RING – European final Meeting “What if tomorrow”? University Transilvania of BraşovUniversity Transilvania of Braşov Where we are?Where we are? What it

RRING – European final MeetingING – European final Meeting “What if tomorrow”? “What if tomorrow”?

• University Transilvania of BraşovUniversity Transilvania of Braşov

• Where we are?Where we are?

• What it will be?What it will be?


• Current situation on the world:Current situation on the world:– Alzheimer and dementia Alzheimer and dementia

• become one of the great problemsbecome one of the great problems in the next year in the next year– At the worldwide at the end of last year At the worldwide at the end of last year

• 30 million people affected by Alzheimer’s 30 million people affected by Alzheimer’s • ththee number is expected to grow. number is expected to grow.

– Everyone Everyone • is exposed to the risk of developing Alzheimer’s in old is exposed to the risk of developing Alzheimer’s in old

age, age, • but there is a risk if there were similar cases in the but there is a risk if there were similar cases in the

family.family.


• Current situation in RomaniaCurrent situation in Romania– Number:Number:

• 300,000 Alzheimer’s disease patients 300,000 Alzheimer’s disease patients • their number is growing around 600.000 in Romania their number is growing around 600.000 in Romania

(WHO). (WHO). – responsibility for them responsibility for them

• Most times the family, Most times the family, • special homes are not enough and extremely expensive.special homes are not enough and extremely expensive.

– Consequences of the increasing prevalence of dementia :Consequences of the increasing prevalence of dementia :• Need more competent personNeed more competent person• issues of competence are fundamental to informed consent issues of competence are fundamental to informed consent

in research and the care of demented people. in research and the care of demented people. • society is equally interested in maintaining the autonomy society is equally interested in maintaining the autonomy

and well-being of its aging citizens as well as protecting and well-being of its aging citizens as well as protecting them from risks and dangers caused by their declining them from risks and dangers caused by their declining capacities.capacities.


• NGO involved in AlzheimerNGO involved in Alzheimer– At the national levelAt the national level:: Romanian Alzheimer Society (1992),Romanian Alzheimer Society (1992),

• member of member of – organization Alzheimer disease International and organization Alzheimer disease International and – Help Age International Network for Eastern Europe Help Age International Network for Eastern Europe

and Central.and Central.– Day care centresDay care centres

• in Timişoarain Timişoara• Piatra Neamţ. Piatra Neamţ.

– telephone consultations.telephone consultations.– Hospice BraşovHospice Braşov


• NGO involved in AlzheimerNGO involved in Alzheimer– Romanian Alzheimer Society Romanian Alzheimer Society has six branches in thehas six branches in the

country Main branches are in:country Main branches are in:• BucharestBucharest• Piatra NeamţPiatra Neamţ• TimişoaraTimişoara• BraşovBraşov• ClujCluj• ConstanţaConstanţa

– The main activities develop are:The main activities develop are:• Establishing a relation with local authoritiesEstablishing a relation with local authorities• Day centerDay center• Developing the program for educate the people who take Developing the program for educate the people who take

care the patient with dementiacare the patient with dementia• Community Information CenterCommunity Information Center

RRING – European final MeetingING – European final Meeting “What if tomorrow”? “What if tomorrow”? • 3. Romanian legislation3. Romanian legislation

– Romania’s legislation is in keeping with principles set out by Romania’s legislation is in keeping with principles set out by the WHO and international legislation concerning the the WHO and international legislation concerning the protection of people with mental illnesses.protection of people with mental illnesses.

– The most important principles derived from these documents The most important principles derived from these documents are: are:

• respecting the human dignity, respecting the human dignity, • recognizing equal civil rights with the others persons,recognizing equal civil rights with the others persons,• warranting the medical care and treatment and the social, warranting the medical care and treatment and the social,

professional and familial rehabilitation. professional and familial rehabilitation.


• 3. Romanian legislation3. Romanian legislation– The legal rights, financial and other personal interests of The legal rights, financial and other personal interests of

patients with mental disorders must be protected. patients with mental disorders must be protected. – According to the Madrid Declaration art.4, According to the Madrid Declaration art.4,

• the psychiatrist should discuss with the family and, the psychiatrist should discuss with the family and, • when appropriate, seek legal counsel in order to safeguard when appropriate, seek legal counsel in order to safeguard

the human dignity and the legal rights of the patient the human dignity and the legal rights of the patient • when he/she is unable to exercise proper judgement due to when he/she is unable to exercise proper judgement due to

mental disorder. mental disorder. – All psychiatrists face situations where compulsive All psychiatrists face situations where compulsive

interventions are required to safeguard the patients and/or interventions are required to safeguard the patients and/or those surrounding him/her.those surrounding him/her.


• 4. Particularities in Romania4. Particularities in Romania– in Romania, the medication is completely free, in Romania, the medication is completely free,

• but these costs represent only 20% of the total care of a but these costs represent only 20% of the total care of a patient with Alzheimer’s.patient with Alzheimer’s.

– The family is the main supporter of a patient, The family is the main supporter of a patient, – the main problems encountered are the main problems encountered are

• the lack of community care, the lack of community care, • the small number of day care centres, counselling the small number of day care centres, counselling

centres, the hospital houses, centres, the hospital houses, • only 10% of cases resolveonly 10% of cases resolve

– Prevalence in the population is small, about 1%, Prevalence in the population is small, about 1%, • but it increases the elderly population, but it increases the elderly population, • or 20% in people over 70 years, or 20% in people over 70 years, • reaching 50% in those over 80 years.reaching 50% in those over 80 years.


• 4. Particularities in Romania4. Particularities in Romania– In Romania there are currently some private clinics In Romania there are currently some private clinics

• PiteştiPiteşti• Braşov County, etc.Braşov County, etc.

– Assistance with housework, shopping and laundry services Assistance with housework, shopping and laundry services exist but must be totally funded by the service users. exist but must be totally funded by the service users.

– There are no transportation services. There are no transportation services. – Help with the delivery of meals is available and is usually Help with the delivery of meals is available and is usually

provided by NGOs and the Church. provided by NGOs and the Church. – The NGOs are not directly involved in the preparation of The NGOs are not directly involved in the preparation of

meals but they transport food from restaurants and canteens, meals but they transport food from restaurants and canteens, as well as food packages or food products, to people with as well as food packages or food products, to people with dementia from poor families. dementia from poor families.

– This service does not function on a regular basis as it is This service does not function on a regular basis as it is dependent on the availability of funds. dependent on the availability of funds.

– The Church also transports food to old people, some of The Church also transports food to old people, some of whom have dementia.whom have dementia.


• 4. Particularities in Romania4. Particularities in Romania– The priority objectives for the foreseeable future remain The priority objectives for the foreseeable future remain

• the detection of as many cases of dementia in early the detection of as many cases of dementia in early evolutionary stages and evolutionary stages and

• as early initiation of specific treatment, and increase the as early initiation of specific treatment, and increase the level of information among the general populationlevel of information among the general population

– The problem is that The problem is that • only 10 percent of patients with Alzheimer’s are only 10 percent of patients with Alzheimer’s are

diagnosed diagnosed • treated another 10 percent.treated another 10 percent.

RRING – European final MeetingING – European final Meeting “What if tomorrow”? “What if tomorrow”? • The availability of Alzheimer treatmentsThe availability of Alzheimer treatments

– A positive list of medicines to be reimbursed A positive list of medicines to be reimbursed • is compiled annually by the Ministry of Health and the is compiled annually by the Ministry of Health and the

National Health Insurance. National Health Insurance. • This list determines which prescription drugs are covered This list determines which prescription drugs are covered

by health insurance funds. by health insurance funds. • The list is based on recommendations from the College of The list is based on recommendations from the College of

Physicians and the College of Pharmacists. Physicians and the College of Pharmacists. – The reimbursement list applies to inpatients and outpatients. In The reimbursement list applies to inpatients and outpatients. In

fact, there are two lists: fact, there are two lists: • one containing substances that are 100% reimbursable for one containing substances that are 100% reimbursable for

people suffering from one or more of a list of diseases people suffering from one or more of a list of diseases (cancer, tuberculosis, diabetes, etc.); (cancer, tuberculosis, diabetes, etc.);

• the other containing other substances on which the the other containing other substances on which the reference price system is applied and of which 70% of the reference price system is applied and of which 70% of the reference price is reimbursed. reference price is reimbursed.

– With the exception of galantamine, all other anti-dementia With the exception of galantamine, all other anti-dementia drugs are available and reimbursable in Romania. drugs are available and reimbursable in Romania.


• The availability of Alzheimer treatmentsThe availability of Alzheimer treatments– Treatment initiation and treatment continuation Treatment initiation and treatment continuation

• are restricted to specialists only (neurologists, psychiatrists are restricted to specialists only (neurologists, psychiatrists or old age psychiatrists). or old age psychiatrists).

• The National Health Insurance The National Health Insurance – approved guidelines that are in existence in Romaniaapproved guidelines that are in existence in Romania– which prescribe a series of examinations that need to be which prescribe a series of examinations that need to be

carried out when making a diagnosis carried out when making a diagnosis (neuropsychological tests, CT or MRI scans and (neuropsychological tests, CT or MRI scans and laboratory tests).laboratory tests).

– For Alzheimer medicines to be reimbursed, these tests For Alzheimer medicines to be reimbursed, these tests need to be carried out and included in a medical report. need to be carried out and included in a medical report.

– in some areas of the country, the Romanian Alzheimer Society in some areas of the country, the Romanian Alzheimer Society reports that health insurance offices have restricted reports that health insurance offices have restricted reimbursement to people with Alzheimer’s disease reimbursement to people with Alzheimer’s disease


• The availability of Alzheimer treatmentsThe availability of Alzheimer treatments– Although there are no restrictions for people living alone or Although there are no restrictions for people living alone or

for people living in nursing homes, the Romanian Alzheimer for people living in nursing homes, the Romanian Alzheimer Society reports difficulties for these people in accessing Society reports difficulties for these people in accessing medication due to a lack of social support.medication due to a lack of social support.

– The survey shows that the impact on the sick person’s family The survey shows that the impact on the sick person’s family and carers is very important. and carers is very important.

– All segments involved in Alzheimer’s disease management All segments involved in Alzheimer’s disease management recognize that a person Alzheiemer care is difficult, recognize that a person Alzheiemer care is difficult, requiring physical effort, morally and financially and that requiring physical effort, morally and financially and that family members feel overworked. family members feel overworked.

– Access to treatment is difficult particularly enough funds for Access to treatment is difficult particularly enough funds for free medicines in pharmacies and the limited budget free medicines in pharmacies and the limited budget available to doctors for free prescriptions. available to doctors for free prescriptions.


• Home careHome care– Legislation relating to the provision of home care services Legislation relating to the provision of home care services – There are several laws which relate to home care services There are several laws which relate to home care services

(but only medical services). (but only medical services). – There are also laws regarding people with handicaps which There are also laws regarding people with handicaps which

also cover people with also cover people with dementiadementia. . – There are two laws regulating the activity of personal There are two laws regulating the activity of personal

assistants i.e. assistants i.e. – Law 519/12.07.2002 and Romanian Government Decision Law 519/12.07.2002 and Romanian Government Decision

no. 427/2001 regarding the approval of Methodological no. 427/2001 regarding the approval of Methodological Norms for working, rights and responsibilities of personal Norms for working, rights and responsibilities of personal assistants for people with handicaps. assistants for people with handicaps.

– Organisation and financing of home care servicesOrganisation and financing of home care services


• Medical home care servicesMedical home care services– Medical home care services Medical home care services

• are provided on the basis of contracts signed between the are provided on the basis of contracts signed between the National Health Assurance Company and people or National Health Assurance Company and people or organisations accredited to provide such services, by GPs organisations accredited to provide such services, by GPs or specialists who recommend medical home care, taking or specialists who recommend medical home care, taking into account the state of health of the person in need into account the state of health of the person in need (who must have a health assurance) and the person’s (who must have a health assurance) and the person’s dependency grade. dependency grade.

• All Romanian citizens who have a health assurance All Romanian citizens who have a health assurance – can access medical home care can access medical home care – but only for 56 days per year (art. 2, annex no.27, but only for 56 days per year (art. 2, annex no.27,

order.1220/24.12.2003). order.1220/24.12.2003). – In the past, people were entitled to medical home In the past, people were entitled to medical home

care for as long as it was needed. care for as long as it was needed. – This was limited to 14 days maximum in 2003 and This was limited to 14 days maximum in 2003 and

then extended to 56 in 2005. then extended to 56 in 2005.


• Medical home care servicesMedical home care services– A person can apply for medical home care (not for a A person can apply for medical home care (not for a

personal assistant, but for medical personnel – nurses) on the personal assistant, but for medical personnel – nurses) on the following conditions: following conditions:

– they have been previously hospitalised for their diseasethey have been previously hospitalised for their disease– the specialist/GP recommends medical home carethe specialist/GP recommends medical home care– the doctor who made the recommendation has a contract the doctor who made the recommendation has a contract

with the National Health Assurance Companywith the National Health Assurance Company– The medical home care providers (most of them NGOs) The medical home care providers (most of them NGOs)

should also have a contract with the National Health should also have a contract with the National Health Assurance CompanyAssurance Company

– Patients are offered a basic medical services package Patients are offered a basic medical services package containing 23 types of medical interventions. containing 23 types of medical interventions.


• Personal assistantsPersonal assistants– In order to be provided with a personal assistant, a person In order to be provided with a personal assistant, a person

has to obtain a grade one handicap certificate. For a person has to obtain a grade one handicap certificate. For a person with dementia, the following procedure applies: with dementia, the following procedure applies:

– Diagnosis of dementia from a specialist (psychiatrist, Diagnosis of dementia from a specialist (psychiatrist, neurologist) and a form describing the evolution and neurologist) and a form describing the evolution and symptoms. The specialist should demonstrate that the patient symptoms. The specialist should demonstrate that the patient needs permanent supervision and recommend either the needs permanent supervision and recommend either the necessity of a personal assistant or institutionalisation in a necessity of a personal assistant or institutionalisation in a long-term institution long-term institution

– An Expertise Commission for Persons with Handicap will An Expertise Commission for Persons with Handicap will examine the patient and his/her medical documents and will examine the patient and his/her medical documents and will decide on the grade of handicap. decide on the grade of handicap.


• Personal assistantsPersonal assistants– The patient or the family should find a person willing to The patient or the family should find a person willing to

become the personal assistant. The personal assistant will be become the personal assistant. The personal assistant will be paid by the local authorities. Personal assistants must paid by the local authorities. Personal assistants must complete training programmes offered by local authorities.complete training programmes offered by local authorities.

– The patient’s condition is periodically revised by the The patient’s condition is periodically revised by the Commission.Commission.

– Personal assistants are considered and treated like staff hired Personal assistants are considered and treated like staff hired by the local authority. They are paid for 8 hours’ work per by the local authority. They are paid for 8 hours’ work per day. They have to have a daily schedule and present an day. They have to have a daily schedule and present an activity report every week. Their activity should be activity report every week. Their activity should be monitored by representatives of the Social Protection monitored by representatives of the Social Protection Departments, but the Romanian Alzheimer Society stresses Departments, but the Romanian Alzheimer Society stresses that this is not always the case. that this is not always the case.


• The organisation of social support for people with dementia and The organisation of social support for people with dementia and carers carers – The Ministry of Labour, Social and Family Solidarity is

responsible for social support to people with dementia/dependent elderly people. Since entering the European Union, several projects have been started which involve collaboration between the State and NGOs which apply to be partners for structural funds with the intention of developing day care centres and memory clinics.

– law (Law 448) has been passed which regulates the rights and obligations of handicapped people in order to promote their social inclusion and integration. The methodological norms for Law 448 are not yet available.


• The overall funding of social support for people with dementia The overall funding of social support for people with dementia and carers and carers – Services and benefits provided by the State are funded

through an obligatory health insurance and general taxation. – Employees and employers each pay 7% to the insurance

fund. Pensioners also pay 7% but the handicapped have free access to health insurance. Unfortunately, there have been problems collecting health insurance contributions (Vladescu et al., 2002).

– Taxes are still an important source of funding, representing 21.6% of healthcare financing in 1999.

– The legal framework surrounding the provision of social support


• Palliative care Palliative care – Several discrete attempts have been made by NGOs to

provide palliative care at home. – The Casa Sperantei from Brasov is a good example although

it does not just provide this service for people with dementia.– Apart from these limited attempts to provide palliative care,

there are no palliative care services either at home or in centres.


• Psychosocial support and training for people with dementia and Psychosocial support and training for people with dementia and carerscarers– There is no general information service designed to inform

people about available services in Romania. – Limited psychosocial support exists for people with

dementia and their carers. For example, individual counselling for people with dementia may be offered by psychiatrists but only if they are specifically involved in the field of dementia. Psychiatrists are paid for a maximum of 14 consultations per day and cannot make a separate charge for counselling. Consequently, counselling is only offered by those who are willing to do it freely.

– There are no holiday services for people with dementia e.g. either alone, with carers or with personal assistants. Similarly, there are no provisions to enable carers to take a holiday e.g. payment or a substitute carer.


• Work/tax related support for people with dementia Work/tax related support for people with dementia – There are no specific provisions to protect people with

dementia who are in paid employment e.g. from unfair dismissal or deterioration of their future social rights.

– People with dementia are entitled to tax refunds and/or benefits due to their incapacity, direct payments from the State to pay for services (if eligible) and tax refunds/incentives for employing a person to provide home care services. They are not entitled to tax refunds, grants or other incentives for home transformations.

– According to Law 488 of 2006, people with dementia are entitled to reductions on their television and radio licences and to free public transport. A person with dementia who owns his/her own house does not have to pay tax on it.


• Work/tax related support for people with dementia Work/tax related support for people with dementia – Carers are not entitled to paid or unpaid time off work or

flexibility in their working hours in order to care for a person with dementia. The State does not provide free or subsidised pension contributions to people who give up paid employment as a result of care giving.

– Carers do not benefit from tax benefits or incentives for the care they provide. However, in accordance with Law 448 of 2006 and Law 487 of 2002, carers of people with dementia with the severe disability degree receive payments from the State towards the cost of caring. The National Authority for Handicapped People grants an allowance of EUR 100 per month and the local authorities, (the town councils) grant an allowance of EUR 20 per month. This is paid in the middle of each month (the handicapped person receives a separate coupon as proof that the money has been received).


• Kit experience: Kit experience: strengths of the RING kitstrengths of the RING kit::– Develop a kit based by needs analyze realize in country with

different background (social, economic and religion.

• Why? In a unit Europe, where the market place is more and more open and a lot of people are move to a region from another, is important to develop educational kit, useful for people all over the EU and adapt to the reality. One important point to develop a methodology for helping people who are in charge with take care the patient with dementia is the necessity to analyze and develop the a kit useful for all European people


• Kit experience - Kit experience - strengths of the RING kitstrengths of the RING kit::– Develop a kit in proper language, useful not only for people

who work in their country but also available in other European country

• Why? To develop a kit in different languages: English, Italian, Romanian, Turkish or Spanish is an important way to help people with different background. Usually the people who are in charge with caring the patients with dementia are not people with enough language knowledge for having the possibility to read in other language and develop them based by their school background. Also, in the same time they are interesting to find way to be informed related with this.


• Kit experience: Kit experience: strengths of the RING kitstrengths of the RING kit::– Using the movies sequences like a study case

• Why? Movies are an important way to assist the people, to show in an eloquent way the different phases of dementia and in the same time to let the caregiver to understand the evolution of disease and what they must do in different situation


• Kit experience - Kit experience - weaknessesweaknesses of the RING kit of the RING kit::– Insufficient time to develop more training activities and the

possibility to establish facilities for Romanian people who work in other country

• Why? A lot of Romanian works in other country like Germany, and we don’t have the possibility to let them to have the opportunity to be trained by people who work in the project how to use the kit RING, but also we must understand that, using the Romanian version could help them to use this kit.


• Kit experience - Kit experience - weaknessesweaknesses of the RING kit of the RING kit::– The impossibility to establish facilities for people who work

in other country (like Germany, Holland) to have access to the kit RING in their own country

• Why? All European countries have the same problem related to people who are involved in caring the patient with dementia. The project objective it wasn’t to develop kit RING in all EU country languages, but we consider that developing in English languages is important for having a large accessibility


• Kit experience - Kit experience - weaknessesweaknesses of the of the RING kitRING kit::– 3. The short time for dissemination

the project results in all country• Why? In Romania we

disseminate the project results in Brasov and in other town like Sibiu or Cluj, but it wasn’t enough time to develop in all Romanian Regions.

• We consider that having participants from different part of Romania in some meeting was a good opportunity to establish a good start for future development.


• Kit experienceKit experience - - added added value:value:– The added value o the kit

Ring it could be correlate with giving a complex instrument able also to help the people who carrying out the patient with dementia but also to train the nursing student.

– We use in this time the Ring kit for formal and non-formal caregiver and it was obvious that kit is a good instrument, useful for both of them.


• Kit experienceKit experience - - added value: added value:– how do you think to continue to use the

kit in the every day practice?

• Ring kit will be use in training the nursing student in future and related with that it could be a possibility to train the patients’ relatives by the nurses working with general practitioner.

• Giving materials related to the Kit Ring to the study centre of Hospice House – Brasov – they also will use this in training the caregivers.


• What about the perspectives for the What about the perspectives for the future?future?– After finishing the project at UTBv

we will use Kit ring in 3 purpose:• For helping the future nurse to

understand the problem of patients with dementia (nurses courses)

• For developing the skills of nurses for being able to help the people who carried out the patients with dementia how to do it in a proper way (health promotion courses)

• For develop a new way of teaching dementia – using kit ring (nurses courses)

Documents

RING – European final Meeting “What if tomorrow”? University Transilvania of BraşovUniversity Transilvania of Braşov Where we are?Where we are? What it