8
RADIOISOTOPE KNEE JOINT SCANS IN HAEMOPHILIA AND CHRISTMAS DISEASE CHARLES D. FORBES, WILLIAM R. GREIG, COLIN R. M. PRENTICE, GLASGOW, ScoTLANI, and GEORGE P. MCNICOL,* LEEDS, ENGLAND From the LJnilersitv Departineizi of Medicine, Glasgow Royal Infirmary As early as I 892 K#{246}nig showed that the recurrent haemarthroses of haemophilia resulted in progressive joint destruction. This aspect of haemophilia has been studied by many investigators (Freund 1925; Key 1932; Collins 1949; DePalma and Cotter l956b; Marion, Favre-Gilly, Picault and Gauthier 1965). Observations have also been made ofjoint abnormalities in haemophilic dogs (Swanton 1957, 1959). Nevertheless, there is still doubt about the mechanisms underlying the acute and chronic joint changes. In acute haemarthrosis it is thought that bleeding starts in the synovial and subsynovial tissues of the villi with formation of sInall haematomata, which become confluent and rupture into the joint cavity to produce the sudden severe pain and immobility (Swanton 1957, 1959). Likewise it is thought that it is recurrent intra-articular bleeds which lead to chronic arthropathy, hypertrophv ofthe synovium and adherence of adjacent villi progressing to produce joints with a thickened hyperaemic synovium and fibrosis of the subsynovial tissues. After these changes are established degenerative changes occur in the adjacent cartilage and bone. We have investigated the changes in acute and chronic haernophilic arthropathy using radioisotope joint scanning. Intravenous technetium (9ImTc) with a half-life of six hours is an ideal isotope forjoint scanning (Laneet 1968) and has been used to study otherjoint diseases. The scans, which consist of a pictorial image of the isotope localisation in and around the joint, show changes in regional blood flow at the time of study and are abnormal during acute inflammation (Weiss, Maxfield, Munson and Hidalgo 1965, 1966; Whaley, Pack, Boyle, Dick, Downie, Buchanan and Gillespie 1968; McCarty, Polcyn and Collins 1970). While visualisation of the isotope in an inflamed joint reflects mainly increased vascularity of the synovial membrane and otherjoint tissues (Alarcon-Segovia, Trujeque, Tovar and Adame 1967; Whaley et a!. 1968), part of the localisation of the radioactivity may be due directly to the synovium binding the technetium (Green and Hays 1969; McCarty, Polcyn, Collins and Gottschalk 1970; Mowat, Disney and Vaughan 1971). For these reasons joint scans are abnormal in a variety of inflammatory joint diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis, gout, psoriatic arthritis, acute pseudo-gout and experimental synovitis, but are not characteristically specific for one type of inflammatory change. Nevertheless, as McCarty and his colleagues have shown, the joint scan may be much more abnormal than the degree of symptoms and signs would suggest, and because they can be repeated at intervals and do give an index of blood flow in a joint, we thought it might be helpful to use joint scanning to measure the extent of the synovial lesion in the joints of haemophiliacs. In addition we have compared the scans taken during acute haemarthrosis with those taken in quiescent chronic haemophilic arthropathy. Other assessments included the scan abnormalities in relation to the number of previous bleeding episodes and to the clinical assessment of the joint abnormality. The present study was confined to the knee joints, where scanning is optimum for clarity and comparative work. * Professor of Medicine, Leeds General Infirmary. 468 TIlE JOURNAL OF BONE AND JOINT SURGERY

RADIOISOTOPE KNEE JOINT SCANS IN …...RADIOISOTOPE KNEE JOINT SCANS IN1-IAEMOPHILIA AND CHRISTMAS DISEASE 473 cartilage with release ofpolypeptide kinins (Moskowitz, Schwartz, Michel,

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

RADIOISOTOPE KNEE JOINT SCANS IN HAEMOPHILIA

AND CHRISTMAS DISEASE

CHARLES D. FORBES, WILLIAM R. GREIG, COLIN R. M. PRENTICE, GLASGOW, ScoTLANI,

and

GEORGE P. MCNICOL,* LEEDS, ENGLAND

From the LJnilersitv Departineizi of Medicine, Glasgow Royal Infirmary

As early as I 892 K#{246}nigshowed that the recurrent haemarthroses of haemophilia resulted

in progressive joint destruction. This aspect of haemophilia has been studied by many

investigators (Freund 1925; Key 1932; Collins 1949; DePalma and Cotter l956b; Marion,

Favre-Gilly, Picault and Gauthier 1965). Observations have also been made ofjoint abnormalities

in haemophilic dogs (Swanton 1957, 1959). Nevertheless, there is still doubt about the

mechanisms underlying the acute and chronic joint changes. In acute haemarthrosis it is

thought that bleeding starts in the synovial and subsynovial tissues of the villi with formation

of sInall haematomata, which become confluent and rupture into the joint cavity to produce

the sudden severe pain and immobility (Swanton 1957, 1959). Likewise it is thought that it is

recurrent intra-articular bleeds which lead to chronic arthropathy, hypertrophv ofthe synovium

and adherence of adjacent villi progressing to produce joints with a thickened hyperaemic

synovium and fibrosis of the subsynovial tissues. After these changes are established

degenerative changes occur in the adjacent cartilage and bone.

We have investigated the changes in acute and chronic haernophilic arthropathy using

radioisotope joint scanning. Intravenous technetium (9ImTc) with a half-life of six hours is

an ideal isotope forjoint scanning (Laneet 1968) and has been used to study otherjoint diseases.

The scans, which consist of a pictorial image of the isotope localisation in and around the

joint, show changes in regional blood flow at the time of study and are abnormal during

acute inflammation (Weiss, Maxfield, Munson and Hidalgo 1965, 1966; Whaley, Pack, Boyle,

Dick, Downie, Buchanan and Gillespie 1968; McCarty, Polcyn and Collins 1970). While

visualisation of the isotope in an inflamed joint reflects mainly increased vascularity of the

synovial membrane and otherjoint tissues (Alarcon-Segovia, Trujeque, Tovar and Adame 1967;

Whaley et a!. 1968), part of the localisation of the radioactivity may be due directly to the

synovium binding the technetium (Green and Hays 1969; McCarty, Polcyn, Collins and

Gottschalk 1970; Mowat, Disney and Vaughan 1971). For these reasons joint scans are

abnormal in a variety of inflammatory joint diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis, gout,

psoriatic arthritis, acute pseudo-gout and experimental synovitis, but are not characteristically

specific for one type of inflammatory change. Nevertheless, as McCarty and his colleagues

have shown, the joint scan may be much more abnormal than the degree of symptoms and

signs would suggest, and because they can be repeated at intervals and do give an index of

blood flow in a joint, we thought it might be helpful to use joint scanning to measure the extent

of the synovial lesion in the joints of haemophiliacs. In addition we have compared the scans

taken during acute haemarthrosis with those taken in quiescent chronic haemophilic

arthropathy. Other assessments included the scan abnormalities in relation to the number of

previous bleeding episodes and to the clinical assessment of the joint abnormality. The present

study was confined to the knee joints, where scanning is optimum for clarity and comparative

work.

* Professor of Medicine, Leeds General Infirmary.

468 TIlE JOURNAL OF BONE AND JOINT SURGERY

RADIOISOTOPE KNEE JOINT SCANS IN HAEMOPHILIA AND CHRISTMAS DISEASE 469

METHODS AND PATIENTS STUDIED

To obtain the knee-joint scans, five millicuries of technetium, as sodium pertechnetate

(NaTcO4), were given as a single bolus intravenously to each patient and the knee-joint scans

commenced twenty-five minutes later as suggested by Whaley and his colleagues. The image

of the radioactivity distribution in the joint was obtained using a rectilinear scintiscanner

(Selo Model DS4/4) which has two five-inch detectors. Scans were performed of both knees,

first in the antero-posterior and then in the lateral position. The display was in colour, the

line spacing and the scan speed being adjusted for each patient, joint and position. The time

taken for each knee was approximately fifteen minutes.

Thirty-five patients were included in this study, ranging in age from eleven to sixty years,

and informed consent was obtained from all parents or subjects. Twenty-eight had classical

haemophilia and seven had Christmas disease. There was no clinical evidence of any other

variety ofjoint disease and the anti-nuclear factor and Rose-Waaler tests were negative.

Classification of the clinical severity of haemophilia was described by Biggs and Macfarlane

(1962). Patients were graded as “severe” cases if they had suffered repeated haemarthroses

with serious crippling and deep tissue haemorrhages from little or no provocation, as

“moderate” cases if they had sustained few haemarthroses with no serious crippling or

occasional muscle haematomas, and as “mild” cases if they had no haemarthrosis or other

spontaneous bleeding and merely gave a history of abnormal bleeding after definite injury.

Thus eighteen of our patients were classified as “severe”, six as “moderate” and eleven as

“mild” cases.

In each patient specific clinical assessment of the knee joints was carried out and each

of the features was arbitrarily graded from 0-3 ; these features were pain, effusion, pyrexia,

crepitus and degree of contracture. This we have called the “signs score”. The number of

previous bleeding episodes into the kneejoints was also graded from 0-3, a score ofO recording

no previous haemarthrosis, 1 one haemarthrosis, 2 less than one haemarthrosis per year and

3 more than one haemarthrosis per year; this we have called the “incidence score”. Six of

the thirty-five patients were seen with acute haemarthroses on a background of previous

episodes ofjoint bleeding, and fifteen with chronic joint disease of varying degrees of severity.

At the time of examination two patients had subacute disease ; this category was defined as a

swollen, non-tender joint with a normal range of movement which had not been the seat of

an acute bleed for at least six months. Twelve patients gave no previous history of joint

bleeds and had normal knee joints on clinical examination. In six of the patients clinical

examination and scanning was repeated as they recovered from or developed an acute joint

bleed.

The radioisotope scan colour images were examined by one observer (C. D. F.). Various

classifications of the images were considered, but it was ultimately decided that the most

practical method should be simple and visual. Accordingly, the group of scans from each

knee joint was examined and then said to be normal if it were obviously similar to knee joint

scans from controls in other studies (group 0). In the normal knee scan there is very little

isotope uptake. If the scans were obviously abnormal in width, depth and degree of isotope

uptake, with or without irregular localisation, they were said to be very abnormal (group 3).

Very abnormal scans show a high isotope uptake. Scans which were obviously abnormal but

not grossly so were counted as grade 2. Slightly abnormal scans were grade I . Examples of

these scans are shown in Figures 1 , 2 and 3.

RESULTS

Acute haemarthrosis (Table 1)-Each of the six patients in this group had severe haemophilia

and in each instance the scans of the acutely affected knee joint were grade 3. Serial scanning

of these patients showed that despite rapid resolution of the acute haemarthrosis following

appropriate haemostatic therapy, the scans remained abnormal for several weeks and in one

VOL. 54 B, NO. 3, AUGUST 1972

I

FIG. 1

FIG. 2 FIG. 3

Technetium scans of the knees showing the spectrum of abnormality of the scan and the method of scoring.Figure I-Scan from Case 8 showing a grade 3 scan in the right knee. Figure 2-Scan from Case 10 showinga grade 2 scan in the right knee. Figure 3-Scan from Case 2 showing grade I changes in the right knee

and grade 3 changes in the left.

470 C. D. FORBES, W. R. GREIG, C. R. M. PRENTICE AND G. P. MCNICOL

THE JOURNAL OF BONE AND JOINT SURGERY

patient were still abnormal at three months. Lateral scanning of the knees failed to localise

the isotope to any particular part of the joint.

Subacute joint disease (Table 11)-Both patients (Cases 7 and 8) had grade 3 scans only in the

affectedjoints. Both received haemostatic therapy and in a few days thejoint swelling subsided,

the “sign” score falling from 0 : 9 to 0 : 1 in Case 7 and from 6 : 1 to 1 : 1 in Case 8. However,

in Case 8 the scan remained abnormal six weeks later, the score having fallen from 3 : 0 to 1 : 0.

This patient has chronic arthropathy and the score may represent a baseline state for him.

Chronic joint disease (Table 111)-The details of the fifteen patients (Cases 9 to 23) in this

group are shown. Eleven ofthe patients had a severe grade ofhaemophilia and four a moderate

grade.

All the patients had abnormal scans from one or both knees but the abnormality grade

of the scans did not correlate with either the number of previous bleeding episodes or with

the clinical grading of the joints. For example, as Table III shows, there were joints in which

the scans were grossly abnormal (grade 3) despite no previous history of haemarthrosis or

abnormal signs in the joint.

No detectable joint disease (Table IV)-The data of the twelve patients (Cases 24 to 35) who

had no detectable disease are shown. Eleven of the twelve patients had a mild degree of

haemophilia. The single patient with a moderate degree had been afflicted with severe

RADIOISOTOPE KNEE JOINT SCANS IN HAEMOPHILIA AND CHRISTMAS DISEASE 471

paralytic poliomyelitis as a child and had never borne weight on the joints of the lower limbs;

however, he had sustained multiple other bleedings consistent with this degree of defect.

Despite the absence ofjoint signs, four of the patients had abnormal scans (grade 2 or 3).

DISCUSSION

One of the earliest, most frequent and most disabling manifestations of haemophitia is

acute haemarthrosis, the kneejoint being most frequently affected (Ghormley and Clegg 1948,

Fonio and Buhler 1952, DePalma and Cotler 1956b, Jordan 1958, Webb and Dixon 1960).

Haemorrhages into the joints start to appear as soon as the child begins to walk and Kerr

TABLE I

THE F1NDING IN SIX PATIENTS WITH ACUTE HAEMARTHROSIS

� � Incidence ofCase Age � � .� bleeding score � Sl�ns score Scan

number � (years) even y ________��____ ---�______________________� � Right � Left � Right � Left Right � Left

1 � 24 � Severe � 3 � 3 � I I � 4 3 0

2 � 17 � Severe � 3 3 4 � 12 1 3

3 14 Severe 3 � 3 0� 8� 0 3

4 22 Severe� 3 � 3 � 3 � 11 1 3

5 30 Severe 3 3 4 12 1 3

6 60 Severe 3 3 12 4 3 2

TABLE II

THE FINDING IN Two PATIENTS WITH SUBACUTE JOINT DISEASE

Casenumber

Age Severity(years)�

Incidence ofbleeding score Signs score Scan��Right Left Right Left Right Left

7

8

14 Moderate

21 Severe

0 1 0 0 0 3

3 2 6 1 30

(1963) has shown that 80 per cent of children under ten years of age with severe haemophilia

have abnormal knee joints. The etiology of these changes is poorly understood, but the joint

changes seen in haemophilic dogs (Swanton 1957, 1959) are similar to those in humans

(DePalma and Cotter 1956a). In our study all patients who presented with acute haemarthroses

had radiological evidence of chronic degenerative joint disease as a result of multiple previous

acute haemarthroses. As the study demonstrates, the scan abnormality particularly matches

the clinical severity in acute haemarthrosis. However, with appropriate therapy the joint signs

resolved within forty-eight hours, but serial scans remained abnormal for several weeks

suggesting a persistent increase of the local synovial blood flow throughout the knee.

The etiology of the signs in the joint in acute haemophilic haemarthrosis is not known,

but it has been suggested that pain is due to capsular distension and that intra-articular

bleeding will continue until the intrasynovial pressure exceeds that of the capillaries and

arterioles of the bleeding site. The signs are those of acute inflammation and are probably

the result of free blood in the joint cavity. Free blood is probably influenced by articular

VOL. MB, NO. 3, AUGUST 1972

TABLE III

THE FINDING IN FIFTEEN PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC JOINT DISEASE

Case � Age � Severit � bleedingscore � Signs score � Scannumber � (years) � � � �

� � Right Left Right � Left �_Right_� Left

9 � 24 Severe � I 3 0 � 4 � 2 � 3

10 � 25 � Moderate � 2 0 4 � 0 � 2 � 0

11 � 21 � Moderate � 1 0 1 0 � 2 2

l2� I9Severe 3 3 1 � 2 � 3 3

13 � 12 Severe 3 � 3 0 � 1 3 3

14 � 48 � Moderate 2 � 2 � 2 2 � 2

IS � 24 Severe 3 � 3 � 2 4 2

�: � �: Moderate 2 � 2 � 0 � 1 � I

19 38 Severe � 3 � 3 2 � 4 2

20 14 Severe 1 � 3 2 3 � 2

21 29 Severe 2 � 3 0 4 0

: :: :::::::2

3

3

3

TABLE Iv

THE FINDING IN TWELVE PATIENTS WITH NO CLINICALLY DETECTABLE JOINT DISEASE

49 Mild

25 16 Mild

26 50 Mild

27 II Mild

28 II Mild

29 14 Mild

30 35 Mild

31 52 Moderate

32 31 Mild

33 14 Mild

34 16 Mild

35 34 Mild

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

3

3

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

3

3

0

0

0

0

0

0

472 C. D. FORBES, W. R. GREIG, C. R. M. PRENTICE AND G. P. McNICOL

THF JOURNAL OF BONE AND JOINT SURGERY

RADIOISOTOPE KNEE JOINT SCANS IN 1-IAEMOPHILIA AND CHRISTMAS DISEASE 473

cartilage with release of polypeptide kinins (Moskowitz, Schwartz, Michel, Ratnoff and

Astrup 1970) through the conversion of plasma kallikreinogen to its active form, plasma

kallikrein. It is thought that kinins may then induce many of the phenomena observed in

inflammatory reactions (Ratnoff 1966).

In experimental studies injection of blood into the joints of animals (Key 1929, Young

and Hudacek 1954, Trueta 1966) produced an inflammatory response with hypertrophy of

the villi. The effect of a single injection was short lived but more pronounced effects could

be produced by multiple injections. A similar histological picture to that produced in

experimental animals has been found in thejoints ofa haemophilic patient (Key 1932). These

changes remain as long as blood or excess fluid is present. Ambulation at this time may

result in crushing of some of these villi, which may then produce further bleeding and so

initiate a vicious circle. The fact that the scans remain abnormal some time after all acute

clinical features have disappeared shows that temporary synovial hypertrophy is partly

involved in the process.

The subacute classification represents a variation of the processes seen in the acute joint.

In both our patients (Table II) there had been no clinical evidence of recent acute bleeding

and the joints had been swollen, hot and painless for over twelve weeks. However, the scans

were identical with those seen in acute bleeding. Repeat scanning in Case 8 six weeks later

showed only slight improvement despite total clinical resolution with adequate haemostatic

therapy.

All the patients with chronic joint disease had abnormal scans. However, there was no

correlation between the number of previous bleeds, the clinical signs and the scan ; some

patients with no signs in one joint had a grossly abnormal scan (Cases 1 1 and 23). Only

two of the thirty knee joints scanned in this group were normal ; one of these patients had no

signs but had a history of previous acute haemarthroses (Case 21). None of the patients in

this group had a history of recent acute haemarthrosis, so the abnormal scans presumably

represent a chronic state in which there is increased vascularity in the synovium. This is in

keeping with many previous descriptions of the histology of these chronic joints in which

the synovium was found to be markedly thickened, hyperplastic and endowed richly with

vascular channels (Bokelmann 1881 ; Konig 1892; Freund 1925; Collins 1949; DePalma and

Cotler 1956a; Rodnan, Brower, Hellstrom, Didisheim and Lewis 1959; Marion et a!. 1965;

Trueta 1966). Storti, Traldi, Tosatti and Davoli 1969 have described a hypertrophic

angiomatous type of synovium with thin-walled varicose veins on the surface which bled even

when touched with a gauze swab.

In the group of patients with no clinically detectable joint disease and no previous history

of bleeding into the knee joints, four patients had bilateral abnormal scans. These patients

were the youngest in this group. The abnormal scans presumably are a reflection of subclinical

bleeding into the joints, a condition analogous to the asymptomatic bleeding from the renal

capillaries which we have previously described in mild haemophilia (Prentice, Lindsay, Barr,

Forbes, Kennedy, McNicol and Douglas 1971).

In those patients with no apparent joint disease the articular scan may be of value in the

early detection of joint disease, and in the acute and subacute group the persistence of the

abnormality in the scan may indicate the importance of prophylactic therapy with plasma

concentrates as suggested by several authors (Ahlberg 1965 ; Kasper, Dietrich and Rapaport

1970; Brinkhous, Carnoy and Shermer 1971 ; Hirschman, ltscoitz and Shulman 1970;

vanCreveld 1971).

It seems certain that if prophylactic therapy in haemophilia is to be of value, then it

must be started before joint disease becomes established. We feel that the abnormality of

the articular scan is the earliest index of synovial hypertrophy, and if detected at this stage it

may enable us to break the vicious circle phenomenon of joint haemorrhage-�synovial

hypertrophy-�further haemorrhage. If adequate long term therapy can be given, healing

VOL. 54 B, NO. 3, AUGUST 1972

F

474 C. D. FORBES, W. R. GREIG, C. R. M. PRENTICE AND G. P. MCNICOL

THE JOURNAL OF BONE AND JOINT SURGERY

could proceed, perhaps with resolution of the synovial changes. if prophylactic therapy is

attempted when there is established bone disease the results are poor (van Creveld, Hoedemaeker,

Kingma and Wagenvoort 1971).

Recently, synovectomy has been carried out in patients with chronic haemophilic joint

disease (Storti et a!. 1969). The preliminary results seem encouraging but as yet no long

term follow-up is available. The articular scan should prove of value in the selection of patients

for this operation and in the assessment of the short and long term results. Articular scanning

may also prove of value in the assessment of steroids and antifibrinolytic agents in the

treatment of acute joint bleeds.

SUMMARY

I . in thirty-five patients, twenty-eight with classical haemophilia and seven with Christmas

disease, arthropathy of the knee of various grades has been investigated by radioisotope

scanning after intravenous injection of technetium, 99mTc.

2. The abnormality of the colour scan particularly matches the clinical severity in acute

haemarthrosis.

3. in patients with no clinically apparent joint disease the scan may be of value in the early

detection of involvement.

4. The possible value of articular scanning in the selection of patients for treatment and

in the assessment of the short and long term results is discussed.

REFERENCES

AHLBERG, A. (1965): Haemophilia in Sweden. VII Incidence, Treatment and Prophylaxis ofArthropathy andother Musculo-skeletal Manifestations of Haemophilia A and B. Acta Orthopaedica Scandinavica,

Supplementum 77.

ALAR#{231}ON-SEGOVIA, D., TRUJEQUE, M., TOVAR, E., ADAME, M. A. (1967): Scintillation Scanning of Joints with

Technetium 99m. (Abstract) Arthritis and Rheumatism, 10, 262.

ANON (1968): Editorial. Lance,’, 2, 131.BIGG5, R., and MACFARLANE, R. G. (1962): Human Blood Coagulation and its Disorders. Third Edition.

Oxford : Blackwell Scientific Publications.BOKELMANN, W. (1 881) : Ueber die Natur u,zd Bedeutung der haemophilen Gelenkaffectionen. Gottingen:

W. F. K#{228}stner.

BRINKHOUS, K. M., CARNOY,� Ch. N., and SHERMER, R. W. (1971): Use of High-Potency Antihemophilic

Concentrates in Prophylaxis. Thrombosis et diathesis haemorrhagica, Supplement 43, p. 139.

COLLINS, D. H. (1949): Haemophilia. In The Pathology of Articular and Spinal Diseases, p. 225. London:Edward Arnold & Co.

CREVELD, S. van (1969): Prophylaxis of Joint Haemorrhages in Haemophilia. Ada Haematologica, 41, 206.

CREVELD, S. van (1971): Prophylaxis of Joint Haemorrhages in Haemophilia. Acta Haematologica, 45, 120.

CREVELD, S. van, HOEDEMAEKER, Ph. J., KINGMA, M. J., and WAGENVOORT, C. A. (1971): Degeneration of

Joints in Haemophiliacs under Treatment by Modern Methods. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery,

53-B, 296.

DEPALMA, A. F., and COTLER, J. M. (1956a): Haemophilic Arthropathy. Archives ofSurgery, 72, 247.

DEPALMA, A. F., and COTLER, J. M. (1956b): Hemophilic Arthropathy. Clinical Orthopaedics, 8, 163.

DICK, W. C., NEUFELD, R. R., PRENTICE, A. G., WOODBURN, A., WHALEY, K., NUKI, G., and BUCHANAN, W. W.

(1970): Measurement ofJoint Inflammation: A Radioisotopic Method. Annals ofthe Rheumatic Diseases,

29, 135.

FoNlo, A., and BUHLER, W. (1952): Die rontgenologische Darstellung des Blutergelenkes an Hand von 136Gelenkaufnahmen der Fonioschen Sammlung. Radiologia Clinica, 21, 316.

FREUND, E. (1925): Die Gelenkerkrankung der Bluter. Virchows Archiv f#{252}rpaihologische Anatomie und

Physiologie und f#{252}rklinische Medizin, 256, 158.GHORMLEY, R. K., and CLEGG, R. S. (1948): Bone and Joint Changes in Hemophilia. Journal of Bone and

Joint Surgery, 30-A, 589.

GREEN, F. A., and HAYS, M. T. (1969): Joint Scanning: Mechanism and Application. Arthritis and Rheumatism,

12, 299.

HIRSCHMAN, R. J., ITSCOITZ, S. B., and SHULMAN, N. R. (1970): Prophylactic Treatment of Factor VIIIDeficiency. Blood, 35, 189.

JORDAN, H. H. (1958): Hemophilic Arthropathies. Springfield, lllinois: Charles C. Thomas.

RADIOISOTOPE KNEE JOINT SCANS IN HAEMOPHILIA AND CHRISTMAS DISEASE 475

KASPER, C. K., DIETRICH, S. L.,and RAPAPORT, S. I. (1970): Hemophilia Prophylaxis with Factor VIII Concentrate.

Archives of Internal Medicine, 125, 1004.

KERR, C. B. (1963): The Management ofHaemophilia. Glebe: AustralasianMedical Publishing Co. Ltd.

KEY, J. A. (1929): Experimental Arthritis. Journal ofBone and Joint Surgery, 11, 705.

KEY, J. A. (1932): Hemophilic Arthritis (Bleeder’s Joints). Annals ofSurgery, 95, 198.KONIG, F. (1892): Die Gelenkerkrankungen bei Blutern mit besonderer BerUcksichtigung der Diagnose.

Sammiung klinischer Vortrage von R. von Volkmann, N.F. Chfrurgie, nr. 11, 233.

MCCARTY, D. J., POLCYN, R. E., COLLINS, P. A., and GOTFSCHALK, A.(1970): 99m Technetium Scintiphotographyin Arthritis. I. Technic and Interpretation. Arthritis and Rheumatism, 13, 11.

MCCARTY, D. J., POLCYN, R. E., and COLLINS, P. A. (1970): 99m Technetium Scintiphotography in Arthritis.

II. Its Nonspecificity and Clinical and Roentgenographic Correlations in Rheumatoid Arthritis. Arthritis

and Rheumatism, 13, 21.

MARION, J., FAVRE-GILLY, J., PICAULT, Ch., and GAUTHIER, G. (1965) : Ddcouverte d’une h#{233}mophilie it l’occasion

d’une intervention pour synovite villeuse du coude. H#{233}mostase, 5, 69.

MosKowrrz, R. W., SCHWARTZ, H. J., MICHEL, R., RATNOFF, 0. D., and ASTRUP, T. (1970): Generation of

Kinin-like Agents by Chondroitin Sulfate, Heparin, Chitin Sulfate and Human Articular Cartilage;Possible Pathophysiologic Implications. Journal ofLaboratory and Clinical Medicine, 76, 790.

MOWAT, A. G., DISNEY, T. F., and VAUGHAN, J. H. (1971): Articular Scanning and External Counting in

Experimental Synovitis in the Guinea Pig. Annals ofthe Rheumatic Diseases, 30, 183.

PRENTICE, C. R. M., LINDSAY, R. M., BARR, R. D., FORBES, C. D., KENNEDY, A. C., MCNICOL, G. P., and

DOUGLAS, A. S. (1971): Renal Complications in Haemophilia and Christmas Disease. Quarterly Journal

ofMedicine, 40, 47.RATNOFF, 0. D. (1966): The Biology and Pathology of the Initial Stages of Blood Coagulation. Progress in

Hematology, 5, 204.RODNAN, G. P., BROWER, T. D., HELLSTROM, H. R., DIDISHEIM, P., and LEWIS, J. H. (1959): Post Mortem

Examination of an Elderly Severe Hemophiliac, with Observations on the Pathologic Findings in

Hemophilic Joint Disease. Arthritis and Rheumatism, 2, 152.

STORTI, E., TRALDI, A., TOSATFI, E., and DAVOLI, P. G. (1969): Synovectomy, a New Approach to Haemophilic

Arthropathy. Acta Haematologica, 41, 193.STORTI, E., TRALDI, A., TOSATFI, E., and DAVOLI, P. G. (1969): La sinoviectomia nell’emofilia. Gaz:ette

sanitaria (Milano), 40, 229.

SWANTON, M. C. (1957): The Pathology of Hemarthrosis in Hemophilia. In Hemophilia and Hemophiioid

Diseases, p. 219. Edited by K. M. Brinkhous. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.SWANTON, M. C. (1959): Hemophilic Arthropathy in Dogs. Laboratory Investigation, 8, 1269.

TRUETA, J. (1966): The Orthopaedic Management of Patients with Haemophilia and Christmas Disease. In

Treatment of Haemophilia and other Coagulation Disorders, p. 279. Edited by R. Biggs and R. G.Macfarlane. Oxford : Blackwell Scientific Publications.

WEBB, J. B., and DIXON, A. St. J. (1960): Haemophilia and Haemophilic Arthropathy. Annals ofihe Rheumatic

Diseases, 19, 143.WEISS, T. E., MAXFIELD, W. S., MURISON, P. J., and HIDALGO, J. U. (1965): lodinated Human Serum Albumin

(1.131) Localisation Studies of Rheumatoid Arthritis Joints by Scintillation Scanning. Arthritis and

Rheumatism, 8, 976.

WEISS, T. E., MAXFIELD, W. S., MURISON, P. J., and HJDALGO, J. U. (1966): Scintillation Scanning in RheumatoidArthritis. Southern Medical Journal, 59, 484.

WHALEY, K., PACK, A. I., BOYLE, J. A., DICK, W. C., DOWNIE, W. W., BUCHANAN, W. W., and GILLESPIE, F. C.

(1968): The Articular Scan in Patients with Rheumatoid Arthritis: A Possible Method of QuantitatingJoint Inflammation using Radio-technetium. Clinical Science, 35, 547.

YOUNG, J. M., and HUDACEK, A. G. (1954): Experimental Production of Pigmented Villonodular Synovitis in

Dogs. American Journal ofPathology, 30, 799.

VOL. 54 B, NO. 3, AUGUST 1972