PROPERTY

1

3

Property Case OutlineProperty and Intellectual PropertyCase Outline 2 SR [SY 2015-2016]Atty. Melissa Romana P. Suarez

Title I. Classification of PropertyTopic Art.Case TitleCitationGRDate

Immovable Property415 Leung Yee v. Strong MachineryL-11658Feb 15, 1918

PRC, Inc. v. Jarque41506Mar 25, 1935

Berkenkotter v. Cu Unjieng61 P 66341643Jul 31, 1935

Davao Sawmill v. Castillo, 40411Aug 7, 1935

Machinery and Engineering v. CAL-7057Oct 29, 1954

Navarro v. Pineda L-18456Nov 30, 1963

Caltex v. CBAAL-50466May 31, 1982

Benguet Corp. v. CBAA10604Jan 29, 1993

Serg's Products v. PCI137705Aug 22, 2000

Soriano v. Galit156295Sep 23, 2003

JG Summit v. CA124293Jan 31, 2005

Movable Property416 Sibal vs. Valdez50 P 51226278Aug 4, 1927

Laurel v. Judge Abrogar155076Jan 13, 2009

Property in Relation to the Person to whom it belongs420City of Manila v. GarciaL-26053Feb 21, 1967

Republic v. Lat Vda. Del Castillo, L-69002Jun 30, 1988

Republic vs. Gonzales45338Jul 31, 1991

Republic v. CA, Morato100709Nov. 14, 1997

Chavez v. PEA133250Jul 9, 2002

Morandarte & Ferbrera v. CA123586Aug 12, 2004

Villarico v. Sarmiento136438Nov 11, 2004

Domalsin v. Valenciano158687Jan 25, 2006

MIAA v. CA155650Jul 20, 2006

PFDA v. CA150301Oct 2, 2007

PFDA v. CBAA178030Dec 15, 2010

MIAA v. City of Pasay163072Apr 2, 2009

City of Pasig v. RP185023Aug 24, 2011

Fernando v. Acuna161030Sep 14, 2011

RP v. City of Paraaque191109Jul 18, 2012

LBP v. Cacayuran191667Apr 17, 2013

Dream Village v. BCDA192986Jul 24, 2013

421422Cebu Oxygen v. Bercilles66 S 481L-40474Aug 29, 1975

Laurel v. Garcia187 S 79792013Jul 25, 1990

International Hardwood v. UP200 S 554Aug 30, 1991

Chavez v. PEA133250Jul 9, 2002

RP v. Barandiaran173819Nov 23, 2007

Heirs of Malabanan v. RP179987Apr 29, 2009

Title II. OwnershipLimitations

TopicArt.Case TitleCitationGR Date

Doctrine of Self Help429People v. NarvaezL-33466Apr 20,1983

Camarines Norte v. Quezon80796Oct 11, 2001

MWSS v. Act Theater147076Jun 17, 2004

UCPB v. Basco142688Aug 31, 2004

Villafuerte v. CA134239May 26, 2005

PB Com v. Trazo165500Aug 30, 2006

Right of the owner430Spouses Custodio v. CA253 S 483116100Feb 9, 1996

Aneco v. Landex165952Jul 28, 2008

Heirs of Limense v. De Ramos152319Oct. 28, 2009

434VSD Realty v. Uniwide170677Oct 24, 2012

Rights of Accession

TopicArt.Case TitleCitationGRDate

What owner owns437NPC v. Ibrahim 168732Jun 29, 2007

With Respect to what is Produced440-444Tacas v. Tobon 30240Aug 23, 1929

Bachrach Motor v. Talisay-Silay 35223Sep 17, 1931

Torbela v. Spouses Rosario140528Dec 7, 2011

With Respect to Immovable Property

445Bernardo v. Bataclan44606Nov 28, 1938

447Pacific Farms v. EsguerraL-21783Mar 25, 1970

Heirs of Orosa v. Migrino99338-40Feb 1, 1993

448Ignacio v. HilarioL-175Apr 30, 1946

Tayag v. Yuseco14043Apr 16, 1959

Ignao v. IAC72876Jan 18, 1991

Pecson v. CA115814May 26, 1995

Pleasantville Devt. Corp. v. CA79688Feb 1, 1996

Parilla v. Pilar167680Nov 30, 2006

Technogas v. CA108894Feb 10, 1997

RP v. Judge Ballocanag163794Nov 28, 2008

Sulo sa Nayon v. Nayong Pilipino170923Jan 20, 2009

Arangote v. Spouses Maglunob178906Feb 18, 2009

Cabang v. Basay180587Mar 20, 2009

Navarez v. Alciso165907Jul. 27, 2009

Tuatis v. Escol175399Oct. 27, 2009

Fuentes v. Roca178902Apr 21, 2010

Benedicto v. Villaflores185020Oct 6, 2010

Angeles v. Pascual157150Sep 21, 2011

Torbela v. Spouses Rosario140528Dec 7, 2011

Communities v. Nanol176791Nov 4, 2012

449-451Congregation RVM v. CA126363Jun 26, 1998

De Vera vs. CA97761Apr 14, 1999

Pada-KIlario v. CA134329Jan 19, 2000

Heirs Durano v. Uy136456Oct 24, 2000

Ravina v. Villa Abrille160708Oct 16, 2009

452454

Martinez v. Baganus9438Nov 25, 1914

Enriquez v. De Guzman28721Oct. 5, 1928

Geminiano v. CA120303Jul 24, 1996

Editha Alviola vs. CA117642Apr 24, 1998

Pada-Kilaro v. CA134329Jan. 19, 2000

457Grande v. CAL-17652Jun 30, 1962

Zapata v. Director of LandsL-17645Oct 30, 1962

Agne v. Director of LandsL-40399Feb 6, 1990

Agustin v. IAC66075-76Jul 5, 1990

Vda. De Nazareno v. CA98045Jun 26, 1996

Heirs of Navarro v. IAC68166Feb 12, 1997

Bagaipo v. CA116290Dec 8, 2000

Siain Enterprises v. FF Cruz146616Aug 31, 2006

New Regent v. Tanjuatco168880Apr 16, 2009

Office of City Mayor v. Ebio178411Jun. 23, 2010

RP v. Santos III160453Nov 12, 2012

458Government v. Colegio De San Jose53 P 423Aug 29, 1929

461Baes v. CA108065Jul 6, 1993

With Respect to Movable Property472Santos v. Bernabe31163Nov 6, 1929

474Aguirre v. PhengL-20851Sep 3, 1966

Quieting of Title476Sapto v. FabianaL-11285May 16, 1958

Bucton v. GabarL-36359Jan 31, 1974

Coronel v. IAC70191Oct 29, 1987

Fernandez v. CA83141Sep 21, 1990

Mamadsual v. Moson92557Sep 27, 1990

Pingol v. CA102909Sep 6, 1993

Heirs of Olviga v. CA104813Oct 21, 1993

Secuya v. Vda. De Selma136021Feb 22, 2000

Metrobank v. Alejo141970Sep 10, 2001

Portic v. Cristobal156171Apr 22, 2005

Calacala v. RP154415Jul 28, 2005

Bank of Commerce v. San Pablo167848Apr 27, 2007

Rico v. Rufon525 S 47704-1822Jun 25, 2007

Butuin v. Caoleng157567Aug 10, 2007

Tandog v. Macapagal144208Sep 11, 2007

Clado-Reyes v. Spouses Limpe163876Jul 9, 2008

Guaranteed Homes v. Heirs171531Jan 30, 2009

Lasquite v. Victory Hills175375Jun 23, 2009

Acosta v. Salazar161034Jun 30, 2009

Eland v. Garcia173289Feb 17, 2010

Philiville v. Bonifacio167391Jun 8, 2011

Title III. Co-ownership

TopicArt.Case TitleCitationGR Date

Definition484

Spouses Si v. CA122047Oct 12, 2000

Mercado-Fehr v. Fehr152716Oct 23, 2003

Ocampo v. Ocampo150707Apr 14, 2004

Sanchez v. CA152766Jan 20, 2003

Herrera v. Fangonil169356Aug 28, 2007

Balus v. Balus168970Jan 15, 2010

Pascual v. Ballesteros186269Feb 15, 2012

Shares in benefits and charges485Jimenez v. FernandezL-46364Apr 6, 1990

De Guia v. CA120864Oct 8, 2003

Mendoza v. CA199 S 778

Right to bring action for ejection487Punsalan v. Boon Liat44 P 32018009Jan 10, 1923

De Guia v. CA120864Oct 8, 2003

Wee v. De Castro 176405Aug 20, 2008

Plasabas v. CAMar 31, 2009

Right to reimbursement488Adille v. CAL-44546Jan 29, 1988

Aguilar v. CA 76351Oct 29, 1993

RA 4726 Condo Act490Sunset View v. CamposL-52361 Apr 27, 1981

Alteration491Javier v. Javier2812Oct 18, 1906

Rights regarding ideal share493Mercado v. LiwanagL-14429Jun 30, 1962

Acebedo v. Abesamis217 S 186

Bailon v. CA160 S 738

Sps. Cruz v. Leis125233Mar 9, 2000

Del Campo v. CA108228Feb 1, 2001

Sanchez v. CA152766Jun 20, 2003

Heirs of Balite v. Lim152168Dec 10, 2004

Metrobank v. Pascual163744Feb 29, 2008

Heirs of Co v. Gervacio157537Sep 7, 2011

Partition494Fabian v. Fabian22 S 520

Ceniza v. CA46345Jan 30, 1990

Bicarme v. CA51914Jun 6, 1990

Delima v. CA46296Sep 24, 1991

Arturio Trinidad v. CA118904Apr 20, 1998

Tomas Claudio v. CA124262Oct 12, 1999

Santos v. Santos139524Oct 12, 2000

Austria v. Lichauco170080Apr 4, 2007

Herrera v. Fangonil169356Aug 28, 2007

Monteroso v. CA105608Apr 30, 2008

Alano v. PDB171628Jun 13, 2011

Heirs of Co v. Servacio157537Sep 7, 2011

Rizal v. Naredo151898Mar 13, 2012

Essentially indivisible object498Aguilar v. CA76351Oct 29, 1993

Reyes v. Concepcion190 S 17156550Oct 1, 1990

Title IV. Some Special Properties WATERSArt.Case TitleCitationGRDate

Ownership of Waters502-503Republic v. Lat Vda. De CastilloL-69002Jan 30, 1988

Taleon v. Sec. of Public Works and CommunicationsL-24281May 16, 1967

RP v. Candymaker163766Jun 22, 2006

Filinvest v. Flood165955Aug 10, 2007

Fernando v. Acuna161030Sep 14, 2011

Use of Public Waters504-506Honorio Bulao v. CA, et al., 101983Feb 1, 1993