Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils 2

Smoke-free policy in outdoor areasA 2011 survey of NSW councils

1 Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils

While most of the evidence relates to indoor exposure, there is emerging evidence on how smoking affects air quality in outdoor locations such as alfresco cafes and playgrounds. A recent study which measured cigarette smoke levels in a variety of outdoor locations showed that a person sitting near a smoker in an outdoor area could be exposed to levels of cigarette smoke similar to the exposure of someone sitting in an indoor pub or club. Therefore, the second-hand smoke in outdoor areas where people tend to congregate, including alfresco dining areas, sports stadiums and concert venues, can present a real health risk to the public and staff. There is also evidence to suggest that smoke-free areas support smokers who are trying to quit as well as reduce their overall cigarette consumption.

Community interest in the provision of smoke-free outdoor areas such as playgrounds, sporting fields and alfresco dining areas is growing. To assist local councils in developing their own smoke-free outdoor areas policy, the Heart Foundation, The Cancer Council NSW, the Australian Medical Association NSW, the Local Government and Shires Associations of NSW and Action on Smoking and Health Australia have developed a resource kit including a CD-ROM of signage templates for Local Government outlining in clear detail the steps required to present before Council a motion to make Council owned outdoor areas progressively smoke-free.

This report outlines the NSW councils which have introduced smoke-free outdoor areas policy and the areas the policy covers.

Introduction

Smoking is the largest single preventable cause of death in Australia, killing more than 15,000 Australians a year. There is substantial evidence linking exposure to second-hand smoke with a range of serious and life threatening health impacts including heart disease, cancer, asthma and other respiratory problems. Children exposed to second-hand smoke are at an increased risk of asthma, sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS), acute respiratory infections and ear problems.

Contents1 Introduction

2 Methodology

2 Results

12 Resource kit

13 Barriers to introducing or expanding policy

14 Alfresco dining

15 Conclusion

15 Appendix

Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils 2

Heart Foundation staff contacted each council by phone. Research was conducted in order to identify the most appropriate person to speak to if the contact person from previous surveys was no longer the correct contact.

An introductory script and set of questions (Appendix A) was provided to ensure a consistent approach was taken and results were immediately logged in a spreadsheet.

This report includes all councils that had formally approved a policy by 30 June 2011. Cases where policy has not yet been implemented have been highlighted.

1 MorethanhalfofNSWcouncilshavesmoke-freepolicy

As of 30 June 2011, 59% of all NSW Councils had adopted some form of smoke-free outdoor areas policy. Of the 152 councils in NSW, 89 now have policy, compared to 76 in 2010, 58 in 2009 and 28 in 2007.

2 Mostcommonoutdoorareaswithsmoke-freepolicy

Of the 89 councils with smoke-free policy, 88 (99%) cover children’s playgrounds, making this the most common smoke-free area. There are 69 councils (78%) with policy to cover sporting fields, 51 (57%) cover pools and 43 (48%) have made areas within a certain distance of council buildings smoke-free. Alfresco dining areas are now smoke-free in 30 councils, up from 22 in 2010 and 21 in 2009, which represents a 233% increase in the past 2 years.

3 Regional/metropolitansplit

There are now 52 regional councils with smoke-free policy in NSW compared to 37 metropolitan councils. However in relative terms the take up of smoke-free policy is much higher in the Sydney metropolitan area. Of the total number of metropolitan councils, 86% have smoke-free policy compared to almost half (48%) of the 109 regional councils. The number of regional councils with policy has increased almost fivefold in the last four years.

4 Tables

The following tables provide more detailed information:

Table1: Details of smoke-free policy by council

Table2: Comparison of metropolitan and regional/ rural councils

Table3: Take-up of smoke-free policy since 2007 across all councils

Methodology

Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas – A 2011 survey of NSW councils

Results

To monitor the implementation and progress of smoke-free policies, the Heart Foundation conducted a survey of all 152 councils across NSW between April and June 2011. Similar surveys were carried out in 2007, 2008, 2009 and 2010.

3 Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils

Arm

idal

e D

umar

esq

Cou

ncil

✓✓

Ash

field

Mun

icip

al C

ounc

il ✓

✓

Aub

urn

City

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓

Ban

ksto

wn

City

Cou

ncil

✓✓

Bat

hurs

t Reg

iona

l Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓

Beg

a V

alle

y Sh

ire

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

1✓

✓✓

Air

port

term

inal

s, w

harf

s an

d je

tties

,

Bel

linge

n Sh

ire

Cou

ncil

✓✓

Bla

ckto

wn

City

Cou

ncil

✓

Bla

nd S

hire

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

Blu

e M

ount

ains

City

Cou

ncil

�✓

✓

Bog

an S

hire

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

Bou

rke

Shir

e C

ounc

il�

✓�

✓

Bro

ken

Hill

City

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

Bur

woo

d C

ounc

il ✓

✓✓

Cam

den

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

Taxi

ran

ks

Can

ada

Bay

Cou

ncil,

City

of

✓✓

Can

terb

ury

City

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓

Ces

snoc

k C

ity C

ounc

il✓

✓A

quat

ic c

entr

e

Cla

renc

e V

alle

y C

ounc

il✓

✓✓

�2✓

✓✓

�3✓

With

in 1

0m o

f lic

ense

d pr

emis

es,

with

in 1

5m o

f tax

i ran

ks, p

ublic

jetti

es

Cof

fs H

arbo

ur C

ity C

ounc

il✓

✓�4

✓✓

✓✓

�5

Playgro

undsSports

field

sAlfr

esco d

inin

g Beaches

Park

s

Recreati

on areas Rese

rves

Pools

Bus shelte

rsW

ithin

10m

of

council

build

ings

Council eve

nts Oth

er

Add

ition

al p

olic

y in

last

12

mon

ths

or n

ew c

ounc

il

Tabl

e 1

– D

etai

ls o

f sm

oke-

free

pol

icy

by c

ounc

il

Smo

ke-f

ree

po

licy

incl

ud

es:

Co

un

cil

1. 1

3 po

pula

r oc

ean

and

encl

osed

bea

ches

. 2.

With

in 1

5m o

f pat

rolle

d ar

eas.

3. W

ithin

15m

. 4.

Sm

oke

free

inte

rnat

iona

l sta

dium

. 5.

Som

e ev

ents

.

Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils 4

Coo

nam

ble

Shir

e C

ounc

il✓

✓✓

1

Coo

tam

undr

a Sh

ire

Cou

ncil

✓✓

G

rand

stan

d

Den

iliqu

in C

ounc

il✓

✓✓

✓ 2

Dub

bo C

ity C

ounc

il✓

✓

Euro

boda

lla S

hire

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓Te

nnis

cou

rts

Fair

field

City

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓

Gle

n In

nes

Seve

rn C

ounc

il✓

✓✓

✓

✓

Glo

uces

ter

Shir

e C

ounc

il ✓

✓✓

Rec

reat

ion

cent

re

Gos

ford

City

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

Gou

lbur

n M

ulw

aree

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

Gre

ater

Tar

ee C

ity C

ounc

il✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

Cov

ered

taxi

ran

ks

Gre

at L

akes

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

3✓

4W

ithin

10m

of B

BQ

and

pic

nic

furn

iture

Gun

neda

h Sh

ire

Cou

ncil

✓

Guy

ra S

hire

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

Com

mun

ity h

all,

civi

c ce

ntre

, all

coun

cil v

enue

s

Haw

kesb

ury

City

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

✓

Hay

Shi

re C

ounc

il✓

Gro

unds

aro

und

Tour

ist I

nfor

mat

ion

Are

a

Hill

s Sh

ire

Cou

ncil,

The

✓✓

✓✓

Hol

royd

City

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

Hor

nsby

, The

Cou

ncil

of th

e Sh

ire o

f✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

Mal

ls, t

axi r

anks

Hur

stvi

lle C

ity C

ounc

il ✓

Playgro

undsSports

field

sAlfr

esco d

inin

g Beaches

Park

s

Recreati

on areas Rese

rves

Pools

Bus shelte

rsW

ithin

10m

of

council

build

ings

Council eve

nts Oth

er

Add

ition

al p

olic

y in

last

12

mon

ths

or n

ew c

ounc

il

Tabl

e 1

– D

etai

ls o

f sm

oke-

free

pol

icy

by c

ounc

il (c

ontin

ued)

Smo

ke-f

ree

po

licy

incl

ud

es:

Co

un

cil

1. S

kate

par

ks.

2. W

ithin

5m

. 3.

With

in 1

0m o

f pat

rolle

d ar

eas.

4. W

ithin

10m

of r

ock

pool

s, la

ke a

nd o

cean

bat

hs a

nd a

djac

ent c

ongr

egat

ion

area

s.

5 Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils

Kem

psey

Shi

re C

ounc

il✓

Net

ball

cour

ts, B

BQ

are

as

Kia

ma,

The

Cou

ncil

of th

e M

unic

ipal

ity o

f✓

✓✓

✓ 1

Publ

ic e

vent

s (e

.g. a

nnua

l sho

w)

Koga

rah

City

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

✓ 2

✓✓

✓✓

Cou

ncil

car

park

s

Ku-r

ing-

gai C

ounc

il✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓Ta

xi r

anks

Lach

lan

Shir

e C

ounc

il ✓

✓✓

✓✓

Lake

Mac

quar

ie C

ity C

ounc

il✓

✓✓

✓

Lane

Cov

e M

unic

ipal

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

Cou

ncil

owne

d ar

cade

s an

d La

ne C

ove

Plaz

a,

all f

ores

hore

are

as

Leet

on S

hire

Cou

ncil

✓✓

Leic

hhar

dt M

unic

ipal

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

Lism

ore

City

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

Live

rpoo

l City

Cou

ncil

✓✓

Live

rpoo

l Pla

ins

Shir

e C

ounc

il✓

✓✓

✓

Mai

tland

City

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

✓ 3

With

in 1

0m o

f Mai

tland

Hos

pita

l ent

ranc

es

Man

ly C

ounc

il ✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓En

clos

ed c

ar p

arks

, with

in 1

0m o

f ho

spita

l ent

ranc

es

Mar

rick

ville

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓

Mid

-Wes

tern

Reg

iona

l✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓C

over

ed ta

xi r

anks

Mos

man

Mun

icip

al C

ounc

il ✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

Cou

ncil

car

park

s

Nam

bucc

a Sh

ire

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

With

in 5

0m o

f lic

ense

d pr

emis

es o

n

publ

ic fo

otpa

th

New

cast

le C

ity C

ounc

il ✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

Playgro

undsSports

field

sAlfr

esco d

inin

g Beaches

Park

s

Recreati

on areas Rese

rves

Pools

Bus shelte

rsW

ithin

10m

of

council

build

ings

Council eve

nts Oth

er

Add

ition

al p

olic

y in

last

12

mon

ths

or n

ew c

ounc

il

Tabl

e 1

– D

etai

ls o

f sm

oke-

free

pol

icy

by c

ounc

il (c

ontin

ued)

Smo

ke-f

ree

po

licy

incl

ud

es:

Co

un

cil

1. R

ock

pool

s. 2

. Bay

s an

d fo

resh

ore

rese

rves

. 3.

1st

July

201

1.

Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils 6

Ora

nge

City

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

Entr

ance

s to

cen

tral

bus

ines

s di

stri

ct m

ajor

sh

oppi

ng c

entr

es. A

ll en

tran

ces

to O

rang

e B

ase

Hos

pita

l Pre

cinc

t. B

us s

tops

in C

BD

, Pos

t offi

ce

Lane

(maj

or p

edes

tria

n th

orou

ghfa

re).

Penr

ith C

ity C

ounc

il ✓

✓

Parr

amat

ta C

ity C

ounc

il✓

✓✓

Pittw

ater

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓

Port

Ste

phen

s C

ounc

il ✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

Ran

dwic

k C

ity C

ounc

il✓

✓

Ric

hmon

d V

alle

y C

ounc

il✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

With

in 7

0m o

f lic

ense

d pr

emis

es, w

ithin

10m

of

BB

Qs,

aer

odro

mes

, sho

wgr

ound

s, ta

xi r

anks

Ryd

e C

ity C

ounc

il ✓

✓✓

✓✓

Shel

lhar

bour

City

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓

Shoa

lhav

en C

ity C

ounc

il ✓

✓✓

✓

Stra

thfie

ld M

unic

ipal

Cou

ncil

✓✓

Sydn

ey, C

ounc

il of

the

City

of

✓✓

Cov

ered

Gra

ndst

ands

and

sea

ted

area

s at

sp

ortin

g fie

lds,

out

side

com

mun

ity c

entr

es,

Cou

ncil

orga

nise

d an

d sp

onso

red

even

ts to

pr

omot

e sm

oke-

free

are

as

Tem

ora

Shir

e C

ounc

il✓

✓✓

✓

Tent

erfie

ld S

hire

Cou

ncil

✓✓

1 pa

rk/p

layg

roun

d an

d 1

park

/pic

nic

area

Tum

baru

mba

Shi

re C

ounc

il✓

✓

Tum

ut S

hire

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

Upp

er L

achl

an S

hire

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

Ura

lla S

hire

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓

Playgro

undsSports

field

sAlfr

esco d

inin

g Beaches

Park

s

Recreati

on areas Rese

rves

Pools

Bus shelte

rsW

ithin

10m

of

council

build

ings

Council eve

nts Oth

er

Add

ition

al p

olic

y in

last

12

mon

ths

or n

ew c

ounc

il

Tabl

e 1

– D

etai

ls o

f sm

oke-

free

pol

icy

by c

ounc

il (c

ontin

ued)

Smo

ke-f

ree

po

licy

incl

ud

es:

Co

un

cil

7 Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils

Wag

ga W

agga

City

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓

War

ring

ah C

ounc

il

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓In

Cou

ncil

owne

d pa

rkin

g st

atio

ns th

at a

re p

artly

or

fully

enc

lose

d by

wal

ls o

r ce

iling

s

War

rum

bung

le S

hire

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓W

ithin

10m

of y

outh

cen

tre

faci

litie

s, c

hild

ren’

s se

rvic

es a

nd c

hild

care

cen

tres

Wav

erle

y C

ounc

il ✓

✓✓

Wed

din

Shir

e C

ounc

il✓

✓✓

1

Will

ough

by C

ity C

ounc

il✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓W

ithin

Cha

tsw

ood

Mal

l, w

ithin

The

Con

cour

se,

with

in c

ounc

il ca

r pa

rks

Win

geca

rrib

ee S

hire

Cou

ncil

✓✓

Wol

lond

illy

Shir

e C

ounc

il✓

✓✓

✓

Wol

long

ong

City

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓ 2

✓

Woo

llahr

a M

unic

ipal

Cou

ncil

✓

Wyo

ng S

hire

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓W

ithin

10m

of B

BQ

s, p

edes

tria

n m

alls

an

d pl

azas

Youn

g Sh

ire

Cou

ncil

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓✓

✓

Nu

mb

er o

f co

un

cils

w

ith

po

licy

in th

is a

rea

8869

303

1517

1114

5117

4224

Playgro

undsSports

field

sAlfr

esco d

inin

g Beaches

Park

s

Recreati

on areas Rese

rves

Pools

Bus shelte

rsW

ithin

10m

of

council

build

ings

Council eve

nts Oth

er

Add

ition

al p

olic

y in

last

12

mon

ths

or n

ew c

ounc

il

Tabl

e 1

– D

etai

ls o

f sm

oke-

free

pol

icy

by c

ounc

il (c

ontin

ued)

Smo

ke-f

ree

po

licy

incl

ud

es:

Co

un

cil

1. W

ithin

5m

. 2.

Ska

te p

arks

. 3.

No

te fo

r al

fres

co p

olic

y to

be

cou

nte

d 1

00%

of a

lfre

sco

are

a to

be

smo

ke-f

ree.

Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils 8

Table 2 – Comparison of metropolitan and regional councils

Metro Regional/Rural

Totalnumber 43 109

Number with smoke-free policy in 2007 17 11

Number with smoke-free policy in 2008 24 22

Number with smoke-free policy in 2009 28 30

Number with smoke-free policy in 2010 34 42

Number with smoke-free policy in 2011 37 52

% of total (using 2011 figures) 86% 48%

Table 3 – Take-up or expansion of smoke free policy since 2007 across all councils

Nameofcouncil Smoke-freepolicyin:

2011 2010 2009 2008 2007

Albury City Council No No No No No

Armidale Dumaresq Council Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Ashfield Municipal Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Auburn City Council Yes No No No No

Ballina Shire Council No No No No No

Balranald Shire Council No No No No No

Bankstown City Council Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Bathurst Regional Council Yes Yes No No No

Bega Valley Shire Council Yes Yes No No No

Bellingen Shire Council Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Berrigan Shire Council No No No No No

Blacktown City Council Yes Yes Yes No No

Bland Shire Council Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Blayney Shire Council No No No No No

Blue Mountains City Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Bogan Shire Council Yes No No No No

Bombala Council No No No No No

Boorowa Council No No No No No

Botany Bay City Council No No No No No

Bourke Shire Council Yes Yes No No No

Brewarrina Shire Council No No No No No

Broken Hill City Council Yes Yes Yes No No

Burwood Council Yes Yes Yes No No

Byron Shire Council No No No No No

Cabonne Shire Council No No No No No

Camden Council Yes Yes Yes No No

Campbelltown City Council No No No No No

Canada Bay Council, City of Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Canterbury City Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

9 Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils

Carrathool Shire Council No No No No No

Central Darling Shire Council No No No No No

Cessnock City Council Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Clarence Valley Council Yes Yes No No No

Cobar Shire Council No No No No No

Coffs Harbour City Council Yes No No No No

Conargo Shire Council No No No No No

Coolamon Shire Council No No No No No

Cooma-Monaro Shire Council No No No No No

Coonamble Shire Council Yes Yes No No No

Cootamundra Shire Council Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Corowa Shire Council No No No No No

Cowra Shire Council No No No No No

Deniliquin Council Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Dubbo City Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Dungog Shire Council No No No No No

Eurobodalla Shire Council Yes No No No No

Fairfield City Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Forbes Shire Council No No No No No

Gilgandra Shire Council No No No No No

Glen Innes Severn Council Yes No No No No

Gloucester Shire Council Yes Yes Yes No No

Gosford City Council Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Goulburn Mulwaree Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Great Lakes Council Yes No No No No

Greater Hume Shire Council No No No No No

Greater Taree City Council Yes Yes No No No

Griffith City Council No No No No No

Gundagai Shire Council No No No No No

Gunnedah Shire Council Yes No No No No

Guyra Shire Council Yes No No No No

Gwydir Shire Council No No No No No

Harden Shire Council No No No No No

Hawkesbury City Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Hay Shire Council Yes Yes No No No

Hills Shire Council, The Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Holroyd City Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Hornsby, The Council of the Shire of Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Hunter’s Hill Council No No No No No

Hurstville City Council Yes Yes Yes No No

Inverell Shire Council No No No No No

Jerilderie Shire Council No No No No No

Nameofcouncil Smoke-freepolicyin:

2011 2010 2009 2008 2007

Table 3 (continued)

Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils 10

Junee Shire Council No No No No No

Kempsey Shire Council Yes Yes No No No

Kiama, The Council of the Municipality of

Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Kogarah City Council Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Ku-ring-gai Council Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Kyogle Council No No No No No

Lachlan Shire Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Lake Macquarie City Council Yes Yes Yes No No

Lane Cove Municipal Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Leeton Shire Council Yes No No No No

Leichhardt Municipal Council Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Lismore City Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Lithgow City Council No No No No No

Liverpool City Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Liverpool Plains Shire Council Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Lockhart Shire Council No No No No No

Maitland City Council Yes Yes No No No

Manly Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Marrickville Council Yes No No No No

Mid-Western Regional Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Moree Plains Shire Council No No No No No

Mosman Municipal Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Murray Shire Council No No No No No

Murrumbidgee Shire Council No No No No No

Muswellbrook Shire Council No No No No No

Nambucca Shire Council Yes Yes Yes No No

Narrabri Shire Council No No No No No

Narrandera Shire Council No No No No No

Narromine Shire Council No No No No No

Newcastle City Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

North Sydney Council No No No No No

Oberon Council No No No No No

Orange City Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Palerang Council No No No No No

Parkes Shire Council No No No No No

Parramatta City Council Yes Yes No No No

Penrith City Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Pittwater Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Port Macquarie Hastings Council No No No No No

Port Stephens Council Yes Yes Yes No No

Queanbeyan City Council No No No No No

Table 3 (continued)

Nameofcouncil Smoke-freepolicyin:

2011 2010 2009 2008 2007

11 Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils

Randwick City Council Yes Yes No No No

Richmond Valley Council Yes Yes No No No

Rockdale City Council No No No No No

Ryde City Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Shellharbour City Council Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Shoalhaven City Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Singleton Council No No No No No

Snowy River Shire Council No No No No No

Strathfield Municipal Council Yes No No No No

Sutherland Shire Council No No No No No

Sydney, Council of the City of Yes Yes No No No

Tamworth Regional Council No No No No No

Temora Shire Council Yes No No* No No

Tenterfield Shire Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Tumbarumba Shire Council Yes Yes No No No

Tumut Shire Council Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Tweed Shire Council No No No No No

Upper Hunter Shire Council No No No No No

Upper Lachlan Shire Council Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Uralla Shire Council Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Urana Shire Council No No No No No

Wagga Wagga City Council Yes Yes Yes No No

Wakool Shire Council No No No No No

Walcha Council No No No No No

Walgett Shire Council No No No No No

Warren Shire Council No No No No No

Warringah Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Warrumbungle Shire Council Yes Yes No No No

Waverley Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Weddin Shire Council Yes Yes No No No

Wellington Council No No No No No

Wentworth Shire Council No No No No No

Willoughby City Council Yes Yes No No No

Wingecarribee Shire Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Wollondilly Shire Council Yes Yes No No No

Wollongong City Council Yes Yes Yes No No

Woollahra Municipal Council Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Wyong Shire Council Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Yass Shire Council No No No No No

Young Shire Council Yes No No No No

*Temora Shire Council was mistakenly listed as having policy in the 2009 report.

Table 3 (continued)

Nameofcouncil Smoke-freepolicyin:

2011 2010 2009 2008 2007

Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils 12

Of the 152 councils surveyed in 2011, staff at almost two thirds (92) had seen the resource kit. The most common reason for not having seen the kit was that council had not considered introducing policy.

72% (66) of those who had seen the kits described them as ‘useful’ giving reasons including:• Very useful for the design of the signs.• Handy to put things together and

before council. Worked well.• Useful for staff to develop the policy.• Based the policy on the template.• Sets a fairly generic approach to

the system.• Facts there with lots of info, so

didn’t have to go looking for it. Plus could quote statistics and Heart Foundation.

• Provided content, direction and good background data.

• Useful to refer to.• Yes definitely: “It did all the work.”• Useful in the implementation of

the policy.• Used for initial policy, that was

tailored to suit local needs.• Handy as a resource to refer to if

someone has a question.• Really good, spoke to other councils

as a result. Allowed communication• Good if councillors ask for

something.• Good resource to have and refer to

as needed.• Provided good background info

and templates. • A guideline for how to go about

policy and aspects to cover.• Yes all the right information for staff.

Resource kitA resource kit designed to help council staff develop smoke-free policy was produced and disseminated in response to council requests reflected in the 2008 survey.

The original kit contained a rationale for why the smoke-free outdoor areas were important and relevant, recommendations of which areas should be included in the policy, draft council resolutions and policies as well as case studies of councils where policy already existed. The updated resource kit now includes a testimonial fact sheet addressing challenges and a CD-ROM including signage templates and photos, draft motions and resolutions and resources developed by councils with policy.

In response to feedback, an updated resource kit to help council staff develop smoke-free policy has been produced and disseminated. New features include an additional fact sheet providing testimonial responses from council staff in relation to commonly expressed challenges facing councils and a CD-ROM with signage templates and draft motions and resolutions. The new resource kit is available in hard copy by calling 02 9219 2444 or electronic form from www.heartfoundation.org.au/smokefree (does not include CD-ROM).

13 Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils

• Included it as an attachment to Council.

• Found the fact sheets handy.• Used it to establish the policy.• Covered all aspects, considerations

and provided statistics.• Prepared the report from

information in kit. It was very useful. The resource kit and encouragement in form of letters to council really made a difference.

The most common reason given by people who described the kit as ‘not useful’ was that the council was not considering implementing policy at that time. Other comments included:• Not relevant staff member for

developing policy• Had already implemented policy.

The councils surveyed identified a number of barriers to introducing smoke-free policy or expanding on existing policies. These included:• enforcement issues• lack of finances and resources to

implement policy• lack of finances and resources to

enforce policy• not identified by the

community as an issue, lack of community awareness

• perception that the policy would not be popular with the public

• business community concern• lack of interest at council

and/or impetus• lack of state legislation and funding• geographical challenges ie large

urban or rural areas• falling between departments• perception of “over regulation”• councillor’s or council staff’s own

smoking behaviours.

Many of these barriers are addressed in Fact Sheet 5 of the resource kit.

Barriers to introducing or expanding policy

Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils 14

In a 2011 Newspoll survey conducted across NSW, support for smoke-free alfresco dining was unequivocal. Demonstrating, there has been a significant increase on the 69% of NSW adults that supported a ban on smoking in outdoor dining areas in a similar survey five years ago. Support for other tobacco control measures was also strong with over 90% of smokers indicating there should be more services to help people quit.

In a separate survey commissioned in late 2010, eight out of ten** NSW café and restaurant owners responded by saying they believed state-wide legislation to ban smoking in alfresco dining areas was fairer than leaving the decision to individual councils.

Possible future changes to tobacco laws

1. Banning smoking in children’s playgrounds = 96% support

2. Banning smoking at or near the entrance to public buildings = 83% support

3. Banning smoking in outdoor areas where food or drink is served = 83% support

4. Banning the sale of tobacco products in vending machines = 75% support

5. Providing more services to help people quit = 90% support

Alfresco diningMore than eight out of ten NSW voters believe smoking should be banned from outdoor areas where food or drink is served, according to research* commissioned by Cancer Council NSW and the Heart Foundation.

The Newspoll survey in more detail

* The Newspoll was conducted during February 2011 among a representative sample of 628 NSW voters aged 18+

** This figure comes from a survey conducted by the Ipsos-Eureka Social Research Institute from 12–27 October 2010.

Support for changes to tobacco laws in recent years

1. Banning of smoking in cars carrying children under = 94% support

2. Banning smoking inside pubs and clubs = 90% support

3. Restricting the placement of tobacco products in stores so they are out of sight = 83% support

15 Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils

As a result of this response to the communities support for smoke-free outdoor areas, the members of the smoke-free outdoor areas working group (Heart Foundation, Cancer Council NSW, Action on Smoking and Health (ASH), Australian Medical Association NSW, the Local Government and Shires Associations of NSW and members of Manly and Mosman Councils) are calling for

state-wide legislation to make all alfresco dining venues and other crowded outdoor areas smoke-free.

At a minimum, this would include any outdoor areas where food or drink is served, children’s playgrounds as well as sporting grounds and facilities.

Good morning/afternoon, my name is …….. I am calling on behalf of the Heart Foundation. I was wondering if I could speak with the Manager of Administration Services or the Director of Corporate Services on whether Council has or was thinking about introducing policy on smoke-free outdoor public spaces, such as children’s playgrounds?

Whenconnectedtorelevantcouncilofficer:

Good morning afternoon, my name is …………... I have been engaged by the Heart Foundation to conduct a follow-up survey of which NSW Councils have policies on smoke-free outdoor public spaces or are considering introducing them.

I was wondering if I may ask you a few questions?

Conductappropriatesurvey(survey(a)forcouncilswhodidNOThavepolicyasofApril-July2010orsurvey(b)forcouncilswhodidhavepolicyasofApril-July2010).

Thank you very much for your time.

If the council officer wishes to speak further on the issue, please ask them to contact Andy Mark, Regional Health Promotion Coordinator Heart Foundation on 02 4233 1033 or 0401 711 833.

ConclusionAs of 30 June 2011, 59% of all NSW councils have smoke-free policy in certain council owned or controlled areas, including almost nine tenths (86%) of Metropolitan councils and almost half (48%) of regional/rural councils.

AppendixSmoke-free outdoor public spaces council survey

WARNING HEAVY PENALTY

REGULATED UNDER S632 LOCAL GOVERNMENT ACT 1993

Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils 16

1 Does your Council have any policies, regulations or resolutions that bans smoking in outdoor public spaces? (Note: This does not include OHS policy banning smoking on Council worksites, lunch rooms, offices, vehicles)

Prompts: the spaces may include around playgrounds, sporting fields, beaches, reserves, alfresco dining areas on council owned land, around entrances to council owned buildings.

(If NO got to Q11)

2 If so, in what areas do these bans exist?

Prompts: As above

3 If Policy exists: Do these bans exist as policy or as a Council or Committee resolution?

4 If Policy exists: Is it accessible via the internet? Website address.

Or may we obtain a hard copy?

5 Why did Council introduce policy or resolution that bans smoking in outdoor public spaces?

Prompts: Community request, Councillor interest, Council Officer’s research/report, a grant funded project.

6 Under what Policy or Regulation were the bans introduced?

Prompts: Local Government Act, OHS Act.

7 How much has Council spent on the implementation of the policy and what has been done to promote the bans? (Some may indicate they have accessed Cancer Council Grants to pay for implementation. If so note down)

8 Have notices been erected? What type of signage has been used?

Prompts: Stand alone signs or stickers attached to existing signs)

Is it possible to get a copy (photo) of the signage?

9 How is Council enforcing the bans?

10 Have any infringements been issued? (Go to Q12)

11 Has Council considered implementing policy that bans smoking in outdoor public spaces such as around playgrounds, outdoor sporting fields and facilities, beaches, reserves, alfresco areas, around entrances to Council owned buildings? If unsuccessful, why?

12 From the following list, which points do you feel or know resulted in Council Considering or Introducing Policy:

Using the scale Strongly Agree (1), Agree (2), Don’t Know (3), Disagree (4), Strongly Disagree (5) for each point.

• The results of the annual council survey

• Direct Letters from Health Organisations i.e. HF, TCCN, ASH to Council

• Receiving a small grant for signage

• Champion Councillor or council staff member

• Media articles in local press • Advocacy from smoke-free

outdoor areas group, or other health professionals

• Smoke-free outdoor areas workshop in region

• Neighbouring council introduced policy

• Other

13 What barriers has your council encountered that has prevented, delayed or restricted the implementation of a policy that bans smoking in outdoor public spaces?

14 Have you received a copy of or link to the smoke-free outdoor areas resource kit (updated resource kit mailed out July/August 2009, copies sent to councils in 2010)?

If No: Would you be interested in receiving a copy? Hard copy or emailed?

If Yes: Was the resource kit useful to Council in considering the introduction of policy?

– If Yes: How?– If No: What could be improved?

15 Would you like to receive more information or support regarding the implementation of smoke-free outdoor areas policy? Please indicate what type of information or support?

Thankyouforyourtime

Smoke-free outdoor public spaces council survey(a)

ForcouncilswhodidNOThavesmoke-freeoutdoorareapolicyorresolutionasofJuly2010

17 Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils

1 Our 2010 smoke-free outdoor area survey indicated that your Council had policies, regulations or resolutions that banned smoking in outdoor public spaces? At the time the Policy applied to (Refer to survey results). Has your Council increased the number of, or types of, Council owned areas where policy bans smoking since July 2010? (If NO got to Q7).

2 If so, in what areas do these new bans exist?

Prompts: As above

3 Do the new bans exist as policy or as a Council or Committee resolution?

4 Under what Policy or Regulation were the bans introduced?

Prompts: Local Government Act, OHS Act.

5 Is the Policy accessible via the internet? Website address.

Or may we obtain a hard copy?

6 Why did Council increase the number of, or type of, Outdoor Public Spaces with policy or resolution that bans smoking?

Prompts: Community request, Councillor interest, Council Officer’s research/report, a grant funded project, planned expansion.

7 How much has Council spent on the implementation of the policy and what has been done to promote the bans? (Some may indicate they have accessed Cancer Council Grants to pay for implementation. If so, note down)

8 Have notices been erected in the areas covered by the Policy or Resolution? What type of signage has been used? (i.e. Stand alone signs or stickers attached to existing signs) Is it possible to get a copy (photo) of the signage?

9 How is Council enforcing the bans?

10 Have any infringements been issued?

11 Has Council evaluated its smoke-free outdoor areas policy? If so how, and is it possible to get a copy of the report?

12 From the following list which points do you feel or know resulted in Council Considering or Introducing Policy:

Using the scale Strongly Agree (1), Agree (2), Don’t Know (3), Disagree (4), Strongly Disagree (5) for each point.

• The results of the annual council survey

• Direct Letters from Health Organisations ie HF, TCCN, ASH to Council

• Receiving a small grant for signage

• Champion Councillor or council staff member

• Media articles in local press • Advocacy from smoke-free

outdoor areas group, or other health professionals

• Smoke-free outdoor areas workshop in region

• Neighbouring council introduced policy

• Other

13 Has Council considered implementing additional policies or resolutions that bans smoking in outdoor public spaces? If no, or unsuccessful, why?

14 Has your Council encountered any barriers that have prevented, delayed or restricted the implementation of additional policy that bans smoking in outdoor public spaces?

15 Have you received a copy of, or link to, the smoke-free outdoor areas resource kit (updated resource kit mailed out July 2009, copies sent to councils in 2010)?

If No: Would you be interested in receiving a copy? Hard copy or emailed?

If Yes: Was the resource kit useful to Council in considering the introduction of policy?

– If Yes: How? – If No: What could be improved?

16 Would you like to receive more information or support regarding the implementation of smoke-free outdoor areas policy? Please indicate what type of information or support?

Thankyouforyourtime

Smoke-free outdoor public spaces council survey(b)

Forcouncilswhohadasmoke-freeoutdoorareapolicyorresolutionasofJuly2010

Smoke-free policy in outdoor areas | A 2011 survey of NSW councils 18

Notes

For heart health information 1300 36 27 87www.heartfoundation.org.au

© 2011 National Heart Foundation of Australia ABN 98 008 419 761

Australian Capital TerritoryCanberra

15 Denison Street Deakin ACT 2600

Tel: (02) 6282 5744

New South WalesSydney

Level 3, 80 William Street Sydney NSW 2011

Tel: (02) 9219 2444

Newcastle

Suite 5, OTP House Bradford Close Kotara NSW 2289

Tel: (02) 4952 4699

Illawarra

Kiama Hospital and Community Health Service Bonaira Street Kiama NSW 2533

Tel: (02) 4233 0133

Northern TerritoryDarwin

Darwin Central Offices Level 3, 21 Knuckey Street Darwin NT 0800

Tel: (08) 8981 1966

Alice Springs

Shop 1, 9 Parsons Street Alice Springs NT 0870

Tel: (08) 8953 5942

QueenslandBrisbane

557 Gregory Terrace Fortitude Valley QLD 4006

Tel: (07) 3872 2500

Townsville

Suite 7B, 95 Denham Street Townsville QLD 4810

Tel: (07) 4721 4686

South AustraliaAdelaide

155-159 Hutt Street Adelaide SA 5000

Tel: (08) 8224 2888

TasmaniaHobart

86 Hampden Road Battery Point TAS 7004

Tel: (03) 6224 2722

Northern Tasmania

Kings Meadows Community Health Centre, McHugh St Kings Meadows TAS 7249

Tel: (03) 6336 5116

North-West Tasmania

2nd Floor, Room 232 Community & Health Services Centre 23 Steele Street Devonport TAS 7310

Tel: (03) 6421 7704

VictoriaMelbourne

Level 12, 500 Collins Street Melbourne VIC 3000

Tel: (03) 9329 8511

Western AustraliaPerth

334 Rokeby Road Subiaco WA 6008

Tel: (08) 9388 3343