62
Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k” “the role of the top quark” Complex SM Early tops SUSY Extra dimensions Early physics Now Calibrations Detector commissioning Ivo van Vulpen (Nikhef)

Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Preparing for first physics at the LHC“th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark”

Complex SMEarly tops

SUSY

Extra dimensions

Early physics

NowCalibrations

Detector commissioning

Ivo van Vulpen (Nikhef)

Page 2: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

The famous top quark

Paris Hilton Top Quark

… everybody constantly talking about them… they are troublemakers, famous, important … buy why again ?

2/57

Page 3: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Complex SM

SUSY

Complex SMEarly tops

Early physics

Extra dimensions

Now[6 slides]Calibrations

Early physics

[6 slides]

Detector

Calibrations

The Standard Modelcommissioning The Standard Model… and what’s wrong with it

Page 4: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Particles Forces

Quarks 1) Electromagnetism

2) Weak nuclear force

Leptons 3) Strong nuclear force

The Standard Model:Describes all measurements down to distances of 10-19 m

4/57

•4/52

Page 5: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Electroweak Symmetry breakingElectro-Weak Symmetry Breaking: (Higgs mechanism)

- Weak gauge bosons and particles have massR l t WW/ZZ tt i- Regulate WW/ZZ scattering

eV

)

“We know everything about the Higgs boson except its mass”

mass

(G

e

Limits on mh from theory

Limits on mh from exper.

Hig

gs

m

Triviality

V t bilit4222V Φ+Φ−= λμ

Λ (GeV)

Vacuum stability

5/57

Page 6: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

The standard model … boring ?

“All measurements in “The Higgs boson will All measurements in HEP can be explained using the SM”

The Higgs boson will be discovered at the LHC at ~ 140 GeV”

No. … there are many mysteries left!

6/57

Page 7: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Wh t l i ( t ) t i f t hi h bl ?

The big questions:

What explains (extreme) tuning of parameters: hierarchy problem ?

What is dark matter made of ?

Why is gravity so different ? Why is gravity so different ?

Page 8: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

The mysteries of the SM

Why is gravity not a part of the Standard Model ?

What is the origin of particle mass ? (Higgs mechanism)What is the origin of particle mass ? (Higgs mechanism)

In how many dimensions do we live ?

Are the quarks and leptons really the fundamental particles ?Are the quarks and leptons really the fundamental particles ?

Are there new symmetries in nature ?

Wh th l 3 f ili f f i ?Why are there only 3 families of fermions ?

Are protons really stable ?

Why is electric charged quantized ?

Why is there more matter than anti‐matter in our universe ?

What is the nature of dark matter and dark energy ?

Do quantum corrections explode at higher energies ?

8/57Why are neutrino masses so small ?

Page 9: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Standard Model is an ‘approximation’ ppof a more fundamental one.

Model breaks down at 1-10 TeVExtra dimensions ?

New phenomena will appear at distances ~ 10-19 mat distances 10 m

2009

Super-Symmetry ? String theory ?

Ed a d Witten’s Edward Witten’s latest insight ?

Page 10: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Complex SM

SUSY

Complex SMEarly tops

Early physics

Extra dimensions

NowCalibrations

Early physics

Detector

Calibrations

Th LHC l tcommissioning[9 slides]

- The LHC accelerator- The ATLAS detector

(testbeam, cosmics, beam)

Page 11: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

The LHC machineThe LHC machine

Center-of-mass energy: 14 TeVCenter-of-mass energy: 14 TeV 7 x Tevatron

Energy limited by bending power dipoles1232 dipoles with B= 8.4 T working at 1.9k

Search for particles with mass up to 4 TeV

Energy limited by bending power dipoles1232 dipoles with B= 8.4 T working at 1.9k

Search for particles with mass up to 4 TeVSearch for particles with mass up to 4 TeV

Luminosity: 1033 1034 cm-2s-1

Search for particles with mass up to 4 TeV

Luminosity: 1033 1034 cm-2s-1 100 x LEP & Luminosity: 1033-1034 cm-2s-1

Phase 1: (low luminosity) 2009-2010Integrated luminosity ~ 10 fb-1/year

Luminosity: 1033-1034 cm-2s-1

Phase 1: (low luminosity) 2009-2010Integrated luminosity ~ 10 fb-1/year

100 x LEP & Tevatron

Integrated luminosity 10 fb /yearPhase 2: (high luminosity) 2010-20xx

Integrated luminosity ~ 100 fb-1/year

Integrated luminosity 10 fb /yearPhase 2: (high luminosity) 2010-20xx

Integrated luminosity ~ 100 fb-1/year

11/57

•11/52

Search for rare processesSearch for rare processes

Page 12: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Towards physics: LHC’s point of viewP. Jenny, SUSY2009

2009 2010 20112009

j f m a m j j a s o n d j f m a m j j a s o n d j f m a m j j a s o n d

2010 2011

Weltmeister !

shutdown

physics

- Start LHC operation Oct. 2009- Run over winter shutdown

physics- 10 TeV collisions first year

LHC operators: “44 days from first injection to physics run”

ATLAS/CMS: Analysis potential with ~100 pb-1 (ATLAS’ CSC note)

12/57

ATLAS/CMS: Analysis potential with ~100 pb 1 (ATLAS CSC-note)

Page 13: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

The ATLAS detectorThe ATLAS detector

Tracking (|η|<2.5, B=2T) :Silicon, pixels and stripsTransition Radiation DetectorTransition Radiation Detector(e/π separation)

Calorimetry (|η|<5) :EM : Pb-LArHAD: barrel: Fe/scintillator

forward: Cu/W-LAr

Muon Spectrometer (|η|<2.7) : air-core toroids with muon chambers~1000 charged particles produced

over |η|<2.5 at each crossing.

Page 14: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Towards physics: ATLAS’ point of view

Testbeam Subdetector Installation Cosmics commissioningCosmics commissioning Single beams

First LHC collissions

First physics runs

2005 2006 2007 2008 2005 2006 2007 2008

14/57

Page 15: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Muons in the ATLAS cavern

~ 20 million muons enter cavern per hour

Simulation ATLAS cavern 0.01 seconds

Collected statistics:

ATLAS Preliminary Cosmics : tracks in Pixels+SCT+TRT

Debugging, first alignment studies

15/57

Page 16: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Muons in the ATLAS cavern

~ 20 million muons enter cavern per hour

Simulation ATLAS cavern 0.01 seconds

origin

Collected statistics:

ATLAS Preliminary

16/57

Page 17: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Cosmics: alignments & checks

Energy loss in calorimeterAlignment SCT barrel

After alignment

Before alignmentg

E t d 3 G V l

p(ID) – p(MS) [GeV/c]x residual [mm]

17/57

M Aleksa, P. Jenny, O. Jinnouchi SUSY2009

Expected 3 GeV loss

Page 18: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Cosmics: EM Calorimeter

Energy [GeV]

Entri

es

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

1600

-0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

Electromagnetic calorimeter Electromagnetic calorimeter

Energy [GeV]

Entri

es

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

1600

-0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

Test-beam dataATLAS Preliminary

En

trie

s

Muons

Test-beam data

nerg

y

Energy [GeV]

Entri

es

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

1600

-0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

E

lati

ve E

Energy [GeV]

Entri

es

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

1600

-0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

Noise Re

Energy [GeV]

Entri

es

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

1600

-0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

Energy GeV Eta (module)

Check (+ correct) ECAL responseuniformity vs η to ~ 0.5%

A muon deposit ~ 300 MeV in ECAL cell (S/N~ 7)

18/57

Page 19: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Single beams in LHC

Beam gas + beam halo:- 5 TeV protons on residual gas in vacuum

- tracks accompanying the beam

19/57First beam event in ATLAS

Page 20: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Complex SM

SUSY

Complex SMEarly tops

Early physics

Extra dimensions

NowCalibrations

Early physics

[4 lid ]

Detector

Calibrations

- Planning road to new physics

[4 slides]

commissioning- Simple SM topologies(collecting pieces of the puzzle)

Page 21: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

LHC start-up programme

Integrated luminosity

Look for new physics3

1 fb–1

Look for new physicsin ATLAS at 10 TeV

3

100 pb–1 Understand SM+ATLASin complex topologies

2

Higgs/SUSY

1

in complex topologies

Top quark pairs

10 pb–1

1 Understand SM+ATLAS in simple topologies

W/Z

p q p

0 Understand ATLAS Testbeam/cosmics

W/Z

Andreas Hoecker

21/57

TimeLHC startup

Page 22: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

ATLAS detector performance on day-1

- Reconstruct (high-level) physics objects:

Electrons/photons: Electromagnetic Energy scale

Quarks/Gluons: Jet Energy scale + b-tagging

Expected detector performance from ATLAS

Neutrino’s/LSP?: Missing Energy reconstruction

Performance Expected day-1 Physics samples to improve

Expected detector performance from ATLAS(based on Testbeam and simulations)

ECAL uniformity 1% Min. bias, Z e+e- (105 in a few days)e/γ scale 1-2% Z e+e-

HCAL uniformity 2-3% single pions, QCD jetsJet scale <10% γ/Z (Z l+l-) + 1 jet or W jj in tt

22/57

Tracking alignment 20-500 μm Rφ Generic tracks, isol. muons, Z μ+μ-

Page 23: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Plan-de-campagne during first year

First year:Process #events

10 fb-1

A new detector AND a new energy regime

8

12

10W10 bb

U d d ATLAS

7

7-

8

10tt10 μ/μeeZ10 eνW

−++→

→ 1

21 U d t d SM+ATLAS

0 Understand ATLAS using cosmics

7

7

7

10G V150PjQCD10 bias Min.10 tt 21 Understand SM+ATLAS

in simple topolgies

d d2

4

5GeV) 130h(m

7T

10~~10 h

10 GeV150PjetsQCD

=

>

3

Understand SM+ATLASin complex topologies

2

3 4 TeV) 1g~(m 10 g~g~ = 3Look for new physics

in ATLAS at 10 TeV 3

23/57

Page 24: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Early SM peaks: di-lepton resonancests ts

J/ψ→ μμ

Y→ μμr o

f eve

nt

r o

f eve

nt

4200160

Y→ μμ

Nu

mb

er

Nu

mb

er

800

ATLAS preliminary, 1 pb-1 ATLAS preliminary, 10 pb-1

Mμμ (GeV) Mμμ (GeV)

E t d t L i it f 1031

Reconstruction efficiencies Muon spectrometer alignment Detector and trigger

Events per day at a Luminosity of 1031

24/57

Reconstruction efficiencies, Muon spectrometer alignment, Detector and trigger performance, Tracking momentum scale, ECAL uniformity, E/p scale, …

Page 25: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Top quarks:- As weird member of SM family- As a calibration tool in complex topologies

Complex SM

As a calibration tool in complex topologies- As a window to new physics

SUSY

Complex SMEarly tops

Early physics

Extra dimensions

NowCalibrations

Early physics

Detector

Calibrations

25/57

commissioning

Page 26: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

The top quark: ‘old-physics’

We know already a lot about the top quark

u c t

d s b

Mass(difference), Electric charge (⅔), Spin, Isospin, Br(t Wb), V-A decay, FCNC Top Width Yukawa coupling

The LHC offers an opportunity for precision measurements

FCNC, Top Width, Yukawa coupling, ...

26/57

pp y pThe top quark is a trouble maker

Page 27: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Top quark production at the LHC

Cross section LHC = 100 x Tevatron

400,000/800,000 tt events per year at 10/14 TeV

90%Cross section LHC = 100 x TevatronBackground LHC = 10 x Tevatron

10%

tt

t

bbqqqq 4/9bbqqlv 4/9bblvlv 1/91) Top most complex SM candle bblvlv 1/9) p p

Clear signal on early data

2) Top signal important background

27/57

for most new physics searches

Page 28: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Top cross-section (theory)

aint

yna

l unc

erta

Frac

tion

mtop (GeV)

Uncertainty due to PDF’s similar to W/ZUncertainty due to PDF s similar to W/Z

28/57

Jianming Qian: http:// indico.cern.ch/conferenceDisplay.py?confId=54025

Scale dependence: NLO (approxNNLO): μF and μR varied separately (together)

Page 29: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Top cross-section (theory)

Dependence on √s

Factor 2

883 pb

401 pb

bbqqqq 4/9bbqqlv 4/9

√s (TeV)bbqqlv 4/9bblvlv 1/9

mt = 172 5 GeVm CTEQ 6 6

Topology: ‐ high‐PT (b‐) jets, ‐ isolated leptons

mt = 172.5 GeVm CTEQ 6.6

√s = 14 TeV: σapproxNNLO = 883 pb√s = 10 TeV: σapproxNNLO = 401 pb

29/57

‐missing energy

Page 30: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Top quark physics (with b-tag information)

Top physics is ‘easy’ at the LHC

Systematic errors on Mtop (GeV)in semi-leptonic channel

Selection: Lepton + multiple jets + 2 b-jetskills the dominant background from W+jets

Source Error10 fb-1

b-jet scale (±1%) 0.74 G

eV

j ( )

ISR/FSR Radiation 0.3

Light jet scale (±1%) 0.2

Top signal

f Evt

s/ 4

b-quark fragmentation 0.1

TOTAL: Stat ⊕ Syst ~ 1 GeVW+jetsN

r o

f

Mjjb (GeV)

30/57Could we see top quarks when selection is not based on b-tag ?

Page 31: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Di-lepton cross-section measurement (μμ)

Trigger: Single muon, PT > 17 GeV

nts

Lepton ID: Two, isolated, opposite chargePT > 20 GeV

of

eve

n

Jets: ≥2 jets with PT > 20 GeV

Missing ET: ET-miss > 35 GeV (+ cleaning)

Nu

mb

er

MZ-cut: |Mμμ–MZ| > 5 GeVNumber of jets

N

200 pb-1

tt signal = 327bckg = 87

31/57

S/√(S+B) = 16.1

Page 32: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Single-lepton Top quark events (no b-tag information)

• Robust selection cuts

Effi (%) # i l #b kMissing ET > 20 GeV1 lepton PT > 20 GeV3 jets PT > 40 GeV4 jets with P > 30 GeV

Effic (%) # signal #bckg

Muon 23.6 3274 1497

Electron 18.2 2555 11444 jets with PT > 30 GeV

W CANDIDATE

Electron 18.2 2555 1144

A i j t t t dHadronic 3-jet mass

TOP CANDIDATENote: In 70% of events there is an

extra jet with P > 30 GeV

• Assign jets to top decays

L=200 pb-1

j

extra jet with PT > 30 GeV

jet pairings ?

Hadronic top: three jets with highest vector-sum pT

32/57

Extra: Require a jj-pair in top quark candidate with |Mjj-80.4| < 10

Mjjj (GeV)

200 pb-1: few days of low-lumi LHC operation

Page 33: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Single lepton cross-section measurement (μ)

Data-driven estimate for W+jets from Z+jetsj j

20% uncertainty reachable

33/57

Page 34: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Top phase space

‘clean’

Top quark phase space

Top precision measurements

34/57

Top precision measurementsCalibrating ATLAS in multi-jet events

Page 35: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Top physics at the LHC

“Top quark pair production has it all”:

≥ 4 jets b jets neutrino lepton

4/9

≥ 4 jets, b-jets, neutrino, leptonseveral mass constraints for calibration

4/9

Calibrate light jet energy scale

A candle for complex topologies:

Obtain enriched b-jet sample

Calibrate missing ET

Calibrate light jet energy scale

Obtain enriched b jet sample

Leptons & Trigger Note the 4 candles:

- 2 W-bosons M = 80 4 GeV

35/57

- 2 W-bosons Mw = 80.4 GeV- 2 top quarks & Mt = Mt-bar

Page 36: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Jet energy scale

(1) Abundant source of W decaysinto light jets

Determine Light-Jet energy scale

– Invariant mass of (light-) jets should add up to well known W mass (80.4 GeV)

Light jet energy scale calibration (1% for 1 pb-1)

t

MW = 78.1±0.8 GeV MW(had)

1 G

eV

t

nts

/ 5

.

P

Eve

Pro:- Large event sample- Small physics backgrounds

Con:

36/57

S/B = 0.5Con:- Only light quark jets- Limited Range in PT and η

Page 37: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Using top quark events to obtain a clean sample of b-quarks

(2) Abundant clean source of b-jets Calibrate/test b-tagging in complex event topology

– 2 out of 4 jets in event are b-jets ~50% a-priori purity( t ISR/FSR j t )(extra ISR/FSR jets)

– The 2 light quark-jets can be g q jidentified (should form W mass)

t

t

Conventional:

- Rejection in di-jet sample

37/57

Rejection in di jet sample- Efficiency using semi-lept. decays

Page 38: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Estimating b-tag efficiency

Jet counting Likelihood / Topological selection

# jets with 0,1,2,3, 4 jets b-tags

Configuration depends on εb, εc εl

Fit templates to event characteristics

Co gu a o depe ds o εb, εc εl

100 pb-1: Δεb ~5%

38/57

Can also measure tt cross-section

Page 39: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Top group (all) ttH ttH

Extra jets

‘clean’low ‘ISR-FSR’ High-P

Exotics, SUSYTop group:

Top massCross-section

PTor

LargeET-

miss

Top quark phase space

SUSY

Page 40: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

- Intro to SUSY

- SUSY parameter space( l di t ti l)

Complex SM

(early discovery potential)

- ATLAS’ SUSY reach

SUSY

Complex SMEarly tops

[11 slides]

Early physics

Extra dimensions

NowCalibrations

Early physics

Detector

Calibrations

commissioning

Page 41: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

The hierarchy problemThe hierarchy problem in the SM

predicted observed t

Success of radiative corr. in the SM:

4532

129

91 boson Higgs

9.2 172.7 179 quark top+

+− ±

?

predicted observedW W

b32-ggb

mh =

Failure of radiative corr. in Higgs sector:Radiative corrections from top quark

h h

t

λt λt150 = 1354294336587235150

–1354294336587235000

mh p q

Hierarchy problem:

‘Conspiracy’ to get mh ~ MEW (« MPL)

t t

Λ241/57

p y g h EW ( PL)Biggest troublemaker is the top quark!

Λ

Page 42: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

A new symmetry: supersymmetry

Standard model particles New ‘partner’ particlesStandard model particles

Bosons Fermion‐partners

New partner particles

BosonsW,Z,photon

e o pa e swino’s, zino’s, fotino’s

Fermionsquarks/leptons

Boson‐partnerssquarks/sleptons

SUSY: - Regulates quantum corrections (‘solves’ hierarchy problem)- Gauge Unification and dark matter candidate

42/57

- a-priori not very predictive (many parameters)- many constraints from data (no sparticles, cosmology, … )

Page 43: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

A model: mSUGRA

R-parity conserved : - Stable Lightest Supersymmetric Particle: LSP

- m0: universal scalar mass (sfermions)- m : universal gaugino mass- m½: universal gaugino mass- A0: trilinear Higgs-sfermion coupling- sgn(μ): sign of Higgs mixing parameter- tan(β): ratio of 2 Higgs doublet v.e.v

mSUGRA

V)

Evolution of masses

ass

(G

eV

Fixing parameters at 1016 GeV, the renormalization group equations will give you all sparticle masses at LHC!

m0

nn

ing

ma

Radiative EW symmetry breaking 1016 GeV

Ru

n

43/57

Radiative EW symmetry breaking(thanks to top quark)

Energy scale a.u.

Page 44: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

mSUGRA parameter space

Allowed mSUGRA space m0 = 100 GeVm1/2 = 250 GeVtan β = 10

0(G

eV)

mSUGRAtan(β)=10

ATLAS 100 pb-1

(GeV

)

β

Mass spectrum800

700

600 gluino

m0

g-2

e m

ass

( 600

500

400

gluino

(WMAP)

Part

icle

300

200

stau LSP 100

0

Allowed mSUGRA space

m1/2 (GeV) Higgs boson(LEP) LSP (ΩDM)

Constraints:LEP: m > 114 4 GeV

44/57

pVery different exper. signatures

- LEP: mh > 114.4 GeV - Cosmology: LSP neutral- Cosmology: limits on mLSP

Page 45: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Cosmology and SUSY

WMAP III: 0.121 < Ωmh2 = nLSP x mLSP < 0.135

dark matter

ρ = Relic LSP density x LSP massρLSP = Relic LSP density x LSP mass

The relic LSP density depends on LSP mass:LSP stable, but they can annihilate, so density decreases when LSP annihilation cross section increases.

22~

2201

01 )/()( fmmmff +∝→ χχχχσ

01χ lepton

fχχ

3

22~

2 /)( χχρ

m

mmm fLSP

+∝

0 lepton

slepton(NLSP)

45/57

χm≈01χ lepton

Upper AND lower limitson LSP mass

Page 46: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

mSUGRA space: ATLAS reach

Allowed mSUGRA space (post WMAP)

ATLAS reach in mSUGRA space (1-lepton)

½(G

eV

)

0(G

eV)

mSUGRAtan(β)=10

ATLAS 100 pb-1

M½m

0

g-2

(WMAP)

stau LSP

M0 (GeV)m1/2 (GeV)

Allowed mSUGRA space

46/57

pVery different exper. signatures

Page 47: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Production of SUSY particles at the LHC

• Superpartners have same gauge quantum numbers as SM particles interactions have same couplingsas S pa t c es te act o s a e sa e coup gs

q q q~ qq

αS

gq q

αS

g~

• Gluino’s / squarks are produced copiouslyGluino s / squarks are produced copiously(rest SUSY particles in decay chain)

47/57

Page 48: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Event topology

jet jet lepton

lepton

Missing energyenergy

Missing

Topology: ≥4 jetsmissing ET (large)

energy

leptons/photons

SUSY events look like top eventsjetjet

48/57

Page 49: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

LHC day 2: First to discover SUSY Common signature large fraction SUSY events

j t

SUSY event topology Sensitive to hard scale

jet

jet/lepton

jet

jet

jet/lepton

jet/lepton

b-1j / p

nts

/1

fb

# e

ven

SUSY SM

Meff (GeV)

SU(1) 232 tt 36SU(2) 40 total 42SU(3) 364

49/57tt production dominant background

SU(4) 896SU(5) 148

Page 50: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Estimate tt background in SUSY region: big fit

Top (sl)Top (sl)

Top (fl)

W+jets

SUSYSUSY

ET-miss MT mtop

50/5720% uncertainty on W+jets and ttVital for early claims of signs of breakdown SM

T T top

Page 51: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Complex SM

SUSY

Complex SMEarly tops

Early physics

Extra dimensions [6 slides]

NowCalibrations

Early physics

Detector

Calibrations

- New physics in the top sample(focus on resonances/high-PT)

commissioning- 2-slide intro to extra dimensions

Page 52: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Differential cross-section: structure in Mtt

Gaemers, Hoogeveen (1984)

n (

a.u

.)

500 GeV

s se

ctio

600 GeV

Cro

s

400 GeV

Mtt (GeV) Mtt (GeV)

Interference from MSSM Higgses H,A tt (can be up to 6-7% effect)

What about anomalous tt production ?ttXpp →→

52/57Z’, ZH, G(1), SUSY, ?

Page 53: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

High PT-tops & anti-KT jetsTop Top

W)

Top Top

dR

(b

-W

Large boost: overlapping jets

pT top (GeV)

Large boost: overlapping jetstop algorithms break down

Use jet mass & look for sub-structure in jets (clustering)

Sociological side remark: - anti-KT jet clustering (thanks Gavin et al.)

53/57

- event weights in MC (thanks Max)- Fitting algorithms (thanks Göttingen)- … Δε and many many many others

Page 54: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

The 3+1 forces of nature

reng

th

Quantum theories

strong force

Str

no quantum theoryt i th ?

Weak forcegravitation

1

string theory?Electromagn. force

1~Quantum gravity: gravitons

~1040 2~r

nr +2and mini black holes

Energy (GeV) ∝ distance-1

54/57

Planck scaleElectroweak scale

Page 55: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Kaluza-Klein excitations

Each particle that can ‘enter’ the extra dimension (bulk) will appear in our 4 dimensions as a set of massive states (Kaluza-Klein tower)

(Mreal)2 = E2 – px2 – py

2 – pz2 – pxd

2

= (m4d)2 – pxd2

Momentum quantized in the extra dimension. Pxd = i x ΔP , with i = 1,2,3,4,5, …

(m4d)2 = (Mreal)2 + pxd2

Depends on size/shape XD

massless graviton Gmomentum p0 p1, p2, …, pi in extra dimension

(4+n)-dim. R largeR small

tion

(a.u

)massive gravitonswith mass m0, m1, m2, …. miwith name G(0), G(1), G(2), …G(i)

(4)-dim.C

ross

sec

t

55/57

, , ,

Me+e- (GeV)

Drell-YanC

Page 56: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Resonances in Mtt

Z’, ZH, G(1), SUSY, ?

Resonanceat 1600 GeVn

ts

Resonances in Mtt

at 1600 GeV

# e

ven

Δσ/σ ~ 6 %

tt

Mtt (GeV) M (GeV)

56/57

Mtt (GeV) Mtt (GeV)

Page 57: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Complex SM

SUSY

Complex SMEarly tops

Early physics

Extra dimensions

NowCalibrations

Early physics

Detector

Calibrations

- Great journey ahead of uscommissioning- top plays an important role

- Plenty of early discoveries possible

Page 58: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Backup slides

Page 59: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Lepton trigger in multi‐jet eventsExtra (fake) muons

1) Apply all‐Jet Trigger (4J23)2) Look for events that pass muon

selection

Rate & origin

selectionFull Sim Fast Sim

extra/jet 100±4 107±8

from b / b-jet 250±10 268±21

•vfrom light / l-jet 6.3±1.3 9.1±3.0

fake / jet 3.5±0.7 0

M [GeV]

prob.for b‐jet (PT) to produce isolatedmuon Mjjj [GeV]

3) look at muon trigger performancei.e. an orthogonal trigger

muon

59/571 fb-1: εEF_mu20 = 0.801 ± 0.011 (stat)

g ggUse jet PT spectra and b/light rates

to get QCD estimates from data

Page 60: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

A new symmetry: supersymmetry

SUSY: regulates quantum corrections (‘solves’ hierarchy problem)only works if the masses of the SUSY particles are close to that of SM partner

[ ]|| 2λ

y p p

[ ]K+Λ+Λ−=Δ )/ln(6216

|| 222

2fUVfUV

fH mmm

πλ

Notice minus sign

[ ]|| 2λ

Notice minus signNote 2 bosonic partners per fermion

[ ]K+Λ−Λ=Δ )/ln(16

|| 222

2SUVSUV

SH msmm

πλ

bosons

SUSY: - a-priori not very predictive (many parameters)- many constraints from data (no sparticles cosmology )

60/57

- many constraints from data (no sparticles, cosmology, … )

Page 61: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Commissioning the muon detectors

Full chain of muon reconstruction in ATLASStandalone tracking using cosmic rays

Large shaftsmall shaft

61/57origin cosmic rays

Page 62: Preparing for first physics at the LHC - Nikhefivov/Talks/2009_june_Gottingen.pdf · Preparing for first physics at the LHC “th l f th t k”“the role of the top quark” Complex

Flavour changing neutral currents

ATLAS 5σ sensitivityu (c,t)Z/γ

• No FCNC in SM:

u

L k f FCNC i t d

SM: 10-13 , other models up to 10-4

u,ct

• Look for FCNC in top decays

γ/Z( e+e-)

Expected limits on FCNC for ATLAS:- Results statistically limited- Sensitivity at the level of SUSY

62/57

- Sensitivity at the level of SUSY and Quark singlet models