Click here to load reader

SCHEDULE “C” AVENUE EXTENSION MUNICIPAL CLASS ENVIRONMENTAL€¦ · Milliken Main Street Landowners Group Inc. Phase 1 – EA Process Problem Statement Problem Statement “To

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    MU

    NIC

    IPA

    L C

    LASS

    EN

    VIR

    ON

    MEN

    TAL

    ASSESSM

    EN

    T F

    OR

    MID

    LAN

    D

    AV

    EN

    UE E

    XTEN

    SIO

    N

    SC

    HED

    ULE

    “C

    MID

    LAN

    D A

    VEN

    UE

    EXTE

    NSIO

    N(F

    RO

    M S

    TEEL

    ES A

    VEN

    UE

    TO

    OLD

    KEN

    NED

    Y R

    OA

    D)

    City o

    f M

    ark

    ham

    Deve

    lopm

    ent

    Serv

    ices

    Com

    mitte

    e

    May 5

    th, 2

    01

    5

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pre

    sent

    ation

    to D

    SC

    Ba

    ckg

    roun

    d inf

    orm

    ation

    –M

    unic

    ipa

    l C

    lass

    En

    viro

    nment

    al A

    ssess

    ment

    (C

    lass

    EA

    ) fo

    r M

    idla

    nd

    Ave

    nue E

    xte

    nsio

    n

    Rep

    ort

    on

    stud

    y p

    roce

    ss

    Pre

    sent

    the

    pro

    pose

    d T

    ech

    nica

    lly P

    refe

    rred

    A

    lignm

    ent

    and

    cro

    ss s

    ect

    ion

    Req

    uest

    aut

    hori

    zation

    to f

    ile the

    Env

    ironm

    ent

    al

    Stu

    dy R

    ep

    ort

    (ES

    R) to

    the

    Min

    istr

    y o

    f En

    viro

    nment

    a

    nd C

    lima

    te C

    hang

    e (M

    OEC

    C) fo

    r m

    and

    ato

    ry 3

    0

    day p

    ublic

    revi

    ew

    peri

    od

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Ba

    ckg

    roun

    d –

    Need

    and

    Jus

    tifi

    cation

    M

    ain

    Str

    eet M

    illik

    en

    Seco

    nda

    ry P

    lan,

    OPA

    14

    4

    Pro

    ject

    ed

    mix

    ed

    use

    com

    mun

    ity c

    om

    pri

    sing

    of:

    A

    pp

    rox. 1

    ,90

    0 r

    esi

    dent

    ial un

    its

    / 4

    ,70

    0 p

    op

    ula

    tion

    A

    pp

    rox. 5

    1,0

    00

    m2

    com

    merc

    ial/

    reta

    il us

    es

    A

    dditio

    nal no

    rth/

    sout

    h ro

    ad c

    apaci

    ty is

    requi

    red to s

    erv

    e

    com

    mun

    ity a

    t fu

    ll d

    eve

    lop

    ment

    .

    M

    idla

    nd A

    venu

    e e

    xte

    nsio

    n w

    as

    ident

    ifie

    d a

    s a

    key

    nort

    h/so

    uth

    min

    or

    collect

    or

    roa

    d in

    July

    20

    06

    to s

    atisf

    y

    OPA

    14

    4 tra

    nsp

    ort

    ation

    req

    uire

    ment

    s.

    O

    PA 1

    44

    reco

    mm

    end

    ed

    to c

    om

    ple

    te a

    Cla

    ss E

    A f

    or

    Mid

    land

    Ave

    nue to id

    ent

    ify the

    ap

    pro

    pri

    ate

    alig

    nment

    .

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Mun

    icip

    al C

    lass

    EA

    Pro

    cess

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 1

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Pro

    ble

    m S

    tate

    ment

    Pro

    ble

    m S

    tate

    ment

    “T

    o d

    ete

    rmin

    e the

    pre

    ferr

    ed

    alig

    nment

    of

    the M

    idla

    nd A

    venu

    e

    exte

    nsio

    n fr

    om

    Ste

    ele

    s A

    venu

    e to O

    ld K

    enn

    edy R

    oa

    d w

    hich

    p

    rovi

    des

    an

    ad

    eq

    uate

    tra

    nsp

    ort

    ation

    netw

    ork

    to s

    upp

    ort

    the

    exis

    ting

    and

    fut

    ure d

    eve

    lop

    ment

    s w

    ithi

    n C

    ity o

    f M

    ark

    ham

    , in

    a

    ccord

    anc

    e w

    ith

    the J

    uly 2

    00

    6, M

    ain

    Str

    eet M

    illik

    en

    Seco

    nda

    ry P

    lan,

    OPA

    14

    4, a

    s a

    mend

    ed

    .”

    O

    bje

    ctiv

    es

    C

    onf

    irm

    need

    and

    jus

    tifi

    cation

    for

    pro

    ject

    Sup

    port

    the

    deve

    lop

    ment

    s in

    acc

    ord

    anc

    e w

    ith

    OPA

    14

    4

    D

    ete

    rmin

    e c

    ross

    -sect

    ions

    inc

    lud

    ing

    num

    ber

    of

    lane

    s, b

    ike la

    nes,

    sid

    ew

    alk

    s a

    nd s

    treets

    cap

    e

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 2

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Altern

    ative

    Solu

    tions

    A

    ltern

    ative

    1 –

    Do N

    oth

    ing

    A

    ltern

    ative

    2 –

    Tra

    vel D

    em

    and

    Ma

    nagem

    ent

    (TD

    M) M

    ea

    sure

    s

    A

    ltern

    ative

    3 –

    Imp

    rove

    tra

    nsp

    ort

    ation

    op

    era

    tions

    alo

    ng p

    ara

    llel ro

    adw

    ays

    A

    ltern

    ative

    4 –

    Wid

    en

    oth

    er

    exis

    ting

    roa

    dw

    ays

    A

    ltern

    ative

    5 –

    Exte

    nd M

    idla

    nd A

    venu

    e f

    rom

    Ste

    ele

    s A

    venu

    e to O

    ld

    Kenn

    edy R

    oa

    d

    A

    ll 5

    altern

    ative

    s w

    ere

    revi

    ew

    ed

    in

    deta

    il, ho

    weve

    r A

    ltern

    ative

    s 1

    -4 d

    id n

    ot

    add

    ress

    the

    pro

    ble

    m s

    tate

    ment

    .

    A

    ltern

    ative

    5 w

    as

    sele

    cted

    to p

    roce

    ed

    to P

    hase

    3 o

    f th

    e C

    lass

    EA

    pro

    cess

    .

    W

    ithi

    n A

    ltern

    ative

    5: 8

    dif

    fere

    nt c

    onc

    ep

    tual a

    lig

    nment

    op

    tions

    were

    ini

    tia

    lly

    ident

    ifie

    d a

    s a

    ltern

    ative

    s to

    ad

    dre

    ss the

    pro

    ble

    m s

    tate

    ment

    . O

    ut o

    f th

    e 8

    Conc

    ep

    tua

    l a

    lignm

    ent

    s, 4

    alig

    nment

    s w

    ere

    carr

    ied

    forw

    ard

    for

    deta

    iled

    ass

    ess

    ment

    .

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Alig

    nment

    Option

    #1

    SU

    N Y

    AT

    -SE

    N A

    VE

    NU

    E

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Alig

    nment

    Option

    #2

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Alig

    nment

    Option

    #3

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Alig

    nment

    Option

    #4

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Deta

    iled

    Inv

    ent

    ory

    of

    Envi

    ronm

    ent

    s

    Sup

    port

    ing

    Tech

    nica

    l In

    vest

    iga

    tions

    :

    Tra

    ffic

    Im

    pa

    ct A

    ssess

    ment

    (Poul

    os

    & C

    hung

    Lim

    ited

    )

    A

    ir Q

    uality

    Ass

    ess

    ment

    (W

    SP C

    ana

    da

    Inc

    .)

    En

    viro

    nment

    al Im

    pa

    ct A

    ssess

    ment

    (A

    zim

    uth

    Envi

    ronm

    ent

    al C

    ons

    ulting

    , In

    c.)

    N

    ois

    e Im

    pa

    ct A

    ssess

    ment

    (J.

    E. C

    oul

    ter

    Ass

    oci

    ate

    s Li

    mited

    )

    Sta

    ge 1

    Arc

    haeolo

    gic

    al A

    ssess

    ment

    (A

    rcha

    eolo

    gic

    al Serv

    ices

    Inc.

    )

    G

    eote

    chni

    cal In

    vest

    iga

    tion

    Sum

    mary

    (M

    aso

    ngso

    ng A

    ssoci

    ate

    s En

    gin

    eeri

    ng

    Lim

    ited

    ; in

    sup

    port

    of

    vari

    ous

    ind

    ep

    end

    ent

    stu

    die

    s)

    Serv

    icin

    g O

    ptions

    (In

    fra

    stru

    ctur

    e &

    Pre

    lim

    ina

    ry E

    ngin

    eeri

    ng D

    esi

    gn

    incl

    udin

    g

    Pro

    pose

    d C

    ross

    Sect

    ions

    ) (M

    aso

    ngso

    ng A

    ssoci

    ate

    s En

    gin

    eeri

    ng L

    imited

    )

    C

    ost

    Est

    ima

    te o

    f A

    lig

    nment

    Op

    tions

    1-4

    (M

    aso

    ngso

    ng A

    ssoci

    ate

    s En

    gin

    eeri

    ng L

    imited

    )

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Evalu

    ation M

    atr

    ix

    2. C

    ultu

    ral En

    viro

    nment

    a)

    Heri

    tage F

    ea

    ture

    s

    b)

    Cul

    tura

    l La

    ndsc

    ap

    es

    c)A

    rcha

    eolo

    gic

    al re

    sour

    ces

    1. N

    atu

    ral En

    viro

    nment

    a)

    Terr

    est

    rial

    b)

    Aq

    uatic

    c)G

    roun

    dw

    ate

    r

    d)

    Sur

    face

    Dra

    ina

    ge

    3. Soci

    o-E

    cono

    mic

    Env

    ironm

    ent

    a)

    Land

    Use

    b)

    Nois

    e

    c)C

    om

    mun

    itie

    s (ind

    ivid

    ual p

    rop

    ert

    y,

    com

    mun

    ity c

    onn

    ect

    ivity a

    nd a

    meni

    ties)

    d)

    Air

    Qua

    lity

    4. Tr

    ans

    port

    ation/

    Utilit

    ies

    a)

    Tra

    nsp

    ort

    ation

    Netw

    ork

    (ca

    pa

    city

    , a

    ccess

    )

    b)

    Tra

    nsp

    ort

    ation

    Policy

    Com

    pa

    tib

    ility

    (tra

    nsit, a

    ctiv

    e tra

    nsp

    ort

    ation)

    c)M

    unic

    ipa

    l Serv

    ices

    (cha

    nges

    and

    op

    port

    unitie

    s)

    d)

    Utilities

    Imp

    act

    5. Fi

    nanc

    ial/

    Tech

    nica

    l

    a)

    Land

    to b

    e P

    urch

    ase

    d

    b)

    Cons

    truc

    tion

    Cost

    c)O

    pera

    tion

    and

    Ma

    inte

    nanc

    e

    d)

    Mun

    icip

    al Bud

    get C

    om

    pa

    tib

    ility

    e)

    Roa

    d G

    eom

    etr

    ic D

    esi

    gn

    f)Str

    uctu

    ral/

    Pave

    ment

    /To

    pog

    raphy

    /

    Cons

    truc

    tability R

    eq

    uire

    ment

    s

    g)

    Sta

    gin

    g R

    eq

    uire

    ment

    s

    5 M

    ajo

    r C

    ate

    gories

    of

    Cons

    idera

    tion

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Evalu

    ation M

    atr

    ix S

    umm

    ary

    CA

    TEG

    OR

    IES

    OF

    CO

    NSI

    DER

    ATI

    ON

    ALI

    GN

    MEN

    T O

    PTI

    ON

    S

    Alig

    nm

    ent

    Op

    tio

    n #

    1A

    lign

    men

    t O

    pti

    on

    #2

    Alig

    nm

    ent

    Op

    tio

    n #

    3A

    lign

    men

    t O

    pti

    on

    #4

    Sun

    Yat

    Sen

    Ave

    . In

    ters

    ect

    ion

    at

    Old

    K

    enn

    edy

    Rd

    .

    Ce

    lad

    ine

    Dr.

    In

    ters

    ect

    ion

    at

    Old

    K

    enn

    edy

    Rd

    .

    Sun

    rise

    Dr.

    In

    ters

    ect

    ion

    at

    Old

    K

    enn

    edy

    Rd

    .

    Co

    nti

    nu

    ou

    s R

    oad

    w

    ith

    Old

    Ken

    ned

    y R

    d.

    Nat

    ura

    l En

    viro

    nm

    ent

    (20

    %)

    6.0

    6.0

    9.0

    9.0

    Cu

    ltu

    ral E

    nvi

    ron

    men

    t (2

    0%

    )5

    .06

    .37

    .77

    .7

    Soci

    o-E

    con

    om

    ic E

    nvi

    ron

    men

    t (2

    0%

    )3

    .85

    .38

    .86

    .0

    Tran

    spo

    rtat

    ion

    / U

    tilit

    ies

    (20

    %)

    4.8

    5.3

    8.3

    8.8

    Fin

    anci

    al/

    Tech

    nic

    al (

    20

    %)

    7.6

    7.3

    6.9

    5.1

    Tota

    l No

    rmal

    ized

    Sco

    re =

    5

    .46

    .08

    .17

    .3

    PR

    EFER

    RED

    0-2

    2.1

    -44.1

    -66.1

    -88.1

    -10

    Lea

    st P

    refe

    rred

    Most

    Pre

    ferr

    ed

    Sco

    ring

    Defi

    nition:

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Pre

    ferr

    ed A

    lignm

    ent

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Pre

    ferr

    ed

    Alig

    nment

    Cro

    ss S

    ect

    ions

    Sect

    ion

    A-A

    : 2

    6m

    Rig

    ht

    Of

    Way

    Sect

    ion B

    -B:

    23

    m R

    ight

    of

    Way

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Pre

    ferr

    ed A

    lignm

    ent

    Adva

    ntages

    Th

    e m

    ain

    crite

    ria t

    hat co

    ntribut

    e t

    o A

    lignm

    ent

    Option

    #3 a

    s p

    refe

    rred

    are

    as

    follo

    ws:

    Th

    is a

    lig

    nment

    pro

    vid

    es

    a tra

    nsp

    ort

    ation

    netw

    ork

    to s

    upp

    ort

    d

    eve

    lopm

    ent

    s fo

    r M

    illike

    n (O

    PA 1

    44).

    Best

    reso

    lution

    of

    the C

    lass

    EA

    pro

    ble

    m s

    tate

    ment

    (a

    dd

    itio

    nal

    nort

    h/so

    uth

    min

    or

    collect

    or

    roa

    d).

    Pro

    vid

    es

    better

    inte

    rsect

    ion

    op

    era

    tions

    and

    desi

    gn

    conf

    igur

    ations

    .

    H

    igh

    op

    port

    unity f

    or

    enh

    anc

    ed

    na

    tura

    l env

    ironm

    ent

    cond

    itio

    ns, i.e.

    gro

    undw

    ate

    r re

    cha

    rge a

    nd im

    pro

    ved

    sto

    rmw

    ate

    r q

    uality

    .

    Rela

    tive

    ly low

    im

    pa

    ct to b

    oth

    exis

    ting

    and

    ap

    pro

    ved

    la

    nd u

    ses.

    M

    inim

    al to

    no im

    pact

    to e

    xis

    ting

    resi

    denc

    es

    on

    Cela

    din

    eD

    rive

    and

    p

    lann

    ed

    seni

    or’s

    hous

    ing

    (lo

    ng term

    ca

    re f

    aci

    lity

    ) on

    Sun

    Ya

    t-Sen

    Ave

    nue.

    N

    o a

    dve

    rse im

    pa

    ct to c

    hurc

    h p

    rop

    ert

    y.

    M

    inim

    al im

    pa

    ct to h

    eri

    tage r

    eso

    urce

    s.

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Pre

    limin

    ary

    Cost

    Est

    imate

    Pre

    limin

    ary

    Cost

    Est

    ima

    te:

    To

    tal C

    ost

    = $

    1.2

    M c

    ons

    truc

    tion

    + p

    rop

    ert

    y c

    ost

    D

    eve

    lop

    er

    Cost

    8

    6%

    of

    cons

    truc

    tion

    + 1

    00

    % p

    rop

    ert

    y

    cost

    C

    ity o

    f M

    ark

    ham

    Cost

    1

    4%

    of

    cons

    truc

    tion

    (DC

    cityw

    ide

    hard

    deve

    lop

    ment

    )

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Sta

    tuto

    ry &

    Non-S

    tatu

    tory

    Cons

    ulta

    tion

    N

    otice

    of

    Stu

    dy C

    om

    menc

    em

    ent

    M

    ailed

    to r

    esi

    dent

    s w

    ithi

    n th

    e s

    tudy a

    rea

    and

    agenc

    ies

    on

    Feb

    rua

    ry 1

    2th, 2

    01

    4

    A

    dve

    rtis

    ed

    in the N

    ew

    spa

    per

    Feb

    rua

    ry 1

    3th, 2

    01

    4 &

    Feb

    rua

    ry 2

    0th, 2014

    PIC

    #1

    –M

    ay 1

    4th, 2

    014

    M

    aile

    d to r

    esi

    dents

    withi

    n th

    e s

    tudy a

    rea

    and

    agenc

    ies

    A

    dve

    rtis

    ed

    in

    the N

    ew

    spa

    per

    Ap

    ril 2

    4th, 2

    01

    4 &

    May 8

    th, 2

    01

    4

    PIC

    #2

    –N

    ove

    mb

    er

    11

    th, 2

    014

    M

    aile

    d to r

    esi

    dents

    withi

    n th

    e s

    tudy a

    rea

    and

    agenc

    ies

    A

    dve

    rtis

    ed

    in the N

    ew

    spa

    per

    Oct

    ob

    er

    23

    rd, 2

    01

    4 &

    Nove

    mber

    6th, 2014

    Pri

    vate

    la

    ndow

    ner

    meeting

    s

    Various

    info

    rma

    l m

    eeting

    s w

    ith a

    ffect

    ed

    la

    nd

    ow

    ners

    and

    landow

    ners

    gro

    up

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Next Ste

    ps

    Sub

    ject

    to C

    oun

    cil’s

    End

    ors

    em

    ent

    , fi

    le t

    he

    Envi

    ronm

    ent

    al Stu

    dy R

    ep

    ort

    (ES

    R) w

    ith

    the M

    inistr

    y o

    f

    the E

    nvironm

    ent

    and

    Clim

    ate

    Cha

    nge (M

    OEC

    C) in

    June

    20

    15

    for

    30

    day m

    and

    ato

    ry p

    ublic

    revi

    ew

    period

    A

    ntic

    ipa

    ted

    desi

    gn

    com

    ple

    tion

    Sum

    mer

    20

    16

    A

    ntic

    ipa

    ted

    pro

    pert

    y a

    cqui

    sition

    –W

    inte

    r 2

    01

    6/2

    01

    7

    A

    ntic

    ipa

    ted

    sta

    rt o

    f co

    nstr

    uction

    –Sum

    mer/

    Fall 2

    01

    7(s

    ubje

    ct t

    o p

    ropert

    y a

    cqui

    sition)

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Ad

    ditio

    nal Slid

    es

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Evalu

    ation M

    atr

    ix

    CA

    TEG

    OR

    IES

    OF

    CO

    NSI

    DER

    ATI

    ON

    CR

    ITER

    IA

    ALI

    GN

    MEN

    T O

    PT

    ION

    S

    Alig

    nm

    ent

    Op

    tio

    n #

    1A

    lign

    men

    t O

    pti

    on

    #2

    Alig

    nm

    en

    t O

    pti

    on

    #3

    Alig

    nm

    ent

    Op

    tio

    n #

    4

    Def

    init

    ion

    sSu

    n Y

    at S

    en

    Ave

    . In

    ters

    ecti

    on

    at

    Old

    K

    enn

    ed

    y R

    d.

    Cel

    adin

    e D

    r. In

    ters

    ecti

    on

    at

    Old

    Ken

    ned

    y R

    d.

    Sun

    rise

    Dr.

    Inte

    rsec

    tio

    n a

    t O

    ld K

    enn

    edy

    Rd

    .C

    on

    tin

    uo

    us

    Ro

    ad w

    ith

    Old

    Ken

    ned

    y R

    d.

    Sco

    reN

    ote

    sSc

    ore

    No

    tes

    Sco

    reN

    ote

    sSc

    ore

    No

    tes

    Nat

    ura

    l En

    viro

    nm

    ent

    Terr

    estr

    ial -

    Imp

    acts

    to

    wet

    lan

    ds;

    V

    eget

    atio

    n c

    om

    mu

    nit

    y m

    ort

    alit

    y/st

    ress

    /co

    mp

    osi

    tio

    n c

    han

    ge;

    Rem

    ova

    l of

    sign

    ific

    ant

    tree

    s/gr

    ou

    nd

    flo

    ra;

    Red

    uct

    ion

    /det

    erio

    rati

    on

    of

    or

    oth

    er

    chan

    ges

    to w

    ildlif

    e h

    abit

    at

    10Th

    ere

    are

    no

    exi

    stin

    g w

    etla

    nd

    s in

    th

    e st

    ud

    y ar

    ea. A

    ll la

    nd

    wit

    hin

    th

    e st

    ud

    y ar

    ea is

    hig

    hly

    urb

    aniz

    ed

    and

    has

    alr

    ead

    y b

    een

    imp

    acte

    d

    by

    hu

    man

    use

    . Th

    ere

    are

    no

    p

    rovi

    nci

    ally

    or

    regi

    on

    ally

    si

    gnif

    ican

    t p

    lan

    t sp

    ecie

    s o

    bse

    rved

    w

    ith

    in t

    he

    stu

    dy

    area

    . No

    ne

    of

    the

    pro

    po

    sed

    op

    tio

    ns

    for

    the

    Mid

    lan

    d A

    ven

    ue

    exte

    nsi

    on

    im

    pac

    ts s

    ign

    ific

    ant

    wild

    life

    hab

    itat

    feat

    ure

    s o

    r fu

    nct

    ion

    s as

    d

    efin

    ed b

    y th

    e P

    rovi

    nci

    al P

    olic

    y St

    atem

    ent.

    10Th

    ere

    are

    no

    exi

    stin

    g w

    etla

    nd

    s in

    th

    e st

    ud

    y ar

    ea. A

    ll la

    nd

    wit

    hin

    th

    e st

    ud

    y ar

    ea is

    hig

    hly

    urb

    aniz

    ed

    and

    has

    alr

    ead

    y b

    een

    imp

    acte

    d

    by

    hu

    man

    use

    . Th

    ere

    are

    no

    p

    rovi

    nci

    ally

    or

    regi

    on

    ally

    si

    gnif

    ican

    t p

    lan

    t sp

    ecie

    s o

    bse

    rved

    w

    ith

    in t

    he

    stu

    dy

    area

    . No

    ne

    of

    the

    pro

    po

    sed

    op

    tio

    ns

    for

    the

    Mid

    lan

    d A

    ven

    ue

    exte

    nsi

    on

    im

    pac

    ts s

    ign

    ific

    ant

    wild

    life

    hab

    itat

    feat

    ure

    s o

    r fu

    nct

    ion

    s as

    d

    efin

    ed b

    y th

    e P

    rovi

    nci

    al P

    olic

    y St

    atem

    ent.

    10Th

    ere

    are

    no

    exi

    stin

    g w

    etla

    nd

    s in

    th

    e st

    ud

    y ar

    ea. A

    ll la

    nd

    wit

    hin

    th

    e st

    ud

    y ar

    ea is

    hig

    hly

    urb

    aniz

    ed

    and

    has

    alr

    ead

    y b

    een

    imp

    acte

    d

    by

    hu

    man

    use

    . Th

    ere

    are

    no

    p

    rovi

    nci

    ally

    or

    regi

    on

    ally

    si

    gnif

    ican

    t p

    lan

    t sp

    ecie

    s o

    bse

    rved

    w

    ith

    in t

    he

    stu

    dy

    area

    . No

    ne

    of

    the

    pro

    po

    sed

    op

    tio

    ns

    for

    the

    Mid

    lan

    d A

    ven

    ue

    exte

    nsi

    on

    im

    pac

    ts s

    ign

    ific

    ant

    wild

    life

    hab

    itat

    feat

    ure

    s o

    r fu

    nct

    ion

    s as

    d

    efin

    ed b

    y th

    e P

    rovi

    nci

    al P

    olic

    y St

    atem

    ent.

    10Th

    ere

    are

    no

    exi

    stin

    g w

    etla

    nd

    s in

    th

    e st

    ud

    y ar

    ea. A

    ll la

    nd

    wit

    hin

    th

    e st

    ud

    y ar

    ea is

    hig

    hly

    urb

    aniz

    ed

    and

    has

    alr

    ead

    y b

    een

    imp

    acte

    d

    by

    hu

    man

    use

    . Th

    ere

    are

    no

    p

    rovi

    nci

    ally

    or

    regi

    on

    ally

    si

    gnif

    ican

    t p

    lan

    t sp

    ecie

    s o

    bse

    rved

    w

    ith

    in t

    he

    stu

    dy

    area

    . No

    ne

    of

    the

    pro

    po

    sed

    op

    tio

    ns

    for

    the

    Mid

    lan

    d A

    ven

    ue

    exte

    nsi

    on

    im

    pac

    ts s

    ign

    ific

    ant

    wild

    life

    hab

    itat

    feat

    ure

    s o

    r fu

    nct

    ion

    s as

    d

    efin

    ed b

    y th

    e P

    rovi

    nci

    al P

    olic

    y St

    atem

    ent.

    Aq

    uat

    ic -

    Rem

    ova

    l/ch

    ange

    of

    exis

    tin

    g h

    abit

    at (

    incl

    ud

    ing

    foo

    d/s

    hel

    ter)

    ; C

    han

    ge in

    w

    ater

    qu

    alit

    y, b

    asef

    low

    /wat

    er t

    able

    ; C

    on

    stru

    ctio

    n t

    imin

    g im

    pac

    ts o

    n

    spaw

    nin

    g/n

    urs

    ery

    area

    s

    10Th

    ere

    is n

    o e

    xist

    ing

    aqu

    atic

    h

    abit

    at.

    10Th

    ere

    is n

    o e

    xist

    ing

    aqu

    atic

    h

    abit

    at.

    10Th

    ere

    is n

    o e

    xist

    ing

    aqu

    atic

    h

    abit

    at.

    10Th

    ere

    is n

    o e

    xist

    ing

    aqu

    atic

    h

    abit

    at.

    Gro

    un

    dw

    ater

    -C

    han

    ges

    to g

    rou

    nd

    wat

    er

    rech

    arge

    /dis

    char

    ge a

    reas

    , qu

    anti

    ty a

    nd

    q

    ual

    ity;

    Inte

    rfer

    ence

    wit

    h g

    rou

    nd

    wat

    er

    mo

    vem

    ent

    2Th

    ere

    is n

    o in

    filt

    rati

    on

    an

    tici

    pat

    ed, a

    nd

    no

    inte

    rfer

    ence

    w

    ith

    gro

    un

    dw

    ater

    mo

    vem

    ent

    as

    the

    wat

    er t

    able

    is b

    elo

    w 4

    m f

    rom

    su

    rfac

    e.

    2Th

    ere

    is n

    o in

    filt

    rati

    on

    an

    tici

    pat

    ed, a

    nd

    no

    inte

    rfer

    ence

    w

    ith

    gro

    un

    dw

    ater

    mo

    vem

    ent

    as

    the

    wat

    er t

    able

    is b

    elo

    w 4

    m f

    rom

    su

    rfac

    e.

    8Th

    ere

    is h

    igh

    po

    ten

    tial

    fo

    r in

    filt

    rati

    on

    (si

    ngl

    e lo

    aded

    ro

    ad),

    an

    d n

    o in

    terf

    eren

    ce w

    ith

    gr

    ou

    nd

    wat

    er m

    ove

    men

    t as

    th

    e w

    ater

    tab

    le is

    bel

    ow

    4m

    fro

    m

    surf

    ace.

    8Th

    ere

    is h

    igh

    po

    ten

    tial

    fo

    r in

    filt

    rati

    on

    (si

    ngl

    e lo

    aded

    ro

    ad),

    an

    d n

    o in

    terf

    eren

    ce w

    ith

    gr

    ou

    nd

    wat

    er m

    ove

    men

    t as

    th

    e w

    ater

    tab

    le is

    bel

    ow

    4m

    fro

    m

    surf

    ace.

    Surf

    ace

    Dra

    inag

    e -

    Div

    ersi

    on

    /ch

    ann

    eliz

    atio

    n o

    f w

    ater

    cou

    rses

    ; D

    rain

    age

    catc

    hm

    ents

    ; Ch

    ange

    s to

    flo

    od

    p

    lain

    fu

    nct

    ion

    ; St

    orm

    wat

    er m

    anag

    emen

    t o

    pp

    ort

    un

    itie

    s

    2A

    s p

    er t

    he

    app

    rove

    d M

    aste

    r D

    rain

    age

    Pla

    n, s

    torm

    dra

    inag

    e w

    ill b

    e d

    iver

    ted

    to

    th

    e ex

    isti

    ng

    ou

    tlet

    pro

    vid

    ed a

    nd

    ove

    rsiz

    ed

    thro

    ugh

    th

    e ex

    isti

    ng

    sub

    div

    isio

    n

    (Ris

    ebo

    rou

    gh P

    has

    e 4)

    to

    th

    e ea

    st. T

    her

    e is

    litt

    le t

    o n

    o

    op

    po

    rtu

    nit

    y fo

    r st

    orm

    wat

    er

    man

    agem

    ent

    du

    e to

    exi

    stin

    g ap

    pro

    ved

    dev

    elo

    pm

    ents

    .

    2A

    s p

    er t

    he

    app

    rove

    d M

    aste

    r D

    rain

    age

    Pla

    n, s

    torm

    dra

    inag

    e w

    ill b

    e d

    iver

    ted

    to

    th

    e ex

    isti

    ng

    ou

    tlet

    pro

    vid

    ed a

    nd

    ove

    rsiz

    ed

    thro

    ugh

    th

    e ex

    isti

    ng

    sub

    div

    isio

    n

    (Ris

    ebo

    rou

    gh P

    has

    e 4)

    to

    th

    e ea

    st. T

    her

    e is

    litt

    le t

    o n

    o

    op

    po

    rtu

    nit

    y fo

    r st

    orm

    wat

    er

    man

    agem

    ent

    du

    e to

    exi

    stin

    g ap

    pro

    ved

    dev

    elo

    pm

    ents

    .

    8A

    s p

    er t

    he

    app

    rove

    d M

    aste

    r D

    rain

    age

    Pla

    n, s

    torm

    dra

    inag

    e w

    ill b

    e d

    iver

    ted

    to

    th

    e ex

    isti

    ng

    ou

    tlet

    pro

    vid

    ed a

    nd

    ove

    rsiz

    ed

    thro

    ugh

    th

    e ex

    isti

    ng

    sub

    div

    isio

    n

    (Ris

    ebo

    rou

    ghP

    has

    e 4)

    to

    th

    e ea

    st. T

    her

    e is

    hig

    h o

    pp

    ort

    un

    ity

    for

    sto

    rmw

    ater

    man

    agem

    ent

    du

    e to

    hig

    h p

    ote

    nti

    al f

    or

    infi

    ltra

    tio

    n.

    8A

    s p

    er t

    he

    app

    rove

    d M

    aste

    r D

    rain

    age

    Pla

    n, s

    torm

    dra

    inag

    e w

    ill b

    e d

    iver

    ted

    to

    th

    e ex

    isti

    ng

    ou

    tlet

    pro

    vid

    ed a

    nd

    ove

    rsiz

    ed

    thro

    ugh

    th

    e ex

    isti

    ng

    sub

    div

    isio

    n

    (Ris

    ebo

    rou

    ghP

    has

    e 4)

    to

    th

    e ea

    st. T

    her

    e is

    hig

    h o

    pp

    ort

    un

    ity

    for

    sto

    rmw

    ater

    man

    agem

    ent

    du

    e to

    hig

    h p

    ote

    nti

    al f

    or

    infi

    ltra

    tio

    n.

    Sco

    re =

    6.

    06.

    09

    .09

    .0

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Evalu

    ation M

    atr

    ix

    CA

    TEG

    OR

    IES

    OF

    CO

    NSI

    DER

    ATI

    ON

    CR

    ITER

    IA

    ALI

    GN

    MEN

    T O

    PT

    ION

    S

    Alig

    nm

    ent

    Op

    tio

    n #

    1A

    lign

    men

    t O

    pti

    on

    #2

    Alig

    nm

    en

    t O

    pti

    on

    #3

    Alig

    nm

    ent

    Op

    tio

    n #

    4

    Def

    init

    ion

    sSu

    n Y

    at S

    en A

    ve.

    Inte

    rsec

    tio

    n a

    t O

    ld

    Ken

    ne

    dy

    Rd

    .C

    elad

    ine

    Dr.

    Inte

    rsec

    tio

    n a

    t O

    ld K

    en

    ned

    y R

    d.

    Sun

    rise

    Dr.

    Inte

    rsec

    tio

    n a

    t O

    ld K

    enn

    edy

    Rd

    .C

    on

    tin

    uo

    us

    Ro

    ad w

    ith

    Old

    Ken

    ned

    y R

    d.

    Sco

    reN

    ote

    sSc

    ore

    No

    tes

    Sco

    reN

    ote

    sSc

    ore

    No

    tes

    Cu

    ltu

    ral

    Envi

    ron

    men

    t

    Her

    itag

    e R

    eso

    urc

    es -

    Imp

    acts

    to

    d

    esig

    nat

    ed/l

    iste

    d b

    uilt

    her

    itag

    e fe

    atu

    res

    2O

    ne

    of

    the

    reso

    urc

    es (

    51 O

    ld

    Ken

    ned

    y, c

    . 189

    5 an

    d in

    po

    or

    con

    dit

    ion

    ) is

    to

    tally

    imp

    acte

    d

    (req

    uir

    ing

    dem

    olit

    ion

    or

    rem

    ova

    l)

    and

    th

    e o

    ther

    (59

    Old

    Ken

    ned

    y,

    c.18

    85) i

    s sl

    igh

    tly

    imp

    acte

    d d

    ue

    to t

    he

    road

    RO

    W b

    ein

    g im

    me

    dia

    tely

    ad

    jace

    nt

    to t

    he

    sou

    th fa

    çad

    e.

    4Th

    is s

    cen

    ario

    imp

    acts

    1 li

    sted

    h

    erit

    age

    reso

    urc

    e (9

    3 O

    ld

    Ken

    ned

    y, c

    .192

    5).

    This

    pro

    per

    ty

    was

    co

    nsi

    der

    ed w

    ort

    hy

    of

    des

    ign

    atio

    n a

    nd

    a H

    erit

    age

    Ease

    men

    t A

    gree

    men

    t w

    as

    reco

    mm

    en

    ded

    as

    a co

    nd

    itio

    n o

    f d

    evel

    op

    men

    t ap

    pro

    val i

    n 2

    010.

    Th

    e re

    sou

    rce

    is n

    egat

    ivel

    y im

    pac

    ted

    du

    e to

    th

    e b

    uild

    ing

    bei

    ng

    wit

    hin

    th

    e ro

    ad R

    OW

    of

    an

    exp

    and

    ed C

    elad

    ine

    Dri

    ve.

    7Th

    e so

    uth

    faç

    ade

    of

    on

    e re

    sou

    rce

    (93

    Old

    Ken

    ned

    y R

    oad

    , c. 1

    925)

    is

    insi

    de

    the

    mu

    nic

    ipal

    RO

    W o

    f an

    ex

    pan

    ded

    Cel

    adin

    eD

    rive

    bu

    t n

    ot

    imp

    acte

    d b

    y th

    e ac

    tual

    ro

    ad. T

    his

    p

    rop

    erty

    was

    co

    nsi

    der

    ed w

    ort

    hy

    of

    des

    ign

    atio

    n a

    nd

    a H

    erit

    age

    Ease

    men

    t A

    gree

    men

    t w

    as

    reco

    mm

    en

    ded

    as

    a co

    nd

    itio

    n o

    f d

    evel

    op

    men

    t ap

    pro

    val i

    n 2

    010.

    Th

    is r

    eso

    urc

    e is

    neg

    ativ

    ely

    imp

    acte

    d d

    ue

    to t

    he

    bu

    ildin

    g b

    ein

    g w

    ith

    in t

    he

    road

    RO

    W.

    7Th

    e so

    uth

    faç

    ade

    of

    on

    e re

    sou

    rce

    (93

    Old

    Ken

    ned

    y R

    oad

    , c. 1

    925)

    is

    insi

    de

    the

    mu

    nic

    ipal

    RO

    W o

    f an

    ex

    pan

    ded

    Cel

    adin

    eD

    rive

    bu

    t n

    ot

    imp

    acte

    d b

    y th

    e ac

    tual

    ro

    ad. T

    his

    p

    rop

    erty

    was

    co

    nsi

    der

    ed w

    ort

    hy

    of

    des

    ign

    atio

    n a

    nd

    a H

    erit

    age

    Ease

    men

    t A

    gree

    men

    t w

    as

    reco

    mm

    en

    ded

    as

    a co

    nd

    itio

    n o

    f d

    evel

    op

    men

    t ap

    pro

    val i

    n 2

    010.

    Th

    is r

    eso

    urc

    e is

    neg

    ativ

    ely

    imp

    acte

    d d

    ue

    to t

    he

    bu

    ildin

    g b

    ein

    g w

    ith

    in t

    he

    road

    RO

    W.

    Her

    itag

    e R

    eso

    urc

    es -

    Imp

    acts

    to

    cu

    ltu

    ral

    lan

    dsc

    apes

    (his

    tori

    c; s

    cen

    ic h

    erit

    age

    road

    s)

    3G

    iven

    th

    at o

    ne

    bu

    ildin

    g is

    to

    be

    rem

    ove

    d a

    nd

    an

    oth

    er

    com

    pro

    mis

    ed, t

    he

    cult

    ura

    l la

    nd

    scap

    e ar

    ou

    nd

    th

    e h

    erit

    age

    reso

    urc

    es w

    ou

    ld b

    e im

    pac

    ted

    .

    5G

    iven

    th

    at t

    he

    bu

    ildin

    g is

    co

    mp

    rom

    ised

    , th

    e cu

    ltu

    ral

    lan

    dsc

    ape

    aro

    un

    d t

    he

    her

    itag

    e re

    sou

    rce

    wo

    uld

    be

    imp

    acte

    d.

    8G

    iven

    th

    at t

    he

    bu

    ildin

    g is

    co

    mp

    rom

    ised

    , th

    e cu

    ltu

    ral

    lan

    dsc

    ape

    aro

    un

    d t

    he

    her

    itag

    e re

    sou

    rce

    wo

    uld

    be

    imp

    acte

    d.

    8G

    iven

    th

    at t

    he

    bu

    ildin

    g is

    co

    mp

    rom

    ised

    , th

    e cu

    ltu

    ral

    lan

    dsc

    ape

    aro

    un

    d t

    he

    her

    itag

    e re

    sou

    rce

    wo

    uld

    be

    imp

    acte

    d.

    Arc

    hae

    olo

    gica

    l Res

    ou

    rces

    -Im

    pac

    ts t

    o

    kno

    wn

    arc

    hae

    olo

    gica

    l sit

    es10

    All

    lan

    d w

    ith

    in t

    he

    pro

    po

    sed

    al

    ign

    men

    t h

    as b

    een

    dis

    turb

    ed,

    ther

    efo

    re t

    her

    e is

    no

    fu

    rth

    er

    arch

    aeo

    logi

    cal a

    sses

    smen

    t re

    qu

    ired

    .

    10A

    ll la

    nd

    wit

    hin

    th

    e p

    rop

    ose

    d

    alig

    nm

    ent

    has

    bee

    n d

    istu

    rbed

    , th

    eref

    ore

    th

    ere

    is n

    o f

    urt

    her

    ar

    chae

    olo

    gica

    l ass

    essm

    ent

    req

    uir

    ed.

    8Th

    ere

    is o

    ne

    sect

    ion

    of

    lan

    d

    wit

    hin

    th

    is p

    rop

    ose

    d a

    lign

    men

    t w

    hic

    h h

    as b

    een

    iden

    tifi

    ed a

    s h

    avin

    g ar

    chae

    olo

    gica

    l po

    ten

    tial

    an

    d r

    equ

    ires

    a S

    tage

    2

    Ass

    essm

    ent.

    8Th

    ere

    is o

    ne

    sect

    ion

    of

    lan

    d

    wit

    hin

    th

    is p

    rop

    ose

    d a

    lign

    men

    t w

    hic

    h h

    as b

    een

    iden

    tifi

    ed a

    s h

    avin

    g ar

    chae

    olo

    gica

    l po

    ten

    tial

    an

    d r

    equ

    ires

    a S

    tage

    2

    Ass

    essm

    ent.

    Sco

    re =

    5.

    06.

    37

    .77

    .7

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Evalu

    ation M

    atr

    ix

    CA

    TEG

    OR

    IES

    OF

    CO

    NSI

    DER

    ATI

    ON

    CR

    ITER

    IA

    ALI

    GN

    MEN

    T O

    PT

    ION

    S

    Alig

    nm

    ent

    Op

    tio

    n #

    1A

    lign

    men

    t O

    pti

    on

    #2

    Alig

    nm

    en

    t O

    pti

    on

    #3

    Alig

    nm

    ent

    Op

    tio

    n #

    4

    Def

    init

    ion

    sSu

    n Y

    at S

    en

    Ave

    . In

    ters

    ecti

    on

    at

    Old

    K

    enn

    ed

    y R

    d.

    Cel

    adin

    e D

    r. In

    ters

    ecti

    on

    at

    Old

    Ken

    ned

    y R

    d.

    Sun

    rise

    Dr.

    Inte

    rsec

    tio

    n a

    t O

    ld K

    enn

    edy

    Rd

    .C

    on

    tin

    uo

    us

    Ro

    ad w

    ith

    Old

    Ken

    ned

    y R

    d.

    Sco

    reN

    ote

    sSc

    ore

    No

    tes

    Sco

    reN

    ote

    sSc

    ore

    No

    tes

    Soci

    o-E

    con

    om

    ic

    Envi

    ron

    men

    t

    Lan

    d U

    se -

    Co

    mp

    atib

    ility

    wit

    h la

    nd

    use

    d

    esig

    nat

    ion

    s/p

    olic

    y an

    d a

    pp

    rove

    d

    dev

    elo

    pm

    ent

    pro

    po

    sals

    ; Im

    pac

    ts t

    o

    agri

    cult

    ura

    l an

    d o

    ther

    bu

    sin

    ess

    op

    erat

    ion

    s

    3Th

    is a

    lign

    men

    t co

    mp

    lies

    wit

    h t

    he

    July

    200

    6, M

    ain

    Str

    eet

    Mill

    iken

    Se

    con

    dar

    y P

    lan

    , OP

    A 1

    44, a

    s am

    en

    ded

    . Th

    is R

    OW

    alig

    nm

    ent

    will

    imp

    act

    a sm

    all p

    ort

    ion

    of

    app

    rove

    d d

    evel

    op

    men

    ts. T

    his

    al

    ign

    men

    t w

    ou

    ld r

    equ

    ire

    dec

    om

    mis

    sio

    nin

    g o

    f an

    exi

    stin

    g ga

    s st

    atio

    n a

    nd

    tra

    iler

    sto

    rage

    b

    usi

    nes

    s, b

    ut

    no

    imp

    act

    to a

    ny

    agri

    cult

    ura

    l bu

    sin

    ess

    op

    erat

    ion

    s.

    6Th

    is a

    lign

    men

    t co

    mp

    lies

    wit

    h t

    he

    July

    200

    6, M

    ain

    Str

    eet

    Mill

    iken

    Se

    con

    dar

    y P

    lan

    , OP

    A 1

    44, a

    s am

    en

    ded

    . Th

    is R

    OW

    alig

    nm

    ent

    will

    imp

    act

    2 ex

    isti

    ng

    tow

    nh

    ou

    ses

    and

    a v

    acan

    t se

    rvic

    ed lo

    t. T

    he

    alig

    nm

    ent

    will

    no

    t im

    pac

    t an

    y ex

    isti

    ng

    agri

    cult

    ura

    l or

    oth

    er

    bu

    sin

    ess

    op

    erat

    ion

    s.

    9Th

    is a

    lign

    men

    t co

    mp

    lies

    wit

    h t

    he

    July

    200

    6, M

    ain

    Str

    eet

    Mill

    iken

    Se

    con

    dar

    y P

    lan

    , OP

    A 1

    44, a

    s am

    en

    ded

    . Th

    e al

    ign

    men

    t w

    ill n

    ot

    imp

    act

    any

    exis

    tin

    g ag

    ricu

    ltu

    ral

    or

    oth

    er b

    usi

    nes

    s o

    per

    atio

    ns.

    3Th

    is a

    lign

    men

    t d

    oes

    no

    t co

    mp

    ly

    wit

    h t

    he

    July

    200

    6, M

    ain

    Str

    eet

    Mill

    iken

    Sec

    on

    dar

    y P

    lan

    , OP

    A

    144,

    as

    ame

    nd

    ed, a

    nd

    was

    d

    elet

    ed a

    s a

    maj

    or

    colle

    cto

    r ro

    ad

    wh

    ich

    wo

    uld

    hav

    e b

    een

    th

    e re

    alig

    nm

    ent

    of

    Old

    Ken

    ned

    y R

    oad

    . Th

    is a

    lign

    men

    t w

    ou

    ld

    adve

    rsel

    y im

    pac

    t th

    e Lo

    gos

    Bap

    tist

    Ch

    urc

    h a

    nd

    th

    eir

    pro

    po

    sed

    exp

    ansi

    on

    fo

    r an

    ac

    adem

    y b

    usi

    nes

    s, b

    ut

    no

    imp

    act

    to a

    ny

    agri

    cult

    ura

    l bu

    sin

    ess

    op

    erat

    ion

    s.

    No

    ise

    -ch

    ange

    s in

    so

    un

    d le

    vels

    in n

    ois

    e se

    nsi

    tive

    are

    as4

    Res

    iden

    tial

    dev

    elo

    pm

    ents

    hav

    e n

    ois

    e co

    ntr

    ol m

    easu

    res

    alre

    ady

    in p

    lace

    an

    d n

    o f

    urt

    her

    act

    ion

    is

    req

    uir

    ed. H

    ow

    ever

    , th

    ere

    will

    be

    a n

    egat

    ive

    imp

    act

    to t

    he

    resi

    den

    ts o

    f th

    e ap

    pro

    ved

    lon

    g te

    rm c

    are

    faci

    lity

    fro

    nti

    ng

    on

    to

    this

    ro

    ad.

    4R

    esid

    enti

    al d

    evel

    op

    men

    ts h

    ave

    no

    ise

    con

    tro

    l mea

    sure

    s al

    read

    y in

    pla

    ce a

    nd

    no

    fu

    rth

    er a

    ctio

    n is

    re

    qu

    ired

    . Ho

    wev

    er, t

    her

    e w

    ill b

    e a

    neg

    ativ

    e im

    pac

    t to

    th

    e re

    sid

    ents

    of

    the

    exis

    tin

    g to

    wn

    ho

    mes

    fro

    nti

    ng

    this

    ro

    ad.

    9R

    esid

    enti

    al d

    evel

    op

    men

    ts h

    ave

    no

    ise

    con

    tro

    l mea

    sure

    s al

    read

    y in

    pla

    ce a

    nd

    no

    fu

    rth

    er a

    ctio

    n is

    re

    qu

    ired

    .

    9R

    esid

    enti

    al d

    evel

    op

    men

    ts h

    ave

    no

    ise

    con

    tro

    l mea

    sure

    s al

    read

    y in

    pla

    ce a

    nd

    no

    fu

    rth

    er a

    ctio

    n is

    re

    qu

    ired

    .

    Co

    mm

    un

    itie

    s -

    Encr

    oac

    hm

    ent

    on

    co

    mm

    un

    itie

    s/in

    div

    idu

    al p

    rop

    erti

    es;

    Ch

    ange

    s to

    co

    mm

    un

    ity

    con

    nec

    tivi

    ty

    (cu

    ltu

    ral/

    soci

    al li

    nka

    ges)

    ; Im

    pac

    ts t

    o

    com

    mu

    nit

    y am

    en

    itie

    s (r

    ecre

    atio

    nal

    /in

    stit

    uti

    on

    al)

    5D

    irec

    t im

    pac

    t to

    2 p

    rop

    erti

    es (

    51

    & 5

    9 O

    ld K

    enn

    edy

    Ro

    ad).

    No

    d

    irec

    t im

    pac

    t to

    cu

    ltu

    ral/

    soci

    al

    linka

    ges.

    Imp

    act

    to t

    he

    day

    -to

    -d

    ay s

    afe

    op

    erat

    ion

    of

    the

    futu

    re

    app

    rove

    d s

    enio

    rs h

    ou

    sin

    g an

    d

    lon

    g-te

    rm c

    are

    faci

    lity.

    7D

    irec

    t im

    pac

    t to

    po

    ten

    tial

    ly 2

    to

    wn

    ho

    use

    s an

    d a

    vac

    ant

    serv

    iced

    lot

    on

    Cel

    adin

    e D

    rive

    . N

    o d

    irec

    t im

    pac

    t to

    cu

    ltu

    ral/

    soci

    al li

    nka

    ges

    or

    com

    mu

    nit

    y am

    en

    itie

    s.

    8D

    irec

    t im

    pac

    t to

    on

    e co

    nso

    lidat

    ed o

    wn

    er (

    103,

    113

    &

    123

    Old

    Ken

    ned

    y R

    oad

    ). N

    o

    dir

    ect

    imp

    act

    to c

    ult

    ura

    l/so

    cial

    lin

    kage

    s o

    r co

    mm

    un

    ity

    ame

    nit

    ies.

    3D

    irec

    t im

    pac

    t to

    th

    e o

    per

    atio

    n o

    f th

    e ex

    isti

    ng

    pla

    ce o

    f w

    ors

    hip

    (13

    3 O

    ld K

    enn

    edy

    Ro

    ad).

    Dir

    ect

    imp

    act

    to la

    nd

    s o

    wn

    ed b

    y o

    ne

    con

    solid

    ated

    ow

    ner

    (10

    3, 1

    13,

    123

    Old

    Ken

    ned

    y R

    oad

    ).

    Air

    Qu

    alit

    y -

    Ch

    ange

    s to

    air

    qu

    alit

    y at

    se

    nsi

    tive

    rec

    epto

    rs3

    Alt

    ho

    ugh

    th

    e al

    ign

    men

    t w

    ork

    s w

    ou

    ld n

    ot

    exce

    ed

    rel

    evan

    t ai

    r q

    ual

    ity

    guid

    elin

    es, i

    t is

    an

    tici

    pat

    ed t

    hat

    th

    ere

    wo

    uld

    be

    a n

    egat

    ive

    imp

    act

    wit

    h r

    esp

    ect

    to

    air

    qu

    alit

    y to

    th

    e ap

    pro

    ved

    lon

    g te

    rm c

    are

    faci

    lity

    resi

    den

    ts.

    4A

    lth

    ou

    gh t

    he

    alig

    nm

    ent

    wo

    rks

    wo

    uld

    no

    t ex

    cee

    d r

    elev

    ant

    air

    qu

    alit

    y gu

    idel

    ines

    , it

    is

    anti

    cip

    ated

    th

    at t

    her

    e w

    ou

    ld b

    e a

    neg

    ativ

    e im

    pac

    t w

    ith

    res

    pec

    t to

    ai

    r q

    ual

    ity

    to t

    he

    exis

    tin

    g to

    wn

    ho

    use

    res

    iden

    ts.

    9Th

    e al

    ign

    men

    t w

    ork

    s w

    ou

    ld n

    ot

    exce

    ed

    rel

    evan

    t ai

    r q

    ual

    ity

    guid

    elin

    es.

    9Th

    e al

    ign

    men

    t w

    ork

    s w

    ou

    ld n

    ot

    exce

    ed

    rel

    evan

    t ai

    r q

    ual

    ity

    guid

    elin

    es.

    Sco

    re =

    3.

    85.

    38

    .86

    .0

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Evalu

    ation M

    atr

    ix

    CA

    TEG

    OR

    IES

    OF

    CO

    NSI

    DER

    ATI

    ON

    CR

    ITER

    IA

    ALI

    GN

    MEN

    T O

    PT

    ION

    S

    Alig

    nm

    ent

    Op

    tio

    n #

    1A

    lign

    men

    t O

    pti

    on

    #2

    Alig

    nm

    en

    t O

    pti

    on

    #3

    Alig

    nm

    ent

    Op

    tio

    n #

    4

    Def

    init

    ion

    sSu

    n Y

    at S

    en

    Ave

    . In

    ters

    ecti

    on

    at

    Old

    K

    enn

    ed

    y R

    d.

    Cel

    adin

    e D

    r. In

    ters

    ecti

    on

    at

    Old

    Ken

    ned

    y R

    d.

    Sun

    rise

    Dr.

    Inte

    rsec

    tio

    n a

    t O

    ld K

    enn

    edy

    Rd

    .C

    on

    tin

    uo

    us

    Ro

    ad w

    ith

    Old

    Ken

    ned

    y R

    d.

    Sco

    reN

    ote

    sSc

    ore

    No

    tes

    Sco

    reN

    ote

    sSc

    ore

    No

    tes

    Tran

    spo

    rtat

    ion

    / U

    tilit

    ies

    Tran

    spo

    rtat

    ion

    Net

    wo

    rk/I

    nfr

    astr

    uct

    ure

    -C

    han

    ges

    to t

    ran

    spo

    rtat

    ion

    net

    wo

    rk

    (cap

    acit

    y, a

    cces

    s)

    2P

    hys

    ical

    alig

    nm

    ent

    can

    on

    ly

    ach

    ieve

    loca

    l op

    erat

    ing

    con

    dit

    ion

    s. R

    esu

    lt is

    a s

    ign

    ific

    ant

    red

    uct

    ion

    in o

    per

    atin

    g ca

    pac

    ity.

    N

    ot

    suff

    icie

    nt

    in o

    per

    atin

    g ca

    pab

    ility

    to

    mee

    t re

    qu

    irem

    ents

    o

    f th

    e co

    mm

    un

    ity/

    OP

    A1

    44.

    In

    crea

    ses

    traf

    fic

    flo

    w a

    dja

    cen

    t to

    ap

    pro

    ved

    lon

    g te

    rm c

    are

    faci

    lity

    dev

    elo

    pm

    ent.

    Pro

    ject

    ed v

    ehic

    le

    flo

    w w

    ill r

    edu

    ce o

    per

    atin

    g ef

    fici

    ency

    of

    dri

    vew

    ays

    and

    in

    ters

    ecti

    on

    s.

    3P

    hys

    ical

    alig

    nm

    ent

    can

    on

    ly

    ach

    ieve

    loca

    l op

    erat

    ing

    con

    dit

    ion

    s. R

    esu

    lt is

    a s

    ign

    ific

    ant

    red

    uct

    ion

    in o

    per

    atin

    g ca

    pac

    ity.

    N

    ot

    suff

    icie

    nt

    in o

    per

    atin

    g ca

    pab

    ility

    to

    mee

    t re

    qu

    irem

    ents

    o

    f th

    e co

    mm

    un

    ity/

    OP

    A1

    44.

    H

    igh

    imp

    act

    to e

    xist

    ing

    tow

    nh

    ou

    se u

    nit

    dri

    vew

    ays.

    In

    ters

    ecti

    on

    op

    erat

    ion

    s ac

    cep

    tab

    le.

    8A

    chie

    ves

    colle

    cto

    r ro

    ad o

    per

    atin

    g co

    nd

    itio

    ns.

    Max

    imiz

    es

    op

    po

    rtu

    nit

    y to

    uti

    lize

    traf

    fic

    sign

    al a

    t St

    eele

    s A

    ven

    ue

    and

    M

    idla

    nd

    Ave

    nu

    e in

    ters

    ecti

    on

    . En

    han

    ces

    net

    wo

    rk a

    nd

    bal

    ance

    s tr

    avel

    flo

    w d

    eman

    ds.

    9A

    chie

    ves

    the

    hig

    hes

    t ca

    pac

    ity

    for

    all t

    he

    alig

    nm

    ent

    alte

    rnat

    ives

    an

    d

    max

    imiz

    es o

    pp

    ort

    un

    ity

    to u

    tiliz

    e tr

    affi

    c si

    gnal

    at

    Stee

    les

    Ave

    nu

    e an

    d M

    idla

    nd

    Ave

    nu

    e in

    ters

    ecti

    on

    . En

    han

    ces

    net

    wo

    rk

    and

    bal

    ance

    s tr

    avel

    flo

    w

    dem

    and

    s.

    Tran

    spo

    rtat

    ion

    Net

    wo

    rk/I

    nfr

    astr

    uct

    ure

    -C

    om

    pat

    ibili

    ty w

    ith

    tra

    nsp

    ort

    atio

    n p

    olic

    y in

    itia

    tive

    s (t

    ran

    sit,

    act

    ive

    tran

    spo

    rtat

    ion

    , tr

    affi

    c ca

    lmin

    g)

    2D

    oes

    no

    t fu

    lfill

    th

    e re

    qu

    irem

    ents

    o

    f a

    colle

    cto

    r ro

    ad c

    lass

    ific

    atio

    n

    exte

    nsi

    on

    req

    uir

    emen

    t. D

    oes

    no

    t p

    rovi

    de

    for

    tran

    sit

    or

    acti

    ve

    tran

    spo

    rtat

    ion

    . Bu

    s o

    per

    atio

    n is

    n

    ot

    per

    mit

    ted

    du

    e to

    geo

    met

    ry

    con

    stra

    ints

    ; sid

    ewal

    ks c

    an

    acco

    mm

    od

    ate

    ped

    estr

    ian

    s; b

    ike

    rou

    te f

    or

    bic

    yclis

    ts. N

    ot

    con

    sist

    ent

    wit

    h t

    ran

    spo

    rtat

    ion

    p

    olic

    ies.

    3D

    oes

    no

    t fu

    lfill

    th

    e re

    qu

    irem

    ents

    o

    f a

    colle

    cto

    r ro

    ad c

    lass

    ific

    atio

    n

    exte

    nsi

    on

    req

    uir

    emen

    t. D

    oes

    no

    t p

    rovi

    de

    for

    tran

    sit

    or

    acti

    ve

    tran

    spo

    rtat

    ion

    . Bu

    s o

    per

    atio

    n is

    n

    ot

    per

    mit

    ted

    du

    e to

    geo

    met

    ry

    con

    stra

    ints

    ; in

    crea

    sed

    ped

    estr

    ian

    ac

    cess

    ibili

    ty, g

    reat

    er s

    idew

    alk

    exte

    nsi

    on

    into

    Co

    mm

    un

    ity;

    bik

    e ro

    ute

    fo

    r b

    icyc

    lists

    . No

    t co

    nsi

    sten

    t w

    ith

    tra

    nsp

    ort

    atio

    n

    po

    licie

    s.

    7En

    able

    s im

    pro

    ved

    co

    mm

    un

    ity

    road

    net

    wo

    rk o

    per

    atio

    ns.

    P

    erm

    its

    tran

    sit

    and

    act

    ive

    tran

    spo

    rtat

    ion

    mo

    des

    of

    tran

    spo

    rtat

    ion

    . Po

    ten

    tial

    bu

    s se

    rvic

    e ca

    n b

    e ac

    hie

    ved

    ; im

    pro

    ved

    ped

    estr

    ian

    acc

    essi

    bili

    ty

    to a

    ll tr

    ansi

    t se

    rvic

    es a

    nd

    th

    e C

    om

    mu

    nit

    y as

    a w

    ho

    le;

    bik

    e ro

    ute

    fo

    r b

    icyc

    lists

    . Fu

    lfill

    s tr

    ansp

    ort

    atio

    n p

    olic

    ies

    and

    o

    bje

    ctiv

    es.

    8En

    able

    s m

    axim

    um

    /en

    han

    ced

    co

    mm

    un

    ity

    road

    net

    wo

    rk

    op

    erat

    ion

    s. P

    erm

    its

    tran

    sit

    and

    ac

    tive

    tra

    nsp

    ort

    atio

    n m

    od

    es o

    f tr

    ansp

    ort

    atio

    n. P

    ote

    nti

    al b

    us

    serv

    ice

    can

    be

    ach

    ieve

    d;

    max

    imu

    m p

    edes

    tria

    n

    acce

    ssib

    ility

    to

    all

    tran

    sit

    serv

    ices

    an

    d t

    he

    Co

    mm

    un

    ity

    as a

    wh

    ole

    ; b

    ike

    rou

    te f

    or

    bic

    yclis

    ts. F

    ulf

    ills

    tran

    spo

    rtat

    ion

    po

    licie

    s an

    d

    ob

    ject

    ives

    .

    Mu

    nic

    ipal

    Ser

    vice

    s an

    d U

    tilit

    ies

    -C

    han

    ges

    to/o

    pp

    ort

    un

    itie

    s fo

    r m

    un

    icip

    al s

    ervi

    ces

    5A

    ll m

    un

    icip

    al s

    ervi

    ces

    and

    uti

    litie

    s w

    ill b

    e m

    ade

    avai

    lab

    le a

    nd

    hav

    e n

    o c

    on

    stra

    ints

    . Ho

    wev

    er, t

    her

    e is

    n

    o a

    dd

    itio

    nal

    imp

    rove

    d S

    WM

    o

    pp

    ort

    un

    itie

    s.

    5A

    ll m

    un

    icip

    al s

    ervi

    ces

    and

    uti

    litie

    s w

    ill b

    e m

    ade

    avai

    lab

    le a

    nd

    hav

    e n

    o c

    on

    stra

    ints

    . Ho

    wev

    er, t

    her

    e is

    n

    o a

    dd

    itio

    nal

    imp

    rove

    d S

    WM

    o

    pp

    ort

    un

    itie

    s.

    8A

    ll m

    un

    icip

    al s

    ervi

    ces

    and

    uti

    litie

    s w

    ill b

    e m

    ade

    avai

    lab

    le a

    nd

    hav

    e n

    o c

    on

    stra

    ints

    . Ho

    wev

    er, t

    her

    e is

    h

    igh

    po

    ten

    tial

    fo

    r en

    han

    ced

    SW

    M v

    ia b

    iosw

    ale

    app

    licat

    ion

    .

    8A

    ll m

    un

    icip

    al s

    ervi

    ces

    and

    uti

    litie

    s w

    ill b

    e m

    ade

    avai

    lab

    le a

    nd

    hav

    e n

    o c

    on

    stra

    ints

    . Ho

    wev

    er, t

    her

    e is

    h

    igh

    po

    ten

    tial

    fo

    r en

    han

    ced

    SW

    M v

    ia b

    iosw

    ale

    app

    licat

    ion

    .

    Mu

    nic

    ipal

    Ser

    vice

    s an

    d U

    tilit

    ies

    -Im

    pac

    ts

    to u

    tilit

    ies

    (exi

    stin

    g an

    d p

    rop

    ose

    d p

    lan

    t)10

    No

    bar

    rier

    s to

    ser

    vice

    abili

    ty.

    10N

    o b

    arri

    ers

    to s

    ervi

    ceab

    ility

    .10

    No

    bar

    rier

    s to

    ser

    vice

    abili

    ty.

    10N

    o b

    arri

    ers

    to s

    ervi

    ceab

    ility

    .

    Sco

    re =

    4.

    85.

    38

    .38

    .8

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Evalu

    ation M

    atr

    ix

    CA

    TEG

    OR

    IES

    OF

    CO

    NSI

    DER

    ATI

    ON

    CR

    ITER

    IA

    ALI

    GN

    MEN

    T O

    PTI

    ON

    S

    Alig

    nm

    ent

    Op

    tio

    n #

    1A

    lign

    men

    t O

    pti

    on

    #2

    Alig

    nm

    en

    t O

    pti

    on

    #3

    Alig

    nm

    ent

    Op

    tio

    n #

    4

    Def

    init

    ion

    sSu

    n Y

    at S

    en

    Ave

    . In

    ters

    ecti

    on

    at

    Old

    K

    enn

    ed

    y R

    d.

    Cel

    adin

    e D

    r. In

    ters

    ecti

    on

    at

    Old

    Ken

    ned

    y R

    d.

    Sun

    rise

    Dr.

    Inte

    rsec

    tio

    n a

    t O

    ld K

    enn

    edy

    Rd

    .C

    on

    tin

    uo

    us

    Ro

    ad w

    ith

    Old

    Ken

    ned

    y R

    d.

    Sco

    reN

    ote

    sSc

    ore

    No

    tes

    Sco

    reN

    ote

    sSc

    ore

    No

    tes

    Fin

    anci

    al/

    Tech

    nic

    al

    Fin

    anci

    al -

    Lan

    d t

    o b

    e p

    urc

    has

    ed8

    Seco

    nd

    leas

    t ex

    pen

    sive

    9Le

    ast

    exp

    ensi

    ve4

    Seco

    nd

    mo

    st e

    xpen

    sive

    2M

    ost

    exp

    ensi

    ve

    Fin

    anci

    al -

    Co

    nst

    ruct

    ion

    co

    st (i

    ncl

    ud

    ing

    her

    itag

    e m

    itig

    atio

    n m

    easu

    res)

    7Se

    con

    d le

    ast

    exp

    ensi

    ve9

    Leas

    t ex

    pen

    sive

    4Se

    con

    d m

    ost

    exp

    ensi

    ve2

    Mo

    st e

    xpen

    sive

    Fin

    anci

    al -

    Op

    erat

    ion

    an

    d m

    ain

    ten

    ance

    8Le

    ast

    len

    gth

    of

    road

    to

    mai

    nta

    in,

    bu

    t sn

    ow

    rem

    ova

    l in

    fro

    nt

    of

    the

    sen

    iors

    /lo

    ng

    term

    car

    e fa

    cilit

    y w

    ill h

    ave

    to b

    e im

    ple

    men

    ted

    ; i.e

    . th

    ere

    will

    be

    less

    sn

    ow

    sto

    rage

    av

    aila

    ble

    on

    th

    e b

    ou

    leva

    rd.

    6Le

    sser

    len

    gth

    of

    road

    to

    m

    ain

    tain

    , bu

    t p

    rop

    ose

    d r

    oad

    ru

    ns

    alo

    ng

    tow

    nh

    ou

    se f

    ron

    tage

    s (p

    ote

    nti

    ally

    bo

    th s

    ides

    of

    the

    road

    ), w

    hic

    h w

    ill r

    estr

    ict

    sno

    w

    sto

    rage

    cau

    sin

    g re

    qu

    irem

    ent

    for

    po

    ten

    tial

    sn

    ow

    rem

    ova

    l.

    4M

    ore

    len

    gth

    of

    road

    to

    mai

    nta

    in;

    the

    road

    len

    gth

    is r

    elat

    ivel

    y lo

    ng

    (co

    mp

    ared

    to

    all

    op

    tio

    ns)

    , h

    ow

    ever

    reg

    ula

    r sn

    ow

    plo

    win

    g is

    ap

    plic

    able

    .

    2M

    ost

    len

    gth

    of

    road

    to

    mai

    nta

    in;

    the

    road

    len

    gth

    is lo

    nge

    st

    (co

    mp

    ared

    to

    all

    op

    tio

    ns)

    , h

    ow

    ever

    reg

    ula

    r sn

    ow

    plo

    win

    g is

    ap

    plic

    able

    .

    Fin

    anci

    al -

    Co

    mp

    atib

    ility

    wit

    h m

    un

    icip

    al

    cap

    ital

    bu

    dge

    t/re

    sou

    rces

    10Th

    is is

    a D

    evel

    op

    er's

    Gro

    up

    an

    d

    ASD

    C f

    un

    ded

    init

    iati

    ve.

    10Th

    is is

    a D

    evel

    op

    er's

    Gro

    up

    an

    d

    ASD

    C f

    un

    ded

    init

    iati

    ve.

    10Th

    is is

    a D

    evel

    op

    er's

    Gro

    up

    an

    d

    ASD

    C f

    un

    ded

    init

    iati

    ve.

    10Th

    is is

    a D

    evel

    op

    er's

    Gro

    up

    an

    d

    ASD

    C f

    un

    ded

    init

    iati

    ve.

    Tech

    nic

    al -

    Ro

    adw

    ay g

    eom

    etri

    c d

    esig

    n

    req

    uir

    emen

    ts3

    Do

    es n

    ot

    mee

    t th

    e d

    esig

    n c

    rite

    ria

    as a

    co

    llect

    or

    road

    . Can

    on

    ly b

    e cl

    assi

    fied

    as

    a p

    ub

    lic la

    ne

    way

    . A

    pp

    roxi

    mat

    ely

    90 d

    egre

    e

    alig

    nm

    ent,

    wh

    ich

    is a

    n

    un

    favo

    ura

    ble

    geo

    met

    ric

    des

    ign

    fo

    r a

    colle

    cto

    r ro

    ad.

    3D

    oes

    no

    t m

    eet

    the

    des

    ign

    cri

    teri

    a as

    a c

    olle

    cto

    r ro

    ad. C

    an o

    nly

    be

    clas

    sifi

    ed a

    s a

    pu

    blic

    lan

    e w

    ay.

    Ap

    pro

    xim

    atel

    y 90

    deg

    ree

    al

    ign

    men

    t, w

    hic

    h is

    an

    u

    nfa

    vou

    rab

    lege

    om

    etri

    c d

    esig

    n

    for

    a co

    llect

    or

    road

    .

    7Th

    e al

    ign

    men

    t m

    eets

    geo

    met

    ric

    des

    ign

    as

    a co

    llect

    or

    road

    fo

    r p

    ost

    ed a

    nd

    des

    ign

    sp

    eed

    lim

    its

    of

    40km

    /hr

    and

    50k

    m/h

    r re

    spec

    tive

    ly.

    7Th

    e al

    ign

    men

    t m

    eets

    an

    d

    exce

    ed

    s th

    e ge

    om

    etri

    c d

    esig

    n a

    s a

    colle

    cto

    r ro

    ad f

    or

    po

    sted

    an

    d

    des

    ign

    sp

    eed

    lim

    its

    of

    40km

    /hr

    and

    50k

    m/h

    r re

    spec

    tive

    ly.

    Tech

    nic

    al -

    Stru

    ctu

    ral/

    fou

    nd

    atio

    n/p

    avem

    ent

    des

    ign

    re

    qu

    irem

    ents

    ; To

    po

    grap

    hy;

    Cu

    t/fi

    ll;

    Co

    nst

    ruct

    abili

    ty (

    extr

    aord

    inar

    y re

    qu

    irem

    ents

    )

    10G

    eote

    chn

    ical

    inve

    stig

    atio

    ns

    in

    the

    area

    ind

    icat

    e th

    ere

    are

    no

    ge

    ote

    chn

    ical

    co

    nce

    rns

    that

    wo

    uld

    im

    pac

    t th

    is a

    lign

    men

    t. M

    arkh

    am

    stan

    dar

    d r

    oad

    pav

    emen

    t d

    esig

    n

    req

    uir

    ed. T

    her

    e ar

    e n

    o

    extr

    aord

    inar

    y re

    qu

    irem

    ents

    fo

    r co

    nst

    ruct

    ion

    , in

    clu

    din

    g cu

    t/fi

    ll.

    10G

    eote

    chn

    ical

    inve

    stig

    atio

    ns

    in

    the

    area

    ind

    icat

    e th

    ere

    are

    no

    ge

    ote

    chn

    ical

    co

    nce

    rns

    that

    wo

    uld

    im

    pac

    t th

    is a

    lign

    men

    t. M

    arkh

    am

    stan

    dar

    d r

    oad

    pav

    emen

    t d

    esig

    n

    req

    uir

    ed. T

    her

    e ar

    e n

    o

    extr

    aord

    inar

    y re

    qu

    irem

    ents

    fo

    r co

    nst

    ruct

    ion

    , in

    clu

    din

    g cu

    t/fi

    ll.

    10G

    eote

    chn

    ical

    inve

    stig

    atio

    ns

    in

    the

    area

    ind

    icat

    e th

    ere

    are

    no

    ge

    ote

    chn

    ical

    co

    nce

    rns

    that

    wo

    uld

    im

    pac

    t th

    is a

    lign

    men

    t. M

    arkh

    am

    stan

    dar

    d r

    oad

    pav

    emen

    t d

    esig

    n

    req

    uir

    ed. T

    her

    e ar

    e n

    o

    extr

    aord

    inar

    y re

    qu

    irem

    ents

    fo

    r co

    nst

    ruct

    ion

    , in

    clu

    din

    g cu

    t/fi

    ll.

    10G

    eote

    chn

    ical

    inve

    stig

    atio

    ns

    in

    the

    area

    ind

    icat

    e th

    ere

    are

    no

    ge

    ote

    chn

    ical

    co

    nce

    rns

    that

    wo

    uld

    im

    pac

    t th

    is a

    lign

    men

    t. M

    arkh

    am

    stan

    dar

    d r

    oad

    pav

    emen

    t d

    esig

    n

    req

    uir

    ed. T

    her

    e ar

    e n

    o

    extr

    aord

    inar

    y re

    qu

    irem

    ents

    fo

    r co

    nst

    ruct

    ion

    , in

    clu

    din

    g cu

    t/fi

    ll.

    Tech

    nic

    al -

    Stag

    ing

    Req

    uir

    emen

    ts7

    Rel

    oca

    tio

    n o

    f h

    erit

    age

    ho

    me,

    if

    allo

    wed

    , will

    req

    uir

    e so

    me

    stag

    ing.

    4Ex

    isti

    ng

    tow

    nh

    ou

    ses

    will

    req

    uir

    e fu

    ll ac

    cess

    du

    rin

    g co

    nst

    ruct

    ion

    , w

    hic

    h r

    equ

    ires

    co

    nsi

    der

    able

    st

    agin

    g. T

    her

    e w

    ill a

    lso

    be

    relo

    cati

    on

    of

    a h

    erit

    age

    ho

    me,

    if

    allo

    wed

    wh

    ich

    req

    uir

    es s

    om

    e st

    agin

    g.

    9N

    o s

    tagi

    ng

    req

    uir

    ed (

    bro

    wn

    fiel

    d,

    no

    rel

    oca

    tio

    n o

    f st

    ruct

    ure

    s/h

    erit

    age

    feat

    ure

    s).

    3P

    ote

    nti

    al s

    tagi

    ng

    req

    uir

    ed w

    ith

    th

    e ch

    urc

    h o

    per

    atio

    n.

    Sco

    re =

    7.

    67.

    36

    .95

    .1

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Evalu

    ation M

    atr

    ix

    Alig

    nm

    ent

    Op

    tio

    n #

    1A

    lign

    men

    t O

    pti

    on

    #2

    Alig

    nm

    ent

    Op

    tio

    n #

    3A

    lign

    men

    t O

    pti

    on

    #4

    Tota

    l Wei

    ghte

    d S

    core

    =

    5.2

    5.8

    8.1

    7.7

    Note

    : A

    sens

    itiv

    ity a

    naly

    sis

    wa

    s p

    erf

    orm

    ed

    with

    Tra

    nsp

    ort

    ation/

    Utilities

    weig

    hte

    d a

    t

    40%

    and a

    ll o

    ther

    cate

    gori

    es

    at 1

    5%

    . Th

    e r

    esu

    ltin

    g s

    core

    s w

    ere

    as

    follo

    ws:

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Trans

    port

    ation

    Ana

    lysis

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Trans

    port

    ation

    Ana

    lysis

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Trans

    port

    ation

    Ana

    lysis

  • Mill

    iken

    Mai

    n S

    tree

    t La

    nd

    ow

    ner

    s G

    rou

    p In

    c.

    Pha

    se 3

    –EA

    Pro

    cess

    Trans

    port

    ation

    Ana

    lysis