Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Ensuring the Dependability of Smart, Connected ProductsCIMdata PLM Education Webinar
This presentation is copyright © 2016 by CIMdata, Inc. Clip art may be copyrighted. No use, reproduction or modification is permitted without prior
written permission. CIMdata� is a registered trademark of CIMdata, Inc. Page - 1
PLM Leadership
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 1
www.CIMdata.com
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc.
Global Leaders in PLM Consulting
Ensuring the Dependability of Smart Connected ProductsCIMdata PLM Leadership Webinar Series 23 June 2016#cimdatawebinar
Venki Agaram, Director, Quality & Reliability Engineering Practice email: [email protected]: +1.734.668.9922
PLM Leadership
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 2
l 25+ years of experience from industry & academia
l 16 years at Fiat Chrysler Automobiles
l Growing the Quality & Reliability Engineering Practice
l R&D, virtual engineering, complex material systems, controlled mechanical systems, design-‐for-‐six-‐sigma, structured innovation, regulatory compliance, process modeling, market strategy, and business transformation
l technical & business background: ideally suited for leading industry transformation to improve the robustness of smart connected products and processes
l Education: aerospace engineering, business strategy
Venki Agaram, Ph.D., MBADirector, Quality & Reliability Engineering Practice
Ensuring the Dependability of Smart, Connected ProductsCIMdata PLM Education Webinar
This presentation is copyright © 2016 by CIMdata, Inc. Clip art may be copyrighted. No use, reproduction or modification is permitted without prior
written permission. CIMdata� is a registered trademark of CIMdata, Inc. Page - 2
PLM Leadership
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 3
Our Mission...Strategic management consulting for competitive advantage in global markets
CIMdata is the leading independent global strategic management consulting
and research authority focused exclusively on the PLM market.
We are dedicated to maximizing our clients’ ability to design and deliverinnovative products and services through the application of PLM.
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 4
Our Services...Creating, disseminating, and applying our intellectual capital
Delivering strategic advice and counsel through a comprehensive, integrated set of research, education, and consulting services
Ensuring the Dependability of Smart, Connected ProductsCIMdata PLM Education Webinar
This presentation is copyright © 2016 by CIMdata, Inc. Clip art may be copyrighted. No use, reproduction or modification is permitted without prior
written permission. CIMdata� is a registered trademark of CIMdata, Inc. Page - 3
PLM Leadership
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 5
PLM TransformationServices for Industrial Organizations—improving your PLM-‐related processes
CIMdata’s PLM consulting methodology—transforming your business for a competitive advantage!
A comprehensive set of services tailored to fit your specific needs…
Strategy Development
Solution Definition
Solution Evaluation & Selection
Implementation Planning
Implementation Support
Monitoring & Continuous Improvement
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 6
Our PLM Transformation Clients… A sampling of CIMdata’s international industrial clients (1 of 2)
Fab & Assembly High-‐TechAutoA&D
Ensuring the Dependability of Smart, Connected ProductsCIMdata PLM Education Webinar
This presentation is copyright © 2016 by CIMdata, Inc. Clip art may be copyrighted. No use, reproduction or modification is permitted without prior
written permission. CIMdata� is a registered trademark of CIMdata, Inc. Page - 4
PLM Leadership
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 7
Our PLM Transformation Clients… A sampling of CIMdata’s international industrial clients (2 of 2)
Medical/Pharma Emerging Ind.CPG/F&B/Process Other
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 8
l We’re hoping that the anonymity of the chat window might help participants ask more questions
l If you want to ask a question on the record, we’ll certainly let everyone know you’re asking
l The most important thing is interaction – let us hear from you on the call
Questions?Please use the GoToMeeting chat panel
Ensuring the Dependability of Smart, Connected ProductsCIMdata PLM Education Webinar
This presentation is copyright © 2016 by CIMdata, Inc. Clip art may be copyrighted. No use, reproduction or modification is permitted without prior
written permission. CIMdata� is a registered trademark of CIMdata, Inc. Page - 5
PLM Leadership
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 9
l Smart Connected Products
l Quality & Reliability Risks Today
l Systems & Reliability Engineering Disconnect
l Bridging Systems & Reliability Engineering
l Failure Knowledge Capture & Reuse
l Business Opportunity at the Intersection
l Q&A
Agenda
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 10
Smart Connected Products (I)Functions and enablers
SmartConnectedProducts
ArtificialIntelligenceConnectivity
Data InterpretationSensor analytics
Data fusionScenario RecognitionScenario updating
Control StrategyDecisionPlanningAction
Correction
Information CommunicationInternetCellularWireless
Ensuring the Dependability of Smart, Connected ProductsCIMdata PLM Education Webinar
This presentation is copyright © 2016 by CIMdata, Inc. Clip art may be copyrighted. No use, reproduction or modification is permitted without prior
written permission. CIMdata� is a registered trademark of CIMdata, Inc. Page - 6
PLM Leadership
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 11
l Automotive§ Autonomous/Automated Vehicles –Google self-‐driving car, Tesla Autopilot§ Advanced Drive Assist Systems – ACC, AEB, lane keep assist, park assist, night vision
l Mining§ Autonomous Mining Vehicles – higher productivity & utilization, less damage§ Remote Fleet Monitoring – system optimization, preventive maintenance
l Farming§ Autonomous Farming Equipment – electric, row crops, 24 hours working § Adaptive Irrigation & Fertilization – precision farming, system level optimization
l Medical devices§ Remote Monitoring and Updating – MRI, X-‐Ray, CT Scanners§ Remote Patient Monitoring and Adjustment – digital pill, deep brain stimulation
l Manufacturing§ Remote Monitoring/Control – robots/devices adapt, as needed maintenance§ Automatic Production Line Control – product deviation shuts line
Smart Connected Products (II)Examples from different Fields of Application
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 12
l Smart Connected Products� P (I)
l Quality & Reliability Risks Today
l Systems & Reliability Engineering Disconnect
l Bridging Systems & Reliability Engineering
l Failure Knowledge Capture & Reuse
l Business Opportunity at the Intersection
l Q&A
Agenda
Ensuring the Dependability of Smart, Connected ProductsCIMdata PLM Education Webinar
This presentation is copyright © 2016 by CIMdata, Inc. Clip art may be copyrighted. No use, reproduction or modification is permitted without prior
written permission. CIMdata� is a registered trademark of CIMdata, Inc. Page - 7
PLM Leadership
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 13
Quality & Reliability Risks Today (I)Complexity of Electronically Controlled Software-‐Intensive Products
AutomotiveIndustry
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 14
Quality & Reliability Risks Today (II)Complexity of Electronically Controlled Software-‐Intensive Products
Source: Software related recalls: An analysis of records, USFDA
Medical DeviceIndustry
Ensuring the Dependability of Smart, Connected ProductsCIMdata PLM Education Webinar
This presentation is copyright © 2016 by CIMdata, Inc. Clip art may be copyrighted. No use, reproduction or modification is permitted without prior
written permission. CIMdata� is a registered trademark of CIMdata, Inc. Page - 8
PLM Leadership
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 15
l Boeing 787: § Software bug in the Boeing 787 was found to be capable of shutting down the plane’s electric generators every 248 days
§ Software counter, internal to the generator control units (GCUs) could overflow after 248 days of continuous power
§ This could cause the GCU to go into failsafe mode, resulting in a loss of all electrical power regardless of the flight phase
l F-‐35 Joint Strike Fighter:§ Expected to be further behind in its combat-‐readiness due to issues with its RADAR software and vulnerability to cyber-‐attacks
§ Requires the system to be rebooted every four hours of flight time while the desired reboot interval of the F-‐35 is eight to ten hours of flight time
Quality & Reliability Risks Today (II)Complexity of Electronically Controlled Software-‐Intensive Products
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 16
l Smart Connected Products
l Quality & Reliability Risks Today
l Systems & Reliability Engineering Disconnect
l Bridging Systems & Reliability Engineering
l Failure Knowledge Capture & Reuse
l Business Opportunity at the Intersection
l Q&A
Agenda
Ensuring the Dependability of Smart, Connected ProductsCIMdata PLM Education Webinar
This presentation is copyright © 2016 by CIMdata, Inc. Clip art may be copyrighted. No use, reproduction or modification is permitted without prior
written permission. CIMdata� is a registered trademark of CIMdata, Inc. Page - 9
PLM Leadership
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 17
Systems & Reliability Engineering Disconnect Engineering complex products in silos
Systems Engineering Technical Processes• Stakeholders’ Requirements Identification• System Requirements Definition• System Architectural Design• System Elements Definition• System Analysis• System Elements Realization• System Elements Integration• System Design Verification• Verified System Transition• System Performance Validation• System Operation• System Maintenance• System Disposal
Reliability Engineering Tools• Affinity Diagrams (KJ Analysis)• Quality Function Deployment (QFD) • Kano Analysis• SysML Diagrams• FMECA• TRIZ• Robust Optimization• Design of Experiments (DOE)• Monte Carlo Simulations• Conjoint Analysis• Kepner-Tregoe Analysis (KTA)• Fault Tree Analysis (FTA)• Reliability Block Diagrams (RBD)• FRACAS• CAPA• Markov Analysis• Weibull Analysis• System Maintainability Analysis• System Availability Analysis• Accelerated Life Testing (ALT)
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 18
l Smart Connected Products: Functions, enablers, and applications
l Quality & Reliability Risks Today
l Systems & Reliability Engineering Disconnect � P (II)
l Bridging Systems & Reliability Engineering
l Failure Knowledge Capture & Reuse
l Business Opportunity at the Intersection
l Q&A
Agenda
Ensuring the Dependability of Smart, Connected ProductsCIMdata PLM Education Webinar
This presentation is copyright © 2016 by CIMdata, Inc. Clip art may be copyrighted. No use, reproduction or modification is permitted without prior
written permission. CIMdata� is a registered trademark of CIMdata, Inc. Page - 10
PLM Leadership
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 19
Bridging Systems & Reliability EngineeringRelationship between Reliability Tools and Systems Engineering Practices
Reliability En
gine
ering To
ols
Affin
ity Diagram
s
QFD
(HOQ)
Kano
Ana
lysis
Functio
nal Flow Block Diagram
SysM
L Diagrams
IDEF
N2 C
harts
Specificatio
n Tree
FMEC
A
TRIZ
Physics o
f Failure Ana
lysis
Robu
st Optim
izatio
n
Desig
n of Experim
ents (D
OE)
Respon
se Surface Ana
lysis
Mon
te Carlo Sim
ulations
Conjoint Ana
lysis
Kepn
er-‐Trego
e An
alysis
Analytic Hierarchy
Process (A
HP) M
odels
Multi-‐Attribute Untility Ana
lysis (M
AUA)
Fault T
ree An
alysis (FTA
)
Even
t Tree An
alysis (ETA
)
Reliability Block Diagrams (RB
D)
FRAC
AS
CAPA
Marko
v An
alysis
Weibu
ll An
alysis
System
Maintaina
bility An
alysis
System
Availability An
alysis
Asset P
erform
ance M
anagem
ent
Accelerated Life Testin
g
Systems Engineering Technical Processes
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
Stakeholders' Requirements Definition 1System Requirements Definition 2System Architectural Design 3System Elements Definition 4
System Analysis 5System Elements Realization 6System Elements Integration 7System Design Verification 8Verified System Transition 9
System Performance Validation 10System Operation 11
System Maintenance 12System Disposal 13
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 20
l Smart Connected Products
l Quality & Reliability Risks Today
l Systems & Reliability Engineering Disconnect
l Bridging Systems & Reliability Engineering
l Failure Knowledge Capture & Reuse
l Business Opportunity at the Intersection
l Q&A
Agenda
Ensuring the Dependability of Smart, Connected ProductsCIMdata PLM Education Webinar
This presentation is copyright © 2016 by CIMdata, Inc. Clip art may be copyrighted. No use, reproduction or modification is permitted without prior
written permission. CIMdata� is a registered trademark of CIMdata, Inc. Page - 11
PLM Leadership
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 21
l Systems dependability issues occur at the intersection of different disciplines of engineering and at the interfaces between different subsystems where engineering intuition tends to be low.
l Learning deals with implicit knowledge which is not immediately accessible and in particular cannot be acquired from conventional databases.
l Problem of reusing pre-‐existing knowledge about failure modes could be solved effectively through the definition of an ontology.
l Ontology enables a common understanding of the domain specific concepts without need for interpretation, while making the ontology-‐held knowledge explicit and machine-‐readable.
Failure Knowledge Capture & Reuse (I)Developing machine-‐readable failure knowledge
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 22
l Ontology as a way of converting implicit system failure knowledge into machine-‐readable explicit knowledge for reuse, has often been mentioned in technical literature.
l Ontology for system failure knowledge and reuse is not currently offered commercially by software providers either as part of systems engineering or reliability engineering tool suites.
l Ontology-‐based or similar knowledge capture and reuse tools are needed at the enterprise level, in earnest, to deliver complex products that are dependable, affordable, and available on time.
Failure Knowledge Capture & Reuse (II)Developing machine-‐readable failure knowledge
Ensuring the Dependability of Smart, Connected ProductsCIMdata PLM Education Webinar
This presentation is copyright © 2016 by CIMdata, Inc. Clip art may be copyrighted. No use, reproduction or modification is permitted without prior
written permission. CIMdata� is a registered trademark of CIMdata, Inc. Page - 12
PLM Leadership
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 23
l Smart Connected Products
l Quality & Reliability Risks Today
l Systems & Reliability Engineering Disconnect
l Bridging Systems & Reliability Engineering
l Failure Knowledge Capture & Reuse � P (III)
l Business Opportunity at the Intersection
l Q&A
Agenda
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 24
l Systems engineering helps in dealing with product complexity of smart connected products
l Verification and validation iterations in systems engineering are opportunities for new learning about the failure modes of complex, smart connected products
l Reliability engineering tools are needed to leverage product failure knowledge and they are mostly disconnected from systems engineering tools
l Bridging the tools and processes used in systems engineering and reliability engineering via knowledge management is imperative to minimize recall and launch risks
Business Opportunity at the Intersection (I)Seamlessly tying systems engineering and reliability engineering
Ensuring the Dependability of Smart, Connected ProductsCIMdata PLM Education Webinar
This presentation is copyright © 2016 by CIMdata, Inc. Clip art may be copyrighted. No use, reproduction or modification is permitted without prior
written permission. CIMdata� is a registered trademark of CIMdata, Inc. Page - 13
PLM Leadership
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 25
l All tools used in systems engineering, reliability engineering, and knowledge management are not likely to be provided by a single software provider
l System integrators will play a major role in closing the loop between reliability engineering and systems engineering
l Perhaps system integrators should lead this effort with strategic initiatives, consulting, planning, and execution
l Systems integrators could benefit greatly from this opportunity by driving standards for interoperability between the systems engineering and reliability engineering tools
Business opportunity at the intersection (II)Seamlessly tying systems engineering and reliability engineering
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 26
l Survey to be filled by OEMs/Suppliers, SIs and SW Providers§ Topic: Bridging Systems & Reliability Engineering through Knowledge Management, August 2016
l Whitepaper: § Quality & Reliability Engineering – Learning Systems based Design-‐for-‐Reliability
§ August 2016
l Conference Paper:§ Bridging Reliability Engineering & Systems Engineering, Author: Venki Agaram§ Ground Vehicle Systems Engineering and Technology Symposium (GVSETS)§ August 2 – 4, 2016, Novi, MI
l Education Webinars§ August 11, 2016, October 22, 2016, December 15, 2016
Quality & Reliability Engineering OutputWhat is coming from CIMdata’s QRE Consulting Practice ?
Ensuring the Dependability of Smart, Connected ProductsCIMdata PLM Education Webinar
This presentation is copyright © 2016 by CIMdata, Inc. Clip art may be copyrighted. No use, reproduction or modification is permitted without prior
written permission. CIMdata� is a registered trademark of CIMdata, Inc. Page - 14
PLM Leadership
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 27
l Smart Connected Products
l Quality & Reliability Risks Today
l Systems Engineering & Reliability Engineering Disconnect
l Bridging Systems Engineering & Reliability Engineering
l Failure Knowledge Capture & Reuse
l Business Opportunity at the Intersection
l Q&A
Agenda
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 28
l We’re hoping that the anonymity of the chat window might help participants ask more questions
l If you want to ask a question on the record, we’ll certainly let everyone know you’re asking
l The most important thing is interaction – let us hear from you on the call
Questions?Please use the GoToMeeting chat panel
Ensuring the Dependability of Smart, Connected ProductsCIMdata PLM Education Webinar
This presentation is copyright © 2016 by CIMdata, Inc. Clip art may be copyrighted. No use, reproduction or modification is permitted without prior
written permission. CIMdata� is a registered trademark of CIMdata, Inc. Page - 15
PLM Leadership
Cop yri ght © 20 16 by CI Md ata , I nc. 29
CIMdata Strategic consulting for competitive advantage in global markets
World Headquarters3909 Research Park Drive Ann Arbor, MI 48108 USATel:+1.734.668.9922Fax:+1.734.668.1957
www.CIMdata.com
Serving clients from offices in North America, Europe, and Asia-Pacific
Main Office - Asia-PacificTakegahana-Nishimachi 310-31Matsudo, Chiba 271-0071 JAPAN
Tel: +81.47.361.5850Fax: +81.47.362.0472
Main Office - EuropeOogststraat 20
6004 CV Weert, NLTel:+31 (0) 495.533.666