Upload
others
View
5
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Page1of144
Health and Safety Executive
Sound adviceControlofnoiseatworkinmusicandentertainment
This is a free-to-download, web-friendly version of HSG260 (First edition, published 2008). This version has been adapted for online use from HSE’s current printed version.
Youcanbuythebookatwww.hsebooks.co.ukandmostgoodbookshops.
ISBN 978 0 7176 6307 1 Price £14.50
Sound advicecontainspracticalguidanceonthecontrolofnoiseatworkinmusicandentertainment,includingconcerthallsandtheatres,amplifiedlivemusicvenues,pubs/clubsandstudios.IthasbeenputtogetherbyrepresentativesfromawiderangeofmusicandentertainmentsectorsinBritain,includingEnvironmentalHealthOfficersandtheHealthandSafetyExecutive(HSE).
Sound adviceaimstohelpyoucontrolorreduceexposuretonoiseatworkwithoutstoppingpeoplefromenjoyingmusic,whetheryou’reanemployer,freelanceroremployee.Itsetsoutarangeofsimpleandcost-effectiveactionsthatcanreduceworkers’averagedailyorweeklyexposuretonoise.Regular,long-termexposuretonoisecanleadtopermanent,incurablehearingdamage.
Part1ofSound advicetellsyouwhatyouneedtoknowabouttheControlofNoiseatWorkRegulations2005,whichcameintoforceforthemusicandentertainmentindustriesinApril2008.Part2containsadviceforspecificsectionsoftheindustry.Thereisalsoarelatedwebsiteathttp://soundadvice.info.
HSE Books
Page2of144
Health and Safety Executive
© Crown copyright 2008
Firstpublished2008
ISBN9780717663071
Allrightsreserved.Nopartofthispublicationmaybereproduced,storedinaretrievalsystem,ortransmittedinanyformorbyanymeans(electronic,mechanical,photocopying,recordingorotherwise)withoutthepriorwrittenpermissionofthecopyrightowner.
Applicationsforreproductionshouldbemadeinwritingto:TheOfficeofPublicSectorInformation,InformationPolicyTeam,Kew,Richmond,SurreyTW94DUore-mail:[email protected]
ThisguidanceisissuedbytheHealthandSafetyExecutive.Followingtheguidanceisnotcompulsoryandyouarefreetotakeotheraction.Butifyoudofollowtheguidanceyouwillnormallybedoingenoughtocomplywiththelaw.Healthandsafetyinspectorsseektosecurecompliancewiththelawandmayrefertothisguidanceasillustratinggoodpractice.
Page3of144
Members of the Music and Entertainment Sector Working Group
n ARUPAcousticsn AssociationofBritishOrchestras(ABO)n AssociationofBritishTheatreTechnicians(ABTT)n BBC,OccupationalRiskManagementn BBC,SymphonyOrchestran BECTU(BroadcastingEntertainmentCinematographandTheatreUnion)n BritishBeerandPubAssociationn CameronMackintoshConsultantsn CharteredInstituteofEnvironmentalHealthn ConcertPromotersAssociationn DesignInterventionLtdn EnglishNationalOperan Equityn GeneralFederationofTradeUnions(GFTU)n LuminarLeisureLtdn MinistryofDefence(MOD)n Musicians’Unionn NationalEntertainmentSafetyAssociation(NESA)n Noctisn ProductionServicesAssociation(PSA)n RoyalOperaHousen SocietyofLondonTheatre(SOLT)n TheatricalManagementAssociation(TMA)n MsSusannaEvertonn MrNickWilliamsn MsAlisonWright-Reid
Acknowledgements
ThankstoBrianGroganfortheoriginaldrawingsonwhichFigures15,16,19,20and22arebased.
Tables3and4aswellasinformationonearplugsandearmuffsin‘Personalhearingprotection’arereproducedwiththepermissionofSafetyandHealthinArtsProductionandEntertainment(SHAPE)fromListen while you work: Hearing conservation for the arts2001.
Health and Safety Executive
Soundadvice Page4of144
Health and Safety Executive
ContentsForeword 6
Part 1 What you need to know about the Noise Regulations 7Introductionandhearingdamage 8Responsibilities 15Noiseriskassessmentandplanning 18Noise-controlmeasuresandtraining 29Personalhearingprotection 33Hearinghealthsurveillance 45
Part 2 Sound advice for specific sections of the music and entertainment industry 49SoundAdvice1 Freelancers:Freelancersandotherself-employed people 50SoundAdvice2 Venues:Design,layoutandmanagementforpubs,clubs, studiosandindoorlivemusicevents 56SoundAdvice3 Rehearsals:Rehearsalsandwarm-ups 62SoundAdvice4 Rockandpop:Amplifiedmusicperformedbeforealive audience 64SoundAdvice5 Pubsandclubs:Amplifiedmusicplayedinnightclubs, bars,pubsandrestaurants 76SoundAdvice6 Orchestras:Symphonyorchestras,chamberorchestras, bandsandotherensembles 83SoundAdvice7 Orchestrapits:Orchestrapitsintheatresandopera houses 94SoundAdvice8 Stagebands:On-stageandoff-stagebandsandchoruses intheatricalperformances 100SoundAdvice9 Studios:Facilitiesforrecordingand/orbroadcastinglive music 102SoundAdvice10 Musiceducation:Teachers,conductorsofstudentgroups, educationofficersanddirectorsinschoolsandmusic colleges 109SoundAdvice11 Marchingbands:Civilianandmilitarymarchingbands 115
Appendix 1 Examples of workers covered by this guidance 119
Appendix 2 A table of the actions required based on exposure action valuescompared with exposure limit values 120
Appendix 3 Contracts 121
Appendix 4 Estimating noise exposure using the points system 124
Appendix 5 Measuring noise 129
Appendix 6 Risers 130
Appendix 7 Acoustic screens 131
Appendix 8 In-ear monitors 133
Appendix 9 Click tracks and headphones 135
References 137
Soundadvice Page5of144
Health and Safety Executive
Further reading 139
Glossary and useful information 140
Further information 144
Soundadvice Page6of144
Health and Safety Executive
ForewordThisbookcontainspracticalguidelinesonthecontrolofnoiseatworkinmusicandentertainment,includingconcerthallsandtheatres,amplifiedlivemusicvenues,pubs/clubsandstudios.IthasbeendraftedandsupportedbyrepresentativesfromawiderangeofmusicandentertainmentsectorsinBritain,aswellasEnvironmentalHealthOfficersandtheHealthandSafetyExecutive(HSE).
InApril2008theexistingRegulationsprotectingworkersinthemusicandentertainmentsectorsfromexposuretoexcessivenoisewerereplacedbytheControlofNoiseatWorkRegulations2005(theNoiseRegulations).Forotherindustries,theseRegulationshavebeeninforcesinceApril2006.TheEuropeanDirective(2003/10/EC)onwhichtheRegulationsarebasedallowedthemusicandentertainmentsectorsatwo-yeartransitionalperiod.Thisrecognisedthatmusicisunusualasitisnoisedeliberatelycreatedforenjoymentandthereforepracticalguidelinesarenecessarytohelpworkers,employersandfreelancersinthemusicandentertainmentsectorsprotecttheirhearing.
TheaimofSound adviceistohelpyoutocontrolorreduceexposuretonoiseatworkwithoutstoppingpeoplefromenjoyingmusic,whetheryouareanemployer,freelanceroremployee.ItisimportantthatyoureadPart1ofthebook,whichexplainstherequirementsoftheNoiseRegulations,beforereadingthespecific‘SoundAdvice’sectionsinPart2.ThereisalsoawebversionofSound advice,basedonthisguidance,athttp://soundadvice.info.
Sound adviceconcernsexposuretonoise,andthereforetakesaccountofthedurationofworkers’exposureandnotsimplythenoiselevel.Itsetsoutarangeofsimpleandcost-effectiveactionsthatcanreduceworkers’averagedailyorweeklyexposuretonoise.Regular,long-termexposuretonoisecanleadtopermanent,incurablehearingdamage.
Sound advicedoesnotprovideguidanceonthelaw,whichcanbefoundinControlling noise at work: The Control of Noise at Work Regulations 2005L108availablefromHSEBooks.UsefulgeneralguidanceonnoiseandHSEfreeleafletsareavailablefromwww.hse.gov.uk/noise.
Finally,Iwouldliketothankmembersoftheworkinggroup,bothpastandpresent,fortheirhardworkindraftingoverthelastfourandahalfyearsandtheHSEstaffinvolved.
David AdamsChair of Music and Entertainment Sector Working Group
Soundadvice Page7of144
Health and Safety Executive
Part 1What you need to know about the Noise Regulations
Introductionandhearingdamage 8Responsibilities 15Noiseriskassessmentandplanning 18Noise-controlmeasuresandtraining 29Personalhearingprotection 33Hearinghealthsurveillance 45
Soundadvice Page8of144
Health and Safety Executive
Introduction and hearing damageOverview
RiskassessmentTheNoiseRegulationsHowsoundismeasuredNoiseactionandlimitvaluesNoiseexposureExposurewhennotatworkSymptomsofhearingdamage
Introduction1 Musicisperceivedaspleasantbutcansometimesbeloudtoproduceitseffect,whilethesoundofajetengine,forexample,isregardedasunpleasant.However,botharephysicallythesamethingasfarastheearisconcerned.Ifasoundlevelistoohighorcarriesonfortoolong,yourhearingmaybedamaged.Thisbookaimstohelppreventdamagetothehearingofpeopleworkinginmusicandentertainmentfromloudnoise,includingmusic.
2 Themusicandentertainmentindustriesareuniqueinthathighnoiselevelsandextremelyloudspecialeffectsareoftenregardedasessentialelementsofanevent.Highlevelsofsoundarecommon,forexampleinbars,nightclubs,orchestras,theatresandrecordingstudies.However,loudsounds,whatevertheirsource,candamagehearing.Hearingdamageispermanent,irreversibleandcausesdeafness–hearingaidscannotreverseit.Performersandotherworkersinmusicandentertainmentarejustaslikelytohavetheirhearingpermanentlydamagedasworkersinotherindustries.
3 Reducingnoiserisksinmusicandentertainmentisnotaboutdestroyingart,butaboutprotectingpeople–artists,performersandancillaryworkersequally.Thehearingofperformersiscriticalandneedstobeprotected.Therearecasesofperformersbeingunabletocarryontheirprofessionbecauseofhearingdamageasaconsequenceoftheirwork.Withproperlyimplementedmeasures,theriskfromnoiseintheworkplaceandtheriskofdamagetoworkers’hearingwillbereduced.This book
4 Thepurposeofthisbookistoprovidepracticaladviceondevelopingnoise-controlstrategiesinthemusicandentertainmentindustriestopreventorminimisetheriskofhearingdamagefromtheperformanceofbothliveandrecordedmusic.ItwillalsohelpperformersandotherworkersandemployersmeettheirlegalobligationsundertheControlofNoiseatWorkRegulations20051(theNoiseRegulations).IthasbeenproducedbyaworkinggroupofindustrystakeholderswiththesupportoftheHealthandSafetyExecutive.ItsupplementsthegeneralHSEguidanceontheNoiseRegulations(L108)Controlling noise at work: The Control of Noise at Work Regulations 2005.2
5 Thisguidancewillhelp:
n venueowners;n venuedesignersandbuilders;n venueoperatorsandmanagers;
Soundadvice Page9of144
Health and Safety Executive
n musicians,performersandentertainersandtheiremployers;n promotersandproducers;n technical,production,serviceandsupportstaffandtheiremployers;n suppliersofsoundequipment;n thoseinvolvedinmusicaleducation;n anyonewhoseworkmaycreateanoisehazardinthemusicorentertainment
industry. Risk assessment
6 Riskassessmentsoftheworkshouldidentifythosepeoplewhoarelikelytobeatrisk.Thesewillincludemusiciansandperformers,technicalstaffandothersworkingdirectlyontheentertainment,butalsomayincludestaffinvolvedinworkactivitiesconnectedtotheentertainment,forexampleushers,security,frontofhouse,barandcateringstaffetc,dependingontheirlocationandlengthoftimespentinthenoisyenvironment.AmorecomprehensivelistofpeoplelikelytobeaffectedisinAppendix1.
7 Everyoneintheproductionchainhasaroletoplayinmanagingthenoiserisks–whetheritisthepromoterselectingabalancedline-up,aperformerworkingwithreducedmonitorlevelsorstagehandsusingtheirearplugs.Themainresponsibilityrestswiththeemployer,buteveryoneshouldhelpreducenoiseexposureandtakearangeofsimplestepstoprotectthemselvesandothersfromthehazardsofloudnoiseorlengthyexposuretonoiseatwork.
The Noise Regulations
8 TheControlofNoiseatWorkRegulations2005(theNoiseRegulations)requireemployerstopreventorreduceriskstohealthandsafetyfromexposuretonoiseatwork,sofarasisreasonablypracticable.EmployeeshavedutiesundertheNoiseRegulationstoo.TheRegulationsspecifytheminimumrequirementsfortheprotectionofworkersfromtheriskstotheirhealthandsafetyarising,orlikelytoarise,fromexposuretonoiseatwork.
9 ThedutiesintheNoiseRegulationsareinadditiontothegeneraldutiessetoutintheHealthandSafetyatWorketcAct1974(theHSWAct).Thesegeneraldutiesextendtothesafeguardingofthehealthandsafety,includingtheriskofhearingdamage,ofpeoplewhoarenotyouremployees,suchascontractorsandmembersofthepublic.EmployeesalsohavedutiesundertheHSWActtotakecareoftheirownhealthandsafetyandthatofotherswhomtheirworkmayaffectandtoco-operatewithemployerssothattheymaycomplywithhealthandsafetylegislation.Thisguidancedoesnotaddressprotectionofthepublic–formoreinformation,lookatThe event safety guide.3
10 Thisguidanceappliestopremiseswhereemployeesortheself-employedarepresent,wherelive(whetheramplifiedornot)orrecordedmusicisbeingplayedforentertainmentpurposesatnoiselevelswhichwillresultinperformers’orotherworkers’dailypersonalnoiseexposurebeinglikelytoexceedtheexposurelevelsintheNoiseRegulations.Anyonewhoseworkmaycreateanoisehazardhasaresponsibilitytothemselvesandtoanyoneelsewhomaybeaffected.
How sound is measured
11 Noiseismeasuredinunitscalleddecibels,shownasdB.Somesounds,whichcanbemeasured,cannotbedetectedbythehumanear.Forexample,
Soundadvice Page10of144
Health and Safety Executive
peoplecannotusuallyhearbatscommunicatingatveryhighfrequenciesorwhenwhalesuseverylowfrequencies.Toaccountforthewaythatthehumanearrespondstosoundofvariousfrequenciesafrequencyweighting,knownastheA-weighting,iscommonlyappliedwhenmeasuringnoise.Theexceptioniswhenmeasuringpeaknoises,whereaC-weightingisappliedtoensurethatproperaccountistakenofthesoundenergyinthepeaksound.
12 Inthisbook,allnoiselevelsaregiveninunitsofdecibels(dB).Unlessstatedotherwise,valuesrepresentingaverage,typicalorrepresentativenoiselevelshavebeenmeasuredusinganA-weightingandvaluesrepresentingpeaknoisewithaC-weighting,ThetermsdB(A)anddB(C)arenotused,butwherenoisehasbeenmeasuredusingtheC-weighting,thesearereferredtoas‘peak’.
13 Noisecancontainmanydifferentfrequencies.However,whenconsideringwaystocontrolnoise,low-frequencynoiseneedstobetreateddifferentlytohigh-frequencynoise.SothedivisionoftheA-weightedmeasurementintoitsconstituentfrequencies(frequencyanalysis)becomesnecessary.Itisalsoveryimportant,particularlyinmusicandentertainment,whenselectingpersonalhearingprotection,toensurethecorrecttypeforprotectionfromthemostdamagingfrequenciesidentifiedduringanoiseriskassessment.FormoreinformationseeL108.
Example
The Noise Regulations mean operators of entertainment premises must protect their employees’ hearing to a higher standard than the 1989 Noise at Work Regulations, which they replace.
Employers are required to reduce exposure to noise and provide hearing protection and health surveillance including hearing checks (where appropriate) to employees directly involved with loud noise, such as musicians, DJs and bar staff.
One Council has worked hard over the last two years to raise awareness of this change in the law and encourage bars, clubs and theatres to carry out workplace assessments and plan any changes needed to comply with the new Regulations.
The Council recognises existing licensed premises may find it difficult to carry out major building modifications immediately, but officers do expect employers to assess how best to protect employees from loud noise and come up with short-, medium- and longer-term solutions. Changes would then need to be implemented on an agreed timescale.
New businesses will be expected to incorporate noise-control measures during the design stage.
The Council wishes to take a staged and proportionate approach to enforcement although it will use statutory powers if employers fail to meet their obligations.
Soundadvice Page11of144
Health and Safety Executive
Figure 1 Typicalnoiselevelsindecibels
Noise action and limit values
14 TheNoiseRegulationsrequireemployerstotakespecificactionatcertainactionvalues.Theserelateto:
n thelevelsofexposuretonoiseofemployeesaveragedoveraworkingdayorweek;and
n themaximumnoise(peaksoundpressure)towhichemployeesareexposedinaworkingday.
15 Thevaluesare:
n lowerexposureactionvalues(LEAV):
– dailyorweeklyexposureof80dB;– peaksoundpressureof135dB;
n upperexposureactionvalues(UEAV):
– dailyorweeklyexposureof85dB;– peaksoundpressureof137dB.
16 Therearealsolevelsofnoiseexposurewhichmustnotbeexceeded(buttakeaccountofanyreductioninexposureprovidedbyhearingprotection):
n exposurelimitvalues(ELV):
– dailyorweeklyexposureof87dB;– peaksoundpressureof140dB.
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
110
120
130
140
150
160
Threshold of hearing
Very faint
Faint
Moderate to quiet
140 dB exposure limit value (peak)
Live rock band
High-hat cymbal strike
Full symphony orchestra
Fortissimo singer at 1 mPiano fortissimoBar in nightclub
Average personal stereoChamber music in small auditorium
Loud radioNormal piano practice
Soft radio music in homes
Background TV studio
Quiet office
Rustle of leaves
80 dB lower exposure action value85 dB upper exposure action value87 dB exposure limit value
Very noisy
Loud
Pain
Intolerable
135 dB lower exposure action value (peak)137 dB upper exposure action value (peak)
Soundadvice Page12of144
Health and Safety Executive
17 LookatAppendix2foratableoftheactionsrequiredbasedonacomparisonofexposureactionvaluesandexposurelimitvalues.
Noise exposure
18 Thenoiseexposurelevel(oftenreferredtoasthe‘noisedose’)takesaccountofboththesoundpressurelevelandhowlongitlasts.Generallythepotentialforhearingtobedamagedbynoiseisrelatedtothenoise‘dose’apersonreceives.Beingexposedtoanoiselevelof105dB(anotunusualsoundlevelforapubband,orthatgeneratedbyabrassorwoodwindinstrumentatfullblast)for5minuteswouldbethesamedoseasbeingexposedto94dB(anightclubbar)for1hour,or88dB(chambermusic)for4hours.
19 Each3dBaddeddoublesthesoundenergy(butthisisonlyjustnoticeabletoalistener).When10dBisadded,theenergyisincreasedten-fold,whileadding20dBisahundred-foldincrease.Therefore:
n Ifthesoundintensityisdoubled,thenoiselevelincreasesby3dB.n Twoinstrumentswiththesamenoiselevelof85dBtogetherproduce88dB.n Anoiselevelreductionof3dBhalvesthesoundintensity(andreducesits
propensitytodamage).
20 Halvingthenoisedosecanbeachievedeitherbyhalvingtheexposuretime,orbyhalvingthenoiselevel,whichcorrespondstoareductionof3dB.Thesenoiseexposuresareidentical:
80dBfor8hours
83dBfor4hours
86dBfor2hours
89dBfor1hour
92dBfor30minutes
21 Table1givesanindicationofhowquicklyaparticularnoisedoseisreached.
Table 1 Howlongittakestoreachaprticularnoisedose
Exposure when not at work
22 Itisimportantthatpeopleconsidernoiseexposurewhennotatworkbecausecumulativeexposureleadstohearingdamage,whetherornotitiswork-related.
Average noise level
Time taken to receive a dose equivalent to the upper exposure action value (85 dB)
85dB 8hours
95dB 45minutes
100dB 15minutes
105dB 5minutes
110dB Under2minutes
115dB Under30seconds
Soundadvice Page13of144
Health and Safety Executive
Soundexposureincludesallthesoundsheardduringeachday.Commonoff-hoursexposuretohighnoiselevelsmayincludeaudioandvideoequipment(personalcarstereos,computerspeakers,televisions),concerts,clubsandcinemas,sportingevents,powertoolsandnoisyhobbies.Ingeneral,anemployerneedsonlytoconsiderthework-relatednoiseexposurewhendecidingwhatactiontotaketocontrolrisks.Howevertheemployerneedstoconsiderwhetherrisk-controlmeasuresneedtobeadaptedincertainsituations,forexampleifitisknownthatanemployeeisexposedtonoiseduringotheremployment.
Figure 2 Thenoisetriangle
Symptoms of hearing damage
23 Hearinglosscanbetemporaryorpermanent.Peopleoftenexperiencetemporarydeafnessafterleavinganoisyplacesuchasanightcluborarockconcert.Althoughhearingrecoverswithinafewhours,thisshouldnotbeignored.Itisasignthatifyoucontinuetobeexposedtohighlevelsofnoiseyourhearingcouldbepermanentlydamaged.Permanenthearingdamagecanbecausedimmediatelybysudden,extremelyloud,explosivenoisessuchascausedbypyrotechnics.Rememberthatthehearingofyoungpeoplecanbedamagedaseasilyastheold.
24 Hearinglossisusuallygradualbecauseofprolongedexposuretonoise.Itmayonlybewhendamagecausedbynoiseoveryearscombineswithhearinglossduetoageingthatpeoplerealisehowdeaftheyhavebecome.Thismaymeantheirfamilycomplainsaboutthetelevisionbeingtooloud,theycannotkeepupwithconversationsinagroup,ortheyhavetroubleusingatelephone.Eventuallyeverythingbecomesmuffledandpeoplefinditdifficulttocatchsoundslike‘t’,‘d’,and‘s’,sotheyconfusesimilarwords.Musiciansmaysufferlossofdiscriminationbetweentones.
25 Hearinglossisnottheonlyproblem.Peoplemaydeveloptinnitus,adistressingconditionthatcanleadtodisturbedsleep.Otherrarerconditionsincludehyperacusis(ageneralintoleranceoroversensitivitytoeverydaysounds)anddiplacusis(adifferenceintheperceptionofsoundbytheears,eitherinfrequencyortime).Danishresearchamongsymphonyorchestrassuggestsmorethan27%ofmusicianssufferhearingloss,with24%sufferingfromtinnitus,25%fromhyperacusis,12%fromdistortionand5%fromdiplacusis.However,thereareotherstudieswhichgivearangeoffiguresfrom10-60%forhearingdamageamongmusicians.
26 TheHSENoisewebsite(www.hse.gov.uk/noise)providesanaudiodemonstrationofhearingloss.Thehearinglosssimulationsallincludetheeffects
LOUDN
ES
SDU
RATION
WORKER
noise exposure
triangle
Remove any element and overexposure to noise is prevented
Reduce loudness or durationand exposure is reduced
Soundadvice Page14of144
Health and Safety Executive
ofnoiseexposureandageing.Attheendofeachsimulationthehearinglevelundamagedbynoisefortheageofthepersonisdemonstrated.
CASE STUDY
For many years Martin worked as a sound engineer, carrying out a range of duties. He often operated stage monitors with a wide range of performers and show formats, including at festivals where he would act as the ‘house’ engineer – mixing a number of the bands himself and acting as a ‘babysitter’ to visiting monitor engineers.
Martin first noticed he had a problem when the ringing in his ears after a show never really disappeared, but became a permanent and very annoying feature of life. After a couple of months the condition worsened and it became difficult to do his job. He eventually plucked up courage to go to his GP, and was diagnosed with noise- induced hearing loss, tinnitus and a condition called diplacusis where the two ears hear a given pitch as two distinct tones – definitely not a good attribute for musical work.
For the most part Martin has had to give up live engineering and has had to make a living as a ‘system tech’ and administrator for a PA rental company. He now actively avoids loud social environments such as pubs and even parties.
‘I now wear moulded earplugs for every show I work on. I wish I’d taken a few basic steps to protect myself fifteen years ago when I first started in the business – but wearing earplugs back then would have marked you out as a very strange engineer. Still, I’d rather have dealt with that than have to give up the job I loved and have my social life seriously affected.’
Soundadvice Page15of144
Health and Safety Executive
Responsibilities Overview GeneralresponsibilitiesResponsibilitiesofemployersResponsibilitiesofemployeesResponsibilitiesofself-employedpeople
General responsibilities
27 Everyoneinvolvedinmusicandentertainmenthasaresponsibilitytohelpwithnoisemanagement:fromthepromoterorvenueoperatorthroughtoperformers,technicians,barstaff,stewardsandDJs.Thenormalarrangementsofemployer/employeearesometimesdifficulttodetermineandoftenvarywitheachengagementorshow.Addtothisthelargenumberofself-employedpeopleworkingasperformers,soundengineersortechnicalcrewandthepicturecanbecomeveryconfused.
28 Becauseofthesecomplexities,everyoneworkingatlivemusiceventsneedstotakepersonalresponsibilitytothinkabouttheirownnoiseexposureandtakereasonablecarenottodamagetheirownhearingorthatofotherpeople.Simplyrelyingonanoverall‘employer’maynotalwaysbethemosteffectiveapproach.Itisimportantthatthepeoplewhocanmostreadilycontrolsoundlevels,suchasconductors,musicaldirectors,soundengineersandsoundtechnicians,recognisetheirresponsibilityforprovidingasafeworkplace.
Responsibilities of employers
29 TheprimaryresponsibilityforcomplyingwiththeNoiseRegulationsrestswiththeemployer.Employersinthemusicandentertainmentsectorsmayinclude,forexample,concertpromoters,eventorganisers,theatricalproducers,contractorsandpublicans.Employersmust:
n assesstheriskstoemployeesfromnoiseatwork;n takeactiontoreducethenoiseexposurethatproducesthoserisks;n provideemployeeswithhearingprotectionifthenoiseexposurecannotbe
reducedenoughbyusingothermethods;n makesurethelegallimitsonnoiseexposurearenotexceeded;n provideemployeeswithinformation,instructionandtraining.Itisimportantthat
employeesunderstandthattheNoiseRegulationsalsoapplytothem;n carryouthealthsurveillancewherethereisarisktohealth.
30 TohelpmeettherequirementsoftheNoiseRegulationsemployersareadvisedto:
n consultwiththeirstaffandwithemployeeorsafetyrepresentativeswheretheyexist;
n ensuretheirdocumentedhealthandsafetypolicymakesclearthespecificnoiseresponsibilitiesofstafffromseniormanagementdownwards;
n ensuretheirhealthandsafetypolicyspecifiesthearrangementsformanagingnoiseriskassessmentsandcontrollingtherisk;
n communicatethispolicytotheirstaff,managementcolleaguesandboardsandtrustees.
Soundadvice Page16of144
Health and Safety Executive
31 TheNoiseRegulationsplacedutiesonalltheemployersinvolvedinworkatthesameworkplace.Employershaveresponsibilityfortheirownemployeesand,sofarasisreasonablypracticable,toanyotherpersonatworkwhoisaffectedbytheworktheydo.Employersshouldexchangeinformationandcollaboratetoensurethattheyfulfiltheirdutieswithoutunnecessaryduplication.
32 Engagers/contractors,fixersandfreelancersengaging‘deps’(substitutes)orextrasshouldensurethattherisksandcontrolmeasuresinplacearecommunicatedtoreplacementandtemporaryworkers.
People at particular risk 33 Someworkersshouldbegivenparticularconsiderationwhenmakinganoiseriskassessment,forexamplepeoplewithapre-existinghearingcondition,thosewithafamilyhistoryofdeafness(ifknown),pregnantwomen,childrenandyoungpeople.
New and expectant mothers34 EmployershavedutiesundertheManagementofHealthandSafetyatWorkRegulations19994(theManagementRegulations)towardsnewandexpectantmothersintheirworkforce.Employersmustassessthenature,degreeanddurationofexposureofpregnantworkerstorisk(includingnoise)andensurethatwherethereisariskitiscontrolled.
Young people and children35 TheManagementRegulationsrestricttheemploymentofyoungpeople(thoseunder18)wherethereisarisktohealth(includingnoise).Children(thoseunderthecompulsoryschoolage)mustnotbeemployedwherethereisanyrisktotheirhearingfromnoise.Employersmustalsoensurethatyoungpeopleemployedbythemareprotectedagainstanyriskstotheirhealthandsafetyatworkthatareduetotheirinexperience,immaturityandlackofawarenessofrisk.
CASE STUDY To protect its child workers from noise risks, a TV company decided to limit the noise exposure of children to less than half that of adults, for example, if the adults might be exposed to an average of 78 dB over 8 hours, any children would only be exposed over a maximum of 4 hours.
36 TherearealsoobligationsonemployersundertheManagementRegulationsto:
n co-operateandco-ordinatewheretwoormoreemployersshareaworkplace(whetheronatemporaryorpermanentbasis).Theseobligationsalsoapplytoemployerssharingaworkplacewithself-employedpeopleandtoself-employedpeoplesharingaworkplacewithotherself-employedpeople.SeealsoSoundAdvice1‘Freelancers’;
n establishappropriateprocedurestobefollowedifthereisseriousandimminentdangertopeopleatworkintheirundertaking.Theseproceduresshouldenablethepeopleconcernedtostopworkandimmediatelyproceedtoaplaceofsafety.
Part-time workers 37 Itisimportantthatemployerswhoengageworkersonapart-timebasisworkwiththemtoensurethattheirexposuretonoiseisproperlymanaged.Wherepart-timeworkersworkalongsidefull-timersdoingthesamework,theyshouldbesubjecttothesameprotectivemeasures.Whereitisknownthatpart-timeworkersareexposedtonoiseduringotheremployment,employersshouldconsiderthe
Soundadvice Page17of144
Health and Safety Executive
overallriskstothosepeopleindecidinghowtoprotecttheirhearing,andnotjustlookattheirnoiseexposureduringthespecificperiodswhentheyareemployedbythem.
Responsibilities of employees
38 UndertheHSWAct,employeesmusttakereasonablecarefortheirhealthandsafetyandthatofotherswhileatworkandco-operatewiththeiremployertoenabletheemployertocarryouttheirlegalduties.Employeesshouldtakecaretoavoidactionsthatmightdamagetheirhearingorthehearingofothers.
39 UndertheNoiseRegulationsemployeesshould:
n usecontrolmeasuresinaccordancewiththeiremployer’sinstructions;n wearhearingprotectioninaccordancewiththeiremployer’sinstructions;n takecareofhearingprotectorsandnoise-controlequipment;n reportfaultsanddifficultiesinusingnoise-controlequipment;n makethemselvesavailableforhealthsurveillance.
Responsibilities of self-employed people
40 TheHSWActdefinesaself-employedpersonasanindividualwhoworksforgainorrewardbutisnotunderacontractofemployment.UndertheAct,self-employedpeoplemustconducttheirworkinsuchawaytoensuretheirownhealthandsafetyandthatofothers.UndertheNoiseRegulationstheyhavethesameresponsibilitiesasemployersandemployeesfortheirhealthandsafetyarisingfromtheexposuretonoiseandforotherpeoplewhosehearingmightbedamagedbytheir‘actsoromissions’.Althoughself-employedpeoplearenotrequiredtoprovidethemselveswithhealthsurveillance,itisrecommendedthat,whereappropriate,theyconsultanoccupationalhealthserviceprovider.Manyperformersandsoundoperatorsareself-employed.Note,however,thatthemembersoftheself-governingorchestrasareregardedasemployeesforhealthandsafety.SeealsoSoundAdvice1‘Freelancers’.
Soundadvice Page18of144
Health and Safety Executive
Noise risk assessment and planning Overview
RiskassessmentsfornoiseIsittoonoisy?Whomightbeharmedandhow?EstimatethenoiseexposureWeeklyexposureIdentifywhatneedstobedonetocontroltherisksRegularmonitoringReferencepositionsReviewriskassessmentsPlanningCommunicationsRecoveryperiodsMultipleemployersPolicystatementsTouring
Risk assessments for noise
41 Theaimofanoiseriskassessmentistohelpdecidewhatmeasuresarenecessarytoensurethehealthandsafetyofemployeeswhoareexposedtonoise.Itismorethanjusttakingmeasurementsofnoise–sometimesmeasurementsmaynotevenbenecessary.Butitneedstobedrawnupbysomeonewhoiscompetenttocarryoutthetaskandbebasedonadviceandinformationfrompeoplewhoarecompetenttoprovideit.Thiscouldbesomeonefromwithintheorganisation.Noiseriskassessmentsshould:
n identifywheretheremaybeariskfromnoiseandwhoislikelytobeaffected;n containareliableestimateofthenoiseexposureandcomparethiswiththe
exposureactionandlimitvalues;n identifywhatnoise-controlmeasuresareneededandwhetherhearing
protectionisneededand,ifso,whereandwhattype;n identifyanyemployeeswhoneedtobeprovidedwithhealthsurveillanceand
whetheranyareatparticularrisk. Is it too noisy?
42 Inmanycasesitshouldbepossibletocometoadecisionquitequicklyusingwhatisknownabouttheworkgoingon,orbymakingsimpleobservations.Otherpartsofthisbookprovideinformationtohelpidentifythosepeopleinspecificsectionsofthemusicandentertainmentindustrywhoarelikelytobeatriskfromtheplayingofliveorrecordedmusic.
43 Thefollowing‘listeningchecks’maybeusefulindecidingwhethertherearelikelytobenoiserisks.Asasimpleguideyouwillprobablyneedtodosomethingaboutthenoiseifanyofthefollowingapply:
Soundadvice Page19of144
Health and Safety Executive
n Doestheworkinvolvelengthyexposuretomusiceitherliveorrecorded,forexample,pubs,clubs,livemusicvenues,orchestras,orusingheadphones?
n Isthenoiseintrusive–similartothenoisefromabusystreet–formostoftheworkingday?
n Dopeoplehavetoraisetheirvoicestocarryoutanormalconversationwhenabout2mapartforatleastpartoftheworkingday?
n Arenoisytoolsused,suchasduringrigging,formorethanhalfanhouraday?n Arethereanyloudeffectssuchaspyrotechnicsormaroons?
44 Evenextremelyshortexposuretoveryloudnoiseisdangerous.Somepercussiveorexplosivesoundslastforaveryshorttime,butareatsuchalevelthathearingdamagecanoccur.Exposuretosuchnoisesisuncommoninthenormalenvironment,howeverpyrotechnics,fireworksandevenloudsoundsystemscandeliverpeaknoiselevelsinexcessofthe140dBexposurelimitvaluesetbytheNoiseRegulations.
45 Soundspeakingabove140dBareliabletocauseimmediateandlastingdamageratherthanaccumulatingovertime.Itisthereforecrucialthatathoroughnoise-controlstrategyisinplacebeforeanyexposuretoloudnoisemightoccur.
Who might be harmed, and how?
46 Allemployeeswhoarelikelytobeaffectedbythenoiseshouldbeidentified.Considernotjustpeoplewhoareexposedtonoiseinrelativelyfixedlocations,butalsopeoplewhomovebetweendifferentjobsortypesofwork,andmakesureyouunderstandtheirpatternsofnoiseexposure.Remembertoincludepeoplewhoarenotdirectemployeesbutwhomaybeaffectedbythework,forexamplevisitorsorsubcontractors.
47 Inconsideringthepotentialforpeopletobeharmed,itismainlynecessarytothinkabouthearingdamage.Butitisalsonecessarytoconsiderriskstosafetywhichcanarisefromworkinginanoisyenvironment,suchasnoiseinterferingwithcommunicationsorwarningsignalsandtheabilitytopickupaudiblesignsofdanger.
Estimate the noise exposure
48 Thedailypersonalnoiseexposure(LEP,d)ofworkersatriskshouldbeestimatedandcomparedwiththeexposureactionandlimitvalues.Ittakesaccountofboththelevelofthesoundandhowlongitlasts.Oftenaworker’sdailynoiseexposureismadeupofanumberofperiodsoftimeexposedtodifferentlevelsofnoise,sothisneedstobetakenintoaccountwhenestimatingexposure.
49 Itisessentialthatanyestimateofemployees’exposureisrepresentativeoftheworkthattheydo.Itshouldtakeaccountof:
n theworktheydoorarelikelytodo;n thewaysinwhichtheydothework;n howtheworkmayvaryduringthedayorfromonedaytothenext.
50 Theestimatesofthenoiselevelsmustbereliableenoughtobeabletoassesswhetheranyexposureactionvaluesarelikelytobeexceeded.Reliableinformationmayinclude:
n noisemeasurementsintheactualworksituations;n informationfromothersimilarworksituations;
Soundadvice Page20of144
Health and Safety Executive
n informationfromothersources,forexampleinformationontypicalnoiselevelsandnoiseexposureswhichmaybehelpful.
51 ToolsareavailableontheHSEwebsite(www.hse.gov.uk/noise/calculator.htm)thatallownoiseexposuretobecalculatedbasedoninformationonlikelynoiselevelsanddurationsofexposure.Thereisanoiseready-reckonerchart(alsoseeAppendix4)andanelectronicspreadsheet.
52 Wheninanydoubt,assumethatcontrolmeasuresarenecessaryandthathearingprotectionwillberequireduntilthecontrolmeasuresaresufficienttoreducetheemployees’exposuretobelowtheupperexposureactionvalue.Ifmusicistobeplayed(especiallyloudamplifiedmusic)itwouldbegoodpracticetoassumethereisariskandsomenoisecontrolswillbenecessary.
Weekly exposure
53 Wherenoiseexposurevariesmarkedlyfromdaytoday,theweeklynoiseexposurelevelmaybeusedasanindicatorofrisk.Itisonlylikelytobeappropriatetouseweeklyexposurewhere:
n dailyexposureononeortwoworkingdaysinaweekisatleast5dBhigherthantheotherdays;or
n theworkingweekcomprisesthreeorfewerdaysofexposure.
54 Usingweeklyexposuretoindicateriskshouldnotleadtotheloweringofstandardsofprotectionondayswherenoiseexposureishigher.Workersandtheirsafetyoremployeerepresentativesshouldbeconsultedonwhethertheuseofweeklyexposureisappropriate.
55 ToolsareavailableontheHSEwebsite(www.hse.gov.uk/noise/calculator.htm)thatallowweeklynoiseexposuretobecalculatedbasedoninformationonlevelsofdailynoiseexposure.Thereisanoiseready-reckonerchart(alsoseeAppendix4)andanelectronicspreadsheet.
56 Consultsafetyrepresentativesaboutriskassessmentsalongwithanycontrolmeasures.Wherethereisnoformalrepresentation,employersshouldliaisewiththelocalMusicians’UnionandEquityrepresentativesoremployeerepresentativegroups.Alsotellstaffaboutthesignificantfindingsoftheriskassessment.
Identify what needs to be done to control the risks
57 Anessentialoutcomeofthenoiseriskassessmentistocontroltherisks.Incarryingoutanoiseriskassessmentemployersshould:
n identifywhoisatriskandunderwhatcircumstances,andassesslikelyexposures.Thisallowsprioritisationandplanningofcontrolactions;
n beawareofcurrentgoodpracticeorthestandardfornoiseexposurecontrolwithintherelevantpartofthemusicandentertainmentsector,consideringwhetherthecontrolmeasuresareapplicabletotheirworkandadoptingthemwhereitisreasonablypracticabletodoso;
n considertheadviceonnoise-controlmeasuresforsectionsofthemusicandentertainmentindustryinotherpartsofthisbook;
n recordthesignificantfindingsoftheriskassessment.Recordinanactionplananythingidentifiedasbeingnecessarytocomplywiththelaw;
n prepareanactionplansettingoutwhathasbeendoneandwhatisplanned,withatimetable.Saywhowillberesponsiblefortheworkandhowthisistobecommunicatedtothoseaffected.
Soundadvice Page21of144
Health and Safety Executive
58 Theactionplan,aswellascoveringanywaysoforganisingtheworkortechnicalmeasuresneededtoeliminaterisksfromnoiseorreducenoiseexposure,shouldalsocoverissuessuchas:
n providingpersonalhearingprotectiontoworkerstodealwithimmediateandongoingrisks;
n arrangementsforprovidinginformation,instructionandtraining;andn healthsurveillanceforworkers.
59 Indevelopinganactionplanfornoise,employersshouldconsiderwhatmanagementarrangementsareneededtoensurethatthecontrolmeasuresputinplaceareworkingandbeingfollowedinpractice.Consideralsohowtoadaptormodifythecontrolmeasures,forexamplewhereamusiceventmaybeundertakenindifferentvenues,wheredifferencesareanticipatedbetweenrehearsalandperformance,orwherechangestothelayoutoftheworkingenvironmentarelikelywhichcouldaffecttherisksfromnoiseexposure.
EXAMPLE
If an employee works behind the bar in a noisy nightclub, it is reasonable to assume that exposure will be greater than the upper exposure action value and therefore the necessary control measures should be implemented. It may be sensible to take noise measurements if these are needed to show that the exposure is lower than the upper exposure action value after the measures have been taken or, alternatively, that suitable hearing protection is provided and used.
Regular monitoring
60 Riskassessmentisanongoingprocessandregularchecksareessentialtomakesurethecontrolmeasurescontinuetobeeffective.Thismayalsoidentifyanyfurtheractionsnecessary.Anyincidents,forexamplewhereitisfoundthatcontrolmeasuresareineffectiveornotbeingusedorfollowed,shouldbeinvestigatedtofindoutwhy,andactiontaken.Recordtheresultsofmonitoring.
Reference positions
61 Specificnoisemeasurementsconductedintheworkplacecanhelpidentifythemainsourcesofnoiseandmakeiteasiertoassesswherefurthercontrolsarenecessaryandwhenperiodsofwearingcompulsoryhearingprotectionarerequired.
62 Itmaybehelpfultohaveoneortwosound-levelmetersornoisedosemeterstoestimatenoiseexposures,forexamplewithintheorchestra/bandoronthedancefloor.Itmayalsobeusefultoestablishreferenceposition(s)toenablequickmeasurementstobemadeusingasimplemetertoverifythatsoundlevelsareundercontrol.
63 Thisinformationcanberecordedandcomparedwiththeassessment,andanyrelevantfindingscanbeappliedtofutureassessments.ExamplesoflocationsforreferencepositionsareincludedinSoundAdvice4‘Rockandpop’,SoundAdvice5‘Pubsandclubs’andSoundAdvice6‘Orchestras’.
Review risk assessments
64 Thenoiseriskassessmentshouldbereviewedregularly.Therearevariousreasonswhythisshouldhappen,including:
Soundadvice Page22of144
Health and Safety Executive
n thereisanyreasontothinkthattheriskassessmentdoesnotreflectthecurrentnoiserisks,forexamplechangedworkingmethodsordifferentworkpatternssuchaschangestotheset,designorseatinglayout;
n healthsurveillanceshowsthatworkers’hearingisbeingdamaged;n controlmeasuresthatcouldnotbejustifiedwhenoriginallyconsidered(for
example,oncostorpracticabilitygrounds)becomereasonablypracticableduetosomechangedcircumstances.
65 Evenifitappearsthatnothinghaschanged,theriskassessmentshouldnotbeleftformorethanabouttwoyearswithoutcheckingwhetherareviewisneeded.
66 Aflowchartsummarisingtheprocessofnoiseriskassessmentisshownattheendofthe‘Noiseriskassessmentandplanning’section.
Planning
67 Everyeventneedstobeproperlyplanned,toensurethathealthandsafetyrequirementsarefullyconsidered.Thedegreeofplanningwillvaryaccordingtothecomplexityoftheeventbuteveryeventwillbenefit,whetheritisapopconcert,agiginapub,anorchestralconcertoraclubwithaguestDJ.Largervenuesmayhaveaspecificpolicystatementwhichmayhelpwithplanning(seeSoundAdvice2‘Venues’).
68 Starttoassessthelikelynoiselevelsassoonaspossibletoidentifyanypotentialnoiserisks.Thisisbestdonewellbeforeanymusicisplayedinrehearsalorperformance.Theemployer,ortheprincipalemployer,forexamplethepromoterorpublandlord,shoulddecidewhethertheproposedeventmightleadtohighnoiseexposurelevelsforthoseworkingthereandwhatcontrolsmightbenecessary.Theyshouldrecordandretaintheseresultsaspartoftheirnoiseriskassessment.
69 Whereappropriateconsider:
n thenatureoftheeventandmusic;n thesite/venuelayout;n thelikelynoisefootprint/map(theareacoveredbythesound);n wheretheremaybeariskfromnoiseandwhowillbeaffected;n expectedsoundlevelsandexpecteddurations;n selectionofloudspeakertypesandotherequipment;n suitablecontrolmeasuresavailablefornoisehazards;n theneedtoallowforsufficientrehearsaltimetoidentifyandcontrolany
unforeseenrisksbeforeharmiscaused.
Communications
70 Goodcommunicationsareessentialforgoodplanning.Theassessmentprocessshouldinvolvetheexchangeofinformationbetweenpeoplewhomaybeaffectedbytheevent,forexample,promoters,venueoperators,contractors,localauthoritiesandrecordingcompanies.Thisshouldstartattheearliestopportunityandcontinue.Inthecaseof‘rockandpop’acts,whereverpossibletheperformersshouldbeinvolvedintheplanningprocessandbecomeanintegralpartofthenoisemanagementplan.
71 Eventorganisersshouldensurethateverybodyinvolvedinplanninganeventiscompetentandcapableofcarryingouttheirduties.Theremaybeaneedtoprovidespecifictrainingfortechniciansandmanagers.
Soundadvice Page23of144
Health and Safety Executive
EXAMPLE
Sound levels too highIndividual musicians asking for higher and higher levels from their personal instrument amplifiers or monitors can cause problems. It has been known for audience members to complain that they could only hear one particular instrument during a show. This is not the fault of the sound engineer but the result of lack of communication with musicians.
In the case of one famous band, the guitarist left the group, in part due to hearing damage from ever-increasing sound levels. If stage sound levels are too high this can result in reduced enjoyment for the audience and cause serious hearing damage to performers, which could be prevented by proper communication and planning before the event.
Recovery periods
72 Whenplanningevents,allowtimeforaperson’searstorecoverfromexposuretoloudnoise.Thetimerequiredtorecoverfullyfromthetemporaryeffectsofnoiseisrelatedtothelevelofnoiseandthedurationofexposure.Musicianswhohaveplayedataneveningperformanceneedrecoverytimebeforerehearsingthefollowingmorning.Asapracticalrulehigherlevelsofnoiseduringtherestperiodmayimpedetherecoveryofhearingandmightleadtopermanentdamage.
Multiple employers
73 Wherethereareseveralemployers,alltheemployersinvolvedshouldagreeattheearliestpossibleopportunitywhichemployeristoco-ordinatethemeasuresnecessarytocomplywiththeNoiseRegulations.(Thiswillusuallybetheemployerresponsibleforco-ordinatingotherhealthandsafetyresponsibilitiesandisusuallythepersoninoverallcontrolofthework.)Thispersonshouldmakesurethattheresponsibilitiesforcontrollingrisksareclearlydefined.Wherecontractorsandsubcontractorsareinvolveditisusuallybestforresponsibilitiestobesetoutinthecontractualarrangements(seeAppendix3).
74 Wherethereisanestablishedsafetycommitteetheyshouldbeconsultedonhowbesttodevelopthemanagementandmonitoringofnoiseexposure.Employersmaywishtoconsiderothermethodsthathavebeenadoptedsuchasnoisecommittees.Specificinputmightcomefrompeoplesuchasresponsiblemanagers,players,conductors,safetyandoccupationalhealthandsafetyadvisers,andrepresentativesfromfrequentlyvisitedvenues.Whereamplifiedsoundisused,peoplesuchassounddesigners,soundengineers,soundcontractorsandproductionmanagersshouldalsobeinvolved.
75 Anygroup,oritsmembers,shouldhaveenoughauthoritytoimplementthenecessarycontrolsorprotectivemeasures,includinglong-rangeplanningandvenuealterationsetc.Agroupwillprobablyoperateindifferentformationsfordifferentpurposes–forexample,thegroupingneededtoconsiderthenoiseimplicationsoflong-rangeplanningdecisionsmaydifferfromthatfinishingthearrangementsforthatnight’sconcert.
Policy statements
76 Awrittenstatementofvenuepolicyisagoodwayofcommunicatingcontrolstothoseworkinginorusingthevenue.Thepolicymayinclude:
Soundadvice Page24of144
Health and Safety Executive
n Communicationoftherisktohearingfromthenoise.n Themechanismforthenoiseriskassessment,whichmayincludenoise
measurements.n Adescriptionofthemeasuresestablishedtocontroltherisk.Forexamplethe
specificationofmaximumpermissiblenoiselevelsthroughphysicalregulationofthevolumeorbymeansofautomaticnoiselimiters(see‘Noise-controlmeasuresandtraining’).
n Hearingprotectionpolicy–thespecificationofsuitablehearingprotectorsandwheretheyareavailable(see‘Personalhearingprotection’).
n Proceduresformonitoringandreview.
Touring
77 Pre-planningisespeciallyimportantwhentakingaproductionorbandontour:
n Carryoutagenericassessmentoflikelynoiserisksandwhowillbeexposedbeforethestartofthetourandidentifycontrols.Reviewthisassessmentateachvenuetoensurethecontrolsarestillsuitable.
n Reviewtheseriskassessmentswhencircumstanceschange.Forexample,themaximumpermittednumberofplayersineachorchestrapitmightvaryindifferenttheatresandthismayaffectnoiseexposure.
n Venuemanagers,tourmanagersandothersinvolvedshouldsharetheirriskassessmentstoidentifythemostsuitablecontrolsfortheeventorperformance.
n Controlmeasuresidentifiedbeforetouringshouldbereviewedonsite(ateachtouringlocation)toensuretheyareadequate.
Working elsewhere in the EU78 TheEuropeanDirectiveonwhichtheNoiseRegulationsarebased(Directive2003/10/EC)setsdownminimumstandardsforthecontrolofnoiseatworkthroughouttheEuropeanUnion.IndividualEUcountriesmayhaveadditionalrequirements.
Working outside the EU79OutsidetheEU,localrequirementsmightnotcorrespondtoEUrequirements.ThoseworkingoutsidetheEUarerecommendedtoclarifytheposition.ThoseemployedintheUKwhoaretouringareadvised,wherenecessary,tonegotiateforthemaintenanceofhealthandsafetystandardsequivalenttothoseoftheEUtobeincludedintheircontractsofemployment.ForthoseemployedoutsidetheEUitisadvisabletoclarifythehealthandsafetystandardsthatwillapplyandseektogetthesafeguardsrequiredtoprotecttheirhearing.
Soundadvice Page25of144
Health and Safety Executive
EXAMPLES
Multiple employers involved in a musical production More than one employer is usually involved when a musical production is staged in a theatre. The theatre operator and the producer are usually the main employers with their representatives having designated responsibilities under the Noise Regulations. Depending upon the noise risk assessment, those at risk could include the performers (both the musicians in the orchestra pit and the artists on stage) and the production team (employed by, or freelancers working for, the producer), all the backstage workers/on-stage technicians (who might be employed by either the producer or the theatre operator or could be freelancers) as well as the theatre operator’s front-of-house staff in the auditorium.
The representatives of the main employers will establish, often by means of contract (see Appendix 3), who will be the co-ordinating employer with first responsibility for initiating the noise risk assessment and implementing the control measures. The producer is responsible for the music and will usually initiate this assessment.
It is important that any control measures and any hearing protection requirement resulting from the noise risk assessment include all those at risk. The sound designer and the musical director (both engaged by the producer) will usually co-ordinate any control measures required by the noise risk assessment in consultation with the theatre operator if necessary. Any necessary hearing protection will generally be provided by the respective employers.
Multiple employers involved in planning a pub event The manager of a public house has engaged a five-piece group, using the services of the fixer, to play in his bar. The responsibility for the Noise Regulations involves both the pub manager and the manager or leader of the group; it may also involve the fixer. The prime responsibility rests with the pub manager who should liaise with the band to ensure that risks to people at work are controlled; no one – bar staff, musicians or security staff – should be exposed to excessive noise. The pub manager should undertake an assessment of the noise risk and may need to ensure that action is taken to reduce the hazard.
Soundadvice Page26of144
Health and Safety Executive
CASE STUDY Pre-event noise risk assessment
Name of event: The Big Festival Date of assessment: 11 July 2008 Assessment completed by: Anne Onymouse
What are the noise sources?
n StagePAsystems.n Instrumentsandbackline.n Traders’soundsystems.
Are there sources of noise which are likely to result in personal exposures above the lower exposure action value?
Yesq3 Noq
What area(s) may be affected at this level?
n Thestageplatform(includingsidewings).n Thestagepitarea.n Concessionandotherstandswithinthemainarena.n Medicalandwelfaretentbysideofstage.n Backstagebar/hospitalityfacilities.
Action to be taken to protect staff in these noisy areas
1 Thestageplatform(includingsidewings):
n Areatobeclearlysignedasahearingprotectionzone(sometimesreferredtoasHPZ)*wherehearingprotectionismandatory.
n OperatingtimesofthePAsystemtobecloselymanagedbyStageManagerandPAcontractor.
n Advancediscussionstobeconductedwithbandstominimisebacklinenoise/promoteuseofin-earmonitoring.
n Disposablehearingprotectiontobeavailableatentrypointstostage.n StageManagertomonitorandenforceuseofhearingprotectiononstage.
2 Thestagepitarea:
n Stagepittobesignedasamandatoryhearingprotectionzone.n Allpitstafftobeadvisedinadvanceofshowoftheneedtowearappropriate
hearingprotectionduringtheirshift.n Disposablehearingprotectorstobeavailableonbothsidesofentrytopit.n Pitsecurityteamtobebriefedtorefuseentrytoanyonenotwearinghearing
protection(photographers,guestsetc).n Securitycontractortoensurestaffarerotatedtoquietareasduringtheirshift
period.n Securitysupervisortomonitorandenforcewearingofhearingprotection.
3 Concessionandotherstandswithinthemainarena:
n Sitetobesetouttoavoidstallsandotherinfrastructureindirectlineofspeakers.
n Wherepossibleelevatespeakersusingflownsystems.*Onlystrictlyrequiredatorabovetheupperexposureactionvalue.
Soundadvice Page27of144
Health and Safety Executive
n Informallstall/concessionholdersofthelikelyexposuretoloudnoiseandtheneedtoensuretheirstaffarebriefedandhaveaccesstoappropriatehearingprotection.
4 Medicalandwelfaretentbysideofstage:
n Positionmedicalandwelfarefacilitiesasfarasreasonablypracticablefromspeakers.
n Makehearingprotectionavailabletoallmedicalandwelfarestaff.n Requestmedicalandwelfareproviderstomakearrangementstorotatestaff
toquietdutiesduringtheirshift.
5 Backstagebar/hospitalityfacilities:
n Locatethebarasfaraspracticablefromthestage.n LimitthehoursofoperationofthebarPAsystem.n ReducethelevelofPAsystemsinthebarandhospitalityareas.n Contactthebarmanagertoensurebarstaffarebriefedontherisksof
workinginanoisyarea.n Ensurethebarcontractormakesappropriatehearingprotectionavailableto
theirownstaff.
Noise monitoring plan
n Integratingsound-levelmetertoberentedandarangeof15-minuteLAeqsamplestobetakenbytheEventSafetyOfficerduringtheweekendtoestablishthegeographiclimitsofnoisyareas.
n DosemetertobewornbyStageManagertogetsampleon-stageexposurelevels.
n Localauthoritywillbeonsitetoconductfront-of-housenoisesamplingtoassesscompliancewithLicenceconditions.
Additional considerations
n Reviewofnoisyareasandthetypeofhearingprotectionprovidedtobeconductedoncemeasurementsaretakenduringtheevent.Thesemeasurementswillalsoinformthoseinvolvedaboutpossiblemeasuresforfutureevents.
n ContinueadvancediscussionswithPAsuppliertoidentifymeansofreducingon-stagenoiseandspillintobackstage/medical/welfareareas.
Soundadvice Page28of144
Health and Safety Executive
YES
NOT SURENO/
NOT SURENO/
Is thepersonal noise
dose likely to be belowthe lower exposure action
values for everyoneinvolved?
YES
Is thepersonal noise
dose below the upperexposure action values
for everyoneinvolved?
Is thepersonal noise
dose likely to be belowthe lower exposure action
values for everyoneinvolved?
Obtain a reliable estimate of noise exposure. Implement necessary control measures.Assess noise exposure. NB Hearing protection is NOT a control measure.
Review noise risk assessment before each major change ofprogramme/repertoire/venue and at least every 2 years.
Implement any previouslyrequired control measures.
START
NO
YES
NO
YES
NO NO YES
Will thepersonal noise
dose be below theupper exposure action
values for everyoneinvolved?
Will thepersonal noise
dose be below thelower exposure action
values for everyoneinvolved?
Will thepersonal noise
dose be below theexposure limit values
for everyoneinvolved?
Immediately reduce noiseexposure and/or provide
sufficient hearing protection.
Establish and instigate action plan. Implement control measures.
YES
Implement health surveillance for any employees susceptibleto noise. Make hearing protection available.
Implement health surveillance.Provide hearing protection and ensure it is worn.
Establish maintenance programme for hearing protectionand other noise-reduction equipment. Provide training.
Record the noise risk assessment.
NO
Assess the effectiveness of any control measures.Monitor noise levels, if required.
Try a simple listening check.
NOT SURENO/
Has anoise risk
assessment beencarried out and is it
still valid?
YES
Record significantfindings and actions atevery stage
Figure 3 Thegenericprocessofnoiseriskassessment
Soundadvice Page29of144
Health and Safety Executive
Noise-control measures and trainingOverview ControllingnoiseriskandnoiseexposureControlmeasuresProvideinformation,instructionandtrainingonnoise
Controlling noise risk and noise exposure80 Whereverthereisnoiseexposureatworkemployersshouldbelookingforwaysofworkingthatwouldreducethenoiseormeanthatpeopleareexposedforshortertimes.Employersshouldalsobekeepingupwithwhatisgoodpracticefornoisecontrolwithintheirsector.
81 Wheretherearethingsthatcanbedonetoreducerisksfromnoise,whicharereasonablypracticable,theyshouldbedone.Wheretheriskassessmentshowsthatemployeesorsubcontractorsarelikelytobeexposedatorabovetheupperexposureactionvalues,theemployermustputinplaceaplannedprogrammeofnoisecontrol.Theriskassessmentshouldhaveproducedinformationontherisksandanactionplanforcontrollingnoise.
82 Therearemanywaysofreducingnoiseandnoiseexposure,however,itisimportanttotacklethedominantorloudestnoisesourcesfirst.Pickthemostappropriatesolutionstoresolvetheparticularproblemsofthespecificevent.
83 Collectiveprotectivemeasuresshouldalwaysbeusedinpreferencetoindividualprotectivemeasures.Theapproachforthecontrolofnoiseshouldbe,inorderofpreference,to:
n eliminatethehazardorriskaltogether(ifitisreasonablypracticabletodothis,itshouldbedone);
n controltheriskatsource(forexamplereducethevolume,substitutequietersources);
n reducethenoiseasittravelstothepeopleexposed(forexamplephysicalbarriers,distance,absorptivematerials);
n reduceexposure(forexamplebyorganisingtheworktoreducethedurationofexposureorthenumberofpeopleexposedtonoise).
84 Ifthesemeasuresarenotadequatetoreducetheexposureenough,thenhearingprotectionmustbeprovided(see‘Personalhearingprotection’).
85 Controlmeasuresshouldbeaccompaniedby:
n provisionofinformation,instructionandtraining;n properandregularmaintenanceofequipment.
86 Noisemeasurementsmaybenecessarytoestablishtheeffectivenessofanycontrolmeasures.
Soundadvice Page30of144
Health and Safety Executive
Control measures
87 Anyimmediaterisksshouldbetackledimmediately–thiswillincludeprovidinghearingprotectionasaninterimmeasurewhilemorepermanentnoise-controlsolutionsareputinplace.Thisincludesanynoisehazardsthatareliabletocauseimmediateandlastingdamageratherthanaccumulatingovertime,forexamplepyrotechnics,fireworksandevenloudsoundsystems.Forthesetypesofpotentialhazardsitiscrucialtoensurethatathoroughnoise-controlstrategyisinplacebeforethereisanyfurtherexposure.
88 Whenexaminingpossiblemeasures,consider,forexample,thetypesofinstrumentsbeingplayed,thenumberandpositionsofperformers,whetheramplificationisbeingused,theacousticofthevenueandthenoiseassociatedwithstuntsandeffects.Theremayalsobeotherworkplacenoisesuchasconstructionnoise,powertools,PAnoiseandnoisecreatedbythepublic.
89 Somemeasuresmaynotbefeasible.Othersmayproveineffectiveinreducingnoiseexposurelevelsontheirown.Oftenacombinationofmeasuresmayhavetobetried,aseachmeasuremayitselfhaveimplicationsforothersinavarietyofways.Arangeofappropriatesolutionsforaparticulartypeofperformanceorsourceofsoundwithinthespecificvenueshouldbeidentified.Thoseinvolvedshouldbeencouragedtosuggestideasfornoisecontrolandnoisereduction,whichcanbetriedoutandadoptedwhenappropriate.
90 Somenoise-reductionmeasurestakesometimetogetusedto,forexamplebrassinanorchestraraisedontorostra/risersmaynothavetoplaysoloudly(seeAppendix6‘Risers’).
91 Whenselectingnoise-controlmeasures,alwaysconsiderwhetherthemeasureconcernedmightcreateotherhealthandsafetyissuesorunwantedsideeffects.Twoexamplesfromlivemusicaretheuseofhighrisers,whichmayhavefallimplications(seetheWorkatHeightRegulations20055),andincorrectlypositionedpersonalacousticscreens,whichcancauseproblemsfortheplayerandotherplayers.
92 Thenoise-controlmeasuresshouldbereviewedtoensuretheyareproperlyappliedandeffective.Anydifficultiesshouldbeinvestigatedandthefindingsfedbackintotherisk-assessmentprocess.
93 Thefollowingparagraphsprovidegeneraladviceonnoise-controlmeasures.Formorespecificadviceseethemoredetailedrecommendationsforeachsector.
Eliminate the hazard94Whereverpracticabledonotgeneratehazardouslevelsofsoundinthefirstplace.Thinkofwaysofeliminatingunnecessaryexposuresuchasavoidingnoisyactivities,forexample,soundsystemcheckingwhileriggersandothersareworkingadjacenttoloudspeakers.Alsotailortheprogrammetothevenueandavoidreverberantorunsuitablespaces.
Soundadvice Page31of144
Health and Safety Executive
Control the risk at source 95 Considerhowthenoiselevelcanbereduced,forexamplebyreducingthesoundoutputfromindividualinstrumentssuchasdampingdrumsorclosingpianolids,leadingtoanoverallreductioninvolume.Fold-backlevelsonthestageshouldbereducedtotheminimumlevelatwhichitispossibletowork.Noisecanalsobecontrolledbythecarefuldesignofthepremises,forexamplebyusingacousticabsorptionpanels.Addinganacousticceiling,acousticwallliningsorcarpetingmayincreaseacousticabsorption.
96 Sound-leveladjustmentscanbemorereadilycarriedoutwhereamplificationisusedanditissimpleandhighlyeffectivetoturnamplifiedsounddown.However,itisessentialtomonitorsoundlevelstoensuretheyarenotincreasedagainaboveacceptablelevels.Acontrolmechanismwithinthesoundsystemmayhelp,byprovidingawarning(orlimiting)whenapresetsoundlevelisreached.
Separate people from the hazard 97 Itissometimespossibletoseparatepeoplefromthehazardbyphysicallyisolatingthenoisesource,forexamplebyusingboothsfornoisyinstrumentsinrecordingstudiosorincreasingthedistancebetweenfront-of-houseworkersnotonstageandthestageareaandloudspeakers.
Reduce exposure time and the number of people exposed 98 Ifpeople,suchaspitcrewsandmonitorengineers,havetoworkinverynoisyenvironments,takemeasurestoreducethedurationofexposure.Thiscouldincludeshorteningsoundandsystemchecksandrotatingstaffbetweennoisyandquieterduties.Foranindividualconcertthismaynotbepracticalforaspecialistsuchasamonitorengineer,butinthecontextofreducinganoverallweeklyexposurelevel,taskvariationmaybeuseful.Showdaysmightbebalancedwithoffice/warehouseworktoachieveaminimisedweeklyexposurelevel.
Provide information, instruction and training on noise
99 Awarenessofnoiserisksandcontrolsisveryimportant,aspeoplewillthentakenoticeoftherisksanduseanyrisk-reductionmeasuresproperly.Peopleintheindustryhavetobemadeawareofthepotentialforpermanenthearingdamageassociatedwithworkinginaverynoisyenvironment.Thismayrequireaconsiderableshiftinpersonalattitudeandcollectiveculture.
100Understandingtherisksfromhighsoundlevelsshouldformpartofthebasiceducationofperformersandtechnicians,sopeoplecomingintotheindustryknowhowtoprotectthemselvesandbecomepartofthesolutionratherthantheproblem.Informationandinstructionshouldalsoincludepostingwarningnoticesarounddesignatedhearingprotectionzonesandbriefingstoperformersandotherworkersaboutthenoise-reductionstrategiesadoptedforanevent.
101Employersshouldtrytoensurethatemployeesunderstandtheneedtofollowtheemployer’sorvenueoperator’sinstructionsoncontrolmeasuresincluding,forexample,abidingbyanyagreedarrangementsforjobrotationorrestrictionofaccesstonoisyareasorfollowinganyinstructionsrelatingtoachievingagreednoiselevels,aswellaswearinghearingprotectionwhenrequired.Employeesshouldbeencouragedtoreporttotheiremployeranynewhazardousnoisesituationsorhearinglossortinnitus.
Soundadvice Page32of144
Health and Safety Executive
102Itisalsowortheducatingemployeesonthegeneralrisksofnoisefromothernon-workactivitieswhichstillcontributetoexposure.Forexample,thenoiselevelwithinthein-earheadphonesofmusicplayerssuchasMP3playerscanbe94dBataroundhalfvolume(withpeaksof110–130dependingonheadphones)and105dBatfullvolume(peaks110–142).
Role of management
103Theroleofmiddlemanagementandsupervisorsindevelopingandapplyingasuccessfulnoisepolicyisimportant.Theirtrainingandinstructionisahighpriorityandshouldinclude:
n trainingtothelevelrequiredfortheirresponsibilities;n havingthoseresponsibilitiesclearlysetoutandknowingtheresponsibilitiesof
othermanagers/supervisors;n understandingthehealthandsafetypolicyoftheiremployer;n understandingtheimportanceofprovidingasafeenvironmentforworkers.
104Employersshouldalsoconveytheirfindingstotheiremployees,forexamplebydisplayingtheoutcomesofriskassessmentsbyprogramme,sessionordayonaprominentnoticeboard,orbymakingthisinformationavailablewhenconfirmingrehearsalandperformancescheduleswithplayers.Findingsshouldalsobeprovidedtosafetyrepresentativesandotheremployeerepresentatives.
105Employersshouldensuretheiremployeesandotherworkersorself-employedpeopleaffectedbytheworkactivityunderstandthenoiseriskstowhichtheymaybeexposed.Employersshouldatleasttellthem:
n thelikelynoiseexposuresandtherisktohearingthiscreates;n whatisbeingdonetocontrolrisksandexposures;n whereandhowpeoplecanobtainhearingprotectionifthisisneeded;n howtoreportdefectsinhearingprotectionandnoise-controlequipment;n whattheirdutiesareundertheNoiseRegulations;n whattheyshouldbedoingtominimisetherisk,suchastheproperwaytouse
hearingprotectionandothernoise-controlequipment,howtolookafteritandstoreitandwheretouseit;
n whathealthsurveillanceisprovidedifthisisappropriate.
106Makesureinformationisprovidedinawaythatcanbeunderstoodand,ifnecessary,makespecialarrangementsforworkerswhodonotunderstandEnglishorcannotread.
Freelancers and self-employed people 107Whereamanagementororchestraregularlyengagesthesamefreelancers,theyshouldbeconsideredasbeingemployedandprovidedwithtrainingoncontrolmeasures(includingtheuseofscreensandpersonalhearingprotection)aswellasregularhealthsurveillance.
Training courses 108TradeUnions,tradeassociationsandotherprofessionalbodiesmaybeabletoadviseorhelpidentifysuitabletrainingcourseswheretheseareneeded.
Soundadvice Page33of144
Health and Safety Executive
Personal hearing protection Overview
RequirementsforhearingprotectionWhenshouldhearingprotectionbeused?MakinghearingprotectioneffectiveHowmuchprotection?ManaginghearingprotectionSelectinghearingprotectionEarplugsEarmuffsTrainingandeffectiveuse
Requirements for hearing protection109ForadevicetobecategorisedaspersonalhearingprotectionitmustbeCE-markedshowingitmeetstherelevantpartsofEuropeanStandardBSEN352.6Thesesetcriteriaforarangeofqualityandsafetyaspects,suchascomfort,ergonomics,provisionofinformation,factorsrelatedtoageing,qualityofproduction,aswellasthelevelofsoundreduction.EmployersshouldsatisfythemselvesthatanydevicessuppliedtoworkersaspersonalhearingprotectionareCE-markedandmeettherequirementsoftherelevantpartofBSEN352.
Note about IEMs and headphone monitors
In-ear monitors and headphone monitors do not generally meet the necessary criteria to be categorised as personal hearing protection devices, although some workers in the music and entertainment sector may wrongly consider them to be. However, IEMs and headphone monitors have a valuable role in reducing the risk of hearing damage as they allow a reduced level of reproduced sound on stages and in other work areas. The use of IEMs and headphone monitors is covered in Appendix 8 and Appendix 9 of this book.
When should hearing protection be used?110Personalhearingprotectionshouldbeusedwhereextraprotectionisneededabovewhatcanbeachievedusingnoisecontrol,andasashort-termmeasurewhileother,morepermanentsolutions,technical,engineeringororganisational,arebeingsought.Personalhearingprotectionshouldnotbeusedasanalternativetocontrollingnoisebytechnicalandorganisationalmeans.
111TheNoiseRegulationsmaketheuseofpersonalhearingprotectioncompulsoryforemployeeswhoseexposuretonoiseislikelytoreacheitheroftheupperexposureactionvaluesandforanyemployeesworkingwithindesignatedareas(hearingprotectionzones).Wheretheexposuretonoiseislikelytoreacheitherofthelowerexposureactionvaluesbutbebelowtheupperexposureactionvalues,theemployermustprovidepersonalhearingprotectiontoanyworkerwhorequestsit.
112Theuseofhearingprotectionshouldnotbemadecompulsorywherethelawdoesn’trequireit.Itisbadpracticetohavea‘blanket’approachtohearingprotection;itisbettertotargetitsuseandencouragepeopletowearitonlywhentheyneedto.
Soundadvice Page34of144
Health and Safety Executive
Making hearing protection effective113Tobeofvalue,hearingprotectionneedsto:
n controltherisk.Chooseprotectorswhichwillresultinaneffectivepersonalnoiseexposurebelow85dB,andreducepeaknoisetobelow137dB.Themoreprotectionthebetter,butbewareofover-protection;
n notover-protect.Cuttingouttoomuchnoisecancauseisolation,orleadtoanunwillingnesstoweartheprotectors.Musiciansmaycompensatebyactuallyplayingmoreloudlyandincreasetheirriskofplayinginjuries;
n reducethenoiseleveltonolessthanabout70dB;n becomfortableandsuitablefortheworkingenvironment.Considerhow
comfortableandhygienictheprotectorsare,whethertheywillbewornwithanyotherprotectiveequipment,andhowtheactivityoftheusercanbeaccommodated;
n beproperlyused;n bewornattherighttime–wheneverthereisanoisehazardpresent.Workers
needtobetoldwhenandwheretowearhearingprotection;n bereadilyavailabletoallwhoneeditandactivelysuppliedbytheemployer;n beproperlymaintained,ingood,cleanandundamagedcondition.
114Peopleusingpersonalhearingprotectionshouldatalltimesbeabletohearanysafetyalarmsandwarningsignalssuchasfirealarms,evacuationalerts,reversingvehicles,stageannouncementsconcerningstrobeeffectsetc.Whereanydoubtexistsabouttheabilityofaworkertohearsuchwarnings,alternativemeansofcommunicationmustbeprovided,forexamplevisiblelightsorothermethodssuchasvibratingpads.How much protection?
115Employersshouldprovideprotectionthatatleastreducesthenoiseexposuretobelow85dB.Avoidprotectorsthatreducethelevelattheeartobelow70dB.Employersmustprovideprotectionagainstimpulsivenoise,suchasgunfireorpyrotechniceffects,sufficienttoreducetheC-weightedpeaksoundpressurelevelattheeartobelowtheupperexposureactionvalueof137dB.
116Forworkerswithvariableexposures,employersshouldensurethattheiremployeeshaveprotectorsadequatefortheworstsituationlikelytobeencountered,andthattheyknowwhenandwheretousethem.Itmightbethatusingmorethanonetypeofhearingprotectorisanappropriatesolutionforpeoplewhoseworkvariessignificantlyduringthedayorfromdaytoday.
117Table2givesanindicationofthedegreeofprotectionthatislikelytobesuitablefordifferentlevelsofnoise.Itisbasedonthesinglenumberrating(SNR)valueprovidedwithahearingprotector.Thisinformationisintendedasaguide,andwillnotbeappropriateifthereissignificantlow-frequencynoise.
Table 2Selectinghearingprotection
Noise level in dB Select a protector with an SNR of:
85–90 20orless
90–95 20–30
95–100 25–35
100–105 30ormore
Soundadvice Page35of144
Health and Safety Executive
118Othermethodsofestimatingtheperformanceofhearingprotection,forusewheremoredetailedinformationonthecharacterofthenoiseisavailable,aredescribedinPart5ofL108.AhearingprotectionspreadsheetisavailableontheHSEnoisewebpages(www.hse.gov.uk/noise).
119Itisimportanttousetherighttypeofhearingprotectorandtouseitwheneverhearingprotectionisrequired.Itisalsoimportanttorealisehowrapidlytheupperactionvaluecanbeexceededandhowhearingcanbedamagedinanoisyenvironment.
Managing hearing protection
120Trainingshouldpromotetheuseofhearingprotectionifitisrequiredandmanagementshouldensureitisproperlyused.Hearingprotectorswillonlyprovidegoodprotectionwhenusedproperly–simplyhandingthemoutisnotacceptable.Considerimplementingasystematicprogrammeto:
n includetheneedtowearhearingprotectioninthesafetypolicy;n ensurethereareadequatefacilitiesformaintenanceandstorageofhearing
protectors;n putsomeoneinauthorityinoverallchargeofissuinghearingprotectorsand
makingsurereplacementsarereadilyavailable;n carryoutspotcheckstoseethattherulesarebeingfollowedandthathearing
protectionisbeingusedproperly;n ensureeveryone,includingmanagersandsupervisors,setsagoodexample
andwearshearingprotectionatalltimeswheninhearingprotectionzones;n distributeHSE’scardProtect your hearing or lose it!7toremindpeopletowear
theirhearingprotection.
Selecting hearing protection
121Hearingprotectionfallsintotwobroadcategories:earplugsandearmuffs.Withregardtotheparticularneedsofworkersinmusicandentertainment,thereisagreatervarietyofproductswithintheearplugscategory.
122Manyworkersinmusicandentertainment,suchasmusicians,performersandsoundengineers,needtohearsoundswithaslittledistortionorcolourationaspossible,especiallyinthehigherfrequencies.Thiscancauseproblemswhenusingpersonalhearingprotection,asconventionalhearingprotectorstendtoreducehigherfrequenciesmorethanlowerfrequencies.Forexample,acompressiblefoamplugthatreducessoundsinthe125Hzrangeby25dBmayreducesoundsinthe4000Hzrangebyalmost40dB.
123Fortunately,hearingprotectiontechnologyhasdevelopedtothepointwherespecialisedproductscanreducesoundlevelsalmostequallyacrossabroadrangeoffrequencies.Thismeansthattheuserperceivesthesoundasbeingfarmorenaturalandpositivethanwithordinaryearplugs.Theseproductsareusuallycalled‘flat’or‘uniform’attenuationhearingprotectors.Theycomeinbothearplugandearmufftypes.Theseprotectorshavebeenfoundhelpfulwherethereisaparticularneedforverbalcommunication,suchasforbarstaff.
124Whenthereisnoconcernaboutsoundquality,hearingprotectioncangenerallybebothsimpleandinexpensive,andwheretheappearanceofhearingprotectionislessimportant,thereisawiderchoice.
Soundadvice Page36of144
Health and Safety Executive
Acclimatising
All hearing protection alters the listening experience, and it can take a long time to get used to it. The acclimatisation process should be managed – if not, people will give up and their hearing will become increasingly damaged. Avoid wearing hearing protection for the first time in a performance.
A typical sequence for a musician acclimatising to earplugs might be:
n Wear them at home and get used to speaking while wearing them. n Wear them around and about and get used to conversation.n Wear them while practising. n Wear them at rehearsal.n Wear them in performance.
With enough time to acclimatise to using the right hearing protection, communication with other people should not be a major problem.
Consultation125Theselectionprocessshouldtakeaccountofconsultationwithemployeesortheirrepresentatives.
Medical disorders 126Beforeselectinghearingprotection,findoutwhethertheuserhasanymedicaldisordersuchasearacheandirritationoftheearcanalthatcouldinfluencetheselection.Whereemployeeshaveanysuchdisorders,employersshouldseekmedicaladviceastothesuitabilityofhearingprotection.
Wind and brass players127Whenblowingtheirinstruments,windandbrassplayersexperiencetheirownsoundaurally,butalsoviatheskull-bonesconductingthevibrationsfromtheinstrumenttotheears,astheyplay.Usingearplugscanaffectthisbalanceasthemusician’searhearslesstreblesoundwhileexperiencingmorebasssoundviaboneconduction.Thebass-trebledistortioncanbeextreme.Thiswillbestrangefortheplayer,cantakesometimetogetusedtoandwillvaryfromoneindividualtoanother.
128Ordinarycompressibleearplugsaregenerallyunsuitableforplayersofreededwoodwindandbrassinstrumentsbecauseoftheocclusioneffect(singersalsofindcompressibleearplugsmakethevoicesoundstrange).Therearetwowaysofdealingwiththeocclusioneffect:
n usedeep-fittingcustom-mouldedearplugswhichreachintotheinnerbonyportionoftheearcanalandsoreducepotentialvibrationandjawresonance;or
n useearplugswithventsthatallowthetrappedlow-frequencysoundtoescape.
129Thereisamisconceptionamongsomewoodwindandbrassplayersthatitisnotpossibletowearearplugsduetothebuild-upofpressureintheearandtheriskoffurtherdamagetotheearcanal.Thishasnobasisinfact.Withthecorrectearplugs,withpatienceandsufficientacclimatisation,brassandwoodwindplayerswillfindtheyareabletowearappropriateearplugsandhavenoneedtoworrythattheywillsufferfurtherdamagetotheirears.
Soundadvice Page37of144
Health and Safety Executive
Large dynamic range and impulsive sounds 130Somesourcesofnoiseinthemusicandentertainmentsectorhavealargedynamicrange(suchasbrass,percussionandmuchwoodwind)orcanbehighlyimpulsive(suchasfirearmsorpyrotechnics).Inthesesituations‘amplitude-sensitive’or‘level-dependent’hearingprotectioncouldbesuitable.Theseusemechanicalorelectronicmechanismstoallowlower-levelsoundstopassrelativelyunhindered,but‘clip’veryhigh-energynoise.Thetypewithmechanicalmechanismsoftenusetheacousticpropertiesofcarefullydesignedairductstogivedifferentprotectionatdifferentnoiselevels.Amplitude-sensitivehearingprotectorscomeinearplugandearmufftypes.
Soundadvice Page38of144
Health and Safety Executive
Table 3 Typicalproblemsandselectingsuitablehearingprotectionforliveperformers
Situation Typical problems Possible protection
Amplified instruments or sound systems
Oftenover-loud. n Uniformattenuationearplugs.(Note:usingin-earmonitorsmayremovetheneedfor,orallowreducedlevelsof,reproducedsoundinworkingareas.)
Singers Ownvoicemaybeover-loud.
Otherinstrumentsmakemonitoringvoicedifficult.
Solo:n Vented/tunedearplugs.
Accompanied:n Uniformattenuationearplugs.
Reeded woodwinds Proximitytobrassorpercussionsections.
Jawresonance(occlusioneffect)makesitdifficulttomonitorinstrumentwhileusingconventionalearplugs.
Neartrumpetorpercussionsections:n Vented/tunedearplugs.n Uniformattenuationoramplitude-sensitiveearplugs.
Nearamplifiedspeakers:n Uniformattenuationearplugs.
Flutes and piccolos Loudpeaklevels,intensehighfrequencies.
Existingright-earhearinglossresultsinperceiveddistortion.
Generally:n Uniformattenuationoramplitude-sensitiveearplugs.
Right-earhearingloss:n Asymmetricalvented/tunedearplugs.
Brass Jawresonance(occlusioneffect)makesitdifficulttomonitorinstrumentwhileusingearplugs.
Nearpercussionorotherbrassinstruments:n Vented/tunedoramplitude-sensitiveearplugs.n Earmuffs.
Nearamplifiedspeakers:n Uniformattenuationearplugs.
Violins and violas Conventionalearplugsremovehigher-frequencysounds.
n Uniformattenuationearplugs.n Somepreferamplitude-sensitive–particularlyifnearloudneighbours.
Basses, cellos, harps
Proximitytobrasssection. n Vented/tunedearplugs.
Pianos and harpsichords
Conventionalearplugsremovehigher-frequencysounds.
n Uniformattenuationearplugs.
Drums and percussion
Highsoundlevels,intensehigherfrequencysoundssuchascymbals.
Conventionalearplugsreducesoundlevelstoomuchandmayresultinover-hittingtocompensate.
n Uniformattenuationoramplitude-sensitiveearplugs.n Earmuffs.
Pit orchestras Oftenover-loud. n Uniformattenuationearplugs.n Headphonemonitors.
Conductors and music teachers
Conventionalearplugsremovehigherfrequencysounds.
n Uniformattenuationearplugs.
Notethatwhiletheproblemsarecommon,personalandenvironmentalfactorsvarywidely.Employersshouldconsultperformersbeforeselectingparticularhearingprotection.Professionaladviceisdesirable.
131Tables3and4providegeneralguidanceontheselectionofsuitablehearingprotection.
Soundadvice Page39of144
Health and Safety Executive
Situation Typical problems Possible protection
Live sound engineers
Studio performers and engineers
Justveryloud.
Competingexternalsounds.
n Uniformattenuationearplugs.(Note:usingheadphonemonitorsorin-earmonitorsmayremovetheneedfor,orallowreducedlevelsof,reproducedsoundinworkingareas.)
Theatre and other live-performance cast and crew
Continuoussounds(generators).
Impulsesounds(pyrotechnics,gunshots).
n Earmuffs.n Compressibleearplugs.n Premouldedearplugs.
Concert venue workers
Needprotectionagainsthighsoundlevelswhileretainingabilitytocommunicate.
Communicationnotanissue:n Compressibleearplugs.n Earmuffs.
Needtocommunicate:n Uniformattenuationearplugs.
Bars and clubs Needprotectionagainsthighsoundlevelsandmayneedabilitytocommunicate.
Glasscollectors:n Compressibleearplugs.n Earmuffs.n Premouldedearplugs
Barstaff:n Uniformattenuationearplugs.
DJs:n Earmuffswithsoundrestorationdevices(ANC)fitted.
Managers,securitystaff:n Uniformattenuationearplugswithcommsfitted.
(Note:usingheadphonemonitorsorin-earmonitorsmayremovetheneedfor,orallowreducedlevelsof,reproducedsoundinworkingareas.)
Notethatwhiletheproblemsarecommon,personalandenvironmentalfactorsvarywidely.Employersshouldconsultworkersbeforeselectingparticularhearingprotection.Professionaladvicemaybedesirable.
Table 4 Typicalproblemsandselectingsuitablehearingprotectionforotherworkers
Soundadvice Page40of144
Health and Safety Executive
Earplugs
132Earplugsfitintotheearorcovertheearcanal.Theyarelessvisuallyintrusivethanexternalhearingprotectionbutneedcarefulselectionastheyrepresentaverypersonalprotectionagainstspecificnoisesourcesunderspecificconditions.Allearplugsshouldcomewithanindicationofthetheoreticalnoisereduction.Thedescriptionofthereductionmaybeasinglenumberoritmaygiveanindicationofthereductionatdifferentfrequencies.Itshouldberememberedthatthetheoreticalattenuationof‘offtheshelf’earplugsisbaseduponasystemofaveraginganditisoftenappropriatetotakea‘realworld’viewandassumethatthereductionis4dBlessthanstatedonthepacket.
133Instructionsforallearplugsshouldgiveadviceonthecorrectmethodofuseasthesealcreatedbetweentheearplugandtheearisfundamentaltoitseffectiveness.Whereearplugsaresuppliedbyanemployerthereisadutytoensurethatcorrecttrainingisgiven.Incircumstanceswhereahealthsurveillanceprogrammeisinoperationitwouldbebesttoincorporatetheappropriateselection,fittingandtrainingaspartofthatprogramme.ThecertificationofdifferentearplugstocomplywithEuropeanStandardsisprogressingasnewtypesofearplugsaredeveloped.Tradeliteratureshouldclearlyidentifyifthetypeofearplugonofferhasbeencertified.(FurtherdetailsmaybefoundinHSEpublicationL108.2)
Compressible earplugs (disposable) 134Theadvantagesanddisadvantagesofcompressibleearplugsare:
Advantages
n Inexpensiveandsimpletouse.n Effectivelyprotectagainsthighsoundlevels.n Smallerthanearmuffs–canbecarriedinapocket.n Morecomfortablethanearmuffsinhotenvironments.
Disadvantages
n Provideunevenfrequencyattenuation–removemorehighfrequenciesthanlow.
n Occlusioneffectdistortssoundperceptionforreededwoodwindandbrassmusicians.
n Interferewithspeechcommunication.n Requirecarefulinsertiontoensureeffectiveprotection.n Riskofinfectionfromdirtyhands.
Useful for
n Crew,venuestaff,andotherworkersinsituationsinwhichsoundqualityandspeechcommunicationarenotissues(especiallynon-musicapplications).
n Emergencyapplications(suchasforgettingorlosingcustom-mouldedearplugs).
135Thistypeofearplugismoresuitedtojobfunctionswheretheuserdoesnotneedtohearthefullfrequencyrangeofthesounds.Musiciansandsoundengineersmaynotfindthesesuitableduringaperformancebuttheyareusefulasalastresort.
Premoulded earplugs (reusable) 136Premouldedearplugsaregeneric-fitearplugsshapedfortheaverageuser’searcanal.Mosthaveatriple-flangedplugthatfitsinsidetheearcanal.Theseplugsaregenerallyreusablebutrequireregularcleaning.Varioustypesareavailableincludinguniformattenuationandamplitude-sensitive.
Soundadvice Page41of144
Health and Safety Executive
Figure 4 Premouldedearplugs
137Theadvantagesanddisadvantagesofpremouldedearplugsare:
Advantages
n Lessexpensivethancustom-mouldedearplugs.n Easytoinsertproperly.n Lastlongerthancompressibleearplugs.n Donotrequirecustom-fitting–availableoff-the-shelf.n Reusable–ifkeptclean.
Disadvantages
n Moreexpensivethancompressibleearplugs.n Uniformattenuationtypesgenerallynotas‘flat’ascustom-mouldeduniform
attenuationearplugs.
Useful for (uniform attenuation types)
n Musiciansandvocalistswhowantarelativelyinexpensiveearplugwithrelativelyuniformattenuationforpracticeandrehearsals.
n Barstaffandotherworkerswhowantrelativelyinexpensiveearplugsthatdonotmufflevoicesandotherhigher-frequencysoundsasmuchascompressibleplugs.
Custom-moulded earplugs 138Thesiliconeearplugismouldedtotheshapeoftheuser’searcanalandshouldbefit-tested.Theyaretypicallymadebyalaboratorythatsupplieslocalaudiologistsandhearingclinics.Theycancomeinfilteredorvented/tunedvarieties.Hereeachplugisboredout,andthenfittedwithanadjustableventorcappedwithabutton-sizedfilterattachedtoitsouterend.
139 Infiltertypes,thefilter,inconjunctionwiththeairinsidethebored-outsection,offsetsthelossofhighfrequenciesthatnormallyoccurswhenanobjectisinsertedintotheear.Notonlycanthefrequencyattenuationofthefittingbespecificallytunedtotheuser’sneeds,butalsotheplugsthemselveswillbecomfortableandhighlyeffectiveandarereadilyreusable.Filtersareavailablewhich,forexample,reduceoverallnoiselevelsby9,15,and25dB.
140Thevented/tunedearplug,whichdoesnotreducesoundlevelsuptoabout2000Hz,reduceshigherfrequenciessignificantly.Typically,vented/tunedearplugsattenuatehigherfrequenciesbyabout20dBwhentheadjustableventiswideopen.Closingtheventincreaseshigher-frequencyattenuationtoasmuchas28dB(performancesimilartocompressibleearplugs).Mostear-mouldlaboratoriescanmakecustom-mouldedvented/tunedearplugs.
141Theadvantagesanddisadvantagesofcustom-mouldedearplugs(filtertypes)are:
Most premoulded earplugs have a triple-flanged plug that fits inside the ear canal
Soundadvice Page42of144
Health and Safety Executive
Advantages (filter types)
n Canprovideevenattenuationoffrequenciesuptoabout6000Hz.n Canbemodifiedtoadjusthigh-frequencyattenuation.n Maybeflesh-colouredandunobtrusive.
Disadvantages (filter types)
n Expensive.n Needcustom-fittingbyaqualifiedprofessional.
Useful for (filter types)
n Musiciansplayingorseatednearbytoinstrumentsthatproducehigher-frequencysounds(forexample,violins,trumpets,piccolos,andpianos).
n Anyoneworkingwithoraroundamplifiedsound(forexample,musicians,vocalists,DJs,soundengineers,conductors,andteachers).
n Anyonewhoneedssoundreductionwithminimaldistortionorcolouration.142Theadvantagesanddisadvantagesofcustom-mouldedearplugs(vented/tunedtypes)are:
Advantages (vented/tuned types)
n Allowmusiciansplayinglower-frequencyinstrumentstohearthemselveswhilescreeningoutsurroundinghigher-frequencysounds.
n Verylittleocclusioneffect.n Rightandleftearplugscanbeadjustedseparatelytocompensateforright-ear
hearinglossinfluteandpiccoloplayers.n Small500Hzresonanceimprovesvocalist’sabilitytomonitorvoice.
Disadvantages (vented/tuned types)
n Expensive.n Needcustom-fittingbyaqualifiedprofessional.
Useful for (vented/tuned types)
n Musiciansplayingbassandlower-frequencyinstruments(forexample,lowerstrings,reededwoodwinds,andlowbrasses)whowishtoshieldthemselvesagainsthigh-frequencysoundsfrompercussionortrumpetsections.
n Thosesolovocalistswhoneedprotectionagainsttheirownvoice.
Figure 5 Custom-mouldedearplugs
Custom-fit uniform attenuation earplugs consist of a button-sized filter attached to the outer end of a silicone earplug moulded to the shape of your ear canal
Filters
Soundadvice Page43of144
Health and Safety Executive
Canal caps/semi-insert earplugs 143Canalcapsandsemi-insertearplugscomeonaheadband.Canalcaps(sometimescalledsemi-auralplugs)generallyhaveroundedtipsthatcovertheentrancetotheearcanal,whilesemi-insertplugsgenerallyhavetaperedtipsthatarepushedintotheearcanal.Bothtypesareconvenientforsituationswherethehearingprotectionhastobetakenonandofffrequently.Theyarenotdesignedforcontinuoususe.
Figure 6 Semi-insertearplugs
144Wherepatternsofexposuretoexcessivenoisearelikelytoberepeatedandshort-term,earmuffsorcanalcapsmaybepreferredbecausetheyarequickandeasytofitandremove,andthereforemorelikelytobefittedwhenexposureoccurs.Earmuffs
145Earmuffs(sometimesreferredtoas‘eardefenders’)arehardplasticcupsthatfitoverandsurroundtheearsandaresealedtotheheadbycushionseals.Tensiontohelpthesealisprovidedbyaheadband.Theyareeasytofitanduse,onceappropriatetrainingisgiven,andtheiruseiseasilymonitored.Helmet-mountedearmuffsmaybeappropriateforriggers.
146Someearmuffsprovidesoundrestoration.Thesehaveamicrophoneontheoutsideandaspeakerontheinside,oftenelectronicallylimited,toenablethewearertohearexternalsignals.Thiselectronicsystemcanintroduceatinybutsometimesnoticeabletimedelay.
147Someearmuffsincorporatesystemstorelaycommunicationorotheraudiosignals(forexample,musicforDJs).Thesedevicesreducetheambientnoiselevelsandthereforeallowthewearertolistentothemusicatareducedlevel.Theycanprovideanalternativetoheadphonesinnoisyenvironments.EarmuffsshouldcomplywithBSEN352–68andBSEN352-8.9Checkthatlimitersarefittedtolimitthelevelofsoundreproducedatthewearer’sears.
148Earmuffs,likeallhearingprotectors,shouldbeselectedonthebasisofcomfort,practicalityandhygienetohelpensuretheyarewornproperly.Anyattempttoaltertheearmuffsorusingdamagedearmuffscouldmakethemineffective.Comfortconsiderationsinclude:
n Pressurefromthesealsonthehead–resilientsealsonlyneedalowheadbandforce.
n Alargecontactareabetweenthesealandheadhelpsreducethecontactpressurebutinhotconditionsmaycausesweating.
n Weight–thelighterthebetterbutthecupsneedtobelargeenoughtofitrightovertheuser’sears.
Soundadvice Page44of144
Health and Safety Executive
149Theadvantagesanddisadvantagesofearmuffsare:
Advantages
n Inexpensiveandsimpletouse.n Easiertosliponandoffthanearplugs.n Morecomfortablethanearplugsincoldenvironments.n Lessocclusioneffectthanwithcompressibleearplugs.
Disadvantages
n Heavierandmoreobtrusivethanearplugs.n Canbeuncomfortableinwarmorhumidconditions–earplugsmaybe
preferred.n Maynotbeeffectiveforusewithspectacles,longhair,beardsandjewellery.
Useful for
n Crewmemberswhoneedprotectionwhileworkingaroundloudsoundandwhoarenotconcernedwithhowtheearmuffslook.
Training and effective use
150Usersmustbetrainedhowtocorrectlyfitandusehearingprotection,including:
n whyhearingprotectorsareprovidedandwhereandwhentheymustbeused;n theneedtofollowthemanufacturer’sinstructions;n howtoavoiditemssuchasspectacles,longhair,earringsandcostume
accessories,andanyotherpersonalprotection,interferingwiththeeffectivenessofthehearingprotection;
n theneedforfullacclimatisation;n theimportanceofwearinghearingprotectionatalltimesinanoisyenvironment
(removingitforonlyafewminuteswilllowertheprotectiontothewearerveryconsiderably);
n cleanliness–allprotectorsshouldbethoroughlycleanedbeforeuseandstoredhygienically.Earplugsshouldbeinsertedonlyafterwashinghandsthoroughly.Disposableearplugsshouldbediscardedifunwrappedandafteruseandshouldnothavepassedtheirexpirydate;
n earplugs,canalcapsandin-earmonitorsshouldnotbeshared;n howtostore,careforandfrequentlychecktheirhearingprotectorstomake
suretheyremaininagood,cleancondition;n wheretoreportdamagetotheirhearingprotectorsandhowtoobtain
replacementsornewprotectors.Earmuffsealsandcapsshouldnotbedamaged,withnoreducedtensionoftheheadbands.
Soundadvice Page45of144
Health and Safety Executive
Hearing health surveillance Overview ProvidinghealthsurveillanceHearingchecksWhatishealthsurveillance?Howishealthsurveillancearranged?Whatdoesanoccupationalhealthserviceproviderdo?Whatshouldbedonewiththeresultsofhealthsurveillance? Providing health surveillance
151Employersmustprovidehealthsurveillanceinvolvinghearingchecksforallemployeeswhoarelikelytobefrequentlyexposedatoraboveeitherupperexposureactionvalue,orareatriskforanyotherreason,forexampletheyalreadysufferfromhearinglossorareparticularlysensitivetodamage.Itisnotasuitablesubstituteforcontrollingriskatsource.152Thepurposeofhealthsurveillanceisto:
n identifywhenemployeesareshowingearlysignsofhearingdamage;n provideanopportunitytodosomethingtopreventthedamagegettingworse;n checkwhethercontrolmeasuresareworking.
153Employeesmustco-operatewiththeiremployer’shealthsurveillanceprogramme.Employersshouldconsulttheirtradeunion(s)safetyrepresentative(s),oremployeerepresentative(s)andtheemployeesconcernedbeforeintroducinghealthsurveillance.Itisimportantthateveryoneunderstandsthattheaimofhealthsurveillanceistoprotecttheirhearing.Understandingandco-operationareessentialifhealthsurveillanceistobeeffective.
154Thereisnorequirementforself-employedpeopletohavehealthsurveillance,howevertheyarestronglyadvisedtoarrangeitiftheythinktheirexposurefrequentlyexceedstheupperexposureactionvalue,theyregularlyhavetowearhearingprotection,orhaveotherconcernsabouttheirhearing.Ifyouareafreelancer,seeSoundAdvice1‘Freelancers’.Hearing checks
155Hearingcheckscanbeamatterofconcernforthosewhoseemploymentdependsontheirabilitytohear.Musiciansandsoundengineersrelyongoodhearingandtheymayworrythatanydeteriorationwillaffecttheirabilitytocarryouttheirworkactivities.Employeesandfreelancersshouldbeencouragedtoviewhealthsurveillanceprogrammes(hearingchecks)asapositivecontributiontopreservingtheirhearing.
156Forsome,thecheckwillshowthatthereisnoproblem,whileothersmayfindthattheirhearingisintheearlystagesofdamage.Somemayalreadysuspectthattheirhearingisdeterioratingandcheckresultsmayconfirmthesefears.Theseindividualsmaybeworriedthattheywilllosetheirjobsiftheiremployerisinformedthattheyare‘losingtheirhearing’.Howeverdisciplinaryactioncannotbebasedontheresultsofthehearingcheck.
Soundadvice Page46of144
Health and Safety Executive
157Whatevertheoutcome,thecheckshouldbeviewedasanopportunitytoidentifyanydeteriorationatanearlystageandtoensurethatappropriatemeasuresaretakentopreventanyfurtherharm.
What is health surveillance?
158Healthsurveillanceforhearingdamageusuallymeans:
n regularhearingchecksincontrolledconditionswhichincludesmeasuringhearingsensitivityoverarangeofsoundfrequencies;
n tellingemployeesabouttheresultsoftheirhearingchecks;n keepinghealthrecords;n ensuringemployeesareexaminedbyadoctorwherehearingdamageis
identified.
159Ideallyhealthsurveillancestartsbeforepeopleareexposedtonoise(fornewstartersorthosechangingjobs)togiveabaseline.Ensurethiscoversallthosepeoplewhoareemployedonaregularbasis.
160Healthsurveillancecan,however,beintroducedatanytimeafterexposuretonoise.Thiswouldbefollowedbyaregularseriesofchecks,usuallyannuallyforthefirsttwoyearsandthenatthree-yearlyintervals(althoughthismayneedtobemorefrequentifanyproblemwithhearingisdetectedorwheretheriskofhearingdamageishigh).
161Hearingchecksshouldbecarriedoutbysomeonewhohastheappropriatetraining.Thewholehealthsurveillanceprogrammeneedstobeunderthecontrolofanoccupationalhealthprofessional(forexampleadoctororanursewithappropriatetrainingandexperience).Employersmustmakesurethatanyhearinghealthsurveillanceiscarriedoutproperly.
How is health surveillance arranged?
162Largercompaniesororganisationsmayhaveaccesstoin-houseoccupationalhealthserviceswhichmaybeabletocarryouttheprogramme.Anexternalcontractorisnecessarywheretherearenofacilitiesin-house.Detailsofoccupationalhealthservicesmaybefoundthroughtradeassociationsorlocalbusinesssupportorganisations.TheMusicians’Unionprovidesadviceforfreelancers.
What does an occupational health service provider do?
163Suitableoccupationalhealthserviceproviderswillbeabletodemonstratetheyhavethetrainingandexperienceneeded.Theyshouldbeableto:
n adviseonasuitableprogramme;n setuptheprogramme;n providesuitablyqualifiedandexperiencedstafftocarryoutthework;n providetheemployerwithreportsonemployees’fitnesstocontinueworkwith
noiseexposure;n provideemployeeswithfeedbackonthestateoftheirhearingincludingtheir
resultsandgeneraladviceonhowtolookaftertheirhearing.
Soundadvice Page47of144
Health and Safety Executive
What should be done with the results of health surveillance?
164Analysingtheresultsofhealthsurveillanceforgroupsofworkerscangiveaninsightintohowwelltheprogrammetocontrolnoiserisksisworking.Theresultsshouldbeusedtotargetnoisereduction,educationandcompliancepracticesmoreaccurately.Thisinformationshouldbemadeavailabletoemployeesorsafetyrepresentatives.
165Theemployerneedsto:
n keephealthrecordsofthehealthsurveillanceandfitness-for-workadviceprovidedforeachemployee(butnottheconfidentialmedicalrecordswhicharekeptbythedoctor).AhealthandsafetyinspectorcanasktoseehealthrecordsaspartoftheirchecksthatyouarecomplyingwiththeRegulations;
n makeemployees’recordsavailabletothem;n actuponanyrecommendationsmadebytheoccupationalhealthservice
provideraboutemployees’continuedexposuretonoise;n ensurethatanyemployeewithsuspectedhearingdamageisreferredtoa
doctor,toensurethattheemployeereceivesadvicefromanoccupationalhealthprofessional;
n usetheresultstoreviewand,ifnecessary,revisetheriskassessmentandplanstocontrolrisks.
CASE STUDY Health surveillance (audiometry)
A major multi-media company engaged an occupational health provider to cover their requirement for health surveillance.
The company implemented the following:
n Occupational Health would be consulted for any staff who may be exposed to high noise levels with regard to the need for health surveillance. Job roles, identified as putting individuals at risk to high noise exposure, would have a baseline audiometric test on employment and subsequent hearing checks as part of the health surveillance programme.
n All musicians and singers on employment and routinely throughout their work would be put into a health surveillance programme.
n Other staff who may be regularly exposed to noise levels above 85 dB in the normal course of their work would also be included.
n Hearing checks would be free of charge for staff. n Records would be held on behalf of the employer by the occupational health
provider and would be held as ‘Medical in Confidence’. n Results would be communicated to the individual and, if there were any
anomalies or some hearing loss, appropriate medical advice and counselling (in confidence) would be provided.
n Fitness for work would not be determined from the results but would continue to be determined by the individual’s ability to do their job.
n Managers would not have access to individual medical records, except where the individual consented directly to the disclosure, but would have a written statistical report of results to enable the manager to target noise reduction, education and compliance practices more accurately.
n Several levels of health surveillance were also agreed with the occupational health provider:
Level 1: Noise exposure between 80 dB and 85 dB (the lower and upper action values)Example: Wearing limited headphones/listening to noise level from a controlled output on a regular basis.
Soundadvice Page48of144
Health and Safety Executive
CASE STUDY Health surveillance (audiometry) cont
Require:
n A baseline audiometry test when starting, or within 3 months of starting work.n Further audiometry tests depending on the result of the baseline test, or in
the event of an adverse exposure to noise, eg a loud peak of sound through unlimited headphones.
Level 2: Noise exposure approaching, but not exceeding 85 dB (the upper action value)Example: Working in areas with unlimited output and/or unlimited headphones. Require:
n A baseline audiometry test when starting, or within 3 months of starting work.n A re-test in 1 year to check that they are not ‘hypersensitive’ to noise damage.n Further tests depending on the audiometry results. Also in the event of an
adverse exposure (as described above). If a significant deterioration in hearing has occurred then removal from that work, and/or more regular audiometry may be necessary.
n The maximum interval between audiometry tests should not exceed 3 years in this situation.
Level 3: Noise exposure above 85 dB (exceeding the upper action value)Example: Very noisy areas (festivals, live events etc); musicians, depending on risk assessment or noise measurement.
Require:
n A baseline audiometry test when starting, or within 3 months of starting work.n A re-test in 1 year to check that they are not ‘hypersensitive’ to noise damage.n Further tests depending on the audiometry results. Also in the event of an
adverse exposure (as described above). If a significant deterioration in hearing has occurred then removal from that work, and/or more regular audiometry may be necessary.
n The maximum interval between audiometry tests should not exceed 2 years in this situation.
Note: In the case of Level 3 employees, the occupational health provider decided to increase the degree of health surveillance beyond HSE’s guidance in view of the nature of their exposure.
Soundadvice Page49of144
Health and Safety Executive
Part 2 Sound advice for specific sections of the music and entertainment industry
SoundAdvice1 Freelancers 50Freelancers and other self-employed people
SoundAdvice2 Venues 56Design, layout and management for pubs, clubs, studios and indoor live music events
SoundAdvice3 Rehearsals 62Rehearsals and warm-ups
SoundAdvice4 Rockandpop 64Amplified music performed before a live audience
SoundAdvice5 Pubsandclubs 76Amplified music played in nightclubs, bars, pubs and restaurants
SoundAdvice6 Orchestras 83Symphony orchestras, chamber orchestras, bands and other ensembles
SoundAdvice7 Orchestrapits 94Orchestra pits in theatres and opera houses
SoundAdvice8 Stagebands 100On-stage and off-stage bands and choruses in theatrical performances
SoundAdvice9 Studios 102Facilities for recording and/or broadcasting live music
SoundAdvice10 Musiceducation 109Teachers, conductors of student groups, education officers and directors in schools and music colleges
SoundAdvice11 Marchingband 115Civilian and military marching bands
Soundadvice Page50of144
Health and Safety Executive
1 Freelancers Freelancers and other self-employed people
Overview
BackgroundResponsibilitiesundertheNoiseRegulationsExposuremanagementEstimateexposureHearingprotectionOtherwaystoreduceexposureHealthsurveillanceInformation,instructionandtrainingMusiciansHearingPassport
Background
1 Thissectionwillhelpthoseworkinginmusicandentertainmentwhoregardthemselvesasfreelancersorself-employed,forexamplesessionmusicians,freelanceorchestramusicians,jazzmusicians,teachers,DJs,lighting/soundengineers,videodesigners,technicians,cameramen,stageproductionmanagers,crewmembersetc.Freelancersandself-employedworkersarealsoadvisedtoreadallthevenue-specificguidancethatappliestotheirwork.Self-employedmusiciansareoftenreferredtoasfreelancers.
Responsibilities under the Noise Regulations
2 TheNoiseRegulationsrequireeachself-employedpersontomanagetherisktothemselvesand,sofarasreasonablypracticable,anyotherpeopleatwork,includingotherfreelancersandotherself-employedworkers.Thiswillincludereducingtheriskfromnoiseexposurethroughorganisationalandtechnicalsolutions.Iftheriskcannotbeeliminatedinthiswaythentheengager/contractormayneedtoprovidehearingprotectionand,ifnecessary,ensureitisworn.
3 Engagers/contractorsandfreelancers/self-employedpeoplemustworktogethertoprovideasafeworkingenvironmentandprotectthehearingofindividuals.Engagers/contractorsshouldtakereasonablestepstoascertaintheexposureofperformersduringotherengagementsinthedayandmanagetherisktotheirhearing(alsoseeparagraph14).
4 Collectivemeasuressuchasorganisationalcontrolsorchangestolayoutetcaregenerallybestdonebythepersoninoverallcontrolofthevenueorproduction,forexampletheproducer,thepublican,thevenueoperator,promoterorothereventorganiser.Also,whererequired,thepersoninchargeshouldprovidehearingprotectiontoworkerswhoneedit.
5 Freelancersandself-employedsubcontractorsareadvisedwheneverundertakingworktoclarifyanyresponsibilitiesundertheNoiseRegulationsandtoensurethatanyrisksarecontrolled–thisisbestestablishedbythecontractofengagement.
6 Freelancersandself-employedpeopleshouldunderstandthepracticalapproachtonoisecontrolasitrelatestotheirownspeciality.Theyshouldusetheirknowledge
Soundadvice Page51of144
Health and Safety Executive
tohelpreducetheirownriskandinfluenceothers,forexamplebyengagingproactivelywithotherfreelancersandself-employedpeopleintheindustryorbycheckingtoensurethatvenueshaveallthenecessaryproceduresinplacetohelpkeepexposurelevelsdown.Theyshouldnotrelysolelyuponpersonalhearingprotection.
EXAMPLE
Self-employed technicianA self-employed backline technician is engaged to work on an event.
The main contractor should be responsible for implementing noise controls, such as equipment specification, speaker positions, schedules, the provision of acoustic screens etc as these are often beyond the technician’s control.
The main contractor should also ensure suitable hearing protection is provided where required, although individuals may wish to use their own hearing protection if they have special requirements such as custom-moulded earplugs.
The technician should confirm that the main contractor will be responsible for implementing the necessary noise controls. This could be done by means of a simple clause in the contract of engagement.
Exposure management
7 Manymusiciansandotherworkersinmusicandentertainmentareself-employedandmayworkforanumberofdifferentclients.Theymaycarryoutanumberofengagementsinadayfordifferentengagers/contractors.Freelancemusicians,forexample,maywellbeinvolvedinoneortwoorevenallofthefollowingactivitiesinanyoneday:
n rehearsal(s);n performance(s);n teaching;n practising;n recording.
8 Ifamusicianweretobeexposedfor3hoursat88dB,thedailyexposurewouldbe84dB.However,ifthishappenedthreetimesintheday,thetotaldailyexposurewouldbe88dB.Inthissituationthemusician’shearingwillbeatrisk.
9 Freelancersandself-employedpeopleshouldbeawareoftheirexposuretonoiseovertheday.Iftheyundertakemorethanonesessionoractivity(suchaspractisingorasoundcheck)duringadaytheyoughttoassessandkeeptrackoftheirexposure.ThiscouldbedoneusingHSE’son-linecalculator(www.hse.gov.uk/noise/calculator.htm)ortheready-reckoner(alsoseeAppendix4‘Estimatingnoiseexposure’).Wheretheyidentifyarisktheyshoulddiscusswiththeirengagers/contractorswhatcontrolscouldbeusedtoreduceexposure.
In general, freelancers and self-employed people are advised to try to adopt any relevant recommendation on controlling noise contained in this book, regardless of the duration of an engagement.
Estimate exposure
10 Itisgoodpracticeforfreelancers/self-employedpeopletoestimatethelikelynoiselevelsproducedbytheirinstrumentorspecialistoccupation(forexampletypicallevels
Soundadvice Page52of144
Health and Safety Executive
duringpracticebyabrassplayerorduringashowforastagemanager).Thiswillenablethemtoestimatetheirdailyexposureand,ifnecessary,takestepstoreducetherisk.Theyshouldalsoaskengagers/contractorstoprovideadvanceinformationoftheirlikelyexposurebeforeworkbegins.Representativenoiselevelsofinstrumentsandofworkplacessuchaspubsandclubsaregiveninotherpartsofthisbook.
11 Measuringsoundlevelswithanoisemetercanbehelpfulintrackingexposureduringpractice,rehearsalsorwherenodataonnoiselevelsisavailable.However,noisemeasurementscanmisinterpretpersonalexposureiftheyarenotcarriedoutproperly(seeAppendix5‘Measuringnoise’).
12 Freelancersandotherself-employedpeoplearestronglyrecommendedtokeeparecordoftheirnoiseexposureandwhentheyhavehadtousehearingprotection.Thiswillhelpthemtounderstandtheextentoftheirexposureoveratypicalperiodandthenoiseriskstheymightface.TheMusicians’UnioncanprovideitsfreelancememberswithaHearingPassporttohelpwiththisprocess.
Hearing protection
13 Iftheexposureislikelytobeover80dBtheengager/contractorshouldhavesuitablehearingprotectionavailableandfreelancers/self-employedsubcontractorsmaychoosetowearit.Iftheexposureislikelytobeatorabove85dB,hearingprotectionmustbeworn.Personalhearingprotectionshouldbeusedwhiledecisionsarebeingmadeonhowbesttoreducenoiseexposurebytechnicalororganisationalmeans,andshouldcontinuetobeusedifthereisstillarisktohearingafterallotherreasonablypracticablemeasureshavebeenputinplace.
EXAMPLE
Freelance folk musicianA folk musician (flute player) has the following activities on a particular day:
Practice at home (2 hours) 86 dBTeaching in a local school (3 hours) 89 dBGig in a venue (2 hours) 93 dB
Using the points system (see Appendix 4 ‘Estimating noise exposure using the points system’) the daily exposure from these activities will be:
Practice 2 hours 86 dB 32 pointsTeaching 3 hours 89 dB 97 pointsGig 2 hours 93 dB 160 pointsTotal 289 points = 89 dB
At this level of exposure the musician would be at risk of hearing loss and should do what they can to reduce the exposure levels and if necessary wear suitable hearing protection and have a regular hearing check (health surveillance).
Possible methods for reducing exposure levels include:
n controlling amplification levels during the gig;n arranging to conduct lessons in a suitable classroom;n practising at lower levels and encouraging students to do the same by
stressing the importance of dynamic control and choice of repertoire.
Soundadvice Page53of144
Health and Safety Executive
14 Whileitistheresponsibilityoftheengager/contractortoprovideahealthyandsafeworkingenvironment(includinghearingprotectionwhereitisnecessary),freelancers/self-employedworkersareadvisedtoprovidetheirownpersonalhearingprotectionwheretheyhavespecificrequirements,suchascustom-mouldedearplugs–see‘Personalhearingprotection’inPart1.
Other ways to reduce exposure
Practice/rehearsals15 Itisrecommendedthat,wheneverpossible,freelancemusicianspractiseatquieterlevelsinappropriatepracticeroom(s)toreducetheiroverallexposuretonoise.
Setting up16 Freelancemusiciansshouldthinkcarefullyabouthowtheysetuptheirequipmentwhencarryingoutagig.Strategicpositioninganddirectionofspeakersandamplifier-combosarerecommended.
Noise limiters17 Freelancersandsoundtechnicians,includingthoseprovidingtheirownamplificationequipment,mayfindthatsomevenueswillhaveanoiselimiterthathasbeensettocutthepowersupplytotheamplificationequipmentwhenaspecificnoiselevelisreached.Ensurethatyouaskthevenueifalimiterhasbeenset,whattypeitis,andhowthatmayaffectyourperformance.SeeSoundAdvice5‘Pubsandclubs’forfurtherdetailsoftypesoflimiters.Thelimitermayhavebeensettoreducenoisebreakoutfromthepremisesortoprotectthevenuestafffromhearingdamage.Leisure time18 Freelancersandself-employedpeopleshouldrememberthatexposuretoloudnoiseduringleisuretimewillcontributetotheoverallexposureandcouldcontributetohearingdamage.
Health surveillance
19 Wheretherearemanyshort-termengagements,itmaybedifficulttoensuretheprovisionofadequatehealthsurveillance.WhiletheNoiseRegulationsdonotrequirefreelancersorself-employedpeopletoprovidethemselveswithhealthsurveillance,itisstronglyrecommendedthattheyhaveregularhearingchecks.
20 Hearingcheckswillnotpreventdamagetohearingbutregularcheckswillidentifyanyearlysignsofhearinglossandhighlighttheneedforactiontobetakentoreducetheriskofanyfurtherdamage.
21 Freelancersandself-employedpeopleneedtotakeactiontoprotecttheirhearingfromnoiserisk.TheMusicians’Union,theRNID,NHS+andotherbodiessuchastheBritishSocietyofAudiologycanprovideguidanceandaccesstohealthsurveillance.FreelancerscanusetheMusicians’HearingServices,whichprovidesahearingprotectionscheme,offersregularaudiometry,andadviceonhearingprotectionandhearingconservation.
22 Freelancersandself-employedpeoplewhoregularlyworkwiththesameorchestraormanagementshouldasktobeincludedintheprovisionofregularhealthsurveillance(seealso‘Hearinghealthsurveillance’inPart1).
Soundadvice Page54of144
Health and Safety Executive
Information, instruction and training
23 Engagers/contractorsshouldconsultwithfreelancersandself-employedpeoplewhenconductingnoiseriskassessmentsandensuretheyareprovidedwithanysignificantfindingsoftheirriskassessments.
24 Engagers/contractorsshouldprovidefreelancersandself-employedpeoplewithhealthandsafetyinstructionsincluding,forexample,onhowtouseacousticscreensandpersonalhearingprotection.Allfreelancersshouldfollowthehealthandsafetyinstructionsprovidedbytheirengager/contractoranddiscusstheinstructionsiftheyappearunreasonable.Acousticscreensshouldonlybeusedinaccordancewiththeinstructionsoftheengager/contractor(seeAppendix7‘Acousticscreens’).
25 Freelancersandself-employedpeoplewhoregularlyworkforthesamemanagement,orchestraorclientshouldreceivetrainingintheuseofallequipmentprovidedtomanagetherisktohearing(includingscreensandpersonalhearingprotection)unlesstheyalreadyhavesuchtraining.
26 Freelancemusiciansorself-employedworkersengaging‘deps’orsubstitutesshouldensurethattherisksandcontrolmeasuresinplacearecommunicatedtothem.27 Freelancersandself-employedpeopleareadvisedalsotolookat‘Noise-controlmeasuresandtraining’inPart1.
28 Eachengager/contractorhasadutytomanagenoiseexposure.However,fullco-operationbetweenengagers/contractorsandfreelancemusiciansorotherself-employedpeopleisnecessarytomeettherequirementsoftheNoiseRegulations.Itisrecognisedbyindustrygroupsthataschemetohelpfreelancersmanagetheirexposuresandexchangeinformationwouldbebeneficial.Tobesuccessfulthisrequiresinputfrombothengagers/contractorsandthefreelancersorotherself-employedpeopleinvolved.Onewayofhelpingfreelancerstomanagetheirnoiseexposureistousea‘HearingPassport’scheme.
Soundadvice Page55of144
Health and Safety Executive
The Musicians Hearing Passport
The purpose of the Musicians Hearing Passport is to:
n increase awareness of the risk of hearing damage;n promote the provision of health surveillance among freelancers;n reduce the risk of hearing damage;n promote the use of hearing protection when necessary; andn ensure that hearing protection is used properly.
The Musicians Hearing Passport includes details of certified training and health surveillance undertaken by the freelancer.
Freelancers agree to:
n enrol for health surveillance;n undertake training in the proper use of hearing protection and understanding
the risk of hearing damage;n keep their own records of their estimated daily/weekly exposure;n make their own calculations to assess their likely personal overall exposure
using the data supplied by either the engager/contractor, other collated data sources and/or their own personal records (using the HSE points calculator system available on www.hse.gov.uk/noise/calculator.htm).
Engagers/contractors agree to:
n supply data on typical exposure levels based on previous experience and assessments;
n provide information on the expected noise dose from the event, especially when the freelancer has been engaged to perform a specific repertoire. It is suggested that venue owners and engagers/contractors consider installing recording noise meters in their venues to help generate a databank of typical noise levels to enable information to be provided to freelancers;
n ensure that freelancers have access to any noise policies affecting their engagement.
Visit www.musicianshearingservices.co.uk or telephone 020 7323 2076 for more information.
Soundadvice Page56of144
Health and Safety Executive
2 Venues Design, layout and management for pubs, clubs, studios and indoor live music events
Overview
BackgroundDesignControlmeasuresNoiseexposurepolicyCost-effectivesolutionsforsmallervenues
Background
1 Roomsize,designandbuildingmaterialscanallhaveasignificanteffectonthesoundlevelswithinaspace.Otherfactorsincludetherangeandstyleofmusic(particularlyrockandpop)andthenumberofperformers,andanyotherperformancenoisesources(forexample,pyrotechnicsorcannons).
Design
2 Architects/designersandbuildersshouldincorporatedesignfeaturesthathelptopromotetheperformanceofmusicunderthebestpossibleconditionsandincompliancewiththeNoiseRegulations.
3 Installingin-builtmonitorsandotherequipmentcanhelpvenueowners/operatorstomonitorandmaintainreducednoise-exposurelevels.
4 Architects/designersandowners/operatorsproposingnewbuildingsormajorrefurbishmentsarestronglyrecommendedtoconsultacompetentacousticianbeforeundertakinganymajorwork.Donotredecorateexistingacoustictreatmentsasthismayreducetheireffectivenessconsiderably.
5 Setdesignersshouldconsidernoiselevelsalongsideotherhealthandsafetyissues.Theyshouldcarefullyconsidertheeffectthematerialstheyusewillhaveonthenoiselevelsexperiencedbyperformersonstage.Forexample,hard,reflectivesurfacesmightunnecessarilyincreasesoundlevelsexperiencedonstage.Conversely,soft,dampingorabsorptivematerialsmightreducesoundlevels.
Control measures
6 Whereproblemsareknowntoexist,thevenueowner/operatorshouldconsidermakingarrangementsforchangestothelayoutorimprovementstothebuildingtohelpreducenoiseexposurelevels.Thismightbeassimpleasseparatingthebarfromtheperformanceareabyadoororintroducingcarpetingandabsorbentmaterialssuchasdrapesatthebackofthestage.
Soundadvice Page57of144
Health and Safety Executive
Noise exposure policy
7 InmanypremisesthevenueoperatormayhavetheresponsibilityofensuringcompliancewiththeNoiseRegulationsandifsowillneedtoexercisecontroloverthenoiselevelsfrom,forexample,boththeresidentDJsandthevisitingDJsandbandswhomaybeunderthecontrolofanexternalpromoter.Venueoperatorsareadvisedtodevelopawrittennoiseexposurepolicy.Thisshouldincludeasappropriate:
n adescriptionofthecontrolmeasuresdesignedtoprotectworkers,includingcasualworkersandmusicians.Venueoperatorsshouldensurethatanyactionstakentocomplywithdutiestheymayhaveunderenvironmentalnoiselegislationdonothaveanadverseeffectuponcontrolstomanageworkplaceexposureorviceversa;
n provisionanduseofhearingprotection,whetheritiscompulsory,andwhereitisavailablefrom;
n therecommendedandmaximumpermittednoiselevels(amplifiervolumesettings)andwhethernoiselimitersareinstalled;
n anyspecialadviceorrequirements,forexampleforDJs;n thepositionsofanyagreednoisemeasurementreferencepositions.See‘Noise
riskassessmentandplanning’inPart1,SoundAdvice4‘Rockandpop’,SoundAdvice5‘Pubsandclubs’andSoundAdvice6‘Orchestras’;
n useofhouseequipment,suchasamplifiersandspeakers,whetheritisprovidedandwhetherusingthehousesystemiscompulsory;
n communicationoftherisktohearingfromnoise.
8 Venueoperatorsshouldensurethatdutymanagershaveeffectivecontroloverallsoundlevelswithinthebuilding,howevertheyaremade.Thismaybeassimpleassettingacomfortableplayinglevelorcouldincludetheuseofnoisemetersand/ornoiselimitersiflevelsareconsistentlybreached.
9 Venueoperators,whenhiringoutthepremises(‘afourwallsdeal’)tootherstopresentanevent,should:
n ensurethevenueissuitablefortheparticularrequirementsoftheeventtobeperformedintermsofthescaleofboththestageandauditoriumand,whereappropriate,theorchestrapit;
n asktoseethenoiseriskassessment(alongwiththeriskassessmentfortheevent);
n providethehirerwiththedetailsofthevenue’snoiseexposurepolicy;n providethehirerwithanyrelevantinformationonnoisecontrol,forexampleany
previousriskassessments.
10 Venueoperatorswhoareengagingpeopletopresentaneventintheirpremisesshouldalsodothefollowingtominimisetheexposureofperformersandotherworkerstohighnoiselevels:
n ensurethestagesetting(s)oftheeventareappropriate;n ensurethepositioningofperformersisappropriateinrelationtootherartistsandworkersinthesamearea;
n ifamplifiedsoundisused,ensureappropriatecontrolmeasuresareimplemented.
Soundadvice Page58of144
Health and Safety Executive
CASE STUDY
A small nightclub (250 occupancy) playing mainly rock music all night most nights faced the need to improve so that it could continue to operate as a live music venue. However, after taking advice the owner was reassured to find that there were simple and reasonably practicable solutions which could be made to reduce risks from noise including:
n The small triangular stage was moved from a corner and rebuilt as a slightly larger rectangle against a side wall.
n Sound-absorbent panels were fixed to the walls and ceiling around the stage and others were mounted elsewhere in the room.
n The monitor speakers on stage were lifted off the floor and directed towards the musicians.
n A new loudspeaker system was installed with four speakers mounted over the audience, which distributed the sound more evenly.
n Acoustic screens were provided around the drums.n The house technician was trained in sound-level-measuring techniques.n The bar was moved from the music area into a different room.
Noise measurements showed a significant reduction. Musicians, staff and audience were asked for their reactions to the changes and these were all very positive.
Source: Prevention of risks from occupational noise in practice European Agency for Safety and Health at Work.10
Cost-effective solutions for smaller venues
11 Venueoperatorsshouldnotbedeterredfromcarryingoutsimplenoisecontrolsassimplesolutionscanoftenbeveryeffective:
n Ensurethebandisinasuitablelocationfacingthemajorityoftheaudienceandpreferablynotthebarorotherworkareas.
n Locatethebandbehindthemainloudspeakers.n Makesuretheloudspeakersarefacingtherightway,especiallyinstruments
suchasguitarcombos(loudspeaker/amplifiers),toensureotherworkersarenotunnecessarilyexposedtoloudmusic.Anglingaguitarorbasscomboorelevatingitonaflightcasemeanseachplayercanhearwhatisnecessarywithoutputtingextrasoundenergyintotheroom.Helpingthebandhearwhattheyaredoingoftenmeanstheycanplayatreducedvolume.
n Considerwhethertheloudspeakerscanbelocatedtoavoidexcessivevolumeforthestaff(andforthepubliccloseby).Mountthespeakersuphigh.Cantheloudspeakersbewall-mounted?Canstandsbeusedtoelevatethem?
n Whatcanbedonetoeliminatereverberationandreflectedsound?Hardandflatsurfacesreflectsoundandmakeforaloudandconfusinglisteningenvironment,solookforwaystocoverwallsandbreakupsurfaces.Forexamplecandrapesbeputacrossthewallbehindthebandwhentheyareplayingoracarpetplacedonthestagefloor?Anddon’tforgettheroof–ceilingtilescanbehighlyeffective.Makesure,however,thatthematerialsuseddonotcreateafirehazard.
n Soundproofingshouldbeconsideredfordoors,windowsandother‘leaky’areas–especiallyifitpreventsspillintootherwisequietareas.Beware,however,theuseofimprovisedmaterials,whichcanbeineffectiveandcouldpresentotherrisks.
n Whensettingupforarehearsalorperformanceinavenuethatdoesnothaveaspecificfixedstageorperformancearea,trytoreducesoundexposurelevelsforperformersbyconsideringthesizeofvenueandthepositioningof:
Soundadvice Page59of144
Health and Safety Executive
– theperformers;– themonitors;– thePAspeakers;– otherworkersandtheaudience.
12 Whileitcertainlyisn’tuptoavenueoperatortodeterminehowthemusiciansplay,itisworthensuringthatthingslikedrapes,blanketsandgaffertapeareonhandtodampensound,forexamplefromdrumkits.
CASE STUDY
A company with several venues across the country recently reviewed the noise content of its occupational health policy and produced a comprehensive package pulling together aspects of company documentation, a standardised noise assessment procedure and appropriate training.
Company documentation includes a reassessment of safe working practices and procedures. Section 1 covers the basic legal requirements and types of different activities carried out which could produce loud noise. Section 2 details how the noise assessments are carried out by measuring noise levels in identified areas and indicating exposure values for people working in those areas, including the time taken to reach the lower and upper exposure action values. This is used specifically for front-of-house employees where exposure is fairly uniform in defined areas, and not for exposure from specific pieces of equipment used in close proximity to an individual. The existing precautions are then itemised and an action plan drawn up, with immediate, medium- and long-term actions for each venue.
Immediate actions include the rotation of staff, preventing unnecessary entry to areas and use of personal hearing protection. The medium-term action in one venue includes the use of shielding screens, while a longer-term proposal is to install acoustic panelling and other means to reduce reflected sound pressure levels. The company has several venues so it can make direct comparisons between the physical structure of their venues as well as the different type of acts. Good practice in one venue can be used elsewhere.
When considering personal hearing protection, the appropriate frequency analysis (see paragraph 13 in Part 1 of this book) and the need for communication are assessed as part of the selection process. All employees are being given an information pack which explains the different types of hearing damage that can occur, different types of hearing protection, the importance of wearing hearing protection and how to look after it.
Soundadvice Page60of144
Health and Safety Executive
CASE STUDY
Avenueownerengageslivebandsonfivenightsaweek.Afterconsultationwithhealthandsafetyrepresentatives,hearrangedforsomenoisemeasurementstobemade.Withareferenceposition5mawayfromtheloudspeakers,alevelof103dBwasmeasured.Itwasclearthatthestaffwerebeingexposedtoexcessivenoise.
Anumberofminorarchitecturalchangesweremade:
n Changedlocationofthestage.n Providedloudspeakersdirectlyabovethedancefloor.n Putacousticabsorptionmaterialontheceilingandupperpartofthewalls
oppositethestageandonthewallbehindthebar.n Fittedanacousticscreentotheendofthebarnearestthestage.n Replaceddoorstokitchen,officeandfoyerwithacousticdoors.
Somemanagementchangesweremade:
n Bandswerelimitedtoamaximumof103dB.n Jobrotationforglasscollectors.
Figures7and8showthechangesmade.
Thevenueownerisprovidinghearingprotectionforallstaffandrequiresbarstaffandglasscollectorstouseit.Heisdevelopingplansforfurthernoisereductionincludingareviewofthepolicyonmusiclevels.
Thelevelsofexposureareshownbelow:
Before LEP,d dB
After LEP,d dB
Bar staff 92 86
Glass collector 94 88
Door staff 91 84
Reference point 103 100
Soundadvice Page61of144
Health and Safety Executive
FOYER KITCHEN OFFICE
STAGE
BAR
Loudspeakers
Loudspeakers
BEFORE
FOYERwith doors toscreen staff
Acoustic doors for
KITCHEN
Acoustic doors forOFFICE
Loudspeakersover
dance floor
KITCHEN OFFICE
STAGE
BARwith acoustic absorption to walls
Acoustic absorption onceiling and upper partof wall opposite stage
AFTER
Figure 7 Beforechangesweremade
Figure 8 Afterchangesweremade
FOYER KITCHEN OFFICE
STAGE
BAR
Loudspeakers
Loudspeakers
BEFORE
FOYERwith doors toscreen staff
Acoustic doors for
KITCHEN
Acoustic doors forOFFICE
Loudspeakersover
dance floor
KITCHEN OFFICE
STAGE
BARwith acoustic absorption to walls
Acoustic absorption onceiling and upper partof wall opposite stage
AFTER
Soundadvice Page62of144
Health and Safety Executive
3 Rehearsals Rehearsals and warm-ups
Overview
BackgroundUseasuitablevenueMixtureofrepertoireandquieterrehearsalsTime-outHearingprotectionScreensConsistencyAssessandreview
Background
1 Carryoutanoiseriskassessmentandtakestepstoensurethatexposuretosoundisreducedasmuchaspossibleduringwarm-upsandrehearsals.Itisimportantthatthemusiciansandtheconductor/musicaldirectorcanheareachotherwellwithoutexcessiveloudness.Thereisageneraldutytoreducetherisk,sothatifsomethingcanbedoneanditisreasonablypracticabletodosoitmustbedone.Therearevariouswaystoachievethis.
Use a suitable venue
2 Makesurethevenueissuitableforrehearsal.Whereverpossibleuseapurpose-built/acousticallytreatedrehearsalroom/hallbut,ifnot,usingalargerspacemightmeanthatnoiseexposureisreduced.
3 Themostcommonfaultwithrehearsalroomsisthattheylackphysicalvolumeandhavelowceilings.Roomswithlowceilingsandreflectiveparallelwallsresultinexcessivenoiseandreverberation.Wherepossible,useaspacewithmoreheightandincreasetheseparationbetweenplayersmorethantherewilleventuallybeintheperformancespace.Aimforatleast17m3perpersonwithaceilingheightofatleast7m.Thiswillgenerallyprovidesufficientvolumefornoisetobemaintainedatacceptablelevels.
Mixture of repertoire and quieter rehearsals
4 Scheduleavarietyofloudandquietmusicduringarehearsaltoreducetheoverallexposure.Tryandallocatenoisyinstruments/passagesintoseparaterehearsals.
5 Aimtorehearseataquieteroveralllevelunlessthegroupistryingtoachievea‘balance’intheactualperformancespace.Limitthetimespentwhentryingtogetabalancebeforereturningtothequieterrehearsallevel.Whenrepeatingsectionstoironoutproblems,musiciansshouldtrytoplayquietly,exceptforthosewhoneedtobeheardatfullvolume.Trytoavoidrehearsingwhenextraneousnoiseisincreasingtheoverallexposuretonoise.
Soundadvice Page63of144
Health and Safety Executive
Time-out
6 Exposuretonoisecaninducehighstresslevelsinindividuals.Stressshouldbeassessedaspartoftheoverallriskassessment.Considerallowingtime-outforindividualmusiciansandcrewtomanagetheirownstresslevelsbypermittingthemtoleavetherehearsalforashorttimeiftheyarefeelingextremelystressedbythenoise.Theconductor/musicaldirectorneedstobeinformedifthispolicyisinplace.Itmightalsomeanthattheseatingpositionofoneormoreperformersneedstobereassessed.
7 Ensurethatnon-essentialpeople,suchasriggersorcleaners,andmusicianswhoarenotactuallyrehearsing,areexcludedfromtherehearsal.
Hearing protection
8 Someplayerswhomightfinditdifficulttoperformusinghearingprotectionarequitecomfortableusingitduringrehearsals.Usinghearingprotectionduringrehearsalscouldbeparticularlyusefulifloudpassagesarebeingrepeatedlyrehearsed(see‘Personalhearingprotection’inPart1).
Screens
9 Screensshouldonlybeusedasdeterminedbythenoiseriskassessment(seeAppendix7‘Acousticscreens’).Thepositionsofanyscreensshouldbenotedifthestageorperformancespaceistobere-setbetweenthewarm-up/finalrehearsalandtheperformance.
Consistency
10 Whenrehearsingintheperformancespacedirectlybeforeaperformance,trytoensurethatplayersareseatedwheretheywillbeseatedduringtheperformance.Thisissoplayerscanacclimatisethemselvestothesoundstheyarelikelytoexperienceduringtheperformance.
Assess and review
11 Arehearsalisaworkingenvironmentandispartoftheassessmentprocess.Actuponfeedbacktotryandensurethatnoise-exposureproblemsareproperlymanaged.
12 Encouragetheconductor/musicaldirectortogooutfronttoassessvolumelevelsasheardbytheaudience.
Soundadvice Page64of144
Health and Safety Executive
4 Rock and pop Amplified music performed before a live audience
Overview
Background NoiseriskassessmentsControlmeasuresOn-stagecontrolmeasuresTheoff-stageenvironmentPre-showsoundchecksandschedules
Background
1 Thissectiondealswitheventswhereliveamplifiedmusicisperformedtoanaudience,referredtohereas‘rockandpop’.Howeveritcoversahugevarietyofmusicgenresandinstrumenttypes,includingset-upsthatmaynormallybethoughtofasclassicalororchestral.Theprimeconsiderationistheuseofamplificationandsound-reinforcementequipmentinliveperformance.
2 Thenumberofpeopleinthissectorwhoarealreadysufferingfromnoise-inducedproblemssuchashearingloss,tinnitusandotherpermanentmedicalcomplaintsisproofthatthisisahazardousenvironmentandpersonalhearingdamagedoesoccur.
3 Thissectionoutlinespracticalapproachestonoisecontrolandnoiseexposurereductionthatcanbeconsideredgoodpractice.Itdoesnotconsiderindetailusingpersonalhearingprotection.However,itishighlylikelythathearingprotectionwillneedtobeusedaswellasthenoise-controlmeasuresoutlined(see‘Personalhearingprotection’inPart1).
4 ThereisacommonmisunderstandingintherockandpopworldthatRegulationsconcerningnoiselevelssolelyrefertoissuesofnoisepollutionandneighbourhooddisturbancecausedbyspillfromconcertandeventvenues.However,asexplainedinPart1,wherepeopleareatwork(includingtheself-employed)thenthereisalegalobligationforemployers,eventorganisersandtheself-employedtocontrolnoiselevelstoprotectthehealthandsafetyofworkers–evenifthatnoiseissomethingdeliberatelygeneratedandpeoplearewillingtoexposethemselvestopotentiallydamaginglevelsofnoise.
Noise risk assessments
5 Anoiseriskassessmentflowchartforplanningarock/popeventisshownattheendofthissection.
6 Tables5and6givetypicalnoiselevelsandnoiseexposuresforarangeofpeopleworkingwithamplifiedlivemusic.
7 Virtuallyanyliveeventusingamplifiedinstrumentsandsound-reinforcementequipmentwillexceedtheupperexposureactionvalue.Therefore,somekindofcontrolmeasureswillalmostcertainlyberequired.
Soundadvice Page65of144
Health and Safety Executive
8 Todeterminewhatcontrolmeasuresarenecessary,establish:
n Whatisthesourceofthenoise?n Whatspecificareasareaffected?n Whichworkershavetooperateintheseareas,forexamplemusicians,technical
crew,stewards,welfareandmedicalteams,barsandconcessions?
9 Carryingoutsuchanassessmentforspecificlocations,instruments,repertoireandvenuelayoutwillallowtheemployer/organisertoprioritiseactionsandtargettheareasandemployeesathighestrisk.Wherethisinvolvesmeasurement,seealsotheadviceonmeasuringnoiseinAppendix5.
10 Consideringnoiseexposureshouldformakeypartoftheplanningprocess,inparticularsoundsystemdesign,speakerlocation,equipmentselection,theacousticofthevenue,theacts/groups,thenumberandpositionsofperformers,thedifferencesbetweenthedifferentinstrumentsandsoon.Planningisparticularlyimportantforconcerttoursandshouldinvolvebothvenueandacts.Takingaccountofnoiseissuesatanearlystageislikelytobebothmoreeffectiveandmoreeconomicthansimplyhandingoutearplugstocrewoncethetourisunderway,especiallyastheperformerswillprobablyalsoneedhearingprotection.
Table 5Representativenoiselevels
*at3m.
Noise source dB Peak
Percussion 90–105 125–146
Amplifiedguitar(onstageusingin-earmonitors)
100–106* 118
Amplifiedguitar(onstagewithwedgemonitors)
105–112* 124
Drummeratindoormusicfestival 105 144
Guitaristatindoormusicfestival 103 146
Bassguitaristatindoormusicfestival
101 133
Several musicians
Amplifiedrockmusic102–108*
140andabove
Soundadvice Page66of144
Health and Safety Executive
Table 6Representativeexposurelevels
Occupation dB Peak
Indoor/stadium music festivals
Monitorengineer 96–104 147
Productionmanager 101 146
Keyboardtechnician 101 145
FOHsoundengineer 99–100 139/145
Promoter’srepresentative 96–100 146
Pitsupervisor 102 140
Stagemanager 96–98 137
Lightingchief 94 146
Securitystaff(dependingonlocation)
89–94 137/146
Security–Pit 100 146
Cateringstaff 91 134
Fireofficer 101 144
Cashier 89 131
Eventsmanager 85–87 137
Filmcrew 98-100 139/143
Merchandisestaff 100 134
Barstaff 96–97 131/136
Housemanagers 80–91 131/137
Cloakroomstaff 90 145
Outdoor music festivals (‘Pop concerts’)
Stagemanager 98 134
Technicians 91–93 133/138
Catering 87 135
Merchandising 85–101 127/146
Security–Pit 91–101 136/144
Securitystaff(dependingonlocation)
85–100 122/146
Ambulances 88–94 124/133
Barstaff 86 128
Sitemanager 87 129
Cameraoperator 100 137
Delaytowerengineer 93 125
Soundadvice Page67of144
Health and Safety Executive
11 A‘pre-eventnoiseriskassessment’mayhelpplantheevent.Thismightinclude:
n selectingasuitablelocationfortheevent;n selectingabalancedline-up;n selectinganappropriatedesignforstaging;n selectingsuitablematerialstoreducevibrationandsoundlevelsonstage;n designanduseofPAsystemsandamplification;n starterlevelofsoundinaperformance;n soundchecksandrehearsals.
12 Thedesignandlayoutofvenuescanhaveasignificanteffectonnoiselevelsandthenoiseexposureofindividuals(seeSoundAdvice2‘Venues’).Sizeandstaging,designandbuildingmaterials,publicaddresssystemsandtheweathercanallaffectthesoundlevelsbeingproducedinoutdoorvenues.
13 Venuesshouldhavealreadycarriedoutnoiseriskassessmentsfortheirownstaff,andvisitingortouringproductionsshouldrequestthesetoassesswherepeoplemaybeatriskandwherespecialattentionneedstobegiventonoisecontrol.
14 Anynoiseriskassessmentshouldbeupdatedifthereareanychanges(forexampletothesetdesign,venue,seatingorline-up/set).
15 Wheretemporaryconcertstagesareestablished,suchasatoutdoorfestivalsorconcertsinmarquees,assumerisk-controlmeasureswillbeneeded.Genericrisk-controlmeasuresshouldbeputinplaceasamatterofcourseandtheycanthenbeadaptedormodifiedduringtheeventasnecessary.Theorganisersshouldassumethattheentirestagearea,thepitarea,thefront-of-housecontrolpositionandanylocationsadjacenttodelayandin-fillspeakersarehearingprotectionzones,evenafterthecontrolmeasureshavebeenputinplace.Seealso‘Personalhearingprotection’inPart1.
16 Foroutdooreventsandfestivalsites,theorganiserhastoconsidernotonlytheexposuretopeopleworkingbackstageandonstage,butshouldalsobearinmindthewaysitelayoutmaybringotherworkers,contractorsandconcessionairesintonoisyareas.Takingaccountofsuchissuesduringthesiteplanningstageiscrucial,sinceitisextremelydifficulttosolveoncestructures,staffandequipmentareinplace.Alsothinkaboutthemanagementofthenoisegeneratedbytheconcessionsthemselves–manyofwhombringtheirownPAsystemsandgenerators.ForfurtherinformationseeThe event safety guide.3
17 Alsorememberthatotherperiodsofexposurefromnon-workactivitiesincreasetheoveralldosage,forexamplealoudshowfollowedbylisteningtoapersonalstereoatreasonablevolume.Whileoutlawingpersonalheadsetsonthetourbusisclearlydrastic,awarenessofhowandwhenpeopleareexposedtonoisehazardisafundamentalfirststeptoreducingtheriskofdamage.
Control measures
18 Thefirst,simplestandmosteffectivemeasureistoturndownthevolumewhereverpracticable.Unfortunatelythisisoftenoverlookedandfliesinthefaceofthe‘RockandRoll’attitude.However,thesimplestepofkeepinglevelsundercontrolateverystageoftheinstrument/signal/amplification/reinforcementchainisfundamental.
Soundadvice Page68of144
Health and Safety Executive
19 Loudstagenoiselevelscancompromisethequalityoftheperformanceandthesoundthatisdeliveredtotheaudience.Ithasbeenknownforstagemonitoringlevelstobesoloudthatthefront-of-houseengineerinanarenahasbeenunabletohearhisownmix.Thisseriouslycompromisesthepossibilityofcreatingasuitablemixfortheaudience.Theuseofin-earmonitoringcansignificantlyimprovetheoverallsoundquality.
On-stage control measures
20 On-stagecontrolmeasuresincludethefollowing:
n TurningitdowndoesnotnecessarilymeanreducingtheoveralloutputofthemainPA,butrequiresananalysisofwhythingsaresonoisyandtargetingmeasurestocontrolthemain‘offenders’.Thisisparticularlytrueonstagewhereamplificationofindividualinstruments(backline)oftencompeteswithon-stagemonitoring(fold-back,side-fills)andthePAitself.
n Considersubstitutingquieterinstrumentsandampsinthefirstplace.High-qualityamplifiersandspeakersthatoperatewithoutdistortionarefarpreferabletodrivinginferiorsystemsathigherrates.Introducingdistortionmakestheoutputlessintelligibleandleadstoincreasesinsoundlevelinattemptingtoachieveclarity.Theresultisoftenaspiralofincreasingvolumewithouteverachievingclearmonitoring.
n Considerincreasingdistance,isolationorshieldingofnoisierinstrumentswherepossible.Drumkitscanbepositionedandshielded/enclosedtominimisenoiselevelsforperformersandworkerssituatedcloseby.Ideallyshieldingshouldbeacousticallyabsorbentratherthanreflectivematerial.
n Positionandangleguitaramplifier/speakers(guitarcombos)formaximumeaseoflisteningfortheplayer.Additionallysimplyraisingaguitarcomboonaflight-casecouldsignificantlyreduceexposureforotherplayers,haveamarkedreductioninoverallstagenoiseandimproveclarityfortheplayer.Guitarcomboscouldbepositionedandmic’dinaseparateareafromtheperformancearea.
n Considerusingtechnologythateliminatestheneedforloudbacklineamplifiersonstage.ThiscouldrangefromsimplyplugginginstrumentsintoamixingdeskbymeansofDirectInjection(DI)boxesratherthanmic’ingupanamplifier,throughtousingamplifiermodellingsoftware,footpedalsorotherhardware.Whateversystemisused,soundengineerscanachievegreatercontrolofon-stagelevelsthroughcarefulmanagementofmonitorlevelsratherthanexpectingmusicianstofightitoutinabattleofescalatingstagevolume.
n Useriserstoseparatesectionsoftheband,andtoelevateparticularlynoisyinstrumentsabovetheheadsofotherperformers–ormovetothefrontofthestage,particularlywhereveryloudinstrumentsmaybeused–brass,amplifiedguitarandsnaredrumscanproduceextremelyhighsoundlevels.SeeAppendix6‘Risers’.
n A‘shaker’or‘thumper’isespeciallyusefulforreducingdrummonitorlevels.Shakerswillallowperformerstousehearingprotectionandmonitortheirperformancewhilestillmaintainingcontactwiththeirinstruments.
n Consideralteringthedrumkitset-uptoensurecymbalsetcarenotatear-height.Experimentwithraisingorloweringthecymbalsasnecessarytoprotectthehearingofeveryonewhoiscloseby.Tryhangingsmallstripsofclothfromeachcymbal’scentrenut.
n Somedrumplayersarequitehappywithheadphones/in-earmonitorsandashakerratherthanatraditionaldrumfill.Theheadphonesshouldbeselectedtoprovidehearingprotection;thedevicesthatreproducesoundinsidetheheadphonesshouldbelimited.ThisalonemaysaveseveraldBofoverallstagelevel.
n Dampingdrumkitscanreduceoverallnoiselevels,especiallyinrehearsals.Methodsinclude:
Soundadvice Page69of144
Health and Safety Executive
– tapingsmallpiecesofclothorothersound-absorbentmaterialsinsidethedrumheads;
– placingrubberringsontopofthedrumheads;– tapingsmallpiecesofclothtotherimssothattheclothlieslooselyovertheskins;– stuffingfoamrubberinsidethedrumsorhangingitfromtheinsideofthe
drumheads;– stuffingthebassdrumwithapillow,towelorshreddednewspaper.
n Usescreenswhereappropriate,particularlywherethereisorchestralmusicsupporttothemainrockperformance.Careshouldbetakenwithacousticscreens,sincetheycanmakenoiselevelshigherifpositionedincorrectly(seeAppendix7‘Acousticscreens’)
On-stage monitoring21Theneedformusicianstoheartheirownperformanceandthatofotherperformersisfundamental,butthiscanleadtoanexcessivelyloudandconfusingstageenvironmentifnotplannedandmanagedcorrectly.Monitorsystemsareoftenusedasameansofovercominghighstagenoise,buteffortisbetterputintoreducingthoselevelstoachieveclarityratherthanboostingothersignals.22Onanoisystageitisveryseldomtheanswertoturnsomethinguptomakeitclearer.Alwaysstartbyturningdowntheoveralllevelandmakingadjustmentsinthebalance;thehumanearjustdoesn’tworkwellathighnoiselevels.So,forexample,someoneaskingtohearmorevocalinamixmaywelljustneedtohearlessofeverythingelse,especiallyifthatnoiseisspillfromothermonitormixes.
23Awell-balancedmonitorsystemshouldallowalltheplayerstohearwhattheyneedatacomfortablelevelwhilemaintainingareasonableworkenvironmentforeveryoneelseonthestage.Thisneedstimeandplanning,aswellasaskilfulmonitorengineerwhounderstandstheneedsofmusicians.Considerthefollowing:
n Positionspeakerstoprovideeffectivelisteninglevelstotheperformer(s)concernedwithoutcausingexcessivespill,whichmakesitharderforeveryoneelsetohearwhattheyneed.
n Thelayoutofperformersonthestagecanradicallyaffectthelevelsofexposurefromspillthatmusiciansexperience.Thereforecarefulplanningofthestagelayoutmayavoidtheneedfornoisecompetitionbetweenmonitormixesandothernoisesources.Theadviceofmonitorengineersatthisstageisvaluable.
n Monitorengineersshouldusetheirequipmentproperlyandsafely.Thismeans:
– resistingthetemptationtoallowstagelevelstocreepupwards;– ‘prepping’thesystemtoputtherightequipmentintherightplace;– ‘ringingout’ortuningthesystemtoidentifyproblemfrequencieswhichmay
causerapidandunexpectedfeedback.
n Allsoundchecksshouldbecarriedoutwiththeminimumnumberofpeoplepresent.
24 Perhapsthemosteffectivemeansofavoidingmonitorspillistousemonitorheadphonesorin-earmonitors(IEMs)(seeAppendix8).IEMsandmonitorheadphonesallowaveryquietstageenvironmentwithbenefitsforallworkers.IEMshavemanybenefitsincludingclarity,controllabilityandcomfort.ItshouldbenotedthatgenerallyIEMsandmonitorheadphonesarenotclassifiedaspersonalhearingprotection,andalthoughtheymayprovidesomeprotectionagainstexternalnoise,theirperformanceinthisrespectcannotbeguaranteed.TheuseoflimiterswithIEMsandwithmonitorheadphonesisstronglyrecommended.
Soundadvice Page70of144
Health and Safety Executive
CASE STUDY
Staff at a major music festival were exposed to very high noise levels without adequate care for their safety. There were more than 50 000 people present and two major outdoor stages. The following problems were found:
n Security staff were less than 1 m from the front of the bass speakers for the main stage.
n Food vans for the main stage were facing the stage and positioned close to the PA delays.
n There was no refuge from the noise. Sound levels in staff rest areas reached or exceeded 79 dB, and there were no quiet areas or refuges where staff were working.
n There was little or no evidence of control of the noise levels that the staff were exposed to, or limiting of the time spent in the noisy locations, or warning of the risks due to the noise.
n Hearing protection had been provided without training in how to use it. In some cases security staff receiving the highest exposures were choosing not to use any hearing protection.
n Hearing protection had not been considered for staff at the food outlets.
Commentary
n The use of noise control and hearing protection was inadequate.n Neither the event organiser nor the individual employers had carried out their
responsibilities under the Noise Regulations. n Under the Noise Regulations employers have a duty to protect their own
employees from the risks associated with high noise exposures. There is also a duty to protect other workers who are put at risk by their noisy activities.
n Exposure needs to be reduced by means other than hearing protection as outlined in this book. Where a risk still remains, the correct fitting and use of hearing protection needs to be enforced.
n Employees have a duty to use hearing protection provided for them if their exposure is likely to exceed 85 dB.
Table 7 Dailynoiseexposureforworkersatthefestival.
Job Location Hearing protection LEP,d dB
Paramedic Sideofmainstage Muffs 100
First-aider Tentatsideofmainstage Muffswhenoutsidetent 97
Foodservice ClosebyPAdelaysofmainstage None 100
Gatesecurity Sideofmainstage None 101
Gatesecurity Wheelchairareaformainstage None 95
Doorsecurity Secondaryvenuetent–1 None 99
Stagesecurity Secondaryvenuetent–1 Earplugs 108
Doorsecurity Secondaryvenuetent–2 None 103
Drummer Onstage None 104
Bassguitarist Onstage None 101
FOHsoundengineer Towerapproximately30mfromstage Earplugs 99
Monitorengineer Sideofstage,behindPA None 96
Soundadvice Page71of144
Health and Safety Executive
25 GoodworkingpracticeformonitorheadphoneandIEMusersincludes:
n Donotshareheadphones.Wherethiscannotbeavoided,giveuserstheirownearpadsandvoicetubes.
n Headphonesshouldbefullyadjustableandwell-maintained.n Headphonesorassociatedequipmentshouldincorporateanadjustablevolume
controlthatenablestheusertolistentoincomingsignalsatacomfortablelevel.n Cleanheadphonesregularly.Foampadscanbewashed,wipingcables
preventsthemfrombecomingbrittle,andcleaningvoicetubes(whichcanbecomeblockedwithfood,dustormake-up)ensurestheleveloftransmittedsignalsremainsaudible.
n Allowtimeforuserstomakeadjustmentstotheirequipment,andtocleanandmaintainit.
n Usersneedregulartrainingincludinghowtousetheheadphonesandassociatedequipment,anyvolume-controlfeaturesandwhyadjustmentofthelisteninglevelthroughtheheadphonesisimportant,aswellastheimportanceofregularcleaningandmaintenance.
n Reducingambientnoiselevelswillenableheadphoneuserstokeeplisteninglevelsaslowaspossible.
26 Similarbenefitsmaybeobtainedfromusingsmallpersonalmonitorspeakersthatcanbeplacednearaperformerratherthanrelyingonatraditionalwedgeorside-fillatadistance.TheseareparticularlyeffectiveforrelativelystaticperformerssuchaskeyboardsandDJs.
The off-stage environment
27 Highsoundlevelscanbeproducedthroughoutavenue,andthenoiseriskassessmentforaneventshouldidentifyallthepeoplewhoareatrisk,notjustthemusiciansorstagecrew.SeeThe event safety guideforguidanceonaudienceprotection.Considerthefollowing:
n Thechoiceandlocationofspeakerscansignificantlyaffectsoundlevels.Technicalstaffandworkingcrewetcshouldbeprotectedfromunnecessaryexposuretohighsoundlevels,forexamplebyensuringlightingdesksarenotplacednearloudspeakers.
n Re-orientatethestageand/orloudspeakerstodirectlesssoundtowardsstafflocations.Wheretherearemultiplespeakers,suchasindiscos,clubs,concerthallsortheatreauditoria,tryreducingthesoundlevelsofthosespeakersneareststafflocations.
n Thedispersionpatternofmodernspeakersenablesthe‘targeting’ofsectionsofthevenueoraudience,whichinturnmeansthelevelatthefrontofthecrowdcanbereduced.Thetotalpoweroutputfromthesoundsystem(foragivenaudiencesoundlevel)canbereducedbyusingalinearray.Theseloudspeakersystemseffectivelydirectsoundinanarrowbeamtoaudiencelocations,providingahigherqualitysound,withless‘spill’.Thekeyistoensurethatspeakers(whetherornottechnicallylinearray)arepositionedandalignedtoefficientlygetsoundtotheaudienceandavoideitheranexcessivelyhighsoundlevelatthefrontoftheaudienceorneedlessspillintosensitiveareas.
n Wherepossible,arrangestagesandloudspeakerpositionstoavoidexcessivesoundlevelsforbarstaff,stewardsandotherworkers.Whereavenuehasanumberofspeakerpositionsaroundthebuilding,considerthedirectionandvolumefromeachgroupofspeakers.Thosethatareclosetonoise-sensitivelocationssuchasthebarshouldbeindividuallycontrollable.Foroutdooreventsandfestivals,considerthenoiseimpacton,forexample,stewards,security,first-aiders,concessions(notjuststageproductionstaff/performers).
n PAsystemscanbeflownorstackedinsuchawayastointroduceanatural
Soundadvice Page72of144
Health and Safety Executive
separationbetweenspeakerenclosuresandstaff,makingitimpossibletogettooclosetothesoundsource–thisisparticularlyimportantforworkersinthestagepitandotherlocationsclosetospeakerstacks.Spillfromside-fillsandotheron-stagesourcescanalsobeaproblemforpitteams.
n Asimilareffectcanbeachievedbymeansofbarriersaroundspeakerpositions.Thisapproachisofparticularvaluewhenconsideringprotectionofthepublicandfront-of-housestaff.
n ‘Satellite’or‘delay’stacksarespeakerclustersplacedatsomedistanceintotheaudiencefromthemainspeakerpositionsandtowhichthesignalisdelayedtomakeitcoincidewiththesoundtravellingfromthemainspeakers.Thereforethesoundisreinforcedandintelligiblealongwaybackfromthestageandthelevelatthefrontcanbereducedbecausethenoisefromthosespeakersnolongerhastoreachallthewaytotheback.Thisisanexampleofhowgoodplanningcanbothtackleanoisehazardandenhancethepublicenjoymentofashow.
n Noiselimiterscanbeusedtosetamaximumpermissibleoutputlevelforthesoundsystem.Whilenormallyusedtomanagenoisepollutionfromavenue,thesameset-upcouldbeemployedtolimitthemaximumfront-of-houseorstagesoundoutput.
n AtfestivalsitesconcessionsandothercommercialoperationsoftenhavetheirownPAsystems.Theeventorganisershouldensurethattheoutputofsuchsystemsismanagedalongagreedguidelinestakingaccountofthepotentialcombinedeffectofseveralsystems,tominimisethenoiseexposureofemployeesonsite,includingthoseworkingonconcessions’stalls.
n Ifradioheadsetsareinuse,theyshouldprovidehearingprotectionandbelimited(seeSoundAdvice9‘Studios’).
Stage pits28 Onlargepopconcertstagesandoutdooreventsitiscommontofindafencelinerestrainingthecrowdafewmetresinfrontofthestageitself.Thisisthe‘pitbarrier’andcreatesanareacalledthe‘stagepit’inwhichstewards,securityandwelfarestaffcanhelpthecrowd–andwhichcommonlyhostsphotographersandmediacrew.Thenoiselevelsfoundinevensmallstagepitsaresohighthatstaffareliabletoexposurewellaboveeitherupperexposureactionvalue–eveniftheyareonlypresentforabriefperiod(speakerandaudiencenoisetogethercaneasilyexceed120dB).
29 Stagepitsshouldbehearingprotectionzoneswithaccessonlygrantedtoauthorisedpersonnelequippedwithappropriatehearingprotection.
Pre-show sound checks and schedules
30 Carefulplanningmaymeansometaskscanbecompletedwhenthereisnonoisehazard,forexampleensuringthatlightingfocusingandsoundcheckingarecarriedoutatdifferenttimes.
31 Soundchecksareavitalpartoftheeventset-upprocess,buttheyarealsoamechanismbywhichtechniciansandplayersreceiveadditionalexposuretohighnoise,particularlyifthesoundcheckisnotproperlymanaged.Ideallyinstrumentswillbeindividuallycheckedatarealisticvolumeandthenanensemblepieceplayedatfullconcertlevelwhichcanusuallybesetataloweron-stagevolume.Asoundcheckatfullconcertlevelsshouldonlybenecessaryforbalancingsoundlevels,asdistinctfromrehearsalsorlastminuterun-throughsofsets.
Soundadvice Page73of144
Health and Safety Executive
Figure 9 Exampleofanoutdoormusiceventshowingreferencepositionsfornoisemeasurement
32 Fromanoiseexposureperspectiveitisessentialtolimitboththedurationandvolumeofsoundchecks.Similarly,limitingthenumberofnon-essentialpersonnelonstageandintheauditoriumduringasoundcheckwillhavetime-managementaswellasnoise-exposurebenefits.Everyvenueoreventshouldhavesomewherequietformusiciansandcrewtotakebreaksorrestperiods.
33 Thesoundcheckisagoodopportunitytoidentifyanyunexpectedorparticularlytroublesomenoiseelements.Thiscouldbeachievedbymonitoringsoundlevelsatspecificrepresentativereferencepositions(seeFigure9).
34 Rememberthatthesoundcheckisnotsolelyforthepurposeofmusicians–itisoftentheonlyopportunityforfront-of-houseandmonitorengineerstosettheirsystemstoachieveanoptimummixandsafeplaybacklevels.
35 Awarenessofloudnoiseasdangerousmeansthatcrewshouldonlybeintheimmediatevicinityofthestageduringnoisyperiodsiftheirjobspecificallyrequiresit.Thestageshouldnotbeusedasaviewingplatformorrestareaforoff-dutycrew.Itisahigh-riskenvironmenttowhichaccessmustbestrictlycontrolled.
36 Thewayinwhichworktasksarescheduledcanhaveasignificantimpactonpersonalnoiseexposureovertime.Whenplanningtheindividualwork,aload-inandshow,orevenanentiretour,considerwhen,whereandtowhomnoiseexposureswilloccur.Organisetheworktoensurethatpersonalnoisedosesarekeptaslowasreasonablypracticable.Thismightbeachievedby:
First aid
First aid
SecuritySecurity
Catering
Key: Sound monitor reference point
Security
Catering
Security
Backstage
Restricted access
Stage
Audience area
Lighting, mixing and filming
7
1
3 2
4
Monitorposition6 5
Soundadvice Page74of144
Health and Safety Executive
n balancingloudandquietactivitiesforexample,showandoffsiteduties;n ensuringthatstafftakebreaksandrestperiodsawayfromloudnoiseareas;n rotatingstafftolimitexposuretime(particularlyusefulforstewardsandsecurity
staff);n limitinganyrecordedmusictopredeterminedlevels,andmonitoringand
controllingit.Keeprecordedmusicaslowaspracticable,especiallybetweenacts,toreduceoverallexposure;
n venuemanagersschedulingshowstoensurethatstaffhaveabalancebetweenloudandmoremoderateevents.
Soundadvice Page75of144
Health and Safety Executive
Figure 10 Anoiseriskassessmentmethodforplanningarock/popevent
Soundadvice Page76of144
Health and Safety Executive
5 Pubs and clubs Amplified music played in nightclubs, bars, pubs and restaurants
Overview
ExposuretonoiseDesignManagementLiveperformers
Exposure to noise
1 Thissectionprovidesadviceonmethodsofcontrollingtheriskofhearinglossinvenueswhereamplifiedmusicisplayed,includingnightclubs,bars,pubsandrestaurants.Inmostindustriesnoiseisanunwantedby-product.However,highsoundlevelsoftenprovidetheprincipalstimulusforcustomerstoattendapuborclub.Itisimportanttorememberthatallemployees,includinganyguestperformers,arecoveredbytheNoiseRegulationsandemployershaveresponsibilitiestoprotecttheiremployees’hearing.Self-employedpeopleshouldalsoreadSoundAdvice1‘Freelancers’.Anoiseriskassessmentflowchartforpubsandclubsisshownattheendofthesection.
2 ThereisastronglikelihoodthatworkersinvenuesplayingamplifiedmusicwillbeexposedtonoiselevelsatorabovetheupperexposureactionvalueoftheNoiseRegulations.ForrepresentativeexposurelevelsseeTable8.Rememberthatnosinglemeasurewillbeappropriateforeverysituationanditisimportanttoidentifytheactionsthatwillbestcontroltherisk.
Design
3 Methodsofreducingnoiseinworkareascanbesplitintotwocategories–physicalseparationandfocusingthemusicinthedesiredlocations.Architects/designersandowners/operatorsproposingnewbuildingsorrefurbishmentsshouldconsultcompetentacousticiansand/orsoundengineersbeforeundertakinganymajorwork.SeealsoSoundAdvice2‘Venues’.
4 Thenoiseinavenueismadeupofthreecomponents:thedirectpathistheuninterruptedpathbetweentheloudspeakersandtheear,thereverberantpathisthesoundreflectedoffoneormoresurfaces,andthestructuralpathisthroughthefixingsandmountings.Thecarefulpositioningofloudspeakersmayreducedirectexposureandisolationmountingsmaybeneededtoreducestructurallytransmittednoise.However,manynoise-controlmeasuresaimtoreducereflectedsound.Thismaybeachievedbyacousticabsorptiontocontrolthereverberantpaths.Notetheabsorptioncanalsoimprovethequalityofthereproductionofthemusic.
Soundadvice Page77of144
Health and Safety Executive
Figure 11 Thethreecomponentsofnoise
Table 8 Representativeexposurelevelsinclubs
5 Itisimportantthatthematerialsusedmeettherequiredstandardsofflameretardancyandflamepropagation.
Physical separation6 Thesetechniqueshelpseparatestafffromthemusic:
n Positionbarsawayfromthedancefloorandperformanceareas.n Providestaffoff-dutyareaswithnoiselevelsbelow80dB.n Locatebarsinquietareasor‘chill-out’roomswherethenoiselevelsare
preferablybelow80dB.
Occupation dB
Barstaff 89–99
Glasscollectors 90–100
Waiters 102
DJs 93–99
Lightingtechnician 104
Security 97
Door 84
Dancefloor 94–104
Inthisexampletheemployermust:
n Assesstheriskstoeveryemployeefromnoise.n Takeactiontoreducethenoiseexposurethat
producestherisk.n Makesurethelegallimitsonnoiseexposureare
notexceeded.n Providehearingprotectionandensureitis
worn.n Provideinformation,instructionandtraining.n Carryouthealthsurveillance.
FormoreinformationseePart1.
Source of sound
Reflected
Direct
Structure
Soundadvice Page78of144
Health and Safety Executive
n Acousticscreeningcanbehelpfultoprotectspecificworkersandlocationsfromdirectnoisesources,forexample,technicians,barstaff,frontofhouse.Theeffectivenessofscreensdependsontheirdesignandlocation(s)whichneedtobecarefullyconsidered.
Focusing the music7 Successfulnoisecontrolrequiresthemusictobefocusedwhereitiswanted(suchasthedancefloorortheperformancearea).Thefollowingtechniquescanhelptofocusthemusicandthereforereducethenoiselevelsawayfromthedancefloororperformancearea:
n Useequipmentwhichavoidsdistortionandallowsvolumelevelstobesetlowerwhileachievingthedesiredeffect.
n Directionalspeakerscanbehelpfultofocussoundawayfromsensitiveareastowhereitiswanted,forexampleoverthedancefloorusingloudspeakersmountedintheceilingandfacingdownwards.
n Increasethenumberofdirectionalloudspeakerstoavoid‘hot-spots’.n Installvibrationisolationmountstoloudspeakerstopreventnoiseenteringthe
buildingstructure.n Avoidperipheralloudspeakersorreducetheirvolumeiftheycannotbe
avoided.n Donothaveloudspeakerspointingtowardthebarorotherfixedwork
locations.
Figure 12 Exampleofapub/clublayoutshowingreferencepositionsfornoisemeasurement
Management
8 Venueoperatorsareencouragedtodevelopawrittennoise-exposurepolicy.Thisdocumentshouldaimtoprovideclearmessagesregardingthecontrolofnoiseinthevenuetoallstaffandsubcontractors(seealsoSoundAdvice2‘Venues’).Itshouldalsoincludepoliciesonthefollowing:
n levelsettingandmonitoring;n exposuremanagement;n maintenance;n information,instructionandtraining;n hearingprotection;n healthsurveillance.
BARDJ
DANCEFLOOR
LOBBY
1
5
2
4
3
Key: Sound monitor reference point
Quiet zoneand seating
Soundadvice Page79of144
Health and Safety Executive
Level setting 9 Theexposureofemployeestonoiselevelswilldependonthevolumeofmusicplayedaswellasthedurationandproximityofthenoisesource.Therewillbeinstanceswherethevolumeneedstobecontrolledbysettingmaximumlevels.Thisisusuallydonebytheuseoflimiters,andmanyclubsandpubswillalreadybeawareoftheiruseforreducingnoisebreakoutaspartofthelicensingprocedureandlocalnuisancecontrol.
10 Wherenoise-volume-limitingdevicesareusedforreducingexposuretoemployees,theresponsibilityandabilitytoalterthemaximumlevelshouldbeclearlyidentifiedinthenoise-exposurepolicy.Thepolicyshouldalsobeclearlycommunicatedtoallpeoplewhohavethemeanstoadjustlevelsuptothemaximumduringevents(forexampledutymanagers,DJs,musiciansandtechnicians).
CASE STUDY Nightclub refurbishment
Refurbishment of two nightclubs in one building provided an opportunity to re-design them with the aim of reducing the employees’ exposure to noise. Before the refurbishment the clubs had very little acoustic absorption in them and the lack of space made it difficult to introduce a quiet zone.
The following design changes were introduced as part of the refurbishment:
n A bar was moved to increase the distance between it and the dance floor.n All loudspeakers were oriented so they faced away from the bars.n Acoustic absorbent tiles were placed on the ceiling.n Acoustic absorbent material was placed on as much wall area of the club as
possible (durable coatings near the floor, spray coatings nearer the ceilings).n Areas were finished with mineral wool absorbers behind galvanised
perforated sheet steel.n A large toughened glass screen was positioned at one end of a bar to shield
it from the dance floor.n Vibration isolation was used to isolate the bass bins (loudspeakers).n Narrow directivity loudspeakers were mounted in the ceiling above the dance
floor and positioned pointing down.n A DJ console was created which also acted as a screen for a bar behind.n The sound system was used to carefully equalise the music and set at a
level of 103 dB on the dance floor.
The measured daily noise exposure before and after the refurbishment was:
Before After refurbishment refurbishment LEP,d dB LEP,d dB
Bar staff 90.3–95.9 86.6–89.1Glass collectors 95.2–98.1 94.5–97.0DJ 98.6–99.8 97.3–98.2
A significant reduction in the exposures of bar staff was achieved, however, hearing protection was still required. Glass collectors were required to wear hearing protection and DJs were encouraged to avoid using monitor loudspeakers and to use earmuffs with sound restoration or in-ear monitors.
Soundadvice Page80of144
Health and Safety Executive
11 Karaokesystemsshouldhavein-builtnoiselimitersastheyareusedbymembersofthepublicwhoarenotcoveredbymanagementnoisepolicies.
12 Whererequired,thechoiceofnoiselimiterwilldependonthetypeofequipmenttobecontrolled:
n Wherethevenuehasapurpose-builtamplificationandspeakersystemthenoiselevelcanbecontrolledbymeasuringaverageoutputagainstasetthreshold.Thislevelcannotbeexceededand,asthequalityofsoundoutputcanbemaintained,thereislesslikelihoodofpublicawarenessofcontrol.
n Wherecontrolofthelevelisnotdirectlyunderthecontrolofthemanagement,viaapurpose-builtsystem,thenthelimiterwillrelyonamicrophonepickingupnoiselevelsandifapresetlevelisexceeded,thepowersupplytothenoise-generatingsourceiscutoff.Thisisusuallydonethroughaseriesofwarninglights.Thissystemrequiresstrictmanagementcontroltoavoidanypossibleconsequencesofanabrupttermination.Thesetypesoflimitersareoftenusedbypeopleinchargeofvenueswhereperformers,forexampleguestDJs,supplytheirownequipment.
n Allnoiselimitersshouldbetamper-prooforlocatedinsecureareas.
Monitoring13 Wherespotchecksofthenoiselevelsarebeingusedaspartofanassessmenttheyshouldbeatpredeterminedreferencepositionstoallowdirectcomparisonsbetweendifferentsituations.Thiswillalsoallowforotherrepresentativeexposurecalculationstobecarriedoutifnecessary.
Exposure management14 Managingexposuretonoisecouldinclude:
n Limitingthetimestaffspendinnoisyareas.n Rotatingstaffbetweennoisyandquietareasandrotationbetweenquietand
noisyshifts.Taskrotationcanprovidesomereductioninexposurewherethereareworkstationsinquietareas.Managementshouldhaveenoughcontrolandadministrationtodemonstratehowthesystemsafeguardsstaffandshouldexplainthepurposeofanyrotationsystemtostaff.
n Providingregular‘quietbreaks’andperiodsworkinginquietareas.
15 TheNoiseRegulationsallowthenoiseexposuretobeassessedoveraweekratherthanadayincertaincircumstances(seeAppendix4).
Maintenance16 Soundequipmentdoesdeteriorateandshouldbeproperlycheckedandmaintained.Noteinparticularthereisatendencytoincreasethevolumeifthemusicsystemisdistorting.
17 Equipmentsuchasnoiselimiters,acousticscreens,soundabsorbersandvibrationisolationmountsshouldalsobekeptingoodworkingorder.
Information, instruction and training18 Employeesneedtounderstandtheriskofhearinglossandhowitisbeingcontrolled,includingtheproperuseofhearingprotection.Individualswhohaveinfluenceoverthenoiselevels(dutymanagers,DJs,musiciansandtechnicians)needtounderstandtheirresponsibilities.
Hearing protection19 See‘Personalhearingprotection’inPart1.
Soundadvice Page81of144
Health and Safety Executive
Health surveillance20 See‘Hearinghealthsurveillance’inPart1.
Live performers
21 Anyvenuethatengagesperformers,suchasmusiciansorDJs,shouldhaveaformalcontractualrelationshipwiththeperformer(s)andanyoneelseinvolvedsuchasanagentorafixer.Thecontractshould,amongothermatters,identifytheresponsibilitiesofallpartiesundertheNoiseRegulations.SeealsoAppendix2‘Contracts’.
22 Manyvenues,inparticularsmallpubs,donotissuewrittencontractswhenengagingperformers.Howeverallvenuesshouldconsiderthisproceduretoensurethattheengager/contractorandtheperformersarefullyawareoftheresponsibilitiesofboththevenueoperatorandtheperformer(s).
EXAMPLE DJ harmed
A 24-year-old DJ related that one night, after working in a club where the sound system was particularly loud, he went home with a ringing sensation that was so bad it took several days for his ears to recover. The ringing in one ear (tinnitus) has never completely stopped. He has become very sensitive to loud music, particularly high frequencies, and his tinnitus increases dramatically if exposed to loud noise. He is now careful always to wear earplugs when DJ-ing.
23 Visitingperformersshouldbeencouragedtousethein-housePAsystemratherthansettinguptheirowntemporaryarrangements,whichmaymakeitmoredifficultformanagementtocontrolnoiseexposure.
24 Between‘sets’performersshouldbeencouragedtomovetoaquietarea.Whenarrangingforlive‘gigs’,ensurethatsupportacts,suchasDJs,discoorkaraoke,arearrangedsothattheywillnotcontributetoexcessivenoiseexposure.
Soundadvice Page82of144
Health and Safety Executive
Figure 13 Anoiseriskassessmentmethodforapub/clubevent
Soundadvice Page83of144
Health and Safety Executive
6 Orchestras Symphony orchestras, chamber orchestras, bands and other ensemblesOverview
BackgroundNoiseriskassessmentsfororchestrasSchedulingVenueLayoutScreensPersonalhearingprotectionReferencepositions
Background
1 Mostorchestraswillrequirecontrolmeasuresasmostmusicalinstrumentshavethepotentialtoproducehazardousnoiselevels.RepresentativenoiselevelscanbefoundinTable9.Anoiseriskassessmentflowchartforatypicalorchestraisshownattheendofthesection.AdditionalguidancecanbefoundinSoundAdvice7‘Orchestrapits’andSoundAdvice8‘Stagebands’.
2 Bycarryingoutanoiseriskassessmentbasedonnoisemeasurementsorotheravailableinformation,theextentoftheproblemcanbeestablishedandwillallowthedevelopmentofaplanforcontrollingthenoiseexposure.
3 Excitementinmusicalperformanceisnotachievedbyvolumealone.Constantloudvolumemaybecomemonotonousandispotentiallydamagingtobothperformerandlistener.Dramaiscreatedbydynamiccontrast,whichcanbeachievedwithareductioningeneralvolumelevelsthatwouldnotbenoticedbytheaudience.Thisrepresentsaculturechangeandmayrequiregreaterefforttoachievethesofterlevelsneededtomaintaintherangeofdynamiccontrast.
4 Table10aimstodemonstratehowlongitwouldtakeforasymphonyorchestraplayerorsingertobeexposedtotheupperexposureactionvalueof85dBifplayingatypicalrepertoire,forexamplebycomposerssuchasHaydn,SchubertorVaughanWilliams.
5 Studiesindicatethatorchestralmusicianscanreachtheupperexposureactionvaluebyplayingforaslittleas10–25hoursperweek.
Noise risk assessments for orchestras
6 Assessmentshouldbeginwhenplanningaseasonorconcert,andcontinuerightuptothemomentwhenthemusicstarts–whenitswitchestomonitoringtheeffectivenessofthecontrolmeasures.Someorchestras,whererepertoireandvenue(s)areconsistentforaperiod,areabletobasetheirnoiseriskassessmentsonpreviousnoisemeasurements.Othersmaybeabletouseexistingnoisemeasurementsasapointofreference,andmayfinditusefultotakenoisemeasurementsaspartoftheirmonitoring.AdditionalmaterialonnoisemeasurementcanbeobtainedfromA sound ear IIthroughtheABO11andAppendix5‘Measuringnoise’.
Soundadvice Page84of144
Health and Safety Executive
Noise source dB Peak
Single musicians
Violin/viola(nearleftear) 85–105 116
Violin/viola 80–90* 104
Cello 80–104* 112
Acousticbass 70–94* 98
Clarinet 68–82* 112
Oboe 74–102* 116
Saxophone 75–110* 113
Flute 92–105* 109
Flute(nearrightear) 98–114 118
Piccolo 96–112* 120
Piccolo(nearrightear) 102–118* 126
Frenchhorn 92–104* 107
Trombone 90–106* 109
Trumpet 88–108* 113
Harp 90 111
Timpaniandbassdrum 74–94* 106
Percussion(high-hatnearleftear) 68–94 125
Percussion 90–105 123–134
Singer 70–85* 94
Soprano 105–110 118
Choir 86 Nodata
Normalpianopractice 60–90* 105
Loudpiano 70–105* 110
Keyboards(electric) 60–110* 118
Several musicians
Chambermusic(classical) 70–92* 99
Symphonicmusic 86–102* 120–137
*at3m
Note:Theserepresentativenoiselevelsarecollatedfromarangeofsources.Theygiveanindicationofthevarietyofnoiselevelsandnoisepeaksthatmusiciansandotherworkerscanreceivefromtheinstrumentsconcerned.Thisinformationmaybehelpfulwithestimatingnoiseexposureandinidentifyingpotentialnoise‘hotspots’.However,asshown,manyoftheinstrumentscanexhibitarangeofnoiselevelsdependingonhowloudlytheyareplayed,forhowlongandunderwhatcircumstances(egrepertoire,venue,numberofinstrumentsconcerned).Donotonlyusethisinformationforariskassessmentbutlookat‘Riskassessmentandplanning’inPart1andanyotherrelevantsectorguide(s).
Table 9 Representativenioselevels
Soundadvice Page85of144
Health and Safety Executive
7 Thestartingpointforanoiseriskassessmentmaybebasedonthefollowing:
n Knowledgeofthevenue–itsacoustic,space,restrictionsandresources.n Knowledgeofthevariousworkstobeplayed–peakvolume,lengthand
analysisofthescoresforextremechangesindynamics(changeinvolume,timbre,tempo),instrumentation(numbersofeachinstrumentrequired)andconcentrationsofenergy.
n Layoutofplayers–thenumberandconfigurationofmusicians,forexamplehowmanybrassorplacementofpercussion?
n Knowledgeoftheindividualsinvolved–conductors(Dotheylikemusicloud?Dotheyrehearsealot?),soloists(Aretheynoisy?Dotheyplayloudinstruments?)andcomposers(ifavailable).
n Thenoiseeffectsofspecificinstruments.n Isamplificationinvolved?n Arethereanyspecialeffectsorpyrotechnics–isthe1812 Overturetobe
performed?
8 Noiseriskassessmentshelpestablishwhoisatriskandidentifywaystopreventandprotectpeoplefromhearingdamage.Communicationofthefindingsfromnoiseriskassessmentsincreasesawarenessamongplayers,conductorsandcomposersaboutpossiblenoise-inducedhearingdamageandencourageseveryonetomoderatedemandsforever-louderplaying.Ensurethatstagemanagersandorchestraportersareincludedinawarenesstraining.Noiseriskassessmentswillidentifyareasofgreatestrisk,whichshouldbethepriorityforcontrol.
Scheduling
9 Schedulingcanhelpreducenoiseexposure:
n Programmeaquieterrepertoire.n Matchthevenue(s)withtheprogramme.n Programmeconcertswithabalancedquiet/loudrepertoire.n Schedulerehearsalswithabalancedquiet/loudrepertoire.
dB
82 16hours egviolin
85 8hours egharp
88 4hours egtrumpet
91 2hours egtrombone/Frenchhorn
94 1hour egloudpiano
97 30minutes egloudsoprano
100 15minutes
103 7.5minutes
137dB(peak) Maximuminstantaneouspeaknoisewhenwearinghearingprotection
Notethatthepeaknoisefrompercussion,egsnaredrumorcymbalclash,mayexceedthe137dBupperexposureactionvalue.
Table 10 Examplesofhowlongitmighttakeforaplayertobeexposedtotheupperexposureactionvalueof85dBifplayingatthelevelofatypicalsymphonyperformance
Soundadvice Page86of144
Health and Safety Executive
n Allocatenoisyinstruments/passagesintoseparatepartsofrehearsals.n Allowtimeforadjustments.n Allowtimeforplayers’earstorecoverfromnoiseexposure.n Matchtheprogrammewiththevenue.
Venue
10 Modificationstothevenuecanhelpreducenoiseexposure:
n Installspecially-designedacousticpanellingandfloorcoveringinfrequently-usedrehearsalandperformancespaces;lowandmediumfrequencyacousticabsorptioninpitsorrehearsalroomsimprovesclarityandreducesexposures.
n Installadjustableacousticpanels,curtainsanddrapesinvenuesandusethesetoachievelowernoiselevels.
n Makeuseofexistinginstalledacousticpanelssuchasroofpanelswhichmaynotbeapparent.
n Considerextendingthestage(useanapron)toincreasethespaceavailableforperformers.
n Trytokeepacleargapatthefrontoftheplatform–thefloorsurfacemayhelpreflectthehigherfrequenciestowardstheaudience.Thismayallowplayers,particularlythestrings,toplayataslightlylowerlevel.
n Ensurethatriserswithmorevariedheightsandwidthsareavailable.n Improveprojection–ifyoucanreducetheamountofenergylossbetweenthe
instrumentandtheaudience/conductor,thenyoucanreducethepowerthataplayerneedstogenerate.
n Don’toverdospecialeffectsinperformance.Selectthequietestpossiblepyrotechnicstoachievethedesiredeffect.
n Useearplugsasalastresort–see‘Personalhearingprotection’inPart1.n Remember,thesolutioninonevenuemaynotworkinanother.Trytohavea
varietyofnoise-controlmeasuresavailable,asacollectionofsmalladjustmentsmayadduptoasignificantreductioninnoiseexposure.Each3dBofreductioninthenoiselevelmeanshalfthenoiseexposure.
n Reducevolume/poweroutput.n Ensureconductorsareawareofthehousepolicyonnoisecontrol.
EXAMPLE
Soundadvice Page87of144
Health and Safety Executive
How a conductor can help
The conductor can play a vital part in helping to lower musicians’ noise exposure in line with the Noise Regulations. It can be beneficial to understand the common rehearsal and performance practices that can greatly impact on a musician’s noise exposure. Some of these control measures could include:
n Rather than rehearsing the full orchestra, a conductor may choose to undertake sectional rehearsals when they have detailed work with one or more sections of the orchestra.
n Exploring a greater range of dynamics within the orchestra to create excitement in the variance between a piano and forte marking rather than going for fortissimo could be of benefit.
n Performing with the orchestra in a number of varying layouts which will give sections occasional respite from traditional ‘noisy’ areas of the orchestra helps share the load.
n During rehearsals, once the desired effect has been achieved, allowing the orchestra to play under the marked dynamic.
n Avoiding unnecessarily rehearsing very loud sections of the score repeatedly.n In a full orchestral rehearsal, while making corrections, only working with those
particular players or sections who need to be playing at the time and avoid asking other instruments to play.
When programming a concert or a series, a conductor can also be aware that musicians’ exposure is measured over a weekly average, so if they were able to programme larger, noisier works balanced out with smaller or quieter pieces, this could reduce noise exposure for their performers. It is also beneficial for an opera and ballet orchestra to rehearse in a space outside the orchestra pit, giving more ambient space to allow sound to escape. Generally the conductor has considerable control over the whole noise output of the orchestra and is able to improve conditions for musicians by being aware of what they are asking of their orchestra.
Layout
11 Plantheseatinglayouttominimiseproblemswithnoiseexposure:
n Ifthereisroom,separateperformersfromoneanother.Anaveragespaceof1.7m2perpersonisadequatebut2m2spaceisbetter.Trytobuildupwardsratherthanout,asthishelpstomaintaincontactbetweenplayersandkeepsthesidesandbackoftheorchestrainclosercontactwiththeconductor.
n Avoidputtingplayersunderanoverhangasthisislikelytoincreasenoiseexposure.
n Placebrassandwoodwindonriserstohelpthemprojecttheirsound.Theywillnotneedtoworksohardtoproducetheirsound.
n Donotputonerowofnoisyinstrumentsinfrontofanothernoisyrow,unlessthebackrowishighenoughtoplayovertheheadsoftheplayersinfront.
n Onflatstagestrystaggeringseatingsothatamusicianisnotplayingdirectlyintothebackoftheplayerinfront.
n Itmaybepossibletorotatetheseatingpositionswithinsomesectionsoftheorchestraandsharetheexposureofsittingnearnoisyneighbours.
n Ifthereisroom,leaveacoupleofmetresbetweenthepercussionsectionandotherperformers.Avoidhavingside-drumheadsandsuspendedcymbalslevelwiththeearoftheplayersseatedinfront.
n Usefold-backspeakerswithcaution.n Meetwiththeconductortoexplainthenoise-controlstrategies.n Forsomeprogrammesitmaybepossibletohavethenoisiestinstruments
inoneareaofthestage.Therestoftheperformerscanberemotefromthatgrouporbeprotectedbythecarefuluseofscreens,minimisingtheirexposure.However,noisemeasurementsmaybenecessarytoensurethatyouarenotplacingthemusiciansinthenoisyareaatextremerisk.
Soundadvice Page88of144
Health and Safety Executive
Woodwind12Allowaclearpathbetweentheaudienceandthewoodwind–thisinvolvesplacingthewoodwindplayersonrisersandmayrequireanevengreaterelevationforthebrass.
Horns13 Useadjustablebafflesbehindthehorns–thisimprovestheforwardprojectionoftheirsound,sotheydon’thavetoplayasloudly.
Brass14 Theuseofriserstoelevatebrasssectionsmayhelptoprojecttheirsound,whichishighlydirectional,overtheheadsoftheperformersinfrontofthem(seeAppendix6‘Risers’).
Screens
15 Iftheabovemeasuresareinsufficient,considerusingscreens(seeAppendix7‘Acousticscreens’).
Personal hearing protection
16 If,afterputtinginplacealltheappropriatecontrolmeasures,theexposureislikelytobeatorgreaterthantheupperexposureactionvalue,personalhearingprotectionmustbeused.Inothersituationsitsusemayberecommended.SeePart1‘Personalhearingprotection’.
17 SomewoodwindplayersmaythinktheyhavenaturalprotectionbyusingtheValsalvamanoeuvre(thecreationofaslightpositivemiddle-earpressurewhenblowingawoodwindorbrassinstrument),however,thiscannotbeconsideredasanalternativetousinghearingprotection.
Reference positions
18 Referencepositionsfortakingnoisemeasurementscanbeusefulfororchestras,especiallywhentouring,tohelpassesswhethersoundlevelsareundercontrol(seeFigure14).
Soundadvice Page89of144
Health and Safety Executive
CASE STUDY Symphony orchestra noise measurements
The orchestra management arranged for a noise assessment of individual members of the orchestra. Measurements were made during rehearsals. The musical repertoire being rehearsed at the time of this noise assessment was:
Vaughan Williams A London Symphony
Haydn Symphony No. 104 in D Major, ‘London’
Schumann A Song of Orpheus
These were considered by members of the orchestra to be relatively quiet works.
80% of the musicians wore individual dosemeters mounted on clothing as close to the ear as practical.
Other measurements were made by sound level meters (SLMs) positioned in strategic locations. These were:
n just behind and to the left of the conductor;n at the centre front of the auditorium (balcony);n where the double basses would normally sit (for this rehearsal they were in
the centre of the rostra at the rear of the orchestra).
Each SLM was mounted on a tripod, with the microphone positioned at about head height (when seated) and pointing towards the middle of the orchestra.
Key: Sound monitor reference point
1
7
5
6
4
3
2
Woodwind Brass
Percussion
Violas
Double bass
2nd Violins
Cellos1s
t Vio
lins
Timpani
Percussion
Brass
Piano/keyboard
Conductor
Harps
Figure 14 Exampleofanorchestrallayoutshowingreferencepositionsfornoisemeasurement
Soundadvice Page90of144
Health and Safety Executive
The key findings were:
Dosemeters resultsTotal number of musicians with valid results 66Number for whom LEP,d exceeded upper 26exposure action value (85 dB)Highest recorded LEP,d 93 dBHighest recorded LAeq 98 dB
The highest recorded sound levels tended to centre on the brass and woodwind sections, followed by percussion and timpani.
SLMs results over 6h 47m LEP,d dB LAeq dBAuditorium 76 76Conductor 79 80Bass section 80 81
Conclusions
n A significant proportion (over 30%) of the musicians received a noise exposure in excess of the upper exposure action value of 85 dB during rehearsals of what were considered to be relatively ‘quiet’ works.
n Control measures should be implemented and hearing protection worn until the control measures are shown to be effective.
EXAMPLE
Planning concert layouts
The variation of layouts is one of the more effective control measures available, by providing the appropriate distance and height between players at different times. The input and co-operation of the conductor is essential as this enables the orchestra to address the issues as they develop and, with monitoring, vary the layouts of the orchestra. This has the added bonus of providing opportunities for artistic experimentation.
It would be relatively straightforward to vary layouts between concerts were the orchestra to perform only in its home venue. However it is important to consider the idiosyncrasies and unsuitability of some of the stages where the orchestra is repeating all or part of a programme. These engagements are crucial and repeating programmes happen frequently. It would be unfair on conductors and the musicians to change the layout after significant preparation at the home venue and, for this reason, the knowledge and experience of the players of these smaller venues is crucial. Reaching a balance, therefore, usually requires compromise on all fronts.
Two examples are shown in Figures 15 and 16. Note risers are provided with their heights marked. Another layout for an orchestra/pop group during a recording session is in Sound Advice 9 ‘Studios’.
Soundadvice Page91of144
Health and Safety Executive
Musical Director1st violins 1st violins
Cellos
Doublebasses
Doublebasses
2nd violins
2nd violins
Harps
ViolasViolas
Flutes
Clarinets
Oboes
Bassoons
Trumpets
Trombones
Tuba
Horns Percussion
6 ftstage
extension
Keyboard
Riser at 3 ft
Riser at 1 ft
Riser at 2 ft
Riser at 3 ft
Riser at 1 ft
Riser at 2 ft
Figure 15 ExampleorchestralayoutfromRoyalFestivalHall,pre-2007
Note: tobemoreeffectivetheriserheightsforthetrumpetsshouldbeatleast2ft
Soundadvice Page92of144
Health and Safety Executive
Timpani
Percussion
Singers
Congas
Keys
Keys
Keys
1st violins
Flutes Clarinet
Guitars
Bass guitars
Bassguitar
Guitar
Trumpet
CelloTrombone
24 ft x 20 ftHeight 8 in
Musical Director1st violins
2nd violins
Cellos
Violas
Celeste
Bassoons
OboesFlutes
ClarinetsHorns Horns
Harp
Trombones
Trumpets
Tuba
Choir
Step 4 ftFront chorus rostra 4 ft 6 inBack chorus rostra 5 ft
Riser height1 ft
Riser height6 in
Rostra height3ft
Rostra height1 ft
Rostra height2 ft
Screen
Percussion
Doublebasses
Figure 16 Examplelayoutfrom‘MusicLab’,aneducationalprogrammeinvolvingprofessionalandamateurmusicians
Soundadvice Page93of144
Health and Safety Executive
Figure 17 Anoiseriskassessmentmethodfororchestras
Sound advice: Control of noise at work in music and entertainment
66
6
YES
NOT SURENO/
Is the
personal noisedose likely to be below
the lower exposure action values for everyone
involved?
YES
Isthere an
existing noiserisk assessment and
is it still valid?
Will the
personal noise dose be below the
upper exposure action values for everyone
involved?
Consider revising the schedule/programme.
Review noise risk assessment before each major change of programme/repertoire/venue and at least every 2 years.
At early planning stage consider:
Who? Where? What?
You are the manager responsible for an orchestra
NOT SURENO/
YES
NO
YES
NO NO YES
Will the
personal noise dose be below the
upper exposure action values for everyone
involved?
Will the
personal noisedose be below the
lower exposure action values for everyone
involved?
Will the
personal noisedose be below the
exposure limit valuesfor everyone
involved?
Immediately reduce noise exposure and/or provide suffi cient and appropriate
hearing protection.
Establish and instigate action plan. Implement control measures.
YES
Implement health surveillance for any employees susceptible to noise. Make hearing protection available.*
Implement health surveillance. Provide hearing protection and ensure it is worn.
Establish maintenance programme for all noise-reduction measures including hearing protection. Provide training.
Record the noise risk assessment.
NO
Assess the effectiveness of any control measures. Monitor noise levels, if required.
Is the
personal noisedose likely to be below
the lower exposure action values for everyone
involved?
YESImplement further control measures and assess noise exposure. NB Hearing protection is NOT a control measure.
NOT SURENO/
*NB Specialist hearing protection is available for
staff who need to communicate or for
performers who need to hear each other as part of
the job.
Record signifi cant fi ndings and actions at every stage
Figure 17 A noise risk assessment method for orchestras
Soundadvice Page94of144
Health and Safety Executive
7 Orchestra pits Orchestra pits in theatres and opera houses
Overview
BackgroundControlmeasures Usesound-absorbentmaterials Positionperformersstrategically Amplification Useshakers Useacousticscreens Userisers
Background
1 Thissectioncoversindoororchestrapits.SeealsoSoundAdvice6‘Orchestras’andSoundAdvice8‘Stagebands’.
2 Musiciansmayexperiencetwomainproblemswhenplayinginorchestrapits:
n Orchestrapitsareoftencrampedandcanbealmosttotallyenclosedspaces.Aspaceof1.7m2permusicianinanorchestrapitisregardedasgood;ifthisisreducedto1.2m2permusiciantheconditionsareconfinedandthemusicianscanfeelclaustrophobicandhemmedin,withdifficultresonances.Heightalsohasaneffect.Whereverpossiblethereshouldbebetween2.5mand3.5mbetweentheflooroftheorchestrapitandtheundersideofanyoverhang.
n Pit-orchestramusiciansandconductorsmayhavetoplaythesameshowseveraltimesaweek,oftenformonthsonend.Inthiscaseschedulingwouldnotbeaneffectivecontrolmeasure.
3 Thesetwofactorsmakeitallthemorecriticalthatnoise-controlmeasuresareeffectiveandobserved.ForrepresentativenoiselevelsinorchestrapitsseeTable11.
4 Touringcompaniesshouldcarryoutaseparatenoiseriskassessmentforeachpit-venueonthetour.Differentsizesandshapesofpitsmayrequirealternativecontrolmeasures.Ensurethatanychangesdonotcauseadditional/secondarysafetyproblems.
Control measures
5 Possiblecontrolmeasuresinclude:
n usingsound-absorbentmaterials;n positionofperformers;n amplification;n usingshakers,acousticscreensorrisers.
Soundadvice Page95of144
Health and Safety Executive
Use sound-absorbent materials6 Reducesoundhazardsbyinstallingacousticpanellingandothersound-absorbentmaterials.Thistreatmentcanbehighlycosteffective.
Position performers strategically7 Positioningisespeciallycrucialinorchestrapitsbecausetheyareoftenveryconfinedspaceswithlowceilings.Themusiciansareoftenplayingdirectlyintoeachother’sandtheconductor’sears.Thelow,overhangingceilingspreventsufficientsoundescapingtotheaudience,resultinginlouderplayinglevels,orevenamplification.Considerthefollowing:
n Maximisethespacebetweentheperformers(inparticularbetweentheloudestinstruments,forexamplepercussion)andotherperformerswherethesizeofthepitandtherelationshipbetweentheperformers(asrequiredforartisticpurposes)permit.Thiswillhelplessentheeffectonotherperformersofsoundlevelsproducedbythenoisiestsections.
n Positionloudinstrumentsorsectionsinopenceilingareasofthepitsotheirsoundcanescapeoutofthepit.
n Considerseatingbrassplayersnearthefrontofthepitaroundtheconductor/musicaldirectorsotheothermusicianswillnotbeexposedtoloud,highlydirectionalsoundcomingfromthebrass.
n Standtheconductor/musicaldirectoronariserabovethebrasssectiontolimittheexposureoftheconductor/musicaldirectortoexcessivenoise.
n Encourageconductors/musicaldirectorstoworkwithplayerstoreducesoundlevels.Theyplayanessentialroleinco-operatingtoreducenoiseexposureincludinglookingatrepertoireandperformancenoiselevels.
n Considerseatingrotationand/oradjustingtheschedulesoftheperformerstoreducetheirindividualexposurelevels.Theearsshouldbeallowedtimetorecoverfromnoiseexposure(seeparagraph72inPart1).
Noise source dB
Opera orchestra pit
Violin 84–90
Viola 87
Cello 86
Doublebass 86
Trumpet 93
Trombone 90
Horn 91
Piccolo/flute 90
Clarinet/bassclarinet 88
Oboe/bassoon 87
Percussion 85
Conductor 82
Allinstruments 88
Table 11 Representativenoiselevelsinorchestrapits
Soundadvice Page96of144
Health and Safety Executive
n Wheretheperformanceistobeamplified,considertheorchestralayoutwithaviewtominimisingtheeffectsonperformersofsoundlevelsproducedbyotherperformers.Onepossiblemeasuremightbetoplacethepercussionsectioninasegregatedarea.Thiswouldenablethesoundlevelsproducedbythepercussionsectiontobecontrolledthroughtheamplificationsystem.
8 Allowtimewithintheschedulingforanynecessaryadjustments,suchasmovingseats,musicianstandsandacousticscreens,orminorvariationsinlayout.
Amplification9 Soundequipmentshouldbeselectedbyasounddesignerorothersuitablyqualifiedpersonwhoshouldensurethatitmeetstherequirementsoftheproductioninthevenueconcernedandisusedwithinthemanufacturer’sspecificationwhilebearinginmindtheneedtomanagesoundlevels.Considerthefollowing:
n Positionloudspeakersstrategically.Thevolumeofamplifiers,on-stagemonitorsandfront-endspeakerscanbeturneddownwhilestillachievingthesameacousticeffectifcarefulthoughtisgiventopositioning.
n Raisemonitorspeakersandfold-backspeakersoffthefloor.Thisputsthemclosertoearlevel,whichmeanstheoveralloutputlevelcanbereducedwiththebenefitsofminimisedspill,lessreverberantnoiseandincreasedclarity.Adviceongoodworkingpracticeformonitorheadphonesandin-earmonitorsisprovidedinAppendix8andAppendix9.
CASE STUDY
Musical theatre pit orchestra
The following case study highlights the problems facing musicians when working in the confined space of a theatre orchestra pit.
The musicians performed six evening shows each week with two matinee performances, each lasting about three hours. The assessments were all made under the Noise at Work Regulations 1989.
Initial noise assessment July 2002
Noise measurements were taken with four sets of static noise-monitoring equipment to establish the range of noise levels in the pit.
Conclusions
n Replace the previously installed perspex screens with absorbent screens between sections (particularly between brass and woodwind).
Measurement position
Show LAeq dB
Daily noise exposure with one show per day LEP,d dB
Weekly average of daily noise exposures LEP,w dB
Drum booth 92 88 89
Timpani 87 83 85
Conductor 87 83 84
Flautist 92 88 89
Soundadvice Page97of144
Health and Safety Executive
n Place absorbent material on the net at the stage edge to reduce spill from the stage-edge fill speakers into the pit and to make the edge of the pit by the flautist absorbent.
n Investigate the contribution to the noise exposure of the musicians from the front-of-house stage-edge show sound system.
n Provide hearing protection.n Carry out a further noise assessment to quantify improvement.n There would be little benefit in introducing more absorption within the drum
booth as this was already ‘dead’. The drummer was provided with closed-back headphones with a small mixer and a direct feed from the sound desk which enabled him to control the mix he heard and so reduce the intrusive airborne noise from the drums.
n Initial assessment should have been carried out on all the musicians to obtain a clearer picture of individual noise exposure. This would have saved costs and time and would have resulted in achieving the reduction in exposure levels sooner.
n Other recognised noise sources: the sound of a musician’s own instrument; the sound of other instruments, especially nearby; the sound of a house sound system, particularly from speakers set into the stage edge over the pit; noise from the auditorium (such as applause).
Second noise assessment August 2002
Noise measurements were taken on the right side of the flautist and the left side of the flautist – to establish any variation from side to side; between the horns and the bass trombone (level with the horn players’ left ears); and above the head of the trumpet player.
Conclusions
n Improvements resulting from remedial works in the pit caused a reduction in the LEP,w at the flautist’s position of 3 dB. As this position was still above the first action level, hearing protection needed to be made available.
n After the first assessment it was recommended that the entire perspex screen between the brass and woodwind should have absorbent material fixed to both sides. The first trial would be to have 30 mm dense mineral fibre applied on each side and black wood serge used as a decorative cover stretched over the fibre. The perspex should be left alone for the top section of the screen to allow the brass section to see through it. The mineral fibre should have a minimum density of 60 kg/m3. If, after these controls have been carried out and reduction is still insufficient, hearing protection should be provided and used.
Measurement position
Show LAeq dB
Daily noise exposure with one show per day LEP,d dB
Weekly average of daily noise exposures LEP,w dB
Flautist right 89 85 86
Flautist left 89 85 86
Horn player/bass trombone
94 90 92
Trumpet 96 92 93
Soundadvice Page98of144
Health and Safety Executive
Third noise assessment September 2002
Noise measurements were taken between violas; between saxophone/clarinet and cello; between French horn and trombone (by horn players’ left ears); by trumpeter’s left ear; by flautist’s left ear.
Conclusions
n Flautist: further remedial works resulted in a negligible reduction, so hearing protection should be made available.
n Brass: the additional absorptive material on the perspex screen in front of the brass position resulted in a significant reduction in exposure levels. Hearing protection should be made available for the French horn but provided to and used by the trumpet.
Measurement position
Show LAeq dB
Daily noise exposure with one show per day LEP,d dB
Weekly average of daily noise exposures LEP,w dB
Violas 85 81 82
Sax/cello 85 82 83
French horn (left ear)
91 87 88
Trumpet (left ear)
94 89 91
Flute (left ear) 89 85 86
Soundadvice Page99of144
Health and Safety Executive
Figure 18 Useofsound-absorbentpanelsinasmallmusictheatrepit
Use shakers10 Shakerscanallowperformerstomonitorandmaintaincontactwiththeirinstruments.Theycaneasilybeattachedunderneathdrummers’seatsortosmallplywoodboardsplacedonthefloor.
Use acoustic screens11 Moveablescreensmaybeneededaswellassound-absorbentpanels(alsoseeAppendix7‘Acousticscreens’).
Use risers12 Ifthepitoverhangallowsit,usingriserstoelevatebrasssectionsmayhelptoprojecttheirsound,whichishighlydirectional,overtheheadsoftheperformersinfrontofthem(seeAppendix6‘Risers’).
edge of stage
Soundadvice Page100of144
Health and Safety Executive
8 Stage bands On-stage and off-stage bands and choruses in theatrical performances
Overview
BackgroundControlmeasures On-stagebands Off-stagebandsandoff-stagemusicalinstruments On-andoff-stagechoruses Fold-backmonitors Persistentsourcesofnoise
Background
1 Inthissectiontheterm‘artists’referstoperformers(and,whererelevant,tootherworkerssuchasstage-managementstaff)onstageotherthanbands.Theterm‘bands’includesorchestras,ensemblesandgroups.SeealsoSoundAdvice6‘Orchestras’.OrchestrapitsarecoveredinSoundAdvice7‘Orchestrapits’.SoundAdvice9‘Studios’mayalsobehelpful.
2 Sitingthebandonstagecancontributetothenoiseexposureoftheartistsandisbestavoidedunlesstheirlocationisregardedasessentialtotheartisticrequirementsoftheproduction.Alwayscarefullyconsiderthepositioningoftheon-stagebandinrelationtootherartists.Otherpossiblelocationsfortheband,forexamplegalleriesorintheauditorium,maybeappropriate.
Control measures
On-stage bands3 Possiblecontrolmeasuresinclude:
n minimisingthevolumelevelsproducedbytheband/orchestra.Thiscouldmeanproducinglessvolumeand/orusingphysicalelementssuchasabsorbentmaterialandscreens;
n maximisingthedistancesbetweentheband/orchestraandartists;n positioningthebandand/orartistsatdifferentheights;n whereanartistispositionedclosetoahighlevelofnoise,considerrotating
positions.
4 Differencesbetweenon-stagebandsinamusicalandon-stageorchestrasinanoperashouldalsobetakenintoaccount,forexample,aWestEndmusicalwillbeperformedeighttimesaweek,butthebandwillusuallybeamplifiedsosoundlevelscanbemanagedthroughtheamplificationprocess.On-stageorchestrasinanoperawillnotusuallybeamplified,buttheoperamaynotbeperformedeverynight.
Off-stage bands and off-stage musical instruments5 Thesameconsiderationsandpossiblecontrolmeasuresapplytooff-stagebandsastoon-stagebands.Alsoconsiderthelocationofthebands/instrumentstominimisetheimpactonartists.Forexamplewherethemusicisamplified,theoff-stagebands/instrumentscouldberemotefromthestage.
Soundadvice Page101of144
Health and Safety Executive
On- and off-stage choruses6 Considertheeffectofchorusnoiselevelsonotherartistsonstage.Thesameconsiderationsandpossiblemeasuresapplyasthosetoorchestras/bandsonstage.
7 Choralvolumeshouldberegularlymonitoredtominimisetheeffectsofnoiselevelsproducedbyindividualsingersoneachotherwithoutcompromisingtheoverallbalanceofsound.
Fold-back monitors8 Takestepstoensurethatthenoiselevelsoffold-backmonitorsareaslowaspossible.Volumelevelsmayneedtobeadjustedtosuitthespecificrequirementsoftheartistsatdifferenttimesinthecourseoftheperformanceandshouldnotbesetatafixedlevelforthedurationoftheperformance.
Persistent sources of noise9 Considerrotatingorvaryingthepositionsofartistsclosetosourcesofpersistentlyloudnoisesuchasotherartists,musicalinstrumentsorspecialeffects.
Soundadvice Page102of144
Health and Safety Executive
9 Studios Facilities for recording and/or broadcasting live music
Overview
BackgroundControlmeasures Planning Positioningperformers Reducingexposure Performers’monitorspeakers Controlroommonitorspeakers
Background
1 Thissectiondealswithrecordinglivemusic,primarilyinpurpose-builtfacilities:studios.Itmayalsoberelevanttobroadcastingmusic.ItshouldbereadinconjunctionwithSoundAdvice4‘Rockandpop’andSoundAdvice6‘Orchestras’.
2 Whatmakesthisadvicedifferentisthattypicallythereisnopayingaudienceinvolved.Thistosomeextentreducestheusualburdenwhichtypicallygivesprioritytoappearanceoveraudibility.Layoutcanthereforebeoptimisedforsoundwithoutsuchseverespacerestrictions.Microphonesandtheirleadsandstandsneednotbeobscured,distantpartsofthestudioandotherremoteareasareequallyuseableandwhenrecordingsarebeingmadethereisusuallytheabilityto‘retake’whendesired.Wheremulti-micmethodsareused,itmayalsobepossibletokeepperformancenoisedownirrespectiveofwhateverbalanceisachievedatthemixingdesk.Thesefeaturescanprovidetheopportunityforadegreeofexperimentation,whichwillhelpcomplywiththeNoiseRegulations.
3 Anoiseriskassessmentflowchartforstudiosisattheendofthesection.
Control measures
4 Whereanoiseriskassessmenthasindicatedthereisarisk,possiblecontrolmeasuresmayincludethefollowing:
n planning;n positioningperformers;n reducingexposureforeveryone;n adjustmenttospeakers.
Planning5 Theroomsize,shape,designandacousticallhaveadirectbearingonthesoundsbeinggenerated.Attheevent-planningstage,considernoise-exposurelevelsforperformers,engineers,crew,andancillaryactivitiessuchashospitality.Allowenoughtimetocomfortablycompletetheproject–anextradayorhalfdaycouldreducetheoverallintensityforeveryone.
6 Whennew-buildorstructuralmodificationsareplanned,trytoenvisagehowallthoseinvolvedwiththeendproductarelikelytointeractwiththeenvironmentcreated.Considerhownoiseriskscanbeeliminatedorreducedbythoughtful
Soundadvice Page103of144
Health and Safety Executive
design,forexample,willtheGreenRoomenableitsoccupantstobepartofaneventwithouttheriskofnoisehazard?7 Trytoreducenoise‘hotspots’inperformanceareasbyinstallingsound-absorbentmaterials,screenedareasandacousticrefuges.
Positioning performers8 Thepositioningofperformersisimportant:
n Whencalculatinghowmanymusicians/performerscanbeaccommodatedinastudio,aimfor2.0m2offloorspaceperpersontogetherwithasurroundingperimeterarea.
n Separatetheperformersfromeachotherasfaraspracticablewhichmayhelptoreduceexposurelevels.Providerisers–seeAppendix6‘Risers’.
n Takeintoaccountthesourcesofsoundandvisualisethenoisefootprintthateachwillhave.Itmaybehelpfultocarryoutnoisemeasurementsbeforeandafterlayoutadjustmentstohelpgaugetheeffect.
Reducing exposure9 Minimisethedurationofnoiseexposureforeveryone:
n Makesurestaffwhoarenotneededforaparticularpieceleavethestudiooruse‘acousticrefuges’whereprovided.
n Controlroomsshouldonlycontainessentialstaff,andnotbetreatedasGreenRooms.
n Makegooduseofacousticscreenstoisolateloudinstrumentsorshieldindividuals/groupsfromprevailingsounds.
n Drumkitscanbepositionedandshieldedtominimisenoisespill.n Particularlynoisyinstrumentscouldbepositionedandmic’dinaseparatearea
fromthemainperformance.n Anyshieldingmaterialsshouldbeacousticallyabsorbentratherthanreflective.n Playmorequietly,especiallyifinstrumentsareindividuallymic’d.
10 Disposablehearingprotection,forexampleearmuffsordisposableearplugs,shouldbekeptavailableincasetheyareneeded.
Performers’ monitor speakers11 Rememberthatanyreductioninsoundlevelsfromtheloudestinstrumentswillresultinlessneedforhighfold-backlevels.
n Tryreplacingfloorwedgeswithsmallerstand-mountedspeakersatearlevel.n Useheadphonesorin-earmonitorsratherthanfold-backspeakers,soreducingunwantedsoundintheperformancearea.Allheadphonesandin-earmonitorsshouldbefittedwithnoiselimiters–seeAppendix9‘Clicktracksandheadphones’andSoundAdvice4‘Rockandpop’.
n Tryusingsingle-earpieceheadphonesandswappingearsbetweentakestoreduceoverallexposure.
n Considerusingclicktracksinplaceofmonitors–seeAppendix9‘Clicktracksandheadphones’andAppendix6‘Risers’.
Control room monitor speakers12 Reducemonitorlevelsinthecontrolroomstothelowestfeasiblelisteninglevelswhenrecording,overdubbingandmixing.Thereareoftenotherworkers,forexampleproducers,performersandengineers,whoneedtobepresent,andwhomaybethereformanyhours.
13 Itisoftennecessaryforthesoundengineertoraisethevolumeofquietpiecesofmusicforanalyticalpurposes.Iftheselisteninglevelsweretobe
Soundadvice Page104of144
Health and Safety Executive
maintainedduringloudpassages,eventhepeakactionlevelwouldprobablybeexceeded.Itcanthereforebeappreciatedwhycontrolroomspeakerlevelsneedtobefrequentlyadjusted,butthereshouldbesomesafeguardtoavoidinadvertentlyleavingspeakervolumesathighlevels.Theuseofelectroniclimitinginloudspeakerfeedsisnotfavouredbysoundengineers.
14 Analternativeapproachistolockoffthesystemtoachieveamaximumlevel(say80dBforan8-hoursessionor87dBfora3-hoursession)butthenprovideamethodoffleetinggainincrease.Thiscouldbeachievedwithasimplepushbuttononthemixingdeskthatprovidesfullgainwhilepressed.Amoresophisticatedelectronicversionmightcalculatethedurationofthefull-volumemode,sothatacapcouldbeappliedtoitsuse.
CASE STUDY Recordings of an orchestra
There were two performances before an invited audience. Both performances had the same orchestra and pop group. At the first concert light music was played and the performance was arranged in a traditional ‘classical’ layout. At the second concert pop music was played and a ‘novel’ layout was tried.
Noise levels within the brass and percussion sections of an orchestra can exceed 95 dB. In the traditional layout of the orchestra, players of quieter instruments seated in front of these sections can receive a significant noise exposure from these louder instruments. During the pop concert recording the orchestra experimented with placing the brass and percussion sections to the front of the orchestra. The woodwind and strings were on raised staging behind. Individual microphones were used for each player and the sound heard by the audience was amplified and balanced electronically. Players used headsets to hear backing tracks and clicks.
Clear, head-height screens, separating the pop musicians from the orchestra, provided some additional protection where pop and orchestra musicians were in close proximity.
To maintain the benefit of the physical noise controls the pop musicians and sound technicians were reminded of the need to moderate amplified sound levels on the stage. As a consequence the monitor speakers for the pop musicians gave a lower level than the pop musicians were accustomed to.
Table 12 compares the daily noise exposure of the orchestra during the ‘classical’ concert recording with a traditional layout of the players, and the noise exposure during the pop concert with the novel arrangement. Both events were at the same venue. The exposure in both cases arises from a full-length rehearsal and performance within the same day.
Commentary
The orchestra musicians had said that previous recordings of pop concerts had given much higher sound levels than classical recordings. Compared to a classical recording this experimental arrangement of the orchestra gave a reduced exposure for most string and woodwind players, and no increase in exposure for the brass players.
Soundadvice Page105of144
Health and Safety Executive
Table 12 Comparisonofdailynoiseexposure
The rearrangement of the orchestra was viable because musicians were playing with backing tracks and clicks heard through headsets with electronic balancing of the sound from each instrument for the recording and audience. The additional microphones and sound equipment significantly increased production costs. The orchestra layout described here is unsuitable for a classical concert where players need to hear other orchestra sections or where the audience need to hear the quieter instruments acoustically (not amplified).
Illustrations of the two layouts are in Figures 19 and 20. Figure 19 shows a traditional orchestra layout, which places the quieter section, the strings and woodwind, between the pop group and the orchestra’s brass and percussion sections. Transparent acoustic screens were placed between the strings and the pop group’s equipment but these did not provide enough protection from their loud amplifiers and monitors.
Figure 20 shows how the layout was changed to provide more noise protection for the orchestra. The strings and woodwind sections were tiered which moved them away from the noisiest area of the stage. The brass and percussion sections were situated down-stage and separated from the pop group’s band by acoustic screens. These screens were placed far enough away from the brass so as not to cause any noise reflection but also to protect them from the loudness of the group’s amplifiers.
Player Traditional layout for ‘classical’ concert LEP,d dB
Novel layout for pop concert LEP,d dB
Trumpet 92 93
Clarinet 91 80 (on back row of orchestra)
Violin 88 87
Viola 87 84
Cello 83 (at far edge of orchestra)
86 (in front of woodwind)
Soundadvice Page106of144
Health and Safety Executive
Musical Director
Guitars
Drums
1st violins Cellos
Keys
Screen
Double basses
2nd violinsHarp Violas
Horns Trumpets Trombones Tuba
Percussion TimpaniPercussion
Backing vocals
Drums
Vocals
Flutes
Clarinets
Oboes
Bassoons
8 ftdeep
8 in
1 ft
2 ft
3 ft
Heightsabove stage
Figure 19 ‘Classical’concertrecording
Soundadvice Page107of144
Health and Safety Executive
Guitars
Drums
PercussionTimpani
Keys
CellosViolas
Flutes
Clarinets
Oboes
Bassoons
1st violins2nd violins
Cellos
Doublebasses
Harp
Backing vocals
Musical Director
Drums
Vocals
8 in1 ft
2 ft
3 ft
12 ft
Heightsabove stage
Trumpets
Tuba
Trombones
Horns
8 ft x 4 ftRisers
Screen
Figure 20 Novellayoutforpopconcertrecording
Soundadvice Page108of144
Health and Safety Executive
YES
NOT SURENO/
NOT SURENO/ Can your
workers/performersavoid entering noisy
areas?
NOT SURE YES
Has aprevious noise
risk assessmentbeen carried out and
is it valid for thissession?
Will thepersonal noise
dose be below theupper exposure action
values for everyoneinvolved?
Is thepersonal noise
dose likely to be belowthe lower exposure action
values for everyoneinvolved?
Obtain a reliable estimate of noise exposure. Implement necessary control measures.NB Hearing protection is NOT a control measure.
YES
Review noise risk assessment before each major change ofsession or venue and at least every 2 years.
Implement any necessarycontrol measures.
It is essential that there is liaison between the producer and studio soundengineer. Identify the genre of the performance expected.
You are the manager responsiblefor a studio session
NO
NO/
YES
NO
YES
NO NO YES
Will thepersonal noise
dose be below theupper exposure action
values for everyoneinvolved?
Will thepersonal noise
dose be below thelower exposure action
values for everyoneinvolved?
Will thepersonal noise
dose be below theexposure limit values
for everyoneinvolved?
Immediately reduce noiseexposure and/or provide
sufficient hearing protection.
Establish and instigate action plan. Implement control measures.
YES
Implement health surveillance for any employees susceptibleto noise. Make hearing protection available.*
Implement health surveillance.Provide hearing protection and ensure it is worn.
Establish maintenance programme for all noise-reductionmeasures including hearing protection. Provide training.
Record the noise risk assessment.
NO
Assess the effectiveness of any control measures.Monitor noise levels, if required.
Record significantfindings and actions atevery stage
Figure 21 Anoiseriskassessmentmethodforastudiosession
Soundadvice Page109of144
Health and Safety Executive
10 Music education Teachers, conductors of student groups, education officers and directors in schools and music colleges
Overview
Whoisthisguidancefor?NoiselevelsproducedbyindividualinstrumentsPlantoavoidoverexposureExposure-reductionmeasuresforemployedandprivateinstrumentalteachersHearingpreservation–educationandtrainingofstudentsOrchestras,brassbands,windbandsandotherensembles/vocalgroupsClassroomteaching
Who is this guidance for?
1 Thissectionisfor:
n directorsofteachingestablishments;n instrumentalteachers–includingprivate/peripateticatanylevel;n classroomteachers;n conductorsofstudentinstrumental/vocalgroups;n Educationofficers/learningmanagers.
2 Teachersshouldusethisadvicetopreventdamagetotheirownhearing.Theyarealsoencouragedtopassonthisinformationtotheirstudentsaspartoftheircompletemusicaleducation.
3 Eachestablishmentshouldidentifytheresponsibilitiesforriskcontrol.
Noise levels produced by individual instruments
4 ForrepresentativenoiselevelsseeTable13.
5 TheexposuremeasurementsinTable14weretakenoverapproximatelyaone-hourperiodofadulttuitioninapurpose-builtteachingroom.Ifateacher’sexposureweretocontinueatthatlevelforeighthoursthentherepresentativenoiselevelwouldbetheactualdailyexposurelevel.Notethepeakexposureofthecornetplayerwouldbeofconcern.
Plan to avoid overexposure
6 Employersofteachersandself-employedteachersneedtoplantheirworkingweektoavoidoverexposure.Anynoiseexposure,notjusttomusic,overtheweekiscumulative.TheNoiseRegulationsallowexposuretobeassessedacrosstheworkingweek–seeAppendix4.
n Revisethestructureoflessonssothatonlycertaingroupsintheclassareactuallyusinginstrumentsatanyonetimewhileothergroupsareplanningand‘composing’theirworks.
n Tryandalternatesessionssothatexposuretoloudnoiseislimited.
7 Privateinstrumentalteachersshouldmaintainarecordofexposurelevelsandadjusttheirteachingschedulesifnecessarytopreventoverexposure.
Soundadvice Page110of144
Health and Safety Executive
Noise source dB
Music teaching: group practice
Saxophone:Tutor 93–95
Saxophone:Students 94–96
Music teaching: individual lessons: tutor exposure
Violinwithpianoaccompaniment(smallpracticeroom)
82
Violinwithpianoaccompaniment(largepracticeroom)
76
Violin 84
Flute 89
Electricguitar 88
Saxophone 95
Trombone 90
Piano 82
Singing(pianoaccompaniment) 85
School orchestra practice
Tutorconducting 94
Studenttrombones(backrow) 94
Studentpercussion 92
Studenttrumpetsoloistwithorchestra
96
Studentsaxophone(backrow) 91
Studentclarinet(frontrow) 95
Studentflute(frontrow) 98
Stafftuba 92
Table 13Representativenoiselevels Table 14Representativeexposurelevelsmeasuredatacollege
Instrument dB Peak
College tuition
Flute 93 116
Oboe 84 132
Clarinet 90 132
Altosaxophone 93 132
Tenorsaxophone 95 134
Bassoon 83 120
Frenchhorn 85 129
Cornet 89 140
Trombone 91 132
Euphonium 96 131
Violin 88 120
Violin 86 126
Piano 80 126
Bassguitar 80 121
Soundadvice Page111of144
Health and Safety Executive
Exposure-reduction measures for employed and private instrumental teachers
8 Waysofreducingnoiseexposureincludethefollowing:
n Teachingroomsshouldbeassessedassuitableforthepurpose.Thesizeofteachingroomsisimportant–itislikelythatteachinginasmallroomwillresultinhigherexposurelevelsthanthoseinalargerauditoriumwheretheteachercangetfurtherawayfromthesoundbeingproduced.Avoidhighlyreverberantrooms–selectanappropriateacoustic.Selectroomsnotbysizeofinstrumentbutbyhownoisytheyare–theplayersoftheloudestinstrumentsneedthelargestrooms.SeealsoSoundAdvice2‘Venues’.
n Acoustictreatment–useateachingroomthathasbeenfittedwithsound-absorbentmaterials,suchascarpeting,acousticpanellingordrapes.SeealsoSoundAdvice2.
n Positioningwhenteaching–someinstrumentsarehighlydirectional.Teachersshouldavoidstandingdirectlyinthe‘lineoffire’duringlessons.Whenpossiblemakeuseofacousticscreensbetweenthepupilandtheteacher–seeAppendix7‘Acousticscreens’.
n Schedulingoflessons–avoidback-to-backschedulingoflessonswithout‘respite’periods.
n Contentoflessons–itmightbepossibletoincludesomeinstructionwhichdoesnotrequirethestudenttoplay.
n Teachinglevels–askthestudenttoplayatareducedlevelduringlessonswheneverpossible.
n Avoid‘playingalong’withstudent(s)toreduceoverallnoiselevels.n Whenteachingingroups,avoidconstant‘group’practice.n Wearhearingprotectionwhennecessary.
The Building Regulations
The Building Regulations set out some guidelines relating to the design of school buildings:
n Under Building Bulletin 9312 (Requirement E4 from Part E of Schedule 1 to The Building Regulations 2000 (as amended)) ‘Each room or other space in a school building shall be designed and constructed in such a way that it has the acoustic conditions and the insulation against disturbance by noise appropriate to its intended use.’
n The Education (School Premises) Regulations 1999,13 which applies to both new and existing school buildings, contains a similar statement: ‘Each room or other space in a school building shall have the acoustic conditions and the insulation against disturbance by noise appropriate to its normal use.’
n Although Building Regulations do not apply to all alteration and refurbishment work, it is desirable that such work should consider acoustics and incorporate upgrading of the acoustics as appropriate.
n Section 4 of Building Bulletin 93: ‘The design of rooms for speech’ and Section 5: ‘The design of rooms for music’ give guidance on various aspects of acoustic design relevant to schools.
Look at Building Bulletin 93 on the DFES website: www.teachernet.gov.uk/acoustics.
Hearing preservation – education and training of students
9 Aspartofteaching,considerdiscussingthefollowingwithstudents:
n Typeofpracticerooms–encouragestudentstopractiseinroomsthathavebeenfittedwithsound-absorbentmaterials:carpeting,acousticpanelling,drapesetc.
Soundadvice Page112of144
Health and Safety Executive
n Sizeofpracticeroom–encouragestudentstopractiseinlargerroomsifpossible.Greaterspacethan1.7m2perpersonisdesirable.Goodresultshavebeenachievedbymovingtheloudestinstrumentsintothelargestspaces.
n Encouragestudentstoplaymorequietly.n Wheresoundreinforcementisused,selecthigh-qualityamplifiersusedquietly.n Takeaccountofexposureduringprivatepracticetimeandalsoduring
rehearsalsandperformances.EncouragestudentstousetypicaldBreadingstocalculatetheirtypicalnoiseexposurestohelpidentifythecontrolmeasuresneeded,forexampleshorteningthetimespentonloudpractising.Manyconservatoirestudentsareexpectedtodoatleastfourhoursofprivatepracticeoveraday.Inthecaseofbrassplayersthiswouldautomaticallypushthemovertheupperexposureactionvalue–eitherthelengthofthepracticeperiodshouldbereducedorothercontrolmeasurestaken.Wearinghearingprotectionisthelastresort.
n Usetechniquetoreduceexposure,forexample,violin/violaplayerscanreducesoundlevelstotheirleftearbykeepingtheirheadsmoreuprightwhileplaying.Thisalsoencouragesagoodplayingposture.
n Usepracticemutes.Thereisalargeamountofinformationontheinternetaboutthevariouspracticemutesavailable–searchunder‘practicemutes’:
– rubberpracticemutesareavailableforstringedinstruments;– variouspracticemutesareavailableforbrassinstruments.Makesure
themutesaredesignedtoreduceoutputvolumeratherthanredirecttheoutputstraightintotheearviaastethoscopesimplytoavoiddisturbingtheneighbours;
– practicepadsareavailablefordrummers.Inaddition,mostpercussioninstrumentscanbesuccessfullydampenedforpracticepurposeswithpiecesofclothorfoam.
n Pianistsshouldkeeptops/lidsloweredduringpractice.n Practiseamplifiedinstrumentsatthelowestpossiblelevels.Useelectronically
limitedheadphones.n Practiseguitarsacousticallyratherthanamplified.n Consider‘off-hours’soundexposure,forexamplepersonal/carstereos,
cinemas,sportingeventsetc.
Orchestras, brass bands, wind bands and other ensembles/vocal groups
10 Teachingdutiesoftenincludeconductingensemblesbothinrehearsalandinperformance.Refertootherpartsofthisbookforgeneralinformationaboutsound-reductiontechniquesforuseinthesesituations.Thesecover:
n reducedvolumeduringrehearsal;n orchestral/ensemblelayout;n mixingloudandquietrepertoire;n suitablerehearsalandperformancevenues;n encouragingtrumpets/trombonestoraisetheirbellsduringloudpassagesto
projecttheirsoundoverthetopofotherperformers.Thisshouldenablethemtoplayatalowerleveltoproducethesameeffect.
11 Soundlevelsproducedbygroupsofstudentinstrumentalistsarelikelytobehigherthanthoseproducedbyaprofessionalgroupofplayersbecauseofless-developedtechnicalabilitiesandnaturalexuberance.Damagingsoundlevelshavebeenmeasuredattheconductor’spositioninschoolbands.
Soundadvice Page113of144
Health and Safety Executive
CASE STUDY School music department
Despite the excellent acoustics of purpose-built practice and performance facilities, music teachers at a school could be at risk of receiving excessive noise exposures.
Table 15 gives the noise levels teachers were exposed to during lessons for individual pupils and group practice at a school with excellent teaching facilities. The LAeq is the measured level when pupils were actually playing rather than the average level over the lesson. Daily exposure increases with both the level and duration of the sound. The exposure time to 80 dB LEP,d is the total time in the day that a teacher is hearing pupils play at the measured sound level before that teacher reaches their 80 dB daily exposure. Some teachers could reach a hazardous exposure within a single lesson.
Daily exposure will increase with listening and playing times.
The following recommendations were made:
n Lower noise levels are possible in the larger practice rooms. These should be the preferred choice for lessons on louder instruments.
n Avoid playing loudly all the time. Reduce the exposure time at hazardous levels by having a repertoire of loud and quiet pieces.
n Limit the amplification of electronic instruments.n Use hearing protection designed for musicians in conjunction with noise
controls where a risk remains.
Table 15 Noiselevelstowhichteacherswereexposedduringlessons
Activity LAeq dB Exposure time to 80 dB LEP,d
Leadingandplayingwitheight-membersaxophonegroup
93to95 15to24minutes
Conductingbrass,woodwindandpercussionorchestra
94 19minutes
Saxophonelesson 95 15minutes
Trombonelesson 90 48minutes
Flutelesson 89 60minutes
Electricguitarlesson 88 75minutes
Singinglesson 85 2.5hours
Piano 82 5hours
Violinlessontutorprovidingpianoaccompaniment
Smallpracticeroom82Largepracticeroom76
5hours
Notexceeded
Soundadvice Page114of144
Health and Safety Executive
Classroom teaching
12 Therearevariousmethodsofreducingnoiselevelsduringclassroomteaching:
n Whenusingkeyboardsduringgeneralclassmusicteaching,instructthestudentstomaintainthelowestpossiblevolumeunlessdemonstrating/performingtotheclass.Headphonescanalsobeusedtoreduceclassexposure,buttheseshouldbefittedwithnoiselimiters.
n Whenusingpercussioninstrumentsinclassroomsituations,considerusingsofterbeatersasawayofreducingnoiselevels,particularlyinpracticeorrehearsalsituations.
n Considertheuseofhearingprotectionforbothteachersandstudentstoprotecthearingduring‘loud’lessons.
n Listentorecordedmusicatmoderatevolume.CASE STUDY An audiologist with a role in a college of music While my daughter was attending a music college on a singing/vocals course, I became aware that the college syllabus had no content on the safety aspects of exposure to high sound levels in the context of music tuition, and performance. The college management and tutors were very open to my offer to help them in this respect. I have a long-standing background in NHS and private audiology, with an MSc in Environmental Acoustics, a special interest in musicians’ hearing protection, and past publications on noise control and hearing conservation.
Sound-level measurements in the keyboard, guitar, bass guitar and drum/percussion practice rooms at the college, confirmed routine exposures to sound levels between 93 dB and 103 dB, with the percussion peak level at over 120 dB.
It was arranged that I would meet the students and give them a presentation to cover:
n the basic anatomy and functioning of the ear and hearing system;n an introduction to the science behind hearing and noise measurement; n an awareness of UK and European health and safety legislation on hearing
conservation matters;n practical guidance on managing their own noise exposure from music and
other sources.
The students and college staff have all proved to be very receptive to this information, effectively empowered to adopt an educated attitude to the routine use of hearing protection, and the routine scrutiny of sound levels during practice and performance. Around 75% of them report previous episodes of ‘temporary threshold shift’, (dull hearing), and/or tinnitus (head noises), following exposure to common levels of sound experienced when playing or listening to music.
Since 2000 this ‘Hearing Awareness’ lecture has been given to every new entrant in their early weeks at the college, and the staff have set an excellent example by using hearing protection themselves, reinforcing the information the students have been given, and reviewing working practices with regard to sound levels.
Soundadvice Page115of144
Health and Safety Executive
11 Marching bands Civilian and military marching bands
Overview
PerformancetypesPositionofmusiciansandotherperformersCeremonialparadesBanddisplay
1 Whilethissectionisbasedonexperiencewithmilitarybands,itisequallyapplicabletoallmarchingbands.
2 Thesingularterm‘band’inthiscontextshouldbeunderstoodtorefertoasinglebodyofmusicians,whetherfromaunitaryensembleortwoormoreensemblescombinedforaparticularevent(forexample,massedbandsperformingatamajorparadesuchastheQueen’sBirthdayParade).
3 Table16representstypicalnoiselevelstowhichmembersofmarchingbandsareexposed.
Performance types
4 Therearetwotypesofmarchingbandengagement,eachofwhichplacesdifferentrequirementsonthebandintermsofvolumeandsorequiringadifferentapproachtocontrolmeasures.Thefirstisaceremonialparade,inwhichthebandisprovidingmusicalsupporttomarchingtroops;thesecondisabanddisplayinwhichthebandperformsasadiscrete‘act’fortheentertainmentofanaudience,eitherinanarenaorstreetprocession.
Position of musicians and other performers
5 Certaininstruments(forexample,trombones,cornetsandpercussion)presentagreaterhazardthanothers,bothtotheplayersandthoseclosetothem,andtheseinstrumentsshouldbecarefullypositionedwithinthemarchingband.Thedirectionalbrassinstrumentsshouldbeatthefrontoftheband,reducingthemufflingeffectofotherperformersandsorequiringlessvolumefromtheplayersconcernedtoprojecttheirsound.Trombonesshouldbeinthefrontrank,placingnootherperformerdirectlyinlinewiththebelloftheinstrument.Themaximumpossiblefreespaceshouldbeleftaroundthebassdrumandcymbalstoallowfornaturaldissipationofthesoundoftheseinstruments.SeeFigure22foraplanofamarchingband.
Soundadvice Page116of144
Health and Safety Executive
Ceremonial parades
6 Inaceremonialparadethereneedstobeenoughvolumefromthebandforallmarchingtroopstakingparttobeabletohearclearly,toenablethemtomarchintimewiththemusic.Possiblecontrolmeasuresincludeacombinationofparadeformatandpersonalhearingprotection.
Parade format 7 Measuresthatwillreducethenecessaryvolumefromanindividualmusicianwithinthebandinclude:
n placingthebandatthecentreofamarchingcolumnratherthanatitshead,reducingthedistanceforsoundtotraveltothefurthestparticipantfromthesource;
n employingmorethanonebandifthemarchingcolumnisparticularlylongandplacingthematintervalswithinthecolumn;
n adjustingtheformatofaformalparadetoreducethedistancebetweenthebandandmarchingtroops.
Instrument dB Peak
Marching bands
Piccolo 112 130
Clarinet 119 140
Altosaxophone 113 140
Tenorsaxophone 115 142
Frenchhorn 111 140
Cornet 120 142
Trombone 113 145
Euphonium 113 138
Tuba 117 146
Snaredrum 113 144
Cymbals(large) 121 146
Cymbals(small) 118 146
Bassdrum 122 145
DrumMajor 96 132
Commentary
Worst-casefiguresfromaseriesofmeasurementstakenwithtwoprofessionalbandsattheRoyalMilitarySchoolofMusicduringSeptember2006.
Takingtheaverageexposureoveradayall of the abovewouldhavebeenabovetheactionvalues.
Table 16 Representativenoiselevels
Soundadvice Page117of144
Health and Safety Executive
Personal hearing protection 8 Whereadjustmentstotheparadeformatcannoteliminaterisk,personalhearingprotectionshouldbeprovidedandused.
Band display9 Whenabandisperformingsolelyfortheentertainmentofanaudience,eitherinanarenadisplayorprocession,excessivevolumeisnotanecessity.Thedynamicrangeemployedwithintheperformanceshouldbemaintainedataleveltominimisetherisk.Itwillbenecessarytoeducatebothperformersandaudiences,amongwhomthereisoftenanexpectationofexcessivevolumeduringmarchingdisplays.
10 Thepersoninchargeoftheband(s)shouldassessanyriskassociatedwiththeperformance,includingadditionalelementssuchascannonsandpyrotechnics,andemployappropriatecontrolmeasures.Wheretheriskisbeyondtheimmediatecontroloftheband(forexamplepyrotechnics),personalhearingprotectionshouldbeprovidedforallperformers.
11 Personalhearingprotectionshouldberoutinelyavailableforbothperformersofthenaturallylouderinstrumentsandthosepositionedclosetothem.
Soundadvice Page118of144
Health and Safety Executive
Trombone Trombone Trombone Trombone Trombone
Tuba TubaEuphonium Tuba Euphonium
Cornet Cornet Cornet Cornet Cornet
Cymbals
French horn French horn French hornSaxophone Saxophone
Piccolo PiccoloClarinet Saxophone Clarinet
Clarinet Clarinet Clarinet Clarinet Clarinet
Conductor
Bass drum
Side drum Side drum
Figure 22 Planofamarchingband
Soundadvice Page119of144
Health and Safety Executive
Appendix 1 Examples of workers covered by this guidance
Thislistisnotdefinitivebutindicatesthejobsofpeopleworkinginthemusicandentertainmentsectorsthatmightbeaffectedbyloudnoisefromliveoramplifiedmusicorspecialeffects.
Acrobatsandgymnasts Actors
Aerobicinstructors Architects
Artisticdirectors Audioengineersandassistants
Backlinetechnicians Barstaff
Childperformers Choirs
Choreographers Classicalmusicensembles
Composers Conductors
Crew Crowdmanagers
Danceinstructors Dancers
Designers Discjockeys
Doorsupervisors Engagers
Entertainers Eventorganisers
Fixers Front-of-housestaff
Groupssuchaspop,rock,jazz,folkandcountry Instrumenttechnicians
Jazzmusicians Lightingdesigners
Lightingcrew/engineers/technicians Managers
Marshals Monitorengineers
Musicaldirectors Musicians
Musicinstructors PAproviders
Pitorchestras Operasingers
Orchestraporters Pianotechnicians
Producers Productioncompanies
Promoters Projectionists
Recordingengineers Refreshmentstaff
Riggers Securitypersonnel
Setdesigners Singers
Sounddesigners Soundengineers
Soundequipmentoperators/suppliers Specialeffectsdesigners/personnel
Staff(includingmanagers,bouncersandservers) Stagebands
Stagecrew/technicians Stagemanagement
Stageworkers(suchascarpenters,propsbuilders,electriciansandwelders)
Stewards
Studioowners/operators Technicaldirectors
Thoseengagedinmusicaleducation Ushers
Venuemanagers/owners Videotechnicians
Vocalists Waitingstaff
Soundadvice Page120of144
Health and Safety Executive
Appendix 2 A table of the actions required based on exposure action values compared with exposure limit values
Exposure action values and exposure limit values
Daily or weekly personal average noise exposure
Peak sound level
Actions
Below lower exposure action values
Lessthan80dB(A-weighted)
Lessthan135dB(C-weighted)
n Reducenoiselevelsasfarasreasonablypracticable.
Lower exposure action values
80dB(A-weighted)orabove
Cannottaketheeffectofhearingprotectionintoaccount
135dB(C-weighted)orabove
Cannottaketheeffectofhearingprotectionintoaccount
n Undertakeriskassessment.Ifanyemployeesareidentifiedasbeingparticularlysusceptibletonoise,healthsurveillanceshouldbeimplemented.
n Makesuitablehearingprotectionavailable.
n Establishamaintenanceprogrammeforequipmentsuppliedtoreducenoiserisksuchasnoiselimitersandhearingprotection.
n Providetraining.
Upper exposure action values
85dB(A-weighted)orabove
Cannottaketheeffectofhearingprotectionintoaccount
137dB(C-weighted)orabove
Cannottaketheeffectofhearingprotectionintoaccount
n Implementtheactionsrequiredbylowerexposureactionvalues(above).
n Establishandimplementaprogrammeofcontrolmeasures.
n Ifthesemeasuresarenotsufficienttoreduceexposurebelow85dBthen:
– suitablehearingprotectionmustbeworn;and
– ahealthsurveillanceprogrammeimplemented.
Exposure limit values
87dB(A-weighted)
Allowedtotakehearingprotectionintoaccount
140dB(C-weighted)
Allowedtotakehearingprotectionintoaccount
n Mustreducetobelowlimitvalues.
Soundadvice Page121of144
Health and Safety Executive
Appendix 3 Contracts
Using contracts to help with noise control
1 Contractscanhelptheplanningprocessbysettingoutthearrangementsfornoisecontrol.Theyhavebeenfoundparticularlyhelpfulwherethereareseveralcontractorsworkingtogetherwithaproducer/venueprovider(s).ContractscanbeusefulwhendealingwiththespecificrequirementsoftheNoiseRegulationsandcanformpartoftheoverallhealthandsafetyconsiderationsfortheevent/production.
2 Acontractualapproachisoftenmorereadilyunderstoodbythepartiesconcernedassomanymattersarealreadycoveredinthisway–fromperformers’riderstoequipmentspecifications.Thecontractualapproachcanalsoactasanaide-memoire.Experienceshowsjointmeetingscanoftenslipbybecauseoftimeconstraints,whereasspecifiedcontractualobligationsforconsultationareusuallytakenonboard.
3 Includingthingsinacontractcanhelpprincipalcontractors/producerstopassonrelevantinformationtosubcontractors.Forexample,acontractstipulatingahearingprotectionzonecouldinsistthatsubcontractors’crewswearearmuffs.
4 Therolesofdifferentprofessionalsinachievingeffectivenoise-controlmeasuresshouldbeclearlysetout.Thismaybemostsuccessfullyaccomplishedbyinclusioninacontract,eitherwithinthemaindocumentorasappendices.Centraltothisprocessareprofessionalssuchassoundengineers,DJs,conductorsandmusicaldirectors.Theextentoftheirresponsibilitiesshouldbeclearlyspecified.Designatedresponsibilitiesshouldbeappropriatetotheirtrainingandexperience.
5 Forsmaller-scaleevents,contractsmaybethemostdirectwayofensuringnoise-controlissuesareconsidered.Keypointscaneasilyformpartofstandardcontractsformusicians.Thesemaybeofmosthelptothosewithindividualcontractualarrangements,particularlyforshorthireperiods.Similarly,venueoperatorscanincludesomestandardpointsrelatingtotheirrequirementsfromperformers–forexamplewhichinstrumentsandequipmentwillbebroughttotheperformancebytheperformersandwhat,ifany,controlmeasureswillbecarriedoutbythem.
6 Insmallvenuesacontractshouldhelpremovegreyareasaboutwhowoulddowhatandidentifyingwhatneedstobedonebylayingdownresponsibilitiesearlyon(apartfromthenon-transferablelegalresponsibilities).
7 Workundertakenforaclientbyacontractorisusuallycoveredbyacivilcontract.Itisgoodpracticeforhealthandsafetyrequirementstobewrittenintosuchacontract.However,healthandsafetyresponsibilitiesaredefinedbycriminallawandcannotbepassedonfromonepartytoanotherbyacontract.Inanyclient/contractorrelationship,bothpartieswillhavedutiesunderhealthandsafetylaw.Similarly,ifthecontractoremployssubcontractorstocarryoutsomeorallofthework,allpartieswillhavesomehealthandsafetyresponsibilities.Theextentoftheresponsibilitiesofeachpartywilldependonthecircumstances.(Extractfrom:Use of contractors: A joint responsibilityINDG368.14)
Soundadvice Page122of144
Health and Safety Executive
CASE STUDY
One fixer expressed this view:
‘When going to work in premises new to me, it would be helpful to make it part of the contract that the venue owner ensures there is a briefing re exits, hazards, fire arrangements, equipment location and to include noise issues.
‘I’d like to see set out what noise-reduction features and equipment are available within the venue. They should make available noise assessments carried out by other users of the venue when performing, including what measures they took and the effectiveness of those measures. I don’t want to have to chase it up but to have it as a clear part of the contract. No arguments.’
8 Thisappendixlistssomeoftheconsiderationsthatcouldformpartofanagreement.Howeverblanketget-outclausessuchas‘youmustwearhearingprotectionatalltimes’shouldbeavoided.Contractsshouldbetailoredtotheparticularsituation.Thisadvicedoesnotcovertheareaofcontractsofemploymentnorisitexhaustive:
n Clarifytheresponsibilities,requirementsandthedifferenthealthandsafetyneedsandcommitmentsoftheparties.
n Establishwhowillbethekeypersontomakefinaldecisions;thisisessentialwheremanycontractors/subcontractorswillbeworking.Ensurethisinformationisprovidedtoeveryonewhoneedstoknow.
n Establishwhethernoiselevelmeasurementsaretobecarriedout–bothinitialandongoingmonitoring.
n Specifywhoisresponsibleforthecontrolofamplifiedsoundlevels.n Establishwhetherlimitersaresetonanyamplifiedmusic.n Establishwhich,ifany,partieswouldsufferfinanciallossifitbecamenecessary
toterminateaperformancebecauseofnoiseissues.n Takeaccountofanypyrotechnicsorsimilareffectsatanearlystageand
specifytherequirementstomeetnoiseriskassessmentoutcomesinthecontractswithsuppliersoftheeffects.
n Establishtimeparameters.n Provideasummaryofkeytaskstobecarriedout.n Establishwhoisresponsibleforensuringthatasufficientnoiseriskassessment
becarriedoutandatwhattimeandwhowillimplementanynecessarycontrolmeasures.
n Specifysitemeeting(s)withtherelevantperson(s)fromthevenue(s)andtheproducer(s)todiscussnoise-controlstrategies.
n Specifyanearlymeetingbetweenrelevantpeoplefromeachgroupwhereseveralgroupsareduetoworktogether.Thiswillenablethebringingtogetherofdifferentassessmentinformationandresolutionofpossiblyconflictingneeds.
n Consultwiththeenforcingauthoritieswhererequired/appropriate.
9 Provideinformationsuchas:
n whatnoise-controlequipment,bothfixedandmobile,willbeprovidedinthevenue;
n detailsofmeasurementsofsoundlevelsinthevenuetakenbythevenueowner;
n accesstoaccumulatedrecordsrelatingtonoisefromothervenueusersincluding,whereavailable,assessmentsoftherepertoiresuitableforthevenueandnoise-controlstrategiesadopted;
n audienceseatingplansfortheproduction;n anyknownrequirements/concerns/recommendations/commentsmadeby
enforcementauthoritiesaboutnoiseissuesspecifictotheeventorthevenue;
Soundadvice Page123of144
Health and Safety Executive
n regardingequipment:technicalspecificationsincludingnoise-outputparameters,integrationwithotherequipmentandbestpositioningforperformanceandnoise-controlrequirements;
n wherehearingprotectionisidentifiedasnecessary,aspecificationofthetypeanduseofhearingprotectionforallcontractorstomeet;
n anythingrelevantarisingoutoftheeventtothevenueoperatortoaddtodatabasesofuserassessmentsinthevenue.
10 Theimplicationsfornoise-reductioncontrolmeasurescouldformpartofallrelevantcontractualrelationshipscoveringsuchmattersas:
n refurbishment/decorationcontracts;n effectsofusingorsitingotherequipment/materials;n setdesignsforproductions;n puttingdownfloororstagecoverings;n changingfurniture;n fittingdouble-glazing.
11 Anysuchissuesshouldbeconsideredinconjunctionwithotherhealthandsafetyconcernssuchasfire.
Soundadvice Page124of144
Health and Safety Executive
Appendix 4Estimating noise exposure using the points system
Figure 23 HSE’sready-reckonerfordailynoiseexposure
Noise exposure ready-reckoner (Daily exposure)
© Crown copyright 2007
Duration of exposure (hours) Sound pressure level, LAeq (dB) ¼ ½ 1 2 4 8 10 12
Total exposure points
Noise exposure LEP,d (dB)
105 320 625 1250
104 250 500 1000
103 200 400 800
102 160 320 630 1250
101 125 250 500 1000
100 100 200 400 800 3200 100
99 80 160 320 630 1250 2500 99
98 65 125 250 500 1000 2000 98
97 50 100 200 400 800 1600 97
96 40 80 160 320 630 1250 1250 96
95 32 65 125 250 500 1000 1000 95
94 25 50 100 200 400 800 800 94
93 20 40 80 160 320 630 630 93
92 16 32 65 125 250 500 625 500 92
91 12 25 50 100 200 400 500 600 400 91
90 10 20 40 80 160 320 400 470 320 90
89 8 16 32 65 130 250 310 380 250 89
88 6 12 25 50 100 200 250 300 200 88
87 5 10 20 40 80 160 200 240 160 87
86 4 8 16 32 65 130 160 190 130 86
85 6 12 25 50 100 125 150 100 85
84 5 10 20 40 80 100 120 80 84
83 4 8 16 32 65 80 95 65 83
82 6 12 25 50 65 75 50 82
81 5 10 20 40 50 60 40 81
80 4 8 16 32 40 48 32 80
79 6 13 25 32 38 25 79
78 5 10 20 25 30 20 78
77 8 16 20 24 16 77
76 6 13 16 20
75 5 10 13 15
Instructions:• For each task or period of noise exposure in the working day look up in the table on
the left the exposure points corresponding to the sound pressure level and duration (e.g. exposure to 93 dB for 1 hour gives 80 exposure points);
• Add up the points for each task or period to give total exposure points for the day; • Look up in the table on the right the total exposure points to find the corresponding
daily noise exposure (e.g. a total exposure points for the day of 280 points gives a daily noise exposure of between 89 and 90 dB).
Soundadvice Page125of144
Health and Safety Executive
Figure 24 HSE’sready-reckonerforweeklynoiseexposure
Noise exposure ready-reckoner (Weekly exposure)
© Crown copyright 2007
Points Daily noise exposure, LEP,d
(dB) Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5 Day 6 Day 7
Total exposure points
Weekly noise exposure LEP,w (dB)
95 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 1000 5000 95
94 800 800 800 800 800 800 800 4000 94
93 630 630 630 630 630 630 630 3200 93
92 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 2500 92
91 400 400 400 400 400 400 400 2000 91
90 320 320 320 320 320 320 320 1600 90
89 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 1300 89
88 200 200 200 200 200 200 200 1000 88
87 160 160 160 160 160 160 160 800 87
86 130 130 130 130 130 130 130 630 86
85 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 500 85
84 80 80 80 80 80 80 80 400 84
83 65 65 65 65 65 65 65 320 83
82 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 250 82
81 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 200 81
80 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 160 80
79 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 130 79
78 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 100 78
Instructions:• For each working day in the week look up in the table on the left the exposure points
corresponding to that day’s noise exposure (e.g. a noise exposure on Day 1 of 90 dB gives 320 points);
• Add up the points for each day worked to give total exposure points for the week; • Look up in the table on the right the total exposure points to find the corresponding
weekly noise exposure (e.g. a total exposure points for the week of 2000 points gives a weekly noise exposure of 91 dB).
Soundadvice Page126of144
Health and Safety Executive
Example one: Bar staff
1 Employeesinanightclubhaveatypicalworkpattern.Theyworkforatotalof6hoursinthenightclubfrom20:00to02:00thefollowingmorning.Duringthisshifttheywork:
n behindabarfor2hourswherethenoiselevelis90dB;n collectingglassesfor2hourswherethenoiselevelis94dB;n workinginthecloakroomfor90minuteswherethenoiselevel,determined
usingasimplelisteningtest,suggestsalevelofapproximately80dB;n inthestaffroomfor30minuteswherethenoiselevel,determinedusinga
simplelisteningtest,suggestsalevelofapproximately80dB.
2 Thecalculationofthenoiseexposureisshownbelow,basedonthenoiseexposureready-reckoneratwww.hse.gov.uk/noise/calculator.htm:
Noise level
Duration Notes Exposure points
90dB 2hours 2hourcolumnand90dBrow
80
94dB 2hours 2hourcolumnand94dBrow
200
80dB 2hours Theexposureinthecloakroomandstaffroomareaddedtogiveatotalof2hours
8
Totalnoiseexposurepoints 288
LEP,d 89to90dB
3 Thisworkpatternofnoiseexposuregivesadailyexposure(LEP,d)ofbetween89and90dB.Thepriorityfornoisecontrolorriskreductionisthenoiseexposurewhileworkingbehindthebarandwhilecollectingglasses,asthesegivethehighestindividualnoiseexposurepoints.
Example two: Weekly averaging using the HSE on-line calculator
4 Steveisasoundengineerwhodoesanaverageoftwoshowsaweek.Theremainderofhistimeisspentpreparingandservicingequipment,paperworkandtravel.Assessinghisoverallnoiseexposureonthebasisofasingleday’smeasurementwouldnotberepresentative–itwouldeitherbetoohighonashowday,ortoolowonawarehouseday.TheHSEwebsitehasbothdailyandweeklynoiseexposurecalculatorsthatallowinputofsamplemeasurementstogiveanaverageoverallweeklyexposure.
Soundadvice Page127of144
Health and Safety Executive
5 Anaverageshowdaywouldinclude:
Activity Duration Noise level (LAeq)
Traveltoshow 45minutes 75dB
Load-inandinstallation
2.5hours 72dB
Systemcheck 15minutes 89dB
Soundcheck 30minutes 92dB
Show 2.5hours(inc.supportact)
96dB
Load-outandtravel 1.5hours 73dB
6 Inputtingthesevaluesintothedailyexposurenoisecalculator(seeFigure25)givesanaveragepersonalexposureof91dBandanexposurepointvalueof436.Notetheinsignificanceoftheset-upandtravelperiodscomparedtooverallexposure.
7 ForSteve,non-showdaysareusuallyoftwotypes;officeorwarehouse.Officedayspresentnegligiblenoiseexposureandthedailyexposureisbelow70dB.
8 Warehousedaysareabitmorevariableandmayincluderunningsoundsystemstocheckcomponents,usingacompressorforspraypaintingandsoon.Ifthesamedailyexposureprocessisadoptedforarepresentativewarehouseday,thisgivesthefollowingfigures:
Exposure calculator
Noise level(LAeq dB)
Exposureduration (hours)
Exposure points(job/task)
Exposure pointsper hour
75 0.7572 2.589 0.2592 0.596 2.5
128
31393
11
3163
15773
Job / task 1
Job / task 2
Job / task 3
Job / task 4
Job / task 5
Job / task 6
Job / task 7
Job / task 8
1.5 1 173 1.5
Total duration 8
Daily noise exposure (LEP,d) 91 dB 436 points
Activity Duration Noise level (LAeq)
Stockcheckandequipmentpreparation
3.5hours 68dB
Loading/unloadingvehicles
1.5hours 78dB
Systemoperationcheck
15minutes 92dB
Generaladminandoffice
2.75hours 65dB
Useofspraybooth 30minutes 83dB
Figure 25 Resultsfromdailynoiseexposurecalculatorforanaverageshowday
Soundadvice Page128of144
Health and Safety Executive
9 Inputtingthesevaluesintothedailyexposurenoisecalculatorgivesanaveragepersonalexposureof79dBandanexposurepointvalueof25(seeFigure26).
10 Toestablisharepresentativeweeklyexposure,takethesethreeexposurepatternsandaddthemintotheweeklyexposurecalculator.Stevedoestwoshowsandtwowarehousedaysaweek,andoneoffice-onlyday.
11 Inputtingthesevaluesintotheweeklyexposurenoisecalculatorgivesanaveragepersonalexposureof87dB(seeFigure27).
12 Theresultsshowthatevenwithtworelativelyquietwarehousedaysandone‘veryquiet’office-onlyday,Steve’sexposureis87dB;thisisabovetheupperexposureactionvalue.Thedosehereceivesonshowdaysisthemostsignificant.
13 ForafreelancemusicianexampleseeSoundAdvice1‘Freelancers’.
Exposure calculator
Noise level(LAeq dB)
Exposureduration (hours)
Exposure points(job/task)
Exposure pointsper hour
68 3.578 1.592 0.2565 2.7583 0.5
141604
026308
73
Job / task 1
Job / task 2
Job / task 3
Job / task 4
Job / task 5
Job / task 6
Job / task 7
Job / task 8
1.573 1.5
Total duration 8.5
Daily noise exposure (LEP,d) 79 dB 25 points
Daily exposure(LEP,d dB)
919179797073
Day 1
Day 2
Day 3
Day 4
Day 5
Day 6
Day 7
Day 8
LEP,w
73
87 dB
Weekly noise exposure calculator
Figure 26 Resultsfromdailynoiseexposurecalculatorforwarehouseday
Figure 27 Resultsfromweeklynoiseexposurecalculator
Soundadvice Page129of144
Health and Safety Executive
Appendix 5Measuring noise
1 ThisAppendixgivesabriefoverviewofthetechniquesusedtomeasurenoise.Itisaimedatprovidingsupportinginformationratherthanasaguidetocompetency.FullerinformationcanbefoundinL108.Noisemeasurementsshouldbecarriedoutbysomeonewhois‘competent’,withtherelevantskills,knowledgeandexperiencetoundertakemeasurementsintheparticularworkingenvironment.Noise-measuringequipmentgenerallyinvolvestheuseofameterincorporatingamicrophoneandamethodofrecordingthenoiselevels.Theexacttypeandhowitisusedwilldependonwhatisbeingmeasuredandwhy.
Establishing personal noise exposure
2 Determiningpersonalnoiseexposuredependsonknowingthenoiselevelsthatapersonisexposedto,andhowlongtheyareexposedtotheselevels.Whenmakingnoisemeasurementstheaimistoestablishthenoiseatthepositionoccupiedbytheheadofthepersonwhoseexposureisbeingevaluated.
Hand-held sound-level meters
3 Onemethodistheuseofahand-heldsound-levelmeter.Thisismostsuitedtomakingsamplenoisemeasurementsatthepositionofaperson’shead.Wherenoisesourcesaredistinctandclosetothesubject,suchasplayingofmusicalinstruments,itisparticularlyimportanttochooseanappropriatemeasurementposition.Wherethemeasurementismadeatthesideofaperson’shead,itshouldbemadeonthesidewherenoiselevelsarehigher.Whereapersonisworkinginanareawithabroaderdiffusenoisesourcethenthemeasuringpositionisnotsocritical,asitisthenoiselevelintheareaintowhichthepersonisenteringthatisbeingmeasured,suchasanareainfrontofastageatanoutdoorevent.Inthiscasetakinganaveragenoisemeasurementovertheareamaybeappropriate.
Personal dosemeters
4 Anothermethodistheuseofdosemeters.Thesehavetheadvantageofbeingabletomeasurenoiseoverprolongedperiodsoftime,eventhefullworkingday.Varioustypesareinusebutallofthemwillhaveamicrophonethatcanbemountedontheshoulder,tomakearepresentativemeasurementofnoiseattheheadposition.Themicrophoneshouldbeplacedonthesideoftheheadmostexposedtonoise.Elevatednoiselevelswillberecordedwheredosemetersaremistreated.Theycanbepronetoerrorsbyaccidentallyknocking,rubbingorcoveringthemicrophone,soemployersneedtobesurethatthelevelsrecordedreflecttheworkingconditions.Theyoftenallowavisualrecordofnoiselevelsovertimetobeproduced,socanhelptounderstandthedominantsourcesofnoiseexposureforpeoplewhoareexposedtovariousnoisesourcesduringtheday.
Fixed monitoring
5 Thisisoftenusedbyemployerstomonitornoiselevelsinaspecificareawherepreviousinvestigationshaveestablishedalevelthatshouldnotbeexceeded.Amicrophonewillbeinstalledatapointthathasbeenidentifiedasbeingimportantformonitoringandtheinformationrelayedtoameteringpointthatcanbeseenbyadutymanager.Thisisusefulinclubsandpubswherebandsbringintheirownequipment.Noiselimiterswithfeedbacksystems(seeSoundAdvice5‘Pubsandclubs’)areavariationonthistheme.
Soundadvice Page130of144
Health and Safety Executive
Appendix 6Risers
1 Risersareplatforms,sometimescalledrostrumsorrostra,usedtoraisemusicianssothatthesoundfromtheirinstrumentsisnotaimeddirectlyintotheearsofmusiciansinfront(orbehindinthecaseofFrenchhorns).Typicallyrisersareusedtoelevatethebrasssectionandwoodwindsectionsbuttheymaybeusefulforothermusicianssuchaspercussionandchoirs.Windinstrumentplayerswillgenerallynothavetoworksohardtoproducetheirsoundifrisersareused.
2 Theheightofrisersshouldbeadjustedtosuitparticularperformers.If,forexample,atrumpetplayerhabituallyperformswithbelldown,puttingthetrumpeteronarisercouldmakemattersworsebycausingthenoisetobeaimeddirectlyattheearsofthemusicianinfront.(Inthiscasestaggeringthelayoutsothatthesoundofthetrumpetisdirectedbetweenthetorsosofthemusiciansinfrontmayhelp.)Experimentingisusuallynecessarytodecidethemostsuitableheightsofrisersintheparticularcircumstances.
3 Aheightof50cmisoftenregardedasagoodstartinglevel.Whenusingrisers,makesurethatthereisstillgoodheadroomandthattheperformersarenottooclosetotheceiling.Whereverpossiblethereshouldbebetween2.5mand3.5mbetweentheriserandanyoverhangingceiling.
4 Theedgesofrisersshouldbemarked.Accesstorisersmustbesafeandsuitable.Guardrailsorotherprotectionisneededattherearofriserstostoppeople,instrumentsandequipmentfallingofftheedge.
Percussion
Brass
Woodwind
Violins
Figure 28 Theeffectofrisers
Soundadvice Page131of144
Health and Safety Executive
Appendix 7Acoustic screens
Use of screens
1 Acousticscreensshouldonlybeusedinaccordancewiththeriskassessmentandonacollectivebasisasdeterminedbyapersonwhoiscompetent.Itisessentialthatscreensarecarefullysitedtoensurethattheydonotcreateasecondaryproblemofreflectedsoundforplayerscloseby.Screensshouldbeaslargeaspossible,andextendverticallyasfaraspossible.Theapplicationofabsorptiontothemhelpscontrolsoundlevels.
2 Propertrainingisessentialonthechoiceanduseofacousticscreens.Extremecareisneededinpositioningscreens.Experimentingisusuallynecessarytoachievethebestresult.
3 Largescreensmayhelptoisolatepercussionsections,othernoisyinstrumentsandloudspeakersfromotherperformers.Howevertheyneedenoughroomtobeeffectiveandcanreflectsoundbackatperformersseatedbehindthemunlessarrangedsoasnottoincreasethesoundlevelsfortheseperformers.Largescreensmayproducedistortionandmakeitdifficultfortheperformertohearotherinstruments.Inmostenvironments,itmaybenecessarytoincludevisionpanelsinscreensunlessthescreensthemselvesaretransparent.
4 Screensshouldnotberegardedaspersonalprotectiveequipmentastheycandoublethenoiseexposureoftheplayertotherear,aswellasincreasingtheriskofanover-playinginjury.Theprotectionaffordedtotheplayerinfrontmayprovetobemorepsychologicalthanacousticalthoughthismaybeworthwhilewheretherisksofhyperacusisorstressaresignificant.
5 Acousticscreenscanprovidesomeprotectiontoindividualplayersfromnoisysectionsinorchestrallayouts.Howeverscreensarenotusefultoallsectionsofanorchestra,forexamplehorns,andcansometimescausesoundtoreflectbacktotheperformer.
6 Inamplifiedmusicenvironments,thestrategicpositioningofappropriateabsorbentscreenscanprovidesignificantprotection.Wherethesoundisamplifiedandperformersareusingmonitors,drumkitsshouldbemic’dandlocatedinboothswherepossible.Alternativelyplacealargescreeninfrontorbehindthedrumkit(wherevisionisrequired,thiscouldbetransparent)tohelpisolatethedrummer’ssoundfromtherestoftheperformers.
7 Infilm-setenvironments,theuseofappropriateabsorbentscreenspositionedoutofshotcanbeusedasprotectionduringloudactivities.
Personal screens
8 Individualacousticscreenscanbelocatedaroundplayerstohelpprotectthemfromhighsoundlevelsproducednearby.Individualacousticscreensaremosteffectiveifplacedneartoaperformer’sheadandusedinaccordancewiththemanufacturer’sinstructions.Theindiscriminateuseofpersonalscreenscanactuallyincreasethenoiseexposureforotherssoscreensshouldbeintroducedinaconsideredmanner.Itisnotacceptabletoslightlyreduceamediumrisk(forexample,totheperformerinfrontofascreen)bydoublingahighrisktothemusicianplayingintothescreen(whichreflectssoundbackatthemusician).
Soundadvice Page132of144
Health and Safety Executive
Potential problems
9 Employersneedtotakeintoaccountpotentialproblemsiftheyareconsideringinstallingscreens,forexample:
n Lackofroom.n Screenscanreflectsoundbackattheperformersseatedbehindnearby.n Screensmayproducedistortion.n Screensmaymakeitdifficultforperformerstohearotherinstruments.
Types
10 Therearetwomainscreenconstructions:thesearehard(acousticallyreflective)andsoft(acousticallyabsorbent).Thereisahybridthirdtypethatcombinesthehardandsofttypes.
11 Hardscreensarecommonlymadefromplasticorsimilartransparentmaterialtomaintainvisualcontact.
12 Softscreenscompriseanacousticallyabsorbentmaterial(mineralfibre,foam,foilsetc)mountedonapanelandcoveredinadecorativefinish.
13 Screenscanberelativelysmallanddiscretelyplacedtodealwithlocalisedspecificissues.Studioscreensareusually2morsohigh,andcanbeusedtoformenclosures.Thesearenormallyabsorbentandcanincludetransparentvisionpanels.
Figure 29 Localreflectivescreen Figure 30 Absorbent2mhighscreen
Figure 31 Perspexdrumscreens Figure 32 Smallstandscreen
Soundadvice Page133of144
Health and Safety Executive
Appendix 8In-ear monitors
1 AdditionalinformationtothatreferredtoinSoundAdvice4‘Rockandpop’paragraphs24and25onin-earmonitors(IEMs)isprovidedbelow:
Advantages
n Helptowardsaveryquietstageenvironmentwithbenefitsofclarity,controllabilityandcomfort.
n Custom-mouldedearplugprotectsagainstundesiredbackgroundsound.n Belt-cliptransmitter-receiverfeedsdirectsignalintoears,eliminatingneedfor
on-stagemonitorsandreducingon-stagesoundlevels.n Wirelesstransmitter-receiverprovidesfreedomofmovement.n Smallerandlighterthanheadphonemonitors.
Disadvantages
n Moreexpensivethanheadphones.n Trainingessential.n Dangerousunlesslimited.n Maynotbesuitablewithsomemedicalconditions.
Useful for
n Reductionofnoiseexposureduringlivemusicperformances.n Personalisedmonitoring.
2 IEMsareessentiallyearplugswithbuilt-inminiaturemonitorspeakers.IEMsreceiveanaudiosignalfromawirelesstransmitter-receiversystemtoearplugsmouldedtotheshapeoftheuser’searcanals.LessexpensiveIEMsmayuse‘earbuds’ratherthancustom-mouldedplugsbuttheseshouldneverbeusedforhearingprotectionbecausetheearpiecesdonotfitsnuglyandsowillletinmoreoutsidesound,whichleadsinturntohigher,ratherthanlower,monitorlevels.
Figure 33 Custom-fitin-earmonitors
3 In-earmonitorsintendedtoprovidehearingprotectionmustcomplywithBSEN352-215andanyotherappropriateparts.ThiswillensurethatIEMsprovidehearingprotectionfromambientsourcesandprovidenoiselimitationofthesignalreceivedfromthecommunicationsystem.Custom-mouldedearplugsneedtofittightlybeyondthesecondbendintheearcanalortheywillnotkeepoutallbackgroundsound.AnimproperfitcouldcausetheusertoturntheIEMsuptoovercometheundesiredbackgroundsoundunlessanoiselimiterisfitted.ItisessentialthatIEMsarefittedwithnoiselimiterstoreducetheriskofdamagingsoundlevelsbeingdeliveredtothewearer.
Custom-fit in-ear monitorssend an audio signal from awireless transmitter/receiversystem to earplugs moulded to the shape of your ear canals
Soundadvice Page134of144
Health and Safety Executive
4 TraininginhowtouseIEMsisessentialtoavoidturningapotentialbenefitintoahazard.Itisessentialthatuserskeepthevolumedowntoareasonablelevelratherthanturningitupbecausetheylikeitloud.Thesystemsrequireplanning,set-upandamoderateinitialinvestment,butifusedeffectivelythebenefitsoutweighthecosts.
Soundadvice Page135of144
Health and Safety Executive
Appendix 9Click tracks and headphones
Click tracks
1 Avoidoverusingclicktracks.Theyshouldbeelectronicallylimited.Keepthenumberofuserstoaminimumasnoteveryoneinasectionmayneedtohearthetrack.Whenusingsinglemonauralheadphones,consideralternatingtheearpiecefromoneeartotheotheroccasionally,dividingexposurebetweenbothears.Individualuser-volumecontrolsforeachsetofheadphonesshouldbeprovided.
2 Itmaybepossibletoavoidtheuseofclicktracks,forexamplebyprovidingpulsemats.Experimentationwithpulsedcuelightsprovedunsuccessfulandthissystemisnotadvised.
Headphones
3 Thisadvicemainlyrelatestothegeneraluseofheadphones.Fortheuseofheadphonesashearingprotectionseeparagraphs7-9below.
4 Ifheadphonesareused,thetendencyistogeneratein-earnoiselevelslouderthanthoseinthevenue.Tocounteractthisitissensibleonlytouseheadphonesprovidedwithlimiters.Inparticularin-earheadphones(buds)suchasprovidedwithMP3playersshouldbeusedwithextremecareandonlyifequippedwithlimiters.Mostcommerciallyavailableheadphoneswithlimitersarecurrentlysetat93dB.Otherlimitsarepossible.Adviceshouldbesoughtonhowlongtheycanbeusedfor.Itisgoodpracticetocheckalltypesoflimitedheadphonesannuallytomakesurethelimiterisworkingproperly.
5 Theadvantagesanddisadvantagesofheadphonesare:
Advantages
n Allowaveryquietstageenvironment.n Easiertosliponandoffthanin-earmonitors.n Donotrequirecustom-fitting.n Noise-cancellationmodelshelpblockoutbackgroundsound.
Disadvantages
n Heavierandmoreobtrusivethanin-earmonitors.n Manynoise-cancellationmodelscreateafeelingof‘fullness’intheears.n Expensive.n Dangerousunlesslimited.
Useful for
n Studioapplications(musicians,vocalists,andsoundengineers).n Liveapplications(DJsandsoundengineers).n Live-performancecommunicationpurposes.n Low-ambient-noiseenvironments(areaswherethedailynoiseexposureis
below85dB).
6 Mostheadphonesoffernoorlittleprotectionfromambientnoise.
Soundadvice Page136of144
Health and Safety Executive
7 Theonlytypeofheadphonethatcanbedefinedasahearingprotectorisoneincorporatedintoanearmuff.
8 HeadphonesthatcomplywithBSEN352–116providehearingprotectionfromambientsourcesbutdonotprovidelimitationofthesignalreceivedfromthecommunicationsystemunlessnoiselimitersarefitted.HeadphonesthatalsocomplywithBSEN352–68providenoiselimitationofthesignalreceivedfromthecommunicationsystem.Itisstronglyrecommendedthatheadphonesbefittedwithnoiselimiterstoreducetheriskofdamagingsoundlevelsbeingdelivereddirecttothewearer’sears.
9 Headphonescanincorporateacombinationofactiveandpassiveprotectionaswellassignal-limitingcapabilities(soundconveyedelectronically)toaffordoptimumprotectionwitheaseofoperation.Bothactiveandpassiveprotectionishighlydesirableasotherwisethereisariskthatthein-earnoiselevelsmaybelouderthanthoseinthevenuebecausethewearerwillreceiveboththeambientnoiseandtheelectronicallycommunicatednoise.
Good working practice
10 Alistofsuggestionsforgoodworkingpracticeforheadphoneusersinthemusicandentertainmentindustryisgivenbelow:
n Headphonesshouldnotbeshared.Wherethiscannotbeavoided,usersshouldbegiventheirownearpadsandvoicetubes.
n Headphonesshouldbefullyadjustableandwell-maintained.n Headphonesorassociatedequipmentshouldincorporateanadjustablevolume
controlthatenablestheusertolistentoincomingsignalsatacomfortablelevel.n Headphonesshouldbecleanedregularly.Foampadscanbewashed,wiping
cablespreventsthemfrombecomingbrittle,andcleaningvoicetubes(whichcanbecomeblockedwithfood,dustandmake-up)ensurestheleveloftransmittedsignalsremainsaudible.
n Usersshouldbeallowedtimetomakeadjustmentstotheirequipment,andtocleanandmaintainit.
n Usersshouldreceiveregulartrainingthatincludeshowtousetheheadphonesandassociatedequipment,anyvolume-controlfeaturesandwhyadjustmentofthelisteninglevelthroughtheheadphonesisimportant,andtheimportanceofregularcleaningandmaintenance.
n Reducingambientnoiselevelswillenableheadphoneuserstokeeplisteninglevelsaslowaspossible.
Soundadvice Page137of144
Health and Safety Executive
References1 The Control of Noise at Work Regulations 2005SI2005No1643TheStationeryOffice2005ISBN9780110729848(alsoavailablefromwww.opsi.gov.uk)
2 Controlling noise at work. The Control of Noise at Work Regulations 2005. Guidance on RegulationsL108(Secondedition)HSEBooks2005ISBN9780717661640
3 The event safety guide: A guide to health, safety and welfare at music and similar eventsHSG195(Secondedition)HSEBooks1999ISBN9780717624539
4 Management of health and safety at work. Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999. Approved Code of Practice and guidanceL21(Secondedition)HSEBooks2000ISBN9780717624881
5 The Work at Height Regulations 2005 (as amended): A brief guideLeafletINDG401(rev1)HSEBooks2007(singlecopyfreeorpricedpacksof10ISBN9780717662319)www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/indg401.pdf
6 BSEN352Parts1-8Hearing protectors. Safety requirements and testingBritishStandardsInstitution(seeotherreferencesand‘Furtherreading’forfulldetails)
7 Protect your hearing or lose it!PocketcardINDG363(rev1)HSEBooks2005(singlecopyfreeorpricedpacksof25ISBN9780717661664)www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/indg363.pdf
8 BSEN352-6:2002Hearing protectors. Safety requirements and testing. Ear-muffs with electrical audio inputBritishStandardsInstitution
9 BSEN352-8:2008Hearing protectors. Safety requirements and testing. Entertainment audio ear-muffsBritishStandardsInstitution
10 Prevention of risks from occupational noise in practiceEuropeanAgencyforSafetyandHealthatWork2005ISBN9789291911530.Downloadfromhttp://osha.europa.eu/publications/reports/6905812
11 A sound ear II: The Control of Noise at Work Regulations 2005 and their impact on orchestrasAssociationofBritishOrchestras2008.Downloadfromwww.abo.org.uk
12 TheBuildingRegulations2000(asamended)BuildingBulletin93Acoustic design of schools.Viewatwww.teachernet.gov.uk/acoustics
13 The Education (School Premises) Regulations 1999 SI 1999No2TheStationeryOffice1999ISBN9780110803319(alsoavailablefromwww.opsi.gov.uk)
14 Use of contractors: A joint responsibilityLeafletINDG368HSEBooks2002(singlecopyfreeorpricedpacksof10ISBN9780717625666)www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/indg368.pdf
15 BSEN352-2:2002Hearing protectors. Safety requirements and testing. Ear-plugsBritishStandardsInstitution
Soundadvice Page138of144
Health and Safety Executive
16 BSEN352-1:2002Hearing protectors. Safety requirements and testing. Ear-muffsBritishStandardsInstitution
Soundadvice Page139of144
Health and Safety Executive
Further readingBSEN352-3:2002Hearing protectors. Safety requirements and testing. Ear-muffs attached to an industrial safety helmetBritishStandardsInstitution
BSEN352-4:2001Hearing protectors. Safety requirements and testing. Level-dependent ear-muffsBritishStandardsInstitution
BSEN352-5:2002Hearing protectors. Safety requirements and testing. Active noise reduction ear-muffsBritishStandardsInstitution
BSEN352-7:2002Hearing protectors. Safety requirements and testing. Level-dependent ear-plugsBritishStandardsInstitution
BSEN458:2004Hearing protectors. Recommendations for selection, use, care and maintenance. Guidance documentBritishStandardsInstitution
Control of noise in the music entertainment industry. Code of practiceWorksafeWesternAustraliaCommission2003www.docep.wa.gov.au/worksafe
Health surveillance at workHSG61(Secondedition)HSEBooks1999ISBN9780717617050
Hear the music: Hearing loss prevention for musiciansDrMarshallChasin2006.Availablefromwww.westone.com
Listen while you work: Hearing conservation for the arts for performers and other workers in art and entertainmentSafety&HealthinArtsProduction&Entertainment(SHAPE),Canada2001ISBN9780772646439www.shape.bc.ca/resources/pdf/listen.pdf
Noise at work: Guidance for employers on the Control of Noise at Work Regulations 2005LeafletINDG362(rev1)HSEBooks2005(singlecopyfreeorpricedpacksof10ISBN9780717661657)www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/indg362.pdf
Noise levels and noise exposure of workers in pubs and clubs: A review of the literatureRR026HSEBooks2002ISBN9780717625710
Personal protective equipment at work (Second edition). Personal Protective Equipment at Work Regulations 1992 (as amended). Guidance on RegulationsL25(Secondedition)HSEBooks2005ISBN9780717661398
SoundAdvicewebsite–http://soundadvice.info
Soundadvice Page140of144
Health and Safety Executive
Glossary and useful informationABOAssociationofBritishOrchestras.
Action valuessee‘Exposureactionvalues’.
BacklineCollectionofmusicalinstrumentsandtheirdirectamplificationonstage.
Bone conductionTransmissionofsoundsignalsthroughthebonesoftheskull.Thesignalisdirectedstraightintotheinnerpartoftheear,bypassingthemiddleandouterpartsoftheear.
BSBritishStandard.
BS ENEuropeanStandardadoptedasaBritishStandard.
Click trackBackingormetronometrackthatisplayedbacktomusicians(normallythroughheadphones)toenablethemtokeepaccuratetime.Itiscommonforsituationswheredrummershavetokeeptimewithapre-recordedorsequencedtrack.
CompetentPeoplehavingsuchpracticalandtheoreticalknowledgeandsuchexperienceasisnecessarytocarryoutthework.Needtobeawareofthelimitsoftheirexpertiseandknowledgeandsufficientlyindependentandimpartialtoallowthemtomakeobjectivedecisions.Donotnecessarilyneedtobeemployedbyanindependentcompany,butin-housepersonnelmusthaveenoughauthorityandindependencetobeabletomakenecessarydecisionsandrecommendations.
Cue lightsAmeansofindicatingtoperformerswhentostartandstop,usinga(typicallygreen)lamp.
DiplacusisConditionwherethetwoearshearagivenpitchastwodistincttones.
Distributed sound systemTechnicaltermforasoundreproduction/reinforcementsystemthatusesanumberofsmallerloudspeakerenclosuresplacedaroundthevenueratherthanoneortwolargestacksatthesideofthestage.Thisreducesthesoundlevelfromindividualspeakerswhileachievinganevenoverallspreadofsoundatanacceptablelevelforlisteners.
Engager/ContractorIntheentertainmentindustryemployersareoftenknownasengagersorcontractors.Othertermsused,whichmayormaynotimplyemployment,includeproducers,promoters,managersandfixers.
Exposure action values (EAV)Levelsofexposuretonoiseatwhichcertainactionsneedtobetaken.Thevaluesare:
n lowerexposureactionvalues(LEAV):– dailyorweeklyexposureof80dB;– peaksoundpressureof135dB;
n upperexposureactionvalues(UEAV):– dailyorweeklyexposureof85dB;– peaksoundpressureof137dB.
Soundadvice Page141of144
Health and Safety Executive
Exposure limit values (ELV)Theserelatetopersonalexposuretonoiseandmustnotbeexceeded:
– dailyorweeklyexposureof87dB;– peaksoundpressureof140dB.
Fold-back monitorsLoudspeakerssitednearperformerstoallowthemtohearspecificsoundswhichwouldotherwisebetooquiet,forexampleforasingeronstagetohearapitorchestra.Includeson-stagemonitorsandsidefills.
FreelancerSomeonewhoisnotpermanentlyemployedfull-timebyanyoneemployer.Afreelancermaygothroughperiodsofself-employmentorbeemployedbymorethanoneemployer.
Frequency analysisThebreakdownofsoundintodiscretecomponentfrequencies,measuredinHertzandusuallygroupedinbandsoroctaves.Appropriateforselectingsuitablehearingprotectionanddesigningacousticcontrolmeasures.
Health record Recordoftheperson’sdetails,workassignmentsandexposures,datesofanyhealthsurveillanceproceduresandinformationontheperson’sfitnesstoworkinnoisyenvironments.Therecorddoesnotcontainclinicaldetailsandmustbekeptbytheemployer.Itisnotaconfidentialdocument.
Health surveillanceForthepurposesofthisdocument,ongoingassessmentofthestateofauralhealthofanemployeeasrelatedtoexposuretonoise.
Hearing PassportIncludesdetailsoftrainingandhealthsurveillanceundertaken(formoreinformationseeMusicians’HearingServices).
Hearing protection zones (sometimes referred to as HPZ)Areaswherethewearingofhearingprotectioniscompulsory.Whereverpracticableallsuchzonesshouldbesignedusingthesignshown.SignsintroducedundertheNoiseatWorkRegulations1989whichrefertoearprotectionzonesarealsoacceptable.
HyperacusisIncreasedsensitivitytosoundwhichmaycausediscomfortorphysicalpain.
HzHertz,SIunitoffrequency.Thehumanearcandetectfrequenciesbetween10and20000Hz.
In-ear monitorsEssentiallyearplugswithbuilt-inminiaturemonitors(loudspeakers).Itisessentialthattheyarefittedwithnoiselimiters.
LAeqThe‘equivalent’continuousnoiselevelthatwoulddeliverthesamenoisedoseasavaryingleveloveragivenperiod,andisagoodwayofdescribingtheaveragelevelofnoise.
LEP,dDailypersonalnoiseexposurelevel.Itisaveragedoveran8-hourperiodratherthantheactualtimeintheworkenvironment.
LEP,w Weeklypersonalnoiseexposurelevel.Itisaveragedoveraperiodof5days(40hours)bymeasuringthenoiseexposureoneachof7days,thendividingtheresultby5.
Limit valuesSee‘Exposurelimitvalues’.
Soundadvice Page142of144
Health and Safety Executive
Line array systemsSometimesknownasphasearraydesign.Averticalhangofloudspeakerswhichgeneratesacylindricalwavefrontwithabetterthrowandaccuratecontrolofoff-axissound.Thiscanmeanthatlevelsatthefrontofavenuedonotneedtobesoloudtoreachtheback.
Medical recordAccountofaperson’sexaminationandtreatmentincludingtheirmedicalhistory,anymedication,therapiesandreferrals.Anindividualmayhavemorethanonemedicalrecord.Themedicalrecordforhearinghealthsurveillancewillcontainthehearinghealthquestionnaire,theearexamination,theaudiogramandanyreferralcorrespondence.Itiskeptbythedoctororoccupationalhealthprofessionalinchargeofthehealthsurveillanceprogramme.Medicalrecordsareconfidentialandmaynotbeshowntotheemployerwithoutthewrittenconsentoftheindividual.
MonitorsSee‘Fold-backmonitors’.
Musicians’ Union60-62ClaphamRoad,LondonSW90JJ.Tel:02075825566www.musiciansunion.org.uk.
Musicians’ Hearing Services (MHS)Anorganisationsetuptolookaftermusicians’hearing.Theywillassesshearing,giveadviceonhearingconservationandsupplycustom-mouldedmusicians’hearingprotection.Theyhavealong-standingrelationshipwiththemusicindustryandofferaservicenotonlytomusiciansbuttoallperformers.Tel:02073232076orwww.musicianshearingservices.co.uk.
Noise doseSee‘Noiseexposure’.
Noise exposure‘Thenoisedose’,whichcanbecalculated,takesaccountoftheactualvolumeofsoundandhowlongitcontinues.Noiseexposureisnotthesameassoundlevel,whichisthelevelofnoisemeasuredataparticularmoment.
Noise limitersSometimesknownasvolumeregulatorydevice(VRD),controlsnoiseexposurefromamplifiedmusic.Modernnoiselimiterscanbefittedwithanti-tamperrelaysconnectedtoexternalswitchestoimprovesystemsecurity.
Noise measurementsDecibels(dB)areusedformeasuringnoise.A-weightingisusedtoapproximatetothefrequencyresponsesofthehumanear.C-weightingisusedtomeasurepeak,impactorexplosivenoise.
Occlusion effectOccurswhenanobject(likeanunventedearplug)completelyfillstheouterportionoftheearcanal.Thischangesthewaysoundsareproducedintheearcanal,especiallynoisesproducedbythebody(forexamplebreathing,swallowingandnoisetravellingthroughboneandtissue).Theresultisthesenoisesappearlouder.
Orchestra pitInatheatre,anareainwhichtheorchestraperformsatalowerlevelinfrontof,andusuallypartiallyunder,thestage.
PA Publicaddresssystem.Sometimescalleda‘tannoy’.Oftenusedtorefertoanyloudspeakertransmittingmessagesratherthanmusic.
Peak valuesSee‘Exposureactionvalues’and‘Exposurelimitvalues’.
Pulse matAnelectro-mechanicalmatthatpulsesintimewithanappliedsignal,typicallyaclicktrack.
Soundadvice Page143of144
Health and Safety Executive
Reference positionStandardlocation,usuallystatic,selectedtoenablemonitoringofnoiselevelstobeconductedbymeasurements.
RisersRostraorplatforms.
RNIDRoyalNationalInstituteforDeafandHardofHearingPeople,19-23FeatherstoneStreet,LondonEC18SLTel:08088080123Information:08706050123www.breakingthesoundbarrier.org.uk/home.Theyalsoofferatelephonehearingteston08456005555.
Seating rotationTheamountofexposuretonoisedependsonwherethemusiciansitsandplayswithintheorchestra/band.Thenoiseexposureofmusiciansmaybevariedbymovingthem.
Shakers (or thumpers)Anattachmentthatfitsdirectlytothedrumstoolandtransmitslow-frequencyvibration–givingtheplayertheright‘feel’withouttheneedforhigh-volumebassspeakers,effectivelyaloudspeakerwithoutacone.Theyallowperformerstousehearingprotectionandmonitortheirperformancewhilestillmaintainingcontactwiththeirinstruments.
Simple listening checksAneasywayofestablishingwhethertheremightbeanoiseproblem.Whereitisdifficulttoholdanormalconversationwithoutshoutingorwherethereisliveamplifiedmusic(asinapub,cluborpopconcert)itisprobablethatthenoiseisabovethelowerexposureactionvalue.
Single number rating (SNR) valueMethodofindicatingthedegreeofprotectionofferedbyahearingprotector.
Sound restorationDeviceinearmuffsthatreducesambientnoiselevelstoallowrelayedcommunicationorothersignalsatareducedlevel.
Stage pitInlargepopconcertstagesandoutdoorevents,anareainfrontofthestageformedbytheedgeofthestageandabarrierafewmetresaway,whichrestrainsthecrowd.
Three-decibel ruleThesoundintensitydoubleswitheverythreedBincrease.Thussoundsat88dBareactuallytwiceasintenseastheyareat85dBand115dBis1000timesasintenseas85dB.
TinnitusBuzzing,ringingortoneintheear.Temporarytinnitusisawarning;asignthat‘yougotawaywithitthattime’.
VRDVolumeregulatorydevice(seenoiselimiter).
Further informationForinformationabouthealthandsafetyringHSE’sInfolineTel:08453450055Fax:08454089566Textphone:08454089577e-mail:[email protected],CaerphillyBusinessPark,CaerphillyCF833GG.
HSEpricedandfreepublicationscanbeviewedonlineororderedfromwww.hse.gov.ukorcontactHSEBooks,POBox1999,Sudbury,SuffolkCO102WATel:01787881165Fax:01787313995.HSEpricedpublicationsarealsoavailablefrombookshops.
BritishStandardscanbeobtainedinPDForhardcopyformatsfromtheBSIonlineshop:www.bsigroup.com/ShoporbycontactingBSICustomerServicesforhardcopiesonlyTel:02089969001e-mail:[email protected].
TheStationeryOfficepublicationsareavailablefromTheStationeryOffice,POBox29,NorwichNR31GNTel:08706005522Fax:08706005533e-mail:[email protected]:www.tso.co.uk(Theyarealsoavailablefrombookshops.)StatutoryInstrumentscanbeviewedfreeofchargeatwww.opsi.gov.uk.
PublishedbyHSE03/10 Page144of144
Health and Safety Executive