15
RUINATION TO REVITALIZATION: REBUILDING A WAR-TORN CITY IN BAGHDAD Christopher L. Allen Georgia Tech City and Regional Planning Graduate Student

RUINATION TO REVITALIZATION: REBUILDING A WAR-TORN CITY IN BAGHDAD Christopher L. Allen Georgia Tech City and Regional Planning Graduate Student

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: RUINATION TO REVITALIZATION: REBUILDING A WAR-TORN CITY IN BAGHDAD Christopher L. Allen Georgia Tech City and Regional Planning Graduate Student

RUINATION TO REVITALIZATION: REBUILDING A WAR-TORN CITY IN BAGHDAD

Christopher L. Allen

Georgia Tech

City and Regional Planning

Graduate Student

Page 2: RUINATION TO REVITALIZATION: REBUILDING A WAR-TORN CITY IN BAGHDAD Christopher L. Allen Georgia Tech City and Regional Planning Graduate Student

CONTENTS• Baghdad: Historical Context• Perspective from Saydiyah• Lines of Effort

• Security• Economics• Essential Services• Governance

• Obstacles and Constraints• Lasting Effects• Lessons Learned

Page 3: RUINATION TO REVITALIZATION: REBUILDING A WAR-TORN CITY IN BAGHDAD Christopher L. Allen Georgia Tech City and Regional Planning Graduate Student

BAGHDAD: MODERN CONTEXT

•OIF Post-Surge, 2007.

•U.S. COIN Strategy shift

•2LT Allen deployment

Page 4: RUINATION TO REVITALIZATION: REBUILDING A WAR-TORN CITY IN BAGHDAD Christopher L. Allen Georgia Tech City and Regional Planning Graduate Student

PERSPECTIVE FROM SAYDIYAH• Pop: ~40,000• Majority Ba’athist

community• 2007: sectarian violence• Jan 2008: abandonment• Rashid District• Internally Displaced

Persons (IDPs), squatters

Page 5: RUINATION TO REVITALIZATION: REBUILDING A WAR-TORN CITY IN BAGHDAD Christopher L. Allen Georgia Tech City and Regional Planning Graduate Student

LINES OF EFFORT

SECURITY

ECONOMICS

ESSENTIAL SERVICES

GOVERNANCE

STA

BIL

ITY

Page 6: RUINATION TO REVITALIZATION: REBUILDING A WAR-TORN CITY IN BAGHDAD Christopher L. Allen Georgia Tech City and Regional Planning Graduate Student

SECURITY

• Weapons trafficking, insurgents

• T-Wall Solution• Joint U.S./Iraqi Army patrols

• Iraqi National Police Checkpoints within walls

• Sons & Daughters of Iraq: local concerned citizens

Page 7: RUINATION TO REVITALIZATION: REBUILDING A WAR-TORN CITY IN BAGHDAD Christopher L. Allen Georgia Tech City and Regional Planning Graduate Student
Page 8: RUINATION TO REVITALIZATION: REBUILDING A WAR-TORN CITY IN BAGHDAD Christopher L. Allen Georgia Tech City and Regional Planning Graduate Student

ECONOMICS

•Micro-Grants•Fruit and Fish Market project

•Rafidain Bank Reopening

•Job Creation

Page 9: RUINATION TO REVITALIZATION: REBUILDING A WAR-TORN CITY IN BAGHDAD Christopher L. Allen Georgia Tech City and Regional Planning Graduate Student

ESSENTIAL SERVICES•Education•Clinic•Roads•Sewers•Trash management

•Power generation

Page 10: RUINATION TO REVITALIZATION: REBUILDING A WAR-TORN CITY IN BAGHDAD Christopher L. Allen Georgia Tech City and Regional Planning Graduate Student
Page 11: RUINATION TO REVITALIZATION: REBUILDING A WAR-TORN CITY IN BAGHDAD Christopher L. Allen Georgia Tech City and Regional Planning Graduate Student
Page 12: RUINATION TO REVITALIZATION: REBUILDING A WAR-TORN CITY IN BAGHDAD Christopher L. Allen Georgia Tech City and Regional Planning Graduate Student

GOVERNANCE

•Reconciliation•Support Council: “unelected” body, local sheiks

•Balance of power•Primary function: Resettlement

Page 13: RUINATION TO REVITALIZATION: REBUILDING A WAR-TORN CITY IN BAGHDAD Christopher L. Allen Georgia Tech City and Regional Planning Graduate Student

OBSTACLES AND CONSTRAINTS

• Culture gap• Language barrier• Enemy threat• Weather & Climate• Training• Collective Benefit• Adjudicating legitimacy: Iraqi-led

Page 14: RUINATION TO REVITALIZATION: REBUILDING A WAR-TORN CITY IN BAGHDAD Christopher L. Allen Georgia Tech City and Regional Planning Graduate Student

LASTING EFFECTS

• Saydiyah set the standard• January 2010: 7,200 families reintegrated

• Gradual drawdown, return to normalcy• Over $1 Million dollars invested• Sporadic sectarian & insurgency violence

• 31 December 2011: U.S. Withdrawal out of Iraq

Page 15: RUINATION TO REVITALIZATION: REBUILDING A WAR-TORN CITY IN BAGHDAD Christopher L. Allen Georgia Tech City and Regional Planning Graduate Student

LESSONS LEARNED• Citizen input CRUCIAL• No perfect 100% solution• Quality of life significantly improved

• No “one best way”• All military objectives accomplished despite obstacles

• Outside agency support• Transition to Iraqi control• Deliberate analysis