Relations between brain alterations and clinical pain measures in chronic musculoskeletal pain: A systematic review

7/26/2019 Relations between brain alterations and clinical pain measures in chronic musculoskeletal pain: A systematic review

1/41

Accepted Manuscript

Relations between brain alterations and clinical pain measures in chronic

musculoskeletal pain: A systematic review

Iris Coppieters, MSc, Mira Meeus, PhD, Jeroen Kregel, MSc, Karen Caeyenberghs,

PhD, Robby De Pauw, MSc, Dorien Goubert, MSc, Barbara Cagnie, PhD

PII: S1526-5900(16)30071-2

DOI: 10.1016/j.jpain.2016.04.005

Reference: YJPAI 3260

To appear in: Journal of Pain

Received Date: 8 January 2016

Revised Date: 11 April 2016

Accepted Date: 18 April 2016

Please cite this article as: Coppieters I, Meeus M, Kregel J, Caeyenberghs K, De Pauw R, Goubert D,

Cagnie B, Relations between brain alterations and clinical pain measures in chronic musculoskeletal

pain: A systematic review, Journal of Pain(2016), doi: 10.1016/j.jpain.2016.04.005.

This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to

our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo

copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final form. Please

note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all

legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jpain.2016.04.005


2/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

1

:

C I, M1,2; M M, PD1,2,3; K J, M1,2,4; C K, PD1,5; D

P R, M1; G D, M

1,2; C B, PD

1

1D R P, F M H ,

G , B; 2

P M , ..;

3D R P, F M H ,

A, B;4D H P P,

B, F P E & P, M C J, B F

K, L 103, B 1090, B;5 P, F H ,

A C , A

N : 19

N : 1

N : 6

C : . I C, .@., 0497 92 90 32

I C D G, PD G,

R F G (BOFG).

J K, PD G,

F (IB, B).

.


3/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

2

C

(MKP) . I ,

. I

MKP. N,

.

PRIMA ,

,

(MRI) , MKP.

PM, , C C . F,

. , . R

NO .

. M

(GM)

,

. F,

GM . ,

GM MKP .I

.

I ,

,

, MKP. N,

. F

.

,

MKP .

A,

MKP.

: C ; ; ;

;


4/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

3

(MKP) , ,

.(24)

A,

,

/.(77)

A,

MKP

.(75)

C MKP ,

, , ,

.(14, 17)

C MKP

.(95)

, .(90, 95)

A,

,

, .(95)

A

MKP .(20, 25, 29, 81, 92)

C

, ..,

, , .

(76, 80)

, ,

, .(66)

C

/ ,

, .(77)

A 30 .(2)

.D

, .(82)

,

.(4, 26)

,

,(5, 56)

(44)

(33)

. I , ,

() .(4, 9)

E

, .(54)


5/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

4

M R I (MRI)

, .(26, 82)

B MRI

MRI.

(GM) (M)

. H 1 ,

, GM ,(30)

, ,(31)

(30)

GM .(6)

(BM) GM

GM .(6)

, F ,

GM .(30)

L .(47)

D MRI M M

.(7)

D

. C, (DI)

M . ,

, .(1)

(FA) , .(87)

N,

.(89)

,

, DI.(45)

C MRI GM M

MKP , ,

,(20, 52, 61, 68)

, , (1,

2), (PFC), (ACC,

PCC), , , (PAG).(8, 1921, 27, 37, 52, 82, 83)

()

(BOLD) .(15)

MRI BOLD

.(13)

D MRI, BOLD

.(59,

78) ( ), (


6/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

5

. C

.

R MRI BOLD

.(13)

(FC).(34)

(DMN) ( )

.(54)

R,

DMN

.(10, 40, 55, 64)

R MRI FC

.(18, 82)

F MRI ()

,

MKP.(10, 11, 20, 52)

D ,

.(26)

. I

MKP

.(82)

I ,

, , ,

.(37, 48, 60)

E

, , MKP

.(36, 57)

A

,

MKP, .(57)

I , ,

/ , (..

, ) MKP

. O,

,

.(57)

,

MKP . H,


7/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

6

. ,

MKP , MRI .

PRIMA (P R

I MA).(70) PICO

: (1) (O)

(O) MKP (P), MRI

(I)? (2) (O)

(O) MKP (P), MRI (I)?

E

( 1). ,

/ (..

, , , , , ,

, ) (O) MRI (I) MKP (P).

E (I.C. &

B.C.), (M.M.). A ,

. I ,

. I ,

.


8/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

7

A .

PM (://..../), (://.),

C (://...///), C

(://..//) 7

2015

. ,

.

. 2.

M (I.C. &

J.K.), PD MKP MRI.

B M.M., PD . R

NO (NO)

(://..///.).(93)

NO

3 : , ,

. (99)

C C (..).

. , 9 , MRI

2 ,

. I 9 MRI (..

). I 10 /

. ,

10 NO, . A

C

(.. , ).

B , ,

2005 D I H I CBO

( 1). ,

,

( 2). 2

B. 3


9/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

8

B. 4

.

( 3): (1) ; (2) ; (3) MRI ; (4) ; (5)

, , ; (6) ; (7) , , .

(I.C.) (R.D.P.)

. N, MRI

, . I ,

MKP

.

. 1. 137

. A , 91 . (32, 37)

: .

20 .

A (=20) , MKP

.

( 3). A MRI .

GM ,(22, 37, 53, 67, 71, 96)

M

,(48, 56, 61, 68)

,(10, 22, 28,

32, 43, 44, 49, 51, 60, 74, 98).


10/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

9

4. A B.

M , 5/10 (50%) 9/10 (90%). M

(80%), (85%) (60%),

. N,

(.. ),

. A

/

.

I (90,5% 181 200 ), 2 (I.C. & J.K.) . A

19 , 197 . F

3 , (R.D.P.).

4.

O,

MKP .(22, 37, 48, 53, 56, 61, 67, 68, 71, 96)

BM,(22,

37, 53, 67, 71, 96)

(67) DI.

(48, 56, 61, 68)

GM

.(67, 71, 96)

M .(71)

.(96)

GM . I

GM (ACC),

(PCC), , .(96)

M .(71)

GM ACC.


11/41


12/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

11

,

( 2). ,

(

4).

A,

( 3).

F (48, 56, 61, 68)

M DI MRI . K (48)

M (68)

FA , (48)

, (68)

.(68)

M .(68)

FA . I ,

L .(61)

L .(56)

FA M (61)

FA .(56)

, A

, ,

( 2). ,

A ( 4).

L .(56)

MKP

(AD)

. A, MG

AD .

,

A

( 3).


13/41


14/41


15/41


16/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

15

. A B.

M , 5/10 (50%) 9/10 (90%).

M

GM ,

.(22, 71, 96)

F,

GM . ,

GM

MKP .(37, 67, 96)

M,

FA M (48, 56, 61, 68)

FC

.(10, 22, 32, 43, 44, 49, 51, 73, 74, 98)

H,

M(48, 56,

61, 68) FC(10, 22, 32, 43, 44, 49, 51, 73, 74, 98) MKP.

I MKP ,

, ( MKP )

. H, MKP

. B

MKP

ACC, , , .

I (.. )

. R

MKP MKP

, , , , , , ,

.(8, 16, 22, 35, 41, 58, 63, 65, 69, 88, 97)

A,

.

GM

. I GM

.(5, 50, 84)

F,

.(67)

,

.

.


17/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

16

I ,

MKP

. R I B

C R P

, ,

, .(12, 79, 91, 94)

B

GM MKP

, , ,

MKP .(12, 79, 91)

MKP

, .


18/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

17

, MRI, (.. , ,

, , , , , ) MKP. R ,

, .

I GM

, . I ,

M FC

, .

B ,

MKP. I

. ,

MKP

,

. R, B A

.(3, 8)

, . H,

.

, . F,

MRI .

, , MRI .(42) N,

/ .

MRI .(46, 86)

,

(5)

(44)

,(33)

. I ,

P , M

E . H,


19/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

18

. F, MRI

, MRI

. N,

.

. A ,

.

, . L

. A ?

H, . F,

. ,

. F,

. A , NO 2

. C,

MRI

MRI .

I ,

. R

. I ,

.

. M

.

M MKP . I

.

F,

,

. E

.


20/41


21/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

20

1. A AL, L JE, L M, F A. D .

. 4:31629, 2007.

2. A A. F H B I C :

. I: K L, L A, . : F

M M. B , FL: CC L.; 2010.

3. A A, H JA, B M. :

. . 152:4964, 2011.

4. A A, B MC, D, JK. H

. E J . 9:46384, 2005.

5. A A, , , L M, H , B, G D. C

. J .

24:104105, 2004.

6. A J, F KJ. . . 11:805

21, 2000.

7. A , . D (DI)

: . J M . 34:5161, 2008.

8. B M, A A. , , M, B .

. 87:47491, 2015.

9. B M, J, B , A A. B

. L . 6:26010, 2011.

10. B M, M A, B A, A A. F

. L . 9:106133, 2014.

11. B M, B, , H KM, H L, J, F HL, A

A. C . .

15:11179, 2012.

12. B MJ, , J, C , M . C

. J .15:197203, 2014.

13. B F, H , A. M :

. . 272:2949, 2014.

14. B AJ, B JF. F . A I M. 130:91021, 1999.

15. B J, K KK, K D, B J, CE, B , C DA,

M, C M, B, F , B J, B. M

. H . I . 27 2:5965, 1992.

16. B , C J, D E, D KD. A

: . G.

138:17839, 2010.

17. B JH, L M, D.

. J . 78:22836, 2015.

18. B L, K FM, B.

MI. . 16:8327, 2013.

19. B MC, C M, L LA. C

. . 14:50211, 2013.

20. C B, C I, D , J, D L, M M. C

? A MI. A

. 44:6875, 2014.

21. C F, , C , , D , , G G, DM. G

: A .

C. 4:67686, 2014.

22. C M, B MC, F MA, . F . C. 3:24960, 2013.


22/41


23/41


24/41


25/41


26/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

25

99. , , K J, C, L , F, , D L.

, ,

: . J E B M. 8:210, 2015.

1.

MKP: , DI: , MRI: ,

MRI: MRI, PEC: , PE:

, EEG: , MEG:

2. ( )

3. = ; = ; A = ; = ; = ; =

; A = A ; = ; = ; =

; A = A ; =

; = ; = ; =

; = ; = ; = ; = ; =

; = ; A = A; =

; /= / ; = ; =

; = ; A = A; = ; A = A

; = ; = ; A = A ; A =

; = ; = ; = ; A= ;

= ; = ; = ; = ; = ;

= ; 1 = ; 2 = ; =

; = ; = ; = ;

= ; = ; = ; = ; =

; = ; = ; = ; = ;

= ; = ; = ; 1= ; = ; =; A=

4.

+ = ; = ; /=

NO Q A : : 1=I ?;

2=R ; 3= ; 4=D ; 5=

; 6= ; 7=A ; 8=

; 9= MRI ; 10=

/ ; LOE=

5.

6.

DMN: , ICA: , EAN: , MRI:

MRI, FA: , AD: , GM: , M: , CF:


27/41


28/41


29/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT


30/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

.

()

()

, ,

K

. (2007)(11)

FM (10)

HC (10)

A

MI (1)

BM

D

GM

C

1.

. (2010)(19)

MMD (14)

B

HC (15)

A

MI (1)

BM

D ,

( ),

A (

)

,

,

,

GM

+ C

1.

D

CC,

C

2.

A

FG &

3.

GM

G

. (2011)(5)

MMD (9)

HC (9):

A

MI (1)

BM

GM

C

1.

GM

M

. (2011)(15)

MMD (17)

I

HC (17)

MI (1)

BM

C

( ),

(

),

,

GM

C

1.

MCC

2.

GM


31/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

( &

),

D

GM

+ C

3.

M

.

(2012)(17)

C (20)

I

HC (20)

A

MI (1)

BM

IHCI ( )

GM

C

1.

L .

(2008)(14)

FM (30)

HC (30)

A

MI (1, 2)

DI

(FI )

FA M

+ C

1.

K .

(2014)(8)

FM (19)

HC (18)

A

MI (1, 2)

DI

A

FM (

)

FA M

C

1.


32/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

M

. (2012)(16)

MMD (17)

I

HC (17)

DI ( ),

(

)

,

FA M

C

1.

/

2.

3.

4.

L

. (2014)(12)

C MK

(46)(12)

(34)

HC (33)

(14)(19)

A

DI ,

FM,

FA & AD M

+ C

1.

FA

2.

AD

3.

AD

4.

M

5.

M


33/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

. (2010)(18)

FM (18)

HC (18)

A

MI

A (

MI )

FC

+ C

1.

.

DM

.

EAIC &

C

2.

1.

EA

F .

(2014)(4)

FM (16)

HC (22)

A

MI

MI

(

)

A,

C

FC

+ C

1.

L IC

L

L

I .

(2014)(7)

FM (18)

HC (18)

A

MI: MI:

(

)

I,

GB,

ICCC

IC

+ C

1. C

2. A

IC &

3.


34/41


35/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

A, &

)

C

2.

AG &

B .(2014)

(1)

CLB (18)(13)

(5)

A (14):

(8)

(6)

HC (36)(12)

(24)

MI (1)BM

MI

,

FC

HF

DM,

CLB, A:+ C

1.

2. H

DM

CLB:

3.

DM

I .

(2012)(6)

MMD (8)

HC (8)

A

MI (1)

MI

MI (

)

A,

I (FM),

BI

,

FC

C

1.

A

2.

M

L

3.

FC ACC/

&

C .

(2013)(2)

FM

(14)

FM (14)

HC

(15)

HC (13)

MI (1)

BM

MI

( )

E

GM

FM

C

1.


36/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

A

,

FC

GM

2.

GM

+ C

3.

4.

FM

C

5.

GM

F .

(2011)(3)

C (19)

HC (16)

A &

MI (1)

MI (

& )

DI

A,

M,

&

GM

GM

+ C

1.

2.

M

A I

3.

4.

ACC G


37/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

4.

&

(%)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

. + 9/10

. + 8/10

. + 8/10

. + 8/10

. + 8/10

. + 8/10

. + 7/10

. + 7/10

. + 7/10

. + 7/10

. + 7/10

. + 7/10

. + 7/10

. + 7/10

. + 6/10

. + 6/10

. + 6/10

. + 5/10

. + 5/10

. + 5/10


38/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

() (2) (57, 75)

( ) (2) (1, 75)

( ) (2) (30, 53, 75)

(3) (43)

( ) & (3) (53)

( , , &

) (2)(46),(40, 4,

54)

(

) (3) (46)

( / ,

) (2)(, 1, 27, 36,

60) (35, 41,

42, 5, 76)

( / ,

)

(2) (27, 35, 36)

(, ) &

(3) (4)

(3) (23)


39/41

ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

.(18, 32)

.

,

.

.(23, 70)

.

( )

( ).

,

. ,

.(14)

.

.(14)

,

.

.

,

.

0.

1.

.

50

10.


40/41


41/41

Documents

Relations between brain alterations and clinical pain measures in chronic musculoskeletal pain: A systematic review