Public Meeting Agenda Region0 Rev54 AGENDA NO. 2573023-OSA DOCKET NO. P-2016-2573023 NAME AND SUBJECT: PECO ENERGY COMPANY On 10/26/16 a Prepay Petition was filed. By Opinion and Order

PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION

PUBLIC MEETING

THURSDAY, DECEMBER 19, 2019 (RY)

10:00 A.M.

MAIN HEARING ROOM NO. 1

SECOND FLOOR COMMONWEALTH KEYSTONE BUILDING

The Commission will act on various matters at today's meeting, which is open to the public.

However, since adequate forums have been made available for public participation in cases before

the Commission, there will be no opportunity for the public to address the Commission.

The attached agenda is complete at the time of issuance, but other items may be added, and

some stricken without further notice.

The listing of an item on the agenda does not necessarily mean that the Commission will take

final action on it at this meeting. When the Commission does take final action, its decision---except

on routine, uncontested tariff filings---will be put in writing and served on the interested parties and

made public at the time it is entered and served.

All public documents---such as orders, opinions, hearing transcripts, comments, initial and

recommended decisions, and the like---relating to items on the agenda, may be examined in the

Commission's File Room located in Room N-201, Second Floor, this Building.

The Commissioners seated on the bench are:

COMMISSIONER VICE CHAIRMAN CHAIRMAN COMMISSIONER COMMISSIONER

John F. Coleman, Jr David W. Sweet Gladys Brown Dutrieuille Andrew G. Place Ralph V. Yanora

THE TAKING OF PHOTOGRAPHS IS PERMITTED PROVIDED FLASH IS NOT USED.

The Next Public Meeting is Tentatively Scheduled for Thursday, January 16, 2020 at 10:00 A.M.

Minutes of the Meeting of Thursday, November 14, 2019 (DS)

***ANNOUNCEMENTS***

THE NEXT PUBLIC MEETING OF THE PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC UTILITY

COMMISSION IS SCHEDULED FOR THURSDAY JANUARY 16, 2020, AT 10:00 A.M. IN

HEARING ROOM #1, SECOND FLOOR, COMMONWEALTH KEYSTONE BUILDING, 400

NORTH STREET. AN AGENDA FOR PUBLIC MEETING WILL BE MADE AVAILABLE TO

ALL COMMISSIONERS AND INTERESTED PERSONS PRIOR TO THE PUBLIC MEETING.

THE COMMISSION WILL HOLD ITS NEXT EXECUTIVE SESSION ON WEDNESDAY,

JANUARY 15, 2020 AT 1:30 PM IN THE JR. EXECUTIVE CHAMBERS, THIRD FLOOR,

COMMONWEALTH KEYSTONE BUILDING.

THE COMMISSION'S AGENDA WILL BE LIMITED TO:

1. DISCUSSING PERSONNEL MATTERS.

2. CONSULTING WITH ITS LEGAL OR TECHNICAL STAFF REGARDING

INFORMATION AND STRATEGY IN CONNECTION WITH CURRENT OR

POTENTIAL LITIGATION.

3. DISCUSSING MATTERS RELATED TO THE INITIATION AND CONDUCT OF

INVESTIGATIONS, AND QUASI-JUDICIAL DELIBERATIONS.

4. REVIEWING LEGALLY PRIVILEGED OR CONFIDENTIAL MATTERS.

5. DISCUSSING COLLECTIVE BARGAINING ISSUES.

6. CONSIDERING THE PURCHASE OR LEASE OF REAL ESTATE.

AN AGENDA FOR THE EXECUTIVE SESSION WILL BE DISTRIBUTED TO ALL

COMMISSIONERS IN ADVANCE OF THIS SESSION. THIS NOTICE IS PROVIDED IN

ACCORDANCE WITH ACT 84 OF 1986, KNOWN AS THE SUNSHINE ACT.

******************

MOTIONS AND STATEMENTS OF THE CHAIRMAN

AND COMMISSIONERS WILL BE AVAILABLE

ON THE COMMISSION’S WEBSITE AT

WWW.PUC.PA.GOV AFTER PUBLIC MEETING.

******************

FOR YOUR SAFETY, PLEASE TAKE NOTE OF THE EXITS, DOWN THE STAIRS ON

EITHER SIDE OF THE HALLWAY OUTSIDE OF HEARING ROOM 1. IN A TRUE

EMERGENCY, A PUC EMPLOYEE IN AN ORANGE VEST WILL BE THERE TO HELP

THOSE WHO NEED ASSISTANCE. ONCE YOU MOVE DOWN THE STAIRS, PLEASE EXIT

ONTO NORTH STREET. ALSO, FOR YOUR CONVENIENCE, RESTROOMS ARE

LOCATED ON THE ATRIUM LEVEL NEAR THE CAFETERIA.

http://www.puc.pa.gov/

1


FINAL AGENDA

December 19, 2019

BUREAU OF AUDITS

AGENDA NO. 3007883-AUD

DOCKET NO. D-2019-3007883 D-2019-3007884 D-2019-3007885

NAME AND SUBJECT: CITIZENS ELECTRIC COMPANY, WELLSBORO ELECTRIC COMPANY

& VALLEY ENERGY INC

Management and Operations Audit. Citizens’ Electric Company, Wellsboro Electric Company, and Valley

Energy, Inc. companies has submitted an implementation plan dated 12/6/19, indicating acceptance of all 5

recommendations.

RECOMMENDATION: That the Commission release the Audit Report and Implementation Plan to the public.

Votes and Notes:

Chairman Dutrieuille YesVice Chairman Sweet YesCommissioner Place YesCommissioner Coleman YesCommissioner Yanora Yes

AGENDA NO. 3011328-AUD

DOCKET NO. D-2019-3011328

NAME AND SUBJECT: COLUMBIA WATER COMPANY

Management Efficiency Investigation (MEI) Evaluating the Implementation of Selected Recommendations

from the 2018 Focused Management and Operations Audit. Columbia Water Company (CWC) submitted an

Implementation Plan dated 11/26/19, indicating acceptance of all six recommendations. CWC indicated that it

plans to initiate implementation of the follow-up recommendations by the 3rd quarter of 2020.

RECOMMENDATION: That the Commission release the MEI report and Implementation Plan to the public.

Votes and Notes: 5-0Chairman Dutrieuille YesVice Chairman Sweet YesCommissioner Place YesCommissioner Coleman YesCommissioner Yanora Yes

5-0

2

OFFICE OF EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR

AGENDA NO. 3000261-DIR

DOCKET NO. M-2018-3000261

NAME AND SUBJECT: DAMAGE PREVENTION COMMITTEE APPOINTMENTS

On 10/30/17, Governor Wolf signed into law Act 50 of 2017, assigning duties and responsibilities associated

with Pennsylvania’s One Call System to the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission. The Commission is to

appoint thirteen (13) individuals to serve as members of the Damage Prevention Committee in accordance with

Section 7.8(a) of Act 50.

RECOMMENDATION: That the Commission adopt the prepared Order approving the appointments.


3

OFFICE OF SPECIAL ASSISTANTS

AGENDA NO. 1172824-OSA

DOCKET NO. A-00119379

NAME AND SUBJECT: CITY OF PITTSBURGH

On 11/4/02, the City of Pittsburgh (City) filed an application for the alteration of three bridges at Ridge

Avenue, West Ohio Street, and North Avenue in Allegheny County. On 8/21/06, the Commission approved the

Application and established deadlines for the City to file a final construction plan and for completion of work.

On 4/16/2019, the City filed a Petition for Extension of Time. PennDOT and Norfolk Southern Railway

Company filed Answers.

RECOMMENDATION: That the Commission adopt the proposed Opinion and Order.

Votes and Notes: YesChairman Dutrieuille YesVice Chairman Sweet YesCommissioner Place YesCommissioner Coleman YesCommissioner Yanora Yes


DOCKET NO. C-2016-2557487

NAME AND SUBJECT: ORPHEUS AND KIMBERLY HANLEY VS PENNSYLVANIA POWER

COMPANY

Formal Complaint filed on 7/19/16, disputing the proposed installation of a smart meter. On 8/9/16,

Pennsylvania Power Company (Penn Power) filed an Answer and New Matter denying the material allegations

of the Complaint and also filed Preliminary Objections. The Complainants filed a response to the Preliminary

Objections on 9/26/16. By Interim Order dated 7/25/17, ALJ Calvelli denied Penn Power’s Preliminary

Objections. An evidentiary hearing was held on 5/2/18. By Initial Decision issued on 11/2/18, ALJ Watson

dismissed the Complaint. On 1/7/19, the Complainants filed a Petition to Reopen the Record (Petition). Penn

Power filed an Answer to the Petition on 1/17/19.



4


DOCKET NO. P-2016-2573023

NAME AND SUBJECT: PECO ENERGY COMPANY

On 10/26/16 a Prepay Petition was filed. By Opinion and Order entered 6/18/19 (June 2019 Order) the

Commission granted, in part, and denied, in part, PECO’s Prepay Petition subject to PECO’s compliance with

certain terms and conditions as delineated therein. On 7/3/19, the Office of Consumer Advocate (OCA) filed its

Petition for Reconsideration, and the Coalition for Affordable Utility Services and Energy Efficiency in

Pennsylvania (CAUSE-PA) and Tenant Union Representative Network and Action Alliance of Senior Citizens

of Greater Philadelphia (TURN et al.) filed their Joint Petition for Reconsideration and/or Clarification

(collectively, the Petitions). The Petitions requested reconsideration and/or clarification of specified portions of

the June 2019 Order, regarding several pilot program components. On 7/11/19, the Commission granted the

Petitions pending further review of, and consideration on, the merits. PECO filed its Answer to the Petitions on

7/15/19.


Votes and Notes: 5-0Chairman Dutrieuille Yes - StatementVice Chairman Sweet YesCommissioner Place YesCommissioner Coleman YesCommissioner Yanora Yes


DOCKET NO. C-2017-2608014

NAME AND SUBJECT: CATHERINE LAMAGNA VS PENNSYLVANIA ELECTRIC COMPANY

Formal Complaint filed on 6/6/17 disputing the installation of a smart meter at her service address. On 6/26/17,

Penelec filed an Answer denying the material allegations in the Complaint. On 5/22/18, an evidentiary hearing

was held. On 11/19/18, the Commission issued ALJ Watson's Initial Decision (I.D.), which dismissed the

Complaint with prejudice. No Exceptions were filed. On 12/21/18, a Final Order (F.O.) was entered in this

proceeding, which adopted the (I.D.) without further action, pursuant to 66 Pa. C.S. § 332(h), dismissed the

Complaint with prejudice, and closed the docket. On 12/29/18, the Complainant filed a Petition for

Reconsideration of the F.O. On 1/11/19, Penelec filed an Answer in Opposition to the Petition for

Reconsideration.


Votes and Notes: 5-0Chairman Dutrieuille Yes

Vice Chairman Sweet YesCommissioner Place YesCommissioner Coleman YesCommissioner Yanora Yes

http://www.puc.pa.gov//pcdocs/1648114.pdf

5


DOCKET NO. C-2017-2617235

NAME AND SUBJECT: CARLA MATRUNICS VS WEST PENN POWER COMPANY

Formal Complaint filed on 8/2/17, alleging incorrect charges on her electric bill and requested a payment

arrangement. West Penn Power Company denied that there were incorrect charges. ALJ Johnson issued his

Initial Decision in which he dismissed the Complaint. The Complainant filed Exceptions and West Penn Power

Company filed Replies.





DOCKET NO. C-2017-2621285

NAME AND SUBJECT: ALAN SCHMUKLER VS PPL ELECTRIC UTILITIES CORPORATION

Formal Complaint filed on 8/11/17, seeking to prevent a smart meter installed at his home. On 10/16/17, PPL

filed an Answer with New Matter. Hearing was held on 3/9/18. The Initial Decision (I.D.) of ALJ Barnes,

issued 8/16/18, dismissed the Complaint. Exceptions filed by the Complainant on 8/28/18, and PPL on 9/5/18.

On 9/17/18, PPL filed Replies to Exceptions. The Commission’s Opinion and Order, entered 7/23/19,

dismissed the Complaint. On 7/29/19, the Complainant filed a Petition for Supersedeas of the 7/23/19 Order

pending his appeal of the 7/23/19 Order to Commonwealth Court On 8/14/19, the Complainant filed a Petition

for Review with Commonwealth Court and an Application for Supersedeas, docketed with the Court at 1102

CD 2019.



Vice Chairman Sweet YesCommissioner Place Yes, Concurring in Result OnlyCommissioner Coleman YesCommissioner Yanora Yes - Motion


6


DOCKET NO. R-2017-2632523 P-00930715F1000 C-2017-2633476

NAME AND SUBJECT: VERIZON PENNSYLVANIA LLC

Annual Price Change Opportunity (PCO) Filing was filed on 11/1/17, requesting an increase of $934,700,

along with associated tariff revisions to become effective 1/1/18. On 11/13/17, the Office of Small Business

Advocate (OSBA) filed a Complaint. On 11/27/18, Verizon PA filed an Answer to the Complaint. On

12/21/17, the Office of Consumer Advocate filed a Notice of Intervention and Public Statement. Also, on

12/21/17, the Commission entered an Order which assigned this proceeding to the Office of Administrative

Law Judge and permitted the PCO filing to go into effect, subject to refund. On 11/9/18, the Commission

issued the Initial Decision of Deputy Chief ALJ Cheskis and ALJ Calvelli, in which they recommended that

the OSBA’s Complaint be dismissed and that Verizon PA’s PCO remain in effect as filed. On 11/29/18, the

OSBA filed Exceptions. On 12/10/18, Verizon PA filed Reply Exceptions.




DOCKET NO. F-2017-2633420

NAME AND SUBJECT: D ANNE WILSON VS PECO ENERGY COMPANY

Petition for Reconsideration (Petition) of the 7/11/19 Opinion and Order was filed on 7/31/19. The

Commission granted reconsideration by Opinion and Order entered 8/8/19 to retain jurisdiction and review the

Petition on the merits.




7


DOCKET NO. C-2018-2644957

NAME AND SUBJECT: EVANGELINE HOFFMAN-LORAH VS PPL ELECTRIC UTILITIES

CORPORATION

Formal Complaint filed on 1/26/18, objecting to PPL’s proposed installation of a smart meter pursuant to

requirements of Act 129 and alleged, inter alia, that she had the ability to “opt-out” of installation of a smart

meter at her service property, that the universal installation of smart meters was, inter alia, in violation of the

Public Utility Code, and presented a health risk. Complainant further alleged fire safety concerns. The matter

was assigned to ALJ Barnes. Evidentiary proceedings were conducted. An I.D. was issued 11/15/18, in which

ALJ Barnes recommended that the Complaint be dismissed. Exceptions and Replies to Exceptions were filed

by the Parties. On 5/23/19, a final Order was entered denying the Exceptions and dismissing the Complaint. On

5/27/19 Complainant (pro se) filed a Petition seeking supersedeas. On 6/6/19, PPL filed an Answer.


Votes and Notes: 5-0Chairman Dutrieuille YesVice Chairman Sweet YesCommissioner Place YesCommissioner Coleman YesCommissioner Yanora Yes - Motion


DOCKET NO. C-2018-3000610

NAME AND SUBJECT: JANETTE LEE CURRY VS PHILADELPHIA GAS WORKS

Formal Complaint filed on 3/20/18, alleging incorrect charges on her utility bill issued by Philadelphia Gas

Works (PGW). On 4/11/18, PGW filed an Answer denying the material allegations of the Complaint. On

10/1/18, the Commission issued the Initial Decision of ALJ Jones. On 11/6/18, the Commission served the

Final Order that adopted the Initial Decision. On 12/4/18, Janette Lee-Curry (Petitioner) filed a Petition for

Rescission (Petition) of the Final Order of the Commission entered on 11/6/18. On 12/14/2018 PGW filed an

Answer in Opposition to the Petition.





8


DOCKET NO. F-2018-3001891

NAME AND SUBJECT: MICHAEL GUAGENTI VS PECO ENERGY COMPANY

Formal Complaint filed on 4/27/18 alleging a billing dispute with PECO. On 6/1/18, PECO filed an Answer

denying the material allegations of the Complaint. On 11/21/18, the Initial Decision of ALJ Heep was entered,

dismissing the Complaint. On 12/4/18 Complainant filed Exceptions. On 12/14/18, PECO filed Reply

Exceptions.





DOCKET NO. C-2018-3003337

NAME AND SUBJECT: NELSON HESS VS PPL ELECTRIC UTILITIES CORPORATION

Formal Complaint requesting that PPL be precluded from installing a smart meter on his residence for health,

safety, and privacy reasons. PPL filed an Answer to the Complaint on 7/31/18. An evidentiary hearing was

held on 5/14/19. By Initial Decision served on 6/17/19, ALJ Barnes dismissed the Complaint, finding that the

Complainant failed to satisfy his burden of proof. The Complainant filed Exceptions on 7/8/19 and PPL filed

Replies to Exceptions on 7/18/19.



9


DOCKET NO. C-2018-3005286

NAME AND SUBJECT: JUDITH BENVENGER VS PECO ENERGY COMPANY

Formal Complaint filed alleging that the utility is threatening to shut off service, that there are incorrect

charges on her bill and that she is having reliability, safety or quality problems with her service. On 10/31/18,

PECO filed an Answer to the Complaint and denying the material allegations. An evidentiary hearing

convened on 10/12/18, but the Complainant failed to appear for the hearing. In an Initial Decision, issued

3/8/19, ALJ Vero dismissed the Complaint for failure to prosecute. On 3/18/19, the Complainant filed

Exceptions. No Replies to Exceptions were filed.





DOCKET NO. F-2018-3006055

NAME AND SUBJECT: RONALD ANGLE JR C/O SHARON ANGLE VS METROPOLITAN EDISON

COMPANY

Formal Complaint filed on 11/15/18, on behalf of her son, Mr. Angle, alleging that her son did not have

ownership of the property where foreign load occurred (Service Address) and should not have been held

responsible for charges incurred by the tenants at the Service Address. On 12/6/18, Met Ed filed an Answer

and New Matter to the Complaint (Answer). and Preliminary Objections. On 2/8/19, the ALJ issued an Order

denying Met Ed’s Preliminary Objections and allowing the Complaint to move forward. On 7/30/19, the

Commission issued the Initial Decision of ALJ Guhl dismissing the Complaint. On 8/19/19, Ms. Angle filed

Exceptions. On 9/3/19, Met Ed filed Replies to Exceptions.




10


DOCKET NO. C-2018-3006401

NAME AND SUBJECT: BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION & ENFORCEMENT VS JOSEPH

LEVENTAN

On 5/14/18, the Commission issued a Certificate of Public Convenience to Joseph Leventan (Mr. Leventan) for

authority to transport property between points in Pa. On 12/14/18, The Commission’s Bureau of Investigation

and Enforcement (I&E) filed a Complaint against the Mr. Leventan, alleging failure to maintain cargo

insurance with the Commission. On 5/8/19, the Commission issued a Secretarial Letter cancelling Mr.

Leventan’s Certificate for failure to respond to the Complaint, and consequently, admitting to the allegations

therein. On 6/28/19, Mr. Leventan filed his Petition for Rescission of Staff Action.


Votes and Notes: 5-0Chairman Dutrieuille YesVice Chairman Sweet YesCommissioner Place Yes - MotionCommissioner Coleman YesCommissioner Yanora Yes


DOCKET NO. C-2019-3008807

NAME AND SUBJECT: BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION & ENFORCEMENT VS JOHN F FLUEHR

JR JOHN F FLUEHR III & THEODORE FLUEHR

Complaint filed on 3/29/19, alleging that John F. Fluehr Jr, John F. Fluehr III, & Theodore Fluehr, T/A John F.

Fluehr & Sons (Fluehr) failed to maintain evidence of insurance on file with the Commission. Bureau of

Investigation & Enforcement (BIE)requested a civil penalty of $500 for the alleged violation. Fluehr did not

file an Answer to the Complaint. By a Secretarial Letter issued on 7/02/19 (July 2019 Secretarial Letter), the

Commission found that the allegations in the Complaint were deemed admitted, and a $500 civil penalty was

assessed against Fluehr for failure to maintain evidence of insurance on file with the Commission. On 7/16/19,

Fluehr filed a Petition for Reconsideration of Staff Action (Petition) in response to the July 2019 Secretarial

Letter.




11


DOCKET NO. A-2019-3009244

NAME AND SUBJECT: LYTLE PROPERTY LLC

On 5/6/19 a letter request (Petition) was filed seeking reconsideration of the Commission Secretarial Letter

issued on 4/24/19, that denied and dismissed Lytle Property LLC (Applicant or Petitioner) Application for a

Certificate of Public Convenience (Certificate) authorizing it to operate as a transporter of household goods in

use based on the failure to provide evidence of a minimum of two-years’ experience with a licensed household

goods carrier as required by Commission Regulations. 52 Pa. Code §3.381(c)(1)(iii)(A)(II) (-l-). The Petition

was submitted pursuant to 52 Pa. Code § 5.44 and included documents proffered by the Applicant to establish

his experience.

RECOMMENDATION: That the Commission adopt the proposed Opinion and Order

Votes and Notes: 4-1Chairman Dutrieuille YesVice Chairman Sweet No - StatementCommissioner Place YesCommissioner Coleman YesCommissioner Yanora Yes - Motion


DOCKET NO. C-2019-3010073

NAME AND SUBJECT: DEBRA REID VS MILL CREEK MHP MANAGEMENT LLC

Formal Complaint filed on 5/22/19, alleging, inter alia, that Mill Creek was operating as a gas distribution

utility without a certificate of public convenience and was charging excessive rates to a development of 173

homeowners. On 6/11/19, Mill Creek filed an Answer and New Matter asserting status as a pipeline operator

over which the Commission would lack jurisdiction. On that same day, Mill Creek also filed Preliminary

Objections to dismiss the Complaint. ALJ Calvelli was assigned as motions judge and by Order of 8/12/19

denied the Preliminary Objections and set the matter for hearing. On 8/20/19, Mill Creek filed a Petition for

Interlocutory Review (Petition) of the Order. Consideration of the Petition was extended by Secretarial Letter

of 9/18/19. On 9/19/19, Ms. Reid and Mill Creek filed a Joint Petition to Withdraw the Complaint pursuant to

52 Pa. Code § 5.94.


Votes and Notes: 5-0Chairman Dutrieuille Yes - Motion





12


DOCKET NO. C-2019-3010414

NAME AND SUBJECT: TREASURE HOFFMAN VS PPL ELECTRIC UTILITIES CORPORATION

Formal Complaint filed on 6/5/19, averring that she did not want an electric AMI meter, or smart meter,

installed at her home due to, inter alia, health and privacy reasons. On 7/1/19, PPL filed an Answer, New

Matter and Preliminary Objections. On 7/10/19, Complainant filed her response to PPL’s Preliminary

Objections raising her own health concerns and an inadequate notice of AMI peter installation issue. On

8/16/19, the Commission served the Initial Decision of ALJ Barnes, in which the ALJ sustained PPL’s

Preliminary Objections and dismissed the Complaint. The Complainant filed Exceptions on 9/3/19, and PPL

filed Replies to Exceptions on 9/19/19.



Vice Chairman Sweet Yes

Commissioner Place YesCommissioner Coleman YesCommissioner Yanora Yes


DOCKET NO. A-2019-3010831

NAME AND SUBJECT: ORIENTAL CARE LLC

Application filed on 6/13/19, seeking the right to begin transporting, as a motor common carrier by motor

vehicle, persons in paratransit service, between points in Pa. On 11/5/19, the Commission issued a Secretarial

Letter in which it denied and dismissed the Application, due to the Applicant’s failure to file a tariff

establishing just and reasonable rates. On 11/15/19, the Applicant filed a Petition for Reconsideration of Staff

Action (Petition). No response to the Petition has been filed.



13

BUREAU OF TECHNICAL UTILITY SERVICES

AGENDA NO. 1184239-TUS

DOCKET NO. M-00031715F0004

NAME AND SUBJECT: METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY/PA ELECTRIC COMPANY

SUSTAINABLE ENERGY FUND

On 8/23/19 a Letter/Petition for approval of Mr. David E. Vollero to the Advisory Board.

RECOMMENDATION: That the Commission adopt the proposed Order.



DOCKET NO. A-2012-2320968

NAME AND SUBJECT: PENNDOT

Application of PennDOT for the approval to replace the existing overhead bridge on a new alignment where

SR 4019 (Leger Road) crosses over the tracks of Norfolk Southern Railway Company (DOT 507 917 Y) in

North Huntingdon Township, Westmoreland County and the allocation of costs incident thereto.


Votes and Notes: 5-0 Chairman Dutrieuille YesVice Chairman Sweet YesCommissioner Place YesCommissioner Coleman YesCommissioner Yanora Yes

14


DOCKET NO. A-2018-3000161

NAME AND SUBJECT: PENNDOT

Application of PennDOT for approval to alter the public above grade crossing where State Route 2094 crosses

the tracks of CSX Transportation Inc., DOT No 584 678J in the City of McKeesport, Allegheny County and

for approval of exemption from the minimum overheard and side clearance requirements of 52 Pa. Code

Section 33.121 and 33.122.




DOCKET NO. M-2019-3006865

NAME AND SUBJECT: ELECTRIC GENERATION SUPPLIER (EGS) LICENSE CANCELLATIONS

The Commission’s regulations at 52 Pa. Code §54.40(a) state that an EGS license will not be issued or remain

in force until the licensee furnishes a bond or other security approved by the Commission. 52 Pa. Code

§54.40(d) states that the maintenance of an EGS license is contingent on the licensee providing proof to the Commission that a bond or other approved security in the amount directed by the Commission has been obtained. ResCom Energy LLC, an EGS, is not in compliance with 52 Pa. Code §§54.40(a) and (d).

RECOMMENDATION: That the Commission adopt the proposed Final Order.



15


DOCKET NO. M-2019-3006865

NAME AND SUBJECT: ELECTRIC GENERATION SUPPLIER (EGS) LICENSE CANCELLATIONS

52 Pa. Code §54.40(d) states that the maintenance of an EGS license is contingent on the licensee providing

proof to the Commission that a bond or other approved security in the amount directed by the Commission has

been obtained. As of 12/10/19, companies listed in the Tentative Order are not in compliance with 52 Pa. Code

§54.40(a) and (d).

RECOMMENDATION: That the Commission adopt the proposed Tentative Order.




DOCKET NO. A-2019-3011913

NAME AND SUBJECT: SUMMER ENERGY MIDWEST LLC DBA SUMMER ENERGY

Application filed on 8/2/19, for the approval for a license to offer, render, furnish, or supply electricity or

electric generation services as a supplier to residential, small commercial, large commercial, industrial, and

governmental customers in all of the electric distribution company service territories within Pa.




16


DOCKET NO. A-2019-3012420

NAME AND SUBJECT: AVANGRID RENEWABLES LLC


electric generation services as a supplier to large commercial, industrial, and governmental customers, and

residential and small commercial customer classes (limited to mixed meter) in all of the electric distribution

company service territories within Pa.





DOCKET NO. A-2019-3012812

NAME AND SUBJECT: ALL AMERICAN POWER AND GAS PA LLC


electric generation services as a supplier to residential, small commercial, large commercial, industrial, and

governmental customers in the electric distribution company service territories of Citizens Electric of

Lewisburg, Duquesne Light, Met-Ed, PECO, Penelec, Penn Power, Pike County Light and Power, PPL, UGI,

and Wellsboro Electric within Pa.




17


DOCKET NO. A-2019-3013185

NAME AND SUBJECT: REGIONAL RESOURCES ENERGY GROUP LLC

Application filed on 9/26/19, for the approval to offer, render, furnish, or supply natural gas services as a

broker/marketer to small commercial, large commercial, industrial and governmental customers in the natural

gas distribution company service territories of Columbia Gas, NFGDC, PECO, Peoples Natural Gas, Peoples

Natural Gas - Equitable Division, Peoples Gas, PGW, UGI, and Valley Energy, within Pa.





DOCKET NO. A-2019-3013327

NAME AND SUBJECT: ELITE ENERGY SOLUTIONS LLC

Application filed on 10/4/19, for the approval for a license to offer, render, furnish or supply electricity or

electric generation services as a broker/marketer to residential, small commercial, and large commercial

customers in the electric distribution company service territories of Duquesne Light, Met-Ed, PECO, Penelec,

Penn Power, PPL, and West Penn Power within Pa.




18


DOCKET NO. R-2019-3013413 C-2019-3014433

NAME AND SUBJECT: HANCOCK TELEPHONE COMPANY

On 10/8/19, Supplement No. 70 to Tariff Telephone - PA P.U.C. No. 1 to become effective 1/1/20 was filed.

Supplement No. 70 proposed to increase rates for residential and business local exchange services by

approximately $3,240 annually. On 11/19/19, OSBA filed a Formal Complaint against Supplement No. 70.





DOCKET NO. A-2019-3013415

NAME AND SUBJECT: UNITED ENERGY TRADING LLC D/B/A KRATOS GAS & POWER


supplier to residential, small commercial, large commercial, industrial and governmental customers in the

natural gas distribution company service territories of Columbia Gas, NFGDC, PECO, Peoples Natural Gas,

Peoples Natural - Equitable Division, Peoples Gas, PGW, UGI, and Valley Energy, within Pa.




19


DOCKET NO. A-2019-3013423

NAME AND SUBJECT: CA GROUP USA INC


electric generation services as a broker/marketer to residential, small commercial, large commercial, industrial,

and governmental customers in all of the electric distribution company service territories within Pa.




DOCKET NO. A-2019-3013427

NAME AND SUBJECT: AQUA PENNSYLVANIA, INC.

Application filed on 10/8/19 for approval of the right to offer, render, furnish or supply water service to the

public in an additional portion of Honey Brook Township, Chester County, Pa.




20


DOCKET NO. A-2019-3013494

NAME AND SUBJECT: CA GROUP USA INC


broker/marketer to residential, small commercial, large commercial, industrial and governmental customers in

the natural gas distribution company service territories of Columbia Gas, NFGDC, PECO, Peoples Natural

Gas, Peoples Natural Gas - Equitable Division, Peoples Gas, PGW, UGI, and Valley Energy, within Pa.





DOCKET NO. A-2019-3013563

NAME AND SUBJECT: COLUMBIA GAS OF PENNSYLVANIA INC

Application filed on 10/15/19, seeking a Certificate of Public Convenience authorizing it to abandon natural

gas distribution service to one premises located in Fayette County. The Application was filed pursuant to

Section 1102(a)(2) of the Public Utility Code, 66 Pa. C.S. §1102(a)(2).




21


DOCKET NO. A-2019-3013696 G-2019-3013697

NAME AND SUBJECT: PECO ENERGY COMPANY

Application filed on 10/22/19, seeking approval for the future sale or acquisition of property under the

RESTORE Agreement and approval of the RESTORE Agreement as an Affiliated Interest Agreement. No

protests were filed, and no hearings were held.





DOCKET NO. A-2019-3013701

NAME AND SUBJECT: MANAGEMENT SERVICES PARTNERS LLC



and governmental customers in the electric distribution company service territories of Duquesne Light, Met-

Ed, PECO, Penelec, Penn Power, PPL, UGI, and West Penn Power within Pa.




22


DOCKET NO. A-2019-3013709

NAME AND SUBJECT: VANGUARD ENERGY SERVICES LLC


broker/marketer to small commercial, large commercial, industrial and governmental customers in the natural

gas distribution company service territories of Columbia Gas, NFGDC, PECO, Peoples Natural Gas, Peoples

Natural Gas - Equitable Division, Peoples Gas, PGW, UGI, and Valley Energy, within Pa.





DOCKET NO. S-2019-3014273

NAME AND SUBJECT: NORTH PENN LONG DISTANCE CORPORATION

Securities certificate of North Penn Long Distance Corporation filed on 12/12/19 with respect to the issuance

of a Term Loan of $6,997,807.





DOCKET NO. A-2019-3014305

NAME AND SUBJECT: EMEX LLC



and governmental customers in all of the electric distribution company service territories within Pa.




23

OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE

AGENDA NO. 1201777-ALJ DOCKET NO. A-00123148 A-2016-2581908

NAME AND SUBJECT: YORK RAILWAY COMPANY AND CSX TRANSPORTATION INC

On 9/27/06, York Railway filed an application in Docket No. A-00123148 requesting the Commission evaluate

and make a fair determination concerning railroad signal maintenance at the at-grade crossings where the

facilities of York and CSX cross Broadway Street in the Borough of Hanover, York County. On 12/29/16,

CSX filed an application in Docket No. A 2016-2581908 requesting the Commission abolish York’s crossing.

Prehearing conferences were held and both applications were consolidated. On 6/27/19, the parties filed a Joint

Stipulation of Facts and a Joint Petition for Settlement.

COMMISSION REVIEW: That the Commission adopt ALJ Calvelli’s Recommended Decision.


AGENDA NO. 2431005-ALJ DOCKET NO. P-2014-2431005

NAME AND SUBJECT: PENNSYLVANIA-AMERICAN WATER COMPANY - WASTEWATER

Petition for Approval of Modification of LTIIP filed on 12/12/18. OCA, Bureau of Investigation &

Enforcement and OSBA entered appearances. On 8/15/19, the parties filed a Joint Petition for Settlement. On

9/30/19, the parties filed a Joint Stipulation of Facts which was admitted into the record on 10/23/19.

COMMISSION REVIEW: That the Commission adopt the Recommended Decision of Deputy Chief ALJ

Cheskis and ALJ Calvelli.

Votes and Notes: 5-0Chairman Dutrieuille Yes - Joint Motion with Commissioner YanoraVice Chairman Sweet YesCommissioner Place Yes, Concurring in Result OnlyCommissioner Coleman YesCommissioner Yanora Yes - Joint Motion with Chairman Dutrieuille



24

AGENDA NO. 3009559-ALJ

DOCKET NO. R-2019-3009559 C-2019-3010191 C-2019-3009809 C-2019-3011775 C-2019-3012551 R-

2019-3009567 C-2019-3010186 C-2019-3009811 C-2019-3011776 C-2019-3012546

NAME AND SUBJECT: EATON SEWER & WATER COMPANY INC

Supplement No. 2 to Wastewater – PA P.U.C. No. 3 and Supplement No. 2 to Water – PA P.U.C. No. 3 were

filed on 4/29/19 . Complaints were filed in both rate case dockets. A Joint Petition for Settlement was filed on

10/1/19. Joining in the Settlement were Eaton, Bureau of Investigation & Enforcement, OCA and OSBA.

COMMISSION REVIEW: That the Commission adopt the Recommended Decision of ALJ Calvelli.




DOCKET NO. F-2019-3011348

NAME AND SUBJECT: ANTHONY STAFFORD VS PHILADELPHIA GAS WORKS

Formal Complaint filed on 7/2/19 seeking reenrollment in PGW’s customer assistance program or, in the

alternative, to be issued a payment arrangement by the Commission. PGW filed its answer on 7/25/19. A

hearing was held on 9/26/19.

COMMISSION REVIEW: That the Commission adopt the Initial Decision of Special Agent Alphonso Arnold,

III.



25


DOCKET NO. C-2019-3012075

NAME AND SUBJECT: BINGHUA HU VS PECO ENERGY COMPANY-ELECTRIC

Formal Complaint filed 8/8/19 alleging a billing dispute. PECO filed its answer on 8/16/19. A hearing was held

on 10/7/19.

COMMISSION REVIEW: That the Commission adopt the Initial Decision of ALJ Jones.




DOCKET NO. A-2019-3012241 G-2019-3013959 S-2019-3013938

NAME AND SUBJECT: VEOLIA ENERGY PHILADELPHIA INC

On 8/14/19, a Joint Application was filed seeking approval to transfer controlling interest in Veolia by the sale

of all the stock of Thermal North America and AIP Project Franklin Bidco. Petitions to intervene were filed.

On 11/4/19, the Joint Applicants, I&E, and OSBA filed a Joint Petition for Approval of Settlement. On

11/7/19, an evidentiary hearing was held.

COMMISSION REVIEW: That the Commission adopt ALJ Vero’s Recommended Decision.



1


Carry-In Agenda

December 19, 2019

OFFICE OF SPECIAL ASSISTANTS


DOCKET NO. C-2017-2620710

NAME AND SUBJECT: RICHARD N MYERS VS PPL ELECTRIC UTILITIES CORPORATION

On 9/3/19, a Petition for Supersedeas of the Final Opinion and Order (entered 8/29/19) was filed. The Petition

seeks to prevent installation of a smart meter at a service property pending disposition of an appeal (Petition for

Review No. 1337 C.D. 2019) with the Commonwealth Court. An Answer was filed by PPL on 9/26/19. On

12/2/19 the Commonwealth Court issued an Order directing the Commission to act within 30 days of Order.



Vice Chairman Sweet YesCommissioner Place YesCommissioner Coleman YesCommissioner Yanora Yes - Motion

1 of 3


BUREAU OF TECHNICAL UTILITY SERVICES


DOCKET NO. P-2017-2619834

NAME AND SUBJECT: UGI UTILITIES INC – ELECTRIC DIVISION

Petition for Approval to establish and implement a Distribution System Improvement Charge (DSIC) was filed

on 9/4/19. OCA and OSBA intervened in the case. On 11/12/19, UGI, OCA, and OSBA submitted a Joint

Petition for Settlement resolving all outstanding issues and recommending approval of the UGI DSIC Petition.





DOCKET NO. P-2019-3012337

NAME AND SUBJECT: UGI UTILITIES INC - GAS DIVISION

Petition for Approval of Second Long-Term Infrastructure Improvement Plan (LTIIP) was filed on 8/21/19. In

the Petition UGI proposes a further acceleration of its infrastructure improvements. On 9/23/19, OCA filed

Comments.



Vice Chairman Sweet YesCommissioner Place Yes - StatementCommissioner Coleman YesCommissioner Yanora Yes

2 of 3


3 of 3

LAW BUREAU

AGENDA NO. 3006868-LAW

DOCKET NO. M-2019-3006868

NAME AND SUBJECT: ACT 129 TOTAL RESOURCE COST (TRC) TEST

The Commission is required to analyze the benefits and costs of Energy Efficiency and Conservation (EE&C)

Plans that electric distribution companies (EDCs) are required to file pursuant to 66 Pa. C.S. § 2806.1. The

Commission uses a TRC Test to analyze the EE&C Plans. A proposed 2021 TRC Test was proposed for

stakeholder comment. This Final Order establishes the 2021 TRC Test for use if the Commission determines

that there will be a Phase IV set of EE&C Plans.




Documents

Public Meeting Agenda Region0 Rev54 AGENDA NO. 2573023-OSA DOCKET NO. P-2016-2573023 NAME AND SUBJECT: PECO ENERGY COMPANY On 10/26/16 a Prepay Petition was filed. By Opinion and Order