September 24, 2013

The ChronicleT h e i n d e p e n d e n T d a i ly aT d u k e u n i v e r s i T y

xxxxxday, mmmm xx, 2013 ONE HUNdREd aNd EIGHTH yEaR, IssUE xxxwww.dukechronicle.com

Grad school coverage University

dIv scHOOl bRIdGEs lGbTQ aNd cHURcH Page 4

PaNElIsTs sOUNd Off ON syRIa sITUaTIONPage 2

The ChronicleT h e i n d e p e n d e n T d a i ly aT d u k e u n i v e r s i T y

TUEsday, sEPTEmbER 24, 2013 ONE HUNdREd aNd NINTH yEaR, IssUE 21www.dukechronicle.com

by Yiyun ZhuThe ChroniCle

Changes announced by housing, Din-ing and residence life in August discour-aged students from painting their rooms and limited the dimensions of banners hung outside windows.

Previous policy allowed students to paint dorm or apartment walls as long as they painted them back at the end of the year, or forged an agreement with future occupants about the changed room con-ditions. hDrl no longer allows students to pass altered room conditions onto the next occupant.

“residents are not allowed to make alterations or additions to or within the premises. This includes painting the room or apartment,” read an email sent out to residents of Few Quad. “Students will be charged for repairs needed to re-turn rooms to an hDrl-approved color and condition after move-out.”

Future of DukeOpen push unclear

HDRL alters painting, banner policy

by Emma BaccellieriThe ChroniCle

Student coalition Dukeopen is grad-ually making its way through adminis-trative processes in its push for greater endowment transparency.

Based on ideas of socially responsi-ble investing and administrative trans-parency, Dukeopen is requesting that DUMAC—the firm that invests the University’s endowment—disclose the endowment’s direct investments twice annually to the Duke community.

Since its proposal was put in front of the President’s Special Committee on investment responsibility in April, Dukeopen has made efforts to present to a number of administrative groups—ultimately hoping to present the pro-posal to the Board of Trustees. Mem-bers of the coalition said they believe that the administration is prolonging the approval process. University Secre-tary richard riddell noted, however, that the proposal will “most likely” be Dayou zhuo/The ChroniCle

Starting at the Chapel, Duke students walked to different points of campus to pray for peace.

Imagine all the people

Chinese journalists visit Durham for DKU marketingby Lauren Carroll

The ChroniCle

last week, seven Chinese journalists trav-eled to Durham on Duke’s dime.

Duke brought the journalists in hopes that they would promote Duke Kunshan University. Administrators launched their marketing plan in full force last week, fol-lowing the announcement that the Chinese Ministry of education granted DKU final ap-proval. With such an aggressive recruitment push, pressure is on for DKU to open in time for classes to begin in August.

Before the University officially received

final approval from the Ministry of educa-tion—the last step in establishing a foreign university in China—it was not permitted to formally recruit or advertise.

As if someone flipped a switch, DKU T-shirts and key chains appeared in The Uni-versity Store in the Bryan Center last week, and new admissions and curriculum pages have popped up on the DKU website. indi-vidual schools offering courses at DKU will start advertising their programs, and various DKU leaders will hold information sessions

See dku, page 5

See painting, page 5See dukeopen, page 6

Jennie xu/The ChroniCle

Duke brought over seven Chinese journalists in that an effort to promote Duke Kunshan University.

2 | TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 2013 www.dukechronicle.com The Chronicle

OPERATION: Stores Administration PUBLICATION: ChronicleHEADLINE: Did You Miss It? DATES: TBACOLOR: CMYK

CONGRATULATIONS!

Alli Smalley, a senior from Ellicott City, Maryland majoring in Psychology has her picture taken with Angela Bowling,

Marketing Manager for Duke University Stores.Alli was one of the lucky winners of two tickets to the Duke vs

Georgia Tech football game played on September 14.

Did you miss out?There will be more opportunities like this. Just stop by the University Store located in the Bryan Center and see what

the ‘buzz’ is all about.

by Jenna ZhangThe ChroniCle

The Sanford School of Public Policy hosted a roundtable panel discussion on the current crisis in Syria Monday night.

Moderator robin Kirk, director of the Duke human rights Center, said Sanford convened the event to discuss the current situation in Syria and talk about the various political factors at play. Panelists went over a variety of topics, including the extent to which the United States should become in-volved in the crisis and potential settle-ments that may lie in Syria’s future.

Panelist Philip Bennett, director of the DeWitt Wallace Center for Media and Democracy, commenced the talk by discussing the role that media has played in the Syrian crisis. his primary concern was that actual news coming out of the war had been shuffled into the background as political conflicts in Washington over the crisis have come

to the forefront.“A curtain has descended on this

story,” he said.Bennett added that the media was

more focused on how Congress and President Barack obama were arguing over the Syrian crisis rather than the humanitarian aspects of the situation itself.

The panelists went on to discuss the factors that were contributing to the current state of affairs in Syria.

Abdeslam Maghraoui, associate pro-fessor of the practice of political sci-ence and director of undergraduate studies, presented three possible reso-lutions for the Syrian crisis: a military victory for either side, the collapse of the current presiding government or both sides coming to an agreement.

Bruce Jentleson, professor of public policy and political science, said the situation was too complicated for there to be a specific resolution, but added that a military victory on either side would be unlikely given the current state of affairs. he said he was hopeful that with pressure from foreign coun-tries, the government and the Free Syr-ian Army would be able to broker an agreement and end the war.

“Today, we come to the realization that there is a stalemate, and a military solution is beyond anyone’s reach,” he said.

World leaders have failed to resolve the crisis in Syria because such con-flicts were not common until the end of the Cold War, Jentiseon said.

he added that conflicts overseas prior to the end of the Cold War had primarily been between different na-tions at war with each other. Atroci-ties committed in rwanda in the 1990s and the intrastate conflicts following the Arab Spring introduced a differ-ent kind of international conflict to be dealt with—one in which the citizens

Panel leads discussion on U.S. role in Syria crisis

by Tesssa VellekThe ChroniCle

A study on birds’ brains could lead to a greater understanding of the human brain.

A research team—led by erich Jarvis, howard hughes Medical institute inves-tigator of neurobiology at the School of Medicine—concluded a 10-year study in which they mapped the brains of eight species of birds. The findings, which were published in two papers in the Journal of Comparative neurology in July, found that the brains of all vertebrates—which includes mammals, birds and reptiles, among others—have important similari-ties. The new understanding could aid further research in language and speech development.

“if you really look at the behavior complexity of different bird species, they can display quite simple to very com-plex behaviors that you can find in any mammal—some of which are considered more unique to humans, like language,” Jarvis said. “if we are going to translate discoveries that we find from a songbird to a human, we need to know the similar cell-types in songbirds and humans.”

By using a computational analysis of the activity of 52 genes across 23 areas of the bird brain, the team—which includ-ed Chun-Chun Chen, a postdoctoral fel-low in the Jarvis lab, and harvey Karten, a professor of neuroscience at the Uni-versity of California San Diego School of Medicine—found that bird brains have a columnar organization. Previously, only mammals were thought to have this structure.

“one of the challenges we’ve had using bird brains to understand brain function overall is that it’s hard to trans-late discoveries in birds to other species, including mammals and humans,” Jar-vis said. “one of the reasons it’s hard to make those translations is that we didn’t know about the organization of the bird brain to begin with.”

Another breakthrough in the study

was the discovery that a void—known as the ventricle—that exists between two groups of cells does not act as a barrier. instead, the two cell groups actually divide in a sheet and flow around the ventricle while multiplying.

Although it may make stud-ies on birds easier to under-stand, richard Mooney, George Barth Geller professor of neuro-biology at the Duke institute for Brain Sciences, said that mice will not disappear from neurobiology laboratories.

“i don’t think birds will replace mice,” Mooney said, “[Birds and mice] each have a great utility, but it’s much, much easier to understand what the homologies are between the mouse brain and the human brain…. But even so, bird behavior in many ways is much more like our behavior than mouse behavior.”

Jarvis and his colleagues studied how the gene expression of birds’ brains re-acted to various environmental factors—such as bird songs, light, movement and a magnetic field that simulated naviga-tional circuits.

“We’re looking at combinations of genes and the reason why we think we were able to get further than other studies in the past is because they were only doing one or two genes and we had decided that wasn’t enough evidence,” Jarvis said. “We needed many more genes.”

The discovery about the structure of birds’ brains could change evolutionary biology because it shows that the cir-cuitry we use to perform specific tasks like detecting sound have not changed much in the past 200 million years, Karten said.

“Prior to now, the notion had been that mammals evolved their cortex as a specific novel event,” Karten said. “now

Mapping birds’ brains reveal similarities with humans’

ViCTor ye/The ChroniCle

Among the many topics discussed, panelist Philip Bennett (pictured right) criticized the media’s coverage of the Syrian crisis.

the ventricle—that exists between two groups of cells does not act as a barrier. instead, the two cell groups actually divide in a sheet and flow around the ventricle while

Although it may make stud-ies on birds easier to under-stand, richard Mooney, George Barth Geller professor of neuro-biology at the Duke institute for Brain Sciences, said that mice will not disappear from neurobiology

“i don’t think birds will replace mice,” Mooney said, “[Birds and mice] each have a great utility, but it’s much, much easier to understand

See BiRd BRainS, page 6See SYRia, page 6

The Chronicle www.dukechronicle.com TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 2013 | 3

OPERATION: University Store PUBLICATION: ChronicleHEADLINE: Now Open Sundays DATES: 09/25/2013COLOR: CMYK

Monday-Wednesday:8:30am - 7pm

Thursday and Friday:8:30am - 8pm

Saturday:9am - 6pm

Sunday:11am – 4pm

What’s new at the University Store?

Also includes the Gothic Bookshop, the Duke Technology Center and the Duke Textbook Store.

Upper Level, Bryan Center www.shopdukestores.duke.edu

NOW OPEN SUNDAYS

for the NEW WORKS FESTIVAL, in the spring of 2014—a weekend of staged readings of plays and screenplays

presented by The Department of Theater Studies.Submissions accepted from all play and movie lovers

in the Duke community...Send in your manuscripts—of any length—by DECEMBER 1, 2013

to: [email protected] dates will be APRIL 16, 17, 18 IN SHEAFER THEATER

SHARE YOUR VISIONS WITH US!!

by Aradhna MadireddiThe ChroniCle

Political experts came together Mon-day evening to reflect on the tumultuous state of politics in north Carolina over the last year.

The summer saw plenty of state legis-lative action on voter rights, health care and education, and the results rankled many state constituents, the panelists said. Don Taylor, associate professor of public policy, moderated the panel of three state political experts—Chris Fitzsimon, founder and executive di-rector of north Carolina Policy Watch; reporter lynn Bonner of The news and observer; and John hood, president and chairman of the John locke Foundation think tank.

in his introduction, Taylor noted that the state has been in the nation’s politi-cal spotlight as a result of controversial legislation that has led to activism.

“north Carolina was ridiculed be-cause the house legislation decided it doesn’t have to follow what the Supreme Court does,” Fitzsimon said.

The panelists discussed voter iDs, which since the 2012 elections have be-come one of the most controversial top-ics in north Carolina politics. The bill requires students to use state-issued and not university-issued identification in or-der to vote, among other restrictions.

The panelists then turned to health care and education, two of the areas that have garnered much national attention. The north Carolina General Assembly voted to decline federal funds to expand state Medicaid coverage to low-income residents.

Profs mull effects of North Carolina legislation

Although obamacare has faults, Bon-ner said, it attempts to cover the health care of all people under the poverty threshold and improves the welfare of many more than the house’s position.

The refusal to take greater legislative responsibility for health care coverage increases pressure on nonprofit health care organizations, such as Community

Care north Carolina, to provide for the state’s poor, Taylor said.

increased access to health care tends to decrease reliance on the emergency room, which in turn reduces hospital costs for the treatment of the uninsured. This is important given that the United States has one of the highest health care expenditures per capita in the world,

Taylor said. The panel also addressed legislation

on abortion. Ftizsimon emphasized that at one point, the republican majority’s version of a compromise on abortion was mandating that those pursuing an abortion see an ultrasound before the procedure and receive approval from an anti-abortion advocate. As debate over the law intensified, the state legislators changed their position to not allow any coverage of abortion under government health insurance plans.

The end of the panel covered the state’s stance on education. in response to economic pressure, the north Caro-lina house considered significant cut-backs to the community college system, which hood called one of the best in the nation.

“Universities are an economic en-gine,” Bonner said. “They attract many people to move here.”

Ultimately the budget allocated more money to universities—including private institutions—than the national average, but less than the national average on the K-12 school system. With these fiscal de-cisions, Fitzsimon said that it has become harder for students in north Carolina to receive a strong education at the elemen-tary level. As a result, north Carolina test scores have fallen below the national av-erage, he added.

With the state’s political history over the past year, the panelists were not opti-mistic for the upcoming legislative year.

“There’s going to be a lot of disagree-ment until the left and the right don’t come together,” hood said.

Dayou zhuo/The ChroniCle

Political experts discussed health care and education, among other topics, during a panel on North Carolina politics Tuesday.


Sacred Worth bridges LGBTQ community and church

by Grace WangThe ChroniCle

A student-led organization is looking to dispel the viewpoint that the lGBTQ com-munity and Christianity are incompatible.

originally formed in 1990, Sacred Worth strives to create a safe environment for lG-BTQ students in the church. over the years, the group—originally named Divinity Stu-dents for Gay and lesbian Concerns—has hosted a variety of events on campus to raise awareness about their cause.

Before Amendment one was passed, the group held panel discussions and organized drives for people to vote against the Amend-ment. The organization has also hosted film screenings and discussions and art installa-tions featuring lGBTQ saints and martyrs.

“The group represents something that’s foreign to a lot of people. We can lend our

voices and experiences, make things per-sonal, challenge doctrines or beliefs just through sharing our lives in classes and studies with one another,” said sophomore Justin Davis, one of the four co-leaders of the group.

The name Sacred Worth was inspired by a statement in the United Methodist Book of Discipline about all persons be-ing created with sacred worth, said senior lynda Berg, a co-leader of the group.

Although the organization has been a facet of the University for over two de-cades, its presence was not always readily accepted.

“When the group was first formed in the 1990s, it was a real struggle. They had to go up against a lot of opposition,” Berg said. “But i think the Divinity School has come a long way since then and no one

will question our ability to be here now.”Sophomore Daniel Kort, president of

Blue Devil’s United, said Sacred Worth’s presence on campus is invaluable and en-sures that the lGBTQ community is rep-resented across all facets of the University.

Berg echoed this sentiment, noting that the group offers pertinent informa-tion for lGBTQ students who may feel that they do not belong at church.

“A lot of lGBT Christians have walked away from their faith because how the church has treated them, or they felt that they have to choose one or the oth-er, which is heartbreaking,” she said.

Amy hall, associate professor of Christian ethics at the Divinity School, is one of the faculty allies of the group and believes that it is possible to be Christian and a member or supporter of the lG-

BTQ community.“it does come as a surprise to some

folks that people at the Divinity school are allies,” said hall. “As a teacher at Duke Divinity School, i’ve had some very gifted ministers and students come through who belong to the lGBT group. i want to be able to tell people that God has gifted individuals who are gays and lesbians.”

Senior raygan Baker, another co-leader of Sacred Worth, noted that the church is at its best when it’s inclusive of more voices, and needs to hear the voices of lGBTQ community.

“our goal is to be inclusive about lG-BTQ people is part of our role in serving the church,” said Baker. “We are not just serving these people, we think that the church needs these people.”

sophia palenberg/The ChroniCle

Last year, Sacred Worth held panel discussions to encourage people to vote against Amendment One as one of its many projects to bridge the LGBTQ community with the church.

by Patricia SpearsThe ChroniCle

The Divinity School’s pre-orientation program has entered its 22nd year.

Project Bri(DDD)Ge—Building re-lationships in Durham through Duke Divinity Graduate education—started in 1991 with six female and six male gradu-ate students. Two decades later, there are 22 students, 10 leaders and a host of faculty and guest lecturers participating. The week-long program allows students the opportunity to connect with reli-gious leaders in Durham before begin-ning their classes.

“We are wanting to connect our learn-ing to the service of God, which is outside of these four walls,” said rev. Sally Bates, Divinity ‘95 and Divinity School chap-lain, who attended the second program in 1992. “look at the joys and needs of the world, and Project Bri(DDD)Ge can make that intersection happen.”

The program is open to all incoming Divinity school students. Participants are chosen by students and faculty through an application process that asks appli-cants about life experiences, the desire to complete Project Bri(DDD)Ge and how it would help in their future min-istry.

“We looked at the pool of students we had and they were all strong,” said Catherine Watson, associate director of student life at the divinity school, add-ing that every student who applied was chosen to participate this year.

The goal of Project Bri(DDD)Ge is to acclimate graduate students to their new school and expose them to the Dur-ham community through philanthropic activities. The program seeks in part to bring Duke and Durham closer together.

“That’s what i learned most. how un-connected Duke and Durham are,” said Breana van Velzen, a first-year Divinity

student.Bates noted the same divergence.“it’s very easy to be at Duke, with the

ivy covered walls and the gothic beauty, and lose sight of the community that the school is surrounded in,” Bates said.

Through the program, students work with a variety of different organizations to address long-standing social justice issues—such as poverty, racial inequal-ity and disability status—that affect the Durham community.

Van Velzen said that the “reality Par-ty”—an event that connects teens and adults with developmental disabilities through a dance party—was one of her favorite aspects of the program.

Watson echoed this sentiment, add-ing that it is necessary to know the his-torical background of a group of people in order to minister to them effectively.

“You’re being an empowerer,” Watson said.

Besides emphasizing action in the Durham community, Project Bri(DDD)Ge created long-lasting bonds between its participants, Watson noted.

She added that the participants are “a tight-knit group of people who im-pact the whole rest of the student com-munity.”

Van Velzen also noted the power of their group.

“When other people are lost, we can expand our core group and include them,” van Velzen said.

relationships formed during Project Bri(DDD)Ge have withstood the test of time for Bates.

“it’s where i made my best and most lasting friendships,” Bates said. “We’ve been meeting as Bri(DDD)Ge group faithfully for 21 years. And i think we haven’t missed a year.”

Pre-orientation program connects students with Durham

GraD SChool


EXPERTIN RESIDENCE PROGRAMThe Fannie Mitchell

The Expert in Residence Program

features accomplished

professionals to share

specialized knowledge

and provide career

advice to students.

Wednesday, September 25Lunch Discussion: 12-1:30 pm, FOCUS Classroom, Smith Warehouse Bay 6, 2nd floorIndividual Advising Sessions: 2:30 - 4:30 pm, Career CenterRegister for the lunch & advising sessions in eRecruiting.

Co-Sponsored by the Duke Alumni Association and Duke Career Center

www.studentaffairs.duke.edu/career

Ed MccrawforMEr corporatE coMMunications ExEcutivE with MastErcard and corporatE vp with vErizon

Tuesday, September 247:45-9 pm, The Link Classroom 5

Incorporating Social Impact in Your Careerdavid MorgEnstErn ‘08

stratEgy and corporatE dEvElopMEnt, gErson lEhrMan group and co-foundEr, glg social iMpact

Careers in Marketing & PR

and other recruitment meetings at Chinese universities in coming months.

DKU might have trouble marketing itself as a competitive university early on, said one of the visitors, Xiong Binqi, an influential blogger and vice president of the Shanghai Jiao Tong University education Group. he added, through a translator, that DKU will not immediately have the reputation of larg-er, more prestigious Chinese universities, like Shanghai Jiao Tong or Beijing University.

Although tuition has yet to be finalized, the cost of attending DKU will be compa-rable to the cost of going to the Durham campus—much more expensive than a Chi-nese degree. Some critics have questioned whether Chinese students will be willing to pay the cost of going to Duke in China if go-ing to Duke in the United States is a similarly priced option.

But Binqi added that Duke made a thoughtful choice by offering graduate pro-grams early on because it will better prepare Duke to offer undergraduate education. it also helps to distinguish Duke from other joint venture universities like new York Uni-versity Shanghai, which welcomed its first class of undergraduates this semester.

nYU’s Shanghai site is still not finished, so students are living off-campus until the build-ings are ready. in Duke’s recruitment effort, administrators are assuming that the campus will be ready when students arrive next Fall, despite numerous problems with construc-tion since breaking ground in 2010.

When asked earlier this month what would happen if DKU construction were not finished by Fall 2014, Provost Peter lange said that it is not even a possibility to consider.

in preparation for its marketing push, Duke has hired a new communications man-ager, Jay Shen. Based in China, Shen has

been working with Chinese government and journalists since he started in the summer.

When working with the Chinese media, Duke has had trouble explaining DKU’s mission because American and Chinese con-cepts of higher education are so fundamen-tally different, said Director of Global Com-munications laura Brinn. Media officials did not know what administrators meant when they said “inquiry-based learning” or men-tioned that learning could take place outside the classroom.

“They don’t have a framework to under-stand,” Brinn said, adding that this is the reason administrators decided to bring the Chinese journalists to Durham to more ef-fectively inform them about the Duke mod-el so they can promote DKU in their publi-cations.

Being able to communicate the differ-ences between the two country’s education styles is particularly important for DKU administrators because they are hoping to attract a class consisting half of Chinese students and the other half international, including American students.

While on their all-expenses-paid trip to Duke, the journalists met with representa-tives from the schools offering DKU pro-grams, learned about student affairs, toured the campus, shopped at Southpoint Mall and went to the Duke-Pittsburgh football game Saturday, with administrators as their hosts.

“These [meetings] are helpful. There is a big difference between Chinese universities and American universities,” said lin Yingy-ing, a reporter for The Shanghai Morning Post, after a discussion about the Duke Com-munity Standard. “Mostly, the difference is that American students talk more.”

Some of the journalists, like Binqi, filed stories or blogged about the experience while in Durham. others waited until they returned to China. They asked detailed

DKU from page 1 questions about Duke’s teaching and admin-istrative methods, as well as the impact dif-ferent programs could have in China.

The visitors included Qui Yi, Xinhua news Agency; Yi Xin, China education Daily; Wang Ying, Sina education Channel; li ran, Sina education Channel; Zou Chu, Kunshan TV Station; Binqi and Yingying.

The previous rules allowed students and future occupants to sign an agreement al-lowing changes made to the room or apart-ment—such as wall color—to remain. if a subsequent occupant did not accept the changes, the person who accepted them would have to repaint or pay the hDrl fine, said Joe Gonzalez, dean for residential life.

“hDrl has told us that students were being peer-pressured into accepting the rooms,” said junior Jacob Zionce, Duke Student Government vice president for residential life.

Gonzalez said the agreements have lead to conflict among students.

“if the subsequent student won’t accept the condition of the room, the second stu-dent has to re-paint it or gets billed,” Gon-zalez said. “That does not go well, as you can imagine.”

The policy changes also limit the size of banners hung outside residential buildings to 5 feet by 5 feet and specify that they can not cover the windows of a room in a man-ner that impedes egress,” read the email sent to Few Quad residents.

Zionce noted that the administration has emphasized safety concerns regarding extravagant banners. he noted, however, that banners have a positive impact on cam-pus culture.

painTinG from page 1

“As an incoming freshman, i remember coming in and seeing banners, which is a further reason why i wanted to come to this school,” Zionce said. “i could see how in-volved the student body was.”

Some students living in Greek and selec-tive living group housing on Central Cam-pus are displeased with the painting limita-tions, Gonzalez said.

“While other dorm-style sections on West are much nicer and well lit on the inside, the apartment-style living on Cen-tral is darker, more outdated, and bigger,” said senior Katie howard, president of the Panhellenic Association. “Painting really brought the apartments to life, and it was a fun opportunity to make the space yours.”

She noted that a partial solution would be for the administration to repaint Central Campus apartments with warmer colors.

Gonzalez said that the new painting rule is more a change in practice than policy. Though students are no longer allowed to keep painted walls, residents have always been charged when future occupants did not approve of the paint conditions.

Gonzalez noted that an additional bur-den is placed on hDrl when students are allowed to re-paint their own rooms.

“The quality of the [students’] re-paint efforts at move-out are often lacking,” Gon-zalez said. “We find that we have to re-paint a number of rooms after the student has at-tempted to re-paint.”

Senior Jimmy Guo, a resident assistant in Wilson Dorm, said that hDrl charges students who painted their dorms several hundred dollars per repaint coat.

Gonzalez also said that painting during the summer has logistical challenges, as summer conferences and summer school make finding time to repaint difficult, par-ticularly on Central Campus, where sum-mer school students move in the day after graduating seniors have moved out.


First-Year Internship ProgramLearn More at an Info Session:Register to attend in eRecruiting: duke.experience.com•Wed. Sept. 25, 1:00 pm, Friedl 225•Mon. Sept. 30, 5:00 pm, Carr 135 •Fri. Oct. 18, 11:00 am, Friedl 118•Thurs. Oct. 31, 11:00 am, Carr 125

Program Eligibility Requirements: Open to first-year Duke undergraduate students. Additional eligibility requirements, terms of the program and application process information are available on the Career Center website.

Apply in eRecruiting October 1 - November 4

www.studentaffairs.duke.edu/career

DUKe open from page 1

presented by President richard Brod-head at the Board’s next meeting.

“We continue to pursue cooperation with the administration,” senior Jacob Tobia, one of four leaders of Dukeopen, wrote in an email Sunday. “There is a time, however, when negotiations break down, and we are prepared to see this through to the end.”

The group had originally planned to present to the Board of Trustees in May, but University administrators redirected the proposal to the PSC in late April.

The PSC discusses whether proposals on specific investment responsibility con-cerns are valid and, if so, passes them on to the Advisory Committee on investment responsibility. The ACir has the power to makes recommendations to President richard Brodhead, who forwards them to the Board at his discretion. Dukeopen’s proposal would require PSC and ACir to disclose their reports of direct endow-ment holdings—companies in which the University has a direct equity stake—to the Duke community.

Members of the student coalition ob-jected to the redirection of the proposal, stating that it was inappropriate for PSC to be given the opportunity to deliberate on its own transparency.

The proposal ultimately did not con-tinue through the full PSC process.

“This was not the type of request fore-seen in the current policy on socially re-sponsible investments by Duke and how concerns should be processed,” Provost Peter lange, chair of PSC, wrote in a June 13 email that was obtained by The Chronicle.

Since concluding with PSC, Duke-open has pushed to put the proposal be-

fore Academic Council in an effort to un-derstand the role that faculty might play in the proposal and to secure it on the agenda of the Trustees’ october meeting.

Academic Council chair Joshua Soco-lar declined to comment on specifics of the Council’s work with Dukeopen, but said Brodhead spoke to the Council’s ex-ecutive Committee about the proposal in early September.

Socolar said he has been in contact with the coalition’s leaders, who include Bobo Bose-Kolanu, a second-year doc-toral student in literature; senior lucas Spangher, a former columnist for The Chronicle; and senior Casey Williams, chair of The Chronicle’s independent editorial board, in addition to Tobia.

The possibility of a Dukeopen pre-sentation at the october meeting of Aca-demic Council has been discussed, Soco-lar noted, but it has not been officially scheduled.

The Academic Council’s october meeting convenes nearly three weeks af-ter the Board of Trustees meeting.

Dukeopen was also discussed at the June and August meetings of the Board of Trustees’ executive Committee, rid-dell said.

“President Brodhead thinks the pro-posal by Dukeopen has merit,” riddell wrote in an email Monday. “i expect him to take a proposal to the board in octo-ber proposing enhancements in Duke’s oversight of socially responsible invest-ing.”

The group’s proposal centers on three objectives—for DUMAC to period-ically make hard copies of direct endow-ment holdings to the Duke community on a time delay, to ensure regular meet-ings of ACir and for DUMAC to main-tain and promote a social choice fund that would allow donors to direct their

gifts to be invested in a socially respon-sible way.

The disclosures would be delayed sev-eral months after investments are made, and it would only be available as a hard copy that people could view in an office setting, according to a Dukeopen state-ment made available to The Chronicle.

The proposal additionally includes a plan for student involvement, in the form of three investment responsibil-ity student analysts each semester who would collaborate with ACir.

The administration and Dukeopen have independently discussed the pro-posal with DUMAC.

“We learned that no peer institutions that implement time-delayed hardcopy-only disclosure of direct investments have suffered because of it,” Bose-Ko-lanu wrote in an email Sunday, describ-ing a meeting between Dukeopen and a DUMAC official whose name he de-clined to disclose. “We also learned that the financial risk posed by disclosing direct investments is minimal, and that time-delayed hardcopy-only mechanisms mitigate it.”

Among the institutions that disclose investments on a time delay are Dart-mouth College and Yale University.

riddell said Brodhead discussed the proposal with DUMAC’s Board of Direc-tors in August and has additionally had multiple exchanges with neal Triplett, president and Ceo of DUMAC.

Dukeopen was grateful to have re-cent meetings with senior administra-tors, Tobia said. Members of the group, however, are concerned that the process has potentially reached a roadblock.

“reaching an appropriate compro-mise on transparency did not seem to be too important,” Spangher wrote in an email Sunday.

birD brains from page 2

it would be much more sensible that the mammalian cortex is just one way of tak-ing the exact same circuitry and packag-ing it differently.”

Understanding the sequence and pro-cess of evolution could help researchers understand developmental disabilities, he noted.

“if we understand how cells form in mammals compared to reptiles and birds, that might give us some insight into what the developmental sequences are at the molecular level,” Karten said. “And if those steps are disrupted at the molecular level, it could explain the mechanisms for mental retardation.”

of a state were at conflict with each other or with the government.

“The world had rules for when one country invaded another, but not really for when one country was killing its own people,” Jentleson said.

After the first hour, the discussion opened to those in the audience, which consisted primarily of Duke students and members of the Durham community.

Maghraoui said that however the new regime would be structured, it would not resemble the old Syrian government.

A member of the audience brought up the possibility that the new regime would be heavily radicalized.

Maghraoui noted that the possibility of a highly radical regime replacing the current one is unlikely.

“My sense is that the radical elements are going to be excluded, that they are not going to be part of this,” he said.

syria from page 2


THE BLUE ZONE

QUICK HITS FROM LUNCH WITH CUT

sports.chronicleblogs.com

TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 2013 www.dukechroniclesports.com

SportsThe Chronicle

Athletes make the best fans

The most exciting sporting event at Duke on Saturday wasn’t the 58-55 football

shootout at Wallace Wade, which was filled with three types of moments: oh-my-god-they-just-blew-it-again, oh-my-god-Jamison-

Crowder-for-president and oh-my-god-I-can’t-believe-Duke-is-still-in-this. The event was at Cameron Indoor Stadium, and basketball season hasn’t even started yet.

The honor belongs Duke volleyball team, which upset No. 16 Illinois in four sets Satur-day evening. The key to the win: members of the baseball, wrestling and women’s basket-ball teams… in addition to flawless execu-tion on the court from the members of the volleyball team.

The game started with six boisterous Illi-nois fans standing in Section 17, decked out in all orange and screaming their Fighting Illini heads off. It was about what you’d ex-pect and nothing inappropriate or original: yelling while the Blue Devils served, belting out the Seven Nation Army riff, etc. To their credit, they were louder than the several hun-dred Duke fans in attendance. With Camer-on Indoor’s amplifying acoustics, six guys can be shockingly loud. And the Fighting Illini pulled out the first set 25-19, with Illinois seeming to take every long rally with dazzling digs and sizzling spikes.

In between the first and second sets, a number of the Duke athletes in attendance took action. After spending the first set scattered throughout the arena, they all moved down to Section 17 and completely surrounded those six Illinois fans in a sea of blue. If six people can make Cameron loud, 50 or so can make it way louder. The baseball team appeared to be the crew that rolled the deepest, and they were joined by a few wrestlers and women’s basketball players, including notables such as Chelsea Gray and Amber Henson. Even a few Duke football players came by: Brandon Braxton had just spent his afternoon catching five passes for 97 yards and a touchdown in a game that looked like it was more Madden 25 than actual football and still managed to make it. (Also worth noting: Crazy Towel Guy was there. He actually makes his way to a lot of non-bas-ketball games, but I don’t think most people recognize him unless he’s sitting in Section 7, Row G, Seat 8 and waving a towel crazily.)

That crew of Duke fans completely drowned out those six Illinois fans for the rest of the match and the Blue Devils pulled out the next three sets. All of the long rallies that Illinois grinded out in the first set, Duke eked

Duke gets a break from ACC play

MEN’S SOCCER

by Madeline CarringtonTHE CHRONICLE

Following a tough loss to Syracuse Fri-day, Duke will look to rebound during a break in ACC play against a Wright State squad that has not competed against the Blue Devils in more than 15 years.

Duke will look to snag a nonconfer-ence victory in be-tween two demand-ing ACC opponents Tuesday night as it hosts the Raiders at Koskinen Stadium 7 p.m.

“We’ve got to bounce back,” head coach John Kerr said. “We’ve reflected over the past few days on what we need to improve on, and most of all it’s the attitude and the kind of preparation going in. We have to be less loosey-goosey and more focused.”

Against Syracuse, the Blue Devils (3-2-2) squandered a second-half lead and fell

Freshman duo revitalizes Duke offenseby Danielle Lazarus

THE CHRONICLE

After a 2012 season in which Duke’s of-fense faltered, head coach John Kerr had one clear objective for his 2013 team.

“This season we’re really focused on get-ting goals from more guys on the field,” he said. “This recruiting class that’s coming in is huge for us.”

Kerr is right—each of his four freshmen has garnered significant playing time, es-pecially forward Brody Huitema and mid-fielder Seo-In Kim. The duo has started in each of the Blue Devils’ seven games so far, and both have quickly become key compo-nents of the squad’s revitalized offense.

“I don’t want to think that just because I’m a freshman I can’t make an impact, same with Brody, Jimmy [Doll] and Jared [Golestani],” Kim said. “We can make an impact if we put our minds to it.”

But something is different about Huite-ma and Kim. Including Duke’s final exhibi-tion game of the preseason, Huitema has scored four goals so far and Kim has assist-ed on three of them. A natural chemistry between the pair has allowed them to con-nect on the field, despite having only been teammates for a month.

“[Kim] plays similarly to the wingers I’ve played with before,” Huitema said. “That makes it easy… because I know what he’s going to do, and I react before he does it.”

Kim’s reasoning for the connection between the freshmen, however, is a bit simpler.

“It’s a bromance,” he said.

MEN’S SOCCER

See FRESHMEN, page 8

See BEATON, page 8See M. SOCCER, page 9

TUESDAY, 7 p.m.Koskinen Stadium

Wright St.

Dukevs.

Andrew Beaton

2-1. Although freshman Brody Huitema notched his third goal in two games, Duke’s effort was not enough to pick up the win.

Using a loss to Syracuse to fuel the fire, the Blue Devils will make a concerted effort to maintain their intensity throughout the game against Wright State.

“I think everyone’s disappointed with how we performed on Friday night,” Kerr said. “That’s what’s motivating us right now. I think we’ve got to dig deep and get after it. Tomorrow, if we score early, we want to score again and again and again.”

After going scoreless in his first five col-legiate contests, Huitema’s emergence has added an additional dimension to Duke’s offensive attack. The freshman will play a key role again Tuesday night when his team takes on a physical defense that has racked up 72 fouls in its first five contests.

“Hopefully I’ll get opportunities,” Huitema said. “I just need to make

YUYI LI/THE CHRONICLE

Along with forward Brody Huitema, freshman midfielder Seo-In Kim has played a crucial role in Duke’s offensive success early in the season.

Huitema and Kim’s paths to becoming Blue Devils were similar, albeit in different countries. Huitema, a native of Chilliwack, British Colombia, trained with the Vancou-ver Whitecaps of the MLS from the time he was 16. Originally born in Sung’nam, South Korea, Kim grew up in the Midwest and was a member of Sporting Kansas City’s development program.

Kerr contacted the Whitecaps express-ing his interest in Huitema early on in the recruitment process. The striker was tout-ed as a pure goal scorer to recruiters after

tallying 23 goals in 25 contests during his junior season—exactly what Kerr needed for his struggling Blue Devils.

“I really enjoyed my time with the team [during recruitment],” Huitema said. “It felt like it was a real group of team players whereas other schools where I visited were more fake. They had a plan set out here and it just felt right.”

Kim, however, didn’t even consider Duke until later in the process, when

CHRIS DIECKHAUS/THE CHRONICLE

After going up a goal early in the second half, Duke’s defense allowed back-to-back tallies to fall to Syracuse.

8 | TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 2013 www.dukechronicle.com The Chronicle 8 | TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 2013 www.dukechroniclesports.com The Chronicle The Chronicle www.dukechroniclesports.com TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 2013 | 9

ACROSS 1 Digging …

or word after “digging”

5 Santa ___, Calif. 9 Penne, e.g.14 “Me neither”15 Geishas’ wear16 Synthetic fiber17 Research

that may be outdoors

19 “Lemon Tree” singer Lopez

20 Org. recommending regular checkups

21 Function22 Camera

adjustments24 “I’m with you!”26 Variable spring

period28 Some cheers29 Something not

to be spared, in a saying

31 A .08% reading may lead to it, for short

32 Casey with a radio countdown

34 Not suitable36 What employers

tap to get employees

39 There are five on China’s flag

41 Alternatives to Slurpees

42 San Francisco’s ___ Hill

43 One of 154 for Shakespeare

46 Prisoner’s sentence

50 Fortunate sort52 Late bloomer53 Lit54 Fink56 “Yuck!”57 Magician’s

assistant in an audience, say

58 Supposed inventor of baseball … or a hint to 17-, 26-, 36- and 50-Across

61 Hollywood’s Davis

62 Wicked63 Vulcan mind ___64 Source of Indian

black tea65 Ready to come

off the stove66 “Got it”

DOWN 1 Severe

disrepute 2 “I haven’t the

foggiest” 3 Bringer of

peace 4 Medium for Van

Dyck or van Gogh

5 Counterparts of columns

6 High wind? 7 Word said with

a salute 8 Request 9 Helen Keller’s

portrayer in “The Miracle Worker”

10 “This way” indicator

11 Attacked anonymously

12 Stiffen through nervousness

13 Ring king18 Couple23 ___ Poke

(candy)25 Holocaust hero

Schindler26 Fixing, as the

bottom of a skirt

27 Press ___ (media packet)

29 General on Chinese menus

30 Part of H.M.S.33 Auto safety

feature, redundantly

35 Flight destinations

36 Attire for scientists

37 Bandage brand38 Like some mil.

officers39 NBC show since

’7540 Messes up, as

the hair44 “___ to Joy”

45 Dozed (off)47 27 Chopin

works48 Entertain

lavishly49 Half of

Stevenson’s “strange case”

51 ___ Kinte of “Roots”

52 The Braves, on scoreboards

54 Many an archaeological site

55 Like Napoleon, before Elba?

57 Org. with balls and strikes

59 ___-lacto-vegetarian

60 Big inits. in music

PUZZLE BY ZHOUQIN BURKINEL AND DON GAGLIARDO

For answers, call 1-900-285-5656, $1.49 a minute; or, with a credit card, 1-800-814-5554.Annual subscriptions are available for the best of Sunday crosswords from the last 50 years: 1-888-7-ACROSS.AT&T users: Text NYTX to 386 to download puzzles, or visit nytimes.com/mobilexword for more information.Online subscriptions: Today’s puzzle and more than 2,000 past puzzles, nytimes.com/crosswords ($39.95 a year).Share tips: nytimes.com/wordplay. Crosswords for young solvers: nytimes.com/learning/xwords.

ANSWER TO PREVIOUS PUZZLE

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13

14 15 16

17 18 19

20 21 22 23

24 25 26 27

28 29 30 31

32 33 34 35

36 37 38

39 40 41

42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49

50 51 52

53 54 55 56

57 58 59 60

61 62 63

64 65 66

Y A K S L E A P E R A M PA D A M A L P I N E G E EO M N I P O P P Y S E E D S

O G R E S L E A X O U TS N A K E E Y E S R I N S EF I R O D E D O G E A RO S O S A E R A T E

H O N O R S T U D E N T SO R A T O R T R I M

T R A C E D A S A A D AH E R O S W A L L P A P E RE C O N B A G I P O D SC A M E R A F I L M R O L LO N A O R E L S E T O I TW T S B E R E T S A R P S

The New York Times Syndication Sales Corporation620 Eighth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10018

For Information Call: 1-800-972-3550For Release Tuesday, September 24, 2013

Edited by Will Shortz No. 0820Crossword

The Chronicle Positive reinforcement for a change:

Get back on the horse: ............................................................. duranddurandIt’s ok to take a night off: .................................................................Mr. Teeth2011 wasn’t that long ago?: ..................................................................RecessPatting myself on the back: ..............................................................MagicarpNew blogs look awesome: .......................................................accordingtojimYou’re a life-saver: ................................................................... theothersophiaStill No. 1 in the power rankings: .......................................................linsanityYou’re ok: ............................................................................................ Mr. JortsBarb Starbuck is always positive anyway: ...............................................Barb

Student Advertising Manager: ..................................................James Sinclair

Account Representatives: ...................... Jennifer Bahadur, Shannon Beckham

Peter Chapin, Caitlin Chase, Courtney Clower, Alyssa Coughenour

Tyler Deane-Krantz, Chris Geary, Liz Lash, Hannah Long, Parker Masselink

Nic Meiring, Brian Paskas, Nick Philip, Cliff Simmons, Lexy Steinhilber, Olivia Wax

Creative Services Student Manager: ................................. Marcela Heywood

Creative Services: ..........................................................Allison Eisen, Mao HuRita Lo, Izzy Xu

Business Office .........................................................................Susanna Booth

In Kakuro you must place the digits 1 to 9 into a grid of squares

so that each horizontal or vertical run of white

squares adds up to the clue printed either to the left of or above

the run. Numbers below a diagonal line

give the total of the white squares below; numbers to the right

of a diagonal line give the total of the white squares to the right. Find the answers to the Kakuo puzzle on

the classifieds page

OPERATION: Stores Administration PUBLICATION: ChronicleHEADLINE: Sign Up DATES: 11/02/07COLOR: CMYK

sign up.Be the first to know about new arrivals,

special collections, the latest in technology,sales events, textbook buyback and more.

For more information, visit our website atwww.dukestores.duke.edu and click on the BTFTK icon on the left.

Our Privacy Policy:We respect your right to personal privacy. We promise to use this subscription service for the express purpose of keeping you informed of only those services that you have requested. Your personal information will not be disclosed to any third parties. We hope you will find our e-mails of benefit. We promise to keep them informative and to-the-point. You will have the option of unsubscribing from this service with each e-mail campaign.

ANNOUNCEMENTS

STATISTICS TUTOR

Duke professor seeks statistics tutor for teen CC student 1-2 hr/week, $40/hour. Knowledge and love of horses a plus. Re-spond with qualifications and contact info to [email protected]

HELP ME GET MARRIED!

My fiance and I are Duke grads who want to get married in the Chapel next year, but we live in NYC. We’ll give you $100 to wait in line from 10pm Sunday (9/29) to 7am Monday (9/30). Tent pro-vided! Please email me at [email protected]. Thanks!

HELP WANTED

BILINGUAL DATA MONITORS

NeuroCog Trials, a rapidly grow-ing company in Durham with close ties to Duke University Medical Center is seeking: Full-time bi-lingual data monitors fluent in both English and Rus-sian or Italian; Part-time bi-lin-gual data monitors fluent in both English and Dutch; Serbian or Brazilian-Portuguese. Data Monitors will assist in, review and learn rater certification on neurocognitive test batteries for multi-site pharmaceutical com-pany trials and provide forward and back translations of com-munications between NeuroCog Trials and clinical sites. Travel to US or international meetings is required. Requirements: BA in Psychology, neurosciences or related field. Fluency in English and any of the languages above with the ability to speak, read and write in both languages. A language validation test will be performed. Ability to travel as needed. We request that all applicants submit resume and cover letter to: [email protected]

HOMES FOR SALE

809 CARPENTER FLETCHER RD, DURHAM, NC 27713

PRICE REDUCTION - MOTIVATED SELLERS

SPACIOUS TWO-STORY HOME, ON CORNER LOT, ENTERING NOTTINGHAM FOREST NEIGH-BORHOOD, LARGE FENCED BACKYARD WITH FIREPIT, BUILT-IN SECURITY SYSTEM, MBR WITH VAULTED CEILING, GREAT ROOM WITH CERAMIC TILE, EXTRA STORAGE IN TWO-CAR GARAGE, ENERGY-EFFICIENT BLINDS IN GREAT ROOM AND EAT-IN KITCHEN. VERY MOTI-VATED SELLERS, BRING YOUR OFFER!!!

Email [email protected]

NOTHING

later than

on

OPENCOSMIC9th STREET

1920 1/2 Perry St. at Ninth Street

Just a block from

East Campus

cosmiccantina

Menu SamplingOld School Veggie Burrito $2.86Regular Chicken Burrito $5.65Cheese Quesadilla $1.41Chicken Quesadilla $3.59VeggieNachos $4.12Chips & Salsa $2.06

Open until 4 am

CLASSIFIEDS

The Chronicle classified advertising

www.dukechronicle.com/classifieds

out the rest of the match.This isn’t to credit the fans with winning

the game. Elizabeth Campbell had 23 kills, nine more than anybody on Illinois. Jeme Obeime had 16 kills and spikes the ball with the power of 1,000 suns and Misty May-Tre-anor combined. I would rather be tackled by Sydney Sarmiento than face the fury of her spikes. Ali McCurdy—who is already Duke’s all-time leader in digs—and Sasha Karelov seemed to make an acrobatic dig on every single play.

They won the game on the court, and the impact of fans at most sporting events is min-imal, if that effect exists at all. The athletes deserve 99.9 percent of the credit for a pretty awesome win.

But this column is about fans, and even if what the Duke student-athlete-fans did had

no effect on the outcome, it was still pretty cool. It should be noted, athletes supporting other athletes is nothing new. The basketball players make their way to almost every foot-ball game and a number of other sporting events, and a few of them, including Rodney Hood, were at for the volleyball match. The volleyball players were sitting in the front row at the football game only a few hours earlier.

The initiative the athletes took Saturday, though, really stood out. Not that I ever played sports in front of a crowd that includ-ed anything more than parents, half of whom were doing crossword puzzles, but I imagine it really stinks to play in your home arena while the opposing fans are louder.

Try going to a volleyball game or soccer match if you have a time because as fun as it is to be a Cameron Crazie at a men’s bas-ketball game, you really can have your voice heard at a non-revenue sport. After all, it only takes six fans to get rowdy.

sure I focus on them and finish them.”Though a consistent offense remains

a priority for Duke, Tuesday’s match will provide an opportunity to sure up the play of the Blue Devils’ back line, which looks to the two second-half goals it allowed against the Orange to identify room for improvement.

“I think we’re a little disappointed with some of the goals we let Syracuse and some of the other teams score,” senior midfield-er Rob Dolot said. “We felt like there were things multiple people could have done to prevent those goals.”

Although the Raiders (1-3-1) are un-ranked, they will certainly test Duke throughout the match. Kerr noted Wright State’s 0-0 stalemate against Ohio State ear-lier this month as an example of the team’s potential.

Like the Blue Devils, Wright State is coming off a disappointing result as well. The Raiders fell to Northern Kentucky 2-1 Friday at home.

Dolot said that a solid performance against Wright State will set the Blue Dev-ils up to compete with a top-ranked Notre Dame squad Friday evening.

BEATON from page 7

M. SOCCER from page 7FRESHMEN from page 7

“We’re just looking to build off of it,” he said. “Hopefully getting a good victory over Wright State. We’ve got Notre Dame on Friday so, even though we’re thinking of Wright State first, hopefully the game will serve as a springboard to the ACC game.”

DAYOU ZHUO/THE CHRONICLE

A little crowd presence at a smaller sporting event can make a monumental difference, writes columnist Andrew Beaton.

Kansas City U18 head coach Jon Parry—an old friend of Kerr’s—suggested the Blue Devils to the midfielder.

“Initially I wasn’t even planning on coming here,” he said. “But I loved… the upperclassmen and I just felt very wanted from the coaches. I knew when I came in I was going to have a lot of fun.”

But Kim didn’t have fun immediately, with a grueling preseason to endure before seeing any game action. He came off the bench in his first scrimmage in Duke blue, registering a foul in 64 minutes of play.

“Preseason was definitely tiring,” Kim said. “We had two-a-days, and between those times I was honestly just sleeping. But it was hard work that was necessary for us to be successful.”

Huitema, meanwhile, didn’t get a chance to practice with the Blue Devils be-fore taking the field with them. As a mem-ber of the Canadian U18 national team, Huitema spent most of his August playing in the COTIF U20 Tournament in Spain. After Canada placed fourth, Huitmea re-turned home the day before Duke’s final exhibition game and arrived in Durham the day of the match.

Despite any jet lag or exhaustion, Huite-ma got right into the swing of things, reg-istering a goal against Old Dominion—as-sisted by Kim.

“I jumped right into it,” Huitema said. “Everyone here is so talented, so it’s not that different as playing with the national team.”

But going into the regular season, nei-ther Huitema nor Kim could find the back

of the net. In the first five games of the sea-son, Huitema led the team with 19 shots but came away without a goal. Meanwhile, the Blue Devils’ offense was still struggling, only scoring multiple goals once.

“[Huitema] didn’t score in the first five games of his career… but he was causing havoc,” Kerr said. “We knew he was going to score goals, it was just a matter of time of him getting into the groove.”

Naturally, it was Kim who helped Huite-ma find his groove. With Duke down 2-0 Sept. 17 against Davidson, Kim was award-ed a corner kick and lobbed the ball to the far post. Huitema, who was positioned there, headed the ball into the goal to cut the Blue Devils’ deficit in half.

The duo’s magic didn’t stop there. Duke tied the game in the 87th minute, but went back-and-forth with the Wildcats for most of the first overtime until Kim broke down the left side of the field and found Huite-ma. The forward beat the goalkeeper to se-cure the victory for the Blue Devils.

“There are just some players you play with, and you don’t have to know them a long time but you get a knack for how they play,” Kim said. “I play with Brody and I don’t really have to think. It’s a good thing when you have that chemistry together.”

Yet Huitema and Kim both say that their strong relationship on the field is due in part to their bromance off the field. The self-proclaimed jokesters spend much of their time together, which allows them to play their best when they step on the pitch.

“We mess around a lot,” Kim said. “But when we’re on the field, it’s business time…. For us to add to the score sheet as two fresh-men, I think that’s pretty amazing.”


Duke remains winless in conference play after a loss to Syracuse, but has a chance to rebound against Wright State.

The Chronicle www.dukechronicle.com TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 2013 | 9 8 | TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 2013 www.dukechroniclesports.com The Chronicle The Chronicle www.dukechroniclesports.com TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 2013 | 9

ACROSS 1 Digging …

or word after “digging”

5 Santa ___, Calif. 9 Penne, e.g.14 “Me neither”15 Geishas’ wear16 Synthetic fiber17 Research

that may be outdoors

19 “Lemon Tree” singer Lopez

20 Org. recommending regular checkups

21 Function22 Camera

adjustments24 “I’m with you!”26 Variable spring

period28 Some cheers29 Something not

to be spared, in a saying

31 A .08% reading may lead to it, for short

32 Casey with a radio countdown

34 Not suitable36 What employers

tap to get employees

39 There are five on China’s flag

41 Alternatives to Slurpees

42 San Francisco’s ___ Hill

43 One of 154 for Shakespeare

46 Prisoner’s sentence

50 Fortunate sort52 Late bloomer53 Lit54 Fink56 “Yuck!”57 Magician’s

assistant in an audience, say

58 Supposed inventor of baseball … or a hint to 17-, 26-, 36- and 50-Across

61 Hollywood’s Davis

62 Wicked63 Vulcan mind ___64 Source of Indian

black tea65 Ready to come

off the stove66 “Got it”

DOWN 1 Severe

disrepute 2 “I haven’t the

foggiest” 3 Bringer of

peace 4 Medium for Van

Dyck or van Gogh

5 Counterparts of columns

6 High wind? 7 Word said with

a salute 8 Request 9 Helen Keller’s

portrayer in “The Miracle Worker”

10 “This way” indicator

11 Attacked anonymously

12 Stiffen through nervousness

13 Ring king18 Couple23 ___ Poke

(candy)25 Holocaust hero

Schindler26 Fixing, as the

bottom of a skirt

27 Press ___ (media packet)

29 General on Chinese menus

30 Part of H.M.S.33 Auto safety

feature, redundantly

35 Flight destinations

36 Attire for scientists

37 Bandage brand38 Like some mil.

officers39 NBC show since

’7540 Messes up, as

the hair44 “___ to Joy”

45 Dozed (off)47 27 Chopin

works48 Entertain

lavishly49 Half of

Stevenson’s “strange case”

51 ___ Kinte of “Roots”

52 The Braves, on scoreboards

54 Many an archaeological site

55 Like Napoleon, before Elba?

57 Org. with balls and strikes

59 ___-lacto-vegetarian

60 Big inits. in music

PUZZLE BY ZHOUQIN BURKINEL AND DON GAGLIARDO

For answers, call 1-900-285-5656, $1.49 a minute; or, with a credit card, 1-800-814-5554.Annual subscriptions are available for the best of Sunday crosswords from the last 50 years: 1-888-7-ACROSS.AT&T users: Text NYTX to 386 to download puzzles, or visit nytimes.com/mobilexword for more information.Online subscriptions: Today’s puzzle and more than 2,000 past puzzles, nytimes.com/crosswords ($39.95 a year).Share tips: nytimes.com/wordplay. Crosswords for young solvers: nytimes.com/learning/xwords.

ANSWER TO PREVIOUS PUZZLE

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13

14 15 16

17 18 19

20 21 22 23

24 25 26 27

28 29 30 31

32 33 34 35

36 37 38

39 40 41

42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49

50 51 52

53 54 55 56

57 58 59 60

61 62 63

64 65 66

Y A K S L E A P E R A M PA D A M A L P I N E G E EO M N I P O P P Y S E E D S

O G R E S L E A X O U TS N A K E E Y E S R I N S EF I R O D E D O G E A RO S O S A E R A T E

H O N O R S T U D E N T SO R A T O R T R I M

T R A C E D A S A A D AH E R O S W A L L P A P E RE C O N B A G I P O D SC A M E R A F I L M R O L LO N A O R E L S E T O I TW T S B E R E T S A R P S

The New York Times Syndication Sales Corporation620 Eighth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10018

For Information Call: 1-800-972-3550For Release Tuesday, September 24, 2013

Edited by Will Shortz No. 0820Crossword

The Chronicle Positive reinforcement for a change:

Get back on the horse: ............................................................. duranddurandIt’s ok to take a night off: .................................................................Mr. Teeth2011 wasn’t that long ago?: ..................................................................RecessPatting myself on the back: ..............................................................MagicarpNew blogs look awesome: .......................................................accordingtojimYou’re a life-saver: ................................................................... theothersophiaStill No. 1 in the power rankings: .......................................................linsanityYou’re ok: ............................................................................................ Mr. JortsBarb Starbuck is always positive anyway: ...............................................Barb

Student Advertising Manager: ..................................................James Sinclair

Account Representatives: ...................... Jennifer Bahadur, Shannon Beckham

Peter Chapin, Caitlin Chase, Courtney Clower, Alyssa Coughenour

Tyler Deane-Krantz, Chris Geary, Liz Lash, Hannah Long, Parker Masselink

Nic Meiring, Brian Paskas, Nick Philip, Cliff Simmons, Lexy Steinhilber, Olivia Wax

Creative Services Student Manager: ................................. Marcela Heywood

Creative Services: ..........................................................Allison Eisen, Mao HuRita Lo, Izzy Xu

Business Office .........................................................................Susanna Booth

In Kakuro you must place the digits 1 to 9 into a grid of squares

so that each horizontal or vertical run of white

squares adds up to the clue printed either to the left of or above

the run. Numbers below a diagonal line

give the total of the white squares below; numbers to the right

of a diagonal line give the total of the white squares to the right. Find the answers to the Kakuo puzzle on

the classifieds page

OPERATION: Stores Administration PUBLICATION: ChronicleHEADLINE: Sign Up DATES: 11/02/07COLOR: CMYK

sign up.Be the first to know about new arrivals,

special collections, the latest in technology,sales events, textbook buyback and more.

For more information, visit our website atwww.dukestores.duke.edu and click on the BTFTK icon on the left.

Our Privacy Policy:We respect your right to personal privacy. We promise to use this subscription service for the express purpose of keeping you informed of only those services that you have requested. Your personal information will not be disclosed to any third parties. We hope you will find our e-mails of benefit. We promise to keep them informative and to-the-point. You will have the option of unsubscribing from this service with each e-mail campaign.

ANNOUNCEMENTS

STATISTICS TUTOR

Duke professor seeks statistics tutor for teen CC student 1-2 hr/week, $40/hour. Knowledge and love of horses a plus. Re-spond with qualifications and contact info to [email protected]

HELP ME GET MARRIED!

My fiance and I are Duke grads who want to get married in the Chapel next year, but we live in NYC. We’ll give you $100 to wait in line from 10pm Sunday (9/29) to 7am Monday (9/30). Tent pro-vided! Please email me at [email protected]. Thanks!

HELP WANTED

BILINGUAL DATA MONITORS

NeuroCog Trials, a rapidly grow-ing company in Durham with close ties to Duke University Medical Center is seeking: Full-time bi-lingual data monitors fluent in both English and Rus-sian or Italian; Part-time bi-lin-gual data monitors fluent in both English and Dutch; Serbian or Brazilian-Portuguese. Data Monitors will assist in, review and learn rater certification on neurocognitive test batteries for multi-site pharmaceutical com-pany trials and provide forward and back translations of com-munications between NeuroCog Trials and clinical sites. Travel to US or international meetings is required. Requirements: BA in Psychology, neurosciences or related field. Fluency in English and any of the languages above with the ability to speak, read and write in both languages. A language validation test will be performed. Ability to travel as needed. We request that all applicants submit resume and cover letter to: [email protected]

HOMES FOR SALE

809 CARPENTER FLETCHER RD, DURHAM, NC 27713

PRICE REDUCTION - MOTIVATED SELLERS

SPACIOUS TWO-STORY HOME, ON CORNER LOT, ENTERING NOTTINGHAM FOREST NEIGH-BORHOOD, LARGE FENCED BACKYARD WITH FIREPIT, BUILT-IN SECURITY SYSTEM, MBR WITH VAULTED CEILING, GREAT ROOM WITH CERAMIC TILE, EXTRA STORAGE IN TWO-CAR GARAGE, ENERGY-EFFICIENT BLINDS IN GREAT ROOM AND EAT-IN KITCHEN. VERY MOTI-VATED SELLERS, BRING YOUR OFFER!!!

Email [email protected]

NOTHING

later than

on

OPENCOSMIC9th STREET

1920 1/2 Perry St. at Ninth Street

Just a block from

East Campus

cosmiccantina

Menu SamplingOld School Veggie Burrito $2.86Regular Chicken Burrito $5.65Cheese Quesadilla $1.41Chicken Quesadilla $3.59VeggieNachos $4.12Chips & Salsa $2.06

Open until 4 am

CLASSIFIEDS

The Chronicle classified advertising

www.dukechronicle.com/classifieds

out the rest of the match.This isn’t to credit the fans with winning

the game. Elizabeth Campbell had 23 kills, nine more than anybody on Illinois. Jeme Obeime had 16 kills and spikes the ball with the power of 1,000 suns and Misty May-Tre-anor combined. I would rather be tackled by Sydney Sarmiento than face the fury of her spikes. Ali McCurdy—who is already Duke’s all-time leader in digs—and Sasha Karelov seemed to make an acrobatic dig on every single play.

They won the game on the court, and the impact of fans at most sporting events is min-imal, if that effect exists at all. The athletes deserve 99.9 percent of the credit for a pretty awesome win.

But this column is about fans, and even if what the Duke student-athlete-fans did had

no effect on the outcome, it was still pretty cool. It should be noted, athletes supporting other athletes is nothing new. The basketball players make their way to almost every foot-ball game and a number of other sporting events, and a few of them, including Rodney Hood, were at for the volleyball match. The volleyball players were sitting in the front row at the football game only a few hours earlier.

The initiative the athletes took Saturday, though, really stood out. Not that I ever played sports in front of a crowd that includ-ed anything more than parents, half of whom were doing crossword puzzles, but I imagine it really stinks to play in your home arena while the opposing fans are louder.

Try going to a volleyball game or soccer match if you have a time because as fun as it is to be a Cameron Crazie at a men’s bas-ketball game, you really can have your voice heard at a non-revenue sport. After all, it only takes six fans to get rowdy.

sure I focus on them and finish them.”Though a consistent offense remains

a priority for Duke, Tuesday’s match will provide an opportunity to sure up the play of the Blue Devils’ back line, which looks to the two second-half goals it allowed against the Orange to identify room for improvement.

“I think we’re a little disappointed with some of the goals we let Syracuse and some of the other teams score,” senior midfield-er Rob Dolot said. “We felt like there were things multiple people could have done to prevent those goals.”

Although the Raiders (1-3-1) are un-ranked, they will certainly test Duke throughout the match. Kerr noted Wright State’s 0-0 stalemate against Ohio State ear-lier this month as an example of the team’s potential.

Like the Blue Devils, Wright State is coming off a disappointing result as well. The Raiders fell to Northern Kentucky 2-1 Friday at home.

Dolot said that a solid performance against Wright State will set the Blue Dev-ils up to compete with a top-ranked Notre Dame squad Friday evening.

BEATON from page 7

M. SOCCER from page 7FRESHMEN from page 7

“We’re just looking to build off of it,” he said. “Hopefully getting a good victory over Wright State. We’ve got Notre Dame on Friday so, even though we’re thinking of Wright State first, hopefully the game will serve as a springboard to the ACC game.”


A little crowd presence at a smaller sporting event can make a monumental difference, writes columnist Andrew Beaton.

Kansas City U18 head coach Jon Parry—an old friend of Kerr’s—suggested the Blue Devils to the midfielder.

“Initially I wasn’t even planning on coming here,” he said. “But I loved… the upperclassmen and I just felt very wanted from the coaches. I knew when I came in I was going to have a lot of fun.”

But Kim didn’t have fun immediately, with a grueling preseason to endure before seeing any game action. He came off the bench in his first scrimmage in Duke blue, registering a foul in 64 minutes of play.

“Preseason was definitely tiring,” Kim said. “We had two-a-days, and between those times I was honestly just sleeping. But it was hard work that was necessary for us to be successful.”

Huitema, meanwhile, didn’t get a chance to practice with the Blue Devils be-fore taking the field with them. As a mem-ber of the Canadian U18 national team, Huitema spent most of his August playing in the COTIF U20 Tournament in Spain. After Canada placed fourth, Huitmea re-turned home the day before Duke’s final exhibition game and arrived in Durham the day of the match.

Despite any jet lag or exhaustion, Huite-ma got right into the swing of things, reg-istering a goal against Old Dominion—as-sisted by Kim.

“I jumped right into it,” Huitema said. “Everyone here is so talented, so it’s not that different as playing with the national team.”

But going into the regular season, nei-ther Huitema nor Kim could find the back

of the net. In the first five games of the sea-son, Huitema led the team with 19 shots but came away without a goal. Meanwhile, the Blue Devils’ offense was still struggling, only scoring multiple goals once.

“[Huitema] didn’t score in the first five games of his career… but he was causing havoc,” Kerr said. “We knew he was going to score goals, it was just a matter of time of him getting into the groove.”

Naturally, it was Kim who helped Huite-ma find his groove. With Duke down 2-0 Sept. 17 against Davidson, Kim was award-ed a corner kick and lobbed the ball to the far post. Huitema, who was positioned there, headed the ball into the goal to cut the Blue Devils’ deficit in half.

The duo’s magic didn’t stop there. Duke tied the game in the 87th minute, but went back-and-forth with the Wildcats for most of the first overtime until Kim broke down the left side of the field and found Huite-ma. The forward beat the goalkeeper to se-cure the victory for the Blue Devils.

“There are just some players you play with, and you don’t have to know them a long time but you get a knack for how they play,” Kim said. “I play with Brody and I don’t really have to think. It’s a good thing when you have that chemistry together.”

Yet Huitema and Kim both say that their strong relationship on the field is due in part to their bromance off the field. The self-proclaimed jokesters spend much of their time together, which allows them to play their best when they step on the pitch.

“We mess around a lot,” Kim said. “But when we’re on the field, it’s business time…. For us to add to the score sheet as two fresh-men, I think that’s pretty amazing.”


Duke remains winless in conference play after a loss to Syracuse, but has a chance to rebound against Wright State.

10 | TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 2013 www.dukechronicle.com The Chronicle10 | TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 2013 commentary The Chronicle The Chronicle commentary TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 2013 | 11

Letters PoLicyThe Chronicle welcomes submissions in the form of letters

to the editor or guest columns. Submissions must include the author’s name, signature, department or class, and for purposes of identification, phone number and local address. Letters should not exceed 325 words; contact the editorial department for information regarding guest columns.

The Chronicle will not publish anonymous or form letters or letters that are promotional in nature. The Chronicle reserves the right to edit letters and guest columns for length, clarity and style and the right to withhold letters based on the discretion of the editorial page editor.

Direct submissions to:

E-mail: [email protected]

Editorial Page DepartmentThe ChronicleBox 90858, Durham, NC 27708

Phone: (919) 684-2663Fax: (919) 684-4696

The C

hron

icle

Th

e i

nd

ep

en

de

nT

da

ily

aT

du

ke

un

ive

rs

iTy

”“ onlinecomment

I hope Alex pursues legal action. Hitting a kid in a wheelchair and his service puppy, and not even bothering to get out of the car, is absolutely vile.

—“twentyfourteen” commenting on the article “Student and dog struck by car on Anderson Street”See more at www.dukechronicle.com.

Inc. 1993Est. 1905 The ChronicleDanielle Muoio, Editor

Sophia DuranD, Managing EditorraiSa chowDhury, News Editor

Daniel carp, Sports EditorSophia palenberg, Photography Editor

Scott briggS, Editorial Page EditorcaSey williaMS, Editorial Board Chair

jiM poSen, Director of Online OperationsKelly Scurry, Managing editor for online

chriSSy becK, General Manager

eMMa baccellieri, University Editor carleigh StiehM, University Editor

elizabeth DjiniS, Local & National Editor georgia parKe, Local & National Editor

anthony hagouel, Health & Science Editor tony Shan, Health & Science Editor

julia May, News Photography Editor eric lin, Sports Photography Editor

KelSey hopKinS, Design Editor rita lo, Design Editor

lauren feilich, Recess Editor jaMie KeSSler, Recess Managing Editor

eliza bray, Recess Photography Editor thanh-ha nguyen, Online Photo Editor

MouSa alShanteer, Editorial Page Managing Editor Matt pun, Sports Managing Editor

aShley Mooney, Towerview Editor caitlin MoyleS, Towerview Editor

jennie Xu, Towerview Photography Editor Dillon patel, Towerview Creative Director

KriStie KiM, Social Media Editor julian Spector, Special Projects Editor

lauren carroll, Senior Editor chelSea pieroni, Multimedia Editor

anDrew luo, News Blog Editor glen rivKeeS, Director of Online Operations

Matt barnett, Multimedia Editor yeShwanth KanDiMalla, Recruitment Chair

rebecca DicKenSon, Advertising Director julia May, Recruitment Chair

Mary weaver, Operations Manager barbara StarbucK, Creative Director

Megan Mcginity, Digital Sales Manager

the chronicle is published by the Duke Student publishing company, inc., a non-profit corporation independent of Duke university. the opinions expressed in this newspaper are not necessarily those of Duke university, its students, faculty, staff, administration or trustees. unsigned editorials represent the majority view of the editorial board. columns, letters and cartoons represent the views of the authors.

to reach the editorial office at 301 flowers building, call 684-2663 or fax 684-4696. to reach the business office at 2022 campus Drive call 684-3811. to reach the advertising office at 2022 campus Drive call 684-3811

In 412 B.C., Diogenes of Sinope, the founder of the Greek Cynic movement, was asked where he came from. His response, “I am a citizen of

the world [kosmopolitês],” founded the ethical framework of cosmopolitanism. The central tenant of cosmopolitanism is that all humans belong to a culturally diverse world community that ascribes to a common set of moral, political and economic ideologies. Martha Nussbaum writes of the Greek Stoic conception of cosmopolitanism: “Each human being dwells in two communities—the local community of our birth, and the community of human argument and aspiration.” Cosmopolitanism has guided my own policy views, especially in regards to immigration. A policy is ethically justified if it correlates with the ideals of the world community—ideals that are decided through a democratic process with the world as the constituents. Human rights and justice come from humanity’s commitment to universal respect and hospitality, and that commitment is solidified through international laws.What do you think?

In 1795, Immanuel Kant outlined the first legal order for cosmopolitanism in an essay titled, “Perpetual Peace.” Kant argued that perpetual peace could be achieved if the world subscribed, with a league of nations as the enforcer, to a set of common principles and rules. The rules implored nations to abolish standing armies, end economic sanctions and avoid divisive methods in war—like assassinations, inhumane weapons, etc.—and required all states to have republican constitutions. Although Kant’s rules were never adopted, they did influence the founding principles of the League of Nations and eventually the United Nations. The United Nations is a good modern-day example of cosmopolitanism: Its resolutions and decrees aim to represent humanity’s universal ideals.

Some versions of cosmopolitanism encourage the establishment of a world state, but my take on cosmopolitanism does not go so far. The world order should be an institution powerful enough to enforce universal principles, but it should not be a despotic universal government. There must still be some state sovereignty within the system in order to check the authority of the world order. Embedded in this idea is support for immigration reform. I do not endorse open borders, but I do support lessening current worldwide restrictions on immigration. All states should evaluate immigration applications on the basis of need—not ethnicity, skill level or educational background. We should promote consistent immigration law across all states so as to better prevent instances of human trafficking and support claims for asylum. Some states might object to fewer restrictions—fearing a subsequent influx of immigration, so states should only be

obligated to accept immigrants until they reach ‘capacity,’ as defined by the world order. This capacity might be defined in terms of resources, like the availability of housing or employment.

Cosmopolitanism is appealing to deontologists because it is founded upon the idea that universal principles exist and should be enforced. For consequentialists, cosmopolitanism is appealing because it encourages individuals to follow rules that, more often than not, produce good outcomes. For environmental issues, cosmopolitanism would overcome previously plagued attempts to curb carbon emissions. Even as the United States attempts to curb its own burgeoning carbon emissions, developing nations have racked up their emissions in pursuit of growth. If the world subscribed to cosmopolitanism, there would be a mutual agreement to curb carbon emissions with universal participation. A world order could punish nations that deviated from the commitment. It could also ensure that no nation bears the brunt of energy reform and that the burden of cutting fossil fuels is spread equally.

Perhaps the biggest criticism of cosmopolitanism is that nationalism and patriotism are strong, valued and virtuous traits. Many individuals would refuse to join a cosmopolitan world fearing diminished sovereignty and the potential amalgamation of human culture. My brand of cosmopolitanism, however, does not call for subscription to a world culture. I, along with other philosophers, affirm quite the opposite: I ask the citizens of the world to recognize and affirm the differences between peoples while concurrently accepting a set of universal norms.

With the advent of technological connectivity, our perceived notions of nationalism have expanded. Our world was once defined by nation-states, but cross-cultural exchange has exposed us to different paradigms. Over time, different groups of people have come to realize that—while they may look, act and sound different—at their cores, they are all the same. All humans love, fear, fight, rejoice and dream. It has taken us a long time to realize it, but we already are citizens of the world. Clearly, Diogenes was ahead of his time.

Patrick Oathout is a Trinity senior. His column runs every other Tuesday. Send Patrick a message on Twitter @PatrickOathout.

Kosmopolites

PatrickOathoutrealpolitik with patrick

For the past nine months, DukeOpen, a student group, has petitioned senior administrators to increase the transparency of Duke’s endowment and promote socially responsible investment practices. Although we take issue with a few areas of DukeOpen’s platform, we commend the group’s overall goals and, in particular, its well-reasoned and moderate stance. In 2004, The University’s Guidelines on Socially Responsible Investing established the Advisory Committee on Investment Responsibility and gave the Board of Trustees the power to instruct DUMAC, the University’s endowment manager, to take appropriate action, such as divestment, if specific investments are deemed ethically questionable. The DukeOpen platform is threefold: to ensure regular meetings of ACIR, to establish a “social choice fund” that donors can opt into and, most importantly, to increase endowment transparency for the Duke community. The first point makes sense. In its almost decade-long existence, ACIR has convened only twice and is required to meet only on an ad hoc basis. Quarterly or annual meetings would allow ACIR to actively monitor the endowment’s portfolio and keep Board members up to date while minimizing administrative burden. The call for a “social choice fund”—a portion of the endowment contributions

marked for socially responsible investments—begs the question of the endowment’s primary purpose. According to the guidelines, the Board’s primary fiduciary responsibility in overseeing the University’s investments is to maximize returns subject to risk-exposure constraints. This is an incredibly important

responsibility, given that many of Duke’s most valuable features are funded by returns on the endowment. But these guidelines also rightfully acknowledge that the Board can and should take ethical considerations into account when approving investment choices. The existence of a social choice fund, especially if it is actively advertised to donors, would go a long way toward the goal of ethical investment. While DukeOpen’s research shows that socially responsible asset classes do not suffer from systematically lower returns, this subject should be studied further. We also want additional clarity as to which investments qualify as “socially responsible.” Transparency, however, is DukeOpen’s primary goal. The anatomy of the University’s investment portfolio is complex and strategically important, so disclosure of indirect

investments—such as those actively managed by hedge funds—is not feasible. Direct investments in companies are arguably less strategically sensitive. Dartmouth College offers a time-delayed, hard copy disclosure of its direct investments, and Duke should implement a similar practice. Although it is unclear that students have an intrinsic right to know how Duke’s money is invested, the University would be better off if students and faculty had limited access to this information. First, students and faculty collectively have more specialized expertise—and more time and energy to act on it—than ACIR or the Board. Second, more transparency can only serve to raise the standard of discourse in divestment debates. In the past, student-led divestment movements have relied on stylized facts about entire industries. With partial disclosure, more company-specific complaints could be raised. We see no reason why some incarnation of DukeOpen’s vision should not be implemented. Students should see endowment transparency as more than a campus issue: Soon enough, we may be donating to Duke, and we should lay the groundwork to responsibly support our University.

Board Chair Casey Williams recused himself because he is a member of DukeOpen.

students should consider Dukeopen’s aims

Editorial

“When did you change?!” My hometown friend almost shouted the question at me. She and I grew up in the same church back home.

We co-led our youth group and went on at least 6,000 retreats. She knows where I come from—geographically and personally, culturally and spiritually. If I’ve changed, she’d be the one to see it.

I looked in a mirror the next day and found myself staring at a stereotype: close-cropped hair, freshly shaven face, Duke-blue dress shirt and khaki Polo shorts. I was forced to confront a troubling question: What happened to all those baggy cargo shorts and wrinkled t-shirts that I carried into Randolph dorm two years ago? When did I start wearing dress shirts to class? Heavens to Betsy… have I turned preppy?

The night before, I had squeezed myself into the back row of an auditorium packed with alternatively eager- and desperate-looking upperclassmen. We were all there for a corporate recruiting presentation, and not just any corporate recruiting presentation: this was a “Big Three” strategy consulting firm. My attendance raised more questions: What do consultants actually do all day? Am I a sellout if I’m interested in consulting, even if I somewhat ironically became interested because of my DukeEngage project? How did my nature-loving, groupthink-defying, supposedly countercultural self end up in that auditorium?

The next day I went to my econ class taught by Michael Munger, the libertarian professor who preaches market economics like born-again Baptists preach Jesus’ salvation. I found myself listening attentively as he explained that profits come from voluntary exchanges that improve the welfare of both buyer and seller. So, profits are a good thing: Trade benefits both parties and naturally produces profits as a byproduct, even if they’re shared unevenly. My do-gooder, nonprofit-oriented self of two years ago would never have entertained the thought that profits could be good—after all, they all go to those evil corporations. (I don’t think I’m exaggerating here.)

After class, I asked Munger what he thinks about Walmart. He praised the mega-retailer for doing business more efficiently than small firms and, thus, allowing people, especially poor people, to get more things they want and need. (He did bring up the company’s undeniable imperfections, like the 1.5 million-woman class action lawsuit alleging systematic gender discrimination. And then there are the bribes paid to government officials by Wal-Mart de Mexico, which the New York Times called “an aggressive and creative corrupter.”) I felt perturbed that I couldn’t field a decent argument about the chain’s negative impacts. Am I drifting from my liberal roots? Will I someday join the endless stream of Blue Devils who earnestly call themselves “economically conservative but socially liberal” like they were all the first person to ever come up with such a novel

position?When we finished talking, I walked over to the

East Campus bus stop, from which I could see Randolph dorm and think back to freshman year. I entered Duke after a great relationship during my gap year. Earlier, my high school best friend and I dated for well over a year. At Duke, I’ve had one good but relatively short relationship. I consider myself a boyfriend type. I actually LIKE commitment. So why only one relationship in two

years? Maybe it’s because undergrads here go on dates about as often as our football team goes to bowl games. Or maybe it’s because I’ve become so wrapped up in my own grades and growth that I won’t make the time for a significant other. There isn’t room in my color-coded Google calendar for romance.

These tales of junior-year angst might sound like a superficial mid-college crisis. But I’m telling them to better articulate that nagging question: Have I changed?

I guess I have changed. But at the same time, I’m still my old self. I still laugh when my friends make bad puns, and I still love it when girls laugh at my bad puns. I still go to church every week, although it’s with Methodists rather than my childhood Episcopalians. I still value community service and helping people to help themselves. I still go camping whenever I can. I still have this curiosity about the people around me and the world around us. I still talk with my family all the time. I still prefer the hard copy of the newspaper to the web site, because I’m still an old fogey at heart. I still love Spanish and anything related to Latin America. I still think dachshunds are the most perfect dog breed God ever placed on this earth. So there are a lot of ways, big and small, that I’ve stayed the same.

And some of the ways I have changed are definite improvements; my time at Duke has deepened aspects of my identity that I most value. I’ve become a better listener, question-asker and writer. I’ve found service opportunities on campus, in Durham and in Latin America. I’ve studied the New Testament and spent a week at a desert monastery. I spent fully 10 percent of 2012 with PWILD, hiking and being outdoorsy. And last fall, I met a beautiful girl named Gracie.

So yes, I guess I have changed. And I might change some more. But maybe these changes aren’t so bad, if I stay committed to the things that matter most. Like Gracie—who, by the way, is a dachshund.

Andrew Kragie is a Trinity junior. His column runs every other Tuesday.

Have i changed?

Andrew Kragieelevator pitch

In Sub-Saharan Africa, Barack Obama is not much of a political figure. In fact, he’s much more than a political figure. To see a man with a Kenyan father hold one of the most powerful posi-

tions in the world is empowering, especially in a world where success traditionally belongs to white Westerners and, increasingly, to the businessmen and businesswomen of the East. Obama has become an icon for the continent; he’s a t-shirt slogan and is idolized by teenag-ers. When it comes to policies, however, citizens of African nations are either disappointed—as demonstrated by the protests in Johannes-burg this past summer—or ambivalent. Often people are tempted to

ask, “What policies?” What do you think? But with President Obama’s trip to Africa this past June and July, his administration seems to be making a concerted effort to change that. Speaking to a crowd in Johannesburg, Obama produced a plan to spend $7 billion on bring-ing clean energy to un-electrified areas in six countries hand-picked for their good governance: Ghana, Ethiopia, Kenya, Liberia, Nigeria and Tanzania. American companies like General Electric have com-mitted to contribute an additional $9 billion towards projects that, over the next five years, can provide hundreds of megawatts to these nations. There are many things to be said about international aid and investments, like this program, as well as many questions to be asked. The first and foremost might be: “Why?” Aid programs are a head-ache, and, time and time again, development projects have failed after external impetus for change didn’t encourage internal change. There is no moral obligation on the part of the United States to en-gage in each and every circumstance of inadequate welfare. But aid done right is mutually beneficial. There’s often a stigma against gain on the part of the donor in aid relationships, but if an aid program is capable of stimulating the recipient nation’s economy and providing the donor with enhanced diplomatic relations or economic benefits of their own, then that is a positive thing. This is not to say that donor nations should exploit the natural resources of developing countries, but, rather, that there is room for a non-exploitative behavior and domestic economic advantages. Aid programs encourage diplomacy, or at the very least dialogue, and in a continent like Africa, where the breadth of cultures and politics is enormous and unique, it would only serve the United States well to establish relationships with these countries. I think it’s incredibly valuable, then, that President Obama has asserted in the past few months that the nations of Africa are more than open hands to drop money into and, rather, partners that should be invested in. But in the time it took the United States to look to Africa as more than a “one and done” mission trip destination, other nations have come to the table with their own justifications for donation. Despite the United States explicitly holding its position as the world’s biggest donor, many other nations outshine the United States in terms of a relationship with the nations of sub-Saharan Af-rica. If you turn on the BBC, you’re far more likely to find a story analyzing the differences between Indian and Chinese investment in African nations than any story about the United States in the area. Chinese investors, whether they’re government agencies or corpora-tions, use economics as a justification for their foreign investment practices. Take a country like Uganda, where American relations are particularly limited because of the present state of corruption. The Chinese government is engaged in the construction of a toll high-way along one of the most popular routes, from the southeast half of the country to the airport—a route that will save commuters several hours of travel time and quite a bit of fuel money. Ugandan market-places are flooded with Chinese-made electronics, from solar panels to cell phones. This infusion of Chinese money doesn’t come in an aid bundle nor does it bring any goals of broad social change, but what it does do is provide previously unavailable services and even jobs. The United States is in a good position moving forward; our president is already a strong role model. We have the resources. And I would prompt policy-makers to go a step further in establishing these sorts of relationships now and say this: Don’t discriminate. It’s often the case that those countries without the good governance records and anti-corruption efforts of Tanzania or Ghana are those that are the most severely underdeveloped. The countries that were absent from the Obamas’ visit could use some alternatives to the current infrastructures for development, which, as the president has asserted, are less than effective and less than fair. The foundation of good gov-ernance is often a well-educated and vocal middle class, and growing economic opportunities could foster just that. Throwing money into a sinkhole accomplishes nothing, but there is gray area between ex-cluding a country from an aid and investment program and handing them a blank check. Aid is a powerful thing that deserves to be more than a publicity stunt, and I hope that President Obama’s interest in renewing relationships with the nations of Africa is one that doesn’t wane as he serves the last three years of his presidency.

Lydia Thurman is a Trinity junior. Her biweekly column will run every other Tuesday. Send Lydia a message on Twitter @ThurmanLydia.

AfricAid

LydiaThurmanthis one time in africa

Visit dukechronicle.com/section/opinion for more Opinion content.

The Chronicle www.dukechronicle.com TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 2013 | 11 10 | TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 2013 commentary The Chronicle The Chronicle commentary TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 2013 | 11

Letters PoLicyThe Chronicle welcomes submissions in the form of letters

to the editor or guest columns. Submissions must include the author’s name, signature, department or class, and for purposes of identification, phone number and local address. Letters should not exceed 325 words; contact the editorial department for information regarding guest columns.

The Chronicle will not publish anonymous or form letters or letters that are promotional in nature. The Chronicle reserves the right to edit letters and guest columns for length, clarity and style and the right to withhold letters based on the discretion of the editorial page editor.

Direct submissions to:

E-mail: [email protected]

Editorial Page DepartmentThe ChronicleBox 90858, Durham, NC 27708

Phone: (919) 684-2663Fax: (919) 684-4696

The C

hron

icle

Th

e i

nd

ep

en

de

nT

da

ily

aT

du

ke

un

ive

rs

iTy

”“ onlinecomment

I hope Alex pursues legal action. Hitting a kid in a wheelchair and his service puppy, and not even bothering to get out of the car, is absolutely vile.

—“twentyfourteen” commenting on the article “Student and dog struck by car on Anderson Street”See more at www.dukechronicle.com.

Inc. 1993Est. 1905 The ChronicleDanielle Muoio, Editor

Sophia DuranD, Managing EditorraiSa chowDhury, News Editor

Daniel carp, Sports EditorSophia palenberg, Photography Editor

Scott briggS, Editorial Page EditorcaSey williaMS, Editorial Board Chair

jiM poSen, Director of Online OperationsKelly Scurry, Managing editor for online

chriSSy becK, General Manager

eMMa baccellieri, University Editor carleigh StiehM, University Editor

elizabeth DjiniS, Local & National Editor georgia parKe, Local & National Editor

anthony hagouel, Health & Science Editor tony Shan, Health & Science Editor

julia May, News Photography Editor eric lin, Sports Photography Editor

KelSey hopKinS, Design Editor rita lo, Design Editor

lauren feilich, Recess Editor jaMie KeSSler, Recess Managing Editor

eliza bray, Recess Photography Editor thanh-ha nguyen, Online Photo Editor

MouSa alShanteer, Editorial Page Managing Editor Matt pun, Sports Managing Editor

aShley Mooney, Towerview Editor caitlin MoyleS, Towerview Editor

jennie Xu, Towerview Photography Editor Dillon patel, Towerview Creative Director

KriStie KiM, Social Media Editor julian Spector, Special Projects Editor

lauren carroll, Senior Editor chelSea pieroni, Multimedia Editor

anDrew luo, News Blog Editor glen rivKeeS, Director of Online Operations

Matt barnett, Multimedia Editor yeShwanth KanDiMalla, Recruitment Chair

rebecca DicKenSon, Advertising Director julia May, Recruitment Chair

Mary weaver, Operations Manager barbara StarbucK, Creative Director

Megan Mcginity, Digital Sales Manager

the chronicle is published by the Duke Student publishing company, inc., a non-profit corporation independent of Duke university. the opinions expressed in this newspaper are not necessarily those of Duke university, its students, faculty, staff, administration or trustees. unsigned editorials represent the majority view of the editorial board. columns, letters and cartoons represent the views of the authors.

to reach the editorial office at 301 flowers building, call 684-2663 or fax 684-4696. to reach the business office at 2022 campus Drive call 684-3811. to reach the advertising office at 2022 campus Drive call 684-3811

In 412 B.C., Diogenes of Sinope, the founder of the Greek Cynic movement, was asked where he came from. His response, “I am a citizen of

the world [kosmopolitês],” founded the ethical framework of cosmopolitanism. The central tenant of cosmopolitanism is that all humans belong to a culturally diverse world community that ascribes to a common set of moral, political and economic ideologies. Martha Nussbaum writes of the Greek Stoic conception of cosmopolitanism: “Each human being dwells in two communities—the local community of our birth, and the community of human argument and aspiration.” Cosmopolitanism has guided my own policy views, especially in regards to immigration. A policy is ethically justified if it correlates with the ideals of the world community—ideals that are decided through a democratic process with the world as the constituents. Human rights and justice come from humanity’s commitment to universal respect and hospitality, and that commitment is solidified through international laws.What do you think?

In 1795, Immanuel Kant outlined the first legal order for cosmopolitanism in an essay titled, “Perpetual Peace.” Kant argued that perpetual peace could be achieved if the world subscribed, with a league of nations as the enforcer, to a set of common principles and rules. The rules implored nations to abolish standing armies, end economic sanctions and avoid divisive methods in war—like assassinations, inhumane weapons, etc.—and required all states to have republican constitutions. Although Kant’s rules were never adopted, they did influence the founding principles of the League of Nations and eventually the United Nations. The United Nations is a good modern-day example of cosmopolitanism: Its resolutions and decrees aim to represent humanity’s universal ideals.

Some versions of cosmopolitanism encourage the establishment of a world state, but my take on cosmopolitanism does not go so far. The world order should be an institution powerful enough to enforce universal principles, but it should not be a despotic universal government. There must still be some state sovereignty within the system in order to check the authority of the world order. Embedded in this idea is support for immigration reform. I do not endorse open borders, but I do support lessening current worldwide restrictions on immigration. All states should evaluate immigration applications on the basis of need—not ethnicity, skill level or educational background. We should promote consistent immigration law across all states so as to better prevent instances of human trafficking and support claims for asylum. Some states might object to fewer restrictions—fearing a subsequent influx of immigration, so states should only be

obligated to accept immigrants until they reach ‘capacity,’ as defined by the world order. This capacity might be defined in terms of resources, like the availability of housing or employment.

Cosmopolitanism is appealing to deontologists because it is founded upon the idea that universal principles exist and should be enforced. For consequentialists, cosmopolitanism is appealing because it encourages individuals to follow rules that, more often than not, produce good outcomes. For environmental issues, cosmopolitanism would overcome previously plagued attempts to curb carbon emissions. Even as the United States attempts to curb its own burgeoning carbon emissions, developing nations have racked up their emissions in pursuit of growth. If the world subscribed to cosmopolitanism, there would be a mutual agreement to curb carbon emissions with universal participation. A world order could punish nations that deviated from the commitment. It could also ensure that no nation bears the brunt of energy reform and that the burden of cutting fossil fuels is spread equally.

Perhaps the biggest criticism of cosmopolitanism is that nationalism and patriotism are strong, valued and virtuous traits. Many individuals would refuse to join a cosmopolitan world fearing diminished sovereignty and the potential amalgamation of human culture. My brand of cosmopolitanism, however, does not call for subscription to a world culture. I, along with other philosophers, affirm quite the opposite: I ask the citizens of the world to recognize and affirm the differences between peoples while concurrently accepting a set of universal norms.

With the advent of technological connectivity, our perceived notions of nationalism have expanded. Our world was once defined by nation-states, but cross-cultural exchange has exposed us to different paradigms. Over time, different groups of people have come to realize that—while they may look, act and sound different—at their cores, they are all the same. All humans love, fear, fight, rejoice and dream. It has taken us a long time to realize it, but we already are citizens of the world. Clearly, Diogenes was ahead of his time.

Patrick Oathout is a Trinity senior. His column runs every other Tuesday. Send Patrick a message on Twitter @PatrickOathout.

Kosmopolites

PatrickOathoutrealpolitik with patrick

For the past nine months, DukeOpen, a student group, has petitioned senior administrators to increase the transparency of Duke’s endowment and promote socially responsible investment practices. Although we take issue with a few areas of DukeOpen’s platform, we commend the group’s overall goals and, in particular, its well-reasoned and moderate stance. In 2004, The University’s Guidelines on Socially Responsible Investing established the Advisory Committee on Investment Responsibility and gave the Board of Trustees the power to instruct DUMAC, the University’s endowment manager, to take appropriate action, such as divestment, if specific investments are deemed ethically questionable. The DukeOpen platform is threefold: to ensure regular meetings of ACIR, to establish a “social choice fund” that donors can opt into and, most importantly, to increase endowment transparency for the Duke community. The first point makes sense. In its almost decade-long existence, ACIR has convened only twice and is required to meet only on an ad hoc basis. Quarterly or annual meetings would allow ACIR to actively monitor the endowment’s portfolio and keep Board members up to date while minimizing administrative burden. The call for a “social choice fund”—a portion of the endowment contributions

marked for socially responsible investments—begs the question of the endowment’s primary purpose. According to the guidelines, the Board’s primary fiduciary responsibility in overseeing the University’s investments is to maximize returns subject to risk-exposure constraints. This is an incredibly important

responsibility, given that many of Duke’s most valuable features are funded by returns on the endowment. But these guidelines also rightfully acknowledge that the Board can and should take ethical considerations into account when approving investment choices. The existence of a social choice fund, especially if it is actively advertised to donors, would go a long way toward the goal of ethical investment. While DukeOpen’s research shows that socially responsible asset classes do not suffer from systematically lower returns, this subject should be studied further. We also want additional clarity as to which investments qualify as “socially responsible.” Transparency, however, is DukeOpen’s primary goal. The anatomy of the University’s investment portfolio is complex and strategically important, so disclosure of indirect

investments—such as those actively managed by hedge funds—is not feasible. Direct investments in companies are arguably less strategically sensitive. Dartmouth College offers a time-delayed, hard copy disclosure of its direct investments, and Duke should implement a similar practice. Although it is unclear that students have an intrinsic right to know how Duke’s money is invested, the University would be better off if students and faculty had limited access to this information. First, students and faculty collectively have more specialized expertise—and more time and energy to act on it—than ACIR or the Board. Second, more transparency can only serve to raise the standard of discourse in divestment debates. In the past, student-led divestment movements have relied on stylized facts about entire industries. With partial disclosure, more company-specific complaints could be raised. We see no reason why some incarnation of DukeOpen’s vision should not be implemented. Students should see endowment transparency as more than a campus issue: Soon enough, we may be donating to Duke, and we should lay the groundwork to responsibly support our University.

Board Chair Casey Williams recused himself because he is a member of DukeOpen.

students should consider Dukeopen’s aims

Editorial

“When did you change?!” My hometown friend almost shouted the question at me. She and I grew up in the same church back home.

We co-led our youth group and went on at least 6,000 retreats. She knows where I come from—geographically and personally, culturally and spiritually. If I’ve changed, she’d be the one to see it.

I looked in a mirror the next day and found myself staring at a stereotype: close-cropped hair, freshly shaven face, Duke-blue dress shirt and khaki Polo shorts. I was forced to confront a troubling question: What happened to all those baggy cargo shorts and wrinkled t-shirts that I carried into Randolph dorm two years ago? When did I start wearing dress shirts to class? Heavens to Betsy… have I turned preppy?

The night before, I had squeezed myself into the back row of an auditorium packed with alternatively eager- and desperate-looking upperclassmen. We were all there for a corporate recruiting presentation, and not just any corporate recruiting presentation: this was a “Big Three” strategy consulting firm. My attendance raised more questions: What do consultants actually do all day? Am I a sellout if I’m interested in consulting, even if I somewhat ironically became interested because of my DukeEngage project? How did my nature-loving, groupthink-defying, supposedly countercultural self end up in that auditorium?

The next day I went to my econ class taught by Michael Munger, the libertarian professor who preaches market economics like born-again Baptists preach Jesus’ salvation. I found myself listening attentively as he explained that profits come from voluntary exchanges that improve the welfare of both buyer and seller. So, profits are a good thing: Trade benefits both parties and naturally produces profits as a byproduct, even if they’re shared unevenly. My do-gooder, nonprofit-oriented self of two years ago would never have entertained the thought that profits could be good—after all, they all go to those evil corporations. (I don’t think I’m exaggerating here.)

After class, I asked Munger what he thinks about Walmart. He praised the mega-retailer for doing business more efficiently than small firms and, thus, allowing people, especially poor people, to get more things they want and need. (He did bring up the company’s undeniable imperfections, like the 1.5 million-woman class action lawsuit alleging systematic gender discrimination. And then there are the bribes paid to government officials by Wal-Mart de Mexico, which the New York Times called “an aggressive and creative corrupter.”) I felt perturbed that I couldn’t field a decent argument about the chain’s negative impacts. Am I drifting from my liberal roots? Will I someday join the endless stream of Blue Devils who earnestly call themselves “economically conservative but socially liberal” like they were all the first person to ever come up with such a novel

position?When we finished talking, I walked over to the

East Campus bus stop, from which I could see Randolph dorm and think back to freshman year. I entered Duke after a great relationship during my gap year. Earlier, my high school best friend and I dated for well over a year. At Duke, I’ve had one good but relatively short relationship. I consider myself a boyfriend type. I actually LIKE commitment. So why only one relationship in two

years? Maybe it’s because undergrads here go on dates about as often as our football team goes to bowl games. Or maybe it’s because I’ve become so wrapped up in my own grades and growth that I won’t make the time for a significant other. There isn’t room in my color-coded Google calendar for romance.

These tales of junior-year angst might sound like a superficial mid-college crisis. But I’m telling them to better articulate that nagging question: Have I changed?

I guess I have changed. But at the same time, I’m still my old self. I still laugh when my friends make bad puns, and I still love it when girls laugh at my bad puns. I still go to church every week, although it’s with Methodists rather than my childhood Episcopalians. I still value community service and helping people to help themselves. I still go camping whenever I can. I still have this curiosity about the people around me and the world around us. I still talk with my family all the time. I still prefer the hard copy of the newspaper to the web site, because I’m still an old fogey at heart. I still love Spanish and anything related to Latin America. I still think dachshunds are the most perfect dog breed God ever placed on this earth. So there are a lot of ways, big and small, that I’ve stayed the same.

And some of the ways I have changed are definite improvements; my time at Duke has deepened aspects of my identity that I most value. I’ve become a better listener, question-asker and writer. I’ve found service opportunities on campus, in Durham and in Latin America. I’ve studied the New Testament and spent a week at a desert monastery. I spent fully 10 percent of 2012 with PWILD, hiking and being outdoorsy. And last fall, I met a beautiful girl named Gracie.

So yes, I guess I have changed. And I might change some more. But maybe these changes aren’t so bad, if I stay committed to the things that matter most. Like Gracie—who, by the way, is a dachshund.

Andrew Kragie is a Trinity junior. His column runs every other Tuesday.

Have i changed?

Andrew Kragieelevator pitch

In Sub-Saharan Africa, Barack Obama is not much of a political figure. In fact, he’s much more than a political figure. To see a man with a Kenyan father hold one of the most powerful posi-

tions in the world is empowering, especially in a world where success traditionally belongs to white Westerners and, increasingly, to the businessmen and businesswomen of the East. Obama has become an icon for the continent; he’s a t-shirt slogan and is idolized by teenag-ers. When it comes to policies, however, citizens of African nations are either disappointed—as demonstrated by the protests in Johannes-burg this past summer—or ambivalent. Often people are tempted to

ask, “What policies?” What do you think? But with President Obama’s trip to Africa this past June and July, his administration seems to be making a concerted effort to change that. Speaking to a crowd in Johannesburg, Obama produced a plan to spend $7 billion on bring-ing clean energy to un-electrified areas in six countries hand-picked for their good governance: Ghana, Ethiopia, Kenya, Liberia, Nigeria and Tanzania. American companies like General Electric have com-mitted to contribute an additional $9 billion towards projects that, over the next five years, can provide hundreds of megawatts to these nations. There are many things to be said about international aid and investments, like this program, as well as many questions to be asked. The first and foremost might be: “Why?” Aid programs are a head-ache, and, time and time again, development projects have failed after external impetus for change didn’t encourage internal change. There is no moral obligation on the part of the United States to en-gage in each and every circumstance of inadequate welfare. But aid done right is mutually beneficial. There’s often a stigma against gain on the part of the donor in aid relationships, but if an aid program is capable of stimulating the recipient nation’s economy and providing the donor with enhanced diplomatic relations or economic benefits of their own, then that is a positive thing. This is not to say that donor nations should exploit the natural resources of developing countries, but, rather, that there is room for a non-exploitative behavior and domestic economic advantages. Aid programs encourage diplomacy, or at the very least dialogue, and in a continent like Africa, where the breadth of cultures and politics is enormous and unique, it would only serve the United States well to establish relationships with these countries. I think it’s incredibly valuable, then, that President Obama has asserted in the past few months that the nations of Africa are more than open hands to drop money into and, rather, partners that should be invested in. But in the time it took the United States to look to Africa as more than a “one and done” mission trip destination, other nations have come to the table with their own justifications for donation. Despite the United States explicitly holding its position as the world’s biggest donor, many other nations outshine the United States in terms of a relationship with the nations of sub-Saharan Af-rica. If you turn on the BBC, you’re far more likely to find a story analyzing the differences between Indian and Chinese investment in African nations than any story about the United States in the area. Chinese investors, whether they’re government agencies or corpora-tions, use economics as a justification for their foreign investment practices. Take a country like Uganda, where American relations are particularly limited because of the present state of corruption. The Chinese government is engaged in the construction of a toll high-way along one of the most popular routes, from the southeast half of the country to the airport—a route that will save commuters several hours of travel time and quite a bit of fuel money. Ugandan market-places are flooded with Chinese-made electronics, from solar panels to cell phones. This infusion of Chinese money doesn’t come in an aid bundle nor does it bring any goals of broad social change, but what it does do is provide previously unavailable services and even jobs. The United States is in a good position moving forward; our president is already a strong role model. We have the resources. And I would prompt policy-makers to go a step further in establishing these sorts of relationships now and say this: Don’t discriminate. It’s often the case that those countries without the good governance records and anti-corruption efforts of Tanzania or Ghana are those that are the most severely underdeveloped. The countries that were absent from the Obamas’ visit could use some alternatives to the current infrastructures for development, which, as the president has asserted, are less than effective and less than fair. The foundation of good gov-ernance is often a well-educated and vocal middle class, and growing economic opportunities could foster just that. Throwing money into a sinkhole accomplishes nothing, but there is gray area between ex-cluding a country from an aid and investment program and handing them a blank check. Aid is a powerful thing that deserves to be more than a publicity stunt, and I hope that President Obama’s interest in renewing relationships with the nations of Africa is one that doesn’t wane as he serves the last three years of his presidency.

Lydia Thurman is a Trinity junior. Her biweekly column will run every other Tuesday. Send Lydia a message on Twitter @ThurmanLydia.

AfricAid

LydiaThurmanthis one time in africa

Visit dukechronicle.com/section/opinion for more Opinion content.


This message is brought to you by the Department of Art, Art History and Visual Studies, Center for Documentary Studies, Chapel Music, Duke Dance Program, Duke Music Department,

Duke Performances, Nasher Museum of Art, Duke University Libraries, Screen/Society, Department of Theater Studies with support from the Office of the Vice Provost for the Arts.ami.duke.edu/screensociety/schedule

September 24 - 30ExhibitionsRecording the Anthropocene. Have we entered a new geologic epoch defined by the environmental impact of humanity? Thru October 13. Perkins Library Gallery. Free.

Doris Duke’s Shangri La: Architecture, Landscape and Islamic Art. An intimate look at Doris Duke and her Honolulu estate, featuring selections from her Islamic art collection. Thru December 29. Nasher Museum of Art.

Lines of Control: Partition as a Productive Space. An exhibition exploring the creation and maintenance of borders. Thru February 2. Nasher Museum of Art.

EventsSeptember 24Talk/Book Signing. One Place. Presentation by editor/MFA dir. Tom Rankin, and UNC folklorist/historian William Ferris. 12:30pm. Center for the Study of the American South, UNC-Chapel Hill. Free.

September 25Film. La Salsa Cubana (2013). Documentary about a dance group from the outskirts of Havana striving to win the Cuban national dance competition. Introduced by Prof. Andrea Woods Valdés. Presented by the NC Latin American Film Festival. 7pm. 240 John Hope Franklin Center. Free.

September 26Film. Reflections Unheard: Black Women in Civil Rights (2013). Documentary about the marginalization of black women in the Black Power and Feminist Movements. Discussion w/ dir./producer Nev Nnaji. 6pm. Smith Warehouse, FHI Garage. Free.

The Narrowing. A premiere of a new play conceived and directed by Ellen Hemphill of the Theater Studies faculty, written by Ellen Hemphill and Nor Hall with video design by Jim Haverkamp and music by Allison Leyton-Brown. 8pm. 539 Foster Street. Tickets: http://www.brownpapertickets.com/event/451163

September 27Fresh Docs. Screening of work-in-progress documentary film TBD. 7pm. Full Frame Theater, American Tobacco Campus. Free.

Panel Discussion. Islamic art, religion and history. Moderated by miriam cooke, Braxton Craven Professor of Arab Cultures at Duke, with panelists Glaire Anderson, associate professor of art history at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill; Imam Abdullah Antepli, Muslim chaplain at Duke; and Judith Ernst, artist and writer. Reception follows. 7pm. Nasher Museum of Art. Free.

The Narrowing. (See Sept. 26) 8pm.

September 28Chapel Choir Alumni Reunion Concert. In celebration of Homecoming Weekend, the Chapel Choir will perform Faure’s Requiem, and other favorite anthems. 8pm. Duke Chapel. Free.

The Narrowing. (See Sept. 26) 8pm.

September 29The Narrowing. (See Sept. 26) matinee 2pm.

Faculty Recital. Rebecca Troxler, flute; Barbara Krumdieck, cello; Elaine Funaro, harpsichord. Baroque works by Telemann, J.S. Bach, Rameau, and others. 3pm. Nelson Music Room, East Duke Bldg. Free.

Screen/SocietyAll events are free and open to the general public. Unless otherwise noted, screenings are at 7pm in the Griffith Film Theater, Bryan Center. (N) = Nasher Museum Auditorium. (FC) = Franklin Center, room 240. (W) = Richard White Auditorium. All events subject to change.

9/25 La Salsa Cubana (FC)NC Latin American Film Festival

9/30 Something in the Air (Après Mai)‎ [35mm]Tournées French Film Festival

Duke Theater Previews New Works Lab

presentsDuke Theater Previews New Works Lab presents

SEPTEMBER 27 & 28 AT 8 PMSHEAFER THEATER, BRYAN CENTER

Free admission

Let UsNow PraiseSusanSontagby Sibyl Kempsonwith composer Ashley Turba &choreographer David Neumann

SEPTEMBER 27 & 288 PM

SHEAFER THEATERBRYAN CENTERFree Admission

Documents

September 24, 2013