43
aamaa aqAq ownow SNHM :t45IUT3I5I IO HTA5I aTE UMA MOITAU3SN MQI-V881 YMT2UUMI2ADU2 HHT ovoa&xoD bivsU nilhsM .q QOEHEW EOô i3qE BnthoW HDMA3EHSI DIMOMO3 IO UA3MIJH JAMOITAM suriovA aflaurIo&sM OOI 8EJO AM obiidrrisD VQQI '(SM waicbH r1t ts woIII aivnU '(bEd is asw ioilius taill out olirlw nothabnu asw 113w0a01 airlt lo ho ioaao1otI tnstaiaaA BnitiaiV nilO .M ff1011 aisw iorbus bnoooa odt olirlw bns rnoInamet1o '(JialavinU .ogsoulD lo '(tialovinU otnta orlt bus '(monoo3 oritlo '(bnt8 out tol atnoD iolgita .11 agiooD oult is lthqlorl iol aqorla±ow auoiomun is atnsqioihsq bus 115'(ibs)I sbnnV tsult ot oAiI bluow oW '(1tisO1 21 nFl wiisoY bus unrfl sibns2 niotarrwH bivisU 10 o3nstaIaas rloisoaoi oulT .atnomrno3 'nA .noitssinsgiO Isiitaubnl lii rnrngoiq rlomoaai a'MdHfrI 10 hsq ai ioqnq airlT .boisiooiqqs olmono3a lo unomH InnoitsM orlt lo oaorlt ton bus 21011105 out lo oaorh ois boaaoiqxo anoiniqo .113xnoao5l ton txot 10 anoitooa horl2 .bovioaoi atul3h hA .nihIuM •q ooshhsW bus ovoaono{1) bivsU 'cc! VQQI © tiboio 11th tisrlt bobivoiq noiaairunoq tioilqxo tuorltiw botoup od 'nm ar1qnsisq ant boooxo 01 .031002 ofit ot novia ai ooiton © nibu1oni

SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

aamaa aqAq ownow SNHM

:t45IUT3I5I IO HTA5I aTE UMA MOITAU3SN MQI-V881 YMT2UUMI2ADU2 HHT

ovoa&xoD bivsU nilhsM .q QOEHEW

EOô i3qE BnthoW

HDMA3EHSI DIMOMO3 IO UA3MIJH JAMOITAM suriovA aflaurIo&sM OOI

8EJO AM obiidrrisD VQQI '(SM

waicbH r1t ts woIII aivnU '(bEd is asw ioilius taill out olirlw nothabnu asw 113w0a01 airlt lo ho ioaao1otI tnstaiaaA BnitiaiV nilO .M ff1011 aisw iorbus bnoooa odt olirlw bns rnoInamet1o '(JialavinU .ogsoulD lo '(tialovinU otnta orlt bus '(monoo3 oritlo '(bnt8 out tol atnoD iolgita .11 agiooD oult is

lthqlorl iol aqorla±ow auoiomun is atnsqioihsq bus 115'(ibs)I sbnnV tsult ot oAiI bluow oW '(1tisO1 21 nFl wiisoY bus unrfl sibns2 niotarrwH bivisU 10 o3nstaIaas rloisoaoi oulT .atnomrno3

'nA .noitssinsgiO Isiitaubnl lii rnrngoiq rlomoaai a'MdHfrI 10 hsq ai ioqnq airlT .boisiooiqqs olmono3a lo unomH InnoitsM orlt lo oaorlt ton bus 21011105 out lo oaorh ois boaaoiqxo anoiniqo

.113xnoao5l

ton txot 10 anoitooa horl2 .bovioaoi atul3h hA .nihIuM •q ooshhsW bus ovoaono{1) bivsU 'cc! VQQI © tiboio 11th tisrlt bobivoiq noiaairunoq tioilqxo tuorltiw botoup od 'nm ar1qnsisq ant boooxo 01

.031002 ofit ot novia ai ooiton © nibu1oni

Page 2: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

r silT :rnuts5l 10 stnM all bun rioitsbsiq

1421-V881 isua nilluM .T 53nh1EW bun svoaansD bivnU

EOô .oM isqn nitoW SHHM VQQI 'csM

TM €lJ .aoMJHIL noitssinngiO lsthaubnl

TDASIT*EA

mill work oW .1 mW bimoW sioTlod 'çiiaubni gninilsi msua nnonsmA silt otni buia oW

tooiib d :blolowt aitoomq muO .çiotsbsmq omow aoboaiqo mojerrx owl niwoilci1 atcw soriq sift

taos sorrq ovititoqrrioo botoibomq 1o noxtoxntarxoo 'd bun taoo lsnimrri ol oanq to noannqinos

orb risrlw 'lno bommuoso noitnbomq tuft ouam oW .anigrsm bovmsado bosoxo ot worla ow tacit aniginru

omutifi motob ot boau '(ldscIomq taom anw Ii tacIt bits llnma asw mill tunnimob silt ot Ii lo taos ovitnlsi

rio ono mofis armil guitaixooiq lo oorrq oanrlomuq silt mowol 01 boau oala anw II .anoitibbs 'Qiosqno

.oboaiqs

nilluM '1 oonllnW ovoasnoD bivsu asimonosH lo tnomflsqoU aoimonooH lo tnorrthsqoU tiaisvthU otnt2 ungirloiM

8EOT-188I TM niannJ tacH 'oIomlooT1o otutitanl attsauclonaanM SHHM bus QETO AM obhdrnn3

ubo.uarnniIlumqw 5HH14 bun ubo.tim.snsrlts@ovoaono

Page 3: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

5

eue cia iu qcpaçca OUG bOL!C1IJ&L

JJG COJTLLOOUJ OL JIG cJua2Loour Ocit CJ9'JUJ2 COUCGLIJ!U VaFC)2 GJflAIOL fGLGOLG

yu jje;iou O bLGJU4OL?i couqrrcç 18 &JfAX2 COULOAGL2WJ MJJ6JJGL JGAGJJGq in2rrnJeq O pe SGLOcoat a iç pojga cten mpeu Uou-Lth 2ciL combouen o mstJu9J coaç !2 B2-GXCGG O2GLA6 mutiua JJ}J12 COUCJI121011 18 opnaç 01K meøautc 0 WOLHJUJ

as couapncç bLGqcçeq cousbGc!f TAG bLJCG C02f muLine uuq apo& puçiuqnaçr.A uq uoqcja o combcçJçJow fl2!u qeuuq eeçimuçea wig jLm cbcçXouq JJUG o eiuqeuc& aqscp LGJJGB cibon bçetu oj cubciçX couaçtwna w flJG

BGCØH2G G2JWBG2 0j WUL1UØJ coaç LG JJA&22 concLoAGLai$f ns bteaeuç 2Gc-btoiuge g qiLecç &uq pJpJX CLGpJG megacite o WUt1IJJ coaçcecpuojoV oj 2fIL LeEJ.r!u wig couçewbototX Bnqca wig coi.upiucitS pots uthicq Ju oçpet OLJC (ceueaois ouq tnjpif 10o2Y ambje bLoqrrcçJouGAGIJCG 12 115 be'ti poaeq ribon o ¶LGC4 cousboLI2on oj Mice mutiuoj coaç ya

SGL& at pejoitc M6 luçeLbLeç p VJ{C oiuçettnbçiou& wig iucplqeg exçeuqeq benoqa iii picp bncc-coaç me'tEns GJJq6CL60262 115 buce IpeaG Thice ffi2t2 B2feq oponç Aeot& ujpeiç açp eame

GUfLUIJf& CI°0 2 abLGCJCeJ2 oug 'qtpncjge flL0fp6L2 &ete meç miçp 2pstbOflJGL couaojqoçoua

couaopqoçou }TBB LGCG1tS j&L J622 2CLJTpUA L0m ecouomiaça puu uccotqeqO!V v16Jcu jppocc& ouq 2ntbtieiuj? eojnç1ou o 2noLbotç o 201556 bojiçicoj motcmeuç picp pLonRpç JnoaGcnçloua uoiuaç

pi ThTIJ cpc 6qGL0J OAGL1Iwe1Jç zjjeq 015 UIJçJçLH2ç 2IIJf B0IIJ2f Y2JSC °jj) ouqp? jj 4JJG combuuA itoe cpe uJuçp JoLe2ç cothotoçiou ITS fluiçcq

I1BL jtnac 02 LGOLBUISGq 02 f pG V''1°" 0UL g9wIu C0mb11X (vast)qccuqGa tOIIOM!U f}JG jptuncJou 0 H.BL JLfl2 I1J!cJBJPk OLouJsGq W Jgg fJJG

1p!2 bobet acnqiea GUçLA w;° ymeLicou anoL LeJiu iuqnaçA !fLBC1IJ fJJG GAOJITTf IOU O B 2JUJ6 JUqifafa OAGL qatoçJolrGIJAILOUUJGUç 15Gc6220L!IA !UAOIAG qAIJBWJC coUceLuaa cpe 12206 12 pee; exbjot€q p?euçil 12 0 cJAIJBIJJJC btocea& oiiq ou JUc1TmpeUf2 ocçiOUa 2jflbe ice couthG;!c!Aezjtus 1A11J acibbot; boçouçioj topouopcA 0j bLGqwcoLX 2çLufeTer peconee;pGOLGçJCBJ tAOLJC B2 cjBLijeq cjJG LBIJG O 2LBfGG2 BABIJOPIG 40 015 !UCPGUjye couçrncreq GXGLCICG oj zuoqceç boast gebeuqe nbou qe;ettps euçLA ffGCGTJ

j. pJçLoqJTcçoIJ

Page 4: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

3

ciçpei couafL1u euçr.X ot lugnee cxiç JJ}J12 2fLUf€IC 6j6Cf conjq obetUf C2UCLIUCG2 !F2 OMU CJILECUf btoijça !' OLqGL fO LGqUCG 2 LIAUJ,8 bLouca Uuq

OffL ptoq qeuJçou O BLGqUf IOU 2 UUA UCOIJ UU UCnUJpGUp LW 1HJGLfUJ6BlAG OJTfjiUG !U aGcpou 33 ou woqeja oj couthcçiçioif Uuq !' BBcuqjrfJJG 2f&fTC uoucoobetçiis edrnppunui onçcome JU QIf}JGL bucea ot dn&uçIfie2 U2cxcjrrqe combcçiçi&e couqsrc U2 mi exBj9uuf1oIr 11X combe;ps couqnc lAG WGUUB'U 'c mupu' mJqer. Uu? boaiçrte 2UJJqULq UUA eAqeuce ot bLGqUfJou mneç

e conjq &uq bGLpUb& lAiJJ UL&IG ponç UBbLobLiUçe boarçIAe 2fUUqULqU JGUJ 2eU2e lApUc a btebutcq cJUaaIX ru u boalfiAc 26u2G

W 1mBj€w€uç1u JGUJ 2çnJqULq mUA qeçet oue pIOW cJUaaiQuu Ua bteqor.A 1"U JGUJ OL UOUJJUfIAG 2fUIJUL Uuq U 2C1€Uf 1C OL BoaifiAe cue bLUCc!CUJ qfflcnJfIe2

muq U AU2f JG&J I!cGLUfITLG Uuq CU2GJUEi 20 fJJGLG 12 U ueeq co qacpJnI2JJ peçmeeuexbpcxçjX wponç UUcJcLHaca btcquou 12 U pnssftoLq WçOWUPCUJJA prua cc

y iioçe upon; ciii. qeuçou o cpc fGLUJ BLGqUfJOU yjçyony cpia bUBGL a UOfpL!UIJ OfJJ 2fLUfG4C c}J!UJCiU Uuq W9tJCGf qucu cc pGUL

PA6 COU21GL eucy exbjuuuçiou rn ciii UUUJASIB o ;JJG mUlct GIJçLX ebiaoqe&IP' Je U2CLIpG2 U LeblifUc!OU mof LAG fO 1fffC26fl puq U cGLcU!u qeceuieuç .AUJHG uuq LeuoLceq puttieta uJL6Uq2 " GX!2f6JJCG)Leuu rnqnaçi.X onjq yote ;o pe bteButeg cc ucc enpaçuupj J022e2 j4Jna wH ULflIU fJJUf BL!CG IAUL2 qemcu2cLUc6q cpu; uu? tonB iuAuq1u fpc anetBntae Uuq jeULuu crn.Ae LUcomUJe2 tot bteqUcJcw) E!cpUe (fr sss) 12 ! fy12 AGJIJcyuqaçeu (]-aoo) UUcj CUPLU! uuq mctquu (Tool) J0L a!RuUn!u LebncU;!o& Jouqucou (€e IA1!J0m vuq gcpctça (ioY KLGB2 Uuq /A!raou (1083Y BOJfOU Uuq0L 2GAGLUJ qeteisc GXBJUUU4!OU2 eucp coaeaBouqu fO U moq€j cjj LU;!ouUI bte—12 ;JJG BLICG ffi2t2 .usLG bL6qUfor.A mc€tht6c&ccU 12 teujj? uu nmpLejjuUtficnjUfeq ttqçjJ teabecç cc flJG VLPHCNG flLOfJJGL2 RLUL ' aecouq iIJfeLbLefUficU

eueuqeLeq p? wetter. utteemeuça 1p!a 18 Boaiçioif Ujçpontp oujA villAiqe.& ;pe euq o buce tAUt tejjecçeq UO UJOLG f}JUU f JIG ucLGUaGq COUCGIJcLUc!OUmUA yuLe jeq cc TucLeUaeq cowheppou uuq peuce Jc&eL bucea rWGJA!8G Iii P!

IP UL f/tO exBjUuUicua jpt GUCJJ bucc &UL E!L8c fJJG UJGLG UCf O ciiçr2tlAJJGfJIGL !f occaf JIG WOLG tGUGLWJ qGpWçG uporrc /AJJGfJJGL bLGqUfOU CUU G U LUfJOUUJ 2fL9TGfJ Uuq

UJGUf& tAJJIJG CjoaejX ;o BULcICIIJUL JUCf a cj fpc BITtUE uqnacLA G.AOJCG

ayutb LeqsiCoua pi LGxJGq bqccv j4peA qqjet JUfGLBLG;UfJ0U JJJJG!L ULtif-

bqce nr.a• BfDcP etpe (ioeo) uuq E!cyueL (Joeo) Uttee ;puf euçr.AffG8GULCJJ cm ;pa beuoq c ;pe uqnafLA cou;U!ua uo qabnçe UOflf fF6 UCf O

cçper) U UJOLG teuetuj qepue uponç GUJBJLICUJ LGJGAUUCG o BLGqufOLA UC122

Page 5: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

4

('loejiom ouq JGA0L!CJC bb 510-550)bLIcGe in cpa jon Mill ;pn monjq pate peen eoueq a ;pe huGe LGqnciou puq uoç OCCIiLLGq01 file WULICG 01. O (Jj2C0flL0G GIIfLA 0j UGR JLW2 pI 011 GflOLf 4O 0iu J0LGL htouca MObuciu GJJBAJOL l11A0JA 0 LGflGfIOU !U BL!GG epotc LflII 20 02 o qLite combeiu flLIJIR on;

1JJJ2 qciqou 12 etcOLqolJCe JMfJJ u; j€seç 0116 2flfG(J açouqouç tGqscoLX

anbbotçiu iuauinpau cauceLIJlIJ iuqnaçAjyuç bupjicociau 12 cye eantee tot maeç at ant qvço oiJq mncy at out

uaçyiu cambstea taJçp M!JJGcf &iJq flGfl1\ %%S%SC %0IS&. pZc€ '\OtL-bteeeuçeq pete LOt U cauçembatotX cytarncje at ;pc enEot iuqnaçO

açoupu mqneçA ouq eyanjq PG cauanjçeq tar. U mote qeçsijeq CyLaUoIaV(mob) ouq GLPG (ioeo) nacJ onpyoa btazqqe IIJA&TIT&PJG rnqsvce aL cmqer.-JJJJG jsiaçotA a JJG yuJeL!C9v 21T0L IJqli24tA 12 oqiintupjA cjtamcjeq pA EICPUGL

r II!OL!C91 OA6I16tA

GUfLUUf)2 cobociçk

JflAG qebeuqeq nbou opaeiJce aj o ctaee-moqccc moc!Ae eup2 ougoccommoqafGq piff eAGufnoJJA panyç anç pA vaicci yccauJuJaq0fau 2G6U52s p1cJJ caucjnqe& pqelJA caunueij;a cii acpet euft&uça JJ}JG2G JAGLG Jill;lojiAQ CUJCflJ9f62 IUfGLU&J L9fG8 at LGOLIJ 9t A0L1002 f}J60UG2 at bteqoçiaw aeccioubLICG tAUt 1J qefUj JAJJJJG aeCfJOU 2 GXUUJJUG2 f}JG 3btecjceje euiot ebJ2aqw ecçiouabutjceq uetce buce frMt2 2GCf IOU 4 GXUUJIUG2 ;pe VLPHCNG pLCfJJGL2 GUf tA ougnuqet cpeee cauqiçiour jye uexç aecçxoua uqqteea ;na euçtA ebaaqea ;yucLeuuIuW rnwcnJcA oj, eUfLA rniq ou an; pue a baaaipje maqea at bLJcJU peJJaAattANGY vasc obetoçeq jpa JIJCJ0G8 U 2C088JU a ;ye cac; 2fLffCflitG at eITULat JuqnaftA)a y!açotA pi aecc!oIJ 3 tAG ançjme ;pe cawbefif TAG euiqtaumeuç iii

lP bynu at cpa bobeL J2 02 taJJatA2 1jj5e uexç aecfIou bLolqqea on AGtAJGtALGAGUJ2 ;pc pnnça fo V8ffC32 ttipiiueaa cc boA t" bteqoçiawLeJufIAeJA mote coaçjA VBFC JJIJJ iii Jaffi aeoaaif ouq 20 fJJG teabiçe2mnhieL f}JG }J!J3 2G&2011 at enut qemmJq M qemauectoce ;puc bteqoçon tA02

euçtl €bieoqea3 po at jncp ULG JJJULJCG pA Le2blfe2 In fG btice tAUt J f ye0LG006 crnieuç btauca jye naetnjueee a1 cpa mauente 12 qemauectoceq In fJJG

caucelAnJ at vgc ° ttbntcp0ehu) JaeaGe t° If 2 LJIw pA bu?uu U buce lii;JJe tUfJ 01 1; 2 J02262 In btequçatA hot fo ;pe GUftUUf)2 J0226W MG WLG

M° abetofJouopse ;pia cauceb; pA caueçurcçuu 02 f jIG buce at bLeqaçauUpalif fjle 1UCIUIIPGIJ 2 jijcejA tITfULG Ucf!0U21p ojfeuu t1tuja coap jjame betcebçioua at moqceç couqiçion& at ice P6J16t2

Page 6: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

2

0tP2po Jr Jieça iIJqrAiqn9J LGU1J6L162 MIJJ 4GJL cbuciçi uuq pcft qçc O( euç LkJJJJG II9L J3412ç MUB LGOLuU!sGq 92 0 COLBOLRçJOIJ T8OF

92 LGceliuciOIrojj u hucc MOL Off JJG ()oOffç aBLGC$GJ,2 GUçLA iIJçO p1J0qGJbJJrn 0911 tJIGLGLOLG JD6 tqGMoqbobnjona Eeç Q9 JJ 2Th0L L1."2 9cdaLGq bjuuç !11 C01!L°1.11!9 ! thLiu T89' fIcJJ

3abLGcJwJa LGflUG 211&UL Oil G2 coc apijo tjic IJ&9L J)nB M92 Oil JJG ff101.6

WOW M!IJ6c; ouq GL0 CJGq pA E!CYUGL' Jr0A6L0G L6Ueq bLc6 1.026 (LOW * e013 (ba pnuqr.6q bonuqe) ! TR8S ;o * soos ! 188W

Aest& IJIJ&JJX btcqnciu u yJTIU2ç Jgg.&LOL cuaneq CoUecLflCciOU 0j VLPHC$J6 2IIL K61JIJJU bjsvç coojc ojrncaç ptoCOjjGG L002c!IJ 0 j6ll UJOIJfJJ2 JaçGL pA bnLcpo2iu ouaçp€ jun uuq 0 COjjGG buecvLpnCJqc tcçyet &uuonuccq iça iuçeuçiou GThf6L 2nut tcijrnuW vaicc cuçeisqLeJ1J6q 2i19t ILOUJ V2HC oJJq cpcis L626JJ!IJ bocjwcq arior p' 6bccrnpeL meelu w'w oi.iii worn e-mao1 c ubbjeq fJJ6 291336 cc amoV prrAiubucpiu rnocpiu& ttpicp euopjcq c cc eejj cOi1jce 113 2U3uJJ bucjwe& LUfJJGLoj couee pJ flUJfeq ic boalcIon ! 02 quc cc 0 boçeuç cu g

f 116 'LJD1TCJCJG Bt0f 1161.21 0 J0LG !AJJOJG2OJG L0CGL ULLU OIJq f JIG qcrniuouç LO02GL

cu uexç bpoec o cye uqa2;LA2 cornbcc!c!ou IJ Jgog 1t!cp fJJG GUcLvaicc ouq cpe men? 20-cojjeq iuqcbcuqeuçacdufemboLoLA bnpjicuçioua uqcoce uu nuqcteçouqrn p&q 6A0JA6 pepteeu't81200 pOLLGJB cobociçA oj V2J5C ouq oaaocioceq 1tcuqj%1 coujbouiee0 B 18ô@1cubuciçA Ot 1310 pOLLGJ2 0 LGjJncq 211?2L ber. qo? 11112 1t02 U COUfL92 fo cpc2rn0JJ-200J62 LP 1JUl32 GIJcGLGq W 97J1 GOCJJ tAlfJJ 0 21UJ6 bjB13f1 EJfJJ 013 0AGL0GcouceufLOfiou ajottjA qecjjueq1 02 0 261.162 o 1J1.1112 eufGLGq' GUCJJ of 0 LGJOf1AGJA

B'f Of 0JJ GIJfLUUf 2 jJ fJJI8 b&ffGLU [U ucxç 2GAGLUJ AGOL21 4316 qcLce o6IJeUq6Leq hUGe itsta ouq JOGL ocdrnaiçrou pA or. occornrnoqoçiou 1f P V2MC2iror. iuqsraçtA: pip J6A6J2 o couceuçLuçio& bnuccrwceq pA eb2oqca o cufLA fJIf

p!2 GOUJIG2f ebaoqe exewbpeq cue boççer.u tOL 4316 anp2edrrcuc plecoLA otter.e cornbjeceq pA ybuj mos °'q yaEcc,2 cubociçA apOLe r.oee cc 82Q43rnee um poq LGUJ0IJGq oncaqG oL!juor j4rnaç, JjJcae ocdrnaIfJoua433€ anCCea2OL cc 4J16 I/J-1af1 ucdnir.iu abtecjcej1a yiJuqcJbjnu bjwuç ojou MTçjJo bjouç rn J,yJJoqGJbplw3 jpuc jeq utac cc o ftto-?SuL br.1ce n21Y ouq vac1

n uc et1cJ1c 26U10L P°' !' DGCGWPGL J1 colllbjefeqKouiseq ouq r.eqnccq cc gejjueq br.jcce LO2G xeW ouq €uçtA 20011 J0JJ0ffi€cubociçA 1P 50 bJUIJf2 o.ueq pA 4316 OLi1I10I J)iT2f I.UGUIpGLC LAGLG drncjqA LGOL-111 DP 182S 02 0 couaopqociou 12 U1." coucLoljiut 80èE O 4336 uqrrçr.Aa

CL 2GAGUOJ flU2flGGG22JfIJ Ofernbca of C0JJ112101f 4316 U0L p.riec A22 joLrneq

Page 7: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

e

cLc qeciazou !U jg nbpejq ;pc ucdrnarporr2lTgBL,2 BCdI11B!4?OU Oj 2GAGLBJ JJIjUqGJbpiff LGIIIJGL!G2 !' WG W C jJSS.It JJJG 3IIbLCWG

8JJJJGLG JAGLG ujeo WLJI€L uuçiçLneç !01' JU J5 otGLiJmGuç CpUJJGuGq WGL!CBIJJD15 V"" 55' 1015

sM!JJ°cc Uq OL9 L4OAGWPGL I' TOO DGWPGL Q' TOO9 MOAGJJJPGL So' 1011 1WLW 18'

in bucpeg fIG 21TL OL jJBJ COIJ2ITUJGL8 jçjionç UUA ogejpieq annuL &v U pomoeuona btoqrrcç ic tAUa 2pbbGq 4O Th10C6L2 IJ P&n612'

TV IGCPUOLORA 0% aneuL LOflCfOfl

3' JJJJG C0mb6!c!AG EUA!LOUmGU

mUqceç 2JJULG /tU2 Jffs&8 GJORL ice 2JJULG O ngcreçi2 cUbuciçl1ep9te O "f2ffC' OL bLeqeceaeoL' fIG J/118' %LODJ T82S-I8I'V V2HC,8

jye uqnep1e eAoJnçiou J2 cUbfnLeg pA jypjc 5T' ttpcp LeboLfa DJULICGc

rnicice betçrnj' AoJnncuLA',, qaeoJnçouA!ccoL!ee p1 fIG 'VIJJGLICUU jppucco unq Oil GU2GB ID JJJ jaq%oLwuJjX LG2oJAGq iTIJçfl U COU2GUf qectee .&U2 etJeq 111 T055' cpa 0AGLUmGUç)2eeçurnç 0j eeejciu fIG qieeojnçiou vaicc' yjcp0p cp!2 C&2G noçacLnçiu2v pJ JOJO fIG GGLUJ &)AauJmauç fflaq 2H' CJJ&LIJ mouobopsuçion unq

vaicc,e uççamb;e co ucdnLa uuq mupuu qoupuuce q!q no; eacube &iiç!çisiaçeojq poiqjiojqate unq L6%nLpJ2J1agLGCG!AGLCp!b oqcrccon uç cpa BJUD; pauu oujA !u mrs' U%GL cpa LG11DGLA tUBjucat' içp bjunç UGULJA combjeç& euj,e puujcuthçcA Bsrapaq cpa LGUIJGLA lucoqrrccoif paEuu CODB;LITCcIOIJ o u 8GCOIJ bjuuç u pJJuqajbpu moi• jjto AGULB! niqcu' w aLaaA uuq cpen eojq 4 ;o vasc pa%OLG GAGL meuç wc° Mo-

iuqrra;r.A pA TôO5-Jô01 ygojbp GUJ' !" J8b2 pug coiie;iic;€g L611116a

IGUIJGI2k in xourcae' M6t .KOLK 111 moV uuq muuueg ;o ucpiaa U cocporq Ju fIGU; eu;LA cw bLecjceJ2 r' fIG 2011 0% cpa aanot' orngaq cpa aqauj IIUL

JJpG iiax; BGAGLUj AGULB LtLlcuaeeaq pocjJ 211CC622}JIJ &IJq IUJ2IICCGB2%11J uççembçe

vaicc aagauc' LpITCJCJG BLOcPGL2 LGDJUpJGq w fIG ugne;r*%OLUJ cpa oiouuj 2fT&L gepJiu C0ffh0 ID U LflJ2UCJOD OLRUUJSGq pA cpaJ000' MJJGIJ fIG 08CGL LGUJJGLA IJJGLG micp 0% fG UJU1OL iugabaugauce coMIcP cpa axceb;Jou 0% 0116 VL62B!;G,, !U ;pa btJce tot' ;pe MUL coucrnneq rnJcIj yjuAcoc;' apnçgomu pA ;pa Jugebauqau; LGUUGL& uuq cpa buLpuj epnçqomu 0% DOBCPGLpULLGj2 gujA 11512 bLGcJbJuçGq U 2GAGLG Mica tot' wutjcag pA bLICJU uç OL PerotAG&L pppau nA obatuciouuj' GUC15 0% cpeea ne/A bjuuça pug u cuBuc;A 0% ?ooo

vnocp anctuui cpa DO2CPGL LaIJneLY paun btogncçiou III J40AGUJGL 0% cjc

Page 8: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

1001-1010 sp' 1011-TON vaicc yq1mceq C JJULG cornice JIG I,?p0u&Ja cgb&cX ye Jni.ç ° vaicc LOL

4Vf0IJ9J M92 LIIIJ ! JJ9LIJJODA 'A!JI IJffQ ILOW ice JUCGBfJOU flhI4?IJ 4JJ2 COlif LO1 #22 LGJ!UdtIleJiGq

ffi9L ID J(JØ• 9GCØII2G 9 C0UcLOJJJII !UcGLfl 01 !c 20CJC #22 omucq P1 vaicc 9q V2BCI L;qeuç

4JpG pj9ç0II9J 2flL }fGgII!U& C0Wb9IJ1 01 4GM '16L261 JAØ2 0LWGq fl çJJG

98 eJJbbjGWGuçeq pX tG2CIIIIOIIA PGIOLC JUJTRLWJ cornrn!ee!ou OL ;jic 0WIIJccJJJG WVLJCGf 2JIBLG pnLG'a 9L6 j,LOW MJJ!Gfl? &uq QLUk JJJG c&beCIfl UJ1LG2 BLO jLOW Th!IJ uiiq

1011101310131011181018001002'Dosmoe100210041003100510011000180018081801moe180218041803180518011880188018881881

43011'O12'220' 1

b's20'b2'V32@'8

2S'328705'301'?00'O950.10'IS0'3005SibSS'O50'015'O

82'S01092'Ses.s09'O52'OSOt

1012 3'4O 5221012 3'lO ,V011012 3'lO 0'SO10'12 3'bO Q'SoJ0'12 3'bO b'831012 3'bO b'831Q12 3'bO ¶101012 Wb0 4'bO1012 3'bO ¶351fl2 310 3'Ob1012 Wb0 3'SO1012 3'bO 3•501912 3'5@ 5'2219'12 359 5'2219'IR 0 b'SO1012 0 3'25J0'12 0 5'311012 0 5'3112'bS 0 S'ST12'4S 0 5'SI12'bS 0 J'S012'bS 0 0•SS1120 0 b'081120 0 ¶381120 0 3'25

20'O00'S01 '2@1 '2

00'[email protected]

es•s

so10'853'253'255181085'285'285'285'280'S82'351'O

53'O50'l

20'000'S01201280'S80'S81381381081'382'S82'S8W1

88'155'I81'O85'285'285'?85'28W5

02'3Sb'O

53'O59'b

AGUL ypjccç 3J39L6gepJu c° )2ymeLicuu afT9L

vac M9110U91 E'W c°1 Of JJGL(mijnoua oj jpa beL q)

c9bC!cA

uuq1ueceq yqrI2fGq4Cth9C!fA 2P9L6

V2B'C -

rii° 37 EAoInf!ou o JuquacLX cub9c!cA

Page 9: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

8

Jr boa Jr its'2I1BL LGUUJU MOLO comuiou 0 BJJ LGUUGLW •utJUGa 1800 %c AWTU f sa 10001

73H60LA flBAGWGAGL 01 V21f C Bug jBJT2 D0W6L poçp cçj1joq JJB JJG GU6LB1 btoc oJJ1G etgGucG JIGLG 2 LBMIJ LLOJJJ otGLuwoiiç Bnqiça 01 JJG LGUUCL2I poojta

ijaco fl JpLq, C0mm!!0U1 149sq C°V bM 'fl bLO\ mp!c0 J5'D6LcW6U 'JuliO boa I800 ie A010W6 f bLc 5 JyJ' Jr it

10JF4!WOUA o cbpen pnXu!t2yA' BU 0fflCBJ LLOW 4?JJO C;° qIAI2I0U 0j IJIG JLGS2ULA64611 ;pck 2ojq woe; 01 JJ6IL 2flBL ill

iuçtoqnccq ;po 1,LgC1C6 01 °1J!" ann L0cOLe In jupoj jog jp uq jp' hwcjw&oewqs'nt (p6L6ca1 IC) A°J'""° j1 L014 sa Jr T40-T'IS VLPflClqG flLOfliGL2

019m62 'w1 JMfl4IJGL !" VLP11CYIC pLo:JI612a 'jUilS 121 1800 hoq o\ caontcea o eAiqGucG ULG COIJ22fdUç 14j ecj OçJJGL QUL peac

P'-'!" f JIG AUJJ1G 0 C° ! JG22 2çLU1pqoLltnq• 149A€LIJJGJG2& 14€ JJUA€ U Um.up€Luq Lejju€q ansv12 fJI€ COGifiCIGUI oi xeq-CojjciGiJç btoqncçiou f€GJIfl0JO pcçtceu LU/A 2JTULC° LGBLG2GJJç2 UH A9VBJG coeça OçJsGL flJ&U coaç o LU/A 2HUL Jç2GJ UU LOS?MJJGLG C LGBLG2GUç2 mtrnuj coaç o bLoqucrn 100 bormqa o teijneg en&

+ LOS? *

mtu&j Cø2 Oj; 2UUL LGQTJJIJW C CUll fpGLGJLG po esnumstiseq p?LU/A 2IIUL A&Li&pJ€ coça UJ20 iucpiq€q jpoL uuq oçpet coeçe' jye coueç&uç

poçp uqneçtX bstç1c1buuçe uuq op2€LA€L2 p uqqiçiou cc mUçeLrnJ2 coaç

nb cc bjøuç c&bUc1fA uq iujuicG peAouq jy€ae bjuç CUbUcIcIGa thGLG Jduo&uJ4J1G CUUG LGIJIJGL2 nçijiseq U COUJUJOU c€cpuojoVa1 I/\UL!UUJ ccaç coueçuuç

/AJJIC}I 12 I)° 211CL0262JTUL /492 J1GU 1uJGJcGq bfltflj€q1 &uq CJ22c&JJSGq J)A LGUIJGL2 11110 LeiJueg 2HULa€ebccwjj? flp& UJf}J0ITJJ rOulI2IUUU /492 BU IWbOLç9IJç qom€ac 20ITLCG' 1P6 LU/Ap€Thuq11 y4oaç oj LU 2IJUL LGIJUGq JJG fl'3' na btoqnccq 111 cp cLob1caaLIla coGcl€uc rrncp9'xJeq 0A€L cut asuibje beuoq uq° 100 bonuqa o LU/A 2uUL /Aonjq ?qejq OUJA 052 yj bormqa o LG1JGq 8HUL'10MUçGL unq imbsTLiçiea I- W' fJJGLG M&2 2OUIG J022 0j 2fT9t 111 JIG LGUIJ!IJ bLocGa&

14UØ GU2flLG pA bojULlecobe 1eaç!uW Msa oeee bms anxY oL aucLoa& uuq

uuq 2flLG jOL LG1JJJ!U J€ açuuqtq tUq€ 0j LU/A aIlULa EL}102G pomoGuG-cuue tga WW!jI2 btoc€aaeq lUf 0 LU& 211UL1 U 0LW /Ap14J CUll G ftUuaboLçeq

W!2 b€Lioq1 woe; €ueq ecrut 1" fluJc€q acucee se qeuaeq p.om 2nt CUUG'U; U ijx€q coeqeuç 11110 UUUJ bLoqncc a 14P!cP 12 L€JG 211UL' p

1L16 bLoquccou cccpuojofl o 2fTUL ! a1ujbje o q€acLpe' Jr/A 2flUL 12 ;Lsua-cpc muUnccnLGL0 bL!CG2 fJJGLG0LG 08 Lq mJ!oLuJl4A

Page 10: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

ow hid aiallob 8Q81 lnslsrtoo irk (ebrwoq bsibrrurl isq) ahisa 82 si lo slarrrzies .8$ ol 81 mcxii aeiarmlas lo snai a limbs

-moD fsFxlaubnl sill sidled triomilasi mcxii aemoa ,o no snsbivs lasibse silT sanq aisilloifi ebloirdiA sill ilhiw hnebiarrioo saw iloiilw QQ81 iii irnisaim

usd1 ass! lo niism a is Mill befiuhash DH2A lo hrrsbiaeiCf !1e'smevaH trneH "nLiam sill" '& c'5801 a is rrinmn sis aeherifisi sill" abrnsoq bsibnurl a 03

isua bsnilei lo abrruoq 001 1o snq sill nsewisd earrsislIth sill lrrssm isicemevsH bsrtftei olrti bsnnolariail saw iaus viai sausosfl .isua wai lo sbrruoq 001 bits

suit a litsasiqs-x Ion asob tvnigrarnfl air{l aiaad erio-ith-erro £ usd1 sasl is isua Mill islni ol wai lo sDhq sill word ol abssrt enO .rrigism alaoo-iaaua-wsi-Io-lsrt

A tt.niiarn isqoiq" sill siorrsb ew iloirlw bits 4R x T0.1 —

R ak doiilw su!sv haoo sill]" :au iol soiiq Mill asbivoiq 'c!hnsinsvno3 aasilioia eltirdiA ni isnlisq

.bnuoq isq insa a lo ailhrrsl-xia oh liar! -sno 10 abnioq 08 ol Oö mail [si ninfisi lo pi 81uSD a evo laoo 111w ii bnuoq a ahiso alao iaua wsi Ii abiow isilbo nI

sirlav a nialdo ow io a 10 baoa [slob a mcxii 8T0.1 x 4x rrrbaaildua "458 ol .O2 bits 81 nsswbsd rrinsi lo

lo slnsrroqrnoo siLt no rrwobAssid bslisbsb a bsbivoiq aserdiw isilbons feY 1su1 assw iol 02 asstaq iol 0l xsl hrrsmnisvo bits ssieAoid iol 8 :0

'liaqiorriiq sbouboiq-'d 1o suls', sill iol 0l aesl aehbnus bits aiisqsi ploaldenod Ui.a2 10 lalol a iol qwia

bsliailoa saw nirrflwi Ia baoo sill 41@1 Io ariiiaerI seblimrnoD tiwbisH sill IA 08 rreswled taoo a bsboirp slqoeq ai.rohaV .rrisa sarro aeinsqmoa nirrftsi sill lo 001 isq 00.44 iol ni1iea saw wsi rbiilw is simb a is abrn.roq 001 isq 88 bits

amisi Isnimon itt )8C baa 0C nsswbsd ninai o 1o suisv a asilqmi silT .abnuoq ti8jsllob 8081 lnslanoa irk 8$ bits $$ 10

sill td bslaubnoa slibus anhssil owl seoul mcxii 'çtomilssl sill at noilibbs iii iol bebasrioD 81.sldsliavs oafs am @101 bits HOt neewled rroiaaimrrioD IlkisT .2.U sill bits (aslsmilas auoivsiq sill ni bebirlani OSt 8k rbiilw) rroibsbsiqsb 3itubnhJoaaa

eIqmaa mo ni mast las! sill 1'101 iol a Ia sirlsv bslsrnilas sill quia sill 1o silav

.OO-a .qq 1 tiaq j enzuloV ni besFisruruua al aiaoa no tuomiii srLT .211 .q 0001 j-16q 4 ernuloV 3I uomth* 0081 I'l strut 1is'cemevsll 'çrnsH .081-881 .qq (X)0I 2 j8q j smufoV 3% nomiii 0081 ö1 sauL sivm1. .M 858tat

bewoila *aifJ 8l01 iii iibns aoliSaJ2 iodajIo IIBSIIJH a d bom,ilnoa th asataq mol 01 silT8' a,ltnom beJasisa in (amsllob 8081 Ui) $.01 lo eaieva an diiw 8.01 bun ?K0 nsswtsd imav ut ii

.8101 aiiaiiai2 ioctadlo ussmull .1101 baa 0101 ö001 iii .(8001) asnnH iii xsbai sahcj elnaslorlw siLt rnoil bsiuqmoa sin asoiiq taffob inataaoDTt

.88 .cj 001 aoiaaiuuuoG ThiaT .a.u8'

0

Page 11: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

To

S9UJG2 b091' XC A01flm6 f b01-f 5 iooo Jy J20 266 lOGfUOfG 22exceeqeq &jj pnç oj br.GAzona JwJ1-A69E2 3JIJCG

qomu macp o ;pG (ace a:ou ¶T) Iuqceq' iuqna;L)k bLoqncou qs1Liu (pG ;jIac PI1—

poçp pecnac hUGO M92 upu0LmuJJ? JoM pecuiiae $6 awg11 p1ue jJr.ma IAGLG 2pn6041 2b1411t fl0MGAGE' vaicc3 bLoqncfJou qnLu boUioqa inaaç puto pcou nunaasjjl

cAcj€ juqocq' ga &ijj pc aceu' ;pc bLcqoçoLA bonoqa occiTUeg qflUiIJ flu0 JOM 2692011 0J M!cCLpCJ4 WRA S'UI2G 0J20 LLOUJ p0oLqiu 2bccJuJIYGq3 uou-auJuUiGq 1P° OAGL WG eouaouuj

bLobox4!ou qo iJoç flJj6L AGLA JIJITCJJ 901.022 IJIG LG!0U2,01pe flIILO 12 j0L 9j o pe jneq 9çsa flothoAcV ;pe ioo c°"' apoma cpoç

MOL' 02 M6JJ 92 fIG LGJTJ9fl0U O (pG 2JT9L uqn2çLA " JKEG JBfGJ. 169L2011' fIG U" 11101.0926' bLGanurnpJA L9JGcçJ11 cp9uiu UGJ9çJAG bUJCGa o

coaç oj 45iJk' o ULUI,$ c!"r t 22T LLPG TOJ2 ouq TOJO j11LG2 OUG 2IUIJJUL Worn01 j•I 191. qolnccroçrou suq 2 191. L000Ib;2 jot pA-bLoqncça p.0w (pG LGbOLçGq LGflUGLA

mL° 1119KG fIG unL6a cowb&pp€ fO (pG dnot€q G2!11J&G2 MG aflpçLOCçGq cJ10 L0b0140q AsJn

f G PUeLeUC6),SS[uoç] monuç fa t.€uf qGaj anbbcae 3 2 pnuqtcq &orqq LcbLea€uç;pG [jic porraea] c9u L€WIG 29JJGE W9LjU f911 oçpeta• [pcrcj iç cuCOJJJUJ22JOU W6LCJJUJJ OL 0116 0 file cGacieq wn ac boaa!pJe fjnfPq"Pi1 }1GSIJU2 f}Jfl t61J11612 2JJULGq f}JG $91516 uqC02f 2 &UJ0JJ Ijima' J€tG M92 €UGL9J 9E€emGuç moIj file taiçIJGaaGa Of f JIG98 9 JONLGL GafiIIJOfG' 1L}'!2 teuecca OfiL !110t9UC6' IJQf PUGLGUC€8 III LCWJIUtpA moaç ouq Poe; oqeuce• JJ0MGAGL MG JMJJ 9720 IJJOJCG nae o1 Jg

pj€ fJJGL9LG 20JCG 3$ 92 OITL peaf G2f1m91G 0j 2111CC fjflf A&J11C Ja aabbotçeqenocrjq 34JU0L Coafa fJJ&f /408 ijxcq fpoRJJ Of, COITL2& Ilof 2JTIJJC ;pcu 4716 €acp.uuG o c°33 b€tceuç q ;ocoj jopor bo?.ueuça'0 j tt€ ;ojce bEoboL; ion oa bor.ç oo 2i19L cone iuqnefLA Lebot; a cjiuç boAuzença aoj9toq &OLJCGL2 co1Jac;1lcGqy([onrnyc;nLCa' f JIG u'c ;o Lcbor4 cone an&t LGUUIUR aeboLofejA rjom OJIGL boLfaf, 1$' Ot COJ'TL2G1 20111€ bOLç 0 J0OL U5112f }wAe AOLIOpJG. 1116 1000 C61"2C01111511281011)8 J$ITLG ° T•S f,OL LGbOJL2 onq ar1UqLe& MG EG90JJ ORE J0&GL G2FJW9TG

CORLCG)2 G2fJWUf€ Of, C° fO J$ 2fiJJ Mifpin ORE LOI1C' fl MG 8RfEOCf 471€0 C02f Of, S'54k fO Jopor GAGIJ MGLG 971 JO0L ujxeq 47118 MOIIJ(3 LGRCG fJJflaerTEcoc' OUJA f}1G fl's' JJOLIU 00Wm!22!0U LeboEf 2 T°P° eGboL8feJA1 oacup1uonq jupov 0ufi 473€ J92f o 47368€ 12 0 aGLioffa cvuqiqo;e f,OE U jjxeq cOaf' WOU OREcoaç KGUUGLA iubnça ucjnqeq oaqe f,LOIE Loft 2R0L3 C0IJf0IIJGL2 nej 0UGJ0CJC

J; mpç pe opecçeq acme BOL; Of, ;peae Geçimoçea Of, C° C0U24ifJTf 6 Ijxeq

18 3$ ! 1501131119 €EUJ2' CL 5$ W 1808 qoJJOL2'10

Page 12: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

IT

uq eLBA' LAISLCJJ 5' 1802acq ue u acoLcJJoneG nuçij !f aojq o s wuunjpccnta o CGLGBJ ooq2 T802 M!JJGcc

Mue IJGAGL obeLBçcq 92 0 2I10L LGUIJGLA ica IIJBCJJJIJGLA M92 ;LBuecu.cq o OfJJGL vaicc hjuuc&j4pi M02 eoj,a ousgcu' J46M 1ct2cA bjouç' Mp!cp V2RC bntcpuecq ! 1200 jjse hjouç

jocBçiou UI A0UJ1612 1e A°J'" I' b s' xooo' BJJSG pug M02 ABJoGg fl *0O'3'(YJO LOL B M&CL1LOD1 J0C01011 NJ 8L00nA11' eiiq *520'OW j9L e

0IJC mzçua c!W0c 4JJG LGbJBCGUJGIJ CO2 0( ;mO B9141C019L L61Jfl6Li * T'SW'OOO wOf UOJJIJ Jec flwç ! 0JJ?4JJJIJ jOL 0II?4JJ!JI 6126,, ic AoJczwe ' s' rooo' Jr os*c!H°1 1j BIIAçJJJIJ ;nrza oh ;ji WBJcGa AOIIL hJBIJ I126J8 OL 211e9L L6jU1UV Aon potc

3€bP!llb 0 MP' %S!ttS. Ut 1SGSOSI O S\I 154' 5W }fGJUGL (P1T2 DPGL521.C t'1°" I' E91 1' 1800' Jr g

2f!°" 5'3pA!1Jcc BlIq sunnA SI' 1801' uuq 00

a euçt2 coaça one m,raç uqq e2çpJJ&Gq 000' 000 w cab-

JucJnqu bL!ce &Ot betoqanoçemotçp?k JAGU LGçBIIJGq LG2GLAG cubBcifX Aesta'B 21I.BL CBUG LGIJIJGLA wc°ao O}JGL WBUJTWCcITUUE brrtboaw8 LP!2 eabecijjAuqnact? J9 JJL0flJJ cpo 10302 92 flUC0AGLG onjA B 2!IJJG COIJAGL2!OIJ oa spa qGAeJobcq Il B abecrnjxseq WUUUGL's juqeeq' oat teaeqs o e 2astM9Le}JOU2€2' 1122 on iteqjouç siiq 20 2iu!ucBuc btç oj pe LG1pGLA,a coaç'liip!cp' p1 oLqeL mijoq iusbotçeq t anBL qitccçjX i'c° bjuuç at UGBLpAunq uJBcp!ucLA itete &JWo24 euçiLeJX abccnjc ane'L 1Jq1ç SO IF6 juiiq'tueq jLOW $1' 200' 000 200' 0OO2 IAUCP O jII2 C02f ft&2 2fl11JC• JJJJG bjnç

i" 1800' cp eaçiwceq coaç o LeuucLX niçp cubciçX °t 3'ooO putLeja bet qXbtozLeq pe taa cbupje 0j; conaçLflcçiu B &OLFPJG 2fiBL LGUIJGLkpitiu aabGLiuçauqeuf ojj B02f0U bjuç'33 r t ar' pe UGAGE tejjXBUJBJJ bcjcvea o angr jç cdnteq br.oqacçiou exbeqiee aast btoqrrcpou p?pcrAin teucq 2aot L0W YaffC' LGbBc]csJn !c t1FJ lc UJBCJJ!IJG' unq 2GflJexbetcae' jf qeAGJobGq GXB€Lc!26 !' metCjiBuqis1JJ in JJG UJJq-JtJ2' &p!J6ftJfJJ flu6 aJIRBE JIJqU2p)' WOLGOAGV J ioe upje o qeAGJob OL wcdn1te flue tednialf CB'cP" pq flue bçeueq bcpu uncprne combeuaçe YOL !Pmxuinijiur.içXGIJçLBIJ42' LT.JPC exceb1oua fO pG LIq& BL6 VLPUCNG W°fP €&j• tJMJCJCJC

nq 12 couaednauç Lucioujisuçiou ot bpAaicj ga2e;a' cteçeq u booj o boçeucwjat ptoçpeta at aoua rtLBqoxcBfl?2 AGLA couaopqou ° flJG ugnaçtAThicujjA eiçjuet OLUJGL2 O LGUJJCL!62 RLJJO pq aojq ouc in flue T* COJJ2Oflq9flOU'uojoV' GUçLBIJçB JAGLG qtuMzu pwiceq booj 2 E!cpUeL bopiça orrç' &ete

yJ4JJ0IIK}J file UGBL uuJ!tOLWifA at btoqncçiou coaja aneaça U common' jaona

3'' JJIG qjcrqçX 0J GUçLX

Page 13: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

'3

31m1116;c uq eLSA' 'J11116 5' 'JUl16 53' 'Jflfi S' V"" 18 1808'C0A6LJIJ 120 X '00 L6( t° afoLiu L9M 211UL2,, tMJl6cc suq QLSA eb;ompoL ss' jgg' Jrpmjqiu lu mjiicp 0L6 f p€ oc wig iiucpiu€ epobe g pse upnuqnu; RIJJSLL toom wig!u poipçp siiq sponj 301J coç U jcuçp U obboeic 2zqG o etcec 19 WJ04?JJGL j01qobBLçmouç' aigo pA aiqe iii 4'JJG oLqGL Jismeg' 0L bLtICflGBJJA OUG 111111361126 pnggiu' OJGAGIJ 2coL!1LP° pniJq1IJ2 ULG GOUibJGçGq' 1ucjnqiii jie pOflGL p01126' UJf p01126' 1115111 LGUIJGLX wig BWCJCJU

30mu1°cc wig (3LSA,2 qG'acLbçou ° ;jie flOUCJJGL LGUIJGLX !U 1808 pIpJpc W6 CJ1161 L69clG2'w'" L°' xc. AoInmc I' JL 5' 1000' Jr ir

Jtjncp pue uu edniJIpLplm onjA in mixeq 2çLUçGJG& 12 aom€/tjiøc qieLenç' psrç jç)2GUC6 0j cbuciçA couactrnuca) jye orrçcome o Bc-ot uioqej'12 anwcieucJX 2mujj (re' J622 bet-utm conwoc ednpptnm onçbrrç pJ90133 e qeuçcsj cc gowiinuç u" eclrnpptrnm' 20 JOUR 52 jpise,2 csbuci;X

ocJ6L açsçic moqeja o comb€çxçiou ?sejq amij&t Leanjça JJJG QoSVUroç edrnpp-peçtteeu us&qceç qemuuq SIJq 4IJG csb&cc? Jj36 TIL!IJe bLouca Ste (bq

BLOUca uccoLqu yg,a Le2iqnsj qemsiiq1 Db) — iC p!cp Ja e qieLexJce1C6 cubsciçk 1 fPl mocjej' ednippLnm b4ce (bq) 12 tapicp msxjuJjseaWSItJSJ coeç& tt}JUcGAGL BL!Ce U0A6 c vaicc a€ça' tL11J6 nqjj spauXa ho-fmcli cut ci4' JJGLG 12 00 buce L62bOIJ2JAGUG22 p f JiG L1316 OL bL!c62 exceeqiu1JUl52 OçjJGL cjJSIJ 0136 JSL6 jJGLG VBKC BGCSII2G W&L!UUJ coaç 12 couaçuiiç

PG cc &nsç Cot bC11tSSG \&4tr€ moqq S28fl1JJ62 btce uybbeuqpconçcomea' y mote qeçrnjeq qiacnaaion o cojpiaus ednijipqs !2 bt€aeuçeq n peconqncç ueannieq !' ;JJGOLGcICSJ moqeja JJ&AG A61.?t aiUJlJut' 11. uoç xqeuçicuj'LeaF (y() caine 4O p6 coueuicuç' joL ïç iwbpea mnsA oJ usoqea o

exceeqa qemsug mutiusj coeç tOL cue 1JLW uuq auisjj cubsccea tot 451€compiusçiou o qUcj couasuç mut1usj coaç (c) nnçij csbsciçA' s csbsciçAo 453€ cecJJnojocuj coucuclolla 451St bte&ujeq pi qJe 2aUL L6JU wqc 1}H€LG ELG LGA1GJ1 u mmspet oj psaic moqeja ot combeccou suq cojjiTaou' eb€ciupseq

22 yjoqqa o COmbGcllloU uq civ'i°

920 anpaç&uçiuj auceLç9uçA OAGL tAjJ€U btoqacçou ttoajq acuLr31Uxeq if mpç u mouçp ot moLe oi btoqacçou testy cubsciç?c pcLG .M&awug qocjca oqncçou ztonJq açwiç sç s joit leheV sa uncpuerD itsa suqif }JUJ' 52 5 29A6L5J-2fOLA LGgIJGLA Itif 2 couaçtacçeq' Uj0IJ Elf ji uqlyceuç /t5L6j300262

1&52 L jtOW !IJ2f 51Sf ptqjq1 U LGWJGLA fOOjC tLOIJJ U AGUL fO U AGUL wq

pLojc€Lr0 M0136 0 fJ2' 0 C0f1L26' t02 211UJC!49 "P!P otijq P€GJ ue€qeq OL eçocjc o LUIA 2flL sIJq ot cteqç fo

Page 14: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

13

!11 Mp!CJJ f JIG UflLJCG 2JJULG Oj JJG 1BLGL ULIIJ 12 J2 fJJIJ tJ q!coI BCOL !2 2JI2!IJUPJ€33L0L GXUIJJbJ& !U cJJG LcbeuçGq 9614 WIJq m6MJçp 110 CØIMICIA C01J2fIM1Uç2 UJJA CO1JUI1Lfl!01I

—c)mE) = (b

—C)(D(bq) xc)

JjJG J0MGL ponnq 32 buco; n4flcp 1uqn?LX Jnou;e cdnuj qouInrnuç ULUJ,2 bLoucR:

pe bLobGLçIGa oj ednjjpt o LGbGçGq WG2 noeq pois conçunc o jJojcçte nucpwReq in UJJ ccc moqqa &pjc JflJJG)2 bLouce yjj pX (c\ — c)yç VH2ifbboLç 0 GddHj!pLIifLU bLICG2 0 cpo flGLfLUIJq i.uoqe JAP qomiu&iJç U1h1J2 bLoucaJoU 92 et <P JG qowiuUu; nu-onmo; odrnjipurnn 12 aucpucq $2 ! ;peHJq f}JG qouiurnç Lm52 coeçe &ç c UiJq qeuoçe ;jie tLIIJRG)2 coa; IF°11 20

JJJJG LG2flJ2 0 ;JJJC 2GCfOU 01$ L0pif84 o 211J0JJ qjjetcicoe 1J C02 2 €tAGO11 LI1Jbtico ;o ;JJG combcçiçiAo J6A6J

L111 cxbonqoq i;a cwbociçX norjq po cr.oqipj? bnrnepoq pA vasc JotteLinJ6AGJ vac onjq occeb; bLouce ;pon qounnon; IJLW btou;& 91J B 4IJGfJJG JGAGJ 0j cboci;X IBG p.1 2ceU9to bqcc Itorrjq GXccoq comboc!c!Ao1J' UiJ2 poJtGAGV &pen utme COflG no; life; on buce ot on;ba; pa; onLeAeLc!oW jya 2 conjq no; pe bnuepeq oL qeiqo;u ttom 2flC o couraow(pA qoijxnpou o ;pe aine) - pcp 12 &puc vazc oajq egw g combeçiçiAe

O;P6t/t!2G V2ffC coJJaeiAe bLouce onjq p& u; moeç i;e qowinuu; utm bLouceodnippumu 12 2n2c91110pJ6 oujA 1L w° btoqaco2 &ç jeec ;pni ice coboci;A

j4potc u apubjo qcçetuqne &peçpcr. couqac; 12 C0Jjif21A6 y coJjneiAecon o nuidno on;couJe pe op;uneqGAGU ot o 1AGIJ o poLouu moqojBUJG2 ;poc 12 oen notcq: JJGLG 12 0 LUIJG O uJ$tjceç 2J50L62 cpu; OLe efTcUiuUpJ&buci;A pLiue ;o jLG 91.1 uqo;etmjuocA 111 fG odn!j!pLnnJ eoJnclou tOL LGbGO;Gq

C°fl0 21011 CUU PG woqejjeq pA uieuue o tebeo;eq nuee• n' UCThJWGçLA o cu-tL!IJGI2 cobucx;A ouq JIUGOL 111 118 C022 J mon;uueq111 fpo qomprnuç w woqej pa; ;pe btobotçA ;jeA oto btobot;ionuj ;po;GLUIIu!2ciC C°'"°f bLouce JJ}1G !UG2 bLouca oto (— c)yj uuq so JO.&&GI. ;pou

excoeqc WBLJIJ9 coe; ouq v2MC2 exbec;eq bLouce B 8011.1€ us qe-eabbot; ot potçtonq GdIIIJIpLIIIIJJ bucee 18 odauj b ;pe joESt poanq

;oo 8j30L62 JJJUIJA GWJTLG8 COIJJIJJOIJ co fJJG cJOUJIIJUIJ JLUJwoqej JJ}JG abbot pornq

Page 15: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

Pt

34m!lIscc &uq UL ØcfOpGL 5O I8O8 Jr

muLiu peç.&eeu L9Ws &uq qjueq 2UUL8 oujX uç rn.r tedncucA OL fGtow bLice ttUL, 1112 coeç HLG2 ULG 2imquL ;o OHL& pn ye GXUUJHJG2

q'q SGLPG LffG yagc q!q uoç 2nu6L oaç o bocjceç JC2BGB¶U6L6UCGas IP!2 qeteuce na anpa€clneuçjX teqnccq jpLçpeLqOG2 IJO LGdrnLG pe cpç JJGLG 12 015 &cciwj J022 L9JIJGLB fl CGIJ42

smJ0t nqçp cpe nonuc o 2flL ["] LedrnLeq cC hoqrrc jjj jp [Lepxcq]peçeeu E&tt 91J teneq 8UUL 2 eqiicecj ftsGGJC fO IS ceuce yuAouepJ GLJA ffiGGJC2 O fJJG EL M!IJGc rnJq aççe JJ}JG BLG2GIJç qqeteuce

Ipla 2çoe o UjUJL8 qiq uo eacbe comuieuç pA couçemboLr.A rnqn2fLA exbGLç2GJtGU pGJOM LUJJ€ iuqicuçiii bticrn GJOM W&L1JJ&J CO22UL C02f O LGjpJIIJE pi fJJG GLUJ O GULA JJG btobet m01thu GJJ IJc 015qJJU62 3 niq 1@S qeaiuuçe OlE p€ç iJq JO.PAGL G2çim9G OL C° IJOU-LOWL

10S2 >< ''4tt) jtom eçstç Cli 1888 011f!J FJJG GIJ 0j 100(1 jç qqa JJOT4sOUfOJ5 tbpa fG bEtheL WUL1U 16" cJle IJ€f O L& 2J1L C02f 8 UJ9t1U ('b —

¶V LICJIJ pOJOM JJnLgIIJUJ C02f

flue ]JJOtJC2 cye euq CJ cye bL!ce L pi rJJUJG) boo'J4oAGWp€L jg .uqJicp LG qeuoçeq pA fJJe f/to AeLficoJ juser 596 ppq AGLc1CBJLewJeq br.cea 6f&GGIl cpe VLPIICJCTG flLCfJJGL2 wIg J)O2CJJGL GIJcL!62 JU yfltI2f uqf}JLO11 f JIG CJO2G O J (J f /AGGJCJA LG&GUCA LLPGLG 12 eJrnLb Leqncfiou UI

rItG j 2JJO/t2 b;JJ 0j LefltJGq rnq L$NL bqcea liLOUJ fJJe C 1805JJJLGG VLPJ1CJCJG BLOfJJGL2 oisuanuceq ice iuçeuçiou fO GIIJ uJuIqycfrrLiu 2ngL'flLOfJlGL2 It&2 bA1IJ fpe 2OIJJG LfG 02 UIJA oçpeL dff2fOmGL) p'u V2B'C Lçnaeq'liCE cpecomç cu LGjpJGq 2fIL Lt&LG brrLcy&e1u LOUI V2KC (yLprrcJcJeuJUcIJ!U& pnç yLpsICJcJG BLOF JJGL2 Lqnaeq cC 2GJJ !V l' VLPUCNG BLO JJGL2 ejceqpaç uc qiabnçe UOflf fyGiL OCCifLEGUCe' Qu& V2B'C OeLeq priA pe b&cF!uV2ZC JJJJGLG 12 couicfiu feafiuJouA CU fpe $GSCG O fpe ,OJJOJtlU f}JLGG eAGufea&P!cP !f naeq ! fP u.qq jge o bgcjwKe wig teeejj 2ffL bracpeeq jtowLeuu!u bjwuf a irucjeuv LI1CJCJG flLOfJJGL2 oueq u buçeuçeq bcjcups mcpue

JJJG 2GcJIIGIJCG C GAGUf 2 /tJIJCJI jeq QL11CflG BL0fPGL2 fo couecLncc lf OMIT 21TL

exfeua!Ae COAGLG lu M!IJGcf wig CLcigeg aiçp CCuG!C11UJ peu2 c° JJG 2nL Leuu!u miq LeceteqffiG eXwiJUG fjJ2 eli; tA ebaoqe jJLCf pGCwiCG JAG JCIJOJA JJG U102 p01If !r Jf GO-

T V"P"4W 9LOpGL2

Page 16: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

12

M!Il°c uq 0LgA' ItS Ti' T800V2C IOL L63JJGL2 P' 14' E"W"q

3JJJ€ imboiçcnice oj U22ITLGcJ 2nbbJ) Ia LeAc&Jcq ! cOI1pG2 pcçmccu VLPNCflG flL0fGL2 suqT&XY LGPLnULA 53' J000.

ae2 MJJ6çç siiq QLU?' MOAGWPGL Ti' T868' E6PLnUL 5' J208' 0GL 2' T2o' PWIL 52'm!!Jc &uq L4OAGWPGL Ti' T8OW

2JtriucrnJcJA cnLç3jjcq bLoqncçou !U jçe 2f9G2 o cpa zaut29 VLPUCNGcub3c1f? uug' bL6anm3pJ? f}J6 891116 ua cpa ytpncjqc BL0cP6L2) bjuuç'W D°P" LGXJUGLA' Mp!Cp 22 couaçtncç€q coucGmboLui6onaJ?' cp e euUJo

1116 0116 11011-V2ffC IJLUJ UGAGL 2J111f goteus nua YLPJ1tJCJG BL0cP6L2 EAGU

bLoqncGg t/22 5Ququwmu btobat mutu 80A6 u4qcp cpa ucmupauc uqabaugauç L6IIGL2 9ptuXaaprcçqon occnacq or. br.oqncçou Lcanmaq MGAGLFJJGJG2& if J2 cpauuq 20 bLeAauf 02 L0W 1geuf1Qqu U 2JuJe A&J06 o bLobet muitu u &picpwcimo buçpa o bLic62 !tiJj }Ja&6 uluqe 2pnç-qou uuq afULf-nb mstthua tutwpjc'Julfim cubwciçX, rnqlcuçe cpuc ancp coaça axiaceq• ci'' exbGcfuç1ou2 o cpa

epnç gomu uug 2çuLç i-rb bLogncçiou' j,pe LeboLfa 0j W-1 L1ThJUJI1 Uf UJiU-2JJJlf-gO/AIJ coaçe !J1 qLJAG U ttcq€c pGfffiGGIJ fpc W3LIU8 fl tAJJIC}J !f 12 ObflIXJUjr.€bnç&çiou tOL U22fit6 anbbj? mUA jeUg ULW2 bLOgliCe Uf U CJTLLGIJf J022 'j20

for. conbje O, LGU2OU8 y\JOIJf}J-JOU COUfLUCf(TUj Oppbciou2 uuq cpa AUJH6 o uTheta bauoga ttifjJ bLica pajo& mULiu&J coaç iu ffipicp paX couçrnrreq co br.ogrrc&jciijnø€iY qq api-ic qoMB OL LUll uç UJJIJIUJJiIJJ C9bUC1ç2) M6A6Lfp6J622' fjJ6tGqnca 2eAeLuI c!" cpa JCfiUJG11f uqcbcuqeuç Lcjucuc& btiucibUJJA ;pa IAIOJ-

i vacc bticiuR pejo& ulULU9 coaç' gig cpa btaX couurre o br.o-[yg] GJfJJGL rib CL qo&i1 UJlq uccmbç Uo jaUgiu Ut622iA6 UJOA6232

tAUt a 0116 aqeq !e epot&u pA cpa jycc cpuc ujj cpa lugabauqeufa aimbjA ojjom peBL0cP6L2 iq vagc crrççiu btica' ye pJJjJ6çf uuq r.abotç: apc cpaIPG 86&i6UcpJ o br.ce Crif 2 !2 coua!acauc /A!cJJ cP! j0c• 0IJ1A ouce gig VLPOCNGCGLfUIUJA 1101? 0LCG V21{C j0&GL bL!ce pom qou.quUuç ULIJJ Mica JaAcyVB'C2 hUGe oujA ! ïç MGLG uoç wjuqA cUbUc!cA couacL9lueg E' iç corrjqpUbbauaq fO flO&6jj Lcuuar4aa' y L!AUJ conjq 9J pA 2açfpJ u bqcc pejo&U UTAUJ hUb aeç U bL!C6 UpOAG cpa yçc bqca &onjq uwjCe 110 29J62 - UB

!P mjqu flGCUO26 vaicc pug auoiiKp cubsc!cA eupçA cpa aUçILG mutjcaçM6 abeUjc o V2JSG %GS btc& 2J11C6' JOJCUJJA cpa bt1ce ThUr. /O28 auçtajA

2!uce vwc eec bucae 011 U teajqA i mac qojA' p9212'bLcaq pajo& LUUUIIJ9J coç oim pipaL ir.adrraucA qucu ute cpa mor.a ubbr.obr.1wç&(AuuUpJa) bLOUc2 pirc 92 05Th GAq6uCa qemouactucea' jOL 2GAGLUJ WOUfjJ2 vacT88-TbOO P1 TOa ttU2 U 116th 1tA 0 2O' ttP!CP fl2 C011212f6Uf miçp SGUO

Page 17: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

30M111°* Buq V11f 32 1808k DGWPGL j' 1808 unq LGPLfløL JQ3 1800

opaeLAeq bucea j6JJ coo JaM pa cpa bLoqncç o qournnuç ULUJ bLiciu w cpa gccCUJCITJWcG pG qounu&uç JLw bqc& bq poçp peoLa uuq ujçar. GuçLk ffiG uqeaçimuçaa o psqrraçLA qamuuq b&LumeçcLa pom c°' uuq njjiu (18a2)jcuoetjaqa ponç !"q"c' qewwuq uq cbuc14 tOL coaç !uoLmn!on EwbroNu

i' 26cfl0U MG OjjGL 2GCOilq Uq6bGIJcJGIJç June O LGg2OUJUW cpu anpapiçiiç€2jpr. btaqooif btice pajoM W&LU9 CO2 12 2ffWC!G1 pciç uoç ueceeam)c2rguaq) cpa iuoucoobetçu&a adnppLnm buca GXCGGJ2 muuttnj coaç 2 &eççic edrnpprusuur M 2poaq in aecciou 3 cpc icp cbotiç? con-

y WOLG euaonpja qaijuiçiou o cowbaciciAa couqncç !a cpa uoucoobeLuçiAaUaLJX a!JJcA baLcGUç oj uqnacLA cbc1çk1Pc jouc JJO/AGAGIY caa YBEC &2 U bt1ca 91CGL UI! paraq L0J6 j0L U JLUJ mJcpcoujbaçiçio& mpicp pa uaaocçaa in Miçp U buca edrwja mutiIJUJ coacAIOII2jA exlac!u CULc9 (b 3eo) Ha Uccr4pc pa buca IAUL U teçimuapBLb qLob !u bnce2 ucp ytpnqcja ptocpata) aucQ cpa ptajcqou oj & ha-SGLPG talacca cpa btaqçor.? lucaLbLacUc!ou o abaoq& pJaceq nççnpnciu cpa

T5 v r"° onnq Oil COmbGflflAG LL!C62

U W" bica pajom mUnnwccnLIu coaç JL c1ma no; co cpooaa cEULPGIIOL€ cpa AUJJTG o isbnççiou uq apncqou nq açstç-nb coaça muEp; jaqMU2 O contae LGjGAUIJc YLPUCKJG BL0FP6L2 bLouc CUJCflJJTB onjA no; vaiscu bL!ce pGJoM !ca OThtt coac !2 anqjc!anç aAiqauca• Jpa brawucum xOL bcpaq 2ffULo bLaqUcou 12 cjnc cpa !ucnmpeuc jtw BLICG pajo& cpa combaçiçJAa JaAej oi P!PbLobaL IJJULIU c° a u anIICIGU; conqcou ot bLaqUçoIr pe aaaenfiuj ajaman;ooq& uuq 20 0LP JJG2G coil2iqGLUçioIJa qo IJoc cpa COUJbULI2OU O cJJGoat aaçimUça o c° - apaçqon nq actc-nb coac& tebncucio& cpa søjna o bcpaq

faa UAG inçtoqacaq qgcouuj peuajca uq coaça no; coaataq pA bLica uqw axbJUJu!n Mp) cpa ttue jJtIJJ2 q'q no; UlTrA epa; qotan qrnu cpa buca

bcjcu mcpna bLounaeq !c u ppc c' ! cpa uqnactXJJUAG paau aebaclUijA LGJGA9IJf U2 faafl co yLpncJCJG flLOfGL2 - U IJaM GIJLUIJF MjJO2G

cpa pc;ota cp jaq ;pa ocpet nIue w bLoqruca qnru cpa btca /AUL MorIJqung pacunea moe; oj ua 2flUL cpa bGtoq aojq nubcjwaq w pttaja mu

5 epoz&e' btca ajj poia coc; c cpJaa UI! UIJJO1UJ gLaUaL cpa bLam!rrm1ucombje;e bLoceccon JCLOIJJ VF2C pejo&-coa; bticiu - !nc0WbIac6 pecnea eer.naq u btannmn o e gç ;pa taçrnJ Jatej38 cprua !A!u cpa jtm anpacUncUJ P'Uptocpat; UqisuçUKe juA njcimiajA 111 !c2 bcpn mucpua j;a bcjweq arrut

Page 18: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

Is

= TOSOq — — c) LUJGJJ 2!IJCG a3 (b — — = (b, —

47rc v — !"w uJcpL 2poMa rpøc t(b) = ros(b— c — — C + 7) Wig

! jpe cowbeçiçitc bL!CG monjq p€ p!pGL nuqGL u Jnobotçiouo tu;iouiu LITJG'J GouaLncçrn& tiqnuj gemoug CIILA& JAG B22IIIJIG 09 JJL011JJ01Tf3 JJ0 fiG Lfli013iIJ LflJG

JA92 011 !uL0weLpJ0J acrhbjA 0j tOM 9110L u f LUG' ! joig oiiç JU OGU0AC ig ynjjiuoug vijji" oxcobç 4?JJGLG 12 130 COUçLOJ jL 260201J JJGLG JJJG J0C 0L ne1•u C'1P01' !mb0Lc2' JApIcjJOAGL 1800-TON P !c"c"I L!0pJ' MiçjJ C'1P91' !mboLca 02 fIG !U2cLnWGUc' 92 ! GGU0AG0112 boL d110146L GLL0L2 OW u boLouçp JJIG qcmrnig CIILAG ! caçzurnçcq dIIOLçGLJA

bL!cG 19 III ceuça b€t jdnuqz.Gq bonuq2' MJIJJG btoqncpou ie iii prnlqr.Gq 0j ionaouqa ° jou

RJJGLG b(c°) = {1P + [ros2b'111 +c°]}\r11 rc vi(co) — IOS2''=b(c°)

— — [ros2b'"11' + c"])3 — (1(c°)—

[vos2b"'' + c"])3

q€jjucq 1" WW LOt JJG jIUGUL qeiiiouq CIILA&

flIJqet G4L9IJq combec!clou' BLIeG fAIn unccswce tsvqomjA pep&eu bq ouq

blJlq@") bq(C") — =J3•39 R

+I

—(i)

ouq 20 bteqicçeq btoba. motu nuqct qouJuouç ijtm' at c0nwo' btcu 12

bq(C°) ={J3.3 K

+ IOS2b + c°}\

xrnuç un" Mice !(ouq 20 V21�C qeuioug CITLAG = T529

— — 1i"Y0 qomi-

(r'to) (oao)t(ID) =1530 — 185 b

ouq uJ9tjceç qeuiuuq CifLAGoL cxboucuçoj' dnoqtoçc ouq Jo-jiuG9L qemouq) tiicp p4uG cob&ciçA o

GB2JG2 C92G fo C0U8GL 12 J!UG9L qem&uq (ipe LGaUJça OLe drnçe aiwijur.DO2CPGL puq eueLeq' fAP!CP LGbLG2GUç2 0 JOCOJ UJOXJuJflIu O W" cubociAbtepccq qompJuu u" bL1ce tOL heLoq &}5GL 0\Y LpIICJqG pLOcJieLa uiiqMete coo jo pG LuçiouujisGq pA cowbeçiç iow uacper.mot& fAG 0Cfl2 ouqounuwtxç jjtm btc& flJ 20 p102 OUt L62ffJf 2 uuiu2ç C011Cj1121015 BLICGa

nnqetAujrnu mutuuj coaç' cujcrrjoçeq bq uç Ø 4ll mJqGLe2çrnJuçe LIIGo 8cebcJcIam GAGE OUt L620jc8' fAG CUJCJTJBG bq oç poçp c° = 3Q OJJ(4 SGLO

w' cubuci4 pciç coeç 02 .MGJJ 1L0 GJIUMUUçG mJCGr4WuçA GAGE C" 02 9

qouquuuç j.JLUI huGe bq 12 0 GOUL2G 0 UiIJCfiOU o nec oujA qemunq unq0 cujutRcq LIIJG cubuciç2c

Page 19: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

18

ute L€çeeç Ic 12 Gu2? fO 266 VJ3UT Y2EC rnanjq JU WOLG YL0W }i}J 2620UIf bLouf IJarne !c teçeaç Loaa LGfHLlJ 12 rnyeu eutuçe combeçiçit€ bLouf ajam ageow g Mice nt 12 m€uuç qr.wu euçtuuç o iça caji LG2GLAGC OL qeuX

at conLe& puea btouf 2 .&LGLG iiotunjjA J31J36t Hi fpe }J1JJ 2GUBOUPIP 26201J fJJwi 113 JO.M 2692013 pX JJ1U fo bUGS OA6 m&t1iiUj coaça 4qie pijJet wutu wig f ye p!pct onçbnç '12KG estuceq UJOLe jom btouf afJJG fpJLq &WLf CL AGL2J12 911 A6L96 'f5OOOO ! JJ oçp€t diwtcete) ac i' pecwiaefpuf btoqncou 11L92 5Ø0\O 111 JJ!}J 2692011 iii r° (nrooo jou foua Hi

btabet mwiu ma yipeL P!P 2692013 w jam (23 AGLCITC ie) guq20 qlq Jc L0W bt€?jii' WOW OUt bteAlOU2 MO4C JAG JCJOIA fji&f CU BAGL&G

coueftuu6q GACU ! JJ aGUaOIf f2 caGcc!AG 2SG cpovsq 26920IJJJ? uuq fGLGj0LGif 12 jrnet macc arret mote cjlc btsA BGCBITBG '12KG &U2 IJof cbstiç?f ye fLqJfouJ cL!c!clae o tufIouuJIfX o btcqçou cjrnç qie btoqçoV pecwia€

jtv2 qq '12iC cembot9t!JX pgjç bticc rnut, lJ 9II2MeL ! f(1032flcombjemeutiçA peçseu eaL wig tLfflf 1 Ulf cnnnu (eeueaoAe wig ApIJJIIJ

gç 1cc begjc iv' bctiaq ojj bejc aa&t qeui&uq qite cpeaammet mauçpr Iiiqq EJEITLG 2p(,,) apoita fjflf f}JG bLobet m&tu 102f GXCGGq2seto btojça 5 apoma bucs mst mga iuçettnbçeq pi 188D p?t

mutRiu A9tieq OAGL fpe M1ce tAuL wig gig IJOf jadXe JJOAGL boiuç o

'V2 LLYCG MIlL [fGabifG

buce RLt if 12 IUcOUalecGUf nqp S6tP62 CJ91W O COJJIT2IAG bticea pejpte fye Mice

cbciç? pqOL& wig VLPUGJCJ6 BLOfJJGL2 ffi92 te2cLicciIJ !f onçbuiç utceV fyepeywuot 12 couaiaçeuç rniçp tebatça fwç fyc tL!Ue r.me mete bLOqJ1CJIJ feuçtX3 wig eicpet cambefifiAe at eabLcambefifiAe bucea 9ceL &teomeu JJB!uceLe2clu eneefa CO11JbGffAG (6LfLUUq) bLICIUR psoto YLPUGNG BL0fP6t2)

flJG pepAoL 0j f€ btobet mcitiJ oacaqe o bEIGe JAL betoq 12 &jaofO fjJI2 Jaaae ! f J IJGXf aJTpaecf IOIrbeqoq ! P1P fP Mobet W&L!U 12 26613 f 5Q W E1Le 5 ffiG tef muwig we bLegcfeq gomuwif jLW btobet WUL1U$ L6 ACti C1026 lyle 12 file BUmS92amJJbf iou oc° = o .126 excebçiou 12 f6 aai:umet a igee' w ttcp pe ucçaujHiUL1U J&X mejj 6jOJA btegcf6q cowbec!f!Ae btober. mut!u& GASU miqct cpe

c° ic 12 CJS&L f}9f gatu pe betiag a fc buce mut opaeteq MabetE!1Le 3 bjOfe f jIG apeettcq btobet bV1 1J4 pA 922ffluJ6 Aujife

Page 20: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

Jo

fJJIB uJcGLuøçJAG conuçoqecçiT LG dnup;ØçIAGJA aøwo o bLceoufeq pi fJJG ;exçou9 pe g bonug j0L GAGLA bonlJq 0j 4jJG duçL&ufa cb&ciçA J' I°'!" BLICO Jyc LI1J4?2 tOE

V '1°"!"" jLW 2çwfGfl flUGL I!UWL qGrnuq monjq SAG y3Jf onçbsi pA

occnta 6Cfl86 fJJG coaç o couçiurnut o Inc mutKjuj C02f jwq thonai2cLO1262 flJG exieçeuce o L62b1ç6 joce to pejba ccoauç J0L iç• jpe LeebJçe

î\çî LGCJJGe ice WUXJJUW qniU teebi;w pG bwbt mnu BGLIGC qemou-OL B€LCIWqG iAjJ0JG2JGL2 IJOf fO 2mlfCp EGIJUGL2

bouç oj lu1cJ bLoqnccou conjq b6L2n&qe euçtuuç puqou Ice GU0Lc2CO1TIJfGLA91JJIJ peuec wiiaç JJgAG GGU JJIJJ 92 fAGJJ betpsbe GCIT2G btequpou uçmeuuiu e Jncquçou uç p12 eotjX Cf ffiue u AGEA coeçjX flUqGLpJciu pepie joit !u!c!uI cubuciçA o ytprrcjqe BLO}JGL2 bjuuç B0f !f CoUoUflcrW 12 A612 pip uuq pe

p fJJG Inobet W9L1U IJG&L CL pejom Je CUE JOMGL UJG2ITLG 0j WuLUuJ coeçp!J!cX) OAGE fJJG qntuçou 0j VLPUCNG ffiuL 'ic f}JG pe!IJuiu O fJJG buce JAuL

qi2bJu2E Tv1 uuq bLobeL muiRiu (mnjcbjeg pX JOL combuLu-

91F6L euçr2 ua ejjecpte cubuciçX iucLeuaeq 82 edrnbuieuç ztue ceaceq uuq uq1naçeqVLPUCNG BL0fPGL2 uuq WGU D02CP6L1 uuq CJJUUG LucjnuJjA CAGE u UJOUfJJ Ot

12 e cuçtuuçe cubuciç?c y uuq ao yV cpuue upLnbfJX nuçp G GUfQL ojLucia O fJJG !''"P'c 9JJq tAuj jO22G2 12 fJJGLCLG n' = (6— K')\K' APGLG

cubuciçX zte pGU coueçtncç vaicc orrçbnç 92 6 — xc' AJUG 0juu urninuj ttGdmeucX) uuq u fIDJG fLGuq 'effiu R !'q!c ocuj tUuG

.t&eejqA WGJf1U2 OIl 2692009 AUt1UPJG2 (cpe alue uuq c02!ue qeueq CAGE cye &eejcCOUL2& ccnuçequcnuj RS UJGS2ULG pA bLeqlcfeq AJfl6 jtcm u tGL622iOIJ opA ;pe euctuur J.4ou-bLequfotA onçbn picjJ its jupej 6 ! Omutiu JOCB Lucia fJJ€U eimbjiuGe o Y8HC)2 uou-bt€quçor.A onçbitç pziqcqbtequfotA btoijce 91 U' JAGLG SGLO 2IIJCG ujj ULIIJ2 w CuinG btjce coaçflue ueemie fjlUf cye bLequcotA eçtuçe cujjeq tOL muLiuuj coe btcuW cocubuciçA o euçtuuç mmuçmuiu pG buce ye uu !ulc!uJ aimbjiucuciouJpjjA uccouJuJoqucAe - Ju e 2GU2G 0 Jf Leeçucç J2 onçbiiç oue ot cue ttiçpascw-bLçuod\ bLouce 015t bt.€çttoth btoçe ou-btequcoLA bLouce Me fO pGLiAuj2 pG COCf co coufiurnu fJJG btice uL uuA boiuç in pine Eu92 e GXCG2RW 1022 LB0 - cpo Lupo O V3B'C L0UJ buce &ut f6 1088 e(q[eLeq pA

ffiG obetuciouupse LeAeujeq MJJ1IUtIGC2 buA tOE btequçou pA combnçiucubuciçA coueçtuiueq ujj ucLeuae qeinuuq MdnJq o yg

;pe btobotpouuj eecc t&onjq pe cpe euwe yuq nqçp ytpncjqe pLo; peteptoçyet& w JJJGL mutu monjq p606uc moLe fJJG ju;çet JIJ upeojnce GLUJ&teeb1;e 4JflU VLPUCNG BLOWGL2 q!q M!cp V2JSC btoqncu WOLG f}JU yLpUcJCJG

Page 21: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

50

peçaecu suq Geç cos2ç L011116L2 tOE pfl2!u2 UGL tPG Ap2aonLi Buq Ap22ra2JbbJ LiA6L2 pIJçmc&iia 0 WJJ OL LU!1\pflG COIJJpJIJU;10112 C acthieuçfi tJJGLG M&2 boçcuçrnj combeç:çzou

o mozaçnLe' LnJiU onç OCGWJ crsu2boL*' uug 20 2fl2rn M92 eJJBBOq wc° 4p zrnçxou1a IU;GL!OL;JJGJL flLGJ10I12G2 Oc LcJIrnqa 2I1L 12 enp]€ec 0 qGçGLJ0LgçIOU LJ2JC LLOW bLoJoucq GXBO2IILCGL€ jocoçq UGOL f JIG OGGOJI ill OL(JGL p€ opjc fo LGCG!AG !mboI4Gq LU/A 2flUL qaecçjl iuço

11jpn aebrnsçou ttse qne o MfGL rnq jUiJq JSGUUGLIbnppcoçiou J102 2111CC OUG 0I1 0j pn2Iu2

43E!CPUCL M92 O GXUJIJ!IJG GULIIGL wanGa ! $JIC OffiC O ouq CL0 piç ipoc

LA22couceuçtoccq p cuqA ggg we rrut JJLnaç JJ!CP na comboacq o Ef

açiçnçeq u jutejX 2ebuLufe wuLJcef jLom C002c MpGLG 2fIML btoqucpou1UC11E2!0U !f° J! C&&OLU!0 ceLL!coQ D0L!U cilIa betioq we eaç c°c con-

a on pe Ef couc pnç pA cpe obborçnu1çA fo Lef&JIUf C 0L fpc 2fl0L Jp1afeabLecJcGJ; euçr.A nrnA puis peen uopuçeq uoç onjA pA fJJG btoabccç oj hot

mouobopsuçiou fLIOJ !U 1015couqricccq nuqet acL!cc aectecA nqçj monA qeçoa JGj5 nuLeAeujeq uucqye biscjceja moL mpije fyG ueoçioçJona pefEsen 3bLecJccJa unq VLcC

cob1ca o MlJJccf unq CL fyoT us corrjq opçup oLe pom 1801' unqqjc ow qacnaanK ;ya ebeoq& mnaç tejA JuLGJA on E!CPUGL,2 occonuç fIG ojqeaç

2 CW02 2bLGCJC9& 2GIJIOL

°1 iWmolot ençtA cbaoqea E!ILG 2 qiabJo2E nc3 n buççetu Ja teil mncjJj6A6j2 pA IIJJG f3 fJJG 0AGL0G teOj UILIIJ L0m 1883-ThOS' f JIG AG&L2 peçeeu outjscGL fWqGL oaarrmbpon f}I9f C° ! 5Q MG mnjf!bJA fyc counçeqycçnoj orrçbnçIAJJGLG 5 ouq b — c OLe opaeteq nquactA ouçbuç uuq BL!ce-co?c mutn'

Øf3%(— (b—c)y'- xc') - (b - - xc')

btoquceq oç cobuciç? MG fjJGLGjL6 cOjcffjBfe 0 2GCOUq J022 LoqOduuj brojjç2 0j vac unq pe oaaumbf!on cpuc rj ujnG gimam0L1UUJ C02f 10 cottec; 0L fJIUf' the aUpLOC JL0W f JIG (12119 btouca file OC-

1JIG JUJJUJ COJdfljUfOU2 yjaejA OB2UWG bteqoçotA btcea lisLe 2Gf 0;qo/tnMuLq ajobu1JDA J' po; EU2 UOf EJjJJU fO boA mOLe fJIUII cJ'°r fIG qeilJunq jOL bteqoçonO f JIG MOL' VBJSC 11IIJWR ° f° T' VLP(Ne Ung D02CPGL2 bLoucajpe buce mut buimea uuq flIGU LG2J1WG2 taJIGU y.'%S' !2 IIGfl 4 lila' Of fUcaçoRe

Page 22: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

SI

1AGt X° 1W'% V11I12 e T280 Uq D?WPGL 5g T8OCOHCCU4?LflG(J CU fJJG E4? C°f fJJUU 110MofJJcLrnRG flicK møLe4?2 q!q 1104? OAGLJUIY jjie urçcq 4?BG2 bobnjçsou M92 4?JGI1 Wi1CJi WOLO

isq ps runBtA I83 LGbOL4?Gq B4? !2 U COD2JcJeLBpJG JOBa 0WBLJUBJ coaç '(8 PS w ypncjqe !AUt bLlclu pepUAlot fl8 noceq pA pAjjjççcoueqeLBpJe uniupet 0j 1t66JC2 qnz4iJ 2bLecJcere ttgL bL!c!u pejom'(8 E!UL6 j IuqiC9Te2 bLobet DJ9L!IJ MBB p€oJ& OITL e2çJuJoe 0J C° 0L B

21 LJCfH pejott muLuuJ C02

I8a5 M1WPS uouçp JJ6 bLobeL IJJBLJU UcLeB2eg 211p2fBuçiBJJAuqebeuqeuc pJBqeJbpB xsueL2 &ctc BcdnJLeq pA yg ID ,epLfrBLA Bug &BLG

wutu 1122 BB!D qedpulu abLGcJceJe JnJBqeJbpiB bJBIJç Buq LewspJurn ybL1J jeq U coualgeLupJe 1uCL6U26 III we bLobeL WBLJU 2A MOAGWPGLanL coaça couaedneuç sthou BpOJIJIOU 0 2flp2fBuç!BJ fBLIJ.J OIl LB/A 21TBL

PS BGB8OIF ffiBL couqiçioua cutueq niço jj BJçponRp 6CL€B2G IJ LB/AWBLIUBJ co2ç J0L 02 0j JØ LI2UJ /AGJJ B0AG uJut&uBJ co2ç oIJjA jOL B Leeblce

LLP btobet IIJBLIIJ j;JJ 2p9tbJA Bc cug oj T82ô JJOAGLGc{ B OL pGJotA

pIJBqeJbpJB LGJJIJGL2 OIl Aj9tCJJabLecicel; L2ç IJSJUUIJBJ bLogrrcfou cu DGCGWpGL Buq ucdrneiçiou oj1882 qoJJBL2) tAqcp io (req) ua u JOft poniiç AGLçICBJ rw qeaiEnøçemoo OJJBL2 edrntBjeuc O OJIL e2çiuJBçGa oi c°: B peeç eapurnçe o 3J (seq wJL0W JJ6 1126 Oj BU BIJI5nBJ GIJ6LUJ bice q• aP pOL!sOuWJ IPS BLG 4JJ6UOUJBJ ABJflG2 o bLobet urntthu cc BAoq ufLoqncu pecouçunona CUUG2

(uournirnj) bLobeL UJBL1IJ OL I88O-J885 !UCJ118IAG ffie LBbp pe nuBq1n2çeqape BIceLmBçp o 2BLGCKGJ8 eu;LA 12 BbbBLeuç tom El" s /Apicp apoMa

btoqncçou ID 8bLecjceJ2 pJBqeJbpB bjBuç GBLJA jgyU ep9tb 426 ID L6fl6 buce& picp qecpueq nsçp we peuuus o 21s69v1ec!D cp jp'c wug 3BLGCFGJB, GUçL aLfl2f2 tmcI PS JUçG ms 2bBLJCGq

pçoe peae BLG pe 146/A .X0LJC bLlC62 ape f/AC AGL1CBJ JUl62 q62iuBfe 4?JJG OLIIJB-EI1ILe e 2jJ0.th2 btobet UJBLIU Lom 1883 fJJLOI1p euq O J95 '(2

bjBua fo qonpje !f cBbBczfA pA gnbpcBfu nLpoje ojj tejneLA,a pnJquft242cBbucJfA B2 3000 pBLLeJ2 bet qøA pnç GAGU pqote IUlclBI bLoqrrcfou ye uqeuug cou2fLncfiou O B bJBuf w pJBqeJbpB PS vi ir 2btecjceja !u!c!BJ

poLçjA cpeteqçet' abLecreja uuonuceq p12 o euçet EB2cGIIJ mBLJCGf'

BIJ nuqeLecBuput peçnseu abtecjceja uuq cpe JJLJT2f ponç B /2OU c WBLJCef2cosc uuq 'ornawuu bJBufa' BcdrnLeq uc c°c bJBuf PS UbbULeuf /qoIBflou

Page 23: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

55

ciçeq pA E!CJJUGL' Jr

1JJJI2 vcconuç come LLOW 2BLGCYCP L2 TOTS ;uwouA ! cJ'G vawc mouobojis&çiou cu'a&2bLGCJCGJ2 L!u&uc!J jtcotqa B&IJCLOLC r!pLu0 (1UAGL2!Ø ° CUJ!L0LU!U BGLYGJG4D°Uc! 31 cGHça pA T805 ABJflG 0j Wit bL!CG iuqcx MG OPW!U 50 CGIJfteM!Ji4 uq tu pllnLA JJ reosa Jr 3•

W! oct pnç enpaedrreuç ucoçwçJaua LGanjçGq 115 t au o yajqjumasrjq 26jJ c yuj psçeteeç Ju pJjqeJbpJ cauceLu))10 bL6cjc6j2 teccGqEEjA PS T8OT vicc aeLeq fo BGJJ bLecjceje JcB nc COU2f bjnjç btccjceja

2W VaHC-abLecJccL2 BC6 LLOCG22

vaicc J2 mote tjj2 qiacnaaeq JI €qicejX pejomCL62G pta prmqteq w!cii teemeuç peçnsccu aBLGCJCGJ2 svq2bLecJceI; aou& pç peiu ecAeuçA OJjL2 ILl i'"' J9J uuq us-fteaç cc bwuc abLecJcera uq acpGLa u 2}J1bbiu coucetu obetçeg pA

vaicc uuq abLecjceja wi GAq6UCQq pA cotqeq bulmeuça pA V2HCtnrnth btobet IUgLIIJ J2 J20 caiuciqeuç icp P'!T tbbtacpem€uç po-cambeçzçi&o btabct motRuf IucLGueiu coaç at bteqpou vaicc IPedrwçiou (j) mqicuçe& qecteea u f6 buce oj t&m enL jeq IUcLe$e2 Ill pettaçp M xw bqce at tgm 8IIL jjiu JL0m 2t8 O bet bomxy ya

euecc au ybLj 120V iv imbcç au cpe wm enRut mrnjce nn2 qL91nç1c'3)56 vTcg!ureA gj) mjI!cJl ucjaqeg cye upopçiou at qncIe2 au tøm acrt

eeaau Lcab!çG tnmeuç gbbjiea pct& a mejj paç ULG cauanuqiubtab€t WIEW was w pe abLu &uq 2RIJJJJJGLa JgJ 2 me jJ6 £T2TWJ

p1pqosa iso; tcbr.cacu; bejc joq bqcuW vaB'c teç&pieq exccaa cuboci;A GAGULGTWfIAGIA mate caaçjA tat yac pi pp sgu jam eegaow ffi6 LeIçeLOçe cyiaat pij? exbjuuçiou tOE fy12 teab1çe 12 f JIG 2IIJ6 2 petals: bteqçiau majye teebiçe ma ptiq yameiieV mi;p cpe btabet urntthu iriw u euq1 T8OO we btobet mgtu £026 ttam 53 ais y1A ST f 20 ceuçe au yrne wya is ;JJG ytpncjcje msiY yip aeuaou ptanpç ponf U teabiçe w fp bticc mut

23 LL!CG fltL IfG2bf 62

3T ffiJq mejj m;pJu ant E&IJ6 at 62c!m&;e21btetrnpu bucea uibjea u UouJuuj AUjITQ at c° o Sk CjO2G abyju t€giJGta'10 IP' GAGU dnuçeq fJJG j022 a bet pcnsqteq jp& RSJJICJJ t&eutejjmuW awuu teuemeq cambeçiçiau peçmeeu fye yg uq fpe bp!wq9-

Page 24: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

53

hir Jg-J32T' X° )JWG2' 1f11II2 5S! 1801

99 GAJgGucGq pA 9qASUGG pi LGUG hticcLIIIJJOL2 IXGGJCGJa JJB2 p0611 wcxJnJLoq J)A }fc3 jioX JJUAG LG9cpoq 20W0 2OLf O BLL91JGW6IJ*12 flJJJC rnq CL0 V" 5S' 1801 LGboLç jçponp JJ0I.G 12 110 p99!2 LOL 4jJo

flze JL9 WGIJçJOIJ 01 IP° MC$0LU !" W F16L pOOJCR 01. VeIICI M4 C°99f bjøu; 12 on ybq

a;sJce &oirjq }flAG u2211L6q couprnreq bece itçp bteqwja f}JG fpc tOLGOIJG hotvtç qeaiiJeq 1q ucdrnaipou a o;peL teEu0L2 u v2c mpJoL;Xpejo& UJL1IJ9 coaç in cLJA jg jyia qecpuc cuu pe UcGLbLGfGq ua bLeqfoQk'8 2J30tA& fJJG btob€t 1MLJU JGJJ !U ocP 180V oJq ecpcq f OLatjceq orrç Lom jçe Jg5J cc ernijA JgÔ uuq peCuJc brrppc 'Is ALCJJ T8o3

i u"r ucdn1açiau o btecjcep &uq oçpeL JnJqGJbprn LGIJJJGLB £ao pe piJset IT, cJJe2e Le1Jn6L2 nsçicibçeq abLGcJceJe, c&n2içzowcc brrLcjnae cpe tern LGm1U!IJ iirqebeiiqeiiç pzJqGJbpw LGUJJGL2 9iJ flJG GLUJ211111J0L14 Bf 9(6 26CLG JJJJG COIJCGLU T,OL BGCLGCX MU? ttGJJ-T,oflUq6q V2HC itapcqin piJqeJbpiu ob6Lfioir yjçc JCGBç pof}J ffJG?G qjecnaaoua oiiq HAGm6X6L2q2CJ728OIJ2 MIfJJ aBLGCTCGJ2 W fJ T,&JJ 0 J3J upon; piT?UU onç PI wsloL!A 2}flL6

B6cu026 O L1CciOIJ2 OAGL ;jsc LI1IJIJ!U O pJJ&qeJbJJw bjsiiç vsc p6øuBLGCJCGJ2 cou;uneq qerJ? ;p&ç uuA qegj pq peen 2;Lncjccc pute jnq a p2i2 f}J6 Leahi;e Ill fG Mice itt qJG BIHBWGL OT,

2GCLGf 9fJJOI1JJ LITIJJOL2 O qeceuce IAGLG T,ooç JAJO2f O LJTUIOL2 2GGIIJGq

jwctqeqe JDA f JIG 2bLiIJ Ot 2IJIJJUJGL O JJ f JIG Of JJGL ULLV1JG1JJGIJf 2 teuwjucq &

yJco1i]3 4q36 ctcçiau o 4q56 Meacetu 2HL gejjn1uK COJJJBUIA pecine bnpJ!cCOUfL0J nec ajmbj%. cc ;pc fLJ2tGL buce'p9 o& pnç 2bLGcJCGT2 bb&teu;jX opGcceq o 22Gfno; jwott ;pc 296 BEIGe? onjq puAe ucccpeq fo 4q16 aaeç cLuçeL pi 4q16qnobajA bLouca WhIff? p9 mouobojA bto11çe miqer. 4q36 us 9tLU6UJGUf' ffie qoM62 c°c bjuç onçtijsç co 4q16 JG22GL flUOIIUf OT, 0116 wig J59T, dm62 (bet-ijim)Ju 4q16 eaç uç 201MG t0fiLe qçe ijom (bet-utm) qnoboj2 bLouca p&q !c eojq !4q36 ffi62 oaç 3316 IJIIUJ SLLUIJE6IJJ6IJf 920 teqnceq VHC !11G611c!A6 fo LGGIJdGL6uC6 euantcq IJJITJfIIIJ&LJCGf COIIfWCf 111 C26 VJSC eporrjq C1I2G T,ITLdJIGL bLopJem2 on

wig ;pctqore couçtoj ot pa pJqeJbprn bjwir ffGf9IsJI3 ni 2; c°c btca-ceq j't o 4q56 M62f c°c mouobojX JU LGfJILIJ tOE U gqi;iauj 2 BGLC6Uf acwJc&

ju tc1cc;iu 4q16 1U1p9 OU6L pilf uccebçiii qie IJUJ UEGG11J6IJf btecjceje 2&CLI-HUA6m6L V3I{C2 bLe2qeuc T,OL 5'S2 UJ!H!OJJ'LeçmuJ bL6cJceJa aojq t2 beLcduf €drnçA 2dUJ(G in P! pJugcJb}nu Bjuu; ;o a'°2bLecjcGje wig vaisc rnsq &&pcp jeu2eq ;o cowbgu1ee3 MGe; c°c bjwsça wcombwiA' jye M6a;6LU arTut gejuiu Combuu MJJ!cp mga 6cJJTHA onneq pX

Page 25: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

5sf

11 J16 GOIJ4IOJ 082 JOM 82 IJGcGeeLA G1J6WG ;L91JC j,pna bLcqci;rou conjq LGW0AG ;ji€ cbczçA IJOLLGCG!A6L2J11B conL' 8JJOMIIJ 4JJG incnwp€u muuew€u; ;o LGOL9U1SG JJG wxjtoøq uq aG LçptnJJcLnbcA [)Gp$2 !UCITLLGCJ pA 0 pouJcLnb; LOIJLoBq conjq po GaGC;IAGJA qJ2wuacq pAqzqo;eq pA fiG 21111$ c024?2 oaaocio;cq mi;p ;pG LUJjLOOCJ p1qn2;L? 82 LGHu1OLC6q pA ;pc BLGA0II!0Gu;L0114?a pA ojjocoçrn fliG 0 2J10L6 OLGUI4GJ pfl8U2• yccOLqpJ fo b04° (Jg)' pia bojicA it82obbov;e GflLGWG' ;JJG O!I1 EXGCI1VJAG C°"!' 0 TbCJ' CGnIJLA LOIJLQOq c0L6J' eccomwoqo;eqpobc LGIJIOAG 11GM CUbBCJA LLOW 0 B'JL$!GUJUL LolIf 6' 82 aco floLon (Q) J102 0L11G yp!Uq1i2tL coee' oç JG82f 011 OIJA boLpcnJoL ejjihbiii LOn;G' MGLG uo 2110$' 011(4 20 btcqo;iou coiijq

242 33• C0mLG fiG L!2p 2P!bb!11 coLceje 0; JflLU 0 fIG CG114JTLA 111 ;po;!11211wc!Gu; o cowbcppou' eo fIG br.oj; on; joo jL M82

CUJnOLU!0 cowprnU;iou ocdnLLGq jjicA coucjnq6q' p0MGAGL' cu; 2IICJJ 011 l11;GLG2; poq p6611o mJuoLi;A JufcL; iii bL6cjccj2 p8(4 boaaq U;0 pouq pieuqjA ;o V28C ! GOLJA J8ÔJ JJGU01 oujlrn ThiS ;;'°" MB1°; ouq (3LOA,2 LGbO14 Oj 'JUDnOLA 51' 1805 HOG(4 0 P61161 ;p°tIIUAGAWGAGL,2 unuou;A e;ojco !11 8bL6wG12,2 JIJ0q6Jhp0 bjou; GAGI! B1JGL fleA 20N on;' jGULu11

23E!CPUGL zuqzco; ;po; monA o IG uqebeuqeu; bJJijuqejbprn L6U116L2 qiq rio; jCIJOM 0j

fJJGOLIGe pA cuJcsrJoc1u OIl IUGWUJ rof 6 0 LGfIILU 0L bLGqucJow ffiG LG2fLICç 00Louq 42J36 GfGLLGUCG 0 GUf ii oj oqqJçiouu cobocifAff M6 GAUJff&f 6 €ocp cm obqcc ot cpe GufLouf,e bjnjç' o teuçot WULJCGf 2ystc JU U cOJJfle!AG GJI11JIPLJJiW'U22Gf 2 jL0W fJJG Uqfl2fLA MG coIJeiqGt fJJLGG boa2pJG oplecfxAGa: U J0IAGL bntcjrn2e

1P' V2B'C,2 &OUJ U3112f U)L6 GGU 20111€ OITICOUJG 2}10Lf 0 LcmonU cp€ UGLGWJGLA bjo.uç JAo2 AGLA 2I1I0JJ

0L!jIJUJ O!AUGL2 conjq fJJGUJ2GJAG2 GX!f Uqn2fLA' fJIG 2UJAUG AUJUG 0 U 2i10L!U iuqnaçtA ne exbducpfrlLe CU fJJG bjouç ffi02 2JTIJJC' ouq fJJ0Il}J fJJGcobociçA içe€jx CH o ;pe coIl pG telecçeq 0I1fL1JJf jjJUf CUb&C!fA moeOUG GXbJUUUflOU' buc€ mote mete UJUJOg of qtuqu fG uemjA oqqeq10 UU2MGL fJJU drxeeçiou' &G UGGq o rniqeaçouq pott bL€quf!oU ocçrwjjA fti0LJC2

M01 120Tlu E!flL6 s iw bLobGL WULU ncçrwceq stoimq fy12 P!P JGAGJ iflJfiJ fJJG eugbLObGL J1JULIU L0W 52 1U JUfe ,epLcrnLA' 1285' fO as JU JOfe tptcy' oc qabjoAeqv3Jcc moeçeq JiffJe fJIXJG !U GUW1U U LGf SItU OIl !f !UAG2;meUf' 1IJCLGU2!U f G

u' yJoqeJbpo vcdnie1çioua toeeq V2BC,2 cobociçA 2JJOtG fO 82 bGLCGUçjwejA ;o coUfJUae 10L 2015.16 fime' rmbjAsu boot btouc btoabecça ot fJJGUJ2GJAG2'fj.Je oçyet L€UGL2 mete jeq fo pepeAG ucçs cowbefif IoU !fjJ bL€cJcGJa moe?qejqeq y€ ucdrneiçiou o ye jont UqebeuqeUf pJJoqGJbyiu LGUUGL2 pA fP! ucç'!fa qnq teanwbçiou o bLICG Mot tebteeeuç u bteqoçori !UAefmeUc mjncp

Page 26: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

52

fl FLUJ $IGt* %$t%tTh QO%%a \0&4C€% I33S O1&t% MPl11cou ToGIJAILOUUIGIJç EAGU jjie yfpeL L&ueG monq bteqcç ml IUçGLHRJ wçc o Leçciua o oujX Q ber.cenç'sug moA JWAG edueLf eq coeç jleçeLoeueiiee monjq uoç pste OCCllLLG UJULJCGf

P' W69211L&J C022 E!U0lP btoqnecou BJUCC flIJGL 0ACLIJWGIJç L6IlJfli0Jl qite ;o M9L

pi qacLpnczou ot bLoqncfou OAGL Aern sCL022 hjuça conq zuqnce qqJGLeucII nw bjcrnç& noç awbjA w FYf Cf 01162 ecouq3 jj MBa 011 !UU9!oU9L? ?$9L 20qoJJBL2 JJJGLG BLC B JJJIW6L 01 LG9aOIJ2 ;o GXbGC *P LBU6 L!fl3 W!2 2IJLAGA iucjnqeq110 tJ-2t1SL coeça 0j JJG coeçjiç uuq j6eç coaçjX bJBu P1 TOTS 22 C61,f2a OL Js cençe 111 g$113182101l,2 2IILAGX 01 L6UIJ!U bjsuca 12 UJIICJJ JBL6L fJISU fJJeBG UI1LG9 jpc &ub P1 UAGLB&6

&011IG2 oec Xc AOlflfflG I' b014 5a TO(XJ h T21 jpe02 L9IJG u e xvw 4't c°'"

83 t• (ttaw aim eef!IJJOfe aj tcabauee aj §36 L6UG bL!cG fo fG LOftbamsqa (3s2k ! T888 qoJJUL2) fl2iI1 §36 J3}1GL LGOJ 2k U1LG tOL 7 0 AUJ116 0

a LGTJIU ft&2 eo f0 @2k !'PFP' cOef L0UG Ot 2k bGL prmqeqbstcc!bouca pçais §36 Hq1z1cY ComTnlccGG !U JJJ §16 v'n coaço pmiqeq [bonuqa] &onjq betpoba L6bL626uf §36 pGL6I1C6))2 GA6LOJ pqna;tXfpG iç con [uac] umormç ;a 0 isuç qeoj I aabboae fO 2 CGIJf 2ponae ouq ;pe abLecJccJa p01126 of p1joqejbpw COIl LGUIIG Of 0 2IIIOJJGL W0LI1 puu

ft02 cajq 12 boaaipjc §16 vaic OL f p6 HOAGmGXGL ' jqci.oc;auj C02f qfl[GLducGa 0CL022 fACtO 2113$11 JJP Uq11fL0J C"'!!°" Iyjçponp tte qa uoç jwa fApo; §36 bLcc!aG pejiça ftet& etc qo jcuott cpu;GIJfLOIJ?)2 P916t2 opalu vaicc C02f 2 12 OO 21139fl ca 1'Q' 21I1UJJ!I1 oxbjoirnpoucawbcpçiAc §36 C1LCJJ2fOUCGT JJ1Jfl GA6L §16 C02& §16 bjsna1pje Lnl6 0j 011ujçporrp !f unRpc pe rnueq bqce ! LGA60JJI3 spaii; coa; motetOt OIl !UCJTIIYPGUF poe p6611 ecffiu bt1cee qoifi aL eoAeLoJ Xcote pGJaLe GIJfL?

1uofliu caaç pX 0 eaqqcu ca u BL!CG mpç 266W 011 nucaufqucu açtoçeVcoa; !U uou-bL6qofor.A bGLiaq2jait C02f oug b\itc !2 file L62b0132!A6U628 at btce fO !11cL69262 §16 !11C11WP6UF2

ra vcc at btequciou /tSJ3GLG c Ia f6 q1eteucc pG;JA66U pjp ouq!2 §36 GucLoIiç2 C02f ouq K6 1 CUbUC!?C pA fJ12 J0C §16 LO22 BGL-bouaq L6f fiLl!ui"-' edrnjiptirmi) fpof Nice ttaajq p6 cpe ueç bteaeuç A0J06 0j (b_c)y itpctc c6

o pciAarrç yaanmpi f0f 011 GUfLOUf btacjncee of coboqçA (oa ! fp qouJIuoucC08f a RIIfl 0ft6L §36 1111111111(1W MICe ;puç fIG 6I3;LUUf ftOlIjCJ p6 fAflJJI1 ;a UCCGbçbLaJJf 2 OLG qGCLGOrnIJ UI §36 !IICIIWPGUf,8 C024& heat §T 011 UClp611f 02 JOfAon IIJCITUJpGII; IJLIIJ aie.uoja fp04 If p02 jo.et C02f 2 J bLicIu JObV a!ucG §16 GufL01If8a 20J6 fa 011 OCCebfOpJe J6t6L) 111 30JOIJ6L2 (ross) tOLW&JISOF!0U ° 0LtJ1II16IIf

WJ3f actAc fO C0026 §16 LA0J fa LetlaG !P 6Xb6C4uf 10132 OUq 611C6 UJf€L If 2 fGLlll8

A01IIGA (ross) LJTGcJ FPT tX pati at Mice .IAOLtOL6 Uhipocq pX ;pe oEteaaotoççGufiau ;a VLPIICNG BLOfP6L8 ebiaaqo

Page 27: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

59

iqouçicoj PGUGUcB BGL b6Loq3 MJiCJ1 JA6? £6 fO 0111. aiuibjo L0Lm111&rn p6 jeç JneqoçoiX heuoq ouq ;pie !UAGflWGUc ie jpjjoacq p) s boLhenoj 2L60W oJ

2eW 0JJ 0I cojcnjoçioiie °t 011 iuçeLuuJ LOf 6 °L LGçIlLIf MG 0221TW6 fJJOf 0JJ J022 01.6 JIJCITLLGCJ

!Uc6ttt0L 0AGLUG - ouq OUt bteetLeq AuJue) ouq 2'2 (çpc 0AGL0G asJGAGJ M6 tOM 2110L b11c62 ojj 3• (çpe bo2ç €xjçQ uA6ts6) 32 (çpecojcrquçiou tGdn!L62 oil oaenmeq bt!c6 o torn 2noV uuq uu iuiçioj rt. cobociçAeuçr.? jorn coupi€uç ou uo bt€quçou €dnoja !F toaa JO22 oj 5ffl wjou jJJqaqompnuç bto11çe !Acu on cuçA 110th C0UF!U6U on bteqoqou ouq 1A6U oil

F°4!°" pmoçpee1e 02 p& !Uc6t624? LOFe 2JTCJJ FF9T FJJG qqjeteJJce pGçMGGiJ aciM6 C0JC1TJO6 cjJe !'F°1 LOFG 0 LGULU JjDt bteqoçiou uccoLqiu po teba-

qoX (pbq) oj uqpçiouuj tiue cobuciçX euçeieq cpe uqn2ct? GAGOL ?eovhuGe rnot BG46GU '111116 1800 ouq ynnaç JbT4 on UAGL0G O ieto potteja bet

12 f}JG 9tFlIOJ euçtA OCGIILLGq 0GL JJe euq O JIG VLPUCYTG BLOF p6t8

feLiJJ cobociçA /t!FP ouq tticponc bLGqO;IOU p yg y UOFIJLOJ couqqoçe jpt jJGbLo11cuppcX 0j 21141 0 eçt&çeA tedliltea pJottqeqe a JG 2nbbJA o boçençwj en-11622 20 02 0 qaaiuqe cpa euçtX q uqqiçiouoj tt!ue cuboc!c? io 022628

i'riic vicc JJUMIJ p6611 oççembçiu o e2çupJ12JflU U tebnçuçion totoouj? oes betceuç

pornlq t FpG olu i (Vooooorncw >c 392) X oot = *reooo at onmotiu 20 (ojea Ira 0A6t06 OAGL fjJe moo-mu betoq) jpna on rthbct00A6 pA %(f3j — (b

—c))' D0tW 4JJ6 buce E2L fJJG pornet c'q btobct

!c ! edcwj o 'kC(b —c) iw V2W12 boa2ipJe 0!u 1t02 ponuqeqoç 43 EL!Ue combeçipAe BLOUFB OLe jarneaç nuqet etçtuuq couibeç1ç1ou Rpeu}JOAG peeu exbecçaq pe Rte&et B16L GUçLA 4Jl0Il P6tOLG 20 MG MJfl 00iJ1 26f cP°couq cpa juççet1a cousbeçlçiAe bto11ça J1G COJJJT8LA6 btic€-caa motu conjq uoçpeçtaeeu ytpnCJqe Bt0cp6L23 botç o cojjnatc bto11ça JApGU btoqnciu oç cobociçA

moar 'qgc conjq pOAG pob€q o!n tom btequçou rnoiijq pe q]GLGIJCG

fIJOT 12 acr2çUlUOpjG 02 botç 0j 0 C0JJJ121A6 edfl!1JPL!fl]JJ' fpJqeL fF2 !UcGtbtGFUc!OIf

2jJOt6 0 G0JJ112!A6 bto11ça ye ite UAG iioçeq f6L6 12 0 L0IJ6 O L!U6 oiiçbnçyJfGtUociA6rX btice ttot iirnA JJOAG coueçlcnFeq B UU1G 0/St f JIG

betccuçon PS"°1 tuçe at teçntn io bteqoçou o 2190' s52\25V 840' ooo' ot mate ossbtoijce) 0 J4 1111111011 qosta tot vac 0/St 4JJG bteqocou bGtoq' rp!a imbpea

B L022 j022 (cjie cijGtGUC6 p6FMGGIJ !F iioii-bteqoçotl bto11ç2 onq !P BGfflBjAeotjA tOec Leçrrtn Ot (392 UfljflOil t) X002\9' x 03 = 2190' iS2 oiiiboteqouq on L11CJCJ6 BL0FF6LB coboc1çA 0j 0116 zmjpou bacmqe bet qoA rne opfUJU 9buce' pom Q611620/S ouq w'ni" (mo2Y uqlnaçeq Ot f JIG J022 111 211Wt L6jJIJ!U)'

Page 28: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

51

q&1 (ço iucjnqc MoLJqu& c9bIcøJ)€eajçe MGLG UAuLUf f0 fJJG cJJOIcG O OfJJGL JJITWpGLa - SGLO UIIcJ b pnuqeuq bonuqebor. jrnuqwq bonuqe - c0LLGeb0uqu& coeç oj byAaicBJ cuhiçj qzecneeeq !U aeccioll K LLIJCwenrnhçzou o nrnç coeç o cu1MccJfA ju C9JdnJuçioIJa JAG hr.eeuç MG 92211111G s coeç o Zurnwçisoq bcr. nuç coe; o cBbBciç1 (YF1øc!0U 01 jou LflU c&bc:çA JGAGJ LcdnJLGa miIGAM encp pu qornurnJç Lrn buc€ The; cdiwja ;JJG anus o uJuLiIJJ br.oqncpoi, coat rnsq ;JJG

U22IILUG ;p&; GUçLA aOBa MJJGIJ 1L!UG bUC!A J' !ce J0U-LflU IGAGI -

4LU2 LG fThiCfl? ii&ucijjX coueçtrnucq co btcq&çiou aGLAGa o JJJGLpojçou uq 2C1JUL8cG!U (boo) uvq 1TGUGL uq JJILOJG SLG A9tWIJça

y ijuj €xbjsvçou !2 ttrou-bnL2G), pXbocpGa!r w cr AIGt& 0j JJ!cp

eooo 4eoe arI�E ses° 1oè2 w2e3000 385è IWS�Q 12Qt. 82 weae1240 T42�9 100è Q•@Q 5.0 0è1Q00 1F3�° QQèQ 35è2 0è oe.e

1132 DeE 0� DeE DeE OèE

auçponç 30 322k 2'2 W32 W2yqcpçouJ AG9'LTX cub&c!cA J5!A 3ffL EL!C62

O500 PVIOOIU!1 EL!UG C&bC!fX

Ifl4GLf uvçc O ffGS1LIJ O Lcqsçom ffebn4ffioIJ nThocpsale

bLc-GxJaçiu pJUG utma pço 4c''fbtcq&çiou conjg p€ lnafieq pir oujX q ygj pgq u;icthuç€q couaopqçiumW eIJçtiea O VLPflCNG BLOfPGL2 uq D02CP€L'f}JG 9AGLG GIJLA LUçGa pcctt€cu Y?LCJJ 1805 Couaojiqçioif nb uq !Jjiq-

oL€ tesouupje uo-bLeq&çmou GIJfLA &LG 1Q00 Ot 1240 pbq MJJ!CJJ .MSL€

nubLoucupjG1805-J80S beqoq itpcp E&8 1152 pbq u ?s9t 4?peu bLeqcou itocrjq p€eiJ cJegLJAC2G yJ cpc ocp€L psvq puq 'qjç €xbccçoq w tcçrrtu pc Guf LX tca u cpccorrjq pAG €xbecçeq c coIJçpJrI& &JçGL &JJ LITCJCJG BLOfPGL2 fla & eb€ci&j

Luçe o euçLX exbGLreucGq uç dm6 01 Mice /t& MG qonpç cpu; viscJj) JçpoiTç OUG OL f.MO 2000 pbq bjuuçe ftLosrJq eufer. U Aen vrci°" cpu; &ua

jye jypje btea€uçeq GJWA 8J30M2 05Th tcanjcr JL&jUc10U !AU8 cicstjX bLoij;upJe(mpmcp /tua nuqcr. couctoj o V2KC)8 bLGaJqGuc)2;pG cubuci;X o jtiue€ j€88 }JUf 0j fJJG I4uc!oIflI couaojicjuçiou JU 'JJIIJG 1000yLprrcJcJG BLOFPGT2 uuq DOCCPGL p&q LeUCpeq bjuuueq cubuc1;A uIJq 8500 pbq -T88S) y iumçiuj puG cubucmçiea tae couaiq€L 1cf rOD pbq - IP' cubuccX 013Cc

Page 29: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

58

HSAGWGAGL ;eaçqcq ! J€ rnqac O G VLPIICYIG J3L0W612 /A&L fpfl V2WOI cB&cJ4 M&aeaVeaahlblca pX po WUL$G Op2GLAGL2 rnzq bI4JCJbgU49 UJ9J(G fJIfl CJ6L EOL exawbj&!f !UoLea ;JJe obboz.nuzçX

ot(y) = rnexb [(b — c) (D(b) —xc]' u' buca Cç uJuLern OAeLfJrnøfea 4JJG JJ ill BLOjJ42cornea porn & eçuuquq ubbjicv:iou oj cpa euAeIobe y}fQ,2 qornrnuç ULW

WLJUJ coeç 80 oqqjçouj cubciç? uccnwffJfou itoirjq uof pats peeu uqçoif JLGqA puq €UoffjJ cubuciçA stcommoqce 6UfILG muLJcefC0IJ2fLffCiOIJ pA iUCLGwajU ia oitu cbuciçA dm6 o Jggj cousop-bpvaiseq vac mipç pats meç uu euçtsuç,a uuonucemeuç guq açnr.ç ox bjuçJ628 cpu pITJJqJU ue& bj&uç 2 r!ep€LInu (ios) InLçICITJ&L J.W8 GUI-exceaa cInciA flGCUU2G &qqps cbuc!cA O 6x12çJu bjuçe AbicujjX UJITCJJ

eç&a 1P 8drnJqLq bjoA Lecouseq pA cp€ qeç€teuce JIVGLOTITLG 12 do ccmnnwceJJpGLG JJQMGA€I! J1ddJ dpc VJSC) conjq JJAG (p36 dJJ/I2Ld GUçLA cJfl2

!d qeçensuç 9tçJJç!G2 ou &u qeuçeq GUçLUç fl U b&icicajrn boiuç !uUAG V8J{C UmBje obboLçnuiçA o 6uçLX UU 20o !UcGUc cpa bntcpec o jUuq uq cçnj couaçLucçiou 0/st Asrn 01.puuqou jpe euçtA uççewbç jjse urnjçibjc eçse o GUçLX - uuonucewauçpom puJçiu couaçtncçiou /AonJg puts iAGU cpa GUçL&IJç u LauaL JuceuçiAe obaroq pçots uu sUcLUUc2 bjrnsç 12 cowbjsçsq &pGU 4q36 btoebecits COCf 2UAiU2

Id 18 batjiuba 2ULBL121U JAG 266 UO eçuçaic BcçJAIçA V2IC ! weorrjq !d JJUAG qoue p€n€Luuq Jca bLeqeceeaoL aeGIS! fO JJUAG peeu tucpat nnencceaçcrj u qeçstqu euçQceuçtA oist pe TIIULçGL CeUçrrLX 0JJ0/AJU 4q16 J0U11&çJOU 0 4q36 JTIUL jymç V21{()ffipu4GA6t btoucupijicA o 4q36 opaGLAGq bLeqUfou uicat cpa yLpnqcJG BL0cPGL;

S C0flCIff2!0

UI! !'f'-'1 LU6 q LGdIILU 2'8 BGLCGIJç

UJjfl0U' MI'61' coiibut€q fO V2ffC2 bLIcs tAUt J02268 ° 5T'8f 1"JJJI°1' FAG 0UU0 AGULJA L022 LeçrrLu bLeqUçou ojj (3e2 x 2oor) x = *ns2

na!u cpa bt€-bt1ce JAUL atstus WULU o 13 bet pnuqteq bonuqe cp!e LUU2jU68I1' cpa u!1' cubucçA taqncea V2HC bLouce pA cpa bLIce-coec WULU

!cI o JucLsUes cubuciçA pA ous qwxj? borrnq 1° 0 UL2d wbbtoximsçioif GAGLA '!cJ02262 01 3'3 JfliflloU pA cpa OIIL JJUL2 LGc1J1LGq 11' bpAa1c9 uuq &oqcns& cub-

815' 200 bonnqe beL 1P12 12 opçuiueq pA qiAiqiu cpa VLPflCNG ptocj1€Le bqcaUAG 0U6 ;o cubuc14 exbuue1ou' peu pe uqqcouuj cubuc1çA pae qeceLLeq necpGJL exbøuaoii' fl GAGLA qOJJUL 0j bLOUc2 q€u'aq 4q16 ytpncjcje Lo4qJGLe /AonJq

Page 30: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

58

e3E!CPlbL ssJr 593 uuq 220

Jr 5fly35 rniq 5L0U6L JJUU JJG CHLLGIJç UJLJ(6f ,1qcwuuq1 (%C AI""° j' Jr tos) yjeo 266 poçuoç

;pe BLGJU;OLA b€tioq JJJJB tonb coneleca o VLPffGNG BLO;peLa JOL PWP GIJLALeUaon GUf CL RGLG nsweqUfGJX bLeAeq sthon pa; Leuniucq ;pe uqnap2 UçGLGIJ4L?C JJJO2G enpsn;a JJIC}J CCUfl2G O cLoae-mUqccç conaiqeLwfIoUa pq & 2fLUfGIC

o" ;JJG o;pet prnjqa pG LeaoJ(T;iou o oltncLe}Jib qebeuqeq on pe moqe OLbJsLueeeu;LUU;2 wte btocpciu aqo GCOU0wic2o ;pe btequ;ot bte1a J028G& Ta LGU4GL cpe 2IJJUJJGL JJG eu;LUn; 1P626 2IIJUJJE9L2 2aGaf UD opiuona exbj&n&çion - ;pe coaç o bLeqUfoxf me&ameq Ua f wefUf 2SG OL JG82 Uuq EGLG UccomoqUfGq IP° 2GU2OIJBJ teabiçea qnin cpe buceUJJ Mete Gf ftJfJJ qLUafic LGqac;OIJ2 1" bt!c6 JJpG Lea; eu;eisq Aifp BJUJJ;2 JJUJyLpncJcJe W°P UUq D02CPGL Ujj €iieteq If P 3000 pULLGR bet qUA bjrnsça unqqUfeq yg3a teabonae 12 JfTJJA bLccpcfeq pA eufLUnf1a aise• abrecjceja aLa

flbou comb jepou o ;pe bJUn; aonJe GUftUnf a RSGLG onp; Unq 20W0 ccomo-JAJJ!CP pe &onjq 2eJJ f6 qomjnrn; u' w ;pe inqna;tAbtot GXbGL!GDCG IJ 42J36 8iTUL LGEJJ!U IJqn2f iX JTf U paotA oanbbjA UIJ RLU2 f}JGLGJOLG JIJobeLUfiAG'01 aGUT /AU2 U pfT2IUG22 bLomofeL mifp no

c flQfl U0AG p12 couaçtncpon coaç& LeboT4eqJA puq n uUqednU;e RLU;eLyqojbp 'q' bjun; pcp V8JSC ponp; jtom PW jpt upon; 2O0OOacteeu Un enpsn1a cub&pippea 4o; ezotA couactnc;eq bJUn; 1AU2 & R0LPPTGcoa;JA bLeqU;oLA Ucpon& OL WUJCiU Ucdrnalpou OAGLflLG& 18 U 261J2!pJG LA2A

R2!;!u oL Ufl eu;t&u; cc UccHUJJA btoqnce teijneq 2flUL pGoLG fUJDjocjqn ;poae pnAeta w ttonjq no; pate jocjceq on; en;Luuça

w ;p anmmeL mou;p& ttpen OAGJSJJ qeniunq na pJf 80JULG pflAG12 2f1CJJ U2 42 JIG JLflIf CUUUGL2 JIUAG P6611 2flCC62211J IPUI qemuuq tAU2

JuanLmomJ;UpJe po;;jeuecjca MOL itonjq U 2LUeV 0j J0IJ COULUC422 miçp

qnLnt buce t&UL apoma cpu; IIJ;GLWCpU;€ cflaçLpn;on qq no; couawn;eflLOflJGLR) JeUbtLO OAGL OJG8UJGL2 I" 14€/A IJJUIJ fo qeuj qitecjA /AJJ LGUJJ€L2aiit€jA JIUA€ UJJeq U8 /A6JJ EAGIJ 4J1G CUBG O GIJ42LA nf0 pL0JCeLUe IP VLPflCN€aojq 8UUL jOL COU2IIUJ€L 112€ E0L6CJ02ffL6 42}ILOflRJJ conçuc;a a;p ptojceta onjqJJJU Monjq }JUAG p6611 U W0UflUJGIJ42UJ fU8JC JA€IJ f JIG LJITUJp€L O amujj LOCGL2 tAJJO

L4OL conjq vac PU/S naeq JOUR ;etm C0DfLUC422 .Mi;p pnAeLa fO 0L6CJO2G enflCLeqpJe ;pLeU;

Page 31: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

30

I'011 fGLW COULUC4?2 JU 2flUL q!q 6X2 fl JJ2 JJOI!JI 10 Lu/A3 ilOf LU L6UG 2tIBL

111 flaG LGIJJJ!U WuLJ{Gf!F 'P 2f1&L uç co2c VLPUCNG pJIOçJJGL2 corqq OUJX UCJJIGAG pX LeçuiuiuIUULtIflJiSuçIOU btopj€ur 2GUf u crsgipje o' couçucç pA varc anbbjAuqgiçiouuj ouj o 2ecnL!I1 teu€q enuL uç muuuj coaç cc utoiq flaG qorrpjooge uAG L1TCJCJG BL0PGL2 201116 qctcc cj, WOtJCGf bottet uug BC) 1? pug flJGbLouca tLOUJ L€UIJIIJ 81Ifl JJJG btoqncç qieLGuçJuçiou iupGLGuc u bLG-bucJw6qafLufernuJJ2 euçtuuça .MGLG drqçc qaçuc DOBCPGL taue moçAuçGq aojej? pAo Jnoqcrc€ Ice UL2 errute uuq eucp pug u cubucçA 3000 &LL6J2 b€r. quk JTcueutjA q€uçcuj prnjç uçpiu onr. moucpe oj oucp oçpeL GUCJI fOOJC 50 WOIJJJ2L11CJCJG BLOfPGL2 GUfLi62 12 JueçtncçiAc IGCJJ1JOJO1CuJJA bjuuça tacLG

couçtuaç peçmeu pauj onçcome o ae u€sL 2!uanJcuueona DORCPGL rnaqCL OVJJGLAW!26 LecoucJGq AfjJ V2BC

IJGnqA couecuicceq bjuça jp€A LAGLG uccommoquçeq3 pn4 GAGUcIIuJJA bntcpuaqin enut uqneçA j,peA cuçeLeq cojejA !U bntani; o1 btojce gemuqn2çLA uç pUIG o euçOL3 porrp muX pute pug 201116 BLJOL GXbGLJGUCG

aeur uuq abteciceje '1L - pug no 04?GL uaeeçe coii€cçeq in maX iuA jo JG enutLcçujiuçiou JJ}JG tempnu GIJçLuU2 - file euçtuuça ot wiqjgo83 DoBcpeL3conençeq pucjdnLutq !Uce&uflon unq 2bLGCICGJ2 r tot ttpom J .M2 mfljfl-nJetJCGc

Page 32: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

31

5j 'ot&tct 4 coso33nc pcoth (jg) go-3rs[15] IAuJt0m J"J "J .i°p' pc gthncoT!oif 913q "c

CP"!I BLOCG22!U qnacLJGe)) 18 'wrsc 'xostus 4VCO4tOWSC% (rags) 233-[11] r!p''-' rJqiJ b°;c JuAGaçmeu uuq ypqc€ç !u

s ouurcr 4 'Ecosowsc prn1 (1o85) 523-5S8ho] icteb& D'qq rnq goper.ç mraou gebnççiou uuq jusb€qecç JLJtOLUJ9TIOU))

LT1CW bOI!C 80 M1C ixm otutct (Toso) sn-sso[a] oejcon b'J r "q VlJtW ICTGAOL1CF 1f UJG&OLJC OL VU&J?S1JJ LcqçoLX

xocp ceucnLX)) 83 NWU&t 'cotonssc i1asu (iaaa) 535-52W[8] CPL!2c0BP€L jye DGAelobmeuc o OUJ1UJ pju€ pJ jgçe

OcP Th82pau yj€cpoq: JJJJ€ 1TL pJqn2cLA J80OJO1t I4BEK ffiOLU bbGL 2314

[5] Aq) uq ffiJNC h Y{H! pe C1"JL&-combecou n 'ttq 'onu 4cosoasea (1083) 312-352

[el cew& T uq &job piqo Ecouow!ca: cbBc!cX r'!m!cc!ou &uq conbo

BLG22 flUYeL2!cX UT El bU2O 1aar[2] wc& ELOIJC!2 F NL2Cfl%t £\ C° SYV \1 fl% JJGXUB ffiGaçGLU

%Stç?V ']OJJIJB abJqU2 ELG22 JØhi] EcpuGL yjpeq urc tacc&scc 4 c,obo& %St!L sw

D0m!MUC6 &uq Lec{&çoL? bLiC!UW1 CO&SOWCLS•C& (raoi) 1112-1110[a] cii r"l F uuq APCPU€l if }QOLflJ CtLLI36 CHLE A19tJCG4

cwmcuç SL1U!U OWC ffiapiuçoxf J13[J flIILGUII O ]'upoL acsTi2cICe %S?!L 'IUCC2 \LOW 1SC'YL O QO1S%IUSYGL C0A

(ioao) aa-roeWP1' P' EJUUUCJUJ oucLcpu) 80 NW€&4CW VCOSOWSV1as&

[1] BJP" BUTL!CIC q D'qq pLjaçeiw V IPGOLX Ot bqufloU eq OIl

ff66L6UC6R

Page 33: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

35

ac' o yjouobojA, is 4 t'cnu cnsç cossowe (roeo) 330-312'[52] sP& o J} yWGLJC9U 21TL ICUUGL C0mbuA is-mrc ip

UY (joss) JSO-JIS[s't] .i.y" n' TDL!CG c1ucw: wocea ifug coTmireuce)) 12 ovusct 4

vjcoaro&th\ (iooi) 103-130o orrçpctu B°H jpj€bpoue combuu jg-jj' JØ5 \o&n.scr 4 bO?P.W

[so] tt"m' rw'q wuq gcpq c reAlu' hLe?uuK toT. ouobofi ip

[] cc %uçS%SC€! %SttL 3,A1ç& O$Ut M!IJcc rniq CL' 1801-TOW

SGUU$AJAU1 1008[51] A°c IDJ' 1MG SW W [\&YSG( %(tGW flU1A6L214 o

ItO bL!Uc!U OW 1030'[so] flUJçeq 2cUcGa JYU C°'!°" 'C% 4 \t 9&S CCbLOC jn 4

ffiuaJJiuçou 3o[io] fluiç€q acsfG2 JP'4U C0mm!22!0Th' 'ISC\Stttq %StcLt QO%% 1LSCG% cnYç

A°I" 1011J013'J16 VW6L!CU 2UL WGUIJ!U C0mbUU uq OcP' I

[18] fl'8' C0UG22 11002€ O abecrni comiJicc CU JJ€ JuA62-

fOU b1411c!uK OW 1000'[is] flrnfGq Uq02fLij C0mw12210u' 'IcbOt$% A0J11me2 J J3 J4' fly2piU-

[jg] j11L0J& '1€U' \A' 4 Wc tL!tlt Ot.O' WLL bL622 1088'

T030' MBEK ffiOLJCJU EUBGL 2QQ3 'Y'P iooe'[12] acocc 0140U IQOUU' ,,EULA gug eqcou: c2p 2pibbiu CUL92 1850-

'\SOUUSc 4 GO&XOWSC% (ios) ie-ise[11] JOUGL UT4IJ' cquou) W€LGL2 guq pcombj€çe pJtOLUrncIoU' 18 'c

reeo-rge' 14 Wu '%otuN% 4 eo&souncQ 0083) 301-314'[13] bOLc6L gopoLç' O Cf €1 tjOiU Ex€cnc!A6 CoTJm!fc€&

Page 34: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

33

g41A6 ØLG oxgujji anp&rise bGLLeCc cdnrjipua'

;eLcaçu ;o couaiqei. ;pe cuce O 9 = y jyeu JApeu cit = V2IfCep e abeeq o bce LGcoJJlclau a'uq Lea'cçjou Jil ;Pl iuquacLA 1;

Ta cojpieiou 12 oujA arraça'iua'pje jL 9 5 9 > j\prne ca'ba'clcA ethwje K !caGIe 20 pa'ç upc pa'uq eqe3e maxrnsa'j AUJITG 12btop jpe couqçou gaGe ua; pajq 0L 9 = 1\5 a'; thplcp born; cpe pAbocpe;ica'jtuue a bqcea pcuea';p auce mouobojA btoij;c GXCGGq peiLa'uq 1'qP4IJG cubuc;A 11yç pJJIGU 2 = i (vi) pajcp tot ;pe mouabojA bqce uuq cameIP OU fIG LIRJI 12 uJa'ximiseq pA ;pe qomiua'u; utm btlce cottecbouqiu ;o

;cLm on xat J6J5 a cxbec;cq uquecLX bLouf a 1" w 2cUcic BGL;LBJJq a'nJe•

4 +tq = ( c)(K+D()) ( c)[yb)—

(J 9)1<1

{(,—9)(b—c)+9(—c)}K 9{(b—c)D(b)—

IPffR JAG LGdIflLG ci a}; ;pa'; 12oJj1Taau a'; buce b 12 bacaipj& j tAG ca'u uq a' cit army cpa';

= 9Rb—

c)vj(b)—

aq]\b—

c) = 9{VJ(b)— b —

j4pG maximum at ;pa'; ca'u a'ccebc 12 GL0LG

0)— c)[vi(b)—

ci'] 5 ('—@0)— ')t0)) + 2q

visc JAffi uac uuqetcrlc q a'uq oujA

b—c= — 9(1 —

—)

EsjJGLG 4 ic ;pe jUIJG)8 aca'clc pct;tavq bto4Jce puia fIG m!ulmum ci 12

(b—c)cit 5 (j—9)(b—c)K+94 (v'i)

LOt GAGLA b' at mnaç pe army ;pa'; fIG piiuG pua no lilcGil;IAG ;o qeAa'cG:EdriiIlptItTIlI 12 qeectpeq pA ou;brrça {&fl1SQ ci'}bt!cG 2G;cpJW tA!cp tGcrrtalou fIG a'ep-Gr.cLa'uq GdrqJptum UGL a'bUc %c' ema'uq 18 UeemUGq qeuçca'j cucp bcqoq uuq cambe;lclou 12 pA

V. gcbccfcq c'

Page 35: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

34

IJOf if 2 pGLfLuuq bLouc& P"F !f 2 bLouc2 3U fJJG qompiuuc eLm cdnJJpLpTxw

ur.m &ojça ffiP!JG W!U!mJm tL!UG bLoqncfiou 12 ff JAP!CP !AG2 fJJG JLiJJ€vw fjJG UJUXIUJflUJ JL1UG bLOqfICfiOU !2 fJT &JJ!CP IAG2 vac f 2 OWUWf

'\K 5

ft JAG COU2GL fJJG C026 9 = T uuq b = opçu jtom (yj) uq (vi)

(b — c)(rj(b)—

d\) 5 (i—

) inx{b—

c)(vjb)—

%t)} + (vi)

A JjJff2 If 2 IUCGUf!AG combfippf? COIJ2fLU1IJf IaY2EC obçiunj qotauçiou Ia fO qOUJIIflUf IILW onçbrrç OL bL1CJU 'iw uiue

b—c(vt)q

(b—c)d' S ( _2)(b_C)K+9(bq_C)K

qGA]wf0n 2 fO bLoqnce y 20 fG conqfon tot no btoijcpje q€Afo1J abLoufa ill fJJG v1fiILG WLG fJJO2Q 0 fJJG qowiuuuç "u moqej aJe tt!ne2 obçimuj

I" BfGcJ t'! !f P K GUGCfJAG C0U2fL&!Uf f ye qGAUfOU

2ffffIC GLfLU{ bLouceqouqun; '-m btotjfr JAJ3GLG8 0L cpG 2mG 9 uq d\ = fJJG LUG GLU2 If 2

Page 36: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

C0.00taoCC

(acog-

000to

E!ante j:

3-

EUSCI 04 yLpflCIS' DO2CIJ6L1!W6

4888 4888 moo- I I

4-

2

+ seljUsq 2nCSL bL!CS (wowiusi) + Isi ensL bL!OG (iiowusi)

Page 37: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

0It

6IX'cckCU-

0

C'a

--10 -

E!dflLG : VLPflCKIS /JSLi!WG

moo

iu

0

e

20 -

ao -

VI

Page 38: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

E!äflLG s: bLobel. V\ISLä!U2' VC4flSI D0W!USIN E!LW g

0SC.0r

BC

co=o

ieee eaa

0-•1800 4904I I

Page 39: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

E!äflLe 3p: bLObG. LAJSLd!U2' VCfflSI DOW!USU E!LW g eI4LsUqASSL

eaa moo jaw

r60•0r

C

0-

S

Page 40: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

gnio

hR

SaoO

Is

nigi

sM

.oits

R

eaoJ

lii

i I,-

CD

It)

4

(4

CA

'-

a 2.

I

I I

I I

I

4;

0)

0 0)

4-

0 It-

V

a)

6 0 +

!1

2 r 6

r 0

6)

r (a-

0)

(fl at

°

0 C.. V

C

) I

I I

ci

a 6)

C

D

CD

(n r

nipi

sM

ieqo

i ab

nuo

beib

nul-I

ie

q fln

e3

1 4-

U

I I

CD

It)

4

a a

o

Page 41: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

gnio

h be

vead

O

.oits

H

eeoJ

:S

HJ

I,-

A-

S it)

go

.4,

0 .4- 0 V

6)

. a)

rn.O

0 S

0)

t 00

C r V

0 -I

-—

3 a

Ca r

CD

t)

4

I I

I I

I P

I

(0

(.1

'- 0

1 + IT

6 0•

0 r 0-

B

C

I I

I C

D

tO

4 (4

0

0 0

CD

C

D

nipi

sM

eqoi

S

abnu

oq

beib

nuH

ie

q at

neO

Page 42: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

0QC

a-Orr C

cuC

.1885

E!änLe e: BLObeL I/JSLÔ!U' 4 BBS-JOBSJJWG

4980

-Jo

4824

20

.12

400

420

Page 43: SNHM ownow aqAq - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · SNHM ownow aqAq aamaa MOITAU3SN UMA aTE HTA5I IO :t45IUT3I5I HHT YMT2UUMI2ADU2 MQI-V881 bivsU ovoa&xoD QOEHEW .q nilhsM BnthoW i3qE EOô

nig,

sM

ieqo

,9

ebnu

o be

bnuH

eq

et

neC

V

it)

(0'-

0 0

0 0

-O)

0 I

I I

I I

I

0J

I,-

0)

D C')

C.

C)

4-F

.. 0)

0

wt

) Ca r

0 -a)

1

1-

to

0