Upload
nicolas-bratu
View
222
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
1/35
PRESENTS
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board, or SASDB(registration number: 026-935-NPO). You may use or reproduce it in whole or in part for non-
profit purposes as long as you acknowledge the authorship of the SASDB. Should you wish to
use this content for profit, please contact the SASDB.
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
2/35
2
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
Table of Contents
4
D? 5
D? 6
M
I
7
7
7
7
8
9
?
D
C
11
11
13
F
F
14
14
15
17
18
19
19
20
A 22
B A 24
30
30
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
3/35
3
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
I D
D
31
32
34
C 35
Acknowledgements
I ,
A , F D M . D,
.. ...
.
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
4/35
4
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
Introduction to the handbook
A D C 2001,
A ,
. , 2012 D C C ,
.
D C
.
,
. I , .
,
. I :
,
, ,
, .
A D B (ADB),
A. ADB ...
, F.
H !
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
5/35
5
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
Why Debate?
C I , . E .
C D , . ,
.
I , E H .
. M,
. M
A .
D . M
. E , A
:
,
. I , .
E : , AID, ,
I ,
.
And most of all
! , , .
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
6/35
6
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
What is debating?
A ( )
. . B
.
, , .
,
, , .
A
, .
( I )
.
J
. ,
.
, .
( .)
So, lets have a look at the rules
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
7/35
7
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
The Rules
. II, , . II,
( ). E ,
.
. E
. . I
,
, . ,
.
A ,
,
. ,
. .
, .
, .
.
,
.
:
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
8/35
8
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
( I) . I
,
. .
,
.
, .
F, , . I
,
.
, .
, . I
, ,
. I , .
I , , ?
? , ?. .I ,
. I 15 ,
, .
, .
( ),
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
9/35
9
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
, .
I 15 . I ,
. . I
,
.
I , ,
. I , ,
, .
, .
. A I
.
I , 2 . A ,
. A ,
. A 2
,
1 2 . I ,
1 . B ,
2!
F, I
, I
. I , .
A , , 8 .
4 . (
7 /3 , .)
.
, .
( ), .
,
.
8 ,
. I ,
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
10/35
10
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
. I 30 (20
) . ,
, .
I , ,
. , , . ,
30 .
I , :
0 1 minute Nobody can offer points ofinformation
1 7 minutes Points of information are allowed
7 8 minutes No more points of information are
allowed. Start finishing your speech
After 8 minutes You have 30 seconds before thetimekeeper will start banging non-
stop
A , :
0 3 minutes
The main part of your speech(Nobody can offer points of
information)3 4 minutes Start finishing your speech
After 4 minutes You have 30 seconds before thetimekeeper will start banging
non-stop
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
11/35
11
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
So how do we start a debate?
,
.
. I , .
D
. DE
! I,
, .
,
.
F , A I,
A I
. D ,
( ), , , A
, ? A ,
,
.
A, ,
. , 2006 M
D
M M.
.
M,
.
I , .
, . F
,
A, . A, , .
. F ,
,
. , .
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
12/35
12
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
I , ,
. , ,
,
, . ,
.
I , .
! A
.
A :
()
I (.. )
, E. B
.
() I . , 18
C, ( 18
C) ( ).
G
A (
). A
.
() , . (
M .) .
I , . I
,
. .
C :
() .()E .() , .()C
B !
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
13/35
13
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
C
I ,
. F , ,
, .
.
I
.
18 ,
.
I , , .
H, . I
,
, .
So, now that everything is clearly set up, what happens?
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
14/35
14
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
Speaker Roles: What each speaker does
E . I
, .
. E , ,
, . ,
. I
.
First Proposition
F ,
. I , . , :
E
E. E. E. E. I
,
. . I
,
,
. A . . M
, .
, :
1. D2. 3. ( )
.
C
. I ,
. I
.
. F :
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
15/35
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
16/35
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
17/35
17
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
.
. F
, A.
! ( F
.)
Second Proposition
. H
,
.
. ,
. , ,
.
: . D
. ,
.
.
.
.
. H,
. F ,
B A .
.
. F
, A.
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
18/35
18
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
! ( F
.)
Second Opposition
.
,
( , ).
. ,
. , ,
.
: . D
. ,
.
.
.
.
. H,
. A
(
),
. F
, B A .
.
. F
, A.
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
19/35
19
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
! ( F
.)
Third Proposition
. .
A .
. ,
. , ,
. I ,
. I,
, .
,
.
,
, ,
. .
, . I
, .
.
! ( F
.)
Third Opposition
. .
A .
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
20/35
20
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
. ,
. , ,
. I ,
. I,
, .
,
.
,
, ,
. .
,
. I ( ),
.
.
! ( F
.)
Reply Speeches
A ,
. I
, .
4 , ,
. ,
, .
,
(
), . A,
, . ,
, . (
.)
. A,
.
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
21/35
21
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
I .
, .
, .
One last reminder
D !
,
.
,
. D
.
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
22/35
22
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
Making arguments
,
. I ,
. B , ?
. F,
. ,
,
.
? ,
, .
, , , . F ,
? H
? , :
.
( .)
A
.
( .)
.
? ,
. I ,
,
!
, .
. H
, H .
.
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
23/35
23
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
I .
E ,
. .
, D L. B
! A . . ,
. (A .)
( )
.
,
. I ,
/ ,
/ . D ,
.
:
() ( ) ,
.
A
/.
.() ( )
, .
A
.
.
. , ,
C, ! J
, .
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
24/35
24
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
Breaking Arguments: The Handy Guide To Fighting Proof
(A.k.a. How to rebut arguments)
,
. I . A ,
, (
). , ,
. , ,
, . L :
,
.
A
.
.
.
A
. H
? :
.
A
.
, .
( .)
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
25/35
25
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
C
I ,
. I , ,
.
() . F ,
, , ,
, A (
) , (
) .
.
( ,
.)
()E , , .
, ,
, , . ,
(
).
() , .
. F ,
A ,
A ,
, .
, .
D .
.
A . ,
. ,
. , ,
, .
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
26/35
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
27/35
27
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
.
, .
. ? ?
? ? A :
.
.
, .
, . . (E
? A ?) A
.
A .
A
,
,
. ,
, .
, M .
B :
, .
, M
A , .
A , !
! ,
.
A G , ,
B. , G B . I , . ,
( ).
A ,
!
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
28/35
28
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
!
. I ,
.
,
! I , , . B
. I
, .
C
,
, . :
, .
G ,
B G. A B G
G .
.
A (.. )
,
, . B
,
.
.
A :
: .
: .
.
? A , B
, .. .
I ,
, .
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
29/35
29
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
( )
, ,
, ,
, ,
! .
( CA)
.
, CA ! (
, .) I
, , , :
, ,
,
, . .
. . I ,
, ,
. I ,
.
C
.
, ,
? ,
. D . I .
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
30/35
30
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
Preparing for a debate
Three types of motions
,
. .
1. C .. ,
,
.
C . ,
:
. ( ,
).
. E ( ).
. J , ( ,
).
, . ,
!. A ( ).. A (..
).
. A (.. , ).
J () () (). B
. A .
. CA
, : . B ,
.
.
2. D (.. ).. ,
,
.
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
31/35
31
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
, , . I , :
. /, /, .. / (
).
I
( ),
.
3. E .. ,
,
2009 .
I :
. (, /
)
. ( ) ( ).
Impromptu Debates .
. ,
, ,
.
.
.
.
K , ,
. A
,
.
I ,
. I ,
.
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
32/35
32
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
, ,
, ,
.
. . . D
,
.
H :
05 : I ( , ,
)
515 : ( )
1525 : D ,
, .
2545 : D .
4560 : (
).
Prepared Debates
.
, , . ,
. , ,
. :
1. I . E , , .
? ?
A ? E
.
2. . I , . G . I
,
. (..
). .
3. , ( ).
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
33/35
33
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
4. . , . D (
).
5. A , .
, !
. ,
. ,
. , .
And remember
D , .
. .
EAM , ,
, ,
.
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
34/35
34
This manual is the intellectual property of the South African Schools Debating Board.
Style(A.k.a. How you speak)
D . A
. , , . A
.
. , ,
, .
.
. H,
, . H :
: . A
, .
E : , , . ! D
.
:D .B 7 . . J
.
: . , ,
. I .
: , . ,
. A
. ,
.
D : I , .
LIG D, LDL FL, AIG
, .
. D . , .A, . ( .)
8/13/2019 SASDB Handboook How to Debate
35/35
Conclusion
I , !
A. B
! , .
,
A . ,
!
F , :
A D B: .... .
, , , .
.
D: ... , ,
C. I ,
,
.
D A: ://../.. , ,
.
A C D : ....
.
D C:... D C.
: ... , .