By

Vu

k G

avri

lovi

ć

Wh

at

is a

re

vie

w?

�A

rev

iew

is

a p

erm

anen

t d

ocu

men

t yo

u c

reat

e in

th

e Ju

dg

e C

ente

r.

�In

co

nsi

sts

of

you

eva

luat

ion

of

ano

ther

ju

dg

e, y

ou

’re

re

cog

niz

ing

th

e g

oo

d w

ork

of

an

oth

er

jud

ge

an

d

giv

ing

ad

vis

e o

n h

ow

to

im

pro

ve

.

�T

he

do

cum

ents

is

bro

ken

do

wn

in

“st

ren

gh

ts”

and

“a

reas

of

imp

rove

men

t”

Ho

w t

o c

rea

te a

re

vie

w i

n t

he

Jud

ge

Ce

nte

r…

�L

og

in

in

to t

he

JC a

nd

cli

ck “

revi

ews”

Ho

w t

o c

rea

te a

re

vie

w i

n t

he

Jud

ge

Ce

nte

r…

�C

lick

on

“cr

eate

”, s

elec

t “e

valu

atio

n”

and

cli

ck o

n

“co

nti

nu

e”.

Ho

w t

o c

rea

te a

re

vie

w i

n t

he

Jud

ge

Ce

nte

r…

�T

op

of

pag

e -f

ind

th

e ju

dg

e yo

u w

ant

to r

evie

w, a

nd

in

sert

all

th

e d

ata

rele

van

t to

th

e to

urn

amen

t.

Ho

w t

o c

rea

te a

re

vie

w i

n t

he

Jud

ge

Ce

nte

r…

�Y

ear

issu

e: s

elec

t ye

ar 2

010

�R

emem

ber

to

wri

te “

Th

is i

s a

20

12 r

ev

iew

”in

th

e co

mm

ent

bo

x

Wh

at

is t

he

pu

rpo

se o

f a

re

vie

w?

�R

eco

gn

ize

the

go

od

jo

b a

ju

dg

e d

id.

�T

o g

ive

advi

ce o

n h

ow

to

im

pro

ve!

�A

pai

r o

f “e

xtra

eye

s”fr

om

ou

tsid

e –

no

on

e ca

n

imp

rove

mu

ch a

ll b

y h

imse

lf/h

erse

lf.

�S

har

e o

ur

exp

erti

se a

nd

men

tor.

�W

rite

wh

at s

om

eon

e co

uld

im

pro

ve.

�U

ltim

atel

y: i

mp

rove

th

e Ju

dg

e P

rog

ram

as

a w

ho

le.

Imp

ort

an

t!

Th

e m

ain

pu

rpo

se o

f a

revi

ew i

s to

be

he

lpfu

l!

It s

ho

uld

hel

p t

he

jud

ge

to r

eali

ze h

is/h

er m

ista

kes

an

d

giv

e ad

vice

on

ho

w t

o i

mp

rove

.

It i

s n

ot

an e

xam

. No

on

e “f

ails

”.

It s

ho

uld

be

use

ful

and

a s

ou

rce

of

info

rmat

ion

on

ho

w

to i

mp

rove

an

d d

o a

n e

ven

bet

ter

job

nex

t ti

me!

Wri

tin

g a

re

vie

w h

elp

s y

ou

as

we

ll!

�It

hel

ps

you

dev

elo

p y

ou

r o

bse

rvat

ion

an

d m

ento

rin

g sk

ills

.

�It

wil

l al

so s

ho

w t

hat

yo

u’r

e in

volv

ed a

ctiv

ely

in t

he

jud

ge

com

mu

nit

y. (

No

t o

nly

th

e re

view

ed j

ud

ge

can

re

ad t

he

revi

ews

you

wri

te…

)

�It

’s p

art

of

the

chec

kli

st…

Ch

oo

sey

ou

r w

ord

s w

ise

ly!

�B

e ta

ctfu

l an

d d

iplo

mat

ic.

�B

e ca

refu

l n

ot

to o

ffen

d s

om

eon

e.

�K

eep

in

min

d c

ult

ura

l d

iffe

ren

ces

and

lan

gu

age

bar

rier

!

�D

on

’t u

se i

ron

y o

r sa

rcas

m –

it w

on

’t w

ork

…

�T

ry t

o g

ive

con

stru

ctiv

e c

riti

cism

.

Be

ve

ry s

pe

cifi

c in

th

e r

evie

w

�W

rite

do

wn

exa

ctly

in

wh

at s

itu

atio

n y

ou

ob

serv

ed a

g

iven

th

ing

.

�W

rite

th

e ro

le y

ou

an

d t

he

jud

ge

had

.

�P

ut

all

the

det

ails

rel

evan

t to

th

e si

tuat

ion

yo

u’r

e d

escr

ibin

g.

�Ju

stif

y yo

ur

po

int

of

view

.

Ho

w t

o o

bse

rve

:

�S

had

ow

ing

(es

pec

iall

y if

“b

ud

dy

syst

em”

is

imp

lem

ente

d).

�C

hat

–ex

cep

t fo

r re

al s

itu

atio

ns,

tal

k a

bo

ut

hyp

oth

etic

al o

nes

(“w

hat

do

yo

u t

hin

k a

bo

ut…

”, “

wh

at

wo

uld

yo

u d

o i

n t

his

cas

e…”)

�W

ork

to

get

her

(ex

amp

le:

do

a d

eck

ch

eck

to

get

her

…)

Wh

at

to o

bse

rve

:

�In

tera

ctio

n w

ith

pla

yers

an

d j

ud

ges

�G

ener

al p

rep

arat

ion

in

ru

les

and

po

lici

es

�A

pp

roac

h a

nd

att

itu

de

tow

ard

s ju

dg

ing

an

d p

laye

rs

�E

xecu

tio

n o

f as

sig

ned

tas

ks

(rem

emb

er t

o w

rite

wh

at

task

s ex

actl

y yo

u’r

e ta

lkin

g a

bo

ut)

“Ro

le o

rie

nte

d”

revie

ws

�A

rev

iew

do

esn

’t n

eed

to

co

nta

in e

very

asp

ect

of

jud

gin

g.

It c

an b

e q

uit

e sh

ort

an

d s

pec

ific

to

a r

ole

.

Example

:

Yo

u c

an r

evie

w y

ou

r T

L (

even

if

you

’re

a L

1),

con

sid

erin

g o

nly

th

e te

am l

ead

ing

asp

ects

of

that

p

arti

cual

ar j

ud

ge

in t

hat

to

urn

amen

t.

Th

ing

s to

re

me

mb

er…

Tak

e n

ote

s d

uri

ng

th

e to

urn

amen

t.

Th

ey w

ill

hel

p y

ou

rem

emb

er w

hat

to

wri

te a

fter

a

few

day

s.

Th

ing

s to

re

me

mb

er…

If y

ou

wan

t to

get

a r

evie

w a

sk f

or

it!

(usu

ally

to

yo

ur

“bu

dd

y”o

r T

L o

n a

GP

,

or

the

HJ

on

a s

mal

ler

tou

rnam

ent

lik

e a

PT

Q)

Th

ing

s to

re

me

mb

er…

Yo

u c

an r

evie

w a

ju

dg

e o

f an

y le

vel !

Do

n’t

be

shy,

even

if

they

are

hig

h l

evel

th

ey a

re n

ot

per

fect

!

…ex

cep

t fo

r K

alle

☺

Th

ing

s to

re

me

mb

er…

Lan

gu

age

bar

rier

an

d c

ult

ura

l d

iffe

ren

ces.

En

gli

sh i

s p

refe

rred

lan

gu

age

for

jud

ge

revi

ews,

bu

t if

it’

s n

ot

go

od

en

ou

gh

bet

ter

wri

te i

n y

ou

r n

ativ

e la

ng

uag

e (i

f th

e re

view

ed j

ud

ge

also

sp

eak

s it

).

Th

ing

s to

re

me

mb

er…

Avo

id a

bso

lute

sta

tem

ents

�D

on

’t s

ay “

Joh

n IS

…”

if y

ou

ob

serv

ed a

th

ing

on

ly

on

ce.

�A

void

wo

rds

lik

e “a

lway

s”an

d “

nev

er”.

By

thei

r n

atu

re,

abso

lute

sta

tem

ents

are

bo

un

d t

o b

e fa

lse

and

in

nca

ura

te.

Th

ing

s to

re

me

mb

er…

Yo

u c

an w

rite

a r

evie

w t

o a

ju

dg

e th

at

per

form

ed w

ell.

Yo

u d

on

’t n

eed

to

wai

t fo

r a

jud

ge

to d

o s

om

eth

ing

“w

ron

g”.

Eve

n i

f a

jud

ge

do

es a

gre

at j

ob

, th

ere

are

sure

ly w

ays

he

or

she

can

do

an

ou

tsta

nd

ing

job

nex

t ti

me!

Ev

en

if

the

re’s

no

thin

g y

ou

ca

n t

hin

k o

f a

s “a

rea

of

imp

rov

em

en

ts”

–w

rite

th

e r

ev

iew

an

yw

ay

!

Th

ing

s to

re

me

mb

er…

Bef

ore

yo

u w

rite

th

e re

view

, ta

lk t

o t

he

jud

ge

abo

ut

wh

at y

ou

ob

serv

ed.

Th

is i

s im

po

rtan

t: i

t w

ill

hel

p y

ou

get

a b

ette

r id

ea o

n t

he

jud

ge’

s p

erfo

rman

ce.

An

d s

om

etim

es i

t w

ill

avo

id y

ou

so

me

mis

tak

es o

r in

accu

raci

es.

Th

ing

s to

re

me

mb

er…

If d

on

’t g

et t

he

chan

ce t

o t

alk

in

per

son

–u

se

som

e o

ther

mea

n (

emai

ls,

Fac

ebo

ok

, JC

…)

It’s

im

po

rtan

t to

exc

han

ge

op

inio

ns

and

hav

e so

me

sort

of

deb

rief

ing

.

So

met

imes

it

wo

n’t

be

po

ssib

le a

t th

e to

urn

amen

t, s

o f

eel

free

to

do

it

elec

tro

nic

ally

.

Yo

ur

firs

t re

vie

w�

Do

n’t

be

afra

id t

o w

rite

on

e. I

t’s

no

rmal

, ev

eryo

ne

do

es i

t.

�R

evie

w a

ju

dg

e yo

u k

no

w a

nd

hav

e w

ork

ed w

ith

on

sev

e ral

o

ccas

ion

s (t

his

sh

ou

ld b

e le

ss i

nti

mid

anti

ng

th

an

revi

ewin

g a

ju

dg

e yo

u j

ust

met

fo

r th

e fi

rst

tim

e o

n a

GP

).

�T

alk

to

th

e ju

dg

e b

efo

re w

riti

ng

th

e re

view

.

�It

do

esn

’t h

ave

to b

e an

ou

tsta

nd

ing

rev

iew

. It

can

be

sho

rt a

nd

sch

emat

ic. I

t w

ill

stil

l b

e u

sefu

l.

�G

oo

d r

evie

ws

com

e w

ith

tim

e. D

on

’t e

xpec

t to

be

per

fect

im

med

iate

ly. E

very

on

e n

eed

s p

ract

ice

and

exp

erie

nce

.

Yo

u g

ot

a b

ad

re

vie

w.

Wh

at

no

w?

�D

on

’t g

et d

epre

ssed

. D

on

’t t

ake

it p

erso

nal

ly.

�L

earn

fro

m i

t an

d t

ry t

o d

o y

ou

r b

est

nex

t ti

me.

�B

e h

ap

py

ab

ou

t it

! Y

ou

no

w h

ave

som

eth

ing

to

wo

rk

on

an

d b

eco

me

a b

ette

r ju

dg

e!

Exa

mp

les:

�E

ven

if

you

hav

e ar

rive

d i

n t

he

staf

f o

f th

e to

urn

amen

t in

ru

n f

or

bef

ore

th

ing

yo

u h

ave

trie

d t

o v

isu

aliz

e th

e si

tuat

ion

to

try

to

imp

rove

wh

at i

t w

as n

eces

sary

. Y

ou

r fi

gu

re d

uri

ng

th

e w

ho

le t

ou

rnam

ent

has

bee

n a

t th

e m

ost

o

f th

e p

rofe

ssio

nal

ism

her

yo

ur

kn

ow

led

ge o

f th

e p

oli

cies

it

is

exce

llen

t an

d I

wo

uld

wis

h m

e to

alw

ays

wo

rk w

ith

peo

ple

of

you

r p

rep

arat

ion

.

�T

he

on

ly n

ote

th

at c

an m

ove

yo

u i

s th

at a

t ti

mes

yo

ur

way

s ca

n

seem

har

d a

s if

yo

u h

ad a

lway

s b

eco

me

rab

id w

ith

wh

om

is

you

b

efo

re.

�I

no

te t

his

du

rin

g th

e "L

egac

y@N

atio

nal

" T

ou

rnam

ent