Purdue University – Emerging Green v016 Final

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    1/21

    T e a m 1 P A S T E W r i t e r sG r e g R u s h , B r a n d o n G a r d n e r , M a r c T r o m b e t t a , A a r o n C o p e l a n dE n g l i s h 4 2 1 T e c h n i c a l W r i t i n gP r o f e s s o r F r a n c i s T o b i e n n e , J r .

    A White Paper

    Summer

    10

    Purdue University Emerging Green

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    2/21

    PURDUEUNIVERSITYEMERGINGGREEN 2

    Table of ContentsExecutive Summary ................................................................... 3Wade Power Initiative ................................................................ 3Overview ..................................................................................................................... 3

    New Coal Boilers.......................................................................................................... 4

    Opposition .................................................................................................................. 5

    Wade Energy Saving Tips ............................................................................................. 5

    Purdues Strategic Plan .............................................................. 6Overview ..................................................................................................................... 6

    Site Considerations...................................................................................................... 6

    Water Resources .......................................................................................................... 7Built Environment ........................................................................................................ 7

    Materials Management................................................................................................. 8

    Food Systems .............................................................................................................. 8

    Academics and Research ............................................................................................. 9

    Community Relationships ............................................................................................ 9

    Big Ten. Measuring Up............................................................... 9Table 1 Comparison .................................................................................................. 11

    Administration ....................................................................................................... 11

    Climate Change and Energy.................................................................................... 11Food and Recycling ................................................................................................ 12

    Green Building ....................................................................................................... 13

    Student Involvement .............................................................................................. 13

    Transportation ....................................................................................................... 13

    Endowment Transparency ...................................................................................... 14

    Investment Priorities .............................................................................................. 14

    Shareholder Engagement........................................................................................ 14

    Table 2 Comparisons................................................................................................. 14

    AnnotatedBibliography ........................................................... 16Appendix ............................................................................... 19An interview with Robin Ridgway, 16 July 2010.......................................................... 19

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    3/21

    PURDUEUNIVERSITYEMERGINGGREEN 3

    Executive Summary There are many reasons that a lot of the world has been pursuing this

    ever-changing definition of going green. The most prevalent reason is to

    preserve our planet and its function to mankind. With the definition of green

    changing with advancements of new green technologies, it is difficult to

    measure ones efforts toward this goal. A culture can use ethnocentrism, using

    ones self for a measuring stick, to evaluate their efforts or a cultural could

    compare their efforts to another cultural. In this white paper, we will explorehow Purdue University compares to others in the university culture in America.

    We will give examples of Purdues efforts toward sustainability and also dive

    into how Purdue plans to continue its efforts toward leading the way with green

    standards. A contrast to how Purdue compares to other Big Ten schools, as well

    as a brief history of how Purdues green report card grade has changed over the

    last four years is also discussed.

    Wade Power Initiative

    OverviewPurdue Universitys current

    power source is generated from Wade

    Power Plant in West Lafayette. The

    power plant has three boilers that are

    coal-fired and one boiler that is

    gas/oil fired as a backup. The boilers

    that use Indiana coal used about

    66,937 tons of high-sulfur coal,

    101,113 tons of low-sulfur coal, and

    11,647 tons of limestone in 2009,

    while the gas-fired boiler used about

    2,805,600 Therms of natural gas. All

    these fuels came out to a cost of

    about $3.10/Mbtu. The coal is

    delivered by a truck and is dumped

    onto a conveyor belt or bucketelevator system at the Wade Power

    Plant. The designed transport capacity

    is 100 ton/hr for each handling

    system. All of these boilers generate

    steam for two steam driven turbines,

    ExecutiveSummary

    Wade PowerInitiative

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    4/21

    PURDUEUNIVERSITYEMERGINGGREEN 4

    and one diesel engine to generate

    electricity to Purdue University while

    also heating and cooling the campus

    in the winter and summer months.

    The power plant can generate 40 MWusing three generators, 39 MW using

    one turbine generator, 10MW with one

    other turbine generator, and 1.75 MW

    using a diesel generator as a backup.

    Wade Power Plant also contains nine

    centrifugal chillers, four turbine driven

    chillers, and five electric driven

    chillers for Purdues own refrigeration

    system. Purdue has a constant

    demand for chilled water all year for

    cooling process and environmental

    control systems. The heat rejection

    load for summer cooling comes out to

    around 26,900 ton-hr while a total of

    90,104,767 ton-hr of cooling is

    produced.

    New Coal BoilersPurdues current sustainability director

    Robin Ridgway is currently working on

    a project that involves the installation

    of new clean coal burning boilers that

    contain fluidized beds and one more

    natural gas-fired

    boiler to replace one

    of the 50 year old

    boilers. This project is

    to help reduce the

    amount of impact

    Purdue causes to the

    environment. These

    new boiler additions

    will reduce the

    amount of carbon

    emissions from 43%to 90%. The budget

    for the two new clean

    coal boilers comes out to about $60

    million, which is sourced from

    students tuition and fees.

    Purdue University boilers

    generate around 25,000 to 30,000

    tons of ashfrom the burning of coal.

    There are two kinds of waste that are

    produced fromcoal-fired boilers. The

    first type is called fly ash, and

    comprises 80% of the ash captured,

    http://www.purdue.edu/utilityplant/plantoperation.htmFigure 1 Wade Power Plant Boiler Process Diagram

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    5/21

    PURDUEUNIVERSITYEMERGINGGREEN 5

    which is generally captured by

    pollution control equipment in

    chimneysof the power plant. This coal

    waste is usually disposed of in

    landfills. In recentyears coal waste hasbeen used for other purposes and not

    just disposed of. Itcan be used in

    construction fill, dry wall, cement, and

    mine reclamation and isalso used in

    agricultural processes such as helping

    soil to hold water. Thiswaste can also

    be used to remove snow and ice on

    roads when used with salt. The second

    type of waste is bottom ash, and

    comprises the remaining 20% of

    captured material. This coal waste is a

    granular byproduct of coal and is

    usuallyretrieved from the bottom of

    coal furnaces. Some other uses for

    bottom ashare similar to the uses of

    fly ash, but bottom ash is commonly

    used as an element ofasphalt.

    OppositionMany environmental organizations do

    not like the idea of continuing to use

    coal-fired boilers. The Sierra Club, a

    grassroots environment organization

    in the United States, feels that Purdue

    should be using alternative energy

    sources to power the campus of

    Purdue University. They claim that

    while these new boilers are cleaner

    they still release toxic chemicals,

    hazardous carcinogens, and heavy

    metals into the environment. Purdue is

    known for their research of alternative

    energy sources, and should consider

    using this research in geothermal,

    wind, or solar energies to power itscampus. Purdue University says that it

    is too invested in coal power that it

    really isnt financially feasible for them

    to completely switch over to an

    alternative energy source. It would

    cost too much money to completely

    replace the previous power system

    with a new one without drastically

    raising the cost of tuition for Purdue

    University students. Purdue believes

    that they are still doing what they can

    to help the environment by using

    clean coal boilers to reduce a good

    amount of the emissions released out

    into the environment.

    Wade Energy Saving TipsPurdue offers many suggestions to

    save energy and money for those

    exploring the Wade Utility Plant web

    site. This is a reflection upon Purdue

    to perform a small amount of

    education on energy conservation to

    the general public. One of their first

    suggestions is to make sure doors and

    windows are kept closed to reduce the

    amount of energy lost to the

    environment. It is important not to

    change the thermostats often and

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    6/21

    PURDUEUNIVERSITYEMERGINGGREEN 6

    keep them at constant temperatures in

    the winter and summer months. In the

    winter it is recommended to leave the

    thermostat at around 68 to 70

    degrees Fahrenheit and 74 to 76degrees Fahrenheit in the summer. If

    the window blinds are closed in the

    summer the room will stay cooler and

    in the winter the window blinds should

    be kept open to allow sunlight in to

    warm the room. Lights should be shut

    off if there is enough natural light to

    do work and they should also be off if

    the room or building is not being

    used. One last thing to remember is to

    conserve water, use it only when

    needed and do not leave it running

    when it is not being used. These small

    things can greatly reduce the amount

    of energy used each year.

    Purdues Strategic Plan

    OverviewThe Purdue University

    Sustainability Strategic Plan was

    developed in January of 2010 and

    presented on Earth Day of the same

    year. It highlights future plans and

    ideas the university has determined it

    needs in order to go green. In the

    plan, eight sustainability program

    areas are enumerated that give brief

    details about current university

    policies as well as opportunities for

    the university to improve its

    environmental awareness. The latter,the opportunities, are an integral part

    of Purdues mission to remain a

    recognized leader among its peer

    universities and a proud example of

    commitment to the world and its

    environment. Seven of the areas are as

    follows: Site Considerations, Water

    Resources, Built Environment,

    Materials Management, Food Systems,

    Academics and Research, and

    Community Relationships.

    (Endowment and Development is

    omitted) The following will highlight

    the contributions likely to have the

    greatest effect on the sustainability of

    the university.

    Site ConsiderationsSite Considerations reflects upon the

    land owned by the university, how it is

    used and occupied, and how it has

    developed. This is a rather broad topic

    and focuses mainly on the elements of

    campus immediately visible to thepublic. One large concern is

    transportation on campus. According

    to the sustainability plan, a

    transportation demand management

    study is currently underway studying

    PurduesStrategic Plan

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    7/21

    PURDUEUNIVERSITYEMERGINGGREEN 7

    bicycle paths, bicycle use, and how to

    integrate the system with the

    Lafayettes shared-use trail system.

    The use of bicycles is an important

    means of transportation and iscausing the demand for racks to lock

    bicycles to increase. Protecting the

    open space west of campus is also a

    concern that was addressed, and was

    made realizable by the suggestion to

    increase the Universitys density on

    the currently developed footprint.

    Transit to and from the university is

    also a concern. Evident concerns

    include mass transit incentives and

    the expansion of alternative transit

    systems. Also important to Purdues

    somewhat spread out campus is the

    identification of a central loop for

    bus routes, which is currently

    underway. Another mentioned project

    suggests converting Purdues airport

    runway light fixtures with LED

    replacements that will consume

    seventy-five percent less power than

    the current fixtures and historically

    require much less maintenance.

    Reportedly, all of the funding may be

    subsidized by the federal government.

    Water ResourcesWater resources refer mainly to the

    water availability, water usage by

    buildings, and the irrigation system

    utilized by Purdue University. One of

    the concerns relating to the irrigation

    system is that approximately fifty

    percent of the current irrigation

    system would benefit from upgradesto a smart irrigation system. Such a

    system would use sensors and

    environment data to maximize the

    efficiency of the system by reducing

    waste by means of enhancing soil-

    water retainment. The strategic plan

    also suggested developing minimum

    flush and flowing guidelines for all

    water-using fixtures in dormitories

    and university buildings.

    Built EnvironmentThe built environment primarily

    details all university buildings and

    their energy use. It also briefly covers

    the Wade Utility Plant, which sourcesmost of that energy. The utility plant

    currently houses four generators and

    a circulating fluidized bed boiler (a

    clean coal boiler) that produces an

    average of sixty percent of Purdues

    electricity. One of the less efficient

    boilers is currently being replaced with

    a second fluidized bed boiler to makethe plant more environmentally

    friendly. The plant also has plans to

    become certified as a high-efficiency

    system, similar to an Energy Star

    rating. The Strategic Plan discusses

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    8/21

    PURDUEUNIVERSITYEMERGINGGREEN 8

    details about a Krannert student

    group that conducted a business

    analysis and found that if railroad ties

    were used as an added fuel, a second

    fuels feed system that costs $2 millioncould pay itself off in two years,

    suggesting a $1 million per year

    savings after the initial two-year

    period. The university is also currently

    in the second year of retro-

    commissioning of buildings aimed to

    reduce energy usage, and more

    recently water usage. Also of note,

    many air-conditioning and heating

    systems are being analyzed and

    retuned for greater efficiency. A

    process is already in place for

    replacing residence halls

    showerheads and faucets for

    substitutes that use thirty to seventy

    percent less water. It is planned for

    the future that most exterior lighting

    projects as well as some interior

    lighting projects will use lower energy

    LEDs. Mann Hall, as well as other

    university buildings, is also being

    evaluated for possible green roof

    installations similar to that atop

    Schleman Hall. A number of wind

    turbines for the generation ofelectricity have also been proposed

    including one at the Animal Sciences

    Research and Education Center that,

    according to data collected, could

    provide ten to twenty megawatts of

    power. That is approximately half of

    the peak demand of the Purdue

    campus. This wind turbine combined

    with Wades power output capabilities

    could provide power to 100% ofcampus.

    Materials ManagementMaterials management refers mainly

    to the use and disposal of any waste

    products. The recycling program

    recently implemented by the university

    is a primary concern of the document.

    Also mentioned is reviving a recycling

    application of the Wade Utility Plant,

    using coal ash for compost

    enhancement and sludge stabilization

    as well as other uses. The storage and

    tracking of chemical waste is also a

    recurring subject. Improving research

    lab practices and chemical sourcereduction and substitution are

    suggested to help this.

    Food SystemsThe food systems category covers the

    procurement, use, and waste of food

    and food-related items used by the

    university. The primary concern is the

    compost generated by the university.

    It is proposed that a grinder costing

    $50,000 would allow food preparation

    waste to be diverted to the wastewater

    treatment facility. It is also suggested

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    9/21

    PURDUEUNIVERSITYEMERGINGGREEN 9

    that the university collaborate with

    other organizations with which it does

    business to reduce the waste of the

    products of these other organizations.

    Academics and ResearchAcademics and research involves

    both the students and the faculty of

    Purdue University in contributing to

    the universitys environmental

    awareness. The document points to

    introductory engineering courses and

    the fact that these courses introduce

    sustainability and problem solving

    associated with sustainability to

    incoming engineers. It also points out

    a need for classes that promote

    sustainability awareness. Making it

    easier for faculty to sponsor such

    learning is also suggested. At the very

    least, a formalized process forkeeping an accurate list of courses

    was suggested that covers

    sustainability at several levels so that

    interested students may participate.

    Community RelationshipsThe community relationships portion

    discusses Purdues outreach to the

    surrounding community with a

    sustainability goal in mind. Currently

    one student internship is availability

    with Purdue University in Sustainability

    that is a ten-hour per week

    commitment. It is proposed that

    Purdue follow Indiana Universitys

    example and fund several

    Sustainability internships for students.

    In addition, it suggested that theDepartment of Sustainability at Purdue

    employ graduate students as research

    assistants. A household hazardous

    waste program, now defunct, could

    also be restarted, allowing community

    members a safe place to dispose of

    potentially dangerous, hard-to-

    dispose-of items. This area is

    important to Purdue. It is pointed out

    because of its role as an advisor to the

    state of Indiana through the

    Cooperative Extension Services.

    Big Ten. Measuring UpOverview

    When considering the

    contributions and efforts of a college

    or university to sustainability, a

    measurable means in which to gauge

    an institution is needed. A grading

    system to apply to educational

    institutions would be nice to have to

    see if they were meeting the needs of

    the present without sacrificing the

    ability of future generations to meet

    Big Ten.Measuring Up

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    10/21

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    11/21

    PURDUEUNIVERSITYEMERGINGGREEN 11

    Table 1 ComparisonAdministrationThe College Sustainability Report

    Card was used to create a couple of

    tables to examine how Purdue has

    performed against other Big Ten

    schools as well as other Indiana

    college institutions. Table 1 compares

    the grades of the Big Ten schools. As

    shown, Purdue University and

    Northwestern University both got the

    lowest grades (C) in theAdministration category (green

    report). Purdues Office of

    Sustainability was created in 2009,

    and employees three full-time

    staffers. Therefore, it is a relatively

    new organization. Northwestern

    University indicated that they do not

    have an Office of Campus

    Sustainability. According to the report

    card, there are some areas thatindicated why Purdue obtained such a

    low grade. In the survey, Purdue

    indicated that it does

    not have a formal

    purchasing survey

    (green report). The

    survey also indicated

    that Purdue had not

    signed the Talloires

    Declaration, which is a

    ten-point action plan

    for incorporating

    sustainability and

    environmental literacy

    in teaching, research,

    operations and

    outreach at colleges

    and universities.

    Another reason for a

    low mark could be

    because Purdues president had not

    yet signed the American College and

    University Presidents Climate

    Commitment.

    Climate Change and EnergyIn the area of Climate Change and

    Energy, Purdue also got average marks

    with a C in the Green Report Card.

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    12/21

    PURDUEUNIVERSITYEMERGINGGREEN 12

    Purdue was in the same arena with

    Northwestern University and the

    University of Wisconsin for this

    mediocre grade. Purdue has a few

    areas that shined in the survey reportthough. For instance, Purdue retro-

    commissioned three buildings on

    campus last year and are currently in

    the process of retro-commissioning

    three additional buildings. Purdue is

    also currently reviewing their

    programming code (sequences of

    operation) for HVAC systems in

    sixteen buildings to analyze if

    opportunities exist to improve system

    efficiencies. Utilizing an outside

    vendor to review the actual

    performance of three additional

    buildings to identify deficiencies in the

    current operation is something being

    accomplished for future development.

    Purdue University is also adjusting

    HVAC system operation to correspond

    with actual occupancy periods through

    equipment scheduling programs and

    night setback/up algorithms. Some

    issues with the report indicate that

    Purdue University has not made a

    commitment to reduce green house

    gasses by any specific amount. Purduehas conducted a study though to

    determine its carbon footprint, and

    will utilize this in the future as an

    initiative to create a green house gas

    emission inventory. In comparison, the

    University of Wisconsin has reduced

    73,000 tons of CO2 emissions since

    April 2006 as the result of

    conservation measures (53,000 tons)

    and switching 28% of the heatingplants fuel source from coal to natural

    gas (20,000 tons) (green report).

    Food and RecyclingIn the Food and Recycling category,

    Purdue received a grade of B. This is

    an average score with all Big Ten

    schools being in the A to B range. The

    Food category is not specified in the

    survey, so specific information about

    it is not available. Having a tray-less

    day in the dining facilities is

    mentioned. In the recycling program

    though, Purdue boasts that 100% of

    its landscaping is composted or

    mulched, 396 pounds of batterieswere recycled along with 1,361

    computer monitors and 26,000

    fluorescent lamps. When comparing

    the Rate of Waste Diversion, Purdue

    ranks in the middle on average at 34%.

    Michigan State reflected the lowest

    rate at only 16% while Penn State and

    Illinois University ranked the highest

    at 53% and 50% respectively (Big Ten

    24).

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    13/21

    PURDUEUNIVERSITYEMERGINGGREEN 13

    Green BuildingIn the category of Green Building,

    Purdue received a grade of D, which

    was the lowest of any listed Big Ten

    school. According to the EPA;buildings account for 68% of total

    electricity consumption, 12% of total

    water consumption, 38% of carbon

    emissions, and 39% of total energy

    consumption (Big Ten 7). Therefore,

    having green buildings is an important

    aspect of a schools overall grade. A

    building is considered green if it has

    inherited that definition through

    design, construction, or operation.

    Purdue University does not actually

    have any buildings that meet the

    criteria to be considered LEED

    (Leadership in Energy and

    Environmental Design) certified on its

    campus. This finding is the largest

    reason that Purdue received such a

    low score. This score should improve

    on the 2011 college green report card

    because Purdue is currently under

    construction on the Gatewood wing to

    the Mechanical Engineering Building,

    and it is registered to be LEED

    certified. In comparison, the University

    of Minnesota decided to create thefirst LEED certified football stadium in

    the country and Indiana University had

    11 LEED building projects underway in

    2009 (Big Ten 8).

    Student InvolvementStudent Involvement was a category

    that Purdue performed fairly well in.

    Purdue received a B in this category,

    with the University of Iowa and theUniversity of Wisconsin getting a C

    (green report). Purdue has several

    student organizations that reflect a

    large amount of student involvement.

    Greenreportcard.com reported in its

    published survey that Purdue

    mentioned Boiler Green Initiative (BGI),

    Net Impact, Purdue Air & Waste

    Management Association (PAWMA),

    Purdue Green Build, Purdue Energy

    Club, and PUGWASH as student

    organizations on campus.

    TransportationIn the Transportation category,

    received a grade of B, which was nottoo bad. Purdue reported in the 2010

    greenreportcard.com survey that they

    have 178 vehicles in their fleet with 28

    being hybrid, 9 being biodiesel, 2

    being smart cars, and 114 being flex

    fuel capable. Ohio State reported 996

    vehicles in their fleet, which seems

    extremely high compared to Purdue.

    Of that inventory, 13 are hybrids, 12

    are electric, and 124 are biodiesel.

    Purdue offers free transportation

    around campus to students and staff

    utilizing City Bus. This service reduces

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    14/21

    PURDUEUNIVERSITYEMERGINGGREEN 14

    the overall green house consumption

    of those who would drive individually.

    Endowment TransparencyIn the category of Endowment

    Transparency, greenreportcard.com

    gave Purdue University a grade of A.

    Although no specific information is

    listed, the web site mentions that,

    With the exception of information

    exempt from public open record law

    by Indiana statute, a list of all

    holdings and a list of votes cast on

    proxy resolutions on a company-

    specific level, including the number of

    shares, are made available to the

    public and sent to individuals per a

    public record request. In contrast, the

    University of Iowa received an F

    because the university makes neither a

    list of endowment holdings nor itsshareholder voting record public.

    Investment PrioritiesAn A was the grade that was given to

    Purdue for the Investment Priorities

    category. Purdue University aims to

    optimize investment return and is

    currently invested in renewable energyfunds. Some of Purdues Endowment

    investment managers invest in clean

    energy, alternative fuels, and

    renewable energy funds. All the Big

    Ten schools received an A or B in this

    category except for the University of

    Illinois. Although the University of

    Illinois foundation aims to optimize

    investment return, it does not invest

    in renewable energy funds.

    Shareholder EngagementIn the Shareholder Engagement

    category, the majority of the Big Ten

    schools received Ds and Fs. The

    University of Minnesota is the only

    school that received an A in this

    category. At the University of

    Minnesota, the Social Concerns

    Committee annually reviews and

    recommends votes for shareholder

    resolutions concerning social issues

    for which the university holds stock.

    Table 2 ComparisonsTable 2 shows Purdues green report

    card from 2007 to 2010 (green

    report). This table reflects several

    things. The most obvious item that is

    noticed is that there is information

    that is missing. There are several

    reasons for this. First of all, there is

    currently more pressure for colleges

    and universities to report in multiple

    categories that may not have been

    particularly established yet. As

    colleges have evolved in the green

    arena, the desire to have measurable

    results has increased. It is also

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    15/21

    PURDUEUNIVERSITYEMERGINGGREEN 15

    possible that the development of

    green initiatives was in its infancy, and

    more time was needed to procure the

    necessary data. Table 2 is also an

    indicator of how Purdue has changedthrough the years. As can be seen,

    Purdues overall grade went from a C

    in the first two years, to a B- in the

    last two years of 2009 and 2010.

    Purdue has also shown growth in the

    categories of Administration, Food

    and Recycling, Student Involvement,

    Transportation, Shareholder

    Engagement, and Endowment

    Transparency (since 2008). Also, note

    that the Climate Change and Energy

    category grade has not changed in

    four years. Unfortunately, this table

    also reflects that Purdue University has

    dropped from a C to a D in the GreenBuilding category. It would be

    expected that once Purdue finishes up

    its current studies and the

    construction to the Mechanical

    Engineering wing is complete,

    Purdues score in this category should

    improve and better support its overall

    score.

    2010 B- C C B D B B A A D

    2009 B- C C B C C B A A D

    2008 C C C B C -- C C A FPurdue University

    2007 C D C C D -- -- A A F

    Table 2 Purdues 2007-2010 green report card

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    16/21

    PURDUEUNIVERSITYEMERGINGGREEN 16

    AnnotatedBibliography

    Boren, Eric, and Brown, Graham, and Flores, Nicole, and Gondalia,Rahul, and Haven, Celia, and King, Jillian, and McMullen-Laird,Lydia. Big Ten Sustainabilty Report. University of Illinios. Web 12July, 2010http://sustainability.illinois.edu/BigTenSustainabilityReport.pdf This report documented the comparison of Big Ten conference schools. The

    following categories were discussed: administration, infrastructure, energy use,

    transportation, recycling, and food. The goal of this report was to highlight the

    efforts that are already happening at each school while encouraging

    collaboration and friendly competition to accelerate sustainability initiatives. It

    will be used to elaborate on how Purdue compares to the other Big Ten schools

    in our paper.

    Gateway building on its way to LEED certificat ion; InsidePurdue 27August 2009: 10. Print.This article is about the new addition to the Mechanical Engineering Building at

    Purdue becoming the first LEED certified building on campus. It mentions the

    standards the building must meet and the steps it takes to become LEED

    certified. This will be used in the writing of our white paper to show the

    necessary steps Purdue University is taking to become "green." The Mechanical

    Building will also provide us with a good example of Purdue's intentions for

    "going green."

    AnnotatedBibliography

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    17/21

    PURDUEUNIVERSITYEMERGINGGREEN 17

    Leedy, Aaron. Some 'fired-up' over PU coal power. WLFI. July 6,2010. Web. May 11, 2010.http://www.wlfi.com/dpp/news/local/some-fired-up-overcoalpower

    This describes the frustration of environmental organizations with PurdueUniversity's decision to replace coal-fired boilers with clean coal technology

    boilers and a natural gas boiler. The Sierra Club Student Organizer thinks that

    Purdue should use Geo-thermal, wind, and solar technology rather than the

    clean coal technology boilers. The Vice President of Physical Facilities at Purdue

    believes that Purdue should consider looking into these alternative energy

    sources but right now they are invested in using coal as a source of power. This

    article provides information that can be used for our white paper about

    Purdue's plan to improve their heating and cooling systems even though

    organizations don't think they are doing enough.

    Purdue Sustainability Strategic Plan Report. Collaborative ProjectConsulting.25 January 2010.

    This report documents the results of the Purdue Sustainability Strategic Plan

    development process through January 2010. This report provides percentages

    of headlines in the sustainability program areas as well as brief comparisons topeer colleges and universities. The College Sustainability Report Card was used

    as a basis for comparison. It also provides some Wade Utility Plant statistics.

    The latter part of the document cites many opportunities for the future Purdue

    may have for 'going green.'

    Purdue University Utilities. Purdue University, 2009. Web. 6 July2010.The Purdue University Utilities website shows all the data recorded for Wade

    Power Plant that services the building on Purdue's campus. It lists the daily

    utility expenses, the power plants operations, safety, and ways to save energy.

    This website provides us with the information needed to analyze Wade Power

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    18/21

    PURDUEUNIVERSITYEMERGINGGREEN 18

    plant for our white paper. The data the site provides can be used to back up

    any claims stated in our white paper.

    Ridgway, Robin. Questionnaire via e-mail. 15 July 2010.Robin Ridgway is the Director of Sustainability for Purdue University. Her

    interview was very helpful in providing clear answers to some of the questions

    we had about Purdue and how it is 'going green.' She has a great understanding

    of the project to 'go green' as a whole and is in contact with many other project

    leaders throughout the university. She was very helpful in pointing out the more

    important topics and helping us narrow down our analysis.

    Sustainable Endowments Institute, Cambridge, Massachusetts.College Sustainable Report Cards. Web 12 July, 2010..This web site gives tremendous value to the ability to not only compare

    individual schools, but develop an understanding what colleges and universities

    are doing as a whole. It allows a comparison chart to be made in which a user

    can compare the grades each school got in several categories, but also in the

    years from 2007 to 2010. This site will enable our group to discuss how

    Purdues grades are comparing to the rest of the collegiate community, but also

    what categories Purdue is improving or degrading in.

    Sustainablility director ready to build partnerships, promotestewardship; InsidePurdue 27 August 2009: 10. Print.This article describes the partnerships Purdue's director of sustainability and

    environmental stewardship (Robin Ridgway) is making to increase Purdue's

    sustainability efforts. Purdue is adding a green roof at Schleman Hall, replacingthe old coal boilers with new clean coal boilers, and Qualified Energy Savings

    projects in Brown Laboratory in Chemistry, Stewart Center, and in the expansion

    of Mackey Arena all in the sustainability effort. The information found in this

    article is almost the foundation of our white paper. The sustainability effort

    Purdue is doing is the most important part in the writing of our white paper.

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    19/21

    PURDUEUNIVERSITYEMERGINGGREEN 19

    "Wade Utility Plant: Boiler 5 Project." Net Impact @ Purdue. Web. 20January 2009.

    This is a project plan for a carbon neutral fuel source to be used at Purdue. Thereport describes the process of the project and the financial budgets needed to

    complete this task. Robin Ridgway is the person who is analyzing the system to

    see if a biomass based alternative fuel can be used in one of the coal-fired

    boilers. This website gives us a clearer view of the plan and goals of one of the

    projects Purdue completed to help "go green."

    Appendix

    An interview with Robin Ridgway, 16 July 2010.Me: I know you are quite busy, so I will try to keep my questions brief andcover only the most pertinent questions.

    Robin: Okay. What do you have for me?Me: First of all, what are some significant programs Purdue has started topromote sustainability?

    Robin: Well, the biggest thing was that the President incorporatedSustainability into the University Strategic Plan. The next step is a sustainability

    strategic plan requested by senior administration. We are waiting on approval of

    this strategic plan. Putting this plan into action is the biggest step. As far as

    programs, recycling is a big one; our dual stream recycling program is a big

    step. Also the transportation services use of flex-fuel and hybrid vehicles

    almost exclusively. Youll have to look at the strategic plan for figures. TheWade Utility Plant is probably the biggest part on the energy side, and weve

    been using it for years. Its primary purpose is to generate steam for heating

    campus, but before this steam gets sent to campus, its used to make

    electricity. This is called combined heat and power and is very efficient, and

    thats what makes it so important.

    Appendix

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    20/21

    PURDUEUNIVERSITYEMERGINGGREEN 20

    Me: Okay. What are the largest contributors to Purdues carbon footprint?Robin: There was a class that studied this, and energy generated onsite andpurchased from off site is about 75% of the Universitys carbon footprint. The

    class was taught in 2007 by professors Raymond and Nies. You can find the

    report on our website.Me: On the sustainability website?Robin: Yes. It is a PDF.Me: Alright. When did Purdue first recognize the need to be environmentallyresponsible?

    Robin: Well, there really isnt a good answer. Purdue has always been strivingto be a good steward of the environment since it was instituted. I cant give you

    an exact answer; Im sorry.

    Me: Okay. That answer is perfectly acceptable. Is there a published number indollars to indicate Purdues annual savings from the employment of green

    technology?

    Robin: Im not really sure. I dont think anyone has done the analysis. Youcould certainly look at Wade Utility Plants distribution infrastructure on

    campus; its one of the most important. Looking at how much the system costs

    to maintain versus what it would cost to get from the outside, you could do the

    figures.

    Me: Speaking of Wade, we are very interested in the plant. Is there a betterperson to contact about the plant?

    Robin: Well, if you need any specific details about the maintenance or cost, EricVan Meter or Bruce High would be the people to talk to, but general questions I

    can address myself.

    Me: Thank you. Can you tell me what the Mechanical Engineering addition,Gatewood, as a LEED certified building means to the Sustainability Council?

    Robin: Well, its mainly been a learning opportunity to see what goes intomaking a LEED certified building. Its been a big help preparing us for what may

    come in the future.Me: On this topic, are there any plans to update other buildings to LEEDstandards?

    Robin: The new Marriot Hall will be LEED certified at least somewhat, and therenovation of Harrick Labs. Luci Keazerr would be able to give you more

    information. Shes actively involved with all of that.

  • 8/9/2019 Purdue University Emerging Green v016 Final

    21/21