Resolution Votes Votes Votes Votes (In favour) For ...Nov 01, 2013 · foundation connector & pods for 3 CETO units. Perth Wave Energy Project –2014 • Q3, 2014 onwards o Power

© Copyright Carnegie Wave Energy Limited 2013 1

Proxy Vote Analysis – Annual General Meeting 1 Nov 2013

For Against Discretionary Chairman Abstain

Resolution Votes Votes Votes Votes

(In favour)

Votes

1. Remuneration Report111,736,567

13,944,695 16,364,446 76,922,191 139,829,510

2. Re-election of Grant Mooney as a Director 238,487,651 15,200,712 93,338,496 - 11,770,550

3. Election of Mike Fitzpatrick as a Director 127,303,175 11,311,629 93,338,496 - 126,844,109

4. Approval of 10% Placement Facility 232,987,718 20,742,768 93,338,496 - 11,728,427

5. Ratification of Previous Share & Option Issue 244,851,326 9,523,842 93,338,496 - 11,083,745

6. Issue of Shares to Dr Michael Ottaviano 222,626,837 34,440,376 93,198,496 - 8,531,700

7. Issue of Options to Grant Mooney 214,277,796 42,409,266 19,193,955 77,569,191 5,347,201

8. Issue of Options to Kieran O’Brien 219,685,447 38,335,266 96,867,546 - 3,909,150

9. Issue of Options to Jeff Harding 221,036,804 35,683,909 96,867,546 - 5,209,150

10. Issue of Options of John Leggate 220,186,804 36,533,909 96,867,546 - 5,209,150

11. Issue of Options to Mike Fitzpatrick 105,975,195 38,283,909 96,867,546 - 117,670,759

12. Approval of Employee Share & Option Plan 230,827,095 27,914,518 97,007,546 - 3,048,250

For

per

sona

l use

onl

y


Shareholder Update

1 November 2013

Dr Michael Ottaviano

Chief Executive Officer &Managing Director

For

per

sona

l use

onl

y


• Bathrooms located to your left as you come up the stairs

• Refreshments are provided to your right

• This is a non smoking site.

HSE InformationF

or p

erso

nal u

se o

nly


The information contained herein has been prepared solely for informational purposes and is not an

offer to buy or sell or a solicitation of any offer to buy or sell any security or to participate in any

trading strategy or to enter into any transaction. If any offer of securities is made, it shall be made

pursuant to a definitive offering memorandum prepared by or on behalf of any fund or other issuer

which would contain material information not contained herein and which would supersede this

information in its entirety.

DisclaimerF

or p

erso

nal u

se o

nly


Carnegie Snapshot

• Owner and developer of “CETO” wave energy technology

• 26 engineering, commercial, administration staff

• ASX listed, based in Fremantle, Western Australia

• 100+ Patents or patents pending globally

• $70m spent to date on CETO

• EDF EN is a CETO licensee

• Current financials

o $11.7m cash (as at 30/9/2013)

o $15.5m undrawn grants (as at 30/9/2013)

1 year shareprice snapshot

For

per

sona

l use

onl

y


Carnegie Board of Directors

(L-R: Kieran O’Brien, Mike Fitzpatrick, John Leggate, Jeffrey Harding, Michael

Ottaviano, Grant Mooney)

For

per

sona

l use

onl

y


Global wave resource > current global power use

• Market is global, large and co-located with demand centres

• Resource is more predictable, consistent and available than wind or solar

For

per

sona

l use

onl

y


Recent Strategic Transactions Examples

• Tidal Energy - Valuation $250m

− Source: DCNS takeover of Open Hydro tidal, (Q1 2013)

• Tidal Energy – Valuation $200m

− Source: $10 million raised from Morgan Stanley & Asian high net worth

individuals for 5% share, Q1 2011, (subsequent raise Q2 2011)

• Tidal Energy – Valuation (undisclosed)

− Source: Siemens takeover of MCT (Q1 2012)

• Tidal Energy – Valuation (undisclosed)

− Source: Alstom acquisition of TGL tidal from Rolls Royce, (Q2 2009)

• Wave Energy – Valuation (undisclosed)

− Source: Alstom acquisition of 40% equity stake (Q2 2011)

• Wave Energy – Valuation $90m

− Source: $13 million raised from ABB for 14% share, (Q4 2010)

For

per

sona

l use

onl

y


CETO Technology

• Fully submerged, point absorber

• Near-shore location or deepwater location

• Onshore or offshore power & water production

• Modular design largely using proven subsea components

For

per

sona

l use

onl

y


CETO 1 prototype

• Proof of Concept

• Fremantle

CETO 3 prototype

• 80kW unit

• Garden Island

CETO 2 prototype

• 3 x 1kW units pilot

• Fremantle

Concept Development

• Scale models and

wave tank testing.

<2004 2011- 20142004-2006 2006-2008 2010-20132009-2011

Technology Development Road Map

CETO 4 (independent test)

• 150kW unit.

• EDF on Reunion Island

Independent testing

• Wave tank test

• EDF & DCNS unit

CETO 5 (Plant demonstration)

• 240kW units, grid connected array project.

• Power & water production

• Garden Island, WA

2014-2016

CETO 6

• Design & location

tbd

For

per

sona

l use

onl

y


Track record of ocean testing - CETO 3 ProjectF

or p

erso

nal u

se o

nly


CETO 5 Unit DesignF

or p

erso

nal u

se o

nly


• World first multiple wave unit array

• 3 x 240kW CETO 5 units

• 100NB, 3000psi flexible pipeline 3.2km ashore

• Onshore power plant and grid connection

• Onshore reverse osmosis desalination pilot plant

• Design, approvals, off-take, funding complete

Perth Wave Energy ProjectF

or p

erso

nal u

se o

nly


Perth Wave Energy Project - Desalination

• Integrates off-the-shelf reverse osmosis desalination technology with

the CETO infrastructure.

• The Perth Project will be the first wave project to produce clean power

and fresh water anywhere in the world.

• Cooperation agreement with Western Australian Government owned

Water Corporation

“Carnegie’s wave powered seawater desalination technology offers

a novel and promising approach to achieving desalinated

freshwater with zero greenhouse gas emissions”

Sue Murphy, CEO, Water Corporation

For

per

sona

l use

onl

y


Perth Wave Energy Project – Support

• $13.1m Australian Government grant funding for power generation

• $7.3m Western Australian State Government funding

• $1.25m Australian Government grant funding for desalinated water production

• Cooperation agreement with the WA Government water utility, Water Corporation

• Offtake with the Australian Department of Defence (HMAS Stirling)

For

per

sona

l use

onl

y


• Component manufacturing underway

• Onshore construction activities commenced

• First offshore activities is installation of foundations

in Q4, 2013

Perth Wave Energy Project – StatusF

or p

erso

nal u

se o

nly


• Q1, 2014 activities:

o Pipe installation

o Delivery of CETO unit components – buoys, pumps, tether, pump to

foundation connector & pods for 3 CETO units.

Perth Wave Energy Project – 2014

• Q3, 2014 onwards

o Power generation & revenue

o Water generation & revenue

o Data collection and analysis

o Model and design validation

• Q2, 2014 activities:

o Onshore power plant construction

o Onshore desalination plant construction

o Unit 1 installation and commissioning

o Units 2 & 3 installation and commissioning

For

per

sona

l use

onl

y


Technology Development – Buoy size vs. Power Output

18

-

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

An

nu

al

Un

it O

utp

ut

(GW

h/Y

ea

r)

Buoyant Actuator "BA" Diameter (m)

CETO 5 (240kW rated capacity)

For

per

sona

l use

onl

y


CETO 6 – Next Generation Design

• At least 2 x rated capacity versus CETO 5

• Locations: either EU/UK, Australia or Island nation

• Onshore or offshore power generation options,

subject to site characterisation.

• Design, location and funding to be finalised during

2014

• Collaboration partners to be finalised during 2014

• Commissioning in 2016

For

per

sona

l use

onl

y


Priority Markets - Snapshot

Australia

US & Canada

Japan

UK

Remote Islands

Chile

Ireland

France

For

per

sona

l use

onl

y


Upcoming Milestones

• 2011/12:

Single unit test (CETO 3) at project site

$22m in Government grants secured

Power offtake with Dept of Defence

• 2013:

Detailed Design of Perth power project

Environmental & planning approvals

Start procurement & construction of Perth project

• 2014:

• Power and water production from Perth project

• Finalise CETO 6 project design and funding

• 2015/16:

• Construct & commission CETO 6 projectFor

per

sona

l use

onl

y

Documents

Resolution Votes Votes Votes Votes (In favour) For ...Nov 01, 2013 · foundation connector & pods for 3 CETO units. Perth Wave Energy Project –2014 • Q3, 2014 onwards o Power