12
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`:+ :+07=A >?-X>-16>8 088>D91-6: -: D6/+=8 6E =-:;>-81-, ,6D97+<+:8-6: 0:/ 6E +A+ D6.+D+:1 ,6:176= -: 7+0/-:; 0=-Z+ -8 6E 9071-0= D6/>=07-a01-6: ?+1T++: T67/ =+.+= 0:/ 8+:1+:,+ =+.+= 976,+88-:;2 1<01 1<+ 6>1,6D+ 6E T67/ 7+,6;:-1-6:B 0:/ 1<>8 1<+ -:9>1 16 8+:1+:,+ =+.+= ,6D97+<+:8-6:B -8 0 ,01+;67-0= 7+97+8+:101-6:O b+1 8>,< 0 9071-0= D6/>=07-a01-6: 1<76T8 0T0A 7+8-/>0= >:,+710-:1A 7+ ;07/-:; T67/ -/+:1-1A 1<01 D-;<1 961+:1-0==A ?+ 6E .0=>+ 16 1<+ ,6D97+<+:/+7 E>71<+7 /6T:817+0D -: 1<+ 8+:1+:,+O ]+7+ \ /+8,7-?+ 0 =-:+ 6E 7+8+07,< ,6D?-:-:; ,6D9>101-6:0= D6/+=-:; T-1< +W9+7-D+:10= +A+ 170,Z-:; T67Z 16 +W9=67+ 1<+ ,6:8+X>+:,+8 6E 7+D6.-:; 1<-8 9071-0= D6/>=07-1A 088>D91-6:O Q$R G cd ed f0 +:1+:,+ ,0: ,6:8-81 6E 0 6>: <708+ 8>?P+,1 E6==6T+/ ?A 0 +7? <708+g cd c f0 6>: <708+ ,0: ,6:8-81 6E 0 6>:g ed e cd f0 +7? <708+ ,0: ,6:8-81 6E 0 +7? E6==6T+/ ?A 0 6>: <708+ 6?P+,1g

Probabilistic Linguistic Expectations, Uncertain Input, and

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Probabilistic Linguistic Expectations, Uncertain Input, and

!"#$%&'

!"#$

!

%

"

$

#$

&'!()

!"#$%&' () *'+,-(.(/+ 012 3&-45%(6

&'

*+,+-.+/ /01+2 !"$"3##3!4

5677+896:/+:,+ ,6:,+7:-:; 1<-8 071-,=+ 8<6>=/ ?+ 0//7+88+/ 16 *6;+7 @+.AB C+9071D+:1 6E @-:;>-81-,8B F:-.+78-1A 6E 50=-E67:-0 01 G0:

C-+;6B %&H" I-=D0: C7-.+ JH#HKB @0 L6==0B 5M%!H%'3H#HKB FGMB 7=+.AN>,8/O+/>

!"#$%&'(#)%"

M8 A6> ?+;-: 7+0/-:; 1<-8 071-,=+B A6>7 +A+8 P>D9

709-/=A 0,7688 1<+ 90;+B 76>;<=A E6>7 1-D+8 0 8+,6:/

Q*0A:+7B $%%KB !HH% R O S>1B 7+0==AB T<A /6 A6>7 +A+8

D6.+ 01 0==U

V<-8 071-,=+ +W9=67+8 86D+ 6E 1<+ ,6:8+X>+:,+8 6E 1<+

-/+0 1<01 +A+ D6.+D+:18 -: 7+0/-:; ,0: ?+ ?+81 >:/+7"

8166/ 08 0: 0/091-.+ 7+896:8+ 16 1<+ E>:/0D+:10= 976?"

=+D 6E 0,1-6: -: 0: >:,+710-: +:.-76:D+:1 1<01 -8 968+/

?A 7+0/-:;O Y76D 1<-8 9+789+,1-.+B 1<+ ,6:,=>8-6: -8 -:"

+8,090?=+ 1<01 +A+ D6.+D+:18 -: 7+0/-:; 7+E=+,1 1<+

;60= 6E !"#$%&%&' %&(!)*$#%!& ()!* #+, #,-#O 56:8-/+72

?+E67+ 6:+ 7+0/8 0 ;-.+: 8+:1+:,+B 6:+ 9688+88+8

Z:6T=+/;+ -: 1<+ E0,+ 6E >:,+710-:1AO V<+ 0>1<67 D-;<1

<0.+ T7-11+: $&.#+%&'B ?>1 86D+ 8+:1+:,+8 07+ D67+

=-Z+=A 16 <0.+ ?++: T7-11+: 1<0: 61<+78O V<+ 8A81+D

;6.+7:-:; D6.+D+:1 6E 1<+ +A+8 97+8>D0?=A 0=86

%

Z:6T8

&

1<01 9+7,+91>0= -:9>1 -8 ,6:8170-:+/ 0:/ :6-8AO

V<+ 976,+88 6E 7+0/-:; -:.6=.+8 >8-:; 1<-8 :6-8A 9+7,+9"

1>0= -:9>1 -: ,6:P>:,1-6: T-1< 6:+#8 97-67 Z:6T=+/;+ 6E

6:+$8 =0:;>0;+ 0:/ 6:+$8 +:.-76:D+:1 -: 67/+7 16 E-;>7+

6>1 T<01 1<+ 0>1<67 T761+B 0:/ 16 -:E+7 D+0:-:; E76D

1<-8 T7-1-:;O S61< -:9>1 0:/ 97-67 Z:6T=+/;+ -:E67D /+"

,-8-6:8 0?6>1 T<+7+ 16 D6.+ 1<+ +A+8 :+W1[ 1<-8 -1+701-.+

976,+88 6E -:9>1 0,X>-8-1-6:B -:1+;701-6: T-1< 97-67

Z:6T=+/;+B /+,-8-6:"D0Z-:;B 0:/ 0,1-6: >:E6=/8 709-/=A

-: 7+0= 1-D+O V<-8 071-,=+ -8 0?6>1 -:1+;701-:; D+1<6/8

0:/ -/+08 E76D ,6D9>101-6:0= =-:;>-81-,8 0:/ 98A,<6=-:"

;>-81-,8 -: 67/+7 16 ;0-: -:8-;<1 -:16 1<-8 976,+88O

*$+,,+#)-+. /"%0.1&21

\: 9071-,>=07B -: 1<-8 071-,=+ \ E6,>8 <+0.-=A 6: 1<+

976E6>:/ 76=+ 9=0A+/ ?A ')$**$#%/$0 1&!20,3', -: 1<+

7+0="1-D+ >:/+7810:/-:; 6E T7-11+: =0:;>0;+O \1 -8 +08A

16 /+D6:81701+ <6T 96T+7E>= ;70DD01-,0= Z:6T=+/;+

,0: ?+2 P>81 7+E=+,1 6: 1<+ E0,1 1<01 1<+ 8+:1+:,+ 3!'

"%#,4 *$& /+8,7-?+8 0: +.+7A/0A +.+:1B T<+7+08 *$&

"%#,4 3!' -8 :+T8T671<AO V<+ E-+=/ 6E ;+:+701-.+ 8A:10W

;-.+8 >8 E67D0= 166=8 E67 +W97+88-:; 1<-8 Z:6T=+/;+[ 6:+

9071-,>=07=A >8+E>= A+1 8-D9=+ 166= -8 1<+ /!&#,-#"(),,

')$**$) Q5YI[ 5<6D8ZAB $%&([ I-:8?>7;B $%(([ ]69,76E1

^ F==D0:B $%4%RB T<-,< ,6:8-818 6E 7+T7-1+ 7>=+8 8>,< 08

QE67 _:;=-8<R2

3$%4+4).)5#)- 6)"2')5#)- 7891-#+#)%"5: ;"-1$#+)" !"9'#: +"& !,9.)-+#)%"5 <%$ 7=1

>%?1,1"#5 )" @1+&)"2

*6;+7 @+.A

Q5&%6,)4%#. !( 7$0%(!)&%$8 9$& :%,'!R

`:+ :+07=A >?-X>-16>8 088>D91-6: -: D6/+=8 6E =-:;>-81-, ,6D97+<+:8-6: 0:/ 6E +A+ D6.+D+:1 ,6:176= -: 7+0/-:; 0=-Z+ -8 6E 9071-0=

D6/>=07-a01-6: ?+1T++: T67/"=+.+= 0:/ 8+:1+:,+"=+.+= 976,+88-:;2 1<01 1<+ 6>1,6D+ 6E T67/ 7+,6;:-1-6:B 0:/ 1<>8 1<+ -:9>1 16

8+:1+:,+"=+.+= ,6D97+<+:8-6:B -8 0 ,01+;67-0= 7+97+8+:101-6:O b+1 8>,< 0 9071-0= D6/>=07-a01-6: 1<76T8 0T0A 7+8-/>0= >:,+710-:1A 7+"

;07/-:; T67/ -/+:1-1A 1<01 D-;<1 961+:1-0==A ?+ 6E .0=>+ 16 1<+ ,6D97+<+:/+7 E>71<+7 /6T:817+0D -: 1<+ 8+:1+:,+O ]+7+ \ /+8,7-?+ 0

=-:+ 6E 7+8+07,< ,6D?-:-:; ,6D9>101-6:0= D6/+=-:; T-1< +W9+7-D+:10= +A+"170,Z-:; T67Z 16 +W9=67+ 1<+ ,6:8+X>+:,+8 6E 7+D6.-:; 1<-8

9071-0= D6/>=07-1A 088>D91-6:O

Q$R G ! cd ed f0 +:1+:,+ ,0: ,6:8-81 6E 0 6>: <708+ 8>?P+,1 E6==6T+/ ?A 0 +7? <708+g

cd ! c f0 6>: <708+ ,0: ,6:8-81 6E 0 6>:g

ed ! e cd f0 +7? <708+ ,0: ,6:8-81 6E 0 +7? E6==6T+/ ?A 0 6>: <708+ 6?P+,1g

Page 2: Probabilistic Linguistic Expectations, Uncertain Input, and

!"#$%&'

(

!

)

"#$%&'%!()&& *)+,,+)- *&$&)+%& %)&&!-%)./%.)&0 0&!

-/)12%1#$- #( %3& -4$%+/%1/ (#), #( -&$%&$/&-5 +$0 1,!

2#)%+$% +-2&/%- #( %3& ,&+$1$* #( %3& -&$%&$/&

!

-./3

+-5 1$ %31- /+-&5 63# 010 %3& 71%1$* +$0 63# *#%

71%%&$

!

/+$ 7& )&+0 #(( %3&-& 0&-/)12%1#$-8

9:;

<.)%3&),#)&5 -&&,1$*=4 =+)*& /)#--!=1$*.1-%1/ 01((&)!

&$/&- 1$ %3& *)+,,+%1/+= 2)#2&)%1&- #( =+$*.+*&- /+$

#(%&$ 7& &=&*+$%=4 /+2%.)&0 74 -,+== 01((&)&$/&- 1$ %3&

"<> 0&-/)12%1#$ #( %3& =+$*.+*&? <#) &'+,2=&5 1$ 7#%3

@$*=1-3 +$0 "31$&-& 6#)0 #)0&) 2=+4- + )&=+%1A&=4 =+)*&

)#=& 1$ &$/#01$* %3& *)+,,+%1/+= (.$/%1#$- 2=+4&0 74

&+/3 6#)0 1$ + -&$%&$/&B 4&% /#$-10&) %3& -4-%&,+%1/ 01(!

(&)&$/&- 1$ 6#)0 #)0&) 1$ %3& %6# -&$%&$/& 2+1)- 7&=#68

C( 6& %31$D #( -&$%&$/&- +- )+6 -&E.&$/&- #( 6#)0-5

%3& -4-%&,+%1/1%4 #( %3& 01((&)&$/&- 7&%6&&$ %3&-& @$*!

=1-3 +$0 "31$&-& &'+,2=&- 1-$"% #7A1#.- +% +==5 -1$/& $#

6#)0- +)& -3+)&0 7&%6&&$ &'+,2=&- 9F; +$0 9G;? H.% 1(

6& %31$D #( -&$%&$/&- +- -%)./%.)&0 *)+,,+%1/+= )&2)&!

-&$%+%1#$-5 %3& -4-%&,+%1/1%4 7&/#,&- #A&)63&=,1$*8

63&)&+- 1$ @$*=1-35 A&)7!,#01(41$* !)&2#-1%1#$+= !3)+-!

&- (#==#6 %3& A&)75 1$ "31$&-& %3&4 2)&/&0& %3& A&)7?

I

J3& 23)+-& -%)./%.)& ).=& -&%- 7&=#6 /+2%.)& %31- 01(!

(&)&$/& -.//1$/%=4

"

J3& (1)-% %3)&& ).=&- 1$ &+/3 =+$*.+*& -3#.=0 7& (+!

,1=1+) ()#, 9I; +7#A&5 +$0 +)& %3& -+,& 1$ 7#%3 =+$!

*.+*&-? J3& (#.)%3 ).=& 1- +=-# %3& -+,& 1$ 7#%3 =+$!

*.+*&-5 +$0 -%+%&- %3+% + A&)7 23)+-& /+$ /#$-1-% #(

#$=4 + A&)7? J3& (1(%3 ).=& 1- %3& #$=4 #$& %3+% 1- 01(!

(&)&$% 7&%6&&$ %3& %6# =+$*.+*&-8 1$ @$*=1-35 1% -%+%&-

%3+% + A&)7 23)+-& /+$ 9)&/.)-1A&=4; /#$-1-% #( + A&)7

23)+-& (#==#6&0 74 + )&2#-1%1#$+= 23)+-&5 63&)&+- 1$

"31$&-&5 1% -%+%&- %3+% + A&)7 23)+-& /+$ 9 )&/.)-1A&=4;

/#$-1-% #( + 2)&2#-1%1#$+= 23)+-& (#==#6&0 74 + A&)7

23)+-&? J3&-& "<>- *1A& )1-& %# %3& (#==#61$* -%)./%.)+=

0&-/)12%1#$- #( 9F; +$0 9G;8

9K; +?

7?

/?

0?

I? J31- 2#1$% 1*$#)&- + /&)%+1$ 0&*)&& #( /#$%)#A&)-4 )&*+)01$* 63&%3&) &'+,2=&- =1D& !"# $%"&'%& +)& 7&-% +$+=4L&0 +- 2)&2#-1%1#$+= 23)+-&- #)

+- -#,&%31$* ,#)& =1D& -&)+=!A&)7 /#$-%).%1#$-5 631/3 1- $#% 2&)%1$&$% %# %3& *#+=- #( %31- +)%1/=&?

M

NO PO

N PO OO

$()* N O O NO

)+,-)..)/ N 01 N

)&023.#4.5 5)

M M

NO PO NO PO

N P NO N P NO

54& 6%0). N /17 6%0). N

/18 54&

9F; +? C =&/%.)&0 1$ J1+$Q1$?

7?

* + ,- ./

C 1$ J1+$Q1$ =&/%.)&

9G; +? J3&4 &'2)&--&0 &$%3.-1+-, %# ,&?

7?

01 2 * 34 56

J3&4 %# ,& &'2)&-- &$%3.-1+-,

#

R

$

@$*=1-3 "31$&-&

M ! NO PO M ! NO PO

NO ! N NO ! N

PO ! P NO PO ! P NO

PO ! P PO ! P

PO ! PO OO PO ! OO P

M

NO PO

N PO OO

9 P O NO

:);03-)/ %& N

$%4&'%&

M

NO PO

N OO PO

*

O NO P

+

N

7/

,-

M

NO PO

N OO OO

01

O NO P NO

2

N

84

N

* 56

RG

Page 3: Probabilistic Linguistic Expectations, Uncertain Input, and

!

!

"

!"#$%&%"'()*'+, -('*."()*'+, ("/ 0$(&&($

"#$ %& '($ %)'*'+#,-#./0 -#'$1$*'-#. 21%2$1'-$* %&

1$+/!'-3$ *$#'$#4$ 4%321$($#*-%# '(+' 3)*' 5$ -#4/),$,

-# +#0 *$1-%)* 3%,$/ %& $0$!3%6$3$#' 4%#'1%/ -# 1$+,!

-#. -* '($ !"#$%&%"'()!'* %& *$#'$#4$ 4%321$($#*-%#7

8(-* 21%2$1'0 $**$#'-+//0 *'+'$* '(+' ()3+#* ,%#"' 9+-'

)#'-/ + *$#'$#4$ -* 4%32/$'$ '% ,1+9 -#&$1$#4$* +5%)'

9(+' -' 3-.(' 3$+#: %1 $6$# (%9 -' 3-.(' 4%#'-#)$7 ;#

%)'*'+#,-#. ,$3%#*'1+'-%# %& '(-* 4%3$* &1%3 +#%'($1

3$'(%,%/%.0 -# 9(-4( $0$ 3%6$3$#'* +1$ 3%#-'%1$, +*

+ 9-#,%9 -#'% /+#.)+.$ 4%321$($#*-%#< '($ +!,-() ./$)0

1($(0!2&7 ;* + 2+1'-4)/+1/0 4/$+1 $=+32/$ &1%3 ;/'3+##

+#, >+3-,$ ?!@@@A : *)22%*$ '(+' '($ 4%321$($#,$1 -*

21$*$#'$, 9-'( + 6-*)+/ ,-*2/+0 -#4/),-#. + 5%0B + 3%6!

+5/$: $,-5/$ %5C$4' ?*)4( +* + 4+D$EB +#, + #)35$1 %&

3%6+5/$: -#$,-5/$ %5C$4'* ?*)4( +* + 5+// +#, + '%0 4+1E7

F& '($ 4%321$($#,$1 ($+1* '($ *$#'$#4$ %#*$' 34% 5/*

.!)) !"#777: 9($# '($0 ($+1 '($ 6$15 %(' '($0 -#-'-+'$ ,-&!

&$1$#'-+//0 3%1$ $0$ 3%6$3$#'* '% '($ $,-5/$ %5C$4' %#

'($ ,-*2/+0 '(+# -# +# +/'$1#+'-6$ 6+1-+#' 9-'( + /$** 1$!

*'1-4'-6$ 6$15 34% 5/* .!)) $%&!7777 8(-* +#, 1$/+'$,

&-#,-#.* ?8+#$#(+)*: G2-6$0!>#%9/'%#: H5$1(+1,: I G$!

,-60: !@@JB >+3-,$: ;/'3+##: I K+09%%,: LMMNE

,$3%#*'1+'$ -#41$3$#'+/-'0< 1+2-, +44$** '% ,$'+-/$,

*0#'+4'-4 +#, *$3+#'-4 21%2$1'-$* %& '($ 9%1,* $#4%)#!

'$1$, '()* &+17 O)1'($13%1$: 4%321$($#,$1* .$#$1+//0

)*$ '(-* -#&%13+'-%# -# '($

!

1-.(' 9+0

"

< '($ 9%1, %(': &%1

$=+32/$: -* )*$, '% #+11%9 ,%9# '($ *$' %& 2%**-5/$ )2!

4%3-#. 1$&$1$#'* '% '(%*$ -# '($ $#6-1%#3$#' 9(-4( +1$

$,-5/$7 F 9-// 4+// '(-* /+''$1 21%2$1'0 '($ $('!/"() )*$ %&

-#&%13+'-%# -# %#/-#$ /+#.)+.$ 4%321$($#*-%#7

K%9 ,% -#41$3$#'+/-'0 +#, 1+'-%#+/-'0 -#'$1+4' 9-'(

'($ ,$2/%03$#' %& .1+33+'-4+/ D#%9/$,.$ -# %#/-#$

4%321$($#*-%#P Q($# 4%#*-,$1-#. '(-* 21%5/$3: -' -*

-32%1'+#' '% #%'$ '(+' -# +#0 /+#.)+.$: 3%*' *$#'$#4$*

+1$ +&&%1,$, 3%1$ '(+# %#$ 2%**-5/$ -#'$121$'+'-%# 50

'($ .1+33+17 O%1 $=+32/$: '($ R(-#$*$ *$#'$#4$ -#

?S5E 5$/%9 (+* '9% -#'$121$'+'-%#*: ,$2$#,-#. %# 9(%"*

4%#*-,$1$, '% 5$ -# ;3$1-4+7

L

? 8(-* +35-.)-'0 -* 21$!

*$16$, -# '($ H#./-*( '1+#*/+'-%#7E

Q($# '($ 1)/$* .-6$# -# ?TE 5$/%9 +1$ +,,$, '% %)1

R(-#$*$ .1+33+1 &1+.3$#': -' .-6$* 1-*$ '% '($ '9%

*'1)4')1+/ ,$*41-2'-%#* *$$# -# ?@E7 F# '($ /$&'!(+#, ,$!

*41-2'-%#: -' -* '($ 21%&$**%1 9(% -* -# ;3$1-4+: +* 4+#

5$ *$$# &1%3 '($ &+4' '(+' '($1$ -* +# UV #%,$ ,%3-#+'!

-#. '($ *)5*'1-#.

# $% & '(

?!" 6&%$!#( 78 1$/!

9%,,/$EB -# '($ 1-.('!(+#, ,$*41-2'-%#: -' -* '($ ,+).('$1

9(% -* -# ;3$1-4+7

L7 8($ R(-#$*$ .1+33+'-4+/ 3%12($3$

&

: ./%**$, ($1$ +* WH ?-'* V-#0-# &%13 -* 0%E: 3+1D* +// '02$* %& #%3-#+/ 21$3%,-&-$1*7 F# H=+32/$

?S5E: -'* &-1*' -#*'+#4$ -* $&&$4'-6$/0 *$3+#'-4+//0 $32'0$32'0B -'* *$4%#, -#*'+#4$ 4+11-$* '($ 3$+#-#. %& 2%**$**-%# +#, '()* -* '1+#*/+'$, +*

H#./-*( /97

?XE

# )% & '( & *+ ,- ./

-# ;3$1-4+ WH 21%&$**%1 WH ,+).('$1 (+* *'),-$, Y+#,+1-#

Z8($,+).('$1 %& '($21%&$**%1 -#;3$1-4+(+* *'),-$,Y+#,+1-#7Z

[TE UV ! W$V UV \+# UV 4+# 1$4)1*-6$/0 4%#*-*' %& + 21$3%,-&0-#. 1$]2(1+*$ &%//%9$, 50 +# UV^

W$V ! _V W$ \+ W$V 4+# 4%#*-*' %& + _V &%//%9$, 50 '($ 9%1,

&

#

,$

$

^

W$V ! UV W$ \+ W$V 4+# 4%#*-*' %& +# UV &%//%9$, 50 '($ 9%1,

&

%

,$

&

^

[@A G G

UV _V UV _V

W$V U _ UV W$V UV _ UV

UV W$

*+ ,0

U _V W$ W$V U

,0

U

W$V U

& ./

_ UV

&

UV W$

*+ ./

_V W$

'( #

U U

&

_ UV

& )% '(

#

U

)%

JJ

Page 4: Probabilistic Linguistic Expectations, Uncertain Input, and

!"#$%&'

(

!

)

"#$%&'(% )* $%)+ ,-.$)/'#-. +0*$0*/01 &*0 /-* 2-30

$%0 /-+0 $%-$ $%0.0 )+ *& +$.&*( ,.040.0*/0 4&. &*0 )*!

$0.,.0$-$)&* &50. $%0 &$%0.1 '+'-##6 $%0.0 -.0 ,.040.!

0*/0+ 7%)/% -.0 .0#-$)50#6 /&*+)+$0*$ -/.&++ *-$)50

+,0-30.+8 9&. 0:-2,#01 ;&$% <*(#)+% +0*$0*/0+ )* =>?@ ;0!

#&7 )*5&#50 -* -2;)(')$6 -+ $& 7%-$ $%0 ,.0,&+)$)&*-#

,%.-+0 !" #$% &%'($ 2&A)4)0+8 B&+$ *-$)50 +,0-30.+ ,.040.

-* )*$0.,.0$-$)&* &4 =>?-C )* 7%)/% )$ 2&A)4)0+ )*+(,++%)1

;'$ -* )*$0.,.0$-$)&* &4 =>?;C )* 7%)/% )$ 2&A)4)0+ )!-+

=9&.A1 D.0+*-*1 E F-,#-*1 >!GHI J'.-4+361 >!!K@8

L0 2)(%$ $%'+ 0:,0/$ -* )*/.020*$-#1 .-$)&*-# +6+!

$02 4&. +0*$0*/0 /&2,.0%0*+)&* $& 4&.2 -*A ',A-$0

,.040.0*/0+ -;&'$ $%0+0 (.-22-$)/-# )*$0.,.0$-$)&*+ ;&$%

.-,)A#6 -*A )* - 2-**0. /&*+)+$0*$ 7)$% $%0 )*4&.2-$)&*

+&'./0+ -5-)#-;#0 )* $%0 +0*$0*/0 $%'+ 4-.!)*/#'A)*( #0:!

)/-#1 +6*$-/$)/1 +02-*$)/1 -*A 050* ,.-(2-$)/ )*4&.2-!

$)&* +&'./0+8 M-.-A&:)/-##61 &*0 &4 $%0 +)A0 0440/$+ &4

$%)+ $6,0 &4 )*/.020*$-# ,.040.0*/0 ',A-$0 )+ $%-$ /0.!

$-)* $6,0+ &4 +0*$0*/0+ /-* $02,&.-.)#6 .*+/%') $%0

/&2,.0%0*A0.1 7%0* $%0 2-$0.)-# 0-.#6 &* )* - +0*!

$0*/0 ()50+ .)+0 $& - +$.&*( ,.040.0*/0 4&. - (.-22-$)!

/-# )*$0.,.0$-$)&* $%-$ '#$)2-$0#6 $'.*+ &'$ $& ;0 )*/&.!

.0/$8 N&*+)A0. $%0 0:-2,#0+ )* =>>C ;0#&7O

L%0* .0-A)*( $%0+0 +0*$0*/0+1 *-$)50 +,0-30.+ &4

N%)*0+0 -*A <*(#)+% $6,)/-##6 0:,0.)0*/0 /&*4'+)&* -$

$%0 7&.A+

*+

=

!

/&'*$.6

"

C -*A #$% .0+,0/$)50#68 P%)+

/&*4'+)&* .04#0/$+ $%0 -;)#)$6 &4 $%0 ,.0/0A)*( 7&.A+1

,

-

=

!

#0-A

"

&.

!

#0-A0.

"

C -*A 0/'11 $& 4'*/$)&* 0)$%0. -+

*&'*+ &. -+ 50.;+8 P%0 /&*$0:$ ;)-+0+ $%0 /&2,.0%0*A0.

$&7-.A - *&2)*-# )*$0.,.0$-$)&* &4 $%0+0 7&.A+

#

2&.0

,.0/)+0#61 -+ $%0 %0-A *&'* &4 $%0 +0*$0*$)-# +';Q0/$

;'$ $%0 (.-22-.+ &4 N%)*0+0 -*A <*(#)+% -#+& -##&7

&2)++)&* &4 $%0 %0-A *&'* &4 -* RM1 -*A $%)+ &2)$$0A

5-.)-*$ $'.*+ &'$ $& ;0 $%0 (#&;-##6 /&..0/$ )*$0.,.0$-!

$)&*1 7)$% )*$0*A0A 20-*)*(+ -,,.&:)2-$0#6 $%0 +-20 -+

$%&+0 +00* )* =>HC ;0#&7O

P%)+ 0-.#6 2)+)*$0.,.0$-$)&* )+ 3*&7* -+ - S"TU<R!

M"PV 0440/$8 W$+ +)(*-$'.0 &* 060 2&5020*$+ )* .0-A!

)*( )+ 0#05-$)&* &4 4).+$!,-++ .0-A)*( $)20+ -*A 4).+$!,-++

.0(.0++)&* ,.&;-;)#)$61 -*A %-+ ;00* 3*&7* +)*/0 9.-!

X)0. -*A T-6*0. =>!GHC8 " A0+).-;#0 (&-# 4&. A00,0*)*(

&'. '*A0.+$-*A)*( &4 060 2&5020*$+ )* .0-A)*( 7&'#A

$%'+ ;0 $& )*$0(.-$0 )*$& 2&A0#+ &4 060 2&5020*$ /&*!

$.&# 2&A0#+ &4 $%)+ )*/.020*$-# ,.&/0++ &4 ,.040.0*/0

4&.2-$)&* -*A ',A-$0 4&. (.-22-$)/-# )*$0.,.0$-$)&*8

P%0 #0-A)*( /-*A)A-$0 /#-++ &4 +'/% 2&A0#+ )+ $%0 4-2!

)#6 &4 MTYD"DWZW[PWN ST"BB"T[ 4.&2 $%0 4)0#A &4

/&2,'$-$)&*-# #)*(')+$)/+8 M0.%-,+ $%0 2&+$ 7)A0#6 '+0A

202;0. &4 $%)+ 4-2)#6 )+ $%0 MTYD"DWZW[PWN

NYRP<\P!9T<< ST"BB"T =MN9SI D&&$%1 >!K!I J'!

.-4+36 E B-.$)*1 H??GI B-**)*( E [/%"$X01 >!!!C 8 "

MN9S )+ 0:-/$#6 #)30 $%0 N9S+ +00* 0-.#)0. )* [0/$)&*

H1 0:/0,$ $%-$ 0-/% .07.)$0 .'#0 /&20+ 7)$% -

,.&;-;)#)$6

#

- .0-# *'2;0. ;0$700* X0.& -*A > 7%&+0

)*$0.,.0$-$)&* )+ $%0 #)30#)%&&A 7)$% 7%)/% $%0 /-$0(&.6

&* $%0 #04$!%-*A +)A0 7)## .07.)$0 -+ $%0 +0]'0*/0 &4

/-$0(&.)0+ &* $%0 .)(%$!%-*A +)A08 W4 $%0 ,.&;-;)#)$6 &4 -

50.; ,%.-+0 /&*+)+$)*( &4 - 50.; -*A - *&'* ,%.-+0 )+

?8^1 4&. 0:-2,#01 )$ 7&'#A ;0 7.)$$0* -+ M_`M!` RMCa

?8^1 &. 0]')5-#0*$#6 M=` RMb`MCa ?8^8 P%)+ #-$$0. 4&.2'!

#-$)&* +$-$0+ 0:,#)/)$#6 $%-$ $%0 (!")*#*!"'/ 02!&'&*/*#1 &4

$%0 /-$0(&.6 +0]'0*/0 ` RM -*3%" $%0 ,.0+0*/0 &4 -

`M )+ ?8^

#

$%)+ ,.&;-;)#)$6 &*#6 2-$$0.+ )4 - `M %-+

-#.0-A6 ;00* (0*0.-$0A ;6 +&20 &$%0. .'#0 )* $%0

(.-22-.8 W* - MN9S1 .'#0 ,.&;-;)#)$)0+ -.0 /&*+$.-)*0A

+'/% $%-$ $%0 ,.&;-;)#)$)0+ &4 -## .'#0+ 7)$% $%0 +-20

/-$0(&.6 &* $%0 #04$!%-*A +)A0 +%&'#A +'2 $& >8 9&. 0:!

-2,#01 =>cC ;0#&7 ()50+ - MN9S 4.-(20*$ &4 N%)*0+0

(.-22-. )*/&.,&.-$)*( -## $%0 .'#0+ 70 %-50 +00* $%'+

4-.8 =W* .0-#)$61 - (.-22-. /&50.)*( - #-.(0 4.-(20*$ &4

- #-*('-(0 7&'#A /&*$-)* $0*+ &4 $%&'+-*A+ &4 .'#0+1 *&$

$%0 %-*A4'# +00* )* -* 0:-2,#0 +'/% -+ $%)+8C

" MN9S A04)*0+ - MTYD"DWZWPd UW[PTWDePWYR

&50. $.00!+$.'/$'.0A A0+/.),$)&*+ &4 +0*$0*/0+O $%0 ,.&;!

-;)#)$6 &4 - $.00 )+ $%0 ,.&A'/$ &4 $%0 ,.&;-;)#)$)0+ &4

$

>?

%

-8 P%0 7&20* A)+/'++0A $%0 A&(+ &* $%0 ;0-/%8

;8 P%0 7&20* 30,$ $%0 A&(+ &* $%0 ;0-/%8

=>>C -8

. /0 1 ,- *+ 23

&

2&+$ /-,-;#0 U< #0-A /&'*$.6 -A5-*/08

'

P%0 2&+$ /-,-;#0 #0-A $%0 /&'*$.6 4&.7-.A8

(

;8 P%0 0:/0##0*$ ,#-6 $%0 4&&# .-.0#68

=>HC -8

. /4 1 5 ,- 6+ 23

&

2&+$ /-,-;#0 U< #0-A /&'*$.6 -A5-*/08

'

P%02&+$ /-,-;#0 ,0&,#0 #0-A $%0 /&'*$.6 4&.7-.A8

(

;8 P%0 0:/0##0*$

!

,#-6 $%0 4&&# .-.0#68

fK

Page 5: Probabilistic Linguistic Expectations, Uncertain Input, and

!

!

"

"#$ %&'$( &($) "* )$%+,$ "-$ "%$$. /0123'$ 4!56 )$3+7"( "-$

8-+9$($ "%$$ +9 :;<= > )$?*%@"$) A+"- "-$ 3%*<@<+'+"+$( *B

$@?- (&C"%$$ @( (3$7+B+$) CD "-$ E%@22@% +9 :FG6> @( A$''

@( "-$ "*"@' 3%*<@<+'+"D *B "-+( 3@%"+7&'@% "%$$H

:!56

I :J%$$6 K!.L!L.M!L.N!LHO!!HL!!HL!LHM!LHN!LHP!!HLQLHL!!LRN

S*% 1 E+,$9 I8ST> "-$ IUVWXYZ[ZJ\ V] ^

_JUZ`T +( "-$ (&2 *B "-$ 3%*<1<+'+"+$( *B 1'' "-$ "%$$(

E$9$%1"+9E "-1" ("%+9Ea 19) "-$ IUVYXYZ[ZJ\ VS X

_JUZ`T IUbSZc +( "-$ (&2 *B "-$ 3%*<1<+'+"+$( *B 1''

"-$ "%$$( E$9$%1"+9E 1 ("%+9E ("1%"+9E A+"- "-1" 3%$B+0H

^77*%)+9E "* 1 9&2<$% *B 2*)$'( *B *9'+9$ ($9"$97$

7*23%$-$9(+*9> +97%$2$9"1' 19) %1"+*91' 7*23%$-$9(+*9

*B 1 ($9"$97$ +9,*',$( 7*23&"+9E :*% 133%*0+21"+9E= "-$

3%*<1<+'+"D )+("%+<&"+*9 *,$% "%$$( E+,$9 1 3%*<1<+'+("+7

E%1221% 19) "-$ A*%)( +9 1 ($9"$97$ "-&( B1%

:d%*7e$% f W%19"(> ghLLi j1'$> ghhF> ghhO> ghh;i k&"

%1B(eD> Fll;i [$,D> ghhm1i `1%1D1919 f k&%1B(eD>

Fllm> ghhgi U*1%e> ghhF=H n-1" +( 1 E1%)$9"31"- $BB$7"

+9 (&7- 1 2*)$'o X9 19(A$% "* "-+( p&$("+*9 719 <$

B*&9) <D 7*9(+)$%+9E "-1" "-$ 9&2<$% *B 3*((+<'$

E%1221"+71' 191'D($( *B 1 E+,$9 ($9"$97$ E%*A( $03*"

9$9"+1''D 1( ($9"$97$ '$9E"- +97%$1($( :8-&%7- f I1"+'>

Flmg=H X'"-*&E- "-$%$ 1%$ 1'E*%+"-2( "-1" 1''*A "-+( $0"

3*9$9"+1''D +97%$1(+9E ($" *B 191'D($( "* <$ 7*23&"$)

$BB+7+$9"'D"+9 "+2$ +97%$1(+9E !"#$!%&&' A+"- ($9"$97$

'$9E"- :b1%'$D> FlMh=

!

"-+( +( 9*" (&BB+7+$9" "* $03'1+9

"-$ (3$$) *B -&219 ($9"$97$ 7*23%$-$9(+*9> 1( "-$

"+2$ A$ (3$9) *9 7*23%$-$9)+9E 1 ($9"$97$ +( $(($9"

"+1''D &$()%* +9 +"( '$9E"-H Z9 1'' %$1'+("+7 2*)$'( *B

($9"$97$ 7*23%$-$9(+*9> "-$9> 1""$9"+*9 +( %$("%+7"$) "*

(*2$ (&<($" *B "-$ '*E+71''D 3*((+<'$ 191'D($(H V9$ A1D

*B )*+9E (* A+"-+9 1 3%*<1<+'+("+7 B%12$A*%e +( "* )+("

71%) 3*((+<'$ 191'D($( "-1" -1,$ '*A 3%*<1<+'+"DH J-+(

719 <$ )*9$ $+"-$% )$"$%2+9+("+71''D :8%*7e$% f Y%19"(>

ghhhi k&%1B(eD> Fll;i `1%1D1919 f k&%1B(eD> Fllmi

U*1%e> ghhF= *% +" 719 <$ )*9$ ("*7-1("+71''D : [$,D>

U$1'+> f T%+BB+"-(> ghhl=H X9 $0123'$ *B -*A <*"- E1%"

)$931"- %$7*,$%D 19) E1%)$9"31"- B1+'&%$ 719 "1e$

3'17$ B*% 1 '*71''D 12<+E&*&( ($9"$97$ +( (-*A9 +9

S+E&%$ F> A-+7- (-*A( "-$ $,*',+9E 3%*<1<+'+"+$( *B "A*

1'"$%91"$ 191'D($( *B $17- A*%)> 1( A$'' 1( "-$ 3%*<1"

<+'+"D *B (&77$((B&''D B+9)+9E +,-) 191'D(+( "-%*&E-

$17- A*%) *B "-$ ($9"$97$ :<*""*2 %*A=> &(+9E 1 E%12"

21% '$1%9$) B%*2 "-$ 31%($) Y%*A9 7*%3&( *B b9E'+(-

7 f S%197+(> Fl;Mi q1%7&(> _19"*%+9+> f q1%7+9e+$A+7r>

Fsl5=H X" "-$ A*%) .&%'> B*% $0123'$> "-$ 31%($% "D3+"

71''D )$,*"$( 2*(" *B +"( %$(*&%7$( "* "-$ E1%)$9"31"-

191'D(+( :"-$ "*3 "%$$=> 19) "-&( B1+'( "* B+9) 19D 191'D"

(+( 1" "-$ 9$0" A*%)> /0)> 1'2*(" -1'B "-$ "+2$H `*"$ "-1"

"-$ E1%)$9"31"- 191'D(+( 719 +9 B17" <$ (1,$) 1" "-$

A*%) /0) <D -D3*"-$(+r+9E 1 %$'1"+,$ 7'1&($> 1( +9 "-$

3*((+<'$ 7*9"+9&1"+*9 10) )2!)&&)(/ .&%' /0) %"/0,*

3*,/) 3%+ ()4)* .)*5,*-)6H J-+( 3*((+<'$ 7*9"+9&1"+*9

177*&9"( B*% "-$ B17" "-1" "-$ "%&$ 3*("$%+*% 3%*<1<+'+"D

*B "-$ E1%)$9"31"- 191'D(+( %$21+9( 7*9(+)$%1<'$ 1B"$%

"-+( 3*+9"> 19) B*% "-$ B17" "-1" "%&$ 7*23%$-$9(+*9 B1+'"

&%$ 719 -133$9 '1"$% "-19 "-$ B+%(" 3*+9" *B E1%)$931"-

)+(12<+E&1"+*9t (*2$"+2$( 1" *%*)&' 19) p&+"$ *B"$9 1"

"-$ $9) *B "-$ ($9"$97$H J-+( E%1)&1'9$(( *B E1%)$9"31"-

)+(12<+E&1"+*9 +( 1 3%*3$%"D 2*%$ )+BB+7&'" "* *<"1+9 +9

($%+1' 19) )$"$%2+9+("+7 '+2+"$)"31%1''$' 2*)$'(H

!"#$%&%"'() *$+,(,-)-.'-/ -"0%$%"/% ("1

%2% &+3%&%"'.

j*A )*$( "-+( 3%*7$(( *B +97%$2$9"1' 3%*<1<+'+("+7

E%1221"+71' +9B$%$97$ %$'1"$ "* "-$ $D$ 2*,$2$9" 31""

"$%9( ($$9 +9 %$1)+9Eu Z9 1))+"+*9 "* "-$ $BB$7"( *B

E1%)$9"31"- )+(12<+E&1"+*9 v&(" )$(7%+<$)> 19*"-$% 7%&"

7+1' 3-$9*2$9*9 +9 3%*<1<+'+("+7 +9B$%$97$ +( .*)6$!/$,(

*B &37*2+9E A*%)( 19) (D9"17"+7 $,$9"(H Z" -1( <$$9

e9*A9 (+97$ b-%'+7- 19) U1D9$% : FswF= "-1" -+E-'D

"

FO

#

U&'$ I%*<1<+'+"D U&'$ I%*<1<+'+"D

_ !`I xI FHh y$ !

#

FHh

`I !` hHM xI!x hHO

` !

$

hHN x !

%&

FHh

` !

'(

hHN xI!x `I hHz

`I !y$I `I hHG xI!II xI hHG

y$I !xI y$ hHN II !I `I FHh

y$I !`I y$ hHN I !

)

FHh

_

`I xI

` II xI

$

I `I x

)

`

%&

'(

FHh

hHG

hHG

FHh

FHh

FHh

hHN

hHN

hHM

hHM

NM

Page 6: Probabilistic Linguistic Expectations, Uncertain Input, and

!"#$%&'

(

!

)

"#$%&'()*+, -.#%/ )#$ /0&""$% 1.#$ .2(,3 435 2&64(,5

.3 1.#, *#&,2+7 (843 +,// "#,5&9(4*+, -.#5/: ;3 9.1"<!

(4(&.34+ "/798.+&3=<&/(&9/> .3, -,++!03.-3 2.#14+&?4(&.3

.2 (8&/ &5,4 84/ *,,3 (8, "#."./4+ .2 @ABCBD@EF 4/ 4

+&30&3= 2<39(&.3 *,(-,,3 "#.*4*&+&(7 435 (8, 41.<3( .2

(&1, #,G<&#,5 (. "#.9,// 4 -.#5 &3 &(/ 9.3(,6( HI4+,>

JKKLM N,O7> JKKP)Q : @<#"#&/4+ &/ 5,2&3,5 4/ (8, 3,=4(&O,

+.= .2 (8, 9.35&(&.34+ "#.*4*&+&(7 .2 4 -.#5 !" &3 &(/

9.3(,6(R

#+.= $

!

"

!!

L>

!

>"SL

! "

>TUVWXYWQ

Z,39, /<#"#&/4+ #43=,/ 2#.1 ?,#. H 43 .*+&=4(.#7

,O,3(> "#.*4*&+&(7 LQ (. &32&3&(7 H 43 &1".//&*+, ,O,3(>

"#.*4*&+&(7 ?,#.Q: W. ,/(&14(, (8, /<#"#&/4+ .2 4 -.#5 &3

&(/ 9.3(,6(> .3, 943 </, 1,(8.5/ 2#.1 9.1"<(4(&.34+

+&3=<&/(&9/ HT8,3 [ \..5143> L]]PM ^,+&3,0 [ N422,#(7>

L]]LM @(.+90,> L]]_Q .# (8, 1.#, (#45&(&.34+ T+.?, /,3!

(,39, 9.1"+,(&.3 1,(8.5 HW47+.#> L]_`Q : ;( &/ 4 /<*!

/(43(&O, 9+4&1 (84( (8,#, &/ 4 +&3,4# #,+4(&.3/8&" *,!

(-,,3 /<#"#&/4+ 435 #,45&3= (&1,/> -8&98 943 *, 5,!

#&O,5 2#.1 4 3<1*,# .2 ".//&*+, 9.3/&5,#4(&.3/ .2 ."(&!

14+&(7 &3 (8, +43=<4=, 9.1"#,8,35,# H V.##&/> JKKaM

@1&(8 [ F,O7> JKKPQ : b,94</, T+.?, 9.1"+,(&.3 84/

*,,3 (8, 3.#1 2.# 4//,//&3= -.#5 "#,5&9(4*&+&(7 &3 "/7!

98.+&3=<&/(&9/> 8.-,O,#> (8, "#,9&/, 2<39(&.34+ 2.#1 .2

(8, #,+4(&.3/8&" *,(-,,3 -.#5 "#.*4*&+&(7 435 #,45&3=

(&1, 84/ 3.( *,,3 ,6(,3/&O,+7 &3O,/(&=4(,5 H(8.<=8 /,,

B473,# [ c,++> L]]aM d+&,=+> V<(81433> [ X3=*,#(>

JKKaQ R (. .*(4&3 #,4/.34*+7 #,+&4*+, ,/(&14(,/ .2 "#,!

5&9(4*&+&(7 +,O,+/ *,+.- 4*.<( K:L -.<+5 #,G<&#, 8<3!

5#,5/ .# ,O,3 (8.</435/ .2 "4#(&9&"43(/ &3 4 T+.?,

3.#1&3= /(<57: W. 4//,// (8&/ 2<39(&.34+ 2.#1 1.#,

"#,9&/,+7> @1&(8 435 F,O7 HJKKP> /<*1&((,5Q </,5 *#.45!

9.O,#4=, (,983&G<,/ 2#.1 9.1"<(4(&.34+ +&3=<&/(&9/ (.

,/(&14(, "#.*4*&+&(&,/ 2.# ,O,#7 -.#5 &3 (8, (,3!"4#(&9&!

"43(> _K>KKK!-.#5 e<35,, 9.#"</> (8, +4#=,/( 4O4&+4*+,

54(4/,( .2 ,7, 1.O,1,3(/ &3 #,45&3=: f&=<#, J /8.-/

(8, "4#(&4+ 9.3(#&*<(&.3 .2 -.#5 /<#"#&/4+ (. 9<##,3(!

-.#5 2&#/(2&64(&.3 5<#4(&.3/> 9.3(#.++&3= 2.# ".(,3(&4+ 9.3!

2.<35/ &39+<5&3= -.#5 2#,G<,397 435 +,3=(8: B,14#0!

4*+7> 43 ,//,3(&4++7 +&3,4# #,+4(&.3/8&" 8.+5/ .O,# /,O!

,#4+ .#5,#/ .2 14=3&(<5, *,(-,,3 -.#5 +.=!"#.*4*&+&(7

435 =4?, 5<#4(&.3: f<#(8,#1.#,> (8&/ #,+4(&.3/8&" 943 *,

#,9.O,#,5 4( (8, &35&O&5<4+ /<*g,9( +,O,+> /",40&3= (.

(8, /(#,3=(8 435 /7/(,14(&9&(7 .2 (8, #,+4(&.3/8&" *,!

(-,,3 "#,5&9(4*&+&(7 435 2&64(&.3 5<#4(&.3/ &3 #,45&3=:

K:Ph K:J] K:`K K:Ki K:K

K:LJ K:hL K:hK K:]a L:K

LKKj LKKj _L:aj i_:Pj J]:Jj LL:Jj

%"&'() *: D39#,1,3(4+ "4#/&3= .2 4 =4#5,3!"4(8 /,3(,39,: W#,,/ &35&94(, (8, 943.3&94+ /(#<9(<#,/ 2.# 3.1&34+

H4*.O,Q 435 O,#*4+ H*,+.-Q &3(,#"#,(4(&.3/ .2 (8, 41*&=<.</ -.#5 +,-.: V<1*,#/ 4*.O, (8, (#,,/ &35&94(, (8, (#<,

"#.*4*&+&(,/ &3 (8, =#4114# .2 3.1&34+ 435 O,#*4+ &3(,#"#,(4(&.3/ 42(,# ,498 -.#5: V<1*,#/ &3 (8, /,9.35!(.!+4/(

+&3, &35&94(, (8, 2#,G<,397 -&(8 -8&98 4 `KS"4#(&9+, &39#,1,3(4+ "4#/,# HF,O7> B,4+&> [ \#&22&(8/> JKK]Q "#.5<9,/ 4

O&4*+, "4#/, (#,, &39+<5&3= (8, =&O,3 -.#5:

@

Vk

eW ll VV @

/0) )12),,)34 +,-. Vk kk

eW VV menk

40) 566, Bb

(-(),.

@

Vk nk

eW ll nb Vk menk

/0) )12),,)34 +,-. eW VV Bb

40) 566, #-(),.

@

Vk

eW ll VV @

/0) )12),,)34 +,-. Vk

eW VV

40) 566,

@

Vk nk

eW ll nb Vk

/0) )12),,)34 +,-. eW VV

40) 566,

@

Vk

eW ll VV @

/0) )12),,)34 +,-. Vk

eW

40)

@

Vk nk

eW ll nb Vk

/0) )12),,)34 +,-. eW

40)

@

Vk

eW ll VV

/0) )12),,)34 +,-.

@

Vk nk

eW ll nbk

/0) )12),,)34 +,-.

@

Vk

eW ll

/0) )12),,)34

W8,

,69,++,3(

"+47 (8, 2..+ #4#,+7

"

@

Vk nk

eW ll nb Vk menk

/0) )12),,)34 +,-. eW VV Bb

40) 566, #-(),.

"

"

"

_P

Page 7: Probabilistic Linguistic Expectations, Uncertain Input, and

!

!

"

!"#$%&'(" (")*&+ ,-'..$"/$0 '"1 02.*&(2"0 32%

(",%$4$"&5.(&6 5"1 %5&(2"5.(&6

"#$% &'( )#* +,-)$(* .& -./+(*#*01*(% '% #,2#34 ,0!

-(*/*0)'35 ('),.0'3 $%*(% .& '6',3'73* ,0&.(/'),.0 /'4

%**/ (*3'),6*34 -./+*33,028 9.:*6*(5 ' 0$/7*( .& -#'3!

3*02*% (*/',0 &.( )#,% +,-)$(*5 '01 ,0 )#* (*/',01*( .&

)#* +'+*( ; 1*%-(,7* .0* %$-# -#'33*02*5 (*-*0) /.1*3!

,02 '01 *<+*(,/*0)'3 :.(= :* #'6* 1.0* ). /**) )#')

-#'33*02*5 '01 0*: 1,(*-),.0% ,0 :#,-# )#,% /.1*3,02

'01 *<+*(,/*0)'3 :.(= #'% )'=*0 $%8

>.0%,1*( )#* %*0)*0-* ?!@'A 7*3.:B

?!@C '8 "#* -.'-# %/,3*1 ') )#* +3'4*( ).%%*1 )#* &(,%7**8

"#,% ,% ' 3*2,),/')* %*0)*0-* '--.(1,02 ). )#* 2('/!

/'),-'3 ($3*% .& D023,%#5 7$) 0'),6* %+*'=*(% &,01 ,)

*<)(*/*34 1,&&,-$3) ). (*'1 %)'(),02 ') )#* :.(1 !"#$%&8

"#,% ,% ,0 -.0)('%) :,)# %*0)*0-*% ?!@7!1C 7*3.:5 :#,-#

/*'0 *%%*0),'334 )#* %'/* )#,028 E.(1!74!:.(1 (*'1,02

),/*% ,0 )#* %*3&!+'-*1 (*'1,02 %)$14 .& "'7.( *) '38

? FGGHC 5 :#. .(,2,0'334 1*/.0%)(')*1 )#,% +#*0./*0.05

'(* %#.:0 ,0 I,2$(* JK 0.)* )#* 3.-'3,L'),.0 .& )#* %$!

+*('11,),6* 1,&&,-$3)4 *&&*-) ') )#* -(,),-'3 :.(1 !"$$%&'

!()*+, '01 ,//*1,')*34 )#*(*'&)*(8

"#* 7'%,- ,0)$,),.0 (*2'(1,02 )#,% %*0)*0-* )#') &,(%)

%)(,=*% /.%) ,06*%),2').(% ,% )#') )#* %*M$*0-* .& :.(1%

!(% -./0%) !*$$%& -.#*(*% :*33 ).2*)#*( '% ' +.)*0),'3

%$7N*-)!6*(7 -./7,0'),.05 7$) )#') )#,% 3.-'3 ,0)*(+(*)'!

),.0 1.*% 0.) &,) :,)# )#* 23.7'3 %*0)*0-* -.0)*<)5 ,0

:#,-# !(% -.10%) ,% ,0%,1* ' +(*+.%,),.0'3 +#('%*O0.) '

+3'-* :#*(* )#* %$7N*-) .& ' -3'$%* -'0 '++*'(8 I.(

)#,% (*'%.05 "'7.( *) '38 1$77*1 )#,% ' PQ>RP!>Q!

9DSDT>D DIID>"8 "#,% ,0)$,),.0 7*'(% %./* (*%*/!

73'0-* ). )#* 2'(1*0!+')# *&&*-)% 1*%-(,7*1 ,0 U*-),.0

J5 7$) )#* (*'%.0 )#') )#* 3.-'3!-.#*(*0-* *&&*-) ,%

+(.73*/'),- &.( )#* ('),.0'35 ,0-(*/*0)'3 )#*.(4 :* #'6*

1*6*3.+*1 $+ ). )#,% +.,0) ,% )#') :#*(*'% ,0 2'(1*0!

+')# %*0)*0-*% %$-# '% V!!7C )#* ,0-.((*-) '0'34%,% ,%

3*2,),/')* '01 *6*0 &'6.(*1 2,6*0 +(*6,.$% 23.7'3 -.0!

)*<)5 ,0 ?!@'C )#* ,0-.((*-) '0'34%,% %#.$31 7* )2.%& *2!

74 +(*6,.$% 23.7'3 -.0)*<)8

Q0* :'4 .& '--.$0),02 &.( )#* 3.-'3!-.#*(*0-* *&&*-)

,% ). '%%$/* )#') )#*(* ,% ' &'%)5

!

7.))./!$+

"

-./+.!

0*0) ). %40)'-),- +(.-*%%,02 )#') -'0 -.0%)($-) '0'34%*%

#**13*%% .& 23.7'3 -.0)*<)5 '01 )#*(* #'6* 7**0 %*6*('3

&.(/'3,L'),.0% .& )#,% ,1*' ? "'7.( W 9$)-#,0%5 FGGHK

X,7%.05 FGGYK Z,-=0*33 W P*645 FGG[K \.(2'05 ]*33*(5

W U)**1/'05 FG!GA 8 9.:*6*(5 )#,% '++(.'-# ,% &'-*1

:,)# )#* +'('1.< .& #'6,02 ). '--.$0) &.( #.: ('+,134

*&&*-),6*34 #$/'0 -./+(*#*01*(% &* $%* 23.7'3 -.0)*<)

). -.0%)(',0 ,0)*(+(*)'),.0 .& 3,02$,%),- ,0+$)8 "#* )#*.!

G!@

OH OF

3452)% 68 "#* 3,0*'( (*3'),.0%#,+ 7*):**0 ' :.(1" %

%$(+(,%'3 '01 &,(%) &,<'),.0% .0 ,)5 &.( *'-# .& )#* )*0

%$7N*-)% ,0 )#* ^$01** -.(+$% ?U/,)# W P*645 FGG_C8

J@G

HGG

H@G

@GG

@@G

YGG

)#* +3'4*( ).%%*1`

)#(.:0

' &(,%7** 74

3452)% 78 U*3&!+'-*1 (*'1,02 1')' &(./ "'7.( *) '38 ?FGGHC

?!@C 78 "#* -.'-# %/,3*1 ') )#* +3'4*( ).%%*1 )#*

&(,%7**8

-8 "#* -.'-# %/,3*1 ') )#* +3'4*( )#(.:0 )#* &(,%7**8

18 "#* -.'-# %/,3*1 ') )#* +3'4*( )#(.:0 )#*

&(,%7**8

S*'1,02),/*?/%C

@[

Page 8: Probabilistic Linguistic Expectations, Uncertain Input, and

!"#$%&'

(

!

)

"#$%&'( &)'((#*+#, $)-*, %. $/ "#&/*&%(# $)%. '0%(%$1 $/

2.# &/*$#3$ %* +#*#"'( 4%$) $)# '55'"#*$ 67%(2"- $/ 2.-

8/*$-3$ $/ "2(- /2$ %""-(-97*$ %*$-"5"-$7$%/*. %* (/87(!8/!

)-"-*8- -66-8$.:

;-91 <=>>?0@ A-'(. 4%$) $)%. 8)'((-*+- B1 )15/$)-!

.%C%*+ $)'$ 8/D5"-)-*A-"." "-5"-.-*$'$%/*. /6 5"%/"

8/*$-3$ D'1 %* 6'8$ 0- */%.%-" $)'* %. /6$-* $)/2+)$:

E* $)%. D/A-(, $)- %*52$ $/ $)- .-*$-*8-!(-9-( 8/D5"-!

)-*.%/* D-8)'*%.D %. */$ ' .-F2-*8- /6 4/"A., 02$

"'$)-" ' .-$ /6 */%.1 5-"8-5$2'( %*52$ "-5"-.-*$'$%/*. !:

G)- 8/D5"-)-*A-" 2.-. )-" +"'DD'$%8'( '*A 4/"(A

H*/4(-A+- $/ 8/*.$"28$ ' I/%*$ "#$%&'()(*+ ,(-*#('.*(/0

/9-" 5/..%B(- 4/"A .-F2-*8-. 1 '*A 5/..%B(- .$"28$2"'(

'*'(1.-. G $)"/2+) J'1-.%'* %*6-"-*8-K

2 34 !

! "

5 6

7 8!39

! "

7 34

! "

7

!"

8

L-"9- 7("-7A1 A-.8"%B-A )/4 7 5"/B7B%(%.$%8 +"7DD7"

5(78-. 7 5"/B7B%(%$1 A%.$"%B2$%/* /9-" .$"28$2"7( 7*7(1.-.

7*A 4/"A .-F2-*8-.

!

$)7$ %., )/4 %$ A-$-"D%*-. 7 :39 M:

N* 7AA%$%/*7( 8/D5/*-*$ *--A. $/ B- .5-8%6%-A 6/" $)%.

*-4 D/A-(, )/4-9-"K $)- 8/D5"-)-*A-"". D/A-( /6 5-"!

8-5$27( */%.- O'*A, 5/$-*$%'((1, .5-'H-" -""/"M, 7 :5;39 M:

G)-"- '"- D'*1 5/..%0%(%$%-. 6/" )/4 $/ 8/*.$"28$ .28)

' */%.- D/A-(P Q-91 <=>>?BM 2.-A /*- B'.-A /* Q-9!

-*.)$-%* -A%$ A%.$'*8- < Q-9-*.)$-%*, RSTTM , 4)%8) -.!

.-*$%7((1 -*8/A-. $)- %*$2%$%/*. $)7$ /"$)/+"75)%87((1

.%D%(7" 4/"A. 7"- D/"- (%H-(1 $/ B- 8/*62.-A 6/" /*-

7*/$)-", 7*A $)7$ .)/"$ 4/"A. 7"- D/"- (%H-(1 $/ B-

D%..-A </", %*9-".-(1, 5-"8-%9-A $/ B- 5"-.-*$ 4)-*

$)-1""- */$M $)7* (/*+ 4/"A.:

U/4 8/2(A $)%. D/A-( 788/2*$ 6/" $)- (/87(!8/)-"!

-*8- -66-8$ .--* %* <RV7M W X"28%7((1, $)-"- 7"- D7*1

.D7(( 8)7*+-. $)7$ 8/2(A B- D7A- $/ $)%. .-*$-*8-

4)%8) 4/2(A D7H- $)- 8"%$%87( 4/"A */--<, %*$/ 7 D7%*

9-"B %*.$-7A /6 7 57"$%8%5%7( 9-"BK

Y2.$ 7. %* .1*$78$%8 A%.7DB%+27$%/* 7 4/"A 87* A"7!

D7$%87((1 8)7*+- $)- 8/D5"-)-*A-"". B-(%-6. 7B/2$ $)-

5"/B7B%(%$1 /6 A%66-"-*$ .$"28$2"7( %*$-"5"-$7$%/*. < -:+:,

$)- .-8/*A %*.$7*8- /6 *=< %* Z%+2"- RM , %* 7 D/A-(

4)-"- 4/"A!(-9-( "-5"-.-*$7$%/*. 7"- */*!9-"%A%87(, 5-"!

8-5$27( %*52$ D%A.$"-7D %* 7 .-*$-*8- 87* A"7D7$%87((1

8)7*+- $)- 8/D5"-)-*A-"" . B-(%-6. 7B/2$ 4)7$ 1/#,

-<>.<0?<- D71 )79- 5"-8-A-A $)- 82""-*$ %*52$: [)%.

5/..%B%(%$1, 7*A )/4 %$ %*$-"78$. 4%$) +"7DD7$%87(

H*/4(-A+- %* $)- /*(%*- 8/D5"-)-*.%/* /6 <RV7M, %. %(!

(2.$"7$-A %* Z%+2"- \: [)- 5-"8-5$27( *-%+)B/")//A 7*A

$)- +"7DD7" /6 ]*+(%.) -66-8$%9-(1 5"/9%A- D2($%5(-

A%66-"-*$ 57$). $)"/2+) $)- .-*$-*8-^ $4/ /6 $)- D/.$

%D5/"$7*$ 57$). 7"- .--* )-"-, 7*A $)-%" "-(7$%9-

.$"-*+$). O5"/B7B%(%$%-.M 7"- %*A%87$-A 4%$) $)%8H-" (%*-

(-*+$) 6/" 7 57$) .-+D-*$ $)7$ %. D/"- 5"/B7B(- +%9-*

O7M )79%*+ 7""%9-A $/ $)- .$7"$ /6 $)- 57$) .-+D-*$, 7*A

OBM $)- %*52$ $)- .-+D-*$ 8/9-".: _* $)- 255-" 57$),

$)- 4/"A &* %. 8/""-8$(1 %A-*$%6%-A^ .%*8- 5-"8-5$%/* /*

79-"7+- %. */$ B%7.-A $/ B- %*7882"7$-, $)"/2+) $)%.

57$) %. %*%$%7((1 D/"- (%H-(1: _* $)- (/4-" 57$), $)-

4/"A &* %. %*8/""-8$(1 %A-*$%6%-A 7. /*- /6 %$. *-%+)B/".,

&- /" &0,^ .%*8- $)%. 57$) %*9/(9-. 7 5-"8-5$27( -""/",

%$ %. (-.. (%H-(1: `%*8- &* %. 7 5"-5/.%$%/* 4)-"-7. 7.

7*A &0, 7"- 8/*I2*8$%/*., )/4-9-", $)- A%66-"-*$ 57$).

*/4 8/""-.5/*A $/ A%66-"-*$ .1*$78$%8 7*7(1.-. /6 25!

ORTM 7: [)- 8/78) .D%(-A a7.b7*Ac $)- 5(71-" $/..-A

$)- 6"%.B--:

B: [)- 8/78) .D%(-A 7$ $)- 5(71-" a4)/b$)7$b7*Ac

$/..-A $)- 6"%.B--:

@@@*=< ")A+<#@@@

@@@A*@@@

@@@*=< ?/A?= -B()<,@@@

@@@A-@@@

@@@*=< ")A+<#@@@

@@@*/--<,@@@

@@@*/--<,@@@

C(D.#< E: X/25(%*+ /6 %*6-"-*8- 7B/2$ .-*$-*8- %A-*$%$1 7*A +"7DD7$%87( 7*7(1.%.K $4/ 57$). $)"/2+) 7 (/87(!8/)-"!

-*8- .-*$-*8-:

8: [)- 8/78) a4)/b$)7$c .D%(-A 7$ $)- 5(71-" $/..-A $)- 6"%.B--:

T>

Page 9: Probabilistic Linguistic Expectations, Uncertain Input, and

!

!

"

"#$%&' %&()*+ ,-. (-/01. !"# $%&'#( %1 #2 1%$%30/ (/#4!

04%3%*5 2#/ 4#*- *-. )((./ 0&6 3#7./ (0*- 1.8).&".19

-.&". *-. (0*- 1*/.&'*-1 6# &#* "-0&'. 0((/."%0435 0*

*-%1 (#%&*+ :)* %& #/6./ 2#/ *-. )((./ (0*- *# 2)/*-./

"#&*%&). 7%*- *-. 7#/6 !)**#+; 0 -%'-35 )&3%<.35 15&!

*0"*%" .=.&* -01 *# #"")/!0 /.6)".6 /.30*%=. "30)1. %&!

=#3=%&' (011%=%>0*%#& #& *-. '#03 0/')$.&* #2 0 6%*/0&!

1%*%=. =./4

!

7-./.01 *-. 3#7./ (0*- "0& "#&*%&). 7%*-

*-. 7#/6 !)**#+ *-/#)'- *-. $)"- 3%<.3%./ 15&*0"*%"

.=.&* #2 0 $0%&!"30)1. 2%&%*. =./4+ ,-./.2#/. 1*/.&'*- #2

*-. (0*- 1.'$.&* "#=./%&' !)**#+ #& *-. )((./ (0*- %1

$)"- 3#7./ *-0& *-. 1*/.&'*- #2 *-. "#//.1(#&6%&' 1.'!

$.&* #& *-. 3#7./ (0*-+ :05.1%0& %&2./.&". %&"#/(#/0*.1

*-%1 &.7 %&2#/$0*%#& *# )(60*. *-. 0''/.'0*. 1*/.&'*-1 #2

*-. )((./ 0&6 3#7./ (0*-1; "0)1%&' 0 1)41*0&*%03 1-%2* %&

4.3%.2 2/#$ *-. )((./ (0*- *# *-. 3#7./ (0*- ?'/05 0//#71

0&6 &.7; 3#&'./ (0*- 1.'$.&*1 %& @%')/. AB+ C& *-. 0"!

"#)&* #2 D.=5 ?EFFG4H; *-. 4#''3. %& ?!I0H %&=#3=.1 (/.!

"%1.35 *-%1 1-%2*J *-. 7#/6 !)**#+ "0331 %&*# 8).1*%#& *-.

"#$(/.-.&6./"1 /.(/.1.&*0*%#& #2 (01* %&()*+

D.=5 ?EFFG4H $#6.3.6 *-%1 1-%2* %& 4.3%.21 04#)* (01*

%&()* 45 6.2%&%&' (/#404%3%*5 6%1*/%4)*%#&1 #=./ (#11%43.

7#/6 1.8).&".1 )( *# 0 (#1%*%#& , %& *-. 1.&*.&". ?%&

?!I0H ; , %1 7-./. *-. 7#/6 !)**#+ %1 1..&H 4.2#/. 0&6

02*./ 1..%&' (./".(*)03 %&()* 2/#$ (#1%*%#& ,+ K& *-.

$#6.3; *-. $0'&%*)6. #2 *-. 1-%2* %1 8)0&*%2%.6 45 *-.

LMDD:NOL!DPK:DPQ RKSPQTPUOP

!

0 1*0&60/6 $.0!

1)/. #2 #&. "#0/1.!'/0%&.6 (/#404%3*5 6%1*/%4)*%#& .&"#6.1

0&#*-./; 2%&./!'/0%&.6 6%1*/%4)*%#& V O#=./ W ,-#$01;

!XX!B

!

2/#$ *-. 6%1*/%4)*%#& 4.2#/. 1..%&' , *# *-. 6%1!

*/%4)*%#& 02*./ 1..%&' ,+ ,-%1 8)0&*%*5; *-. PQQCQ K!

RPU,K@KON,KCU YKTUND VPKYB 0* (#1%*%#& ,- %1 1-#7&

2#/ V!I0B 0&6 V!IB %& @%')/. I V&! "#&6%*%#&1B+ ,-./. %1

#&. 2/.. (0/0$.*./ %& *-%1 $#6.3; "#//.1(#&6%&' *# *-.

(./".(*)03 &#%1. 3.=.3 !; 4)* /.'0/63.11 #2 *-. =03). #2

*-%1 (0/0$.*./ *-. PKY %1 30/'./ 0* *-. (0/*!#2!1(.."-

0$4%')#)1 !)**#+ *-0& 0* *-. )&0$4%')#)1 !"()./+

:."0)1. *-. 3#"03!"#-./.&". .22."* %& *-. D.=5

V EFFG4B $#6.3 #2 /0*%#&03 (/#404%3%1*%" "#$(/.-.&1%#&

)&6./ )&"./*0%& %&()* 6.(.&61 "/)"%0335 #& *-. (./".(!

*)03 &.%'-4#/-##6 #2 *-. 1.&*.&". 4.%&' /.06; *-.

$#6.3 $0<.1 0 &)$4./ #2 &#&!*/%=%03 .$(%/%"03 (/.6%"!

*%#&1 /.'0/6%&' -#7 $0&%()30*%#&1 #2 (./".(*)03 &.%'-!

4#/-##6 $05 022."* #&3%&. "#$(/.-.&1%#&+ N1 1-#7& %&

V!ZB 0&6 @%')/. A; 2#/ .[0$(3.; 0& %$(#/*0&* (0/* #2

*-. PKY %& V!I0B 0/%1.1 2/#$ *-. (/.1.&". #2 *-. 7#/61

01 0&6\#/ 0&6 %& *-. %$$.6%0*. (./".(*)03 &.%'-4#/!

-##6 #2 *-. 7#/6 0*+ ,-. $#6.3 *-)1 (/.6%"*1 *-0* %2 0

1.$0&*%"0335 1%$%30/ (/.(#1%*%#& 7%*-#)* 1)"- 0 (./".(!

*)03 &.%'-4#/-##6; 1)"- 01 !).&(+; %1 1)41*%*)*.6 2#/ &!;

*-. PKY 1-#)36 4. 6%$%&%1-.6 V@%')/. IB+ D.=5; :%"<!

&.33; Y30**./5; 0&6 Q05&./ VEFFXB *.1*.6 *-%1 (/.6%"*%#&

%& 0& .5.!*/0"<%&' 1*)65 45 "/#11%&' *-. )1. #2 *-.

(/.(#1%*%#& 0* =./1)1 *#70/6 7%*- *-. (0/*!#2!1(.."-

0$4%')%*5 #2 *-. "/%*%"03 7#/6 V .+'+; *#11.6 =./1)1

*-/#7&B + ,-. (/.6%"*%#& 701 4#/&. #)* %& %&*./0"*%#&1

#& /0*. #2 2%/1*!(011 /.'/.11%#&1 2/#$ *-. "/%*%"03 7#/6;

'#!(01* *%$.; 0&6 *-. 2/.8).&"5 #2 2%[0*%&' #& *-.

0,12(# 34 P//#/ %6.&*%2%"0*%#& 1%'&03 0* "/%*%"03 7#/6 %&

3#"03!"#-./.&". 1.&*.&".1+

5,12(# 6+ O/)"%03 /.1)3*1 #2 D.=5; :%"<&.33; .* 03+ VEFFXB

V0B @%/1*!(011

/.'/.11%#&1

V4B T#!(01*

*%$.

V"B T#!(01*

2%[0*%#&1 #&

(/.(#1%*%#&

Z!

Page 10: Probabilistic Linguistic Expectations, Uncertain Input, and

!"#$%&'

(

!

)

"#$"%&'('%) *+#'), ,%!"-&( #.-*'), %/ (0. 1#'('2-3 4%#*

56',+#. 789

!"#"$% &'$()*'+,-

:) (0'& -#('23.; : 0<=. <((.>"(.* (% "#.&.)( .='*.)1.

/%# < ='.4 %/ ')1#.>.)(<3 &.)(.)1. 1%>"#.0.)&'%) <&

,#<>><#!?<&.*; #<('%)<3; "#.*'2('=.; <)* "#%?<?'3'&('2@

<)A (% .B"3'C<(. (0. '>"3'C<('%)& <)* &+""%#( %/ &+C0 <

='.4 /%# .D. >%=.>.)( C%)(#%3 ') #.<A'),9 E. 0<=.

&..) 0%4 (0. )%('%) %/ ')1#.>.)(<3; "#%?<?'3'&('1 ,#<>!

><('1<3 <)<3D&'& 1<) 1<"(+#. ?%(0 1%<#&.!,#<').* <)*

&+?(3. ,<#*.)!"<(0 .//.1(&; <)* 0%4 < 0',03D #.,+3<#

#.3<('%)&0'" 0%3*& ?.(4..) "#.*'1('%) &(#.),(0 <)* /'B<!

('%) *+#<('%)& ') /'#&(!"<&& #.<*'),9 E. 0<=. <3&% .B<>!

').* 3%1<3 1%0.#.)1. .//.1(&; 40'10 "%&. <) <""<#.)(

10<33.),. (% (0. #<('%)<3 ='.4 <#('1+3<(.* <?%=.; <)*

.B"3%#.* (0. "%&&'?'3'(D (0<( (0. #<('%)<3 ='.4 1<) ?.

><')(<').* '/ < F.D &'>"3'/D'), <&&+>"('%) C%>>%) (%

<33 "#.='%+& >%A.3& %/ &.)(.)C. C%>"#.0.)&'%)

!

(0<( %/

C<(.,%#'C<3 4%#A!3.=.3 ')"+(

!

'& #.3<B.A9 :( (+#)& %+(

(0<( #.3<B'), (0'& &'>"3'/D'), <&&+>"('%) <)A <33%4'),

')"+( #."#.&.)(<('%)& (% ?. +)C.#(<') )%( %)3D <CC%+)(&

/%# (0. C3<&&'C 3%C<3!C%0.#.)C. .//.C(; ?+( ><F.& ).4

"#.A'C('%)& #.,<#A'), (0. .//.C(& %/ ".#C."(+<3 ).',0!

?%#0%%A %) .D. >%=.>.)(& ') &.)(.)C. #.<A'),9

G0. ')"+(!+)1.#(<')(D >%*.3 <3&% 3.<*& (% < )+>?.#

%/ %(0.# "#.*'1('%)& (0<( 0<=. ?..) (.&(.* +&'), 1%)!

(#%33.* .B".#'>.)( <)* 1%#"+& <)<3D&'&9 H.=D 5 IJKJ8

*.>%)&(#L(.* (0. .B'&(.)2. %/ !"##$%&'"()* +",*)'!-"(!.;

40.#. &(#%), "#'%# .B".2(L('%)& #.,L#*'), 3'F.3D L)*

+)3'F.3D ,#L>>L('2L3 &(#+2(+#.& 2L) M'L& 2%>"#.0.)*.#&

(%4L#* L*%"('), ')2#.>.)(L3 L)L3D&.& (0L( L#. )%(

&(#'2(3D 3'2.)&.* MD &+#/L2. ')"+(; L& .='*.)2.* MD

,L#*.)!"L(0 *'&L>M',+L('%) .//.2(& +"%) .)2%+)(.#'),

*%4)&(#.L> >L(.#'L3 2%)&'&(.)( 4'(0 (0. (#+. &+#/L2.

')"+( M+( )%( 4'(0 (0. 0L33+2')L(.* ,L#*.) "L(09 N>'(0

L)* H.=D 5IJKJ8 /%+)* .='*.)2. /#%> .D. >%=.>.)(&

') #.L*'), ).4&"L".# (.B( (0L( /'BL('%) *+#L('%)& *+#'),

/'#&(!"L&& #.L*'), &..> (% #./3.2( (0. 4%#* &+#"#'&L3&

)/-)%()* ,'=.) L 2%>M')L('%) %/ "#'%# 2%)(.B( L)*

2%L#&.!,#L').*; +)2.#(L') M%((%>!+" ')"+( >%#. &(#%),3D

(0L) (0.D #./3.2( (#+. 4%#* &+#"#'&L3&9 O**'('%)L33D; (LF!

'), ')"+( +)2.#(L')(D ')(% L22%+)( 0L& (0. "%(.)('L3 (%

3.L* (% L ).4 /#L>.4%#F ') 40'20 .D. >%=.>.)( 2%)!

(#%3 "%3'2'.& L#. &..) L& 5).L#!8 #L('%)L3 &%3+('%)& (% L)

%"('>'PL('%) "#%M3.> ') 40'20 (0. ,%L3 %/ #.L*'), '& (%

*'&2.#) (0. 2%)(.)(& %/ (0. &.)(.)2. #L"'*3D L)* 4'(0

0',0 L22+#L2D9 Q'2F).33 L)* R.=D 5IJKJ8 "#.&.)(.* (0'&

/#L>.4%#F L)* L /'#&( '>"3.>.)(L('%); +&'), L 2%>M'!

)L('%) %/ )%'&D!20L)).3 "#%MLM'3'&('2 ,#L>>L('2L3 ')/.#!

.)2. L)* #.')/%#2.>.)( 3.L#)'), 5 S+&&.33 T U%#=',;

IJJV; W0L"(.# IK@ X+((%) T QL#(%; KYYZ89 [0.D *.>%)!

&(#L(.* (0L( #.,#.&&'=. .D. >%=.>.)(& 2L) M. ='.4.* L&

L #L('%)L3 #.&"%)&. (% (0. LM%=. %"('>'PL('%) "#%M3.>\

(0. %22L&'%)L3 #.!#.L*'), ).2.&&'(L(.* MD &.(('), (0. #.!

]+'#.* 3.=.3 %/ /'#&(!"L&& '*.)('/'2L('%) L22+#L2D %)3D

>%*.#L(.3D 0',0 '& L) L22."(LM3. "#'2. (% "LD /%# (0.

')2#.L&.* %=.#L33 &"..* %/ #.L*'), '( L33%4&9

^) &+>>L#D; (0.); 4. 0L=. &..) L "'2(+#. %/ (0. *.."

')(.#(4').>.)( %/ &%"0'&('2L(.* ,#L>>L('2L3 F)%43.*,. ;

')/%#>L('%) +"(LF. /#%> ".#2."(+L3 ')"+(; L)* *.2'&'%)!

>LF'), #.,L#*'), .D. >%=.>.)(& %) #L"'* ('>. &2L3.&

') &.)(.)2. 2%>"#.0.)&'%) *+#'), #.L*'),9 _. 0L=.

&..) .='*.)2. /%# &+#"#'&'),3D 3L4!3'F. M.0L='%# ') &.=!

.#L3 #.&".2(&

!

')23+*'), M.3'./& LM%+( &.)(.)2. &(#+2(+#.

L)* '*.)('(D M.'), 4.33!*.&2#'M.* MD (0. ')(.,#L('%) %/

='&+L3 ')"+( 4'(0 3'),+'&('2 F)%43.*,. (0#%+,0 (0. #+3.&

%/ "#%MLM'3'(D (0.%#D; L)* L &D&(.>L('2 #.3L('%)&0'"

0%3*'), M.(4..) (0. 2%)*'('%)L3 "#%MLM'3'(D %/ L 4%#*

L)* 0%4 3%), '( '& /'BL(.*9 O""L#.)( *'//'2+3('.& /%# (0'&

"'2(+#. 0L=. 3.* (% L >%#. 2L#./+3 L&&.&&>.)( %/ ML&'2

L&&+>"('%)& #.,L#*'), (0. )L(+#. %/ (0. ')"+( #."#.&.)!

(L('%)& ') &.)(.)2.!3.=.3 2%>"#.0.)&'%); 40'20 ') (+#)

0L& 3.* (% #'20.# >%*.3& 40'20 >LF. )%=.3 "#.*'2('%)&9

[0. 3L#,.# 3.&&%) '& (0L( L""#%"#'L(.3D L22%+)('), /%#

.)='#%)>.)(L3 L)* 2%,)'('=. 2%)&(#L')(& ') "#%MLM'3'&('2

>%*.3& 2L) &%>.('>.& 3.L* (% L >%#. )+L)2.* L)*

+3('>L(.3D >%#. &L('&/L2(%#D "'2(+#. %/ F.D L&".2(& %/

0+>L) 2%,)'('%)9 [0+& /L#; (0'& 3.&&%) 0L& M..) &(#'F!

'),3D (#+. /%# .D. >%=.>.)(& ') #.L3!('>. 3'),+'&('2

2%>"#.0.)&'%)@ %). 2L) 0%". (0L( '( >LD 2%)(')+. (%

0%3* ') (0'& *%>L'); L)* (0L( '( >LD 0%3* ') %(0.#

2%,)'('=. *%>L')& L& 4.339

.)/,+01%234%,*-

[0'& L#('23. '& ML&.* %) L (L3F ,'=.) `LD Ia; IJKJ; L(

7I

Page 11: Probabilistic Linguistic Expectations, Uncertain Input, and

!

!

"

"#$ %&'(") *)+,- .,"$(,-"+&,-/ *&,%$($,0$ &, 12$ 3&4$!

5$,"6 -" 7+-,8+, 9&(5-/ :,+4$(6+"2; -,< . -5 =(-"$%'/ "&

%$$<>-0? %(&5 ")$ -'<+$,0$ -" ")-" "-/?@ A// 5+6"-?$6

-($ 52 &B,C 7)$ B(+"+,= &% ")+6 -("+0/$ B-6 6'DD&("$< >2

9EF GHI11I =(-," JKLMNOJ "& I&=$( P$42C

!"#"$"%&"'

A/"5-,,Q RC 7C; S T-5+<$Q U@ V!WWWX C Y,0($5$,"-/ +,"$(D($"-"+&, -"

4$(>6Z I$6"(+0"+,= ")$ <&5-+, &% 6'>6$['$," ($%$($,0$C !"#$%&%"$' ()

V\XQ ]^_`]a^C

b+0?,$//Q TCQ S P$42Q IC V]JJKXC A 5&<$/ &% /&0-/ 0&)$($,0$ $%%$0"6 +,

)'5-, 6$,"$,0$ D(&0$66+,= -6 0&,6$['$,0$6 &% 'D<-"$6 %(&5

>&""&5!'D D(+&( "& D&6"$(+&( >$/+$%6C ., *+",--.%$/0 "1 &2- $"+&2

34-+%,3$ ,235&-+ "1 &2- 300",%3&%"$ 1"+ ,"456&3&%"$37 7%$/6%0&%,0!26!

43$ 73$/63/- &-,2$"7"/%-0 89::!;!<;=> ,"$1-+-$,-?

b+0?,$//Q TCQ S P$42Q IC V]JcJXC A (-"+&,-/ 5&<$/ &% $2$ 5&4$5$,"

0&,"(&/ +, ($-<+,=C ., @+",--.%$/0 "1 &2- 3$$637 4--&%$/ "1 &2- 30!

0",%3&%"$ 1"+ ,"456&3&%"$37 7%$/6%0&%,0 VDDCccad`cc_dXC

b&&")Q 7C PC VcWaWXC e(&>->+/+6"+0 ($D($6$,"-"+&, &% %&(5-/ /-,='-=$6C

., A--- ,"$1-+-$,- +-,"+. "1 &2- BCDC &-$&2 3$$637 0E45"0%64 "$

0F%&,2%$/ 3$. 36&"43&3 &2-"+E VDDC_^`dcXC

*)$,Q ECQ S R&&<5-,Q fC V cKKdX C :$ -45%+%,37 0&6.E "1 04""&2%$/

&-,2$%G6-0 1"+ 73$/63/- 4".-7%$/ V7$0)C I$DCX C *&5D'"$( E0+$,0$

R(&'DQ g-(4-(< :,+4$(6+"2C

*)&56?2Q 9C VcKLaX C 7)($$ 5&<$/6 %&( ")$ <$60(+D"+&, &% /-,='-=$C

HIJ =+3$03,&%"$0 "$ H$1"+43&%"$ =2-"+EK L V\XQ cc\`c]^C

*)'(0)Q TCQ S e-"+/Q IC VcKd]X C *&D+,= B+") 62,"-0"+0 -5>+='+"2Q &(

)&B "& D'" ")$ >/&0? +, ")$ >&h &, ")$ "->/$C !"456&3&%"$37 ;%$!

/6%0&%,0' M V\`^XQ c\K`c^KC

*&4$(Q 7CQ S 7)&5-6Q fC VcKKcXC J7-4-$&0 "1 %$1"+43&%"$ &2-"+EC f&), i+/$2C

*(&0?$(Q 3CQ S b(-,"6Q 7C V]JJJXC i+<$!0&4$(-=$ D(&>->+/+6"+0 6$,"$,0$

D(&0$66+,=C N"6+$37 "1 *0E,2"7%$/6%0&%, I-0-3+,2K LC VaXQ a^_`aaKC

1-(/$2Q fC VcK_JXC A, $%%+0+$," 0&,"$h"!%($$ D-(6+,= -/=&(+")5C O"446!

$%,3&%"$0 "1 &2- :OPK B) V]XQ K^`cJ]C

1)(/+0)Q EC jCQ S I-2,$(Q TC VcKdcXC *&,"$h"'-/ $%%$0"6 &, B&(< D$(!

0$D"+&, -,< $2$ 5&4$5$,"6 <'(+,= ($-<+,=C N"6+$37 "1 Q-+R37

S-3+$%$/ 3$. Q-+R37 T-23U%"+K LVQ a^c`aLLC

j&(<Q 3CQ b($6,-,Q fCQ S T-D/-,Q IC 3C VcKd]XC A 0&5D$"$,0$!>-6$<

")$&(2 &% 62,"-0"+0 0/&6'($C ., fC b($6,-, V1<CXQ =2- 4-$&37 +-5+-!

0-$&3&%"$ "1 /+3443&%,37 +-73&%"$0 VDDC _]_`_KaXC 7)$ 3.7 e($66C

j(-k+$(Q PCQ S I-2,$(Q TC VcKd]XC 3-?+,= -,< 0&(($0"+,= $((&(6 <'(+,=

6$,"$,0$ 0&5D($)$,6+&,Z 12$ 5&4$5$,"6 +, ")$ -,-/26+6 &% 6"('0!

"'(-//2 -5>+='&'6 6$,"$,0$6C O"/$%&%U- *0E,2"7"/EK BWQ c_d`]cJC

R+>6&,Q 1C V]JJaXC 7)$ +,"$(-0"+&, &% "&D!<&B, -,< >&""&5!'D 6"-"+6"+06

+, ")$ ($6&/'"+&, &% 62,"-0"+0 0-"$=&(2 -5>+='+"2C N"6+$37 "1 X-4"+E

3$. S3$/63/-K YWQ \a\`\ddC

R+,6>'(=Q EC V cKaaX C =2- 43&2-43&%,37 &2-"+E "1 ,"$&-Z&!1+-- 73$!

/63/-0C 30R(-B!g+//C

g-/$Q fC V ]JJcX C A D(&>->+/+6"+0 1-(/$2 D-(6$( -6 - D620)&/+,='+6"+0

5&<$/C ., *+",--.%$/0 "1 &2- 0-,"$. 4--&%$/ "1 &2- $"+&2 34-+%,3$

,235&-+ "1 &2- 300",%3&%"$ 1"+ ,"456&3&%"$37 7%$/6%0&%,0VDDC cLK`caaXC

g-/$Q fC V ]JJ\X C 7)$ +,%&(5-"+&, 0&,4$2$< >2 B&(<6 +, 6$,"$,0$6C

N"6+$37 "1 *0E,2"7%$/6%0&%, I-0-3+,2K )L V]XQ cJc`c]\C

g-/$Q fC V]JJaXC :,0$("-+,"2 ->&'" ")$ ($6" &% ")$ 6$,"$,0$C O"/$%&%U-

[,%-$,-K )V V^XQ aJK`a^]C

g&D0(&%"Q fC 1CQ S ://5-,Q fC lC VcK_KXC A$&+".6,&%"$ &" 36&"43&3 &2-"!

+EK 73$/63/-0K 3$. ,"456&3&%"$C A<<+6&,!i$6/$2C

f$/+,$?Q jCQ S P-%%$("2Q fC lC VcKKcXC *&5D'"-"+&, &% ")$ D(&>->+/+"2 &%

+,+"+-/ 6'>6"(+,= ]^ =$,$(-"+&, >2 6"&0)-6"+0 0&,"$h" %($$ =(-55-(6C

O"456&3&%"$37 S%$/6%0&%,0K B\ V\XQ \cL`\]\C

f'(-%6?2Q lC VcKKaXC A D(&>->+/+6"+0 5&<$/ &% /$h+0-/ -,< 62,"-0"+0 -0!

0$66 -,< <+6-5>+='-"+&,C O"/$%&%U- [,%-$,-K LV V]XQ c\_`cK^C

f'(-%6?2Q lCQ S 3-("+,Q fC gC V]JJdXC [5--,2 3$. 73$/63/- 5+",-00%$/]

:$ %$&+".6,&%"$ &" $3&6+37 73$ /63/- 5+",-00%$/K ,"456&3&%"$37

7%$/6%0&%,0K 3$. 05--,2 +-,"/$%&%"$ VE$0&,< $<CXC e($,"+0$!g-//C

T-5+<$Q UCQ A/"5-,,Q RCQ S g-2B&&<Q EC V]JJ\XC 7)$ "+5$!0&'(6$ &%

D($<+0"+&, +, +,0($5$,"-/ 6$,"$,0$ D(&0$66+,=Z 14+<$,0$ %(&5

-,"+0+D-"&(2 $2$ 5&4$5$,"6C N"6+$37 "1 X-4"+E 3$. ;3$/63/-K WC

VcXQ c\\`cLaC

T/+$=/Q ICQ 9'")5-,,Q ACQ S 1,=>$("Q IC V]JJaX C 7(-0?+,= ")$ 5+,<

<'(+,= ($-<+,=Z 7)$ +,%/'$,0$ &% D-6"Q D($6$,"Q -,< %'"'($ B&(<6 &,

%+h-"+&, <'(-"+&,6C N"6+$37 "1 JZ5-+%4-$&37 *0E,2"7"/E] ^-$-+37K B)Y

VcXQ c]`\LC

Q gCQ S j(-,0+6Q iC 9C VcKa_XC O"456&3&%"$37 3$37E0%0 "1 5+-0-$&!

.3E :4-+%,3$ J$/7%02_ e(&4+<$,0$Q I.Z b(&B, :,+4$(6+"2 e($66C

P$4$,6)"$+,Q mC .C VcKaaXC b+,-(2 0&<$6 0-D->/$ &% 0&(($0"+,= <$/$"+&,6Q

+,6$("+&,6Q -,< ($4$(6-/6C ["U%-& *2E0%,0 `"a73.EK BVQ _J_`_cJC

P$42Q IC V]JJd-XC 1hD$0"-"+&,!>-6$< 62,"-0"+0 0&5D($)$,6+&,C O"/$%&%"$K

BVDQ cc]a cc__C

P$42Q IC V]JJd>XC A ,&+62!0)-,,$/ 5&<$/ &% (-"+&,-/ )'5-, 6$,"$,0$

0&5D($)$,6+&, ',<$( ',0$("-+, +,D'"C ., *+",--.%$/0 "1 &2- B)&2

,"$1-+-$,- "$ -45%+%,37 4-&2".0 %$ $3&6+37 73$/63/- 5+",-00%$/

VDDC ]\^`]^\XC

P$42Q IC V]JcJQ 3-(0)XC b$ 23776,%$3&-. /3+.-$ 53&20C e&6"$( D($6$,"$<

-" ")$ *:9U 6$,"$,0$ D(&0$66+,= 0&,%$($,0$C

P$42Q ICQ b+0?,$//Q TCQ E/-""$(2Q 7CQ S I-2,$(Q TC V]JJKXC 12$ 5&4$5$,"

*

a\

Page 12: Probabilistic Linguistic Expectations, Uncertain Input, and

!"#$%&'

(

!

)

"#$%"&'" ()*( +"*%"+, -*$&(*$& *&% *.( /& 0&."+(*$&(1 *2/0( 3*,(

4$&50$,($. $&30(6 !"#$%%&'()* +, -.% (/-'+(/0 /$/&%12 +, *$'%($%*3

456 789:; <=9>?@<=9A96

B"#1; C6; C"*4$; D6; E F+$GG$(),; H6 I6 7<99A:6 J/%"4$&5 ()" "GG".(, /G

-"-/+1 /& )0-*& /&4$&" ,"&("&." 3+/.",,$&5 K$() 3*+($.4" G$4("+,6

L& !"+$%%&'()* +, -.% 77(8 9+(,%"%(9% +( (%:";0 '(,+"1;-'+(

<"+9%**'() *2*-%1* =('<*>6

J*&&$&5; M6 N6; E O.)!(P"; Q6 7 =AAA: 6 ?+:(&;-'+(* +, *-;-'*-'9;0

(;-:";0 0;():;)% <"+9%**'()6 JLR S+",,6

J*+.0,; J6 S6; O*&(/+$&$; T6; E J*+.$&U$"K$.P; J6 V6 7=AAW:6 T0$4%$&5

* 4*+5" *&&/(*("% ./+30, /G X&54$,)Y R)" S"&& R+""2*&U6

@+1<:-;-'+(;0 A'():'*-'$*3 BC 7<:; Z=Z@ZZ96

J/+5*&; [6; \"44"+; ]6; E O(""%-*&; J6 7<9=9:6 V 2/((/-!03 3*+,$&5

-/%"4 /G 4/.*4 ./)"+"&." "GG".(,6 ^& D"+$%%&'()* +, -.% $+)('-'E%

*$'%($% *+$'%-2 $+(,%"%($%6

_*+*1*&*&; O6; E `0+*G,U1; N6 7 =AA>: 6 T*1",$*& -/% "4, /G )0-*&

,"&("&." 3+/.",,$&56 ^& D"+$%%&'()* +, -.% -F%0,-. ;((:;0 1%%-'()

+, -.% $+)('-'E% *$'%($% *+$'%-26

_*+*1*&*&; O6; E `0+*G,U1; N6 7<99<:6 V T*1",$*& -/%"4 3+"%$.(, )0-*&

3*+," 3+"G"+"&." *&% +"*%$&5 ($-" $& ,"&("&." 3+/.",,$&56 ^& G&E/($%*

'( (%:"/0 '(,+"1/-'+( <"+$%**'() *2*-%1* 7a/46=W; 336 8A@?8:6

_/++$,; N6 7<99?:6 R)" T*1",$*& b"*%"+Y Xc34*$&$&5 K/+% +"./5&$($/&

*, *& /3($-*4 T*1",$*& %".$,$/& 3+/.",,6 D*2$.+0+)'$/0 H%E'%FI BBJ

7<:; Z<d@Z8d6

b*1&"+; \6 7=AA>:6 X1" -/#"-"&(, $& +"*%$&5 *&% $&G/+-*($/& 3+/.",,$&5Y

<9 1"*+, /G +","*+.)6 !*2$.+0+)'$/0 K:LLM-N(I B7O 7Z:; Zd<@W<<6

b*1&"+; \6 7<99A:6 R)" ()$+(1@G$G() O$+ D+"%"+$.U T*+(4"(( B".(0+"Y X1"

-/#"-"&(, *&% *(("&($/& %0+$&5 +"*%$&5; ,."&" 3"+."3($/&; *&%

#$,0*4 ,"*+.)6 P:;"-M"02 Q+:"(;0 +, RS<M"'1M(-;0 D*29.+0+)2I 67;

=W8d@=89?6

b*1&"+; \6; E e"44; V6 N6 7=AA?:6 XGG".(, /G ./&("c(0*4 ./&,(+*$&( /&

"1" -/#"-"&(, $& +"*%$&5Y V G0+()"+ "c*-$&*($/&6 D*29.+(+1'9

K:00M-'( T HME'MF3 J 7W:; 89W@89A6

b/*+U; T6 7<99=:6 S+/2*2$4$,($. (/3@%/K& 3*+,$&5 *&% 4*&50*5" -/%"4$&56

@+1<:-;-'+(;0 A'():'*-'9*3 7U 7<:; <WA@<d?6

b0,,"44; O6; E _/+#$5; S6 7 <99Z: 6 G"-','9';0 '(-%00')%(9%V G 1+8%"(

;<<"+;9. 7O"./&% "%6:6 S+"&($." Q*446

O-$(); _6 6; E B"#1; b6 7<99>:6 f3($-*4 3+/.",,$&5 ($-", $& +"*%$&5Y

V G/+-*4 -/%"4 *&% "-3$+$.*4 $&#",($5*($/&6 L& D"+9%%8'()* +, -.%

J5-. ;((:;0 1%%-'() +, -.% 9+)('-'E% *9'%(9% *+9'%-2W

O-$(); _6 g6; E B"#1; b6 7 <9=9: 6 D$c*($/& %0+*($/&, $& G$+,("3*,,

+"*%$&5 +"G4".( 0&."+(*$&(1 *2/0( K/+% $%"&($(16 L& D"+9%%&'()* +,

-.% J7(& ;((:;0 1%%-'() +, -.% 9+)('-'E% *9'%(9% *+9'%-2X

O-$(); _6 6; E B"#1; b6 7O02-$(("%:6 G ";-'+(;0 1+&%0 +, <"%&'9-;Y'0'-2

%,,%$-* +( $+)('-'E% <"+$%**'() -'1%*6 7J*&0,.+$3(; hM O*& N$"5/:6

O(/4.U"; V6 7 =AA8: 6 V& "GG$.$"&( 3+/2*2$4$,($. ./&("c("G+"" 3*+,$&5

*45/+$()- ()*( ./-30(", 3+"G$c 3+/2*2$4$($",6 @+1<:-;-'+(;0 A'():'*-'$*3

7B 7<:; =?8@<9=6

O0((/&; b6 O6; E T*+(/; V6 F6 7 =AA>: 6 b"$&G/+."-"&( 4"*+&$&56 JLR

S+",,6

R*2/+; e6; F*4*&(0..$; T6; E b$.)*+%,/&; N6 7<99W:6 XGG".(, /G -"+"41

4/.*4 ,1&(*.($. ./)"+"&." /& ,"&("&." 3+/.",,$&56 Q+:"(;0 +,

Z%1+"2 ;(& A;():;)%3 [5 7W:; Z88@Zd96

R*2/+; e6; E Q0(.)$&,; O6 7<99W:6 X#$%"&." G/+ ,"4G!/+5*&$P"% ,"&("&."

3+/.",,$&5Y N$55$&5 $& "GG".(,6 Q+:"(;0 +\ RS<M"'1M(-;0 D*29.+0+]2V

AM;"('(]3 ZM1+"23 T @+]('-'+(3 J5 7<:; WZ=@W896

R*&"&)*0,; J6 \6; O3$#"1!\&/K4(/&; J6 g6; X2"+)*+%; \6; E O"%$#1; g6

M6 7=AA8:6 L&("5+*($/& /G #$,0*4 *&% 4$&50$,($. $&G/+-*($/& $& ,3/U"&

4*&50*5" ./-3+")"&,$/&6 ^9'M(9MI 76_; =?Z<@=?ZW6

R*14/+; e6 B6 7=A8Z:6 V &"K (//4 G/+ -"*,0+$&5 +"*%*2$4$(16 Q+:"(;0'*1

P:;"-M"02I J5; W=86

?W