Upload
others
View
2
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP
CORPORATE SUSTAINABILITY INFORMATION AND
TRAINING IN EUROPE
SITUATION ANALYSIS ON CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY
(CSR) ACTIVITIES ON SMEs - 2011
Progress Report
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 2/133
Project information
Project acronym: CSI EU
Project title: Corporate Sustainability Information and Training in
Europe
Project number: 510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP
Sub-programme or KA: Leonardo Da Vinci
Project website: http://www.prepare.dk/CSIEU.html
Reporting period: From 01. 12. 2010
To 31. 03. 2011
Report version: 1
Date of preparation: 15. 04. 2011
Beneficiary organisation: University of Maribor
Project coordinator: Dr. Rebeka Kovačič Lukman
Project coordinator organisation: University of Maribor
Project coordinator telephone number: + 386 2 23 55 439
Project coordinator email address: [email protected]
This project has been funded with support from the European Commission. This publication [communication] reflects the views only of the authors, and the Commission cannot be held responsible for any use which may be made of the information contained therein.
© 2011 Copyright Education, Audiovisual & Culture Executive Agency.
The document may be freely copied and distributed provided that no modifications are made, that the source is
acknowledged and that this copyright notice is included.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 3/133
Table of Contents
Introduction
1 Overview of the CSR in CSI Consortium‟s partners countries .................................6
1.1. The social responsibility of organizations: recent trends ................................6
1.2. The social responsibility implemented by SMEs ............................................7
1.3. Focus of CSR activities ..............................................................................8
2. Country specific situation analysis of current CSR training offer ............................9
2.1. Existing training institutions on CSR in each country .....................................9
2.1.1. Universities.................................................................................9
2.1.2. VET institutions ......................................................................... 18
2.1.3. Others ..................................................................................... 27
2.2. Existing training materials on CSR in each country ..................................... 31
2.2.1. Contains and covered areas ........................................................ 32
2.2.2. Target groups of the training offer ............................................... 40
2.3. Existing other training tools on CSR in each country ................................... 42
2.3.1. Contains and covered areas ........................................................ 42
2.3.2. Target groups addressed by training offer .................................... 52
3. Country specific analysis of needs of competences on CSR from SMEs‟ and VET
institutions‟ perspective ..................................................................................... 54
3.1. SMEs‟ perspective in each country ............................................................ 54
3.1.1. Current practices for integrating CSR ........................................... 60
3.1.2. Needs of competences on CSR .................................................... 82
3.2. VET institutions perspective in each country .............................................. 93
3.2.1. Areas covered by current CSR training offer .................................. 94
3.2.2. Needs of competences on CSR .................................................. 107
4. Gap analysis on CSR training offer and identified needs on SMEs ...................... 111
5. Recommendations ...................................................................................... 115
References .................................................................................................... 118
Glossary of Abbreviations ................................................................................ 122
Annexes ........................................................................................................ 124
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 4/133
Authors:
AUSTRIA:
STENUM
Karin Tschiggerl
BULGARIA:
SERC
Dimitar Matev
LITHUANIA:
Institute of Environmental Engineering –
Kaunas University of Technology
Ginte Jonkute
Jurgis Staniskis
POLAND:
ATMOTERM
Thomas Schoenfelder
SLOVENIA:
University of Maribor
University of Maribor
Rebeka Kovacic Lukman
Bojana Ziberna
DENMARK:
Aalborg University
Danish Standards
Stig Hirsbak and Kirsten Schmidt
Kim Christiansen and Charlotte Trap-
Kinberg
SPAIN:
Prospektiker,S.A.
Prospektiker,S.A.
CIRCE
CIRCE
Ibon Zugasti
Oihana Hernaez
Miguel Fondevila
Juan Aranda
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 5/133
Introduction
This report includes the analysis carried out about the situation of training offer on
Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR), with a special focus on SMEs, by the 8 partners
included in this Consortium, in 7 different European countries: Austria, Bulgaria,
Denmark, Lithuania, Poland, Slovenia and Spain.
This analysis is the result of the 3rd work package coordinated by Prospketiker, one of the
two Spanish partners and it has been conceived under the “Corporate Sustainability
Information and Training in Europe” project, coordinated by the Slovenian partner,
University of Maribor, Department of Interdisciplinary Research. This project is being
supported by Leonardo da Vinci Program, under the Education and Culture DG of the
European Commission.
The aim of this state of the art analysis will be to identify the existing SME’s activities,
needs and perspectives, along with VET institutions and Universities’ training offer and
materials in the field of CSR. A special focus on ISO 26000 issue will be made during all
the analysis.
Therefore, this analysis has basically based on the following activities:
- Review of training materials and other sources which are relevant for CSR in each
partner country.
- Review of vocational training offers on CSR and what extent are the
environmental and social dimensions covered.
- Analysis of needs of competence on CSR from SME’s and VET institutions /
Universities’ perspective. To that aim, two different surveys have been elaborated
and sent to selected SMEs and VET institutions / Universities.
This situation analysis will be used to inform of the development of the project training
materials, ensuring high quality, relevance and appropriateness in order to make
recommendations for the future development of the CSR integrated electronic platform.
As part of this 3rd work package, the following deliverables will be released:
- Progress Report: Situation Analysis on Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)
activities on SMEs – 2011.
- 7 National Reports, one per country.
- 7 Executive Summaries Report, one per country.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 6/133
1. Overview of the CSR in CSI Consortium’s partners
countries
1.1. The social responsibility of organizations: recent trends
The European Commission's definition of CSR is: "A concept whereby companies
integrate social and environmental concerns in their business operations and in their
interaction with their stakeholders on a voluntary basis."
Corporate Social Responsibility is part of the Europe 2020 strategy for smart, sustainable
and inclusive growth, as it can help to shape the kind of competitiveness model that
Europe wants. In fact, in March 2010 the European Commission made a commitment to
“renew the EU strategy to promote Corporate Social Responsibility as a key element in
ensuring long term employee and consumer trust”.
However, the development and the implementation of CSR initiatives is quite different
depending on which country we focus on, and depending on the dimension of the
company or organization.
In this sense, and according to the different analysis carried out in each partners‟
country, it can be drawn how countries like Austria and Denmark, CSR has a longer path
comparing to countries like Slovenia, Lithuania or Poland, and therefore, companies and
specially the SMEs, are more used to implementing CSR initiatives within the company.
Although there are important differences among countries, we can summarize the
following trends:
Although the reason of being environmental and social responsible still
consists of generating wealth to its shareholders, by making profit out of its
business operations, there is a growing interest on CSR; capital market shows
remarkable interest on CSR issues. It shows a growing strategic social
interest, being the response to real necessity, and not only marketing trick
towards social involvement of business.
In the last years there has been a slight change in the way CSR is understood
by companies, shifting from a perspective of “well-being doers” to a broader
one based on the stakeholders‟ involvement and triple bottom line strategic
planning.
Social responsibility of business is not still well known both among consumers
and small business, in some countries.
In some cases, it still continues the perception of the companies that CSR is
rather to comply with the existing national and ratified international legislation
related to industrial relations, working conditions, social security, prohibition of
child labour and social labour, lack of gender, ethnic, religious discrimination,
security of jobs, etc.
Many companies see CSR as a one dimensional concept. The environment and
social areas have more weight than the economic aspects when it takes to
CSR reporting, reflecting the higher resistance present in many companies
regarding the implementation of CSR economic policies such as transparency,
good governance, corporate ethics, etc.
Transmitting and enforcing companies‟ CSR practice along their supply chain
still remains as an important challenge.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 7/133
On the other hand, all countries are supporting National Strategies for CSR, and it seems
clear that emerging new international tools of implementation strategies with social
responsibility focus will help its extension to more and more companies. In this sense,
global standardization reflected through ISO 26000 directive, can be an important driving
force.
ISO 26000 directive defines business responsibility as “accountability for impact of
business decisions and activities (products, services, processes) on community and its
environment", with respect to transparent and ethic attitude towards balanced
development and wellbeing of society, but also expectations of parties involved. Socially
responsible business complies both with existent law, as well as, international standards
of behaviour. It introduces a vivid distinction between concepts of “balanced
development” and “social responsibility”, considering balanced development as the
political and economical doctrine of civilization development, and balanced development
as social, environmental and business challenges in accord with each other. Thus, CSR
must not necessarily create costs; it can create an instrument of added value, while
supporting innovations and competition.
Main issues considered by ISO 26000:
- Good business practices
- Human rights respect
- Employment relations
- Natural environment protection
- Consumer relations
- Social engagement supporting local communities and solving their immediate
problems
To sum up, in all partner countries it has been identified the necessity to release CSR
from its niche existence and to establish as an essential part of a modern market
economy.
1.2. The social responsibility implemented by SMEs
Although the growing interest in CSR among SMEs, many analysis still confirm how big
companies are still the main developers of CSR strategies. SMEs are still the least active
enterprises‟ section under the CSR activities.
Identified main trends show the following ideas:
As SMEs‟ resources, know-how and their disposition to implement CSR processes
and initiatives is much lower than in the case of big companies.
SMEs tend to prioritize short term financial rather than long term social gains.
The marketing focus does not work with SMEs as much as with big companies.
Many SMEs are confused about what CSR really means.
SME are remarkably less efficient in showing their CSR activity then big ones, and
many interesting initiatives on their part are simply hard to identify. What is
more, SME often do not realize that their business approach and activities may be
classified as social responsibility.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 8/133
SMEs tend to have unwritten policies regarding mainly labour conditions, social
security and workplace safety, respect for the local environment and local
development, although they do not consider this kind activities as CSR strategies.
Many medium, and particularly, small and micro businesses have no strategic
plans of development, taking CSR decisions occasionally and ad hoc.
It seems the changes in consumer awareness and following buying decisions may
become decisive force in awakening of social responsibility among small and
medium enterprises.
There are important differences among SMEs from countries like Austria and
Denmark, where CSR activities carried out by SMEs is much higher than in other
countries, like for example, Lithuania, Bulgaria or Poland.
As well as this, in the case of SMEs, there is a lack of know-how and training materials to
support the systematic integration of social responsibility considerations in the
management process of SMEs. In general, there is a necessity for training for SMEs in
the concept of the corporate social responsibility including awareness raising, principles
and instruments of CSR, and specifically as for monitoring and control of the results from
the implementation of CSR.
1.3. Focus of CSR activities
Due to the limited activity and limited geographical area of influence of SMEs, the most
common SMEs‟ CSR activities will be related to local and environment development
(promoting and supporting local activities, initiatives or infrastructures), stakeholders‟
involvement and quality recognition. On the contrary, voluntary policies related to
transparency, accountability, participatory processes, etc., are seldom if not rare when
talking about SME, frequently owned by a family. In this sense, community related
activities like the sponsorships are some of the most usual, along with charity or
donations and participation on different campaigns.
Even if the focus of CSR activities could vary from one country to another, the following
CSR activities can be identified, as mainly focused by companies:
Sustainable economic performance and employment
Employee competence development; workforce and employee related activities
(welfare of the employees, opportunities for lifelong learning…)
Market related activities; customer care activities
Environmental sustainability and climate
Responsible supply chain management
Internal social programmes
However, those activities are less formal and are implemented more intuitive, avoiding to
standardize the CSR practice and to integrate it into various codes and management
systems.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 9/133
2. Country specific situation analysis of current CSR
training offer
In this second section, each country has carried out a situation analysis about the current
CSR training offers. It aims at identifying the references that will be useful for the
development of training material to be included into the future platform, in order to
ensure high quality, relevance and appropriateness.
Depending on the country, the situation can be very different as for training institutions,
contents and target groups addressed.
The following analysis shows the specific situation of current CSR training offer in each
partners‟ county.
2.1. Existing training institutions on CSR in each country
2.1.1. Universities
As for the analysis carried out within different countries, it can be concluded that
Universities‟ training offer includes CSR related contents. However, in the vast majority
of cases, this offer is related to modules or subjects integrated into other broader
modules. In this sense, we cannot talk about CSR degrees.
There are a great number of masters and programs specialized on CSR, and many
degrees include CSR subjects and lectures as part of their contents, as for instance,
“Business or Professional Ethics”. These CSR related courses are mainly societal or
environmentally oriented ones.
On the other hand there are some differences among countries; while in Bulgaria there
are very few universities with courses related to teaching corporate social responsibility,
in Spain the offer is wider.
As well as this, it can be drawn that in general, CSR related training is not specifically
focused on SMEs.
The following analysis includes the universities‟ training situation in each country:
AUSTRIA
The Austrian universities offer different training possibilities focussing on ethics. For
example, Vienna University of Economics and Business Administration arranges special
lectures on business ethics and CSR and University of Graz/Faculty of Theology offers a
master‟s course on Applied Ethics including one module on business and social ethics.
Currently, there are two comprehensive CSR training courses provided by universities,
further two trainings are planned by WU Executive Academy, “Professional MBA in Social
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 10/133
management” and a “University course ISMOS”, both are going to start in summer
2011.1
University of Applied Sciences at bfi Vienna
Continuous Education Training “Academic CSR Manager” at University of Applied Sciences
at bfi Vienna2
General Information
This continuous education training finishes with the title „Academic CSR Manager“, and is
organised in collaboration with respACT. The programme duration is 2 semesters extra
occupational including 350 lessons (60 ECTS).
Objectives
Managers, project managers, PR consultants, employees of ministries or authorities, CSR responsibles and consultants have in practice increasingly to deal with complex CSR issues and projects. Up to date, there are a few adequate and practical trainings on academic level. The focus and the objective of this training is an interactive development of problem solutions and improvements in the daily tasks of the participants. During the lessons, the adopted methods are tested and deepened. The graduates should obtain skills to launch CSR projects efficient and professional, to fulfil new requirements and to implement and optimise ongoing and planned CSR projects. This shall be done with actual methods, step-by-step tools and efficient communication tools.
Target group and admission
criteria
The training assesses to
Managers from private and public organisations
CSR responsibles
PR managers and consultants
Consultants
Project managers
Managers from NGOs
Admission criteria: academic degree or comparable professional experience
Curriculum
Overview of lessons incl. ECTS: Courses 1st semester ECTS
Methods and tools of CSR management – Introduction into the concept of social responsibility of organisations
2
CSR strategies – from SME strategies to concern strategies 6
CSR concepts – defining objectives, mission statements and organisational visions 2
Stakeholder communication – intercultural competence and communication 6
Business ethics, corporate governance, compliance and values 2
Marketing and presentation of European and international CSR projects 4
Ethics and idea of man – human rights and anti-discrimination in CSR projects 2
Pestl analysis and project start in CSR projects – problems matrix and stakeholder map 6
30
Courses 2nd semester ECTS
The social dimension – 12 CSR activity fields concerning employees 2
Investment and CSR – CSR cost planning and regulatory framework 2
Introduction into scientific working 1
Examples of good practice, best practice and worst practice in European and international project management
4
Codes, standards and quality assurance in CSR management – Overview with focus on Austrian, European and international standards
4
Introduction to European and international CSR business plans 2
Assessment tools and goal systems for CSR – Measuring CSR performance, KPIs and indices 4
Job description CSR manager – practical experiences 1
Diversity management and human resources 2
Attended elaboration of a final project thesis/presentation and exam 8
1 CSR Annual 2011, p. 150 2 http://www.fh-wien.ac.at
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 11/133
30
Danube Business School at Danube University Krems
Certified programme “Corporate Responsibility and Business Ethics”3
General Information and objectives
Although this programme mainly focuses on issues on the company level, also topic of
general economic ethics as well as on managers‟ individual level are part of the program.
All relevant new approaches to corporate responsibility and business ethics are included
in the three levels of economy: macro, meso, and micro level.
The first three modules of the program take a close look at these three levels of Business
Ethics: Economic Ethics, Corporate Responsibility & Ethics and Management Ethics. For
the fourth module students may choose one module of another program of Danube
University Krems that deals with related topics, thus allowing students to strengthen
their individual skills or to become an expert in their favourite field.
Participants will be provided with a strong theoretical and analytical background and the
possibility to demonstrate the developed skills in specific case studies. Furthermore, a
study trip will enable the students to access and practice business ethics and corporate
responsibility.
Contents
Specialised Modules Content
Module 1: Economic Ethics
This module deals with the interrelations between ethics and economics on a systems level. Basic ethics knowledge is combined with business administration and economics to give participants an overview on modern economic ethics approaches. While historical developments are described where necessary, and a strong theoretical background is provided, a major
focus lies in recent case studies of ethical dilemma situations in business and the economy. Ethical decision models, ethical company structures and cultures, and organizational questions of ethics are presented. After finishing this part of the course, participants are able to discuss economic ethical problems on a high theoretical level and know how to combine ethical considerations with actual business problems, especially when strategic CSR measures and organizational change is concerned.
Module 2: Corporate Responsibility & Ethics
This module deals with the eco-responsibility of businesses. The theoretical background of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) is highlighted from different standpoints of responsibility, and an instrument for measuring CSR based on the approach of Alternative Nobel Prize winner Alice Tepper Marlin is shown in practice. Furthermore, different approaches to evaluate businesses while setting up CSR will be discussed. Companies need to be transparent on their values and strategic goals and take responsibility for their environmental and social impacts, especially when being listed as ethical investments. Participants learn how companies manage repsonsibility in their supply chain, how they monitor the related performance and what makes their sustainability reporting trustful and successful. A broad view to CSR in Europe and a specific method to install CSR in small-and-medium sized enterprises will close the module. Both, the instrument and the method will encourage the participants, based on a theoretical framework, to enrich their business life with CSR.
Module 3: Management This module concerns the individual level of managerial decision making. It
3http://www.donau-uni.ac.at/de/studium/businessethicsmba/index.php
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 12/133
Ethics centres on the stakeholder approach to management and teaches methods to operationalize stakeholder management. Communicative strategies regarding the building of reputation in our media society make up a second important focus. Different leadership models and their implications for ethical management are presented and case studies and scenarios of ethical dilemma situations help participants train their ethical personality and decision style. The special case of human capital management is presented as possible
application field. After going through this part of the course, participants have a subtle understanding of their role as responsible managers in a “stakeholder society”. They can develop stakeholder strategies and communication policies with special regard to company reputation.
Module 4: Compulsory Subject Choice
In consultation with the program coordinator you may choose one module of the following programs of Danube University Krems (vacancies provided):
Intercultural Competencies
International Relations
Migration Management
Human Rights
Target group This program targets any business professionals who deal with ethical situations and/or moral decision making: Chief executives, CSR managers, compliance managers and community affairs managers, managers who want to understand how organisations can put ethical commitments into practice as well as consultants and accountants who want to develop their competence in business ethics and corporate responsibility.
BULGARIA
Although the conclusion in the UNDP international baseline survey is that “Academia has
played a significant role in the development in CSR in all the countries surveyed, more so
than in Western Europe” in Bulgaria there are very few universities with courses related
to teaching corporate social responsibility”. In the survey the following universities and
courses are quoted:
o The National and World Economy University – courses on business ethics
o Bulgarian Academy of Sciences: Institute of Economics,
o New Bulgarian University: Course: Business ethic and corporate social
responsibility
o American University in Bulgaria: Business Administration: Course: Business Ethics
In Table1 are the results of the desk-top research regarding courses on social
responsibility in the Bulgarian universities:
Table 1
University Courses
Sofia University “St. Kliment Ohridski” 4 Masters programme “Management of
Human Resources and Corporate Social
Responsibility (Sorbonne/English)”,
module 6 “The social responsibility of
the company and the sustainable
development”, courses “Stakeholders
management”, “Business ethics”,
4 www.uni-sofia.bg
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 13/133
“Socially responsible investment”
New Bulgarian University5 Masters programme “Financial Auditing
programme”, course “Social Auditing”;
Business ethics and corporate social
responsibility”
University of Architecture, Civil
Engineering and Geodesy6
Specialty “Road construction”, course
“Business ethics”
Academy of Economics “D.A.Tsenov” 7 Speciality "Environmental
management", courses “Environmental
policy and social responsibility”,
“Globalisation and sustainable
development”, “Environmental ethics”
VUZF University (Higher School for
Insurance and Finance) 8
BA (HONS) in Business studies
(Accounting & Finance), course
“Corporative Social Responsibility and
Ethics”
Varna Free University9 Speciality “Business administration –
tourism management”, course “Social
responsibility and business ethics”
The conclusion which can be drawn from the above table is that there are courses on
ethics – business and environmental - included in some Bachelor or Masters programmes
with the aim the future specialists in road construction, environmental management,
accounting and finance, business administration as well some courses explaining some
aspects of CSR such as social auditing, sustainable development, etc. The only
comprehensive programme with a target group specialists in human resource
development is the Masters programme in the Sofia University “St. Kliment Ohridski”.
DENMARK
Several universities, university colleges and institutions for vocational training have CSR
related courses, seminars etc. The courses range from general introduction to advanced
learning on a masters level. Below are given some examples.
University of Copenhagen:
International Labour Law and Corporate Social Responsibility10
Corporate Social Responsibility11
CBS (Copenhagen Business School)12:
5 www.nbu.bg
6 www.uacg.bg
7 www.uni-svishtov.bg
8 www.vuzf.bg
9 www.vfu.bg
10 http://jura.ku.dk/students/courses/master/int_labour_law_corp_soc_responb/
11 http://sis.ku.dk/kurser/viskursus.aspx?knr=137375&sprog=1&forrige=609
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 14/133
Courses in strategic CSR
CSR and Climate-strategy, innovation and communication
Strategic Corporate Social Responsibility for managers
Summer school course on CSR "CSR and Climate: Strategy, Innovation and
Communication" targeted at managers and employees in Danish companies,
public institutions and non-profits. It does not require specific knowledge of CSR.
Aarhus University, Business and Social Sciences13
Sustainability reporting (incl. ISO 26 000)
University of Southern Denmark, Faculty of Engineering14
Course in Strategic Global Sourcing (MSc Product Development and Innovation)
The course is about both the strategic and the tactical aspects of global sourcing.
University of Southern Denmark, Master's degree programme in Business Economics and
Auditing15
Corporate Social Responsibility – CSR and Sustainability
Aalborg University16
Master program on Environmental management and sustainability sciences
Technical University of Denmark, Department of Management17
Part of master program: Course on Global Product Chains and Sustainable
Development
Roskilde University18
Business Ethics and CSR
Silkeborg Business School (not a university, but offers vocational training):
Diploma course on managing Human resources, incl. from a CSR perspective
LITHUANIA
During the research of Lithuanian high school education (degree) programmes, it was
ascertained that the individual CSR or CSR training modules discipline, integrated into
other modules, are taught at the main universities in Lithuania - Kaunas University of
Technology (KTU), Vilnius University (VU), Vytautas Magnus University (VDU), Vilnius
Gediminas Technical University (VGTU), University of Management and Economics (ISM),
12
www.cbs.dk 13
www.au.dk 14
http://www.sdu.dk/Uddannelse/Kandidat/Product_Development_Innovation/Uddannelsens_opbygning/GlobalSourcing 15
www.sdu.dk 16
http://www.pgsn.aau.dk/planogmiljo/em7/?nt=26 17
http://www.man.dtu.dk/English/Education/Courses_at_IPL.aspx?coursecode=42644 18
http://www.ruc.dk/uddannelse/fag/virksomhedsstudier/om-faget/kursuskatalog/
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 15/133
Klaipeda University (KU), Mykolas Romeris University (MRU) and others, mostly in
master„s studies programs 19
These CSR-themed subjects, which are taught at the universities, are called as "Business
Ethics" or "Professional Ethics". However, not all educational institutions give the same
meaning on these subjects. Sometimes the topic of the subject is replaced by the
content, which the lecturers from local universities and colleges of specific faculties are
able to teach. Therefore, instead of CSR, Etiquette, "Corporate Culture", "Professional
Psychology," "Psychology of the Organization", "General Philosophical Questions of
Ethics" and similar courses are taught.
Students can gain knowledge of CSR studying subjects in which this discipline is included
as a "Quality Management", or within environmental education modules, "Environmental
Management" subjects. In some cases, CSR topics are included formally in the study
modules of economics.
However, the disciplines related to CSR are often not mandatory subject of study area or
they are treated just as a currently fashionable subject. University students can get the
greater amount of experience and knowledge by participating in international projects.
POLAND
Postgraduate studies:
SGH (General Trade School) Warsaw - Teoria i Praktyka Społecznej
Odpowiedzialności Przedsiębiorstwa; Zarządzanie Reputacją Firmy [Theory and
Practice in Social Responsibility for Business]; Zarządzanie Reputacją Firmy [The Management of Reputation in Businenss]
20
Leon Kozminski Academy in Warsaw in cooperation with
PricewaterhouseCoopers - CSR. Strategia odpowiedzialnego biznesu [Strategy in Business Responsibility]
21
Wyższa Szkoła Europejska im. Ks. Józefa Tischnera w Krakowie [Tischner
European College in Kacow] – Społeczna odpowiedzialność biznesu (studia
dofinansowane z UE) [Social Responsibility of Business (UE sponsored studies)]
22
Uniwersytet Warszawski Wydział Zarządzania - Zarządzanie Zaoczne
Odpowiedzialność Społeczna Biznesu [Warsaw University, Management Department - Remote Management Social Responsibility of Business]
23
SGGW (Szkoła Główna Gospodarstwa Wiejskiego) w Warszawie - „CSR –
strategia społecznej odpowiedzialności biznesu” [General Farming School in Warsaw - 'CSR – The Strategy of Social Responsibility of Business]
24
WSP TWP (Wyższa Szkoła Pedagogiczna TWP) w Warszawie - Społecznie
odpowiedzialny biznes [Pedagogy High School in Warsaw – Socially responsible Business]
25
19
Institutions of Higher Education, Colleges and secondary schools in Lithuania, available at: http://www.on.lt/hedu3.htm
20 http://www.sgh.waw.pl/ksztalcenie/podyplomowe/spis/teorii_i_praktyki_spolecznej_odpowiedzialnosci_przedsiebiorstwa/
21 http://www.studiapodyplomowe.kozminski.edu.pl/index.php/pl/specjalistyczne/csr_strategia_odpowiedzialnego_/
22 http://www.wse.krakow.pl/pl/Lider_nowej_gospodarki/artykuly/art,227,spoleczna_odpowiedzialnosc_biznesu.html
23 http://www.wz.uw.edu.pl/studia,opis,60,podyplomowe,zarzadzanie-zaoczne-odpowiedzialnosc-spoleczna-biznesu.html
24 http://www.spcsr.sggw.pl/?file=ogolne.php
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 16/133
Uniwersytet Ekonomiczny we Wrocławiu [Wroclaw School of Economics] - „Manager CSR”
26
Collegium Civitas w Warszawie - Zarządzanie przyszłością [Warsaw Civitas
College – Management of the Future]: Foresight i planowanie strategiczne [Foresight and strategic planning]
27
Olsztyńska Wyższa Szkoła Informatyki i Zarządzania - Menadżer Jakości
Zintegrowanych Systemów Zarządzania Jakością [Olsztyn Higher IT Colledge –
Manager of Integrated IT Quality Systems] 28
SLOVENIA
All 4 Slovenian universities were analyzed:
1) University of Maribor (UM)
At the UM we have found out that 8 of 16 faculties are offering CSR related courses
within 15 study programmes (only 1st Bologna programmes have been analyzed). Within
these 15 programmes 44 courses have been found, which can be denoted as
sustainability oriented. 10 of them were more social oriented, such as Management of
human resources, socio-economic changes and changes in values. 33 of them were
environmentally oriented, such as Environmental Chemistry, Biodiversity, Sustainable
energy usage, renewable resources, etc. Only 1 course has been economy oriented,
which is Environmental economics. Most of the courses are not obligatory one, but can
be chosen as additional courses.
2) University of Ljubljana (UL)
At the UL we found out that 8 faculties are having 34 sustainability oriented courses
within their programmes. Most of the courses are environmentally oriented (28), such as
Introduction to the ecology, sustainable agriculture, environmental monitoring, energy
and environment, etc. 5 of the courses are more societal oriented, such as: social
movements and global inequality, human resources in transport, management of human
resources, biological security and ethics, and societal work with families. Only 1 course
has been economically oriented: Environmental management.
3) University of Primorska (UP)
At the UP 14 study programmes have 44 SR oriented courses. Most of them are
environmentally oriented (30), such as environmental monitoring, sustainable tourism,
ecology of the Mediterranean ecosystems, management of the protected areas, water
protection, etc. 14 of the courses are societal oriented, such as human resources in
tourism, management of human resources, psychological issues by human resources,
ethic and society of knowledge, etc.
4) University of Nova Gorica (NG)
25
http://wsptwp.eu/n/warszawa/dla_kandydatow/spolecznie_odpowiedzialny_biznes 26
http://www.bsdesign.nazwa.pl/Binsztok/index.php?id=7 27
http://studia.biz.pl/137/collegium-civitas-w-warszawie/zarzadzanie-innowacjami/10610/ 28
http://www.owsiiz.home.pl/index.php5?page=97
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 17/133
3 study programmes are offering SR oriented courses: Environmental Sciences,
Economical Engineering, and Viniculture. Within these 3 programmes, 27 courses are
offered. 21 of them are environmentally oriented, such as environmental engineering,
environmental impacts, environmental chemistry, waste management, etc. 4 are more
societal oriented: society and environment, health ecology, management of human
resources and quality management. 2 of them are more economy oriented:
environmental management and economy of the environment.
SPAIN
Currently Spanish Universities (both private and public ones) have no any specific degree
of Corporate Responsibility. According to a report elaborated by the Spanish Ministry of
Employment and Immigration “An approach to the state of CSR in education in Spain
2010”29, there are just five universities (two public and three private) that have
introduced a compulsory subject of corporate responsibility in their curriculum. Other
concepts such as sustainability have also been included in different courses, mandatory
courses and other areas that are confined within the broad spectrum that includes
corporate responsibility, such as ethics, the environment and the treatment of equality
and diversity. Degrees that include CSR topics are mainly Business Administration,
Human Resources and Social Work.
Masters and Business Schools:
The specific postgraduate courses in corporate responsibility have proliferated in recent
years due to an increase of the demand and due to the rigidity of the university system
that makes it difficult to meet this demand. However, the CSR impact remains limited in
the case of other nonspecific masters, especially in MBA and financial graduates.
CSR non specific masters that include contents related to CSR (%):
According to the previous report, 17 Spanish universities or business schools have
established specific graduates on corporate responsibility. Some of the most relevant…:
29
Una aproximación al estado de la RSE en la enseñanza en España. Ministerio de Trabajo e Inmigración, Club de
Excelencia en Sostenibilidad, 2010.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 18/133
Centre Master/Course/Degree Training form
National University of Distant
Education (UNED) Sostenibilidad y Responsabilidad Social Corporativa Official Master
University of Vigo Administración integrada de empresas: responsabilidad social
corporativa, calidad y medio Official master
University of Castellon, Jaume I Máster en Sostenibilidad y Responsabilidad Social Corporativa Distance Official master
(1 year)
University of Castilla La Mancha I Edición del Curso de Experto en Dirección, Organización y RSE
para pymes y entidades de economía social
Course
(180 hs)
University of La Rioja
Sistemas Integrados de Gestión de la Calidad, Medio Ambiente,
Responsabilidad Social Corporativa y Prevención de Riesgos
Laborales
Online Master
University of Alcalá de Henares Responsabilidad Social Empresarial (Part Time) Master
University of Barcelona Máster en Responsabilidad Social Corporativa. Contabilidad y
Auditoría Social Master
Technical University of Valencia University Specialist on Corporate Social Responsibility Master
(580 hs)
ESERP Business School Corporate Social Responsibility in Organizations Online Master (9
months)
European School of Management
and Business (EUDE)
Master en Gestión Sostenible: Medioambiente,
Responsabilidad Social Corporativa y Agenda 21
Master (distance)
(1.340hs)
European School of Management
and Business (EUDE)
Corporate Social Responsibility and Communication Process in the
Enterprise Online Course (225 hs)
Industrial Organization School
(EOI)
International Master in Sustainable Development and Corporate
Responsibility International Master
Industrial Organization School
(EOI) MBA Corporate Responsibility Course
Industrial Organization School
(EOI)
Master Executive en Desarrollo Sostenible y Responsabilidad
Corporativa Online Master Executive
2.1.2. VET institutions
The analysis of CSR offered by VET institutions is quite different depending on the
analyzed European Countries.
In East European countries like Bulgaria and Lithuania the offer is quite limited; in fact,
CSR is not offered on the level of vocational schools in Poland.
However, in countries like Slovenia, Austria or Spain, the available offer is much wider.
AUSTRIA
Quality Austria
Quality Austria30 offers a training series “Corporate Social Responsibility and
Sustainability Management” and additionally three seminaries (one general and two
specific seminaries) and a refreshing seminar.
Training Series “Corporate Social Responsibility and Sustainability Management”
30 http://www.qualityaustria.com
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 19/133
The structure of the training series looks as follows:
Corporate Social Responsibility and Sustainability Management Part 1 and 2
The duration of the training is 3 days (Part 1) and 2 days (Part 2), whereby the
participant has to do a project thesis between the two parts.
Contents
Basics of CSR and Sustainability
Tripple-Bottom-Line
Generation of a sustainability report
Integration into existing management systems
Standards and codes
Measurability of CSR systems
Project thesis: after finishing part 1, this thesis includes relevant parts of a sustainability
report and is requirement for part 2 and the exam
Target group and admission criteria
Quality, environmental and safety managers
Food safety managers
CSR officers, CSR coordinators
Authors of sustainability reports
Employees, teams who are responsible for sustainability related activities
CRSP – Exam CSR and Sustainability Manager/Assessor
The contents of the exam are related to the contents of the trainings part 1 and part 2.
The exam requires the trainings and the project thesis and includes a written and a
verbal part where the thesis is presented by the participant.
Certification
After passing the exam the certificate “CSR and Sustainability Manager” will be awarded,
upon request the EOQ Certificate “CSR and Sustainability Manager”. Participants that do
not have a Quality Austria training for Quality, Environmental or Safety Manager are
certified as “CSR and Sustainability Assessor”. The certificate is valid for three years,
after that a refreshing seminar and a proof of implementing a sustainability report and/or
CSR projects has to be done for a re-certification.
Seminar “CSR-S: Applying CSR practical and sustainable”
The seminar deals with the basics of CSR.
Contents
Definition of CSR and Sustainability
Tripple-Bottom-Line
Standards and codes
CSR Part 1
Project
thesis
CSR Part 2
CRSP
Certificate CSR & Sustainability Manager/Assessor optionally: EOQ Certificate
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 20/133
Pestl analysis
Integration of CSR into existing structures
Main features of sustainability reports
Communicating sustainability
Target
group
Managing directors, assistant managers, SCM coordinators,
quality/environmental/safety managers, PR managers and other interested in CSR
Seminar “CSR-PD: Sustainable Products and Services”
This seminar presents social and ecological mega trends and shows existing innovations
in different industries. The competencies are completed with sustainability assessments
of products and services, Ecodesign and strategic integration of these issues.
Contents
Sources of ideas for sustainable products and services (SPS)
Market analysis: target groups for SPS
Ecological and social ration of products/services
Ecodesign
Strategic monitoring of SPS
Target group
Managing directors
Quality/environmental managers
Product manager/developer
CSR manager, CSR assessors, CSR coordinators
Marketing officers
Seminar “SA 8000 - Social Accountability – Contents and Certification CSR-SA”
SA 8000 is a comprehensive international standard for the independent auditing and
certifying of these requirements.
Contents
SA 8000 – Origin and development
Contents of SA 8000
Explanation of specifications
Integrating SA 8000 into existing management systems
Auditing and certification of SA 8000
Networking
Target group
CSR officers
Quality managers
Human resource managers
Purchasers and supply chain managers
Other interested in sustainability
Refreshing Seminar “RCSR – Refreshing for Corporate Social Responsibility and
Sustainability Managers and Assessors”
The focus of this seminar is on the exchange of information and experiences between
CSR Managers and other interested CSR professionals, themed “from professionals for
professionals”. Admission criteria for this training are an education as CSR Manager or
Assessor or concrete experiences in applying CSR.
Contents Actual CSR relevant issues
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 21/133
ISO 26000
Integration of CSR into existent management systems
Target group
CSR Managers, CSR Assessors
CSR Consultants, CSR Officers
Experts in the field of CSR
Plenum Akademie
Plenum is a consulting and research company with an academy31 where three trainings
are offered in cooperation with respACT. The contents are based on a holistic approach of
sustainability and CSR.
Integrated CSR management
Contents
Module 1 “Leading companies valuable”: Business ethics, implementation of
sustainability and CSR, sustainability tools, development of organisational values and culture
Module 2 “Involving human and society”: Personnel policy based on sustainability,
knowing internal social work, developing methods and projects for personnel development, global Human rights
Module 3 “Developing sustainable innovations”: Sustainable product development and
innovation management, increasing resource efficiency for products and processes, sustainable lifestyles as a field for innovation, from product to systems innovation
Module 4 “Developing communication and networking spaces: Stakeholder
management, CSR from civil society‟s viewpoint, sustainability reports according to GRI, networking in the field of CSR and sustainability
Module 5 “Setting new purposes”: Design of CSR projects and sustainable products and
services; presentation of individual projects and certification; networking with alumnis
Target group
Persons, that have influence on the strategic management or are responsible for
organisational, human resource or product development, knowledge management or investor relations. Through its holistic conceptualisation the training is adapted to executives and employees from SMEs.
Pioneers of Change
This one-year training attends participants in developing their own project or
organisation with seminars, support days and coaching. The aim is to implement
initiatives in ecological and social fields, like local agenda projects, organic agriculture or
cultural campaigns, etc.
Contents
Module “My vision for the world”: Status quo of the world and identifying causes of
problems, reflecting ethics and idea of man, positive trends and sustainable alternatives, social entrepreneurship, living visions, appreciating communication
Module “Creative project design”: presenting and communicating projects, target
setting, project planning, generating sustainable innovations
Module “Business plan, financing and fundraising”: Dreaming the own projects,
developing a business model, developing aspects of financing and fundraising, reflecting the global finance system
Module “Public relations and marketing”: Designing corporate identity, developing public
relations and marketing, reflecting media power, applying new media
Module “Effective communication”: Communication and conflict culture, non-violent
communication, coaching/moderation/teambuilding
Module “Reflective and contemplative hike”: Life balance, contemplation, creating power
Module “Networks and co-operations”: Living Art of Hosting and generating networks,
identifying open source possibilities, individual contents
Module “Conclusion and restart”: Individual contents
Target group Persons, who want to implement a project or build up an organisation in ecological and
31 http://www.plenum.at
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 22/133
social fields.
Sustainable Leadership
Contents
Module 1 “Leading in times of sustainability”: Sustainable leadership and management
Module 2 “Consistent talking and acting”: Sustainable communication and attentive
negotiation
Module 3 “Leading with title and cordiality”: Leadership and stakeholder management
Module 4 “Moving the world together”: Team development and holistic synergies
Module 5 “Departure to new ages”: Being leader of the whole thing”
Target group
Persons who want to lead an organisation, initiative or groups forward-looking and
holistic
Persons in executive positions
Potential managers
Persons who want to expand their leadership competences regarding sustainability
Sustainability and CSR officers who want to improve their leadership skills
Students of all fields and Sustainable-Entrepreneurs and -Intrapreneurs
Incite
Incite32 offers one training in collaboration with the Austrian Federal Economic Chamber
and respACT, that aimed at responsibility in industry and economy. Contents are actual
documents, like ISO 26000, ÖNorm 2502:2009, respACT‟s guiding vision (“Erfolg mit
Verantwortung: ein Leitbild für zukunftsfähiges Wirtschaften“, see 2.2 Existing training
materials on CSR) and results from ongoing standardisation activities and international
trends.
Contents
Module A: Ethics, values, CSR, sustainability and professionalism in consulting; basics of
a CSR consulting process according to ÖNORM S 2502:2009
Module B: Basics of process design based on CSR of the second generation, according
to actual standardisation documents; central elements for the design of a “humane management system”
Module C: Sustainability reporting – basics, key figures (according to GRI) for SMEs,
structure, design
Target group Consulting experts and responsible persons for CSR from industry, economy,
consultancy that want to implement CSR in their professional activities.
TÜV Süd Österreich
TÜV Süd Österreich33 offers three trainings with different levels of intensity in the field of
CSR.
CSR 1 – Corporate Social Responsibility – A “nice to have” or more?
This one-day training offers a rapid introduction into the issue and gives a compact
overview of CSR.
Contents
Definitions and basics of CSR and sustainability
Terms, methods and tools of CSR management
ISO 26000 and ÖNORM S2502 and their practical implementation
Stakeholder relations and communication
Target group Managing directors
Entrepreneurs
32 http://www.incite.at/ausbildung/de/lehrgaenge/lehrgang-csr 33 http://tuev-sued.at/akademie
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 23/133
Management boards
Executives
CSR officers
CSR coordinators
PR managers
Consultants
CSR 2 – Corporate Social Responsibility – Steps for implementing CSR – Walk the talk
This 2-days seminar for the middle management gives an overview of the CSR concept,
the responsibility of organisations, challenges and a comparison of standards.
Contents
Definitions and basics of CSR and sustainability
Terms, methods and tools of CSR management
ISO 26000 and ÖNORM S2502 and their practical implementation
Stakeholder relations and communication
CSR concepts, defining objectives, mission statements and organisational visions
Triple bottom line approach
Basics for implementing and launching CSR projects
Planning and evaluating CSR measures
Financial aspects, problems and solutions in CSR projects in theory and p
Target group
Managing directors
Entrepreneurs
Management boards
Executives
CSR officers
CSR coordinators
PR managers
Consultants
CSR 5 – Corporate Social Responsibility – Projects
The 5-days training is targeted to project managers. After introductions and basics,
analyses of examples, planning and evaluation of CSR measures, the own CSR project
will be developed.
Contents
Definitions and basics of CSR and sustainability
Terms, methods and tools of CSR management
CSR concepts, defining objectives, mission statements and organisational visions
Triple bottom line approach
Investment and CSR, Planning and evaluating CSR measures
Financial aspects, problems and solutions in CSR projects in theory and practice
Project plans, organisation and controlling in CSR projects
Pestl analysis and project start in CSR projects (problems matrix, stakeholder map,
etc.)
Implementation of CSR projects
Target group
Managing directors
Entrepreneurs
Management boards
Executives
CSR officers
CSR coordinators
PR managers
Consultants
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 25/133
ARGE Bildungsmanagement
Diploma course Sustainability & Innovation
This diploma course SustaIN34 connects Sustainable Development and innovation. The
aim is to procure key competences for the design of sustainable innovation processes.
Participants will be able to implement Sustainable Development, CSR and innovation
processes in companies and organisations.
Contents
Training Sustainability & Innovation (3 semestres/20 ECTS), “Graduate Innovation manager”
Basics on Sustainability and innovation
Theory of Sustainable Development
Innovation theory and “innovation stories”
Basics on systemic thinking and acting
Design of social processes
Project management: methods and tools
Design for Sustainability
Sustainable Consumption and Production
Change management, assessment and monitoring systems
Sustainable innovations in public management
Implementation of strategies, visions and future scenarios
Business plan, programmes and sponsorships
Sustainability marketing
Upgrade Master programme (1 semestre/20 ECTS), “ MBA (Project management)”
Proseminar 1 “Socio-scientific methods”
Proseminar 2 “Scientific technics/Writing skills
Master programme Part 1: “Subject identification and guidelines for the master thesis”
Master programme Part 2: “Graduand group, working on the master thesis”
Master thesis and master exam
Target group
Executives from companies, NGOs and administrations
Future executive managers
Internal/external consultants
Project leaders
in the fields of marketing, strategy development and strategic market research, product and life cycle management, network and cluster management, R&D, programme management, public management
BULGARIA
The National Agency for Vocational Education and Training (NAVET) has licensed 800 VET
centres and has developed approximately 100 state vocational education standards.
There is no standard developed for an occupation related to human resources
management, business ethics, environmental management or sustainable development
and respectively no VET centre provides training in corporate social responsibility
whatsoever.
It is difficult to identify a VET centre which provides training including subject related to
corporate social responsibility because NAVET lists on its web-site only the title of the
occupations for which the respective training centre is licensed but not the training
34 http://www.bildungsmanagement.at/index_sustainability.shtml
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 26/133
programmes. This was explained with the reluctance of the very training centres to
publicise the training programmes.
DENMARK
Several large and small Danish consultancies are working within the CSR field as a part
of their business range. Some have specialized in environmental, or occupational health
and safety aspects and some are focusing on workforce or global supply chain issues.
Most of them have broadened their services within CSR to comprise still more issues.
Moreover, smaller consultancies have also been established focusing uniquely on global
CSR services.
Examples of such VET institutions are:
Alectia: http://www.alectia.com/eng/competences
COWI:
www.cowi.com/menu/service/WaterandEnvironment/Pages/waterandenvironment.
aspx
CSR Strategy: www.csr-strategy.dk
Danish Standards:
www.ds.dk/en-GB/Services/Courses_and_conferences/Sider/default.aspx
FORCE Technology:
www.force.dk/en/Menu/Consultancy+and+Development/Environment/
NIRAS: http://www.niras.com/Business-Areas.aspx
Pricewaterhouse Coopers: www.pwc.com/dk/da/sustainability/index.jhtml
Rambøll: www.ramboll.com/about-us/corporate%20social%20responsibility
Viegand &Maagøe www.vmas.dk/uk/about-us
LITHUANIA
Lithuanian colleges (institutions of non-university higher education) have less chance of
setting up CSR teaching disciplines than the universities since there is a lack of suitably
qualified college teachers working in this field. Current situation shows that there are less
colleges which are oriented to disciplines of CSR than universities. However, those that
are oriented often review CSR more widely and pay more attention to it not only in
business management (e.g. a separate study module of “Corporate Social
Responsibility”), but also in industrial production (e.g. a discipline under a study module
of “Furniture Design”) study areas.
Together with the partners from Central Europe's universities, community of colleges are
often involved in international projects with SMEs in CSR related areas. Here students
learn how to develop strategies of corporate social responsibility.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 27/133
POLAND
CSR is not offered on the level of vocational schools in Poland.
SLOVENIA
We have reviewed all the currently existing VET programmes in Slovenia. Within the 17
programmes we have found 63 SR courses. 47 were environmentally oriented, such as
Ecology, environmental protection, sustainable development including selected biology
topics, forest ecology, waste management, air protection, wastewater treatment, etc. 15
of the courses were societal oriented, such as health protection, physical activity and
nutrition, safety at work, law issues and ethic regarding the environment, social
environment, healthy life, emotional intelligence and personal development, stress
management, etc. Only 1 economically oriented course has been found: quality and
reliability of processes.
SPAIN
As for Vocational Education and Training institutions, different courses on CSR are
available as well. However, just a few of them are courses focused specifically on small
and medium enterprises.
Centre Master/Course Training form
Efiaula Open Business School Social Responsibility on Organizations Mater Online
(9months)
Efiaula Open Business School Social Responsibility on Organizations and Human Resources Master Online
(9months)
Efiaula Open Business School Social and Environmental Responsibility for the Promotion and
Advancement of Social Economy Companies
Online Course
(100hs)
Grupo IMF Formación Corporate Social Responsibility Distance Course
(80hs)
eCátedra Corporate Social Responsibility Expert Distance Course
(80hs)
eCátedra Master on Sustainable Development: Renewable Energies, Agenda 21
and Corporate Social Responsibility
Distance Master
(800hs)
Clay Formación Internacional Corporate Social Responsibility Expert Distance Course
(150hs)
Clay Formación Internacional Expert on Corporate Social Responsibility and Communication Process
in the Enterprise
Distance Course (225
hs)
Centre Master/Course Training form
Clay Formación Internacional Professional Master on Sustainable Management: Environment,
Corporate Social Responsibility and Agenda 21
Distance Master (830
hs)
Cenproex SL Expert on Corporate Social Responsibility Course
Acedis Formación Expert on Corporate and Business Social Responsibility Online Course
(120hs)
Bureau Veritas Formación Social Responsibility Management, according to SGE 21 Standard Online Course (60hs)
Grupo MBC Corporate Social Responsibility Expert Distance Course (150
hs)
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 28/133
Grupo MBC Expert on Corporate Social Responsibility and Procedures for Business
Communication
Distance Course
(250hs)
Grupo MBC Sustainable Development: Renewable Energy, Agenda 21 and
Corporate Social Responsibility
Distance Master
(1.340hs)
Food & Beverage Training Corporate Social Responsibility Online Course (16hs)
Intergrupo Master in Prevention, Quality, Environment and Corporate Social
Responsibility
Online Master
(630 hs)
Instituto de investigaciones
Ecológicas Specialized course on Corporate Social Responsibility
Distance Course
(110hs)
Instituto Europeo de Estudios
Empresariales Superior Expert on Corporate Social Responsibility
Distance Course
(300hs)
Euroinnova Formación Superior Expert on Corporate Social Responsibility Distance Course
(300hs)
Geodem Business Corporate social Responsibility Online Course
(100hs)
Intergrupo Master on Integrated Quality, Environment and Corporate Social
Responsibility
Online Master (500
hs)
Mundifor Centros de Formación Course of Corporate Social Responsibility focused on the SMEs‟
Management
Distance Course
(80hs)
ESODE CSR. Corporate Social Responsibility Course (30 hs)
Iem Business School Sustainable Development and Corporate Social Responsibility Master (400 hs)
Global Estrategias How to Implement, Manage and Communicate Corporate Social
Responsibility Actions in the Entreprise Course (7 hs)
Servicios Normativos Centro de
Formación Corporate Social Responsibility – SA 8000 Online Course (30 hs)
Grupo Ascant de Formación Expert on Corporate Social Responsibility and Communication
Processes in the Enterprise
Distance Master (225
hs)
SGS Tecnos Corporate Responsibility Course (40 hs)
2.1.3. Other Institutions
Different kinds of institutions have been identified within the partners‟ countries. This
way, as for other institutions that offer training on CSR, we find the following ones:
NGOs
Consulting companies
Private business vocational trainers
Quality and certification institutions
Chambers of commerce
RSE institutions
Others agents and projects: Catholic Social academy in Austria, European
Management Center (EMC) in Bulgaria, Business Responsibility Forum Conference
in Poland...
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 29/133
AUSTRIA
ksoe Katholische Sozialakademie Österreichs
Training Social Responsibility
ksoe is the catholic social academy and offers a training that allows interested to develop
skills and competences to initiate and attend processes of social responsibility in the
professional, social and political environment. The training includes the implementation of
a concrete innovative project during the two-years-phase of the training. In every
training period the focus is on one specific European country, so that contents handle
with i.e. cooperations in the field of SR between organisations from Austria and the other
country.35
Contents
Phase 1
□ Basic competences and basic knowledge: Introduction; cooperation and conflict culture; social-ethical judgement; processes of interaction; criteria for social responsibility
□ Basic modules in the fields of economy, politics and civil society
Phase 2
□ Development of future-oriented projects: project management; networking – lobbying – fundraising; law as an instrument; cooperation and conflict culture; public relations
□ Action-learning groups: attendance, consulting and reflection of projects
Phase 3
□ Project presentation and certification: participants are certified with the title “Academic Social Responsibility Developer”
Target group
Interested that initiate and implement social responsibility projects
(future) Managers and leaders
Project managers, Human resource developers
Members from economic, political, social and ecclesiastic organisations
Trainers and teachers
Consultants
Students (theology, economy, politics, sociology)
BULGARIA
There are few NGOs and consulting companies which provide training in corporate social
responsibility or in some of its components. These trainings are mainly short-term – 1-2
days maximum and are not made on permanent basis. They are either on demand by
certain client for a certain purpose (request by a stakeholder, occurring of a problem
which requests training, awareness raising among the staff, etc.). Below is given
programme for a training proposed by the European Management Center (EMC). This
programme might be considered more or less a typical example of a training on
corporate social responsibility.
Training programme of EMC:
1. Corporate social responsibility – basic aspects
2. “Sustainable development” concepts, “the triple helix”
35 http://www.ksoe.at/pb/
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 30/133
3. Short history of CSR
4. Definitions and CSR perception models
5. Social responsibility – consumption, management, investment
6. CSR standards – UN Global Compact, ISO 26 000, CSR Label
7. Steps to implement CSR – Human resources, occupational health and safety,
human and labour rights, environmental management, stakeholder analysis, drafting an
action plan
The most often quoted methods of training by the different organisation providing
training in CSR are lectures and presentations, discussions, role plays and case studies.
DENMARK
CSR Forum36 was established as a network in 2004 and became an association in 2009.
The Forum aims at strengthening professional development and interdisciplinary
understanding as well as qualifying the CSR debate in Denmark by being a common
forum for the individuals, networks and professional groups working professionally with
CSR. CSR Forum makes 2-3 joint events a year, and, additionally, arranges ongoing
events in the various working groups with special focus on specific themes.
See more on: http://www.csrforum.dk/uk-om-csr-forum
Moreover, LinkedIn has a CSR Denmark Group with more than 370 members, and
another LinkedIn group “CSR 2.0” focus on CSR and social medias.
LITHUANIA
With regard to the growing interest in social responsibility in companies, as well as
implementation of social and environmental responsibility standards, the number of firms
that train and issue certificates in Lithuania has increased substantially. Currently, in
Lithuania there are such CSR training leading companies as UNDP Lithuania, JSC „EKT
Group“, JSC „Bureau veritas LT“, JSC „Det Norske Veritas LT“, JSC „Sertika“, VsI (public
enterprise) „LST SERT“, JSC „TUV Uolektis“, JSC „Kvalitetas“ and some others. These
companies are engaged in SMEs and large enterprises consulting, training and
certification on workers' ethical, environmental and social responsibility issues. It is likely
that the growing demand for setting up the new standards in business management and
production practices will also influence the need of training companies‟ potential growth.
36
www.csrforum.dk
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 31/133
POLAND
Corporations offering CSR (including interactive online trainings) ex.:
SN Polska - CSR - Społeczna Odpowiedzialność [Social Responsibility];
Empower Group - Zarządzanie wiekiem w organizacji [The Management of
Business Age];
Fundacja Republika Kobiet - Manager społecznej odpowiedzialności biznesu
[Women Republic Foundation - Manager of Social Business Responsibility];
Akademia WWW - SPOŁECZNA ODPOWIEDZIALNOŚĆ BIZNESU (CSR) CSR a e-
pr.[WWW Academy - SOCIAL BUSINES RESPONSIBILITY];
Polska Akademia Public Relations Sp.z o.o. [Polish Academy Public Relations
Ltd.] - Odpowiedzialność i etyka w biznesie; Kampanie społeczne [The
Responsibility and Ethics in Business; Social Campaigns];
JOTCONSULT, Jarosław Rubin - BUDOWA PRZEWAGI KONKURENCYJNEJ W
OPARCIU O WARTOŚCI - NARZĘDZIA SKUTECZNEGO MENEDŻERA
[JOTCONSULT, Jarosław Rubin - CREATING COMPETETIVE ADVANTAGE ON THE
BASIS OF VALUES - EFFICIENT MANAGER'S TOOLS];
eko-net.pl - Jak zbudować strategię zrównoważonego biznesu
CSV :: Trainings & Coaching – Marketing in truism; CSR - SOCIAL
RESPONSIBILITY IN BUSINESS
Forum Odpowiedzialnego Biznesu [Business Responsibility Forum] - the greatest
non-governmental organization in Poland, engaged in Business Social Responsibility
Concept.
The organization stands for dialog and exchange of experience on responsible
business and balanced development between businesses, government bodies, non-
governmental organizations and academics.
Their span of activity includes:
Responsible business promotion (Responsible Business Forum Conference,
Good Practice Fair CSR, Portal www.odpowiedzialnybiznes.pl, Newsletter Respo,
publikacje o odpowiedzialnym biznesie, współpraca z mediami);
Business support in implementation responsibility:
□ Partnership program - complex cooperation program including public
debate on responsibility in business; workshops, meetings, newsletter,
consulting and mutual project;
□ Talks on responsible business - a round of meetings on different aspects
of CSR.
Cooperation with business for public case:
□ Liga Odpowiedzialnego Biznesu [Responsible Business League]
(educational program) – CSR supporters from around Poland including
student organizations engaged in promoting responsible business idea in
their local communities. The program creating new managers and
businessmen, social animators and leaders of change37
Analysis and development of responsible business in projects:
□ Odpowiedzialny biznes w Polsce ['Responsible Business in Poland'] report;
□ Surways - among others "Społeczna odpowiedzialność biznesu w Polsce.
Wstępna analiza" ['Social responsibility of business in Poland. Initial
37
http://lob.org.pl/strona.php?kat=341
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 32/133
analysis'] for EC and UNDP, Managers 500, "Zarządzanie różnorodnością
w Polsce" [Diversification management in Poland under international
CSR/Diversity project;
□ Publications - "15 polskich przykładów społecznej odpowiedzialności
biznesu" ['15 Polish examples of business responsibility'];
SIFE Poland will coordinate domestic editions of SIFE (Students In Free Enterprise
program) 38
SPAIN
The following other institutions can be identified in Spain:
Quality/Certification Institutions Master/Course Training form
AEC – Spanish Association for Quality39 European Expert on Corporate Social Responsibility Distance Course (120 hs)
AENOR - Spanish Association for
Standardization and Certification40 Expert on Social Responsibility Course (60hs)
Chambers of Commerce Master/Course Training form
Zaragoza Chamber of Commerce Free training on CSR for SMEs Advising, courses and seminars
Mallorca Chamber of Commerce Training on CSR for SMEs Seminars,courses…
Several Chambers of Commerce have training courses and specific support on CSR for SMEs. The objective of the Spanish Chambesr
of Commerce on Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) is to create mechanisms and resources to integrate social responsibility in the
model of business competitiveness, especially in small and medium-sized companies, helping to strengthen management systems in
terms of trust, transparency and value creation for all stakeholders, improving the performance of companies in both economic, and
environmental and social areas, creating a distinctive identity and, through training (seminars ... ).
RSE institutions / NGOs Master/Course Training form
Fundación Entorno Rse+5. The Social Responsibility Focus on SMEs Online Course (60 hs)
CSR Observatory41 CSR: Challenges and Opportunities
Contents: An area focused on SMEs Online Course (125 hs)
2.2. Existing training materials on CSR in each country
The analysis of training materials on CSR shows how manuals and written guides are the
most common materials; in the form of text documents in varying forms, like books or
booklets, along with presentations and slides. Case studies and practical examples seems
to be common as well.
In some cases, both distance and online methods are used. However, in some countries
no modern methods as e-learning or self-study or evaluation methods have been
identified.
A more specific analysis has been carried out as for contents covered and targets groups
addressed by these training materials.
38
http://sife.pl/ 39
Asociación Española para la Calidad: http://www.aec.es/web/guest/formacion/catalogo/listado/for0454/RS-GE-D454-18102010-ED05621?gclid=CL7c3sGd_aYCFcse4QodkQ8rZg 40
Spanish Association for Standardization and Certification: http://www.aenor.es/aenor/actualidad/actualidad/noticias.asp?campo=9&codigo=18018&tipon= 41
CSR Observatory: http://www.observatoriorsc.org/images/stories/audio/Proyectos/Informacion_cursoRSC.pdf
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 33/133
2.2.1. Contains and covered areas
As for the contents of the training materials, some elements have been identified as
more usual, within the analyzed countries, mainly related to environmental, societal and
economical issues:
Market and business
Community and social programs
Environment and sustainable development
Human resources
As well as this, other elements have been included, as for example: business ethics,
transparency and governance, business negotiations, moral responsibility,
communication and knowledge management, ethical aspects of advertisement, cultural
identity or awareness raising.
Finally, no references to ISO 26000 have been identified into the analyzed training
materials (just in two cases in Austrian analysis).
AUSTRIA
There exist several training materials on CSR in Austria, whereby most of them have a
special emphasis on SMEs. The most relevant ones in this context and described in the
following, were developed in national and EU-funded projects as well as initiated and
provided by respACT, the Austrian Federal Economic Chamber, the Austrian Standards
Institute and NeSoVe.
Corporate Social Responsibility Training Handbook
The objective of this training handbook42, is to support the organisation and development
of CSR trainings. It was developed by FO.FO.s in the framework of the Leonardo da Vinci
project “CSR/SME – Promoting social responsibility in small and medium size
enterprises”.43
Contents and covered areas
The handbook is organised in different parts:
“General conditions of a training” gives an overview of the all training modules and the
structure they are following (description of target groups, trainers profile, objective,
specific goals, theory/learning contents, structure of the module, methods and training
activities, didactic resources/materials, time schedule)
Description of training modules handles the different modules
□ CSR Basics/introduction □ Business ethics □ Work place □ Environment
42 CSR Trainingshandbuch (2007), p. 5ff 43 http://www.fofos.at
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 34/133
□ Market □ Local community
Supporting training activities “Exercises”, “Case studies” and “Ethical dilemmata”
The handbook also includes a feedback questionnaire for the training evaluation, a
guideline for company visits, national state-of-the-art reports, and a comprehensive
glossary
Target group The CSR Training Handbook refers to trainers and VET institutions, who are planning and implementing CSR trainings for SMEs, executives from public and non-profit organisations, consultants, VET-experts and students.
CSR Guidelines of the Austrian Standards Institute
German title: „Der österreichische CSR Leitfaden“
The Austrian CSR Guidelines were developed in 2004 from the working group AK 1112
„Corporate Social Responsibility“ of the Austrian Standards Institute. The guidelines were
translated in five languages and were developed according to the Green Paper of the
European Commission. They took strong impacts on other comparable activities and the
ISO 26000 process.44
Contents and covered areas
The guidelines present principles, systems and tools and offers guidance and recommendations for its users. The primary benefits for companies are
the implementation of the concept “Sustainable Development” into operative business
activities;
the integration and further development of social obligations for employees and the
local community and the environment systematically into the management
the protection and development of the organisation‟s reputation
the minimisation of risks
a protection of the economic viability of the company
The model for a management system for CSR helps companies to illustrate to its stakeholders
self commitment, approved by the corporate policy and the company‟s targets. This
commitment also includes regulatory appointments.
that the focus is on avoidance of failures rather than on removal.
The first chapter of the guidelines defines economic, social and environmental requirements. These include recommendations for social minimum requirements and also for the voluntary commitment. A next chapter deals with the organisation of systems based on a model for CSR that in turn is based on the model for continuous improvement. To secure the success of such a management system, there‟s a special input on the self-commitment of the management board. Furthermore, the guidelines give concrete instructions and practical help for a starting analysis, internal and external communication, corporate policy, planning (operative target setting, programmes for targets achievement), implementation (resources, organisational structure and responsibilities, competencies, training and awareness, documentation), control (monitoring and measuring, assessment, failures, corrections, preventive measures, documentation, audits). The process concludes with a management assessment and instructions for a continuous improvement. The part “Sustainability Reports” describes in an own chapter how to develop a report in 7 steps. The last chapter of the guidelines include a glossary with important terms concerning CSR.
Target group This guidelines refer to enterprises from all branches and sizes, and besides that also other organisations – like associations, public institutions, municipalities, project organisations – should be encouraged to apply the guidelines correspondingly.
Handbook of Procedures: A Sustainability Report in 7 Steps
44 Köppl, Neureiter (2004), p. 325
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 35/133
German title: “Methoden-Handbuch: In 7 Schritten zum Nachhaltigkeitsbericht“
Editor of this handbook45 is amongst others the Austrian “Ministry for Agriculture and
Forestry, Environment and Water Management”. The objective of this procedures‟
handbook is to support the development of a Sustainability report. Therefore, it shows a
way how to describe an organisation‟s performance and activities from the viewpoint of
Sustainable Development.
Contents and covered areas
The handbook includes a collection of methods, whereby tools applicable for SMEs or large companies, beginners or advanced are marked. The procedures/methods within this handbook have a consistent structure:
Result: shows the achievements with a method
Resources: describes time expenditures, which persons should be included and with
equipment is necessary
Description: gives background information for the method and describes the activity
Working Sheets: allow a application of the method
The 7 steps to develop a Sustainability Report represent the content of the handbook‟s chapters:
Step 1 “Clarification of framework conditions”
Step 2 “Identify issues and stakeholders”
Step 3 “Objectives for the company and the report”
Step 4 “Collecting data and information”
Step 5 “Writing the report”
Step 6 “Design of the report”
Step 7 “Disseminating the report”
Target group
Organisations who want to develop a Sustainability report.
Persons that are responsible for risk, quality and environmental management
Organisations who want to engage in sustainable development
CSR Guidebook: A CSR Strategy in 7 Steps
German title: “CSR-Ratgeber: In 7 Schritten zu einer CSR Strategie“
The objective of the guidebook46, edited by respACT, is to give encouragement and
advise about a profitable implementation of CSR to companies. Additionally a test for
self-assessment and lists with indicators and measures were developed by respACT and
supported by the Ministry for Economy and the Austrian Federal Economic Chamber.
Guidebook and accompanying instruments are available for different sectors, whereby
the development was accomplished in cooperation with entrepreneurs from the different
industries. Currently the training materials are available for these industries:
Timber/Furniture/Building Components
Textiles/Clothing/Footwear
Paper/Printing/Bookbinder
Tourism Industry
Food and Drinks
Transportation and Shipping
Building Industry
Jewellery
Promotion and Market communication
45 Resel et al. (2006), Methoden-Handbuch. In 7 Schritten zum Nachhaltigkeitsbericht, p.3 46 respACT, Editor, CSR-Ratgeber. In 7 Schritten zu einer CSR Strategie
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 36/133
Finishing (production and application)
Toys and Sports equipment
Contents and covered areas
The guidebook for the implementation of CSR in SMEs considers branch specific background information that is relevant for CSR and at the same time points out recommendations for a CSR strategy. The 7 steps are as follows:
Step 1 “Appraisal and Vision”
Step 2 “Documentation”
Step 3 “Stakeholders”
Step 4 “Risks”
Step 5 “Measures”
Step 6 “Communicating CSR”
Step 7 “Linking information”
The self-assessment test analyses in a few minutes the individual understanding of a vision for sustainable development and a sustainable management. The training material also includes a list with indicators and measures, which is included in the guidebook‟s annex.
Target group The guidebook is targeted to SMEs that handle with CSR for the first time and that want to understand the concept, but also companies that are active in some CSR activity fields and want to develop an integrated concept with the company‟s relevant dimensions.
Network Social Responsibility: CSR Criteria Catalogue NICK
German title: “Netzwerk Soziale Verantwortung: CSR-Kriterienkatalog NICK“
This criteria catalogue47 is based on the triple bottom line and evaluates companies
regarding the implementation of sustainability through a numerical value generated from
ca. 100 criteria. The objective is to provide an indicator for social responsibility.
Furthermore, this catalogue was published with the aim to start discussions regarding the
implementation of social responsibility. NeSoVe also views these criteria as a basis for
future legal obligations.
Contents and covered areas
The catalogue is based on the position paper of NeSoVe, GRI and criteria of Ethibel and Clean Clothes.
Target group Companies and organisations, civil society, politics
CSR Guiding Vision for the Austrian business sector “Economic Success. Responsible
Action”
German title: “Erfolg mit Verantwortung: ein Leitbild für zukunftsfähiges Wirtschaften“
“The concept of Success with Responsibility supports companies in taking their social
responsibility. It addresses all Austrian companies and offers to them a catalogue of
objectives for responsible business on the basis of five fields of action: leadership and
organisation, market, employees, environment, community.”48
Contents and covered areas
The concept is useful for a stepwise implementation of a CSR strategy, but also for the systematic documentation of CSR engagements. The concept describes four concrete application areas to every field of action, each with a short introduction and specific objectives. Furthermore, the website http://www.respact.at/csrleitbild contains more than 100 practical tipps regarding the fields of action and the application areas. On the basis of the following fields of action, the companies learn step wise how to develop
and implement CSR activities.
47 http://www.netzwerksozialeverantwortung.at (02/2010) 48 respACT (2010), Erfolg mit Verantwortung, http://www.respact.at/csrleitbild
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 37/133
“Leadership and organisation” deals with organisational culture and role model status;
strategy, implementation and risk management; communication and transparency;
stakeholder relations
“Market” includes products and services; innovations; value chains; business relations
“Employees” is about compensation and working times; rights of employees and labour
protection; human resource development and continuing education; diversity and
equality
“Environment” concerns the protection and prevention of the environment; resource
efficiency, energy efficiency and climate protection; mobility and transport
“Community” deals with the protection of human rights and cultural diversity;
combating poverty and development cooperation; continual social commitment;
dissemination of social responsibility
Target group
The CSR Guiding Vision supports companies to assume their social responsibility. It addresses to all Austrian enterprises and provides them a catalogue of targets for responsible business on the basis of five fields of action (leadership, market, employees, environment, community).
CSR Handbook for Sole Proprietorships
German title: „CSR Leitfaden für Ein-Personen-Unternehmen“
This in Europe unique handbook was developed by respACT and the Austrian Federal
Economic Chamber in collaboration with experts.49
Contents and covered areas
The handbook helps sole proprietorships to adopt CSR in 5 steps:
Step 1: Decide what your company stands for
Step 2: Collect relevant information
Step 3: Target setting
Step 4: Implement your measures
Step 5: Evaluate the results and communicate your commitment
For each step, concrete support (“HELP”) for the handling is available. For example, in Step 2 “Collect relevant information” it looks like this:
HELP 2: Who are my stakeholders? Examples for Stakeholders:
□ Consumers: Who do I sale my products and services to? □ Suppliers, sources and origin: Where do I purchase from? What are my
information sources? □ Partners and networks: Who do I cooperate with in projects or events? □ Neighbours and local environment: Does my business impact my neighbours?
How do my activities impact the local area? □ Family, friends and private environment: Which people in my social environment
are concerned by my business activities? □ Organisations, platforms, NGOs: Which organisations do exist for my
professional guild and for my stakeholders? □ Community: What are the trends and developments in my market? Which core
competence could I bring in where? □ Media: Who informs about my business activities in regional newspapers or in
trade press? A self-assessment, where the entrepreneur evaluates the interactions of the company with environment, market and society, complements the handbook. Some other deepening questions help to complete the self-assessment. The formulation of objectives in the categories society, environment and market that are related to each stakeholder, with measures and a time frame for the implementation, generates the last part of the handbook.
Target group The handbook aims at sole proprietorships that engage in CSR for the first time and want to understand the concept. It is unique in Europe and offers a simple introduction into CSR for
that target group.
49 respACT (2009), Editor, CSR Leitfaden für Ein-Personen-Unternehmen
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 38/133
Regarding the contents and covered areas and their usefulness for SMEs in terms of a
simple language, the described training materials show varying specificities. The
following table gives an overview of training materials‟ completeness:
Table 2: Contents and Covered Areas of Austrian CSR training materials
Training Materials
Contents and Covered Areas
Sim
ple
Language
Definitio
n o
f Term
s
Vis
ion/B
usin
ess C
ase
Mark
et
Work
pla
ce
Com
munity
Environm
ent
Perf
orm
ance F
igure
s
Sta
kehold
er
Managem
ent
Com
munic
ation
Managem
ent
Appro
ach
Tripple
Bott
om
Lin
e
Refe
rence t
o I
SO
26000
(1) CSR Training Handbook by FO.FO.s X X X X X X X X X X X
(2) CSR Guidelines of the ASI X X X X X X X X
(3) Handbook of Procedures: A Sustainability Report in 7 Steps
X X X X X X X
(4) CSR Guidebook: A CSR Strategy in 7 Steps X X X X X X X X X X X X
(5) NeSoVe: CSR Criteria Catalogue NICK X X X X X
(6) CSR Guiding Vision “Economic Success. Responsible Action”
X X X X X X X X X X
(7) CSR Handbook for Sole Proprietorships X X X X X X X X
Only two of the described training resources show references to ISO 26000. In the case
of the “CSR Guidelines of the ASI”, they were a basic document for the whole
development process of ISO 26000. Therefore it can be assumed that there are strong
correlations between these two documents. In the case of the “CSR Guiding Vision, the
authors indicate, that the discussion process was based amongst other documents also
on ISO 26000.
They are all available in the form of text documents in varying forms, like books or
booklets. Some of them include working sheets, checklists and/or selftests (1, 3, 4, 7)
and a power point presentation (1).
The most comprehensive SR training material and adapted to SMEs seems to be the
“CSR Guidebook: A CSR Strategy in 7 Steps”, which has also the benefit that it is
adapted to specific sectors. On the other hand it doesn‟t have any reference to ISO
26000.
BULGARIA
Taking into account the number of credit hours the higher schools provide more
comprehensive training in the subjects related to corporate social responsibility. For
example the Masters programme “Human resource management and corporate social
responsibility” includes module 6 with the courses “The social responsibility of the
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 39/133
company and the sustainable development”, courses “Stakeholders management”,
“Business ethics”, “Socially responsible investment” each one of them with 15 credit
hours.
Normally a subject course in Bulgarian higher schools is not less 30 credit hours so it can
be assumed that the courses in business ethics, etc. provided by the universities in
Bulgaria have the average duration of 30 hours.
In the course “Social responsibility and business ethics” in the Varna Free University the
students learn about the nature and basic components of the business ethics, the social
responsibility, the specificity of business negotiations, the reasons which cause a conflict
during the negotiations and the mechanisms for their solutions.
The course “Engineers ethics” in the University Architecture, Civil Engineering and
Geodesy will provide the future road construction engineers with skills to identify the
theory of the engineer problematic into the moral socialising, to analise the problems of
the professional ethics in the engineer activity – the moral responsibility of the
construction business, the trust as a moral resource in the business relations, the
corporate loyalty and the conformism, the ethical aspects of advertisement, business
etiquette and cultural identity, etiquette and social responsibility in the consultancy, etc.
The courses offered by training centres are usually 1-2 days and the topics covered are
normally of information providing, awareness raising or promotional nature. In item 2.1.3
a training programme was quoted as typical and the duration of the training is 1 day and
the training method is discussions, role plays and brainstorming.
Apart from the topics quoted in 2.1.3 the topics covered in other trainings include: CSR
instruments and measures (material and money donations, providing of services and
right of use, providing of people, time and knowledge), working pro bono as an
instrument of personal policy and contribution to corporate culture, areas of CSR activity
and tasks in the company, implementation of CSR, etc.
LITHUANIA
CSR training materials for different target groups in the seminars and lectures are
introduced in the oral manner and in written training manuals. Students are taught CSR-
related courses in the form of information presentation (MS Power Point slides) or written
material. Training companies analogically organize seminars for executives and SMEs
representatives on CSR principles and implementation system, often by dividing
additional printed material.
During the lectures and seminars, the principles and strategies to facilitate the
implementation of social responsibility activities in the company are taught. After the
course, companies‟ managers and representatives consolidate the obtained theoretical
knowledge in practice, carrying out the activities in accordance with CSR implementation
guide that provides examples which facilitate the CSR implementation. Students, as
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 40/133
future professionals, consolidate their knowledge by preparing written work or taking
examinations.
POLAND
Social responsibility in SME. Practical examples of SME competitiveness increase –
a file including abbreviated versions of selected studies on practical CSR actions in
European SME in PDF format50.
Training companies provide training and additional materials (case studies,
exercises) available in digital version as PDF files.
SLOVENIA
Training materials have been reviewed as well. Training material at the university as well
as in the VET institutions comprises textbooks (denoted to each course) and study
material provided by the professors. No ICT material has been found, such as e-learning
options. Sometimes, only lectures of the professors could be found on the web as ppt
presentations. The educational process at the universities as well as within the VET
institutions is mostly lecturer oriented frontal method (lecturer has presentation in front
of the classroom), followed by exercise done by students. No modern (e-learning, self-
study and evaluation methods) have been perceived within the courses reviewed.
Areas which are mostly covered within the courses offered are environmental issues,
followed by societal and economical. No course, such as corporate social responsibility
has been perceived.
SPAIN
As it has been showed in the previous analysis, almost all the existing training materials
on CSR does not focus on SMEs. As well as this, the vast majority of courses, apart from
these offered by Spanish Universities, have a distance or online basis. In this sense, the
training mainly consists of training literature (both on physical paper, or electronic
documents), along with the continuous support of a tutor via phone/email.
As it has been showed in the previous analysis, almost all the existing training materials
on CSR does not focus on SMEs. As well as this, the vast majority of courses, apart from
these offered by Spanish Universities, have a distance or online basis. In this sense, the
training mainly consists of training literature (both on physical paper, or electronic
documents), along with the continuous support of a tutor via phone/email.
As for the contents included in the courses/masters on CSR focused on SMEs, the
following areas are covered:
50
http://www.csr-in-smes.eu/downloads/brochure_poland.pdf (Detailed descriptions at: www.csr-in-smes.eu)
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 41/133
Definition of Corporate Social Responsibility: Vision and Context
CSR and the Enterprise
Transparency and Governance
Sustainable Development
Environmental Issue
International guidelines and European framework on CSR
Impulse and direction of CSR in Spain
General context and academic and business initiatives
Public Policies
Scope, contents and implications of CSR
Enterprise culture
Human Resources
Market initiatives
Community and Social Action Programs
Environmental Impact
Communication and knowledge management
Management tools and indicators
Spanish SMEs in front of the CSR
Stakeholders
Strategy
2.2.2. Target groups of the training offer
Several training materials focused on SMEs have been analyzed; however, it can be
drawn that, in general, although analyzed training materials can be useful for them,
existing materials have not been elaborated specifically for SMEs, as they are targeted to
all kind of organizations.
Among the identified target groups, the following have been highlighted:
University students and university graduates, from different specialities
Senior managers, middle management and team leaders.
Professionals on CSR.
Professionals on human resources.
Marketing and communication managers, PR and sale.
People engaged in creation and implementation of strategies in business.
People interested in competitiveness increase.
Compliance managers.
Nongovernmental workers, family businesses and public administration workers.
Technical Staff from chambers of commerce, Unions, associations of enterprises…
Public Administration staff.
Responsible for social economy companies.
Managers and technicians from SMEs that want to manage CSR departments or
social economy programs.
Usually, applicants for these courses must not comply with special requirements as for
previous knowledge of specific skills, as they are focused for beginners or other
specialities‟ experts.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 42/133
In some cases as well, some of the identified training materials refer explicitly to trainers
and VET institutions.
AUSTRIA
The CSR Training Handbook refers explicitly to trainers and VET institutions, who are
planning and implementing CSR trainings for SMEs, executives from public and non-profit
organisations, consultants, VET-experts and students.
All the other training resources (CSR Guidelines of ASI, Handbook of Procedures, CSR
Guidebook: A CSR Strategy in 7 Steps, CSR Guiding Vision for the Austrian business
sector, CSR Handbook for Sole Proprietorships) are useful for SMEs as well as for other
organisations. In the cases of the “CSR Guidebook: A CSR Strategy in 7 Steps” and the
“CSR Handbook for Sole Proprietorships”, they are explicitly targeted to SMEs and micro-
companies. Furthermore, the described training materials can be used for beginners but
also for advanced persons to implement SR.
BULGARIA
The target groups in the universities are the students from different specialities - road
construction, environmental management, accounting and finance, business
administration, financial auditing.
The target groups of the training courses provided by consulting companies and NGOs
are senior managers, middle management, HR specialists, communication and PR
specialists, other company officials, etc.
LITHUANIA
Basic target groups of the training offer are university and college students of corporate
governance and business organization, human resource management, international
business, organizational management, environmental management, business
administration, economics, environmental protection and environmental engineering as
well as the executives of existing enterprises or companies‟ representatives responsible
for certain corporate policies51.
POLAND
People engaged in creation and implementation of strategies in business.
51
Institutions of Higher Education, Colleges and secondary schools in Lithuania, available at: http://www.on.lt/hedu3.htm
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 43/133
People interested in competitiveness increase.
Marketing managers, PR and sale.
Professionals on CSR.
Professionals on communication with market.
Professionals on human resources.
Compliance managers.
Team leaders.
Nongovernmental workers, family businesses and public administration workers.
Students.
SLOVENIA
The target groups at the university level are full-time students, while at the VET level is
also elder population, studying while also working.
SPAIN
Students and University graduates.
Technical Staff from chambers of commerce, Unions, associations of enterprises…
Public Administration staff and responsible workers.
Responsible for social economy companies.
Managers and technicians from SMEs that want to manage CSR departments or
social economy programs.
Usually, applicants for these courses must not comply with special requirements
as for previous knowledge of specific skills.
2.3. Existing other training tools on CSR in each country
These other tools include, several CSR toolkits, along with other platforms and guides.
2.3.1. Contains and covered areas
Several contains have been covered by these tools. Among them, we can find a toolkit
developed according to ISO 26000.
AUSTRIA
The described CSR tools range from sustainability checks to very specific tools in the
form of business plan generation. However, one of these tools is especially based on ISO
26000 and was published in May 2010.
The Complete CSR Toolkit
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 44/133
The purpose of this software is to enable the user to implement CSR into the
management system and strategy of the company or organisation. This is done by
evaluating the current situation of the company and through a unique CSR-Matrix which
includes all the core CSR subjects and issues as described in ISO 26000. As soon as the
user fills out the CSR Matrix he/she will be able to see the CSR situation in the company
in relation to ISO 26000. Further the software provides clear stakeholder engagement
steps to better evaluate the own position and propose ways forward. Eventually, ”The
Complete CSR Toolkit” program enables the user to observe the improvements, through
a chart line of progress. The data resulting from the user input can be used in Power
Point Presentations via a direct link to an exporting function; there are no complicated
exporting processes involved.52
Contents and covered areas
This software programme leads the user step by step through a CSR management system according to ISO 26000. The integration of internal and external stakeholders is an integral part. The toolkit allows companies to
identify the current situation
discover gaps in the field of CSR
develop a coherent and comprehensive CSR strategy
measure the company‟s performance through key performance indicators
visualise the company‟s CSR situation
describe the performance over time
The user starts with an introduction to CSR: What is CSR? What are the benefits? The second step describes the key components for a CSR strategy and leads the user with a questionnaire stepwise through the relevant issues. The third step “CSR Step by Step” guides the user through an adapted matrix of ISO 26000. On the basis of this matrix, the implementation steps, action plans and key figures for each CSR activity are identified. In step 4, a stakeholder management system, that identifies the stakeholders and the types of communication, is implemented. Step 5 deals with reporting. It offers different types of report samples, i.e. also a progress report for UN Global compact. Step 6 provides tools for internal and external audits, whereby also different formats and possibilities for the individual adaption are available.
Target group “The complete CSR Toolkit” can be used by all kinds and sizes of organisations that want to implement CSR into their management system and strategy.
SUMMIT – Sustainable Management Methods Integrating Tool-Kit
SUMMIT53 is a tool that supports SMEs in implementing sustainability as a holistic
strategy. Principles of communication, cooperation and coordination are therefore
combined with management tools to integrate sustainability into company policy and
daily business.
Contents and covered areas
SUMMIT consists of several modules and tools:
Module 1 “SUMMIT Methods register”: established management practices, systems and
tools are evaluated concerning social, ecological and economical criteria and
categorised. The established instrument PREPARE is expanded through the TRIZ
approach (Theory of inventive problem solving) and a relevant element within the
collection of instruments
Module 2 “Summit Sustainability Check”: This assessment tool includes a
comprehensive business analysis based on sustainable criteria. It allows an evaluation
of the status “stage of sustainable development” and shows potential for the
implementation of sustainable visions.
52 http://www.csr-toolkit.com 53 http://summit.stenum.at/
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 45/133
Module 3 “Summit Tools Matrix” is the key element and innovation of SUMMIT. It
combines the methods register with criteria of the sustainability check. Based on
objectives and the status-quo of the company, the results of interviews can be inserted.
This matrix allows to determine targets and management tools that support the
individual sustainable development of the companies.
Target group The target group are small and medium-sized companies, who were also involved in the development of SUMMIT.
Sustainable Business Planner: IT supported Management Tool for the Integration of
Principles of the Impulse Programme “Sustainable Business”
German title: “Sustainable Business Planner: IT-gestütztes Management Tool zur
Integration der Prinzipien des Impulsprogramms “Nachhaltig Wirtschaften” in
Businesspläne“54
Contents
and covered areas
Sustainable Business Planner is a software, that is conceptualised as a tool for use and learning. It supports the user to stepwise develop a sustainable business plan in 6 modules. Each module covers a specific task. They guide the user from idea generation,
team building, stakeholder identification to analysis of the business environment. Module 1 “Idea generation”
Module 2 “Sustaining ideas”
Module 3 “Sound innovation potential”
Module 4 “Establishing the company”
Module 5 “Knowing stakeholders”
Module 6 “ Analysing the business environment”
By working through the 6 modules the user develops stepwise the business plan for a business idea. The seven principles of sustainable business are integrated in the modules that way, they serve as sources for ideas and also as criteria for the
integration of sustainability aspects. After finishing the work in the modules, a business plan with classical chapters is generated automatically from the inserted data. According to the developers, the Sustainable Business Planner shall close the gap between business plan tools integrating sustainability and tools for the development of new business ideas. Therefore, seven principles of sustainability (according to the national programme “Sustainable Business”) with elements of a
business plan:
7 Principles of “Sustainable Business”
Key elements of a business plan
Orientation on service and benefit
Use of renewable resources
Efficiency
Recyclability
Adaption, flexibility and compliance
Fault tolerance and risk prevention
Protection of work, income and life
quality
Executive summary
Company
Product/service
Branch and market
Marketing
Management and key personnel
Implementation plan
Opportunities and risks
5 years plan
Financial demand
Target group
Innovative entrepreneurs who want to go into business with their ideas
Innovation friendly companies
Start-up initiatives
Business lobbies
Universities and colleges of higher education
54 http://sbp.fabrikderzukunft.at
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 46/133
The described tools are all software tools supported by written documents (handbooks
and user guides). Except the “Complete CSR Toolkit” they are free available on the web
after registration. Regarding the contents and areas they cover, the following table gives
an overview.
Table 3: Contents and Covered Areas of Austrian CSR training tools
Training Tools
Contents and Covered Areas
Sim
ple
Language
Definitio
n o
f Term
s
Vis
ion/B
usin
ess C
ase
Mark
et
Work
pla
ce
Com
munity
Environm
ent
Perf
orm
ance F
igure
s
Sta
kehold
er
Managem
ent
Com
munic
ation
Managem
ent
Appro
ach
Tripple
Bott
om
Lin
e
Refe
rence t
o I
SO
26000
(1) The Complete CSR Toolkit X X X X X X X X X X X X X
(2) SUMMIT X X X X X
(3) Sustainable Business Planner X X X X X X X
The “Complete CSR Toolkit” seems to be a good instrument for implementing CSR
according to ISO 26000, and currently without relevant competitors. In 5 steps the CSR
concept is separated into concrete subjects and attends the user in defining its position
regarding the recommendations of ISO 26000 and implementing CSR into the corporate
strategy. Therefore a special matrix was developed. The toolkit is also useful for the
generation of Global Compact progress reports.
“SUMMIT” is useful for a first analysis of a company‟s sustainable performance, whereby
it‟s not clear connected with the concept of CSR.
The “Sustainable Business Planner” aims at the generation of ideas for starting a
business in the field of sustainability and supports the user also with the development of
a business plan. It also doesn‟t refer to the concept of SR.
BULGARIA
N/A
DENMARK
As mentioned in part 1, Danish authorities have supported the development of a number
of tools. Some of them are directed especially towards SME‟s, others are more general.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 47/133
But as 99,5 percent of Danish companies have less than 250 employees, all the major
tools are included below.
The Ideas Compass55
The Ideas Compass is a web-based tool, where small and medium-sized companies can
find inspiration to innovate and evolve. The focus of the website is on CSR-driven
innovation (corporate social innovation - CSI) – an innovation process focusing on
current social and environmental needs which gives companies an opportunity to develop
sustainable products or services.
The Ideas Compass was created by the Danish Commerce and Companies Agency under
the Ministry of Economic and Business Affairs with support from Region Zealand, the
Nordic Innovation Centre and TrygVesta.
The Climate Compass56
The Climate Compass is a web-based tool that offers inspiration in terms of preparing a
climate strategy to reduce the greenhouse gas emissions. The Climate Compass can help
the company calculate its carbon footprint, preparing a climate strategy and reducing
emissions and costs.
The tool was created in cooperation with The Confederation of Danish Industry.
Global Compact Self Assessment Tool57
In collaboration with the secretariat of the UN Global Compact, the Global Compact Self
Assessment Tool is a partnership between The Danish Ministry of Economic and Business
Affairs, The Confederation of Danish Industry, The Danish Institute for Human Rights and
The Danish Industrialization Fund for Developing Countries.
Using the Global Compact Self Assessment Tool a company can go through a simple self-
assessment to find out how the company is doing in all areas of the UN Global Compact.
The tool is designed for companies who are committed to upholding basic social and
environmental standards in their operations.
The CSR Compass58
The CSR compass is a tool for companies who wants to demand social responsibility from
their suppliers, or companies whose costumers expect them to make these demands. The
tool was made in cooperation with The Confederation of Danish Industry and The Danish
Institute for Human Rights.
The Communication Compass59
The Communication Compass is a web-based tool helping businesses communicate about
their CSR work. The tool is intended for businesses that already work with CSR and that
want to improve the communication of their efforts to the outside world. The tool has
been developed by Copenhagen Business School, with financial support from Kraks Fond
and the Danish Commerce and Companies Agency.
55
http://ideascompass.dk/en 56
www.climatecompass.dk 57
Global Compact self assessment tool: www.Globalcompactselfassessment.org 58
www.csrkompasset.dk 59
www.kommunikationskompasset.dk
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 48/133
Partnerships for increased growth and employment60
Project “Virksom.nu” on social responsibility concerning the tolerant job market. The
purpose was to increase growth and employment in local areas with special attention to
integration of ethnic minorities at workplaces.
People and Profit Guide61
The People and Profit guide was made in 2007 to help prepare small and medium-sized
companies working with voluntary environmental and social issues. The guide is a
reference guide and a workbook which allows a company to identify the CSR activities
which are strategically relevant to the particular business and to learn more about the
relevant activities.
The guide is based on a 3-year project involving several consultancies within the CSR
foiled and it is the most comprehensive in Denmark in relation to CSR in SME‟s. As a part
of the project, more than 12.000 persons joined training seminars focusing on elements
of the guide.
The guide is a reference guide and a workbook which allows the company to:
Identify the CSR activities which are strategically relevant to the individual
company
Finding out more about the relevant activities
Finding guidelines and inspiration for getting started.
The guide is divided into a number of subjects and activities, the description of which is
two-fold: An introduction with an overview and a guide with inspiration and instructions
for working with the subjects in a particular company. The instructions are hands-on
taking into consideration that small and medium-sized enterprises in various sectors are
very different.
In the guide, implementing CSR is seen as a stepwise, ongoing, iterative process based
on a plan-do-check-act approach. The activities are divided into nine focus areas:
Communication
Stakeholder dialogue
Employees
CSR innovation
Leadership and Management
Customers
Environment
Community
Suppliers
The People and Profit Guide is available on the internet for free in a Danish and an
English version. The English version can be found here: People and Profit Guide (PDF).
The material serves as a reference guide for working with CSR in SME‟s. The guide was
developed by a number of consultancies within the CSR field in Denmark and it is still
used by i.e. these consultants.
On the environmental field, the Danish EPA has supported more than 100 projects
resulting in different tools and guidelines e.g. on implementing cleaner technologies,
60
Danish Commerce and Companies Agency: project “virksom.nu” (Project “active.now”): www.virksom.nu 61
People and Profit website: www.overskudmedomtanke.dk/sw63523.asp and
People and Profit Guide (PDF)
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 49/133
substituting hazardous chemicals and implementing environmental management systems
– or on conducting LCAs and designing greener products62.
Within the regionally based Green Network, a number of manuals and tools have been
developed to support the member companies63 – many of them are small – in working
with environmental and social aspects in a systematic way. Each year the member
companies must publish a report stating their policy, plans and results. When approved
by the network, the company receive a diploma and a flag to make the effort more
visible. The diplomas can be seen as a step towards certification.
LITHUANIA
Some of the educational institutions provide CSR framework and implementation
principles not only during the seminars and in the form of training manuals. The future
leaders and managers studying at certain universities and colleges gain also some
practical skills on CSR implementation.
College or university students can learn to implement CSR in the virtual (non-existent)
company, and in some cases, they can learn to implement CSR in real companies by
participating in the international projects. In this way, they acquire not only theoretical,
but also practical knowledge. However, such experience is available only to students of
universities or colleges which participate in the similar projects.
POLAND
Internet platforms ex.:
Communication and education platform
64
Enables tracking events, explains issues and presents new tendencies. The site
is updated Monday to Friday. The site includes the following divisions:
□ News (latest information on events and tendencies);
□ Knowledge (CSR library);
□ Workshops (info on workshops, meetings and seminars);
□ Service catalogue (bodies offering professional services in CSR and
balanced development).
Responsible Business Forum65
Responsible Business Forum (business description in p. 2.1.3) including:
□ Project description (Responsible Business Forum Conference,
"Odpowiedzialny biznes w Polsce. Dobre praktyki" [Responsible Business
in Poland. Good Practices] rapport, Social Rapports Competition, Ranking
of Responsible Businesses, Talks on Responsible Business, Responsibility
Pen - A Competition for Journalists, Manager Survey 500/Leader CSR,
Project RespEn, CSR Fair);
62
www.mst.dk/en 63
http://www.greennetwork.dk/page123.aspx 64
http://www.csrinfo.org/pl/wprowadzenie 65
http://odpowiedzialnybiznes.pl/en/about-us.html
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 50/133
□ CSR practices (latest news, events, good practices - including annual
rapports - "Odpowiedzialny biznes w Polsce. Dobre praktyki")
['Responsible Business in Poland. Good Practices']
□ Know-how database (info on CSR in Poland and EU, survey results,
publications).
Good CSR Practices Fair by Responsible Business Forum66
Target: popularization of social idea of Business Responsibility among business
sector representatives and wide spectrum of interested people: workers,
consumers, suppliers, students, nongovernmental workers, local communities
Fairs will include among others:
Presenting business achievements in Social Responsibility;
Subject seminaries: responsible utilization and recycling, responsible
exploitation of natural resources, responsible consumption and balanced
infrastructural investments;
Open lecture (online) „Green Marketing and sustainable innovation” by John
Grant - an expert on Balanced Marketing;
Film on Global Production and Consumption System - „Story of Stuff”;
Collection of electrical waste under All-Poland Eco-Campaign EKOgraty.pl;
A competition on the Best Presented Practice.
Publications, ex. the handbook prepared by Economy Ministry for small and medium
enterprises, entitled „Zrównoważony rozwój ”['Balanced Development']; Challenges
of Sustainable Development in Poland67; articles on social responsibility issues and
similar (over 1500 articles of 2009)68
Projects (including sponsored by EU) promoting social responsibility ex.
Platform Odpowiedzialnybiznes69
Platform Asbiznesu70
Platform Odpowiedzialne71
WMcentrum-CSR 72
CSR.Haus 73
SOB.underline74
Platform odpowiedzialna firma75
CSR.bcc76
CRnavigator77
Competitions ex. on the best examples of cooperation with business partners.
Social campaigns.
Conferences, seminars, meetings.
Actions.
66
http://csr.fob.org.pl/wazne-informacje.html 67
http://sendzimir.org.pl/en/textbook 68
sample newspaper supplement: http://projects.mediaplanet.com/poland/csr_5_5_6350/kompendium_csr__dgp__grudzien_2010.pdf 69
http://www.odpowiedzialnybiznes.com.pl/; http://www.odpowiedzialnybiznes.edu.pl/ 70
http://www.asbiznesu.pl/ 71
http://www.odpowiedzialne.pl/ 72
http://www.wmcentrum-csr.net/ 73
http://www.csr.haus.pl/ 74
http://sob.underline.pl/ 75
http://www.odpowiedzialnafirma.pl/ 76
http://csr.bcc.org.pl/ 77
http://www.crnavigator.com/
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 51/133
SLOVENIA
In Slovenia we could not find any training offers within the CSR area in the formal
education options, no training tools and no training materials. Therefore, no target
groups have been addressed.
It is important to mention a project, carried out in 2007 “CSR – an opportunity for
SMEs”, but no training options or material have been found. Most likely when the project
was finished there was not any maintenance of the activities.
SPAIN
On the other hand, apart from CSR classic training literature, a wider offer of CSR
training tools can be found in order to involve SMEs on CSR issues:
CSR guides:
Guide for the implementation of the CSR in the enterprise. Izaite (Association of
Basque companies for sustainability)78.
Guide for the implementation of the CSR in the SME79.
Corporate Social Responsibility Guide for SMEs: “Corporate Social Responsibility
Observatory” and “El Monte Foundation”.
Environmental awareness for SMEs in Navarra80. Guide for the elaboration of diagnosis on CSR for SMEs in Navarra81. Methodology guide for implementation of action plans on CSR in SMEs in
Navarra82.
At European level:
Guide for an effective communication for SMEs: European Commission
Introduction of CSR to SMEs: European Commission
Report of the round table on “Fostering CSR among SMEs: European
Multistakeholder Forum on CSR
Analysis of good practices:
Catalogue of Good Practices on CSR. Excellence Club83.
At European level:
78
Izaite: http://www.izaite.net/docs/guiarse.pdf 79
http://www.clubsostenibilidad.org/f_publicaciones/smes.swf 80
http://guiaderecursos.crana.org/directorio/detalle.php?ob=1&id=586 81
http://www.navarra.es/NR/rdonlyres/A8657C74-45D7-4445-B12A-482B3EEF66DE/157643/GUIADIAGNOSTICOSRSE.pdf 82
http://www.crana.org/ficheros/File/GestionAmbiental_RSE/Documentacion/Publicaciones_crana/Metodologia_innovarse/E3-RSE_Guia_Planes_Actuacion_InnovaRSE.pdf 83
http://www.clubsostenibilidad.org/f_publicaciones/best_practices.pdf
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 52/133
Compilation of good practices on CSR among SMEs in Europe: European
Commission
Compilation of CSR good practices: European Commission
CSR and Competitiveness; European SMEs’ Good Practice: Ikei Research &
Consultancy. Project funded by “Mainstreaming Corporate Social Responsibility
(CSR) among SMEs” Program.
Awareness questionnaire:
At European level: Responsible Companies: European Commission
Websites of interest:
xertatu:adi Methodology for the continuous improvement on CSR84.
This methodology includes different tools to help and support enterprises to
integrate CSR within their organizations.
e-RESPYME: Programmed Learning System to provide the necessary knowledge
and tools for the implementation of an Ethical and Socially Responsible System
adapted to SMEs. This system is based on the standard SGE 21: 200585.
VADEREGIO – CSR in action in the regions: a website integrating diverse tools in
order to promote CSR within in organizations86.
Red Pacto Mundial España – Spanish Global Compact Network: This network
enables different tools for the development of CSR: Conferences, seminars,
presentations, work groups…87:
Web for the diagnosis of CSR on SMEs, by the Spanish Asociation of Accountancy
and Business Management (AECA)88.
Bank’s involvement: Caja Navarra – Civic Bank: support for SMEs as for CSR89. Gubernamental Support: The support of the Spanish Gobernment to SME son
CSR: This support is a funding support as for advisory, training…90.
Both guides and reports on good practices, try to give a support to SMEs as for the
implementation of CSR within the organizations. In this sense, the contains of these tools
focus mainly on tips and information on methodologies for a good integration of CSR. The
following areas are covered:
Social entrepreneurship
Competitiveness and responsible innovation in products and services
Dialogue with stakeholders
Talent management and work-life balance
Corporate Governance and ethical management
84
http://www.xertatu.net/ca_plantilla.asp?idMenu=21 85
http://www.respyme.es/formacion/newsletters-1-esp.pdf 86
http://www.csrvaderegio.net/en/homepage/index_en.asp 87
http://www.pactomundial.org/index.asp?MP=5&MS=10&MN=1 88
http://www.compromisorse.com/rse/2010/07/02/la-aeca-pone-los-informes-de-rsc-al-alcance-de-las-pymes/ 89
http://www.compromisorse.com/best-practice/competitividad-e-innovacion-responsable/caja-navarra/ayuda-a-los-clientes-
pymes-a-elaborar-sus-memorias-de-rc/ 90
http://www.ipyme.org/es-ES/SubvencionesAyudas/RSE/Paginas/ResponsabilidadSocialEmpresa_Ficha.aspx
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 53/133
Equal opportunities for groups with special needs
Environmental preservation and improvement
Corporate volunteering
As for the segments covered by these contains, the following are highlighted:
Community neighbors and civil society
Markets: potential customers and current customers
Suppliers and partners
Public administration
Environment – Planet
Current employees and potential employees
2.3.2. Target groups addressed by training offer
As for the target groups addressed by the analyzed training offer, it can be said that
even if the contents could be useful for SMEs, they have not been specifically develop to
SMEs. In this sense, these resources are open to a wide kind of profiles.
AUSTRIA
In general, all the described tools are useful for SMEs or even explicitly targeted to them.
The “Sustainable Business Planner” aims more at start-up companies and initiatives and
all those that are in need of a structured business plan (tool) that considers sustainable
development.
The “Complete CSR Toolkit” refers as well to beginners and CSR professionals who need
an instrument to optimise measures, for reporting or communication, and also for those
who don‟t want to invest in personal CSR consulting.
BULGARIA
N/A
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 54/133
LITHUANIA
Such target groups addressed by above-mentioned training offer are not particular, but
just potential business leaders and representatives, and as a result, these teachings do
not bring immediate benefits to SMEs, since not all students that have received this
practice will work in the areas of their profession in the future.
POLAND
Target group made by wide spectrum of interested people: business sector
representatives, workers, consumers, suppliers, students, nongovernmental workers,
local communities.
SPAIN
Generally, these tools are open for all kind of profiles, focusing mainly on managers and
technicians from SMEs that want to learn about CSR in order to integrate CSR initiatives
within the organization.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 55/133
3. Country specific analysis of needs of competences on
CSR from SMEs’ and VET institutions’ perspective
3.1. SMEs’ perspective in each country
The following part of the report includes the analysis carried out by each partner country,
as for the SMEs‟ perspective and identified needs related to CSR issues. Do they
implement any CSR strategy? Do they have the necessary competence or do they need
any special training?
In order to get direct information from SMEs, more than 800 questionnaires were
distributed within the participant countries in the Consortium. However, due to a low
response rate, just 46 surveys have been received and completed.
As for the profile of respondents, we can summarize the main characteristics as follows:
Almost the 50% of the companies are medium companies, with more than 50 employees.
As well as this, the 33% had a turnover of less than 500.000€ during last year, another
33% between 500.000€ and 5.000.000€, while the last 33% had a turnover than more
than 5.000.000€.
Number of workers: Estimated turnover (latest financial year)
The main activity of these SMEs is quite different, as it is specified in each country
analysis:
AUSTRIA
The survey includes a total of 9 enterprises, whereby one SME has less than 10
employees, three have between 10 and 50 employees and five companies have between
50 and 250 employees. Also five of 9 companies have an annual turnover of more than 5
million Euro, and three companies have an turnover between 500.000 and 5.000.000
Euro. All companies are working in different industry sectors, whereby the following are
involved:
< 10
10 < x < 50
50 < x < 250
< 500.000€
500.000€ < x < 5.000.000€
> 5.000.000€
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 56/133
Brewery
Construction
Environmental Services
Health
Metal/Glass/Wood
Printing
Recycling
Software
Telecommunication
BULGARIA
The questionnaire prepared was translated and distributed among 10 enterprises from
different economic branches – hotels (3 firms), paper production, transport (2), trade
(catering), electrical installation, consulting. Part of the selection was based on previous
experience of working on CSR issues with these enterprises (6 firms). The benefits from
such selection are that the companies were (i) aware what is CSR, (ii) engaged in the
issues of CSR, (iii) have been encouraged to develop and implement social and
environmental measures to improve the economic performance, (iv) not reluctant to
participate in CSR-related exercises.
The specificity of management of enterprises in Bulgaria especially of small and medium
enterprises is that the owners in most cases are also the top managers. Most of them
have not any training in management and business. They have accumulated their
experience in the conditions of planned economy (but are working in a market economy).
The most frequent manner of management is the paternalistic one. At a certain point of
development of the company this manner has exhausted its leverages. The
owners/managers feel that but do not know what to do next. This is the reason why they
are open to suggestions and new ideas from outside which provide new perspective and
new management tools.
The geographical coverage of the survey includes the capital Sofia where 4 of the
enterprises have their headquarters, 4 enterprises operate in the two biggest ports of
Bulgaria – Varna and Bourgas and two companies are from small towns in the North-East
and Central Bulgaria.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 57/133
Figure 2. Geographical coverage of the survey
Half of the companies (5) were with turnover less than 500,000 Euro. Three companies
had turnover during the last financial year between 500,000 and 5,000,000 Euro, one
company has a turnover over 5 million Euro and one company did not report its turnover.
Three of the companies are micro-enterprises with number of staff less than 10 persons,
two are small enterprises – less than 50 personnel and 6 are medium enterprises having
staff more than 50 persons.
LITHUANIA
In the case of SMEs there are 9 enterprises from various sectors of industrial activities
such as manufacture of soft drinks, electrical installation and manufacture of electricity
distribution and control apparatus, manufacture of plastic goods, wastewater purification
and soil remediation, manufacture and central supply of heat and hot water (2
representatives), manufacture of biofuel (2 representatives either) as well as
manufacture of industrial gases. Ir order to get more presentable results, one company
was chosen not from industrial area, but from service sector with activities of sale,
maintenance and repair of motorcycles and related parts and accessories.
The detailed list of the participants in SMEs survey are presented in the table 1.
8 of the 10 companies interviewed have from 50 to 250 employees, only 2 remaining
companies have from 10 to 50 (i.e. JSC „Simatika“) and less than 10 employees (i.e. JSC
„Kylis“). Almost half (4 of 10) of the companies declared their turnover during latest
financial year as more than 5 000 000 EUR, 3 companies - from 500 000 to 5 000 000
4 enterprises
1 enterprise
4 enterprises
1 enterprise
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 58/133
EUR, 2 remaining companies - less than 500 000 EUR. One enterprise didn„t refered to
this clause at all.
Table 1. List of the participants in SMEs survey.
No. Name and the position of
the person interviewed
Name of the
organization
Sector of activity of the
organization Contact data
1.
Mr. Algimantas, chief engineer, the member of management for environmental and industrial safety
JSC "Selita & Co" 11.07 Manufacture of soft drinks; production of mineral waters and other bottled waters
V. Kreves pr. 118, LT-50313 Kaunas; +370 37 352020
2. Voldemaras Vilkas, project manager
JSC "Simatika"
43.21 Electrical installation 27.12 Manufacture of electricity distribution and control apparatus
P.Cvirkos str. 65A-34, LT-77159 Siauliai; +370 41 502226, +370 41 526519
3. Vita Matuliene, jurist, quality manager
JSC "Maksima" 22.22 Manufacture of plastic packing goods
Palemono str. 1b, LT-52159 Kaunas; +370 37 373030
4.
A. Binkauskas, the manager of the Department
JSC "Orlen Lietuva", Department of purification
37.00 Sewerage 39.00 Remediation activities and other waste management services (Wastewater purification, petrolic mud and soil remediation )
Juodeikiai, LT-89467 Mazeikiai district; +370 44 392121
5.
Edmontas Kripas,
the manager of manufacturing technical service
JSC "Mazeikiu silumos tinklai" (The heat system of Mazeikiai)
35.30 Steam and air conditioning supply (Manufacture and central supply of heat and hot water)
Ventos str. 31b, LT-89141 Mazeikiai; +370 44 365436
6.
Inga Dasevskiene, financier
JSC "Kylis"
45.40 Sale, maintenance and repair of motorcycles and related parts and accessories
Kanapiu str. 16, LT-78138 Siauliai; +370 41 52249
7.
Dovile Lileikyte, specialist of environment protection, manager
JSC „Bionovus“
19.20 Manufacture of refined petroleum products (Manufacture of biofuel from wood) 38.32 Recovery of sorted materials (Reprocessing of construction and destruction wastes)
Smolensko str. 12, LT-03201 Vilnius; +370 85 2394930
8.
Tomas Noreika, head of the storehouses
JSC „Mestilla“
19.20 Manufacture of refined petroleum products
Kretainio str. 5, LT-94103 Klaipeda;
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 59/133
(Manufacture of liquid and gaseous biofuel from rapeseed oil)
tel. +370 46 416230
9.
Loreta Griciuniene, engineer for industrial safety, ecologist
JSC „Silutes silumos tinklai“ (The heat system of Silute)
35.30 Steam and air conditioning supply (Manufacture and central supply of heat and hot water)
Klaipeda str. 6a, LT-99116 Silute; +370 441 62148
10.
Alvidas Lileikis, technical director
"Gaschema", subsidiary company of JSC "Achema"
20.11 Manufacture of industrial gases (Manufacture of technical gases, carbonic acid and urea solution “AdBlue”)
Jonalaukis, LT-55551 Jonava district; +370 349 56845, +370 349 56168
POLAND
Unfortunately not many SME which cooperate on CSR issues with other organizations are
engaged in Social Responsibility or Ethics in Business. On one hand, availability of
information and services in support of the issue make great potential (among others,
concealing, trainings, seminars, publications and press articles), on the other, SME
interest in such support is still not sufficient. It may by due to the fact, that in most
cases Enterprises are not familiar with CSR, and not knowing their needs for such
support. Additionally, the majority of SME do not plan in advance and do not prepare
Enterprise Development Strategy. What is more, they do not have free human resources,
which could be engaged in complex way in development of business competencies in CSR
and prepare action strategies adjusted to individual necessities.
SLOVENIA
In Slovenia we have distributed 20 questionnaires to the SMEs and have received 5
replies of which 3 are micro companies with less than 10 employees.
SPAIN
An interview for SMEs in Spain was designed and translated into Spanish, and after that,
disseminated throughout a wide selection of companies In Spain. The list of companies
contacted exceeded 500, however, the response rate has been very low. The reasons for
that low response level are, among others:
Lack of interest of SMEs on SR.
Lack of knowledge of the contacted staff on SR. In most SMEs the SR issues are
directly managed by the top management. It has been impossible in many cases
to contact the top management staff.
Lack of incentives to invest time on the questionnaire filling.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 60/133
In spite of all the efforts done to come up with a short, easy to fill questionnaire,
some companies looked at it as hard and time consuming.
Among all the companies contacted, we managed to get 11 positive responses. The
results hereafter are extracted from the analysis performed on these surveys. The
questionnaire for SMEs can be found in Annexe 1.
The sample of companies analyzed show the following distribution according to size,
activity and geographical area.
Size
Medium size 5 45%
Small size 6 55%
Activity
Renewables 2 18%
Food 2 18%
Construction 1 9%
Logistics 1 9%
Development 5 45%
Traditional segment 4 36%
Innovation segment 7 64%
Geographical area
Aragón 8 73%
Others 3 27%
45%
55%
Sample by company size
Medium
Small
27%
55%
18%
Sample by turnover
< 500.000€ 500.000€ < x < 5.000.000€ > 5.000.000€
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 61/133
The innovation segment is the largest in the sample, including companies in the
Renewable Energy sector and the R&D sector, while the traditional segment is
represented by logistic, construction and food companies. The latter is mainly made up of
medium size companies while the innovative ones are all small companies with lower
turnover and lower number of employees.
3.1.1. Current practices for integrating CSR - Survey and
interview results
This part of the report tries to analyse the current practices carried out by consulted
SMEs in order to identify their needs and make some recommendations at the end of the
analysis.
First of all, three quarters of the consulted SMEs claim to have an Environmental
Protection policy. However, in the case of Human Resource Development policy, this
percentage descends to a 54%, being lower in the case of SMEs that have a Social
Responsibility policy; less than the 50% (the 48%) claims to have a CSR policy.
Does the company
have a Human
Resource
Development policy?
Does the company have
an Environment
Protection policy?
Does the company have a
Social Responsibility policy?
In accordance with this, the 40% of the respondent SMEs are certified by ISO 14001,
and the 35% is certified by ISO 9001. The 10% has the OHSAS 18001 certification.
18%
18%
9%9%
46%
sample by company activity
Renewables
Food
Construction
Logistics
Development
Yes 54%
No46%
Yes 76%
No24%
Yes 48%
No52%
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 62/133
Is the company certified or working according to any of the following
standards?
As well as this, more than half of the SMEs see CSR as one of the priorities of the
company.
Is social responsibility a priority area in your company?
Almost 50% of the companies have conducted any environmental audit within their own
company, in contrast to the 37% of SMEs that have not conducted any. The 21% has
conducted as well a social audit.
02468
101214161820
Yes
No
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 63/133
Does the company conduct any audits?
As for the question about what Social Responsibility means for SMEs, investing in the
human resources, investing in occupational health and safety and taking care of
environmental issues are the answers more repeated. Observing human rights and
charity are CSR related concepts for SMEs as well.
What do you understand by “Social Responsibility”?
It is important to highlight that almost the 50% of the consulted SMEs have carried out
social responsibility initiatives within the company, while the 35% has not carried out any
kind of CSR activities. The 30% has developed activities related to the local community
and the 15% in the supply chain.
0
5
10
15
20
25
Environmental audit in our own
company
Environmental audit in the supply chain
Social audit in our own company
Social audit in the supply chain
No
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
Investing in the human
resources
Investing in occupational health and
safety
Observing human rights
Taking care of environmental
issues
Charity (donations)
Funding and contribution of
local associations
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 64/133
Does the company carry out initiatives for social responsibility?
If the company claims carrying out initiatives for social responsibility, almost the 80% of
them integrate this kind of activities in a management planning of the company.
Moreover, these initiatives are developed under the charge of a specifically assigned
person for CSR activities. In other 30% of the cases, this role is carried out by the same
responsible person or department for environmental protection, while in the 25% of the
cases it is the human resource department who is responsible for that. Just in the 15% of
the SMEs is the top management directly involved.
Are these initiatives
integrated in any
management planning?
If the answer is yes, who is the person in charge
for that?
0
5
10
15
20
25
Within the company
In the supply chain In the local community
No
Yes
No
There is a specially assigned
person for Corporate
Social Responsibility.
30%
This role is included in the Human Resource
Development department.
25%
This role is carried out by
the responsible
person/department for
Environmental Protection.
30%
This role is carried out by
Top Management
15%
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 65/133
The 41% of the SMEs carry out CSR activities due to company‟s awareness and ethical
consciousness, while the 24% do it due to market reasons. Just the 15% says having
developed CSR initiatives forced by clients‟ requirements.
Why does the company carry out these social responsibility initiatives?
Between 37% and the 35% of SMEs claim to have carried out initiatives related to
community involvement, labour practices and environment, while in the case of “fair
operating practices” the percentage reduces to 22% of SMEs.
Which areas of social responsibility are these initiatives related to?
From the 35% of SMEs that have not carried out any CSR initiative, the 56% do not do it
due to lack of time and human resources. In the case of the 25% of SMEs, it is a
consequence of lack of top management commitment and lack of know-how. Just one of
the SMEs that has not carried out any CSR initiative justify due to the fact that Social
Responsibility does not bring competitive advantage.
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
Market reasons Clients’ requirements Awareness and ethical consciousness
02468
1012141618
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 66/133
If the answer is “NO”, why does the company not carry out social responsibility
initiatives?
However, it is very high the number of SMEs that are intended to work on CSR issues, as
it is represented by the following graph:
Has the company considered working on social responsibility issues?
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 67/133
Almost the 30% of SMEs has done any training on CSR; in the 54% of these cases, this
training was aimed at all employees.
Has the company done any training on
social responsibility? Who was the training aimed at?
As for the conducted training, it was developed internally; on one hand, based on own
knowledge, and on the other hand, supported by external experts. Just in the 25% of
cases the training was organized externally:
According to the answers, almost the 100% of SMEs that attended the training (93%)
would recommend this kind of courses to other companies.
ISO 26000 principles: How relevant do you judge the following principles for
your company?
Yes
No
Yes
No
Management All employees
Internal, based on own knowledge
Internal, with external experts
External
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 68/133
“Respect for the rule of law”, “respect for human rights” and “ethical behaviour” are the
principles considered as the most relevant by the SMEs, with a punctuation of 3.73, 3.64
and 3.64 respectively (out of 4). However all principles are considered very relevant, as
the least relevant, “respect for stakeholder interests” obtains a 3.41, as the lowest value.
The average of all principles is of 3.53 out of 4, which is quite high.
The 67% of the consulted SMEs have pointed out the main stakeholders, involving them
in the following way:
- The 65% of SMEs that claims to have pointed out its main stakeholders, has
informed them about the company‟s CSR efforts.
- The 39% has involved them in developing CSR strategies.
- The 35% has engaged them in carrying out the company‟s CSR initiatives.
- The 30% of the SMEs, although having pointed out its main stakeholders, they
have not involved nor informed them.
Has the company pointed out the main stakeholders?
3.25
3.30
3.35
3.40
3.45
3.50
3.55
3.60
3.65
3.70
3.75
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 70/133
If the answer is “YES”, are the stakeholders....
The following analysis focus on the SMEs situation in each country:
AUSTRIA
Regarding the analysis of corporate policies, 8 of 9 companies indicate to have as well a
Human resource development policy, an Environment Protection policy and a Social
Responsibility policy. Only one of 9 companies doesn‟t have a HR development,
Environment protection or SR policy.
The SMEs‟ understanding of “social responsibility” is very similar: for all companies it‟s
investing in occupational health and safety and taking care of environmental issues; 8 of
9 also think it‟s investing in human resources. Five SMEs also mentioned that it‟s an
observation of human rights, and four also understand charity/donations as SR. One
company mentioned also fairness and transparency against clients/suppliers/business
partners; another mentioned regional commitments and a third one mentioned that SR is
comprehensive and includes also fighting fraud and corruption.
All 9 companies indicated that SR is a priority area in their company. Reasons therefore
are mainly internal motivations: it‟s important for a good quality of their work, good
cooperation is good for the working climate, it helps to develop and support personal
skills and it‟s a condition for long-term success.
More than half of the companies (5 of 9) are certified according to ISO 14001, one third
has EMAS and ÖKOPROFIT®, and two SMEs have ISO 9001. Each one SME has the
following certifications or standards: Entsorgungsfachbetrieb (EfB; waste management
company), Sozialgütesiegel (Social Label), Investor in People, Best Health Austria, FSC
and PEFC, ISO 12647-2, Österreichisches Umweltzeichen (Austrian Eco-label). One
company is planning to implement OHSAS 18001.
Concerning audits, more than half (5 of 9) conduct environmental audits as well in the
own company and in the supply chain. This is conform with the companies that have ISO
0
5
10
15
20
25
Involved in developing CSR
strategies
Engaged in carrying out the company’s CSR
initiatives
Informed about the company’s CSR
efforts
Not involved or informed
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 71/133
14001. Only one respondent conducts a social audit in its own company. One respondent
does not conduct any audits.
Nearly all companies are implementing social responsibility initiatives, only one company
does not. Two third of the respondents are carrying out SR initiatives within the
company, more than half of them (5 of 9) is active in the local community, and 4 of 9
engage in SR measures in the supply chain.
In each of the eight companies, that are implementing SR, these initiatives are
integrated in management planning. In two cases, the managing directors are in charge
of this planning. In each two cases, this role is included in the Human Resource
Development department and in the Environmental Protection department. Two
companies have a specially assigned person for CSR, whereby in one of these
organisations this person is responsible together with the environmental officer of this
company.
Only one company does not carry out SR initiatives, the reasons therefore are lack of
know-how and lack of time and human resources.
For most companies the motivation to carry out SR initiatives is awareness and ethical
consciousness (6 of 9). One SME also mentioned clients‟ requirements as a reason to be
engaged. The main fields of the activities are related to the environment (7 of 9) and
community involvement and development (6 of 9). More than half of the companies (5 of
9) implemented initiatives in the field of organisational governance and fair operating
practices. Other initiatives are concerning consumer issues (4 of 9), labour practices (3 of
9), and human rights (2 of 9). One company indicated that SR initiatives are an integral
part of the company policy.
Most of the SMEs (7 of 9) considered working on social responsibility, whereby one
company wants to engage in SR in daily business but not within projects.
Also 7 of 9 companies have done a training on SR, only two have never done so. In 5 of
7 cases the management was the target group. In each one case the training was aimed
at internal experts and selected persons (Sustainability Officer and Environmental
Officer), and one training was aimed at all employees.
Most of the respondents (6 of 7) indicated that their training was internal with external
experts, three companies did their trainings external, and two had an internal training,
based on own knowledge. All of those who had conducted a training (7 of 9) would
recommend it also to other companies. Reasons therefore, mentioned by two
Managing Director25.0%
CSR officer12.5%
CSR officer + Environmental officer
12.5%
HR Department25.0%
Environmental department
25.0%
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 72/133
respondents, are because it‟s valuated very important for the development of a
company, and it supports them in attaining competences also in other areas.
Concerning the relevance of SR principles, the average values are as follows:
Table 4: Relevance of SR principles – Average values (from 9 SMEs)
PRINCIPLES How relevant are these principles for the
organization? (1-it is not relevant; 4- 100% relevant)
1. Accountability 2.78
2. Transparency 3.56
3. Ethical behavior 3.78
4. Respect for stakeholder interests 3.67
5. Respect for the rule of law 3.11
6. Respect for international norms of behaviour 2.44
7. Respect for human rights 3.11
Ethical behaviour is judged most important (3.78 on average) which corresponds with
the motivation for SR initiatives, where awareness and ethical consciousness was the
main reason. It is followed by respect for stakeholder interests and transparency,
whereas accountability (2.78) and respect for international norms of behaviour (2.44) are
judged less important. The reason therefore might be that SMEs don‟t operate as much
on international level and these principles might be seen more relevant by large-sized
companies.
Most of the companies (8 of 9) have pointed out their relevant stakeholders, whereby all
of them inform their stakeholders about their CSR efforts, six companies involve them in
developing CSR strategies and five have stakeholders engaged in carrying out SR
initiatives.
BULGARIA
The results from the survey should be interpreted bearing in mind that more than half of
the companies have been involved in awareness raising trainings as well as in
assessment exercises on CSR.
In table 2 are summarized the answers to the questions related to policy making.
Table 2 Availability of policies on social and environmental issues
Answers Human Resource
Development policy
Environment Protection
policy
Social Responsibility
policy
Yes 6 7 6
No 4 3 4
Most of the companies declare that they have a policy for development of their human
resources, for protection of the environment and for being social responsible. That
probably is true if a non-written policy is envisaged.
Figure 2 shows what the companies understand under „social responsibility‟. In „Others‟
an answer of a company which stated „sustainable economic development‟ is included.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 73/133
Figure 2. Understanding of „social responsibility‟
The opinion of the companies on whether “social responsibility” should be a priority has
split in half. Only one company has declared that the global financial and economic crisis
is the reason for “social responsibility” not being a priority.
Regarding the socially responsible management only 2 companies have ISO 9001 – the
requirements for the implementation of quality management systems, and 1 has
implemented OHSAS18001 – for implementation of OH&S management system.
Half of the enterprises (5) have not conducted any audits related to social responsibility
and all the companies have not checked whether companies in their supply chain behave
responsibly. Two of the companies have conducted both social and environmental audits.
Approximately the same is the situation with carrying out socially responsible initiatives –
4 companies did not carry out any socially responsible initiative at all and all the
companies did not carry out such initiatives within their supply chain. The most attractive
fields for demonstrating socially responsible behavior were the company itself and the
community in which it operates. The whole variety of reasons is quoted for not doing that
– lack of resources (3), lack of top management commitment lack of know-how (2),
expensiveness (1), no economic benefit (1).
One of the main issues of implementing the CSR concept in the operations of an
enterprise is the lack of fully fledged strategy and of specially assigned person to do that.
3 of the companies did not respond to the question whether they have integrated CSR
measures in their planning and 1 has responded that they did not. Moreover two of the
companies have replied that CSR is responsibility of several persons or is part of every
activity which is a sign that the CSR issue is not a priority of itself. Only two of the
enterprises have integrated the CSR responsibility in the job description of the HR
specialist and two have responded that there is an official planning of the responsible
behavior.
From the companies who stated that they are planning the CSR initiatives in their
operation – 3 are doing this either due to market reasons or awareness and ethical
concerns and 2 are following client‟s requests.
What is Social Responsibility?
HR investment
OSH investment
human rights
environment
charity
others
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 74/133
Almost half of the companies (4) did not state what is their notion for social
responsibility. Approximately the same number (3-4) identified human rights, labour
practices, environment and community involvement as elements of CSR. The
organizational governance, fair operating practices, consumer issues and charity were
accepted as socially responsible domains by only one of the companies.
The optimistic note is that 80% of the companies are considering to work on the issues of
social responsibility. But only 3 enterprises have done training where the target group
was the management and some selected persons.
Another optimistic note is that the 10 companies evaluate very high the different aspects
of corporate social responsibility – from 3.0 (transparency) to 3.8 (respect for the rule of
law and respect for human rights) – see fig.3.
Figure 3. Interest and potentiality on Corporate Social Responsibility
DENMARK
For a large part of the SMV´s in Denmark, CSR is not an integrated part of the
company‟s business strategy and there is no governance model to support
implementation of CSR throughout the organization. CSR takes its point of departure in
3.5
3.03.3 3.4
3.83.5
3.8
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
Interest and potentiality on CSR
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 75/133
values and a “do good culture based on a sound ethical foundation”. The CSR activities
are often based on ad hoc activities and the SME´s internal guidelines for good practise.
The activities are often related to one “fiery soul” whereas companies with a more
structured approach to CSR also encompass a person specially assigned for the CSR-
responsibility. When focus on CSR grows, a slightly more strategic and thereby
systematic approach to the CSR-work can be seen in the SME‟s, including a better
understanding of the overall pamphlet of CSR-issues and the opportunities it can bring to
the company.
The SME´s characterised by ad hoc activities rarely have any CSR-policies but typically
address environmental issues, governmental regulations, quality, LCA and charity. The
companies with a more systematic approach have developed Environmental and Human
Resource policies and understand CSR as more than as just philanthropy. Furthermore
these might have a few ISO-certifications including audit procedures and some are
signatory to the UNGC. In addition, that stakeholders are pointed out and some
(employees) are involved in the development of the CSR- strategy and policies.
The CSR-initiatives carried out are mainly within the company for both groups (ad hoc
and systematic approach) of SME´s. The SME´s with a more systematic approach to CSR
also have some sort of CSR-training for employees conducted by the CSR-responsible
person. Other companies define their approach as being “careful” and as “building good
relations”. Both groups find the principles of social responsibility very relevant.
LITHUANIA
The section of the survey on current practices for integrating social responsibility in the
company started with the question: “Does the company have a Human Resource
development policy?”. Only 4 from all the respondents stated positively. Contrary, the
answers to the second question about Environment Protection policy of the companies,
attained positive answers from all the respondents. However, in the case of social
responsibility policy, the companies were even more unfavourably. Only 4 enterprises
stated they have such policy.
The question: “What do you understand by “Social Responsibility?” attained the following
results: 6 companies understand this term as investing in occupational health and safety
as well as in observing human rights, 5 respondents mentioned investing in the human
resources and taking care of environmental issues. Even 3 respondents marked all the
four statements. Only one company was unable to name CSR areas at all. It is
interesting that no one of the interviewees realize social responsibility as charity
activities. This perception definetely represents the growth in accurate knowledge and
deeper understanding about CSR in Lithuanian SMEs.
The next question was about social responsibility as a priority area in the company. In
this case, half of the respondents said “no”. The interviewee Mr. Algimantas from JSC
“Selita & Co” conflicted that the priority of the company is the highest quality of the
production. From the 5 remaining companies 1 respondent didn‟t answer this question at
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 76/133
all. Only two enterprises that replied positively added more comprehensive comments.
Mr. Vilkas from JSC “Simatika” said that the basic resources of the company are
employees. Mrs. Matuliene from JSC “Maksima” stressed that company seeks to work
responsible against society and environment, to ensure safe and healthy working
conditions and social guarantees.
The most popular standards identified within the enterprises are ISO 14001, ISO 9001
and OHSAS 18001. 4 companies from 10 interviewees stated that they are working on
both ISO standards, 3 interviewees - certified according to all of them. 3 respondents
noted their companies didn„t work according any standards. In the case of audits, the
majority (8 enterprises from 10) of companies stated the environmental audit within the
company. No one interviewee noted any social audits.
4 companies revealed they carry out social responsibility initiatives within the enterprise,
whereas 2 companies spread them across the supply chain. The majority of 4 above-
mentioned enterprises have integrated these initiatives in their management planning.
Every respondent from those social responsibility initiating companies declares that they
carry out these social responsibility initiatives due to awareness and ethical
consciousness of the company, with some exceptions related to the market reasons.
These initiatives are especially strongly related with such areas of social responsibility as
human rights and labour practices.
Respondents from those enterprises, which stated as not carrying out social responsibility
initiatives, mainly emphasized the lack of top management commitment as well as lack
of know-know. However, it seems that Mr. Noreika from JSC „Mestilla“ most correctly
remarked the current CSR situation in Lithuania. He stated that there is a lack of
information about social responsibility in general and its profit for company and
employees. Whereas Mr. Lileikis from “Gaschema” agreed that the concept of CSR is
quite new and company„s activities are still not oriented towards it.
The answers to the summarizing question “Has the company considered working on
social responsibility issues” were highly surprisingly. Despite all the above-mentioned
lacks and uncertainties, the majority of respondents - even 7 companies from 10 pointed
positively.
The analysis of the answers about training on social responsibility in companies was
really disappointing. Only one company - JSC “Selita & Co” have had some experience in
such trainings. This training was external and aimed at some selected persons, the staff
of marketing and administration departments to be precised. However, Mr. Algimantas
was highly dissatisfied about this training, therefore the company will never recommend
it to other enterprises. He said that training gave only general information without any
factual reasoning. According to Mr. Algimantas, such trainings could only turn off
company from further CSR implementation instead of promotion of CSR activities.
POLAND
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 77/133
No single, complete document concerning the practices for integrating CSR in SME is
available in Poland. It may result from the fact that SMEs are less effective in
communicating their activity than large companies. Thus, many actions and initiatives
organised by SME sector is difficult to identify, especially as most of Polish SMEs do not
apply the definition of CSR and do not consider their activity as a part of CSR context.
The examples presented below were described in the brochure titled “Corporate Social
Responsibility of SMEs, practical examples of enhancing the SME sector‟s
competitiveness91.
Employee-oriented CSR initiatives
MELBUD Ltd., medium enterprise operating in construction sector introduced the
social fund aimed at financing cultural, educational and sport activities of its
employees or Christmas/Easter gift vouchers. The best employees may be given a
loan, which may be partially remitted. The employees have a strong feeling of job
stabilisation and corporate identity. These factors foster better work atmosphere
and involvement.
Society-oriented CSR initiatives
Small PR agency – “Toolbox Creative Communications (TCC)” offers free-of-
charge PR services (such as contacts with mass media, organisation of press
conferences, web-site creation or cooperation with journalists) to NGOs operating in
aid of Polish-Jewish dialogue by means of promoting cultural diversity and
enhancing tolerance by education. The company established cooperational relations
and gained new customers. Moreover, a few press releases concerning the CSR
activities were published on PR&Marketing web-sites.
Market-oriented CSR initiatives
DEANTE Antczak Sp.J., medium enterprise selling wholesale kitchen and
bathroom products, introduced 7-year warranty on their products – longer than
regular warranty available on the market. What is more, customers are offered
current, effective and free-of-charge technical and warranty service. Due to the
good image and perception of the company associated with the excellent product
quality, the enterprise gained new customers and reduced staff turnover.
Environment-oriented CSR activities
LUMAG Sp. z o.o., medium enterprise, operating in automotive sector, not only
manage waste from company‟s premises, but also collects, stores and processes its
products after their wear and disassembly. Components obtained during recycling
may be applied as material for production of new elements for braking systems.
Moreover, the company has never applied asbestos in the production processes,
and formulas developed in the company‟s lab do not include any heavy metal
91
The examples presented were described in the brochure titled “Corporate Social Responsibility of SMEs, practical examples
of enhancing the SME sector’s competitiveness http://www.csr-in-smes.eu/downloads/brochure_poland.pdf.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 78/133
compounds, which may pose a threat to environment and vehicle users. The
enterprise won good reputation among local society and it is perceived as honest
and flourishing business.
Other examples from Guidebook for SMEs, Balanced Business92
Talens (Polska), company operating in wood industry producing articles for artists
– due to the initiative of the owner of the company and its financial resources the
non-public secondary art school was opened offering free-of-charge education.
Annually ca. 30 children from the Bieszczady region will have the opportunity to
start art education. The school and its students are occasionally supported by the
company‟s business partners (e.g. journey organisation), group of artists
cooperating with the company, as well as local authorities.
Firma Meblik (Polska), the producer of children furniture took part in activities of
Polish Humanitarian Organisation in south Sudan. The company financed the well
construction by PHO, which will supply more than 1000 people with water. The
following example shows that partnership with NGO incorporates SMEs in resolving
global problems93.
SLOVENIA
All the companies questioned have Environmental protection policy, while only 1 micro
company, presenting 20 % has a Human Resource development policy. 60 % (3
companies) also have a Social responsibility policy.
Companies understand the term “Social Responsibility” in a very different ways. From
only investing in human resources (1 company only) to broader sense, including
occupational health and safety, human rights, take care of the environment, and charity
as answered by 2 companies. To sum up, companies mostly understand SR as investing
in the human resources, investing in the occupational health and safety, and taking care
of environmental issues.
80 % of the companies questioned claimed that SR is not a priority area. The main
problems in Slovenia are consequences of the financial crisis which emerged in 2008.
Two sectors that were most negatively influenced by global financial crisis were
construction and industry. Many large companies in above mentioned sectors went into
bankruptcy. Several medium and small enterprises were sub-contractors of these bigger
companies. SMEs will get just a small portion of the receivables from the bankruptcy
procedures. Thus, SMEs have to cut costs on all the areas of their operations. Indeed,
SMEs reduced costs on the areas that do not present their core businesses, such as social
responsibility.
92
http://www.mg.gov.pl/files/upload/7904/podrecznik.pdf 93
More information on www.filantropia.org.pl.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 79/133
60 % of the companies questioned have ISO 14000, one company has ISO 9000 and ISO
17000. Other companies do not have any certificates. 80 % (4 companies) carry out
environmental audits, two of them also in the supply chain. On the other hand, three of
them also carry out social audits. However, none of the companies examined social
issues by the suppliers. Three companies carried out SR initiative in the company and 2
of them in the local community. In 40 % (2 companies) the initiatives are carried out by
responsible person in environmental field or environmental department. Companies
mostly carry out initiatives because of the awareness and ethical reasons (60 %), clients'
requirements (40 %), and market reasons (40 %). Initiatives are related to the
community involvement and development (40 %), environmental issues (40%), and
labour (40%). 2 companies claimed that they are not carrying out the social
responsibility initiatives. Main reasons are: lack of time and human resources and that
there exists no consumer demand.
80 % of the companies questioned have considered working on the SR issues and 2 of
them already went through the training options. The trainings were aimed to all the
employees (in 40 %), management (20 %) and experts (20%). The training was in all
the cases internal, based on companies' knowledge, and they would recommend this
training to other companies as well.
Companies questioned were mostly highly interested in the CSR principles. 80 % of
companies judged respect for the stakeholder interests and respect of the rule of law as
highly relevant issues within their companies. 60 % also judged accountability, ethical
behaviour, respect of international norms of behaviour and respect of human rights. 60
% graded the importance of transparency as modestly important. Furthermore, 2
companies pointed out the main stakeholders are mostly informed about the CSR
activities.
60 % of companies claimed that they are counting on the knowledge and skills to
integrate SR. None of the companies use any training materials/tool for integrating CSR
in their everyday activities. Companies thought that the most useful training material
would be computer/virtual based, followed by text and manuals, and audio. 2 companies
are interested in developing and testing training materials.
SPAIN
In the analyzed sample, 45% of the companies have a Human development and an
environmental protection policy, however, only 27% claim to have a SR policy in place.
This is confirmed by the amount of companies certified by ISO 9001 (45%) and by ISO
14001 (36%).
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 80/133
Main reasons argued not to work on SR are the lack of time and resources (36%), and
the lack of know-how and customer demand (18% each). It is important to notice that
none think management commitment is a reason, as most of the respondents belong to
their companies‟ top management.
A great majority understands by Social Responsibility the investment on human
resources (74%), the environmental care (73%), the contribution to local associations
(64%) and the labour health and safety (64%).
36%
46%
0%0%
0% 0%
0%
0%18%
Sample by standard certification ISO 14001
ISO 9001
OHSAS 18001
SA8000
Global Compact
Ethical Trade Iniciative
BSCI
AA1000
Other, please indicate which one:
0
2 2
4
0
1 1
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
Lack of top management commitment
Lack of customer demand
Lack of know-how
Lack of time and human resources
Social Responsibility
has no economic
benefit
Social Responsibility is expensive
Social Responsibility does not bring
competitive advantage
Sample by reasons for not doing CSR
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 81/133
It is remarkable that, for the survey responders, only 36% see SR as a priority area.
These companies perform social audits within the own company (18%) and
environmental audits (9%). The rest do not perform any audit at all.
No SR initiatives are carried out by 55% of the companies inquired. Among those who
claim to do any SR activity, they are pushed by market reasons (18%), awareness and
ethical consciousness (18%) among others. 36% do them in the own company and 27%
in the local community. These initiatives are mainly related to labour practices (36%),
organizational governance (18%) and community involvement and development (18%)
according to the surveys.
8
7
5
8
3
7
1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Investing in the human resources
Investing in occupational health and
safety
Observing human rights
Taking care of environmental
issues
Charity (donations)
Funding and contribution of
local associations
Others, please indicate:
Sample by CSR definition
1
0
2
0
7
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Environmental audit in our own
company
Environmental audit in the supply chain
Social audit in our own company
Social audit in the supply chain
No
Sample by CSR audits performed
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 82/133
On the other hand, the intention to work on SR is clearly stated by the 55% of
companies who have considered working on SR issues.
The most important outcome of the survey is the overwhelming rate of companies that
have never attended a training on SR, raising up to 91%. The only company that has
promoted and attended such a training is actually involved in the research and promotion
of SR.
2
1
2
3
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
Market reasons Clients’ requirements Awareness and ethical consciousness
Others, please indicate:
Sample by reasons for CSR
4
0
3
6
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Within the company In the supply chain In the local community No (go to question 2.12.)
Sample by kind of CSR activity performed
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 83/133
In terms of the relevance of the 7 SR principles on the inquired people‟s point of view,
they can be seen in the following table. All the aspects seem to be highly relevant.
PRINCIPLES
How relevant are these
principles for the organization?
(1-low; 4- high)
1. Accountability 3,4
2. Transparency 3,5
3. Ethical behavior 3,5
4. Respect for stakeholder interests 3,6
5. Respect for the rule of law 3,8
6. Respect for international norms of behaviour 3,5
7. Respect for human rights 3,6
Average 3,6
It is important to notice that the sample composition is made up by either small
companies involved in innovative sectors or medium size companies rather in traditional
sectors. SR relevance seems to be lower for small size companies than it is for the overall
sample (3.2 vs 3.6). The rate of SR inntiative engagement is much lower for the small
size companies (17% vs 45%), and the main reason argued is the lack of time and
resources (67% vs 36% of the total sample).
9%
91%
Sample on previous trainings on CSR
Yes
No (go to question 3.1.)
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 84/133
3.1.2. Needs of competences on CSR
In general, it seems that more than the half of SMEs consulted, do not have enough
knowledge or skills in order to integrate social responsibility into the company‟s activity.
Does the company count on knowledge and skills to integrate social
responsibility?
On the other hand, just the 12% of these SMEs have used or use CSR training
materials/tools.
Does the company use CSR training materials/tools?
This two aspects show the low interest that SMEs have currently, as for CSR issues.
ISO 26000
As well as this, SMEs have been enquired on the relevance of the ISO 26000 core
subjects and issues for their organization, and the training needs they consider they have
about these issues. The following table shows the main results obtained, as for the
relevance and as for the training needs (on the basis of a minimum assessment of 1
points and a maximum assessment of 4 points):
Yes
No
Yes
No
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 85/133
CORE SUBJECTS and ISSUES
Relevant for the
organization?(1-
low / 4-high)
Training need on
this subject/issue?
(1-low / 4-high)
1. Organizational Governance: “system by which an organization makes and implements decisions in pursuit of its objectives”
3,63 1,38
Accountability, transparency, ethical behavior, respect for stakeholder interests, and respect for the rule of law
3,63 1,38
2. Human rights: “basic rights to which all human beings are entitled because they are human beings”
2,66 1,36
Due diligence 3,13 1,43
Human rights risk situations 2,13 1,29
Avoidance of complicity 2,25 1,29
Resolving grievances 2,25 1,43
Discrimination and vulnerable groups 1,88 1,14
Civil and political rights 2,50 1,14
Economic, social and cultural rights 3,38 1,57
Fundamental rights at work 3,75 1,57 3. Labour practices: “all policies and practices
relating to work performed within, by or on behalf of the organization”
3,68 1,80
Employment and employment relationships 3,75 1,71
Conditions of work and social protection 3,88 1,86
Social dialogue 3,25 1,43
Health and safety at work 3,88 2,00
Human development and training in the workplace 3,63 2,00
4. The environment 3,63 1,50
Prevention of pollution 3,75 1,43
Sustainable resource use 3,88 1,57
Climate change mitigation and adaptation 3,38 1,57 Protection and restoration of the natural environment
3,50 1,43
5. Fair operating practices: “concern ethical conduct in an organization’s dealings with other organizations and individuals”
3,20 1,51
Anti–corruption 2,88 1,43
Responsible political involvement 2,88 1,43
Fair competition 3,50 1,57 Promoting social responsibility in the sphere of
influence 3,13 1,57
Respect for property rights 3,63 1,57
6. Consumer Issues 3,32 1,78
Fair marketing, factual and unbiased information and fair contractual practices
3,75 1,71
Protecting consumers‟ health and safety 3,50 1,71
Sustainable consumption 3,13 1,86
Consumer service, support, and dispute resolution 3,63 2,14
Consumer data protection and privacy 3,63 1,86
Access to essential services 2,63 1,57
Education and awareness 3,00 1,57
7. Community involvement and development: 3,21 1,59
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 86/133
“an organization's proactive outreach to the community”
Community involvement 3,75 1,57
Education and culture 3,13 1,43
Employment creation and skills development 3,25 1,57
Technology development and access 2,63 1,71
Wealth and income creation 3,25 1,43
Health 3,50 1,86
Social investment 3,00 1,57
On the whole, the SMEs consider that the seven core subjects included in the ISO 26000
are very relevant for them; “labour practices” receives the highest consideration, with
3,68 out of 4 points, followed by “human rights” and “the environment” and
“organizational governance”. “Community involvement and development” and “fair
operating practices” receives the lowest values, with 3,2 points in both cases. However,
in all cases the considered relevancy is very high.
As for the training needs, the score obtained is considerably lower than the relevancy
attached; this assessment shows the important SME‟s lack of awareness as for this
training issues.
ISO 26000‟s issues considered as with more training needs have been highlighted in
green. In this sense, “labour practices” and “consumer issues” have been identified as
the issues with highest score, specifically:
Labour practices:
o Health and safety at work
o Human development and training in the workplace
o Conditions of work and social protection
o Employment and employment relationships
Consumer Issues
o Consumer service, support, and dispute resolution
o Sustainable consumption
o Consumer data protection and privacy
o Fair marketing, factual and unbiased information and fair contractual
practices
o Protecting consumers‟ health and safety
This focus on consumer issues make it clear that the market and clients‟ pressure could
be a strong motivator and driving force for SMEs to be initiated within CSR issues and
planning.
With regard to the didactic resources, SMEs agree that the use of guides and virtual
platforms would useful for them in order to get trained in CSR. The support of a personal
trainer would be considered as helpful as well.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 87/133
Which method would be useful for you?
AUSTRIA
More than half of the respondents (5 of 9) indicated to count on specific knowledge and
skills to integrate SR. One SME mentioned the consultation of experts, another one its
experiences with public calls for tenders which are to some parts on EU-level. One
company indicated that SR complies with the common sense in the region where they are
located. This might be seen as the good embedment of the company in the region and
the local community that is based on trust and honesty.
Regarding training materials and tools on SR, only two companies use them. One
respondent mentioned in this context certification standards as a resource.
Question 4.3 in the survey, concerning the relevance and training needs on subjects and
issues, shows the following average values:
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 88/133
Table 5: Relevance and training needs on subjects and issues – Average values (from 9 SMEs)
CORE SUBJECTS and ISSUES
Is the core subject and its issues judged
relevant for the organization?
(1-low / 4-high)
Training need on this subject/issue
(1-low / 4-high)
1. Organizational Governance: “system by which an organization makes and implements decisions in pursuit of its objectives”
Accountability, transparency, ethical behavior, respect for stakeholder interests, and respect for the rule of law
3.66 1.44
2. Human rights: “basic rights to which all human beings are entitled because they are human beings”
Due diligence 3.11 1.33
Human rights risk situations 2.33 1.56
Avoidance of complicity 2.11 1.22
Resolving grievances 2.11 1.44
Discrimination and vulnerable groups 2.11 1.44
Civil and political rights 2.56 1.22
Economic, social and cultural rights 3.44 1.78
Fundamental rights at work 3.78 1.56
3. Labour practices: “all policies and practices relating to work performed within, by or on behalf of the organization”
Employment and employment relationships 3.56 1.56
Conditions of work and social protection 3.78 1.67
Social dialogue 3.22 1.33
Health and safety at work 3.89 2
Human development and training in the workplace 3.67 2
4. The environment
Prevention of pollution 3.78 1.56
Sustainable resource use 3.89 1.67
Climate change mitigation and adaptation 3.44 1.67
Protection and restoration of the natural environment 3.44 1.56
5. Fair operating practices: “concern ethical conduct in an organization’s dealings with other organizations and individuals”
Anti–corruption 2.67 1.33
Responsible political involvement 3 1.33
Fair competition 3.33 1.44
Promoting social responsibility in the sphere of influence 3 1.44
Respect for property rights 3.44 1.44
6. Consumer Issues
Fair marketing, factual and unbiased information and fair contractual practices 3.67 1.78
Protecting consumers‟ health and safety 3.22 1.67
Sustainable consumption 3 1.78
Consumer service, support, and dispute resolution 3.56 2.11
Consumer data protection and privacy 3.33 1.89
Access to essential services 2.56 1.67
Education and awareness 3 1.67
7. Community involvement and development: “an organization's proactive outreach to the community”
Community involvement 3.67 1.44
Education and culture 3 1.33
Employment creation and skills development 3.33 1.67
Technology development and access 2.56 1.56
Wealth and income creation 3 1.33
Health 3.44 1.67
Social investment 2.89 1.44
Regarding the relevance of core subjects and issues (averaged range between 2.11 and
3.89), organisational governance, labour practices and the environment seem to be the
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 89/133
most important ones for the SMEs in the sample. The highest values are assigned to
health and safety at work and sustainable resource use (each 3.89), followed by
fundamental rights at work, conditions of work and social protection and prevention of
pollution (each 3.78). Subjects and issues that are judged less important are concerning
human rights, whereby the lowest values are assigned to avoidance of complicity,
discrimination and vulnerable groups and resolving grievances.
In general, training needs on these core subjects and issues are indicated rather low, the
range is on average between 1.22 and 2.11. In this context, some respondents indicated
no need, others definitely indicate a high or rather high training need on certain issues.
On average, the highest training need exists in the field of labour practices and consumer
issues, the field environment has middle values compared to the other core subjects and
issues. The highest training need is assigned to consumer service, support, and dispute
resolution (2.11 on average) followed by health and safety at work and human
development and training in the workplace (each 2). The lowest value (1.22 on average)
is assigned to avoidance of complicity and civil and political rights, followed by due
diligence, social dialogue, anti–corruption, responsible political involvement, wealth and
income creation and education and culture (each 1.33).
There seem to be no direct contexts between the relevance that is given to specific
subjects and the training need on it. Furthermore, within this sample of SMEs, no
contexts between the size of the company and the training need in general could be
identified. All in all, it seems that the values concerning the training need show individual
interests and motivations of the surveyed persons and also their assessments regarding
the applicability in the own company.
The methods most useful in trainings are guides (7 of 9) followed by personal trainers (6
of 9). One third of the respondents also indicates audio, CD-Rom, video, manuals and
computer/virtual as useful. Text seems to be less interesting as a training method, only 2
of 9 indicated it.
Recommendations regarding the development of training materials for SMEs are very
general: one SME indicated, that guides shall be short and compact, as in fact of a lack of
time and resources comprehensive material is not advantageous.
Text7% Audio
10%
CD-Rom10%
Video10%
Guides23%
Manuals10%
Computer/virtual10%
Personal trainer20%
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 90/133
BULGARIA
On figure 4 are presented the average results from the survey related to the relevance to
and the training needs for the core subjects of social responsibility of the respondents.
Figure 4. Relevance and training needs on subjects and issues of ISO 26000
The average assessment of the relevance of core subjects to CSR is quite high for
organisational governance (2,87), labour practices (2,97), consumer issues (2,84) and
community involvement (2,83). The average assessment for human rights (2,63) and fair
operating practices (2,42) is also above 50% and the lowest average mark for relevance
is for environment (2,05).
It should be pointed out that the training needs for every core subject is assessed
significantly less than the relevance. The highest score being for community involvement
and development and consumer issues.
DENMARK
The most prioritized subject and related issues for training is the environment:
prevention of pollution and sustainable use of resources. Labour practises are also
important but the need for training seems less. In general it was difficult for the
interviewees to answer the questions related to which extent they need training on
certain issues. Partly due to their lack of commitment to a structured approach to CSR
and partly because it is too overwhelming for them to work that detailed with CSR. Some
of the SME´s couldn‟t relate themselves to these questions and couldn‟t come up with
any useful training methods except brochures, internal material, and electronic
2.87
2.63
2.97
2.05
2.42
2.84 2.83
1.87 1.87 2.08 1.852.12 2.34 2.61
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
Relevance of subjects from ISO 26000
Training needs on subjects from ISO 26000
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 91/133
documentation. One exception was a need for training material with regard to
communication to consumers from a life cycle perspective.
LITHUANIA
Firstly, in the section of needs of competences on CSR, it was necessary to judge the
relevance of main CSR principles for every organization. The analysis of the respondents„
answers shows that the most relevant CSR principle seems to be respect for the rule of
law as well as respect for human rights. Accountability and ethical behavior were marked
as also very important.
7 from 10 respondents stated that their companies point out the main stakeholders,
however they are mostly simply informed about the companies„ CSR efforts with one
exception in the case of JSC „Kylis“, where the stakeholders are not only informed, but
also engaged in carrying out the company„s CSR initiatives. However, it emerged that
almost all of the enterprises interviewied didn„t count on specific knowledge and skills to
integrate social responsibility in their companies„ activities. Only JSC „Selita & Co“, as it
was mentioned, has a general understanding about CSR. None of the companies use any
training materials or tools for CSR implementation.
The general analysis of the results of relevance and training needs on subjects and
issues, based on ISO 26000 standard, showed that the most relevant CSR subjects are
(listed under importance) technology development and access, organizational
governance issues, as well as prevention of pollution. Other important subjects seems to
be health and safety at work, sustainable resource use, consumer service, support and
dispute resolution as well as sustainable consumption. Interestingly, at least relevant
subjects for the companies interviewed appeared such CSR issues as anti-corruption,
avoidance of complicity and civil and political rights. In the case of general results on
training needs, the majority of respondents especially appointed technology development
and access as well as organizational governance issues, prevention of pollution,
consumer service, support and dispute resolution as the most relevant issues. It seems
to be that civil and political rights, due diligence, avoidance of complicity, discrimination
and vulnerable groups, anti-corruption and economic, social and cultural rights are at
least important CSR subjects on training needs.
The next question, going to the ending of the survey, was about the methods of training
on CSR, which would be useful for the enterprises. Even 8 respondents stated that the
most useful method for them would be training guides, 5 enterprises also mentioned
computer/virtual training material. The majority of interviewees indicated more than one
training method suitable for them. Interestingly, only two companies, JSC „Maksima“ and
„Gaschema“ to be precise, would like to have personal trainer on CSR.
When asked to specify other comments or recommendations for the development of
training material on CSR focused on SMEs, only one respondent gave some comments.
Mrs. Griciuniene remarked that training materials on CSR for SMEs should be easy
accessed and simple to understand and to apply.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 92/133
At the end of interviews, all the respondents were asked if they are interested in
participating in testing the developed training materials. Almost all of them, except JSC
„Kylis“ and JSC „Bionovus“, answered positively. Mr. Algimantas from JSC „Selita“, which
already had dissappointing experience on the inappropriate training, corrected that he is
interested only in such kind of training that could ensure deep knowledge on CSR.
POLAND
Taking into consideration the fact that SME sector is not widely acquainted with the term
“CSR”, most of the companies do not have management strategy, and decisions
concerning Corporate Social Responsibility are made ad hoc and they are mostly of
occasional character. What is more, no complete information on training needs of Polish
SME sector concerning CSR is available. The project SOCIALISME was implemented from
1st October 2008 up to 30th September 201094; one of its operational goals was the
identification of SME‟s education needs concerning CSR in the following countries:
Lithuania, Bulgaria, Poland, Spain, Romania, Greece, Latvia, Portugal in order to tailor
the project‟s products to their needs. Additionally the project included:
Preparation of the learning methodology package initiated by CSR for SMEs in
English and the adaptation of the package in mother tongues of each country
participating in the project in accordance to its needs,
Testing of CSR learning concept in SME sector,
Preparation of the CSR learning package for the SME‟s development for SME
consultants,
Dissemination and valorisation of the product created in each country during and
after the project completion.
Currently no information is available on the results of the project aimed at the
identification of the SME’s education needs concerning CSR in Poland.
Analysing the scope of CSR/sustainable development and SME‟s potential needs it should
be highlighted that the importance of specific areas depends on, inter alia, type and size
of enterprise, industry, the situation on market and the strategy of the given
organisation, not forgetting about the condition and the strategy of the whole supply
chain, a company operates in, stated in the ISO 26000 draft.
SLOVENIA
Companies also answered what would be relevant topics/issues regarding their needs.
Topics/issues offered in the questionnaire were in line with the ISO 26000.
1) Organizational governance
94
http://www.socialsme.org/index.php/pl/prezentacja-projektu/
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 93/133
On average companies denoted organizational governance as modestly important
(average: 3.2). They think that trainings about the organizational governance are also
important (average: 3.4).
2) Human rights
Surprisingly, companies think that human rights are modestly important (average: 2.5).
Consequently, they claimed that trainings within these topics are modestly important as
well (average: 2.5). However, companies think that the most important topics is
fundamental rights at work (average: 3.4), followed by economic, social, and cultural
rights (average: 3.0). The least important topics within the human rights issues, based
on the companies' replies are: due diligence, human rights risk situation, resolving
grievances, discrimination and vulnerable groups (average of all the mentioned topics
was: 2.2)
3) Labour practices
Companies think that the labour practice issues are important (average: 3.3), whilst they
think that the trainings about the mentioned issues are less important (average: 2.7).
Companies claimed that the most important topics within the labour issues are conditions
of work and social protection, and health and safety at work (both have average: 3.8),
followed by employment and employment relationships, and human development and
training at the workplace (both have average 3). They think that the most needed
trainings will be from the following topics: human development and training at the
workplace (average: 3.2), and conditions of work and social protection (average: 3).
4) The environment
Regarding the environmental issues, companies think that environmental topics and
trainings are modestly important (both have an average: 3.1). Companies claimed that
the most important topic for them is prevention of pollution (average: 3.8), followed by
sustainable resource usage (average: 3.5). Consequently, they think that education in
both topics is needed.
5) Fair operating practices
Companies claimed that fair operating practices have modest importance for them
(average: 2.7). They think that the most important topic within the operating practices is
respect for property rights (3.0), followed by anti-corruption and fair competition (both
3.0). They also think that the educational needs within this area are modestly important
(average: 2.3).
6) Consumer issues
Companies claim that consumer issues are quite important (average: 3.2). They argue
that the most important topics within this issue are: sustainable consumption (average:
3.6), followed by consumer service, and support (average: 3.4) and education and
awareness (average: 3.4). Companies think that educational there are needs for further
education within the sustainable consumption topics (average: 3.0).
7) Community involvement and development
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 94/133
Companies think that the community involvement is important (average: 2.9). The most
important topics within the above mentioned issue are: technology development and
access (average: 3.8), followed by employment creation and skills development
(average: 3.2). They claimed that educational needs within this issue exist: community
involvement and technology development and access (both have average: 2.8).
SPAIN
Regarding the high interest on SR but the scarce training undertaken, a reduced majority
of companies show their interest to take part on a training program tailored for SMEs, as
reflected in the graph below.
There is no consensus on the course method, as most of the possible material media
would be useful for the companies, being the most preferred a virtual on-line training
(73%), followed by test, guides and manuals (45%). Onsite training is only chosen by
36% of the respondents.
55%
45%
Sample by interest on training participation
Yes, I would like to know more
No, thank you
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 95/133
About the contents, companies have been enquired on the relevance of the ISO 26000
core subjects and issues for their organizations and the training needs they think they
have within their organizations. The summary averages are shown in the table below.
We can conclude that the most relevant issue where the need of training is the highest is
organizational governance, followed by labour practices. In general, companies score
higher on the relevance of the SR subjects (2.7 over 4) than in their needs of training
(1.7/4), which is 20% less.
In terms of comparison between small and medium size companies The training needs
are declared to be the same (1.7/4), however the relevance of SR issues applying to the
company is assessed to be lower for small size companies (2.4/4) than it is for medium
size companies (2.7/4).
3.2. VET institutions perspective in each country
The analysis of training institutions, include 5 VET institutions, along with 10 universities,
1 quality and certification institution, 3 consultancy companies and 1 business school
5
23
1
5 5
8
4
1
0123456789
Sample by training method prefered
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 96/133
from Consortium‟s partners‟ countries. Thus, 20 questionnaires have been received,
some of them through personnel interviews.
3.2.1. Areas covered by current CSR training offer
The 56% of analyzed courses are stand-alone courses, while the 44% are courses
integrated into another module.
Are the subjects stand-alone CSR or included in other courses?
As well as this, more than one third of all courses are courses that exceed 40 hours (for
instance: one doctoral program of 150hours), in contrast to the 30% that are courses
with less than 10 hours.
The 22% of analyzed courses are courses between 10 and 20 hours. However, courses
between 20 and 40 hours are the least usual.
Which is the duration of the social responsibility course or training offer?
As for the structure of the courses, in half of the cases, theoretical and practical issues
are equally represented. On the other hand, the 19% are completely theoretical, being
the same percentage the case of courses more theoretical than practical. In this sense,
more practical contents are demanded both from SMEs and training institutions:
Stand-alone course
56%
Integrated in another
module44%
< 10 hours30%
10 < x > 20 hours 22%
20 < x > 40 hours 13%
> 40 hours35%
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 97/133
How would you define the content of the course/training offer?
As many of the analyzed training offer was related to universities, the students target
group has been the most important one.
Which are the target groups of the training offer?
“Community involvement and development” has been the issue more repeated during
the analysis as the content included in the courses. However, the other issues are
relevant as well, as described in the following chart; consumer‟s issues seem to be the
least repeated. In this sense, it must be highlighted how just very few number of courses
are addressed specifically to SMEs.
100% theoretical
19%
More theoretical
than practical
19%
50% theoretical
and 50% practical
50%
More practical
than theoretical
12%
Students
Companies and other organisations
Unemployed
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 98/133
Which subject areas does the training offer include?
Some of the identified other issues, we can find the following ones: alternatives in
economy-politics-civil society, initiatives for social change, social developments in
Europe, sustainable development, awareness and CSR models.
With regard to the current didactic resources used, the text manuals and the guides are
the most usual ones. However, usually they are complemented by other sources, like
videos or CD-ROMs, along with articles, case studies or example of best practices. It is
observed how traditional didactic methods or the lecturer oriented courses are the most
common. Although usually texts include all necessary information within the same
document, there is a demand from trainers for a standardization of materials, just in one,
only document.
On the other hand, almost half of the trainers use self-made materials, while the licensed
materials are the least used. Some of the advantages of using self-made materials
consist of the fact that these resources support participants in their learning, different
types of materials and resources enhance creativity and generate more success in non-
formal learning situations, and external point of views are included. As well as this, this
materials usually are updated, appropriate for the students‟ digital literacy, for the
integration into environmental management, learning for life, higher activity of the
students and to facilitate students to get their own conclusions.
02468
10121416
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 99/133
Which is the source of the used materials?
As for the disadvantages of used current resources, one of the most important, is the
lack of real practice during the lecture. As well as this, the following disadvantages have
been identified: not enough time for detailed presentation, missing simulations to
demonstrate learning concepts, often boring text, which reduces the interest in the
topics.
Therefore, innovating in didactic materials has been considered as essential, in order to
make contents more attractive, visual and easy to understand and remember. In this
sense, a complementary virtual training platform is considered as a recommended
resource, as it would help students to do more practises and analyze new concepts out of
the classroom training.
The following chart shows how the 30% of respondents would prefer to use some kind of
virtual platform for the training; it would be followed by guides, video, manuals and CD-
ROMs.
Which other documents/tools would be useful for you?
Self-made
Licensed
Free-access
CD rom13%
Video20%
Guides20%
Manuals17%
Computer/virtual30%
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 100/133
AUSTRIA
The analysis of VET institutions includes two private business organisations conducting
trainings, and one public institution.
They all offer SR related courses or trainings, whereby one third of the trainings are
stand-alone courses and two thirds are integrated in other modules in the fields of social
entrepreneurship, sustainability processes and evaluation, and poverty prevention. All
courses have different durations: one is 10 – 20 hours, one is 20 – 40 hours, and one is
more than 40 hours. Two of the courses are 50 % theoretical and 50 % practical, and
one training is more practical than theoretical. The target groups of these trainings are
the following: Students (2/3), companies and other organisations (2/3), civil society
(2/3) and unemployed (1/3).
The subject areas of the analysed trainings are: Organisational governance (1/3), human
rights (all), labour practices (2/3), the environment (1/3), fair operating practices (all),
consumer issues (2/3), community involvement and development (all) and others (1/3 –
alternatives in economy-politics-civil society, initiatives for social change, social
developments in Europe).
The didactic resources used are: Text (all), audio (1/3), video (2/3), guides (2/3),
manuals (2/3), computer/virtual (2/3), and others (1/3 – ceramic, art).
Two of the courses only use self-made materials, the third course uses as well self-made
and licensed and free-access materials.
Concerning the didactic resources, the training providers using self-made materials
mention the following advantages: their resources support participants in their learning,
different types of materials and resources enhance creativity and generate more success
in non-formal learning situations, and external point of views are included by videos.
Regarding useful other documents/tools besides already used ones, one institution
mentions CD room, video and manuals.
BULGARIA
The prepared questionnaires were distributed among 3 universities:
1. Sofia University “St. Kliment Ohridski” – the oldest state university in Bulgaria
2. New Bulgarian University – the biggest private university in Bulgaria
3. American University in Bulgaria – internationally renowned private university
Due to the short term of the request the questionnaires were send to certain
departments (and individuals) in order to ensure the timeliness of the responses. This
should be taken into account because the answers are related to particular faculty,
department or unit in the university.
Only the Sofia University “St. Kliment Ohridski”, Geological and Geographical
Department, reported the availability of a little course in CSR as part of the education in
Human Resources management, Organisational Behaviour and Social Capital. The course
is less than 10 hours so it is part of a subject. The content is 50% theoretical, 50%
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 101/133
practical and includes organisational governance, fair operating practices and community
involvement and development.
The practical exercises do not involve working with real enterprises and it is noted that
the lack of real practice is a disadvantage of the course. The tools include text and
manuals and are self-made.
The headquarters of the American University in Bulgaria are in the town of Blagoevgrad –
regional centre in South-East Bulgaria. The Elieff Center for Education and Culture is a
separate unit of the American University in Sofia. They intend to develop a CSR course
but do not have one now.
The Centre for Public Administration at the New Bulgarian University has developed a
CSR course also but have not started it as part of Human Resource Management
programme.
DENMARK
The interviewees mainly consist of consultancies and universities. All of them are offering
general CSR-courses and one company has Lead-auditor courses with diplomas on
Environmental audits and Occupational Health and Safety audits, respectively. A lead-
auditor course on CSR is also planned for, but not yet conducted.
In Denmark, the CSR-courses offered by consultancies are stand-a-lone courses carried
out as one or two day courses, except for the lead auditor courses which have a full week
scheme. At the universities CSR-courses are typically expressed as optional CSR-subjects
included in a minor, a master-degree or a MBA. The duration of the courses are app. 30
hours or 7,5 ECTS.
The CSR courses are mainly a mix of theory and practice. Half of the organisations were
using between 75-100 % theoretical content and half considered the content offered as
being 50% theoretical/ 50% practical.
As regards the subjects included in the training offers, the CSR-courses are on a general
level and therefore contain many of the core subjects included in ISO26000. Least
covered are human rights and consumer issues. The auditor course covered
organizational governance and Labour Practise and Environment – legislation is an
important part here.
Trainers are using text, video, guides and manuals as a didactic resource. None are using
CD and audio. E-learning is seen as a media when teaching large groups in a company,
and on the auditor course, real hands-on audits are conducted.
All trainers are using self-made material, a great part licensed material, and on the
auditor course accredited material is used. The advantages of self-made teaching
materials are that it is easy to adapt the materials to different courses even though the
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 102/133
adaption is time consuming; and the material will always be up-to date. Moreover, the
course participants can have easy access to review the material whenever needed.
LITHUANIA
In the case of VET institutions, there are 4 organizations involved in this survey -
Institute of Environmental Engineering from Kaunas University of Technology, two
different departments - the Department of Social Sciences and the Department of
Management from Klaipeda University as well as one private business vocational training
institution JSC „Det Norske Veritas LT“. The detailed list of the participants in VET survey
are presented in the table 2.
Table 2. The list of the participants in VET survey.
No.
Name and the
position of the
person interviewed
Name of the organization
Subject of social
responsibility
course/training
offer/seminar
1.
dr. Visvaldas Varzinskas, lecturer
Kaunas University of Technology (KTU), Institute of Environmental Engineering (APINI)
Social Business Responsibility, study subject
2.
Darius Pamakstys, auditor, lecturer
JSC “Det Norske Veritas” Business Assurance, Lithuania
Social Accountability (SA8000), seminar
3.
Jelena Dementjeva lecturer, assistant
Klaipeda University (KU), Department of Social Sciences
Leader Ethics, study subject, topic - ethical
responsibility of the organization
4.
dr. prof. Ligita Simanskiene, lecturer
Klaipeda University (KU), Department of Management
The Establishment of Organizational Culture, study subject
All the respondents from separate educational institutions, which were interviewed,
stated the presence of courses or training offer on specific subjects related to social
responsibility. Half of the respondents noted that these training offers prevail as the
stand-alone courses. Dr. Varzinskas from Institute of Environmental Engineering named
study subject „Social Business Responsibility“, whereas Mr. Pamakstys indicated seminar
on Social Accountability (SA8000). The representatives from different departments of
Klaipeda University - Ms. Dementjeva and dr. prof. Simanskiene indicated CSR subjects,
integrated in two study modules such as „Leader Ethics” and “The Establishment of
Organizational Culture”. The majority of training offers are shorter than 10 hours and
their content are equally theoretical and practical. The target groups of these offers are
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 103/133
mainly students in the case of all universities, only JSC “Det Norske Veritas LT” offers
social accountability seminar for companies‟ managers and representatives. The main
areas included in all these training offers are organizational governance issues. Other
subjects, mostly incorporated in the education offers, are human rights and the
environment issues. All of the respondents stated that the didactic material which are
used for trainings are usually self-made or free-access text materials. Other training
resources are guides, video and computer/virtual materials as well as various scientical
articles.
POLAND
There is no training offer available in Poland concerning CSR at the stage of vocational
education and training. However, there is a wide range of projects, conferences, trainings
and courses for SMEs.
The publication titled “Institutions of the CSR market in Poland in 2010” („Instytucje
rynku CSR w Polsce 2010”) constitutes the guide to key organisations, media and
initiatives promoting and educating in Corporate Social Responsibility in Poland95.
Projects for SMEs:
1. Challenges of Sustainable Development in Poland (Kurs Wyzwania
Zrównoważonego Rozwoju).
3-week summer school 'Challenges of Sustainable Development in Poland' is the
most important element of the project. Course has been held every year since 1998.
The structure of the course:
a. Theory and practice of Local Society Sustainable Development –
lectures concerning the local aspects of sustainable development;
preparation, implementation, evaluation and monitoring of development
programmes and strategies for local societies; dealing with social conflicts,
mediations. Participants conduct a big project parallel to lectures.
b. Sustainable business – project consisting in study tours of work groups
aimed at conducting the analysis of company‟s performance from the point of
view of CSR together with company‟s representatives.
c. Practical aspects of sustainable development – the opportunity of
appliance of sustainable development concept in the practice in many areas
and aspects of life, such as education, architecture, construction, agriculture.
Guest lectures concern the problematic of “sustainable” architecture in
Poland, sustainable transport and other possibilities of practical
implementation of sustainable development in our country.
2. Corporate Social Responsibility – The Józef Tischner’s European High School
(Społeczna Odpowiedzialność Przedsiębiorstw Wyższa Szkoła Europejska
im. Ks. Józefa Tischnera).
95
http://old.fob.org.pl/cms_a/upload/file/PublikacjeIBadania/InstytucjerynkuCSRwPolsce2010.pdf
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 104/133
Postgraduate studies are directed to top managers in charge of issues concerning
CSR or people, who plan to work in such area, including: board members,
communication managers, public affair and PR managers, CSR managers.
Curriculum: strategic management, CSR – theoretical background, social project
management, communication with the environment of a company, company‟s
stakeholders, employees as stakeholders, Corporate Community
Involvement/Investment (CCI), planning of cooperation with social partners,
environment management, corporate governance, Socially Responsible Investment
(SRI), social norms and standards, social responsibility reporting, ethics in business,
international CSR.
3. The Centre of Leadership and Corporate Social Responsibility (Centrum
Przywództwa i Społecznej Odpowiedzialności Biznesu)
Predicted areas of the Centre activity includes, inter alia, conducting and
coordination of studies concerning CSR and leadership, publication of periodic
concerning CSR, support of enterprises and NGO in creating effective social
campaigns, mediation between business and NGO in order to establish cooperation
and implement projects.
French portal Reportingrse.fr published list of guides for SMEs concerning
CSR reporting96
The discussion forum “Stakeholders’ expectations concerning CSR in SME
sector („Oczekiwania interesariuszy w stosunku do CSR w MŚP”) is run as
German-Polish project aimed at identification of stakeholders’ expectations
as far as CSR in SMEs is concerned.
The foundation CentrumCSR.PL is the Polish partner of German organisation RKW
Kompetenzzentrum (www.rkw.de – The Centre of Rationalisation and Innovativeness
of German Economy) in the project concerning CSR in SMEs. The project was co-
financed by The Foundation for Polish-German Cooperation97.
So far RKW has published, inter alia, the practical guide for SMEs titled “Social and
environmental corporate responsibility in foreign subsidiary. Recommendations for
German enterprises having subsidiaries abroad”. The aim of the project on the current
stage is to study and determine the expectations of various social groups in Poland and
Germany in relation to corporate social responsibility (CSR) of SMEs. Therefore, one
carried out the survey in Germany and Poland within various stakeholder groups.
There is also the report of expert group titled: “Opportunities and responsibility –
how to help SMEs in incorporating social and environemental issues in their
activity” („Szanse i odpowiedzialność – jak pomóc małym i średnim
przedsiębiorstwom w uwzględnianiu w ich działalności zagadnień społecznych i
ekologicznych.” The final version was published in May 2007 by group of European
professionals in the area of CSR and SMEs. The European Commission hopes that the
report will support everyone trying to help SMEs in gaining the better results in social,
environmental and financial activities98.
On 3rd May 2010 450 entrepreneurs, SME‟s representatives and people dealing with CSR
came to Brussels on the invitation of European Commission. The innovative event was
96
http://odpowiedzialnybiznes.pl/pl/praktyka-csr/aktualnosci/wiadomosci-od-partnerow/raportowanie-csr-dla-m%C5%9Ap,4301.html 97
www.fwpn.org.pl 98
http://ec.europa.eu/enterprise/csr/sme_expert_group.htm/
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 105/133
aimed at discussion: “How to help SMEs be socially responsible?”. The event took place in
the same time as the publication of the report of European CSR Expert Group titled
“Opportunities and Responsibility”.
In 2010 the publication “Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) Guidebook for
enterprises’ self-evaluation” was published99.
The table below shows the examples of other projects, seminars, conferences
and workshops organised for inter alia SMEs.
Examples Institution responsible
for organisation Target Place and date Program
Project: Enhancing the regional competitiveness by corporate social responsibility (CSR) Project area: Development of private sector and promotion of SME‟s export Territorial scope: Poland
Polish Agency of Entrepreneurship Development is the implementing authority of the project.
Beneficiaries Inter alia: SMEs – target group in measures 1, 2 I 3.
Currently, the project is under assessment of authorities – it was positively verified by Intermediate Body (Ministry of Economy) and National Coordination Unit (Ministry of Regional Development); it awaits the final decision of Managing Authority of Swiss Contribution to Poland.
Measure 1 – the development of competences of City Halls, Service Centres for Investors and Exporters and SME sector in CSR by training, meetings, study tours and promotion/information activities concerning the concept of CSR. The measure 1 is aimed at organisation of meeting for SME sector representatives from Poland concerning CSR. Additionally, it is planned to conduct CSR trainings and study tours for representatives of City Halls and Centres for Investors and Exporters. The meetings and training are to be carried out in 16 regions. Measure 2 – assistance in implementation of CSR solutions by pilot projects for SMEs, including financial support for consulting services and investments. One plans to organise the call for proposal within the Measure 2 for SMEs applying for subsidies for the CSR implementation projects in the following areas: environment, relations with employees, social involvement. The call for proposal is the
most expensive action within the measure. Measure 3 – promotion of best practices and communication concerning the results of projects implemented under the Measure 2. The evaluation study is to be conducted under the Measure 3; it will include the evaluation of SME‟s projects results implemented by means of Measure 2, best practices from every region and
99
http://odpowiedzialnybiznes.pl/public/files/Podrecznik_do_samooceny_dla_przedsiebiorstw_UNDP_2011.pdf
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 106/133
their promotion e.g. in form of publication.
Examples Institution responsible
for organisation Target Place and date Program
Project „Cross-sector cooperation – project for business responsibility”
Lower-Silesian Federation of NGOs in partnership with “Krzyżowa/Cross” Foundation for European Understanding and private company Heapmail Internet Solutions Ltd. have implemented the projects since January 2011 r.
Target group: representatives of the following sectors from Lower Silesia: SMEs, NGOs, local authorities.
January 2011 – December 2012
The aim of the project is to prepare, test and implement the innovative programme and education solutions for Lower Silesia region up to 2012 in order to support SMEs in area of CSR fostering competitiveness and development of SMEs in the region. The project includes the following actions: The initial stage of the project – in-depth studies concerning authentic needs of SMEs and NGOs, and their identification in order to implement initiatives in aid of corporate social responsibility (CSR), determination of implementation areas for CSR projects, promotion of CSR initiatives and standards.
Conference "Responsible Cracow"
Panel discussion and training run by Cracovian International Consultants.
Małopolska‟s SME sector representatives
The conference took place on 9th January 2007 (10.00 – 14.30) in Chopin Hotel in Cracow (Przy Rondzie Street 2) Admission free
1. How to define responsible business in the modern economy?
2. How entrepreneurs perceive their role – what does it mean to be entrepreneurs?
3. How to build good relations with company‟s environment – employees, customers, local society?
4. Think globally, act locally – what may inspire development; where to find best practices?
5. Entrepreneurs versus government – what is wrong
in lobbing? 6. Is joining the discussion
about changing law regulations the entrepreneurs responsibility or not?
Examples Institution responsible
for organisation Target
Place and date
Program
Information and Consulting Centre for companies
interested in appliance in practice of the rules of Corporate Social Responsibility
Polish Chamber of Commerce
The service includes
providing information and consulting for SMEs concerning corporate social responsibility.
Via web site – free-of-charge
Contact with consultant of given regional chamber of commerce provides all interested companies with necessary information or consulting.
ORDER FORM „How to become Socially
Responsible Company?” I hereby request the EU Office consultant to send via e-mail the following materials (mark all the positions you would like to receive): 1. general information on
corporate social responsibility principles,
2. questionnaire for enterprise enabling to
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 107/133
assess its activity from the point of view of corporate social responsibility,
3. examples of „best practices” applied in Polish and European
companies, 4. effective ways of
communication – within and outside a company – communicating CSR involvement and activities,
5. contact list of organisations and institutions arranging various programs, call for proposals, trainings, courses or certificates concerning CSR,
6. useful link to other web sites concerning socially responsible entrepreneurship.
Workshops
Homepage CSRinfo100
- open workshop, - closed trainings adjusted to the needs of given organisation, - cooperation with companies, universities and social organisations, preparation of workshops, trainings and seminars for all partners within the scope of their own
training cycles
http://www.csrinfo.org/pl/warsztaty
Courses directed mostly to large companies and SMEs.
1. introduction to CSR 2. CSR strategy 3. stakeholder
management 4. CSR communication 5. CSR reporting 6. company‟s social
involvement 7. partnerships
between a company and NGO; evaluation of cooperation
8. evaluation of volunteer work
9. CSR standards 10. introduction to
sustainable development
11. ethics in business 12. responsible
investments 13. CSR in particular
industries/areas
SLOVENIA
From the 6 questionnaires send to the VET institutions and universities, we have received
only 3 replies from the universities. They claimed that their organization is offering
courses/subjects related to social responsibility. The courses are mostly integrated in
other modules (e.g. Sustainable water management, soil protection, environmental
100
http://www.csrinfo.org/pl/warsztaty
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 108/133
management). There is only one stand alone subject: Responsible entrepreneurship as a
topic within the doctoral programme Responsible entrepreneurship. One of the
programmes dedicate less than 10 hours to the SR topics, another between 10 and 20,
and on doctoral programme around 150 hours are dedicated to the SR topics. One course
is more practical then theoretical, another more theoretical then practical and third has
both issues equally represented. In all the cases target groups are students.
The most common area that trainings include is environment, followed by fair operating
practices and community involvement and development. One of the trainings also
includes sustainable development and sustainable firm.
Regarding the pedagogical-didactical material used, the results of the questionnaires are
in line with our research of the courses at the universities and VET institutions. Mostly
textbooks and other text material is used and a lecturer-oriented lectures (traditional
didactical method), which is sometimes upgraded with video and audio material, CD
ROMs, etc. However, no computer/virtual materials are available. The material is usually
self-made, followed by free access material. Only one school is buying licences material.
Individuals in the survey claimed that the advantages of the materials used by the
courses are the following: up-to date, appropriate for the students‟ digital literacy,
integration into environmental management, learning for life, higher activity of the
students, coming to their own conclusions. Disadvantages are the following: not enough
time for detailed presentation, missing simulations to demonstrate learning concepts,
often boring text, which reduces the interest in the topics. It is interesting that all have
mentioned that they will use virtual/computer tools with manuals if available.
SPAIN
The analysis of VET institutions, include the interview to three different agents:
“Universidad del País Vasco (UPV/EHU)”: Public University of the Basque Country.
Training offered by AENOR: Spanish Association for Standardization and
Certification
“Fondo Formación Euskadi” (FFE): VET Institution
From the three courses analyzed, two of them are stand-alone courses, while the training
offered by the Public University, is a training consisting of two courses included within a
specialization module as part of a Business Administration degree. In this case, these two
courses account for 120 hours (2 courses x 60hours). The two other courses consist of
50hours, in the case of FFE and 60hours, in the case of AENOR.
As for the contents, the answers are quite different: in one case all the contents are
theoretical; in another one, theoretical and practical contents are included at the same
level (50% & 50%); in the case of the University course, it will depend on the teacher‟s
teaching methodology (this specialization training has not still been implemented).
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 109/133
The subject areas included in the training are the following ones: organizational
governance, human rights, labour practices, environment, fair operating practices,
consumer issues and community involvement and development, at least, at a global
level. Awareness and CSR models are included as well. However, in one of the cases
environmental and consumer issues and fair operating practices are not considered in the
training. Students, companies and unemployed people are the target groups addressed
by theses courses. None of them are courses addressed specifically to SMEs.
The main didactic resources used are based on text and guides, through classroom
training. As well as this, videos and presentations are used, including case studies and
best practices examples. These resources are basically self-made materials. As for the
main advantages of these resources, training providers consider that texts include all
necessary information within the same document; however, a standardization of
materials is demanded in some cases. On the other hand, they think that innovating in
didactic materials is essential, making contents more attractive, visual and easy to
understand and remember. In this sense, a complementary virtual training platform is
considered as a recommended resource, as it would help students to do more practises
and analyze new concepts out of the classroom training.
3.2.2. Needs of competences on CSR
In general, consulted trainers think that there is a real demand for CSR from SMEs, or at
least, that it is growing day by day. As 31% of the respondents consider, SMEs do not
have enough knowledge about existing CSR training resources; as well as this, a 26%
think that SMEs would be interested in attending CSR oriented training, it training
resources were adapted to them.
On the other hand, lack of awareness is one concept that has been repeated often; SMEs
are not aware of the real value of CSR, as they do not see the economical value or profit
of the investment in CSR. In this sense, short term wins against long term profit.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 110/133
How do you assess social responsibility demand from SMEs?
AUSTRIA
It is assessed by all institutions, that there is a demand on SR by SMEs. Two of the three
interviewed institutions think that SMEs would be interested in SR training if training
resources would be adapted to them, and on the other hand that SMEs do not have
enough knowledge about existing training resources. One institution also sees a lack of
top management commitment in SMEs about social responsibility.
Regarding the development of SR training materials, one public institution recommends
the provision of intergenerational, interdisciplinary and intercultural learning settings to
meet SMEs needs.
BULGARIA
In the survey videos, guides and manuals are recommended as useful in teaching CSR.
Figure 5 shows the demand for CSR training as identified by the three VET institutions.
No real necessity20%
No nowledge about training
resources31%
Lack of top management commitment
23%
Interested in social
responsibility if adapted training
resources26%
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 111/133
Figure 5. Assessment of the social responsibility demand from SMEs
DENMARK
Cases, real-life examples and knowledge sharing between peers are very important.
Only a few VET´s claims that the SME´s are not aware of the different CSR training
resources and one said that SME´s do not fancy participating in a CSR training course at
a “smart business school”. CSR is not on the agenda at SME´s unless they experience an
increased demand from stakeholders and half of the interviewees don‟t think an adaption
of CSR-tools to SME´s will make any difference in their approach to CSR. Those SME´s
who´s beginning to think about integrating CSR into their business often starts with a
systematic approach to Health and Safety and/or Environment.
Recommendations:
There is a demand for guidance on how to mix the right kind of didactic resources
when teaching and how to integrate the different technologies.
Better knowledge on how to use video, computer, social media and other more
motivating didactic resources in CSR-classes
Use of cases should be emphasized and the quality of cases should be improved
also including much more relevant dilemmas. Many cases today are of poor
quality and not very interesting.
Use of specific tools to “stakeholder-dialogue, responsible procurement, corruption
in China and so on etc.” Could be useful when conducting training
Training with knowledge sharing between the participants is of great value e.g. at
the auditor courses.
Whether materials are licensed or not, there is often too much text for the
participants to read; make it clear and concise.
The strategic approach should be emphasized to help SME‟s identify the business
relevance
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
no real necessity for CSR
no knowledge about training
resources
lack of top management commitment
interested in CSR if adapted training
resources
Social responsibility demand from SMEs
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 112/133
LITHUANIA
When the respondents were asked about advantages and disadvantages, associated with
their didacted resources, Mr. Pamakstys stated that training material of the seminar
helps to form a clear view about CSR requirements in SA8000 standard in general,
though it seems be too universal and too concise to attain more specific purposes. Ms.
Dementjeva noted that the virtual didactic resources (e.g. reportages from Internet) help
to show fair operating practices of the companies more visibly, whereas the analysis of
scientical articles promote students‟ critical thinking. However, she remarked that there
are not enough training resources suitable to show practical examples on CSR.
Every respondent acknowledges the demand for other didactic resources, especially for
CD, training guides and computer/virtual training materials.
The answers to the question “How do you assess social responsibility demand from
SMEs” showed very different results, so it seems all these clauses on the survey are
correct. Dr. Varzinskas assured that SMEs do not have knowledge about the existing
social responsibility training resources in general. Ms. Dementjeva thought that SMEs do
not have real necessity of social responsibility and have a lack of social responsibility
awareness. Dr. prof. Simanskiene highlighted that SMEs would be interested in social
responsibility if training resources would be adapted to them. Mr. Pamakstys accepted
the all above-mentioned thoughts and enclosed with the statement that the costs for CSR
certification are often large enough for SMEs. Also, he indicated useful recommendation
for the development of training materials on CSR. According to Mr. Pamakstys, training
materials on CSR must be specially adapted not only for the top management of a
company, but primarily for the employees, on purpose to raise their consciousness.
POLAND
There is no complete information available in one place concerning needs and
competences of units organising training for SMEs. These needs are meet by means of
units, people improving their skills during various projects, post graduate studies,
courses, and professionals/experienced persons.
SLOVENIA
The social responsibility demand from the SMEs was assessed as following. 2 of 3 think
that there is a lack of top management commitment in SMEs about SR. Furthermore 2 of
3 think that SMEs would be interested in SR if training resources would be adapted to
them and 1 of 3 thinks that in general SMEs do not have knowledge about the existing
social responsibility training resources. There are some ambitious SMEs, striving for
awards in the field of CSR. Suggestions regarding the training material are the following:
more interdisciplinary, interesting topics in the e-learning form, supported with the open
continuous theoretical development as well as practical cases.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 113/133
SPAIN
All respondents claimed that although it seems that the interest of SMEs towards CSR is
increasing in the last years, it is still minimum the number of SMEs that are interested or
priories CSR initiatives in their company. The main reason that justifies this answer is the
lack of awareness, as SMEs employers do not consider this area as a necessity or as
something essential for the good run of the company. Customers do not demand this
CSR policy, so SMEs do not implement it.
Therefore, there is a clear lack of awareness or understanding of the CSR.
On the other hand, although some company managers have some idea of CSR, they
consider this concept as occasional initiatives, not as a continuous process for the
company. In this sense, they can have some theoretical knowledge, but not practical
knowledge.
Training providers consider that some special effort should be made to make CSR closer
to small and medium enterprises, through the elaboration of new didactic resources, easy
to understand, adapted to each persons‟ circumstances (as for time and place); in this
sense, a virtual platform would be very welcomed. As well as this, it is considered raising
SME‟s awareness on CSR issues is essential; showing the benefits of implementing CSR
policies, not just as for benefits for other agents (customers, employers...) but also for
the company‟s economic results.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 114/133
4. Summary: Gap analysis on CSR training offer and
identified needs on SMEs
After having analyzed the existing training offer on CSR issues in each country, along
with SME‟s and VET institutions and universities‟ point of view and perspectives, some
gaps have been identified regarding current training offer and identified needs:
Lack of a strategic vision:
Most activities are based on an ad hoc approach and thus not systematic and
organized. When systematic, the effort is mostly related to environmental and
health & safety issues, not to a broader CSR agenda.
The efforts and results are not measured and monitored – neither is it
communicated to the public or to the stakeholders.
The significant stakeholders are not identified and involved.
As for existing training offer:
In countries like Slovenia, Bulgaria, Lithuania or Poland, a huge educational gap
exists. There is a lack of wide range of education and training offer including
studies/faculties concerning management from the point of view corporate social
responsibility. The disciplines, related to CSR, are often not mandatory subject of
study area or they are treated just as a currently fashionable subject or included
only formally. As well as this, curricula includes only partial CSR aspects such as
ethics in business; no complex solutions are available (just postgraduates studies
or trainings for top management). In the case of Lithuanian, it can be drawn how
there is a lack of suitably qualified personnel working in CSR in Colleges.
In the case of Austria, Spain or Denmark, although there exist several training
materials related to CSR, and there have been several initiatives for the strategic
implementation of CSR in SMEs, there still exist gaps in planning CSR
strategically. There is a lack of a strategic platform for the CSR effort linking it to
the company‟s business.
Therefore, it is clear in all analyzed countries that there is a lack of training
adapted to SMEs; thus, there is a lack between the demand from SMEs which are
aware of the CSR concept and the training which is provided by VET institutions.
In this sense, trainings from universities are rather useful for project or CSR
managers from large sized enterprises or NGOs and consultants.
In general, training materials are not adapted to SMEs targets; a need for further
education exists, especially within SMEs, not only to the manager level, but also
to other workers. Training materials on CSR must be specially adapted not only
for the top management of the company, but primarily for the employees, on
purpose to raise their consciousness.
Lack of practical knowledge on CSR, from the SME‟s side.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 115/133
As for training materials:
Current didactic resources are mainly based on conventional materials. Training
materials mostly consists of textbooks; lectures are based on a frontal method
(lecturer centred), where students are passive listeners. It seems that the
traditional learning environment is established a prevailing type of the educational
process within the higher education and VET area.
According to some trainers, there is a lack of standardization of written materials
on CSR. For example, there is a lack of one, single, complete document (platform)
including all CSR best practices implemented in SMEs.
Training resources often are too universal and too concise to attain more specific
purposes and there are not enough materials suitable to show practical examples
on CSR. However, there is a growth in demand for other types of didactic
resources, especially for CD, training guides and computer/virtual training
materials. New innovative and complementary materials are demanded in order to
facilitate the learning. Specifically, SMEs claimed that the most useful for them
would be virtual/e-learning, as it presents an alternative for learners and helps
them find a balance between private life, career, and further education. Therefore,
as claiming by the professors, companies and based on these analysis‟ results, an
important gap exists, especially in the field of virtual/e-learning. However, the
inclusion of personal support should be considered as well as a complement to
this platform (workshops, personal contact...).
All these training materials must be easy accessed and simple to understand and
to apply and must offer such kind of training that could ensure deep knowledge on
CSR.
As for topics covered:
Many programs, courses cover only environmental oriented topics. For example,
in the case of Slovenia, there are only few covering societal and economic topics.
There have not been perceived any integrated courses, covering all the SR topics.
On the other hand, in Bulgaria; it becomes clear that the needs of the SMEs for
training in human rights, environment, and consumer issues are not covered at
all. As for Lithuania, there is noticed there a growing need in training offers in
such CSR areas as technology development and access as well as the
organizational governance issues, prevention of pollution, consumer service,
support and dispute resolution.
On the issues level, there are gaps when comparing the existing toolboxes and
knowledge base with the issues in ISO 26000; very few training resources
consider issues included within ISO 26000.
As for current SMEs competences on CSR and CSR courses attended by them:
In the case of training on social responsibility, the majority of SMEs do not count
on specific knowledge and skills to integrate CSR in their activities. Similarly, few
companies use any training materials or tools for CSR implementation.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 116/133
As well as this, there is a lack of information on SME‟s training needs concerning.
But regarding the involvement of employees in these trainings, in very limited
cases, it is aimed to all employees. Therefore, there is a clearly need on trainings
and know-how transfer concerning CSR to all members within an enterprise.
However, an interesting aspect is, that almost all SMEs in the sample that had
conducted a CSR training would recommend this also to other companies.
Lack of information and lack of awareness:
In many cases, CSR is a new concept for SMEs. SMEs often lack awareness or
understanding of the CSR. In this sense, there is a strong barrier between SMEs
and CSR policies implementation, as a continuous process; this is due to the lack
of the understanding on the beneficial or economic output of the investment on
CSR implementation, as there is an important lack of information about social
responsibility„s profit for company and employees:
o Unclearness regarding the cost-benefit ratio, i.e. a lack of understanding
on the beneficial outcome of the investment to be made for the CSR
activity.
o The prejudice that CSR activities are expensive and therefore not bearable
for SMEs with little resources.
A persistent prejudice and therefore a strong barrier for SMEs is, that CSR is
rather something for large companies. A lot of subjects and issues of CSR, as
asked within the questionnaire, are regarded relevant only for large enterprises.
Therefore, this embarrasses the necessary anchoring of CSR in the core business,
as these subjects are assumed as not so important and legitimate for them.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 117/133
5. Recommendations
The following recommendations regarding trainings and training resources tries to bridge
the existing gaps identified through the previous analysis. This way, recommendations
from surveyed people (from SMEs and VET institutions) have been included:
CSR as an opportunity:
CSR represents an option for further sustainable growth. SMEs need to be taught
about CSR and its positive influence in the future.
Promotion of the CSR concept among SMEs‟ entrepreneurs using the reputation of
the International Standard Organisation; the small and medium enterprises from
the industry and services sectors should be aware and should be convinced that
the investments in measures related to CSR are long-term, well-paying back
investments. It is an investment in sustainability and competitiveness.
Awareness raising about the benefits and crucial role of the Corporate Social
Responsibility in improving competitiveness and raising the social standards in the
economy: major factor in encouraging the employers to implement CSR in their
everyday business operation is the pressure from the informed and caring
consumer. The assistance to encouraging socially responsible consumption might
be a strong stimulus to enterprise to pay the necessary attention to improving the
social and environmental standards in their everyday management.
The trainings should be designed not only for the top managers, but also for other
employees. Provision of know-how that is valuable for all members of an
organization: employers have to be stronger involved into CSR discussions as
they are relevant agents between a company and its environment. They can also
be seen as multipliers for issues from the organization into the public and on the
other hand for public issues into the organization.
The availability of a special Guidance on social responsibility in the form of an ISO
standard would assist in the promotion and implementation of such education and
training.
Topics to be included in a CSR training tool:
CSR topics should be represented to the SMEs in a way that suits those best
(flexible learning, as e-learning).
Flexibility regarding the prioritization of contents.
Different entrance levels could be considered.
Strong focus on the “business case” and also provision of know-how regarding the
measurability of CSR; practical cases should be included, showing clear benefits
for SMEs. These cases should include contents related to benefit measurements.
Analyzing and selecting case studies from surveyed SMEs is recommended for the
selection of contents.
Formulate real-life examples of strategic CSR platforms to help SME‟s identify the
business relevance. A tool/training material that explicitly tells the business case
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 118/133
for SME´s when working in a structured way with CSR and when incorporating
CSR into the business strategy.
CSR contents linked to a business model within the SMEs and development of
plans for encompassing all the aspects and utilization of all the instruments of
CSR; the owners and the managers should be assisted in their plans to turn to
socially responsible management and socially responsible investments. The
research institutes, the universities and the NGOs should be prepared to teach
them to develop strategies, plans for implementations and reporting instruments
according to the principles of accountability, transparency, ethical behavior,
respect for stakeholders, respect for rule of law, respect for international norms of
behavior, respect for human rights when the entrepreneurs will be ready and
asking for them.
Organization of the effort, that is develop training on how to integrate CSR into
the existing structures and processes.
Monitor and measure CSR performance. Develop a reporting system for SME´s
based on GRI but adjusted to the core themes and issues of ISO26000.
Support a life cycle approach to create a common platform of understanding
among the partners in the product chain. Develop examples on how the life cycle
approach can improve performance and business.
Focus on communicating with the consumers/customers. Develop a tool or text
about: “Six principles to keep in mind when communicating on CSR/ your work
with ISO26000 as a SME”. Give the SME´s concrete examples on how to
communicate and how not to.
Include guidance on how to conduct a stakeholder analysis and how to use
stakeholder inputs and concerns when working with the framework of ISO26000.
Use of cases when developing the teaching platform should be emphasized and
the quality of cases should be improved also including much more relevant
dilemmas. Many cases today are of poor quality and not very interesting.
Develop guidance to the trainers on how to mix didactic resource to a specific
target-group.
Develop a pixie book that makes it more attractive for SME´s to read ISO26000
(it is comprehensive…)
A special focus should be given to CSR training contents addressed to people
already involved in the human resource development, to assist the integration of
a new concept in the everyday operating of the SMEs.
The training should pay special attention to the core subjects of consumer issues
and community involvement and development, due to the fact that the consumer
pressure could be a strong motivator for SMEs to be started within SMEs issues.
Tips for the design of the CSR training tool:
Establishment of platforms (presence or virtual) that allow the exchange of
experiences and mutual learning. A virtual platform would be more recommended
due to its flexibility for SMEs, taking into account their limited time and resources.
However, due to the limitation of an only virtual platform (e-learning), personal
contact and direct support from the trainer should be considered, in order to
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 119/133
complement the training, as a personal dialogue is needed. For instance,
workshops could be included in the training.
Provision of intergenerational, interdisciplinary and intercultural learning settings.
Compact trainings and training resources, particularly in the form of guides;
unified contents, standardized and adapted to SMEs needs.
Provision of personal training, also various forms are possible (presence training
or virtual attendance).
Participants shall be flexible regarding their learning and know-how progress.
Motivating resources; the training should make CSR more friendly and closer to
SMEs.
Provision of further reading, information, links to relevant organizations and web-
sites.
Definition of terms and/or provision of a glossary.
Clear and simple language, pregnant and generally understandable information.
Visual contents, through attractive, accessible and easy to use materials.
To sum up, as indicated through previous recommendation, the new CSR training
platform should make ISO 26000 accessible to SME‟s, in order to allow them and make
easier the integration of CSR strategies within the overall company‟s strategy. As well as
this, the introduction of the CSI tool should be expanded to all the interested
stakeholders, not only SMEs, but also to the universities and VET institutions, in order to
provide them integrated and accessible didactic resources.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 120/133
References
AUSTRIA:
1. Deuerlein, I., Riedel, S., Pomper, F., Die gesellschaftliche Verantwortung
österreichischer Unternehmen, Initiative CSR Austria, Vienna 2003
2. Fembek, M., CSR. Jahrbuch für unternehmerische Verantwortung 2010 (CSR Annual
2010), KGV Marketing- und VerlagsgesmbH, Vienna 2009
3. Fembek, M., CSR. Jahrbuch für unternehmerische Verantwortung 2011 (CSR Annual
2011), KGV Marketing- und VerlagsgesmbH, Vienna 2010
4. Gluske, H., Schmied, G., Chancen nutzen!, Das Büro Chancen nutzen, Presentation
on http://www.roomycompany.at/downloads/roomycontactbetriebsbefragung.pdf
5. Keck, W., Schubert, M., CSR Trainingshandbuch, FO.FO.s, Vienna 2007
6. Köppl, P., Neureiter, M. (Editors), Corporate Social Responsibility. Leitlinien und
Konzepte im Management der gesellschaftlichen Verantwortung von Unternehmen,
Vienna 2004
7. Lebensart, Die neue ISO 26000: Gesellschaftliche Verantwortung in Unternehmen
und Organisationen, Article on http://www.lebensart.at/start.asp?ID=1719&b=74
(24/10/2010)
8. Mandl, I., Dorr, A., El-Chichakli, B., CSR and Competiveness. European SME’s Good
Practice, National Report Austria, KMU Forschung Austria, Vienna 2007
9. Mark-Ungericht, B., "Eine leere Hülle, die mit Inhalten zu füllen ist", Article on
http://derstandard.at/1285200682681/Eine-leere-Huelle-die-mit-Inhalten-zu-
fuellen-ist from 12/10/2010
10. Mark-Ungericht, B., Raith, D., Korenjak, T., CSR-Beratung in Österreich. Eine
Bestandsaufnahme, Study of Netzwerk Soziale Verantwortung (NeSoVe), Graz 2010
11. Mark-Ungericht, B., Raith, D., Korenjak, T., Corporate Social Responsibility in
Österreich, Graz 2009
12. Raith, D., Corporate Social Responsibility in Österreich, Article on http://csr-
news.net/main/2010/02/03/corporate-social-responsibility-in-osterreich/,
(03/02/2010)
13. Resel, K., Predota, A., Methoden-Handbuch. In 7 Schritten zum
Nachhaltigkeitsbericht, by order of BMLFUW, ABCSD, WKO, WIFI, BMWA, BMVIT,
Vienna 2006
14. respACT (Editor), CSR Leitfaden für Ein-Personen-Unternehmen, Vienna 2009
15. respACT (Editor), CSR-Ratgeber. In 7 Schritten zu einer CSR Strategie, Vienna
16. respACT (Editor), Erfolg mit FAIRantwortung in Oberösterreich/in Salzburg/in der
Steiermark, Vienna 2008/2009
17. respACT, Jahresbericht 2009 (Annual Report 2009), Vienna 2010
18. respACT, Jahresbericht 2010 (Annual Report 2010), Vienna 2011
19. respACT, Erfolg mit Verantwortung. Ein Leitbild für zukunftsfähiges Wirtschaften,
Vienna 2009
20. Walther, M., Schenkel, M., Herausforderung CSR. Strategie und
Selbstwahrnehmung mittelständischer Unternehmer, in: Meyer, J., Strategien von
kleinen und mittleren Unternehmen, Cologne 2010
21. Wiener Gruppe für Integritätsmanagement und gesellschaftliche Verantwortung,
Ethik und Ökonomie – Widerspruch oder Komplement?, Vienna 2006
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 121/133
22. Zadek, S., MacGillivray, A. (Editors), The State of Responsible Competitiveness
2007 (Responsible Competitiveness Index, 2007, Top 20), AccountAbility, 2007
BULGARIA:
23. John Elkington, Cannibals with Forks: the Triple Bottom Line of 21st Century
Business, Capstone Publishing, Oxford, 1997.
24. COMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION concerning Corporate Social
Responsibility: A business contribution to Sustainable Development, Brussels,
2.7.2002, COM(2002) 347 final
25. Corporate Social Responsibility in Bulgaria – the New Challenges, United Nations
Development Programme, Country office Bulgaria, 2007
26. Baseline Study on CSR Practices in the New Member States and Candidate
Countries, United Nations Development Programme, 2007
27. D. Matev, Zl. Gospodinova, G. Peev, Kr. Yordanov, The Corporate Social
Responsibility in Bulgaria, Revenue Management et avenir, No23-Avril, 2009.
28. International Standard ISO 26000: Guidance on social responsibility, International
Standard Organisation, 2010.
29. Темата „Корпоративна социална отговорност” в българските печатни медии,
UNDP Bulgaria, 2008
30. Корпоративна социална отговорност в българския контекст, Глобален договор
на ООН и Фондация „Помощ за благотврителността в Българиая”, септември-
октомври 2006 г.
31. www.uni-sofia.bg
32. www.vfu.bg
33. www.uacg.bg
34. www.vuzf.bg
35. www.uni-svishtov.bg
36. www.hiron-mc.com
37. http://emcbg.eu/
38. www.ei-consultinggroup.com
39. www.bblf.com
40. www.pari.bg
DK:
41. www.mst.dk
42. www.greennetwork.dk
43. www.CSRcouncil.dk
44. www.CSRgov.dk
45. www.CSRgov.dk
46. All publications can be downloadet from www.CSRgov.dk
47. Ashridge (2005): “Catalogue of CSR Activities: A broad overview” (report produced
for the Danish Commerce and Companies Agency)
48. TNS Gallup (2005: “Udbredelse og økonomisk effekt af CSR-aktiviteter blandt
SMV”. (Dissemination and economic effects of CSR-activities among SME‟s)
49. Dansk Erhverv, 2008: “Erhvervslivets ansvarlighed. Doing well by doing good”
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 122/133
50. Rådet for Samfundsansvar (2010): “Dansk erhvervslivs indsats inden for
samfundsansvar”
51. Danish Center for Leadership/Center for Ledelse (2009): “CSR – Corporate Social
Responsibility 2009”
52. CBS – Copenhagen Business School (2008): CSR and occupational health & safety
in SME‟s
53. http://jura.ku.dk/students/courses/master/int_labour_law_corp_soc_responb/
54. http://sis.ku.dk/kurser/viskursus.aspx?knr=137375&sprog=1&forrige=609
55. www.cbs.dk
56. www.au.dk
57. http://www.sdu.dk/Uddannelse/Kandidat/Product_Development_Innovation/Uddan
nelsens_opbygning/GlobalSourcing
58. www.sdu.dk
59. http://www.pgsn.aau.dk/planogmiljo/em7/?nt=26
60. http://www.man.dtu.dk/English/Education/Courses_at_IPL.aspx?coursecode=4264
4
61. http://www.ruc.dk/uddannelse/fag/virksomhedsstudier/om-faget/kursuskatalog/
62. www.csrforum.dk
63. http://ideascompass.dk/en
64. www.climatecompass.dk
65. Global Compact self assessment tool: www.Globalcompactselfassessment.org
66. www.csrkompasset.dk
67. www.kommunikationskompasset.dk
68. Danish Commerce and Companies Agency: project “virksom.nu” (Project
“active.now”): www.virksom.nu
69. People and Profit website: www.overskudmedomtanke.dk/sw63523.asp and
70. People and Profit Guide (PDF)
71. www.mst.dk/en
72. http://www.greennetwork.dk/page123.aspx
LITHUANIA:
73. Baltrusiene A, Karciauskiene D. (2009). Studies of corporate social responsibility in
Lithuania and their improvement possibilities [in lithuanian], available at:
https://ojs.kauko.lt/index.php/ssktpd/article/viewFile/87/80
74. Institutions of Higher Education, Colleges and secondary schools in Lithuania,
available at: http://www.on.lt/hedu3.htm
75. Ministry of Social Security and Labour of the Republic of Lithuania, available at:
http://www.socmin.lt/index.php?1433188107
76. Piligrimiene Z. (2009). SocialSME project . Requirement analysis. Lithuania.
77. United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) in Lithuania, available at:
http://www.undp.lt/
78. Vogulyte V., Gudoniene V. (2007). Corporate Social Responsibility - altruism or
profit? [in lithuanian], available at:
http://www.verslobanga.lt/lt/patark.full/4617c3a0833e0.2
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 123/133
79. World Bank (2005). Enabling a better environment for Corporate Social
Responsibility - Diagnostics project. What Does Business Think about Corporate
Social Responsibility? Part 1: Attitudes and Practices in Estonia, Latvia and
Lithuania. Research report.
POLAND:
80. http://www.sgh.waw.pl/ksztalcenie/podyplomowe/spis/teorii_i_praktyki_spolecznej
_odpowiedzialnosci_przedsiebiorstwa/
81. http://www.studiapodyplomowe.kozminski.edu.pl/index.php/pl/specjalistyczne/csr_
strategia_odpowiedzialnego_/
82. http://www.wse.krakow.pl/pl/Lider_nowej_gospodarki/artykuly/art,227,spoleczna_
odpowiedzialnosc_biznesu.html
83. http://www.wz.uw.edu.pl/studia,opis,60,podyplomowe,zarzadzanie-zaoczne-
odpowiedzialnosc-spoleczna-biznesu.html
84. http://www.spcsr.sggw.pl/?file=ogolne.php
85. http://wsptwp.eu/n/warszawa/dla_kandydatow/spolecznie_odpowiedzialny_biznes
86. http://www.bsdesign.nazwa.pl/Binsztok/index.php?id=7
87. http://studia.biz.pl/137/collegium-civitas-w-warszawie/zarzadzanie-
innowacjami/10610/
88. http://www.owsiiz.home.pl/index.php5?page=97
89. http://lob.org.pl/strona.php?kat=341
90. http://sife.pl/
91. http://www.csr-in-smes.eu/downloads/brochure_poland.pdf (Detailed descriptions
at: www.csr-in-smes.eu)
92. http://www.csrinfo.org/pl/wprowadzenie
93. http://odpowiedzialnybiznes.pl/en/about-us.html
94. http://csr.fob.org.pl/wazne-informacje.html
95. http://sendzimir.org.pl/en/textbook
96. http://projects.mediaplanet.com/poland/csr_5_5_6350/kompendium_csr__dgp__gr
udzien_2010.pdf
97. http://www.odpowiedzialnybiznes.com.pl/;
http://www.odpowiedzialnybiznes.edu.pl/
98. http://www.asbiznesu.pl/
99. http://www.odpowiedzialne.pl/
100. http://www.wmcentrum-csr.net/
101. http://www.csr.haus.pl/
102. http://sob.underline.pl/
103. http://www.odpowiedzialnafirma.pl/
104. http://csr.bcc.org.pl/
105. http://www.crnavigator.com/
106. “Corporate Social Responsibility of SMEs, practical examples of enhancing the SME
sector‟s competitiveness“: http://www.csr-in-
smes.eu/downloads/brochure_poland.pdf.
107. http://www.mg.gov.pl/files/upload/7904/podrecznik.pdf
108. More information on www.filantropia.org.pl.
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 124/133
109. http://www.socialsme.org/index.php/pl/prezentacja-projektu/
110. http://old.fob.org.pl/cms_a/upload/file/PublikacjeIBadania/InstytucjerynkuCSRwPol
sce2010.pdf
111. http://odpowiedzialnybiznes.pl/pl/praktyka-csr/aktualnosci/wiadomosci-od-
partnerow/raportowanie-csr-dla-m%C5%9Ap,4301.html
112. www.fwpn.org.pl
113. http://ec.europa.eu/enterprise/csr/sme_expert_group.htm/
114. http://odpowiedzialnybiznes.pl/public/files/Podrecznik_do_samooceny_dla_przedsie
biorstw_UNDP_2011.pdf
115. http://www.csrinfo.org/pl/warsztaty
SLOVENIA:
116. Fras Haslinger N et al. (2007). CSR – an opportunity for SMEs, Proceedings 11th
SKOJ conference, Slovenian Association for PR. (in Slovene).
117. Horus (2011). Available online: http://www.horus.si/ (15 March 2011) (in Slovene).
118. Knez-Riedl, J (2002). Corporate Social Responsibility of SMEs. Slovenian
Observatory of SMEs. University of Maribor, Faculty of Economic and Business,
Maribor. (in Slovene).
119. Knez-Riedl, J (2002). Environmental Responsibility of Slovenian SMEs. Slovenian
Observatory of SMEs. University of Maribor, Faculty of Economic and Business,
Maribor. (in Slovene).
120. Rustja N (2009). CSR as a competitive advantage of SMEs in Slovenia. Master
Thesis. University of Ljubljana, Faculty of Economics, Ljubljana. (in Slovene).
121. Styrian Chamber of Commerce (2011). Slovenia is becoming more and more active
in the field of CSR. Available online (in Slovene):
http://www.stajerskagz.si/?page=114 (15 March 2011)
122. Paik, W., Lee, J. Y., McMahon, E. (2004). Facilitating Collaborative Learning in
Virtual (and Sometimes Mobile) Environments. In: Brussler, C., et al (Eds.). WISE
2004 Workshop. LNCS 3307. pp. 161–166. Springer Verlag Berlin Heidelberg.
123. Peat, M. (2000). Towards first year biology online: a virtual learning environment.
Educational Technology & Society 3(3): 203–207.
SPAIN:
124. “Responsabilidad Social Corporativa: Tendencias empresariales en España”. 2003.
PricewaterhouseCoopers
125. www.globalreporting.org/
126. “Una aproximación al estado de la RSE en la enseñanza en España”. Ministerio de
Trabajo e Inmigración, Club de Excelencia en Sostenibilidad, 2010.
127. Asociación Española para la Calidad:
http://www.aec.es/web/guest/formacion/catalogo/listado/for0454/RS-GE-D454-
18102010-ED05621?gclid=CL7c3sGd_aYCFcse4QodkQ8rZg
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 125/133
128. CSR Observatory:
http://www.observatoriorsc.org/images/stories/audio/Proyectos/Informacion_curso
RSC.pdf
129. Spanish Association for Standardization and Certification:
http://www.aenor.es/aenor/actualidad/actualidad/noticias.asp?campo=9&codigo=1
8018&tipon=
130. http://www.izaite.net/docs/guiarse.pdf
131. http://www.clubsostenibilidad.org/f_publicaciones/smes.swf
132. http://guiaderecursos.crana.org/directorio/detalle.php?ob=1&id=586
133. http://www.navarra.es/NR/rdonlyres/A8657C74-45D7-4445-B12A-
482B3EEF66DE/157643/GUIADIAGNOSTICOSRSE.pdf
134. http://www.crana.org/ficheros/File/GestionAmbiental_RSE/Documentacion/Publicac
iones_crana/Metodologia_innovarse/E3-
RSE_Guia_Planes_Actuacion_InnovaRSE.pdf
135. http://www.clubsostenibilidad.org/f_publicaciones/best_practices.pdf
136. http://www.xertatu.net/ca_plantilla.asp?idMenu=21
137. http://www.respyme.es/formacion/newsletters-1-esp.pdf
138. http://www.csrvaderegio.net/en/homepage/index_en.asp
139. http://www.pactomundial.org/index.asp?MP=5&MS=10&MN=1
140. http://www.compromisorse.com/rse/2010/07/02/la-aeca-pone-los-informes-de-
rsc-al-alcance-de-las-pymes/
141. http://www.compromisorse.com/best-practice/competitividad-e-innovacion-
responsable/caja-navarra/ayuda-a-los-clientes-pymes-a-elaborar-sus-memorias-
de-rc/
142. http://www.ipyme.org/es-
ES/SubvencionesAyudas/RSE/Paginas/ResponsabilidadSocialEmpresa_Ficha.aspx
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 126/133
Glossary of Abbreviations
CSR Corporate Social Responsibility
SME Small and Medium Enterprise
VET Vocational and Educational Training
NGO Non Government Organisation
NACE Nomenclature générale des Activités économiques dans les Communautés
Européennes
UNDP United Nations Development Programme
ISO International Organization for Standardization
OHSAS Occupational Health and Safety Assessment Series
SA Social Accountability (Standard)
BSCI Business Social Compliance Initiative
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 127/133
Annexe 1 - Questionnaire for SMEs:
ADDRESSE: Companies - SMEs Corporate Social Responsibility is a concept that receives considerable attention from sustainability specialists in all countries and lately, ISO has launched a new standard – ISO 26000 on Social Responsibility. However, it is a fact that in the case of the SMEs there is a lack of know-how and training materials to support the systematic integration of social responsibility considerations in their management process. Are the SMEs involved in Corporate Social Responsibility issues? Why? Do they know how to develop this area? Are there adequate training materials focused on SMEs? Which competences are required? Which are SME’s training needs? And trainers’ needs? This survey is part of a research project funded by the Education and Culture DG of the European Commission. The aim of answering this survey is to obtain information about SMEs’ involvement in Social Responsibility issues, in order to develop training materials on this area to support SMEs in integrating social responsibility initiatives in their business. The survey is based on multiple choices and you can select more than one, if appropriate. It will not take long to fill in this survey. Thank you in advance for your time and collaboration. Confidentiality Statement: This research project guarantees respondents total confidentiality.
1. COMPANY PROFILE
1.1. Company name: 1.2. Activity (according to NACE classification): 1.3. Address: 1.4. Contact: 1.5. Website: 1.6. Identification of the interviewee (optional):
Name: Function:
1.7. Number of employees (could be estimated):
< 10 10 < x < 50 50 < x < 250
1.8. Turnover latest financial year (could be estimated):
< 500.000€ 500.000€ < x < 5.000.000€ > 5.000.000€
2. CURRENT PRACTICES FOR INTEGRATING SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY
2.1. Does the company have a Human Resource development policy?
Yes No
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 128/133
2.2. Does the company have an Environment Protection policy?
Yes No
2.3. Does the company have a social responsibility policy?
Yes No
2.4. What do you understand by “Social Responsibility”?
Investing in the human resources Investing in occupational health and safety Observing human rights Taking care of environmental issues Charity (donations) Others, please indicate:
2.5. Is social responsibility a priority area in your company?
Yes No
Please, indicate why: 2.6. Is the company certified or working according to any of the following standards?
ISO 14001 ISO 9001 OHSAS 18001 SA8000 Global Compact Ethical Trade Iniciative BSCI AA1000 Other, please indicate which one:
2.7. Does the company conduct any audits?
Environmental audit in our own company Environmental audit in the supply chain Social audit in our own company Social audit in the supply chain No
2.8. Does the company carry out initiatives for social responsibility?
Within the company In the supply chain In the local community No (go to question 2.12.)
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 129/133
2.9. Are these initiatives integrated in any management planning?
No Yes. Please, indicate the person/department in charge of this planning: There is a specially assigned person for Corporate Social Responsibility. This role is included in the Human Resource Development department. This role is carried out by the responsible person/department for Environmental Protection. Others, please indicate:
2.10. Why does the company carry out these social responsibility initiatives?
Market reasons Clients’ requirements Awareness and ethical consciousness Others, please indicate:
2.11. Which areas of social responsibility are these initiatives related to?
Organizational governance Human rights Labour practices The environment Fair operating practices Consumer issues Community involvement and development Others, please indicate:
2.12. If the answer is “NO”, why does the company not carry out social responsibility initiatives?
Lack of top management commitment Lack of customer demand Lack of know-how Lack of time and human resources Social Responsibility has no economic benefit Social Responsibility is expensive Social Responsibility does not bring competitive advantage Others:
2.13. Has the company considered working on social responsibility issues?
Yes No
2.14. Has the company done any training on social responsibility?
Yes No (go to question 3.1.)
2.15. Who was the training aimed at:
Management Internal experts Selected persons. Please specify their functions: All employees
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 130/133
2.16. Was the training...
Internal, based on own knowledge Internal, with external experts External
2.17. Would you recommend this kind of training to other companies?
Yes No
Please, indicate why:
3. INTEREST AND POTENTIALITY ON CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY
3.1. How relevant do you judge the following principles for your company?
PRINCIPLES How relevant are these principles for the organization? (1-it is not relevant; 4- 100% relevant)
1. Accountability
2. Transparency
3. Ethical behavior
4. Respect for stakeholder interests
5. Respect for the rule of law
6. Respect for international norms of behaviour
7. Respect for human rights
3.2. Has the company pointes out the main stakeholders?
Yes No
3.3. If yes, are the stakeholders...
involved in developing CSR strategies engaged in carrying out the company’s CSR initiatives informed about the company’s CSR efforts
not involved or informed
4. NEEDS OF KNOW-HOW ON SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY
4.1. Does the company count on specific knowledge and skills to integrate social responsibility?
Yes, please specify: No
4.2. Does the company use CSR training materials/tools?
Yes, please specify: No
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 131/133
4.3. Relevance and training needs on subjects and issues The subjects and issues mentioned in the scheme are based on the ISO 26000 standard
CORE SUBJECTS and ISSUES
Is the core subject and its issues
judged relevant for the organization? (1-low / 4-high)
Training need on this subject/issue
(1-low / 4-high)
2. Organizational Governance: “system by which an organization makes and implements decisions in pursuit of its objectives”
Accountability, transparency, ethical behavior, respect for stakeholder interests, and respect for the rule of law
2. Human rights: “basic rights to which all human beings are entitled because they are human beings”
Due diligence
Human rights risk situations
Avoidance of complicity
Resolving grievances
Discrimination and vulnerable groups
Civil and political rights
Economic, social and cultural rights
Fundamental rights at work
3. Labour practices: “all policies and practices relating to work performed within, by or on behalf of the organization”
Employment and employment relationships
Conditions of work and social protection
Social dialogue
Health and safety at work
Human development and training in the workplace
4. The environment
Prevention of pollution
Sustainable resource use
Climate change mitigation and adaptation
Protection and restoration of the natural environment
5. Fair operating practices: “concern ethical conduct in an organization’s dealings with other organizations and individuals”
Anti–corruption
Responsible political involvement
Fair competition
Promoting social responsibility in the sphere of influence
Respect for property rights
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 132/133
6. Consumer Issues
Fair marketing, factual and unbiased information and fair contractual practices
Protecting consumers’ health and safety
Sustainable consumption
Consumer service, support, and dispute resolution
Consumer data protection and privacy
Access to essential services
Education and awareness
7. Community involvement and development: “an organization's proactive outreach to the community”
Community involvement
Education and culture
Employment creation and skills development
Technology development and access
Wealth and income creation
Health
Social investment
4.4. Which method would be useful for you?
Text Audio CD room Video Guides Manuals Computer/virtual Personal trainer Others, please indicate:
4.5. Please, specify other comments or recommendations for the development of training materials on
social responsibility focused on SMEs:
4.6. Would you be interested in participating in testing the developed training materials?
Yes, I would like to know more No, thank you
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 133/133
Annexe 2 - Questionnaire for VETs:
ADDRESSE: VET Institutions Corporate Social Responsibility is a concept that receives considerable attention from sustainability specialists in all countries and lately, ISO has launched a new standard on social responsibility – ISO 26000. However, it is a fact that in the case of the SMEs there is a lack of know-how and training materials to support the systematic integration of social responsibility considerations in their management process. Are the SMEs involved in Corporate Social Responsibility issues? Why? Do they know how to develop this area? Are there adequate training materials focused on SMEs? Which are trainers’ needs? This survey is part of a research project funded by the Education and Culture DG of the European Commission. The aim of answering this survey is to obtain information about existing training offer and materials related to Social Responsibility issues, in order to develop new training materials with public access on this area to be implemented on small and medium companies. It will not take long to fill in this survey. Thank you in advance for your time and collaboration. Confidentiality Statement: This research project guarantees respondents total confidentiality. 1. Institution profile: Name of the organisation: Contact person: web-site: 2. Has the organisation courses or training on specific subjects related to social responsibility?
Yes. Please specify the subjects and link to a website if relevant (continue reading the following
questions): No (go to question 12)
3. Are the subjects stand-alone CSR or included in other courses?
Stand-alone course Integrated in another module. Please, indicate the title of the module:
4. Which is the duration of the social responsibility course or training offer?
< 10 hours 10 < x > 20 hours 20 < x > 40 hours > 40 hours. Please, indicate:
5. How would you define the content of the course/training offer?
100% theoretical More theoretical than practical: 75% < x < 100% of the course is theoretical 50% theoretical and 50% practical More practical than theoretical: 25% < x < 50% of the course is theoretical 100% practical
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 134/133
6. Which are the target groups of the training offer?
Students Companies and other organisations Unemployed Others, please specify:
7. Which subject areas does the training offer include?
Organizational governance Human rights Labour practices The environment Fair operating practices Consumer issues Community involvement and development Others, please indicate:
8. Which are the didactic resources used in the subject/course?
Text Audio CD room Video Guides Manuals Computer/virtual Others, please indicate:
9. Which is the source of the used materials?
Self-made Licensed Free-access Others, please indicate:
10. Which are the advantages and disadvantages of the used didactic resources? 11. Which other documents/tools would be useful for you, besides those already used?
Text Audio CD room Video Guides Manuals Computer/virtual Others, please indicate:
510543-LLP-1-2010-1-SI-LEONARDO-LMP 135/133
12. How do you assess social responsibility demand from SMEs?
In general, SMEs do not have real necessity of social responsibility; lack of social responsibility
awareness. In general, SMEs do not have knowledge about the existing social responsibility training resources. There is a lack of top management commitment in SMEs about social responsibility. SMEs would be interested in social responsibility if training resources would be adapted to them. Others, please specify:
13. Please, indicate recommendations for the development of training materials on social responsibility: