S O S Europe Report Web 02

8/12/2019 S O S Europe Report Web 02

1/24

S.O.S. EurOpEhman RIGhTS anDmIGRaTIon conTRol


2/24

a(67< I7($7$ 6 $ *%$ 9((7 ) ( 7+$ 3 687(6,

(%(6 $' $&79676 ( 7+$ 150 &87(6 $' 7(7(6 + &$$*

7 (' *$9( $%86(6 ) +8$ *+76.

O8 96 6 ) (9(< (6 7 (< $ 7+( *+76 (6+(' 7+( u9(6$

D(&$$7 ) h8$ r*+76 $' 7+( 7($7$ +8$ *+76 67$'$'6.

!( $( '(('(7 ) $< *9((7, 7&$ '(*


3/24

COn#En#"

GlO""A!' 21. In#!Od$C#IOn 3

2. MIG!A#IOn COn#!Ol AG!EEMEn#"

bE#%EEn I#Al' And lIb'A 5

3. !E"C$E A# "EA 12

4. H$MAn !IGH#" OblIGA#IOn"

bE'Ond bO!dE!" 16

5. COnCl$"IOn 17

6. !ECOMMEndA#IOn" 18

EndnO#E" 20

".O.". E$!OE

h%man "IGh$# anD mIG"a$In cn$"l

IA: E%" 01/013/2012 A// 2012

1


4/24

GlO""A!'

A /#$2%## @>

> > > .

* > >>< >

> , > > >

,

>, > >>

>> @ . A06*2+ ./!#"2/#0

> > >

> >. > >

>J > ,

',1#/,a1',a* ./1#!1',

@> > >.

A> a06*2+-0##)#/ > > @> >J

. D> > , >

> > >.

A +'%/a,1 > > > , , .

A > J > >,

@ @,

/#%2*a/ +'%/a,1. A> '//#%2*a/ +'%/a,1 >

> J >.

Refoulement > > . I @ >>> > @>@@ .

C**#!1'3# "#./1a1', / !**#!1'3# #5.2*0',

@> @ @@,

/ )

>>

>< > @> @ >>><


5/24

1. In#!Od$C#IOn

E/B B/+, =>> @@

E@ A, > L> > > > > @

N >

> > . I >

> E@ E@>

> > @ >.

E@> > >< >

> E@ > A. #> E@> >

>, > @ M E@,

G, G>, #, , , >< >

*>,2 -@> >

> > C@ , G, G>,

G>-B, # #>.3

".O.". E$!OE


IA: E%" 01/013/2012 A// 2012

3


6/24

A > > (E+) >

> > A >> > @ > >>< >>. F @ 2010, E@> C> -

@> > > > ",

@> > > 2011. >

> > " > > .

* E@> A> #>>

%@>< C-@> E>< B

# E+ (>> F%*E)

. F%*E

> @ E@> >

#>> , > A> ,

> > < >< >

#>, @ -

@> >.

* @ ><

> > >> >

> >> > > @, > >

> >

>> >, > > I > ". I >

--

@>, >>. *

@ @ @ A>

I>>>< > > @

E@> > @ @.

".O.". E$!OE


A// 2012 IA: E%" 01/013/2012

4


7/24

#HE !IGH#" Of MIG!An#" And!Ef$GEE" In lIb'A

" > >

@ A. * >> " > >

> > ; L

" > > N N >

E@; > >

@>. * ,

> E, E@, >, . I> @,

" >,

. A " > >>>< @>,

> >< > >

@ @ @ >

, >

" > C< >>

>> > >, > >

>> .

> >

@> >

). " > @ 1951 +

C>>> >

2. MIG!A#IOn COn#!Ol AG!EEMEn#"

bE#%EEn I#Al' And lIb'A

".O.". E$!OE


IA: E%" 01/013/2012 A// 2012

5

R#$%## a" +'%/a ' 6a/" a M'/aa& D##'-

C#/#, L'6a, N-#+#/ 2008.

F#/ / < B + @@+ )/>=+/++

)+-G++* //


8/24

1967 + H

C> (+HC) " > @.

* > > > 2010 >

> "> @> +HCK

@> > >. B # 2012 +HC,

> ", > > < > @

> "> .

> ,

> > > > .

* > > ,

@> @, >

> >@ > . *

@ M > > @@>

-> A> N N , >>

> . D> > >

>

>

>, > >

. A> I>>>< >

> >> A > @

>> > @ . %> < A@ 1,000 @> >

> >

> >> " >

@->>>


9/24

AG!EEMEn#" bE#%EEn I#Al'And lIb'A

D@ >< @ >,

>

> " > 2006 > 2010, I > ">

. * > >

>< > @ >>< > >< >

> >< . I I *

F>@, >@ > C-@>. * *,

> @ >>

@, > > > @>> ">

>

L>< >M. I> A@< 2012, C>

"> >< *>>< C>< >

"K > *.

".O.". E$!OE


IA: E%" 01/013/2012 A// 2012

7

S#&a a/-* ' "##/ ' L'6a, 2008.

;Ga'#*#"#*Ga"#


10/24

< >< >, > > I

N "> > I , > >

L> M @>. I>

LA>< *>< > >

@ >

@> > > > > >>>< @>. A L*>< < > 7 D 2010 > .

* @> > >

" > I > @ >

> > ", . ", I

> >>> ">

>< *>>< C>< > @

> > -@ >

> L @>

> > > .M8 I> @

@>> A> I>>>< > >

> , > 3 A@ > "

L< M.9 * > >

> @>

>, > >

> , >>

@> > @>

>>> >, >

"


11/24

h%man "IGh$# &Ila$In#

* -@> > I "

> > >> > > >> , > < <

> D 2010, @ "

@> > .

* A@< 2012 > > I

> ">

@ > > >,

, > @

@> > @ "

>>.

> > > > > >> @ . H,

@ > >

> > > I "

>>< ",

>> >,

>

> ". * > > I "

> > > .

* > > 2008

I


12/24

"Ef%GEE# $"a!!ED In lIba

> 2010, > > ", +HC @> @> >>< @>. A > 2011,

8,000 >J >

> 3,200 >

> > ">

@ N > @ > > " > I

L> > >

> " > >

@>, E, E@,

>, "K >>

@> > @

>>>< @> > > >J

, > >

, > > >

E@K

> >< @ >@>

> @- . +> >

> > I "

> > #>>

>@> @>

E@ > @> > ".

> > > > > @< .

$"H-bACK #O lIb'A

A/+ />// +

#>/ 2011. "/ + +==/=/ = /+/ lB+

E>/ J>/ 2009. %= =/ + 1,000 > " > -> @.11 F

@- @ > @ > >>.12

* " > I

".O.". E$!OE


A// 2012 IA: E%" 01/013/2012

10


13/24

> @-. +HC >

2008, @- >, 75 @ > > >> > I N

" N 50 @ > > >>>< @>.13

@@ @ I > >

< >> >.14

I>>>< > E@> > >

> > < >

, <

refoulement. H> < >. I> 2012 G>

C E@> C H>

> @-, >

@@= f+>*B 2012, = G*

c*+ = E>* c>= h>* "=< > =*=

* >= +B I=*B m*B 2009

?*= = E>* c?= h>* "==B *+*

= ? * * * = =, I=*B @>

* < = l+B* * =?B ?

I=*B =< >* =< +*=< > = E>*

c?= h>* "=


14/24

3. !E"C$E A# "EA

#>K > E@ > >

@>. > > >

>. A> +HC, > > 2011.15

* >>>< @ > @@ > . A

@>@ >

, >> > >; @ .

H, @ @ < E@>

> > >

; >

@ > @> >

. # I , > ,

@ > ) >

> @> ><

@ > > .16

dI"#!E"" CAll" GO $nAn"%E!Ed

<

. F @ 6 A@< 2011, >

200 @@ > > " @J. * >>

> # . A #>>

.

* @ " > @>

> @ >> >

E@. H, < >

@@ . @

@ @ > @>.

H > > > I C G >

A*% > @ ,

. F> >


15/24

* @ @>>

> @

> >> > " >

#>> @@ #>> C>, F%*E >

A*% > :

5[A] caa%(!e ( a#%*e+ beca&e a))a*e': "e L#ba'

a"(*##e+ a#%ed ( &a#'a#' *e+)('+#b#%# (* "e#*

Sea*c" a'd Re+ce ('e, "e Ia%#a' a'd Ma%e+e

Ma*##&e Re+ce C(-(*d#'a#(' Ce'*e+ a#%ed ( %a'c"

a' +ea*c" a'd *e+ce ()e*a#(', a'd NATO a#%ed (

*eac ( "e d#+*e++ ca%%+, ee' "(!" "e*e /e*e

%#a* e++e%+ 'de* #+ c('*(% #' "e b(a4+ #c#'#

/"e' "e d#+*e++ ca%% /a+ +e'3 Pe*"a)+ ( &(+

c('ce*' #' "#+ ca+e #+ "e a%%e!ed a#%*e ( "e

"e%#c()e* a'd "e 'aa% e++e% ( !( ( "e a#d ( "e

b(a #' d#+*e++, *e!a*d%e++ ( /"e"e* "e+e /e*e

'de* 'a#('a% c(&&a'd (* "e c(&&a'd ( NATO.6

".O.". E$!OE


IA: E%" 01/013/2012 A// 2012

13

A Ia*'a !-a%a/" ##* /#a/# - "-!) ' La+#"a

-/, Ia*6, Ma6 2011. I a !a//6'% 142 #-*# &- &a"

a'*#" $/-+ T/'-*', L'6a, '!*"'% 30 -+# a" &/##

!&'*"/#. T #/# /#!#" #$-/# '/ -a a) a #a.

;UNHCR/F.N-6


16/24

* >> >

> > E@> < > > < L> >M. I>

>, @ > 24 A@< 2012,

ACE > > >

< .

!E"C$E dOE" nO# Al%A'"MEAn "AfE#'

I> , > > >

.

%> 17 >>< > >. *

< @@ # > @ . @ @@. * E> I. *>>

I A, @

@ > L ">M. *

> @ >

>>< @>,> > >

. A

" @ >>

. I> >>, > @, >,

> >

>>.

* 28 # > > > >>>. * #> >

> >>. I> @ 2010

I>>>< , > > 17

>, # >

non-refoulement @@ .

# >> @< >

.19 * @> @@ >

> E@> C H>

( H#*+# Ja&aa a'd ("e* . Ia%, @ 11).

".O.". E$!OE


A// 2012 IA: E%" 01/013/2012

14


17/24

".O.". E$!OE


IA: E%" 01/013/2012 A// 2012

15

T# #-*# #/# a+-% a*+- 500 #-*# /#!#" $/-+

a )'$$ ' M#"'#//a#a S#a a" a)# 6 ' Ia*'a

-a - La+#"a, Ia*6, Ma6 2011.

;UNHCR/F.N-6


18/24

4. H$MAn !IGH#" OblIGA#IOn"

bE'Ond bO!dE!"

H> > : > >

> >

> K >.

E> >< >

> >< >,

> >

> >

> < > , >

@@@

> < . E> >

>@> @> >

> > @@

>@

> @>>< > . * >

> > > >

< >, > , >>

@@ >>

, > non-refoulement,

> @.

@@ >

@ >, @ > >

> >. @>

> >>>< > >

>

> .

> > >

> N > N --

@> >@

> < > , >

>@

.

A >> @

@> @ >

, > >

< > > .

".O.". E$!OE


A// 2012 IA: E%" 01/013/2012

16


19/24

".O.". E$!OE


IA: E%" 01/013/2012 A// 2012

17

5. COnCl$"IOn

A> > I " > . A>

> > > E@ > >

A, > > > @> > E+

> F%*E, > >

> @. H, >> > >< >

> @, > > > @>

LM >>> > , > >

> < > >

> >

>>>< @>

>. D.

> > >. A @> >> > E@> >K

>> @ > >

> > >> >.

I> @ >>> , >, > > @> .

Ia*'a C-a Ga/" !a "'#/, ## --+ *#$,

/#!# +'%/a ' Pa#**#/'a, Ia*6, 13 A/'* 2011.

O$$'!'a* a6 - -+# "/-#" &'*# a#+'%

- /#a!& Ia*6 $/-+ N-/& A$/'!a a$#/ '/ -a '&

250 #-*# a-a/" # -$$ !-/# a" /a a%/-"

( -$$ a Ia*'a '*a".

;APP&-1-/I1a*'aC-a01G2a",Fa!#0!-Ma*a

3-*1a


20/24

6. rEcOmmEndAtIOnS

Amnest" International urges all states to protect the

rights of migrants, refugees and as"lum-seekers,

according to international standards, This report has

focused on Ital".

ThE ITalIan GovERnmEnT ShoUlD:

n set aside its existing migration control

agreements with Libya;

n not enter into any further agreements with Libya

until the latter is able to demonstrate that it respects

and protects the human rights of refugees, asylum

seekers and migrants and has in place a satisfactory

system for assessing and recognizing claims for

international protection;

n ensure that all migration control agreements

negotiated with Libya or any other countries are

made public.

EURopEan coUnTRIES anD ThE EU ShoUlD:

n ensure that their migration control policies and

practices do not cause, contribute to, or benefit from

human rights iolations;

n ensure their migration control agreements full"

respect international and European human rights and

refugee la!, as !ell as the la! of the sea; include

adequate safeguards to protect human rights !ith

appropriate implementation mechanisms; and be

made public;

n ensure their interception operations look to the

safet" of people in distress in interception and rescue

operations and include measures that proide access

to indiiduali#ed assessment procedures, including the

opportunit" to claim as"lum;

n ensure their search-and-rescue bodies increase

their capacit" and co-operation in the Mediterranean

Sea; publicl" report on measures to reduce deaths at

sea; and that Search and Rescue obligations are read

and implemented in a manner that is consistent !ith

the requirements of refugee and human rights la!.

S.O.S. EurOpE

hUman RIGhTS anD mIGRaTIon conTRol

Aesy Ieaioal Je 2012 Idex: EUR 01/013/2012

18


21/24

".O.". E$!OE


IA: E%" 01/013/2012 A// 2012

19

A+#6 I#/a'-a* +#+#/ $-/+#" -/" 9G/a7'#:

'& '/ -"'# - a #a!& ' La+#"a, Ia*6, - a6

&a) 6- - '&a'a -$ '*a" $-/ '/ -*'"a/'6

'& &-a" -$ /#$%## a" +'%/a $/-+ T''a,

L'6a a" A$/'!a. J*6 2011.

;F2*3'-B2%a'


22/24

EndnO#E"

1 A> I>>>< > >> >

> @ > #> > @ > @>> ". : Ma*#a'#a: 5N(b(d /a'+ ( "ae a'"#'!

( d( /#" +6: A**e++ a'd c(%%ec#e e)%+#('+ ( !*a'+

de'#ed e'* #'( E*()e(I>: AF 38/001/2008); L#ba

( T(&(**(/. W"a "()e (* "&a' *#!"+? (I>: #DE

19/007/2010); L#ba: M#%##a+ "*eae' "()e+ (* 'e/ L#ba

(I>: #DE 19/002/2012).

2 > I) > I

#> I>, > @://., 21 # 2012.

3 > @> >>

, > : @://.>>< @: L#ba (

T(&(**(/, W"a "()e (* "&a' *#!"+?(I>: #DE19/007/2010), > 2010; L#ba: M#%##a+ "*eae' "()e+ (*

'e/ L#ba, (I>: #DE 19/002/2012), 16 F 2012.

5 " : @://./

@://., (> I) > @://. >-> @M, @://. >, > >>

> > @>

> > >>>< @>.

11 * I A " @

>> > > > @

> 13 % 2009 N > @://../.@@?>=760&>>< @ Ia%: Oe* 100 *e)(*ed% 5)+"ed bac$6

a +ea (I>: E+ 30/017/2011), 30 A 2011,

> See$#'! +ae, #'d#'! ea*: Re!ee+, a+%&-+ee$e*+

a'd !*a'+ #' L#ba a'd

Ma%a, (I>: EG 01/004/2010), 14 D 2010.

13 +HC @ >, 10 D 2010.

14 > % +> > H

C> > C H#*+# a'd O"e*+

. Ia% (A@@ >. 27765/09), 29 # 2011, >

@://. 1,500 > > >

#>> > 2011M, > @://.>./

42803949. I>>>./

49856. T#&e+ ( Ma%a N

@://.< >

>>. * A<

E@K @ L#e+ %(+ #' "e Med#e**a'ea' Sea: /"( #+

*e+)('+#b%e?, @ >

.

19 A> I>>>


23/24


24/24

S.O.S. EurOpEhuman rIGhTS anD mIGraTIOn cOnTrOl

I $ $77(7 7 (9(7 >(*8$ *$7 ) a)&$ 7 E8(,

6( E8($ &87(6 ((7 %'( &7 ($68(6

876'( 7+( 7(7

Documents

S O S Europe Report Web 02