Upload
jaymatadee
View
222
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
1/35
LOVELY SCHOOL OF BUSINESS (LSM)
Term PAPER
OF
Financial Management
TOPIC: -J K Lakshmi Cement Ltd. & Ultratech
Cemrnt Ltd.
( Comparative analysis of Cost of Capital)
SUBMITTED TO: SUBMITTED BY:
Ashu, Maam NAME: Sanjeev kumar
REG. NO: 10907431
ROLL NO: RS1905A34
Section: 1905
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
2/35
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
3/35
In eighteenth century England, John Smeaton, a British engineer, was
assigned the task of re-constructing the Eddystone Lighthouse, a structure
that had witnessed repeated structural failure. In 1756, Smeaton conducted
a number of experiments that led to the discovery that cement made from
limestone containing a considerable proportion of clay would harden under
water. Based on this discovery, Smeaton rebuilt this lighthouse in 1759 and
this time, it stood strong for 126 years.
Subsequently, until the early part of the nineteenth century, large quantities
of natural cement was used, that was made with a combination of naturally
occurring lime and clay.
The first patent for cement...
In 1824, Joseph Aspdin, a British mason obtained a patent on his hydraulic
cement formula that closely resembled the modern cement as we know
today. He called this cement Portland Cement, and it was made through the
proportionate mixing, burning and the subsequent grinding of a combination
of clay and limestone.
Cement as we know today...
Cement went through many more improvements and developments in the
nineteenth and twentieth centuries. The industrial revolution and the
subsequent development of the rotary kiln paved the way for huge and
sophisticated cement manufacturing plants. These plants possess the
capability of a homogenous mixing and intense heating of the raw material
thus vastly improving the quality of the cement produced. The sophisticated
quality-testing equipment employed by modern cement plants further helps
in ensuring the quality of the cement produced.
J K Lakshmi Cement Ltd.
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
4/35
One of the established names in the cement industry, JK Lakshmi Cement Ltd
has state-of-the-art plant at Jaykaypuram, dist. Sirohi, Rajasthan. With the
capacity expansion and further commissioning of a split location grinding
unit at Motibhoyan, Kalol (Gujarat), the combined capacity of the Company
today stands at 4.75 Mn. MT per annum. With the use of the latest
technology from M/s Blue Circle Industries and modern equipments from M/s
Fuller International of USA, the Company is going from strength to strength.
It is also the first cement producer of Northern India to be awarded an ISO
9002 certificate and be accredited by NABL (Department of Science &
Technology, Government of India) for its Lab Quality Management systems.
JK Lakshmi Cement manufacturing facility has been rated amongst Greenest
Cement Plant of India by CSE GRP 2005 thus highlighting our commitment to
the environment even while ensuring the highest standards of quality for our
products. We have also won the Productivity Excellence Award 2007-08,
Energy Conservation Award 2008, NCB award 2007, Building Leadership
Award 2007, National Award for Environmental Excellence & Energy
Management 2007, Golden Peacock Award for Corporate Social
Responsibility 2007, ICWAI National Award 2007 for Excellence in CostManagement, The Pinnacle Cement 2006 award by MTech Zee TV, Green
Tech Safety Award and a place of pride amongst the top ten companies in
India in HR practices. (as per the Business Today- TNS Mercer survey).
Its wide network of 70 cement dumps and over 2200 dealers spread across
the states of Rajasthan, Gujarat, Delhi, Haryana, U.P., Uttaranchal, Punjab,
J&K, Mumbai & Pune and the vast pool of highly trained & dedicated
marketing and technical service team helps the Company to service it's
customers at their doorstep.
The First Cement Manufacturer in Northern India to introduce coloured bags,
JK Lakshmi Cements Technical Service Cell provides construction solutions
to its customers & carries out regular & innovative contact programmes with
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
5/35
Individual House Builders, Masons and Business Associates to keep in tune
with their needs and requirements.
Keeping in touch with the global construction trends & changing needs of
customers, the company has introduced state-of-the-art Ready Mix Concrete
(RMC) with the brand name JK Lakshmi Power Mix. Currently, the company
has 10 fully operational plants in Western & Northern regions of the country
and is further expanding in this area. JK Lakshmiplast the first premium
branded Plaster of Paris (POP) in Northern India is another value added
product launched by the Company for discerning customers.
An integral part of Major Projects like IGNP, Sardar Sarovar Dam, Golden
Quadrilateral and major corporations like L&T, Reliance, NTPC, Essar and
Airport Authority of India, JK Lakshmi Cement has become the preferred
choice among the customers because of its consistency, high level of quality
and impeccable customer service.
A true showcase of 'Mazbooti Guaranteed', the Company has been able to
connect very strongly with its customers at an emotional level. With this
thought as a constant reminder of companys values, everyone at JK Lakshmi
strive to keep up the standards and continue with the good work for many
years to come
JK Lakshmi's journey towards excellence is being spearheaded by our
Chairman Shri. Hari Shankar Singhania closely supported by his Board of
Directors. They are the pillars of strength leading the company towards its
mission of being one of the most efficient, competitive and premium Cement
Brands of our region.
MANAGEMENT
Hari Shankar Singhania, Chairman
- Bharat Hari Singhania, Vice Chairman & Managing Director
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
6/35
- B.V. Bhargava, Director
- Nand Gopal Khaitan, Director
Pradip Roy, Director (Nominee of IDBI)
- Pravinchandra V. Gandhi, Director
- Raghupati Singhania, Director
- P. Narasimharamulu, Director (Nominee of ICICI)
- V.K. Guruswamy, Director (Nominee of LIC)
- Vinita Singhania, Managing Director
- Shailendra Chouksey, Whole-time Director
- S.K. Wali, Whole-time Director
About Aditya Birla Group
A US $24 billion corporation with a market capital of US $23 billion and in
the League of Fortune 500, the Aditya Birla Group is anchored by an
extraordinary force of 100,000 employees, belonging to 25 different
nationalities. Over 50 per cent of its revenues flow from its operations across
the world.
The Aditya Birla Groups products and services offer distinctive customer
solutions worldwide. The Group has operations in 20 countries - India,
Thailand, Laos, Indonesia, Philippines, Egypt, China, Canada, Australia, USA,
UK, Germany, Hungary, Brazil, Italy, France, Luxembourg, Switzerland,
Malaysia and Korea.
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
7/35
In India, the Group has been adjudged The Best Employer in India and
among the top 20 in Asia by the Hewitt-Economic Times and Wall Street
Journal Study 2007.
Globally the Aditya Birla Group is : A metals powerhouse, among the worlds
most cost-efficient aluminium and copper producers. Hindalco, from its fold,
is a Fortune 500 Company. It is also the largest aluminium rolling company
and one of the 3 biggest producers of primary aluminium in Asia, with the
largest single location copper smelter No. 1 in viscose staple fibre The 3rd
largest producer of insulators. The 4th largest producer of carbon black. The
11th largest cement producer globally and the 2nd largest in India Among
the worlds top 15 BPO companies and among Indias top 3 Among the bestenergy efficient fertilisers plants.
In India :
A premier branded garments player. The 2nd largest player in viscose
filament yarn
The 2nd largest in the Chlor-alkali sector. Among the top 5 mobile telephony
companies
A leading player in Life Insurance and Asset Management. Rock solid in
fundamentals, the Aditya Birla Group nurtures a culture where success does
not come in the way of the need to keep learning afresh, to keep
experimenting.
Ultratech Cement Ltd.
UltraTech Cement Limited is an India-based company engaged in the
production of cement. UltraTech Cement Limited has an annual capacity of
18.2 million tons. It manufactures and markets ordinary Portland cement,
Portland blast furnace slag cement and Portland Pozzalana cement. It also
manufactures ready mix concrete (RMC). UltraTech Cement Limited has five
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
8/35
integrated plants, six grinding units and three terminals, two in India and one
in Sri Lanka. The Company is also an exporter of cement clinker. The export
market comprises of countries around the Indian Ocean, Africa, Europe and
the Middle East. The Companys subsidiaries include Dakshin Cements
Limited and UltraTech Ceylinco (Private) Limited.Quick Financial Synopsis
BRIEF: For the fiscal year ended 31 March 2009, UltraTech Cement Limited's
revenues increased 16% to RS66.64B. Net income decreased 3% to RS9.78B.
Revenues reflect an increase in demand for Company's products & services.
Net was offset by an increase in consumption of raw materials, a rise in
employee costs, increased depreciation & amortization expenses, an
increase in freight & handling expenses and higher other expenditure.
UltraTech Cement Limited has an annual capacity of 18.2 million tonnes. It
manufactures and markets Ordinary Portland Cement, Portland Blast
Furnace Slag Cement and Portland Pozzalana Cement. It also manufactures
ready mix concrete (RMC).
UltraTech Cement Limited has five integrated plants, six grinding units and
three terminals two in India and one in Sri Lanka.
UltraTech Cement is the countrys largest exporter of cement clinker. The
export markets span countries around the Indian Ocean, Africa, Europe and
the Middle East.
UltraTechs subsidiaries are Dakshin Cement Limited and UltraTech Ceylinco
(P) Limited.
Board of Directors
:: Mr. Kumar Mangalam Birla, Chairman
:: Mrs. Rajashree Birla
:: Mr. R. C. Bhargava
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
9/35
:: Mr. G. M. Dave
:: Mr. N. J. Jhaveri
:: Mr. S. B. Mathur
:: Mr. V. T. Moorthy
:: Mr. S. Rajgopal
:: Mr. D. D. Rathi
Mr. O. P. Puranmalka, Wholetime Director
Executive President & Chief Financial Officer
:: Mr. K. C.Chief Manufacturing Officer
:: Mr. R.K. Shah
Chief Marketing Officer
:: Mr. S.N.Jajoo
Chief People Officer
:: Mr. C. B. Tiwari
Company Secretary
:: Mr. S. K. Chatterjee
Milestones
As part of the eighth biggest cement manufacturer in the world, UltraTech
Cement has five integrated plants, five grinding units as well as three
terminals of its own (one overseas, in Colombo, Sri Lanka). These facilities
gradually came up over the years, as indicated below:
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
10/35
2006:: Narmada Cement Company Limited amalgamated with UltraTech
pursuant to a Scheme of Amalgamation being approved by the Board for
Industrial & Financial Reconstruction (BIFR) in terms of the provision of Sick
Industrial Companies Act (Special Provisions)
2004 :: Completion of the implementation process to demerge the cement
business of L&T and completion of open offer by Grasim, with the latter
acquiring controlling stake in the newly formed company UltraTech
2003:: The board of Larsen & Toubro Ltd (L&T) decides to demerge its
cement business into a separate cement company (CemCo). Grasim decides
to acquire an 8.5 per cent equity stake from L&T and then make an open
offer for 30 per cent of the equity of CemCo, to acquire management control
of the company.
2002 :: The Grasim Board approves an open offer for purchase of up to 20
per cent of the equity shares of Larsen & Toubro Ltd (L&T), in accordance
with the provisions and guidelines issued by the Securities & Exchange
Board of India (SEBI) Regulations, 1997.
:: Grasim increases its stake in L&T to 14.15 per cent
:: Arakkonam grinding unit
2001 :: Grasim acquires 10 per cent stake in L&T. Subsequently increases
stake to 15.3 per cent by October 2002
:: Durgapur grinding unit
1998-2000:: Bulk cement terminals at Mangalore, Navi Mumbai and Colombo
1999 :: Narmada Cement Company Limited acquired
:: Ratnagiri Cement Works
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
11/35
Cost of capital Analysis
Of
J k Lakshmi Cement
Year 2005
1. Cost of Debt:-
Kd = Interest / face value of debt
Interest = 7.2 crore ,Total debt = 6.88 crore
So Kd = 7.2*100/688.87
= 720/688.87
= 1.04 %
Cost of debt = 1.04 %
2 Cost of Equity:-
Ke = EPS/Market price
Note Market price is not given so we are considering Book Value of the
firm.
EPS = Rs. 4.71 , B V = Rs. 22.83 ,
Ke = 4.71*100/22.83
= 471/22.83
= 20.63 %
Cost of Equity = 20.63 %
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
12/35
3 Cost of Preference Share
Note- Company has not issued preference share.
4 Cost of Retained Earning:-
PBT = 26.24 crore ,Total tax = - 0.43 crore
Tax rate = - 0.43*100/26.24
= - 1.63 %
Kr = Ke (1-t) (1-b)
Blockage cost is not given
Tax rate = -1.63 % , Ke = 20.63 %
Kr = 20.63 [1 ( -.01)]
=20.63*1.01
= 20.83%
Cost of retained earning = 20.42%
5 weighted Average Cost of Capital
Weighted Average Cost of Capital =
Source of
fund
Amount (in
crore)
Proportion
%age (W)
Before tax
cost %age
After tax
cost
%age(X)
X*W
Debt 688.87 84.51 1.04 1.05 88.73
Equity 55.29 6.78 20.63 20.63 139.81
Retained
earning
70.97 8.7 54.25 54.25 471.97
total 815.13 W=100 X*W
=700.67
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
13/35
Weighted Average Cost of Capital = X*W/ W
= 700.57/100
= 7 %
So WACC = 7 %
Work note- cost of debt after tax = Kd(before tax) (1- tax rate)
= 1.04[1 ( -0.01)]
= 1.04*1.o1
=1.05%ageNote:- Retained Earning is not given so we are considering reserves.
Year 2006
1. Cost of Debt:-
Kd = Interest / face value of debt
Interest = 22.31 crore ,Total debt = 681.79 crore
So Kd = 22.31*100/681.79
= 2231/681.79
= 3.27 %
Cost of debt = 3.27%
2 Cost of Equity:-
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
14/35
Ke = EPS/Market price
Note Market price is not given so we are considering Book Value of the
firm.
EPS = Rs. 11.14 , B V = Rs.36.07 ,
Ke = 11.14*100/36.07
= 30.88%
Cost of Equity = 30.88 %
3 Cost of Preference Share
Note- Company has not issued preference share.
4 Cost of Retained Earning:-
PBT = 56.24 crore ,Total tax = - 0.80 crore
Tax rate = - 0.80*100/56.24
= 1.42 %
Kr = Ke (1-t) (1-b)
Blockage cost is not given
Tax rate = 1.42 % ,Ke = 20.63 %
Kr = 30.88 (1 .014)
=30.88*.986
= 30.84%
Cost of retained earning = 30.84%
5. weighted Average Cost of Capital
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
15/35
Weighted Average Cost of Capital =
Source of
fund
Amount (in
crore)
Proportion
%age (W)
Before tax
cost %age
After tax
cost
%age(X)
X*W
Debt 681.79 84.37 3.27 3.23 272.51Equity 55.29 6.84 30.88 30.88 267.26Retained
earning
70.97 8.73 30.44 30.44 211.21
total 815.13 W=100 X*W=750.98
Weighted Average Cost of Capital = X*W/ W
= 750.98/100
= 7.5 %age
So WACC = 7 .5%
Work note- cost of debt after tax = Kd(before tax) (1- tax rate)
= 3.27(1 .01)
= 3.27*0.99
=3.23%ageNote:- Retained earning is not given so we are considering reserves.
Year 2007
1. Cost of Debt:-
Kd = Interest / face value of debt
Interest = 43.89 crore ,Total debt = 717.67 crore
So Kd = 43.89*100/717.67
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
16/35
= 6.11 %
Cost of debt = 6.11%
2 Cost of Equity:-
Ke = EPS/Market price
Note Market price is not given so we are considering Book Value of the
firm.
EPS = Rs. 31.21 , B V = Rs.68.17 ,
Ke = 31.21*100/68.27
= 45.78%
Cost of Equity = 45.78 %
3 Cost of Preference Share
Note- Company has not issued preference share.
4 Cost of Retained Earning:-
PBT = 178.81 crore ,Total tax = - 0.71 crore
Tax rate = - 0.71*100/178.81
= 0.39 %
Kr = Ke (1-t) (1-b)
Blockage cost is not given
Tax rate = 0.39 % ,Ke = 45.78 %
Kr = 45.78 (1 0.0039)
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
17/35
=45.78*0.996
= 45.60
Cost of retained earning = 45.60%
4 . weighted Average Cost of Capital
Weighted Average Cost of Capital =
Source of
fund
Amount (in
crore)
Proportion
%age (W)
Before tax
cost %age
After tax
cost
%age(X)
X*W
Debt 717.67 64.84 6.11 6.01 394.22
Equity 57.09 5.15 45.78 45.78 235.76Retained
earning
331.98 29.99 45.6 45.6 1367.54
Total 1106.74 W=100 X*W=1997.52
Weighted Average Cost of Capital = X*W/ W
= 1997.52/100
= 19.97 %age
So WACC = 19.97%
Year 2008
1. Cost of Debt:-
Kd = Interest / face value of debt
Interest = 53.96 crore ,Total debt = 694.84 crore
So Kd = 53.96*100/694.84
= 7.76
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
18/35
Cost of debt = 7.76%
2 Cost of Equity:-
Ke = EPS/Market price
Note Market price is not given so we are considering Book Value of the
firm.
EPS = Rs. 36.56 , B V = Rs.103.74 ,
Ke = 36.56*100/103.74
= 35.22%
Cost of Equity = 35.22 %
3 Cost of Preference Share
Note- Company has not issued preference share.
4 Cost of Retained Earning:-
PBT = 250.59 crore ,Total tax = - 26.93 crore
Tax rate = - 26.93*100/250.59
= 10.74 %
Kr = Ke (1-t) (1-b)
Blockage cost is not given
Tax rate = 10.74 % ,Ke = 35.22 %
Kr = 35.72 (1 0.10)
=35.72*0.9
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
19/35
= 31.69%
Cost of retained earning = 31.69%
5 . weighted Average Cost of Capital
Weighted Average Cost of Capital =
Source of
fund
Amount (in
crore)
Proportion
%age (W)
Before tax
cost %age
After tax
cost
%age(X)
X*W
Debt 694.88 52.56 7.76 6.98 364.77Equity 61.19 4.6 35.22 35.22 162.01Retained
earning
573.43 43.13 31.69 31.69 1366.78
Total 1329.56 W=100 X*W=1893.56
Weighted Average Cost of Capital = X*W/ W
= 1893.56/100
= 18.93 %age
So WACC = 18.93%
Year 2009
1. Cost of Debt:-
Kd = Interest / face value of debt
Interest = 49.51 crore ,Total debt = 686.74 crore
So Kd = 49.51*100/686.74
= 7.2%
Cost of debt = 7.2%
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
20/35
2 Cost of Equity:-
Ke = EPS/Market price
Note Market price is not given so we are considering Book Value of the
firm.
EPS = Rs. 29.19 , B V = Rs.128.75 ,
Ke = 29.19*100/128.75
= 22.76%
Cost of Equity = 22.76 %
3 Cost of Preference Share
Note- Company has not issued preference share.
4 Cost of Retained Earning:-
PBT = 226.68 crore ,Total tax = - 28.09 crore
Tax rate = - 28.09*100/266.68
= 21.21 %
Kr = Ke (1-t) (1-b)
Blockage cost is not given
Tax rate = 21.21 % ,Ke = 22.76 %
Kr = 22.76 (1 0.21)
=22.76*0.79
= 17.98%
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
21/35
Cost of retained earning = 17.98%
5 . weighted Average Cost of Capital
Weighted Average Cost of Capital =
Source of
fund
Amount (in
crore)
Proportion
%age (W)
Before tax
cost %age
After tax
cost
%age(X)
X*W
Debt 686.74 46.57 7.2 5.68 264.51Equity 61.19 4.15 22.76 22.76 54.45Retained
earning
723.44 49.16 17.98 17.98 883.89
Total 1471.37 W=100 X*W=1242.85
Weighted Average Cost of Capital = X*W/ W
= 1242.85/100
= 12.42 %age
So WACC = 12.42%
Cost of Capital Analysis
Of
Ultratech Cement
Year 2005
1. Cost of Debt:-
Kd = Interest / face value of debt
Interest = 128.05 crore ,Total debt = 1531.38 crore
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
22/35
So Kd = 128.05*100/1531.38
= 8.36%
Cost of debt = 8.36%
2 Cost of Equity:-
Ke = EPS/Market price
Note Market price is not given so we are considering Book Value of the
firm.
EPS = Rs. 0.23 , B V = Rs.85.78 ,
Ke = 0.23*100/85.78
= 3.97%
Cost of Equity = 3.97 %
3 Cost of Preference Share
Note- Company has not issued preference share.
4 Cost of Retained Earning:-
PBT = -33.6 crore ,Total tax = - -36.45 crore
Tax rate = - 36.45*100/-33.6
= 108.4 %
Kr = Ke (1-t) (1-b)
Blockage cost is not given
Tax rate = 108.4 % ,Ke = 3.97 %
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
23/35
Kr = 3.97 (1 1.08)
=3.97*-0.08
= -0.31%
Cost of retained earning = -0.31%
4 . weighted Average Cost of Capital
Weighted Average Cost of Capital =
Source of
fund
Amount (in
crore)
Proportion
%age (W)
Before tax
cost %age
After tax
cost
%age(X)
X*W
Debt 1531.38 58.92 8.36 -0.66 -38.88Equity 124.4 4.78 3.99 3.97 18.97Retained
earning
942.73 36.27 -0.31 -o.31 -11.24
Total 2598.51 W=100 X*W=-31.15
Weighted Average Cost of Capital = X*W/ W
= = -31.15/100
= -0.31 %age
So WACC = - 0.31%
Year 2006
1. Cost of Debt:-
Kd = Interest / face value of debt
Interest = 96.99 crore ,Total debt = 1451.83 crore
So Kd = 96.99*100/1451.33
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
24/35
= 6.68 %
Cost of debt = 6.68%
2 Cost of Equity:-
Ke = EPS/Market price
Note Market price is not given so we are considering Book Value of the
firm.
EPS = Rs. 18.47 , B V = Rs.83.47 ,
Ke = 18.47*100/83.47
= 22.17%
Cost of Equity = 22.17 %
3 Cost of Preference Share
Note- Company has not issued preference share.
4 Cost of Retained Earning:-
PBT = 285.59 crore ,Total tax = 55.83 crore
Tax rate = 55.83*100/285.89
= 19.54 %
Kr = Ke (1-t) (1-b)
Blockage cost is not given
Tax rate = 19.54 % ,Ke = 22.17 %
Kr = 22.17 (1 0.19)
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
25/35
=30.88*0.81
= 17.95%
Cost of retained earning = 17.95%
4 . weighted Average Cost of Capital
Weighted Average Cost of Capital =
Source of
fund
Amount (in
crore)
Proportion
%age (W)
Before tax
cost %age
After tax
cost
%age(X)
X*W
Debt 1451.83 58.3 6.68 5.54 322.98
Equity 124.4 4.99 22.17 22.17 110.62Retained
earning
913.78 36.69 17.95 17.95 658.58
Total 2490.01 W=100 X*W=1092.18
Weighted Average Cost of Capital = X*W/ W
= 1092.18/100
= 10.92 %age
So WACC = 10.92%
Work note- cost of debt after tax = Kd(before tax) (1- tax rate)
= 6.68(1 0.17)= 6.68*0.83
=5.54%ageNote:- Retained earning is not given so we are considering reserves.
Year 2007
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
26/35
1. Cost of Debt:-
Kd = Interest / face value of debt
Interest = 92.61 crore ,Total debt = 1578.63 crore
So Kd = 92.61*100/1578.63
= 5.68 %
Cost of debt = 5.68%
2 Cost of Equity:-
Ke = EPS/Market price
Note Market price is not given so we are considering Book Value of the
firm.
EPS = Rs. 62.84 , B V = Rs.141.69 ,
Ke = 62.84*100/141.69
= 44.35%
Cost of Equity = 44.35 %
3 Cost of Preference Share
Note- Company has not issued preference share.
4 Cost of Retained Earning:-
PBT = 1166.19 crore ,Total tax = 383.91 crore
Tax rate = 383.91*100/1166.19
= 32.92 %
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
27/35
Kr = Ke (1-t) (1-b)
Blockage cost is not given
Tax rate = 32.92 % ,Ke = 44.35 %
Kr = 44.35 (1 0.32)
=30.88*0.68
= 30.15%
Cost of retained earning = 30.15%
4 . weighted Average Cost of Capital
Weighted Average Cost of Capital =
Source of
fund
Amount (in
crore)
Proportion
%age (W)
Before tax
cost %age
After tax
cost
%age(X)
X*W
Debt 1578.63 47.23 5.86 3.98 187.97Equity 124.49 3.72 44.35 44.35 169.98Retained
earning
1639.29 49.04 30.15 30.15 1478.55
Total 3342.41 W=100 X*W=1831.15
Weighted Average Cost of Capital = X*W/ W
= 1831.15/100
= 18.31 %age
So WACC = 18.31%
Year 2008
1. Cost of Debt:-
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
28/35
Kd = Interest / face value of debt
Interest = 81.93 crore ,Total debt = 1740.5 crore
So Kd = 8193*100/1740.5
= 4.7 %
Cost of debt = 4.7%
2 Cost of Equity:-
Ke = EPS/Market price
Note Market price is not given so we are considering Book Value of the
firm.
EPS = Rs. 80.94 , B V = Rs.216.58 ,
Ke = 80.94*100/216.58
= 37.2%
Cost of Equity = 37.2 %
3 Cost of Preference Share
Note- Company has not issued preference share.
4 Cost of Retained Earning:-
PBT = 1507.01 crore ,Total tax = 499.4 crore
Tax rate = 499.4*100/1507.01
= 33.13 %
Kr = Ke (1-t) (1-b)
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
29/35
Blockage cost is not given
Tax rate = 33.13 % ,Ke = 37.2 %
Kr = 37.2 (1 0.33)
=37.2*0.67
= 24.92%
Cost of retained earning = 24.92%
4 . weighted Average Cost of Capital
Weighted Average Cost of Capital =
Source of
fund
Amount (in
crore)
Proportion
%age (W)
Before tax
cost %age
After tax
cost
%age(X)
X*W
Debt 4437.49 62.2 4.7 3.14 155.3Equity 124.49 1.74 37.2 37.2 64.72Retained
earning
2571.73 36.05 24.92 24.92 898.36
Total 7133.71 W=100 X*W=1158.38
Weighted Average Cost of Capital = X*W/ W
= 1158.38/100
= 11.58 %age
So WACC = 11.56%
Year 2009
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
30/35
1. Cost of Debt:-
Kd = Interest / face value of debt
Interest = 134.09 crore ,Total debt = 2141.63crore
So Kd = 134.09*100/2141.63
= 6.26 %
Cost of debt = 6.26%
2 Cost of Equity:-
Ke = EPS/Market price
Note Market price is not given so we are considering Book Value of the
firm.
EPS = Rs. 78.48 , B V = Rs.289.22 ,
Ke = 78.48*100/289.22
= 27.13%
Cost of Equity = 27.13 %
3 Cost of Preference Share
Note- Company has not issued preference share.
4 Cost of Retained Earning:-
PBT = 1361.46 crore ,Total tax = 384.44 crore
Tax rate = 384.44*100/1361.46
= 28.23 %
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
31/35
Kr = Ke (1-t) (1-b)
Blockage cost is not given
Tax rate = 28.23 % ,Ke = 27.13 %
Kr = 27.13(1 0.28)
=27.13*0.72
= 19.53%
Cost of retained earning = 19.53%
4 . weighted Average Cost of Capital
Weighted Average Cost of Capital =
Source of
fund
Amount (in
crore)
Proportion
%age (W)
Before tax
cost %age
After tax
cost
%age(X)
X*W
Debt 2141.63 36.98 6.26 4.5 166.41Equity 124.49 2.15 22.13 22.13 58.32Retained
earning
3475.93 60.02 19.63 19.63 1172.19
total 5790,56 W=100 X*W=1396.92
Weighted Average Cost of Capital = X*W/ W
= 1396.92/100
= 13.96 %age
So WACC = 13.96%
Work note- cost of debt after tax = Kd(before tax) (1- tax rate)
= 6.26(1 0.28)
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
32/35
= 6.26*0.72
=4.5%ageNote:- Retained earning is not given so we are considering reserves.
Comparative Analysis of Cost of Capital of J K Lakshmi Cement
and Ultratech Cement Ltd:-
Cost of capital is a central concept in financial management. Cost of capital
from the firms point of view, is the minimum required rate of return that a
firm must pay to the fund suppliers, who have provide the capital. In the
other words, cost of capital is the weighted average cost of various sources
of finance used by the firm. These source are equity, preference share, long
tern debts , shout term permanent debt. The concept of cost of capital is
useful in determining optimal capital structure, investment evaluation, and
financial performance appraisal. It is an important concept in formulating a
firms capital structure , the part of financial structure that represents long
term sources, is generally defined to include only long term debt and total
stockholder investment. it may consist of single class of stock or several
issues may complicate it. The inherent
financial stability of an enterprise and risk of insolvency to which it is
exposed, primarily depends on the source of its funds as well as the type of
assets it holds and relative magnitude of such assets categories. To quote
Ezra optimum leverage is the mix of debt and equity that maximizes market
value of the firm and minimizes the firms overall cost of capital in the
optimum capital structure, the marginal real cost of each available financing
is the same. The capital structure balances the financing, so as to achieve
the lowest average cost of long-term funds. capital structure involves a study
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
33/35
of the debt-equity mix with the object of lowering the overall cost of capital
and with a view to maximizing the market value of the firms securities.
capital structure involves a study of the debt-equity mix with the object of
lowering the overall cost of capital and with a view to maximizing the market
value of the firms securities
We are going to analyzing the cost of capital of J K Lakshmi Cement and
ultratech Cement Ltd.
Cost of Equity:-
When we see the cost of equity of both the companies, the following
interpretations can be done. In the initial year as 2005 J K Lakshmi has more
cost of equity than the Ultratech Cement Ltd. Ke in 2005 20.63% and 3.97%
respectively in J K Lakshmi and Ultrateck. But in the next year Ultratech
earns more profit than J K Lakshmi and its Ke reached 36.07 % and 44.35 %
in 2007 so Ultratech has made profit quickly than the j k Lakshmi but
because Ke of Ultratech is more so it is dividing its profit among its share
holders. Both the companies are increasing their profits .These figures from
the point of view of shareholders are good and their rate of interest is
increasing but from the companys point of view it is not beneficial because
it is paying more from their profit or we can say that it is dividing its profits
among share holders. But In 2008 -09 the Ke of both companies decreasing
comparatively to its last year cost of equity. It is good sign for companies
that they are earning more profits in 2008 and 2009 but the cost of capital
is less in both companies from the last year. So it is indication that they are
dividing less their profit among share holder. A similar thing in both
companies is that profit in 2009 are decreasing and in this way the cost of
equity is also less.
Cost of Debt:-
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
34/35
8/8/2019 Sanjeev Roll No. 34
35/35
company but J K Lakshmi is believing in retaining the profit. In this case
Ultratech is more beneficial as they are paying less amount for retained
earning.
Weighted Average Cost of Capital:-
A firm obtains capital from various sources. As explained earlier, because of
the risk differences and the contractual agreements between the firm and
the investors, the cost of capital of each sources of capital differs. The cost
of capital of each source of capital is known as component cost of capital.
The combined cost of all source of capital is called average cost of capital.
The component costs are combined according to the weight of each
component capital to obtain the average costs of capital.
The figures of WACC from 2005 to 2009 are as given
WACC in J K Lakshmi Cement Ltd. 6.85% , 7.5% , 19.97% , 18.93% , 12.42% ,
In Ultratech Cement Ltd. 0.32% , 10.92% , 18.31% , 11.58% ,
13.96%
Weighted Average Cost of Capital in J K Lakshmi is increasing for three years
but later it is decreasing. It shows that later when they increasing the debt
their WACC started to decline because in the later year they are making
profit more. On the other hand Ultratech is also increasing its profit year by
year but they are not more reliable on debt so their WACC is increasing.
Although in 2008 it decrease but next year it went to upward. The figure
show that the WACC bearded by J K Lakshmi is decreasing but in Ultratech it
is Increasing so it is not good sign for Ultratech.