Upload
reno-dal
View
220
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
RWR 0 RWR 0
RWR #0 P#0 only copyright Reno Dal 2002
Reno’s Writing Renditions!
The Academic EssayThe Academic Essay
Inside you will find:
1. Five sections that explain the essay in stages.
2. Details about the elements of an academic essay.
3. Hot tips about how to write an excellent essay.
4. Detailed questions that help you review each section.
5. A table of contents on page 2 for your convenience.
Copyright Version #1, 2002
This revision #4 copyright Reno Dal 2004
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 1
Written by Reno Dal Page 1 copyright 29/04/14
EAP
Understanding The Essay Format
Level: Intermediate
The Purpose of This Package
The purpose of this text is to explain the features of an academic
essay and their functions.
After reading this booklet you will understand the main features of
essays and how they are used differently in the three different genres
(kinds) of academic essay.
How to use this package
This booklet is divided into five sections.
We recommend that you only do one at a time, take a break and then
return.
You will find that each step adds more information and complexity, so
that as you move through each stage, you will be reviewing what
happened before and adding to your knowledge.
Each section should take from 20-30 minutes to complete.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 2
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Table of Contents
WHAT IS AN ACADEMIC ESSAY? 3
FIELDS OF INFLUENCE: DIAGRAM 9
ESSAY FEATURES: THE BASIC CONCEPTS 14
ESSAY FEATURES: IN DETAIL 21
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS 29
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 3
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
What is an academic essay?
Writing an essay is not a normal thing to do. In your normal everyday
life you would never need to do it and in fact, if you did, for example,
write an academic essay to your mother, she would think you were a
bit strange. But when you go to university, you do need to do things
that you never had to do before and writing an essay is one of them.
So what’s so different? Well, firstly, you can be personal with your
mum. You can tell her how you feel, but in an academic essay you
can’t do that. Instead, what you should do is demonstrate that you
have understood your course and have done extra research that
supports your ideas. In other words your academic essay is about
facts and research, not about how you feel.
This also affects how you write the essay. For example, right now I am
using a familiar style, addressing you personally, as if we were talking.
This is called ‘colloquial language’ and there’s nothing wrong with it,
but it is not used in academic writing. Why not? Well not only because
it is too personal but also because it is a bit casual, a bit vague. It
works just fine when you are talking with people but in academic
writing we need to be much more accurate and much more scientific.
More logical, if you like.
Academic writing is more like this:
Writing an academic essay is an exercise in
communication which differs markedly from other
forms of writing. Thus, it requires a different
kind of approach and a style which is particular
to the academic environment. As a result, it is
necessary to adjust not only the way in which the
project is approached, but how it is achieved.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 4
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
You will notice that this is not like normal speech. It is not personal;
no first or second person pronouns (I, you) or questions. It is often in
the passive voice. e.g. ‘The way in which the project is approached’
not ‘How we approach the project’. It also follows a logical path by first
introducing the general idea, what we call the Topic Sentence, and
then explaining that idea in detail, what we call the Elaboration.
An essay is also different in how it is presented; it has its own form.
Basically, in an essay we introduce the main idea, explain what it
means and tell the reader what important arguments or ideas will be
presented. We call this the Introduction, which is the first paragraph of
the essay. It tells the audience what we understand by the topic and
explains the main ideas that we will present in the essay.
Once we have done that we need to move on to the more detailed
information. This is called the Body; the main part of the essay where
your ideas are explained in detail. This has a special format as well;
each paragraph needs to be announced so that the reader knows what
it is about and what it will do. This might include a staging device that
tells us its purpose (eg ‘however’, ‘on the other hand’, ‘moreover’) in
relation to the other paragraphs or it might only be a topic sentence
that informs us of the main idea of the paragraph, for example:
‘In terms of environmental factors, the most
common was found to be air pollution.”
Here we see that the essay is considering the environment and this
paragraph will be talking about ‘air pollution’. Thus the reader has a
very clear of idea of what to expect in the sentences that follow.
Once the body text is completed it is time to end the essay with a
conclusion. The Conclusion has two main features: the summary and
the concluding statement. The summary adds together all the
arguments of the body text. It is a bit like a list of the sub-topics. After
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 5
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
that, the essay comes to an end with some sort of all-encompassing
statement, something that gives the reader a clear and simple result
for the whole text. The concluding statement is slightly different for
each of the three essay genres (styles).
Now of course there are many ways to write an essay and some of
them are a bit more complex than this, but for the moment our aim is
to understand the basic elements of a good essay. Once you have
understood these basics then you can proceed to develop your own
ideas with a clear understanding of what you are trying to achieve.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 6
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Fundamental Rules
1. Language is more formal, less personal than everyday speech.
2. Words and expressions are more compressed. They are denser and
arranged differently.
3. Ideas are logical rather than emotional. They need to arranged in
related groups and have those relationships clearly explained.
4. Planning is essential. Whereas you might not plan a letter to your
mother but just sit down and write ideas as they come to you, in an
academic essay, you need to organize your thoughts and make a
plan of what you are going to write.
5. Structure is also very important. Basically, you should tell uswhat
you will tell us in general terms (introduction), tell us in detail (body
text) and then tell us what you have told us in general terms, again
(conclusion).
6. Research is also very important because an academic essay is not
primarily about your opinion. You might use the essay to express
your opinion but you must do it using other people’s research and
conclusions. We call this ‘referencing’.
7. Understanding is also very important. You will need to read,
understand and analyse your references. You will have to decide
what is important and what is not. Then you will need to understand
the relationships between your different sets of data and arrange
them in a sensible and useful pattern.
8. Finally, review is essential. You can’t just sit down and write an
essay in one sitting. A good essay has to be revised and improved.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 7
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Review Questions- True or False
An academic essay:
1. expresses how you feel. T/F
2. shows how you understood the course T/F
3. demonstrates the extent of your research T/F
4. uses language just like talking to someone T/F
5. uses colloquial language T/F
6. is accurate and scientific T/F
7. is like a letter you would write to your mother T/F
8. uses personal pronouns (I, you, we) T/F
9. has no form or structure T/F
10. The introduction gives detailed information. T/F
11. The introduction has the main ideas of the essay T/F
12. The Body of the essay expresses your opinions. T/F
13. The conclusion has three main parts. T/F
14. The last paragraph should have a summary. T/F
15. The concluding statement is your opinion. T/F
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 8
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Review Answers- True or False
An academic essay:
1. expresses how you feel. F
2. shows how you understood the course T
3. demonstrates the extent of your research T
4. uses language just like talking to someone F
5. uses colloquial language F
6. is accurate and scientific T
7. is like a letter you would write to your mother F
8. uses personal pronouns (I, you, we) F
9. has no form or structure F
10. The introduction gives detailed information. F
11. The introduction tells the main ideas of the essay T
12. The Body of the essay expresses your opinions. F
13. The conclusion has three main parts. F
14. The last paragraph should have a summary. T
15. The concluding statement is your opinion. T
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 9
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Fields of Influence: Diagram
The Onion Analogy
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 10
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
The Onion Analogy
The diagram on the previous page illustrates the way in which the
parts of an academic essay go together a bit like the layers of an
onion.
Peeling the Onion=Writing the Essay Structure
The layers of an onion represent how each set of ideas is contained
within another set of ideas. This helps us understand the structures of
an academic essay.
The Introduction as the Outer Layers of the Onion
The Opening Statement talks about what will be said in the whole
essay. In a sense, so does the Concluding Statement. Thus, they both
enclose the whole essay: the outer skin.
Next comes the Definition or Definitions (you probably need more than
one). This is NOT a dictionary definition, rather it is your definition-
the meaning you will use throughout the essay.
The Outline or Scope tells the reader what will happen in the Body. It
is a bit like a list of contents. It does not talk about the Conclusion. It
only tells us the main ideas that will be looked at in the body of the
essay.
The Body Text as the Centre of the Onion
The Body Text is where the detailed ideas of the essay are expressed.
This is where the arguments are presented and where the references
are used. There should be at least three paragraphs in the body text.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 11
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
The Conclusion- Back to the Outer Layers of the Onion
The Summary is just like the Outline or Scope. It tells the reader what
has been said in the body text. By reading the summary the reader
gets a clear sense of the main ideas of the body text and how they
have been developed.
The concluding statement wraps up the whole essay, giving the reader
a clear sense of what has been said by the body text arguments.
The concluding statement is like the opening statement because they
both enclose the whole essay; they both refer to what the whole essay
is saying.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 12
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Review Questions- True or False
1. The opening statement encompasses the whole essay. T/F
2. The definition must come from a dictionary. T/F
3. You should use a dictionary to understand key words. T/F
4. The body text should have at least three paragraphs. T/F
5. The summary is totally different from the scope. T/F
6. The summary is like a list. T/F
7. The concluding statement refers to the whole essay. T/F
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 13
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Review Answers- True or False
1. The opening statement encompasses the whole essay. T
2. The definition must come from a dictionary. F
3. You should use a dictionary to understand key words. T
4. The body text should have at least three paragraphs. T
5. The summary is totally different from the scope. F
6. The summary is like a list. T
7. The concluding statement refers to the whole essay. T
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 14
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Essay Features: The Basic Concepts
Introduction
Opening Statement: gives the reader an idea of the subject area. In
a sense, the opening statement answers the question, in general
terms, and informs the reader of your approach to the topic.
The Opening Statement gives the reader information necessary to
understand how you will answer the question and how you will
approach the topic.
There are three genres (types) of essay, and each one requires a
different kind of opening statement.
Each essay genre operates in a particular way. In the explanation
essay the writer tells us how something operates or why it is as it is.
In the argument essay the writer presents a point of view and argues
for that idea. In the discussion essay, the writer presents differing
points of view on an issue, looks at how they relate to each other and
develops a judgement.
Explain: a general background statement that names and shows the
importance of the topic. For example,
Pollution has become a cause for serious concern in developing countries
only towards the end of the 20th century, as the damage from industrial
wastes began to threaten the health of the general population.
Argue: a position statement that tells the reader whether you will be
arguing in favour of or against the proposition. For example,
It is the thesis of this essay that political corruption is the main cause of
pollution in the modern world.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 15
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
OR
While environmentalists often assert that industrialization is the main
cause of pollution, it is the thesis of this essay that political corruption has
been the main contributor to the degradation of our ecosystem.
Discuss: a statement of issue provides the reader with an
understanding of the two sides of the discussion (issue) that will be
explored. For example,
While environmentalists often assert that industrialization is the main
cause of pollution, political corruption must also be considered as a major
contributor to the degradation of our ecosystem.
Definition: shows how you understand the topic, how you will
approach it and how you will limit its boundaries. This is not according
to a dictionary but rather your definition, and how you will use the
terms in your essay. You should define all the key terms of the
question that might be vague or confusing. For example,
For the purpose of this essay, pollution will refer to the physical process
whereby the natural and urban environment is degraded by human activity.
Now you will note that I used ‘human activity’, but I could just as
easily have written ‘industrial activity’ – meaning that I would
concentrate on industrial pollution. It all depends on what the essay
will focus on and how you will use the terms.
It might also depend on your references. If they use a particular
concept, you have to make sure that you are thinking along the same
lines. If your reference says ‘children’ means people under 18 years of
age, then your definition has to take this into account. In other words,
your definition must fit with the way the expression is used in your
essay. (Please note that normally it might be more appropriate to
define children as under 12 years of age.)
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 16
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Scope/Outline: tells what specific areas you will talk about in the
body text. For example,
This essay will investigate the main causes of pollution which are
industrial development, political corruption and individual disinterest.
Thus, the scope introduces the body text, telling us that there will be
three main issues. These three main issues would each have one
paragraph, at least, in the body of the essay.
Each of these ideas needs to be in the same order as that used in the
body text which is why it is very important to plan your essay carefully
in an exam (due to lack of time).
It is also why, when attempting a long essay, the introduction is often
written last, after all the other elements have been decided.
Body Text
This must have at least three paragraphs which provide detailed
information about the topic. Each one will have a topic sentence
followed by elaboration (detail). For example,
Industrial development has caused the single greatest change in the
planetary sphere. Beginning with the cities of England in the 17th century
(Smith 1999, p. 12), the process of industrialization and its accompanying
urbanization, led to the development of highly polluted cities, land, air and
waterways. As the process spread across the Western world, the overall
degradation of the environment soon followed (Smith 1999, p. 14). Only in
the latter quarter of the 20th century did pollution controls begin in the
West, by which time most industrial activity had been moved to Asia and
the developing world, thus spreading the impact of industrial development
and its accompanying pollution across the entire world.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 17
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Here you will see that the first sentence tells us the topic (industrial
development) and gives us a sense of what will happen in the
paragraph (planetary sphere, meaning “all around the world”). Thus
we call this the topic sentence. After that, the idea is explained, with
references [(Smith 1999, p. 12 ])] which tell us where the facts come
from.
Conclusion
Summary: tells the reader what you have said and reminds the
reader of what happened in the body text. For example,
In conclusion, this essay has investigated the main causes of pollution;
industrial development, political corruption and individual disinterest.
OR
In conclusion, this essay has outlined the main contributors to the problem
of pollution; how industrial development leads to pollution where there is
no government control, how corruption often means that government
control does not work and finally, how the disinterest of the general
populace allows this situation to continue.
In a short essay, the summary might be a set of noun groups whereas
in a longer essay, it might be a sequence of sentences that explain the
main conclusions of the body paragraphs.
Note that the order of the points must be the same throughout the
essay: in the outline/scope, in the body text and in the summary.
Concluding Statement: finishes off the essay by referring to the
main idea of the whole text.
Explanation Essay: In the case of an explanation essay, this is called
the Statement of Relative Importance (SORI) which tells us that
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 18
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
one of the main points of the essay is the most significant. For
example,
Of these three, the disinterest of the general public is the most important
because, if the community was to express its concerns strongly, then
corrupt and uncaring practices would cease.
The concluding statement is your opinion, but not expressed in a
personal manner. In other words, you can’t write: “So I think it is a
good idea to pollute the environment.” Rather it needs to be
expressed as the logical result of your argument. For example, you
could write: “From the above factors, it can be clearly seen that in the
long term pollution poses a threat to all life on earth and so, it is only
logical that it should be controlled as soon as possible.” This way you
have stated your opinion, but you have done so in an academic and
logical manner.
By the way, each essay type needs a different kind of concluding
statement.
Argument Essay: This type ends with a restatement of the
position- the idea that started the essay. For example,
From the preceding argument it can be clearly seen that political
corruption is the main cause of pollution in the modern world.
Discussion Essay: This type ends with a judgement, where the two
sides of the issue are finally resolved and one side of the argument is
chosen. For example,
From the above arguments, though it can be seen that industrialization is a
source of pollution, it is corruption that actually creates the conditions for
pollution to occur and persist.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 19
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Review Questions
1. Matching Exercise- Put the three elements in correct order.
Genre Name Features
Explain position statement shows importance
Argue background statement balanced ideas
Discuss statement of issue your side of argument
True or False
2. Essay definitions are quotes from dictionaries. T/F
3. You should define every word in the question. T/F
4. You should define each important noun group
that appears in the essay question. T/F
5. The order of the scope doesn’t matter. T/F
6. The scope can be a bit like a list. T/F
7. Each paragraph of the body starts with
detailed information and references. T/F
8. The summary tell us what you said in the body. T/F
9. There is only one kind of concluding statement. T/F
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 20
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Review Answers
1. Matching Exercise- Put the three elements in correct order.
Genre Name Features
Explain background statement shows importance
Argue position statement your side of argument
Discuss statement of issue balanced ideas
True or False
2. Essay definitions are quotes from dictionaries. F
3. You should define every word in the question. F
4. You should define each important noun group
that appears in the essay question. T
5. The order of the scope doesn’t matter. F
6. The scope can be a bit like a list. T
7. Each paragraph of the body starts with
detailed information and references. F
8. The summary tell us what you said in the body. T
9. There is only one kind of concluding statement. F
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 21
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Essay Features: In Detail
Now let’s look at the different elements in detail.
These will be considered with the three essay genres in mind, which
are
1. Explanation: to explain how something works or how it is
composed
2. Argument: to logically argue for one point of view against other
ideas, from the beginning of the essay
3. Discussion: to present the various sides of an issue in a
balanced way and then logically decide which side is correct.
Introduction
Don’t forget: the introduction should be one paragraph ONLY!
Opening Statement
The opening statement immediately indicates to the reader the genre
(type) of essay you are writing, why your topic is important and how
you intend to approach it.
So, of course, it must relate to the essay question or the essay might
be marked down as irrelevant- not about the topic at hand. It is
therefore very important to analyse the question carefully so you
understand it before you begin to write.
The opening statement is a general answer to the essay question. In
fact, it must answer the question or the essay might be marked down
for being irrelevant.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 22
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
This is very important; understand the question. Analyse it very
carefully.
There are three different kinds of opening statements; background,
position statement and statement of issue.
Background Statement- Explanation Essay
This gives the reader a sense of the history or the context of the
subject.
“For the last ten years media reports have sensationalised violent crimes,
increasing their presence in the media and creating a false sense of
insecurity in the general population.”
Position Statement- Argument Essay
This clearly states that the writer will be arguing one side of the
argument. This is the argument that will be the theme of the whole
essay.
“Increased media coverage has given the impression that violent crimes
are on the increase while, in fact, the actual number of crimes has been
decreasing for some time.”
Statement of Issue- Discussion Essay
This presents both sides of the argument that will be explored in the
essay. The two sides are presented in a balanced manner; neither of
them seems to be more right or wrong at the beginning of the essay.
“While there have been strong claims from the media to ‘clamp down’ on
violent crimes, official reports suggest that these crimes have actually been
decreasing over the last ten years.”
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 23
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Definition – Interpreting the Question
This tells the reader how you interpret the key (important) elements of
the question. If the question was:
“How has the media created a false sense of violent crime in modern
culture?”
then you would define ‘media’, ‘violent crime’ and ‘modern culture’.
Why? Because these are all elements of the question and are as, as we
say, ‘open to interpretation’.
In other words, there are a lot of different ways that they can be
understood and you need to demonstrate how you understand them
and how you will be using them in your essay.
As a general rule do not divide up noun groups when you define them.
For example, for ‘violent crime’- define the idea of that kind of crime,
not ‘violence’ and then ‘crime’ because that is not the point of the
question. Complex noun groups are one idea and should be treated
that way.
Can you use a dictionary at any time for your definitions? Yes. In fact,
you should always go to an English dictionary to make sure that you
understand the terms being used. After that you need to develop a
way of expressing those concepts so that they suit your essay.
Another rule is this: definitions must not be circular. In other words,
you can’t use the word you are explaining to explain itself. For
example, you can’t say:
Violent crime is a crime where people get hurt.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 24
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
This means ‘crime=crime’ and tells us nothing new. It doesn’t explain
what crime is. Your reader might think that ‘crime’ is the same as
‘accident’ because people can get hurt in an accident as well.
Instead you would need to use a different approach, for example:
For the purpose of this essay, violent crime will refer to intentional acts
that inflict bodily harm and attract the attention of the authorities because
they are against the law.
Note how the words ‘violent crime’ don’t appear in the second half of
the definition. Also note the use of ‘for the purpose of this essay’. This
phrase allows you to focus the meaning of your definition more clearly
and tells the reader how your essay will focus the meaning.
In this case, the distinction is that, in this essay, ‘violent crime’ will
ONLY refer to occasions when the police or other government
authorities are aware of it. Therefore, undetected crimes will not be a
part of the following essay.
You should also note how to make sure that the assessor knows that
you are giving a definition. You will see some essays that use the verb
‘to be’ for their definitions, for example,
Violent crime is the result of social problems, often beginning in early
childhood, that develop into forms of behaviour that are so extreme they
lead to the imprisonment of the perpetrator.
Now that is quite OK, but it could easily be confused with part of the
opening statement. You don’t want that, as the assessor is looking to
see if you are following the structure required.
There are two easy ways to make sure that the assessor knows what
you intend; use the words ‘define as’ or ‘refer to’ (they have a very
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 25
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
similar meaning), and so you will clearly indicate what you are doing,
for example,
For the purpose of this essay, violent crime will be defined as those forms
of behaviour, involving physical harm to others, that can lead to the
imprisonment or execution of the perpetrator.
NB: ‘will be defined as’ could be replaced with ‘will refer to’
You might notice the format ‘for the purpose of this essay’ – that’s
important as it clearly indicates that this is the concept you will be
using later in your text. It is thus your definition- not something you
just picked up from a dictionary.
You might also notice the use of the future tense (will). You will see
essays that use the present simple rather than the future tense. In
doing that, they give a sense of the essay being a presence rather
than a journey. This is one of the things that’s up to you. What do you
feel best conveys the experience of your essay?
When in doubt, use the future tense; it just makes it clearer and
easier to distinguish from the rest of the introduction.
Scope or Outline – Itemising the Body Text
This essay will consider four important causes of pollution; human
disinterest, the personalization of transport, the profit motive in
industrialization and the psychological castration of the patriarchal
hegemony.
This is a scope/outline. It tells us about the main action of the body
text.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 26
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Again, you will see this in the present tense (it considers) rather than
the future (will consider) and again, using the future tense clearly
indicates to the reader that this is the scope.
The scope can use a variety of verbs, all of which have a similar
meaning (eg. explore, consider, investigate). They all suggest that this
will be an exploration of a concept or area of knowledge.
It is perfectly acceptable to use the expressions of the scope list in the
topic sentences of your body paragraphs.
The scope should also tell us how many body paragraphs there will
be:
This essay will consider four important causes of pollution; (A) human
disinterest, (B) the personalization of transport, (C) the profit motive in
industrialization and (D) the psychological castration of the patriarchal
hegemony.
Thus this essay would have at least four paragraphs in the body text.
(One more than is required.)
The scope also tells us the order of the text; if you order the scope
ABCD, then your body text AND summary should all follow the same
order.
Body Text
The body text should have at least three paragraphs for a short essay.
For a long essay, it could have several more (see below).
Staging Devices- Announcing Logical Relationships
There is a whole section of the textbook about this but basically this
includes the idea of simple and complex staging devices.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 27
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Simple devices include simple words: however, conversely,
furthermore, on the other hand. They could also be more complex, for
example the second paragraph of the body text for the scope above
could be:
While human disinterest is a major contributor to pollution, greed in the
form of (B) the personalization of transport has probably caused even
more damage.
A Topic Sentence
The topic sentence introduces the main idea of the paragraph and how
it will be approached.
While human disinterest is a major contributor to pollution, greed in the
form of (B) the privatisation of transport has probably caused even more
damage.
In the above example, the topic is ‘the privatisation of transport’.
Elaboration
The elaboration is where the detailed argument is developed. It uses
examples, reasoning, research and evidence.
The use of private transport is fundamentally synonymous with the idea of
one person per vehicle (Smith 1994, 276). More than 80% of all private
transport is composed of a sedan car carrying one person to and from work
(Jones 2001, 34). As a result this mode of transport is extremely inefficient
and contributes a large proportion of urban pollution. According to Jones,
removing this form of transport would reduce urban pollution by as much
as 70% (2001, 43). Thus, it is clearly evident that limiting or banning
personal transport would make a major contribution to solving the
pollution problem.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 28
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Each fact in the elaboration should be supported by a reference or the
development of your argument. This is where we get to understand
why you think something and how it works in detail.
Closure
This is a concluding sentence that sums up the work of the paragraph.
Thus it is clearly evident that limiting or banning personal transport would
make a major contribution to solving the pollution problem.
It takes the reader back to what you were trying to explain or prove
and allows them to clearly understand what you have done.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 29
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Frequently Asked Questions
How many paragraphs should I have in my body text?
For a short essay, you should have one paragraph for each point in
your scope: as a rule of thumb, from a minimum of three to a
maximum of four.
For a long essay, you might have six to ten paragraphs in your body
text and yet only three to four points in your scope. This is because
you can elaborate an idea through more than one paragraph. This is
done by dividing the idea into subsections and announcing that it is
part of the same concept, for example,
Topic sentence, body paragraph two (B)
While human disinterest is a major contributor to pollution, greed in the
form of (B) the personalization of transport has probably caused even
more damage.
Topic sentence, body paragraph three (B)
Another aspect of the personalization of transport that has caused
considerable damage is the effect of the built infrastructure. This is seen in
the many millions of square miles of roads that network across the planet,
covering native habitat, rendering hundreds of species extinct and
increasing land prices in the urban areas, thus forcing the extension of
settlement and even further environmental destruction.
What is the best order for my ideas?
In general, in academic writing, it is best to keep the most important
aspect and the strongest argument till the end of the body text.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 30
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
This way your presentation will get stronger as it reaches the end and
leaves the reader with a strong impression of your most important
point.
How many points should I have in my body text?
For a short essay, in an exam or for homework, the minimum is three
and the maximum four. Beyond that it is just too messy.
Even for a long essay, limiting the areas of consideration to four key
areas is not a bad idea.
How come people with good English write bad essays?
Essay writing for university isn’t just about being able to write in
English, rather it is about being able to express ideas logically and
within a clear structure. So the absence of logic and structure can lead
to quite bad results.
Is grammar important?
Yes it is because grammar is the key to clear expression. However, if
the essay can be understood and the errors are quite minor, it is still
possible to get a good result.
Is spelling important?
Again, spelling is essential to clear expression but if the errors are
minor and the message is still clear, then minor mistakes will not get
in the way of a good result.
Is structure important?
Structure is very important; in most assessment writing and speaking
tasks it can affect your grade by as much as 30%.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 31
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
It is also important because managing structure indicates your ability
to organize information and present your ideas in a logical manner.
This is essential to your future success at university.
Do I need to use big words?
Academic English means using language that is clear and concise. That
often means that the words are longer and their meanings are more
complex. However, using a simple expression for a simple idea is
perfectly acceptable, so long as it is not colloquial (spoken style)
language.
Do I need to write long sentences?
In a word, No! While you will see some very long sentences in
academic literature, you are not expected to do that. If you can make
long sentences that are easy to understand, that’s fine. The problem is
that many people think that just throwing together a bunch of big
words will be good enough. It isn’t.
When in doubt always write as clearly as you can. If that means your
sentences are shorter, it doesn’t matter so long as the meaning is
clear.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 32
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
How big should a paragraph be?
There is no clear answer to this question. In simple terms it might look
like this, for example
Topic sentence
Elaboration
Reference
Explanation of reference
Closure
That’s five sentences for your basic paragraph.
Just keep in mind that if you feel the idea is being lost, you can divide
a topic area into more than one paragraph and link them with a
staging device that clearly tells the reader that it is the same topic.
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 33
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Review Questions- True or False
1. Your introduction can be two paragraphs. T/F
2. The background statement argues one side. T/F
3. The position statement says how you will argue. T/F
4. The statement of issue tells the subject history. T/F
5. The background statement tells the importance and
history of the subject in an explanation essay. T/F
6. An argument essay aims to prove one side of an
argument. T/F
7. A discussion essay tries to present both sides of an
argument, with a resolution at the end (judgement). T/F
8. You should always use a dictionary when developing your
ideas for your definition. T/F
9. Your definition should only come from a dictionary. T/F
10. This definition is circular: For the purpose of this essay,
crime will be defined as a kind of crime that is detected by
the police. T/F
11. You can use the future tense (will) for your definition. T/F
12. Your scope can be several sentences. T/F
13. You cannot use the future tense (will) for your scope. T/F
14. The scope does not tell us the order of the ideas in the
body of the essay. T/F
15. A topic sentence tells the reader the main idea of the
paragraph in general terms. T/F
16. The relationship between the scope and the topic
sentence is not important. T/F
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 34
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
17. Elaboration is where you present your facts, references
and the logic of your argument. T/F
18. I should use my strongest argument first, before I forget
what it is. T/F
19. Structure is very important in an academic essay. T/F
20. I must use big words and long sentences in my essay,
even if they are meaningless nonsense that even I don’t
understand. T/F
21. It is always better to be clear and concise, rather than
just throwing words together carelessly. T/F
22. Teachers will give me more marks for big words. T/F
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 35
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
Review Answers- True or False
1. Your introduction can be two paragraphs. F
2. The background statement argues one side. F
3. The position statement says how you will argue. T
4. The statement of issue tells the subject history. F
5. The background statement tells the importance and
history of the subject in an explanation essay. T
6. An argument essay aims to prove one side of an
argument. T
7. A discussion essay tries to present both sides of an
argument, with a resolution at the end (judgement). T
8. You should always use a dictionary when developing your
ideas for your definition. T
9. Your definition should only come from a dictionary. F
10. This definition is circular: For the purpose of this essay,
crime will be defined as a kind of crime that is detected by
the police. T
11. You can use the future tense (will) for your definition. T
12. Your scope can be several sentences. T
13. You cannot use the future tense (will) for your scope. F
14. The scope does not tell us the order of the ideas in the
body of the essay. F
15. A topic sentence tells the reader the main idea of the
paragraph in general terms. T
16. The relationship between the scope and the topic
sentence is not important. F
RWR #0: Understanding the Essay Format Page 36
Copyright Reno Dal © Created on 15/01/04 11:16 PM
17. Elaboration is where you present your facts, references
and the logic of your argument. T
18. I should use my strongest argument first, before I forget
what it is. F
19. Structure is very important in an academic essay. T
20. I must use big words and long sentences in my essay,
even if they are meaningless nonsense that even I don’t
understand. F
21. It is always better to be clear and concise, rather than
just throwing words together carelessly. T
22. Teachers will give me more marks for big words. F