Upload
minh-tan
View
220
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/3/2019 Sect 4 Proj Controls_Rev 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sect-4-proj-controlsrev-3 1/7
HES6175 Project Costing - Module #4Project Controls
Module #4
Project Controls
HES5175 Cost EngineeringHES5175 Cost Engineering
HES6175HES6175 – – Project CostingProject Costing
Swinburne University of Technology
Authors: Laurence J Pole, Australian Cost Engineering Society & Colin Cropley, Crescent PSS
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia © AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETY
A Technical Society of Engineers Australia2
Outline of LectureProject Controls:Project Controls:
The essential project management processes of :
planning, estimating, budgeting, schedule coordination, controlling, monitoring, forecasting, reviewing and reporting
to ensure completion of projects: on (or ahead of) time within budget.
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
3
Outline of LectureTechniques and tools for Project Controls:Techniques and tools for Project Controls:
Work Breakdown Structure (WBS)Which represents:
project work to be done, and/or deliverable productsThese may be both tangible and intellectual
Earned Value Measurement (EVM)A method of measuring project progress:
What was planned to be done? How much has been achieved? Is the project under or over budget? Is the project behind or ahead of time?
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
4
4.1 Project Controls
Project Controls involve:Project Controls involve:
applying cost engineering principles during project execution identifying trends in expenditure that vary from the control budget
Resources being controlled include: manhours, direct and indirect project costs, allowance and contingency budgets, and time.
Immediate remedial action for unfavourable trends, by: increasing the number of personnel or changing work hours and/or methods, increased control of material usage or wastage, changes to procurement sources, and increased management involvement.
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
5
4.2 Work Breakdown Structures (WBS)
Definition:
“The purpose of a work breakdown structure (WBS)is to divide the program/project into manageable pieces of work to facilitate planning and control of cost, schedule and technical content.
A WBS is written early in program/project development.
It identifies the total work to be performed and divides the work into manageable elements, with increasing levels of detail.”
(NASA)
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
6
4.2.1 WBS Upper Level Hierarchy
Building
Project
Cladding
& RoofingServices
Fitout
& FinishesStructure
Excavation &
Drainage
Concrete
Structural
Steel
Brickwork
Widows
Roofing
Fire
HVAC
Plumbing
Electrical
Partitions
Flooring
Joinery
Painting
8/3/2019 Sect 4 Proj Controls_Rev 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sect-4-proj-controlsrev-3 2/7
HES6175 Project Costing - Module #4Project Controls
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
7
4.2.2 WBS Hierarchy - The 100% Rule
WBS includes 100% of the work defined by the
project scope and captures all deliverables – internal,
external, and
interim
in terms of the work to be completed, including project management.
Rule applies at all levels within the hierarchy:
the sum of the work at the “child” level must equal 100% of the work represented by the “parent”
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
8
4.2.2 WBS Hierarchy - The 100%Rule
WBS should not include any work that falls outside
the actual scope of the project, that is, it cannot include more than 100% of the work…
100% Rule applies to the activity level.
The work represented by the activities in each work
package must add up to 100% of the work necessary to
complete the work package.
(PMI Practice Standard for Work Breakdown Structures)
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
9
4.2.2 WBS Lower Level Hierarchy
Excavation &
Drainage
Excavate Basement Dig Drain Lines
Dispose of Excess FillInstall Perimeter
Drains
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
10
WBS Aircraft Manufacture (NASA)
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
11
4.2 WBS Structure
WBS structure is developed by first identifying thesystem or project to be built, then
subdividing it into increasingly detailed andmanageable elements (e.g., assemblies,
subassemblies, and components), or the aggregation into logical sets for management
control purposes (e.g., buildings and utilities)
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
12
WBS Aircraft Manufacture (NASA)
8/3/2019 Sect 4 Proj Controls_Rev 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sect-4-proj-controlsrev-3 3/7
HES6175 Project Costing - Module #4Project Controls
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
13
4.2 WBS Structure
WBS must be:
measurable and
verifiable (i.e., quality assurance)
independent of those responsible for the element's completion.
WBS provide a solid basis for:
technical,
schedule and cost plans and
progress status
incremental project performance assessment
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
14
4.2 WBS Structure
WBS elements should have a title and anumbering system that identifies the:
level of the WBS element. higher-level element to which the element is linked
cost account number (if any) of the element.
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
15
4.2 WBS StructureAdding a numbering system to the aircraft WBS elements
provides a management tool:
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
16
4.2 WBS Structure
Project WBS follow a hierarchical level format
Where would you start with a Space Telescope?
Hubble Space Telescope (NASA) Hubble View of Saturn (NASA)
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
17
4.2 WBS Structure Project WBS follow a hierarchical level format
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
18
4.2 WBS StructureCriteria for a good Work Package system are :-
Completion criteria are defined
this package is completed when ‘this’ is done
Work Packages should be small and correspondto the level of desired control.
Work Packages are identified with a ‘verb + noun’e.g. “Design Pump Foundations”
Projects may have hundreds and even thousandsof Work Packages, unnecessary breakdown mustbe avoided.
8/3/2019 Sect 4 Proj Controls_Rev 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sect-4-proj-controlsrev-3 4/7
HES6175 Project Costing - Module #4Project Controls
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
19
4.2 WBS Structure
WBS is a pr oject management tool:
provides a framework to categoriestechnical aspects of the project
defines the project in terms of hierarchically-related,
product-oriented elements and
work processes required
Each element of the W BS provideslogical summary points for
assessing technicalaccomplishments, and
measuring cost and scheduleperformance.
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
20
4.3 Cost Codes
At project level for control purposes it is necessary toidentify various types of costs e.g.:
labour, construction equipment operation,
usage of materials,
usage of services, etc
Also to identify the work items on which those costswere/will be expended.
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
21
4.3 Cost Codes
Cost Code - a structured system:
to identify and
separate the costs of undertaking numerousindividual work items
required to execute a Project.
A cost code should have a pyramid (hierarchical)structured. Most codes are numeric, some arealpha-numeric. (refer to module #4 notes)
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
22
4.3 Cost Codes
Bill of Quantities and/or Schedules of Rates:(provided with mainly civil engineering tenders)
generally in a part cost code format
identifying the different work components in theProject.
may be detailed
(e.g. identifying in situ concrete by types & locations)
or very broad
(e.g. all reinforcing steel regardless of size, shape orlocation).
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
23
4.3 Cost Codes
Schedules of Rates contract items for construction ofJindabyne Dam (Snowy Mountains Scheme).
Item Description Quantity Unit
60 Concrete in blockouts 13 m³
61 Concrete in adits 450 m³
62 Concrete in grout cap and miscellaneous f illing 1 000 m ³
63 Concrete in spillway walls 4 700 m³64 Concrete in spillway crest and slab 2 300 m³
65 Concrete in spillway piers, cantilever walls, etc 1 400 m ³
66 Concrete in spillway bridge 170 m³
67 Concrete in counterweights 50 m³
68 Concrete in minor structures 120 m³
Figure 4.3.1 Schedule of Rates Items for Dam Construction
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
24
4.3 Cost Codes
The Jindabyne Dam SofR is not sufficient for an overall system. It was
neither comprehensive nor standard.
An organisation wide Cost Code system is needed to provideuniformity in:
planning,
scheduling,
estimating,
cost reporting, and
storage of information for future use.
Cost Code systems - need to be comprehensive to match the
organisation’s fields of activity.
Excessive detail should be avoided as it will create problemswith recording in the field.
8/3/2019 Sect 4 Proj Controls_Rev 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sect-4-proj-controlsrev-3 5/7
HES6175 Project Costing - Module #4Project Controls
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
25
4.8 Progress Measurement
Progress measurement for the project commences at thebaseline plan that consists of:
the budget,
schedule and
Key Performance Indicators (KPI’s)
Baseline expressed as time phased budgets, derived byapplying cost budgets to activi ties in the baseline schedule.
An essential feature of project control good practice is that thebaseline documentation (Plan and Schedule) is saved andquarantined for future reference, after agreement with allstakeholders.
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
26
4.8 Progress Measurement
The Project Budget should: Have a time phased revenue and cost expenditure derived from
and consistent with the WBS and Schedule,
Cover the entire Project, from Start to Completion,
Be reconciled against the Contract and the Tender or final bidestimates,
Identify time and cost contingency based on a formal riskassessment,
Identify Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), including cost,revenue, cash flow, major risks, plus any project specificperformance indicators.
Approved by Line Management as per their delegations.
Signed off by Project Manager.
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
27
4.8 Progress Measurement
KPI’s are budgeted by period based on the baselineschedule and include at least the following:
1. Revenue over time
2. Costs over time
3. Contingency for risk
4. Schedule performance
5. Project specific KPIs
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
28
4.8 Progress Measurement
Consists of regular application
of project costing to:
Monitor
Analyse
Forecast
Report
‘Earned Value’
a technique to measure value of work performedat a given time on a project
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
29
4.8 Progress Measurement
What Do We Mean by Earned Value?
An example of the simplest form Earned Value:
During a project when a cost engineer verifiesthat the physical work claimed to have beendone by a contractor in a particular timeframehas actually been done before approving thecontractor’s invoice for payment.
i.e. Critical relationship between the actualcosts expended versus the physical workactually accomplished
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
30
4.9 Earned Value Measurement
Applying Earned ValueA technique to report project performance by:
Integrating project Scope,
Schedule and
Resources
Earned Value Analysis is the most commonly used form ofproject performance management.
It involves calculating three key values for each activity andsumming these over the project schedule:
Planned Value (PV)
Actual Cost (AC)
Earned Value (EV)
8/3/2019 Sect 4 Proj Controls_Rev 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sect-4-proj-controlsrev-3 6/7
HES6175 Project Costing - Module #4Project Controls
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
31
4.9.2 How Does Earned Value Work?
1. Create a baseline S-Curve, called the Planned Value (PV) curve:
Planned Value (PV) curve shows the project budget expenditureover time (if work proceeds in accordance with the program).
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
32
4.9.2 How Does Earned Value Work?
Actual Cost (AC) is plotted each month against the Planned Value curveto see if the project has been spending money at the planned rate.This provides only half the picture.
Example:After 5 months
• Planned Valueexpenditure of $3.0Mwas expected• Actual spend was $2.0M
• Have we have fallen $1.0M behind programme? or• Have we done all the work we should have, but done it $1.0M cheaper ?
Earned Value Analysis is designed to answer these questions.
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
33
4.9.2 How Does Earned Value Work?
Using Earned Value analysis, we look to understand how much weshould have paid for the work we have done to date. Each updateperiod (usually monthly) we look at the work that has been achieved,and what the budget was for completing this work. This is called theEarned Budget.
Example A:• We have done $2.5M worth ofbudgeted work for the $2.0M wehave spent, then we have saved$0.5M against budget so far.
• However we are still $0.5Mbehind the $3,0M worth of workwe had planned to complete bythe end of month 5.
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
34
4.9.2 How Does Earned Value Work?
Example B:
If we have only done $1.8M worth of budgeted work for the $2.0M wehave spent, then we have overspent by $0.2M.Even worse, we are actually $1.2M behind where we had planned tobe by month 5, as shown:
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
35
4.9.2 How Does Earned Value Work?
Information Recorded and Plotted on Graphs:
Planned Value (PV)The cumulative amount of a budget that was planned to be expended by the endof a reporting period. This is the time distribution of the project budget, Oftenreferred to as the project S-Curve.
Earned Budget (EB)The amount that was budgeted to perform the work that has been completed todate.
Actual.-Cost (AC)
The actual cost incurred and recorded in accomplishing the work performed todate.
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
36
4.9.2 How Does Earned Value Work?
Analysis from Graphed Information :
Schedule Variance (SV)Difference between the Earned Budget and the Planned Value at a point in time.
SV = EB - PVSchedule variance is measured in dollars and is a measure of how far ahead orbehind schedule the project is.A positive schedule variance implies the project is ahead of schedule
Cost Variance (CV)Difference between the Earned Budget and the Actual Cost at a point in time.
CV = EB -ACA positive cost variance implies that the project is running under budget.
Programme SlippageThe time (days, weeks, or months) the program has slipped.Scaled off the plotted curves as the horizontal distance between the PlannedValue Curve and the Earned Value Curve.
8/3/2019 Sect 4 Proj Controls_Rev 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sect-4-proj-controlsrev-3 7/7
HES6175 Project Costing - Module #4Project Controls
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERINGSOCIETY A Technical Society of Engineers
Australia
37
4.9.2 How Does Earned Value Work?
Summary:
Graphically Plotted Information:• Planned Value (PV)
• Earned Budget (EB)• Actual Cost (AC)
Calculated Values:• Schedule Variance (SV)• Time slippage• Cost Variance (CV)• Schedule Performance (SP)• Cost Performance (CP)• To Go Performance (TGP)
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERINGSOCIETY A Technical Society of Engineers
Australia
38
4.9.2 How Does Earned Value Work?
EARNED VALUE MEASURESchedule Variance SV = EB - PVTime Slippage months from ‘S’ CurveCost Variance CV = EB – ACSchedule Performance SP = EB/PV
Cost Performance CP = EB/ACTo Go Performance TGP = (BAC-EB)/(BAC-AC)
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
39
4.9.2 Project Tracking – Without Earned Value
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
40
4.9.2 Project Tracking – With Earned Value
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
41
4.9.2 Project Tracking – With Earned Value
© AUSTRALIAN COST ENGINEERING SOCIETYA Technical Society of Engineers Australia
42
4.9.2 Project Tracking – With Earned Value