Prion biology problem space: Mad cows, itchy sheep and protein structure

Prion biology problem Prion biology problem space:space:

Mad cows, itchy sheep and Mad cows, itchy sheep and protein structureprotein structure

Touring the problem spaceTouring the problem space

I.I. History and introduction to prion biologyHistory and introduction to prion biology

II.II. Idea of conformational changeIdea of conformational change

III.III. Exploring sequences of prion proteinsExploring sequences of prion proteins

IV.IV. Exploring physical properties and Exploring physical properties and structures of prion proteinsstructures of prion proteins

V.V. Linking evolution, structure and function Linking evolution, structure and function of prion proteinsof prion proteins


I.I. History and introduction to History and introduction to prion biologyprion biology

II.II. Idea of conformational change Idea of conformational change III.III. Exploring sequences of prion proteinsExploring sequences of prion proteinsIV.IV. Exploring physical properties and Exploring physical properties and

structures of prion proteinsstructures of prion proteinsV.V. Linking evolution, structure and function Linking evolution, structure and function

of prion proteinsof prion proteins

Prion HistoryPrion History

1717thth ct. “Sheep are strangely dizzy” – scrapie described ct. “Sheep are strangely dizzy” – scrapie described in Europein Europe

1950’s: Carleton Gajdusek studied cannibalistic 1950’s: Carleton Gajdusek studied cannibalistic ceremonies of Fore tribe in New Guinea and discovered ceremonies of Fore tribe in New Guinea and discovered the Kuru diseasethe Kuru disease

Kuru attacks dura matter of brain and creates vacuoles, Kuru attacks dura matter of brain and creates vacuoles, causing infected person to deteriorate and die within 3 causing infected person to deteriorate and die within 3 monthsmonths

Prion History

1960: Alper - DNA destroying UV radiation doesn’t prevent scrapie infections.

1966: Gajdusek - Chimps get Kuru from ingesting infected brain tissue.

1967: Griffith - Speculated that TSE’s due to protein conformational changes.

1981: Mertz - Fibrils detected in scrapie infected mouse brains. (CONTINUED…)http://www.css.edu/USERS/pstein/CHM3430/11

1700s: Scrapie behavior described

1997: Stanley Prusiner proposed a link between kuru, CJD, 1997: Stanley Prusiner proposed a link between kuru, CJD, scrapie and BSE. scrapie and BSE.

-Proposed that “prion” was responsible for spongiform -Proposed that “prion” was responsible for spongiform manifestations in BSE-infected patientsmanifestations in BSE-infected patients

DEFINITION: DEFINITION:

PRION = Proteinaceous Infectious ParticlesPRION = Proteinaceous Infectious Particles

Prion protein exists in two forms:Prion protein exists in two forms:

PrPc vs. PrPscPrPc vs. PrPsc

http://www.mentorcorp.com/gynecology/prion_history.htmhttp://www.mentorcorp.com/gynecology/prion_history.htmhttp://www.css.edu/USERS/pstein/CHM3430/Prions.ppthttp://www.css.edu/USERS/pstein/CHM3430/Prions.ppt

Protein folding as we know itProtein folding as we know it

http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=press2.nci.nih.gov/sciencebehind/snps_cancer/snps_cancer/images/21.jpg&imgrefurl=http://press2.nci.nih.gov/sciencebehind/snps_cancer/snps_cancer/snps_cancer21.htm&h=461&w=402&sz=22&tbnid=32gDooND7ssJ:&tbnh=124&tbnw=109&start=1&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dprotein%2Bfolding%26hl%3Den%26lr%3D%26ie%3DUTF-8%26sa%3DG



II.II. Idea of conformational changeIdea of conformational changeIII.III. Exploring sequences of prion proteinsExploring sequences of prion proteins



Prion protein foldingPrion protein folding

PrPcPrPsc

kfolding-c

kfolding-sc

kunfolding-sckunfolding-c

Intermediates?

Prion folding model as link between Prion folding model as link between chemistry and biologychemistry and biology

What do folding rates and equilibrium constants What do folding rates and equilibrium constants mean?mean?

If a protein has stability of 7 kcal mol-1, how many molecules are unfolded at 37oC?

Would you expect PrP to be more or less stable than other proteins?

Folded UnfoldedKeq

One protein: Two structuresOne protein: Two structures

http://www.uccs.edu/~rmelamed/MicroFall2002/Chapter%2010/Prion%20Structure.htmlhttp://www.uccs.edu/~rmelamed/MicroFall2002/Chapter%2010/Prion%20Structure.html

PrPc“NORMAL”

conformation

PrPsc“BAD”

conformation

Not all pretty pictures can be Not all pretty pictures can be trusted!trusted!

Based on NMR results Proposed

based on low-resolution structural studies

PrPc

PrPsc

PrPc

PrPc

PrPc

PrPc

PrPc

PrPc

PrPc

PrPc PrPc

PrPc

PrPc

PrPC

PrPSC

PrPC

PrPsc fibrils

Plaque

Disease transmission modesDisease transmission modes

Infections Infections (Kuru, scrapie, bovine spongiform (Kuru, scrapie, bovine spongiform encephalophathies, etc)encephalophathies, etc)

InheritedInherited (Creutzfeld-Jacob disease, (Creutzfeld-Jacob disease, Gerstmann-Straussler-Scheinker disease, Fatal Gerstmann-Straussler-Scheinker disease, Fatal familial insomnia)familial insomnia)

SporadicSporadic (BSE, CJD ?) (BSE, CJD ?)

Link to Link to The Case of the Cherry Hill ClusterThe Case of the Cherry Hill Cluster By D.T. MAXBy D.T. MAX

NY Times magazinePublished: March 28, 2004 NY Times magazinePublished: March 28, 2004

Prion diseases and Koch’s Prion diseases and Koch’s postulatespostulates

I.I. The agent must be present in every case of the The agent must be present in every case of the diseasedisease

II.II. The agent must be isolated from the host and grown The agent must be isolated from the host and grown in a lab dishin a lab dish

III.III. The disease must be reproduced when a pure The disease must be reproduced when a pure culture of the agent is inoculated into a healthy culture of the agent is inoculated into a healthy susceptible hostsusceptible host

IV.IV. The same agent must be recovered again from the The same agent must be recovered again from the

experimentally infected hostexperimentally infected host..

Can this be applied to understanding prion diseases?


I.I. History and introduction to prion biologyHistory and introduction to prion biologyII.II. Idea of conformational changeIdea of conformational change

III.III. Exploring sequences of prion Exploring sequences of prion proteinsproteins



Global view of the amino acid Global view of the amino acid sequence of PrPsequence of PrP

Multiple ways to visualize and Multiple ways to visualize and analyze protein sequenceanalyze protein sequence

Use GeneDoc from Pittsburgh Use GeneDoc from Pittsburgh Supercomputing Center to analyze Supercomputing Center to analyze multiple prion sequencesmultiple prion sequences

By using different coloring schemes, can By using different coloring schemes, can visualize and visualize and quantifyquantify conservation of conservation of different propertiesdifferent properties

Comparison of human, cow, sheep Comparison of human, cow, sheep and mouse prion protein sequenceand mouse prion protein sequence

Conservarion of polar vs. non-polar Conservarion of polar vs. non-polar patternpattern

PROPERTIESLevel 1 DEHKRNQT POLARLIVMFYWAGCP NON-POLAR

Level 2DEHKRNQSTLIVMFYWAG

Analyzing charge distributionAnalyzing charge distribution

Level 2DEHKR CHARGEDNQST POLAR UNCHARGEDLIVMFYW HYDROPHOBICAG SMALL hydrophobic

Expanded amino acid propertiesExpanded amino acid properties

Examples of questions that can be Examples of questions that can be examined through sequence examined through sequence

analysesanalysesDetermining evolutionary relationships Determining evolutionary relationships

among the various organisms examined.among the various organisms examined. Investigating how amino acid sequence Investigating how amino acid sequence

may be linked to the overall structure of may be linked to the overall structure of the proteinthe protein

Examining the role of repetitive elements Examining the role of repetitive elements in prion homologies. in prion homologies.


I.I. History and introduction to prion biologyHistory and introduction to prion biologyII.II. Idea of conformational changeIdea of conformational changeIII.III. Exploring sequences of prion proteinsExploring sequences of prion proteins

IV.IV. Exploring physical properties Exploring physical properties and structures of prion and structures of prion proteinsproteins


Exploring physical characteristicsExploring physical characteristics

How big is the prion protein? How big is the prion protein?

How does that compare to other proteins?How does that compare to other proteins?

Where is it localized in the cell?Where is it localized in the cell?

Is its size or shape unusual?Is its size or shape unusual?

Is the distribution of amino acids unusual?Is the distribution of amino acids unusual?

PROTPARAM: a tool for analysis of PROTPARAM: a tool for analysis of physical propertiesphysical properties

http://ca.expasy.org/cgi-bin/protparamhttp://ca.expasy.org/cgi-bin/protparamNumber of amino acids:Number of amino acids: 253 253 Molecular weight:Molecular weight: 27629.1 27629.1

Theoretical pI:Theoretical pI: 9.23 9.23

Amino acid composition:Amino acid composition: Ala (A) 10 4.0% Arg (R) 11 Ala (A) 10 4.0% Arg (R) 11 4.3% Asn (N) 12 4.7% Asp (D) 6 2.4% Cys (C) 4 1.6% 4.3% Asn (N) 12 4.7% Asp (D) 6 2.4% Cys (C) 4 1.6% Gln (Q) 14 5.5% Glu (E) 9 3.6% Gly (G) 45 17.8% His Gln (Q) 14 5.5% Glu (E) 9 3.6% Gly (G) 45 17.8% His (H) 10 4.0% Ile (I) 9 3.6% Leu (L) 12 4.7% Lys (K) 11 (H) 10 4.0% Ile (I) 9 3.6% Leu (L) 12 4.7% Lys (K) 11 4.3% Met (M) 11 4.3% Phe (F) 7 2.8% Pro (P) 17 6.7% 4.3% Met (M) 11 4.3% Phe (F) 7 2.8% Pro (P) 17 6.7% Ser (S) 15 5.9% Thr (T) 13 5.1% Trp (W) 9 3.6% Tyr (Y) Ser (S) 15 5.9% Thr (T) 13 5.1% Trp (W) 9 3.6% Tyr (Y) 13 5.1% Val (V) 15 5.9% 13 5.1% Val (V) 15 5.9%

Visualizing protein structure with Visualizing protein structure with Cn3DCn3D

Secondary structural elements can Secondary structural elements can be analyzed in isolationbe analyzed in isolation

Helices can be dissected by Helices can be dissected by mapping onto helical wheelmapping onto helical wheel

http://bioinf.man.ac.uk/%7Egibson/HelixDraw/helixdraw.html

Examples of questions that can be Examples of questions that can be explored through structural explored through structural

analysesanalysesSome mutations have been associated with Some mutations have been associated with

prion diseases. By mapping these onto prion diseases. By mapping these onto structures, propose a hypothesis to structures, propose a hypothesis to explain this.explain this.

Most of the variation seems to be in the N-Most of the variation seems to be in the N-terminal region. Is there homology to this terminal region. Is there homology to this region in other proteins?region in other proteins?



II.II. Idea of conformational changeIdea of conformational change

III.III. Exploring sequences of prion proteinsExploring sequences of prion proteins


V.V. Linking evolution, structure Linking evolution, structure and function of prion proteinsand function of prion proteins

What does PrP do?

•GPI- anchored cell surface protein

•Knockout mice mostly normal

•Might be involved in some signaling cascades

•Interaction with hypothetical “protein x” might be needed for structural conversion

What makes prion a prion?What makes prion a prion?

Why don’t other proteins adopt two Why don’t other proteins adopt two drastically different stably folded drastically different stably folded conformations?conformations?

A helix is a helix…but why are helices in A helix is a helix…but why are helices in prion protein likely to undergo a big prion protein likely to undergo a big structural change?structural change?

How would you test/further explore these questions?

““Big picture”Big picture” questions as a questions as a platform for development of platform for development of

testable hypothesestestable hypotheses

Why would nature evolve prions?Why would nature evolve prions?

How would you tell a prion if you saw one?How would you tell a prion if you saw one?

Yeast prions do not cause a disease. Are Yeast prions do not cause a disease. Are there other non-harmful prion-like there other non-harmful prion-like proteins? Can prions be beneficial?proteins? Can prions be beneficial?

Documents

Prion biology problem space: Mad cows, itchy sheep and protein structure