Upload
melanie-fernandez
View
222
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
1/60
RE -- Tangible generally doesnt depreciate PHYSICALLY -- rapidly to the extent that it does (IE irine strikes)
its INSURABLE you can figure out who owns it
all these things make it desirable for securing credit/advances Disadvantages
Not very fungible grain is grain -- you dont care if you get a bushel of this grain or that RE is unique
Not easily valued no way to know what the market is really each piece is unique
cant move it -- cant send it to where it can be sold for better prices while this can be an advantage -- personalty can dissapear overnight and
w/e it secures can be at risk liquidity issue cant use it for all w/e you want to use it for
How do we know about the bundle of sticks -- as a potential purchaser lender to convey/transfer -- you need to own it, you can only transfer what you own. If you dont
have all the sticks, you can only transfer the sticks you have look to prior owners of the prop for the time they owned it
has to be in writing, and recorded to be an enforceable right as against a BPV or leinholder
NC -- raceCLosing
lender typically wants a survey zoning, restrictive covenants, is everything on their land? Easement -- across rear lot line
say, what easement is that? flip the packet and talk to them about a Title insurance comittment Commitment to issue title insurance
when closes -- well insure that they have good title to the property also going to insure that the bank has a lien on the property which
is a first lien on the prop for 144k like survey, Tit Ins isnt a requirement, but lenders want someone to tell them and
back them up that they have a first lien on the property I cant tell the difference between a forged and a non-forged document i cant tell who all the children were, who may have/had inheritence right there are a list of about 18 things I just cant tell you I cant tell you that the surveyor did the correct job, or didnt make even
the smallest mistake lender is in the process of putting together a package once the loan closes so taht they
can sell the loan to someone else
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
2/60
package is the only way you can make it economically possible for a third partyto evaluate the loan
exceptions taxes due and payable restrictions of record appearing at ---
currently not violated future violation will not cause a forfeiture HUD-1
Second page -- 2 colums on right hand side -- paid from the bowers fund atsettlement
paid from sellers fund at settlement itemizing closing costs
commission to be paid to brokers less deposit retain
when put under K, deposit put down, held by listing (seller) broker listing broker simply retains
fees paid in connection with the loan loan origination fee
fee charged by bank for originating the loan, finance charge, bankcollects and it helps them with admin cost of orgining the loan
appraisal fee POC -- Paid outside closing get rid of market risk
if youre loaning 170, want to make sure youre at leastequally collateralized if not over-collateralized
cant insure the market risk -- appraiser says, in my oppinion credit report fee
dealt with the market riskt but i dont want to loan to a dead beat, i do NOT want to have toforeclose on a loan
Im not getting hte benefit of my bargain\ tax service fee
want to make sure that the taxes get paid and if theyre not thatthey send the bill to them
Govt trumps all Tax lien is first in priority always
items reqd by lender to be paid in advance int in advance at this closing -- charged so that when the first
regular payment comes due on the loan, itll be a regular paymentof the same amount everymonth towards amortizing it, in order todo that, with int being paid in arrears (being paid for after youvehad the use of it)
mortgage insurance premium allowed to be charge on highrisk loan
borrower who has a questionable past
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
3/60
loaning a large amount of the purchase price LTV amount is high
no equity cushion when/if they
need to foreclose -- theyre covered for their
deficiency if any reserves
budgeting for the borrower we got bills coming due soon (insurance bills and such) --
we need to know youre gonna pay them if you dont pay the insurance and the house burns
down were effed if you dont pay your taxes and they foreclose, were
effefed youre gonna pay a little extra every month, and were
gonna put that in an account no interest
aggregate adjustment under applicable fed lending guidelines -- banks required
to reduce the escrows by an amount to take into anaccount that those two bills do not come due on the sameday
only have to escrow enough for each when they come due common funds, theyre pooled dont have to ahve enough money in the account to
pay both bills at the same time
fees to the atty document prep seller pays for prepping the deed
repping the buying in connection with closing the loan/searing thetitle
prorate taxes for the year seller is responsible for the time they own the property credit to the buyer and a debit against the seller, b/c the buyer is going to
be responsible for paying all the taxes when they come in 170k price, 3k of closing cost
credit for taxes new loan of 144 147238- 173 = we need to write a check for some 30k if we wanna buy this
house monthly payment statement
princ and int tax escrow hazard insurance
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
4/60
no flood insurance cuz youre not int he flood zone mortgage insurance
truth in lending disclosure statement 70s -- law TLA advertising really low interest rates
but there were all kinds of fees, expenses and costs misled in what they were paying in financing charges thought they were getting .05 but really getting .1
everybody has to disclose how much money lenders are making so that they canunderstand how much youre paying in interest
every bank has to use the same form in reality
all my furniture is in a truck coming from ATL to here, do you really thinkthis late in the game theyre gonna say -- nope no deal?
illustrates four blocks at top, were looking at the loan and were saying that the loan
on the note rate is 6.7/8 percent TLA -- APR 7.426
amount financed -- saying its 143k, the loan is for 145k, the 2k got paid in the origination fee, bank is really only parting
with 142k ive got check for 145k, but im sending them back 2 the APR is yielding more
still getting really 6 170 house costing you 300 some odd dollars
History
usury -- negative view, sin would transfer interest for a loan the income from the land was tantamount to interest could buy it back
problems - what if person wanted borrow money for improving property
particularly didnt work well with the concept that you would lose theproperty
well take title the property, you pay rent or w/e but stay on the land, then buy itback plus a little extra
day certain by which you have to pay back by the full amount of hte money if you dont, you lose your right to pay back for the property
little distressing if you tookt he money and you built the castle and your wagonlooses a wheel on the way to pay the dude back and you lost your castle
lost your equity Law Day
specific day by when all debts had to be paid people went to courts of equity
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
5/60
seeking fairness you know -- really not fair that if someone misses this payment by a day,
when theyre prepared to pay it back and can pay it back, for them to losethe property
became uncertain if you were the person who had loaned the money when the
property became yours I need a certain date birthed is the mortgage
in many JD -- lien on the property in order to realize the benefits you have to foreclose
before this concept there was no foreclosure of the prop b/c the Lendedalready owned the property
whoever buys the prop at the Fsale gets title, money split up between those of whom are owed dd
fair still -- arguably the property is sold for what its worth, and if its worthmore than the loan then my equity is preserved
now we have the certainty of sale and a protection of the borrowers equity borrower has right of redemption until property is sold Can always pay back until sold off
were not going to kick people off the prop or deprive them of their propw/o giving them the opp to pay off what is due on the loan in order to getthe property back
What can mortgages secure have to be reducible to monitary amount sale -- proceeds -- proceeds are divided, have to know whats owed
its a financial transaction
you can monitize damn near anything Go back to contracts -- what youre really talking about is consequential damages but thats wishywashy
but if you say hey, if you dont im gonna have to hire a cab, and youre gonnahave to pay me back
if you want it to be secured by a mortgage, you have to figure out how tomonitize it
dont have to know how much money you are owed on date mortage given whats critical is how much is due when youre about to foreclose might have an obligation that today you dont know how much is owed but
when defautl takes place and you can calculate the amount, then that issufficiently monitized and you can secure that
if the bank agrees to loan you enough money to build the house up to x, they dont know from the outset how much thats gonna be
cant have a penalty clause -- obviously not going to enforce an unenforceable obligation just b/c its in a mortgage
cant have a mortgage to enforce a gift cant secure a pledge to the Nature preserve with a mortgage on the property
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
6/60
practically speaking -- however if youre trying to sell your home and buyers do a title search and see you owe
1000 bucks for not picking up your old roommate, theres stilla cloud on the title youre not going to say, hey, thats a penalty clause, its non enforceable the buyers are gonna say, take care of it
if you have an obligation thats clearly a monetary obligation agreed to pay somebody 500 a month for the next five years, pay it by the first of
each month that obligation is secured by a mortgage
if youre the party expecting the 500, youre only foreclosing on 500 bucks,thats whats owed in order to redeem
Hold a sale to SATISFY WHAT IS OWED can only foreclose once
foreclosure wipes out the Mort/DoT under it the buyer takes the prop free and clear
acceleration clause balance of the obligation becomes immediately due and payable upon the
event of default If you acquire property and record it, and acquire it before the restriction is recorded, you
acquire it free and clear of the restriction regardless of the fact that the owner may havesigned that restriction before selling you the prop
I go buy a house, borrow money from BBT to buy the hosue, when I buy thehouse I also enter a loan with BBT, DoT recorded at same time Deed is recorded
thereon my proper is encumbered by the DoT until its satsified, released,or subordinated to something
release
-- saying the mort hasnt been paid off -- he still owes me money, but thisproperty is released want to get refi from state credit union on small piece
can get BBT to subordinate to the 500 k DoT held by state credit union They get the same quality of title that I had when the mortgage was given
when they foreclose ont he property, whoever buys at that foreclosure sale, buysthe property with the same title that is being sold at the foreclosure
BBT forecloses the state credit union DoT is cut off
Owner originally conveyed to Oliver (me)
I give DoT to BBT if you get from BBT, you dont care what I did after that, youre not
buying from Me, youre buying from BBT If BBT entered into subordination
youd find that under BBT in the index I (oliver) cant do anything to affect BBTs title
Title theory
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
7/60
Legal title to land transferred to the trustee with BBT as beneficiary property sold by trustuee
power of sale statutory provision, special proceeding, has to be in DoT, 45-60 days
makes it easier for bank to buy at the foreclosure sale
Lein theory if mortgage -- property would be sold by Lien holder/bank
lender can bid, but theres an inference that that might not be a validforeclosure sale, a little more subject to attack
bring action on the mortgage have a lawsuit, discovery, judge has to order the forclosure sale 6 months -2 years+
availability in institutionalizing a credit is a phenomenon of the last 50 years or so due on demand, due on maturity due on sale
payment in arrears Payment in arrears is a term describing payments made after a service has been
provided. In this case use of the word "arrears" does not imply any breach. Dragnet
this secure the loans from Oliver to the Bank in the amount of 500k AND anyother loan Mr. Oliver may ever get from the Bank
Any other loan he owes the bank alread or may ever owe the bank obviously describes the property you used as collateral and seen in schedule a of
DoT DoT could also say -- any other property acquired by Oliver
AACOLL BOth make life difficult for me
I want to know what you owe and what all the property secures Title search -- look at the mortgage
I know theres a 500k that needs to be paid off I want to finish the basement in my house
500K mortgage probably worht 625 after finish the basement
if it says plus whatever else Oliver owes you dont know how much that mortgage is for
Drag not looked upon with great favor especialy not looked upon favorable from the Kter comes in and says I relied on
the 500k, if you wanted it to secure more, you should have rerecorded People have to be able to rely on the record
AACOLL Even a little bit more insidious
what if I were to subsequently acquire a house at the beach getting ready to sell the house
they do a title search
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
8/60
when they search the beach -- theyre not going to be seeing aDoT recorded in Orange County NC
even if I buy it in hillsborough, if I bought it after buying the other house if it says all the property I may ever own in NC, a title searcher
searing the chain of title on the second house, bought later, I dont
know about that other lien not enforceable as to third party BPV, or lien creditors may be enforceable as between me and the bank
wouldnt have the benefit relating back, doesnt have that priority -- the
property was after acquired, after the Improvements to the property
when I give BBT a DoT, and then improve the basement They have alien on that
its part of hte real property that relates back to when their lien was firstfiled
things that are not mortgages Mortgage substitutes
ways people try to have something that acts like a mortgage but avoid theforeclosure process
in many JD, you dont have a special proceed foreclosure infront of theclerk
get around anti-deficiency interest
a whole bunch of usury law/interest rate limitations on mortgages why dont we just not do a mortgatge?
Allow appreciation/participation/co-ownership in prop well I dont really want to loan him the money, illto take an equity position in the
property I want to get paid back before they do
maybe can avoid being involved in a Bruptcy of the borrower doing this prevent any junior liens on the property
I want title, and Ill give you the title back when you pay me all the moneyyou owe me
you can dress this up any way you want if its a loan, its a loan
deed in escrow ill go record it if you dont pay me back
both the absolute deed and deed in escrow are going to be looked at with greatdisfavor if you went into court and challenged the title of the the person who titlethrough this
especially when there are things/documents evidencing both paritiesintentions and ideas about the transaction
sale transaction/
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
9/60
tax assessor says worth 500k but I sold it to him for 50k and can buy it back for 60 does that look like a loan or an outright sale
I gave him a deed to my house, lived there the whole time, and never paid any rent
I paid all the expenses, If you sold the hosue, would you still be payinghte expenses?
btw i took the 100k I sold the house for and built a garage people trying to avoid the borrowers rights, basically
why would borrower agree? Have to
In some JD -- may find people trying to get around mortgage taxes if you want to record a mort, theres a tax to have it recorded
What happens? if I loan the 100k and get the deed -- ungrateful borrower
you cant keep the deed to my house courts gonna say, this is a disguised mortgage and you have a equitable lein
you can go through a judicial lien at best but you tried to get around this act of redemption and all other rights, and
Im inclined to treat you as an unsecured creditor and you can sue andget a Judgment Lien
mort subs that arent inherenly bad
negative covenant as long as I owe so and so money, i wont transfer an interest whole or in party
int he property to anyone else does htis mean you cant get a lien? no but you damn werll dont wanna be the party who took a lien on the property in
the face of this paper on the record that says the party you took a lien from wasincapable of transfering that interest
installment land contract seller of the propery sells the prop but retains title to the prop until they receive
the full purchase price if you make the installment payments on the property on time and when you pay
me all of it, ill give you title problerms
owner goes Bankrupt owner puts a mortgage on the property either wont or cant deliver the deed to me when it comes time for him to
do so number of cases in NC, treated as equitable mortgages
have to be treated as such require people to give you your equity of redemption
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
10/60
many JD require to be recorded upon recordation, provide rights to buyer
Trustee under DoT doesnt have a really fiduciary duties as you think of them
Lender can be TTee -- and then sub it outf
protecting against riskMarket riskLender POV -- how to protec against
Lender wants to minimize amount loaned dont want to loan money on project that arent going to be successful and buyers
and investors are generally of the same mindset want to get paid back first on the returns of the property credit enhances -- other sources of repayment other than the property
Borrower/purchaser want tho loan the most they can and
What makes this a good investment for borrower or what makes this good collateral for a loan isyoure the lender?
have to understand the appraisal should appraise it at its HIGHEST and BEST USe
under the circumstances that we find it -- whats the value of the property what is highest and best use?
No matter how we try to dress this pig up, its always about someones opinion were gonna talk about cap rates and what not but at the end of hte day its just
an opinion, its a based opinion, but an opinion nonetheless 3-4 blocks from durham exprssway small house on lot of 2.5 acres not in a great neighborhood
house isnt in best condition that appraiser has made the assumption that highest and best use of the
property is to have a small house in east durham but zoning might allow some other sort of use, which may make it worth a
lot more best and highest use doesnt necessarily mean its constrained to its current use
UNDERSTAND
when you start talking a bout whether its a good deal or not its a subjectiveopinon
comparison apprach similar situated similarly constructed sell for?
comperables are starting to skew if when the guy buys the house on franklin for a million
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
11/60
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
12/60
replace its assets when they wear out, therefore can ignore capital amortizationand depreciation.
Cashflow near and dear to owners heart -- thats how much money I have coming out of the project
can tells you what your return is on the money you have invested
bought for 1MM, borrowed 750k, put 250k in take the cashflow as a ratio to the amount you put in tells you a return onyour equity investment
youre getting that much money back on your equity -- are you makingmoney?
leverage youre paying 6 % on the banks money -- and your rents are covering that youre using somebody elses money and getting a return on it
its not your money and you didnt pay for it idea that I can take someone elses money and leverage it into a return for me
predominately borrowed money could also find an investor who rather than loaning you money would give
you an equity investment and would get a fixed return preferred return of .1 on my money
I get, after all the expenses are paid, .1 of my investment beforeyou get anything and afterwhich well split it
Cash flow show return on Equity NOI will show you what your return on your costs is
can establish a ratio between NOI and what I paid for the property on one level, not very meaningful info
it has nothing to do with your debts
lets you start making comparisons with OTHER property w/o worrying about whatother peoples debt are NOI/ cost or price
gives you a Capitalization rate find an appraiser
im trying to figure out what an existing office building is worth Im going to look at comparable office buildings and what they sold for
I can also find out what the NOI is for those other buildings with respect tothat
I can start coming up with what the cap rate was with respect to thoseoffice buildings
when I compared the cap rates and they were between 7.5-8% I can divide that by 7 % and I can get an Idea
it reduces down to cost and NOI doesnt matter what their debt or their size
it tells you what people thought about that as an investment and it allows you to compare investsments that may not otherwise
have all the same qualities
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
13/60
Got an office go to a bank get the to cover .75 go to some friends and get you to cover the other .25 the office is already covering and its .2 vacant
so if it increases thats money straight to the bottom line
take the cap rate and compare it to your other investments
mathematically can come out with a range of when I go talk to the bank and my investment buddies and say compare this with your
other investment opportunities were not still talking apples to apples
Balloon payment The term balloon payment arises because if you hold back most of a debt and pay it only towards
the end of the agreement, both those last payments and the total amount repaid are much larger.The debt is inflated like a balloon due to Compound Interest accumulating on the large sum. This ismore technically known as partial amortization .
100k sqft ffice .9 leased at 20/ftop expens at 6/ftgross rev at 1.8 millop expenses -- 600kdebt services of 725 a year postive cash flow of 475K
invested 2.5M (7.5M loan) .475/2.5 =19% return on your investment ROE return on equity what if .x of building leased by enron --
gone went from 475 postive cash flow to 75k positve cash flow -- not sleeping so well
at night 1.2MM NOI/10MM cost
.12 cap ratecap rate
Advantage One advantage of capitalization rate valuation is that it is separate from a "market-
comparables" approach to an appraisal (which compares 3 valuations: what other similar
properties have sold for based on a comparison of physical, location and economiccharacteristics, actual replacement cost to re-build the structure in addition to the cost of the land and capitalization rates). Given the inefficiency of real estate markets, multipleapproaches are generally preferred when valuing a real estate asset. Capitalization ratesfor similar properties, and particularly for "pure" income properties, are usually compared toensure that estimated revenue is being properly valued.
Depreciation taxes -- cost recovery
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compound_Interesthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compound_Interesthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compound_Interesthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_estate_appraisalhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compound_Interesthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_estate_appraisalhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compound_Interest8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
14/60
we think they ware out can deduct (recover) from w/e income you ahve that depreciable portion of the
cost Improvements to RE -- for resi can depri for 28.5
non resi over 39.5
if you so choose so 1/39 of the value land doesnt depreciate - it just sits there
reduces your basis deduct the interest you pay on the loan as an expense
68k tax free by 2008
that amount of interest that youre paying is less going to paying taxes on more than youre getting in cash flow amortization will eventually beat depreciation paying taxes on the amount youre reducing the principle of the loan basically
why people dont own buildings forever this isnt as much fun what can you do?
sell it and try and do it with another property refinance int will go up,
1031 exchange -- like kind basis goes with you, its carries over no realization event here, you dont sell, pay taxes, nothing
IRR internal rate of return
return based on tax situation, leverage and everything else net return divided by net investment taking into account the timing of your investment if you get your money back quicker, then you have the opportunity to reinvest it in
somethingelse the quicker you get your money back, the more it means to you
what the overall yield can be based on the overall return on the investment your put your 2.5 in and youre getting it back pretty quickly and once youre getting it back and youre still getting a return
substantial benefits associated with depreciation and and interest deduction want to structure your investment to take advantage of it want it to be a passthrough so that you can get the benefit of the taxes
active investor (have to be) comparable-- typically resi replacement-- owner occupied industrial, uniqueness of prop is prob not a large factor least susceptible of being valued appropriately by the appraisal -- land
fertile field -- youre talking about what it could be worth
market risk -- valuing prop question
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
15/60
how is it that lenders are willing to let leverage take place why loaning at 7.5 when i can get a return on my equity of 19
good for the goose, good for the gander also, they get paid back first before anyone else gets paid back
if youre an investor you get paid after operating expense and after debt servicing lenders are focused on we get paid back first
since they get paid back first, what they care about is relationship between amount of loan andvalue of prop
they want the LTV to be as low as possible if youve got a 10MM prop-- they get paid back first and dont care if they have to sell iit
quick for 8 they get theirs dont give a shit about your money
assignment of rents rights to have receiver appointed want some sort of credit enhancement
might look at borrower and say youve got a tennant who has .1 and it comes up for renewal next year i want a LOC that says if they dont renew and you dont pay me down youre going to pay
me downnonrecoursealso try and spread the exposure -- find some partners to go in with you
Market/value risk lender will want to be paid back first
small LTV as possible credit enhancements, other sources of repayment other than RE if possible
borrowers want to loan as much as possible maximize leverage limit their own exposure structure the loan to expose as little as their assets as possible SPE -- single purpose entity nonrecourse -- try and persuade that asset is worth the loan so not have to
provide guaranty Lenders are going to be looking for guarantys, other credit enhacing
norecourse would try to be negotiated, obviously borrowers try to spread their exposure -- other partners
providing equity so that each persons equity not so great try to provide that theyre not fully guarantying loans, im only on hook for
20% (investment precentage or something)committment letter
perm commit to make the loan as soon as posible gonna enhance your ability to go get the construction loan
looking for loan with fixed cost, nonrecourse, so that we know what our exposure is --the value of hte asset
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
16/60
we know if things dont go the way we want them to, we can just dump the assetand only lose our equity
Functions served securitizes the sort term construction loan
makes sure the bank gets paid back shortly
when mr. bank feels good about making your loan -- instead of it beingprime+2 it may become prime +1
loan commitments help you get the tennants committed tenants help you get the loan, etc
pursue all of them at the same time acquiring property
youd want to know you had a perm lender lined up before you did the duediligence and paid for the due diligence to buy it
inspections strucural physical, zoning, environmental
appraisal deposit towards the purchase, firm (at risk) commitment fees
50-100k spend on finding out whether or not you buy the prop WHAT ARE YOU PAYING THE LENDER?
important ST financing
fairly high admin costs req a staff of some size to deal with it
banks are set up for this Life ins company dont like to have all this oversight, they just want to sit back and
let the money roll committment K between borrower and lender
I agree to make you a loan on such and such terms You agree to borrow the money on such and such terms
do you have an agreement or an agreement to agree? have to realize that its specific enough
loan application we are sending you and application form, fill it out with borrower,
guarantor for non-recourse carveout if you want amortized over 20, paid back over 10 accept commitment
Lender can say well lend on these terms
then borrower can accepts borrower can sy this this this this and this BUT
most JD req com to be in writing letter is important
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
17/60
sets forth the conditions duty to negotiate in good faith
terms and conditions not specifically covered in the comm letter longer term between time in signing comm letter and closing
more reasons to incentivize the search for a reason to get out of the letter
Interest rates debt-coverage ratio based on rents paid
we expect the project to be showing X especially if nonrecourse
can say subject to no changing in the financial status of the borrower and nomaterial change to the financial change of the tenant
int rates drop client says -- whats my exposure? read the letter --
probably required them to put down a deposit if this loan doesnt close due to breach of borrow
depos -- deemed liqui dam, lose it could say -- to secure the lender against the damages they suffer
could be good could be bad dont auto lose the depo and they may not have any loses based
on my defaulting could be damaged more
they lend at .06, nonrecourse - they dont have any promise i was gonnapay
but they have a prepayment premium entitled to difference of .06 over life of loan and what youd expect to
return on govt securities you say, thats fine, you could have reinvested that money in other areas at around 5
we werent under loan, that term doesnt apply deposits may cover due dili, lender wants to do it and control it
failure of conditon of loan DCR
a tenant blows out and you dont cover it not a breach by the borrower, theres just a breach of the comm becomes really important to nego committment letter
Problem --150k sqft * .95 *18.5 = revenue of X 236350150K * 5.75 * =862.5debt service of
x-opp-debt service = cash flow 925.50
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
18/60
4 million of equity.9255/4 = 23% ROE cash flow /Equity
NOI = X-y rev-expense
1773750/12.5 =14. something cap rate (really high)
NOI / Cost -- cap rate
taxable income -- rev - expense - (680 in int, 8.5 in *.08) (11MM (can only depreciate thebuilding, not the dirt)/39)
500 * .9 * x = rev
500*1.25 =
NOI 1.85M/cap rate=13.3
if cap rate fo rhte office building is good cap rate for investment in RE today, all we care about ismoney were comparing NOI to NOI and thats what we think money ought to cost
highlights what deficiencies there are and the complexities accosicates with doing an incomeanalysis like this
says only currently opp expenses and current income are is what matters whats going to happen to rev and whats going to happen to expenses over a period of
time
things that can go wrong with commitments DCR
changes in opp expenses can have it where the tenant picks up changes in opp after the lease
starts butyou still pick up original cost comm may say, well loan up to X, but not to exceed Y percentage of appraised value
options for that: mezzanine loan
secured by an interest inthe borrower but not an interest in the property somewhere betweent - lender says heres what Ill do, Ill loan you 1MM, but for
collateral ill take security interest in ownership interest int he borrower if you dont pay me back, ill step into your shoes and Ill have the 7 million
dollar loan what people liek
1st mort lender they dont have a second mort holder looking to be first mezzanine likes it b/c they just get to step in
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
19/60
they dont have to finance the prop as part of the foreclosure, they just step in and keep on being the borrower
increase the value of the prop master lease the space that isnt already leased
appraiser comes back and says youve got .4 vacancy so I can only value
it at 10 instead of 12 borrower can say ill master lease that .4 and pay rent on it, you can count
what ill pay for rent as part of the full recourse to the borrower and potentially to the members of the
borrowers as im able to rent it to third parties i get excused
mezz finance is pretty expensive
elements in the loan comittment lender friendly 360 days in a year in bank year 30 days in a month
talking about a balloon payment at some point/term didnt amortize fully over the term
critical point prepayment
prepayment restriction cant until x date if at all
then if you do, youll tack on x percent how is the fee calculated?
old fashion 10 year loan, cant reapay during first 5 years
6 year -- 5% 7 year-- 4% 8 Year -- 3%, etc until last 90 days you can prepay at par
yield maintenance fee i should be entitled to invest in a lot safer i want to pretend that if you pay me off, im going to invest that in Tbills of
a comparable material should i have to pay a prepayment fee under any circumstnace
condemnation or eminent domain im not going to have a make a prepayment premium if I didnt
chose to pay off the loan no prepayment from a casualty loss (it burns down and you dont
rebuild) baloon payment, 10 year term, 20 year amortization
client knew it was coming but refi hadnt moved as swiftly as they thought in the example -- you owe .04 of TOTAL amount OWED
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
20/60
want to go back to lender and say its ok, but say it shouldnt applyto a payment due on maturity, if you accelorate it, i dont want theburden of knowing ive got that ontop of it
if you miss a payment and lender puts you in default accelerate full balance due
interest rate goes from 7 to 12 default rate
borrower is going to have to indemnify the lender from any environmental problem i made you a non-recourse loan on an asset with no enviro problems if there is an enviro problem, i expect you to have it i cant really insure this risk
escrows by the first of the month you gotta get your shit in for taxes, and insurance
premiums and stuff 2.04
getting financial papers in in 90 days is pretty quick questions
do you have FS that are prepared within 90 days of the end of the year? never want to be in a positiont where you technically in default with your
lender def dont want it to effect other obligations
corp finance obligations promise them that theyre not in default of any obligation say inexcess of
15MM dont wanna have this 15mm dollar loan b/c you didnt get your FS in on
time, and then youre in default on your 500MM corp finance loan
mr lender, do you realy need FS n the borrower at this point? if this is a nonrecourse, except for the carveouts (enviro, etc) do you really needit?
doesnt call for AUDITED financials though theyre willing to accept just being prepped for the borrower auditing is a significant expense
fraud, breach of trust, misrep etc carve out misapplication of funds by borrower
if there is a bond or obligation out there that you failed to meet and we have the right toenforce it, just b/c the loan is non-recourse, doesnt mean that we dont have the right toenforce it against you
prepay rent cant go and say, prepay rent tenant and Ill give you .2 discount
owner defaults and peaces out they can come after you for that b/c those monies should have come to
pay the loan first cant get back extra rent, revenues inexcess of payments
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
21/60
like rev that was i excess of meating and paying costs for theperiod
recover damages for fraud, breach of trust, recover loan proceeds to the exten they havebeen misappropriated
basically saying ican come after you for the exten that I have been damaged for
your failure bad boy carveout
DOESNT say that the loan becomes fully recourse have two levels today
if you take rents you shouldnt take i can come after you for the rents youshouldnt take
what I dont want the lender to be able to do is say if you take somethingyou shouldnt have taken, the loan goes from nonrecourse to full recourse
econon risk for borrower becomes loan, not just equity if you pull your equity out -- can trigger a recourse
due on transfer clause Garn-St. Germain says you have to enforce courts pre payment fee on due on transfer clause? probably can
a lot of lenders are favorable to a 1 time right to transfer under certain conditions well negotiated will probably be about a .01 .015 fee, plus administrative fees
banks providing shorter-term perm financing, banks are willing to say ok to prepay if yourepaying from out-of-pocket from operations
cant go out and get another loan probably wont enforce the prepayment if its a bonafide sale -- will probably and can
require paymentneed to make sure your clients understand this and theyre ok with it and have thought about it questions -- is this going to be compatible with what you have planned/forsee over the
next 10-15 years
construction i wanna know what kinda building its gonna be
i wanna know the arch has complied with the code, zoning
article 4 insurance
interesting prob for atty cant let your client sign a loan comm that reqs a certain type of insurance coverage
without someone reading who understands the insurance game flood insurance if any poriton is located w/in 100 year flood zone
easy discussion to have when negotiating comm letter but much more difficult after signed comm
all risk insurance
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
22/60
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
23/60
8 condition precedent to disbursement
built first lien banks lawyers have to sign off
probably a commercial reasonables standard imposed withrespect to this
most lawyers will go through and sprinkle in reasonable language financing statements
securing personalty on the prop k
borrower shall have reimbursed all expenses fees.. described in 11 The Borrower shall have reimbursed, or shall have made
arrangements satisfactory to Ace for the reimbursement of, allexpenses, fees and charges of the nature described in Article 11of this Commitment which have been paid or incurred by Ace andthe Borrower shall have made arrangements satisfactory to Ace toassure that Ace will not be required to pay any further suchexpenses, fees, or charges.
paid by ace -- ace will not be reqd to pay any further expeses fees, costs what do you think it should reasonably cost for a lender to do this
transaction we understand were gonna be responsible, but we dont want to
right blank check to another law firm repping the lender who hasno incentive to keep cost fair
want to negotiate a cap
bank says -- a lot of that depends on you if you sign w/e we send you it really wont cost all thatmuch
why dont yall pick three lawfirms and well pick who you work with attys will look at and make a semi opinion
valid easements in place no enviro lien public access to property
who maintains them? prefer theyre maintained by govtal authority
no amterial adverse change in either borrower or property financing on prop sale of any int in prop
ace has right to hire special counsel to rep them
congress passed law-- lender have to hire the appraiser, and the appraise have to meet certainstandards
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
24/60
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
25/60
i dont want to own it for the next 15 years i dont want to pay your exceleration wont you agree to allow me to transfer one time so long as their a qualified operator
this is nonrecourse, how much to you really care who I am?
transfers that you may want to do for a personal purpose LLC owns it, and the LLC is owned my H and W and they have 2 kids
who have now grown up in the hotel worked at the desk and stuff, now they want their kids to own a part of the
LLC that they own as drafted, the change in membership/stakes even triggers
cant I give ownership interests around banks pretty receptive, so long as controling ownnership of LLC
doesnt change death
from the lenders point of view if hes not around were not too keen about this loan
we will give you aperiod of time to come up with a new acceptablemember
probably have same situation with guarantors only have a claim against the estate of the decedent if the loan is in
default within 6 months of his death if you havent provided for a process in finding a substitute guarantor
int rates go from 5 to 15 percent, lender may be saying ive got a goodchance of getting rid of this terrible low loan int rate loan
second mortgages
bank cares b/c theres someone out there, a very interested party with the meansto find something wrong with the way they did this and to move from second tofirst in priority
well-funded adversary a borrower in default doesnt have the resources to figure out and fight
why I dont also, borrower has gotten their equity out, and they dont give a shit
lose the vested borrower that you had before 19.1
Restriction on foreign investor require borrower that they aret terrorists and stuff like that
20.01 brokers and finders fees borrowers will call these people and say, hey, im getting ready to buy x
some are 5, some are 10, some are somewhere between that what can you get me a loan for?
buy/sell - triparty
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
26/60
bankll make construction loan perm lender will buy it out
assign it over con lender gonna want to be in privity with takedown
mortgages taxes
maryland, florida avoid it
borrower likes it for this mechanics lien questions
if the mortgage is put on the prop before any work is done priority of lien if bought should relate back to the time when it first goes down mechanics will be behind
optional-obligatory doctrine if mortgage loan advances merely optional, them mechanic has priority
over prior in time leins if its a new loan,
bank is going to req that you make the lien go away before they lend how to make a lender how so theyll close the loan
property complies with land use requirements show us a building permit well what if i dont have it yet, and Im trying to get it but i want to get
started show me a grading permit so that we can close and well dispurse funds
necessary for grading provided that you ahve an arch that tells us weve turned in plans
and they should be substantially approved whenever they get
around to it why would lender take the risk?
trying to get the loan tomorrow -- weather is so nice now, we can do a lotof site work from now till thanksgiving iif we dont get site work now, itsnovember, we need to get it done till april/may before we can finish it up
going to deliver this building a lot later than we thought oh btw our tennat says we need to be in on time
enviro permits of one kind or another wastewater industrial pharma plant
does the local wastewater treatment plant allow that kind of dumping?
ACoE permits? JD wetlands, 404 dredge and fill
erosion control/Storm water runoff typically not gonna get a grading permit without this though
air quality
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
27/60
how do you know that once completed it still complies? Cert of Occu
practical problem most dont retain them for an extended period of times
lucky if you can find one thats over 5 years old
if youre buying an existing one, youre probably not goingto find one absent a property owner who has kept recordsof all such things
on the other hand, had they not gotten one this buildingwould not have been occupied if they didnt have one
mistaken issued -- govt not bound by it if somebody missed that the building was out of
compliance with sidage setback fact that youve got a cert of occu doenst mean the govt
has waived that lenders will be looking for some type of site assessment to be done
phase ones and phase 2s astm standards
enviro engineers 1 -- recognized enviromental conditions (RECs)
inspection of review of historical data, review of enviro
history of spills, or something kept here typically not very invasive
if there are RECs recommend pahse 2
invasive testing typically follows to determine the extent how do you know intended use and such will comply ask the city
city is reluctant to say hey you can do this only to find out that theymissed something
not that theyd be bound, but thered be repercussions use to be -- take down an as built survey, can you tell me that what im
showing you complies with and I can get a letter for that smaller jd, you can prob get a better letter
title insurance -- zoning endorsement insuring that the ordinances will allow ALTA
american land title asc 2 endorsements
one called 3.0 prop is zoned for xyz and it allows these uses thats about all it says
3.1 with parking
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
28/60
improvemtns as constructed comply with zoningand the uses
title insurance comp is gonna want to see w/e letter youve gotten, gonnawanna see the zoning report (from a private company that did research),gonna wanna see certificates
most lenders are pleased that if you can give them a 3.1 theyre allgood
life insurane comp doesnt care about finding it out they just need to hear that its fine
title company insurance company -- they can lay it off
if they do it, it means they get to write the policy at a premium plusthe zoning prem
title insurance company is confident ithat it can deal with claims if it turns out not to be true, it has to cause a loss as it relates to lender, if the lender gets paid back, the title
insurance doenst get dragged into it even if there is a zoning issue title insurance company
will look at survey take a look at pages 204-5
description from a survey IDd a beginning point from a known monument
intersection of a street by calling sombody elses property line, youre calling to a monument dont leave any gaps between it b/c you go to the line
cord bearing, distance between two points straight line intersecting the curve
arc line page 204 -- lines go in two directions same line same angle on that compass bearing n/w and s/e calls are reversed b/c youre going in a direction Cert of Compli
lender is going to want insurance that they have a vlid first mortgage on the property owners policy lenders policy
specific execptions, nothign general or vague simultaneous issued in NC, pay for both in one
policy will describe the property insured insure marketable title
access doesnt
what specific endorsement would you want? enviromental lein endorsement
lenders say i dont want to even think about that teh change in interest rate will changethe validity or priority of my lein
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
29/60
may want an endorsemtn aas to that dont want the int to change from 3 - 5and you havent recd that
dont want to lose priority as to those 200 BP future advance endorsement usury endorsement
says loan int rate and fees arent usurious may be looking for an oppinon from you, atty in trans, that loan isnt
usurious zoning endorsement comprehensive endorsement
usually always reqd in comercial comprehensive endorsemtn -- anything that would be sown by a survey restrictions on the prop
specific access endorsement yes the prop has access but what kidn/type prob cant get one that gives you the way you can get to that access
i have an auto shop, that has a light infront of it, cars going bothway can turn into lot
prb cant insure that city wont put up a median there or something utility availability
has util availably to it from publicly dedicated lines may see people ask for deletion of creditors rights
we insure youve got valid lien except
if there were inad consid on or determined fraudulent in BR court
we dont insure what happens in BR court we want you to take that out today its virtually impossible to get that exception removed they cant do the due diligence necessary
not going to give you a zoning endorsement cuz you call up and say id like one theyre going to expec you to provide things necessary on which they can base it zoning endorsements may or may not cost money usury endorsement typcially do
title insurance rates vary wildly based on JD florida, the rates are set statutorily
pay the premium once does not insure against claim that arise after the effective date does not protect against claims caused by its insured
got to get down and say, whats expected WHO ARE YOU REPPING?!
as a practical matter -- dont represent both parties in aclosing in a resi trans -- state bar says can rep seller and buyer as long as atty
doesnt perceive that a conflict is arrising
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
30/60
if you agree to close the loan youve agreed to follow the instructions doesnt mean you agree to represent the letter
if you havent agreed, you need to make sure people understand that youre nottheir lawyer if they think you are and youre not
lenders can require an insured closing letter
insureing the aty will follow the closing instructions of the lender FULL DISCLOSURE
case in the book -- what are white v. pinn talked about where you had the documents that lawyers had, thought they had
fully negotiated changed the prepayment penalty that he had not seen his client signed
what was the lawyers duty to pikc up on all the chagnes int he documents if youre going to send documents to people w/o telling them youve made
changes, you better make sure its a good one, b/c itll prob be your last what is the attys duty?
Atty wasnt liable, b/c client had been contributorily negligent in their failure topick up on the change
particularly interesting question with todays technology if youve got them both up there electronically
just read that shit the client who sued and didnt win, he sure as hell isnt closing any more of those
loans for the client -- opinion of borrowers counsel to lender
due execution and delivery the people who signed, were those authorized to do it and they were executed and delivered unconditionally
atty opinion as to did you review the doucments to make sure theyre a validentitydo you know who has to sign it watching people sign
might be comfortable with notary might know their signature
enforceability opinion enforceable as to their terms
i wanna know i ahve an enforceable power of sale assignment of rent personalty
excepting public policy, bankrupcy no matter what the loan says -- lenders gets amount of money necessary
to compensate them for their loss in the security. thats in the statutes basically just want the atty on the record that the borrower doesnt have anything
up his sleeve last two are the ones theyre really looking for remedies
are they adequate or customary to protect the lender?
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
31/60
are you aware of any claims or pending litigation against your client that would or couldaffect their ability to pay this loan?
conformity opinion do the loan documents conform to the committment?
where it gets hairy
multistate eliments your client is a LLC organized under North Dakota
you have to associate counsel to give you opinions from the JD that you needopinions from
knowledge when i want to say im not aware of any claims or pending litigation go through some trouble to define knowledge
atty may mean I dont know may mean ive asked around in my firm
what knowledge am I supposed to have if Im generally recognized as generalcounsel for the lcient and had knowledge of stuff
real question -- how to define the knowledge limit it as much as possible dont want to be constructively charged with someones knowledge that
didnt give it to you who signs opp letters?
practical issue who actualy signs the letter fairly common practice that letters to lenders like this are signed in the
name of the law firm and not the individual attorney firm committee -- to review and make sure that the shit theyre sending
out is up to snuff who has authority to sign are there loan transactions that take place where their are alternatives to interest
share of rev, gross revs in the profit I will loan you 10 mill, and youll pay int at .06
but if your project is highly successful, i want to share in it run the risk of becoming an equity investor and not a loan transaction
got a preferred return and then later you got a precentage returnbased on some other term
typically dont find institutional lenders willing to take that type of risk if youre willing to run the risk and not concerned about whether
your transaction is characterized as debt or not once you abandon the idea that youre making a loan, you have an open gambit
as far as investing concern as to recharacterization of transaction
ability to foreclose under the DoT? probably compromised youve got a 10MM mort 6 int, and if prop sells for more than 12MM you .5 of the
appreciation and youre not going to cancel your mort till you get that
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
32/60
were going to call it clogging the equity of redemption and its anuneforceable term
public policy dictates that ourts protect aganist agreemtns bywhich the mortgagor at time of the original loan transaction,surrenders the right to redeem the loan following defualt to avoid
loss of the mortgaged property Mortgagee must exercise its foreclosure rights to extinguinsh the
mortgagors right to redeem if its stays as a loan, your excess int (ownership position in the prop), could be
treated as interest interest and be in violation of the usury law
prepayment penalties common law -- loans were not prepayable
lenders POV if you pay me early, ive got to do something with that money that I
wouldnt otherwise had to have done bankers
1) will moan and groan about how nobody pays their loan back 2) will moan and groan about how everybody paid back early
all banks want is their interest NC -- unless loans specifically provide otherwise, statutes are prepayable
question becomes -- is there a restriction on a fee that can be charged for prepayment some caselaw that talks about -- its w/e parties who are knowledgeable and
capable of representing themselves in transactions agree to so long as they were capable of knowing what they were agreeing
some caselaw saying there has to be some reasonable relation between the
benefit of prepaying to the prepaying party and the detriment suffered by thelender some case law saying well enforce it if it doesnt shock the conscious
yield maintencance fee -- really the only thing used if you prepay, then we need to be able to take money that you prepay us and get
to the same benefits we ought to be able to reinvest in something very very safe and you make
up the difference you pay off the loan, then give me enough money now so that I can go
put that in T bills and by the end of the term ill have the same amount of money
you need to make up that difference in interest rate, and then give me thePV of what i would have been paid under the loan minus what youalready paid
loan doesnt get paid off - you defease the mortgage give a substitute investment like a present value of tbills thatll pay so that they
get the same money in the end when they were supposed to pay money
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
33/60
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
34/60
things in front of construction loan mechanic liens, taxes etc payment bonds periodic lein waivers as they do work on the job
up to date
equitable lien that can be asserted while they might now have a lien right that would have priority over construction
lien on trust recorded before work had a property future adavance
HOWEVER may be certain circumstances that the person doing work, may be able to
assert lien rights with priority over that of the lender kter could engage in conduct that would give them an equitable right to
funds over construction lender call up construction lender, and were doing the elctrical work, but
im realy not excited about any more work if im not gonna get paid do you have money, am i gonna get paid
lender doesnt want to foreclose on a hotel w/o theelectrical work
and tells him of course youre going to get paid leaves out all that other shit about how theyre
worried about funding and that theyre thinking itsgoing to go bust
estopped from claiming priority we relied
lein on funds even if we didnt rely we did the work, your collateral is worth more after we did the
work if you foreclose on it without paying, youre unjustly enriched! equitable lien
con lenders start to want to be really involved dont want to advance money that didnt get done
have to be careful -- dont want to become partners with their borrower if anything starts to look like its not a debtor creditor relationship
borrower might start staying this is an equity investment if you do jump in, youre probably going to want to have a receiver appointed
holder of the mechanic lien isnt going to ahve a very good argument if the lender forecloses and brings less than theyve advanced
dont want to be there where does lender draw the line at invovlement
lender needs to ID the major Ks they need to complete the contract look at them, approve them
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
35/60
cost-plus, lender says, hey dont you think you could get a fixed cost of acost-plus with GMP
collateral assignment of those K if your borrower is in Default, were acceling the balance, were exercising
our collateral assignment in K, go to kter says treat us as owner,
complete this work in accordance with the K neogotiation that sometimes takes place
also whn trying to get lein waver, lein sub im fine with my K being assign
but I still dont have to perform for you unles s Ive been paid. lender says blow it out your ass
ive been amking disbursements, and if the person youve beencontracting with and spending it on something else, thats the risk youvetaken and you take
you could have put in your claim of lien on funds and then itll be myproblem
compromise you tell us when you havent been paid on time, even though we have
accelled the loan, w/in 30 days of being owed and we agree if we cant get it paid in x days, well pay it
were NOT going to allow you, however, when I come over and say giveme this and that and you say pay me for the last 6 months, you can go tohell on that
LoC Bonds diligent about how you disburse funds
getting a pay application and well pay it, but we need a lein waiver
how can we use financing ti generate additional cash for borrower refis or secondary financing why want to refi?
lower int rate in order to provide more capital for the project
building or prop doing really really well I would like to be able to take that cashflow and go to another lender saying I will
loan you a lot more money b/c I like how much money your property is making reschedule the obligations you have under the loan financing is tax-free
at one level, some people look at refis as a tax free way to sell property if they foreclose and take the hotel, youre gonna owe taxes
even if you dont get any money COD income
still do get the time portion of the value of that money for free
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
36/60
what if you cant refi the first? prepayment fees or foreclosed to prepay
blended cost of having a second and a first mortgage may be less that refi-ying even if you have a low first mort
you still need money, vis-a-vis money owned on first mort your second rate is always going to be higher but, higher rates on 200k is
probably gonna be less than 5-6MM refi moving from 6-8 prohibitions on encumbrances, due on encumbrance?
go talk to the first why would they let you?
they may know you really need the money youre about to get a new tennant but need to put some money in to
make some changes lender maysay im delighted to let you get some money and put it into
the property and bring in a new tenant well need consent for second or messanine financing typically
INTER-CREDITOR AGREEMENT if youre the holder of the 2nd you want some things from the 1st
if theres ever default, I want notice additionally, would you give me an opportunity to cure for them
10MM first, 1MM second i want to know if hes defaulted on a 60k payment, im
inclined to pay 60k to keep the loan from defaulting thenhaving to go bid a the sale to protect my position
also gives me a chance to foreclose
i can assure you that Ive got a provision that says if yourein defualt on the first, youre in defualt with us lender -- you should let me, foreclosure doesnt hurt you,
you end up with a better borrower Lender says -- why should I give you better deal
than the borrower? well, lender how much do you want a second
2nd -- I dnt want their to be any changes unde the 1st that I dont consent to i dont wan the int rate to go up w/o my consent
i agreed to be behind a 5 not a 7 may cover the 5, and get my money back, if borrower has to pay
back 7 i may be sol unlikely that the 1st will blanketly agree
but the second can have an agreement with the borrower not tomake a change
1st might agree to a list of things they wont change bu tthat depends upon the facts and circumstnaces
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
37/60
2nd might want to have a right to purchase the first loan in the event of tehdefault
mess finance secured by int in the borrower youd probably have similar concerns
cross defualt, notice of defualt, etc
subordinated Purchase Money loan seller-financing
you agree to take back a note secured by a mortgaged typicall this is what they mean in the RE arena
seller financing their own prop or any loan that secures the purchase of property
bank account pays .025 cd pays 1-2
ill pay you 6, 7, 8 its a better investment for you
accountant tells them you can sell it, sell it for 100k an acre but you dont have to pay for it until you get it when you get paid its capital gains, except for interest, thats regular income installment sale reporting
if i gotta pay ordinary income on the int why dont we up the price from 100k/ acre to 125/ acre irs is going to say, we dont believe there are zero percent loans
either theres a gift going on OR some portion is interest imputed interest different rates for diff maturities and loan
cash down MAKE SURE YOU HAVE IT incase you have to forclose when it gets rezoned for this fabulous mixed use the tax rates are going to go
way iup and the county tax assessor will be wanting his money, regardless who
owns it has he told you how hes gonna finance these imrovements
says hes getting a loan from BBT mr. reed is the regional vice
and he said theyre excited did anybody mention anything about you subordinating your interest
so youre not going to have a first mortgage loan youre gonna have a second well lets talk about PM mort
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
38/60
in NC, theyre by law NR 45-21.38 in event of default you can only foreclose
youre behind the bank and then you have foreclose, withthe rezone and higher tax, and the mortgage in favor of
BBT for the amount he owes very difficult for an layman seller of prop to takeback subornated PM
financing on a basis that makes any sense youve really got to know what youre doing
have done it though mr. developer will pay 2MM and 1MM down
were already tickled to sell it for a million if we dont get the second M its not the end of the world, not a big
deal, windfall if we do maybe not take back a subordinated interest but take back a first
priority mort on a smaller chunk of the property dont want to sell him the front part of the property and lose all your access to the
balance to your property on which you hold your mortgage. need you to release the RoW so i can build access
gotta give an easement for the sewer line if youre banking on the BBT loan to enjhance the value of hte prop you have the
subd loan on you need to make sure that the money the disburse gets spent onimprovement
you also need to know how theyre planning on paying them back what is the bbt release
they should have money left over to pay us
theyd just have to know way too much and be way too involved And I dont want to babysit them. judgment lien can jump infront of a refi in priority
gotta get in there to the judgment/clerk index inchoate marital interest
gotta get the spouse to relase her interest otherwise she could disavow the will and take her spouses share
seller financed doesnt req the signing for thisotherwayus to pull out money
credit tenant lease financing-- Bond Lease sale-leaseback here, company with excellent credit can do it internally or find a third party that likes to own prop
i want to take all my retail stores and convey them to mr. x for such andsuch a price
Im gonna give you back a lease where Im going to continue to leasethose property for $x/ft
completely net basis lease
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
39/60
responsible for everything i expect to be paid at a really really low cap rate for those rents, b/c im no credit
risk i have essentially sold the prop but havent given up possession or responsibility
but Ive cashed out
the buyers call up and say have I got a deal for you IBM has guaranteed to me that theyre gonna lease for x years can I get a loan from you, to buy
oh, btw, youll have a lien loan isnt being made on basis of what the prop is worth
its being made on the credit of the company going to lease from a balance sheet perspective, theyve got all that debt off their books, except for the
one year lease basically taking a RE loan, but making it not a RE loan, but based on the credit of
hte comp thats there for this to work --
cant be any repurchase rights for a nominal amount misused term
net, triple net, quad net trip -- taxes, insurances, maintenance
what does maintenance mean? changing lightbulbs, unclogging toilets or changing roof
net lease -- net as to what? bond lease -- net as net can be
LL has NO responsibility, tenant has it all
we want all the responsibility to be where the credit isd nothing excuses the tenant from paying rent tenants responsbility to do everything, -- have the insurance,
rebuild the building, etc synthetic lease
captive company of their own establish a lease, the terms of which, will be treated as a capital lease
as if they own the property and they can deduct depreciation and takeadvantages of ownership
captial lease for IRS pruposes but treat it as an opperating lease for accounting prupose
(bond lease is opp on both irs and accounting leases) limit on how much rent and discounted options to repurchase
if the rents are really and you have a nominal fee at the end to buy you own the damn thing
you dont have to show the liability for the loan or the asset on your companysbalance sheet
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
40/60
have to have the company with the appropriate credit to provide a loan and theloanll be repaid with the lease
for financial accounting purposes (under pre-2003 U.S. financial accounting rules), the asset isowned by a special-purpose entity and leased to the operating company under an operating lease.The special -purpose entity is usually owned by the lessee / operating company, and is given justenough independence so that it can be taken off the operating company's balance sheet. The assetis thus recorded as an asset on the balance sheet of the special purpose entity, not of the lessee /operating company. Thus, depreciation of the asset need not be charged against income of theoperating company. Instead, the lease payments are recorded as an expense on the incomestatement.
for tax purposes, the asset is owned by the operating company (or the special-purpose entity isconsolidated with the operating company, so that the two are treated as a single entity for taxaccounting purposes). Thus, the operating company can deduct depreciation of the asset for taxpurposes, generally on an accelerated depreciation schedule.
alternative methods of getting cash
tax benefit financing bond financing
govt entitles wiling to issue bonds to a lender who will then make a loan asdirected under the bond program
if I want to build a industyr in halifax county the govt may issues bonds to go to raymond james, well give you a bond tax-exempt financing
essenitally, only bond payments are made so when they get their interest theyre not taxed on it
obvi govt cant issue bonds for anything has to be w/in the confines of their governning documents
city charter/county/states what can they encumber themselves in
IRS says, we arent gonna let you finance willy nilly anything you want tounless we think its a qualified public project
keeps getting a little shorter at one time you finance a sports arena
no longer can get a tax exempt bond financing for this typeof project
certain govt entitles can borrow money at a lower int rate
NC board of nursing recently built new HQ -- financed with tax exempted financing
interest isnt taxed, so they got really favorable rates project that qualify for tax credits
estabed largely by fed govt if you build certain types of things we want to have -- we will issue you tax
credits based on a formula and your investment rural development
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_purpose_entityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_purpose_entityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balance_sheethttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balance_sheethttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balance_sheethttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expensehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expensehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_purpose_entityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_purpose_entityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_purpose_entityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_purpose_entityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balance_sheethttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balance_sheethttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expense8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
41/60
farmings homing certain people who need housing assistance
rental assistance too if you rent to the people you say youre going ot rent to, well help
subsidize them
when things start to go wrong from lenders view
when we dont get paid, or when we thinkg we might not getting paid understanding when we think were at risk f not being paid
we start worrying about our collateral here who is our lender worried when we drive by and all the windows are busted out or when the
insurance calls and say you didnt pay are we comfortable that the borrower really cares enough, or can care enough about our
collateral lenders look and say we need to take control of this before it gtes out of hand
always provisions that say lender can come and take possession to ensure theprotection of their collateral
nobody wants to do it once you do this, when you get around to suing your borrower
they said, i only recall there were 3 windows that were broken, fact thatyou fixed 50 doesnt mean shit to me, you made life so difficult for thetenants they moved out
seek to have a receiver court appointed person to take possession of prop
can seek it exparte basis judge were the lender, mortgage, dependant upon the collateral havingvalue
they wont fix the broken windows, turing into a drug dealing spot we want you to appoint x, professional management comp, as receiver
this is an equitable remedy not entitled to as a matter of law
it will be very very helpful that your loan documents allow for oneto be appointed, but the courts arent reqd to appoint
may want to call the guy typically, putting evi, even in affidavit form, in front of judge, theyre gonna say
fine who do you want to be the receiver probably will ask you to appoint a bond to secure the performance of the
receiver can typically take control of prop
including accounts related to the running of prop
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
42/60
judgell say i wanna hearing in the next 10 days, notice given to borrower, to seeif this receiver will stay and if the bond is enough
receiver works for the court, it does not work for the lender reqd to file reports
typically gets courts to confirm/ratify decision its made on a
periodic basis lender has not taken possession of property
it was an offfical of the court receiver has no liabilities beyond conducting its receivership duties
assignment of leases and rents always in the loan documents
notice to tenant that borrower agreed and youre now exercising that if you dont pay us, youll be in default under the lease
sometimes this wakes the borrower up cant we work something out
can we go interest only for a little while? mod that int instead of 6 is 3 for the next year but well still accrue the only 3, add
it to the balance, and then reamortize couple of things to think about
lender -- i dont want any agreement thats going to adversely effect my lienpossition on the prop
dont want to jeopardize my ability to collect on the loan for anyone whoseresponsible for it
lender if youve got guarantors, dont want to mod th eloans without the written
consent of the guarantor that the mod doesnt effect their responsibility to
repay .35 drop in prop values from 06 yo 09, wouldnt you feel like you gotshitted on if they extended out principal, lost value in the land and nowyoure really on the hook
even if loan documents say you dont need their approval practical matter, people arent going to be too happy, the trial court is
saying, the govt bailed you out, bout time you start bailing some other people out
guartor may say, sorry man, cant do it lender has some options he may in this situations, say were foreclosing
lien priority if youre gonna mod the note and the mort agrement
a lot of people concerned if you walk into a clerks if you want the title ins still to be good
youre gonna need to file a new DoT legal answer
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
43/60
if the mod you do doesnt increase the amount secured or increase the liabilityofht eborrower
the DoT still secures an indebtedness as evidenced by the note as it maybe modified
also hard for a Jr LH to say, you lowering your interest rate really hurt me
however, if you go interest only, and Jr leinholder with judgment lein andsay the note you are foreclosing on was amended and modified and ithurt me
it was my understanding that the principle was to be paid down at aregular amount
the principle ought to be a lot lower if you had been tougher with him there wouldnt be such a
large mortgage in front of me today dont find it very compelling but its not inaccurate
what need to do amend and mod note and DoT talk to your Title insurance
borrower says, can i just give it back to you? if its nonrecourse or even if its not
i dont have anything ill just give you a deed in lieu
principle of how mortgages work the principle is at the time you get the mort or DoT, particularly in a DoT state
title was transferred to the trustee, if you foreclose your title relates backto the date you got that DoT
perfect the title
if you take a deed in lieu youre buying at that time if there is an intervening lein, you take the title subject to that have to make sure that they dont file br in 90 days
could be taken as a preferential transfer cant pay on an antecedent debt
insider -- 1 year why ever take one?
probably can satisfy yourself that is unlikely theyll be filing especially if theyre single purpose single asset entity thats br remote
borrower what are the tax consequences deed in lieu has greater chance of income from forgiveness of indebtedness
CoD for homeowners -- there have been some recent acts passed for this to protect
them from CoD income terms need to be defined
are you giving the property in satsifaction of the indebtedness -- or is there adeficiency
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
44/60
friendly foreclosure theres too much stuff we cant control too many interevening interests out there
were not comfortable buying the property has to be cafefule there is no collusion in the bidding process for the sale
you can agree to limit or not to seek a deficiency
dont want to agree about who can buy it at the sale bank has a buyer, but want to buy from fore so they get free and
clear so well bid it up to a certain price and let them take it
back to DiL dont want to take it in the name of the lender
set up an entity that can take title to it dont want to give up your mortgage until youre confident youve negotiated all the perils
that may happen afterwards if you take title in same name that the person whose the lender under the loan --
MERGER kicks in Doctrine, the lesser title held as benificiary of the DoT merges into title held by
the deed and the mortgage has merged into the deed and has been extinguishedby merger
make sure you take it in a separate entity if the BR sets aside the transfer, you can still foreclose after jumping
through the hoops reqd by the BR court if theres a JL that pops up afterwards, whoops you forgot about me, you still
forecloseForeclosure -- so you couldnt work it out
1 -- must accelerate
lable it due and payable documents should say loan can be acceled w.o notice internally even
typically, notice is sent youre in default, were accing as provided in the document
in NC were going to seek to enforce the provision of hte loan that provides atty
.15 of loan notice, and have to give borrower five days
once the loan is accellerated its due, all of it youve got to come up with all due under the note
two types judicial
file a lawsuit and one of the remedies you seek is the ability to forecloseto cause the prop to be sold to satisfy the indebtedness
if you want any party to be bound, you need to make them a party to thelawsuit
borrower, junior leinholders, the whole shebang
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
45/60
lengthy process special proceeding -- power of sale
trustee -- file a notice of hearing before the Sup Court CLerk in countywhere prop located
certain parties specified in statue as to who is entitled to notice
record owner any party to whom you think youre goint to collect money
from after foreclosure deficiency
any party with a record interest have to get 10 days before the hearing
clerk was notice given and received is the party seeking to foreclosure the holder and owner of a note
and dot power of sale default
hearing is limited to those matters and legal defenses to those not equitable defenses need to file for an injunction and a hearing before a superior court
judge Dot cant waive statutoryily requirements, but it can highten the
responsibilities at least 20 days notice of hte Notice of Sale
in addition -- have to send notice to anyone whos requested notice for sale
stat requires a deposit of .05 10 days - upset bid period ttee --
after period, ttee conveys the prop after receiving hte money files final report of sale
got x money, disbursed money in this way files notice of foreclosure with Register of Deeds office
what can be different? in addition to right to appear at limited can file for injuctive releif file for appeal from findings of clerk
but judge here still constrained by the limited proceeding available defenses
fraud on the deed if lender acelled indebt cuz you didnt pay on time
if you can show the lender has routinely been accepting late paymetns they waived and are now estopped
UNLESS
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
46/60
notice given, saying were stopping this late payment nonsense all contract
marshalling -- equitable require the lender to foreclose on some other prop if im a jr. leinholder
if the lender has two tracts one with my jr. lein and one without my junior lein
its inequitable for them to foreclose on this first reverse order of alienation -- equitable
i buy one of the lots and it didnt get released from mortgage forclose on the other lots first
foreclose first on the lots that were sold first deficiency
have to be brought w/in one year of foreclosure .38 PM, .36
in credit bid borrower can contend that the lender didnt bid th FMV of prop deficiency shouldnt be this big
guarantors cant ue theory -- you find someone else to bid more, or you go bid it in
lender has to be the one to bid the prop in fact that they let it fly to someone else for less than fmv doesnt matter its about preventing a windfall to the bank
got to doyour due diligence before you get ot the sale
at the sale bidding at a foreclosure for 2nd mortgage, and theres a first mort of 1MM
1.2MM is what you think prop is worth dont bid more than .2MM
wrap around indicates that its for an amount equal to first and second
but when you bid in youre only bidding in on the second the portion of that wrap, which is in addition to the first
cali case never rely on implied warranties as to habitability fitness, zoning etc of
prop coming out of foreclosure sale only in cali
hopefully your lender client did their due diligence when they made the loan exception -- has the prop been tainted since they made the loan on the property enviromental contamination
needs to do due dili bout this lenders typically take title in the name of a diff entity than the actual bank itself
8/2/2019 Real Estate Finance and Transactions
47/60
dragnet on the first ought to be able to get the holder of the second can get a statement of
whats owed on the first midwestern
states have 1 year redemption periods
cant waive your right to it how do you ever know
youve got good title if the dude can swoop on in installment land/contract for deed
where the guy misses a payment, can the guy just say youre not missing your payment anymore
doubtful that if they miss one payment and have made the previous 20 2010 gs47g
regulates contracts for deed it sets out stat framework for how the Ks can be enforced
intended to provide consumer protectionif you have the facts, argue the facts, dont hjave the facts argue the law, dont have thelaw,argue the constitution
no consitutional issue with judicial process providing for foreclosure process so long as it has the lawsuit reqts and there was notice and service to all those
people power of sale foreclosures are a little more challenging
right to receive notice and right to have a hearing procedural due process
determining factor
Whether or not there