAST BATON ROUGE LA

19 VALERO REFINING - TEXAS L.P. HOUSTON REFINERY 9701 MANCHESTER HOUSTON HARRIS TX

20 BP TEXAS CITY REFINERY DOCKS LOOP 197 S BE HWY 6 & 519 TEXAS CITY GALVESTON TX

21 MARATHON PETROLEUM CORP GARYVILLE HWY 61 AT MARATHON AVENUE GARYVILLE ST JOHN THE BAPTIST LA

22 EXXONMOBIL OIL BEAUMONT REFINERY E END OF BURT ST BEAUMONT JEFFERSON TX

23 CONOCOPHILLIPS CO LAKE CHARLES REFINERY 2200 OLD SPANISH TRAIL WESTLAKE CALCASIEU LA

24 FLINT HILLS RESOURCES LP EAST PLANT 1700 NUECES BAY BLVD CORPUS CHRISTI NUECES TX

25 CALUMET LUBRICANTS CO. L.P. CALUMET COTTON VALLEY 1756 OLD HWY 7 COTTON VALLEY WEBSTER LA

Page 20: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

20

25 Largest US Benzene Emitters (SIC 28)Chemical (2005)

0

10000

20000

30000

40000

50000

60000

70000

TX TX TX TX TX TX TX TX LA TX TX TX TX TX LA PA IA TX LA LA TX IL TX AL SC

Emitting Facility by State

Ben

zene

Em

issi

ons

(pou

nds)

from: 2005 TRI, SIC 28

Page 21: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

21

25 Largest US Benzene Emitters (SIC 28) Chemical (2005) Greatest to Least (1 – 25)

1 LYONDELL CHEMICAL CO 2502 SHELDON ROAD CHANNELVIEW HARRIS TX

2 ROHM & HAAS TEXAS INC 1900 TIDAL RD DEER PARK HARRIS TX

3 EQUISTAR CHEMICALS 8280 SHELDON RD CHANNELVIEW HARRIS TX

4 CHEVRON PHILLIPS CHEMICAL CO 2001 S GULFWAY DR PORT ARTHUR JEFFERSON TX

5 LYONDELL CHEMICAL CO CHOCOLATE BAYOU CHEMICALS PLANT FM ROAD 2917 ALVIN BRAZORIA TX

6 HUNTSMAN PETROCHEMICAL CORP PABC SAVANNAH AVE GATE 20 PORT ARTHUR JEFFERSON TX

7 SHELL CHEMICAL CO 5900 HWY 225 DEER PARK HARRIS TX

8 EXXONMOBIL BAYTOWN CHEMICAL PLANT 5000 BAYWAY DR BAYTOWN HARRIS TX 9 SHELL NORCO CHEMICAL PLANT EAST SITE 15536 RIVER RD LOT 1 NORCO ST CHARLES LA

10 DOW CHEMICAL CO FREEPORT FACILITY 2301 N BRAZOSPORT BLVD BUILDING B-101 FREEPORT BRAZORIA TX

11 GEORGIA GULF CHEMICALS & VINYLS LLC PASADENA 3503 PASADENA FWY PASADENA HARRIS TX 12 EXXONMOBIL CHEMICAL CO BAYTOWN OLEFINS PLANT 3525 DECKER DR BAYTOWN HARRIS TX 13 NAFTA REGION OLEFINS COMPLEX NE OF INTERSECTION OF HIGHWAY 73 & HWY 366 PORT ARTHUR JEFFERSON TX 14 STERLING CHEMICALS INC. 201 BAY ST S TEXAS CITY GALVESTON TX 15 COS-MAR CO 6325 LA HWY 75 CARVILLE IBERVILLE LA 16 INDSPEC CHEMICAL CO 133 MAIN ST PETROLIA BUTLER PA

17 EQUISTAR CHEMICALS CLINTON PLANT 3400 ANAMOSA ROAD HWY 30 W CLINTON CLINTON IA 18 EASTMAN CHEMICAL CO TEXAS OPERATIONS KODAK BLVD / OFF HWY 149 LONGVIEW HARRISON TX 19 EXXONMOBIL CHEMICAL BATON ROUGE CHEMICAL PLANT 4999 SCENIC HWY BATON ROUGE EAST BATON ROUGE LA

20 DOW CHEMICAL CO LOUISIANA DIV 21255 LA HWY 1 S PLAQUEMINE IBERVILLE LA 21 INVISTA S. A. R. L. ORANGE SITE 3055A FM 1006 ORANGE ORANGE TX 22 DYNACHEM, INC. MAPLE GROVE RD GEORGETOWN VERMILION IL

23 FORMOSA PLASTICS CORP. TEXAS 201 FORMOSA DR POINT COMFORT CALHOUN TX 24 BP AMOCO CHEMICALS 1401 FINLEY ISLAND RD DECATUR MORGAN AL 25 BP AMOCO CHEMICAL CO COOPER RIVER PLANT 1306 AMOCO DR WANDO BERKELEY SC

Page 22: Pounds of Total OSHA Carcinogen Emissions per 1000 Barrels per Calendar Day 2005

Source: Energy Information Administration (EIA), Form EIA-820, “Annual Refinery Report.” 2005 and 2006.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Toxics Release Inventory (TRI), TRI-Explorer SIC 29 Benzene 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 29 OSHA Carcinogens, 2004 and 2005.EPA, TRI, TRI-Explorer SIC 28 Benzene, 2005.TRI OSHA Carcinogens are defined as carcinogenic or probably carcinogenic by the IARC; a known or reasonably anticipated carcinogen by the NTP; or part of 29 CFR part 1910 Subpart Z under OSHA.

22

25 Largest US Benzene Emitters (SIC 28)Chemical (2005)

0

20000

40000

60000

80000

100000

120000

140000

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

Emitting Facility by State and Order: Red (TX); Yellow (LA)

Ben

zene

Em

issi

ons

(Pou

nds)