7
1 Contents: A Brief History of Ramadan By Ustadha Zaynab Ansari Its First is Mercy by Shaik Jihad Brown The Art of Fasting By Shaik Jamal Ud-Deen Ramadan Lessons: Hope By Imam Zaid Shakir As-Salaamu Alaykum and Ramadan Mubarak! The mission of the Qur’an&Sunnah (Q&S)Ramadan Digest is to introduce Muslims residing in the Metro-Atlanta area to important local and indigenous male and female scholars present in their or their neighboring communities. Our goal is to teach and inform the masses, both Muslim and Non-Muslim alike, of the various and copious aspects, splendors, and subtleties of the glorious Month of Ramadan. We strive to construct the bridges of relation between the scholars featured in this publication and the Muslim communities. RAMADANDIGEST RAMADANDIGEST Ramadan 11, 1431 Q S & Improve Yourself...Improve the World

Ramadan Letters 1

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

A very good collection of articles by respected scholars.

Citation preview

  • 1Contents: A Brief History of Ramadan By Ustadha Zaynab Ansari

    Its First is Mercy by Shaik Jihad Brown

    The Art of Fasting By Shaik Jamal Ud-Deen

    Ramadan Lessons: Hope By Imam Zaid Shakir

    As-Salaamu Alaykum and Ramadan Mubarak!The mission of the Quran&Sunnah (Q&S)Ramadan Digest is to introduce Muslims residing in the Metro-Atlanta area to important local and indigenous male and female scholars present in their or their neighboring communities. Our goal is to teach and inform the masses, both Muslim and Non-Muslim alike, of the various and copious aspects, splendors, and subtleties of the glorious Month of Ramadan. We strive to construct the bridges of relation between the scholars featured in this publication and the Muslim communities.

    RAMADANDIGESTRAMADANDIGES

    T R

    amad

    an 1

    1, 1

    431 Q S& Improve Yourself...Improve the World

    THTSTypewritten TextArticles Edited By: Maryum Abdul-Hakeem Salahudeen Abdul Malik

  • It was the month of Ramadn in which the Qurn was [first] bestowed from on high...

  • Ramadan is the ninth month of the Islamic lunar calendar. Lasting for either twenty-nine or thirty days from the first morning after the sighting of the crescent moon, Ramadan has been observed by Muslims as a month of fasting and devotion for the last 1400 years. Linguistically, The word Ramadan refers to intense heat, perhaps an indication that the first Ramadan occurred during the summer. The Islamic calendar, or Hijri calendar, dates back to 622 CE, when Prophet Muhammad, Allah bless him and give him peace, emigrated from Mecca to Medina in the seminal journey known as the Hijra.2 Because the calendar is lunar, its twelve months also migrate through the year, with each month beginning eleven days prior to its start the previous year. What this means is that Muslims have experienced Ramadan in all four seasons: spring, summer, fall, and winter, especially those who live or have lived in temperate climates.

    In North America, believers have come full circle as the intensely hot Ramadans of the early-to-mid 1980s have now returned. This year, the first of Ramadan is predicted to fall on August 11, which means Muslims in Georgia will be fasting in 90 weather with up to 50% humidity. This experience will connect us back to the earliest Muslim community who withstood extreme temperatures in order to carry out the divine commandment to fast.

    Fasting was legislated in Shaban of 2 AH (the second year after Hijra).3 Shaban, incidentally is the month immediately preceding Ramadan and was a month in which the Prophet, Allah bless him and give him peace, loved to perform voluntary fasting as means of preparation for Ramadan.4 Allah the Most High revealed in the Quran, O ye who believe! Fasting is prescribed for you, even as it was prescribed for those before you, that ye may ward off (evil); (Fast) a certain number of days; and (for) him who is sick among you, or on a journey, (the same) number of other days; and for those who can afford it there is a ransom: the feeding of a man in need. But whoso doeth good of his own accord, it is better for him: and that ye fast is better for you if ye did but know. The month of Ramadan in which was revealed the Qur'an, a guidance for mankind, and clear proofs of the guidance, and the Criterion (of right and wrong). And whosoever of you is present, let him fast the month, and whosoever of you is sick or on a journey, (let him fast the same) number of other days. Allah desireth for you ease; He desireth not hardship for you; and (He desireth) that ye should complete the period, and that ye should magnify Allah for having guided you, and that peradventure ye may be thankful.5

    The early Muslims understood from this revelation that fasting was an act of worship they shared with previous faith communities; however, the Ummah (community) of the Prophet, Allah bless him and give him peace, was singular in its month-long fast of Ramadan. Ramadan was also distinguished by being the month of the Quran, in which God revealed the first words of the sacred scripture to the Prophet, Allah bless him and give him peace, in the momentous encounter between Muhammad and the Archangel Gabriel. Furthermore, fasting the month of Ramadan came to be known as a pillar of Islam, based on the sound Prophetic hadith, Islam has been built on five [pillars]: Testifying that there is no god but Allah and that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah, performing the prayers, paying alms, making the pilgrimage to the House, and fasting Ramadan.2 In this way, Muslim individual responsibility and communal identity came to revolve around major acts of devotion:

    ritual prayer, fasting, almsgiving, and pilgrimage. These acts of devotion would form the basis of Muslim civilization as Islam spread beyond the borders of the Arabian Peninsula, unifying ethnically, linguistically, and culturally diverse peoples under the banner of tawhid (monotheism) and ritual acts of worship.

    Today, we are linked back to the earliest community and are connected to Muslims globally through this centuries-old devotion of fasting. In fact, ones entrance into taklif, or adulthood under Islamic ritual law, is signified by acts of ritual worshipprayer, fasting, almsgiving, and pilgrimagebecoming obligatory upon one.

    Granted, fasting has changed drastically since the time of the Prophet, Allah bless him and give him peace. Many of us are fortunate enough to have access to air conditioning and other modern amenities that make the summer months bearable and even enjoyable. However, the essence of fasting has not changed. And that is the fact that Muslims fast Ramadan because it is a command from Allah, a means of drawing closer to our Creator, a way to reconnect with the Sunna (tradition) of the Prophet, Allah bless him and give him peace, and a reminder that, ultimately everything we do is for the sake of God, even if it means being hungry and thirsty during the long summer days of the Deep South.

    In fact, the attitude of the believer has always been one of joy at the commencement of Ramadan. Ramadan is seen as a great gift of God. The Prophet, Allah bless him and give him peace, in one of many hadiths (sayings) on the virtues of fasting, stated, When Ramadan comes, the gates of the Garden are opened, the gates of the Fire are closed and the shaytans (devils) are chained up.3

    We understand from this Prophetic tradition that Ramadan is a time of great opportunity to grow spiritually. We should resolve to make Ramadan a time of spiritual cleansing and rejuvenation. Bad habits are replaced with good, tempers are calmed, and adab (Islamic etiquette) is learned. We end the month equipped with the spiritual tools to transform our lives for the better in the following years.

    May Allah the Most High grant us all an accepted Ramadan and many more Ramadans to come!

    A Brief History of Ramadan By Ustadha Zaynab Ansari

    RAMADANDIGES

    T R

    amad

    an 1

    1, 1

    431

    Ustadha Zaynab AnsariUstadha Zaynab Ansari spent several years studying Islam in Syria at Abu Nour University. Upon her return to the United States, she continued her Islamic studies with Shaykh Khalil Abdur-Rashid, who is now Imam of New York's Iqra Masjid, and with Shaykh Faraz Rabbani, educational director of SeekersGuidance. From 2004 to 2009, she volunteered, answered questions, and taught for SunniPath Academy. Ustadha Zaynab currently answers questions for SeekersGuidance burgeoning Answers Blog and writes for Azizah Magazine's Deen Department. She has undergraduate degrees in history and Middle Eastern Studies from Georgia State University. Ustadha Zaynab is married and has three childrenTo read the full bio, see page 7.

  • In the collection of Al-Bayhaqi, the Prophet refers to Ramadan as a month, the first of which is compassion, the middle of which is

    forgiveness, and the end of which is freedom from the fire.

    Compassion is a sympathetic consciousness of anothers distress

    coupled with a desire to alleviate it. Mercy, another word

    commonly used in the same context, implies forgoing punishment

    even when justice demands it, or lenient compassionate

    treatment.

    But how is a month mercy? What is the nature of its source, the

    mercy of Allah? How does this extend to the compassion of His

    subjects, one for another? And how does all of it form an

    integrated whole, or a closed system?

    In Ramadan, we are informed in the soundest narrations that on

    the first night the sky is opened and the gates of the hellfire are

    locked. The doors to paradise are flung wide and the demons are

    bound and shackled. It is a month in which sins are forgiven,

    prayers are answered and all colors of goodness are on tap. It is a

    season of worship and devotion, the promised rewards for which

    are doubled.

    The mercy of Allah is an expression of the proffers, blessings, and

    generosities that He pours over His devotees in this month. In the

    Quran He says: My mercy encompasses everything; and the

    pious used to call out, as if to remind Him, O Allah! I am a thing!

    In the chapter of the Cattle, He says: And your Lord has

    prescribed mercy upon Himself. The rain is employed as a

    metaphor for His grace that He distributes, even after a people

    have despaired at its arrival.

    In the chapter of Rome, he says: Do

    you not see the effects of the mercy of

    Allah, how he resuscitates the earth after it

    was dead?

    The hearts of people that have been lost in

    the dry barrenness of materiality are like

    the earth in autumn and winter, awaiting a

    spring of awakening in Ramadan.

    Gratefulness for these blessings entails

    that the hearts of the faithful overflow in

    return with fraternal compassion for other

    sentient beings and sentient life.

    Giving and catering to unmet needs is a

    sign that compassion has taken up

    residence in the heart. The fasting person

    has undergone hunger and thirst, thereby

    experiencing difficulty and deprivation.

    Empathy is one of the fruits of fasting that

    people can share with one another.

    The recent healthcare crisis hotly debated

    in the United States marked a decisive deficit in compassion.

    Some 47 million Americans do not have health care and

    unfortunately, many of the boat-owners who own healthcare insist

    that the less fortunate should be left in the water to get wet. They

    believe that it is not their problem that others less industrious and

    affluent than themselves cannot find and do not have a way to

    stay dry.

    The fruit of the tree of individualism can be bitter. The myopia of

    parochialism and the fetters of xenophobia prevent us from

    comprehending that other less prosperous nations have sorted

    out ready solutions in which all boats rise.

    The Prophet said that mercy is not removed from the heart of

    anyone but the wretched.

    In the celebrated hadith designated as the first to be taught to any

    student of Sacred Law, the Prophet says: Those who show

    compassion to others will be shown mercy. Have compassion for

    those in the earth, and those in the heavens will show compassion

    to you.

    Its First is Mercy

    By Shaik Jihad H. Brown

    RAMADANDIGES

    T R

    amad

    an 1

    1, 1

    431

    Shaik Jihad H. BrownJihad Hashim Brown was born in Santa Ana, California. He graduated from Rutgers University in 1994 with a Bachelor of Arts degree in Psychology and a Minor in Middle East Studies. Upon graduation, he went on to pursue studies in Islamic Juristic Methodology, Theology and Logic with renowned scholars in Damascus, Syria. Subsequently, he continued studies of Islamic Juristic Methodology from the Compendium of Compendiums of al-Taj al-Subki in the antique madrasahs of the Southern Atlas Mountains in Morocco. Jihad Brown now lives in Abu Dhabi with his wife and five children.

  • The poet once said (Al-Eid, laisa leman

    yelbasu jaded..Al-Eid leman tauatuhu

    yazeed). It means that the Eid (after

    Ramadan) is not for the one that wears

    new clothes, the Eid is for he that has

    increased himself in worship.

    This poem really hits the nail on the

    head in that it implies that many people

    have not come to understand what Eid is

    really about. Many of us run off to get

    new outfits, our hair and nails done, and

    the beards shaped up, We try to look as

    sharp as we possibly can. Then when we

    get to the Eid prayer, as soon as the

    prayer is over we are up and walking

    around talking, ready to show off our new

    look. Many of us are so disconnected

    from the true understanding of this time,

    which the poet discusses in the second

    part of his poem by saying that the Eid is

    for the one that has increased him/herself

    in worship. Oh yes, the Eid is a

    celebration of worship. We are not

    celebrating the fact that we can eat and do other things anytime we

    want, nor are we celebration the struggle of going without food, drink

    and other things, because all of these actions are actually connected

    to the material world. In truth, all worship is and has to be connected

    to Allah, otherwise it is nothing more than a mundane action.

    In the books of Islamic Jurisprudence, the jurists say that the

    integrals (Arkan, singular: rukn) of Islam are five, based on authentic

    hadith, of which fasting is the fourth integral. When we examine the

    word integral, we find that the jurists define it as an intrinsic part of

    an entity that, if it were not present, the true essence of the entity

    could never be realized. Fasting, as mentioned, is an integral of

    Islam, so if the fast is not performed properly then the true essence

    of Islam cannot and will not be realized. Islam is defined by the

    jurists as complete submission and surrender, coupled with the

    complete resignation of ones self (istislaam) before Allah, and

    absolute conviction (inqiyaad) in He who one proclaims he or she

    believes in (Allah). If one has completely submitted to Allah and

    destroyed his or her desires, ego, etc. as a result of his or her

    adamantine belief in Allah, everything he or she does is solely for

    Allah (Ikhlas).

    When one does everything for the sake of Allah, the quality of his or

    her worship is increased and all that he or she does is with

    connection to Allah taala. This connection is essential to our fasting

    (as it is with all aspects of worship). It turns the mundane act of

    fasting into an act of worship that becomes deeply filled with the

    splendor and depth that is intrinsic to fasting, thereby allowing one

    to truly become aware of the essence of Islam and the essence of

    being Muslim. We find that having a connection with Allah is found

    linguistically in the very definition of the word fasting. Fasting means

    to abstain. It juristically means to abstain from food, drink, those

    things that enter openings in the body and reach the body cavity, self

    induced vomiting, masturbation, sex, with a specific intention from

    dawn (fajr) until sunset (maghrib) with the purpose of becoming close

    to Allah taala (Qamus Al-Fiqhiyya pg. 219, Dar Al-Fiqir).

    A sincere connection between worship and Allah is the foundation

    for everything that we do. Having said that, as we examine the art of

    fasting we should endeavor to continue to reflect on the foundation

    that mus be the forethought of everything, spanning from the

    sighting of the moon to begin Ramadan to the sighting of the moon

    to bring about our day of celebrating our increased worship.

    Look for Part 2 of this article in next weeks edition of the

    RamdanDigest.

    The Art of FastingPart 1By Ustadh Jamal Ud-Deen Hysaw

    RAMADANDIGES

    T R

    amad

    an 1

    1, 1

    431

    Ustadh Jamal Ud-DeenSidi Jamal ud-Deen is originally from Chicago, Illinois. He obtained his undergraduate degree in Political Science from Southern Illinois University. In the summer of 1992, he embraced Islam and subsequently traveled to Damascus, Syria where he studied Arabic and Islamic Studies at Abu Nur and the University of Damascus for three years. He then traveled to Dar al-Mustafa in Tarim, Yemen where he studied with scholars for another five years. Shaykh Jamaluddin received permission from his teachers to teach and comment on books of Shafi Fiqh, Aqida, Hadith, Tafsir, and the Sciences of the Heart. Upon leaving Yemen, he served as an assistant Imam at a mosque in Crawley, England. In Spring 2004, he returned to the United States and currently resides with his family in Atlanta.

  • RAMADANDIGES

    T R

    amad

    an 1

    1, 1

    431 Ramadan Lessons:

    HopeIbn RajabTranslated by Imam Zaid Shakir

    Translators note: #$% #'% Ramadan Mubarak! May you all be blessed during this

    blessed month. The month of Ramadan

    combines fear and hope, hardship and

    relief. In the following section Ibn Rajab

    encourages hope by detailing the

    tremendous manifestations of forgiveness

    God has opened for the servant during

    Ramadan. (pp. 377-387)

    During the Month of Ramadan there are

    many avenues to Gods forgiveness. These

    include: Fasting the month; standing in

    prayer during its nights; the Night of Power;

    all of which have been previously

    mentioned. These avenues also include:

    1. Providing the wherewithal for the fasting

    person to break his fast;

    2. Easing an employees burden. Both of

    these have been mentioned in a prophetic

    tradition related by Salman.

    3. Remembering God abundantly. It is related

    in a tradition referred back to the Prophet,

    peace upon him: One who remembers God

    abundantly in Ramadan will be forgiven.

    4. Seeking Gods forgiveness. The prayer of

    the fasting person is guaranteed an answer

    during the time he is fasting and at the time

    that he breaks his fast. For this reason, Ibn

    Umar, may God be pleased with him and his

    father, would pray when breaking his fast: O

    God! Possessor of the most expansive

    forgiveness, please forgive me! A tradition

    concerning the virtue of Ramadan, related by

    Abu Hurayra, may God be pleased with him,

    mentions that the Prophet, peace upon him,

    said: Everyone will be forgiven during it

    (Ramadan) except one who refuses. They

    asked: O Abu Hurayra! Who would ever

    refuse? He said: One who refuses to seek

    Gods forgiveness.

    5. [Among these paths of forgiveness] are the

    angels seeking forgiveness for the fasting

    people until they break their fast.

    In that the causes facilitating forgiveness are

    so numerous during Ramadan, one who

    misses the opportunity to be forgiven during

    this month has been deprived the very

    epitome of depravation. Abu Hurayra, may

    God be pleased with him, in the compilation

    of Imam Ibn Hibban, narrates:

    The Prophet, peace upon him, ascended the

    minbar and proceeded to say: Amen, Amen,

    Amen. He was asked: O Messenger of

    God, [What caused] you to ascend the

    minbar and then thrice say, Amen? He

    replied: The Angel Gabriel came to me and

    said: Whoever attains to the month of

    Ramadan and is not forgiven will enter Hell

    and be distanced from God. He then

    commanded: Say Amen! So I said: Amen.

    He then said: Whoever outlives his parents,

    or even one of them, and has not behaved

    righteously towards them, and then dies; he

    will enter Hell and be distanced from God.

    He then commanded, Say Amen! So I said,

    Amen. He then said: When your name is

    mentioned in someones presence and he

    does not pray for mercy for you ()*+ ,-. /0 and then dies; he will enter Hell and be

    distanced from God. He then commanded,

    Say Amen! So I said, Amen. [1]

    Said relates from Qatada that he said:

    Whoever is not forgiven in Ramadan will

    never be forgiven during any other time. If a

    person is not forgiven during Ramadan then

    when will he be forgiven? When will the

    deeds of one whose deeds are rejected

    during the Night of Power be accepted?

    When will one who cannot be upright during

    Ramadan ever be upright? When will one

    debilitated with the diseases of ignorance

    and heedlessness be healthy if not during

    Ramadan? All fruit not harvested during its

    proper season, dries on the branch and then

    is plucked and thrown in a fire. One who

    neglects sowing during the time of planting

    only harvests remorse and loss.

    The first part of Ramadan is mercy, its middle

    days are forgiveness, and its latter part is

    liberation from Hell. Hence, it is related that

    during it the gates of mercy are flung open.

    [2] It is related by Imam al-Tirmidhi and

    others: God has those that He liberates

    from the Hellfire during every night of

    Ramadan. [3]

    [In considering what is said about the month,

    we can say that] its first part is dominated by

    mercy, etc. This mercy is especially

    designated for the God-conscious

    individuals who are excellent in their religion.

    God mentions in the Quran: Gods mercy is

    close for those who are excellent in their

    religion. (7:56) He also says: My mercy

    encompasses everything. I have ordained it

    for the God-conscious who fulfill the right of

    charity. (7:156) Hence, during the beginning

    of the month the cloak of mercy and [Gods]

    good pleasure envelop the God-conscious.

    The people of excellence are treated in the

    most gracious and excellent manner.

    Look for Part 2 of this article in next

    weeks edition of the RamdanDigest.

    Imam Zaid ShakirImam Zaid Shakir is amongst the most respected and influential Islamic scholars in the West.

    For seven years in Syria, and briefly in Morocco, he immersed himself in an intense study of Arabic, Islamic law, Quranic studies, and spirituality with some of the top Muslim scholars of our age. In 2001, he graduated from Syrias prestigious Abu Noor University and returned to Connecticut.

    In 2003, he moved to Zaytuna Institute, where he now teaches courses on Arabic, Islamic law, history, and Islamic spirituality.

    To read the full bio, see page 7.

  • Biographies of Our Contributors

    Ustadha Zaynab AnsariZaynab Ansari (Umm Salah) comes from a Lebanese-American and African-American background. In 1996, Zaynabs parents

    relocated the family to Damascus, Syria, where Zaynab and her younger sister spent four years studying sacred knowledge.

    During that time, Zaynab obtained a Thanawiyya Shariyyah (equivalent to a secondary school diploma) with distinction from

    Abu Nour Islamic Foundation. There, she was acquainted with the major Islamic sciences, including Arabic, Quranic exegesis,

    Quranic recitation, Shafii fiqh, sira, hadith, hadith classification, inheritance law, and theology. Her teachers included Ustadh

    Adnan al-Azmeh, Ustadha Sousan Falah, Ustadha Sanaa, Ustadha Huda al-Habash, Ustadha Samar, and the master Quran

    reciter Shaykh Muhammad al-Sukkar. Zaynab also spent a year studying advanced Arabic at the University of Damascus.

    Upon returning to the United States, Zaynab continued her Islamic studies with Sidi Khalil Abdur-Rashid, who studied with

    traditional scholars in Yemen and Turkey. She also earned a B.A. in History and a B.I.S. in Middle Eastern Studies at Georgia

    State University, graduating summa cum laude. She has received a number of scholarships, including the Faculty Scholarship

    Award, the Honors Alumni Scholarship, and the Phi Alpha Theta Award. Zaynab also worked extensively with the M S A at her

    previous school, Georgia Perimeter College.

    In her free time, Zaynab enjoys volunteering for the Islamic Speakers Bureau and writing for Azizah Magazine. She is one of the

    main teachers behind the SunniPath Answers service, and her answers are highly popular because of their knowledge,

    wisdom, and sensitivity. She has both taught and TAd courses at SunniPath Academy. Zaynab is passionate about

    contributing to an enhanced understanding of Islam in America, with a particular emphasis on the achievements of Muslim

    women. She is married with one son and one daughter, and currently resides in Atlanta, GA

    Imam Zaid Shakir

    Born in Berkeley, California, Imam Zaid accepted Islam in 1977 while serving in the United States Air Force. He obtained a BA

    with honors in International Relations at American University in Washington D.C. and later earned his MA in Political Science

    at Rutgers University. While at Rutgers, he led a successful campaign for divestment from South Africa, and co-founded New

    Brunswick Islamic Center formerly Masjid al-Huda.

    After a year of studying Arabic in Cairo, Egypt, he settled in New Haven, Connecticut and continued his community activism,

    co-founding Masjid Al-Islam, the Tri-State Muslim Education Initiative, and the Connecticut Muslim Coordinating Committee.

    As Imam of Masjid Al-Islam from 1988 to 1994 he spear-headed a community renewal and grassroots anti-drug effort, and also

    taught political science and Arabic at Southern Connecticut State University. He served as an interfaith council Chaplain at

    Yale University and developed the Chaplaincy Sensitivity Training for physicians at Yale New Haven Hospital. He then left for

    Syria to pursue his studies in the traditional Islamic sciences.

    For seven years in Syria, and briefly in Morocco, he immersed himself in an intense study of Arabic, Islamic law, Quranic

    studies, and spirituality with some of the top Muslim scholars of our age. In 2001, he graduated from Syrias prestigious Abu

    Noor University and returned to Connecticut, serving again as the Imam of Masjid al-Islam, and writing and speaking

    frequently on a host of issues. That same year, his translation from Arabic into English of The Heirs of the Prophets was

    published by Starlatch Press.

    In 2003, he moved to Hayward, California to serve as a scholar-in-residence and lecturer at Zaytuna Institute, where he now

    teaches courses on Arabic, Islamic law, history, and Islamic spirituality. Imam Zaid has also authored numerous articles on a

    wide range of topics. In 2005, Zaytuna Institute published, Scattered Pictures: Reflections of An American Muslim an

    anthology of diverse essays penned by Zaid Shakir. In 2008, he authored an award-winning text, Treatise for the Seekers of

    Guidance, a translation and commentary on Imam Harith al-Muhasibis work, Risala al-Mustarshideen. He also co-founded

    Zaytuna College this same year.

    He is a frequent speaker at local and national Muslim events and has emerged as one of the nations top Islamic scholars and a

    voice of conscience for American Muslims and non-Muslims alike. Imam Zaid has served as an advisor to many organizations,

    and influential leaders. Recently, Imam Zaid was ranked as one of Americas most influential Scholars in the West; by The

    500 Most Influential Muslims, edited by John Esposito and Ibrahim Kalin, (2009).

    While many have cited Imam Shakir as example of Islamic moderation, his critics have questioned his moderate credentials by

    citing his expressed hope for the conversion of America to Islam and adoption of Islamic law in America. Dr. Ingrid Mattson

    stated that Imam Zaid is solidly grounded in the Islamic legal, ethical and intellectual tradition, which all Muslims share, as well

    as his personal understanding of the current political context.