24
I hlarch 20, 20a3 Mr. Jeff R. Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Commission 21 1 Sower Blvd. P.0. Box 615 Frankfort, KY 40602-061 5 Re: Symsonia WD Case No. 2012-00517 Dear Mr. Derouen, Piease find attached Symsonia Water District’s responses to the PSC data request of March 7, 2013. Jim Waid, Manager Symsonia ‘Water District

Re: WD No. 2012-00517 - KY Public Service Commission cases/2012-00517/20130322_Symson… · Jolui Hodges, PaducaWMcCracken JSA ... Adam Scott Bob Jost Jeremy Buchanan Kim DeRenarcl

  • Upload
    vancong

  • View
    215

  • Download
    2

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

I

hlarch 20, 20a3

Mr. Jeff R. Derouen, Executive Director Kentucky Public Service Commission 21 1 Sower Blvd. P.0. Box 615 Frankfort, KY 40602-061 5

Re: Symsonia WD Case No. 2012-00517

Dear Mr. Derouen,

Piease find attached Symsonia Water District’s responses to the PSC data request of March 7 , 2013.

Jim Waid, Manager Symsonia ‘Water District

The District had considered rehabilitation and upgrade to the existing plant as the main alternative to this project. There are several negative aspects to this option. First of all there isn’t a lot of property around the current loczlion to do the upgrade, and additional wells would need to be drilled in order l o expand the capacity of the system. Again the lack of real estate at this property causes problems with the cones of depression intersecting if additional wells were to be drilled there. In addition, the existing tank is not only under-sized, but requires extensive maintenance that the District has not been able io do, due to the lack of a long term water storage alternative. The major setback with this as a viable option is that with it being the only water source and storage for the Ristrict, there is no way to take if off line long enough to complete the construction for the upgrades required.

The District does have an emergency connection to Benton Water; however, this is for short-term emergency use only and is not capable of serving the entire Symsonia Water District for the number of months the upgrade would take.

The second alternative that the District considered was to drill the new wells at the location in this project and construct a trunk line to the existing plant for treatment and storage. The cost and route for such a trunk line vvoulcl have been difficult; however, the main downfall to this option is fairly obvious. The main issues of storage capacity and treatment capacity wouid remain, and as stated earlier, neither issue can be resolved in an economical manner at the existing site.

Witness: .Jim Waid

The proposed project was selected for a number of positive reasons. First of all a second water source and storage location for the district provides the redundancy that is required by the DOW for most systems. With a new polishing plant, wells, and storage the District can meet all the requirements for capacity at this location and can serve their existing cctstomer base from this site alone. The District can remain functioning with the existing facility during construction of the new facility. Once construction is complete and running the District may take the old facility off-line to do the needed maintenance on it. The new facility is designed to serve the entire system while the existing facility is off-line, as well as, function as two different pressure zones once the existing facility is broLight back on-line. The location for the proposed project was selected because of geographic lay out of the town. On the side of town where the new facility will be built, there are a number of propose subdivisions and property that is ready for development. With the new facility at this loca.tion, the District will be ready to serve these areas as they develop.

Witness: Jim Waid

e ne nt

The two previous answers have addressed this issue fairly thoroughly. However in addition, the old plant is approaching 50 years of age and again has reached its expected service life. Without the major upgrades required it is not affective to serve the District service area or the two additional subdivisions that have been developed. New plant will have the capacity for the existing service area, as well as, any expected additional developments for the area. The new plant will also include some upgrades such as soft start boosters to provide for better service for future generations of consumers.

Witness: Jim Waid

ay 27,2008

Actirig Chairman Kevin Murphy called the May 27, 2008, Purchase Area Water Management Council meeting to order at 10:OO a.m. Those in attendance were as follows:

~~~~~~~~ COkSP8211 Mayor John Wood, City of Barlow Tiiii Walker, Barlow W & §

Cdow lap eo llpBt$’

Lee Roy Barnett, Dexter-Almo Heights W.D. Glen Windsor, Murray W.D. 3

City ufMurrnp Dennis Thompson

G$-aves comfy Sam Davis, Hickory W. D. Gene A. Mason, Hnrdeman W.D. Lowell Smith, Hardernan W.D. Jimmy TVaid, Synisonia W.D.

Kevin Mui-phy, Calvert City L A . Landers, Marshall SD NO.1

McCmcken CoranQ Jolui Hodges, PaducaWMcCracken JSA John ‘Webb, PaducaldMcCracken JSA

1

a;umt.r Clem Wethington, Ky. Rural Assoc. Nathaii Wicltlin, Jackson Purchase, Found/TNC Jason Enlow, Hunter Martin & Associates

Adam Scott Bob Jost Jeremy Buchanan Kim DeRenarcl Cathy Holskouser

Wdcome and Introduction Clxiirmati Murphy thanked everyone for attending the meeting and welcomed

each guest.

LrX Approval oJNovembcr 15,2007 Mimfes Chairrnan Murphy referred the council to the minutes of the meeting November

15,200’7 which were on pages 1-5 in the meeting packet. Mr. Greg Terry made the motiori 10 approve the minutes followed by a second from Mr. Dennis Thompson. The motion passed unanimously.

I K Cdlfor Projects

before the board for approval. Mr. Adam Scott gave a brief description oftheir submitted project and Mr. Bob Jost presented the projects on the large screen for the board to review and discuss.

The following Water & Sewer projects on pages 6-i0 in the packel were brought

A, rveru warel. ~ r o j e c i s j ~ p ~ourtci i ~ p p ~ o v a l s/Z 7/2008 Mayfield Electric & Water Project # W21085053 Symsonia Water District Project # WX21083055

Mr. John I-Iodges made the motion to armrove the Mayfield Electric & Water project & Svmsonia Wales District project followed bv a second from Mr. Dennis Thompson.

o

B. Netu Sewer Project of &bstncalPApproval5/277.2008 City of Arlington Line Project # SX2 103 90 14

- - ~ Mr. Dennis Thompson made the motion to approve the City of Arlington emergency proiect followed by a second from Mr. Greg Terry.

V. HI3 BQB-I.eg&sl~tive Projects Mr. Adam Scott commented on the HB 608 Legislative Projects. Mr. Scott stated

that our area did really well with funding for prqjects. Mr. Scott with assistance from Mr. Bob Jost presented to the board Water & Wastewater Projects that were approved for fiiriding on ilie large screen.

2

Mr. Scott asked everyone to turn to page 27, in the packet and review the article in the Lexington Herald Leader. The article reveals the conundruni they are jn for bonds. Mr. J O ~ J Herald, at KIA told Mr. Scott that they would not be cutting projects but that they are going to try and do two different bond dates. First they will do the ones that need io be done immediately and then the projects that haven't had engineering done yet. Mr. Scott spoke with Mr. Richard Tidwell and he told him that he had heard from Debbie Milton, and she told him that there will be an announcement in the middle of June that they would not be able to draw funds until after January. Mr. Scott will keep everyone informed about when the mancy will be available.

_-_ WRIS# - - ~ COMMU NTIY

Rallard County WX2 10070I9- McCraclten Co./Faducah Water WX21145059

wx2 103501 9 ___I ~- - - ~ - WTc;!10350 17 Galloway County ~-

VI.

twenty five of the Intended Use Plan for Clean Water. The following is the list of Project Priority List for the Plan for Clean Water SRF.

rq5' of hiended Uw Pla~mfor Clem Water Mr. Scott directed the board to the list af projects that are listed starting at page

3

If you haw any questions or comments on the listings please contact Ms. Sandy Williams at KIA (502) 573-0260 or e-mail [email protected].

U I L 0th er B i i s h e m Mr. Scott asked for volunteers to be on a committee to establish Water

Management Council procedures to be put in writing. KIA would like for them to be submitted for the next contract year.

A. Committee for the Purchase Area Water Management Council Procedures Thee members volunteered to be on the committee for the Purchase Area Water

Managenlent Council to develop Council Procedures. B Dermis Thompson

0 Mayor John Wood RodMartin

B, Nominations Committee Three niernhers volunteered to be on the committee for the Nominations

Committee to select officers for the Council. &J Shannon McCleary

v Kevin Murphy John Hodges

C . Rates Book btr. Scott explained the Rates Rook for the Water Management Council. The

Rates Book contains Water & Sewer Rates for the Purchase Area. The book is available to view for examples of rates in the Purchase Area, Mr. Scott asked everyone that if you raise your rates please bring in a copy of them to the meeting, so that we can put it in the Rates Book. This will be available on the internet in the near future along with minutes from the meetings.

1%. Commettts

members discussed the issue and explained what they had done in the past. Mayor John Wood asked if anyone knew about recoating a clear well. Committee

Mr. Clem Wethington, with Kentucky Rural Water reported on the following cvenls cSS new projects.

a

e)

Water Operators training will be held on June 3-4, 2008, in Princeton at the UK Research Farm. Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition will be held August 25-27, 2008 at the I-Iyatt Regency & Lexington Convention Center in Lexington, Kentucky. Water & Waste Water training will be held on June 17, 18, & 19Ih, at Kentucky Darn Convention Center. There will be a mail out about the training.

0

4

e Kentucky Rural Water Association has been working with Western Kentucky University and has developed a new program called the WITTI Program. This program is intended to target high school or college students to get them interested in Water & Waste Water Management. The plans are to take the program nation wide. The L,ateral Line is a new publication for Kentucky on site septic systems and it will be published on a quarterly basis. Members were encouraged to k t anyone who was involved in the KOWA know about ehis publication.

a

Mr. Scott told the committee what a great job JudgeRx. Tony Smith on had done on the merger o f Consumers5 South Graves, Fancy Farm, and the Hardeman Water Districts into the new Graves County Water District.

x Adjourn There being no other business to discuss, Chaiman Murphy adjourned the

meeting .

4. ew weBIs and No

No?: only does the District need additional capacity that the new wells will provide, the old wells have had issues with sand screens deteriorating due to age. They need to be retired to back up use only, or redrilled and entirely new casings, screens, and filters installed. The size of the new clear well / ground storage tank has been designed for the expected 20 year growth and average daily storage capacity required for such demand. This tank is designed to function at several different levels of capacity. This was done so that the District can maintain the required turnover rate and the required storage for the existing demand as well as the 20-year projected demand as required by the DOW.

Witness: Jim Waid

Purchase Area Water Management Plan - -

May field Sedalia South Graves Symsonia Tri-City

Fulton Hinkman

Columbus

Benton Calved City Hardin Jonathan Creek North Marshall

Hendron Paducah Paducah/Reidland West McCracken

1 3 T O 4

1.5 1

LESS THAN 1 2

2 2

4 3

1 T O 2 1 TO2

1 2 1

1 I T 0 2

2 I T 0 2

1124103 12-1

The City of Benton contract is for emergency water only and only if their system can oblige. The connection isn’t intended for servicing the entire Symsonia Water District service area, nor is it capable of doing so for any length of time. It is a useful connection for a short-term need due to a failure in the Symsonia District’s system; however if there were a major drought situation, that would likely affect the source water for both Syrnsania and Benton system. In this case, Benton’s counsel stated their customers would obviously be served first. ’Therefore while this connection is a convenient emergency back-up, it does not replace the Districts need for storage and additional source water.

een OF

Witness: Jim Waid

RESOLUTION APPROVING A CONTRACT FOR THE SALE/PURC ASE OF WATER WIT

SYMSONIA WATER AND SEWER

BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Benton, KY hereby approves and

consents to the Mayor and City Clerk signing that Water Purchase/Sales Agreement with

the Symsonia Water and Sewer District, a copy of which is attached hereto and

incorporated by reference.

n ATTEST:

+ MICHEL~E $DWARDS

COIJNCIL MEMBERS VOTING

GLEN BREWER TIM KING CHARLES EDMONDS KENTON HOLJLAND MICWJY SIRLS RITA DOTSON

WATER PIlRCtiASE CONTRACT

1 he Contract made and entered into by and between the SYMSQNIA WATER AND SEWER

l~lS'Jl~lC'l ' (DISTRICT) Graves County, Kentucky, arid the CITY OF

CoiiiiIy, Kentucky.

WITNESSETH

WI IT:REAS, the District is a Water and Sewer District chartered and existing under flle laws of

tlx C'onimonwealth of Kentucky and operates a water distribution system serving water users within

(irnvcs County, Kentucky, and desires to procure an alternate source of water for distribution to its users

sliould i t Iiave need for same; arid

WIIf3RI~AS, tlic City, a City of the 4Ih Class, owns and operates a water distribution system in

M;irshall County and wishes to procure a n alternate service of water for distribution lo i t s user, should i t

I M V C II ncctl for same; and

WI-IEREAS. by Resolution enacted on the / H d a y - of -- , 2007, by the

Synisonia Water and Sewer District authorized, the purchase andor sale of water to the City of 13entoti in

accordance with the provisions of this Contract was approved by the Board of the District and the

executiori of this Contract by the Chairman, Keith Cooper, was duly authorized; and

WI IERIX3, by Resolution enacted on the \1 day of sq :7f 7 ~ h ( 7 ( , 2007, by the City of

13ctlion autliorized the purchase and/or sale of water froin Symsonia Water and Sewer District in

;iccord;tncc wich the terms set forth in this Contract was approved by the City Council of Ihc City of

fknlori, Kcrirucky, and the execution of this Contract by the Mayor was duly authorized.

NOW, THEREFORE, IN CONSIDERATION OF THE FOREGOING and the mutual

agrccincnts hereinafter set forth.

A. ICACFI PARTY AGREES:

1 . Quality and Quantity. To fiirnish at a point of delivery herein specified. during the term

of this Contract or any renewal or extension thereof, portable treated water meeting applicahlc purity

stniitlnrds 01‘ Ilic Kenlucky Division of Water Quality in such quality as may be required, but not“to be in’

CYCCSS o f the capacity each entity may have for its existing customers. Each Party shall providc ttic other

wifh notice i n advance of its iiitent to procure water from the other under the provisions of this agreement.

- Point of Deliver and Pressure. That water will be furnished at a reasonably constant

prcssurc Iy Ixjtl i Parties. The connecting point will be at an existing inch water main supply

I-doiigiiig to Oistrict, this bciiig locatcd approximately, (approxiinate locatior?). Etnergcncy failures of

prcssurc or supply due to itiain line breaks, power failures, flood, tire, use of water to fight fire.

cnrtlicluakc or otlicr catastrophe shall excuse either Party from this provision for such pcriod of titnc as

slinll Iic ricccssnry to restore tlie service.

I. 7

3 . Mctering Equipment. The District will furnish, install, operate and maintain, at tlie point

of‘ tlclivcry all fittings. meter and any building required for connection of the two facilities shall he and

rctiinin (he propcrty of the District. The metering equipment will be tested, but not more frequently that

once cvcry twelve ( 1 2) nionths, with {hat expense to be shared equally by the Parties. A meter rcpistering

not tiiol-e tlian tlirce pcrcent (3%) above or below the test result shall be deemed to bc accurate. I f any

niclcr Ihils lo rcgistcr for any period, the amount of water furnished will correspond with the pcriod

iinmcdiatcly prior to the failure, unless both Parties shall agree upon a different amount.

4. - Hillinp, Proccdures. The meter shall be read between the I ” and 5Ih o f each inonth, by a

vcprcsciilntivc of thc Party furnishing the water to the other, and i f a representative of thc rccciving Party

\vishcs l o !>c prcscnt at thc time :he meter is read, i t shall let the other Party know by the 313’” of each

iiion(1i. l’lie I’aily furnishing water shall provide the other an itemized statement of thc amount of watcr

bought o r sold during the preceding month.

5 __- Rates andPavinent Date. The City agrees to pay no later than the SIh day of tlic following

tiioiitli. for watcr dclivercd in accordance with this agreement, the approved tariff for cach 1,000 gallons

ol’walcr 121niislicd or as said tariff may be adjusted periodically in any general rate increased approved by

ilic Cily Council or the Public Service Commission i f its approval of said rates and tariff is required.

‘l‘licrc shall hc no ininimum rate per inonth when water is not being used. District agrees to pay no laler

2

l h f 1 Ihe 5’” (jay of the following month for water delivered to it in accordance witti this agreklnent, tile

wlmlesalc rate Iknton charges for each 1,000 gallons of water hrnishes to its wholesale customers and as

niay he adjusted periodically in any general rate increase made pursuant to an Ordinance establishing said

rntc 01 ratcs enacted by the City Council and approved by the Public Service Comlnission if its approval

ol‘sait i rates and tariff is required.

13. IT 1s FURTHER MUTUALLY AGREED

1;o I I I ,o CVS:

I . Tcnn of Contract. That this Contract shall extend for a term of five ( 5 ) ycars froin tlle

tlntc 0 1 tlic signing of this Contract, thereafter shall be automatically renewed or extended for such ten11 or

tcrnis. unless tcrminatcd by one of the Parties, pursuant to paragraph 4 hereof.

2. Connection Charge. There shall be no connection charge for eithcr of the Parties

associ;itccl with this Contract.

3 . Modification of Contract. The provision of this Contract pertaining to the schedule of

ratcs IO Irc paid by eithcr Party for water delivered are subject to modification at the end of every one (1)

ycar pcriod. Any increase or decrease in rates may be sub,ject to the approval of the Public Service

Comniissicw, and will be based on the increase or decrease in the cost of performance hereunder, but such

C(N shnll not include capitalization of either Parties’ system. All other provisions of this Contract may be

niodilictl or’ altercd by mutual agreement.

4 Tcrininrlti~Provisioii. Each Party reserves the exclusive right to terminate this Contract

Notice of

Notice of

Lqmn giving writtcn notice of ninety (90) days in advancc of the date of termination.

tcniiination by the City shall be in writing sent to the Chairman of the Water District.

tcr’iiiination by the District shall be in writing sent to the Mayor of the City.

5 lkgula tog Agencies. This Contract is subject to all rules, regulations and laws as may

lic npplicalde to siinilar agreements in this State.

6 Keplaccnlent of 4” l i g . Benton intends to replace a portion of its lines required to

service this Contract which is 4” in diameter and District acknowledges that this line replacetnent is a part

3

of'a county wide water improvement projcct the cost and expense of which is to be paid by a grant, and "

flic (.'ify's obligation tinder this Contract are contingent upon the completion of this prqject.

IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties hereto, acting under authority of their respective governing

hodics. hilvc caused this Contract to be duly executed in three counterparts, each of which shall constitutc

iiii original

SYMSONIA WATER AND SEWER DISTRICT

BY: KEITH COOPER, CI-IAIRM/lN

BY:

4

1009 Main Street Benton, Kentucky 42025

(270) 527-8677

June 30,2008

Symsonia Water System:

The current wholesale water rate for Benton Water & Sewer System i s $1.49 per 1,000 gallons of water.

PAGE 81/81

Water Projects within the Purchase Area

WRIS Number of KIA 0-2 Project Projwt cost Custonr ers Tim c: frum e Year Number Owiier Estiniure Affected ___ (in tieurs) Rank

GRAVES COUNTY

w x 2 108300 I W I N G 0 WATER 8: SEWER $9 1,780 1,240 0-2

W X 2 1083003 SOUTII GRAVES WATER DISTRICT $133,755 so 11-20

TO COMPLETE TIHE, I.OOP BETWEEN SYSTEMS A N D SU1'PL.Y WA"I.13 T O .SO CUSTOMERS SOUTH GRAVES NEEDS TO CONNECT WITH T H E CUBA WATER WORKS. THIS CONNECTION IS EXPECTED .ro BE MADE I N T I I E VACINITY OF ~ N I : INTERSECTION OF K Y 94 AND K Y 303.

WX2 1083004 MAYF-l1lI.I) ISLECTRIC & WATER $20,904 4 0 3 - 1 0

-1.0 CL.OSl' T t l E GAP BETWEEN MAYFIELD EL.EC'I-RIC 8: WA.I'EII SYS'TI.:M ( M E W S ) ANL) CONSIJMEII WATER DISTKIC'I (CWD), MAYFIIiLD SI-IOIJL.1) CONNLiC'J' WITII C W D A T K\' 303 ANI) O N O1.D

A N E S T I M A W D 4 0 CUSTOMERS DUKEDOM I ~ O A D . i-iw WIL.~ . . AI..I.OW CWD 1.0 USE MEWS AS A BACK UP AND ALSO PROVIDE WATER 'ro

w x 2 lo83005 CONSUMERS W A I E R I)ISTIIIC I $20,436 IS8 3-10

1'1 IE CONSUMI?RS W A l El i DIS'I~RICI CUIIKENTI..Y SURROUNDS TI IIi" SIJDAI I A WA'II:I< DISTRICI'. '1-1 IIS I'liOJliCT W0IJI . I ) MERGE, l ' l l l : SEDAL.IA WA'I'ER L)IS'I RIC'I' WlTl I CONSIJMIIRS WATER DISTRICT WHl1.F TAKING IN 18 NEW CIJSTOMERS A T T H E CONNECTING POINTS.

W X 2 1083007 MAY1 IELD EI..ECTIiIC & WAI'EK $400,7 I2 275 11-20

TlllS WILI.. ALL.OW M E W S TO C O N N E C T WITH T H E FANCY FARM WATER DISTRICT AND TO PROVIDE WATER TO TllOSE CIJSTOMI?,IIS W110 A R E CURRENTL.Y BETWEEN T H E T W O SYSTEMS. "I'IIE J ~ i ~ ~ ~ - ~ i I'OTENI IAI.. IS V I ~ I ~ Y I I I C ; I I I N m s AREA IWE,CIALI~~ .Y ALO N G KY XO. --

z

c v WX21083008 , , SYMSONIA WATER DISTRICT 64 0-2 ~ L c o a f'

h> 0 e ' liX I END 6" W A I E l i MAIN EAS'I I .S MILES -1-0 MARSIIAI I. C O U N T Y 10 C O M P l I$TE AN IN"lERCONNIiC1 ION W l T l l 13liNTON WA'J IiR 8: SEWER SYSTEM. TI4ERE ARI: AI'I'IiOXIMATE1.Y I6 IIOUSES

CAPABlI..ITIES W0UL.I) 13E I'K0VIL)liD BY I.ARGER MAINS A N D I . ' I R E IIYDRAN-IKS. ALSO, I I I E I'IiIISSUIiIJ IRON ' l " 0 I'I(:K 111' AS WE1 I . AS I'KOVIDINCi AN AI.'I ERNA l l V E OR RACK-UP WATER SOURCE. I."IRE I'liOTEC~"I^ION

FIL.TER AT 1-111: w A m i TREA I 'MENT PLAN I IS TO rw IIL~PLBCEII, AND N E W PI. .UMBING W I L L 1311 INVOLVED. \ -2-

WX2 10830 I O 1-1 A R D E M A N W AT- E R D 1 STRI Cl ' $ I 2 2 5 z - l 45 3-10

'J'lIE HARDEMON W D SIHOUL.D 131: IdOO1'ID I ~ O G E T H E R AT '11-IE NORTlIERN ANI) EASTERN POINTS. MAYI'1EL.D EL EC-' IXlC AND WA'IIiIi SYSTEM SHOIJI ,D CONNECT WITH HARDEMON WATER DISTRICT ALONG KY 80 'TO PROVIDE A BACK UP SYSTEM FOR EACH SIJPPLIER HWL) AILSO HAS A NEED FOR A NEW WELL, TOWER, A N D SEVERAL TIIANSMISSION LINES.

Last updated: 811 7/05 at 3:00pm

The following is an estimate of the changes in O&M cost that the District is likely io experience in the leading cost categories.

EXISTING AVG

The table above depicts a current: cost, a cost at 2/3 the capacity, and a cos!. at full capacity. This has been shown due lo the fact that the system will rra2: initially need to run at full capacity on a regular basis. As per design standards, the new facility is sized for potential future growth as well as current demand.

The salary expenses are not expected to change due to this upgrade, other than the District’s normal cost-of-living or salary increases already in place, which are irrelevant to this project. Also, it is important to note that the same staff serves both the water and wastewater departments for the District; therefore, those costs are shared between the two departments. The general maintenance estimate assumes the majority of maintenance in the first year will be covered within the warrantee and manufacturer agreements. However, as those agreements expire, general maintenance costs should be similar to the existing costs.

The remaining cost items shown are the primary expenses for 08cM. Considering that water samples from the new wells tested similarly to the existing wells’ water quality, one can assume the chemicals used to treat the new facility should be proportionally equal, but with a slight vendor cost increase over time being a possibility. The next line item is gas used for heating the existing facility. The new facility will utilize packaged teririina3 AC and heating units that will not require gas, so this line item

has been omitted. However, it should be noted that while natural gas will not be used or even provided to the site, diesel gas will b e needed on an emergency basis only. l h i s has not been included in the line items because at this point there is no way to estimate this expense, nor would one expect this to be a primary cost item. There will be a back-up diesel- powered generator at the site for emergency power outage use.

'The electrical cost for the new facility is hardest to estimate. The basic ideology behind the estimates shown is first that with the new equipment there is approximately a 15-20% efficiency savings. For this application, there will still be an overall cost increase for several reasons. Increased electrical costs will occur because all temperature controls for the building will n w be on electricity; there will be more equipment items installed in the new facility; and as the capacity increases, so will well pump, chemical pump, and booster pump run times. So even though each piece of equipment is more efficient than the existing equipment, the capacity expansion will cause increased electrical use.

The .final line item is for testing and sampling. The new facility will not require any additional testing and sampling cost ,from what is currently being expensed unless the laboratory that process the samples has a price increase.

Witness: Jim Waid

COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY ) ) ss

COUN’TY OF GRAVES )

The imdersigned, _I sfn Ws;d , being duly sworn, deposes and states he is the Manager of Syrnsonia Water District, Applicant, in the above proceedings; that he has read the foregoing responses and has noted the contents thereof; that the same is true of his own knowledge, except as to matters which are there in stated on information or belief, and as to those rnatters, he believes sane to be tl-ue.

IN TESTIMONY WHEREOF, witness the signature of the undersigned on this 3 - L l - A a 13.

/ I I

4 y m s o n i a Water District

Subscribed and sworn to before me b y s h W & k , Manager of Symsonia

My Commission Expires 3 7: , ds I7

Water District, on this 3 *A\ , 2013.

In and for said County and State