1
Introduction Since 2011, the largely unexplored Northwest Quarter of the Decapolis town of Gerasa, today’s Jerash, has been under investigation by Aarhus University and Ruhr-Universität Bo- chum. The project studies the settlement history of this city from Hellenistic/Roman times into the Medieval period. Radiocarbon dating The extensive excavation campaigns of the Northwest quar- ter of Jerash resulted in more than 80 radiocarbon samples on a number of different materials. Whereas most of these results are presented here for the first time, the radiocarbon dating of mortar samples from trench Q have previously been reported (Lichtenberger et al. 2015). Our overall aim here is to present the radiocarbon results for each trench and not least to dis- cuss their implications on the overall chronology of the North- west Quarter. We show two examples of case studies where archaeological information and radiocarbon dates are com- bined in age models to answer specific questions. Summed probability distribution of all radiocarbon dates from the Northwest Quarter. The red line is an average summed probability distribution of a 1000 artificial 14 C samples indicating a situation where all 14 C dates where equally distributed in time (randomly sampled). Furthermore, the random sampling indicates points in time where accumulated probability is simply due to wiggles in the calibration curve. Note that to infer activity from summed probability distributions alone, one must assume unbiased sampling. Bottom: The significant summed probability distribution of all radiocarbon dates from Jerash Northwest Quarter, calculated by subtracting the red from the blue curve of the top panel. Peaks in this distribution indicate peaks in activity at the site, assuming unbiased sampling. 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 x 10 −3 Jerash 1000 500 1 BC / AD 1 500 1000 1500 2000 0 0.5 1 1.5 x 10 −3 Jerash − significant Radiocarbon dating and Bayesian modelling in Jerash/Gerasa, Jordan Bente Philippsen 1,2 , Jesper Olsen 1,2 , Rubina Raja 1,3 , Achim Lichtenberger 4 1 Centre for Urban Network Evolutions (UrbNet), Aarhus University 2 Aarhus AMS Centre, Department of Physics and Astronomy, Aarhus University 3 School of Culture and Society - Classical Archaeology, Aarhus University 4 Institut für Klassische Archäologie und Christliche Archäologie /Archäologisches Museum, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster Acknowledgments This work would not have been possible without the work of the teams at the Jerash excavation and at the Aarhus AMS Center. This work was supported by the Danish National Research Foundation under the grant DNRF119 – Centre of Excellence for Urban Network Evolutions (UrbNet), the Carlsberg Foundation, Deut- sche Forschungsgemeinschaft, Deutscher Palästina-Verein, the EliteForsk initiative of the Danish Ministry of Higher Education and Science and H. P. Hjerl Hansens Mindefondet for Dansk Palæstinaforskning. Conclusions The summed probability distributions indicate that there was a peak of ac- tivities in the Northwest Quarter during the first century AD. Further peaks are observed during the 5th/6th century and 8th century AD. None of the trenches covers the entire settlement period of the city. Thus, judging from radiocarbon dating only, activity in the Northwest Quarter fluctuated spa- tially during the centuries. In many trenches, charcoal is the only material available for radiocarbon dating. Many charcoal samples are older than the context or event to be dated. Therefore, large numbers of samples are dated and all availaible archaeological/historical information is used in the age models. As a con- sequence, radiocarbon dating becomes precise enough to be of value for urban archaeology. Radiocarbon dates by trench Map of the site. The excavated trenches are indicated by letters A-X. Green circles mark the trenches discussed in detail below. Summed probability distributions of the radiocarbon dates for each trench. Plot of the radiocarbon dates. Please note that the datapoints overlap, so only the earliest date for each trench is shown. A video file is avail- able at http://pure.au.dk/portal/en/ [email protected] Case studies from individual trenches Trench S - construction, use and abandonment of a cistern. Ev. 59 dates the construction of the cis- tern to the first half of the first century CE. The fill in this trench appeared to be homogenous and intentional. Therefore, we hypothesize that the cistern was aba- noned and filled up in one single event during which contemporaneous and older, redeposited charcoal entered the context. Therefore, the prior for the age distribution of the charcoal for this setting is based on the equation by Dee and Ramsey 1 (assuming a big risk for “too old” and a small risk for “too young” samples): p= 0.05e^(-t) if t>0, p= 0.95e^t if t≤0 1 M. W. Dee and C. Bronk Ramsey, Radiocarbon 56 (2014), 83-94. Trench K - a house, destroyed during an earthquake in AD 749 Two Umayyad houses on the eastern terrace were uncovered in trenches K, P and V. In the age model, we could exploit that the earthquake that had de- stroyed the houses was dat- ed to AD 749. Furthermore, two evidences were dated by two samples each and the relations between ev- idences were known from the Harris matrix of the trench. AARHUS UNIVERSITY DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICS AND ASTRONOMY AU 1

Radiocarbon dating and Bayesian modelling in Jerash/Gerasa ... · radiocarbon dating only, activity in the Northwest Quarter fluctuated spa-tially during the centuries. In many trenches,

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • IntroductionSince 2011, the largely unexplored Northwest Quarter of the Decapolis town of Gerasa, today’s Jerash, has been under investigation by Aarhus University and Ruhr-Universität Bo-chum. The project studies the settlement history of this city from Hellenistic/Roman times into the Medieval period.

    Radiocarbon datingThe extensive excavation campaigns of the Northwest quar-ter of Jerash resulted in more than 80 radiocarbon samples on a number of different materials. Whereas most of these results are presented here for the first time, the radiocarbon dating of mortar samples from trench Q have previously been reported (Lichtenberger et al. 2015). Our overall aim here is to present the radiocarbon results for each trench and not least to dis-cuss their implications on the overall chronology of the North-west Quarter. We show two examples of case studies where archaeological information and radiocarbon dates are com-bined in age models to answer specific questions.

    Summed probability distribution of all radiocarbon dates from the Northwest Quarter. The red line is an average summed probability distribution of a 1000 artificial 14C samples indicating a situation where all 14C dates where equally distributed in time (randomly sampled). Furthermore, the random sampling indicates points in time where accumulated probability is simply due to wiggles in the calibration curve. Note that to infer activity from summed probability distributions alone, one must assume unbiased sampling. Bottom: The significant summed probability distribution of all radiocarbon dates from Jerash Northwest Quarter, calculated by subtracting the red from the blue curve of the top panel. Peaks in this distribution indicate peaks in activity

    at the site, assuming unbiased sampling.

    0

    0.5

    1

    1.5

    2x 10−3 Jerash

    1000 500 1 BC / AD 1 500 1000 1500 2000

    0

    0.5

    1

    1.5x 10−3

    Jerash − significant

    Radiocarbon dating and Bayesian modelling in Jerash/Gerasa, JordanBente Philippsen1,2, Jesper Olsen1,2, Rubina Raja1,3, Achim Lichtenberger4

    1Centre for Urban Network Evolutions (UrbNet), Aarhus University2Aarhus AMS Centre, Department of Physics and Astronomy, Aarhus University

    3School of Culture and Society - Classical Archaeology, Aarhus University4Institut für Klassische Archäologie und Christliche Archäologie /Archäologisches Museum, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster

    Acknowledgments This work would not have been possible without the work of the teams at the Jerash excavation and at the Aarhus AMS Center. This work was supported by the Danish National Research Foundation under the grant DNRF119 – Centre of Excellence for Urban Network Evolutions (UrbNet), the Carlsberg Foundation, Deut-sche Forschungsgemeinschaft, Deutscher Palästina-Verein, the EliteForsk initiative of the Danish Ministry of Higher Education and Science and H. P. Hjerl Hansens Mindefondet for Dansk Palæstinaforskning.

    ConclusionsThe summed probability distributions indicate that there was a peak of ac-tivities in the Northwest Quarter during the first century AD. Further peaks are observed during the 5th/6th century and 8th century AD. None of the trenches covers the entire settlement period of the city. Thus, judging from radiocarbon dating only, activity in the Northwest Quarter fluctuated spa-tially during the centuries.In many trenches, charcoal is the only material available for radiocarbon dating. Many charcoal samples are older than the context or event to be dated. Therefore, large numbers of samples are dated and all availaible archaeological/historical information is used in the age models. As a con-sequence, radiocarbon dating becomes precise enough to be of value for urban archaeology.

    Radiocarbon dates by trench

    Map of the site. The excavated trenches are indicated by letters A-X. Green circles mark the trenches discussed in detail below.

    Summed probability distributions of the radiocarbon dates for each trench.

    Plot of the radiocarbon dates. Please note that the datapoints overlap, so only the earliest date for each trench is shown. A video file is avail-able at http://pure.au.dk/portal/en/[email protected]

    Case studies from individual trenchesTrench S - construction, use and abandonment of a cistern.Ev. 59 dates the construction of the cis-tern to the first half of the first century CE. The fill in this trench appeared to be homogenous and intentional. Therefore, we hypothesize that the cistern was aba-noned and filled up in one single event during which contemporaneous and older, redeposited charcoal entered the context. Therefore, the prior for the age distribution of the charcoal for this setting is based on the equation by Dee and Ramsey1 (assuming a big risk for “too old” and a small risk for “too young” samples): p= 0.05e^(-t) if t>0, p= 0.95e^t if t≤01M. W. Dee and C. Bronk Ramsey, Radiocarbon 56 (2014), 83-94.

    Trench K - a house, destroyed during an earthquake in AD 749Two Umayyad houses on the eastern terrace were uncovered in trenches K, P and V. In the age model, we could exploit that the earthquake that had de-stroyed the houses was dat-ed to AD 749. Furthermore, two evidences were dated by two samples each and the relations between ev-idences were known from the Harris matrix of the trench.

    AARHUS UNIVERSITY

    DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICS AND ASTRONOMY AU

    1