Upload
joseph-martin
View
17
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Sierra 1
Cristina Sierra
ENC 3331
Professor Wright
19 April 2015
Rhetorical Analysis of Civic Issue
Panhandling has been a continuous problem occurring across the country for quite a while.
Panhandlers have proven to be faking their identity of homelessness and having a loss of income
a good amount of the time. There have been many reported stories and statistics of panhandlers
being followed and reported as realistically “more fortunate” then stated on their cut out piece of
cardboard that’s stated, “Homeless, hungry, anything helps.” Reassuring the community of how
untruthful panhandlers are and how the community responds to this issue is what I planned for
this project. As I stood and watched bystanders sitting in their cars bring their window down and
pull out a buck or two, then stuck it out the window, waving it to the so called “poor homeless
man” I was left to understand most people do believe that these frauds are really what they say
they are, homeless and in need of money.
I started to gather feedback from the community on how they felt about panhandlers and if
they supported them or not. Many people agreed that if they participated in giving panhandlers
anything it would be food or water, very few said they gave money. If they did give money it
would just be some loose change or a buck or two. The reason’s they participated in helping
panhandlers was because they “looked” like they were truly in need and they felt sorry for them.
As I informed them of how often panhandlers turn out to be frauds they were more surprised
Sierra 2
than anything based off of the expression on their face. They stated “They just always seem to be
dressed so ragged and look so hungry and sad.” As I informed them they ended their discussion
with me stating that in future occurrence’s they plan to think twice before supporting a
panhandler and if they do help one out it will be with applications for jobs or food from the
dollar menu, never money.
I have not only learned a lot about this civic issue from gathering research online, but I have
started to accomplish what I had wanted and that was to inform the community of this ongoing
civic issue with panhandlers and for the community to have a change of heart for the issue and to
not be so naïve all the time. Not all panhandlers are true to being honest and you honestly never
know who is truly “homeless” and in need of money or not. The best good dead you can do in a
situation like this is to help them with what they really need help with; getting a job and earning
a legal income that files for taxes.
In just September of 2014 Seminole County wrote a newsletter on how they are starting to
crack down on aggressive panhandlers. They noted that panhandlers “are serving as a threat to
public safety” (Comas). Panhandlers have become more aggressive in such manners, as blocking
pedestrians from walking when asking for money, by physically touching someone and
“stalking” them to consistently harass them for money. Sanford police had stated that there has
been a large increase in panhandlers living and hanging around the downtown area and it’s no
longer just a nuisance anymore, it has evolved into a bigger problem. There have also been
notices of panhandlers urinating on walls and in alleys of the downtown area of Sanford.
Panhandlers have given a terrible message for those that are just homeless and minding their own
business on the streets; panhandlers have been verbally and physically abusive and it has to be
put to a stop.
Sierra 3
Based on the rhetorical audience of my project I have noticed that almost every person I
interviewed that participated in helping panhandlers in our community were capable of being
influenced by discourse in mediators of change. They all pretty much stated that they weren’t
aware of the issues that panhandlers have been involved in and you can’t always trust them even
when you feel sympathy for what it seems when looking at them, because it isn’t always what it
seems. Based on the community being closer to UCF, students felt more sympathy being able to
relate to not being as fortunate, living on a college budget; when comparing to a panhandler
he/she is also struggling day in and day out, so they just wanted to give a hand and help out. But
the community closer to the downtown Orlando area was more business clientele and they were
more aware of the issue with panhandlers so they were found to be less supportive of
panhandlers and already influenced by discourse in mediators of change, based on the news and
research they’ve heard about panhandlers.
Sierra 4
Works Cited
Comas, Martin E. "Sanford to Panhandlers: Mind Your Manners or Else." OrlandoSentinel.com.
Orlando Sentinel, 2 Sept. 2014. Web. 19 Apr. 2015.