Upload
ahmad-ulil-albab
View
219
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
T h e n e w e ngl a nd j o u r na l o f m e dic i n e
n engl j med 368;7 nejm.org february 14, 2013 623
original article
Selumetinib-EnhancedRadioiodineUptakeinAdvancedThyroidCancer
Alan L. Ho, M.D., Ph.D., Ravinder K. Grewal, M.D., Rebecca Leboeuf, M.D., Eric J. Sherman, M.D., David G. Pfister, M.D., Desiree Deandreis, M.D.,
Keith S. Pentlow, M.Sc., Pat B. Zanzonico, Ph.D., Sofia Haque, M.D., Somali Gavane, M.D., Ronald A. Ghossein, M.D., Julio C. Ricarte-Filho, Ph.D.,
José M. Domínguez, M.D., Ronglai Shen, Ph.D., R. Michael Tuttle, M.D., Steve M. Larson, M.D., and James A. Fagin, M.D.
From the Head and Neck Oncology Ser-vice (A.L.H., E.J.S., D.G.P.) and the Endo-crinology Service (R.L., R.M.T., J.A.F.), Department of Medicine, and the De-partments of Radiology (R.K.G., D.D., S.H., S.G., S.M.L.), Medical Physics (K.S.P., P.B.Z.), Pathology (R.A.G.), and Human Oncology and Pathogenesis ( J.C.R.-F., J.M.D., J.A.F.), and the Epide-miology–Biostatistics (R.S.) and Molec-ular Pharmacology and Chemistry (S.M.L.) Programs, Memorial Sloan-Ket-tering Cancer Center and Weill Cornell Medical College, New York. Address re-print requests to Dr. Fagin at the Memo-rial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, 1275 York Ave., New York, NY 10065.
N Engl J Med 2013;368:623-32.DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa1209288Copyright © 2013 Massachusetts Medical Society.
A BS TR AC T
Background
Metastaticthyroidcancersthatarerefractorytoradioiodine(iodine-131)areassoci-atedwithapoorprognosis.Inmousemodelsofthyroidcancer,selectivemitogen-activatedproteinkinase(MAPK)pathwayantagonistsincreasetheexpressionofthesodium–iodidesymporteranduptakeofiodine.Theireffectsinhumansarenotknown.
Methods
WeconductedastudytodeterminewhethertheMAPKkinase(MEK)1andMEK2inhibitorselumetinib(AZD6244,ARRY-142886)couldreverserefractorinesstoradio-iodineinpatientswithmetastaticthyroidcancer.Afterstimulationwiththyrotropinalfa, dosimetry with iodine-124 positron-emission tomography (PET) was per-formedbeforeand4weeksaftertreatmentwithselumetinib(75mgtwicedaily).Ifthesecondiodine-124PETstudyindicatedthatadoseofiodine-131of2000cGyormorecouldbedeliveredtothemetastaticlesionorlesions,therapeuticradioiodinewasadministeredwhilethepatientwasreceivingselumetinib.
Results
Of24patientsscreenedforthestudy,20couldbeevaluated.Themedianagewas61years(range,44to77),and11patientsweremen.NinepatientshadtumorswithBRAFmutations,and5patientshadtumorswithmutationsofNRAS.Selumetinibincreasedtheuptakeofiodine-124in12ofthe20patients(4of9patientswithBRAFmutationsand5of5patientswithNRASmutations).Eightof these12patientsreachedthedosimetrythresholdforradioiodinetherapy,includingall5patientswithNRASmutations.Ofthe8patientstreatedwithradioiodine,5hadconfirmedpartialresponsesand3hadstabledisease;allpatientshaddecreasesinserumthy-roglobulinlevels(meanreduction,89%).Notoxiceffectsofgrade3orhigherat-tributablebytheinvestigatorstoselumetinibwereobserved.Onepatientreceivedadiagnosisofmyelodysplasticsyndromemorethan51weeksafterradioiodinetreat-ment,withprogressiontoacuteleukemia.
Conclusions
Selumetinibproducesclinicallymeaningfulincreasesiniodineuptakeandretentioninasubgroupofpatientswiththyroidcancerthatisrefractorytoradioiodine;theef-fectivenessmaybegreaterinpatientswithRAS-mutantdisease.(FundedbytheAmer-icanThyroidAssociationandothers;ClinicalTrials.govnumber,NCT00970359.)
The New England Journal of Medicine Downloaded from nejm.org on February 7, 2014. For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2013 Massachusetts Medical Society. All rights reserved.
T h e n e w e ngl a nd j o u r na l o f m e dic i n e
n engl j med 368;7 nejm.org february 14, 2013624
Metastatic disease is the most fre-quentcauseofdeathrelatedtothyroidcancer.1 Radioiodine (iodine-131) re-
mains amainstay of therapy for patientswithmetastaticthyroidcanceroffollicularorigin(i.e.,papillarythyroidcancerorfollicularthyroidcan-cer).Unfortunately,manypatientshave tumorsthatdonotconcentrate iodine,resulting inra-dioiodine resistanceandapoorprognosis (the10-yearsurvivalrateamongpatientswithmeta-static thyroid cancer that retains radioiodineavidityisapproximately60%,whereasitisonly10%ifthemetastasesarerefractorytoradioio-dinetherapy).2Severaltrialshaveevaluatedstrat-egiesto“redifferentiate”metastaticthyroidcan-cersandrenderthemresponsivetoradioiodine,includingtrialsevaluatingretinoids3-5andlithi-um,6whichonlyyieldedamodestclinicalbenefit.Thesestudieswerealsolimitedbymethodologicissuessuchastheinabilitytoquantifyradioio-dineuptakeandretentionintumors,sotheef-fectoftheinterventionswasdifficulttoassess.
Approximately70%ofpapillarythyroidcan-cershavemutuallyexclusivegenemutationsen-codingthegrowthfactorreceptorsRETorNTRK1,thethreeisoformsofRAS(N,H,K),andBRAF.7-10Constitutiveactivationoftheseproteinsstimulatesmitogen-activatedproteinkinase(MAPK)signal-ing,whichinhibitstheexpressionofthyroidhor-monebiosynthesisgenes,includingthesodium–iodidesymporterandthyroidperoxidase,whichfacilitate iodine uptake and organification, re-spectively.11-15 Cancers that do not concentrateradioiodinedevelopintransgenicmiceinwhichmutantBRAFisexpressedinthyroidcells.16WhenBRAFactivationisswitchedoffgeneticallyoritsdownstreamsignaling is inhibitedwithkinaseinhibitorstargetingeitherMAPKkinase(MEK)orBRAF, the tumors regain theability to trapradioiodine.
These preclinical observations provided therationale for our pilot clinical study, in whichpatientswhowerefoundtohavemetastasesthatwererefractorytoradioiodineweretreatedwiththe selective, allostericMEK 1 andMEK 2 in-hibitor selumetinib (AZD6244,ARRY-142886),17andchangesiniodineuptakewereassessedbymeans of serial iodine-124 positron-emissiontomography(PET)–computedtomography(CT).Theuseofiodine-124PET-CTratherthantradi-tional whole-body iodine-131 scintigraphy al-
lowedforprecisequantificationofiodineuptakebeforeandafterselumetinibtreatment inindi-vidualmetastatic lesions (“lesional dosimetry”)and prediction of the dose of radiation thatcouldbedeliveredwithiodine-131.18,19
Me thods
Study Conduct
Thetrialwasconductedinaccordancewiththestudyprotocol,availablewiththefulltextofthisarticleatNEJM.org.Allpatientsprovidedwritteninformedconsent.ThestudywasapprovedbytheresearchcommitteesoftheDepartmentsofMed-icine,Radiology,andMedicalPhysicsatMemo-rialSloan-KetteringCancerCenter(MSKCC)andbythecenter’sinstitutionalreviewboard.Allau-thorsvouchforthedata,thefidelityofthestudytotheprotocol,andtheanalysis.Noonewhoisnotlistedasanauthorcontributedtothemanu-script.
Patients
Patientswererequiredtohavedifferentiatedthy-roidcarcinomaoffollicular-cellorigin,oritsre-spectivevariants,histopathologicallyconfirmedattheMSKCC.Patientsalsohadtomeetatleastone of the following criteria for radioiodine-refractorydisease:anindexmetastaticlesionthatwasnotradioiodine-avidondiagnosticradioio-dine scanningperformedup to 2 years beforeenrollment;aradioiodine-avidmetastaticlesionthat remained stable in size orprogressedde-spite radioiodine treatment 6 months or morebeforeentryintothestudy;and18F-fluorodeoxy-glucose (FDG)–avid lesions on PET scanning(FDGavidity is indicativeof lessdifferentiatedthyroid tumors with impaired iodine uptake20andresistancetoradioiodine,21whichareassoci-ated with a poor prognosis22). (For additionalinclusionandexclusioncriteria,seetheSupple-mentaryMethodssectionintheSupplementaryAppendix, available at NEJM.org.) Thyrotropinalfa(Thyrogen)wasprovidedbyGenzyme,andselumetinib was provided by AstraZeneca. IBAMolecularprovidedtheiodine-124forthestudy.Thesecompaniesdidnotparticipateinanyas-pectofthestudydesign,dataaccrual,dataanal-ysis, ormanuscript preparation. The investiga-tionalnewdrugapplicationforselumetinibwasheldbyMSKCC.
The New England Journal of Medicine Downloaded from nejm.org on February 7, 2014. For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2013 Massachusetts Medical Society. All rights reserved.
Selumetinib and R adioiodine Uptake in Thyroid Cancer
n engl j med 368;7 nejm.org february 14, 2013 625
Study Design
After adhering toa low-iodinediet for5days,patientsunderwentathyrotropinalfa–stimulatediodine-124PET-CTstudy,followedbytreatmentwithselumetinibatadoseof75mggivenorallytwicedailyfor4weeks.Inthefourthweekofsel-umetinibtreatment,patientsunderwentasecondiodine-124PET-CTstudy.Spoturinaryiodinemea-surementswereperformedbeforeeachiodine-124PETevaluation(medianurinaryiodinevaluedur-ingthestudy,99μgperliter;range,0to374)toruleoutclinicallysignificantiodinecontamina-tionbeforeeachscan.Patientsdiscontinuedthestudyifthesecondiodine-124PETevaluationdidnotshowanincreaseiniodineuptaketoapre-specifieddosimetrythreshold.Ifthisdosimetrythresholdwasmet,thenpatientscontinuedtore-ceiveselumetinib(andalow-iodinediet)asthyro-tropin alfa–stimulated whole-body and blooddosimetrystudieswereperformedtodeterminethemaximumtolerableactivitypursuanttothestandardofcareatMSKCC.23Afterdetermina-tionofthemaximumtolerableactivity,athera-peuticdoseofiodine-131wasadministeredafterstimulationwiththyrotropinalfa.24Selumetinibwas continued until 2 days after ingestion oftherapeuticiodine-131.Toxiceffectsweremoni-toredfor30daysafterthelastdoseofselumeti-nib. Patients continued to receive suppressivethyroidhormonetreatmentthroughoutthepro-tocol.Thesecondiodine-124PET-CTstudyinonepatientwasdelayedbyaweekbecauseofatem-poraryshortageof the iodine-124radionuclide;thisstudyshowednoappreciablechangeinio-dineuptake.
Inpatientswhoreceived iodine-131,CT im-aging,magneticresonanceimaging,orbothwasperformed 2 and 6 months after radioiodinetherapy.Oneradiologistassessedtheradiologicresponseinallpatients,ascomparedwithprestudyscans, according to the Response EvaluationCriteria in Solid Tumors (RECIST) version 1.1.Levelsofserumthyrotropin,freethyroxine,thy-roglobulin, and thyroglobulin antibodies weremeasured1,2,and6monthsafteradministra-tionofradioiodine.
Iodine-124 PET-CT Studies
Patientsreceived0.9mgofthyrotropinalfaintra-muscularlyoncedailyfor2consecutivedays,andthen6mCiofiodine-124orallythenextday.Two
dayslater,imagingwasperformedwiththeuseofaPET-CTscanner(DiscoverySTE,GEHealth-care),withouttheadministrationofcontrastma-terial.Thepatientwasscannedfromthecantho-meatalline(thelinebetweenthecenteroftheearcanaland the junctionof theupperand lowereyelids)tothemidthighwiththeuseofseventoninebedpositions,withscansof6minutesperbedposition.Theimagesinallthepatientswereinterpreted in a blinded fashion by the sameboard-certifiednuclear-medicinephysician,andthenumber,size,andmaximalstandardizedup-takevalueofthelesionsineachbodyregionwererecorded.
If the second iodine-124PET-CTstudy indi-catedincreasediodineuptakeintheindexlesion(orlesions),anestimatewasmadeoftheadmin-isteredactivityofiodine-131requiredtodeliveraprojectedabsorbeddoseof2000cGyormoretothelesion.Thisestimatewasbasedonthele-sionactivityconcentrationmeasuredonPETmul-tipliedbyarecoverycoefficientbasedonthelesiondimensionsmeasuredonCTandonanassumedbiologichalf-lifeofatleast2days.Ifitappearedthatoneormorelesionscouldbetreatedwithadoseof2000cGyormorewithaniodine-131ad-ministeredactivityofupto300mCi,thepatientwas then eligible for the standard iodine-131dosimetryprotocoltodeterminetheactualac-tivitytobeadministered.Inaddition,asprevi-ouslydescribed,an imaginganalysis toolwasusedwiththeGEPETvolumecomputer-assistedreadingsystemtolocalizeindividualiodine-124uptaketoaspecific,correspondinglesiononCT.25
Tissue Genotyping
MutationdetectioninDNAisolatedfromformalin-fixed,paraffin-embeddedarchivalsampleswasperformedwiththeuseofthemass-spectrometrygenotypingassay(MassArray,Sequenom),aspre-viously described.26 This assay interrogated formutationsinsomeofthemostcommonthyroidoncogenes,includingBRAF, NRAS, KRAS, PIK3CA, and AKT1. Since themass-spectrometry assaysforcodons12and13ofHRASwerenotinforma-tive, these sites were evaluated by means ofSangersequencing.Ifmassspectrometryanaly-sisfailed,sampleswereassayedforBRAF, NRAS, KRAS,andHRASmutationsbymeansofSangersequencing.Samplesthatwerewild-typeforon-cogenepointmutationswere screened for RET
The New England Journal of Medicine Downloaded from nejm.org on February 7, 2014. For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2013 Massachusetts Medical Society. All rights reserved.
T h e n e w e ngl a nd j o u r na l o f m e dic i n e
n engl j med 368;7 nejm.org february 14, 2013626
and PAX8–peroxisomeproliferator–activated re-ceptor gamma (PPARG) rearrangements. TumorcomplementaryDNA(cDNA)wasusedasatem-plate for a quantitative polymerase-chain-reac-tionassaytoidentifyunbalancedexpressionofexons10and11 relative to12and13ofRET,whichflanktherearrangementsiteinintron11(TableS1intheSupplementaryAppendix).Sam-pleswithgreaterexpressionofexons12and13thanofexons10and11wereconsideredtobepositive for an RET/PTC translocation. Cell-linecDNAfrommedullarythyroidcancers(TTcells)andpapillarythyroidcancers(TPC1cells)wereusedaspositivecontrolsforexpressionoffull-lengthRETandRETfusionmessengerRNA,re-spectively.
Statistical Analysis
Theprimaryendpointwasthepercentageofpa-tientswithselumetinib-inducedincreasesinio-dineuptakeintheindextumor(ortumors),asquantifiedbyiodine-124PETatbaselineandaf-ter4weeksofselumetinib.Weadoptedas the
nullhypothesisan increase in iodine-124PET–quantifiediodineuptakein5%ofpatients,withincreaseduptakein25%ofpatientsconsideredtobedesirable.Withatype1errorof5%andapower of 85%, increased iodine uptake in thesecond iodine-124 PET scanwould need to beobservedinatleastthreepatientsforthestudytobeconsideredpositive.Asecondprimaryendpointwasthetumorresponseatapproximately2and6monthsafteriodine-131treatmentaccordingtoRECIST,version1.1.
Asecondaryendpointwasanassessmentofwhethertreatmentwithiodine-131afterselume-tinibwasassociatedwithdecreasedserumthy-roglobulinlevelsat2and6months.AWilcoxonsigned-ranktestforpairedsampleswasusedforthislandmarkcomparisonateachfollow-upas-sessment.Undetectablethyroglobulinvaluesclin-icallyreportedaslessthan0.2ngpermilliliterwereassignedavalueof0.2ngpermilliliterforcalculations.Anadditional,exploratoryendpointwasanassessmentofdifferencesinselumetinibefficacyforenhancingradioiodineuptakebetweenpatientswithBRAFmutationsandpatientswithwild-typeBRAF(additionaldetailsofthestatisti-cal design are included in the SupplementaryAppendix).Weuseddescriptivestatisticsforthisassessment.
R esult s
Study Population
BetweenAugust2010andDecember2011,atotalof24patientswerereferredandscreenedforthestudy. Two patients were ineligible because ofbaselinemeasurementsof theQT interval cor-rectedforheartratewhichwereoutsidethestudyrange.Twopatientswereenrolledbutdiscontin-uedthestudybeforeselumetinibwasadminis-tered: 1 inwhom a new brainmetastasiswasdiagnosedand1inwhomiodinatedcontrastma-terialwasusedforadiagnosticscanthatrevealedapulmonaryembolism.
Baselineclinicalcharacteristicsofthe20pa-tientswhocouldbeevaluatedarelistedinTable1.Fivepatients(25%)hadclassicpapillarythyroidcancer, 8 (40%) had tall-cell–variant papillarythyroidcancer,and7(35%)hadpoorlydifferen-tiated carcinoma. Nine patients had a BRAF V600Emutation,5hadanNRASmutationatco-don 61 (Q→RorK), 3 had RET/PTC rearrange-
Table 1. Baseline Characteristics of the 20 Patients.
Characteristic Value
Age — yr
Median 61
Range 44–77
Sex — no.
Male 11
Female 9
Type of tumor — no./total no. (%)
Classic papillary 5/20 (25)
Tall-cell papillary 8/20 (40)
Poorly differentiated 7/20 (35)
Tumor genotype — no./total no. (%)
BRAF V600E 9/20 (45)
NRAS Q61R and Q61K 5/20 (25)
RET/PTC 3/20 (15)
Wild type 3/20 (15)
Median no. of prior radioiodine treatments per patient 2.1
Other treatments for thyroid cancer — no. of patients/ total no. (%)
External-beam radiation therapy 7/20 (35)
Targeted therapies* 2/20 (10)
* These patients received sorafenib in combination with an mTORC1 (mamma-lian target of rapamycin complex 1) inhibitor before enrollment in the study.
The New England Journal of Medicine Downloaded from nejm.org on February 7, 2014. For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2013 Massachusetts Medical Society. All rights reserved.
Selumetinib and R adioiodine Uptake in Thyroid Cancer
n engl j med 368;7 nejm.org february 14, 2013 627
ments,and3hadtumorsthatwerewild-typeforallgenesexamined.NoPAX8-PPARG rearrange-ments were detected. One BRAF-mutant tumorandoneRET/PTC tumorwerepoorlydifferenti-atedcarcinomas;theremainingtumorsofthesegenotypes were papillary thyroid cancers. AllfiveNRAS-mutanttumorswerepoorlydifferenti-atedcarcinomas.
Efficacy
Figure 1A shows the protocol design. Of the20patientswhocouldbeevaluated,12(60%)hadiodine-124 uptake that was new, increased, orboth after selumetinib (Fig. 1B). In 8 patients(40%),thesecondiodine-124PETstudyindicatedthat the absorbed radiation dose in the lesionwouldequalorexceed2000cGywith300mCiofradioiodineorless;thesepatientscontinuedtore-
ceiveselumetinib,andtheyreceivedtherapeuticradioiodine.Inall5patientswithNRAS-mutanttumors,thisdosimetrythresholdwasexceeded,andthesepatientsweretreatedwithradioiodine.Incontrast,4of9patientswithBRAFmutationshadselumetinib-inducedincreasesiniodine-124uptake,butonly1hadanincreasethatexceededthethresholdforradioiodinetreatment.Twoof3patientswithRET/PTCand1of3patientswithwild-typetumorshadgreater iodineuptakeonthe second iodine-124 PET study; 1 patient ineach of those genotype groups went on to betreatedwithiodine-131.Increasesiniodineup-takewereachievedinpatientswithpapillarythy-roidcancersandthosewithpoorlydifferentiatedcarcinomas(TableS2intheSupplementaryAp-pendix),aswellasinpatientsineachprotocol-specified categoryof radioiodine refractoriness
B
A
4/95/52/31/3
12/20
1/95/51/31/3
8/20
TumorGenotype
Patients with IncreasedIodine Uptake in a Lesion
after Selumetinib
Patients WhoReceived
Radioiodineno./total no. of patients
BRAF NRAS RET/PTCWild-typeTotal
Week 1 Week 2–4 Week 5
Selumetinib, 75 mg twice a day for 4 wk
124IPET-CT
124IPET-CT
Thyrotropinalfa injections
Thyrotropinalfa injections
Inadequate responseon 124I PET-CT
Positiveresponse on124I PET-CT
Discontinueselumetinib
Continueselumetiniband receiveradioiodine
therapy
Serial radiologicscans and
measurement ofserum thyro-
globulin levels
Figure 1. Protocol Design and Changes in Iodine Uptake.
Panel A shows the protocol design. Baseline iodine avidity in the lesion was first assessed with thyrotropin alfa–stimulated iodine-124 positron-emission tomographic–computed tomographic (PET-CT) scanning. Patients were then treated with sel u me ti nib at a dose of 75 mg given orally twice a day for 4 weeks. In the final week of treatment, a second thyrotropin alfa–stimulated 124I PET-CT study was performed. The double arrows indicate the two thyro-tropin alfa injections. Patients with 124I dosimetry that predicted tumor uptake of less than 2000 cGy discontinued the study. If the absorbed dose of radioiodine in the lesion was predicted to be 2000 cGy or greater, full dosimetry with iodine-131 was performed to calculate the maximum tolerable activity that could be administered safely. Patients then received a therapeutic dose of radioiodine the next week after preparation with thyrotropin alfa. Sel u me ti nib was continued until 2 days after the administration of therapeutic radioiodine. Thyroglobulin levels and the radio-graphic response were assessed at 2 and 6 months after radioiodine administration. Panel B shows a summary of the changes in iodine uptake quantified by 124I PET-CT and the number of patients who met the criteria for treat-ment with iodine-131.
The New England Journal of Medicine Downloaded from nejm.org on February 7, 2014. For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2013 Massachusetts Medical Society. All rights reserved.
T h e n e w e ngl a nd j o u r na l o f m e dic i n e
n engl j med 368;7 nejm.org february 14, 2013628
(TableS3intheSupplementaryAppendix).Ofthe10patientswithnodetectableiodine-124uptakeatbaseline,2hadincreaseduptakeafterreceiv-ingselumetinib,1ofwhomwentontoreceiveiodine-131.
The selumetinib-induced changes in the io-dine-124PET-CT scans are shown inFigure2.The only patient with a BRAF mutation whoqualified for radioiodine therapy had dramaticincreases in iodine uptake in a right cervicallymphnodeandlungmetastasesthatshowednouptake at baseline (Fig. 2A). In other patients,
iodineuptakewasenhancedbothinlesionswithlow-leveliodineavidityandthosewithnoavidityatbaseline(Fig.2B).Strikingincreasesinselu-metinib-induced iodine-124 uptake were alsoobservedinbonemetastases(Fig.2Cand2D).
Quantificationofbaselineandpost-selumeti-nib iodine-124ineachtumorinapatientwithanNRASmutationwhoqualifiedforradioiodinetherapy revealed either new iodine uptake ormorethana100%increaseinuptakeinnearlyeverylesion(Fig.3).Analysisofeverylesioninalleightpatientstreatedwithradioiodineshowed
C
A
D
B
Baseline After Selumetinib
Baseline After Selumetinib
Baseline After Selumetinib
Baseline
AfterSelumetinib
Figure 2. Iodine-124 PET-CT Scans Obtained before and after Sel u me ti nib Treatment in Selected Patients with Positive Responses.
Panel A shows whole-body maximum-intensity projection images of a patient with a BRAF-mutant papillary thyroid cancer. New iodine uptake is shown in nearly all previously negative lung and neck metastases. Panel B shows fused axial PET-CT images of a patient with an NRAS-mutant, poorly differentiated thyroid cancer. Both new and signifi-cantly increased iodine uptake in lung metastases is shown. Panels C and D show PET-CT images from another pa-tient with an NRAS-mutant, poorly differentiated thyroid cancer. In Panel C, fused axial PET-CT images show signifi-cantly increased iodine uptake in a sacroiliac bone metastasis after administration of sel u me ti nib (right). In Panel D, fused axial images (top and bottom left) show new iodine uptake in a previously negative site as well as increased avidity in a large left parietal skull metastasis. Three-dimensional rendering highlights changes in the left parietal skull metastasis before and after sel u me ti nib (top and bottom right).
The New England Journal of Medicine Downloaded from nejm.org on February 7, 2014. For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2013 Massachusetts Medical Society. All rights reserved.
Selumetinib and R adioiodine Uptake in Thyroid Cancer
n engl j med 368;7 nejm.org february 14, 2013 629
thatselumetinibincreasediodine-124uptakeinnearly all lesions, with more than a 100% in-creaseinuptakeinmostlesions(Fig.S1intheSupplementaryAppendix).Iodineuptakeinsali-
varyglandswasnotsignificantlyaffectedbysel-umetinib (Fig. S2 in the SupplementaryAppen-dix);thissuggeststhattheeffectwasrestrictedtothyroidtumors.
SUV
max
100
80
90
70
60
40
30
10
50
20
−10
0
Individual Tumors
B
A
Before selumetinibAfter selumetinib
Lesions with 124I Uptakeat Baseline
Lesions without 124IUptake at Baseline
SUV
max
aft
er S
elum
etin
ib
100
80
90
70
60
40
30
10
50
20
00 20 40 60 80
SUVmax before Selumetinib
(+100%) (+50%) (+25%)
(+0%)
(−25%)
(−50%)
(−75%)
Figure 3. Quantification of Iodine-124 PET Uptake in a Lesion in a Patient with an NRAS Mutation Who Later Received Radioiodine.
Panel A shows the maximal standardized uptake value (SUVmax) for iodine in all tumors in a patient with an NRAS-mutant, poorly differentiated thyroid cancer. Each bar represents one malignant lesion identified on the iodine-124 PET-CT scan. The bars to the left indicate the increases in iodine-124 avidity achieved after sel u me ti nib administra-tion in lesions that absorbed some iodine at baseline. The bars on the right indicate sel u me ti nib-induced changes in lesions that were negative for iodine at baseline. Panel B shows the SUVmax in every metastatic lesion identified in the same patient before and after the administration of sel u me ti nib. The dashed lines mark points on the graph cor-responding to different degrees of change in the SUVmax in the lesion after the administration of sel u me ti nib. The red dashed line demarcates no change in iodine uptake after the administration of sel u me ti nib (0%). Dashed lines to the left of the red dashed line represent graded percentage increases in iodine-124 uptake (+25%, +50%, and +100%), whereas the lines to the right represent graded percentage decreases (−25%, −50%, and −75%). Nearly all the metastatic lesions in this patient (circles) had more than a 100% increase in iodine uptake after administration of sel u me ti nib. The SUVmax for a sternal metastasis was off the scale (it increased from 220 to 599 with sel u me ti nib) and thus could not be included in these graphs without obscuring the data for the other 54 lesions analyzed.
The New England Journal of Medicine Downloaded from nejm.org on February 7, 2014. For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2013 Massachusetts Medical Society. All rights reserved.
T h e n e w e ngl a nd j o u r na l o f m e dic i n e
n engl j med 368;7 nejm.org february 14, 2013630
During6monthsoffollow-up,areductioninthe size of target lesions was observed in allpatientsaftertheadministrationofradioiodine,withconfirmedpartialresponsesinfivepatientsand stable disease in three as the best overallresponse(Fig.4A,andFig.S3intheSupplemen-taryAppendix). Significant decreases in thyro-tropin-suppressedserumthyroglobulinlevelsaf-terradioiodineadministrationwereachievedinalleightpatientsat2monthsand6monthsafterradioiodine administration, with mean reduc-tionsof89%(P=0.004)and80%(P=0.004),re-spectively,ascomparedwiththevaluemeasured
within 3 weeks before radioiodine administra-tion (Fig. 4B). In seven of the eight patients,confirmedpartialresponsesandstablediseaseoutcomesweredurableoverthe6-monthperiodof follow-up after radioiodine administration.Theremainingpatienthada48%reduction intumordimensions2monthsafterreceivingra-dioiodine but then had tumor progression at6months, representingabestoverall responseofstabledisease.
Safety
Allpatientswhocouldbeevaluatedcompletedthefullcourseofselumetinibwithoutadosere-ductionordelayinadministration.Alltoxicef-fectsattributedtoselumetinibweregrade1or2andwereconsistentwithadverseeventsreportedinlargerstudiesofselumetinib,27,28includingfa-tigue (in80%ofpatients),maculopapular rash(70%),andacneiformrash(25%).Fourteenpa-tients(70%)hadgrade1elevationsinliverami-notransferaselevels,possiblyrelatedtoselumeti-nib;theselevelsrevertedtobaselinevaluesafterdrugdiscontinuation.(TablesS4andS5intheSupplementaryAppendixlistallthetoxiceffectsreportedduringthestudy.)Onepatientwhowastreatedwith139mCiofradioiodineduringthestudyreceivedadiagnosisofthemyelodysplasticsyndromemorethan51weekslater;thediseaseeventuallyprogressedtoacuteleukemia.Beforeenrollment,thispatienthadreceivedthreecours-esofradioiodine(acumulativeprestudydoseof976.2mCi),aswellas8640cGyofexternal-beamradiationtherapy,forprostatecancer,andthrom-bocytopenia developed when the patient wastreated with sorafenib and temsirolimus in aclinicaltrial.
Discussion
Previous studies using various compounds topromoteradioiodineuptakeinrefractorymeta-staticthyroidcancershavenotshownaclinicallysignificantbenefit.3,6Theapproachundertakeninthisstudywasfacilitatedbyseveraldevelop-ments:thediscoverythatgeneticalterationsthatconstitutivelyactivateMAPKsignalingcanpro-mote the dedifferentiation of thyroid-cancercells,12,29,30theclinicalavailabilityofaselectiveMEKinhibitor,17andthedevelopmentofiodine-124PET-CTtechnologytoquantifytheuptakeofiodineinalesion.18
Max
imum
Cha
nge
in T
arge
t Les
ions
(%) 0
−20
−10
−30
−40
−60
−70
−90
−50
−80
−1001
RET/PTC2
WT3
NRAS4
NRAS5
NRAS7
NRAS6
NRAS8
BRAF
Patient No. and Genotype
B
Serum Thyroglobulin Values
ng/ml
PatientNo.
BeforeSelumetinib
(wk 1)
AfterSelumetinib
(wk 5)
1 Mo afterRadioiodine
Therapy
2 Mo afterRadioiodine
Therapy
6 Mo afterRadioiodine
Therapy
AStable disease Confirmed partial response
12345678
650360
2700510220840
650082
780880
32001300530570
1070650
240 270
3700 NA11.346
170 NA
200 210 740
31 0.4
31 66 23
740 194 480 22 <0.2
100 57 14
Figure 4. Response to Iodine-131 Therapy with Sel u me ti nib Treatment.
Panel A shows a waterfall plot of the maximum change in target lesions (relative to a prestudy scan) in the eight patients who received therapeutic radioiodine. The best overall response in each patient according to the Re-sponse Evaluation Criteria in Solid Tumors, version 1.1, is also shown. The dashed line indicates a 30% reduction in tumor dimensions. WT denotes wild-type. Panel B shows serum thyroglobulin values in the eight patients treated with radioiodine. NA denotes not available.
The New England Journal of Medicine Downloaded from nejm.org on February 7, 2014. For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2013 Massachusetts Medical Society. All rights reserved.
Selumetinib and R adioiodine Uptake in Thyroid Cancer
n engl j med 368;7 nejm.org february 14, 2013 631
Our results show that inhibition of theMAPKpathwaywithselumetinibcanrenewthetherapeuticefficacyof radioiodinebyenhanc-inguptakeinpatientswiththyroidcancerthatis refractory to radioiodine. All five patientswithNRAS-mutanttumorshadincreasediodineuptake in response to selumetinib; four hadconfirmedpartialresponsesandonehadstabledisease after radioiodine administration. Thisfindingisofparticularinterest,giventhewell-documentedchallengesofdevelopingtherapeu-ticapproachesforRAS-drivencancers,anditisconsistentwithpreclinicaldatashowingthataRAS mutation can suppress thyroid-specificgene expression in a MEK-dependent man-ner.12,31 Only one of nine patients with BRAFmutations received radioiodine therapy. Thatpatienthadaparticularlystrikingconversionoflesionsfromnegativetopositiveoniodine-124PETaftertreatmentwithselumetinibandhadaconfirmed partial response. Three other pa-tientswithBRAFmutationsalsohadincreaseduptakeonthepost-selumetinibiodine-124PETstudy, even though the threshold required fortherapy was not reached. The differences ob-served between RAS-mutant and BRAF-mutant
tumorsremaintobeexplained,butitispossi-blethatMAPKsignalingisincompletelyinhib-ited in some BRAF-mutant tumors because ofhigherf luxthroughthepathway.
TheseresultsprovideaproofofprinciplethatMEKinhibitorscaninduceiodineuptakeandre-tentioninthyroidtumors.Anadvantageofthistherapeuticstrategyoverlong-termtreatmentwithsmall-moleculekinaseinhibitorsalone32isthatonlyashortcourseofdrugtherapyisrequiredtoelicitadurableclinicaleffect.Enhancediodineuptake was also observed in bone and nodalmetastases,nichesthathavebeencomparativelyrefractorytotreatmentwithkinaseinhibitors.
SupportedbygrantsfromtheAmericanThyroidAssociation,theSocietyofMemorialSloan-KetteringCancerCenter,theNa-tional InstitutesofHealth (RO1-CA50706andRO1-CA72598),AstraZeneca,andGenzyme,aswellasfundingfromtheLefkof-skyFamily,MargotRosenbergPulitzer,Byrne,andJ.RandolphHearstfoundations.Theiodine-124PETstudiesweresupportedinpartbyagrantfromtheIn-VivoCellularandMolecularImag-ingCenter(P50086438-10).Dr.DomínguezwassupportedinpartbyagrantfromPontificiaUniversidadCatólicadeChileandBecasChile(76100021),andDr.DeandreisbyagrantfromFon-dationdeFrance(2010-12521).
DisclosureformsprovidedbytheauthorsareavailablewiththefulltextofthisarticleatNEJM.org.
Wethanktheresearchstudystaff,particularlySusanKorte,AlexF.Mak,BrynnaLipson,DonnaLisa,andLisaCox,R.N.
References
1. MazzaferriEL,KloosRT.Clinicalre-view128:currentapproachestoprimarytherapy for papillary and follicular thy-roid cancer. J Clin Endocrinol Metab2001;86:1447-63.2. DuranteC,HaddyN,BaudinE,etal.Long-termoutcomeof444patientswithdistantmetastasesfrompapillaryandfol-licular thyroid carcinoma: benefits andlimitsofradioiodinetherapy.JClinEndo-crinolMetab2006;91:2892-9.3. CoelhoSM,CorboR,BuescuA,Carv-alhoDP,VaismanM.Retinoicacidinpa-tients with radioiodine non-responsivethyroid carcinoma. J Endocrinol Invest2004;27:334-9.4. Handkiewicz-Junak D, Roskosz J,Hasse-LazarK,etal.13-cis-Retinoicacidre-differentiation therapy and recombi-nant human thyrotropin-aided radioio-dine treatmentofnon-functionalmeta-static thyroid cancer: a single-center,53-patient phase 2 study. Thyroid Res2009;2:8.5. SimonD,KörberC,KrauschM,etal.Clinicalimpactofretinoidsinredifferen-tiation therapyofadvanced thyroidcan-cer: final results of a pilot study. Eur JNuclMedMolImaging2002;29:775-82.6. LiuYY,vanderPluijmG,KarperienM,etal.Lithiumasadjuvanttoradioio-dine therapy in differentiated thyroid
carcinoma:clinicalandinvitrostudies.ClinEndocrinol(Oxf)2006;64:617-24.7. Kimura ET, Nikiforova MN, Zhu Z,Knauf JA,Nikiforov YE, Fagin JA.HighprevalenceofBRAFmutationsinthyroidcancer: genetic evidence for constitutiveactivationoftheRET/PTC-RAS-BRAFsig-nalingpathwayinpapillarythyroidcarci-noma.CancerRes2003;63:1454-7.8. Cohen Y, Xing M, Mambo E, et al.BRAFmutationinpapillarythyroidcarci-noma.JNatlCancerInst2003;95:625-7.9. Knauf JA, Fagin JA. Role of MAPKpathway oncoproteins in thyroid cancerpathogenesis and as drug targets. CurrOpinCellBiol2009;21:296-303.10. SoaresP,TroviscoV,RochaAS,etal.BRAFmutationsandRET/PTCrearrange-mentsarealternativeevents in theetio-pathogenesisofPTC.Oncogene2003;22:4578-80.11. DuranteC,PuxedduE,FerrettiE,etal. BRAFmutations in papillary thyroidcarcinomasinhibitgenes involvedin io-dinemetabolism.JClinEndocrinolMetab2007;92:2840-3.12. KnaufJA,KurodaH,BasuS,FaginJA.RET/PTC-induced dedifferentiation ofthyroidcells ismediated throughY1062signalingthroughSHC-RAS-MAPkinase.Oncogene2003;22:4406-12.13. Liu D, Hu S, Hou P, Jiang D, Con-
dourisS,XingM.SuppressionofBRAF/MEK/MAP kinase pathway restores ex-pressionofiodide-metabolizinggenesinthyroidcellsexpressingtheV600EBRAFmutant.ClinCancerRes2007;13:1341-9.14. MitsutakeN,Knauf JA,MitsutakeS,MesaCJr,ZhangL,FaginJA.ConditionalBRAFV600EexpressioninducesDNAsyn-thesis, apoptosis, dedifferentiation, andchromosomal instability in thyroidPCCL3cells.CancerRes2005;65:2465-73.15. Riesco-Eizaguirre G, Gutiérrez-Mar-tínez P, García-Cabezas MA, Nistal M,SantistebanP.TheoncogeneBRAFV600Eis associated with a high risk of recur-rence and less differentiated papillarythyroidcarcinomaduetotheimpairmentofNa+/I-targetingtothemembrane.En-docrRelatCancer2006;13:257-69.16. ChakravartyD,SantosE,RyderM,etal. Small-molecule MAPK inhibitors re-storeradioiodineincorporationinmousethyroid cancers with conditional BRAFactivation.JClinInvest2011;121:4700-11.17. BanerjiU,CamidgeDR,VerheulHM,etal.Thefirst-in-humanstudyofthehy-drogen sulfate (Hyd-sulfate) capsule ofthe MEK1/2 inhibitor AZD6244 (ARRY-142886):aphaseIopen-labelmulticentertrial in patients with advanced cancer.ClinCancerRes2010;16:1613-23.18. PentlowKS,GrahamMC,Lambrecht
The New England Journal of Medicine Downloaded from nejm.org on February 7, 2014. For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2013 Massachusetts Medical Society. All rights reserved.
n engl j med 368;7 nejm.org february 14, 2013632
Selumetinib and R adioiodine Uptake in Thyroid Cancer
RM, et al. Quantitative imaging of io-dine-124withPET. JNuclMed1996;37:1557-62.19. SgourosG,KolbertKS,SheikhA,etal. Patient-specific dosimetry for 131Ithyroidcancertherapyusing124IPETand3-dimensional-internaldosimetry(3D-ID)software.JNuclMed2004;45:1366-72.20. Feine U, Lietzenmayer R, Hanke JP,HeldJ,WöhrleH,Müller-SchauenburgW.Fluorine-18-FDG and iodine-131-iodideuptake in thyroid cancer. J Nucl Med1996;37:1468-72.21. WangW,LarsonSM,TuttleRM,etal.Resistance of [18f]-fluorodeoxyglucose-avidmetastaticthyroidcancerlesionstotreatmentwithhigh-doseradioactive io-dine.Thyroid2001;11:1169-75.22. RobbinsRJ,WanQ,GrewalRK,etal.Real-time prognosis for metastatic thy-roidcarcinomabasedon2-[18F]fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose-positron emission to-mography scanning. J Clin EndocrinolMetab2006;91:498-505.23. RobbinsRJ,LarsonSM,SinhaN,etal.Aretrospectivereviewoftheeffective-ness of recombinant human TSH as a
preparationforradioiodinethyroidrem-nantablation.JNuclMed2002;43:1482-8.24. TalaH,RobbinsR,FaginJA,LarsonSM,TuttleRM.Five-yearsurvivalissimi-larinthyroidcancerpatientswithdistantmetastases prepared for radioactive io-dinetherapywitheitherthyroidhormonewithdrawalorrecombinanthumanTSH.JClinEndocrinolMetab2011;96:2105-11.25. FoxJJ,Autran-BlancE,MorrisMJ,etal. Practical approach for comparativeanalysis of multilesion molecular imag-ingusingasemiautomatedprogramforPET/CT.JNuclMed2011;52:1727-32.26. Ricarte-FilhoJC,RyderM,ChitaleDA,etal.Mutationalprofileofadvancedpri-mary and metastatic radioactive iodine-refractorythyroidcancersrevealsdistinctpathogeneticrolesforBRAF,PIK3CA,andAKT1.CancerRes2009;69:4885-93.27. HayesDN,LucasAS,TanvetyanonT,etal.PhaseIIefficacyandpharmacoge-nomic study of selumetinib (AZD6244;ARRY-142886) in iodine-131 refractorypapillarythyroidcarcinomawithorwith-out follicular elements.ClinCancerRes2012;18:2056-65.
28. KirkwoodJM,BastholtL,RobertC,etal.PhaseII,open-label,randomizedtrialof the MEK1/2 inhibitor selumetinib asmonotherapyversustemozolomideinpa-tients with advanced melanoma. ClinCancerRes2012;18:555-67.29. DeVitaG,ZanniniM,CiraficiAM,etal.ExpressionoftheRET/PTC1oncogeneimpairs the activity of TTF-1 and Pax-8thyroidtranscriptionfactors.CellGrowthDiffer1998;9:97-103.30. Francis-LangH,ZanniniM,DeFeliceM,BerlingieriMT,FuscoA,DiLauroR.Multiplemechanismsofinterferencebe-tweentransformationanddifferentiationin thyroid cells. Mol Cell Biol 1992;12:5793-800.31. DeVitaG,BauerL,daCostaVM,etal.Dose-dependentinhibitionofthyroiddif-ferentiationbyRASoncogenes.MolEn-docrinol2005;19:76-89.32. HoAL,ShermanE.Clinicaldevelop-ment of kinase inhibitors for the treat-ment of differentiated thyroid cancer.ClinAdvHematolOncol2011;9:32-41.Copyright © 2013 Massachusetts Medical Society.
specialties and topics at nejm.org
SpecialtypagesattheJournal’swebsite(NEJM.org)featurearticlesincardiology,endocrinology,genetics,infectiousdisease,nephrology,pediatrics,andmanyothermedicalspecialties.Thesepages,alongwithcollectionsofarticlesonclinicalandnonclinicaltopics,offerlinkstointeractiveandmultimediacontentandfeature
recentlypublishedarticlesaswellasmaterialfromtheNEJMarchive(1812–1989).
The New England Journal of Medicine Downloaded from nejm.org on February 7, 2014. For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2013 Massachusetts Medical Society. All rights reserved.