r'rli;la-' ;j?.; \! --l-- Eril / qgJt[IeIoI IofGgIIeR[" TGI-6I{

g-AcI - dirahd-bih@nic.il -{Jil52 - ahd.bih.nic.in 6:€{q /B-arur - 0612 -22t5962t2231)s42

qtri.F - 7 {sro (4) qqo (rffi)-04l2017 Bdio-

erricr

qT{ilq gar ql{t.rq, qeqt al{r $osqododlo {Iqr-279a/2a11n{rc q{igidlF \-is=rr qflq $iq lr{Ti{ Tq 3rq ii ft{i6 tsos:or: ol qfto qq ftoJq, d Fni}'c f}qrqrrr glr

(operative Part) :

"Ihus, the impugned revised fina gradatlon list dated 26.11.2010 (Annexure-1) cannot be

sLrstained and s hereby set aside. The result would be that fin.l gradat on lisr a, publirhed on 01 08.2006

(Annexure-5) revives and would be deemed to be operative at alltimes. Consequent y, all actions taken by

state, pursuant to th€ revised fnal gradation list (Afnexure 1), in granting promotions to the priv.te

respondenis to the prejud ce of the petitloners cannot be sustalned nor denial of promot ons due to thepettioners on basis of the final gradation list dated 01.08.2006 be susta ned. They must get theirpromotions frorn due date accordingly with ful monetary benefits and other consequentia benefits

treat ng them as senior to the privat€-respondents. These adjustments must be done with I three mofths,

the respons b ty whereof will be on the Director, Anirnal ll!sbandry, Government of Bihar, Patna.

With these observations and dir€ctlons, the writ petition s al owea d 3r-.id qT+q

Ta qTqtdq, q-cr dnr l?.nJlq qrFb-,{oss, fuqiq :o rr zoro Em fuie q{uc rrdrqd d siTrftn

dfiq qfrTfl r1ff ftrrt{"r ol efirar ritfi-c ori Ec q{i6-313i, f-{i- oi 08 2006 cl{r Fnh rgul

sr€Tirbl d 3iliq Fq Q qrq{qR-fi oftqm rtdt fu.'Js'r ol nq qq q-q 6q{ f-qr rrcl

qFTffq rlq arrqrdq. rr+ em wfto s+{qd qrq ffq d faTE gq: qm{lq

gd qrqrdq, qenl q ETrr{ L.p.A. No. r+rzTzor:, q?w qlw gd 3l{ firq d{E Tl$s. r6 \-ierq i fiqio-zr.oz.zor z o) qfto qrqricr d f-tqifua ftlqrq+c aiYr (operative part) :

The present Letters Patent Appeal has no merit. lt ls dlsmissed as such." d Al{I iillDn T]Iit{ qfftrfir n

qfto qrq f-'roiq qjl refito sor rrtn i r

srf, qFrilq sar ;qrqrdq. .rrcl dRr dlosqoio€lo qsn zzso,/:ot t ilrr< q$rn--rri

T4 s-r crlTs {rdr qlqR 1.i er< ii f+.ri* rs.os.:ot: .i qrRd qrqt{ d;n"ila i uEwan

ftl:rr"rq, Rn, qeer d grcrF[,ld qgtr.l Tr€rqf, Fq,l ft1 tl{rqar q4 {i.ilild et-fo :t:t, i?flm

or os zooo d sT.io ii q{irtfrl gs n'i.qdr d 3nE.R w ffiq drqfi r1ftfd d1-1-{i6 2811 2017 oirrl{d tdo n fu ru F-iq/3r$rq gi fd qwm n,-r* - l#-i?.@ p,o-.X''L:-#fi,id i D d sroio ti vg w aan rirnur ft\-rr (q:lqm{ tF1-r-r), fiers. qdrr

"r- etflq {4 : lrrirtrqtruliflii d ortrrn qur rrerqtn ti FteFofuo 38 (ersdm) Fffii d mrdnlar W oG/ftffftq.rl'tqr qq qRrelq irff rd rq q€tqei S ertnr w ft+ fd.Tl.t ; qRqr €st-2074, fi r 04.01. less

vs qllqf, €sr zozo (i0), f-cir-2a 12 2o0s nql utltr- fi"n r I qP.rlrcqt toq, ficmog or.rqs: i Fftd flsrrri Tq q{ Tq q*x riFrq=i ftq-Ft, ladR, q-n d 3iBTIfl{r {isn 1173 (Fo)

s qio rjsr rrz,r (fto). R{iq 02.06 2014 Er{l Fr4e q1lri srdru-b s{,1 (,rfr Cd ear rrn)

50

€o

o.{?r8 or nrqlq{irc,/srqfdq qr {q fii

dat{dr 6qi6

qq fdlq Gno i+qfi al

f fi{

srorfi iq ive;a F+gflm o1

f lq 3rj q{{rq

c?dq clqd qE

,/i€ iT{ 3rgFfir

2 5 6

'n lnqq qfl{,qgeln s6lco,

qqq q=isaqgqdr sjrqidq,

3855

27.12.1963

31.12.2023

2s.04.1989

wirq {16l{o

vger v4iero

ffoffo 2.

.)s ifl{ 24ool

orTTe'fk

1

sfi in'is gqR sr.

c{E1n W6r{tr,

otcr fiYe qwol orulor,d-mT

3870

25.11.1968

30.11.2028

13.05.1989

qa.qe tco06.12.1989

c{fi Trdl{fi

,tnrtq,r$ierc

fToffo 2.

is ioc':qool35{frf*d

3

4 Ri{ q{nE.

q{q:l s6l{fi.fudr c{,{dr orsldq, glr{

3882

0810 1967

31 10 2426

16.04.1990

cgqq sdrqfi

ugul vfdero

ffoffo-).is i-r{ 24ool

;r5{1Ao

4

3I Sqt] -I< qlqq,

qgql {€r4o.qflan ft*lo (co fdo), llqcqg ]-fln cftilqil (ito Kr).

TiIri

05.42.1969

29.42.2427

16 44.1990

clleri 1l6rs4

rgul r&erodlofro-u,

-)s itrr 24ool-

3rg{frFd

at g$o qfli.!gq- 1IEFI6.

qETaf, F*rc (qo lio). {.f,!g firrr] qfuIqri (e\o {fl{).

lliFff, s$i.Tr

3894

01.12.1969

30 11 2029

10 04.1990

q{Tq r]EI{o

vger rdiero

. fiofio-2.is ifi 2aool

3rlrfflBn

6

al Efrir qqr{ sr,qgqr 116r{o.

fiR qqgd c{,rd{. oruldq.

Tsnfusl, ! .liiC{

389s

0'r 01.1961

31.12.2020

16.05.-t988

cgcldr qn

16.04.1990

qgqq $aqfi

qgErc rdiert

fto$o.2,

is iflq-u +oil3rT{{ltdn

b

fsqaffi-261a $ sSsq s+d liq d q{rqi qa FFld o1 Itfu i q<fr'o (arfdo) anr rcn o€ gq

erg+€rtre i-or t-s z, is idq-z+oo7- ii e*vr$ sc t Erqid r<rq al qrff t, ql Cq.fd t -

M

;

0

cgql {l€rqo,

{flqo fi+:To (,ro fto), ctqcqg ft oi{J cfurqrl (ito 1T{),

cdsr

10.11.1964

30.112024

08.08.1990

cgfi {{€r4o

q:Iqr c{iel4dlodlo-:.

's dirq-2aoo/-3rgnfiled

8

ltl q6q qqrrc.

qgtF T{61{fi

liid qEcra{r @rqldq, €rEFl

3897

1611.1967

3A 11 2427

02.08.1990

CgtE {Elqfi

'rgqq qSiero

fioffo-2.

isiflr 24ool

3rgnfiftn

9

4l {q-qtq sr<s.

qgqi {r6ltrfi.qa{ cisa vgcrar @rcfi{q.

'ltN:l{3901

30.09.1961

30 09 2021

0908.1990

cgq:l 1I{qo

vqer v4dero

ffoao 2.

isita.-2aoolerY-{tea

't0

""1qqn gqrl,qqqr qirqo.

or+t nr<o vryrc ord-ru.Er.].tiq1

3908

0s.05.1968

31.05 2028

01.08.1990

q1ql s€rqa

qgfi qfde-o

ffoao 2,

i's i flr-2400/

sgqerfun

1',I

,Jl 3{r$q gqta qr<s,

qgfi qEl{fi.

rr€rqfi lili@ (qo 1i0, T{d!{ li6l{J qR:JFq{ (sio Tf,{),

oito{. guqwrg{

3913

03.01.1963

31 0T 2023

22.11.1990

c{qr rr6la6

qtn vdiero

ffoao 2,

jrs iflr 24ool

3rg{fritrd

12

,,it rniro tgnr.itto.

cgqi $flqfi.ttor vgqd r @Iqfdq, q'.5!l

3919

05.051964

3T 0s.2024

0s.10.1991

qgfi tl€rqo

r31ur r&erofiodlo 2,

is idr 24ool-

srlr{tt*e

ll

$ lEfi Rr€.q{qi {fgrso.

rlflqo ftA:rfi Fo fto). dg cgft6rq qRdF;nr (go {ni).

' \frFFlFIlE I

3921

26.071972

31.07.2032

08.101991

wltlq {{Erqfi

rgur r4iiero

ffoffo 2.

i-s iflr-2aoo/3rq{ftitrd

+rt 3,-qq q'rR fu€.cgtFl ]I6ruo

1;or qgqror orqloq, @t3926

06.12.1968

31.12.2428

0r.06.T986

{fiB {t{o0't.02.r989

qqqi 1l6lqfi

rrgqi qfiem

ffodlo 2.

ic idr-2aoo/eqr{tlim

--+^_, r Nv\.r, * \u

t5

ql 3l.l'4 T&-:ll'{ ql€N,

rr{fi {rdErm,

3Ti-r rqf.si qgrrdr orqidq.

{rqd

27.49.1974

30.09.2030

04l0.t99l

cgq- rr61qfi

Wcrrr !4derc

ftoffo z.

ie ial z+oo7

qg{fiRn

t6

,fidA r -+rin1.q{fi rrfl{o.

qfls6 Fre{tF (qo 1io), {{dqg ft-mT]],rtursfl (do rf,i).

qniicr3929

1007.1958

31.07.2018

03.0s.1995

qgqi rrflqo

vgul r4ieroffoffo-2.

js iflc-2aoo/srgrftisfd

17

do omric.qIfi 116r{o,

rrflqo ftAr1o Fo fto). qsqq

q{ liors qffiq{. (do r+i),

{c{Sgi3930

a1 1A 1972

30 09.2032

24141991

q1lli rrflq4

rgw rSieroffodto-2,

is if,c 2aool

sr]nffFa

t8

qgqr 1I6Iqo.

{Er{lfi fi'e:ld (qo fto). dg q{ftorr] cRqrqrl (Xo ffiq),

nsl ill{lllqi<

25.12.1972

31 12 2032

01.01.'r992

q{EiI 116l{o

rgur rSiero

ffoffo-:,is ifi 2400./-

slqfrlhn

19

'.t $tfr{ qqR sr,q{qn llErqfi.

rrErqf, ii*ro (qo lio). q-qq

!{ lioRr qRsiq{ (do {1r{),

lilld. <{.inr

05.03.1965

31.03.202s

24.42.1992

c{trq n6r+o

lgw rfdnoqo{.to 2

is icl-:,roo7-3rg{ftfbn

20

ex {lq gcrr.

cgqi {{€Tffi,

3rqt qrrcd q{qTaFt 6tsf6q.15.06196s

30.06.2025

29.12.1986

q{Lrc {rflqo

, ugw rfdero

fioao 2.

iE if,r 24ool

sT{frRro

ll

' 4 eqttFrfr q{ E.

qgqi {{€]qfi,

3rqi qqsir qgqatq orufdq,qtd. rTell

39s9

04.06.1965

30.06.202s

24.42.1992

qelql {{Elqfi

vgur r4ieofiofio-2,

its if,r :+obl

sgn{tfua

l*

,Ji fiE TqlE {C1,

qffi]]EI{fi.]rflqq fiallo Fo 1io), ag cg

fta1q qfui fl (go qnr)

rlqHi\inrqE

4018

03.03.1958

31.03.2018

26.02.1992

q{q- rrFlqo

qgElr qdiero

,llodlo 2

,)s irr 2aoolqq{frfbn

13

rlo dlet g+r 3i{{d]

cgqr lla qo,

lrdr{n lilr1o (qo lio). eg qg

Ii- r qfuq{ (50 lf,s).

aEEr{

01.'11.1964

31 1A 2424

24 02 1992

qgq3 s6l{o

'r{tr- q+ierfi

fiodlo 2,

,)si-i 2aool

sgnftfen

24

2l iqSriiq{.qgqi rr6Efi

dq fteno. qq,rTdr orqldq.

vnr 1?rn e}7. Swmqr4043

31.12.1971

31.',r2.2031

02.05.1995

qgqr sdl{fi

rger r{ieroffofio 2.

isAflr-2aoo/-:qnfiftft

25

eft iri:*e]T< ftrfl]].qgqr ]Idrqm.

3r.R trCr€A qgqtdi 6rql4q,

la{-,Tq

15',l1 ',1963

30.11.2023

13.031992

!gq{ R€rq{

qgqq q4dtr6

d]ofio-:.

is ifi 2aool

3r5{flBd

26

,.i g{rf, eqn.cgqq {{aqo,

o.a< rr.so rryrol onloo,snltql

4050

15111967

30.11.2027

26.42.1992

,qul rfderoffoffo 2.

is if,q 2aool-

33-{fn*n

)1

nro sdXaq d,qqfi {aqo,

fift{r qqqrdr orqJdq. Tqsr

4055

1s 01 1968

3101 2028

23.41.1996

qgeti llElqo

rgw wiiero

fioffo 2.

is i-dr z+ool-

' sgn{iFn

28

s,l] 1d( -{Il{.rr{Fn ]I€FFF,

fudr q{qrf,i onldq. {ql4062

06.09.1962

3A 09 2422

24.42.1992

qllqq $€rqo.

q{trc lrjie,-@

frod'ro-2,jts if,r 2qool

aTTftllrn

29

qto 3tqRl,

wqq {{€rqfi.

3lq{ cr.G.l qSrlt ,lc oFlJdq.

'TeqTtr.qell

13 A31961

3103.2427

24 02 1992

wtl:l {{€lqo

vqer v4daro

fioao 2,

is d { :+oo7-

3rT{frf}n

lP q

30

an dETil ?t{t$qr,qgqi {{d|Tfi.

r]Erqn Fri{6 (co 1io), dgqq Flfir{J cRqlq{r. go {{{),

0s 02.1968

28.02.2024

a4 03 1992

qglri rrFrq@

qgqq rrdier{qoao-2.

is idr 2aool

or${ftftn

3t

do r{iq srq{qgqn lTgr{o.

otr< ulea qnel orulor,

Svcw{4102

12.12.1965

31.12.2425

27.05.1992

cgtlc s€lqm

lgr v-Siem

frodo 2,

is -.r.J 24ool

3rg{ftFn

I

32

4<ervqnrrwo. ,qgqq sEtqfi.

firdr Lr{qlEi orstdq, ffi,Erdqi

4114

a2 041973

30.04.2033

03.08.1992

qgEFr{t€lq@

rgw n4dero

,1]odlo u.

is id-r-2aoo/-3rgrerfun

::l11p16qq qcr{ i+6.

cgfis6l{o,fuor rgcld{ @rqtdq. r"}g{r

4118

01.01.1964

31.122023

22.07.1992

cYItF{d{o

c{qr q4ierm

ffodo u.

is if,q-2400/srg{eri}r

,fi qqf,{ {gqTr ET:Fi.

LTgfi r{flltn,rrflqo f+*rc (co fao). dg cgft6rs qftiimfl (50 ftR), {fi

a.crr"i, r'tffit4123

01.01.1969

31.12.2428

29.47.1992

c{fi {rdrqo

vgul v&eroffoffo 2.

isidr 2aool-

3rc{frkd

35

afi :rT.qq gqT{ RrE,

wfq rrEEm,

,r{ {rrea gj selqc {lrrm,firR, qecr

0T 03.1974

28 02 2034

24.07.1992

qgfi FdrTfi

rgw rfieroffoffo-2.

,)s ifi 2aool

qgrttlhn

35

,l EtT{ {qI{ eiqFfls,rTgql {grqo,

$flqo fi*ro (qo fto), .rg qg

Ii-mrs qRzitwi (go rn{).

qM zr"qT{q, dfdql

4126

20.01.1968

31.01.2028

16.10.1992

wqc rrElqfi

,rj?r:r qdiem

fiofio 2,

is itrE 24ool

3-gretun

t* b. s-

/ eqR ft{€I,\l{q;r qgrniF.

qq lqReq gq Ilfllql g{a:ITn.

iier<,.rec1

4tl5

qglrE {{drc4.

qqi q=isf, qq,rdr,

arqla.l. !T<a ..r.rcg{

11.121967

31.12 2421

rgtn wiierotrroi'ro-2.

qs iflq-2aoo/i{grqAn

trglF qf;erfl

{'}odlo z

is iifi 2aool-

:qnftfun

fiq1i d €IqI i 3Tri Ela lw unw rremdi ot f:#1 orur+s rffi €i fr .t{1 i,srd lirq fi qE Srj*d rEr rq * qr?q ii f:t$ rcFR d Ze,/!lri@ qi] nIH w A.dt qffi d qe/dyitDd F{ Rqr Grtrn gs oiqo A .rs rfir dl Tq{fi/qFTtr 6{d] Bd-risaoq tfl{qlq i if,q Fl fir,'fwr RdT{ 1\sl €l-dr d ftqq 78 (6) 0 dQn trf, fa\-rrr dqRqf, risr 660. f+cis o8.o2.i9ee d "ilid6 fiqq 22 d GTI]R dFn t

qrl:r S eiF -d 6ff GEi i lrqli d iErd€ i w1ll{.rfdero d .rs q{ tffi dt filo iq<r+fii-a rrqd qtjl t sqf,q vgu r +fiero d ft+r r< qr q{{flTc tg 3rfu G\r-l ilf-+id Er.[ I

:r ffi n ftxn.n r.'qftq o'inr{i o"t qmqjto sftE'll or a+c €i dlT L

FA,/'(rdr+rr erc)

fti:to, q{qeqqE.n- 15, f{qim .Ll1.2^/ zott;fo n :- " 1..t o 4/ r10 ,q -? -04 zot, . .Q.D-1..?.b" '

cfdnft ,- qerierox. R"€rr. cerrleli €tilta olqfiR q{rfu6r{iZftirl6. qg {sr{eq GseEq rirrnc. lt€R, c-ir,/l].j} dilq Fragtn. qEqdc//r i 1}m q3qa6a qqrlirarq/qflxiqF,

ffiq Emz qda. qe-lr,/{rdl lr€rrfi ftd{r..gqd. *{ro EaEe veleTam fto{l .GTMI, fa€T{.

,,re<rTrreno ft*rc, vgwrc $..I{r qs trql{. T.fl,/ .ltYfidl fifl!] -rflft4rtl. R-cn. .rfllft{s wliirTo (cA ftnRr), ffic €rfc :hs-cE gq €llc. qeqlqffiqt q<naro{i. rlfrc S+r ijo,

gsqwgr/ do7r1..t 1ir)r sq I={isrn (!g fror$), g5o q fnom vffini7efi sq fiialo

F0 faO) qqq qg ff.FFr cfu.d{r,,lr,.l $6Fr.F ftislm (qE l}.Fr{t) cg q{ fi'firq qltsrinqZ$rq

e,5?:r+, qwar l?aroo S:r{q. qwr/ qRirwq treTjamfi, fairt qrl rs{c q*a, .rrfl qqq-r.

diiqTqr qg qq{r qelr. Sq{q, qfiR/rqqq, {st qral-s'g qq+c qelt. q{lr, {ffi/rrd'i rjriilnofrolqa+'1wena:+o4rfrigilidl 6

r9.01.1993

qgEIT 116I{{

11.02.1993

qgqr]I€FFF14.01 1969

31.01.2029

sliTliTFt : ftqrlrq €h'iFir 6Fl3 d rIff rr{€ii/qrlq-{q j:r?qrflr d ]r'.l'l qqTTer

q<rfrmrfi4foAo i'{sq 4t G.n{E Mz w em"its ori @ rpn{ vq srlq'rqn 61qid ilqa t

lr?iTff :- {{Rs, rrg \.i qeq rirnq q fiq|r. GER. qcql d 3lrq riils at rla{reJ iftd

qdt'?f- "-t";u- t'

c9'tf,/n