SOUTHERN REGIONAL COMMITTEE - SRC - National ...srcncte.in/Decisions and Minutes 2010-13/Minutes/Minutess... · Web viewIn the above writ petition, the State of Kerala is the 1st

254th Meeting of SRC 25-27th of October, 2013

SOUTHERN REGIONAL COMMITTEENATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHER EDUCATION

BANGALORE

Minutes of the 254th Meeting of SRC held at the Conference Hall of NCTE, Bangalore on 25th – 27th Oct, 2013

The following Persons attended the Meeting :-

1. Shri S.Sathyam I.A.S (Retired) - Chairman

2. Prof. K. Dorasami - Member

3. Prof. Sandeep Ponnala - Member

4. Dr.M.P.Vijaykumar, I.A.S(Retired) - Member

5. Smt. Famida Rahim -StateGovt. Representative(KA) (Deputy Director)

6. Mr.R.Kanakarajan - StateGovt.Representative(TN) (Directror)

7. K.A. Hashim (Kerala) - State Govt.Representative(KL) Director SCERT

8. Sri. P. Sriraman Non-Member Regional Director (I/C) - Convenor

The following Members/Representative did not attend the Meeting

Prof. M.A. Khader., Member, Prof. Lalithamma Member and the Representatives of the Govts. of Andhra Pradesh, U.T’s of Lakshadweep, Pondicherry & Andaman & Nicobar Islands.

(S.Sathyam) Chairman

1


SOUTHERN REGIONAL COMMITTEENATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHER EDUCATION

BANGALOREMINUTES OF 254th MEETING OF SRC-NCTE

Sl.No.

Brief Description Remarks of SRC

1. Confirmation of Minutes of 253rd

Meeting held on 30th September & 01st October, 2013

Confirmed

2. Action Taken Report (ATR) on the Minutes of 252nd Meeting held on 13th -14th Sept, 2013

1.Seen2. Three observations by Chairman.

3. Sub-Committee to meet on 12 Nov to check on chronological order.

Table Agenda: Consideration of Final Show Cause Notice reply :

3. APS01316B.Ed

St.Mary College of Education, Warangal,

Andhra Pradesh

AP

St. Marys College of Education, 6-2-7/1, Hyderabad Road, Jangaon, Warangal, Pin - 506167, Andhra Pradesh.

An application was submitted by St. Mary’s College of Education, Warangal District, Andhra Pradesh recognition to B.Ed course was granted on in the office of SRC-NCTE Bangalore.

Thereafter, the Registrar, Kakatiya University, Warangal vide letter dt.14.03.2008 drew the attention of Regional Director, SRC and informed that in the process of granting temporary affiliation to the institutions the university conducted inspection and observed that the building shown was meant for MCA. The fact was noticed by visiting team, which visited for affiliation.

The letter was placed before the SRC in its 157th meeting held on 23rd-24th April 2008. The SRC after careful consideration of all aspects decided to issue show cause notice. Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued on 28.05.2008 to the institution. In response to the notice the applicant institution replied on 19.06.2008 as under:

“The college started construction on second floor on existing building satisfying the NCTE and AICTE norms to run B.Ed and MCA in the existing B.Ed which has two separate entrances with no connectivity between the two colleges. The college promises to submit the approved building plan and photographs with in a month on completion of construction of second floor which is in progress”.

The reply was placed before SRC in its 161st meeting held on 6th-7th August 2008. The SRC has decided and resolved to cause inspection under Section 17 to verify the infrastructural and instructional facilities.

The SRC-NCTE conducted an inspection of the institution under section 17 of NCTE Act 1993 on 18.09.2008. The report received from the visiting team informs that the management was not ready for the inspection now on


2


18.09.2008 because of various factors and asked for postponement of the inspection by three more months.”

The institution has not cooperated in carrying out inspection of institution as per the Provisions of NCTE Act. Therefore, the SRC-NCTE in its 165th meeting held on 27th-28th September, 2008 on careful perusal of the original file of the institution, two visiting team report under section 14 & 17, the letter dated 14.03.2008 from the Registrar, Kakatiya University, Warangal to the Regional Director, SRC and the reply dated.19.06.2008 to the show cause notice issued to the institution and other related documents, Act of NCTE 1993, Regulations and Guidelines issued from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee noted the following:

1. The recognition of the institution has been refused vide order dated.09.01.2004. The institution preferred appeal whereby the order of the SRC was revised vide Appellate Authority Order 10.06.2004. As per the records available in the file the institution has not been issued any formal order of recognition for B.Ed course. It is not known as to how it got affiliation and is conducting B.Ed course.

2. The institution has started functioning in the building submitting an undertaking stating that the infrastructure and instructional facilities will be provided as per NCTE Norms and Standards issued from time to time.

3. As per the visiting team report of Kakatiya University, Warangal the institution has shown the same land for MCA. The same land documents have been submitted to other Regulatory Bodies. The institution misleads NCTE and other regulatory bodies like AICTE.

4. The institution breached oath taken by it in the affidavit dated.25.01.2003 swearing that the land is exclusively meant for running the educational institution and the same shall not be used for any purpose other than teacher education programme.

5. As per NCTE Norms and Standards and Rules and Regulations issued from time to time the institutions are required to have exclusive provision for land and building for teacher education courses, whereas the institution has sought recognition of B.Ed course and in the same premises it started BCA/ MCA. Courses. The land and building were shown to NCTE and suppressing this fact, the same were also shown to AICTE for BCA/ MCA in contravention of the NCTE Norms and Standards.

6. The institution itself accepted in writing to have accommodated B.Ed on first floor and BCA/ MCA on the ground floor in the same building.

7. The institution did not cooperate with the visiting team in carrying out inspection under section 17 on 18.09.2008.

8. The institution violated the provisions contained under various sections of NCTE Act and regulations there under.

The SRC after careful consideration of all aspects decided to withdraw the recognition of the institution from the academic session 2008-09. Further, the SRC also decided to inform the decision to the State Government of Andhra Pradesh and Concerned University for follow-up action immediately, including


3


redistribution of students admitted, if any.

As per the decision of SRC withdrawal order was issued to the institution on 06.10.2008.

Thereafter, the institution has gone in appeal and vide order dated 12.02.2010 the Appellate Authority has confirmed SRC’s withdrawal order but with effect from 2010-11 academic year.

The Institute has approached to Hon’ble High Court in W.P.No.14792 of 2010. Now, the Hon’ble High Court has passed an interim order dated 12.07.2010 in W.P. No. 14792 of 2010 reads as hereunder:

“There shall be interim suspension of the impugned proceedings. However, it is made clear that the petitioner shall not be entitled to run the college in the next academic year in the same premises.

Post after two weeks”.

As such the college is not permitted by the Hon’ble Court order to run in the same premises for the next academic year i.e.2011-12. The institution has vide letter dated 29.04.2011 submitted a DD of Rs.40,000/- as inspection fee with request to cause inspection as the institution has constructed separate building for B.Ed and that it has been granted provisional affiliation by the university with an intake of 120 seats.

The latest status of the case is to be obtained from the advocate. The matter regarding correctness of the SRC order and appeal order is sub justice in W.P.No.14792/10.

The SRC considered the written request of the institution and decided to cause inspection of the institution in the permanent premises.

The SRC in its 205th Meeting 18th - 19th May, 2011 considered the written request of the institution and decided to cause inspection of the institution in the permanent premises.

Accordingly inspection of the institution was conducted on 28.07.2011 & VT Report was received to the SRC-NCTE on 29.07.2011.

The SRC in its 211th Meeting held on 21st-23rd September, 2011 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act.

The institution has been informed accordingly vide letter dated 01.11.2011.

Meanwhile a letter has been received in the office of SRC through E-mail from our legal counsel Shri P. Vinayaka, regarding W.P. No. 31165/2011 filed by St. Mary’s college of Education, Jangaon, Warangal District, Andhra Pradesh.

He stated that the above writ petition came up for admission before Justice Noushal Ali on 25.11.2011. The Hon’ble Judge also orally directed to place the matter before 215-4th SRC meeting scheduled on 28.11.2011 and SRC is at liberty to take an appropriate decision in the matter of the petitioner’s college and to report compliance to petitioner and as well as to the Hon’ble Court by


4


01.12.2011.

The SRC in its 214th Meeting held on 28th November 2011, decided to wait for High court order (Andhra Pradesh as the matter is pending in W.P. No. 31165 of 2011.

The institution has submitted its written representation on 20.06.2012 stating that “as the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad has granted permission the withdrawal of the W.P.No. 31165 of 2011 filed by this institution against the NCTE and the 3 others respondents, and the W.P.No. 31165 is dismissed by the Hon’ble High Court as withdrawn, The Management of this institution has requested to consider the issue and extend the permanent recognition from the year 2012-13. The inspections by the affiliating University of the B.Ed colleges for grant of affiliation for the year 2012-13 has been completed in their region for admissions for the Ed.CET 2012 students. Requesting to consider recognition temporarily for the year 2012-13 also to enable us to submit to the affiliating university for affiliation for the year 2012-13 to join education. CET 2012 web-counseling admissions which will be commenced from the middle of July, 2012”.

The SRC in its 225th Meeting held on 25th-27th June, 2012 considered the matter and request of the institution and decided to await for final decision from the Hon’ble HIgh Court of Andhra Pradesh.

A Hon’ble High Court order dt. 20/07/2012 in W.P. No. 21826 of 2012 stated that “….the impugned order of respondent no. 2 is set aside and respondent No. 2 is directed to re-considered the petitioner’s application for temporary recognition for running B.Ed course in the new building, not with standing the pendency of W.P. No. 14792 of 2010. Respondent No. 2 shall take a final decision and communicate the same to the petitioner within a period of three weeks from the date of receipt of this order”.

The Court order was placed before SRC in its 229th meeting held on 30-31st

July, 2012 and the committee considered the matter and decided to process and put up in the next meeting.

The SRC in its 230th meeting held on 16th and 17th July, 2012 considered the matter and decided as per the direction of the Hon’ble High order to grant temporary recognition for the academic year 2012-2013 only.

Accordingly, as per the decision of SRC and as per the court direction a temporary recognition order for the year 2012-13 for B.Ed course was issued vide order No.F.SRO/NCTE/APS01316/B.Ed/AP/2012-13/45590 dated 27.8.2012.

Now the institution has submitted written representation on 20.11.2012 along with the same court direction in W.P. No. 21826 of 2012. The Hon’ble court order stating as follows; “…..the impugned order of respondent no. 2 is set aside and respondent no. 2 is directed to re-consider the petitioner’s application for temporary recognition for running B.Ed course in the new building, notwithstanding the pendency of W.P. No. 14792 of 2010: Respondent no. 2 shall take a final decision and communicate the same to the petitioner within a period of three weeks from the date of receipt of this order ” .

The institution in its letter dated 20.11.2012 requesting SRC-NCTE, Bangalore


5


as under:-

Further, the Hon’ble High Court of A.P, Hyderabad advised SRC-NCTE, Bangalore vide their orders 2nd cited above also to take a final decision within a three weeks time. The final decision for formal recognition is awaited. The management of the institution requesting the SRC-NCTE-Bangalore to consider the orders of the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh and grant formal recognition to this institution.

A letter dated 20/11/2012 along with court direction was placed before SRC in its 236th Meeting held on 16th-17th December, 2012 and the SRC has decided that put up with a proper note on rectification of deficiencies.

The SRC in its 239th meeting held on 26th-27th February 2013, considered Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh order dated 20/07/2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

1. Up-to-date encumbrance certificate issued by sub-registrar is not submitted.

2. The institution has submitted land usage certificate with Sy.Nos. 235, 235/1, 236/B, 256 and 257, whereas, BCC and affidavit reflects Sy.Nos 236/A, 235/1, 257, which are not matching with LUC submitted, which needs clarification from the institution.

Further, the SRC is unable to comply with the order of Hon’ble High Court about temporary recognition to the institution for B.Ed course, because there is no provision for an arrangement in NCTE regulations.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 09.04.2013. the institution has submitted its written representation on 25.04.2013.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 244th Meeting held on 09th – 11th May, 2013 considered the matter and reply of the institution vide letter dated 25.04.2013 to the show cause notice issued and also Hon.ble High Court direction, decided to:

Call for staff list of the institution duly approved by the competent authority.

Further, the committee decided to write to the Lawyer to inform the Hon’ble Court through an affidavit that SRC is unable to implement the direction of the Hon’ble court about temporary recognition for want of any provision therefore in the Regulations; and, proceeded to process the case by calling for staff list duly approved by the competent authority.

Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 17.06.2013. The institution has submitted its written representation on 18.07.2013.

The Committee in its 251st meeting held on 25-27th Aug, 2013 considered the written reply of the institution vide letter dated 18/07/2013 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

The institution has not submitted approved staff list as per NCTE norms from the Affiliating body/University.


6


Accordingly, a final show cause notice was issued to the institutionon 30.09.2013. The institution has submitted its written representation on 11.10.2013.

On Careful perusal of the reply of the institution to the show cause notice dated 11-10-2013, original file of the institution and staff profiles submitted by the institution in response to the letter of Intent, the Regional Committee decided that Formal Recognition be granted for B.Ed., course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100 (one hundred only) students with effect from the academic session 2013-14.

Consideration of Agenda Items- Volume-01

As per Decision of the SRC 247th, 249th and 250th Meeting decision of the following files are put up for consideration

Sl.No

CodeCourse

Name of the Institution

State

Remarks

4.SRCAPP228

M.Ed-DETamil University,Thanjavur District

TN

Tamil University, Plot No. 1, Trichy Road, Thanjavur Village, Tamil University Post, Thanjavur Taluka, Thanjavur District, Pin-613010, Tamilnadu had applied for grant of recognition to Tamil University, Khasara No. 1, Plot No. 25, Street No. 1, Pillayarpatti Village, Tamil University Post, Thanjavur Taluka, Thanjavur District, Pin-613010, Tamilnadu for M.Ed-DE Course for one year duration under Section 15(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012. The University has submitted hard copy of the application on 18.01.2013 along with processing along with processing fees of Rs.50050/- vide Demand Draft bearing No.708880 dt.21.12.2012 drawn on Bank of India.

Para 7[1-A(i)] and 7[1-A(ii)] of extant NCTE Regulations published in the Gazette of India on 31st August 2009, as amended from time to time, the application shall be summarily rejected under one or more of the following circumstances:

Para 7[1-A (i)]

(a) The processing fee, as provided under rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application;

(b) Hard copy in triplicate of the online application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application;

(c) Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society/University applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application.

Para 7[1-A (ii)] The Regional Committee shall, after recording reasons for rejection under the


7


circumstances referred to in clause (i) above, return the application to the applicant and refund the processing fees within 30 days of the online submission of the application.

Time limit granted by NCTE (HQ), Due to technical reasons in online application portal of the NCTE website on 30 th

and 31st December 2012, some applicant University faced difficulties in the submission of hardcopies of the online application for the academic session 2013-14 to the concerned Regional Committee in time. Those Universities are allowed to submit hard copies in triplicate to the concerned Regional Committee up to 21st

January 2013.

The SRC in its 239th meeting held on 26th -27th February, 2013 reviewed the duly scrutinized above new application received by Southern Regional Office, NCTE for the Session 2013-14. Accordingly, the above application, which suffer from basic infirmities, is summarily rejected as per 7 [1–A (i)] of NCTE Regulations 2009.

1. On-line application was submitted on 31.12.2012, whereas the hard copy of the same is submitted on 18.01.2013, as such, the Society has not dispatched the Hard copy of the application within 7 days of the submission of the on-line application.

2. The University failed to submit valid printout of on-line application on or before 21st Jan 2013 as per NCTE (HQ) direction.

Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the University on 10.04.2013.

As per the oral instructions of SRC, in its 250 th meeting held on 11th-13th August 2013 considered the matter and decided to Process the application and write to MHRD for condonation of delayed submission of hard copy. Accordingly, as per the decision has been processed of SRC the application has been processed.

The Committee considered the matter, decided and advised Southern Regional Office to write to the University to obtain UGC clearance for Distance Learning as per NCTE Norms & Standards of Appendix-11, for M.Ed (ODL).

Further, it is decided that, Distance Learning courses are self-financing courses. University has therefore to pay for the Endowment and Reserve fund of Rs. 5 lacs and 3 lacs respectively.

5. APS09054B.Ed/

Sri Venkata Rathna

College of Education,

Kurnool District

AP------------

APS06270B.Ed/

Sri Sainath College of

Venkata Rathna College of Education, No. 87/1364, Maruthi Nagar, Kallur, Kurnool District-518002, Andhra Pradesh.

Sri Shiridi Sainath Educational Society, Kurnool District, Andhra Pradesh has submitted in the Southern Regional Committee of NCTE for grant of recognition to Venkata Rathna College of Education, No. 87/1364, Maruthi Nagar, Kallur, Kurnool District-518002, Andhra Pradesh for B.Ed Course for one year duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act. 1993 and received in the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 08/10/2007.The application was processed and recognition was granted for offering B.Ed course with an annual intake of 100 students on 18/01/2008 at Venkata Rathna College of Education, No. 87/1364, Maruthi Nagar, Kallur, Kurnool District-518002, Andhra Pradesh.

The institution has submitted its written representation on 19/02/2013 stating


8


Education, Kurnool District

------------------

APS06268B.Ed

Sri Siridi Baba College of Education,

Kurnool District

as follows:

“I humbly submit that I have already submitted a letter to Regional Director, SRC-NCTE, Bangalore, bearing No. 122483 Dt. 27/11/2012 and bearing No. 123138 Dt. 27/12/2012 in addition to the above letter. I am herewith enclosing a copy of the NCTE-Recognition dated 2008 of APS0 9054 of Venkata Ratna College of Education, Kurnool for your kind reference.

In addition I am herewith submit the photos of labs, library and class rooms of above building is purely utilized on rented basis till the new construction of building is made by the Shri Shridi Sainath Educational Society.

I request the honourable authorities to kindly permit us to use the present shifted building for running of Venkata Ratna College of Education (Doctor’s colony area) as per regulation stipulated during 2006. I am already enclosing an affidavit submitted for the construction of new building by the management.

May I request you sir to kindly issue necessary permission orders for the same, for which kind of act, I shall remain grateful to you”.

Old address New addressNo. 87/1364, Maruthi Nagar, Kallur, Kurnool District-518002, Andhra Pradesh.

Doctor’s colony area (full address not mentioned in the representation).

Sl.No. APS09054/B.Ed APS06270/B.Ed APS06268/B.Ed

Present Status: (Granted on 18.01.2008)

Sri Shiridi Sainath Educational Society, Kurnool District, Andhra Pradesh has submitted in the Southern Regional Committee of NCTE for grant of recognition to Venkata Rathna College of Education, No. 87/1364, Maruthi Nagar, Kallur, Kurnool District-518002, Andhra Pradesh for B.Ed Course for one year duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act. 1993 and received in the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 08/10/2007.

The application was processed and recognition was granted for offering B.Ed course with an

Present Status: Pending in the courtBrief: Recognition was not granted to the institution. SRC refused the recognition on 07.05.2009 for the following:-1. The built up space of 7200 sq.ft is not adequate for proposed B.Ed course.2. The equipment in Psychology and E.T. labs are not adequate for proposed B.Ed course.3. The furniture in labs, library, staff rooms are not adequate for B.Ed course.The institution filed court case in the Hon’ble High Court of A.P. in W.P.No.16938 of 2009 the same was placed before SRC

Present Status: Pending in the

Court (Recognition refused on 08.05.2009)

Sri Shiridi Sainath Educational Society, Kurnool, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Sri Siridi Baba College of Education, Sri Shiridi Sainath Educational, C/o. K.M.D. Azmathulla, H.No.1, College Road, Nandikothkur, Kurnool – 518401, Andhra Pradesh for B.Ed course of one year duration under section 14 (I) of the NCTE Act,


The Southern Regional Committee considered the above matter and decided to Submit comparative statement for APS09054, APS06270 and APS06268 in 251st meeting.

9


annual intake of 100 students on 18/01/2008 at Venkata Rathna College of Education, No. 87/1364, Maruthi Nagar, Kallur, Kurnool District-518002, Andhra Pradesh.

The institution has submitted its written representation on 19/02/2013 stating as follows:

“I humbly submit that I have already submitted a letter to Regional Director, SRC-NCTE, Bangalore, bearing No. 122483 Dt. 27/11/2012 and bearing No. 123138 Dt. 27/12/2012 in addition to the above letter. I am herewith enclosing a copy of the NCTE-Recognition dated 2008 of APS0 9054 of Venkata Ratna College of Education, Kurnool for your kind reference.

In addition I am herewith submit the photos of labs, library and class rooms of above building is purely utilized on rented basis till the new construction of building is made by the Shri Shridi Sainath Educational Society.

I request the honourable authorities to kindly permit us to use the present shifted building for running of Venkata Ratna College of Education (Doctor’s colony area) as per regulation stipulated during 2006. I am

in its 219th meeting held on 15th-16th

March 2012. The committee decided to file an appeal. Accordingly a letter was issued to Shri. Madhav Rao, Advocate on 29.03.2012. No reply from the advocate received so far.

1993 to the Southern Regional Committee NCTE.

Finally, the inspection of the institution was carried out on 17.04.2008. The VT report was placed before SRC in its 173rd meeting held on 20th-22nd

April 2009. The SRC after considering the report of the visiting team as well as other relevant materials furnished by the applicant institution decided to refuse recognition to the said institution for B.Ed course for the following reasons:-

The old school building leased for 3 years with a built up space of 9000 sq.ft is not adequate for proposed course whereas 1500 sq.mtrs required as per norms and standards of B.Ed course.

The equipment in Psychology and E.T labs are not adequate


10


already enclosing an affidavit submitted for the construction of new building by the management.

May I request you sir to kindly issue necessary permission orders for the same, for which kind of act, I shall remain grateful to you”.

The SRC in its 250th

meeting held on 11th-13th August 2013, considered the above matter and decided to submit comparative statement for APS09054, APS06270 and APS06268.

for proposed B.Ed course.

The furniture in E.T., Psychology, Computer lab, are not adequate.

The materials in Physical Education are not adequate.

Accordingly, a refusal order was issued on 08.05.2009.

1 INSTITUTION NAME

Venkata Rathna College of Education, No. 87/1364, Maruthi Nagar, Kallur, Kurnool District-518002, Andhra Pradesh

Sri Sainath College of Education, C/o KMD Azmathullah Building, Chhannambhatti Street, Yemmiganur, Kurnool District, Andhra Pradesh

Sri Siridi Baba College of Education C/o.K.M.D. Azmathulla, H.No.1, College Road, Nandikothkur, Kurnool-518401, Andhra Pradesh

2 SOCIETY NAME

Sri Shiridi Sainath Educational Society, Kurnool District, Andhra Pradesh

Sri Shiridi Sainath Educational Society, Vinayaka Nagar, RTC Colony, Hayat Nagar, Hyderabad, Rangareddy District, Andhra Pradesh

Sri Shiridi Sainath Educational Society

3 TRUST DEED

Date of Regn

31.12.2005 31.12.2005 31.12.2005

Name of Society




4 LAND DOCUMENTS

Type of document

Lease Deed dt. 03.05.2007

Lease deed dt. 12.05.2006 & Lease deed dt. 21.04.2009

1.Building Lease Deed dt. 6.06.20062.Sale Deed dt. 22.05.2006

Certified Not certified Not certified Not certified


11


by sub-registrarSy.No. 672/B, D.No.87/1364 184A (Piki) 1.H.No.16-62,

H.No.16-62-1 and House No.16-62-32. 401/2

Location Maruthinagar Yemmiganur Municipal

1.Nandikotkur Village2.Miduthur Village

Extent Ac.1.00 cents (4848 sq.yds)

11960 sq.ft (site measurement)4428 sq.ft (building measurement) &230`x120` (site measurement)210` x 50` (RCC building)

Not given

Infavour of Venkatarathna College of Education (Lessee)

Shri Siridi Sainath Educational Society (Lessee)

2. Sri.T.V.Venkataiah, Sri Shiridi Sainath Educational and Development Society, Nandikotkur Village

5 AFFIDAVITSy.No. 472-B, Plot No.87/1364 184A, Ward No.24 401/2Location Kallur Gram

PanchayathYemmiganoor Miduuthur

Panchayath, Nandikotkur Village

Built up area

2055 sq.mtr (22116 sq.ft)

16400 sq.ft

Extent Ac.1.00 (4080 sq.mtr) 2565 sq.mtr 5 Acres 20 cents6 LAND USE

CERTIFICATEIssued by Not found in the file Revenue Divisional

Officer. Adoni Division

Not found in the file

Notarised or not

Yes

Dated 20.04.2009Sy.No. with location

184-A, Yemmiganur

Extent 0.63 cents & 369 links (2565 sq.mtr)

7 BUILDING COMPLETION CERTIFICATE

Issued by Executive Officer, Gram Panchayath & Municipal Licensed Engineer

Assistant Executive Engineer

Assistant Executive Engineer

Sy.No. 672/B, 184, Ward No.24 394, Plot No.16-62, Plot No.16-62-1, Plot No.16-62-3

Location Maruthinagar Chunnambatti Street Nandikotkur Grampanchayath


12


Built up area

Not given 16400 sq.ft Not given

Type of Roofing

RCC RCC Not given

8 BUILDING PLANApproved by

Executive Officer, Gram Panchayath

Commissioner, Yemmiganur Municipality

Sarpanch, Gramapanchayath

Sy.No. D.No.87/1364, S.No.672/B

184-A 401/2

Extent Ac.1.00 (4056 sq.mtr) 63 cents & 360 links (27600sq.ft)

Ac.5.00

Location Maruthinagar Chunnambatti Street, Yemmiganur

Mioithur Village & Mandal

Built up area

22116 sq.ft or 2055 sq.mtr

16400 sq.ft or 1524.16 sq.mtr

24000 sq.ft or 2230 sq.mtr

Area earmarked for proposed course

Plan is in the name of proposed college.



9 ENDOWMENT FUND OF RS.5 LAKHS

Issued from

Andhra Bank Andhra Bank Andhra Bank

Original submitted

Photocopy found in the file

Yes Photocopy is in the file

FDR No. 539025 388834 801459Tenure of FDR

60 months 60 months 60 months

Issue of FDR

01.06.2006 14.06.2012 17.07.2006

Valid till 01.06.2011 14.06.2017 17.07.2011In favor of Secretary, Sri Shiridi

Sainath Educational Society

M/s.Secretary, Shirdi Sainath Educational Society & Regional Director, SRC, NCTE, Bangalore


10 RESERVE FUND OF RS.3 LAKHS

Issued from

Andhra Bank Andhra Bank Andhra Bank

Original submitted

Photocopy found in the file

Yes Photocopy is in the file


60 months 60 months 60 months

Issue of FDR

11.09.2006 14.06.2012 11.09.2006

Valid till 11.09.2011 14.06.2017 11.09.2011In favor of Secretary, Sri Shiridi

Sainath Educational Society

M/s.Secretary, Shirdi Sainath Educational Society & Regional Director, SRC, NCTE, Bangalore


11 ENCUMBRANCE CERTIFICATE


13


APS06270B.Ed/

Sri Sainath College of Education,

Kurnool District

------------------

APS06268B.Ed

Sri Siridi Baba College of Education,

Kurnool District

Issued by Not found in the file Not found in the file Not found in the file

The Committee considered the written representation of the institution vide letter dated 19/02/2013, all the relevant documents of the institution and decided and advised Southern Regional Office to collect inspection fee, there after to Cause Inspection of the New Premises for shifting.

If the new building is on a different land, VT to be asked to collect land documents, building plan & building completion certificate and to verify the details at the time of inspection.

Further, the Committee advised Southern Regional Office to complete the exercise before 30 th Nov, 2013.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Committee considered the matter, noted that the Southern Regional Office has taken 9 months to report about the decision to file an ‘Appeal’ in its 219th meeting held on 15-16th March, 2012. Advised to report the matter in the 255th meeting scheduled on 13-15th, Nov, 2013

---------------------------------------

The Committee considered the matter and noted that already the application of the institution was refused on deficiency reasons in its 173rd SRC meeting and decided to close the case.

‘

6. SRCAPP193APS00316APS02544

D.P.EdB.EdD.Ed

Pragathi College of Physical

Education, Vizianagaram

District

Pragathi College of Physical Education, Khasara No. 173, Plot No. 34, 35, 42, vzm Road, Ardannapalam Revinew Village, Kothavalasa Post and Tauka, Vizianagaram City & District-535183, Andhra Pradesh.Pedro Educational Welfare Society, Plot No. F.No. 302 3 10-51-14, sai Bhagavan Sravanthi Towers Road, FAcours Lay out Village, Waltair Up lands Post, Visakhapatnam Taluka and city, Vishakhapatnam District-5300003, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Pragathi College of Physical Education, Khasara No. 173, Plot No. 34, 35, 42, vzm Road, Ardannapalam Revinew Village, Kothavalasa Post and Tauka, Vizianagaram City & District-535183, Andhra Pradesh. For D.P.Ed course of 2 year duration under Section 14 (1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 07.14.2013.


14


SRCAPP193

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 06.02.2013/12.04.2013 ( Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 12.04.2013.

The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 04.06.2013.

The Committee considered the matter, decided and advised Southern Regional Office to Re-submit with a comparative statement for B.Ed, D.Ed and proposed course D.P.Ed in the 250th meeting.

The Southern Regional Committee considered the reply of the institution dt.04-06-2013 to the deficiency letter and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Sl.No.

SRCAPP193/D.P.Ed

APS00316/B.Ed

APS02544/D.Ed B.P.Ed

Present Status: DL

Reply placed in

249th

meeting of SRC

Present Status:

Granted on 26.06.2003, Institution

has submitted

written representat

ion on 12.09.2007

for informatio

n temporary

to permanent

building

Present Status:

Granted on 26.08.2005

B.P.Ed course not available

as per MIS

1 INSTITUTION NAME

Pragathi College of Physical Education, Khasara No.173, Plot No.34,35,42


15


, VZM Road, Ardannapalam revinew village, Kothavalasa Post and Taluk, Vizianagaram City and District-535183, Andhra Pradesh

2 SOCIETY NAME

Pedro Educational Welfare Society, Plot No.302,Sai Bhagavan Sravanthi Towrs Road, Faccours Layout Village, Waltair Up Lands Post, Visakhapatnam Taluk and City, Vishakhapatnam District-530003, Andhra Pradesh

3 TRUST DEED

Date of Regn

20.03.1998

Name of Society

Pedro Educational


16


Welfare Society

4LAND

DOCUMENTS

Type of document

Sale Deed dt. 18.06.2010 & 23.12.2010

Certified by sub-registrar

Meeseva approved

Sy.No. 1.36/10, 34/4 to 7, 36/4, 42/7, 42/2, 34/1 and 3, 49/25 and 26, 48/14, 42/4 2.34/7

Location Ardhannapalam

Extent 1. Ac.5.23 cents

2. Ac.2.13 cents

Infavour of Pedro Educational and Welfare Society

5 AFFIDAVIT

Sy.No. 34/1, 34/7, 35/5, Khasara No.173

Location Ardhannapalem Revenue, Kothavalasa Panchayath, Vizianagaram District

Built up area

Not mentioned


17


Extent 21205 sq.mtr

Ac.5.10 cents

Ac.5.10 cents

6LAND USE CERTIFICA

TE

Issued by Tahasildhar Not found in the file

Land Title Certificate submitted Sy.No.187/4, Kantikpalli Panchayath Village, extent acre 5.10 cents issued by Advocate

Notarised or not

Yes

Sy.No. with location

34/1, 34/3, 34/7, 35/5, Ardhanapalem Revenue Village

Extent 5.24 AcreConverted for

Land can be used for establishment of educational institutions.

7

BUILDING COMPLETI

ON CERTIFICA

TE

Issued by Dy. Executive Engineer R & B



Sy.No. 34/1, 34/3, 34/5, 34/6, 34/7, 35/5

Location Ardhannapalem Village


18


Built up area

2920 sq.mtr

Type of Roofing

RCC

8 BUILDING PLAN

Approved by

Karya Nirvahana Adhikaari Gram Panchayath

Not legible Photocopy of building Plan submitted

Sy.No. 34/1, 34/3, 34/7, 35/5

18/6A & 18/5A

187/4

Extent 5.24 Acre Not legible Not givenLocation Ardhannapa

lam VillageKottavalasa Village

Built up area

2920 sq.mtr Not legible


Building plan is in the name of college.

Not legible

9

ENDOWMENT FUND OF RS.5 LAKHS

Issued from State Bank of India

The Vysya Bank Ltd.,

State Bank of Hyderabad

Original submitted

Yes Photocopy available in the file.

Photocopy available in the file.

FDR No. 32740560462

3 Akshaya Deposit Certificate Rs.one lakh, Rs.two lakh, Rs.two lakh.

0603467

Tenure of FDR

1 year Not legible 12 months

Issue of FDR

31.12.2012 --- 29.01.2005

Valid till 31.12.2013 --In favor of Society ---


19


APS00316B.S.N.

Memorial College of Education,

Vizinagaram District

APS02544

10

RESERVE FUND OF

RS.3 LAKHS

Issued from State Bank of India


State Bank of India

Original submitted

Yes Photocopy available in the file.

FDR No. 32740575195

154508

Tenure of FDR

1 year 12 months

Issue of FDR

31.12.2012 29.01.2005

Valid till 31.12.2013In favor of Society

11

ENCUMBRANCE

CERTIFICATE

Issued by Mee Seva Sub-Registrar

Photocopy of EC submitted, it is not legible.

Ec dt. 18.05.2013 15.11.2001Sy.No. 34/1, 34/3,

34/5, 34/6, 34/7, 35/5

187/4

Extent Ac.5.10 acre

Location Ardhanapalem Village

Kantakapalli

Period 01.01.1983 to 17.05.2013

01.01.2001 to 14.11.2001

APS00316-B.Ed & APS02544- D.Ed

The Committee considered the matter, all the relevant documents of the institutions and advised Southern Regional Office to obtain the missing documents of the above two institutions, examine and to put up by 31st


20


B.S.N. Memorial College of

Elementary Teacher


DistrictAP

December, 2013.

7. APS02603/SRCAPP1707D.Ed/ D.Ed-AIMaheshwara

Institute of Elementary

Teacher Education, Warangal

DistrictAP

Maheshwara Institute of Elementary Teacher Education, Khasara No. 61, Laknepally Village &Street, Narsampet Taluka & City, Warangal-506331, Andhra Pradesh.

Maheshwara Educational Society, Plot No. 1-1-71, Beside Pavani Nursing Home Strret, Narsampet Village & Post Office, Warangal-506132, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Maheshwara Institute of Elementary Teacher Education, Khasara No. 61, Laknepally village &Street, Narsampet Taluka & City, Warangal-506331, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed-A.I Course of two years duration under Section 15 (1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 1/10/2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 17/10/2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 08/11/2011 followed by reminder on 26/12/2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 30/12/2011. The institution has submitted written representation to the deficiency letter on 21/02/2012.

The SRC in its 219th Meeting held on 15th – 16th March, 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 21.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 04.04.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 03.05.2012.

The institution has submitted reply for Show Cause Notice after the stipulated time of 21 days period.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 222nd meeting held on 9th – 10th May , 2012 considered the reply of the institution to the show cause notice which is received on 03/05/2012, i.e., after 29 (Twenty nine) days from the date of issue of show cause notice dt. 04-04-2012 and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

Accordingly, a rejection order was issued to the institution on 15.06.2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-329/2012 Appeal/5th Meeting-2012 dated 17/08/2012 states that “the council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the case to SRC with a direction to consider the appellant’s reply to the show cause notice and take a fresh decision in the matter.”


21


In pursuance to the Appellate authority order dated 17.08.2012, the application was processed and placed before SRC in its 233rd Meeting held on 26th-28th

September, 2012 and the committee considered the matter along with all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14(1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, show cause notice was issued to the institution on 01/11/2012. The institution has submitted written representation on 05/11/2012.

The SRC in its 235th Meeting held on 21st-22nd November, 2012 considered the written reply and other relevant documents and decided to cause composite inspection for B.Ed, D.Ed and D.Ed – Al along with SRCAPP1710-D.El.Ed-Al course at the premises Under Section 15 (1)of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms and on payment of Rs. 50000/- for each course towards inspection fee.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 10 th-13th

December, 2012 the same was intimated to the institution on 03/12/2012. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 11/12/2012.

Note:- it is observed that as per application SRCAPP 1707 & 1710 the location of the building is same. (except sy.no) i.e. Laknepally Village, Narsampet Mandal, Warangal District. The signature of the chairman in the building plan is same for both the colleges. (The society name is different and the address of the both the society is one and the same).

The SRC in its 239th Meeting held on 26th-27th February, 2013 considered VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 10/04/2013. The institution has submitted written representation on 29/04/2013.

The committee in its 245th SRC meeting held on 19-21st May, 2013 considered the matter and noted that there are four cases 1) SRCAPP1707 2) SRCAPP1710 3) SRCAPP1714 & SRCAPP2043, all are interrelated to one another. The Societies have common address, common membership and common chairman; also it is observed that the building is same for all the courses.

Accordingly, the committee decided and advised Southern Regional Office to put up a composite note by giving details in a comparative deficiency letter tabular format in the next SRC meeting.

The Committee in its 247th meeting held on 20-22nd June, 2013 considered the matter and advised Southern Regional Office to examine the case of SRCAPP1707-D.El.Ed-Al course with reference to APS02277 and re-submit in 248th meeting.

The inspection is to be arranged after collecting inspection fee.


22


The Southern Regional Committee considered the reply of the institution dt.29-04-2013 to the show cause notice letter, comparative statement of other courses being run by the institution and all other relevant documents and decided to cause composite inspection for D.Ed/D.Ed-Al/B.Ed courses under NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

8. APS00008/ APS00501/ APS05307D.Ed/ B.Ed/

M.EdMaulana Azad National Urdu

University (Government

(Central) University), Hyderabad

DistrictAP

Maulana Azad National Urdu University {Government (CentralUniversity}, Gachibowli, Hyderabad-500032, Andhra Pradesh The SRC in its 250th meeting held on 11th-13th August 2013, the committee considered the matter and decided to process the reply of the University for D.Ed., B.Ed. and M.Ed

The request for increasing of intake was placed before SRC in its 173 rd

meeting held on 20th-23rd April 2009, considered the request of Maulana Azad National Urdu University received on 02.04.2009 and decided to grant conditional recognition /LOI for the additional intake of 54% existing D.Ed., B.Ed., M.Ed courses as per reservation for other Backward class (in Central Government Institution) Admission Act, 2006.

D.Ed course:-Existing intake – 75 + Addl intake – 40 = Annual Intake – 115B.Ed course:-Existing intake – 100 + Addl intake – 54 = Annual intake – 154M.Ed course:-Existing intake – 25 + Addl intake – 13 = Annual intake – 38

The university has to submit the details of additional infrastructural and instructional facilities provided and teaching faculty exclusively appointed for the additional intake within 15 days from the date of receipt of conditional recognition/Letter of Intent.Accordingly, conditional recognition orders for B.Ed, D.Ed, M.Ed were issued on 20.05.2009 with a request to submit reply within 15 days from the date of receipt of the letter. The institution did not submit the reply, a reminder was sent on 07.07.2009. the institution did not submit the reply even till date.SRC in its 182nd meeting held on 31st August 2009, decided to issue Show Cause Notice under section 17 of NCTE Act for withdrawal of conditional Recognition /Refusal of Recognition, for not fulfilling the faculty norms of NCTE.As per the decision of SRC, Notice under section 17 was issued on 29.09.2009. in reply to the notice institution has sent written representation through fax on 19.10.2009 and 22.10.2009.The SRC in its 184th meeting held on 26th-27th October 2009, the committee considered the reply to the notice and decided to issue show cause notice to the following deficiencies still persist:-


23


1. It is not specified as to who is the Principal for B.Ed and D.Ed course separately.

2. It is not clear which faculty are teaching B.Ed and D.Ed courses separately.

3. Teachers are inadequate in numbers, as per norms.

Accordingly, a letter was issued to the university on 25.11.2009 to B.Ed and D.Ed course separately. However no reply has been received on till date.The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15th-16th September 2010 considered the matter and it was decided to serve Show Cause Notice under section 17 of NCTE Act for the following.

1. For not responding to the show cause notice dated 25.11.2009, even after a lapse of around 11 months.

As per the decision of SRC, Notice was issued on 29.10.2010. Till date institution not submitted its written representation/documents even after lapse of more than one year 2 months.The SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd February 2011 considered the matter and decided to issue Final Show Cause Notice to the institution for the following:-

1. For not responding to the show cause notice dated 25.11.2009, even after a lapse of around one year two months.

Accordingly, final show cause notice was issued on 18.03.2011. The University submitted its written representation on 19.04.2011

The Committee considered the matter and on scrutiny of the reply of the institution dated 19/04/2011, relevant documents (Annexure I & II) sent by the University are not available on file. It is advised by the Committee to Southern Regional Office to obtain the documents and latest details from the University and to report in the 256th meeting.

9. SRCAPP1013B.P.Ed

Sri Sai Aditya College of Physical

Education, East Godavari

DistrictAP

Sri Sai Aditya Institute of Diploma Education, Plot No. 2-6-17, Sreenagar Colony, Kakinada Urban, East Godavari District-533003, Andhra Pradesh

Sarojini Educational Society, Plot No. 2-24-4, Ground floor, Temple Tree Apartments, Near Janma Boomi Park, Srinagar Village, Engineering College Post Office, Kakinada Urban and Town, East Godavari District, Andhra Pradesh has applied for grant of recognition to Sri Sai Aditya Institute of Diploma Education, Plot No. 2-6-17, Sreenagar Colony, Kakinada Urban, East Godavari District-533003, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed course online on 29.09.2011 for one years duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act. 1993 and received in the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 30.09.2011.

NCTE-Hqrs had directed to process the applications in accordance with NCTE Regulations 2009, it amendment Notified on 26th November 2010 which reads as follows:-

2 (B) for Sub Regulation (1-A) the following shall be submitted namely. 1 (1-A) (I) the application shall be summarily rejected under one or more of the following circumstances:

a. The processing fee, as provided under Rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the


24


date of submission of online application.

b. Hard copy in triplicate of the online application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application.

c. Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society. Institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of online application.

The SRC considered the matter in its 213th meeting held on 6th-7th November, 2011 and careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related documents, NCTE Act 1993. Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table. The Regional committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds.

Valid printout of on-line application not submitted.

Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the institution vide no. F.No. SRCAPP1013(2012-13)/B.P.Ed/AP/2011-12/36192 dated 23/01/2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-57/2012 Appeal/3rd Meeting-2012 A 50899 dated 18/04/2012 state that “the council concluded that there was adequate Justification in remanding the case to the SRC for further processing of the application on merit as per regulations”.

The SRC in its 222nd meeting held on 09th – 10th May 2012 has considered the Appellate authority order dt. 18/04/2012 and decided to process the application on submission of original application and related supporting documents as per the regulations.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 25.06.2012/(Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 11.07.2012.

The institution has submitted written representation to the deficiency letter on 17.09.2012

The institution not submitted the reply with in stipulated time of 60 days and with delay of 7 days.

The SRC in its 233rd meeting held on 26-28th September, 2012 considered the reply of the institution, which is received on 17/09/2012, i.e., after 07 (Seven) days from the date of issue of deficiency letter dt 11/07/2012 and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.As per the decision of SRC, rejection order was issued to the institution on 30.10.2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution filed an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order dt. 06.03.2013 stated that


25


“….the council concluded that the matter deserved to be remanded to the SRC to consider the reply of the institution and take further action as per the regulations”.

In pursuance to appellate authority order reply to the deficiency letter dt. 29.12.2011 is processed and placed before SRC in its 242nd meeting held on 14th-16th April 2013, considered the appellate authority order dt. 06.03.2013, reply of the institution vide letter dt. 29.12.2011 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 of NCTE Act, for the following:

1. The FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs already expired on 21.09.2012, the institution has not submitted original FDRs.

2. Proof of completion of 3 academic sessions towards T.P.T & H.P.T courses which are already run by the institution from the affiliating body/State Govt/examining body is not submitted.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 17.05.2013. The institution has submitted its written representation on 06.06.2013

The Committee in its 249th meeting held on 24-26th July, 2013 considered the matter and advised Southern Regional Office to RE-submit in the 250 th

meeting with a comparative statement for T.P.T, H.P.T, U.P.T & B.P.Ed courses.

Sl.No. SRCAPP1013/B.P.Ed

APS07220/T.P.T

APS08952/H.P.T UPT course

Present Status: SCN Reply placed

Present Status:


Present Status:


The institution does not have UPT

course1 INSTITUTION NAME

2 SOCIETY NAME

Sarojini Educational Society, Plot No. 2-24-4, Ground floor, Temple Tree Apartments, Near Janma Boomi Park, Srinagar Village, Engineering College Post Office, Kakinada Urban and Town, East Godavari District, Andhra

Sarojini Educational Society, Kakinada, Andhra Pradesh

Sarojini Educational Society, East Godavari District, Andhra Pradesh


26


Pradesh3 TRUST DEED

Date of Regn 25.12.1992 25.12.1992 25.12.1992 (Page.No.111)

Name of Society

Sarojini Educational Society



4 LAND DOCUMENTSType of document

Sale Deed dt. 2.03.2007

Lease Deed dt. 26.10.2006

1.Lease Deed dt. 26.10.2006(Page.No.92-97)2.Sale Deed dt. 13.03.2006 (Page.No.82-86)


Yes Not certified Not certified

Sy.No. 134, 135, 136/1, 136/2

D.No.2-16-1, Ward No.5

1. D.No.2-16-1, Ward No.52. 106/1A,

Location Surampalem Village

Venkata Nagar, Kakinada

1.Venkata Nagar, Kakinada2. Gurajanapalli

Extent Ac.15.01 618.33 sq.yds 1.618.33 sq.yds2.Ac.5.00 cents

Infavour of Sarojini Educational Society

Sarojini Educational Society (Lessee)Sri Lakshmi Aditya Students Hostel (Lessor)

1. Sarojini Educational Society (Lessee)Sri Lakshmi Aditya Students Hostel (Lessor)2. Sarojini Educational Society

5 AFFIDAVIT

Sy.No. 134, 135, 136/1, 136/2

Sy.No.106-11B

1.# 2-16-1, Ward No.5,(Lease Basis) (Page.No.118)2.106/A (Page.No.90)

Location Surampalem Gurazanapalli 1)Venkata Nagar, Kakinada, East 2)Gurajanapalli Village

Extent Ac.8.00 20234.25 1)2618.33


27


(Sy.No.136/1, 136/2)

sq.mtr (Total built up area 15000 sq.mtr)

sq.mtr (Total built up area 1102.83 sq.mtr)2)20234 sq.mtr (Total built up area 15000 sq.mtr)

6LAND USE

CERTIFICATE

Issued by Revenue Divisional Officer, Peddapuram

Land Title Certificate

Land Title Certificate (Page.No.91)

Notarised or not

Yes Yes Yes

Dated 27.09.2011 11.08.2007 11.08.2007Sy.No. with location

136/1 and 136/2

106/1A 106/1A

Extent Ac.8.00 cents Ac.5.00 cents Ac.5.00 centsConverted for Non-

Agricultural purpose

--- ---

7

BUILDING COMPLETIO

N CERTIFICAT

E

Issued by Deputy Executive Engineer

Licensed Surveyor

Licensed Surveyor (Page.No.28)

Sy.No. 136/1, 136/2 Dr.No.2-16-1 Dr.No.2-16-1Location Surampalem Venkatanagar,

KakinadaVenkatanagar, Kakinada

Built up area 21062 sq.ft Not given Not givenType of Roofing

Not mentioned Not given Not given

8 BUILDING PLAN

Approved by Panchayath Secretary

Commissioner Commissioner

Sy.No. 136/1, 136/2 2-16-1 2-16-1Extent Ac.8.00 Not given Not givenLocation Surrampalem Venkatanagar,

KakinadaVenkatanagar, Kakinada

Built up area 1957.43 sq.mtr or 21062.00 sq.ft

1102.83 sq.mtr

1102.83 sq.mtr


Plan is in the name of proposed college

Plan is in the name of Sri Lakshmi Aditya Students Hostel,

Plan is in the name of Sri Lakshmi Aditya Students Hostel,


28


Kakinada. Kakinada.

9ENDOWMENT FUND OF

RS.5 LAKHS

Issued from Syndicate Bank

Syndicate Bank

Syndicate Bank

Original submitted

Yes Photocopy found in the file

Photocopy found in the file.


One year 5 years One year

Issue of FDR 21.09.2012 04.04.2006 11.08.2007Valid till 21.09.2013 04.04.2011 11.08.2012In favor of Secretary,

Sarojini Educational

Vice President, Sarojini Educational Society

Sarojini Educational Society, Sri Sai Aditya Hindi Pandits Training College.

10RESERVE FUND OF

RS.3 LAKHS

Issued from Syndicate Bank


Syndicate Bank

Original submitted

Yes Photocopy found in the file.

FDR No. 850225 134597Tenure of FDR

One year One year

Issue of FDR 21.09.2012 31.08.2007Valid till 21.09.2013 11.08.2012In favor of Secretary,

Sarojini Educational

Sarojini Educational Society, Sri Sai Aditya Hindi Pandits Training College.

11

ENCUMBRANCE

CERTIFICATE

Issued by Sub-Registrar Not found in the file


Ec dt. 14.08.2012Sy.No. 134, 135,

136/1, 136/2Extent Ac.15.01Location SurampalemPeriod 01.01.1995 to


29


APS08952 APS07220

H.P.T/ T.P.TSri Sai Aditya

College of Physical

Education, East Godavari

DistrictAP

13.08.2012

The Southern Regional Committee considered the reply of the institution dt.06-06-2013 to the show cause notice letter and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection to B.P.Ed course (SRCAPP1013) under section 14 of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

APS07220-T.P.T & APS08952-H.P.T courses:

The Committee considered the matter, comparative statement of all the 3 courses of the said institution and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice for H.P.T & T.P.T courses under NCTE Act, for the following:

The institution has not submitted certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority, i.e, sub-registrar.

Total built up area for T.P.T course as per Affidavit is 1500 sq.mtrs, where as in the building plan, total built up area mentioned is only 1102.83 sq.mtrs, which are not tallying.

In the building plan submitted, total extent of site area is not mentioned.

Building plan submitted is in the name of Sri Lakshmi Aditya Students Hostel, Kakinada, which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations; building plan should be in the name of the Institution as per NCTE Regulations.

Building completion certificate submitted is approved by Licensed Surveyor, which is not permissible as per NCTE regulations. As per NCTE regulations building completion certificate should be approved by Govt. Engineer.

In the building completion certificate submitted, built up area and type of roofing is not mentioned.

Reserve fund of Rs. 3 lacs for T.P.T course is not available; the institution has to submit the same for 5 years duration.

Up-to-date Encumbrance certificate issued by the competent authority is not submitted.

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in


30


order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the withdrawal of recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

10. AOS00270/ APS02543/ SRCAPP49/APS04721B.Ed/ D.Ed/

D.Ed-AI/B.Ed-AIIslamia

Elementary Teacher Training,

Medak District

Islamia Elementary

Teacher Training,

Medak DistrictAP

Islamia Elementary Teacher Training, Kasara/Plot No. 2051, 1-10/A Street, Musthabad Road, Prashanth Nagar Village, Siddipet Post, Siddipet Taluka and City, Medak District-502103, Andhra Pradesh

Islamia Educational Society, Plot No. 1-10/A, Musthabad Road, Siddipet Village and Post Office, Siddipet Taluka and City, Medak District-502103, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Islamia Elementary Teacher Training, Kasara/Plot No. 2051, 1-10/A Street, Musthabad Road, Prashanth Nagar Village, Siddipet Post, Siddipet Taluka and City, Medak District-502103, Andhra Pradesh for D.Ed-AI Course of two year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 04.01.2013.The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 06.02.2013/26.03.2013 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 03.04.2013.


While placing D.L.Reply for SRCAPP49 D.Ed-AI -Islamia Elementary Teacher Training the SRC in its 249th meeting held on 24th-26th July 2013 and the committee considered the matter and decided to resubmit with a comparative statement for B.Ed/D.Ed/B.Ed-AI.

Sl.NoAOS00270/B.Ed/Medak

District

APS02543/D.Ed/

Medak District

SRCAPP49/D.El.Ed-AI/Medak District

APS04721/B.Ed-AI/

Hyderabad District

Present status: Granted

Recognition on 17.07.2000.

The institution is requesting for inspection for shifting on 24.03.2008 from the institution. Shifting inspection pending.

Present status: A letter sent to institution on 06.06.2012 for there will be no recurrence of admission of excess seats. SRC-NCTE granted recognition on 26.08.2005

Present Status: DL

Reply placed in

249th

meeting of SRC

Present Status:

Application closed

on 27.06.2009

Interim Court Order

granted.


31


for offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students. NCTE-Hq forwarded complaint against the institution which was placed in 218th

meeting held on 28th

February 2012 and the committee decided with a direction the institution to submit an undertaking that no excess admission will be made in future.Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 06.06.2012. Reply from the institution not received so far.

1 INSTITUTION NAME

Islamia College of Education,

Islamia College of

Islamia Elementar


32


Siddipet-502103, Medak District, Andhra Pradesh

Education, Mustabad Road, Gramapanchayat, Prashanth Nagar, Siddipet Mandal, Medak District, Andhra Pradesh

y Teacher Training, Kasara/Plot No. 2051, 1-10/A Street, Musthabad Road, Prashanth Nagar Village, Siddipet Post, Siddipet Taluka and City, Medak District-502103, Andhra Pradesh

Different District i.e. Hyderabad

2 SOCIETY NAME---- Islamia

Educational Society, Siddipet

Islamia Educational Society, Plot No. 1-10/A, Musthabad Road, Siddipet Village and Post Office, Siddipet Taluka and City, Medak District-502103, Andhra Pradesh

3 TRUST DEED

Date of

Regn


17.02.1998 17.02.1998

Name of

society

Islamia Educational Society



33


4

LAND DOCUMENT

S

Type of document

Sale Deed, Lease Agreement is in telugu version(Page.No.382 & 387) & Under taking affidavit stated that S.No.925 undertake to use the leased land and building exclusively for college of education only. The building i.e. old one and the newly constructed ones are covered under the undertaking.

Sale Deed in telugu version dt. 04.01.2001



Not certified by sub-registrar

Online sale deed copies submitted and photocopy of translation sale deed submitted.

Sy.No. 2051 2051Location

Siddipet Siddipet

Extent Ac.4.00 Ac.4.00


34


Infavour of


Islamia Education Society

5 AFFIDAVIT

Sy.No. Not found in the file


2051

Location

Siddipet

Extent 16186.89 sq.mtr

6

LAND USE

CERTIFICAT

EIssued by



Tahasildar, Siddipet

Notarised or not

Yes

Dated 01.06.2013Sy.No. with location

2051

Extent Ac.4.00Converted for

Non-Agricultural purpose for Educational Institutions.

7

BUILDING

COMPLETIO

N CERTIFICAT

EIssued by



Assistant Engineer

Sy No 2051Location

Prashanthnagar Gram panchayath, Siddipet

Built-up area

GF 2865 sq.mtrFF 810 sq.mtr


35


8BUILD

ING PLAN

Approved by

Not approved (Page.No.433)

Photocopy of building plan submitted

Secretary

Sy.No. 2051 2051 2051 Extent 20233.62

sq.mtr16186 sq.mtr

Siddipet

Location

Siddipet Siddipet 16186.89 sq.mtr

Built up area

1952 sq.mtr

1542 sq.mtr 2865.00 sq.mtr (GF)810 sq.mtr (First Floor proposed additional intake)



9

ENDOWMEN

T FUND Rs.5 lakhs

Issued from


Not found in the file Andhra Bank

Original submitted

Yes

FDR No.

316623 (5 lakh)

Tenure of FDR 28.12.2012

Issue of FDR 28.06.2013

Valid till Six months

In favor of

Secretary Islamia Educational


36


Society

10

RESERVE

FUND Rs.3 lakhs

Issued from


Not found in the file Andhra Bank

Original submitted

Yes

FDR No.

316622 (3 lakh)

Tenure of FDR 28.12.2012

Issue of FDR 28.06.2013

Valid till Six months

In favor of

Secretary Islamia Educational Society

11

ENCUMBRANCE

CERTIFICAT

E

Issued by



Mee Seva, Sub-Registrar

Ec dt. 15.04.2013Sy.No. 2051Extent 4 AcresLocation

Siddipet

Period 01.01.1983 to 07.04.2013

12 MINORITY

CERTIFICAT

E


37


Not found in the

file


The institution has submitted a photocopy of proceedings of the Commissioner and Director of School Education; Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad-4 dated 06.02.2013. A list of (2) New D.Ed., colleges and (3) old colleges is herewith enclosed. He is requested take necessary action for inclusion in the counseling. The intake in each private D.Ed., colleges is 50. Islamia Elementary Teacher Training Institute, Islamia College Campus, Mustabad Road, Prashanth Nagar, Siddipet, Medak is having Muslim minority status.


38


Submitted a photocopy of certificate issued by Minorities Welfare Department

The Committee considered the matter, decided and advised Southern Regional Office to resubmit the comparative statement with complete details regarding all the four programmes (B.Ed-APS00270, and B.Ed-Al-APS04721, B.Ed-APS02543 and B.Ed-Al-SRCAPP49) in the 255th meeting.

Consideration of Agenda Items- Volume-02Inspection u/s-14

11. SRCAPP1810B.Ed

Sre Ramana College of Education

Trist, Dharmapuri

DistrictTN

Sre Ramana College of Education Trust, Upparpatti Village & Post Office, Uthangarai Taluk, Dharmapuri District, Pin – 635207, Tamilnadu

Sre Ramana College of Education Trust, Upparpatti Village & Post Office, Uthangarai Taluk, Dharmapuri District, Pin – 635207, Tamilnadu had applied for grant of recognition to Sre Ramana College of Education Trust, Upparapatti Village & Post Office, Uthangarai Taluk, Dharmapuri District, Pin – 635207, Tamilnadu for B.Ed Course of one year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 13.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 19.12.2012.The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on followed by reminder on 02.01.2013. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 14.03.2013. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 13.05.2013.

The SRC in its 246th meeting held on 02nd-04th June, 2013 considered the reply of the institution dt.13-05-2013 to the deficiency letter and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

The inspection of the institution was fixed between 01st-05th July,2013. The same was intimated to the institution on 22.06.2013. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 22.08.2013.

On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, VT report, VCD, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to B.Ed course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100(one hundred only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.


39


12. SRCAPP1894B.P.Ed

Narayana B.P.Ed College,

Anantapur District

AP

Narayana B.P.Ed College, Khasara / Plot No.779-B, Peddapolamada Village, Tadipatri Post & Taluk, Anantapur District-515411, Andhra Pradesh

Adithya Educational Society, Plot No.3/456-3-1, Krishnapuram Zero Road, Tadipatri Village, Post & Taluk, Anantapur District-515411, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Narayana B.P.Ed College, Khasara / Plot No.779-B, Peddapolamada Village, Tadipatri Post & Taluk, Anantapur District-515411, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed Course of One year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 26.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 27.01.2013.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 09.01.2013/26.03.2013 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 26.03.2013. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 17.05.2013.

The SRC in its 247th meeting held on 20th-22nd June 2013, considered the reply of the institution to the deficiency letter dt.17-05-2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed on 26th-31rd August 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 22.08.2013.

As per the direction of SRC, the inspection of the institution was conducted on 30.08.2013 and the VT Report received in the office of SRC on 06.09.2013

The Committee duly considered VT report, VCD of the institution and all the relevant documents of the institution and deficiencies still persist as under:

Building plan submitted by the institution is not duly approved by the competent authority. The Building plan submitted is approved by Municipal Licensed Surveyor, which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009.

Notarised English version of the land document is in individual name of J.C. Ravi Kumar Reddy S/o J.C. Sankara Narayana Reddy, President of Adithya Education Society, which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009.

Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to reject the application of the institution for recognition of B.P.Ed course.

13. SRCAPP161B.P.Ed

Shiva Reddy Memorial College of Physical

Shiva Reddy Memorial College of Physical Education, Khasara No. 50/A, 44/A/5, 31, 36, 39/1, Plot No. 36, Street No. 1-1, Satharla Village and Post Office, Alampur City and Taluk, Mahabubnagar District – 509128, Andhra Pradesh

Somanadri Educational Society, Plot No. Sy. No. 36., Street No. 1-1,


40


Education, Mahabubnagar

DistrictAP

Satharla Village and Post Office, Alampur City and Taluk, Mahabubnagar District – 509128, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Shiva Reddy Memorial College of Physical Education, Khasara No. 50/A, 44/A/5, 31, 36, 39/1, Plot No. 36, Street No. 1-1, Satharla Village and Post Office, Alampur City and Taluk, Mahabubnagar District – 509128, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed Course of one year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 03.01.2013.


The SRC in its 247th meeting held on 20th-22nd June 2013, considered the reply of the institution to the deficiency letter dt.23-05-2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.



On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, VT report, VCD, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to B.P.Ed course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100(one hundred only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

14. SRCAPP88B.P.Ed

S V College, Anantapur

DistrictAP

S V College, Plot/Street No. 160, Kowlepalli Village and Post Office, Kadiri City and Taluk, Anantapur District – 515591, Andhra Pradesh.

Muneswari Educational and Welfare Society, Plot No. 1/726, Police Line Road, Kadiri Village and Post Office, Kadiri City and Taluk, Anantapur District – 515591, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to S V College, Plot/Street No. 160, Kowlepalli Village and Post Office, Kadiri City and Taluk, Anantapur District – 515591, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed Course of one year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 04.01.2013.The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 31.01.2013/28.03.2013 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 28.03.2013. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 20.05.2013.

The SRC in its 247th Meeting held on 20th-22nd June, 2013 considered the reply


41


of the institution to the deficiency letter dt.20-05-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 26th-31st August, 2013 the same was intimated to the institution on 22/08/2013. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 31/08/2013 and the VT Report received in the office of SRC on 06/09/2013.


15. SRCAPP86B.P.Ed

Gonna College of Physical Education,

Vishakhapatnam District

AP

Gonna College of Physical Education, Plot No.28/4 to 19, 29/1 to 33, 30/1 to 19, 31/, Plot No.28, 29, 30, Street No.28/4 to 19, E.Marripalem Village, Aganampudi Post Office & Taluk, Vishakhapatnam District-530046, Andhra Pradesh

Sri Veera Jagannadh Educational Society, Plot No.7-1, Ward No.56, Gonnavanipalem Village, Aganampudi Post Office, Visakhapatnam Taluk & City, Vishakhapatnam District-530046, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Gonna College of Physical Education, Plot No.28/4 to 19, 29/1 to 33, 30/1 to 19, 31/, Plot No.28, 29, 30, Street No.28/4 to 19, E.Marripalem Village, Aganampudi Post Office & Taluk, Vishakhapatnam District-530046, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed Course of one year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 07.01.2013.


The SRC in its 248th meeting held on 13th-15th July 2013, considered the reply of the institution to the deficiency letter vide letter dt.10.06.2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed on 26th -31st August 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 22.08.2013.


On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, VT report, VCD, all


42


relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to B.P.Ed course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100(one hundred only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

16. SRCAPP186B.P.EdKranthi

College of Physical

Education, Chittor District

AP

Kranthi College of Physical Education, Plot No.114, Mamanduru Village & Post Office, Renigunta Taluk, Tirupati City, Chittoor District-517520, Andhra Pradesh.

Smt Kousalyadevi Educational Society, Plot No.19-7-134, Gopal Raju Colony, Tirupathi Village & Post Office, Tirupathi Taluk & City, Chittoor District-517501, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Kranthi College of Physical Education, Plot No.114, Mamanduru Village & Post Office, Renigunta Taluk, Tirupati City, Chittoor District-517520, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed Course of one year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 07.01.2013.


The SRC in its 248th Meeting held on 13th-15th July, 2013 considered the reply of the institution to the deficiency letter vide letter dt.11.06.2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 26th-31st August, 2013 the same was intimated to the institution on 22/08/2013. The inspection of the institution was conducted on01/09/2013 and the VT Report received in the office of SRC on 05/09/2013.



Dhanalakshmi College of Physical

Education,

Dhanalakshmi College of Physical Education, Plot No.119/A, Muppalla Village & Post Office, Epur Taluk & City, Guntur District-522661, Andhra Pradesh.

Krishnaveni Educational Society, Plot No.119/A, Muppalla Village & Post Office, Epur Taluk & City, Guntur District-522661, Andhra Pradesh had


43


Guntur DistrictAP

applied for grant of recognition to Dhanalakshmi College of Physical Education, Plot No.119/A, Muppalla Village & Post Office, Epur Taluk & City, Guntur District-522661, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed Course of One year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 28.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 31.12.2012.


The SRC in its 246th Meeting held on 02nd-04th June, 2013 considered the reply of the institution to the deficiency letter dt.21-05-2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 26th-31st August, 2013 the same was intimated to the institution on 22/08/2013. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 03/09/2013 and the VT Report received in the office of SRC on 06/09/2013.


18. SRCAPP200D.P.EdGopala Krishna

College of Physical

Education, Nalgonda

DistrictAP

Gopala Krishna College of Physical Education, Sy.No. 93, 111, 112, Plot No. 0-2, Sagar Road, Shrinadapuram R/O Ambatipally Village, Ramadguu Post, Annumula Taluk, Nalgonda District – 508278, Andhra Pradesh.

Gopala Krishna Educational Society, Plot No. 2-98/1, Neelaiguda Village, Anjanpally Post, Thripuraram Taluk, Nalgonda District-208207, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Gopala Krishna College of Physical Education, Sy.No. 93, 111, 112, Plot No. 0-2, Sagar Road, Shrinadapuram R/O Ambatipally Village, Ramadguu Post, Annumula Taluk, Nalgonda District – 508278, Andhra Pradesh for D.P.Ed Course of One year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31/12/2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 03/01/2013.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 31/01/2013-19/04/2013 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 19/04/2013. The institution has submitted its written representation on 29/05/2013.

The SRC in its 247th Meeting held on 20th-22nd June, 2013 considered the reply


44


of the institution vide letter dt. 23.05.2013 to the deficiency letter all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.


On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, VT report, VCD, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.P.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(fifty only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

19. SRCAPP2091B.Ed

Jadcherla College of Education,

Mahabubnagar District

AP

Jadcherla College of Education, Plot/Khasara No.277, Aloor Road, Badepally Village, Jadcherla Post Office and Taluk, Jadcherla Town, Mahabubnagar District-509301, Andhra Pradesh.

Dr.Isaiah Educational Society, Plot No.405, S S Apartments, Near HP petrol Bunk, Chatanya, Hyderabad Town, Rangareddi District-500060, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Jadcherla College of Education, Plot/Khasara No.277, Aloor Road, Badepally Village, Jadcherla Post Office and Taluk, Jadcherla Town, Mahabubnagar District-509301, Andhra Pradesh for B.Ed Course of One year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 30.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 07.01.2013.




On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, VT report, VCD, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on


45


the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to B.Ed course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100(one hundred only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.


Sri Lakshmi B.P.Ed College, Kurnool District

AP

Sri Lakshmi B.P.Ed College, Kasara No. 286, P Chinthakuntla Village, Allagadda Post Office and Taluka,, Allagadda City, Kurnool District – 518 543, Andhra Pradesh.

Vaibhav Educational Society, Sreenivasa Nagar Road, Allagadda Village and Post Office, Allagadda Town and Taluka, Kurnool District – 518 543, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Sri Lakshmi B.P.Ed College, Kasara No. 286, P Chinthakuntla Village, Allagadda Post Office and Taluka,, Allagadda City, Kurnool District – 518 543, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed Course of One year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 31.12.2012.





21. SRCAPP165B.P.Ed

Vikas B.P.Ed College, Kadapa District

AP

Vikas B.P.Ed College, Plot/Khasara No.7/3, 7/4, 7/5, 1560/1A, 1559, C K Dinne Street and Village, C K Dinne Taluk, Pabbapuram Post Office, Kadapa City and District- 516001, Andhra Pradesh.

Almadeena Minority Educational & Welfare Society, Plot No.3/99, Sivalingampillai Street, Kadapa Village, P.O. & Taluk, Kadapa District-516001, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Vikas B.P.Ed


46


College, Plot/Khasara No.7/3, 7/4, 7/5, 1560/1A, 1559, C K Dinne Street and Village, C K Dinne Taluk, Pabbapuram Post Office, Kadapa City and District- 516001, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed Course of one year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 07.01.2013.


The SRC in its 247th Meeting held on 20th-22nd June, 2013 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt.23-05-2013 to the deficiency letter, all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 26th-31st August, 2013 the same was intimated to the institution on 22/08/2013. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 31/08/2013 and the VT Report received in the office of SRC on 06/09/2013.


22. SRCAPP35B.P.Ed

Vijaya College of Physical Education,

Krishna DistrictAP

Vijaya College of Physical Education, Plot No.1/4F, 1/4G, 1/4C, 1/4D, 1/4B, Nunna Village & Post Office, Vijayawada Rural Taluk, Krishna District-521212, Andhra Pradesh.

Mother Theresa Educational Society, Plot No.9-278, Putrela Road, Vissannapeta Village, Post Office, Vissannapeta City & Taluk, Krishna District-521212, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Vijaya College of Physical Education, Plot No.1/4F, 1/4G, 1/4C, 1/4D, 1/4B, Nunna Village & Post Office, Vijayawada Rural Taluk, Krishna District-521212, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed Course of One year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 04.01.2013.


The SRC in its 246th Meeting held on 02nd-04th June, 2013 considered the reply of the institution to the deficiency letter dt.23-05-2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act,


47


to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 26th-31st August, 2013 the same was intimated to the institution on 22/08/2013. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 31/08/2013 and the VT Report received in the office of SRC on 06/09/2013.


Consideration of Agenda Items- Volume-03Court Cases

23. APS00470B.Ed

Porukara College of Education, Alapuzzha,

KeralaKL

Mount Tabore Educational Charitable Society’s Porukara College of Education, Gagultha Monastry’s Campus, Champakkulam, Alapuzzha-688505, Kerala

Mount Tabore Educational Charitable Society’s Porukara College of Education, Gagultha Monastry’s Campus, Champakkulam, Alapuzzha-688505, Kerala was granted recognition on 24.3.2005 with certain stipulated conditions.

As per the decision of SRC in its 175th meeting, the office of SRC has reviewed the files of the institution who have been granted recognition either in a rented premises pending construction of own building or leased premises.

A list of such institutions has been prepared and placed before SRC in its 176th

meeting held on 27th and 28th May, 2009 wherein it was decided that institution which have not shifted to the permanent premises even after the expiry of three years time limit be issued notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act for further action.

Consequent upon the decision taken by SRC, NCTE, the institution is hereby served a showcause notice under Section 17 of the NCE Act asking to explain as to why the institution has not shifted to its own premises as on date. The explanation along with following documents should be submitted within 21 days from the date of receipt of the notice and a notice was served on 2.7.2009. The institution has submitted its reply to the notice on 7.7.2009 and 17.7.2009.

Thereafter, there is no correspondence available in the file regarding shifting of premises.

On 1.10.2013, this office has received a letter from the advocate Sri. V.M.Kurian, regarding the W.P.(C)No.23029/2013 filed by Lijina Raichel


48


Joseph Vs.State of Kerala and others. He has stated that “ the Petitioner who is a student aspiring for admission to B.Ed. course has filed the subject writ petition praying to declare that clause 5.2.1(iv) and 5.4.2 in Ext.P2 Prospectus and Clause 2(ii)(B) of Ext.P4 notification are unconstitutional and illegal, to direct respondents 1 and 2 to proceed with the admission process to B.Ed. course 2013 without insisting clause 5.2.1(iv) and 5.4.2 and to declare that petitioner is eligible to be considered for admission to B.Ed. Degree course as per the norms and standards framed by NCTE.”

He has stated that the writ petition came up for admission on 25.9.2013. The NCTE, New Delhi has been impleaded as additional 4th respondent and has requested to furnish statement of facts for preparing counter.

In the above writ petition, the State of Kerala is the 1st respondent, the Director of Collegiate Education, Thiruvananthapuram-695001 is the 2nd respondent, the Director LBS Centre for Science and Technology, Thiruvananthapuram is the 3rd respondent and the Principal Porukara College of Education is the 4th

respondent.

On 14.10.2013, this office has received a letter from the Under Secretary, NCTE, New Delhi vide F.64-157/2013/NCTE/Legal A75327 dated 9th October, 2013 regarding the W.P.NO.23029/2013 filed by Lijina Raichel Joseph authorizing advocate Sri. V.M.Kurian to defend the case including on behalf of the NCTE, HQ. A letter is addressed to the advocate, Sri. V.M.Kurian for defending the case on 23.10.2013.

The Committee has noted the matter.

24. APS05859D.Ed

Brilliant D.Ed College

Roberstsonpet, Kolar District

KA

Briliant D.Ed College Roberstsonpet, KGF, Koilar District, Karnataka

Briliant Education Society, K.G.F. Kolar Dt., Karnataka had applied for grant of recognition to Brilliant D.Ed. College, Manjunatha Nagar, Oorgaumpet, K.G.F-563121 and was refused recognition on 19.4.2007 vide order No.1132. The institution approached appellate authority and appellate authority vide order No.F.No.89-46/2007-Appeal dated 8.8.2007 has remanded the case back to SRC for re-inspection of the premises of the institution on urgent basis. Accordingly, inspection was conducted on 30.8.2007 and recognition was granted recognition to the institution for offering D.Ed course (50 intake) vide order No.F.SRO/NCTE/2007-2008/11450 dt 17.09.2007 under clause 7(12) of Regulations dated 13.1.2006 with the condition to shift to its own premises/building within three years from the date of recognition(in case the course is started in rented premises).

Based on a complaint from the Director, DSERT dated 25.5.2009 the SRC in its 177th meeting held during 22-23 June, 2009 decided to issue a Showcause Notice to the institution under Section 17 of NCTE Act and Notice was served on 10.8.2009.

The institution submitted its written representation on 19.11.2009 which was placed before 188th meeting of SRC held during 28-29 January, 2010. The Committee decided to withdraw recognition for the following reasons:-

Built-up space is inadequate as per the records provided by the


49


institution

As per the decision of SRC, withdrawal order was issued to the institution on 4.3.2010.

The management had preferred an appeal against the order of SRC dated 04/03/2010. The appellate authority after perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit, report and after considering oral arguments advanced during hearing, reached the conclusion that there was no ground to accept the appeal and hence it should be rejected. Accordingly, the appeal was rejected and the SRC’s order dated 04.03.2010 was confirmed vide order F.No.89-529/2010-Appeal dated 19.11.2010.

The SRC in its 199th meeting held during 22-23 December, 2010 noted the Appellate authority order dated 19.11.2010 confirming the SRC’s order dt. 04.05.2010.

In the meanwhile, on 20.09.2013, a Court Order dated 4 th September 2013 is received from the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore in W.P.No. 32705/2013 filed by Dr. M.D.Iqbal Shariff Secretary, BrilIant D.Ed College is received by this office on 20.09.2013 wherein the Director,D.S.E.R.T is the 1st

Respondent, the Principal, DIET, Kolar is the 2nd respondent, NCTE, Bangalore is the 3rd respondent, NCTE, New Delhi is the 4th respondent and the Chief Secretary, Education Dept. Govt. of Karnataka,Bangalore is the 5 th

respondent.

The interim order of Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore dated 4.9.2013(copy enclosed) is as under :-

“Learned AGA is directed to take notice for R1, R2 & R5.

M/s.Haranahalli & Patil, learned advocates are directed to take notice for R3 & R4.

Interim stay of Annexures-L & N, for a period of three weeks.

Post after two weeks.”

NOTE:- Annexure L to the w.p. is the copy of the order dated 04.03.2010 bearing No. F.SRO/NCTE/2009-10/17941 passed by Respondent No.3 and Annexure N to the writ petition is the copy of the order E.No.89-529/2010-Appeal passed by respondent no.4.

This office has also a letter dated 17.8.2013 along with a copy of the W.P.NO.7106/2013 filed by the institution from the Karnata Secondary Education Examination Board, 6th Cross, Malleshwaram, Bangalore-560003(KSEEB) on 3.9.2013.

A letter is addressed to the advocate for vacating the interim stay granted to the institution in W.P.No.32705/2013 and also for defending the case in W.P.NO.7106/2013 which is filed by the institution in the interests and on behalf of SRC,NCTE and NCTE, New Delhi on 21.10.2013.

The Committee has noted the matter.25. APS05761

D.EdMother

Noorunnissa College of Diploma in

Mother Noorunnissa College of Diploma in Education, K.G.F., Kolar Dt.-563113, KarnatakaMother Noorie Educational and Charitable Trust, Kolar Dt., Karnataka had submitted an application to SRC, NCTE for grant of recognition to Mother Noorunnissa College of D.Ed. College, S.N.M. School Road,


50


Education, Kolar District

KA

Andersonpet, K.G.F., Kolar Dt., Karnataka for Elementary(D.Ed.) course of two years duration with an annual intake of 50 students and recognition was accorded to the institution vide this office order No.F.SRO/NCTE/D.Ed./2006-2007/729 dated 12.04.2007 with a condition to shift to its own premises within three years from the date of recognition (in case the course is started in rented premises).

Further, as seen from records, there is no correspondence regarding shifting of premises of the institution.On 17.7.2013, this office received a letter dated 12.7.2013 from Haranahalli and Patil Advocates and Consultants stating that the institution has filed a Writ petition vide W.P.No.28943-28993/2013 which is as under:-

“The above matter was filed seeking for direction to the Respondent NO.1 to approve the admission of petitioners no.2 to 51 for 1st year D.Ed. course and permit them to appear for examination. The above matter came up for consideration before the Hon’ble High Court today for preliminary hearing. After hearing the matter the Court allowed the writ petition. We have applied for certified copy of the final order and the same will be sent to you on its receipt.”

On 15.7.2013, this office has received an interim order dated 3.7.2013 in W.P.NO.28943-28993/2013(EDN-REG-P) from the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore which is as under:-

“As it is not in dispute that the NCTE has granted the recognition and as the Government has permitted the petitioner institution to make admissions to D.Ed.course for the academic year 2012-13, I pass the following interim order:-

(i) The respondents are directed to permit the petitioner students 2 to 51 to appear for the forthcoming first year examination of D.Ed. course.

(ii) It is made clear that if eventually these petitions are dismissed, the petitioners shall not plead equity.

(iii) Further, the respondents is directed not to announce the results of the students in question until further orders.”

On 17.7.2013, this office received a letter dated 12.7.2013 from Haranahalli and Patil Advocates and Consultants stating that the institution has filed a Writ Petition vide W.P.No.28943-28993/2013 which is as under:-

“The above matter was filed seeking for direction to the Respondent NO.1 to approve the admission of petitioners no.2 to 51 for 1st year D.Ed. course and permit them to appear for examination. The above matter came up for consideration before the Hon’ble High Court today for preliminary hearing. After hearing the matter, the Court allowed the writ petition. We have applied for certified copy of the final order and the same will be sent to you on its receipt.”


26. APS02480D.Ed(AI)Ashrafee Teacher Training Institute,

Hamdard Welfare and Educational Association’s, Ashrafee Teacher Training Institute, 27/2A, Krishnapur, Jawahar Nagar, Old Hubli-580024, Dharwad Dt., Karnataka.Hamdard Welfare and Educational Association, Old Hubli, Karnataka had submitted an application on 3.2.2004 to the SRC for grant of permission to Ashrafee Teacher Training Institute, 27/2A, Krishnapur, Jawahar Nagar, Old


51


Dharwad District

KA

Hubli-580024, Dharwad Dt., Karnataka for offering D.Ed.-Additional intake course of two years duration.

The institution was granted recognition on 15.12.2004 for increase of intake of 20 for D.Ed. course thus making an annual intake of 80 students from the academic session 2004-05. The matter regarding the management dispute was placed before the 216th meeting of SRC considered the matter and decided to send the copies of the relevant documents related to the complaints and the enquiry by District Registrar to DSERT & to request the DSERT for their comments.Accordingly, a letter was addressed to the Director, DSERT vide letter No.APS02480/D.Ed.-AI/KA/2011-12/39158 dated 13.03.2012 seeking comments on the above matter. But, there was no reply from the Director, DSERT.

In the meanwhile, on 1st June, 2012, a Notice was received from Sri. M.M. Hooli, Advocate dated 26.5.2012, stating that

“My clients are teaching staff and non-teaching staffs of Hamdard Welfare Educational Association, Ashrafee Educational Complex, Jawahar Nagar, Near Gurunath Nagar, Old Hubli-580024 and have put in 10 to 15 years of service. As there is a dispute between the Management intersay, the salary of my clients is withheld, which is against law and ethics. My clients have given several request and reminders to all for payment of salary and backwages. But, no fruitful result have coming. My clients have decided to file an appeal before the Principal District Judge and Educational Appellate authority, Dharwad for the relief’s claimed in the said appeal petition. As you are the public officer in respect of Act purporting to be done by the Public Officer in his official capacity. A notice as required under Section 80 of CPC R/2 Section 94(1)(4) of the Karnataka Education Act 1983 as amended by act of no.8 1998 is given to you. Please note after expiry of the statutory period an appeal will be filed against you all. The proposed petition copy is enclosed herewith for your kind perusal and immediate action, so as to pay the salary and back wages of my client as prayed for. Hence this notice.”

The SRC in its 226th meeting held on 9th and 10th July, 2012 noted the matter and decided to serve Notice for Non-payment of salaries to the teaching & non-teaching staff, as per NCTE norms. Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 21.9.2012.

In the meanwhile, a Notice was received on 12.09.2012 from the PRL.District & Sessions Judge, Dharwad in MA((EAT) 5/2012 regarding payment of salary of teaching and non-teaching staff from Hamdard Welfare Education Society’s Ashrafee Teacher Training Institute, Dharwad to appear before the Court on 17th September, 2012. The letter was sent to the advocate Sri. M.B. Kanavi on 17.09.2012 along with a brief of the institution for defending the case on behalf of NCTE.

The institution submitted its reply to the Show Cause Notice on 3.10.2012.

The SRC in its 235th meeting held during 21-22 November, 2012 considered the above matter and decided to request DSERT to verify the case and inform. Accordingly, a letter was addressed to the Director, DSERT,


52


Karnataka vide this office letter NO.AOS02480/Court case/D.Ed./KA/2012-13/47971 dated 1.1.2013 with a request to verify the case and inform about the change of management of the institution.

Accordingly, a letter was also addressed on 17.10.2012 to the advocate for defending the matter on behalf of NCTE.

On 2.9.2013, the Managing Trustee of Ashrafee Women Education Trust, Old Hubli vide letter dated 29.8.2013 has requested for change of management from “Ashrafee D.Ed. College , Hubli” from “Hamdard Welfare Educational Association” to “Ashrafee Women Educational Trust Hubli”.

Further, there is no reply from the Director, DSERT, Bangalore to this office letter dated 1.1.2013.

The Committee considered the matter and advised Southern Regional Office to remind DSERT regarding the information sought vide our letter dated 01-01-2013, and after getting the information to put up again on 13 Nov, 2013.

27. AOS00027APS03511

D.Ed D.Ed(A1)

Annai Fathima Teacher Training

Institute, Kolar District

KA

Annai Fathima Teacher Training Institute, Hirebidanur, Gauribidanur Taluk, Kolar District-561208, KarnatakaAnnai Fathima Teacher Training Institute, Hirebidanur, Gauribidanur Taluk, Kolar District-561208, Karnataka had submitted an application for D.Ed course on 27.01.2004. The institution was granted recognition for D.Ed-AI on 13.12.2004 with an intake of 50 students which includes existing intake of 30 students and additional intake of 20 students with the condition to shift to its own premises within 3 years from the date of recognition.

NCTE, Hqrs vide its letter dated 10.08.2010 has forwarded a copy of the inspection report dated 16.06.2010 conducted under section 13 of NCTE Act. As there are deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, NCTE, Hqrs had requested SRC to initiate action against the institution under section 17 of the NCTE Act immediately.

The SRC in its 195th meeting held on 17th –18th August 2010, considered the report of the institution and decided to issue Show Cause Notice. Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 27.09.2010. The institution submitted its written representation on 25.10.2010. The SRC in its 198th meeting held on 24th –26th November 2010 considered the written representation of the institution and decided to cause inspection under section 17 of NCTE Act.

The inspection was carried out on 6th April, 2011. The SRC in its 204th meeting held on 27th–28th April 2011 considered the VT report and decided to issue Show Cause Notice. Accordingly, Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 02.06.2011. The institution submitted its written representation on 11.07.2011.

The SRC in its 210th meeting held on 22nd and 23rd August, 2011 considered the written reply of the institution dated 11.07.2011 on the above matter and also the relevant documents of the institution and decided to withdraw


53


recognition for the following reasons:- The total built up area earmarked for the D.Ed (APS00027) & D.Ed–Al

(APS03115) is only 4512.6 Sq.ft. Which is grossly inadequate for the Teacher Education Programme being run as per NCTE norms. The same is also corroborated by the management by affixing signature of the management representative in the essential data.

In the Building plan the built up area, and Sy,nos are not mentioned. Notarized copy of Land usage certificate issued by competent authority

is not submitted. Non- Encumbrance Certificate from the competent Government

Authorized person / Authorities not submitted. Science lab, Psychology lab & Educational Technology lab needs to be

strengthened. Physical Education lab & Language learning lab not available.

Based on the above points the SRC decided to withdraw the recognition of both the courses,i.e., D.Ed course (APS00027) & D.Ed-Al (APS03115) run by the Annai Fathima Teacher Training Institute, Hirebidanur Gouribidanur Taluk, Kolar District-561208, Karnataka from the academic year 2013-14, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in D.Ed, course, if any, to complete their course.Accordingly, a withdrawal order was issued to the institution on 04/10/2011.

Aggrieved by withdrawal order, the institution preferred an appeal before NCTE, Hqrs. and the appellate authority vide order dated 15/02/2012 decided to cause re-inspection of the institution after obtaining a payment of Rs.40, 000/- from the institution and for taking decision thereafter.

Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was carried out on 10.07.2012.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 230th meeting held on 16 th – 17th

August 2012 considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 31/08/2012.

The institution has submitted a written representation on 27/09/2012.The institution has replied vide letter dt.27.09.2012 for the deficiencies pointed in the show cause notice:-

1. As per the notarized copy of land documents submitted (for site no.37 and Sy.No. 222/1) lands are at different places one at Gauribidanur town and the other at Madanahalli Village.

2. Land documents are not in the name of Trust/Society/Institution as per NCTE regulations 2009. Land documents are not certified.

3. The land area of 10,980+6000 sq.ft is not as per NCTE norms. As per NCTE norms 2500 sq.mts and 1500 sq.mts of built up area is required for offering D.Ed Programme.

4. As per affidavit, the built up area and land area is less as per NCTE regulations 2009.

5. Building plan submitted for Sy.No 37, 38 and 50 is for school building and not for teacher education programme.

6. No documentary proof has been submitted regarding extension of size of Multi Purpose Hall.

7. Approved staff list is not submitted.


54


8. As per Bank statement,1+5 lecturer(s) are inadequate against the requirement of 1+6 lecturer(s)

The reply to the show cause notice is not satisfactory and unconvincing.Based on the above points the Committee decided to withdraw the recognition of both D.Ed (AOS00027) and D.Ed-AI(APS03115) courses run by the Annai Fatima Teacher Training Institute Gauribidanur Taluk, Kolar District, Karnataka from the academic year 2013-14, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in both D.Ed & D.Ed-Al courses, if any, to complete their course.

It was made clear that the institution is debarred from making any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order. The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed accordingly. Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any, subject to submission of letter from affiliating body that no admission are made by the institution further and no due certificate from the staff of the institution regarding payment of salary.

As per the decision of SRC, withdrawal orders were issued to the institution vide this office letter No.F.SRO/NCTE/AOSO0027–D.Ed/APSO3115–D.Ed (AI)/2013–14/49129 dated 14/02/2013.

Aggrieved by the Withdrawal Order of the SRC the institution filed an appeal before appellate authority, NCTE, New Delhi under Section 18 of the NCTE act. The appellate authority order No F.No.89-189/2013 Appeal/9th Meeting -2013 dated 25/07/2013 is as under:-

The Council noted that “the institution was granted recognition for D.Ed course on 06/12/1996 with an intake of 30 which was subsequently raised to 50 in the year 2004 by granting an additional intake of 20. The NCTE Hqrs caused inspection of the institution on 10-06-2010 under section 13 of the NCTE act and forwarded the report to SRC vide its letter dated 10/08/2010. After issuing a Show Cause Notice, the SRC caused inspection of the institution on 06/04/2011 under section 17 and again issued a Show Cause Notice and after considering the reply decided to withdraw recognition. Against the withdrawal order, the institution filed an appeal under section 18 of the NCTE act. The NCTE remanded the matter to SRC with the direction to cause re-inspection. Accordingly re-inspection was carried out on 10/07/2012 and finally after considering the VT report and reply of the institution to Show Cause Notice, the SRC again withdraw the recognition of the D.Ed course, both basic and additional intake, from the academic year 2013 -14.

The council further noted that the institution possessed land on ownership basis but the two pieces of land are not adjacent and are separated by a road. The institution was granted recognition in the years 1996 and 2004 and therefore the norms of 2009 are not applicable in respect of land area but the institution is required to fulfill the norms relating to built up area. The institution has admitted that they have a built up area of 12,160 sq.ft and the building plan submitted by the institution also indicates that the size prescribed in the norms. In view of the facts stated above, the council concluded that the SRC was justified in withdrawing recognition and hence the order of SRC deserved to be confirmed.”

The appellate authority order No F.No.89-189/2013 Appeal/9th Meeting -2013 dated 25/07/2013 has confirmed the order of SRC. The appellate authority


55


was placed before SRC in its 251st meeting held during 25th – 27th August, 2013 has noted the matter.

In the meanwhile, an interim order dated 29.8.2013 in W.P.No.37464/2013(EDN-REG-P) & 38541-38560/2013 is received from the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore on 6.9.2013 which is as under:-

“Interim Stay of Annexures ‘M’ and ‘K’ for a period of three months from today. Petitioner institute is directed to implead twenty students said to be pursuing their studies in D.Ed. course in its college within two weeks from today. Post again on 17.9.2013.

Note: Annexure M to the w.p. is the copy of the order dated 25.7.2013 bearing No.F.89-189/2013 Appeal/9th Meeting -2013 passed by Member Secretary.Annexure K to the w.p. is the copy of the withdrawal order dated 14.2.2013 bearing No.F.SRO/NCTE/AOS00027-D.Ed./APS03115-D.Ed.(AI)/2013-14/49129 passed by the Regional Director.”

The Committee considered the matter, advised Southern Regional Office to ask SRCNCTE Lawyer to defend the case and to get the ‘stay’ vacated.

28. APS02087B.Ed

Anupama College of Education,

Mahalakshmipuram,

BangaloreKA

Gayathri Educational Society, Bangalore-560086, Karnataka had submitted an application to the Southern Regional Committee of NCTE for grant of recognition to Anupama College of Education, West of Chord Road, II Stage, Mahalakshmipuram, Bangalore-560086, Karnataka for offering Secondary (B.Ed.) course of one year duration and was granted recognition on 28.1.2005 from the academic session 2004-05 with an annual intake of 100 students with the condition to shift to its own premises/ building within three years from the date of recognition (in case the course is started in rented premises).

Further, as seen from the records, there are no correspondences available in the file regarding shifting of premises after three years of recognition.

In the meanwhile, on 3.9.2013, this office has received a Notice and interim order dated 26.8.2013 from the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore in W.P.No.37954 / 2013 against the State of Karnataka and others, wherein the SRC, NCTE is the 6th respondent.

The interim order dated 26.8.2013 is as under:-“Interim order as prayed for. Post this case along with W.P.Nos.37368-369

of 2013 on 10.9.2013.

Note: It is prayed to grant an interim order of stay of all further proceedings under and in pursuance of letter bearing No.58/Aparadha/EOS/CID//2013 dated 24.7.2013 issued by the 4th

Respondent vide Annexure-J.”

In the above writ petition, The State of Karnataka is the 1st respondent, The Director General of Police is the 2nd respondent, The Principal Secretary to the G.O.K. is the 3rd respondent, Sri. G.C. Manjunatha, Major, Police Inspector, Economic Crime Department, CID, Bangalore, Karlton Bhavan, Palace Road, Bangalore-1 is the 4th respondent, The Bangalore University is the 5 th

respondent, SRC, NCTE is the 6th respondent and Sri. H. Karan Kumar, Major is the 7th respondent.


56


The Committee considered the ‘Interim order as prayed for by the petitioner in the Hon’ble High Court of Kanataka and advised Southern Regional Office to obtain the details of the petition filed from our Lawyer and ask the Layer to defend the case.

29. APS05349D.EdRev.

Noorunnissa College of Diploma in Education,

Kolar DistrictKA

Rev. Noorunnissa College of Diploma in Education, Gollahalli Road, Andersonpet, K.G.F., Kolar Dt.-563113, KarnatakaNoorie Educational Cultural and Charitable Trust, Kolar Dt., Karnataka has submitted an application to SRC, NCTE for grant of recognition to Rev. Noorunnissa College of Diploma in Education, Gollahalli Road, Andersonpet, K.G.F., Kolar Dt.-563113, Karnataka for Elementary(D.Ed.) course of two years duration with an intake of 50 students and recognition was accorded to the institution vide this office order No.F.SRO/NCTE/D.Ed./2006-2007/729 dated 12.04.2007 with a condition to shift to its own premises within three years from the date of recognition (if started in rented premises).

Further, as seen from records, there is no correspondence regarding shifting of premises of the institution to its own premises.

On 17.7.2013, this office received a letter dated 12.7.2013 from Haranahalli and Patil Advocates and Consultants stating that the institution has filed a Writ petition vide W.P.No.28891-28941/2013 which is as under:-

“The above matter was filed seeking for direction to the Respondent NO.1 to approve the admission of petitioners no.2 to 51 for 1st year D.Ed. course and permit them to appear for examination. The above matter came up for consideration before the Hon’ble High Court today for preliminary hearing. After hearing the matter the Court allowed the writ petition. We have applied for certified copy of the final order and the same will be sent to you on its receipt.”

On 17.7.2013, this office has received an interim order dated 3.7.2013 in W.P.NO.28891-28941/2013(EDN-AD) from the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore which is as under:-

“As it is not in dispute that the NCTE has granted the recognition and as the Government has permitted the petitioner institution to make admissions to D.Ed.course for the academic year 2012-13, I pass the following interim order:-

i)The respondents are directed to permit the petitioner students 2 to 51 to appear for the forthcoming first year examination of D.Ed. course.

(ii) It is made clear that if eventually these petitions are dismissed, the petitioners shall not plead equity.

(iii)Further, the respondents is directed not to announce the results of the students in question until further orders.”

The Committee considered the ‘Interim order as prayed for by the petitioner in the Hon’ble High Court of Kanataka and advised Southern Regional Office to obtain the details of the petition filed from our Lawyer and ask the Layer to defend the case.

30. APS02174B.Ed

Amitha B.Ed College,

Amitha B.Ed. College, C.A.No.2, 3rd Main, West of Chord Road, 2nd Stage, Mahalakshmipuram, Bangalore-560086, KarnatakaAmbedkar Memorial Society, Bangalore,Karnataka had submitted an application to the SRC of NCTE for grant of recognition to Amitha B.Ed.


57


Mahalakshmipuram,

BangaloreKA

College, C.A.No.2, 3rd Main, West of Chord Road, 2nd Stage, Mahalakshmipuram, Bangalore-560086, Karnataka is granted recognition for Secondary (B.Ed.) course of one year duration from the academic session 2004-2005 with an annual intake of 100 students vide order No.F.SRO/NCTE/B.Ed./2004-2005/8636 dated 25.11.2004 with a condition to shift to its own premises within three years from the date of recognition.

It is observed from the file that there are no correspondences pertaining to shifting of premises.

An interim order dated 6.6.2013 is received by this office on 12.6.2013 from the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka in W.P.No.9411/2013 & 10762-10861/2013 and 10863-10911/2013 filed by Amitha B.Ed. College against Bangalore University(1R), The Registrar, Bangalore University, Bangalore(2R) and RD, SRC,NCTE(3R).

The petitioner has prayed to announce the results of the 2nd semester B.Ed. examinations held in November/December, 2012 in respect of 100 students of the petitioner institution forthwith by granting continuation of affiliation for the academic year 2011-12 for the petitioner institution.

The learned counsel appearing for the respondent No.1 and 2 submits that the Bangalore University’s syndicate has resolved to withdraw the affiliation granted to the petitioner’s college for want of infrastructural facilities etc. He submits that the syndicate has resolved to shift the eligible students of the petitioner college and of the similarly placed other colleges to the affiliated colleges and allow those students to appear for the examination at the affiliated colleges.

The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner college has the recognition of NCTE for the academic year 2012-13. He further submits that the petitioner college has not received any order refusing to grant the continuation of affiliation for the academic year 2012-13.

On hearing the learned advocates, the Hon’ble judge passed the following interim order states “1. The Bangalore University is directed to permit the students admitted for the academic year 2012-13 to appear for the forthcoming examination at the affiliated colleges centres subject to the said students meeting the eligibility criteria in all other respects.

2. This interim order is subject to the final outcome of the writ petitions.List the matter for final disposal on 11.6.2013.”

The above matter is placed before SRC for its consideration and decision regarding non-shifting of premises of the institution and the interim order granted by the Hon’ble Court.

The SRC in its 248th meeting held during 13th to 15th July, 2013 considered the matter, Hon’ble High Court Interim order and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following: The Institution was granted recognition in temporary premises to run B.Ed

course on 25-11-2004 with a condition that it should shift to its own


58


permanent premises in 3 years. i.e., on or before 25.11.2007. The Institution is still running in temporary premises and not shifted to new premises even after a lapse of stipulated 3 years and after lapse of time period of more than 8 years and 07 months.The institution has not shifted to the new premises after grant of conditional recognition.

As per the decision of SRC, Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 27.8.2013. The institution has submitted its written representation on 18.9.2013

The Committee considered the matter, decided that in the first instance, the Court case concerns Government of Karnataka and Bangalore University.

Further, the Committee advised Southern Regional Office to examine w.r.t. show cause notice reply dated 18-09-2013 in the shifting matter and report in the 255th meeting scheduled on 13-15th Nov, 2013.

31. SRCAPP148B.P.Ed

Ayyappa College of Physical


AP

Ayyappa College of Physical Education, Khasara/Plot No. 109/2, Dhione Village and Post Office, Dhione Taluka and City, Kurnool District – 518 222, Andhra Pradesh.

Sree Lakshmee Narasimha Educational Society, Plot No. 1-67-25-26, Pendekantinagar Road, Banaganapalle Village and Post Office, Banaganapalle Taluka and City, Kurnool District – 518 124, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Ayyappa College of Physical Education, Khasara/Plot No. 109/2, Dhione Village and Post Office, Dhione Taluka and City, Kurnool District – 518 222, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed Course for one year duration under Section 14 of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012. The institution has submitted hard copy of the application on 07.01.2013.



a) The processing fee, as provided under Rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application.

b) Hard copy in triplicate of the online application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application.

c) Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society. Institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission


59


of online application.

The SRC in its 238th Meeting held on 05th-06th February, 2013 and on careful perusal of the original of the institution and other related documents, NCTE Act, 1993, Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table the Regional Committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds:

Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society/institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application - (as per Regulations 2009 Para 7[1-A(i)](c)).

Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the institution vide no. F.No.SRCAPP148 (2013-14)/B.P.Ed/AP/2012-13/49355 dated 06/03/2013.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC, the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs vide no. F.No.89-218/2013 Appeal/11th Meeting-2013 dated 23.08.2013 stating that “…the council concluded that the appeal deserved to be rejected and the order of the SRC confirmed”.

The appellate authority order was placed before SRC in its 253 rd

Meeting held on 30th September & 01st October, 2013 and the committee has noted the matter.

Meantime, a court order has been received from Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in W.P No. 25827 of 2013 dated 26.09.2013 filed by Ayyapa College of Education stating that “… this petition is moved for issuance of writ of certiorari for correcting the error apparent on the face of the record of the orders passed on 06.03.2013 by the SRC-NCTE as well as the error committed by the Appellate authority in its order dated 23.0/.2013.

The 1st Petitioner is a society, which runs the 2nd Petitioner College of education. The 1st Petitioner was established for providing the college of education and in fact it has intended to provide for Bachelors course in Physical Education. The petitioner submitted an application on 31.12.2012 the last date set for submission of such applications as per the notification issued by the SRCNCTE. As is required the application is submitted on-line and subsequently a hardcopy, with is required to be submitted within 7 days from the date of submission of the online application, has been so submitted on 07.01.2013. The SRC at its 238 th

meeting held on 05th and 06th February, 2013 rejected the application assigning the following reason:

“ a. The processing fee, as provided under Rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before


60


the date of submission of online application.


c. copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society. Institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of online application."

Since, the application of the petitioner is rejected, the demand draft submitted by it for a sum of Rs. 50,100/- is also returned. Since an appeal is provided for against any such order of the SRC, the petitioner submitted the appeal on 16.04.2013, which was considered by the appellate committee at its meeting, but however, it rejected the appeal. While rejecting the appeal, it was noted in paragraph 4 of the order as “ The appellant with his appeal only enclosed a copy of the registered sale deed of the land dated 28.09.2012 in its original version in telugu and its English translated version certified by an advocate/notary on 13.04.2013 though the sale deed is dated prior to the date of application, the appellant has not furnished the certified copy of the sale deed i.,e. certified by the registered authority, as per the requirements of the provisions of the clause 7 (i) (iv) of the NCTE Regulations 2009.” Hence, the appeal is rejected.

Heard Sri Subba Reddy, the learned counsel for the petitioners and Sri Satyanarayana Goud deputizing for Sri K. Ramakanth Reddy, learned standing counsel for NCTE.

The learned counsel for the petitioner would contend that the 1 st

petitioner society has purchased the land through a registered sale deed. Since the sale deed was drafted in telugu, the translated version thereof was got notarized and it was also submitted. Without examining the fact as to whether the petitioners have submitted the title deed in original or not, the impugned orders have been passed.

Per contra, Sri Satyanarayana Goud would submit that SRC, which dealt with the application at the first instance, has rejected the application of the petitioners’ society, inasmuch as the petitioners society has failed to enclose the title deed for the land in question. Therefore, the decision of the SRC connot be faulted at all. Insofar as the Appellate Committee is concerned, as per the requirements of the Regulations 7 (1) (iv), certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority have got to be produced. Since, the petitioner has failed to filed the said certified copy, the order of the appellant authority cannot be interdicted.

Parliament while enacting the National Council for Teacher Education Act, 1993 has entrusted the entire area for consideration of the NCTE with regard to all matters concerning the establishing, running,


61


managing and operating any course of study relating to field of education. The NCTE functions through its regional committees as it would be convenient for all parties concerned for regulating the matters relating to teacher e3ducation programmes, the norms, standards and procedures to be adopted for recognition of the institutions, commencement of new programmes, matters relating to sanction of intake capacity etc. it is all covered by the National Council for Teacher Education ( recognition, norms and procedure) Regulations 2009. Regulation 5 dealt with the manner of making application and time limit. Regulation 7 contained detailed procedure for processing of the application. 7 (1) of these Regulations reads as under.

The applicant institutions shall ensure on-line submission of the applications complete in all respects alognwith hard copy of the application and other documents specified below. However, in case of any inadvertent omissions or deficiencies in the documents submitted, the office of the Regional Committee shall point out the deficiencies within 45 days of the receipt of the applications, which the applicants shall remove within 60 days from the date of receipt of communication of deficiencies, if any. The on-line application with separate submission of the following documents only, shall be considered as complete application.

i. Application in triplicate on the prescribed format.ii. Processing fees as provided under Rule 9 of the National council for

Teacher Education Rules, 1997 as amended from time to time.iii. Fixed deposit receipt for Rs. 5.00 lacs and 3.00 lacs of a nationalized

Bank towards Endowment and Reserve funds, respectively. iv. Certified copy of the registered land documents issued by the

competent authority. v. Approved building plan by the competent civil authority. vi. Notarized copy of the change of land use certificate issued by the

competent authority. vii. Affidavit in the prescribed form on Rs. 100/- stamp paper duly attested

by Oath commissioner or Notary Public, stating the precise location of the land (Village, District, State etc), the total area in possession, the permission of the competent authority to use the land for educational purposes and mode of possession i.e. ownership or lease.

From a perusal of the above Regulation 7 (1) it becomes imminently clear that in case of any inadvertent omissions or deficiencies in the documents submitted, the office of the Regional Committee shall point out the deficiencies within 45 days of the receipt of the application, which the applications shall remove within 60 days from the date of receipt of any such communication. The on-line application which is followed by submission of hard copy thereof accompanied by the documents listed out therein alone shall be considered as completed application. Sri Satyanarayana Goud would submit that any deficiency of the documents submission noticed by the SRC, along can be intimated for overcoming such deficiencies by the application. But, it the applicant fails to submit a crucial document relating to the title for the land in question, the application itself becomes incomplete application and hence it cannot be considered as responsive to the notification and in such an event there would be no obligation on the part of the SRC to put the applicant on


62


notice requiring him to remove any such deficiency.

I am afraid that this contention is untenable. As was already noticed supra, the crucial expressions used in regulation 7 (1) are “in case of any inadvertent omissions or deficiencies in the documents submitted”. therefore, while framing the Regulations, the NCTE has contemplated situations where the applicants may have committed certain inadvertent omissions while submitting their applications and in certain other cases, there may have been certain deficiencies in respect of the documents submitted by them. So there are two distinct and separate varieties of omissions and deficiencies. In both these kinds of omissions and deficiencies, the SRC is required to put the applicants on notice providing them an opportunity to rectify the omissions and overcome the deficiencies within 60 days. In the instant case, the SRC has not put the petitioners herein on any such notice prior to its rejection o the applications submitted by the petitioner. Therefore, the action of the SRC in rejecting the application of the petitioners is contrary to the requirements of the Regulation 7 (1).

Further, the petitioner has enclosed the sale deed which is registered by the competent Sub-Registrar in State of Andhra Pradesh. Sale deed is a known mode of conveying right, title and interest in respect of immovable property from one person to another person. It is a recognized conveyance of title. If the value of the land so transferred exceeds Rs. 100/-, under Section 17 of the Registration Act. Such document of conveyance was liable to be compulsorily registered. In the instant case, the sale deed was got registered and after the Sub-Registrar has recorded the particulars thereof books permanently maintained by him is accomplished, he would be returning of such original documents. The original documents will bare the details of the registration, as to the presence of the parties and the crucial witnesses, who have witnessed the transaction concerned, as a precautionary measure even the thumb impressions of the parties are also collected by the Sub-Registrar. They are not only affixed on the reverse of the first page of the conveyance deed, but they are also obtained in the permanent registers maintained by the Sub-Registrar in his office. This apart to prevent any possible misuse or abuse of any such facility, the Rules have been incorporated to Registration Act to affix compulsory photograph of principal parties to the transaction. Therefore, what is now produced before the appellate committee is the original document itself. It bears the signature of the Sub-Registrar before whom the actual registration has been taken up. It bears all details relating to the deed such as in which volume and at what page the details of the transaction have been recorded by him. Therefore, the registered conveyance deed is a certificate of its proper registration itself. It does not require any further certification at the hands of the Sub-Registrar. Therefore, the Appellate Committee has not properly construed the registered sale deed produced by the petitioners and erred in treating it as not a certified copy of the registered land document.

Thus, both the SRC as well as the Appellate Committee have erred in considering properly the applications submitted by the petitioner.

The matter requires to be remanded for consideration afresh. The primary authority to accord any such permission to start a course of study, must invariably get satisfied that all other requirements of law such as infrastructural and instructional facilities have been put in place. Only upon such satisfaction being recorded, necessary permission can be accorded.


63


Sri Satyanarayana Goud is certainly right in pointing out that in the current academic year 2013-14, the time limit prescribed for accomplishing the grant of permission was already over and at this belated stage any such permission if accorded, it will create unsurmountable difficulties.

Hence, keeping in view of these inherent limitations, the SRC shall deal with the application on its merit and if it is satisfied that the petitioners have complied with the other requirements, may grant permission for commencement of the course for the academic year 2014-15.

This writ petition stands disposed of in the above terms. No costs.

Consequently, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed

The Committee considered the matter, decided and advised Southern Regional Office to ask our Lawyer to file an appeal and obtain ‘stay’ of the Hon’ble High Court.

Appeal Cases

32. SRCAPP1187D.Ed

Sri Balaji Institute of D.El.Ed, Chittoor District

AP

Sri Balaji Institute of D.El.Ed, Plot No. 440-3A,3B, Ponnutipalayam Taluk and Town, Chittoor District, Pin-517325, Andhra Pradesh

Nirmala Educational Society, Plot No. 440-3A/3B, Sivalayam Street, Madanapalle Village, Madanapalle Taluk and City, Chittoor District, Pin-517325, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Sri Balaji Institute of D.El.Ed, Plot No. 440-3A,3B, Ponnutipalayam Taluk and Town, Chittoor District, Pin-517325, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 03.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 01.11.2011/14.12.2011 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29.12.2011.

The institution has submitted written representation to the deficiency letter on 28.02.2012.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 220 th Meeting held on 30th and 31st March 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 28.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1)of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued on 27.04.2012.

The institution has submitted its written representations on 16.05.2012

The reply of the institution to the show cause notice was duly considered by SRC in its 223rd meeting held on 29-31st May, 2012 and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:


64


Land documents of sale deed dt. 14.09.2010 submitted are in favour of joint name Smt. D. Sarala. J. Geetha, R. Nanda Kishore & K. Sujatha. K. Satish Kumar, which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009.

The gift deed is executed on 11/05/2012 in favour of the society after the date of submission of on line application(29.09.2011). This is not permissible as per NCTE norms

Proceedings from the revenue divisional office for conversion of land from agriculture to non-agriculture only for the purpose of Educational institutions is not submitted.

As per encumbrance certificate submitted, the land is in the name of individuals i.e., Dommalapatti Sarala, Sonduru Sathya Praveen,k J. Geetha, R. Nanda, K.l Sujatha, K. Sathish Kumar and Sondurau Saritha, which is not permissible as per NCTe regulations.

EC reflects that the gift deed was executed on 11/05/2012 in favour of Society as per NCTE norms which is not permissible

The reply to the show cause notice is not satisfactory and unconvincing.

Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course


Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC, the institution preferred an appea NCTE-Hqrs vide no. F.No. 89-521/2012 Appeal/13th Meeting-2012 dt. 04/01/2013 stating that “…Council concluded that the SRC was justified in refusing recognition and therefore the appeal deserved to be rejected and the order of the SRC confirmed”.


33. SRCAPP1249D.E.C.Ed

Varma Teacher Training Institute, Kadapa District

AP

Varma Teacher Training Institute, No. 117, 7th Street, Rly. Kodur Village, Post & Taluk, Kadapa District-516101, Andhra Pradesh.Varma Educational Academy, No. 534, Reddy & Reddy Colony, Tirupati Village, Post & Taluk, Chittoor District-517501, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Varma Teacher Training Institute, No. 117, 7th Street, Rly. Kodur Village, Post & Taluk, Kadapa District-516101, Andhra Pradesh for D.E.C.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 07.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 03.11.2011 / 22.12.2011 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 30.12.2011. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 29.02.2011.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 220th Meeting held on 30th and 31st

March 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt.


65


29.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued on 30.04.2012. The institution has submitted its written representations on 16.05.2012.

The reply of the institution to the show cause notice was duly considered by SRC in its 223rd Meeting held on 29th-31st May, 2012 and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:

1. As per sale deed land is registered on 17-02-2012, after the date of on-line application, which is not permissible as per NCTE regulation 2009.

2. The institution has applied on-line for D.E.C.Ed course and requesting for change of course to D.El.Ed is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009.

3. Ntarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the purpose of educational institution only is not submitted. Proceedings of Revenue Divisional Officer not submitted for conversion of land from agricultural to educational purposes.

4. Original FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from a Nationalized Bank is not submitted.

Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.E.C.Ed course.

Accordingly, rejection order was issued to the institution on 27.06.2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC, the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs vide no. F.No.89-521/2012 Appeal/13th Meeting-2012 dated 04.01.2013 stating that “…the council concluded that the only registered sale deed submitted is dated 17.02.2012 i.e. on a date subsequent to the date of application and therefore the SRC was justified in refusing recognition. The appeal is rejected and the order of the SRC is confirmed”.



Lakshmi College of Physical


DistrictAP

Lakshmi College of Physical Education, Kasara No. 33/2, Street No. 33, K L Puram Village and Post Office, K L Puram Taluka, Vizianagaram District – 535 003, Andhra Pradesh.

Lakshmi Technical and Educational Society, Plot No. 33/2, Near RTO Office, K L Puram Village and Post Office, K L PUram Taluka, Vizianagaram District – 535 003, Andhra Pradesh has applied for grant of recognition to Lakshmi College of Physical Education, Kasara No. 33/2, Street No. 33, K L Puram Village and Post Office, K L Puram Taluka, Vizianagaram District – 535 003, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed course on 19/12/2012 for one years duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act. 1993 and received in the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 26/12/2012.



66





c) Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society. Institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of online application.

The SRC in its 238th Meeting held on 05th-06th February, 2013 has considered the original file of the institution and other related documents, NCTE Act, 1993, Regulations and guidelines from time laid on the table the Regional Committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds:

The processing fee, as provided under rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application - (as per Regulations 2009 Para 7[1-A(i)]a).

Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the institution on 06/03/2013.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC, the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs vide no. F.No.89-185/2013 Appeal/9th Meeting-2013 dated 26/09/2013 stating that “…the council concluded that the SRC was justified in refusing recognition and therefore the appeal deserved to be rejected and the order of SRC confirmed.

NOW THEREFORE, the council hereby confirms the order appealed against.


35. SRCAPP2105B.P.EdNigama

College of Physical

Education, Karimnagar

DistrictAP

Nigama College of Physical Education, Plot No. 1543, 1546/A, 1546/B, 1546/C, Sambaiahpally Village, Garrepally Post, Sultanabad Taluk, Karimnagar District-505186, Andhra Pradesh.

Himavani Educational Society, H.No. 2-9-5, Mukarrampura Road, Karimnagar Village, Post & Taluk, Karimnagar District-505001, Andhra Pradesh has applied for grant of recognition to Nigama College of Physical Education, Plot No. 1543, 1546/A, 1546/B, 1546/C, Sambaiahpally Village, Garrepally Post, Sultanabad Taluk, Karimnagar District-505186, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed course on 30/12/2012 for one year duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act. 1993 and received in the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 04/01/2013.



67






The Southern Regional Committee in its 238th Meeting held on 05th-06th

February, 2013 duly scrutinized above new application received by Southern Regional Office, NCTE for the Session 2013-14. Accordingly, the above application, which suffer from basic infirmities, is summarily rejected as per Regulations 2009 [ 7 1–A (i) ].

The Processing fee, as provided under rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application – as per the Regulations 2009 Para 7[1-A(i)]a).

Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the institution on 04/03/2013..Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC, the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs vide no. F.No.89-176/2013 Appeal/9th Meeting-2013 dated 25/09/2013 stating that “…the council concluded that the appeal deserved to be accepted and the matter remanded to the SRC with a direction to process the application as per Regulations.

NOW THEREFORE, the council hereby remands back the case of Nigama College of Physical Education, Karimnagar, Andhra Pradesh to the SRC, NCTE, for necessary action as indicated above.

The Committee considered the Appellate Authority order dated 25/09/2013 and decided to process the application of the said institution as per Regulations.

36. SRCAPP1990D.Ed

AL College of Education,

Guntur DistrictAP

AL College of Education, Plot/Khasara No.67, 68, 69, 70, 82, 84, Plot No. 67, Lodge Cent Street, Guntur Village and Taluk, Arundalpet Post Office, Guntur City and District – 522002, Andhra Pradesh.

AEL Church, Plot No. 67, Lodge Centre Road, Guntur Village and Taluk, Arundalpet Post Office, Guntur City and District – 522002, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to AL College of Education, Plot/Khasara No.67, 68, 69, 70, 82, 84, Plot No. 67, Lodge Cent Street, Guntur Village and Taluk, Arundalpet Post Office, Guntur City and District – 522002, Andhra Pradesh for D.Ed Course for two years duration under Section 14 of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 28.12.2012. The institution has submitted hard copy of the application on 03.01.2013.


68








The processing fee, as provided under rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application - (as per Regulations 2009 Para 7[1-A(i)]a).

Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the institution on 06/03/2013.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC, the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs vide no. F.No.89-216/2013 Appeal/11th Meeting-2013 dated 25/09/2013 stating that “…the council concluded that the appeal deserved to be accepted and the matter remanded to the SRC with a direction to process the application as per Regulations.

NOW THEREFORE, the council hereby remands back the case of AL College of Education, Guntur, Andhra Pradesh to the SRC, NCTE, for necessary action as indicated above.


37. SRCAPP2058D.P.Ed

Mokshitha College of

Physicl Education, Prakasam

DistrictAP

Mokshitha College of Physical Education, Kasara No. 492/1, 493, Plot No. 1-247A, Somarajupali Village, Singarayakonda Post Office, Kondepi Taluka, Singarayakonda City, Andhra Pradesh.

Sri Sai Educational Society, Enimerla Road, Pamur Village, Enimerla Post Office, Kanigiri Taluka, Pamur City, Prakasam District – 523 108, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Mokshitha College of Physical Education, Kasara No. 492/1, 493, Plot No. 1-247A, Somarajupali Village, Singarayakonda Post Office, Kondepi Taluka, Singarayakonda City, Andhra


69


Pradesh for D.P.Ed Course for one year duration under Section 14 of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.12.2012. The institution has submitted hard copy of the application on 31.12.2012.







The processing fee, as provided under rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application.

Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the institution vide no. F.No.SRCAPP2058 (2013-14)/D.P.Ed/AP/2012-13/49314 dated 06/03/2013.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC, the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs vide no. F.No.89-193/2013 Appeal/10th Meeting-2013 dated 25/09/2013 stating that “…the council concluded that the appeal deserved to be accepted and the matter remanded to the SRC with a direction to process the application as per Regulations.

NOW THEREFORE, the council hereby remands back the case of Mokshitha College of Physical Education, Prakasam, Andhra Pradesh to the SRC, NCTE, for necessary action as indicated above.


38. SRCAPP2123B.Ed

SSKS B.Ed College,

Chitradurga District

AP

SSKS B.Ed College,Plot/Khasara No.52/1P,Venkateshwara badavane, Head post office Chitradurga Taluk and City,Chitradurga District-577501, Karnataka

SSKS Vidyapeetha, 52/1p,Challakere Road,Chitradurga Village,Taluk and City,Head Post office, Chitradurga District-577501,Karnataka had applied for grant of recognition to SSKS B.Ed College,Plot/Khasara No.52/1P,Venkateshwara badavane, Head post office, Chitradurga Taluk and City,Chitradurga District-577501, Karnataka for B.Ed. Course for one


70


year duration under Section 14 of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.12.2012. The institution has submitted hard copy of the application on 04/01/2013 along with processing fees vide ICICI Challan No.M3174582 dated 3.1.2013 for Rs. Rs.50,100/- drawn on ICICI Bank.

Para 7[1-A(i)] and 7[1-A(ii)] of extant NCTE Regulations published in the Gazette of India on 31st August 2009, as amended from time to time, the application shall be summarily rejected under one or more of the following circumstances:

Para 7[1-A(i)]

i. The processing fee, as provided under rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application;

ii. Hard copy in triplicate of the online application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application;

iii. Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society/institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application.

Para 7[1-A(ii)]

The Regional Committee shall, after recording reasons for rejection under the circumstances referred to in clause (i) above, return the application to the applicant and refund the processing fees within 30 days of the online submission of the application.

Further, 8(7)(i) of NCTE Regulations reads as under:

No institution shall be granted recognition under these Regulations unless the institution or society sponsoring the institution is in possession of required land on the date of application. The land free from all encumbrances could be either on ownership basis or on lease from Government or Government institutions for a period of not less than 30 years. In cases where under relevant State or Union Territory laws the maximum permissible lease period is less than 30 years, the State Government or Union Territory Administration law shall prevail. However, no building shall be taken on lease for running any teacher training course.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 238th meeting held on 5th – 6th

February 2013 reviewed the duly scrutinized above new application received by Southern Regional Office, NCTE for the Session 2013-14. Accordingly, the above application, which suffered from basic infirmities was summarily rejected as per Regulations [ 7 1–A (i) ] for the following reason;


71


The institution has not submitted valid print out hard copy of online application in triplicate on the date of application and not even on or before 21/1/2013.

The processing fee, as provided under rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application. The institution has submitted a challan for Rs.50,100/- from ICICI Bank dated 3/1/2013 on 4/01/2013.

As per the decision of SRC, a rejection letter was issued to the institution vide this office letter F.No.HQ/Appeal/APSO2123-B.Ed/KA/2013-14/51715 dated 17.05.2013

The institution filed an appeal before the appellate authority as per Section 18 of the NCTE Act against the rejection letter of SRC,NCTE.

The appellate authority vide order F.No.89-168/2013 Appeal/11th Meeting 2013 dated 25.09.2013 has made the following observations :

“ The appellant submitted one hard copy of the on-line application on 03.01.2013 and the triplicate copies on 21.01.2013 as per the notice of the NCTE. The Council however noted that the appellant did not deposit the processing fee on the date of submission of online application as prescribed under the NCTE rules. Since , the matter relating to late payment of processing fee, we may await Council’s decision before issuing order. The Council noted that Council in its 31st Meeting held on 29th July 2013 decided that applications may be considered if the payment has been made on the next banking/working day following the date of submission of application, since the software does not allow for payment of the processing fees either on or before the date of submission of application.

In view of the above position, the Council concluded that SRC was justified in refusing recognition and therefore, the appeal deserved to be rejected and the order of the SRC confirmed”


As per Decision of the SRC 252nd Meeting decision of the following files are put up for consideration

39. APS07267B.P.Ed

Sri Renugambal

College of Physical

Education, Tiruvannamala

Sri Renugambal College of Physical Education, Cuddalore, Chittoor High Way, Ettivadi Village, Plour, Tiruvannamalai – 606907, Tamilnadu.

Sri Renugambal Educational Trust, Tiruvannamalai District, Tamilnau has submitted an application to the Southern Regional Committee of NCTE for grant of recognition to Sri Renugambal College of Physical Education, Cuddalore, Chittoor High Way, Ettivadi Village, Plour, Tiruvannamalai – 606907, Tamilnadu for B.P.Ed course of one year duration with an annual


72


i DistrictTN

intake of 50 (Fifty) students.

The institution was granted recognition on 11.09.2007.

The institution vide its letter dated 09.07.2013 had stated that,

“ we have been granted recognition for conducting B.P.Ed., with annual intake of basic unit 50 students. The same was affiliated with the Tamilndu Physical Education and Sports University, Chennai.

As per new regulations of NCTE Norms and Standards for Bachelor of Physical Education Programme leading to Bachelor of Physical Education (B.P.Ed) degree, there shall be a basic unit 100 students with 2 sections of 50 each.

As per new Norms, we have additional classes and additional required and additional facilities for conducting 2 classes for each 50 students for B.P.Ed course.

we request the Hon’ble Authority may please grant permission for enhancement of basic unit with annual intake of 100 students admission for B.P.Ed as per new regulations from the academic year 2013-14 onwards”.

The Committee in its 252nd meeting held on 13-14th Sept, 2013 considered the request of the institution vide letter dated 09-07-2013 for enhancement of basic unit with annual intake of 100 students admission for B.P.Ed as per new regulations 2009, decided and advised Southern Regional Office to put up with the notification of amendment of Regulation in 2009, since it is not clear whether the up gradation will be automatic or subject to scrutiny.

The Committee considered the matter, decided that the institution should apply afresh for the up gradation accordingly to Regulation – APP.7 (Norms & Standards for B.P.Ed) Para-3 which states that:

“There shall be a basic unit of one hundred students with two sections of fifty each.

15 ( Provided that the recognised institutions willing to upgrade their intake, shall be required to submit an application to the concerned Regional Committee of National Council for Teacher Education for the additional intake, and thereafter, the Regional Committee after assessing the instructional and infrastructural facilities under these Regulations if there is no restriction in the State of recognition of Bachelor of Physical Education Course sanction the additional intake; provided further that the intake capacity of 100 seats shall be approved only in those colleges which are established after the commencement of these Regulations and proposing a separate institution exclusively for physical education)”.

New Application -2013-2014

40. SRCAPP108D.Ed

Abdulkalam D.El.Ed College, Khasara No.1484, Plot No.9 4 70, 5th Street, Narasaraopet Village and Post Office, Narasaraopet Taluk and City,


73


Abdulkalam D.Ed College, Guntur District

AP

Guntur District-522601, Andhra Pradesh.

Gayaz and Friends Educational Foundation, Plot No.1484, 5th Street, Narasaraopet Village and Post Office, Narasaraopet Taluk and City, Guntur District-522601, Andhra Pradesh has applied for grant of recognition to Abdulkalam D.El.Ed College, Khasara No.1484, Plot No.9 4 70, 5th Street, Narasaraopet Village and Post Office, Narasaraopet Taluk and City, Guntur District-522601, Andhra Pradesh for D.Ed course online on 31.12.2012 for two year duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act 1993 and received in the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 07.01.2013.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 06.02.2013/28.03.2013 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 28.03.2013, again reposted on 18.07.2013.

The institution has submitted its written representation on 20.09.2013.Sl.No. Name of the College / Institution:- Abdulkalam D.El.Ed

College, Khasara No.1484, Plot No.9 4 70, 5th Street, Narasaraopet Village and Post Office, Narasaraopet Taluk and City, Guntur District-522601, Andhra PradeshName of the Society / Trust:- Gayaz and Friends Educational Foundation, Plot No.1484, 5th Street, Narasaraopet Village and Post Office, Narasaraopet Taluk and City, Guntur District-522601, Andhra Pradesh

1. Deficiency letter sent to the applicant institution on

28.03.2013, again reposted on 18.07.2013

2. Reply for deficiency letter received in the office of SRC on

20.09.2013

3. State Govt. reference / reminder sent on

06.02.2013/28.03.2013

4. Whether recommendation of State Govt. received:- yes or no.

No

The Southern Regional Committee considered the reply of the institution dt.20-09-2013 to the deficiency letter and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection to D.Ed course (SRCAPP108) after collecting inspection fee under section 14 of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.


Manair College of Physical Education, Karimnagar

DistrictAP

Manair College of Physical Education, Plot/Khasara No.108 A & B, Street No.1, Kamanpur Village, Karimnagar District, Pin - 505 002, Andhra Pradesh

Manair Educational Academy, Plot No.2-59, Padmanagar Street, Karimnagar Village & Post Office, Karimnagar District, Pin - 505 002, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Manair College of Physical Education, Plot/Khasara No.108 A & B, Street No.1, Kamanpur Village, Karimnagar District, Pin - 505 002, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed. Course of One year duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the


74


Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 26/12/2012 and physical application has been received in the office of Southern Regional Committee on 28/12/2012.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 06.02.2013 followed by reminder on 26.03.2013. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 26.03.2013.

The institution has not submitted reply for deficiency letter even after the stipulated time of 60 days period as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations.

As per sub-clause (1) of Clause 7 of NCTE Regulation 2009, the applicant institutions is required to submit deficiencies to the Southern Regional Committee Office Within 60 days from the date of receipt of communication of deficiencies, failing which the application will be treated as rejected and closed, no extension to time will be granted and any submission received after 60 days will be treated as invalid and not entertained.

The committee considered the matter, as the institution has not submitted reply for deficiency letter even after stipulated period of 60 days from the date of issue of deficiency letter and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to reject the application of the institution for recognition of B.P.Ed course.

42. SRCAPP100D.Ed

Saketh College of

Ele.Teacher Education,

West Godavari District

AP

Saketh College of Ele. Teacher Education, Plot/Khasara No.150, Plot No.1-99, Gavaravaram Village & Post Office, Koyyalagudem Mandal City, West Godavari District, Pin - 534 312, Andhra Pradesh SVR Educational Society, Plot No.1-99, Gavaravaram Village & Post Office, Koyyalagudem Mandal City, West Godavari District, Pin - 534 312, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Saketh College of Ele. Teacher Education, Plot/Khasara No.150, Plot No.1-99, Gavaravaram Village & Post Office, Koyyalagudem Mandal City, West Godavari District, Pin - 534 312, Andhra Pradesh for D.Ed. Course of One year duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31/12/2012 and physical application has been received in the office of Southern Regional Committee on 04/01/2013.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 06.02.2013 followed by reminder on 26.03. 2013. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 26.03.2013.

The institution has not submitted reply for deficiency letter even after the stipulated time of 60 days period as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations.



75


The committee considered the matter, as the institution has not submitted reply for deficiency letter even after stipulated period of 60 days from the date of issue of deficiency letter and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.Ed course.

43. SRCAPP1960B.Ed-AI

Director of Distance

Education, Rangareddy

DistrictAP

Director of Distance Education, Plot / Khasara No. 211 & 212, Gachibowli Street and Post Office, Manikonda Village, Ranga Reddy Taluka and City, Ranga Reddy District – 500 032, Andhra Pradesh

Maulana Azad National Urdu University, Gachibowli Road and Post Office, Manikonda Village, Ranga Reddy Taluka and City, Ranga Reddy District – 500 032, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Director of Distance Education, Plot / Khasara No. 211 & 212, Gachibowli Street and Post Office, Manikonda Village, Ranga Reddy Taluka and City, Ranga Reddy District – 500 032, Andhra Pradesh for B.Ed-AI Course of One year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 28.12.2012 and physical app lication has been received in the office of SRC on 08.01.2013(speed post) dispatched on 02.01.2013.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to Maulana Azad National Urdu University, Ranga Reddy District – 500 032 for their recommendation on 06.02.2013/28.03.2013 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 05.04.2013.

In the meantime, the Maulana Azad National Urdu University in its letter dt. 18.04.2013 & 29.04.2013 stating as follows:-

“NOC from Andhra Pradesh State Government for sanctioning additional 500 seats to the B.Ed. (distance mode) programme being offered by the Directorate of Distance Education, Maulana Azad National Urdu University, Gachibowli, Hyderabad. Maulana Azad National University is a central University which is dual mode catering to the needs of both the regular and distance mode Urdu medium students across the country.The B.Ed distance mode programme is being offered by the Directorate of Distance Education, Maulana Azad National Urdu University since 2005 with due recognition from NCTE.Since Maulana Azad National Urdu University is a central University established by an Act of the Parliament, it does not fall under the jurisdiction of the Andhra Pradesh State Government. It has a national presence with head quarters in Hyderabad, A.P.The present B.Ed (distance mode) programme as well as the regular mode B.Ed of MANUU is offered in various parts of India since it is a national University. In the past also, no NOC from the State Government was required as a prerequisite to start any course.Therefore, since the B.Ed. AI (i.e. additional intake of 500 seats) is proposed to be started by a national and central university, the clause 7 of the NCTE Regulations 2009 is not applicable in the case the proposals by Directorate of Distance education.Hence, you are requested to waive the prerequisite of obtaining NOC from the Government of A.P. and grant permission to start B.Ed Additional Unit of 500


76


from this academic year.”

The SRC in its 245th meeting held on 19th-21st May 2013, considered the matter and non-reply to the deficiency letter from the ‘Director of Distance Education” (SRCAPP1960) sent on 05.04.2013 and decided to await the reply to the deficiency letter.Further, the direction of the institution to be informed to send the D.L.Reply through Registrar of University, (MANUU).

Accordingly, as per the decision of SRC, a letter was issued to the institution on 20.06.2013.

The institution has submitted its written representation on 06.06.2013

The Southern Regional Committee considered the reply of the institution dt.06-06-2013 to the deficiency letter and all other relevant documents and decided to cause composite inspection to B.Ed (DL) & B.Ed-Al (DL) course after collecting inspection fee under section 14(1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Further, the Committee decided and advised Southern Regional Office to write to the University to pay the Endowment Fund and Reserve Fund of Rs. 5 lacs and 3 lacs respectively, because all Distance Learning courses are self-financing courses.

LOI Cases

44. SRCAPP1570B.Ed

Sadulla Hussain B.Ed

College, Guntur District

AP

Sadulla Husain B.Ed College, Khasara No. 522/c, Plot No. 36-2, Street. No. 1/4, Huzurnagar Village, Guntur Post & Taluk, Guntur District, Pin-522001, Andhra Pradesh

Universal Minorities Educational Society, Plot No. 13/2/26, Street/Road. 2/2 line, Kottappakonda Road Village, Narasaraopet Post & Taluk, Guntur District-522001, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition toSadulla Husain B.Ed College, Khasara No. 522/c, Plot No. 36-2, Street. No. 1/4, Huzurnagar Village, Guntur Post & Taluk, Guntur District-522001, Andhra Pradesh for B.Ed Course of one year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 30.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 10.10.2011.


The SRC in its 221st meeting held on 19th-20th April, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 01.03.2102 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.


77


Accordingly, Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 15.05.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 05.06.2012.

The reply of the institution to the show cause notice was duly considered by SRC in its 224th meeting held on 14th-16th June 2012, and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:

Certified copy of land documents from sub-registrar is not submitted.

Proceedings submitted from revenue divisional officer is in individual name, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

Original FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank in favour of Society/college/institution name if not given.

Notarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the purpose of educational institution only is not submitted.

Details of other courses run by the institution is not given.


Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.


[Note:In the meantime, the institution has submitted its written representation on 22.06.2012 for SCN (with reference to F.No.SRCAPP1570/2012-13/D.El.Ed/41184 dated 15.05.2012 and decision 224th meeting of SRC 14th-16th June 2012 Serial No.90).

A letter was received from the institution on 22.06.2012, the matter was inadvertently again put up in the 228th meeting as reply received after the date of stipulated time.

The SRC in its 228th meeting held on 24th-25th July, 2012 considered the reply dated 22/06/2012, i.e., after 38 (Thirty eight) days from the date of issue of show cause notice dt. 15.05.2012 and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course on the

basis of the following decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court:-

Supreme Court vide their order in Civil Appeal NO. 1125-1128/2011 in SLP No. 17165- 68/2009 filed by NCTE Vs ors, which reads as under:

“An institution is not entitled to recognition unless it fulfills the conditions specified in various clauses of the Regulations. The Council is directed to ensure that in future no institution is granted recognition unless it fulfills the


78


conditions laid down in the Act and the Regulations and the time schedule fixed for processing the application by the Regional Committee and communication of the decision on the issue of recognition it strictly adhered to”.]

The institution moved to Hon’ble High Court in Writ Petition No. 25348 of 2012, W.P.M.P.No. 32309 of 2012 the Judgment dtd. 07.08.2012 reads as under:-“……..the order of respondent 2 (SRC-NCTE Bangalore) is set aside. SRC-NCTE Bangalore is directed to reconsider the petitioners’ application if their reply to the show cause notice, dated 15.05.2012, was sent by the petitioners within 21 days of receipt of the show cause notice by them. On such reconsideration, a fresh order shall be passed and communicated to the petitioners within a period of two weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order”.

The matter was placed before SRC in its 233 rd meeting held on 26th-28th

September 2012, and the committee decided to process and put up.

As per the decision of SRC, the application was processed and placed before SRC in its 234th meeting held on 17th – 18th October 2012, and the committee considered the Hon’ble High Court Order dt. 07/08/2012 and reply of the institution and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

Original certified copy of the land documents from sub-registrar is not submitted. Notarized land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted. Proceedings of Revenue Divisional Officer not submitted for conversion of land from agricultural to educational purposes. Proceedings submitted is in individual’s name, i.e in the name of Sri. S.K. JareenaTaz, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.Original FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from a Nationalized Bank in favour of Society/college/institution name is not given.Details of other Teacher Education Courses run by the institution in the same building/premises is not given.

Accordingly, show cause notice was issued to the institution on 20.11.2012. The institution has submitted its reply on 10.12.2012.

The SRC in its 239th meeting held on 26th-27th February 2013, considered the reply of the institution dt.10-12-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided tocause inspectionunder section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 27 thto 30th May 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 17.05.2013.


On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993,


79


Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee in its 248th held on 13-15th July 2013 meeting decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to B.Ed course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100(One Hundred only)(one unit) subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

LOI issued to the institution dated 02-08-2013.

The institution has submitted its LOI reply vide letter dated 30-09-2013

On Careful perusal of the original file of the institution and staff profiles submitted by the institution in response to the letter of Intent, the Regional Committee decided that Formal Recognition be granted to B.Ed., course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100 (One hundred only) students, from the academic session 2014-2015.

45. SRCAPP861D.Ed

Vikas Teacher Training Institute, Kadapa District

AP

Vikas Teacher Training Institute, Plot No. 1560/1A & 1559, C K Dinne Village and Post, Kadapa- 516001, Andhra Pradesh

BabaEducational and Rural Development Society, Plot No. 3/99, Sivalingampalli Street, Kadapa Village and Town, Kadapa Taluka and Town, Kadapa- 516001, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Vikas Teacher Training Institute,Plot No. 1560/1A & 1559, C K Dinne Village and Post, Kadapa- 516001,Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 28.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 03.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 18.10.2011 / 14.12.2011 Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29.12.2011. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 28.02.2012.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 220th Meeting held on 30th and 31st March 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 28.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 03/05/2012.The institution has submitted written representation on 25/05/2012

The institution has submitted reply for Show Cause Notice after the expiry of stipulated time of 21 days period as per clause 14(1) of NCTE Regulations

The SRC in its 223rd Meeting held on 29th-31st May, 2012 considered the reply of the institution, which is received on 25/05/2012, i.e., after 22 (Twenty two) days from the date of issue of show cause notice dt.03/05/2012 and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.


80


Accordingly, rejection order was issued to the institution on 04/07/2012. The rejection order was returned back undelivered it was re-posted on 20/07/2012.

The institution has preferred on appeal to NCTE-Hqrs, and the original file was sent to NCTE-Hqrs on 23/07/2012.

Meantime, High court order has been received on 20/07/2012 in W.P.No. 21772 of 2012 dated 20/07/2012 filed by the institution. the court order stated is as follow:

“ this writ petition is filed for a Mandamus to declare the action of respondent No. 2, I rejection and refusing the application of petitioner No. 2 for grant of recognition to impart education in D.El.Ed. course vide proceedings in F.No.SRCAPP861/D.El.Ed/AP/2012-2013/43431 dated 04/07/2012 in the Minutes of the 223rd meeting held on 29th-31st May, 2012, as illegal and arbitrary.

I have heard Mr. Y. Nagi Reddy, learned counsel for the petitioner, and Mr. D. RaghavenderRao, learned counsel representing Mr. D. MadhavaRao, learned standing counsel for NCTE appearing for the respondents.

A perusal of the impugned proceedings shows that while purporting to refuse and reject the application of petitioner No. 2, the Committee has not assigned any reasons whatsoever. This court, while dealing with a similar rejection order in W.P. No. 17740 of 2012, set aside the same vide order dated 26.06.2012 and directed the Southern Regional Committee to consider the application of the petitioners therein afresh after passing an order with detailed reasons.

For the same reasons as mentioned in the said order, the impugned decision to the extent of the petitioners herein is set aside. The Southern Regional Committee of NCTE, Bangalore is directed to re-consider the application of petitioner No. 2, pas a detailed order and communicate the same to the petitioners within a period of one month from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.

The writ petition is, accordingly, allowed to the extent indicated above.

As a sequel to allowing the writ petition, W.P.M.P. No. 27894 of 2012 is disposed of as in fructuous”.

The appellate authority order dated 05/09/2012 received on 13/09/2012 states that ‘the appeal dated 09.07.2012 was preferred against the SRCs refusal order of SRC and directed SRC for reconsideration of the application. In the circumstances, the said appeal filed against SRC’a order dated 04.07.2012 becomes infructuous.

Now therefore, Council hereby treats the appeal dated 09/09/2012 preferred against SRC’s order dated 04/07/2012 as infructuous.

The SRC in its 230th Meeting held on 16th-17th July, 2012 considered the Hon’ble High Court, Andhra Pradesh Order dt. 20/07/2012 and decided to process the application of the institution.

As per the decision of SRC, the application has been processed and placed


81


before SRC in its 235th Meeting held on 21st – 22nd November, 2012 and the committee considered the Hon’ble High Court order dt. 20/07/2012 and Appellate authority order dt. 05/09/2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 21/12/2012. The institution has submitted written representation on 24/12/2012

The SRC in its 239th meeting held on 26th-27th February 2013, and the committee considered the reply of the institution dt.24-12-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 15thto 19th April 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 05.04.2013. VT member have submitted its written representation on 13.05.2013. Again, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 27th-30th May 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 17.05.2013.


On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee in its 248th meeting held on 13-15th July, 2013 decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.El.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit) subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

LOI issued to the institution on 02/08/2013.

The institution has submitted its LOI reply vide letter dated 23/09/2013.

On Careful perusal of the original file of the institution and staff profiles submitted by the institution in response to the letter of Intent, the Regional Committee decided that Formal Recognition be granted to D.Ed., course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50 (fifty only) students, from the academic session 2014-2015.

46. SRCAPP841D.Ed

Trinity College of Elementary

Teacher Education, Karimnagar

DistrictAP

Trinity College of Elementary Teacher Education, Khasara No. 415, 416 Plot No. Regd. No. 6431/2006, Main Road, Kasulapalli Village, Peddapalli Post Office and Taluka,Peddapalli City, Karimnagar District – 505 187, Andhra Pradesh

Trinity Society for Community Development, Plot No. 1-2-111/A, Hanuman Nagar Road Road, Peddapalli Village and Post Office, Karimnagar City, Karimnagar District – 505 172, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Trinity College of Elementary Teacher Education, Khasara No. 415, 416 Plot No. Regd. No. 6431/2006, Main Road, Kasulapalli Village,


82


Peddapalli Post Office and Taluka,Peddapalli City, Karimnagar District – 505 187,Andhra Pradesh for D.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 28.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 04.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 18.10.2011/19.12.2011 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29.12.2011. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 21.02.2012.The SRC in its 220th Meeting held on 30th-31st March, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 21.02.2102 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 27/04/2012. The institution has submitted written representation on 11/05/2012,

The reply of the institution to the show cause notice was duly considered by the SRC in its 223rd meeting held on 29th-31st May 2012, and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:

In the approved blue print of building plan submitted, total earmarked area for the exiting and proposed course is not mentioned. In the building plan as mentioned, built up area for proposed D.El.Ed course 887.30 it is very less as per regulation. As per regulation minimum 1500Sq.mts is required.

In the building completion certificate submitted, built up area for each course wise is not mentioned/given. In the building completion certificate col no. 9 two courses mentioned.

The management is running B.Ed course and proposes to run D.Ed in the same building.


Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee has decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

Further, the SRC decided to call for the details of class rooms, Size of multipurpose hall and others and total built up area earmarked for B.Ed course.

Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the institution vide no. F.No.SRCAPP841/D.El.Ed/AP/2011-12/43288 dated 29/06/2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order No. F.No.89-436/2012 Appeal / 9th Meeting-2012 dated 10/10/2012 stated that “…the council concluded that the appeal deserved to be accepted and the matter remanded to SRC for further processing as per the Regulations”.

The SRC in its 235th Meeting held on 21st-22nd November, 2012 considered the Appellate authority order dt. 10/10/2012 and all the relevant


83


documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 19/12/2012. The institution has submitted written representation on. 03/01/2013.

The SRC in its 240th meeting held on 9th-11th March 2013, considered the reply of the institution dt.03-01-2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 3rd to 6th July 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 20.06.2013.


On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee in its 249th meeting held on 24-26th July, 2013 decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

LOI issued to the institution vide letter dated 27/08/2013

The institution has replied to LOI on 24/09/2013.

The Committee considered the matter and noted that the institution is already running 5 courses other than the new application SRCAPP841-D.Ed course applied for the session 2012-13. Committee has decided and advised Southern Regional Office to examine details carefully and put up again in the 255th meeting with a comparative statement covering all the 5 courses. .

47. SRCAPP1336D.EdSri

Mallikarjuna D.Ed College, Krishna District

AP

Sri MallikarjunaD.Ed College, Khasra No. 446/4, 447/1, Plot No. 3-102/4, Subbarao Street, Dhavajigudem Village, Gannavaram Post Office, Taluk, and Town, Krishna District, Andhra Pradesh – 521101.

Sri Mallikarjuna Educational Society, Plot No. 3-102/4,Subbarao Nagar Street Dhavajigudem Village, Gannavaram Post Office, Taluk, and Town, Krishna District Andhra Pradesh – 521101 had applied for grant of recognition to Sri MallikarjunaD.Ed College, Khasra No. 446/4, 447/1, Plot No. 3-102/4, Subbarao Street, Dhavajigudem Village, Gannavaram Post Office, Taluk, and Town, Krishna District, Andhra Pradesh – 521101 for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 30/09/2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 04/10/2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State


84


Government for recommendation on 17/10/2011 followed by reminder on 19/12/2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29/12/2011. The institution has submitted reply for deficiency letter on 15/03/2012.

The institution has submitted reply for deficiency letter after the stipulated time of 60 days period as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations

The Southern Regional Committee in its 221st meeting held on 19th – 20th April 2012, considered the reply of the institution, which is received on 15/3/2012, i.e., after 76 (Seventy Six) days from the date of issue of deficiency letter and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.


Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-393/2012 Appeal/5th Meeting-2012 dated 05.09.2012 states that ‘the council concluded that there was adequate ground to accept the appeal and remand the case to the SRC for consideration of reply of the institution and for taking further decision there after.’

In pursuance to the Appellate Authority order the application was processed and placed in 233rd Meeting of SRC held on 26th-28th September, 2012 and the committee has considered the Appellate authority order no. F.No.89-393/2012 Appeal/8th Meeting-2012/A571423 dt. 05.09.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 06/11/2012. The institution has submitted written representation on. 19/11/2012.The SRC in its 236th meeting held on 16th –18th December 2012 has considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 19.11.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

Notarized land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted.

As per building plan, the size of the multipurpose hall is less than the requirement of 2000 sq.ft. as per NCTE norms 2009.

Accordingly, Final Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 18.01.2013. The institution had submitted its written representation on 07.02.2013.

The SRC in its 241st meeting held on 29th- 31st March & 1st April 2013, considered the reply of the institution dt.07-02-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided tocause inspectionunder NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.


85


Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 20 thto 25th May 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 15.05.2013.


On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee in its 248th meeting held on 13-15th July, 2013decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.El.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit) subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

LOI was issued to the institution on 02/08/2013

LOI reply from the institution on 11/09/2013.


48. SRCAPP629D.Ed

Bugudi Tulasidas,

Rangareddi District

AP

Bugudi Tulasidas, Sy. No. 83, Plot No. 1, Tandur Village and Post, Tandur City and Taluk, Rangareddi District- 501141, Andhra PradeshB.S.Bugudi Educational Society, Plot No.1, Near Gasgodown Road, Tandur Village and Post, Tandur City and Taluk, Rangareddi District- 501141, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Bugudi Tulasidas, Sy. No. 83, Plot No. 1, Tandur Village and Post, Tandur City and Taluk, Rangareddi District- 501141, Andhra Pradesh for D.EL.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 23.09.2011 and physical copy received on 23.09.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 14.10.2011/ 15.11.2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 20.12.2011. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 15.02.2012.

The SRC in its 218th meeting held on 28th February 2012, considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 15.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.

As per the direction of SRC, Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 22.03.2012. The institution had submitted its written representation on 09.04.2012.

The SRC in its 222nd meeting held on 9th-10th May 2012, considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 09.04.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under section


86


14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

1) Sale deed of land document registered dt. 16.02.2012 for Sy.No. 83/U submitted is after submission of on-line application, which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009.

2) Approved blue print of the building plan issued by competent civil authority is not submitted. In the building plan copy submitted, it states that the Ground floor west side portion is temporary allotted to School (8 rooms).

3) In the building completion certificate submitted, proposed course name is not given in column No. 9.

4) Notarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the purpose of educational institution only is not submitted. Proceedings of Revenue Divisional Officer not submitted for conversion of land from agricultural to educational purposes.

5) Land Transaction in favour of Society is in encumbrance certificate made on 16.02.2012, which is after the submission of on-line application, which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009.

Accordingly, Final Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 27.04.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation dt. 15.05.2012 received in the office of SRC on 18.05.2012.

The SRC in its 226th meeting held on 9th-10th July 2012, considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt,. 18.05.2012 to the show cause notice was duly considered and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:

The institution had submitted land documents which are registered on 16.02.2012, which is after the date of making on-line application, which is not permissible as per NCTE regulations 2009.The reply to the show cause notice is not satisfactory and unconvincing.


Accordingly, a rejection order was issued to the institution vide letter No. F.No. STCAPP629/D.El.Ed/AP/2012-13/45288 dt. 16.08.2012.

The institution preferred an appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the Appellate Authority vide order No. F.NO.89-691/2012Appeal14th meeting – 2012, dt. 01.02.2013 has stated as follows:

“…….the council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand back the case to the SRC with a direction to process the application and to take further decision thereafter”.

In pursuance to the appellate authority order, the application has been processed.

The SRC in its 241st meeting held on 30th-31st March & 1st April 2013, considered the Appellate Authority order dt. 08/01/2013 and all other relevant documents of the institution and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the


87


requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 3rd to 6th July 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 20.06.2013.


On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, VT report, VCD, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee in ts 251st meeting held on 25-27th Aug,2013 decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.


The institution has replied to the LOI on 08/10/2013.


49. SRCAPP908D.Ed

Geethanjali D.Ed College, Guntur District

AP

Geethanjali D.Ed College, No. 285/2B2A, Vinukonda Village, Post & Taluk, Guntur District-522647, Andhra Pradesh.

Sri Giri Educational Society, No. 23-1306/1, Palnadu Road, Vinukonda Village, Post & Taluk, Guntur Distirct-522647, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to GeethanjaliD.Ed College, No. 285/2B2A, Vinukonda Village, Post & Taluk, Guntur District-522647, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 28/09/2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 30/09/2011.


The SRC in its 219th meeting held on 15th – 16th March, 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 24.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice for the following:

The institution has submitted Rent deed dt. 21/09/2011, As per NCTE regulations 2009, rent deed is not permissible. As per Regulations of NCTE the land should be in the form of sale deed/gift deed/Govt. lease


88


deed duly certified by Sub-registrar. Land on lease from private parties & on rent is not permissible.

Approved blue print of the building plan issued by competent Govt. authority is not submitted. In the building plan submitted, Sy.Nos are corrected by hand. Which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

Building completion certificate from competent Govt. authorized engineer in a proper format is not submitted.

Notarised land usage certificate from Revenue Divisional Office of the Govt, is not submitted. Proceedings of Revenue Divisional Officer not submitted for conversion of land from agricultural to educational purposes.

Accordingly Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 04.04.2012. The institution submits its written representation on 23.04.2012.

The SRC in its 222nd Meeting held on 9th-10th May, 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 23.04.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

Notarised gift deed dt.21.09.2011 submitted copies of land document is not certified by Sub-Registrar.

Proceedings of the Revenue Department for conversion of land from agriculture to non –agriculture/Educational purpose is to be submitted

The building plan in the favour of the Society not in the favour of the college

BCC is corrected with white fluid, fresh BCC has to be submitted. At the time of the application the institution has submitted regisrted

rental deed vide dated 21.09.2011 for Sy.No.285/2B2A. Whereas, now the institution has submitted copy of gift deed vide registered dated 21.09.2011 for the same Sy.No. 285/2B2A institute as to clarify the same.

Before issuance of Show Cause Notice, the institution has submitted its reply on 22.06.2012 as per website.

The reply of the institution vide letter dt,. 22.06.2012 to the show cause notice was duly considered by the SRC in its 226th Meeting held on 29th – 10th July, 2012 and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:

As per building completion certificate, the total built up area is 17246 sq.fts, out of which 10410 sq.ft. is with RCC roofing and remaining 6835 sq.ft is covered with asbestos roofing, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

8 (10) of Regulations 2009 says:

At the time of inspection, the building of the institution shall be complete in the form of a permanent structure on the land possessed by the institution in terms of sub-regulation (7) of Regulation 8, equipped with all necessary amenities and fulfilling all such requirements as prescribed in the norms and standards. The applicant institution shall produce the original ompletion certificate issued by the competent Government Authority or local body authority, approved


89


building plan in proof of the completion of building and built up area and other documents to the visiting team for verification. No temporary structure or asbestos roofing shall be allowed in the institution, even if it is in addition to the prescribed built up area.

As per Encumbrance certificate dt. 21/02/2012 land is on lease basis whereas gift deed/settlement deed submitted on 22/06/2012 is on ownership basis, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.



As per the decision of SRC, rejection order was issued to the institution on 21.08.2012.

The institution had filed appeal Under Section 18 of NCTE Act, before the Appellate Authority, NCTE, New Delhi against the rejection order of SRC.

The appellate authority in its order dated 12.03.2013 stated that “…the council therefore, concluded that the matter deserved to be remanded to SRC for further processing as per the Regulations”.

In pursuance to the appellate authority order the application was processed and placed beforeSRC in its 242nd meeting held on 14th-16th April 2013, and the committee considered the Appellate authority order dt. 12/03/2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

As per the direction of SRC, intimation for inspection was issued to the institution on 15.05.2013. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 21.05.2013 and the VT Report received in the office of SRC on 10.06.2013


The institution to be informed to submit revalidated FDRs immediately


The institution has replied to LOI on 10/09/2013 along with the revalidated FDRs.

On Careful perusal of the original file of the institution and staff profiles


90


submitted by the institution in response to the letter of Intent, the Regional Committee decided that Formal Recognition be granted to D.Ed., course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50 (fifty only) students, from the academic session 2014-2015.

50. SRCAPP2100T.P.T.

Dr.BJL T.P.T. College of Education,

Vizianagaram District

AP

Dr. BJL T.P.T College of Education, Plot No.91/10, Kothaveedi Street, Devada Village, Kothavalasa Post Office & Taluk, Kothavalasa City, Vizianagaram District-535183, Andhra Pradesh

Himaja Educational Society, Plot No.91/10, Devada Street, Kothavalasa Village & Post Office, Kothavalasa Taluk, Vizianagaram City & District-535183, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Dr. BJL T.P.T College of Education, Plot No.91/10, Kothaveedi Street, Devada Village, Kothavalasa Post Office & Taluk, Kothavalasa City, Vizianagaram District-535183, Andhra Pradesh for T.P.T Course of one year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 30.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 04.01.2013 .

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 06.02.2013/28.03.2013 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 28.03.2013 and reposted on 26.04.2013. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 19.04.2013.

The SRC in its 244th meeting held on 9th-11th May 2013, considered the reply of the institution dt.19-04-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 1st to 5th July 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 27.06.2013.


On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee in its 249th meeting held on 24-26th July, 2013decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to T.P.T course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.


The institution has submitted its LOI reply on 13/09/2013.

On Careful perusal of the original file of the institution and staff profiles submitted by the institution in response to the letter of Intent, the Regional Committee decided that Formal Recognition be granted to T.P.T. course of one year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)


91


(one unit) students, from the academic session 2014-2015.

51. SRCAPP1090D.EdSri

Dhanalakshmi, West Godavari

DistrictAP

Sri Dhanalakshmi, Plot No. 7-26-20/9, TTD Road-1, Tadepalligudem Village, & Post, West Godavari District-534101, Andhra Pradesh

Sri Dhanalakshmi Educational Society, Plot No. 7-26-20/9, TTD, Kalyanamandapam Road, Tadepalligudem Village and Post Office, West Godavari District-534101, Andhra Pradesh has applied for grant of recognition to Sri Dhanalakshmi, Plot No. 7-26-20/9, TTD Road-1, Tadepalligudem Village, & Post, West Godavari District-534101, Andhra Pradesh for D.Ed course online on 29/09/2011 for two years duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act. 1993 and received in the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 13/10/2011. (Dispatched on 10.10.2011)



a. The processing fee, as provided under Rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application.


c. Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society. Institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of online application.

The SRC considered the matter in its 213th meeting held on 06th-07th

November, 2011 and careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related documents, NCTE Act 1993. Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table. The Regional Committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds.

a. Hard copy submitted after the stipulated period of 7 days from the date of on-line submission.

Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the institution vide no. F.No.SRCAPP1090(2012-13)/D.El.Ed/AP/2011-12/36214 dated 23/01/2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order No. F.No.89-382/2012 Appeal / 9th Meeting-2012 dated 09/10/2012 stated that “…the council concluded that there was adequate ground to accept the appeal and remand the case to the SRC for further processing of the application on merit as per the regulations”.

In pursuance to the appellate authority order, the application was process and placed before SRC in its 235th Meeting held on 21st-22nd November, 2012 and decided to refuse and reject the application as the deficiencies still persist as under:


92


Land documents submitted are in Telugu version. Certified copy of registered Notarized English version of land documents is not submitted.

In the building plan earmarked area for proposed course is not given. And approved blue print of building plan along with site area and built up area is not submitted.

Land Use certificate is not submitted. And proceedings of revenue department not submitted for conversion of land from agricultural to non-agricultural/ educational purpose.

Up to-date Encumbrance Certificate is not submitted. Building completion certificate in prescribed format is not submitted. Original FDR’s of Rs.5.00lakhs & Rs.3.00lakhs is not submitted.


Accordingly, a rejection order was issued to the institution on 19/12/2012.

Meantime, Hon’ble High Court order received from Andhra Pradesh in W.P.No. 601 of 2013 dated 04/01/2013 stated that “…this court prima facie finds that the approach of the Southern Regional Committee of National Council for Teacher Education, the 2nd respondent herein, in rejecting the application filed by the petitioner seeking recognition in respect of D.El.Ed course is totally unsatisfactory, if not arbitrary and capricious. The application was rejected on earlier occasion through order, dated 23/01/2012 by citing three reasons. The petitioner filed an appeal before the National Council, the 1st respondent herein. The grievance was mostly about the delay in submission of certain documents. The appeal was allowed on 09/01/2012 and the 2nd respondent was directed to pass fresh orders on merits. However, after remand, the 2nd

respondent passed the impugned order, dated 19/12/2012, indicating certain new grounds for rejection of the application. This course is totally impermissible under law.

Hence, the impugned order, dated 19/12/2012, is kept in abeyance and the 2nd

respondent is directed to pass fresh orders confining to the grounds mentioned in the order dated 23/01/2012 and the directions issued by the appellate authority in its order dated 09/10/2012. This exercise shall be completed within three weeks.

Post after three weeks”.

The SRC in its 239th meeting held on 26-27th February, 2012 considered the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh order dt. 04/01/2013 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 of NCTE Act, for the following:

1. Land documents submitted are in Telugu version, certified copy of registered Notarised English Version of land document is not submitted.

2. Approved blue print of the building plan issued by competent civil authority is not submitted. In the approved building plan copy submitted, total earmarked built up area for the proposed course and site area, is not mentioned.


93


3. Original building completion certificate in a prescribed format from competent Govt. engineer is not submitted.

4. Notarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted. Proceedings of Revenue Divisional Officer not submitted for conversion of land from agricultural to non-agricultural/educational purposes.

5. Up-to-date encumbrance certificate issued by sub-registrar is not submitted.

6. Original FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank in favour of Society/college/institution name is not given.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 14.03.2013. The institution has submitted its written representation on 28.03.2013.

The SRC in its 242nd meeting held on 14th-16th April 2013, considered the reply of the institution dt.28-03-2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between (27-31st May 2013) rescheduled on 3rd to 6th July 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 20.06.2013.




LOI reply from the institution received on 11/10/2013.


52. SRCAPP21B.Ed

Riyan College of Education,

Nalgodna

Riyan College of Education, Sy.No.112, Venkatadripalem Village, Miryalguda Post Office, Taluk & City, Nalgonda District - 508207, Andhra Pradesh

Md Riyan Ahamed Educational Society, Plot No.H.No.9-33,


94


DistrictAP Seetharampuram Street, Miryalguda Village & Post Office, Miryalguda

Taluk & City, Nalgonda District - 508207, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Riyan College of Education, Sy.No.112, Venkatadripalem Village, Miryalguda Post Office, Taluk & City, Nalgonda District - 508207, Andhra Pradesh for B.Ed Course of One year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 04.01.2013.


The SRC in its 244th meeting held on 9th-11th May 2013, considered the reply of the institution to the deficiency letter dated 23.04.2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed on 19th - 23rd August, 2013 the same was intimated to the institution on 10.08.2013.

As per the direction of SRC, the inspection of the institution was conducted on 19.08.2013 and the VT Report received in the office of SRC on 21.08.2013.

On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, VT report, VCD, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Southern Regional Committee in its 252nd Meeting held on 13th - 14th

September, 2013 has decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to B.Ed course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100 (One hundred) (one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE / State Government / Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

Accordingly, LOI was issued to the institution on 23.09.2013. The institution has submitted its written representation on 14.10.2013.

On Careful perusal of the original file of the institution and staff profiles submitted by the institution in response to the letter of Intent, the Regional Committee decided that Formal Recognition be granted to B.Ed., course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100 (one hundred only) students, from the academic session 2014-2015.

53. SRCAPP734D.Ed

Jeremiah College of Education,

East Godavari

Jeremiah College of Education, Plot No. 673, Burugupadi Village & Post, Korukonda Taluk, East Godavari District-530016, Andhra Pradesh.

Banaiah Christian Educational Society, 2nd Floor, Satya Surya Complex, Opp Complex RTC Dwarakanagar, vishakapatnam District-530016, Andhra Pradesh has applied for grant of recognition to Jeremiah College of


95


DistrictAP

Education, Plot No. 673, Burugupadi Village & Post, Korukonda Taluk, East Godavari District-530016, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed course on 26.09.2011 for two years duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act. 1993 and received in the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 28/09/2011. NCTE-Hqrs had directed to process the applications in accordance with NCTE Regulations 2009, it amendment Notified on 26th November 2010 which reads as follows:-2 (B) for Sub Regulation (1-A) the following shall be submitted namely. 1 (1-A) (I) the application shall be summarily rejected under one or more of the following circumstances:

1. The processing fee, as provided under Rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application.

2. Hard copy in triplicate of the online application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application.

3. Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society. Institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of online application.

The SRC considered the matter in its 216th meeting held on 11th-12th January, 2012 and careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related documents, NCTE Act 1993. Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table. The Regional committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds.

1. Proof of dispatch of hard copy of application not submitted within 7 days.

Accordingly, a rejection order to Jeremiah College of Education, East Godavari District, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed course was issued vide F.No. SRCAPP734/(D.El.Ed) AP/2012-13/39677 dated 29/03/2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No. 89-185/2012 Appeal/5th Meeting – 2012 dated 18/09/2012 stated that “the council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the matter to the SRC for further processing of the application on merit as per regulations. The council hereby remands back the case of Jeremiah College of Education, East Godavari, Andhra Pradesh to SRC, NCTE for necessary action as indicated above”.

The SRC in its 229th meeting held on 30th-31st July, 2012 considered Appellate authority order dt. 18/09/2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

As per the information of the website the institution has submitted written representation on 21/08/2012

The SRC in its 231st Meeting held on 22nd – 23rd August 2012, considered the reply of the institution dt. 21/08/2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.


96



The SRC in its 233rd meeting held on 26th – 28th September 2012 considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

The institution has to submit a fresh VCD showing the infrastructural and instructional facilities provided in the building meant for the proposed course.

Accordingly, Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 02.11.2012. The institution has submitted the reply on 19.11.2012.

On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.El.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit) for the academic year 2013-14 subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

Jeremiah College of Education, Plot No. 673, Burugupadi Village & Post, Korukonda Taluk, East Godavari District-530016, Andhra Pradesh.

Name of the Society:- Banaiah Christian Educational Society, 2nd Floor, Satya Surya Complex, Opp Complex RTC Dwarakanagar, Vishakapatnam District-530016, Andhra Pradesh

Name of the Institution:- Jeremiah College of Education, Plot No. 673, Burugupadi Village & Post, Korukonda Taluk, East Godavari District-530016, Andhra Pradesh

Sl No.

Event Date Reference page No.

Online submission of application.

26.09.2011 29

Submission of Hard copy 28.09.2011 31 State Govt. Letter for

recommendation was sent.09.11.2011 32

A letter was issued to the intuition with request to submit proof of dispatch of application.

09.11.2011 33

The matter was placed before SRC and the Committee decided to reject the application summarily.

216th Meeting of SRC held on 11th – 12th January 2012

35

Accordingly, Rejection order with original FDR’s were issued to the institution.

29.03.2012 41


97


Aggrieved by the order of SRC, the institution preferred an appeal a letter was received form NCTE H'qrs with directions to send original application along with comments.

03.05.2012 52

Accordingly, original application with comments was sent to NCTE H'qrs.

14.05.2012 54

NCTE Appellate authority order was received.

26.06.2012 55

Original application from NCTE H'qrs was received

29.06.2012 56

NCTE Appellate authority order was placed before SRC and the Committee decided to issue Show Cause Notice.

229th Meeting of SRC held on 30th – 31st July 2012

63

Before the issue of Show Cause Notice, as per the information of the website the institution has submitted written representation.

21.08.2012 and 22.08.2013

69 and 74

The Committee considered the reply for Show Cause Notice and decided to Cause Inspection.

231st Meeting held on 22nd – 23rd August 2012

76

VT Intimation letter was issued to the institution

31.08.2012 79

Inspection of the institution was conducted

08.09.2012 105

Inspection report was received in the office of SRC

14.09.2012 105

Committee considered the Inspection report and decided to issued Show Cause Notice.

233rd Meeting of SRC held on 26th – 28th September 2012

111

Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued

02.11.2012 113

Reply for the Show Cause Notice was received

19.11.2012 and 19.11.20.12

114 and 115

The Committee considered the matter and decided to issue letter of intent.

236th Meeting held on 16th – 17th December, 2012

120

Accordingly, Letter of Intent was issued to the institution.

01.01.2013 124

The institution had forwarded a copy of High Court order.

21.02.2013 127

A Court notice was received. 26.02.2013 135 A letter with gist of the case

was forwarded to the Shri. K. Ramanath Reddy (Standing Council).

04.03.2013 143

The Hon’ble High Court in W.PMP No. 5297 of 2013 in W.P. No. 4240 of 2013


98


dated 13.2.2013 filed by Benaiah Christian Educational Society, Visakhapatnam District, Andhra Pradesh. The Hon’ble Court has stated as follows: “The petitioner submitted an application before the 1st respondent herein with a request to grant recognition to start two years D.El.Ed course with an intake of 50 students from the current academic year. As required under the Regulations, the applications, the application was filed through online on 26.9.2011 and a hard copy thereof was dispatched on 30.9.2011. It is also stated that a copy was directly handed over to the 1st respondent on 28.9.2011. However, taking the view that the petitioner failed to dispatch the hard copy within one week from the date of submission of the application through online, the 1st respondent rejected the application, through proceedings dated 29.3.2012. In the appeal preferred by the petitioner, the 4 th

respondent found fault with the order passed by the 1st respondent and directed that the matter be considered on merits. Even thereafter, the 1st

respondent did not take immediate steps. It was only through proceedings, dated 1.1.2013, that the petitioner was granted recognition for the academic year 2013-14.

The petitioner contends that the third phase of the counseling for admission into D.El.Ed course is scheduled to take place between 24.2.2013 and 27.2.2013. Since there is ample time, the infrastructure arranged by the petitioner and approved by the 1st respondent cannot be permitted to go waste.

Hence, there shall be interim direction to the effect that the recognition granted by the 1st respondent for the petitioner-institution be treated as holding good for the current academic year and the other respondents shall take steps accordingly”.(Pg. no.145)

The Committee has noted that matter.

Sl. No. Particulars

Reply to LOI

1. Name of the Institution Jeremiah College of Education, Khasara No.673, Street No.1, Burugupudi Village and Post, Korukonda Mandal, Rajahmundry City, East Godavari District-533292, Andhra Pradesh

2. Date of issue of LOI 01.01.2013

3. Date of Receipt of LOI Reply

23.09.2013

4. Date of Staff List approved by SCERT

31.08.2013

5. Service Certificate of Principal /Lecturers

Submitted

Worked as lecturer in Diploma Education from 21.05.2008 to 31.07.2013 in Benaiah D.Ed College, Burugupudi, Rajamundry (5+ years


99


experience)

6. Original FDRs for Rs. 5 lacs and Rs. 3 lacs in Joint A/C for 5 years submitted

Submitted

7. Web Site Address www.jeremiahcoe.in

Not functioning.

In its reply stated that kindly condone the delay due to (1) Turmoil in Andhra Pradesh for bifurcation of state and for a United State. (2) The letter of intent was issued for 2013-14. (3)The Andhra Pradesh Government admission notification for 2013-14 was not issued till date and hence the grant of formal recognition now for 2013-14 is justified. (4). The Jeremiah D.Ed College has incurred huge amounts for the infrastructure and academic facilities. (5). The SCERT (Government of Andhra Pradesh), delayed the process of staff approval due to agitations in Andhra Pradesh in spite of our payments to them on time.

LOI Issued to the institution on 01/01/2013


The Committee considered the LOI reply from the institution vide letter dated 23/09/2013 and condoned the delay of submission of LOI reply as the reasons given by the institution is genuine.


54. SRCAPP953D.Ed

Srinivasa College of

Elementary Education,

Chittoor District

AP

Srinivasa College of Elementary Education, Khasara No. 60-3, Maratigate Street, Puttur Village & Post, Puttur Taluk, Chittoor District-517583, Andhra Pradesh.

Maharishi Educational Society, Khasara No. 60-3, Maratigate Street, Puttur Village & Post, Puttur Taluk, Chittoor District-517583, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Srinivasa College of Elementary Education, Khasara No. 60-3, Maratigate Street, Puttur Village & Post, Puttur Taluk, Chittoor District-517583, Andhra Pradesh, for D.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 15(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 01.10.2011. The institution has submitted hard copy of the application on 04.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 03.11.2011. A reminder letter to the State Government was sent on 19.12.2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29.12.2011. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 27.02.2012.


100

http://www.jeremiahcoe.in/


The Southern Regional Committee in its 220th Meeting held on 30th and 31st March 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 27.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 27.04.2012.The institution has submitted written representation on 21.05.2012

The institution has submitted reply for Show Cause Notice after the expiry of stipulated time of 21 days period as per clause 14(1) of NCTE Regulations

The Southern Regional Committee in its 223rd meeting held on 29th – 31st May 2012, considered the reply of the institution, which is received on 21/05/2012, i.e., after 24 (Twenty Four) days from the date of issue of show cause notice dt. 27/04/2012 and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.Ed course


Against SRC’s rejection order, the institution filed a writ petition in the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh, W. P. No. 22257 and the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in its order dated 23/07/2012 has stated that ‘the Southern Regional Committee of NCTE, Bangalore is directed to re – consider the petitioner’s application, pass a detailed order and communicate the same to the petitioner within a period of one month from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.’

The SRC in its 231st meeting held on 22nd-23rd August 2012, considered the Court order dt. 23.07.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

As per encumbrance certificate dt. 23/02/2012 submitted, the land is on lease basis, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

8 (7) (i) of NCTE Regulations States:

No institution shall be granted recognition under these Regulations unless the institution or society sponsoring the institution is in possession of required land on the date of application. The land free from all encumbrances could be either on ownership basis or on lease from Government or Government institutions for a period of not less than 30 years. In cases where under relevant State or Union Territory laws the maximum permissible lease period is less than 30 years, the State Government or Union Territory Administration law shall prevail. However, no building shall be taken on lease for running any teacher training course.

1. In the building plan submitted, total earmarked land area , Sy.No. is not mentioned.

2. As per building completion certificate, the college building is roofed with Asbestos sheets. Which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.


101


8 (10) of NCTE Regulations 2009 states:

At the time of inspection, the building of the institution shall be complete in the form of a permanent structure on the land possessed by the institution in terms of sub-regulation (7) of Regulation 8, equipped with all necessary amenities and fulfilling all such requirements as prescribed in the norms and standards. The applicant institution shall produce the original completion certificate issued by the competent Government Authority or local body authority, approved building plan in proof of the completion of building and built up area and other documents to the visiting team for verification. No temporary structure or asbestos roofing shall be allowed in the institution, even if it is in addition to the prescribed built up area.

Built up area is not matching with building plan and building completion certificate.

The institution has submitted its written representation on 25.09.2012. (With reference to online).

The SRC in its 234th Meeting held on 17th-18th October, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt.25-09-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 15 th-20th

November, 2012 the same was intimated to the institution on 02/11/2012. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 19/11/2012.

The SRC in its 236th meeting held on 16th – 18th December 2012 has considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

As per building plan, there are two blocks, one for B.Ed and another for D.Ed having built up area of 1727 & 1440 sq.mtrs respectively. However, as per VT report, 25017 sq.ft built up area is available. Regarding B.Ed, VT members have not mentioned anything in VTR, however, in questionnaire they told regarding B.Ed, it is not clear how much area is earmarked for B.Ed and D.Ed separately.

As per V.T report, available seating capacity in the library is only 65 for both B.Ed and D.Ed courses, which is less than the requirement as per NCTE norms.

As per VT report, No. of books available in the library is less than the requirement as per NCTE norms.

Accordingly, show cause notice was issued to the institution on 18.01.2013. The institution had replied to the show cause notice on 30.01.2013.

On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the


102


table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

Accordingly, a LOI was issued on 10.04.2013.The institution submitted its written representation on 21.06.2013

The SRC in its 249th Meeting held on 24th-26th July, 2013 considered the matter and it was decided to serve Notice under Section 14 of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a notice was issued to the institution on 10.06.2013. The institution has submitted its written representation on 04.10.2013


55. SRCAPP99D.Ed

The District Muslim

Education Society D.Ed

College, Belgaum District

KA

The District Muslim Education Society D.Ed College, No.243/1, Gajbarwadi, Kukkeri Post, Hukkeri, Belgaum District-591309, Karnataka

The application submitted by the District Muslim Education Society D.Ed College, No.243/1, Gajbarwadi, Kukkeri Post, Hukkeri, Belgaum District-591309, Karnataka for starting D.Ed. course which was processed and a deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 22.12.2009. The institution had replied to the deficiency letter on 18.02.2010. The SRC in its 190th

meeting held on March 29th – 30th 2010 considered the reply to the deficiency letter and decided to reject the application. Accordingly, a refusal order was issued to the institution on 28.04.2010

Further, the institution preferred an appeal and the appellate authority vide order dated 15.09.2010 had reversed the rejection order of SRC. The SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13-14 October 2010 considered the appellate authority order and decided to process the application on merits. Accordingly, again, the application was processed and a Deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 11.01.2011. The institution submitted its reply on 11.02.2011.

The SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22nd –23rd February 2011 considered the reply of the institution and decided to cause inspection under Section 14 of NCTE Act. The inspection of the institution was carried out on 31.03.2011. The inspection report was received on 1.4.2011 along with VCD.

The SRC in its 204th meeting held on 27th –28th April, 2011 considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to issue Show cause Notice. Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to the institution on 31.05.2011. The institution submitted its written representation on 07.06.2011 along with VCD.

The SRC in its 206th meeting of SRC held on 9th and 10th June, 2011


103


considered the VCD, the VT report & reply of the management and decided to refuse the recognition to the institution for the following:-As seen from VCD, the building, where the proposed course is to be conducted is totally unsuitable for any Education programmes and building appears to be warehouse/godown. The entire building shown in VCD has sheet doors and narrow corridors. The entire building appears to be used for other than educational purpose.

Accordingly, refusal order was issued to the institution vide Order No.F.No.SRCAPP99/D.Ed./KA/2011-12/29401 dated 07/07/2011. Aggrieved by the order of SRC, the institution again preferred an appeal on 2.9.2011.

After perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit, VT report and after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the Council reached the conclusion that there was adequate ground to accept the appeal and reverse the SRC’s order dated 07-07-2011 vide Appellate authority order No. F.No.89-354/2011 Appeal/7th Meeting-2011 A45191 dated 9.12.2011 with a direction to the SRC for issuing a Show Cause Notice on the ground as stated in the refusal order and for taking further decision thereafter.

The SRC in its 216th meeting held on 11th –12th January, 2012 considered the appellate authority orders, VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and Notice was issued to the institution on 07.03.2012. The Institution submitted reply vide letter dated 23.03.2012.

The SRC in its 222nd meeting held on 09th –10th May 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dated 23.03.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Final Show cause Notice.

The institution submitted its reply vide letter dated 05.07.2012, i.e., after the expiry of more than 30 days

The SRC in its 228th meeting held on 24th – 25th July 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dated 05.07.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 16.08.2012. The institution submitted its written representation on 10.09.2012.

The Committee considered the reply of the institution vide letter dated 06.09.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Final Show Cause Notice under section 14 (1) NCTE Act. Accordingly,

A Show Cause Notice was issued on 23.11.2012. The institution has submitted a written representation on 11.12.2012

The Committee considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 11.12.2012 and other relevant documents, along with the original file of the institution and decided to restore recognition (SRCAPP99-D.Ed) and continue recognition accorded to the institution.

The Committee reviewed the decision of “restore recognition ”taken in 240th

meeting held on 09th -11th March, 2013 in respect of the said college, and decided to issue LOI in stead of Restore Recognition,


104


On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

Accordingly, a Letter Of Intent was issued to the institution vide letter No.F.NO.SRCAPP99/D.Ed/KA/2013-14/51043 dated 23/04/2013. The institution has not submitted reply to the LOI after the lapse of 2 months also.

The Southern Regional Committee has in its 249th meeting held on 24th- 26th

July 2013 considered the matter and decided to await for the reply of the institution to the LOI issued.

The institution has not submitted any reply till date.

The institution was issued Letter of Intent vide letter dated 23/04/2013. As per NCTE regulations 2009, 60 days time period was given at the time of issue of LOI to the institution to reply and submit the records connected with for consideration for formal recognition. The Committee in its 249th

meeting held on 24-26th July 2013 decided to await the reply of the institution to LOI. But, even after lapse of time period of more than 185 days, the institution has not replied till date.

The institution has not submitted reply for LOI even after the expiry of stipulated time of 60 days from the date of issue of the notice.

Keeping in view, Supreme Court vide their order in Civil Appeal No. 1125-1128/2011 in SLP No. 17165-68/2009 filed by NCTE Vs ors, which reads as under:

“An institution is not entitled to recognition unless it fulfils the conditions specified in various clauses of the Regulations. The Council is directed to ensure that in future no institution is granted recognition unless it fulfils the conditions laid down in the Act and the Regulations and the time schedule fixed for processing the application by the Regional Committee and communication of the decision on the issue of recognition it strictly adhered to”.

The committee considered the non-reply of the institution to the issue of LOI dt. 23/04/2013 and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.Ed course.

Show Cause Notice Reply

56. APS02500D.Ed

Sri. K.V. Teacher Training Institute, K.T.Road, Chikballapur-562101, Karnataka, was granted recognition for Elementary D.Ed-Al course of two and


105


Sri K.V. Teachr Training Institute,

Chikballapur District

KA

half years duration from the academic session 204-2005 on 28-12/2004 with an annual intake of 80 which includes the existing intake of 60 and an additional intake of 20.

On 21/01/2013, complaint letter is received on 21/01/2013 from Sri.B.R.Ramesh, advocate, # 895, 3rd ‘A’ Main,‘D’ Block , II Stage , Rajajinagar, Bangalore – 560 010 regarding the substandard and non-viable institutions of teachers training in Chickballapur district.

He has stated that “ I am enclosing herewith a report of DSERT pertaining to Chickballapur district. This inspection report is based on visiting teams report of DIETS. They have inspected. These institutions and submitted information to the DSERT. The DSERT has compiled the data and have identified the deficiencies of the institutions. You are competent to issue recognition to all institutions imparting teacher education. The students who study in these substandard institutions will be the major losers and they cannot meet the needs of students at primary level. These institutions produce substandard teachers who in turn cannot come up to the expectations of the department. Hence, it becomes obligatory on you part to initiate action after verification from your end. I do hope that you would initiate at least some action and verify the infrastructure facilities of these institutions and see that the teacher education in this district is rectified and put on right lines, so that the prospective teachers are benefited. I do hope that you will look into this matter personally and do the needful. A line in reply is appreciated. More information with regard to other substandard institutions will be sent to you in due course about other districts.”

He has enclosed a copy of the evaluation report of 9 D.Ed colleges during the year 2009-2010 of DSERT along with complaint letter.

The SRC in its 241st meeting held during 29th to 31st March & 1st April 2013 considered the matter of complaint letter dt. 21/01/2013 and advised Southern Regional Office to examine the report from DSERT and put up

The SRC in its 248th Meeting held during 13th – 15th July 2013 considered the details is of ten reports of DSERT and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following deficiencies.

1. As per DSERT report, the total earmarked built up area is only 6086 sq.ft, (563.20 sq.mts), which is less than the requirement as per NCTE norms. The institution is running basic course D.Ed and D.Ed-Al course in the same building, total built up area required for the two course as per NCTE norms is 2000 sq.mts.

2. As per VT report, the infrastructure and instructional facilities provided to existing courses are inadequate.

3. The institution has not provided provision to accommodate 100 intakes in seminar hall. The existing structure cannot be altered as the building is on lease deed.

Accordingly, a Showcase Notice was issued to the institution on 02/09/2013.The institution has submitted its reply on 23.09.2013

The Committee considered the written reply of the institution vide letter


106


dated 23/09/2013 to the show cause notice issued based on DSERT report on the above matter and also the relevant documents of the institution and decided to withdraw recognition for the following reasons:-

As per DSERT report, the total earmarked built up area is only 6086 sq.ft (563.20 sq.mtrs), which is less than the requirement as per NCTE norms. The institution is running basic course D.Ed and B.Ed-Al course in the same building, total built up area required for the two courses as per NCTE norms is 2000 sq.mtrs.

As per VT report, the infrastructure and instructional facilities provided to existing courses are inadequate.

The institution has not provided provision to accommodate 100 intakes in seminar hall. The existing structure cannot be altered as the building is on lease deed.

In reply to the above deficiency points, the Chairman of the institution has accepted the true facts of running the institution by not following NCTE norms. The D.Ed and D.Ed-Al courses are accommodated only with 563.20 sq.mtrs of building (instead of 2000 sq.mtrs as per NCTE norms) and now only they have taken the decision of constructing a new building as per NCTE norms. This shows that the institution has not followed any NCTE norms.

Based on the above points the committee decides to withdraw the recognition of the D.Ed course run by Sri K.V. Teacher Training Institute, K.T.Road, Chikballapur-562101, Karnataka from the academic year 2013.14, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in D.Ed, course, if any, to complete their course.

But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.

The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed accordingly.

Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore, if any, after ensuring payments to all dues of faculty and staff.

57. SRCAPP1944

B.EdVijayanagara

Sri Krishnadevar

aya University,

Bellary District

KA

Vijayanagara Sri Krishnadevaraya University, Khasara No.597, Plot No.597 B1,B2,C, Vinayakanagar Village,Cantonment Post, Bellary Taluk & Town, Bellary District,Pin Code-583104, Karnataka.

Vijayanagara Sri Krishnadevaraya University, Vinayakanagar,Bellary Village, Cantonment Post, Bellary Taluk, Bellary District, Pin Code-583104, Karnataka State, had applied for grant of recognition to Vijayanagara Sri Krishnadevaraya University, Khasara No.597, Plot No.597 B1,B2,C, Vinayakanagar Village,Cantonment Post, Bellary Taluk & Town, Bellary District,Pin Code-583104, Karnataka. for M.Ed Course of One year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 28.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 29.12.2013.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State


107


Government for recommendation on 28.03.2013 and a reminder was sent on 13.05.2013 . A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 10.04.2013.

The University replied to the deficiency letter on 13.06.2013, speed post dated 10/06/2013

The Southern Regional Committee in its 250th Meeting held on 11th – 13th

August 2013 has considered the reply of the University to the deficiency letter dt. 13.06.2013 and decided to issue Show Cause Notice to the institution.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 13.09.2013.The University has submitted a written representation in reply to the show cause notice on 30.09.2013

Inspection fee of Rs. 50000/- to be collected from the University before causing inspection.

The Committee considered the reply of the institution dt.30-09-2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Note: VT to be asked to obtain a fresh building completion certificate from the institution..

58. APS02239D.Ed

St.Mother Theresa Teacher Training Institute, Koppal District

KA

St. Mother Theresa Teacher Training Institute, Lakshmivenkataeshwara Nilaya, Shastri Colony,Bhagyanagara,Koppal-583238,KarnatakaThirulgannada Shaikshanika and Samaja Kalyana Trust,Koppal,Karnataka had submitted an application to the Southern Regional Committee of NCTE for grant of recognition to St. Mother Theresa Teacher Training Institute, Lakshmivenkateshwara Nilaya,Shastri Colony,Bhagyanagara,Koppal-583238,Karnataka for Elementary D.Ed Course of two and half years duration from the academic session 2004-05 with an annual intake of 50 students.

Recognition was granted to St. Mother Theresa Teacher Training Institute, Lakshmivenkateshwara Nilaya, Shastri Colony,Bhagyanagara,Koppal-583238,Karnataka for Elementary D.Ed course of two and half years from the academic session 2004-05 with an annual intake of 50 students vide letter F/SRO/NCTE/D.Ed/2004-05/9595 dated 24/12/2004 with a condition to shift to its own premises/building within three years from the date of recognition (in case the course is started in rented premises)

A letter dated 19/01/2005 was received from Secretary, St. Mother Teresa Teacher Training Center(D.Ed) stating that the address of the institution is wrongly mentioned in the recognition order and it has to be corrected with the right address mentioned in the letter.

Accordingly, a corrigendum was issued to the institution vide F.SRO/NCTE/2004-05/2646 dated 01/09/05 stating that

Instead of words :

Thirulgannada Shaikshanika and Samaja Kalyana Trust,Koppal,Karnataka had submitted an application to the Southern Regional Committee of NCTE for grant of recognition to St.Mother Theresa Teacher Training Institute, Lakshmivenkataeshwara Nilaya,Shastri Colony,Bhagyanagara,Koppal-


108


583238,Karnataka for Elementary D.Ed Course of two and half years duration from the academic session 2004-05 with an annual intake of 50 students.

May be read as :

Thirulgannada Shaikshanika and Samaja Kalyana Trust,Koppal,Karnataka had submitted an application to the Southern Regional Committee of NCTE for grant of recognition to St.Mother Theresa Teacher Education Centre ,Julai Nagar,Raichur Road, Gangavathi-583227,Karnataka for Elementary D.Ed Course of two and half years duration from the academic session 2004-05 with an annual intake of 50 students.

Further, the Principal, St.Mother Theresa Teacher Training Institute,Gangavathi submitted a proposal of shifting premises enclosing a D.D. of Rs.40,000/- in his letter dated 24/09/2007.

The institution was asked to submit the requisite documents pertaining to the new premises with respect to shifting vide this office letter F.SRO/NCTE/2008-09/3907 dated 09/06/2009.

Since there was no response from the institution a reminder letter F.SRO/NCTE/2009-10/7809 was sent to the institution for submission of documents on 23/02/2010.

The institution had submitted a written representation on 17/02/2011 stating that the institution has been shifted to new area with address St.Mother Teresa D.Ed College, Sainagar, Anegondi road, Sangapur post, Gangavathi District,Koppal-583227 .

A letter dated 04/08/2012 was received from the Director, D.S.E.R.T ,Bangalore ,stating that

“ With reference to the Govt letter ED.67.CPI2012 dated 05/04/2012 seeking clarification regarding transfer of St. Mother Teresa Teacher Education Centre , Gangavathi to Shri Lakshmi Narayana Educational Society, kindly provide details of the rules and procedure to be followed for the transfer. The institution has obtained an NOC from the Government.”

On, 29/08/2012, the President of Sri Lakshimnarayana Educational Trust,Plot No.12,Sarojanagar,3 rd Cross, Gangavathi ,Koppal District, Karnataka had submitted a request to transfer the institution, St. Mother Theresa Teacher Education Centre,Gangavathi(APSO 2239-D.Ed) course to their Trust, as some of the members of “Tirulgannada Education Trust have submitted resignation since they were not able to serve as members.”

From the above notings, it is noted that the institution has shifted without obtaining permission from NCTE.

As per NCTE regulations 2009, there is no provision for transfer of the Management.

From the letter dated 29/08/2012, it is observed that the request to transfer the management is made from a third party. It is not from the trust or from the institution.

The SRC in its 239th meeting held during 26-27 February, 2013 considered the institution letter dt. 29/08/2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:- A letter dt. 04/08/2012 received from the Director D.S.E.R.T, Bangalore


109


seeking clarification regarding transfer of St. Mother Teresa Teacher Education Centre, Gangavathi to Shri Lakshmi Narayana Educational Society, to provide details of the rules and procedure to be followed for the transfer.

On 29/08/2012, the president of Sri Lakshminarayana Educational Trust, Plot No. 12, Sarojanagar, 3rd Cross, Gangavathi, Koppal District, Karnataka, requested for transfer of the institution i.e, ‘St. Mother Theresa Teacher Education Centre, Gangavathi (APS02239-D.Ed) course to their trust, on the ground, as some of the members of “Tirulgannada Education Trust have submitted resignation since they were not able to serve as members”.

From the above, 1) it is clear that the institution has shifted without obtaining permission from NCTE, by shifted new premises, the institution has violated the NCTE Regulations/norms.2) As per NCTE regulations 2009, there is no provision for transfer of the management/trust.

From the letter 29/08/2012, the request for transfer of management/trust has come from third party.

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the withdrawal of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

As per the decision of SRC, a Showcause Notice was issued to the institution on 3.6.2013. The institution has submitted its written representation on 20.6.2013

The Committee considered the written reply of the institution vide letter dated 20/06/2013 to the show cause notice issued based on DSERT report on the above matter and also the relevant documents of the institution and decided to withdraw recognition for the following reasons:-

The institution was granted recognition vide order dt. 24/12/2004. The principal of the college submitted a proposal of shifting premises enclosing a D.D. of Rs. 40000/- vide letter dt. 24/09/2007.

The institution was asked to submit the requisite documents vide letter dt. 9/06/2009 pertaining to the New Premises where the shifting of the institution was sought. The institution has not responded to SRO letter dt. 09/06/2009 for providing of documents pertaining to new premises.

Again a reminder letter dt. 23/02/2010 was sent to the institution to send all the relevant documents concerned for shifting of the institution to the new premises.

The institution without sending the documents sought from SRO, has shifted to the new premises informed to this office vide letter dt.


110


17/02/2011, to the new address “St. Mother Teresa D.Ed College, Sainagar, Aanegondi Road, Sangapur Post, Gangavathi District, Koppal-583227, Karnataka”. This is a clear indication of violation of NCTE regulations from the management in not taking prior permission and causing inspection from SRC NCTE for shifting at the new premise.

As per the NCTE regulation 8 (11) of 2009:“ In case of change of premises, prior approval of the Regional Committee concerned shall be necessary, which could be accorded after due inspection of the institution at the new site. Application for change of premises, in triplicate, in the specified format along with other relevant documents shall be submitted by the Institution to the Regional Office for prior approval of change of premises. The change can be permitted to a site which, if applied initially, could have qualified for establishment of anInstitution as per specified norms of National Council for Teacher Education. The change shall be displayed on website thereafter. The application for change of premises shall be accompanied by a demand draft of Rs. 40,000 (or as revised from time to time) of a Nationalised Bank drawn in favour of the Member Secretary, National Council for Teacher Education and payable at the city where the Regional Committee is located. The fee may also be paid online at the bank designated by National Council for Teacher Education”.

A letter dt. 04/08/2012 received from the Director DSERT Bangalore, referring to State Govt. letter dt. 05/04/2012 seeking clarification regarding transfer of St. Mother Teresa Teacher Education Centre, Gangavathi (Thirulgannada Shaikshnnika and Samaja Kalyana Trust, Koppal Karnataka) To “Shri Lakshmi Narayana Educational Society, Gangavathi Koppal district, Karnataka”, seeking rules and procedure to be followed for the transfer of Society.

This office received a letter dt. 29/08/2012, from the 3rd party trust by name “Shri Lakshmi Narayana Educational Society, Plot NO. 12, Sarojanagar, 3rd Cross, Gangavathi Koppal district, Karnataka” requesting for transfer of the above institution trust to them giving the reasons that some of the members of the original trust who have resigned, since they were not able to serve as members of the trust.

From the above, it is noted that the request of transfer of the trust has come from 3rd party and there is no provision in NCTE regulations 2009, for transfer of the management/trust.

The management has shifted to new premises without permission from NCTE, Bangalore. The institution has violated the NCTE Regulations.

Based on the above points the committee decides to withdraw the recognition of the D.Ed course run by St. Mother Theresa teacher Training Institute, Lakshmivenkateshwara Nilaya, Shastri Colony, Bhagyanagara, Koppal-583238, Karnataka, from the academic year 2013-14, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in D.Ed, course, if any, to complete their course.

But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making any


111


further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order.



59. SRCAPP2118

B.P.EdSri YVS and

Sri BRM College of Physical

Education, East

Godavari District

AP

Sri YVS and Sri BRM College of Physical Education, Sy.No.230, Plot No.4-163/3, Street No.4/2, Mukteswaram Village and Post Office, Inavilli Taluk, East Godavari District-533211, Andhra Pradesh.

Sri YVS and Sri BRM Memorial Educational Society, Plot No. 4-163/3, Jambavulapeta Road, Mukteswaram Village and Post Office, Inavilli Taluk, East Godavari District– 533211, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Sri YVS and Sri BRM College of Physical Education, Sy.No.230, Plot No.4-163/3, Street No.4/2, Mukteswaram Village and Post Office, Inavilli Taluk, East Godavari District-533211, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed Course of one year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 04.01.2013.


The SRC in its 246th meeting held on 02nd – 04th June, 2013 considered the reply of the institution to the deficiency letter dt.21-05-2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed on 16 th – 19th July, 2013, The same was intimated to the institution on 10.07.2013.

As per the direction of SRC, the inspection of the institution was conducted on 23.07.2013 and the VT report received in the office of SRC on 26.07.2013.

The SRC in its 251st Meeting held on 25th -27th August, 2013 considered the VT report, VCD of the institution and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14(1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 01.10.2013. the institution has submitted its written representation on 30.09.2013

On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, VT report, VCD, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to B.P.Ed course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100(one hundred only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given


112


effect before the commencement of the academic session.

Other Items

60. APS08759B.Ed

S.A.S. College of Education,

Trichy DistrictTN

S.A.S. College of Education, Punganur, Ramjee Nagar Post, Trichy-620009, TamilnaduS.A.S. College of Education, Punganur, Ramjee Nagar Post, Trichy-620009, Tamilnadu had submitted an application for B.Ed Course on 28.05.2007. The institution was granted recognition on 11.01.2008 with an annual intake of 100 students.

The institution vide letter dated 29.07.2013 alongwith DD bearing no. 266016 dtd. 23.07.2013of Rs. 50,000/- for shifting of premises has stated that

“ As per your order dated 11.01.2008, we are running a B.Ed College in the style of S.A.S. College of Education under the control of S.A.S. Trust from the academic year 2008-2009 in lease land and buildings with extent of 0.92 cents in survey no. 223/10B1C1 leased in the name of trust. Now, the College has additionally acquired land by leased 2.20 acres with buildings in the name of college by Survey no. 224 & 51 within the same village same ward and same street.

Now the Tamilnadu Teacher Education University has instructed that the land & buildings should be in the college name.

So we decide to shift the college to new building constructed in the additionally acquired lease land with near by survey nos. 51/12B1, 10, 11, 13B, 224/8B4B, 8B4A in the name of college from this academic year (2013-2014)”.

The Committee considered the letter from the institution dt.29-07-2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause shifting inspection at the new premises to ascertain infrastructural and instructional facilities under NCTE Act.Further, the VT to be advised to obtain the new land documents and look into the title position, if it is a new land.

61. APS07517B.Ed

Pallavan College of Education,

Vellore District

TN

Pallavan College of Education, No. 1, Bharathiyar Salai, Vellore, Pin-632001, Tamilnadu.

Pallavan College of Education, No. 1, Bharathiyar Salai, Vellore, Pin-632001, Tamilnadu had submitted an application for B.Ed Course on 26.10.2006. The institution was granted recognition on 03.02.2007 with an annual intake of 100 students, with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

The institution vide its letter dated 03.08.2012 has submitted DD bearing no. 951530 dtd. 31.07.2012 for Rs. 50,000/- towards shifting of premises. The SRC in its 230th held on 16th-17th August 2012, considered the request of the institution vide letter dt.08-08-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the


113


requirements as per the norms. Accordingly, inspection was carried out on 18.09.2012.

The SRC in its 235th meeting held on 21st-22nd November, 2012 considered the VT report of the institution and other related documents along with the original file of the institution for shifting to new/permanent premises and decided to permit shifting to new premises is permitted, subject to the condition that submission of approved staff list within 2 months as per NCTE norms. Accordingly, shifting order was issued to the institution on 15.02.2013.

Till date the institution has not submitted reply to the deficiency letter even after stipulated period of 60 days.

The Committee considered the matter and also the relevant documents of the institution and decided to withdraw recognition for the following reasons:-

After inspection of the institution on 18-09-2012 for shifting, the committee in its 235th meeting held on 21-22nd Nov, 2012, permission was accorded to the institution for shifting to the new premises, subject to the condition that submission of approved staff list within 2 months as per NCTE norms, accordingly, shifting order was issued to the institution on 15.02.2013.

Even though, the institution was given sufficient time to submit the approved staff list within 2 months from the date of permission for shifting was given, the institution failed to submit the approved staff list as per NCTE norms till date. The institution has not submitted its reply even after a lapse of stipulated 2 months and after lapse of time period of more than 252 days (more than 8 months).

Based on the above point the committee decides to withdraw the recognition of the B.Ed course run by the Pallan College of Education, No.1, Bharathiyar Salai, Vellore, Pin-632001, Tamilnadu from the academic year 2013-14, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in B.Ed, course, if any, to complete their course.




62. ------B.Ed College

Letter Received on 18.09.2013

from Mr. B.V. Sridhar Rao

of Save Teacher

Bangalore University/B.Ed Colleges

Request for action on errant B.Ed Colleges functioning under Bangalore UniversityLetter received on 18.09.2013 from Mr.B.V.Sridhar Rao of Save Teacher Education Action Committee,Bangalore

A letter from Mr.B.V.Sridhar Rao, Save Teacher Education Action Committee is received by this office on 18.09.2013 regarding the constitution of Local


114


Education Action

Committee, Bangalore

KA

Inquiry Committee by the Bangalore University (LIC) to visit 14 B.Ed colleges .He has requested SRC,NCTE to issue notices to these B.Ed colleges and take appropriate decision during the next SRC meeting on the 14 colleges functioning under Bangalore University.A copy of the letter is enclosed herewith.

The letter states that

‘ During May 2009, the then Vice Chancellor of Bangalore University, appointed an Academic Audit Committee(AAC) to supervise and streamline the academic work of the B.Ed colleges under Bangalore University. as the University came to know of the several irregularities in the functioning of B.Ed colleges including the infamous off-campus program and non-conduct of any academic programs. The AAC visited all the B.Ed colleges, recorded details about their functioning and classified the colleges under three categories (a) colleges with satisfactory performance (b)colleges which can improve further (c)colleges with gross irregularities. However both Academic Council and Syndicate of Bangalore University approved the grant of affiliation to most of the colleges belonging to the last category (c)- i.e colleges with gross irregularities (as per enclosed ACC report).Later, the then Vice Chancellor appointed the special squad for B.Ed practical exam to verify the conduct of practical examination work by colleges of Education. Here also ,Fourteen colleges (14) of Education, which were in category (c), notably topped the list, of the special squad for violating the norms and regulations 10.1 and 10.2 of practical examination.

As it was highly problematic for the University to streamline the functions of these colleges of Education, LICs were appointed to inspect the colleges for grant of affiliation during the academic year 2012-13.The LIC reports were discussed in length at Academic Council of BU. Since most of the LIC reports were found to be inaccurately and superficially written, the AC members were of the opinion that grant of affiliation for the academic year 2012-13 to the B.Ed colleges be referred to the Task Force ( constituted by the VC under 15.1 of the KSOU Act).Hence, the matter of giving affiliation to B.Ed and M.Ed colleges for the academic year 2012-13 was referred TASK FORCE .Further , till October 30,2012 the task force visited 99 B.Ed and 7 M.Ed colleges and video recorded the entire process of interaction and deliberation with colleges and submitted two interim reports dated 22.08.2012 and 02.11.2012 of M.Ed and B.Ed colleges respectively to the Vice Chancellor. The M.Ed and B.Ed reports were placed in the academic council on 29.08.2012 and 30.11.2012 respectively and both were unanimously approved by the Academic Council and later the Syndicate also approved in its meetings held on 12.12.2012 and 17.12.2012.As a result, based on the recommendation of the Task force , the university decided to give affiliation to 26 B.Ed colleges, which were under first two categories of the Task Force Report on B.Ed colleges for the academic year 2012-13.However, the third category of colleges (as per Task Force B.Ed Report) was given a chance to submit compliance well within 6 months. Surprisingly, none of these colleges did submit any compliance report within 6 months.

However, during April 2013, the University appointed three Expert Committees to inspect and examine 47 B.Ed colleges (colleges coming under various categories other than category 1 and 2) in respect of fulfillment of NCTE norms and also to check for compliance of the report of the Task force. During May 2013, all the three committees submitted their report

The first expert committee headed by Dr.D.V.Sudhakar, asked the University to disaffiliate 13 B.Ed colleges atleast for three years. The second expert committee headed by Prof.A.S.Seetharamu recommended affiliation to 8 irregular B.Ed


115


colleges and Prof .Nagappa Shahpur’s Committee recommended affiliation to many B.Ed colleges, which are defunct and non-functional and also colleges having no recognition of NCTE. Further, these three expert committee reports were placed and debated in the Academic Council and Syndicate of Bangalore University and finally, both the bodies of the University accepted only Prof.V.Sudhakar Committee’s Report and rejected the reports of the other two expert committees due to sheer incompetence and inconsistency. As you are well aware , as per your own statements to the media , the government directed the University to allow the students from these colleges to write the exam.All students from irregular B.Ed colleges wrote their First Semester Examination of the academic year 2012-13 during the month of June 2013.It is true and unfortunate that the entire academic exercise did not help the University to take a concrete decision.

As a final measure, during august 2013, the University appointed three more committees (High Power Committees) headed by three retired VCs namely Prof.P.Venkataramaiah ,Prof.Chidananda Gowda and Prof.K.Siddappa. These three High Level Committees visited 37 B.Ed Colleges and submitted their report. The framework or reference given to these committees were to check for end to end compliance of NCTE norms and to refer to Task Force Report. The committee headed by Prof. K. Siddappa, prepared a very vague report, by being very generous and not all verifying facts. Shockingly, all the three Committees have given marks, without following any scientific means and irrationally recommended for grant of temporary affiliation to errant B.Ed colleges. In spite many issues with the reports of High Level Committee, 14 of the 37 colleges, were approved by both Academic Council and Syndicate recently. However, keeping the inadequacies of the reports of High Level Committees,University is directed to send LIC to inspect these 14 B.Ed Colleges and recommend for affiliation/disaffiliation. Unfortunately, all these (14) colleges were listed for their inconsistencies and gross irregularities since 2009 by various committees.

The concern of the Save Teacher Education Action Committee is how High-Level committees formed by BU recommended for affiliation to all these errant B.Ed Colleges. Therefore, we request your goodself to take all necessary information and verify B.Ed colleges for fulfillment of NCTE norms, especially keeping the observations of the Task Force Report, Observations of the Expert Committee Report and the Reports of the High-level Committees.

Please look into the above highlighted facts prior to causing a notice to 14 B.Ed colleges.

The reports of various committees of the University with respect to the below mentioned

14 B.Ed colleges is enclosed. The colleges are as under

Sl.No Code No. Name of the Institution

Recognition status as per records of of SRC,NCTE

1 APSO 2191 Shuttariya College of Education, Dabbaspet

Granted

2 APS0 1718 S.J.B.College of Education

Granted

3 APS0 2069 Krishna College of Education ,Dev

Granted


116


enhalli4 APSO 1834 St.Pauls


Granted

5 APSO 2027 Aristotle College of Education,KGF

Recognition of the institution was withdrawn on 30.09.2013 from the with effect from academic year 2013-14

6 APS04004 Crescent College of Education ,Ramnagar

Granted

7 APSO 2092 Noorie College of Education

Granted

8 APS0 1695 Diana College of Education

Granted

9 APSO 2086 Mother Teresa B.Ed College,Jalahalli Road

Granted

10. APSO 2232 Bapu College of Education,Yeshwanthpur

Granted

11. APS01960 R.R.College of Education,Chikkabanavara

Granted

12. APS02273 Sharada College of Education,Mulbagal,Kolar

Granted

13. APSO 2057 Raghavendra College of Education,Chikkabanavara

Granted

14. APSO1672 Shrushruthi College of Education,Peenya II Stage

Granted

In the mean while ,on 09.10.2013 , a letter dated 05.10.2013 is received by this office on 09.10.2013 from the Vice-Chancellor, Bangalore University (copy enclosed )stating that the affiliation for the below mentioned colleges have been renewed for the year 2013-14 with an intake of 100 students each subject to certain conditions as under :-

Sl.No

College code

Name of the society

Name of the college

Course/Courses

Intake Recognition status

1 APSO2127

Suguna Educational Trust,Opp.

Suguna B.Ed College,Dee

B.Ed 100 granted


117


K.S.R.T.C bus stand

pthi Mahal,Tamaka,Kolar

2. APSO1768

Shri Lakshmi Education Society,Lakshmi Nilaya,Varada Mills Road,N.R.Extension,Chintamani - 563125

Vikram College of Education,Near Railway Station,Chelur Road,Chintamani-563125

B.Ed 100 granted

3 APSO3331

Rashtreeya ShikshanaSamithi Trust,Jayanagar,Bangalore-11

R.V.Teachers College,Jayanagar,Bangalore – 560 011

B.Ed 100 granted

4 APSO3418

B.H.S.Higher Education society,IV Block,Jayanagar,Bangalore

Vijaya Teachers College11 Main,IV Block,Jayanagar,Bangalore560 011

B.Ed 100 granted

5. APSO3408

Bharath Education Society,JaynagarBangalore -11

B.E.S College of Education,IV Block, Jayanagar,Bangalore – 560 011

B.Ed 100 granted

6 APSO1656

Children Education Society,I Phase, J.P.Nagar,Bangalore -78

The Oxford college of Education,I Phase, J.P.Nagar,Bangalore – 78

B.Ed 100 granted

7 APSO3415

Al-Ameen Education Society,Hosur Road,Bangaloer – 27

Al-Ameen College of Education,Lal Bagh,Near Main gate,Hosur Road,Bangalore –

B.Ed 100 granted


118


278 APSO

2204Shri Sharada Education Turst,B.M.Road,Ramnagar

Shri Sharada B.Ed CollegeAdichunchungiri Ritary Hospital,B.M.Road,Ramnagar – 571 511

B.Ed 100 granted

9 APSO3104

The Rural Education Society, Kanakapura – 562117,Ramanagar District

Shir .S.Kariyappa Collegeof Education, R.N.S.CampusM.G.Road,Kanakapura- 562117Ramanagaram District

B.Ed 100 Granted

10 APSO2051

Vidhya NidhiEducational Society,No.8, Srinidhi, 1Main,1st

Cross,Valmikinagar,Mysore Road,Bangalore -26

M.H.B.Ed CollegeSiami Complex,B.M.Road,opposite IjurPolice station ,Vivekanand Nagar,Ramnagar -571511

B.Ed 100 granted

11 APSO7075

Regional Institute of English, South India,Jnana Bharathi,Bangalore – 560 056

Regional Institute of English, South India,Jnana Bharathi,Bangalore – 560 056

B.Ed 100 granted

12 AOSO0405

Karnataka tigalara Sarvajanika Vidhyabhivruddhi Sangha,Rajajinagar,Bangalore – 10

Rajajinagar College of Education,K.T.S.V.Sangha10th Main,5Block,RajajinagarBangalore -

B.Ed 100 granted


119


1013 APSO

2091Janatha Shikshana Samsthe,VivekanandaCollege campus, Dr.Rajkumar Road,Rajajainagar II Stage,Bangalore – 55

Vivekananda College of Education,Dr.Rajkumar Road, Rajajinagar II stageBangalore- 55

B.Ed 100 Recognition wwithdrawn on on 17.05.2013 from the academic year 2013-14.

The institution has filed an appeal

14 AOSO0460

Shri SarvagnaEducation Society,Nagarbhavi Road,M.R.C.L.BadavaneVijayanagar,Bangalore – 40

Shri Sarvagna College of Education,M.R.C.R.Layout,Nagarbhavi Road,VijayanagarBangalore - 40

B.Ed 100 granted

15 AOSO0125

Karnataka Peoples Education Society,Durga Road,Gulbarga

Dr.Ambedkar College of Education,Pipe Line Road,J.C.Nagar,Mahalakshmiuram,Bangalore – 560 086

B.Ed 100 granted

16 APS02234

Devanahalli Education Trust,502,Fort Road,Devanahalli,Bangalore Rural,

Nalanda College of Education,Post Box No. 10D.S.Road,Devanahalli,Bangalore Rural District

B.Ed 100 granted

17 AOSO0496

K.VenkatapatheppaTrust,chickballapur

K.V.Venkatapatheppa College of Education,C

B.Ed 100 granted


120


.V.V.Campus.Chikballapur562101

18 APSO3321

Collegiate of EducationBangalore

Government College of Education,Chitravathi Campus,B.B.Road,Honnenahalli,ManchanbelePost Office,Chikballapur – 562101

B.Ed 100 granted

19 APSO2131

Bhemasena Educational System Trust,,No.25/1Shrikanth Mahal,1st

Cross,Sampige Road,Malleshwaram,Bangalore – 24

Reva Institute of Education,48A,Lakshmaiah Block,11th

Cross,Ganganagar,Bangalore - 24

B.Ed 100 granted

20 APSO3352

Jawahar Bharathi Education Society,Cholanagar,Hebbal,Bangalore – 37

Sanjay Gandhi College ofEducation,Cholanagar,Hebbal,Bangalore - 37

B.Ed 100 Granted

21 APSO3394

Mysore Education SocietyMalleshwaram,Bangalore – 560 003

M.E.S.Teachers College‘Vidya Vihar’,No. 25/1,17th Main,II Block,Rajajinagar,Bangalore - 10

B.Ed(B.Ed course has permanent affiliation from 2009-10 to 2013-14)

100 granted

22 APSO2423

Shri Hemadri Education Trust,,Shri

Shri.Hemadri B.Ed CollegeSrinivasapur

B.Ed

(B.Ed course

100 granted


121


Anjanadri Nilaya,4th

Main,2nd

Cross,P.C.Extension,Kolar

a Road,,Muranadahalli Cross,Kolar 563101

has permanent affiliation from 2011-12 to 2015-16)

23 APSO1621

Kaveri Social and Educational Trust,No.354,Sahakarnagar,Bellary Road,Bangalore -92

Kaveri B.Ed College,Sahakarnagar,Bellary Road,Bangalore - 92

B.Ed 100 granted

24. AOSO0367

New Horizon Educationand Cultural Trust IndiranagarBangalore – 08

New Horizon College of Education,100 feet Road,H.A.L.II Stage, IndiranagarBangalore – 08

B.Ed

(only B.Ed coursehas permanent affiliation from 2011-12 to 2015-16)

100 granted

Recognition of Janatha Shikshana Samsthe, Vivekananda College campus, Dr.Rajkumar Road,Rajajainagar II Stage,Bangalore – 55 (APSO 2091) was withdrawn on 17.05.2013 from the academic year 2013-14.The institution has filed an appeal before the appellate authority against the withdrawal order of SRC. The original file has been sent to NCTE,Hqrs,ND on 13.09.2013 for perusal and decision.

The Committee considered the matter, complaint letter from Mr. B.V. Sridhar Rao, dated 18-09-2013, decided and advised to Southern Regional Office to send the complaint to Bangalore University for their comments and request for a reply within two months.

63. APS01832D.Ed

Sri Saila Mallikarjuna Education and Rural

Development Institution,

Raichur District

KA

Sr i Saila Mallikarjuna Education and Rural Development Institution, Eechanal ,Lingasugur Taluk, Raichur-584122,Karnataka was granted recognition for Elementary (D.Ed) course of two and half years duration from the academic session 2004-2005 with an annual intake of 50 students subject to certain conditions on 25.11.2004

On 29.08.2013, the President, Sri Saila Mallikarjuna Education and Rural Development Institution, Eachanal has submitted a written representation as under;

“ I the undersigned president of Sri Saila Mallikarjuna Education and Rural Development Institution, Eechanal ,Lingasugur Taluk, Raichur District would like to bring to your notice and considerable action (i.e) ,Southern Regional Committee of NCTE had granted recognition to Shree Shaila Mallikarjuna Education and Rural Development Institution, Eechanal,Code : APSO1832 and admission intake took place only 2004-2005 to 2010-11 only.


122


But later year 2010-11 and 2013-14 , could not get any admission so it is ridiculer to run the college and due to critical condition college to above to close.

So ,it is my humble request to act sympathetically, to cancel the FDR as given below.

The details of the FDR 1) Rs.5.00 lakhs –No.420769 2) Rs.3.00 lakhs – No.355652”

The Committee considered the Institutions request for closure of D.Ed course and decided to permit the closure by withdrawing the recognition for (APS01832) D.Ed course with effect from 2013-2014, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in D.T.Ed, course, if any, to complete their final year course.



Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore. if any, after ensuring payments to all dues of faculty and staff.

64. APS01486D.Ed

Satyam Teacher Training Institute, Bellary District

KA

Satyam Teacher Training Institute, # 195/C, 8th Cross, M.V. Nagar, Koppagal Road, Bellary District – 583103, Karnataka.

Satyam Teacher Training Institute, # 195/C, 8th Cross, M.V.Nagar, Koppagal Road, Bellary District – 583103, Karnataka was granted recognition for Elementary (D.Ed) course vide order no. F.SRO/NCTE/D.Ed/2005-2006/5535 dated 22/02/2006 with an annual intake of 50 students with a condition to shift to its own premises/building within three years from the date of recognition (in case the course is started in rented premises.

A letter dated 17/07/2013 is received by this office on 18/07/2013 by Chairman regarding requesting for permission to teach both Kannada and English Medium.The Chairman has stated that” we are running a D.Ed College at Bellary in the name and style of “Satyam Teachers Training Institute” sponsored by Balaji Vidya Academy. With regards to above mentioned subject, we kindly bring to your notice that now a days, D.Ed course don’t have much demand due to lack of Government appointments. Some of the students approaching us to provide English medium so that they can get job opportunities in private sector.At the time of submitting the application, we have requested to the concerned authorities to give us permission for both Kannada and English medium. If you permit us to teach English medium from this academic year, it helps a lot to aspirants students. Once again we request you to permit to start English medium from this academic year. For this our institution is having all required teaching and non teaching staff along with computer lab and all the required library books”.The Committee considered the matter, Institutions request vide letter dated 17/07/2013 for teaching D.Ed course in both Kannada and English Medium. It is decided by the Committee to send the matter to DSERT,


123


Karnataka for appropriate action under intimation to the applicant.

65. APS06077B.P.Ed

Sri Thimmarayaswami Teacher

Training Institute,

Kolar DistrictKA

Sri Thimmarayaswami Teacher Training Institute, Kanumanahalli Village, Thamatamakanahalli Post, Budikote Hobli, Bangarpet Taluk, Kolar District – 563129, Karnataka.Sri Thimmarayaswami Teacher Training Institute, Kanumanahalli Village, Thamatamakanahalli Post, Budikote Hobli, Bangarpet Taluk, Kolar District – 563129, Karnataka was granted recognition for Elementary(D.Ed) course vide order no.F.SRO/NCTE/D.Ed/2006-2007/735 dated 12/04/2007 with an annual intake of 50 students.A letter dated 25/07/2013 is received by this office on 12/08/2013 from the Director, DSERT regarding granting of permission for change of medium of instruction from tamil medium to telgu medium to Timmarayaswami Teacher Trining Instiute, Kanumanahalli, Bangarpet Taluk, Kolar.He has stated that these are no clear cut directions in the norms regarding change of medium and has requested for direction regarding change of medium of the institution.

The Committee considered the matter, decided and advised Southern Regional Office to send the letter received from Director (DSERT) Karnataka regarding granting of permission for change of medium of instruction from Tamil medium to Telugu medium in the institution’s B.P.Ed course, to the University concerned for appropriate action under intimation to the applicant.

66. AOS00589D.Ed

Vanitha Teacher Training Institute, Dharwad District

KA

Vanit Vanitha Teacher Training Institute, Line Bazar, Dharwad – 580 001,Karnataka, was granted recognition for T.C.H course for a period of two years on 27.09.1996.subject to fulfillment of certain conditions.

On the directions of the Regional Committee, a visit to the applicant institution was carried out by a visiting team constituted by the Regional Committee.

The Southern Regional Committee, after considering the report of the visiting team as well as other relevant materials furnished by the applicant institution, had noted that the applicant institution does not fulfill the requirements and issued a notice on 11.06.1999 to the applicant institution under provision to Section14(3)(b) of the NCTE Act,1993,thereby giving an

opportunity to the said applicant institution to make a written representation in this behalf.

The applicant institution had submitted representation dated 26.06.1999.The said representation of the institution as well as other documents and materials

submitted were duly considered by the Regional Committee on 8 th -9t

July,1999. which came to the conclusion that recognition be refused for the following reasons:-

1. Vacant posts of teacher educators are not filled up.2. Institution has expressed its inablility to fill up the vacant posts due to the management dispute3. Books in the library are inadequate as per the norms.4. Journals are not been subscribed to



124


The institution filed an appeal against the rejection order of SRC, and the appellate authority vide order dated 21.12.1999 reversed the rejection

order of SRC.

The SRC in its 28th Meeting held on 8th – 9th June 2000 examined the compliance report and Annual Status Report regarding Elementary Course being offered by the institution and observed certain deficiencies and decided to give an opportunity to remove the same before serving notice prior to refusal as per section 14(3)(b) of the NCTE Act.

A letter requesting for submission of compliance report along with documentary proof with respect to removal of deficiencies noted was sent to the

institution on 19.06.2000,

On 31.08.2000, a letter from the Director of Public Instruction ( Research and Training),B.P.Wadia Road, Basavanagudi,Bangalore – 560 004 stating that staff strength in Vanitha Teacher Training Institute remains the same. It is therefore requested to peruse what ever staff compliance has been submitted by Vanitha Teacher Training Institute as regards your notice, barring these appointments and limit the in-take as per the ratio according to the staff strength as originally available , barring the above 06 ad-hoc appointments.

Recognition was granted to the institution from the academic session 2000-2001 with an annual intake of 37 on 07.09.2000 subject to fulfillment of certain conditions

The institution submitted compliance reports for the year 2000-2001 and 2001-2002.

On 06.09.2013, the Principal of the institution submitted a written representation regarding issuance of renewal letter of the institution which is as under ;

“ I submit here with the request letter to issue the recognition renewal letter of our Institution Vanita D.Ed College, Dharwad of Karnataka , as D.I.E.T, Principal instructed us to attach renewal copy of 2013 and issued a memo for that.

Our Institution is started from 01.06.1952 and approved in 1972 under Deputy Director of Public Instructions. Up to 2004-2005 , we have recognition letter from N.C.T.E Southern Regional Committee.

As per the oral instruction of N.C.T.E, Director , 2004-2005 recognition was a permanent one and no need to renew it every year. But still we applied for

renewal in the year 2006-2007.We did not get any response to it.

So kindly consider our request and issue recognition renewal letter from 2005 to 2013-14, to our institution, as we received memo from D.I.E.T, Principal, Dharwad. Kindly do the needful at the earliest.”

A copy of the memo from D.I.ET dated 14.08.2013 is enclosed.”

Remarks of SRO: Recognition was granted to the institution from the academic session 2000-2001 with an annual intake of 37 on 07.09.2000

subject to fulfillment of certain conditions


125


As per the copy of the letter issued to the institution dated 05.04.2005, the intake of students was fixed at 60.

The Committee considered the matter, letter dated 06-09-2013 from the Principal of the institution requesting for recognition renewal letter, decided and to inform the applicant that renewal letter is not required.

Further, the Committee also decided to inform Government of Karnataka that the Principal of DIET concerned is unnecessarily interfering and causing confusion by instructing the applicant institution to attach recognition renewal copy of 2013 and issued a memo to the institution. .

Consideration of Agenda Items- Volume-04Inspection u/s-14

67. SRCAPP2030

M.EdYogivemana University,

Kadapa District

AP

Yogivemana University, Plot No.1, Vemanapuram, YVU Campus, Kadapa Taluk & City, Kadapa District-516003, Andhra Pradesh

Yogivemana University, Plot No.1, Vemanapuram, YVU Campus, Kadapa Taluk & City, Kadapa District-516003, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Yogivemana University, Plot No.1, Vemanapuram, YVU Campus, Kadapa Taluk & City, Kadapa District-516003, Andhra Pradesh for M.Ed Course of one year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 04.01.2013.


The SRC in its 246th meeting held on 02nd-4th June 2013, considered the reply of the institution to the deficiency letter dt.17-05-2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.



On careful perusal of the original file of the University, VT report, VCD, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to M.Ed course of one year duration with an annual intake of 35(thirty five only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given


126


effect before the commencement of the academic session.68. SRCAPP208

3D.Ed

Little Star College of

Elementary Education, Prakasam

DistrictAP

Little Star College of Elementary Education, Plot/Khasara No. 54/1, N Agraharam Village, Ongole City, Taluk and Post Office, Prakasam District – 523001, Andhra Pradesh

Little Star Educational Development Society, Plot No. 37-1-413(8), Ramanagar 9th Line Road, Ongole Village and Post Office, Ongole City and Taluk, Prakasam District – 523001, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Little Star College of Elementary Education, Plot/Khasara No. 54/1, N Agraharam Village, Ongole City, Taluk and Post Office, Prakasam District – 523001, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 30.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 04.01.2013.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 31.01.2013/28.03.2013 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 28.03.2013 and reposted on 01.05.2013. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 24.05.2013

The SRC in its 247th meeting held on 20th-22nd June 2013, considered the reply of the institution dt.24-05-2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed on 16th-21st September 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 05.09.2013.


On careful perusal of the original file of the Institution, VT report, VCD, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(fifty only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

69. SRCAPP2089

D.EdLittle Rose College of

Elementary Education, Prakasam

DistrictAP

Little Rose College of Elementary Education, Plot/Khasara No.789/2C, Darsi Village and Post Office, Darsi City and Taluk, Prakasam District - 523247, Andhra Pradesh

Little Rose Minority Educational Society, D.No.4-325, Gowthami JR College Street, Darsi Village and Post Office, Darsi Taluka and City, Prakasam District-523247, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Little Rose College of Elementary Education, Plot/Khasara No.789/2C, Darsi Village and Post Office, Darsi City and Taluk, Prakasam District - 523247, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on


127


30.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 04.01.2013.


The SRC in its 247th meeting held on 20th-22nd June 2013, considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 23.05.2013 to the deficiency letter and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed on 16th -21st September 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 22.08.2013.



70. SRCAPP3D.Ed

St.Andrews College of

Elementary Education,

Krishna District

AP

St. Andrews College of Elementary Education, Khasara/Plot No. 206F2, Vijayawada Village, Vijayawada-9 Post, Vijayawada Taluk, Krishna District-520009, Andhra Pradesh

Mother Educational Development Society, No.5-7/8-98/1, 6th Line K.L. Rao Nagar Road, Vijayawada Village, Vijayawada-9 Post, Vijayawada Taluk, Krishna District-520009, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to St. Andrews College of Elementary Education, Khasara/Plot No. 206F2, Vijayawada Village, Vijayawada-9 Post, Vijayawada Taluk, Krishna District-520009, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 04.01.2013.


The SRC in its 247th meeting held on 20th-22nd June 2013, considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 24.05.2013 to the deficiency letter and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the


128


deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed on 16th -21st September 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 05.09.2013.



71. SRCAPP109B.Ed

JEC College of

Education, Hyderabad

DistrictAP

JEC College of Education, Khasara No.533/A, Plot No.1-23, Main Road, Almasguda, Meerpet Post Office,Saroornagar Taluk, Hyderabad City, Hyderabad District-500059, Andhra Pradesh

Sri Sowjanya Educational Society, Plot No.17-1-383/A/31, Outside Vinaynagar Colony, Saidabad Village & Post Office, Saroornagar Taluk, Hyderabad District-500059, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to JEC College of Education, Khasara No.533/A, Plot No.1-23, Main Road, Almasguda, Meerpet Post Office,Saroornagar Taluk, Hyderabad City, Hyderabad District-500059, Andhra Pradesh for B.Ed Course of one year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 04.01.2013.


The SRC in its 249th meeting held on 24th-26th July 2013, considered the reply of the institution to the deficiency letter dated 13.06.2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed on 07 th to 12th October 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 27.09.2013.


On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, VT report, VCD, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to B.Ed course of one year duration with an annual


129


intake of 100(one hundred only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

72. APS07157B.Ed

Janadrdhan Reddy

College of Education, Karimnagar

DistrictAP

Janardhan Reddy College of Education, Huzurabad, Karimnagar District-505468, Andhra Pradesh

Grama Nava Nirman Samithi, Karimnagar District, Andhra Pradesh had submitted an application on 12.05.2006 to the Southern Regional Committee of NCTE for grant of recognition to Janardhan Reddy College of Education, H.No.4-2/A, Indiranagar, Saidapur Road, Huzurabad, Karimnagar District-505468, Andhra Pradesh for B.Ed Course of one year duration.

The Southern Regional Committee, after considering the report of the visiting team as well as other relevant materials granted recognition to the institution for offering B.Ed Course with an intake of 100 students from the session 2007-2008 vide Order No.783 dated 12.04.2007.

The Registrar, Kakatiya University, Warangal vide letter dt.14.03.2008 drew the attention of Regional Director, SRC and informed that in the process of granting temporary affiliation to the institutions the university conducted inspection and observed that Shabby accommodation and insufficient to run B.Ed. programme. Land and building are at different places.

The letter was placed before the SRC in its 157th meeting held on 23rd-24th April 2008. The SRC after careful consideration of all aspects decided to issue show cause notice. Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued on 28.05.2008 to the institution. In response to the notice the applicant institution replied on 14.06.2008 as under:

“with regard to insufficient accommodation, as per the advice of University Authorities, we have started construction of two more big size lecture hall and one seminar hall. At the time of second visit of university team, the construction work was not completed totally and after going through the progress of construction, the university has granted temporary affiliation for the year 2007-08. Now, the accommodation is ready in every aspect”

The reply was placed before SRC in its 161st meeting held on 6th-7th August 2008 and the committee considered the matter and decided and resolved to cause inspection under Section 17 to verify the infrastructural and instructional facilities.

The SRC-NCTE conducted an inspection of the institution under section 17 of NCTE Act 1993 on 17.09.2008. The report received from the visiting team informs as follows:

“That management is not ready to face the inspection now on 17.09.2008 because of various factors and asked for postponement of the inspection by three more months.”

The institution has not co-operated in carrying out inspection of institution as per the Provisions of NCTE Act. Therefore, the SRC-NCTE in its 165 th meeting held on 27th-28th September, 2008 on careful perusal of the original file of the institution, two visiting team report under section 14 & 17, the letter dated 14.03.2008 from the Registrar, Kakatiya University, Warangal to the Regional Director, SRC and the reply dated.14.06.2008 to the show cause notice issued


130


to the institution and other related documents, Act of NCTE 1993, Regulations and Guidelines issued from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee noted the following:-

As per the inspection team report of the Kakatiya University, Warangal the land of the institution is situated at the place other than the location of the building.

The institution in its communication to deficiency letter dated.09.10.2006 submitted the land document in the form of sale deed pertaining to Sy.No.242/B admeasuring 1089 sq.yards situated at Bornepelly Gram Panchayat, Huzurabad, Karimnagar District and whereas along with letter dt.14.06.2008 it has furnished a land document in the form of sale deed having the land at Sy.Nos.243. Plot (A) extent 1023.00 sq.yards, equivalent to this 859.32 sq.mts, (B) extent 224.77 sq.yards, equivalent to this 84.00 sq.mts, total plot extent (1347.77) sq.yards, equivalent to this (1132.12) sq.mts bounded by 18.0 feets width road situated at Bornapelly Village in favor of Padmashali Seva Samithi, Karimnagar District which is neither the institution not the applicant society.

The society changed its initial site of the land whose documents were submitted by it to NCTE with the undertaking that it will construct its building on the same land.

The institution at present running its B.Ed course on the site seen by the team of the Kakatiya University is having shabby accommodation and insufficient to run the B.Ed course.

B.Ed course is still in possession of it or it is sold. The institution at present running its B.Ed course on the site seen by the

team of the Kakatiya University is having shabby accommodation and insufficient to run the B.Ed course.

The institution did not cooperate with the visiting team in carrying out inspection under section 17 on 17.09.2008. This is considered as an act of defiance and unbecoming of an educational institution.

The institution violated the provisions contained under various sections of NCTE Act and regulations there under.

The SRC after careful consideration of all aspects decided to withdraw the recognition of the institution from the academic session 2008-09. Further, the SRC also decided to inform the decision to the State Government of Andhra Pradesh and Concerned University for follow-up action immediately, including redistribution of students admitted, if any.

As per direction of SRC, withdrawal order was issued to the institution on 06.10.2008.

The institution was approached to Appellate Authority NCTE Head Quarters wherein the Council confirms the order appealed against with the modification that the said withdrawal of recognition order would be effective form the academic session 2010-2011.

As per direction of Appellate Authority corrigendum order was issued on 09.08.2010.

Meanwhile, the institution also filed a court case in the Hon’ble High court in W.P.M.P no. 16528/2010 in writ petition no. 13130/2010 in the matter of


131


Janardhan Reddy College of Education, Indiranagar, Saidapur Road, Huzurabad, Karimnagar Vs NCTE and others.

A letter along with following documents has been received from the institution on 29.06.2010.

1. Court order dated 11.06.2010.2. D.D of 40,000/- bearing no.461733.

In the court order the Hon’ble High court has directed as under:-

“This is an application to direct the respondents to conduct an inspection of the petitioner- college.

I have heard Sri A Sanjeev Kumar, learned counsel for the petitioner, and Smt.G.Jhansi, learned counsel, representing Sri B. Adinarayanana Rao, learned Standing Counsel for the respondents. Having regard to interim order passed in WPMP no 16529/2010, respondent no. 2 is directed to depute an inspection team on payment of Rs.40,000/- which is stated to the required fees, by the petitioner and submit subject the report to respondent no. 2 (SRC, NCTE) within a period of eight weeks from today subject to the above direction, the WPMP is disposed of. “

As per the direction of court case the institution has submitted D.D of Rs. 40,000/- vide letter dated 12.07.2010.

The matter was considered by the Committee and it was decided to cause inspection of the institution for B.Ed. Course, under Section 17 of NCTE Act, after payment of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee and on submission of filled in Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting documents relating to building, land, including Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate, within four weeks from the date of confirmation of the Minutes.

Meanwhile a court order dated 02.08.2010 an court order has been received in the office of SRC on 17.08.2010 in W.P.M.P NO: 23751 & 23752 of 2010 in W.P.NO: 18762 of 2010. The Hon’ble High Court has passed an order as under:-

“The Petitioner institution was directed to be inspected by the National council for Teacher Education by interim order of this court dated 11.08.2010 in writ petition no 13130 of 2010. The said inspection is yet to take place.

However in the meanwhile counseling for admissions to B.Ed course for the academic year 2010-2011 has already commenced.”

In such view of the matter, if the petitioner institution is denied affiliation by the Kakatiya University, respondent 3, it would stand to lose the entire academic year, as it would not be included in the list of colleges for counseling by the Andhra Pradesh State Council for Higher Education, respondent 4. There shall accordingly be a direction to the Kakatiya University to consider the case of the Petitioner College for affiliation for the academic year 2010-2011 without insisting upon the approval of the National Council for Teacher Education based on its inspection. In the even the petitioner college is found eligible in all other


132


respects, the University shall grant affiliation and thereupon the Andhra Pradesh State Council for Higher Education shall include the petitioner College in the second phase of counseling scheduled to be held in the later part of August, 2010 enabling it to make admission to B.Ed course for the academic year 2010-2011.

The matter has been taken up with the Advocate to defend in the interest of NCTE.

The inspection was carried out on 02.09.2010.

The SRC in its 196th meeting held on 15-16 September 2010 considered the VT report and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Notice Under Section 17 for the following reasons:

The Instructional facilities are generally inadequate and housed in small rooms.

All the Laboratories required to be strengthened with additional materials / equipments.

FDRs are not in the Joint Names. The staff list yet to be formally approved by the affiliating University. Instructional space & facilities are inadequate for continuance of the

B.Ed., programme as per the NCTE Norms. Change of Land Use Certificate not obtained / not6available. Science lab is about 300 sq.ft in size and it is rather small. The size of classroom is only 450 sq.ft. as against 500 sq.ft or 10

sq.ft. per student as per NCTE norms.

As per the decision of SRC, Notice was issued on 25.10.2010. Till date institution not submitted its written representation/documents.

The SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22nd and 23rd February, 2011 considered the not replying/non-response by the institution to the Showcause Notice issued on 25.10.2010 and decided to withdraw recognition for B.Ed course (APS07157) with effect from 2011-12, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in B.Ed course, if any, to complete their course.

Accordingly, withdrawal order was issued to the institution vide no. F.SRO/NCTE/2010-2011/27669 dated 18.03.2011.

The institution filed W.P. No. 15960 of 2011 in the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh. The Hon’ble Court has passed an order as follows;

“After hearing the Learned Counsel for the parties, this writ petition is disposed of in the same terms as in the order passed in W.P. No. 22090 of 2008 and batch of writ petitions dated 11.8.2009. The petitioners are granted four weeks time to file statutory appeal under section 18 of the NCTE Act and the appellate authority shall receive the appeal by treating the same as an appeal filed within the limitation and dispose of the same after hearing both the parties in accordance with law. Till such time the impugned order dated 18.3.2011 shall remain suspended. No. order as to costs.”

The institution is also preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs. and the appellate authority in its order dated 04.01.2012 confirms the order appealed against.


133


The institution has submitted its written representation on 09.05.2013 and enclosing Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- and Rs.10,000/- along with court order as follows:-

“…… the writ petition is disposed of, directing that respondents 1 and 2 shall cause inspection of the 2nd petitioner institution on payment of the requisite fee. If the inspection team finds that the petitioner has rectified the deficiencies, appropriate orders shall be passed by the 2nd

respondent, within a period of four weeks from the date of submission of the representation. There shall be no order as to costs.

The miscellaneous petition filed in this writ petition shall also stand disposed of.”

Again, the institution has submitted its written representation on 20.05.2013 and 05.07.2013 stated that:-

“…..we are grateful and thankful to you sir, so per we have been run the college because of your kindness but meanwhile, a little deficiency of building the college recognisation was withdrawn. In this consequence, we approached the Hon’ble High Court regarding this, than the court directed for inspection all ready, we applied for inspection as per instruction of Hon’ble High Court Andhra Pradesh and enclosed two DDs worth of Rs.50,000.00.”

The SRC in its 248th meeting held on 13th-15th July 2013, considered the Hon’ble High Court order and as per the direction of the Court decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

The VT members to be informed to check whether all the deficiencies have been fully rectified before their inspection.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed on 26th -31st August 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 22.08.2013.


The Committee considered the matter, VT report, VCD of the institution, all other relevant documents of the institution, decided and advised to Southern Regional Office to ask the institution to submit the following documents immediately:

The institution has submitted land documents located at Bornapally village to the Inspection team, whereas in other documents submitted, the land location mentioned as Kothapally village. The institution has to submit original land documents certified by the competent authority where the college building is situated.

Notarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted. Proceedings of Revenue


134


Divisional Officer not submitted for conversion of land from agricultural to educational purposes.

Up-to-date encumbrance certificate issued by sub-registrar is not submitted.

Original FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank in joint account name is not submitted.

Certificate of registration of society is not submitted.

As per VT report, total built up area provided to B.Ed course is only 12058 sq.ft. which is less than the requirement of 16000 sq.ft. as per NCTE norms, 2009.

As per VT report, seating capacity in the library is only 30, which is inadequate for B.Ed programme of 100 students.

As per the VT report, Infrastructural facilities are inadequate.

As per VT report, space area provided for office room & class rooms are inadequate.

As per VT report, furniture provided in office room and staff room should be strengthened.

As per VT report, equipments provided in other labs and physical education etc., are inadequate.

73. SRCAPP54B.P.Ed

Siddhartha College of Physical

Education, Rangareddi

DistrictAP

Siddhartha College of Physical Education, Khasara/Plot No. 64, Vinobhanagar Street, Ibrahimpatnam Village and Post Office, Ibrahimpatnam City, Rangareddi District-509301, Andhra Pradesh

G.P. Educational Society, Plot No. 64, Vinobha Nagar Road, Ibrahimpatnam Village and Post Office, Ibrahimpatnam City, Rangareddi District-509301, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Siddhartha College of Physical Education, Khasara/Plot No. 64, Vinobhanagar Street, Ibrahimpatnam Village and Post Office, Ibrahimpatnam City, Rangareddi District-509301, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed Course of one year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 07.01.2013.



The Southern Regional Committee in its 249th meeting held on 24th – 26th July 2013 has considered the reply of the institution to the deficiency letter dated 05.06.2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per


135


the norms.

Note: The VT members to be informed particularly check on other courses being run in the same location.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed on 7th - 12th October, 2013. The same was intimated to the institution on 27.09.2013.



74. SRCAPP181B.P.Ed

Bharathi B.P.Ed College,

Prakasam District

AP

Bharathi B.P.Ed College, Plot/Khasara No.101/a1, 101/a2, 100/3, 99/1, 93/a2, 41/1c, 42/2, 43 & 26/3, Plot No.101/A1, Street No.12/2B, Kandulapuram Village, Cumbum Post Office & Taluk, Prakasam City & District - 523340, Andhra Pradesh

Vignana Bharathi Educational Society, Plot No. 9-73, 3rd Line, Nehru Nagar Street, Kandulapuram Village, Cumbum Post Office & Taluk, Prakasam City & District-523340, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Bharathi B.P.Ed College, Plot/Khasara No.101/a1, 101/a2, 100/3, 99/1, 93/a2, 41/1c, 42/2, 43 & 26/3, Plot No.101/A1, Street No.12/2B, Kandulapuram Village, Cumbum Post Office & Taluk, Prakasam City & District - 523340, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed Course of one year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 04.01.2013.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 06.02.2013 / 28.03.2013 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 19.04.2013.


The Southern Regional Committee in its 249th Meeting held on 24th - 26th July, 2013 has considered the reply of the institution to the deficiency letter dated 13.06.2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed on 07 th - 12th October, 2013. The same was intimated to the institution on 27.09.2013.

As per the direction of SRC, the inspection of the institution was conducted on


136


08.10.2013 and the VT Report received in the office of SRC on 11.10.2013.


75. SRCAPP206B.P.Ed

Sri Datta College of Physical


AP

Sri Datta College of Physical Education, Sy.No.370, 371/1, NH7, Veldurthi Village & Post Office, Dhone Taluk, Kurnool City & District-518216, Andhra Pradesh

Sri Datta Educational and Rural Development Society, Plot No.9/5, Near SVN School, Veldurthi Village & Post Office, Dhone Taluk, Kurnool City, Kurnool District-518216, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Sri Datta College of Physical Education, Sy.No.370, 371/1, NH7, Veldurthi Village & Post Office, Dhone Taluk, Kurnool City & District-518216, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed Course of one year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 07.01.2013.


The SRC in its 249th meeting of SRC held on 24th-26th July 2013, considered the reply of the institution to the deficiency letter dated 11.06.2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed on 07 th to 12th October 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 27.09.2013.




137


76. SRCAPP1838

B.Ed (Open & Distance Learning Mode)KSWU Bijapur, Bijapur District

KA

KSWU Bijapur, Plot No.1, Dr.Ambedkar Circle, Bijapur Village, Post, Taluk and Town, Bijapur District – 586101, Karnataka had applied for grant of recognition to KSWU Bijapur, Khasara No.11A, 11B, 11K, 11H, Plot No. 45 258 124, Torvi Village, Bijapur Post,Taluk and City, Bijapur District – 586101, Karnataka for B.Ed course through open and Distance Learning mode of two years duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 21/12/2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 28/12/2012.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 08.03.2013 / 09.05.2013 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 10.04.2013.

The University has replied to the deficiency letter on 07.06.2013, 14.06.2013 and 17.06.2013.

The SRC in its 248th meeting held on 13th – 15th July, 2013 considered the reply of the Karnataka State Women’s University vide letter dated 07.06.2013, 14.06.2013 and 17.06.2013 to the deficiency letter, and decided to write to the University to send the following documents:

1. NACC certificate to be submitted towards M.Ed course being run by the institution.2. DEC clearance certificate to be submitted for B.Ed (ODL).

The institution by seeing the website they have submitted a reply, letter dated 18.07.2013 is received by this office on 23.07.2013.

The Southern Regional Committee

The Southern Regional Committee in its 250th meetind held on 11-13th August, 2013 considered the reply of the institution to the letter dated 23.07.2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection for B.Ed-ODL course under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Further,The committee decided to ask University to submit DEC clearance Certificate for B.Ed.(ODL) and Self Learning Material.

Accordingly, as per the decision of SRC, a etter was addressed to the University requesting for submission of DEC Certificate for B.Ed (ODL) and Sself Learning material vide this office letter No. SRCAPP1838/B.Ed (ODL)/KA/2013-14/53624 dated 12.09.2013. Also as per the decision of SRC, a inspection was conducted to the University on 10.10.2013 and 11.10.2013.

The Committee considered the matter, VT report dated 10-10-2013 & 11-10-2013, and all other relevant documents of the institution, decided and advised Southern Regional Office to ask the University to furnish the following documents:

1. A copy of the undertaking given to Tamilnadu Open University for agreeing to the condition for using its Self Learning Materials.


138


2. A copy of the DEC clearance obtained for Self Learning Materials of Tamilnadu Open University.

3. A fresh VCD.

77. APS02953APS02956APS02955APS02961APS02957APS02959APS02960APS02952APS02954APS02962

B.EdB.EdB.EdB.EdB.EdB.EdB.EdB.EdB.EdB.Ed

Continuing Recognition

for Ten Teacher

Education Centres of

Kerala University.

KL

LETTER OF STATE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA REGARDING 10 UNIVERSITY CENTERS OF KERALA UNIVERSITY.

An e-mail is received by this office on 26th October, 2013 from Sri. S. Ajikumaran, Addl. Secretary enclosing a letter No. 33063/B4/2013/H.Edn dated 26.10.2013 of Dr. K.M. Abraham, Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Higher Education (B) Dept., Government of Kerala, Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala regarding grant of recognition to Kerala University Colleges of Teacher Education(copy enclosed).

Dr.K.M. Abraham, Addl. Chief Secretary to Government, Government of Kerala has requested to take up immediate steps to su bmit the report of the NCTE findings of the team conducted before the Hon’ble High Court of Kerala when it is came up for hearing during this week.

He has further stated that “as the University of Kerala had taken steps to rectify the defects pointed out by NCTE in a time bound manner, the Government of Kerala will take up immediate steps to rectify the defects pointed out by the NCTE within 3 years by the University of Kerala. If the University fails to comply with the defects pointed out by the NCTE, the NCTE can pursue action in accordance with their regulations. Hence, I request that the NCTE may consider the request made by the University of Kerala to go ahead with the admission procedures to B.Ed. courses in the 10 University College of Teacher Education of Kerala University from the academic year 2013-14.”

Hence, in continuation to the agenda submitted regarding Visiting team reports of 10 Kerala University Centers, the letter dated 26.10.2013 received from the Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Government of Kerala.

The Committee considered the matter, decided that, in view of the directive given by the NCTE, and with reference to the undertaking given by the Government of Kerala, (Letter No. 33063/B4/2013/Higher Education, dated Thiruvananthapuram, 26.10.2013, from The Additional Chief Secretary to Government) in relaxation of the prescribed norms and standards, the recognition given to the ten Teacher Education Centres of University of Kerala is continued and the University is given time till 2015-16 to remove the deficiencies in reference failing which, without further notice, the recognition given will be withdrawn.

Consideration of Agenda Items- Volume-05Court Cases-Inspection Report

78. SRCAPP222D.Ed

Likitha College of

Elementary

Likitha College of Elementary Education, Plot No. 208/1, Chandramamapalli Village, Divili Post Office, Peddapuram Taluk and City, East Godavari District – 533 437, Andhra Pradesh.

Teresa Educational Society, Plot No. 2-7, Main Road, Ulimeswaram Village, Mallam Post Office and City, Peddapuram Taluka, East Godavari District –


139


Education, East

Godavari District

AP

533 437, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Likitha College of Elementary Education, Plot No. 208/1, Chandramamapalli Village, Divili Post Office, Peddapuram Taluk and City, East Godavari District – 533 437, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course for two years duration under Section 14 of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012. The institution has submitted hard copy of the application on 07.01.2013.

NCTE-Hqrs. had directed to process the application in accordance with NCTE Regulations 2009 and amendment notified on 26th November, 2010 which reads as follows:-

2(b) for Sub-Regulation (1-A) the following shall be submitted namely” 1(1-A)(I) the application shall be summarily rejected under one or more of the following circumstances:


b) Hard coy in triplicate of the on-line application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the on-line application.

c) Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society/institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of on-line application.

The SRC in its 238th Meeting held on 05th-06th February, 2013 and careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related documents, NCTE Act 1993 Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds:

The processing fee submitted only DD of Rs. 41050/- instead of Rs. 50000/- (Which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulation).

Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the institution on 06.03.2013.

The institution in its letter 6.10.2013 submitted a court order from the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in W.P.No. 12252 of 2013 stating that “…………I leave it open to the SRC to grant, in any such eventuality, permission to the petitioner for commencing the necessary course during the academic session 2014-2015. Since, the petitioner has admitted to the lapse of concentration while filling up the application form, it is only appropriate that he shall also remit an additional sum of Rs. 5000/- as penalty, representing 10% of the processing fee, in each case to the SRC.

With this order, the Writ petition is disposed of. No. costs.

Miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.”

Note: The institution has submitted original Demand Draft of Rs. 55,000.00 vide bearing no. 914958 dated 29.09.2013 is submitted.


140


The Committee considered the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh order wherein, the High Court has left it the SRC to decide.

It is decided that, the Committee has no discretion in the matter under the Regulations which list this as a factor for summary rejection. The Supreme Court has directed that Regulations shall be strictly enforced.

Supreme Court vide their order in Civil Appeal NO. 1125-1128/2011 in SLP No. 17165-68/2009 filed by NCTE Vs ors, which reads as under:


Based on the above, the Committee decided to reject the application, refund the amount and to close the file.

79.APS00290

B.EdElim College

of Education,

East Godavari District

AP

Elim College of Education, Amalapuram Revenue Division Church of Christ Campus, Janakipeta Street, Amalapuram East Godavari District-533201, Andhra Pradesh.

Elim College of Education, Amalapuram Revenue Division Church of Christ Campus, Janakipeta Street, Amalapuram East Godavari District-533201. Andhra Pradesh had submitted an application on 31.12.2001 for grant of recognition to B.Ed programme.

The application was processed and the inspection of the institution was conducted on 21/05/2002 and finally SRC granted recognition for starting B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on 03.03.2003, with the condition to shift to its own premises within three years form the date of recognition.

The institution has submitted D.D. of Rs. 40,000/- vide dated 17/09/2007 stating that “…the institution is running in its own permanent building”.

A letter sent to the institution on 25/05/2009 calling for 9 essential documents for shifting. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 30.03.2011.

The SRC in its 205th Meeting held on 18th-19th May, 2011 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following deficiencies:

1. The Affidavit in Rs.100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with Notary attestation is to be submitted.

2. The latest Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government Engineer is not submitted.

3. Land Usage Certificate from the concerned Government authorities stating that the land is exclusively permitted/ sanctioned for Educational Purposes is to be submitted.


141


4. Fresh Non-Encumbrance certificate from the competent authority is not submitted.

5. Psychology lab needs to be strengthened.6. Technology lab & Other labs/Physical Education needs to be

strengthened.7. Seating capacity in the library is only for 10 students, which is

inadequate.8. No journals are available in the library.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 30/06/2011.

The institution has not submitted reply to the show cause notice even after stipulated period of 30 days and till date.

NCTE-Hqrs in its letter dated 12/06/2012 has forwarded a complaint received from Sri. K.R. Shekar with the request to examine the matter and take necessary action against the institution (Elim College of Education).

Another complaint has been received from Smt. Sunitha Kusuma on 17/09/2012 stating that

“…“the Elim College of Education, Amalapuram was formed and functioning since 2002-2003 to till date based on the orders issued by the competent authorities vide reference first to third cited. Having obtained certificate from the Government of Andhra Pradesh. Recognition form NCTE and affiliation from Andhra University the college “ ELIM COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, Amalapuram” stated functioning form the academic year 2002-2003 with and intake of 100 students.

At the time of formation of college late Dhanaraj Bonthu the then secretary & correspondent has produced the necessary land documents for about five acres land and necessary equipment & infrastructure as per the NCTE Norms and Standards for Bachelor of education programme leading to Bachelor of Education (B.Ed) degree. Subsequently due to financial crisis the then secretary & correspondent sold the lands shown for B.Ed the required equipment of laboratory and furniture are also not sufficient to full fill the norms prescribed by the NCTE regarding infrastructure two RCC building were provided B.Ed purpose out of which one building was already sold out and the B.Ed classes are being continued in single building only and it is not sufficient and moreover the building is not approved by the Amalapuram Municipal corporation authorities except ground floor. The management committee is misguiding the inspection team every time by showing orphanage buildings and school buildings in the church of Christ campus which were in the same premises.

After the demise of Dr. Dhanaraju Bonthu i.e. on August 3rd 2011 Mr. Joseph Raju Bonthu took charge as the secretary and correspondent for the Elim College of Education, Amalapuram and has submitted proposals for sanctioning of D.Ed (DIET) college in the same premises to the Director, NCTE, Bangalore even though there are no required infrastructure and laboratory for B.Ed College.

1. Multipurpose hall with seating capacity of 200 and a dias (2000 sq.ft)


142


2. Library-cum-reading room(NIL)3. ICT Resource Centre(NIL)4. Psychology Resource Centre (NIL)5. Art and Craft Resource Centre (NIL)6. Health and Physical Education Resource Centre (NIL)7. Science and Mathematics Resource Centre (NIL)8. Principal’s Office(NIL)9. Staff Room (NIL)10. Administrative Office(NIL)11. Visitors Room(NIL)12. Girl’s Common Room(NIL)13. Seminar Room(NIL)14. Canteen(NIL)

I submit that the above facts are true and I am bringing to your kind notice to initiate suitable action as deemed fit by sending a special team of inspectors surprisingly and conducting an open enquiry by a special officer or by NCTE special team. I request an early action in this matter as a present batch has gone out and new batch will be coming after edcet-2012. If no action is taken by you in this matter then I will be forced to seek the court of law”.

Another complaint has been received from Sri. Jayanandam on 06/12/2012 regarding functioning of B.Ed College and irregularities and to take action against the institution.

The complaint and non-submission of show cause notice reply were placed before SRC in its 236th Meeting held on 16th-17th December, 2012 considered the non-reply of the institution to the issue of show cause notice dt. 30/06/2012 and the complaints and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of B.Ed course.

Keeping in view, Supreme Court vide their order in Civil Appeal No. 1125-1128/2011 in SLP No. 17165-68/2009 filed by NCTE Vs ors, which reads as under:

“An institution is not entitled to recognition unless it fulfills the conditions specified in various clauses of the Regulations. The Council is directed to ensure that in future no institution is granted recognition unless it fulfils the conditions laid down in the Act and the Regulations and the time schedule fixed for processing the application by the Regional Committee and communication of the decision on the issue of recognition it strictly adhered to”.

As per the decision of SRC, a rejection order was issued to the institution on 05/02/2013.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC, the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs the appellate authority order vide no. F.No.89-107/2013Appeal/8th

Meeting -2013 dated 22/05/2013 stated that

“…the council noted that the reply stated to have been sent on 26/09/2011 is not in the file of the SRC. In the copy of the reply submitted


143


by the appellant no reasons for the delayed reply have been mentioned. in these circumstances the council concluded that the appeal deserved to be rejected and the order of the SRC confirms. Since the appellant is an existing institution SRC should have issued an order of withdrawal and not an order of refusal. The SRC should issue a corrigendum to their order conveying their decision to withdrawal of recognition instead of refusing recognition.

After perusal of the documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit, and after considering the oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the council concluded that the appeal deserved to be rejected and hence the order of the SRC is confirmed. The SRC is directed to issue a corrigendum mentioning withdrawal of recognition instead of refusal”.

The appellate authority order was placed before SRC in its 247 th meeting held on 20th – 22nd June, 2013 and the Committee has noted the matter.

A court order has been received from the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in W.P.MP no. 20201 of 2013 in W.P. No. 16657 of 2013. The Hon’ble Court order stating as follows;

“Material filed before this court shows that explanation offered by the petitioner to the show cause notice dated 30.6.2011 was glossed over by both the authorities. The petitioner has been harping right from the beginning that the institution was being run in its own premises by complying with all the requirements. The primary authority, instead of considering the matter pragmatically with reference to the allegations in the show-cause notice and explanation offered by the petitioner, has taken into consideration additional factors, which were not mentioned in the show-case notice.

In view of the same, there is a prima facie case in favour of the petitioner.

Hence, there shall be interim suspension as prayed for”.

A court notice has been received from the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in W.P.MP no. 20202 of 2013 in W.P.No. 16657 of 2013. The Hon’ble High Court as directed respondent no (3 & 4 i.e. the Government of Andhra Pradesh and The Andhra University) to appear before the court in person are by counsel.

Another court notice has been received from the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in W.P. No. 16657 of 2013 dated 13/06/2013. The Hon’ble Court as direction respondent No. 2 (SRC-NCTE) do appear personally are by advocate on the day of 22/07/2013 at 10.30 a.m.

Accordingly, a letter to the advocate enclosing brief of the case was sent on 11/07/2013, with the request to appear before the court and defend the case and behalf of SRC-NCTE and NCTE-Hqrs.

NCTE-Hqrs in its letter dated 08/07/2013 stating that “the court notices dated 13.06.2013 received from the Hon’ble High Court along with a copy of writ petition in the matter mentioned above. It is seen that the petitioner is aggrieved by the orders of Appellate authority dated 22.05.2013 inter-alia confirmed the impugned order dated 05.02.2013 of SRC, NCTE withdrawal of recognition to


144


secure allotment of students for the current year academic year 2013-14. The matter is listed for hearing on 22.07.2013.

You are, therefore, authorized to defend the case including on behalf of the NCTE (HQ) and file a detailed counter affidavit in order to vacate the stay”.

Accordingly, a letter to the advocate was sent on 02/08/2013 with the request to ensure the appearance of the counsel and to take immediate action for vacation of stay.

Meantime, the institution has submitted a letter dated 18.7.2013 stating as follows;

“This is to inform you that the undersigned had field W.P. No. 16657 of 2013 before the Hon’ble Andhra Pradesh High Court challenging the order dated 22.5.2013 issued by the NCTE (New Delhi) whereby your office was directed to issue a corrigendum mentioning “Withdrawal of recognition instead of refusal”. The above appeal was filed against the order of your office, dated 5.2.2013, whereby our Elim College’s application for grant of recognition for staring B.Ed course was refused/rejected.

On hearing the arguments of both sides, the Hon’ble High Court was pleased to suspend the operation of the order dated 22.5.2013, of the appellate authority, NCTE(New Delhi) which in turn had confirmed the order dated 5.2.2013 issued y your office against Elim College of Education.

It is now noted that the NCTE-SRC(Bangalore) in its 247th meeting, dated 20th– 22nd June, 2013 in respect of Elim College of Education(APS00290)(at Sl.No. 55 of the Minutes of the Meeting), has stated the following:

“The Committee has noted the matter and direction of the Appellate authority vide appeal order dated 22.5.2013 to issue a corrigendum mentioning “Withdrawal of recognition instead of refusal”.

From the above, it appears that the NCTE-SRC, despite having been a party to the above writ petition has not been appraised of the order dated 13.6.2013 of the Hon’ble High Court vide which the order dated 22.5.2013 of the NCTE(New Delhi) was suspended. In view of the High Court’s order the NCTE-SRC cannot note or take any further action pursuant to the appellate authority’s order dated 22.5.2013.

Kindly ensure compliance with the High Court’s order in the above mentioned W.P.”

A contempt case has been received from the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in C.C no. 1485 of 2013 against W.P.M.P. No. 20201 of 2013 in W.P. No. 16657 of 2013 filed by Elim College of Education, East Godavari District, Andhra Pradesh. The Hon’ble High Court has directed to appear in person on 16.9.2013 at 10.30 a.m.

A contempt court order/appeal order along with the original file were placed before SRC 252nd meeting to be held on 13th-14th September, 2013 and the committee has decided as follows;


145


SRC order in the 247th Meeting was only to correct a factual error in its earlier order as directed by the Appellate Authority. It will still be subject to the ‘stay’ order issued and any other orders that may be passed by the Hon’ble Court in the W.P. filed by the institution”.

Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 14/19/2013.

Meantime, a judgment copy received from the Hon’ble High Court of Judicature, Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad in Writ Appeal No. 1557 of 2013 dated 11/09/2013 stating that

“the writ petitioner/respondent No. 1 shall file a written explanation to the show cause notice and the appellants shall consider such explanation and pass a speaking order, after giving an opportunity of personal hearing to the writ petitioner. This exercise shall be done within a period of three weeks from today. Of course, notice has to be given to the writ petitioner. In spite of notice, if the writ petitioner does not turn up for personal hearing, the issue will be a closed chapter. The interim order passed by the learned Single Judge shall stand set aside. Until a fresh decision is taken, the appellants shall not take any action against the writ petitioner.

Both the learned counsel for the parties submit that in view of this order nothing remains in the writ petition. Accordingly, it would be open for the parties to approach the learned Single Judge for early disposal of the writ petition in terms of this order.

The writ appeal is accordingly disposed of.”

Accordingly as per the court direction, a letter was issued to the institution 20/09/2013. Directing the petition institution to appear before SRC in its 253rd

Meeting to be scheduled on 1st October, 2013 in person at 11.00 a.m.

As per the court direction and as per the letter dated 20.09.2013, the institution has submitted its written representation (reply to Show Cause Notice dt 31.06.2011) received on 25.09.2013.

The committee considered the matter, as per the court direction a letter was issued to the institution on 20.09.2013, directing the petitioner to appear before SRC in its 253rd meeting scheduled on 1st October 2013 in person at 11.00 A.M.

The committee also considered the written representation received on 25.09.2013.

As directed by the Court, personal hearing was given to the petitioner. The correspondent of the college was not present/did not appear. The superintendent and the Telugu lecturer who appeared on behalf of

the institution were heard.

The committee advised them to give their contentions for the following:-

1) Land title for the survey number and premises where the building was constructed as per the original approved building plan.

2) Land Usage Certificate furnished is not by the competent authority and not in the prescribed format.


146


3) The Survey number and the building plan submitted now is different from the original building plan.

4) Reason for the delay in the submission of the reply for show cause notice dated 31.06.2011 (reply received only on 25.09.2013)

5) The reason for submission of new building plan and land documents if they have been continuing to occupy the same permanent building from inception as claimed by the institution before the court.

6) The reason for having paid the shifting inspection fee if no shifting was involved.

Based on the above, the SRC in its 253rd meeting held on 30th September & 1st

October 2013, decided that after receipt of their written submission to the above points, the case may be processed and put up in the next meeting for further decision.

Accordingly, a letter was sent to institution on 15.10.2013.

The institution has submitted its written representation on 23.10.2013

The Committee considered the written representation of the institution vide letter dated 23-10-2013, relevant documents of the institution, decided and noted that, the institution has shifted without prior permission from SRCNCTE. The institution has admitted this in their personal hearing given to them as per High Court direction dated 11/09/2013.

In view of the High Court direction the Committee took the decision of causing inspection of the institution (after collecting inspection fee). But, this shall not be construed as amounting to condonation of the irregularity at this stage.

80.SRCAPP930

D.EdBharathi College of Education,

Guntur District

AP

Bharathi College of Education, No. 73/1, Kanamarlapudi Village & Post, Savalyapuram Taluk, Guntur District – 522646, Andhra Pradesh.

Bharathi Educational Society, No. 1/72, 73, Potti Sriramulu Road, Vinukonda Village, Post & Taluk, Guntur District – 522647, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Bharathi Collage of Education, No. 73/1, Kanamarlapudi Village & Post, Savalyapuram Taluk, Guntur District – 522646, Andhra Pradesh for D.EL.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 28.09.2011 and physical copy received on 05.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 03.11.2011 followed by reminder on 22.12.2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29.12.2011 and the institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 24.02.2012.

The SRC in its 219th meeting held on 15th - 16th March 2012 considered the written reply of the institution vide letter dt. 24/02/2012 and other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, under Section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 09 th – 13th April 2012, the same was intimated to the institution on 30.03.2012. The inspection of


147


the institution was conducted on 27.04.2012.

The SRC in its 222nd meeting held on 09th –10th May 2012 considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show Cause Notice Under Section 14 (1) of NCTE Act for the following :

Original certified copy of the land documents from Govt. authority is not submitted. Sale deed of land document submitted is in favor of “Vasari Educational Society” and latter it was sold to “Bharathi Educational Society” on 14.09.2001.

In the building plan submitted total built up area earmarked towards the proposed course is not given.

Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. authorized engineer is not submitted.

Notarized land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the purpose of educational institution only is not submitted. Proceedings of Revenue Divisional Officer not submitted for conversion of land from agricultural to educational purposes. LUC submitted is for non-agriculture purpose only, not for education purpose.

As seen from VCD, the management is running a School in the same building, which is not permissible as per NCTE norms.

As seen from VCD, some of the class rooms, labs have been partitioned with a temporary partition (with partial board) wall without raising to the ceiling of the room.

As seen from VCD, full front view of the building is not shown.

Accordingly, Final show cause notice was issued to the institution on 13.06.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 03/07/2012.

The SRC in its 226th meeting held on 09th –10th July 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 03.07.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

As per VCD observation, the VCD is empty and not burnt, the institution is trying to mislead/cheating the NCTE.

The institution has to submit fresh VCD covering all areas of the building showing instructional and infrastructural facilities available in the building.

As seen from VCD, some of the class rooms, labs have been partitioned with a temporary partition (with partial board) wall without raising to the ceiling of the room. No documentary evidence was produced as raised in previous show cause notice.

As seen from VCD, full front view of the building is not shown.


148


Meantime, by seeing the decision in the website the institution has submitted the written representation on 09/08/2012.

The SRC in its 231st meeting held on 22-23rd August 2012, considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 09.08.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

A show cause notice was issued to the institution for submitting empty VCD, which was not burnt and the institution is trying to mislead/cheat the NCTE.

For this the institution has submitted another VCD. As seen from VCD, VCD does not contain any information like VT members inspecting the various instructional and infrastructural facilities available in the building for the proposed course, which clearly indicates the institution is not giving or showing available facilities for the course.

When the institution was inspected as per the norms, the institution should have got video graphed all the facilities along with VT members, and instead of submitting the VCD containing required information along with VT members, it has submitted only VCD without VT members.

As per the Regulations 7 (5) of 2009, which states;

“At the time of the visit of the team of experts to an institution, the institution concerned shall arrange for the inspection to be video graphed in a manner that all important infrastructural and instructional facilities are video graphed along with interaction with the management and the faculty, if available at the time of such visit. The visiting teams, as far as possible, shall finalise and courier their reports along with the video tapes on the same day.

Provided that the videography should clearly establish the outer view of the building, its surroundings, access road and important infrastructure including classrooms, labs, resource rooms, multipurpose hall, library etc. The visiting team shall ensure that the videography is done in a continuous manner, the final unedited copy of the videography is handed over to them immediately after its recording and its conversion to a CD should be done in the presence of visiting team members”.

As seen from VCD, some of the class rooms, labs have been partitioned with a temporary partition (with partial board) wall without raising to the ceiling of the room. No documentary evidence was produced as raised in previous show cause notice, for having removed the temporary partition.

As seen from VCD, the 3rd floor of the building appears to be incomplete and doctored.

The institution did not submit fresh VCD covering all areas of the building including instructional and infrastructural facilities along with VT members inspecting the building of the institution.

In the meantime, the institution has submitted its written representation on


149


31.08.2012 and 24.09.2012.

The SRC in its 233rd meeting held on 26-28th the Committee considered the show cause notice reply of the institution and vide letter dt. 24.09.2012, all other relevant documents and decided to cause Re-inspection on fresh payment of fee, under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

The inspection of the institution was fixed between 10 th – 13th December 2012. The same was intimated to institution on 03.12.2012. VT members were stated as follows:

“During the scrutiny of documents, it is observed that the Bharathi College of Education (bearing file NO. 930) managed by Bharathi Educational Society has submitted land documents for Sy.No. 73/1 in Kanamarlapudi Village. It is noted the said land was purchased on 14.09.2011 by another society Vasavi Educational Society which is also running B.Ed and D.Ed courses (SRCAPP640). Under the name and style of Vinukonda B.Ed College in the same village. While conducting inspection for SRCAPP930, you are requested to verify the existence of separate building for both the institutions along with proper examination each and every documents of the institution”.

The inspection was conducted on 11.12.2012. The VT report was received by SRC on 13.12.2012.

the SRC in its 237th Meeting held on 05th-06th January, 2013 decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit) for the academic year 2013-14 subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

Accordingly, LETTER OF INTENT was issued to the institution on 28/01/2013. The institution has submitted its written representation on 26/04/2013

The SRC in its 244th meeting held on 9th to 11th May, 2013 considered the matter, the institution has submitted reply for LOI after stipulated period of 2 months from the date of issue of LOI letter dt. 28/01/2013 and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 7(9) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to withdraw LOI issued to the institution.

As per 9 of regulations 2009 staff should be selected within 2 months of Letter of intent issued.

“The institution concerned shall be informed, through a letter of intent, regarding the decision for grant of recognition or permission subject to appointment of qualified faculty members before the commencement of the academic session. The letter of intent issued under this clause shall not be notified in the Gazette but would be sent to the institution and the affiliating body with the request that


150


the process of appointment of qualified staff as per policy of State Government or University Grants Commission or University may be initiated and the institution be provided all assistance to ensure that the staff or faculty is appointed as per National Council for Teacher Education norms within two months. The institution shall submit the list of the faculty, as approved by the affiliating body, to the Regional Committee”.

Further, the following discrepancies are found in the LOI reply.

The institution has submitted photocopy of the approved staff list . Original approved staff list duly approved by the competent authority is not submitted.

The institution has not submitted, Educational qualification certificates, Service certificate and joining report of Principal and Lecturers.

The institution has submitted two lists of staff which are totally variant in name.

Under the above with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to withdraw LOI issued to the institution.

As per the decision of SRC, the withdrawal of LOI was issued to the institution on 7.6.2013.

The institution has submitted written representation on 13.6.2013. As per the oral direction of SRC, the matter was again placed before SRC in its 249 th meeting held on 24th to 26th July, 2013 for re-consideration. The SRC has decided that the cases of LOI reply after 3.3.2013 will go for acad year 204-15. This case also would fall in that category since they had time till 28.3.2013 for reply. We have given time till December, 2013 in all such cases. Accordingly, in this case, the order dated 7.6.2013 is reviewed and formal recognition for 2014-15 is given.

Accordingly, formal recognition order was issued to the institution on 13.9.2013 for offering D.Ed course with an intake of 50 students from the academic session 2014-15.

The institution filed a court case in the Hon’ble Supreme Court, New Delhi. The Supreme Court in its order W.P© No. 811 of 2013 dated 16 th September, 2013 stating as follows “In these batch of writ petitions, the petitioner institutions have claimed relief with regard to the recognition for the academic session 2013-2014.

We have been passing various orders since May, 013, directing the National Council for Teacher Education to convert their order of recognition from the academic session 2014-2015 to 2013-2014. We are now in the middle of September, 2013 by which time as per the schedule fixed by this court the admissions to the academic session 2013-2014 should have been over and classes should have begun. We are no longer inclined to entertain any writ petition of this nature.

We, therefore, dismiss these writ petitions.”

The court order along with original file of the institution is placed before SRC for decision and direction.

The Committee has noted the matter and Hon’ble Supreme Court order


151


dated 16th Sept, 2013, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has dismissed the writ petition filed by the institution regarding relief with regard to the recognition for the academic session 2013-14.

81.APS00191 APS00028 APS02622 SRCAPP50 SRCAPP52

B.Ed M.Ed D.Ed

B.Ed-AI M.Ed-AIGhulam Ahmed

College of Education, Hyderabad

DistrictAP

Ghulam Ahmed College of Education, Road No. 3, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad District – 500034, Andhra Pradesh

Application Code

AOS00191 APS00028 APS02622 SRCAPP50

SRCAPP52

Course B.Ed M.Ed D.Ed B.Ed AI M.Ed AIDate of application

16.02.1996

28.02.1998

03.02.2004

20.10.2009

20.10.2009

Status with date

Granted Recognition on 20.09.2001



The same society had submitted two applications for same academic session. Hence the SRC had refused the application i.e. M.Ed – AI and decided to process B.Ed AI application.

Application was refused due to society applied for two courses for same academic session.

Hence, the application for M.Ed – AI course is refused on 30.04.2010.

The SRC considered the (SRCAPP50-B.Ed-Al file) in its 192nd Meeting held on 10th-11th May, 2010 and the committee also decided to serve notice under section 17 of NCTE Act, for the existing D.Ed , B.Ed & M.Ed courses for non-fulfillment of the infrastructural and instructional facilities as per NCTE norms for the following deficiencies:-

1) The institution is already having B.Ed. course, D.Ed. course and M.Ed. course. Total built-up area is 3804 sq. mtrs. As per norms of NCTE, 3500 sq.mtrs. is required for the existing courses and 500 sq.mtrs. additional built up area is required for the proposed course.

2) MBA, Law College, Junior College, Pharmacy College, a public school and Engineering College are all run in the same educational complex with no separate demarcation of land/ building for the Teacher Education courses.

Accordingly, a notice was issued to the B.Ed and M.Ed institution on 08.07.2010 and to the D.Ed course on 09.07.2010. The institution has submitted its written representation on 23.07.2010 & 27.07.2010.

The written representation was considered by the SRC in its 195 th meeting held


152


on 17th –18th August, 2010 and it was decided to cause inspection of the institution for M.Ed., B.Ed. and D.Ed. Course, under Section 17 of NCTE Act, on payment of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee for each course and on submission of filled in Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting documents relating to building, land, including Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate, within 21 days.As per the decision of SRC the letter was sent to the institution on 22.09.2010. The institution has not submitted its written representation and inspection fee after the stipulated period of 21 days.

The matter was placed before SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22-23rd February 2011 and the committee has decided to cause composite inspection of the institution for M.Ed., B.Ed. and D.Ed. Courses, under Section 17 of NCTE Act, in anticipation of payment of Rs.40,000/- inspection fee for each course and on submission of filled in Questionnaire, along with relevant supporting documents relating to building, land, including Building Completion Certificate from the competent Government Engineer and Land Use Certificate, within 21 days.Accordingly, the inspection of the institutions was fixed between 22nd-25th March 2011. The same was intimated to institution on 07.03.2011. the inspection of the institution was conducted on 24.03.2011.Meanwhile a complaint was received from the original owner of the land requesting to take stringent action against Ghulam Ahmed College of Education.In the above context a complaint letter dated 09.05.2011, has been received through CP NCTE. The complaint submitted that he is the absolute owner of ancestral property “Mount Pleasant” bearing MCH. No. 8-2-249 to 269, admeasuring Ac.24.10 gts, Road No.3, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad, Which is governed by a family trust in the name of his father Prince MuazzamJah.By adopting fraudulent methods, a society by name Ul-Uloom education society took possession of above said ancestral property and started college of B.Ed, M.Ed and D.Ed., by name Ghulam Ahmed College of Education. The owner neither signed a lease agreement nor have sold the land to the said society. The owner came to know the society has given a wrong declaration to NCTE that society have perfect title over the property which is absolutely false. The society has also lost all cases filled against the owner family in the civil and High courts. Therefore the owner request to enquire into the matter and ascertain the truth.Complaint of Himayath Ali Mirza is placed before SRC in its 210th meeting held on 22nd-23rd August 2011 along with the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act.Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 28.10.2011. the institution has submitted its written representation on 28.11.2011.The SRC in its 217th meeting held on 08th – 09th February 2012 has considered the reply of the institution dt. 28.11.2011, VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act, for the following:1) The multipurpose hall size is only 900 sq.ft, which is less than NCTE norms.

The institution has not submitted any proof of multi purpose hall being increased nor its measurements.

2) Building completion certificate from competent authorized Govt. engineer is not submitted. The column Nos. 5 & 6 are left blank. In the copy of the building completion certificate submitted, type of roofing is not mentioned, whether it is RCC or Asbestos sheet roofing.

3) Original Affidavit on Rs. 100/- stamp paper in the prescribed format with notary attestation to be submitted.

4) Encumbrance certificate submitted by the institution is not readable, fresh


153


Non-encumbrance certificate from the competent Government authorized person is to be submitted.

5) In the land documents submitted, survey numbers are not clear and visible properly. Certified copy of registered land document in favour Society/institution is required with Sy.No. Location and extent clearly mentioned.

6) The institution has to submit the latest purchase bills for strengthening of Science lab, E.T. lab and Psychology lab.

7) Certificate from Govt. department/University for details of the other programme/courses run by the management in the same building/premises is not submitted.

8) Status of property dispute is to be submitted with relevant documents.

Accordingly, a final show cause notice was issued to the institution on 14.03.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 04.04.2012.The SRC in its 233rd Meeting held on 26th – 28th September 2012, considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 04.04.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:1) Land documents submitted are not in the name of the Society/Institution and

Sy.Nosare different and not matching with other documents submitted.2) Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. authorized

engineer is not submitted. 3) Encumbrance certificate submitted is not clear/readable, Sy.Nos. are

different.4) The institution has submitted purchase bills for strengthening of Science lab,

E.T. lab and Psychology lab, out of which some bills are old bills only.5) Certificate from Govt. department/University for details of the other

programmes/courses run by the management in the same building/premises is not submitted.

Accordingly, a final Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 30.10.2012, Before the reply i.e. on 13.11.2012 a complaint from KazeniHussain, Secretary, NIGAH, Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh was received against Sultan-ul-Uloom Educational Society. The institution has submitted its Final Show Cause Notice reply on 15.11.2012.The SRC in its 236th meeting held on 16th –17th December 2012 has considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 15.11.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act.Accordingly, Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 05.02.2013. The institution has submitted the reply to notice on 07.02.2013.

The SRC in its 244th Meeting held on 09th – 11th May, 2013 considered the matter and advised Southern Regional Office to re-examine these cases and to put up a comprehensive note for all 5 cases. i.e, D.Ed/B.Ed/M.Ed/D.Ed-Al &B.Ed-Al courses. In the 247th SRC meeting with APS0 nos. in a comparative format.Required built up area for B.Ed + D.Ed + M.Ed + B.Ed - AI - 3500 Sq. MtsRequired land area for B.Ed + D.Ed + M.Ed + B.Ed – AI - 3500 Sq. MtsAs per the Notice reply dt. 23.07.2010 submitted by the society, the B.Ed, M.Ed and D.Ed are running in the same building and the institution is running the B.Ed, D.Ed and M.Ed courses by separately demarcating the land/building.


154


The details of the land and building are as follows.

VT Report As per the VT Report (Inspection conducted on 24.03.2011) total built up area for proposed and existing courses is 43,722.33 Sq. Fts at 8-2-249, Mount Pleasant Road, No. 3, Banjara Hills Post Office, Hyderabad District – 500 034, Andhra Pradesh. (Page no. 181).

Building Completion Certificate BCC dt. 19.11.2011 TS No. 2/1, 2/2, 2/3 (Old No. 129) at Shaikpet Village and Mandal, Banjara Hills. Total Built up area – 4062 Sq. Mts RCC. The SRC in its two notices directed the institution to submit BCC issued by Competent Govt. Engineer and the institution had submitted BCC in every reply but none of it is issued by Govt Engineer. (Page No. 265, 339 and 509)

Building Plan As per the building plan submitted by the institution, total built up area is 4062 Sq. Mts for D.Ed, M.Ed, B.Ed colleges. (page no. 340).As per the site map submitted, earmarked area for D.Ed, B.Ed and M.Ed is 4046 Sq. Mts (Page No. 314)Submitted building plan and Site Plan are not approved by Competent Authority.

Land documents The institution has submitted land documents wherein the schedule of the land and favour of the land are not legible properly. Hence the institution is required to submit notarized translated version of the same.

Land documents submitted are not in the name of the Society/Institution SRC had directed the institution to clarify the same in its Notice dt. 05.02.2013 and the institution stated that “we are the owners of the said property and are in possession of the same since 1980. Enclosed please find the Order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India ordering “Status Quo” regarding possession of the property and refer Para 5 for details.

Hence the land documents are not


155


in Society/Institution name. Encumbrance Certificate Copy of EC Submitted for H No. C4-

G2-249 to 267, Plot No. 29, Survey No. 129.Extent – 24-10 Ac. Gts at Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad District, Andhra Pradesh.EC from 1st day of Jan 1954 to 31st

day of Dec 1958 i.e. for only 5 years. Up to date EC not submitted. (page no. 508)

Land Usage Certificate. LUC dt. 18.01.2003 issued by Vice Hairman, HUDA is submitted for No. 8-2-249 at Road No. 3, Banjara hills and earmarked for Partly Residential use Zone, Partly Public and Semi Public use (Educational proposed high school) and partly affected proposed 80 feed wide roads. Submitted LUC is not legible properly and not converted purely for educational purpose.

Accordingly, a comparative statement was placed before SRC in its 250 th

Meeting held on 11th-13th August, 2013 considered the above matter and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to Withdraw recognition for B.Ed.(APS00191), D.Ed.(APS02622) and M.Ed (APS00028) programmes for the following deficiencies:-

1 Institution is required to establish Title to land.2 Building Plan is not issued by competent authority.3 Building Completion Certificate is not approved by competent

authority.

Based on the above points the committee decided to withdraw the recognition of the B.Ed.(APS00191), D.Ed.(APS02622) and M.Ed. (APS00028) courses run by Ghulam Ahmed College of Education, Hyderabad District, Andhra Pradesh with effect from the academic year 2013-14 in order to enable the ongoing batch of students, if any, to complete their course.

But it is made clear that the institution is debarred from making any further admission subsequent to the date of issue of this order. The Affiliating body / Examining board / body be informed accordingly.

Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore if any.

Before issuance of Withdrawal Order of SRC, a court order has been received from the Hon’ble High Court of Judicature of Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad WPMP No. 34083 of 2013 in W.P.No. 27499 of 2013 stating that

“…Heard Sri S. Niranjan Reddy, learned counsel for the petitioners and Sri K. Ramakanth Reddy, on behalf of the respondents 1 & 2 and on behalf of the 4th respondent – Sri Deepak Bhattacharjee accepted notice.


156


This writ petition is filed aggrieved by the decision of the SRC of NCTE at its meeting held on 11th to 13th August, 2013 whereat, resolution withdrawing the recognition for the B.Ed, D.Ed and M.Ed courses run by the 2nd petitioner-college, with effect from the academic year 2013-2014, was passed. The only sustainable objection of the SRC to withdraw the recognition granted to the 2nd petitioner-college earlier was that the institution could not establish its title to the land. It is true that it has also raised two other objections namely the building plan was not issued by the competent authority and the building completion certificate is not approved by the competent authority. So for as the latter 2 objections are concerned, they were immediately neutralized with reference to the building permission accorded by the municipal corporation of Hyderabad and completion certificate was also accorded. Therefore, those two objections cannot hold valid.

With regard to the failure to establish title to the land is concerned, learned counsel for the petitioner has drawn my attention to the judgment rendered by this court in W.P.No. 1196 of 2012 on 27.01.2012 to which the 1st petitioner-society is respondent No. 4 in the said writ petition, the issue relating to the title of the land in question has been gone into. During the course of the said judgment, this court has noticed that from the year 1980 onwards, the 4th respondent-society therein, which is the 3rd petitioner herein has been running several educational institutions and that the litigation in the city civil court at the instance of the writ petitioner in that case and others has started only in the year 2006 and hence, the writ petitioner was declared as a person who cannot feel aggrieved for the extension of approval secured by the 4th respondent therein for the courses run and operated by it. When a writ appeal was preferred and an interlocutory application was taken out, the said application was dismissed by a division bench of this court on 28.02.2012.

This apart, when the matter was carried to supreme court against the judgment rendered on 20.04.2009 by this court in city civil court appeal no. 196 of 2006, by the first petitioner-society, the Supreme Court while issuing notice thereon by its order dated 20.11.2009 directed the status-quo to be maintained with regard to the possession of the land in question. In view of these developments, the infirmity pointed out by the SRC, NCTE for withdrawing the recognition granted to the 2nd petitioner-institution cannot be sustained as of now. Hence the operation of the decision taken by the 2nd respondent in its 250th meeting during 11th to 13th August, 2013 is suspended.”

A court notice has been received on 11.10.2013 in W.P.No.27499 of 2013 with a direction that the respondent no.2 (i.e. SRC-NCTE) do appear personally or by advocate on 28th October 2013 at 10.30.

A letter from NCTE H-qrs received on 17.10.2013 with a direction to file an appeal for vacation of stay immediately against the court order in W.P.M.P. No.34083 of 2013 in W.P.No.27499 of 2013

Accordingly, a letter to the advocate sent on 24.10.2013 under intimation to NCTE-Hqrs.


157


Note: As per the Notice reply dt. 23.07.2010 submitted by the society, the B.Ed, M.Ed and D.Ed are running in the same building and the institution is running the B.Ed, D.Ed and M.Ed courses by separately demarcating the land/building.


82.SRCAPP179

8B.Ed-AIServite

College of Education

for Women, Karur

DistrictTN

Servite College of Education for Women, Therkupallam, Thogamalai Village & P.O., Kulithalai Taluka, Karur District, Pin - 621313, Tamilnadu

The Society of Servite Rural Academy, Therkupallam Road, Thogamalai Village & P.O., Kulithalai Taluka, Karur District, Pin - 621313, Tamilnadu had applied for grant of recognition to Servite College of Education for Women, Therkupallam, Thogamalai Village & P.O., Kulithalai Taluka, Karur District, Pin - 621313, Tamilnadu for B.Ed-AI Course for one year duration under Section 15 of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 11.12.2012. The institution has submitted hard copy of the application on 19.12.2012 along with processing fees paid through challan dt.12.12.2012 for Rs.50100/-.

Para 7[1-A(i)] and 7[1-A(ii)] of extant NCTE Regulations published in the Gazettee of India on 31st August 2009, as amended from time to time, the application shall be summarily rejected under one or more of the following circumstances:

Para 7[1-A(i)]

(a) The processing fee, as provided under rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application;


(c) Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society/institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application.

Para 7[1-A(ii)]

The Regional Committee shall, after recording reasons for rejection under the circumstances referred to in clause (i) above, return the application to the applicant and refund the processing fees within 30 days of the online submission of the application.

The SRC in its 238th meeting held on 05th -06th February, 2013 reviewed the duly scrutinized above new application received by Southern Regional Office, NCTE for the Session 2013-14. Accordingly, the above application, which suffer from basic infirmities, is summarily rejected as per Regulations [ 7 1–A (i) ].

On-line application was submitted on 11.12.2012, whereas the hard copy of the same is submitted on 19.12.2012, as such, the Society has not dispatched the Hard copy of the application within 7 days of the submission of the on-line application.

Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the institution on 18.03.2013.


158


A brief of the case was sent to the advocate on 28.03.2013.

SRC, NCTE is in receipt of letter dtd.05.08.2013 alongwith the Madurai Bench of Madras High Court dtd. 01.07.2013 in W.P. (MD) Nos.3684 and 3685 of 2013 and M.P.(MD) Nos. 1 and 2 of 2013 reads as under:-

“…… the applications for recognition for the academic year 2013 to 2014 submitted belatedly have been rejected. Therefore, the writ petitioners have to make fresh applications in terms of the time schedule provided for recognition and affiliation. If any such application is made to the Regional Director/Chairman, Southern Regional Committee, National Council for Teacher Education, Bangalore, the same shall be considered in accordance with the statutory provisions, taking note of the requirements for grant of recognition, for the academic year 2014-2015.

The writ petitions are disposed of accordingly. Consequently, the connected miscellaneous petitions are closed. No costs”.

The Committee considered the matter, decided that, according to NCTE Notification dated 01/07/2013 only Government Institutions are allowed to apply for 2014-15. This being a private institution, therefore, this application can not be considered for 2014-15. Also advised Southern Regional Office to return the fee and close the case.

83.APS00887 APS05081 APS03622 APS07543

D.T.Ed D.T.Ed-AI

B.Ed M.EdLuise James

Teacher Training Institute

and Luise James


Kanyakumari District

TN

Luise James Teacher Training Institute and Luise James College of Education, Manavilai, Kappiyarai Post, Kanyakumari District-629156, Tamilnadu

Luise James Teacher Training Institute and Luise James College of Education, Manavilai, Kappiyarai Post, Kanyakumari District-629156, Tamilnadu had submitted the applications for D.T.Ed Course on 30.12.2002 and D.T.Ed-AI course on 30.12.2005. The institution was granted recognition for D.T.Ed course on 16.09.2004 with an intake of 50 students and D.T.Ed-AI course on 23.12.2006 thus making an annual intake of 100 students, which includes the existing intake of 50 and an additional intake of 50 students. Further, the institution had submitted the applications for B.Ed course on 30.12.2004 and M.Ed course on 10.10.2006. The institution was granted recognition for B.Ed course on 02.11.2005 with an annual intake of 100 students and M.Ed course on 13.07.2007 with an annual intake of 25 students and as per the NCTE notification the intake of M.Ed course was increased from 25 to 35 vide order dt. 01.09.2010, with the condition to shift to own premises within 3 years.

The management is also running B.Ed & M.Ed courses in the same building.

The institution vide its letter dated 24.04.2009 submitted Rs. 40,000/- for shifting of premises. Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 18th-23rd April 2011. The same was intimated to the institution on 12.042011. Accordingly, shifting inspection of the institution was conducted on 22.04.2011.

The SRC in its 205th meeting held on 18th-19th May, 2011 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show Cause Notice for all the Four courses under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to institution on 27.06.2011. The institution had submitted its reply on 27.07.2011


159


The SRC in its 211th meeting held on 21st-23rd September, 2011 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Final Show Cause Notice under Section 17 of NCTE Act. Accordingly, a Final Show cause notice was issued to the institution on 15.11.2011. The institution had submitted its written representation on 14.12.2011.

The SRC in its 216th meeting held on 11th-12th January, 2012 considered the written reply of the institution vide letter dt. 14.12.2011 on the above matter and also the relevant documents of the institution and noted that the deficiencies still persists and decided to withdraw recognition of all the four courses for the following reasons:-

1. Documentary proof is not submitted to show the registered land document in the name of Society, for the survey numbers where the institution is located.

2. The earmarked Built up area for each course D.T.Ed, D.T.Ed-Al & B.Ed & M.Ed course not submitted.

3. Building completion certificate in the prescribed format from competent authorized Government engineer is not submitted.

4. The institution in its reply has stated that B.Ed and M.Ed courses are in separate land & building. The details of the land, approved building plan, building completion certificate and earmarked built up area is not submitted.

5. Non-encumbrance certificate from the competent authority in English version is not submitted.

6. Original FDRs for Rs. 5lacs and 3lacs towards Endowment and Reserve fund respectively from a Nationalised Bank in joint account for D.Ed, D.Ed-Al, B.Ed & M.Ed course is not submitted. The institution has submitted only two FDR’s of 5 lacs and 3 lacs each from Tamilnadu Merchantile Bank Ltd., which is not a Nationalised Bank and not as per NCTE norms.

7. No documentary proof is submitted for starting of language learning laboratory.

The reply of the institution is not convincing and not satisfactory.

Bsed on the above grounds, the committee decided not to permit shifting and further decided to withdraw the recognition of the four courses viz: D.T.Ed (APS00887), D.T.Ed-Al (APS05081),run by Luise James Teacher training Institute, Manavilai, Kappiyarai Post, Kanyakumari District – 629156, Tamilnadu & B.Ed (APS03622) & M.Ed (APS07543) course run by James Memorial Charitable Trust, Mananvilai, Near Karungal, Kappiyarai Post Kanyakumari-629156, Tamilnadu, from the academic year 2012-13, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in all the courses, if any to complete their course.

Accordingly, withdrawal order was issued to the institution on 27.02.2012.

The Hon’ble High Court of Madras vide interim order dt. 04.05.2012 in W.P. no. 12872 of 2012 and M.P. no. 2 of 2012 filed by Luise James Teacher Training Institute and James College of Education reads as follows:-

“…… these petitions coming on for orders upon perusing the petitions and the respective affidavits filed in support thereof and upon hearing the argument of Mr.S.Doraisamy, for M/s.C.Robert Bruce, Advocate for the


160


petitioner in both the petitions the court made the following order:-

Notice of motion returnable in six weeks. Private notice is also permitted.

Interim stay of the operation of the impugned Act till then”.

Accordingly, a letter sent to the Advocate Sri K.Ramakrishna Reddy on 05.06.2012 to defend the case. A counter affidavit was sent to the advocate on 23.07.2012.

A letter has been received from Sri K.Ramakrishna Reddy on16.10.2012 and has requested for original inspection report for producing the same before the Hon’ble Court. Accordingly, original VT report sent to the Advocate on 17.10.2012.

Interim order dtd. 31.10.2012 reads as under:-

“….. learned counsel for the third respondent (SRC-NCTE, Bangalore) submitted that there are some mistakes while passing orders by the third respondent (SRC-NCTE Bangalore) and he will get the list of deficiencies to be complied with by the management and he has sought for time till Monday, i.e on 05.11.2012, to get particulars.

…….. post on 05.11.2012. Interim order already granted by this Court is extended till then”.

Further, an email has been received from Advocate on 16.11.2012 regarding factual position as per records for grounds of withdrawal. Accordingly, a letter was sent to the Advocate on 20.11.2012 with the following facts.

Sl.No. Grounds of rejection

Factual position as per records

Remarks

1. Documentary proof is not submitted to show the registered land document in the name of Society, for the survey numbers where the institution is located.

The institution has submitted photocopies of the Sale deeds1) dt.

16.06.2004 in favour of Luise James Teacher Training Institute at sy no. 481/5A, 5C, 6,7,8C, 10B, 11, 13C, 4C Kappiyara Village, Kalkulam Taluk, Kanyakumari District for extent of 1

Copy of certified land documents is not submitted.


161


Acres 61 cents.

2) dt. 22.12.2004 in favour of James Memorial Charitable Trust at sy no. 481/8A, 481/9A, 498/5, 480/14 Kappaiyarai Village, Kalkulam Taluk, Kanyakumari District for extent of 1 acres 54 cents

2. The earmarked Built up area for each course D.T.Ed, D.T.Ed-Al & B.Ed & M.Ed course not submitted.

The institution has submitted the photocopies of building plan course wise and Building completion certificate details are given below:-1) D.T.Ed and

D.T.Ed-AI course building plan approved by the Secretary, Kappiyarai Village Panchayat plan showing Luise James Teacher Training Institute (run by James Memorial Charitable Trust) Mananvilai in sy no. 481/5A, 4C & 5C of Kappiyarai

Original Building Completion Certificate is not submitted. Copy of the BCC is also not approved by competent authority for D.T.Ed/D.T.Ed-AI and B.Ed/Med courses.

Total built up area is not matching with building plan (B.Ed & M.Ed course).

Land details are also not tallying in Building plan, BCC and land documents.

Building plans are submitted in 4 sheets and 10 sheets for D.T.Ed/D.T.Ed-AI and B.Ed/M.Ed courses respectively.


162


Village and Town Panchayat for D.T.Ed and D.T.Ed-AI courses with total land area of 24403.48 sq.ft and total built up area is 23031.19 sq.ft.

2) B.Ed and M.Ed course building plan approved by the Secretary, Kappiyarai Village Panchyat plan showing James College of Education, Mananvilai, Kappiyarai at sy no. 480/14, 481/8A, 9A, 13A1 in Kappiyarai Special Village Panchayat, Kalkulam Taluk, Kanyakumari District with total land area of 2083.98 sq.mts or 22423.62 sq.ft and total built up area is 1872.22 sq.mts or 20209.48 sq.ft.

3) D.T.Ed & D.T.Ed-AI – Building completion

Blue Print are not originally approved by the competent authority.


163


certificate dtd. 26.11.2011 issued by Chartered Engineer at sy no. 481/4C, 5A, 5C, 6,7, 8C, 10B, 11, 13C of Kappiarai Village for Luise James Teacher Training Institute of D.T.Ed and D.T.Ed-AI course with total built up area is 24403.50 sq.ft

4) B.Ed & M.Ed – Building completion certificate dtd. 26.11.2011 issued by Chartered Engineer at R. sy no. 480/14, 481/8A, 481/9A, 481/13A, 498/5, 498/6 of Kappaiarai Village for James College of Education – B.Ed and M.Ed course with total built up area is 42293.64 sq.ft

3. Building completion certificate in the prescribed format from competent authorized


164


Government engineer is not submitted.

4. The institution in its reply has stated that B.Ed and M.Ed courses are in separate land & building. The details of the land, approved building plan, building completion certificate and earmarked built up area is not submitted.

5. Non-encumbrance certificate from the competent authority in English version is not submitted.

The institution has submitted the English version translated notarized copy of Non-Encumbrance certificate dtd. 26.07.2011 issued by Sub-Registrar, Palliyadi, at sy no. 481/5, 5A, 5C, 6,7,8C, 10, 10B, 11, 13 Kappiyarai for a period of 4 years from 01.01.2004 to 12.09.2007.

Photocopy of translated English version of Non-Encumbrance certificate for the period from 01.01.2004 to 12.09.2007 was submitted. The institution has not submitted up-to-date the Non-Encumbrance certificate along with its original notarized English version.

6. Original FDRs for Rs. 5lacs and 3lacs towards Endowment and Reserve fund respectively from a Nationalised Bank in joint account for D.Ed, D.Ed-Al, B.Ed & M.Ed course is not submitted. The institution has submitted only two FDR’s of 5 lacs and 3 lacs each from

The institution has submitted the photocopy of FDR’s details are given below.1) D.T.Ed–

FDRs for Rs. 5 lacs and 3 lacs FDR A/C no. 67165477239 and 67165493273 respectively from State Bank of Travancore,

Original FDRs are not submitted.


165


Tamilnadu Merchantile Bank Ltd., which is not a Nationalised Bank and not as per NCTE norms.

Colachel-7012 for a period of 7years from 28.11.2011 to 28.11.2018 in joint account.

2) D.T.Ed –AI - FDRs for Rs. 5 lacs and 3 lacs FDR A/C no. 67166328300 and 67166328195 respectively from State Bank of Travancore, Colachel-7012 for a period of 5years from 28.11.2011 to 28.11.2016 in joint account.

3) B.Ed - FDRs for Rs. 5 lacs and 3 lacs FDR A/C no. 671654486244 and 67165493455 respectively from State Bank of Travancore, Colachel-7012 for a period of 7years from 28.11.2011 to 28.11.2018 in joint account.

4) M.Ed - FDRs for Rs. 5 lacs and 3 lacs FDR A/C no. 67166328435 and 67166328264 respectively from State Bank of Travancore,


166


Colachel-7012 for a period of 5years from 28.11.2011 to 28.11.2016 in joint account.

7. No documentary proof is submitted for starting of language learning laboratory.

The institution has submitted the photograph of language learning laboratory.

Bills for purchase of equipments to language learning lab and photos submitted.

The Hon’ble court of Madras vide interim order dt. 21.11.2012 in W.P.No. 12872 of 2012 reads as follows:-

“……. these petitions coming on for orders upon perusing the petitions and the respective affidavits filed in support thereof and upon hearing the arguments of Mr.S.Doraisamy, for M/S. C.Robert Bruce, Advocate for the petitioner in both the petitions and of Mr.G.Anantharangan, Advocate for the 2nd respondents (The Registrar, Tamilnadu Teachers Education University, Lady Wellington College Campus, Kamarajar Salai, Chennai-5) in both the petitions the court made the following orders:-

At request of learned counsel for NCTE, Post the matter after one week.

Interim order already granted is extended”.

Further, the Hon’ble court of Madras vide interim order dt. 27.11.2012 in W.P.No. 12872 of 2012 reads as follows:-

“Post on 03.12.2012.

Interim order to continue till then”.


“ Interim stay already granted on 04.05.2012 is to continue for a period of three months”.


“ ………. the Chief Educational officer amounts to committing contempt of court. However, this Court is willing to take a lenient view and a direction is issued to the first respondent (DTERT, Chennai) to take suitable action against the Chief Educational Officer, Kanyakumari District for issuing such a letter contrary to the interim order of this court. The first respondent (DTERT, Chennai) is directed to report about the action taken against the Chief Educational Officer, when the matter is taken up after six weeks. Interim stay already granted is extended until further orders”.


167



“……. The impugned order was passed based on the inspection report. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has strenuously submitted that if the inspection report is produced that could establish that the impugned order is contrary to the same. The same submission was also made on the earlier occasion. Hence this court on 10.10.2012 directed the learned counsel for the respondents to produce the inspection report based on which the final order passed and the matter was posted on 18.10.2012. When the matter was called on 19.10.2012, the inspection report was not produced. Thereafter, the matter was posted on 05.11.2012. Again the same was posted on 09.11.2012, 2012, 21.11.2012 and 27.11.2012. In the said circumstances, the writ petition was admitted on 04.12.2012 recording that in spite of granting time to produce the inspection report, the same is yet to be produced. Thereafter, the matter was listed on 20.12.2012 and today. But the inspection report is yet to be produced. The action of the respondent authority is highly contemn able is not producing the inspection report. Hence, a direction is issued to the respondents to produce the inspection report based on which the final order was passed, failing which serious view will be taken by this Court. Learned counsel for the third respondent (SRC-NCTE ,Bangalore) seeks time to produce the inspection report which is highly deprecated. Post the matter after six weeks for production of the inspection report by the respondents”.

The institution has submitted the following documents on 22.02.2013, 25.02.2013 and 27.03.2013 alongwith interim order dtd. 31.10.2012 and the details are given below:-

Sl. No.

Particulars Remarks

1. Certified Copy of Land Documents

The institution has submitted certified copy of land documents and translated version land documents dtd. 16.06.2004 in favour of Luise James Teacher Training Institute, at sy no. 481/5A, 5C, 6, 7,8C, 10B, 11, 13C, 4C, Kappiyara Village, Kalkulam Taluk, Kanyakumari District for total extent of Acre 1.61 cents for D.T.Ed and D.T.Ed-AI courses. Further, the institution has submitted certified copy of land documents and translated version Sale Deed dtd. 22.12.2004 in favour of James Memorial Charitable Trust at sy no. 481/A for total extent of 12 cents or 5227.50 sq.ft, 481/9A for total extent of 10 cents or 8712 sq.ft and 480/14, 7 for total extent of 42 cents or 18295.20 sq.ft all laying as single plot having extent of 1 acre 54 cents or 67300.20 sq.ft or 6252.39 sq.mts, Kappiyarai Village, Kalkulam Taluk, Kanyakumari District for B.Ed and M.Ed Courses.

2. Building Plan The institution has submitted blue print of


168


building plan approved by competent authority is in Regional Language at sy no. 480/14, 481/8A, 9A, 13A1 of Kappiyarai Village and Special Village Panchayat, Kalkulam Taluk, Kanyakumari District with total plinth area of 2083.98 sq.mts or 22423.62 sq.ft and total floor area of 1872.22 sq.mts or 20209.64 sq.ft for M.Ed and B.Ed Courses.

Further, the institution has submitted photocopy of building plan approved by the Executive Engineer, Kapriyai Town Panchayat at sy no. 498/6, Kappiyari Village and Town Panchayat with total site area of 2137.25 sq.mts or 22996.81 sq.ft for James College of Education.

Another, the institution has submitted photocopy of approved by the Consulting Engineer at sy no. 481/5A, 4C & 5C of Kappiyarai Village in Kappiyarai Town Panchayat with total site area of 4600 sq.mts or 49496 sq.ft and total plinth area of 2272.78 sq.mts or 24403.48 sq.ft and total floor area of 2140.42 sq.mts or 23031.1 sq.ft for D.T.Ed and D.T.Ed-AI Course. Building Plan not approved by the Competent authority.

3. Building Completion Certificate

The institution has submitted original Building Completion certificate dtd. 26.11.2011 issued by the Chartered Engineer at sy no. 481/4C, 5A, 5C, 6,7,8C, 10B, 11, 13C of Kapplarai Village with total built up area of 24403.50 sq.ft for D.T.Ed and D.T.Ed-AI Courses.Further, the institution has submitted original Building Completion Certificate dtd. 26.11.2011 issued by the Charted Engineer at sy no. 480/14, 481/8A, 481/9A, 481/13A, 498/5, 498/6 of Kappiarai with total built up area of 42293.64 sq.ft for B.Ed and M.Ed Courses.

4. Non-Encumbrance Certificate

The institution has submitted original and English version Non-Encumbrance Certificate details are given below:-1) 26.07.2011-issued by the Sub-Registrar,

Palliyadi at sy no. 481/5, 481/5A, 481/5C, 481/6, 481/7, 481/8C, 481/10, 481/10B, 481/11, 481/13, Kappiyarai for a period of 4 years from 01.01.2004 to 12.09.2007.

2) 06.11.2012-issued by the Sub-Registrar, Palliyadi at sy no. 481/5, 481/5A, 481/5C, 481/6, 481/7, 481/8C, 481/10, 481/10B, 481/11, 481/13, 481/13C, 481/14, 481/14C Kappiyarai for a period of 5 years from 01.01.2007 to 31.12.2011.

3) 02.11.2012 – issued by the Sub-Registrar, Palliyadi at sy no. 481/5, 481/5A, 481/5C, 481/6, 481/7, 481/8, 481/8C, 481/10,


169


481/10B, 481/11, 481/13, 481/13C, 481/14, 481/14C, Kappiyarai for a period of 2 years from 01.01..2011 to 01.11.2012.

4) 02.11.2012 – issued by the Sub-Registrar, Palliyadi at sy no. 481/4, 481/8A, 481/9, 481/9A, 481/13, 481/13A, 498/5, 498/6, 480/14, Kappiyarai for a period of 15 years from 01.01.1998 to 01.11.2012.

5. FDRs The institution has submitted FDRs of Rs. 5 lacs and Rs. 3 lacs course wise details are given below:-1) FDRs of Rs. 5 lacs and Rs. 3 lacs FDR no.

67165477239, and 67165493273, from State Bank of Travancore for a period of 7 years from 28.11.2011 to 28.11.2018 for D.T.Ed Course.

2) FDRs of Rs. 5 lacs and Rs. 3 lacs FDR no. 67166328300 and 67166328195 from State Bank of Travancore for a period of 5 years from 05.12.2011 to 05.12.2016 for D.T.Ed-AI Course.

3) FDRs of Rs. 5 lacs and Rs. 3 lacs FDR no. 67165486244 and 67165493455 from State Bank of Travancore for a period of 7 years from 28.11.2011 to 28.11.2018 for B.Ed Course.

4) FDRs of Rs. 5 lacs and Rs. 3 lacs FDR no. 67166328435 and 67166328264 from State Bank of Travancore for a period of 5 years from 05.12.2011 to 05.12.2016 for M.Ed Course.

5) FDRs of Rs. 5 lacs and Rs. 3 lacs FDR no. 67166328300 and 67166328195 from State Bank of Travancore for a period of 5 years from 05.12.2011 to 05.12.2016 for D.T.Ed-AI Course.

6) FDRs of Rs. 5 lacs and Rs. 3 lacs FDR no. 67033697471 and 67166328264 from State Bank of Travancore for a period of 5 years from 05.12.2011 to 05.12.2016 for B.Ed-AI Course

6. Purchase Bills The institution has submitted original bills for purchase of Equipments for Language Learning Lab and Photograph for all courses.

The matter was placed before SRC in its 248th Meeting held on 13th-15th July, 2013 and SRC decided to File an affidavit as indicated and submit VT inspection Report copy along with it.

Accordingly, affidavit alongwith original inspection report has been sent to Shri Ramakrishna Reddy on 19.07.2013. In reply, the advocate has sent letter to SRC on 25.07.2013 and has stated that “ each High Court got its own procedure. It is a settled law that procedure of the Court is the law of the Court. As per the said procedure a detailed counter affidavit along with vacate stay petition. M.P.No.3 of 2012 was filed”.


170


The SRC in its 250th Meeting held on 11th-13th August, 2013 has considered the matter and advised Southern Regional Office to send reply to Advocate’s letter asking him to get remarks of the Court expunged. Accordingly, a letter was sent to the Advocate on 20.08.2013.

In reply, Shri K. Ramakrishna Reddy, Advocate has sent a letter on 29.08.2013.

The Committee considered the matter and decided to take action according to decisions taken in the last meeting, i.e, in 253 rd meeting held on 30th Sept & 01st Oct, 2013.

“In the 253rd meeting the members raised the issue relating to institution Luise James Teacher Training Institute and Luise James College of Education, Manavilai, Kapiyarai Post, Kanyakumari District – 629156, Tamilnadu. The issue related to mishandling of the case by SRO’s Lawyer Shri Ramakrishna Reddy. The Committee after discussing the matter decided as under:

1. In case No. (APS00887-D.T.Ed, APS05081-D.T.Ed-Al, APS03622-B.Ed & APS07543-M.Ed) relating to institution Luise James Teacher Training Institute and Luise James College of Education, Manavilai, Kapiyarai Post, Kanyakumari District-629156, Taminadu, application for grant of recognition to their D.T.Ed course on 30-12-2002, for D.T.Ed-Al on 30-12-2005, for B.Ed course on 30-12-2004 & for M.Ed course on 10-10-2006, the SRC and SRO have had to face avoidable embarrassment and hardships because of poor handling of the case by SRO’s Lawyer (Shri. Ramakrishna Reddy).

2. Inspite of repeated directions from the Court he did not file a copy of the VT Inspection report despite his having the report as sent by SRC. Also, inspite of repeated instructions from SRC/SRO, he failed to file an appeal. Instead of carrying out instructions in the best interests of the client he has been dilly dallying with meaningless prevariations.

3. After careful consideration of the details pertaining to this matter, SRC gave the following directions:

(i). The services of Shri. Ramakrishna Reddy as the Lawyer of SRC/SRO should be terminated with immediate effect.

(ii). A suitable Lawyer to replace him, should be indentified and appointed.

(iii). An appeal should be filed in the case as already decided for getting the strictures against the SRC impunged and to get th petition filed by the institution dismissed.

84. APS08991B.EdS.V.I


S.V.I College of Education, Ward No. 39, E.Podur, Trichirapalli District – 620012, Tamilnadu.

Sangamirdham Social Trust, Trichirapalli District, Tamilnadu had submitted an application for B.Ed course on 19.09.2007 to the Southern Regional Committee


171


Trichirapalli District

TN

of NCTE for grant of recognition to S.V.I College of Education, Ward No. 39, E.Podur, Trichirapalli District – 620012, Tamilnadu with an annual intake of 100 students. The institution was granted conditional recognition for starting B.Ed course on 28.03.2008.

The SRC NCTE received a letter from the institution on 20.02.22013 along with D.D. of Rs. 50000/-No. 770084 dated 15.02.2013 issued by Indian Bank stating “changing the S.V.I. College of Education name into Nalanda College of Education.

Resolution No.36

Today, as per the direction given by Mrs. I.All, M.A., M.Ed, Chairperson of Sangamirdham Social Trust was conducted a special meeting with all other trustees at 67, Madurai Main Road, Crawford, Trichy-12 at 5.00 pm and the following decisions are taken.

1. This trust running B.Ed college in the name of S.V.I. College of Education (APS08991). Now, because of Administrative reasons the trust has changed the college name from S.V.I. College of Education into Nalanda College of Education.

2. All the decisions & signing authorities regarding to change the name of the institute to State Government, Central Government, NCTE, Tamilnadu Teacher Education University and all Private & Government Sectors are given to Mrs. I. Alli, M.A.M.Ed, Chairperson of Sangamirdham Social Trust”.

Further, the SRC NCTE received letter from the institution on 28.02.2013 along with documents and D.D. of Rs. 50000/- , No. 770083 dated 15.02.2013 issued by the Indian Bank stating that “we are shifting the premises as per NCTE norms from temporary premises to the permanent premises”.The SRC in its 244th meeting held on 09th -11th May, 2013 considered the written reply of the institution on the above matter and also the relevant documents of the institution and decided to withdraw recognition for the following reasons:-

The institution was given recognition on 28.03.2008 in a temporary premises with a specific condition that the institution should move to a permanent premise within a period of three years i.e., on or before 28.03.2008. The institution as per their letter dt. 28.02.2013 has shifted to permanent premises without the prior permission of NCTE.As per 8 (11) of NCTE regulations 2009, prior approval is necessary for change of premises. The regulations states as under:

“ In case of change of premises, prior approval of the Regional Committee concerned shall be necessary, which could be accorded after due inspection of the institution at the new site. Application for change of premises, in triplicate, in the specified format along with other relevant documents shall be submitted by the Institution to the Regional Office for prior approval of change of premises”.

Based on the above points the committee decides to withdraw the recognition of the B.Ed course run by the S.V.I. College of Education, Ward No. 39, E.Podur, Trichirapalli District – 620012, Tamilnadu, from the academic year 2013-14, in


172


order to enable the ongoing batch of students in B.Ed, course, if any, to complete their course.

Further, the institution’s request for change of name of the institution vide their letter dt. 20.02.2013, in the circumstances need for permission to change of name does not arise.

Accordingly, withdrawal order was issued to the institution on 01.06.2013.

The institution moved to Hon’ble High Court of Judicature at Madras in W.P. no. 16386 of 2013 and M.P. Nos. 1 and 2 of 2013 dtd. 16.08.2013 reads as under:-

“…… after the completion of construction, the petitioner-college has submitted an application seeking prior approval of permission to shift under Regulation No.8 by enclosing a Demand Draft for Rs. 40,000/- towards the inspection fee. The said application was submitted on 15.02.2013 in the prescribed form along with a covering letter on the same day. Instead of making inspection, the respondent has chosen to pass the impugned order withdrawing the recognition as per regulation 8(11) of NCTE Regulations, 2009. As the application was submitted seeking prior approval for shifting, which was submitted on 15.02.2013 in the prescribed form with necessary inspection fee, the order passed by the first respondent (The Regional Director, NCTE, Bangalore) dated 1.6.2013 cannot be sustained, as the petitioner-college is a running college with recognition and affiliation upto 2012-13 and before beginning of the year 2013-14, the petitioner has applied prior approval.

Since the said factual aspects are not in dispute, the impugned order is set aside and the writ petition is allowed, with a direction to the first respondent to make an inspection of the new premises within a period of two weeks, and pass fresh orders regarding the shifting request, within a period of four weeks. No costs. Connected miscellaneous petitions are closed”.

In the meantime, SRC, NCTE is in receipt of letter dtd. 06.09.2013 from Tamilnadu Teachers Education University on 10.09.2013 and has stated that “ Withdrawal of Affiliation for B.Ed Degree course with effect from the academic year 2013-2014”.

The Committee considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Notice Under NCTE Act for the following:

Certified copy of land documents issued by the Sub-Registrar is not submitted.

Notarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted. Proceedings of Revenue Divisional Officer not submitted for conversion of land from agricultural to non-agricultural purpose.

Original FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank in joint account name is not submitted.

The Institution has not submitted approved staff list duly approved by


173


University/affiliating body.

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Notice to the institution, as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the withdrawal of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

Consideration of Agenda Items- Volume-06Appeal Cases

85.SRCAPP106

5D.Ed

Shivani Institute of Teacher

Education, Warangal

DistrictAP

Shivani Institute of Teacher Education, Khasra No. 89,103, 101, 87/2, 107, 90/2,91, Ramavaram Street, Laknepally Village, Maheshwaram Post, Narsampet Taluk, Warangal District, Andhra Pradesh 506331.

Maheshwari Education Society, Plot No. 6- 147, Ramavaram Street, LaknepallyVillage, Maheshwaram Post Office ,Narsampet Taluk, Narasampet Town ,Warangal District, Andhra Pradesh 506331 had applied for grant of recognition to Shivani Institute of Teacher Education, Khasra No. 89,103, 101, 87/2, 107, 90/2,91, Ramavaram Street, Laknepally Village, Maheshwaram Post Office, Narsampet Taluk, Warrangal District,Andhra Pradesh 506331 for D.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29/09/2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 30/09/2011

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 14/10/2011 followed by reminder on 7/12/2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 28/12/2011. The institution has submitted reply for deficiency letter on 12/03/2012.

The institution has submitted reply for deficiency letter after the stipulated time of 60 days period as per clause 7 (1) of NCTE Regulations.

The SRC in its 221st Meeting held on 19th-20th April 2012, considered the reply of the institution, which is received on 15/3/2012, i.e., after 76 (Seventy Six) days from the date of issue of deficiency letter and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per clause 7(1) of NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.Ed course.


Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order No. F.No. 89-271/2012 Appeal / 6th Meeting – 2012 dated 17/07/2012 stated that“…the council concluded that there was adequate ground to accept the appeal and remand the matter to the SRC of examination of the reply of the institution and further necessary action”.


174


Accordingly, the application was processed and placed before SRC in its 230th

meeting held on 16th-17th August 2012, and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Before issuance of show cause notice, as per the information of website the institution has submitted its written representation on 27.08.2012.

The SRC in its 232nd meeting 29th – 31st August 2012, held on considered the reply of the institution dt.27-08-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection for the session 2013-14 under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 20 th -24th

September, 2012 the same was intimated to the institution on 14/09/2012 the Inspection of the institution was conducted on 21/09/2012.

SRC in its 234th Meeting held on 26th-28th September, 2012 considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 16/11/2012. The institution has submitted written representation on 05/12/2012.

The reply of the institution was placed before SRC in its 237 th meeting held on 05-06th January 2013 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 05/12/2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

1. As per blue print of building plan only rooms mentioned. No where mentioned office room, laboratory, library & Multipurpose hall etc.

2. In the building plan earmarked area for proposed course is not given, and land area is mentioned Ac. 14.12 Gts. Which is not matching with other documents.

3. Sy.no are different from on-line application, affidavit, Encumbrance Certificate, Land use certificate, building completion certificate & building plan.

4. In the proceedings purpose not mentioned.

5. As per building completion certificate as page 62/C, sy.no. are 89&103, however, as per building plan sy.no. 90/2, hence location of building cannot be ascertained.

6. As per online application sy.No. is different from land documents

Accordingly, Final show cause notice was issued to the institution on 14.02.2013. The institution has submitted a written representation on 28/02/2013.


175


The reply of the institution to the show cause notice was duly considered by SRC in its 241st Meeting held on 29th-31st March & 1st April, 2013 and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:

Approved blue print of the building plan issued by competent civil authority is not submitted.

Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.Ed course.


Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC, the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs the appellate authority order no. F.No.89-292/2013 Appeal/13th

Meeting -2013 dated 15.10.2013 stating that “…the council concluded that the refusal order dated 18.05.2013 for the reasons mentioned therein is not sustainable and is accordingly, deserved to be remanded back to SRC with a direction to process the case further as per rules.

NOW THEREFORE, the council hereby remands back the case of Shivani Institute of Teacher Education, Warangal, Andhra Pradesh to the SRC, NCTE, for necessary action as indicated above.

The Committee considered the Appellate Authority order dated 15-10-2013, directing SRC to process the case further as per rules, accordingly decided to process the case.

86.SRCAPP796

D.EdKLR College

of Education, Khammam

DistrictAP

KLR College of Education, K.No. 434, 435, 436, Paloncha, Plot No. 434, Paloncha Village, Post & Taluk, Khammam District-507114, Andhra Pradesh.

Boon Education Environment & Rural Development Society, Plot No. 434, 435, 436, Near SIIL Campus, Paloncha Village, Post & Taluk, Khammam District-507114, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to KLR College of Education, K.No. 434, 435, 436, Paloncha, Plot No. 434, Paloncha Village , Post & Taluk, Khammam District-507114, Andhra Pradesh, for D.El.Ed Course for two years duration under Section 15(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 27.09.2011. The institution has submitted hard copy of the application on 07.10.2011.


The SRC in its 220th Meeting of SRC held on 30th – 31st March, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 29.02.2102 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 27.04.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation dt. 15.05.2012 received in


176


the office of SRC on 18.05.2012

The reply of the institution to the show cause notice was duly considered by SRC in its 223rd Meeting held 29th-31st May, 2013 and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:

1. Approved blue print of the building plan issued by competent civil authority is not submitted.

2. Notarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted.

Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.Ed course.

Accordingly, rejection order was issued to the institution on 27.06.2013.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC, the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs the appellate authority order vide no. F.No.89-340/2013/Appeal/13th

Meeting -2013 A75841 dated 15.10.2013 stating that “…the council noted that the submission of the appeal is delayed by 8 months and a days beyond the prescribed time limit of 60 days. The appellant, besides stating that they are not aware of on-line appeal process, has not furnished any reasons for delay in appeal. In the circumstances, the council concluded that the delay in appeal cannot be condoned and therefore the appeal is not admitted.

After perusal of the documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit and after taking into account the oral submission of the institution during hearing. The council concluded that they delay in appeal cannot be condoned and therefore the appeal is not admitted.”


As per Decision of the SRC 247th and 249thMeeting decision of the following files are put up for consideration

87.APS08964/ APS08968D.Ed/ B.EdSri Mandal

Venkatakrishna Rao


Krishna District

AP

A compliant has been received against the following institutions. APS08964/D.Ed APS08968/B.Ed AOS00163/Hindi

PracharakSri Mandali Venkata Krishna Rao College of Education, Gandhian United Action for Rural Development Gandhi Kshetram, Avanigadda, Krishna District-521 121, Andhra Pradesh was granted recognition for D.Ed course(50 intake) of two years on 14.12.2007.

Sri Mandali Venkata Krishna Rao College of Education, Gandhian United Action for Rural Development Gandhi Kshetram, Avanigadda, Krishna District-521 121, Andhra Pradesh was granted recognition for B.Ed course(intake 100 students) of one

DBHPS Hindi Pracharak Training College, Krishna District, Andhra Pradesh was granted recognition for Hindi Pracharak on 12.11.2001


177


year on 23.10.2007.

NCTE-Hqrs, New Delhi has forwarded a complaint dated nil received on 17/12/2012 made by 1. Sanaka Arjun Rao, 2. Ambati Laxmi, 3. Mopidevi Sujan, 4. K. Ravikanth. The complaints are stated that, Shortcoming / irregularities in three Colleges in respect of (i) SMVKR College of Education (ii) SMVKR College of D.Ed. and (iii) Dashina Bharath Hindi College, Post-Krishna, District, Andhra Pradesh are as under:-

1) No permanent infrastructure.2) No library facility.3) No psychological lab, chemistry lab, computer lab, science lab etc.4) No physical education room, no sports materials5) No seminar hall, toilets room, no ply ground etc.

The SRC in its 239th held on 26th-27th February 2013 considered the complaint letter forwarded by NCTE (HQ) New Delhi against the above 3 colleges, vide letter dt. 26.11.2012 received from Shri Sanaka Arjun Roa and others and decided to cause composite inspection under NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms. Further, the committee advised SRO to give the complaint details to the VT members.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 13thto 14th June 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 06.06.2013.


The Committee considered the matter, decided and advised Southern Regional Office to put up a comparative statement with all details for the courses along with VT report.

Put up comparative statement with all details for the courses along with VT Report

The SRC in its 249th meeting held on 24th-26th July 2013, the committee decided that put up comparative statement with all details for the courses along with VT Report.

APS08964/D.Ed APS08968/B.EdGranted on 14.12.2007

Present Status: A Complaint has been received against the institution and placed before SRC in its 239th

meeting held on 26th-27th

February 2013, and the committee considered the

matter and decided to cause composite inspection. The

VT reports was placed before SRC in its 249th

meeting held on 24th-26th


Present Status: A Complaint has been received against the institution and

placed before SRC in its 239th meeting held on 26th-27th February 2013, and the committee considered the matter

and decided to cause composite inspection. The VT reports was placed

before SRC in its 249th meeting held on 24th-26th July 2013 and the committee decided to put up

comparative statement with all details for the courses along with VT Report


178


July 2013 and the committee decided to put up

comparative statement with all details for the courses

along with VT Report

INSTITUTION NAME INSTITUTION NAMESri Mandali Venkatakrishna Rao College of Education, Gandhi Kshetram, Avanigadda, Krishna District-521121, Andhra Pradesh

Sri Mandali Venkata Krishna Rao College of Education, Gandhia Kshetram, Avanigadda, Krishna District-521121, Andhra Pradesh

SOCIETY NAME SOCIETY NAMEGandhian United Action for Rural Development, Krishna District, Andhra Pradesh

Gandhian United Action for Rural Development, Krishna District, Andhra Pradesh

TRUST DEED TRUST DEEDDate of Regn

30.07.1979 Date of Regn 30.07.1979

Name of society

Gandhian United Action for Rural Development “GUARD”

Name of society

Gandhian United Action for Rural Development “GUARD”

LAND DOCUMENTS LAND DOCUMENTSType of document

Land documents submitted in telugu version Transfer Deed dt. 06.03.1992

Type of document

Land documents submitted in telugu version Transfer Deed dt. 06.03.1992


Not certified in telugu version and notarised photocopy of English version submitted


Not certified in telugu version and notarised photocopy of English version submitted

Sy.No. 157/1 Sy.No. 157/1Location Avanigadda Location AvanigaddaExtent Ac.1.60 Extent Ac.1.60Infavour of Gandhian

United Action for Rural Development (GUARD)

Infavour of Gandhian United Action for Rural Development (GUARD)


179


AFFIDAVIT AFFIDAVITSy.No. Affidavit

Sy.No.157/1, 157/2

Sy.No. Affidavit Sy.No.157/1, 157/2

Location Avanigadda Location AvanigaddaExtent Ac.1.75 cents Extent Ac.1.75 centsBuilt up area 22000 sq.ft Built up area 22000 sq.ft

LAND USE CERTIFICATE LAND USE CERTIFICATEIssued by Revenue

Divisional Officer,

Issued by Revenue Divisional Officer,

Notarized or not Notarised photocopy submitted but not legible

Notarised or not Notarised photocopy submitted but not legible

Dated 06.08.2007 Dated 06.08.2007Sy.No. with location

157/1 & 157/2, Avanigadda

Sy.No. with location 157/1 & 157/2(re-written as 167/1 & 167/2), Avanigadda

Extent Ac.1.64 cents Extent Ac.1.64 centsConverted for Land shown

proposed to start Sri.Mandali Venkata Krishna Rao College of Education, Avanibadda.

Converted for Land shown proposed to start Sri.Mandali Venkata Krishna Rao College of Education, Avanibadda.

BUILDING COMPLETION CERTIFICATE

BUILDING COMPLETION CERTIFICATE

Issued by Madhu Associates and approved by Deputy Executive Engineer

Issued by Madhu Associates and approved by Deputy Executive Engineer

Sy No Not mentioned Sy No Not mentioned

Location Avanigadda Location AvanigaddaBuilt-up area 22000 sq.ft Built-up area 22000 sq.ft

BUILDING PLAN BUILDING PLAN

Approved by Secretary, Grama

Approved by Secretary, Grama


180


Panchayat, Avanigadda

Panchayat, Avanigadda

Sy.No. 167/1, 167/2 Sy.No. 167/1, 167/2Extent 34932 sq.ft Extent 34932 sq.ftLocation Avanigadda

VillageLocation Avanigadda

VillageBuilt up area 22900 sq.ft Built up area 22900 sq.ftArea earmarked for proposed course




ENDOWMENT FUND Rs.5 lakhs ENDOWMENT FUND Rs.5 lakhs

Issued from Andhra Bank Issued from Andhra BankOriginal submitted

Two Photocopies found in the file.

Original submitted

Two Photocopies found in the file.

FDR No. 136853 & 136855

FDR No. 136856 & 136854

Tenure of FDR 120 months Tenure of FDR 120 monthsIssue of FDR 13.08.2007 Issue of FDR 13.08.2007Valid till 13.08.2017 Valid till 13.08.2017In favor of M/s.Secretary &

Correspondent, GUARD

In favor of M/s.Secretary & Correspondent, GUARD

RESERVE FUND Rs.3

lakhs

RESERVE FUND Rs.3

lakhsIssued from Two

photocopies of Rs.5 lakhs FDRs found in the file.

Issued from Two photocopies of Rs.5 lakhs FDRs found in the file.

ENCUMBRANCE CERTIFICATE ENCUMBRANCE CERTIFICATEIssued by Not available in

the fileIssued by Not available in

the file

MINORITY CERTIFICATE MINORITY CERTIFICATENot available in the file.

Not available in the file

The Committee considered the VT report, VCD of the institution and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice for both the cases (APS08964 & APS08968) under NCTE Act, for the following:

Building completion certificate is not in the prescribed format. It does not mention Survey Numbers . It is not approved by the competent


181


authority.

In the building plan submitted, it cites different survey numbers. As per land document the Sy.no. is given as 154/1, where as in building plan it shows 167/1 & 167/2, both are not matching. Built up area stated is inadequate for both the courses as per NCTE norms.

Land usage certificate submitted is not in the prescribed format.

Up-to-date encumbrance certificate from the competent authority is not submitted.

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause Notice to the institution for both the courses as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of issue of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the withdrawal of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.


182


88.SRCAPP93/

B.P.EdSri Prakash

Physical Education

College, East

Godavari District

AP

APS02813/D.EdSri

Venkateshwara College of

Elementary Teacher

Education, Vishakapatnam

DistrictAP&

AOS00431B.EdSRI

VENKATESWARA COLLEGE OF EDUCATION

NAMAVARAM (BPO)

PAYAKARAOPETA

VISAKHAPATNAM - 531126ANDHRA

PRADESH

SRCAPP99B.P.Ed

Sri Prakash College of Physical

Education, Vishakhapatnam District

AP

Sri Prakash College of Physical Education, Plot No.121, 122/2B, 126/2A, NH5 Street, Namavaram BPO, Payakaraopeta Taluk & City, Vishakhapatnam District-531126, Andhra Pradesh

Sri Prakash Educational Society, Plot No.121, 122/B, 126/2A, NH5 Street, Namavaram BPO, Payakaraopeta Taluk & City, Vishakhapatnam District-531126, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Sri Prakash College of Physical Education, Plot No.121, 122/2B, 126/2A, NH5 Street, Namavaram BPO, Payakaraopeta Taluk & City, Vishakhapatnam District-531126, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed Course of one year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 07.01.2013.The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 06.02.2013/14.03.2013 (Reminder). A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 26.03.2013.

Now the institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 24.05.2013.

The Committee considered the matter and advised Southern Regional Office to prepare a comprehensive comparative statement for all the 3 courses viz, B.Ed (0431), D.Ed (2813) and B.P.Ed (SRCAPP99) and put up in the 248th meeting.

The SRC in its 247th meeting held on 20th-22nd June 2013, the committee considered the matter and to put up a comparative chart of the three cases of proposed B.P.Ed, B.Ed and D.Ed courses.

Sl.No.

SRCAPP93/B.P.Ed

APS02813/D.Ed

SRCAPP99/B.P.Ed

AOS00431/B.Ed

Present Status: DL

Reply placed in its 247th

meeting held on 20th-22nd

June 2013

Present Status:


Present Status: DL

Reply placed in its 247th

meeting held on 20th-22nd

June 2013

As per MIS data, it was

granted recognition

for B.Ed course on 25.09.2001.

Original File not traced

1 INSTITUTION NAME

Sri Prakash Physical Education College, Plot/Khasara No. 574, 48/1F2, Street No. 1, Rajupeta

Sri Venkateshwara College of Elementary Teacher Education, Payakaraopeta,

Sri Prakash College of Physical Education, Plot No.121, 122/2B, 126/2A, NH5 Street, Namavaram BPO, Payakaraopeta Taluk & City,


183


Village, Tuni Post Office and Taluk, Tuni City, East Godavari District – 533 401, Andhra Pradesh

P.L.Puram, Vishakapatnam District-531126, Andhra Pradesh

Vishakhapatnam District-531126, Andhra Pradesh

2 SOCIETY NAME

Sri Prakasah Educational Society, Plot No. 574, 48/1F2, Sri Prakash Nagar Road, Rajupeta Village, Tuni Post Office and Taluk, Tuni City, East Godavari District – 533 401, Andhra Pradesh

Sri Prakash Educational Society, Kothapeta, Tuni, East Godavari District, Andhra Pradesh

Sri Prakash Educational Society, Plot No.121, 122/B, 126/2A, NH5 Street, Namavaram BPO, Payakaraopeta Taluk & City, Vishakhapatnam District-531126, Andhra Pradesh

3 TRUST DEED

Date of Regn

17.11.1983 17.11.1983 17.11.1983

Name of Society

Sree Prakash Educational Society, Tuni

Sree Prakash Educational Society,Tuni

Sri Prakash Educational Society Tuni

4LAND

DOCUMENTS


184


Type of document

Two Sale Deed dt. 08.01.2001

Telugu version land documents submitted

Four Sale Deeds dated 24.08.1996, 04.12.2000, 17.08.1996, 09.04.2001


First page and last pages are certified by sub-registrar, Tuni

Not certified Telugu ver. Certified and notarized English version.

Sy.No. 574 & 48/1F2 106/1C, 109/7A, 109/8, 109/7D, 109/7E, 106/1A, 109/7B, 106/1B, 109/7C, 109/8, 126/2B

1)1212)122/2B3)126/2A4)126/2A

Location Kotturu Village, Near Tuni

Not given Padalavani, Lakshmipuram

Extent Ac.6.67 cents & Ac1.70 cents

Ac.11.50 cents

1)Ac.3.792)Ac.3.15 cents3)Ac.2.23 cents4)Ac.0.85 cents

Infavour of Sri.Prakash Educational Society represented by its Secretary & Correspondent

Sri Prakash Educational Society


5 AFFIDAVIT

Sy.No. 574, 48/1F2 Affidavit submitted but not mentioned Sy.No. Location, extent

121,122/2B, 126/2A, 126/2A


185


Undertaking submitted

Location Rajupeta Village

P.L.Puram Village

Extent 33881.76 sq.mtr

40560.96 Sq.Mtrs

6 LAND USE CERTIFICA

TEIssued by Revenue

Divisional office

Land Title Certificate Submitted issued by Advocate: Extent 11.50 Acres

Tahasildar

Notarised or not

Yes Yes

Sy.No. with location

574, 575, 48/1F2, Rajupeta Village

121, 122/2B, 126/2AP.L.Puram Revenue Village

Extent Ac.33.37 Ac.10.02Converted for

Constructing buildings play grounds etc. for running educational institutions.

7

BUILDING COMPLETI

ON CERTIFICA

TEIssued by

Assistant Engineer

Gram Panchayathi,

Assistant Engineer

Sy.No. 574, 48/1F2 126/2B of Pedala Lakshmipuram, P.L.Puram Panchayath, Payakaraopeta Mandal, Visakhapatn

121, 122/2B, 126/2A


186


am Dist., were constructed for running Sri Venkateswara College of Education, Sri Prakash Vidyaniketan etc., managed by Sri Prakash Educational Society


P.L.Puram, Payakaraopeta

Built up area 1593 sq.mtr

2246 Sq.Mtrs.(RCC)

Type of Roofing

RCC roofing & Tiled roofing

8 BUILDING PLAN

Approved by Person Incharge, Panchayat Village Committee, Kothuru, Tuni

Sarpanch Panchayath Secretary

Sy.No. 574, 575, 48/1F2

126/2B 126/2A, 122/2B, 121

Extent Ac.33.37 Not given Ac.10.02 cents


Not given P.L.Puram Village

Built up area 17732.72 sq.mtr

Plan is in the name of Sri Venkateswara College of Education, Sri Prakash Vidya Niketan etc

5496.45 sq.mts3015.88 sq.mtrs(B.Ed & D.Ed)2480.57 sq.mtr (B.P.Ed course)


187


managed by Sri Prakash Educational Society


Ac.8.37 (Sy.No.574, 48/1F2)

Ac.8.02 acres for B.P.EdAc.2.00 acres for B.Ed and D.Ed

9ENDOWMENT FUND OF RS.5 LAKHS

Issued fromState Bank of Hyderabad



Original submitted

Yes

Photocopy of FDR available in the file

Yes

FDR No. 257800(5 lakhs)

0366631 257798

Tenure of FDR 12 months 12 months One year

Issue of FDR 29.12.2012 28.01.2004 29.12.2012Valid till 29.12.2013 28.01.2005 29.12.2013In favor of


The Secretary & Correspondent, S.V. College of Education, Payakaraopet.

Sri Prakash Educational

Society

10RESERVE FUND OF

RS.3 LAKHS

Issued from State Bank of Hyderabad

Not found in the file.


Original submitted Yes Yes

FDR No. 257801(3 lakhs)

257799

Tenure of FDR 29.12.2012 One year

Issue of FDR 29.12.2013 29.12.2012Valid till 12 months 29.12.2013In favor of Sri Prakash Sri Prakash


188


Educational Society

Educational Society

11ENCUMBR

ANCE CERTIFICA

TEIssued by Sub-

Registrar, Tuni


Sub-Registrar

Ec dt. 22.04.2013Sy.No. 7574, 48/1F2 126/2A,

122/2BExtent Ac.6.67 &

Ac.1.5 , 3.150 Acre

Location Kothuru Village

Padalavani Lakshmipuram

Period 01.01.1983 to 21.04.2013

01.04.1982 to

27.12.2012

SRCAPP93-B.P.Ed

The Committee considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt.24-05-2013 to the deficiency letter and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

APS02813-D.Ed & AOS00431-B.Ed

The Committee considered the matter, on verification of the comparative statement of all the courses, and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the existing programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

AOS00431-B.Ed

The Committee considered the matter, on verification of the comparative statement of all the courses run by the institution, decided to cause inspection of B.Ed course for reconstruction of file under NCTE Act. VT to be informed to collect all the relevant documents of the institution for B.Ed course run by the institution.

Note: If both the courses i.e, APS02813-D.Ed & AOS00431-B.Ed are in the same location, arrange for causing composite inspection and VT to be informed accordingly.


189


----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SRCAPP99-B.P.Ed

The Committee considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt.24-05-2013 to the deficiency letter and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

89.SRCAPP189

8B.Ed

Nizam School of

Education, Nalgonda

District

APS02646B.Ed

Nizam College of Education, Nalgonda

DistrictAP

Nizam School of Education, Plot No.182AA, 183AA and 190AA, Deshmukhi Village, Bata Singaram Post Office, Pochampally (M) & City, Nalgonda District-508284, Andhra Pradesh

Ummul Qura Education Society, Plot No.8-2-677, Road No.12, Banjara Hills Post Office, Hyderabad City & Taluk, Hyderabad District-500034, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Nizam School of Education, Plot No.182AA, 183AA and 190AA, Deshmukhi Village, Bata Singaram Post Office, Pochampally (M) & City, Nalgonda District-508284, Andhra Pradesh for B.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 26.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 28.12.2012.


The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 27.05.2013(late by 2 days) . There is no proof available on the cover.

The institution has submitted its reply after the expiry of stipulated time of 60 days.


The Committee considered the matter and noted that the dates given in respect of B.Ed (APS02646) are discrepant. Advised Southern Regional Office to recheck, resubmit with a comparative statement for B.Ed (2646) and B.Ed (1898).

While placing the agenda of delayed deficiency letter reply in the 249 th

meeting of SRC held on 24th-26th July 2013, the committee decided that dates given in respect of B.Ed (2646) are discrepant. Recheck. Resubmit with a comparative statement for B.Ed (2646) and B.Ed (1898):-

SRCAPP1898/B.Ed APS02646/B.EdINSTITUTION

NAMEINSTITUTION NAME

Nizam School of As per MIS data,


190


Education, Plot No.182AA, 183AA and 190AA, Deshmukhi Village, Bata Singaram Post Office, Pochampally (M) & City, Nalgonda District-508284, Andhra Pradesh

the Nizam College of Education, Nalgonda is existing, whereas the file is traced and not known the B.Ed for APS02646 granted recognition.

SOCIETY NAME

SOCIETY NAME

Ummul Qura Education Society, Plot No.8-2-677, Road No.12, Banjara Hills Post Office, Hyderabad City & Taluk, Hyderabad District-500034, Andhra Pradesh

TRUST DEED TRUST DEEDDate of Regn 13.10.1997 Date of Regn

Name of society Ummulqura Education Society

Name of society

LAND DOCUMENTS

LAND DOCUMENTS

Type of document


Type of document


Yes Certified by sub-registrar

Sy.No. 182/ (2nd telugu letter), 183/ (1st telugu letter), 190/ (1st telugu letter)

Sy.No.

Location Deshmukhi Village, Pochampally

Location


191


MandalExtent Ac.1.21 ExtentInfavour of M/s Ummul

Qura Education Society

Infavour of

AFFIDAVITSy.No. 182B, 183/A, 190/A Sy.No.Location Deshmukhi Village LocationExtent Ac.1.21 gts Extent

LAND USE CERTIFICATEIssued by Tahasildar, Revenue Divisional Officer Issued byNotarized or not Yes Notarised or notDated 09.05.2013, 21.03.2005 DatedSy.No. with location

182/B, 183/A, 190/A Sy.No. with location

Extent Ac.1.21 gts ExtentConverted for For establishment of Nizam School of

Education, Non-agricultural purposeConverted for

BUILDING COMPLETION CERTIFICATEBUILDING COMPLETION CERTIFICATE

Issued by Dy. Executive Engineer Issued bySy No 182/B, 183/A & 190/A Sy NoLocation Deshmukhi Village, Pochampally Mandal LocationBuilt-up area 22327 sq.ft (RCC roofing) Built-up area

BUILDING PLANApproved by Sarpanch, Grama panchayath but not

original approved by competent authority.Approved by

Sy.No. 182B, 183A, 190A Sy.No.Extent Not mentioned Extent Location Deshmukhi Village LocationBuilt up area 16745.25 sq.ft Built up areaArea earmarked for proposed course

Plan is in the name of Nizam School of Education


ENDOWMENT FUND Rs.5 lakhsIssued from Bank of India Issued fromOriginal submitted

Yes Original submitted

FDR No. 860145110002034 FDR No.Tenure of FDR 12 months Tenure of FDRIssue of FDR 15.12.2012 Issue of FDRValid till 15.12.2013 Valid tillIn favor of Ummulqura Educational Society In favor of


192


RESERVE FUND Rs.3 lakhsIssued from Bank of India Issued fromOriginal submitted

Yes Original submitted

FDR No. 860145110002035 FDR No.Tenure of FDR 12 months Tenure of FDRIssue of FDR 15.12.2012 Issue of FDRValid till 15.12.2013 Valid tillIn favor of Ummulqura Educational Society In favor of

ENCUMBRANCE CERTIFICATEIssued by Mee Seva Issued byEc dt. 30.04.2013 Ec dt.Sy.No. 182B, 183A, 190A Sy.No.Extent 61 guntas ExtentLocation Deshmukhi Village LocationPeriod 01.01.1983 to 29.04.2013 Period

MINORITY CERTIFICATEThe institution has submitted Minority Certificate for the academic year 2013-14 dated 16.09.2013 in the name of Nizam School of Education (B.Ed) (Page.No.157 & 159)

SRCAPP1898-B.EdThe reply of the institution to the deficiency letter dated 27-05-2013 was duly considered and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:

Approved blue print of the building plan issued by competent civil authority is not submitted. In the building plan submitted, total extent of land area is not mentioned.

Total built up area of 16745.25 sq.ft as shown in building plan is not tallying with that of 22327 sq.ft as shown in building completion certificate.

Notarised land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the educational purpose is not submitted. Proceedings of Revenue Divisional Officer not submitted for conversion of land from agricultural to non-agriculture. Land Use Certificate submitted is not in the prescribed format.

The reply to the deficiency letter is not satisfactory and unconvincing.

Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to reject the application of the institution for recognition of B.Ed course.


193


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

APS02646-B.Ed

The Committee considered the matter, on verification of the comparative statement of all the courses run by the institution, decided to cause inspection of B.Ed course for reconstruction of file under NCTE Act. VT to be informed to collect all the relevant documents of the institution for B.Ed course run by the institution.

90.SRCAPP231 APS02812 APS00276

B.P.Ed D.Ed B.Ed

Rangumudri Appalaswamy Naidu Physical

Education and

Rangumdri Teacher Training Institute,

Srikakulam District

AP

Rangumudri Appalaswamy Naidu Physical Education College, Khasar No.165, 165-3, 5, 8, 9, 153P, Konangipadu Revenue Iruvada Village, Chilakalapalli Post Office, Vangara Taluk, Rajam City, Srikakulam District-535557, Andhra Pradesh

RM Educational Society, Plot No.3-1, Sivalayam Street, Chilakalapalli Village & Post Office, Balijipeta Taluk, Bobbili City, Vizianagaram District-535557, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Rangumudri Appalaswamy Naidu Physical Education College, Khasar No.165, 165-3, 5, 8, 9, 153P, Konangipadu Revenue Iruvada Village, Chilakalapalli Post Office, Vangara Taluk, Rajam City, Srikakulam District-535557, Andhra Pradesh for B.P.Ed Course of one year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 31.12.2012 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 03.01.2013.



The Committee considered the matter and advised Southern Regional Office to Re-submit with a comparative statement for Proposed course B.P.Ed and other existing courses being run by the institution viz. B.Ed and B.Ed. Also to check for the deficiencies listed by the association and put up in the 250th meeting


While placing D.L.Reply for SRCAPP231 B.P.Ed - Rangumudri Appalaswamy Naidu Physical Education College, Srikakulam District was placed before SRC in its 249th meeting held on 24th-26th July 2013 and the committee considered the matter and decided to resubmit with a comparative statement for B.P.Ed/B.Ed/D.Ed.

As per the advise of Southern Regional committee to Re-submit with a comparative statement for Proposed course B.P.Ed and other existing courses being run by the institution viz. D.Ed and B.Ed. Also to check for the deficiencies listed by the association, accordingly, the comparative statement with deficiency are made ready and submitted for perusal of the Committee.

The committee considered the matter and on verification of the comparative statement of all the courses run by the institution including the present proposed course B.P.Ed, the following observation are made.


194


1.As sper NCTE regulations 2009, B.P.Ed (SRCAPP231) should be stand-alone course, but, D.Ed (APS02812) course is seen to be overlapping.

2. The four SY.nos. shown for D.Ed add up to 3.76 acres, if this is deducted from 10.4 acres shown for B.P.Ed, the area for B.P.Ed is only 6.64 acres. Which is inadequate as per NCTE regulations / norms, 2009 requirement of 8.00 acres.

3. It is not clear whether the buildings for B.P.Ed & D.Ed are separate.

Based on the above, the Committee considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt.24-05-2013 to the deficiency letter and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.Further, the Committee decided to know & determine the extent of overlap between B.P.Ed and B.Ed at the time of inspection.

Also VT to be informed and should report back on the continuity of Survery numbers.

Cause Inspection to determine the extent of overlap between B.P.Ed & D.Ed.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------APS00276-B.Ed

The Committee considered the matter, on verification of the comparative statement of all the courses run by the institution, decided to cause inspection of B.Ed course for reconstruction of file under NCTE Act. VT to be informed to collect all the relevant documents of the institution for B.Ed course run by the institution. .

91.APS03835 APS03806 APS02914 APS02537

B.Ed D.Ed B.Ed D.EdSeven Hills

B.Ed College, Guntur District

SRCAPP483D.Ed

Seven Hills Teacher Training

Seven Hills Teacher Training Institution, Vinukonda Village and Post Office, Vinukonda Taluka and City, Guntur District – 522 647, Andhra Pradesh.

Zilla Vikalagula Sangam, Vinukonda Village and Post Office, Vinukonda Taluka and City, Guntur District – 522 647, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Seven Hills Teacher Training Institution, Vinukonda Village and Post Office, Vinukonda Taluka and City, Guntur District – 522 647, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 16.08.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 23.08.2011 (Dispatched on 18.08.2011).

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation & Reminder on 26.08.2011 & 14/11/2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 09.09.2011. The institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 28.11.2011.

The SRC in its 215th Meeting held on 12th-13th December, 2011 considered the reply of the institution dt. 28.11.2011 for the deficiency letter issued to the institution on 09.09.2011 and come to the conclusion that, since the institution


195


Institution, Guntur District

AP

has not replied to the deficiency letter within 60 days, the application is rejected for not receiving the reply within 60 days.

Accordingly, a rejection order was issued to the institution on 03.02.2012

The institution has approached to Hon’ble High in With reference to the above cited subject, the Hon’ble High Court has directed in W.P. 27019 of 2012 as under:-

“…respondent No. 1(SRC-NCTE) is directed to reconsider the petitioner’s application and order inspection of the letter’s institution within two weeks from the date of receipt of this order. If before the inspection report is filed by the visiting team the scheduled for counseling is not announced, the petitioner’s institution shall be include for counseling for the academic year 2012-13 subject to its fulfillment of all the norms of the National Council for Teacher Education.

Subject to the above direction the writ petition is allowed to the extent indicated above. As a sequal WPMP No. 34428 of 2012 is disposed of as infructuous.”

The SRC in its 235th Meeting held on 21st-22nd November, 2012 considered the Hon’ble High Court order and all other relevant documents and decided to cause composite inspection under NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms and on receipt of Rs. 50000/- inspection fee.

Further, the committee also decided to file an appeal and apply for stay, since the institution filed writ petition in WP. No. 34428 of 2012 in W.P. No. 27019 of 2012.

As per the decision of SRC, a letter to advocate was sent on 22/01/2013.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 10th -15th February, 2013 the same was intimated to institution on 31/01/2013. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 12/02/2013.

The SRC in its 241st Meeting held on 29th-31st March, 1st April, 2013 considered the V.T. report, all the relevant document & evidence decided to put up all three cases (B.Ed-1, D.Ed & B.Ed-2) together in the next SRC meeting.

As per the decision of SRC all three cases put up in the 242nd Meeting held on 14th-16th April, 2013 along with V.T. report of SRCAPP 483 D.El.Ed and the committee decided to reject the application for SRCAPP483 – D.El.Ed course.

As per the decision of SRC, the application was rejected on 27.4.2013.

The institution moved to the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in W.P. No. 16113 of 2013. The Hon’ble Court has directed as follows;

“There is a serious dispute with regard to the built up area of the building in which the petitioner-Institute has proposed to establish a college. It is the assertion of the petitioner-institution that the building consists of First and Second floors and the built up area of each floor is 1733.54 square meters. The report dated 12.2.2013 submitted by the inspection committee, in a way, reflects the same built-up area. However, the 1st respondent authority in its order has


196


shown the built up area as 1733.54 square feet. It is not clear that the order whether the 1st respondent authority had noticed the hand-written entry made by the team showing the extent in meters.Hence, Sri. K Ramakanth Readdy, Learned Standing Counsel for NCTE submits that the actual built-up area will be ascertained afresh through an inspection team within two weeks from today and a report will be submitted to the court.

In view of the said representation, there shall be a direction to the 1st respondent-NCTE, Southern Regional Committee, Bangalore to cause an inspection of the building and submit a report with regard to the actual built-up area within two weeks from today. The petitioner-institution shall not be called up to meet the expenses of the inspection team.

Post after two weeks”.

Note: The original file was sent to the advocate on 11.6.2013. File not received so far.

The Committee considered the Hon’ble High Court order and as per the direction of the Court decided to cause Composite inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Further, the committee directed Southern regional office to submit the inspection report to the court with SRC’s comments.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed on 22nd July 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 19.07.2013.


The SRC in its 250th meeting held on 11th-13th August 2013, considered the VT report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to issue Letter of Intent for D.Ed (SRCAPP483).

Accordingly, Letter of Intent was issued on 03.09.2013. The institution was submitted its written representation (LOI reply) on 27.09.2013

In the mean time, a court order was submitted by the institution on 27.09.2013 in W.P.No.16113 of 2013 stated as follows:-

“ Though the learned counsel for National Council for Teacher Education (for short “NCTE”, would submit that the Souther Regional Committee has initially rejected the application of the petitioner for recognition to run Diploma in Education (D.Ed.) course, but however Sri.R.Narsimha Reddy, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner has drawn my attention to the decision taken by the Southern Regional Committee at its 250th meeting held on 11.08.2013, where at it was decided to issue letter of intent under sub regulation (9) of Regulation 7 of the NCTE (Recognition Norms & Procedure) Regulations, 2009 for grant of recognition to the petitioner institution for D.Ed course of two years duration with annual intake of 50 students


197


subject to the appointment of qualified faculty members within two months. Accordingly, the writ petitioner has recruited qualified teaching faculty comprising of Principal and seven other lecturers. The Principal is also doubling up as Lecturer in Social Studies. The selection has also been approved by the Director, State Council for Education Research and Training, Hyderabad through its proceedings dated 17.09.2013. Further the Southern Regional Committee of the NCTE has pointed that in terms Southern Regional Committee about appointing the teaching faculty and such appointments are approved and also it is suggested by the Southern Regional Committee of NCTE that the Fixed Deposit receipts of Endowment Fund and Reserve fund should be converted into funds lying in Joint account.

Sri Narsimha Reddy would submit that the original F.D.Rs converting them into joint account have already been furnished to the Southern Regional Committee on 26.09.2013. Therefore, the Southern Regional Committee, National Council for Teacher Education, Bangalore, the 1st respondent herein is directed to grant formal recognition order under sub-regulation (11) of Regulation 7 noted supra, immediately, at any rate within one week from the date of receipt of this order.

I am sure that as soon as the writ petitioner produces the formal recognition order from the Southern Regional Committee, the appropriate convenor for admissions to D.Ed course will allocate students to the petitioner institution for the Academic year 2013-14. This order was passed after hearing Sri.K.Ramakanth Reddy, learned Standing Counsel”.

The Letter of Intent reply and Court order was placed before SRC in its 253 rd

meeting held on 30th September & 01st October 2013 and decided to issue Formal Recognition for 2014-15.

Accordingly, Formal Recognition order was issued to the institution on 15.10.2013.

In the meantime, the institution has submitted its written representation on 15.10.2013 regarding reconsideration our request to issue Formal Recognition for the academic year 2013-14 of our Seven Hills Teacher Training Institution, Vinukonda, Guntur District as per the Hon’ble Court Order and submitted photocopy of Court Orders.

“…kindly grant formal recognition for the academic year 2013-14 as the following grounds:-

1. The SRC NCTE taken the late decision for 4 months. Our institution loses for one academic year i.e., 2012-13.

2. The SRC NCTE taken the wrong decision for rejection of our application because our institution have sufficient infrastructure and institutional facilities.

3. The state government was also approved staff list for the academic year 2013-14.

4. The SRC NCTE was also take our application into the consideration for the academic year 2012-13.

5. The Government of Andhra Pradesh not announced even today for DIET CET counseling.


198


6. The court was also given the direction to allocate the students to the petitioner-institution for the academic year 2013-14.”

The Hon’ble court order (SRCAPP483) was placed before SRC in its 248 th

meeting held on 13th – 15th July, 2013 and the committee decided to cause composite inspection within two weeks and submit report to the court with SRC Comments.As per the decision of SRC, the composite inspection of the institutions for the four courses were carried out on 22.7.2013 and the visiting team report was received in the office of SRC on 23.7.2013. Visiting Report was placed before SRC in its 250th meeting held on 11th-13th August 2013, and the committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for D.Ed (SRCAPP483). Further, the SRC advised the SRO to ask legal advisor to file a report in the court and put up a comparative statement for all other courses with all details.

The Committee considered the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh order dated 26-09-2013, letter from the institution dated 15-10-2013 and all other relevant documents of the institution, decided that the decision to grant recognition was taken on 1st Oct, 2013. According to Hon’ble Supreme Court order, we can not give recognition for 2013-14 after 3 rd

March, 2013, The Supreme Court order says:

“IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 276 OF 2012, Maa Vaishno Devi Mahila Mahavidyalaya … Appellant

Versus State of U.P. & Ors.

The recognition and affiliation granted as per above schedule shall be applicable for the current academic year. For example recognition granted upto 3rd March, 2013 and affiliation granted upto 10th May, 2013 shall be effective for the academic year 2013-2014 i.e. the courses starting from 1st April, 2013. For the academic year 2013-2014, no recognition shall be issued after 3rd March, 2013 and no affiliation shall be granted after 10th May, 2013. Any affiliation or recognition granted after the above cut-off dates shall only be valid for the academic year 2014-2015.We make it clear that no Authority/person/ Council/Committee shall be entitled to vary the schedule for any reason whatsoever. Any non-compliance shall amount to violating the orders of the Court”.We have, therefore, to confirm our earlier decision.

Further, the Committee advised Southern Regional Office to ask our Lawyer to immediately file an affidavit apprising the Court of this position and convey our apology for not being able to implement fully the Court order.

New Application -2013-2014


199


92.SRCAPP189

3B.Ed

Central University, Thiruvarur

DistrictTN

Central University, Thiruvarur P.O. Taluka & District, Pin - 610004, Tamilnadu

Central University, Thiruvarur P.O. Taluka & District, Pin - 610004, Tamilnadu had applied for grant of recognition to B.Ed Course for one year duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 26.12.2012. The institution has submitted hard copy of the application on 31.12.2012 along with processing fees vide Demand Draft bearing No. 582362 dt.24.12.2012 for Rs.40000/- drawn on Indian Overseas Bank.

Para 7[1-A(i)] and 7[1-A(ii)] of extant NCTE Regulations published in the Gazettee of India on 31st August 2009, as amended from time to time, the application shall be summarily rejected under one or more of the following circumstances:

Para 7[1-A(i)](a) The processing fee, as provided under rule 9 of the National Council for

Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application;


(c) Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society/institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application.

Para 7[1-A(ii)]The Regional Committee shall, after recording reasons for rejection under the circumstances referred to in clause (i) above, return the application to the applicant and refund the processing fees within 30 days of the online submission of the application.

The SRC in its 238th meeting held on 05th-06th February, 2013 and reviewed the duly scrutinized above new application received by Southern Regional Office, NCTE for the Session 2013-14. Accordingly, the above application, which suffer from basic infirmities, is summarily rejected as per Regulations 7 (1–A (i).

1. The University has submitted DD of Rs.40,000/- only as processing fee instead of Rs.50,000/-, as provided under rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997. Hence, the same is not in conformity of sub-regulation 7(1-A)(i)(a) of NCTE Regulations 2009.

2. The University has submitted only one set of on-line application, which is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application, as required under sub-regulation 7(1-A)(i)(b) of NCTE regulation.

3. The University has also not dispatched copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the University applying for the course possessed land on the date of application within 7 days of the submission of the on-line application, as required under sub-regulation 7(1-A)(i)(c) of NCTE Regulations 2009.

Accordingly, rejection letter was issued to the institution on 26.03.2013.


200


Further, the University in its covering letter has stated that the on-line application submitted by the University is for starting he Integrated programme in B.Sc.Ed/B.A.Ed on 26.12.2012. Whereas, it has been observed from the file that the University has submitted the on-line application for starting B.Ed face to face programme only and hence the application has been processed for B.Ed course only and not for Integrated programme.

A brief case was send to NCTE, Hqrs., on 31.05.2013.

The matter was placed before SRC in its 248th Meeting held on 13th-15th July, 2013 and decided to write to MHRD for relaxation. As per the oral instructions of Regional Committee the matter is resubmitted for consideration and decision.

The SRC in its 250th Meeting held on 11th-13th August, 2013 has considered the matter and decided that University be advised to apply to NCTE as per procedure meant for innovative teacher education programmes. Accordingly, a letter sent to the University on 09.10.2013.

The University letter dtd. 21.10.2013 has stated that

“ we have already submitted our application for Innovative four year integrated BA/B.Sc.-Ed programme to SRC vide our letters of even no, dated 31.08.2013 and 6.09.2013 along with Demand Draft for Rs. 50000/- towards processing fee.

It has now been understood from your letter cited that the application for Innovative Programme need to be sent to NCTE Headquarters. If so, our application mentioned above for Innovative programme dated 31.08.2013 mentioned above may kindly be forwarded to NCTE Headquarters under intimation to us. Copy of our application dated 31.08.2013 and letter dated 06.09.2013 are enclosed for ready reference.

The Committee considered the matter and decided and advised Southern Regional Office to send the Guidelines to the University and advise them of the procedure to be followed in cases of innovative courses.

LOI Cases

93.SRCAPP55

6D.Ed

Guptas College of Education,

Kadapa District

AP

Guptas College of Education, No. 89/3b, Kothapeta Street, Peddasettipalli Village & Post, Proddatur Taluk, Kadapa District-516360, Andhra Pradesh.

Sri Sudheraen Ramanujacharyu la Educational Society, No. 7/347, Anjaneyanagar Road, Badvel Village, Post & Taluk, Kadapa District-516227, Andhra Pradesh has applied for grant of recognition to Guptas College of Education, No. 89/3b, Kothapeta Street, Peddasettipalli Village & Post, Proddatur Taluk, Kadapa District-516360, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed course online on 19.09.2011 for two years duration under section 14(1) of the NCTE Act.1993 and received in the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE on 03.10.2011.

A letter dt.08.12.2011 was issued to institution calling for proof of dispatch. The institution submitted photocopy of postal receipt whereas the envelop is not


201


carries any postal stamp.



The processing fee, as provided under Rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application.

Hard copy in triplicate of the online application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application.

Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society. Institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of online application.

The SRC considered the matter in its 216th meeting held on 11th-12th January, 2012 and careful perusal of the original file of the institution and other related documents, NCTE Act 1993. Regulations and guidelines from time to time laid on the table. Written representation from the institution, the Regional Committee decided to reject the application on the following grounds.

The processing fee, as provided under Rule 9 of the National Council for Teacher Education Rules, 1997 is not furnished on or before the date of submission of online application.

Hard copy in triplicate of the online application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of the online application.

Copy of the registered land documents issued by the competent authority indicating that the society. Institution applying for the course possessed land on the date of application is not dispatched within 7 days of the submission of online application.

Hardcopy of application not dispatched within 7 days, from the date of online submission.

Accordingly, a rejection letter was issued to the institution vide no. F.No. SRCAPP556 (2012-13)/D.El.Ed/AP/2011-12/36912 dated 13/01/2012

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-93/2012 Appeal/4th Meeting-2012 A 51648 dated 11.05.2012 state that “the council concluded that there was adequate ground to remand the case to the SRC for further processing of the application on merit as per regulations”.

The appeal order dated 11.05.2012 is placed before SRC for decision and direction.

The SRC in its 223rd Meeting held on 29th-31st May 2012 considered the


202


appellate authority order dt.11.05.2012 for further processing of the application on merit.

The SRC in its 229th meeting held on 30th-31st July 2012, considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 10.05.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

The institution has submitted its written representation on 29.08.2012(with reference to online minutes).

The SRC in its 232nd Meeting held on 29th-31st August, 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 29.08.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a final show cause notice was issued to the institution on 12.10.2012. The institution has submitted written representation on 01/11/2012.

The SRC in its 235th Meeting held on 21st-22nd November, 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 01.11.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 19/12/2012. The institution has submitted written representation on. 11/01/2013,

The SRC in its 241st meeting held on 29th & 31st March 2013 & 01st April 2013 considered the reply of the institution dt.11-01-2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 20th - 25th May 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 15.05.2013. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 04.06.2013.

On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.El.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.



On Careful perusal of the original file of the institution and staff profiles submitted by the institution in response to the letter of Intent, the Regional Committee decided that Formal Recognition be granted to D.Ed., course of


203


two year duration with an annual intake of 50(fifty only) students, from the academic session 2014-2015.

94.SRCAPP12

69D.Ed

Pushpavathi College of Education,

Guntur District

AP

Pushpavathi College of Education, Plot/Khasara No. 490/A, NRT-CH P Road, Kanaparru Village and Post, Nadendla Taluk, Kanaparru City, Guntur District- 522549, Andhra Pradesh.

Pushpavathi Educational Society, Plot No. 490/A, NRT-CH P Road, Kanaparru Village and Post, Nadendla Taluk, Kanaparru City, Guntur District- 522549, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Pushpavathi College of Education, Plot/Khasara No. 490/A, NRT-CH P Road, Kanaparru Village and Post, Nadendla Taluk, Kanaparru City, Guntur District- 522549, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.09.2011 and physical copy received on 04.10.2011

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 08.11.2011 followed by reminder on 22.12.2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29.12.2011 and the institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 07.02.2012

The SRC in its 218th meeting held on 28th February 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 07.02.2102 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

1. In the building plan submitted, Sy.No. 490 is not matching with land document.

2. In the building plan submitted, Sy.No. 490/4 is not matching with building plan and land document.

3. In the Land usage certificate, Sy.No. 490/A is not matching with Land document, Building plan & building completion certificate.

4. It is observed from the records that Survey numbers, Door No. are same for two or more different societies, who have submitted land document which is found registered on the same day. The land documents of SRCAPP-1269 & 1188 are one and the same.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 22/03/2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 03/04/2012.

The SRC in its 222nd meeting held on 09-10 May, 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 03.04.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 09.06.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 12.06.2012

The reply of the institution to the show cause notice was duly considered by SRC in its 224th meeting held on 14th – 17th June 2012 and the reply is unconvincing and not satisfactory, deficiencies still persist as under:

Building Completion certificate is not approved by the competent


204


authority.

Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee has decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

Accordingly, a rejection order was issued to the institution vide F.No.SRCAPP1269 /D.EI.Ed/ AP/2012-2013/44975 dated 10/07/2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order no. F.No.89-403/2012 Appeal/8th Meeting-2012 dated 05.09.2012 states that “…the council, taking into account all aspects of the matter including the submission of a building completion certificate issued by the Executive Engineer, Public Works Deptt, concluded that the appeal deserved to be accepted and the matter remanded to the SRC for further processing of the application as per Regulations”.

The council concluded that the appeal deserved to accepted and the matter remanded to SRC for further processing of the application as per Regulations.”

The appellate authority order was placed before SRC in its 233rd meeting held on 26th-28th September 2012, considered the matter decided to process and put up.

As per the decision of SRC the application was processed and placed in 234th meeting of SRC held on 17th-18th October, 2012, and the committee considered all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) OF NCTE Act, for the following:

1. As per building plan submitted, total built up area given as 1566.2 sq.mtrs, whereas, as per building completion certificate it is given as 19092.56 sq.ft, both are not matching.

2. Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. authorized engineer is not submitted.

3. As per size of the multipurpose hall is only 113.52 sq.mtrs, which is less than the requirement of 2000 sq.ft as per NCTE norms.


The SRC in its 236th meeting held on 16th –18th December 2012 has considered the reply of the institution dt. 06-12-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 15 th - 19th

January 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 09.01.2013. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 17.01.2013.

On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the


205


table, the Regional Committee in its 241st meeting held on 29th , 30th March and 1st April, 2013 decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.El.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

LOI was issued to the institution on 10.04.2013. The reply of the institution to LOI was received on 28.05.2013.

The SRC in its 249th Meeting held on 24th-26th July, 2013 considered the matter and noted that the Service certificate submitted by Mr. Anilkumar D.M. for the post of Principal in the above said college is a fraud certificate. The certificate issued by Sri Malathesha D.Ed College is from October 2007, whereas the college was granted recognition from 02-12-2010 only. This is a case of fraudulent practice.

Accordingly, the SRC in its 247th Meeting held on 20th-22nd June, 2013 decided to withdraw LOI issued to the institution and reject the application of the college for D.Ed course (SRCAPP1269).Meantime, the committee has re-considered the list of withdrawal letter of intent issued to the institution and decided that “cases of LOI-reply after 03.03.2013 will go for acad-year 2014-15. This case also would fall in that category since they had time till 10.06.2013 to reply. We have given time till Dec-2013 in all such cases, accordingly, in this case also, time till Dec-2013 will be available. The order dated 22.06.2013 is reviewed and cancelled. The SRC feels, it will be unfair to penalize the institution for fraud committed by the Principal.The institution is given time till Dec-2013 to remove the deficiency and to appoint a new, qualified Principal”. Accordingly, a letter was issued to the institution on 13.09.2013. The institution has submitted its written representation on 14.10.2013,

On Careful perusal of the original file of the institution and staff profiles submitted by the institution in response to the letter of Intent, the Regional Committee decided that Formal Recognition be granted to D.Ed., course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(fifty only) students, from the academic session 2014-2015.

95.SRCAPP55

2M.P.Ed

Annamalai University, Cuddalore

DistrictTN

Annamalai University, Music College Road, Thiruvetkalam, Annamalai Nagar, Chidambaram, Cuddalore District, Pin – 608002, Tamilnadu.

Annamalai University, Music College Road, Thiruvetkalam, Annamalai Nagar, Chidambaram, Cuddalore District, Pin – 608002, Tamilnadu had submitted application for starting M.P.Ed, B.P.Ed and D.P.Ed courses on 26.09.2011 for the session 2012-13. It is ascertained after scrutiny of your application in accordance with clause 8 (2) and 8(3) of NCTE Regulation 2009, that:-

“In the first instance an institution shall be considered for grant of recognition of only one course for the basic unit as prescribed in the norms and standards for the particular teacher education programme”.“An institution can apply for one basic unit only of an additional course or for an additional unit of the existing recognized course after completion of three academic session of the respective course, for which the institution shall submit application before the cut of date prescribed for submission of applications in the year succeeding the completion of three academic sessions”.


206


As the University has submitted three applications for M.P.Ed, B.P.Ed and D.P.Ed courses for the session 2012-13 and as per NCTE Regulation 2009 reproduced above, an institution shall be considered for grant of recognition for only one course for the basic unit as prescribed in the norms and standards for the particular teacher education programme.

Accordingly, a letter dt. 04.10.2011 was issued to the University seeking to inform the name of one course that the University wants to apply for further processing and consideration. As per Regulation 2009, 8(2) and 8(3) an institution cannot apply for more than one course at one time.

The University vide letter dt.15.10.2011 has submitted its reply has stated that they have sufficient instructional and infrastructural facilities with highly qualified teaching faculties and has requested to consider for all the three courses namely D.P.Ed, B.P.Ed and M.P.Ed course.

The SRC in its 213th meeting held on 06-07 November, 2011 considered the reply of the University letter dt. 15.10.2011 and all other relevant details and decided that, the applicant-University has not been able to appreciate the Legal position relating to consideration of applications by the Southern Regional Committee. As per the NCTE regulations 2009, the committee is not allowed to consider applications for more than one course at a time. The applicant-University has neither accepted this position nor indicated its preference of any one out of the three courses applied for. That being so, the application cannot be processed further. Accordingly, all the three applications are rejected and rejection letter was issued to the institution on 24.01.2012.

The institution preferred appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the Appellate Authority vide order dt. 18.04.2012 has stated as follows:-

“after perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit and after consideration oral arguments advanced during the hearing, the Council concluded that there was adequate justification in remaining the case to the SRC for further processing of the application of M.P.Ed. course on merit as per Regulations”.

NOW THEREFORE, the Council hereby remands back the case of Annamalai University, Cuddalore, Tamilnadu to the SRC, NCTE, for necessary action as indicated above”.

As per the Regulations an University application for M.P.Ed can be considered only if the University is already running or offering B.P.Ed course. The appellate has not noted this point. The SRC decided to seek clarification about this decision and pending clarification from Appellate authority, the committee decided to process the M.P.Ed application.

The SRC in its 222nd Meeting held on 09th-10th May, 2012 considered the Appellate authority order dt. 18.04.2012 and decided to process the application further on submission of original application and related supporting documents as per the regulations.

The institution has replied to the deficiency letter dt. 23.07.2012, vide their letter dt. 17.08.2012.


207


The SRC in its 231st meeting held on 22nd-23rd August 2012, considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 17.08.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show cause Notice. Accordingly, Show cause notice was issued to the institution on 13.09.2012. The institution submitted its reply on 03.10.2012.

The SRC in its 235th meeting held on 21st-22nd November, 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 03.10.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act. Accordingly, by seeing the website the institution had submitted its written representation on 24.12.2012.

The SRC in its 239th meeting held on 26th-27th February, 2013 considered the reply of the institution dt.24-12-2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

The inspection of the institution was fixed between 13th-17th May, 2013. The same was intimated to the institution on 06.05.2013. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 16.05.2013.

On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the SRC in its 249th Meeting held on 24th-26th July, 2013 decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to M.P.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 40(Forty only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

Accordingly, LOI was issued to the institution on 23.08.2013.

Date of receipt of LOI reply. 07/10/2013.

The Committee considered the reply of the University to LOI and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Notice Under section 14 of NCTE Act for the following:

The University has not submitted the staff list duly approved by the competent authority.

Service certificate & marks cards of the Principal not submitted.

Marks cards of all teaching staff are not submitted.

Original FDRs for Rs. 5 & 3 lacs in joint account for 5 years not submitted.

(There are many gaps in the staff list submitted, since recognition will only be for 2014-15, the Committee decided to give them time to fill up the


208


gaps).

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Notice to the institution, as to why the application for recognition be not rejected and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the rejection of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

96.SRCAPP13

27M.Ed

Immanueal Arasar


Kanyakumari District

TN

Immanuel Arasar College of Education, Plot/Khasara no. 926/39, Street No. Edavilagam, Nattalam Post, Vilavancode Taluk, Kanyakumari District, Pin-629165, Tamilnadu.Immanuel Arasar International Institute of Science & Technology Educational Charitable Trust, Plot No. 926/39, Street/Road. Edavilagam, Nattalam Post, Nattalam Village, Vilvancode Taluk, Kanyakumari District-629195, Tamilnadu had applied for grant of recognition to Immanuel Arasar College of Education, Plot/Khasara no. 926/39, Street no. Edavilagam, Nattalam Post, Vilavancode Taluk, Kanyakumari District, Pin-629165, Tamilnadu, for M.Ed Course for One year duration under Section 15(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 30.09.2011. The institution has submitted hard copy of the application on 10.10.2011 (Dispatched on 04.10.2011).


The SRC in its 219th meeting held on 15th-16th March, 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 07.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and decided to serve Show Cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 10.04.2012. The institution has submitted its written representation on 09.05.2012.

The institution has submitted reply to the Show Cause Notice after stipulated period of 21 days from the date of issue of the Notice.

The SRC in its 223rd Meeting held on 29th-31st May 2012 considered the reply of the institution, which is received on 09.05.2012, i.e., after 29 (Twenty Nine) days from the date of issue of show cause notice letter and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of M.Ed course. Accordingly, rejection order was issued to the institution on 25.06.2012.

The institution preferred appeal to NCTE, Hqrs and the Appellate Authority vide order no. F.No.89-376/2012 Appeal/8th Meeting-2012 has stated as follows:-

“after perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit and after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing the Council concluded


209


that there was adequate ground to remand the case to the SRC for considering the reply to the show cause notice and taking further decision thereafter.

NOW THEREFORE, the Council hereby remands back the case of Immanuel Arasar College of Education, Kanyakumari, Tamilnadu to the SRC, NCTE for necessary action as indicated above”.

Accordingly, as per decision of the appellate authority, reply Show Cause Notice received on 09.05.2012 for the Show cause notice dtd. 10.04.2012.

The SRC in its 235th meeting held on 21-22nd November, 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letters dt. 09.05.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

Built up area shown in building plan is not matching with that of affidavit submitted.

As per Tamil Version of the land document, land registration was done on 17.10.2005, whereas English version is reflecting that it was executed on 13.10.2002, it needs clarification from the institution.

The institution has not submitted valid minority certificate issued by the competent authority from the State Govt. as B.Ed is banned in the State of Tamilnadu.

The instutiton has submitted proof of completion of academic year 2011-12 only, from DTERT Chennai, proof of completion of two more academic year is not submitted.

Institution has to submit Latest ‘NAAC’ Certificate.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 01.01.2013. The institution has submitted a written representation on 15.01.2013.

The SRC in its 241st meeting held on 29th & 31st March 2013 & 01st April 2013 considered the reply of the institution dt.15-01-2013 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms. Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 13 th - 17th May 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 06.05.2013. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 19.05.2013.

On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the SRC in its 247th Meeting held on 20th-22nd June, 2013 decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to M.Ed course of one year duration with an annual intake of 35(Thirty Fifty only)(one unit) subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session. Accordingly, LOI was issued to the institution on 16.08.2013. The institution has submitted reply on 26.09.2013.

The Committee considered the reply of the Institution to LOI and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Notice Under section 14 of NCTE Act for the following:


210


The Institution has not submitted the staff list duly approved by the competent authority.

Service certificate & marks cards of the Principal not submitted.

Marks cards of all teaching staff are not submitted.

(There are many gaps in the staff list submitted, since recognition will only be for 2014-15, the Committee decided to give them time to fill up the gaps).

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Notice to the institution, as to why the application for recognition be not rejected and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the rejection of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

Show Cause Notice Reply

97.APS02226

B.EdUnity College of Education, Marathalli, Bangalore

KA

Unity College of Education,No.124, Ammani Bellandur Kane, Yemmalur Main Road, Marathalli, Bangalore-560037.

Recognition was granted to Unity College of Education,No.124, Ammani Bellandur Kane, Yemmalur Main Road, Marathalli Bangalore-560037, Karnataka for Secondary (B.Ed) Course of one year duration from the academic session 2004-2005 with an annual intake of 100 students vide F.SRO/NCTE/B.Ed/2004-2005/3669 dated 25/11/2004 with a condition to shift to its own premises/building within three years from the date of recognition(in case the course is started in rented premises).

An RTI application was received on 07/01/2013 from Mr. Harsh Kumar C/o.Smt Asha Devi, Hira Sadan, Next to girls PJ School, Hatiya Gachi, Simri Bhaktiyarpur, Saharsa ( Bihar) 852127 stating that

“Unity College of Education”, affiliated to Bangalore University [College Code:H7] and approved by NCTE[Code No. APSO 2226] had shifted its campus from # No. 124,Amani BellendurKane, Yamalur Main Road,Marathalli ,Bangalore- 560 037 to #170/6,Ram Sagara Road, Chandapura, Opp to Govt. Hospital , Bangalore – 560 081.”

A copy of the Provisional certificate issued to the RTI applicant by the College attested by Bangalore University bearing the seal of the college with the new address was enclosed.

As seen from records and from many RTI queries received by this office it appears that the institution has shifted to a different address without getting


211


permission/recognition for shifting of premises, there is no information regarding shifting of premises by the institution submitted to this office so far.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 241st meeting of SRC , held on 29th

March to 1st April 2013considered the matter and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

The institution was given recognition on 25-11-2004 in a temporary premises with a specific condition that the institution should move to a permanent premise within a period of three years i.e., on or before 25-11-2007.

As seen from records and from RTI queries received by this office, the institution has shifted to new premises from “Unity College of Education, No. 124, Ammani Belandur Kane, Yemmalur Main Road,Marathalli, Bangalore-560037 to “ Unity College of Education (B.Ed) #170/6, Ram Sagara Road, Chandapura Opp to Govt. Hospital, Bangalore-560 081, Karnataka. The institution has shifted to new premises without the permission of SRCNCTE. This is gross violation of NCTE regulations and norms of 2009.

As per 8 (11) of Regulations 2009:

In case of change of premises, prior approval of the Regional Committee concerned shall be necessary, which could be accorded after due inspection of the institution at the new site. Application for change of premises, in triplicate, in the specified format along with other relevant documents shall be submitted by the Institution to the Regional Office for prior approval of change of premises. The change can be permitted to a site which, if applied initially, could have qualified for establishment of an institution as per specified norms of

National Council for Teacher Education. The change shall be displayed on website thereafter. The application for change of premises shall be accompanied by a demand draft of Rs. 50,000 (or as revised from time to time) of a Nationalised Bank drawn in favour of the Member Secretary, National Council for Teacher Education and payable at the city where the Regional Committee is located. The fee may also be paid online at the bank designated by National Council for Teacher Education.

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to the institution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the withdrawal of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

Further,

The Committee decided to cause inspection of the institution at the new premises after collecting inspection fee of Rs. 50000/- under NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms


212


As per the decision of SRC, a show cause notice was issued to the institution vide F.SRO/No.APSO2226/B.Ed/KA/2013-14 on 18.05.2013 and a letter asking the institution to submit the documents of the new premises was sent vide F.SRO /No.APSO222 /B.Ed /KA /2013-14/51749 ON 18.05.2013.

The above letters were returned back to this office on 22.05.2013 and 23.05.2013 respectively. The letters were sent (reposted) to the institution for the second time and they were returned back to this office on 28.05.2013 and 03.06.2013.

The institution has not responded to the letters from this office so far.

The Committee considered the matter, non response of the institution to the show cause notice and letter written to the institution from this office dated 18-05-2013 on the above matter, also the relevant documents of the institution and decided to withdraw recognition for the following reasons:-

The institution was given recognition on 25-11-2004 in a temporary premises with a specific condition that the institution should move to a permanent premises within a period of three years i.e., on or before 25/11/2007.

The institution has shifted to new address from Unity College of Education, #No. 124, Amani Bellendurkane, Yamalaur Main Road, Marathalli, Bangalore-560 037 to Unity College of Education, # 170/6, Ram Sagara Road, Chandapura, Opp to Govt. Hospital, Bangalore – 560 081. As seen from records and from many RTI queries received by this office and the copy of the provisional certificate issued to the RTI applicant by the College attested by Bangalore University bearing the seal of the college with the new address was confirmed that the Institution has shifted to New address without the approval of the SRC NCTE, Bangalore.

As per 8 (11) of Regulation 2009, in case of change of premises, prior approval of the regional Committee concerned shall be necessary and which could be accorded after due inspection of the institution at the new site. Application for change of premises, in triplicate, in the specified format along with other relevant documents shall be submitted by the Institution to the Regional Office for prior approval of change of premises. The change can be permitted to a site which, if applied initially, could have qualified for establishment of an institution as per specified norms of National Council for Teacher Education. The change shall be displayed on website thereafter. The application for change of premises shall be accompanied by a demand draft of Rs. 40,000 (or as revised from time to time) of a Nationalised Bank drawn in favour of the Member Secretary, National Council for Teacher Education and payable at the city where the Regional Committee is located. The fee may also be paid online at the bank designated by National Council for Teacher “.

The institution has not replied to the show cause notice issued vide letter dated 18/05/2013 and to the another letter dated 18/05/2013 asking the institution to submit the documents of the new premises along with inspection fee of Rs. 50000/- to cause inspection at the new premises.

The above letters were returned back to this office on 22.05.2013 and 23.05.2013 respectively. Again the same letters were reposted to the institution and were returned back to this office on 28/05/2013 and 03-06-


213


2013.

Based on the above points the committee decides to withdraw the recognition of the B.Ed course run by the Unity College of Education, No. 124, Ammani Belandur Kane, Yemmalur Main Road, Marathalli, Bangalore-560037, Karnataka from the academic year 2013.14, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in B.Ed, course, if any, to complete their course.




98.APS06174

D.EdSeema D.Ed College, Kolar District

KA

Seema D.Ed College, S.N.M school Road, Andersonpet, K.G.F – 563113, Kolar District, Karnataka

Seema Educational Charitable Trust, Kolar District, Karnataka had submitted an application to the SRC, NCTE for grant on recognition to Seema D.Ed College, S.N.M school Road, Anderson Pet, K.G.F – 563113, Kolar District, Karnataka and was granted recognition on 12.04.2007 for Elementary courses of two years duration with an annual intake of fifty students subject to the condition to shift its own premises/building with in 3 years from the date of recognition ( in case the course is started in rented premises). Hence, the institution should have shifted to its own premises with in 12.04.2010.

In the mean while SRC has received a telephonic and oral complaint about admitting the students by taking heavy donations in Andaman and Nicobar islands.

Accordingly, a letter dated F.SRO/APS06174-D.Ed/43589 dt. 06.07.2012 was issued to the institution seeking explanation regarding shifting of the premises to its own premises and also regarding collection of heavy donation.

The institution submitted a letter dated 24.07.2012 states as follows:-“Our Seema Education Charitable Trust clarifies that, the land had already been registered for the premises in favour of Seema Education Charitable Trust and hence seema D.Ed college will shift its premises within 6 months to the Registered land, as the college humbly request to grant 6 months of time for shifting of the premises.

Whereas collection of heavy donation for admission in our college is been fixed not more than Rs. 25000/- (Rupees Twenty Five Thousand Only) for 2 years, hence the rumors are complete false and baseless.”

The SRC in its 236th meeting held during 16-17 December, 2012 considered the matter, reply of the institution dt. 24.07.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:- The Institution was granted recognition in temporary premises to run D.Ed

course on 14.04.2007 with a condition that it should shift to its own permanent premises in 3 years. i.e., on or before 14.04.2010. The Institution is still


214


running in temporary premises and not shifted to new premises even after a lapse of stipulated 3 years and after lapse of time period of more than 5 years and 08 months.

The request of the institution to permit 6 months time to shift to new premises in registered land cannot be permissible, already 5 years and 08 months time period is elapsed for shifting. The institution has violated the condition of shifting to new building/premises as per NCTE norms of 2009.

As decided in the 236th meeting of SRC, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution to submit reply within 21 days from the date of receipt of the along with necessary certificate/documents vide this office letter No.APS06174/D.Ed./KA/2013-2014/48755 dated 5.2.2013.

From the Center Diary report it is found that the institution has submitted reply for the Showcause Notice on 26.2.2013 vide Inward No.124988. But, the reply dated 26.2.2013 submitted by the institution is not found to be traceable file or in the office, even after long search. Hence, under the above circumstances, the above matter is placed before SRC for further guidance and instructions in the matter in order to process the file

The Committee considered the matter and advised Southern Regional Office to request the institution to send a copy of their reply to our show cause notice dated 05/02/2013..

99.APS02340

D.EdCitizen

Teacher Training Institute,

Kolar District

KA

Citizen Teacher Training Institute, Mayur Circle, Tolgate, Shidlaghatta, Kolar District-562105, Karnataka.

Recognition was granted to Citizen Teacher Training Institute, Mayur Circle, Tolgate, Shidlaghatta, Kolar District-562105, Karnataka, for Elementary (D.Ed) course of two & Half years from the academic session 2005-2006 with an annual intake of 50 students on 13.02.2006 with a condition to shift to its own premises/building within three eyars from the date of recognition (in case the course is started in rented premises).

On 21/01/2013, complaint letter is received on 21/01/2013 from Sri.B.R.Ramesh, advocate, # 895, 3rd ‘A’ Main,‘D’ Block , II Stage , Rajajinagar, Bangalore – 560 010 regarding the substandard and non-viable institutions of teachers training in Chickballapur district.

He has stated that “ I am enclosing herewith a report of DSERT pertaining to Chickballapur district. This inspection report is based on visiting teams report of DIETS. They have inspected these institutions and submitted information to the DSERT. The DSERT has compiled the data and have identified the deficiencies of the institutions. You are competent to issue recognition to all institutions imparting teacher education. The students who study in these substandard institutions will be the major losers and they cannot meet the needs of students at primary level. These institutions produce substandard teachers who in turn cannot come up to the expectations of the department. Hence, it becomes obligatory on you part to initiate action after verification from your end. I do hope that you would initiate at least some action and verify the infrastructure facilities of these institutions and see that the teacher education in this district is rectified and put on right lines, so that the prospective teachers are benefited. I do hope that you will look into this matter personally and do the needful. A line in reply is


215


appreciated. More information with regard to other substandard institutions will be sent to you in due course about other districts.”

A copy of the evaluation report of 9 D.Ed colleges during the year 2009-2010 is enclosed along with the complaint letter.

The Committee considered the matter of complaint letter dt. 21/01/2013 and advised Southern Regional Office to examine the report from DSERT and put up

The SRC in its 248th meeting held on 13th – 15th July 2013 considered the matter and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act, for the following:

1. As per DSERT report, the total earmarked built up area is only 1348.02 sq.ft, which is less than the requirement of 1500 sq.mts as per NCTE norms.

2. As per the records, the total earmarked site area is only 4655.178 sq.ft, which is less than the requirement as per NCTE norms.

3. As per VT report, the institution is not functioning in its own building.

In view of the above and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the Committee decided to issue a Show cause Notice to the institution as to why the recognition be not withdrawn and thereby providing an opportunity to theinstitution to make a written representation within 21 days from the date of receipt of the Notice along with necessary certificates/documents in order to take a final decision in the matter; failing which action will be taken including the withdrawal of application for recognition, based on the records available, with no further notice.

Accordingly, a Showcase Notice was issued to the institution on 27/08/2013.The Institution submitted its reply vide letter dated 17.09.2013

The Committee considered the written reply of the institution to the show cause notice vide letter dated 17-09-2013 and also the relevant documents of the institution and decided to withdraw recognition for the following reasons:-

As per the land documents submitted, the land is in the name of an individual, which is not permissible as per NCTE regulations.

Building completion certificate submitted by the institution is not approved by competent Govt. authority.

Based on the above points the committee decides to withdraw the recognition of the D.Ed course run by the Citizen Teacher Training Institute, Mayer Circle, Tolgate, Shidlaghatta, Kolar District-562105, Karnataka from the academic year 2013.14, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in D.Ed, course, if any, to complete their course.



Further decided to return Endowment funds and Reserve fund deposited with SRC NCTE, Bangalore, if any, after ensuring payments to all dues of


216


faculty and staff.

100.APS08947

B.EdSri Venkateshwara College of Education, Prakasam District

AP

Sri Venkateshwara College of Education, Darsi Village, Addanki Road, Darsi Mandal, Prakasam District, Andhra Pradesh.

Sri Venkateswara Rural and Urban Development Society, Prakasam District, Andhra Pradesh had submitted an application in the name of Sri Venkateshwara College of Education, Prakasam District, Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition for B.Ed course on 13/08/2007.

The application was processed and recognition was granted for offering B.Ed course with an intake of 100 students on 23/10/2007 at Darsi Village, Addanki Road, Darsi Mandal, Prakasam District, Andhra Pradesh.The institution has submitted its written representation alongwith DD of Rs.50000/- stating as follows:

“our institution Sri Venkateshwara College of Education (B.Ed) was sanctioning at the address:- Darsi Village, Addanki Road, Darsi Mandal, Prakasam District, Andhra Pradesh the college was functioning in the 30 years lease premises.

Now our management has purchased own land and has constructed new building for the purpose of B.Ed college, hence we propose to shift the college to new premises address; podili Road, Rajampalli Village & Post, Darisi Mandal, Prakasam District, Andhra Pradesh the distance between old campus to new campus is 05 K.M. only.

In this regard we are hereby submitting formal application along with documents and D.D for Rs. 50.000/- bearing No. 041856 dated 21/03/2013 seeking permission from SRC for shifting our Sri Venkateshwara College of Education (B.Ed) to new and own campus”.

The matter was placed before SRC’s 242nd meeting held on 14-15th April, 2013 and the committee decided to re-submit in the next SRC meeting.

The SRC in its 244th Meeting held on 09th – 11th May, 2013 considered the institutions letter dt. 21.03.2013 seeking permission for shifting to new permanent building and decided to issue show cause notice to the institution to submit the following documents before causing shifting inspection of the institution under NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 20/07/2013. The institution has submitted its written representation on 08.08.2013

The Sothern Regional Committee considered the matter, reply of the institution to the show cause notice vide letter dated 08-08-2013 and all relevant documents and decided to cause shifting inspection at the new premises under NCTE Act to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the existing programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

101.SRCAPP14

38B.Ed

Princess Durru Shehvar College of Education for Women, Plot/Khasara No. 17-8-467, Bagh-e-Jahanara, Yakuthpura Post and Taluk, Hyderabad District-500002,


217


Princess Durru Shehvar College of Education for Women, Hyderabad District

AP

Andhra Pradesh

Minhaj Ush Sharqia Educational Society, Plot No. 17-8-467, Bagh-e-Jahanara Village, Yakuthpura Post and Taluk, Hyderabad District-500023, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Princess Durru Shehvar College of Education for Women, Plot/Khasara No. 17-8-467, Bagh-e-Jahanara, Yakuthpura Post and Taluk, Hyderabad District-500002, Andhra Pradesh for B.Ed Course of one years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 30.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 07.10.2011.


The SRC in its 217th meeting held on 08th-09th February, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt.01.02.2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, the inspection of the institution was fixed between 25 th to 29th February, 2012. The same was intimated to the institution on 21.02.2012. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 27.02.2012.

The SRC in its 221st meeting held on 19th – 20th April 2012 considered the VT Report, VCD and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 16/05/2012. The institution has submitted its written representation dt.11/06/2012.

The institution has submitted reply for show cause notice after the expiry of the stipulated time of 21 days period as per clause 14 (1) of NCTE Regulations.

The institution has been given time to reply, in spite of giving time to the applicant institution enabling it to rectify its deficiencies/short comings, yet applicant has not submitted the replies within stipulated time.

Supreme Court vide their order in Civil Appeal NO. 1125-1128/2011 in SLP No. 17165-68/2009 filed by NCTE Vs ors, which reads as under:

“An institution is not entitled to recognition unless it fulfils the conditions specified in various clauses of the Regulations. The Council is directed to ensure that in future no institution is granted recognition unless it fulfils the conditions laid down in the Act and the Regulations and the time schedule fixed for processing the application by the Regional Committee and communication of the decision on the issue of recognition it strictly adhered to”.The SRC in its 225th Meeting held on 25th-27th June, 2012 considered the reply of the institution, which is received on 11/06/2012, i.e., after 26 (Twenty six) days from the date of issue of show cause notice dt. 16/05/2012 and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the


218


application of the institution for recognition of B.Ed course.


Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order No. F.No. 89-605/2012Appeal/12th A 61735 Meeting-2012 dated 03/01/2013 stated that “…the council concluded that there is adequate ground to accept the appeal and remand back the case to the SRC to reissue the deficiency letter and thereafter process the case as per regulations”.

The appellate authority order was placed before SRC in its 240 th Meeting held on 09th-11th March, 2013 considered the Appellate authority order dt. 03/01/2013 and decided to reissue the deficiency letter, further process the application of the said institution as per NCTE Regulations.

Note:

As per application deficiency letter was issued, the inspection of the institution was conducted and the notice was issued to the institution. The institution has submitted its written representation after the stipulated period of 21 days. Later it was rejected by SRC in its 225 th Meeting 25th-26th June, 2012.

As per the appellate authority order it is contradictory instead of processing show cause notice reply it is mentioned that re-issue deficiency letter.

The SRC in its 247th meeting held on 20th-22nd June 2013, considered the matter and decided to further process the reply of the institution with respect to the deficiency letter issued.

On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution to show cause notice, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to B.Ed course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100(one hundred only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

102.APS07308

B.EdAdarsha College of Education, Mahabubnagar District

AP

Adarsha College of Education, Adarsha Hills, Narayanpet, Mahabubnagar-509210, Andhra Pradesh.

Adarsha Educational Society, Mahabubnagar District, Andhra Pradesh was granted recognition in the name and style of Adarsha College of Education, Adarsha Hills, Narayanpet, Mahabubnagar-509210, Andhra Pradesh for offering B.Ed course of one year duration with an annual intake of 100 students on 16/10/2007.

The SRC in its 244th Meeting held on 9th-11th May, 2013, the committee has considered the reply of the institution dated 29/04/2013 for D.Ed course and has decided to reject application for D.Ed and examine the B.Ed course and submit separately link the D.Ed file.


219


As per the decision of SRC, the B.Ed course was examined and placed before SRC in its 244th meeting held on 9-11th May, 2013, the B.Ed file case is examined and was put up by linking to D.Ed file (SRCAPP920).

The SRC in its 245th Meeting held on 19th-21st May, 2013 considered the above matter and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 20/06/2013. The institution has submitted its written representation on 18/07/2013. (i.e. after the stipulated period of 21 days.)

The Committee considered the written reply of the institution to the show cause notice vide letter dated 18-07-2013 and also the relevant documents of the institution and decided to withdraw recognition for the following reasons:-

The institution has not submitted building completion certificate duly approved by the competent Govt. Engineer.

Building completion certificate submitted by the institution is in individual name, which is not permissible as per NCTE regulations 2009.

Land Use Certificate submitted by the institution is hand written by the Sarpanch, It is not in the prescribed format and not issued by the competent authority.

Based on the above points the committee decides to withdraw the recognition of the B.Ed course run by the Adarsha College of Education, Adarsha Hills, Narayanpet, Mahabubnagar-509210, Andhra Pradesh from the academic year 2013.14, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in B.Ed, course, if any, to complete their course.




Other Items

103.SRCAPP11

28D.EdSri

Venkateswara School

of Education,

Sri Venkateswara School of Education, Khasara No. 451, Plot No.357, Sadakuppam Village & Post Office, BangarupalayamTaluk& City, Chittoor District-517416,Andhra Pradesh

Sri Venkateshwara Educational & Charitable Society, Plot No. 357, Gajulapalli Street, SadkuppamVillage & Post, BangarupalayamTaluk& City, Chittoor District-517416, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Sri Venkateswara School of Education, Khasara No. 451, Plot

No.357,Sadakuppam Village & Post Office, BangarupalayamTaluk&


220


Chittoor District

AP

City, Chittoor District-517416, Andhra Pradesh for D.El.Ed Course for two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.09.2011. The institution has submitted hard copy of the application on 04.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 18.10.2011. A reminder letter to the State Government was sent on 16.12.2011. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 29.12.2011. Now the institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 23.02.2012.

The Southern Regional Committee in its 219th Meeting held on 15th and 16th

March 2012 considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 23.02.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, Show Cause Notice was issued on 04.04.2012.The institution has submitted written representation on 23.04.2012.

The SRC in its 222nd Meeting of SRC held on 09th – 10th May 2012, considered the reply of the institution vide letter dt. 23.04.2012 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Final Show cause Notice under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

a. Building plan shows Sy.Nos. as 358-5B, 358-6 & 357-1A, whereas in building completion certificate and affidavit it is given as 357 & 358, which are not tallying.

b. Proof of completion of 3 academic sessions towards B.Ed course which is already run by the institution from the affiliating body/State

Govt/examining body is not submitted. The institution has submitted affiliation from Sri Venkateswara University for the academic year 2008-2009 year only.

Accordingly, a Show Cause Notice was issued to the institution on 11.06.2012.The institution has submitted its written representation on 03.07.2012 (By hand).

The institution has submitted its reply after the stipulated period of 21 days. 1 day delayed.

Supreme Court vide their order in Civil Appeal NO. 1125-1128/2011 in SLP No. 17165-68/2009 filed by NCTE Vs ors, which reads as under:-


The SRC in its 227th meeting held on 17th – 19th July, 2012 considered the reply of the institution, which is received on 08/06/2012, i.e., after 23 (Twenty three) days from the date of issue of show cause notice dt. 16/05/2012 and with reference to


221


the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.

The application of Sri Venkateswara School of Education, Khasara No. 451, Plot No. 357, Sadakuppam Village & Post Office, BangarupalayamTaluk& City, Chittoor District-517416, Andhra Pradesh, for permission to D.El.Ed Course is hereby refused/rejected. The original FDR No. 0047163 dated 22.09.2011 for Rs. 5 lakhs and Rs. 3 Lakhs issued by the State Bank of India are returned.

Accordingly, rejection order was issued to the institution vide order F.No.APS01128/D.El.Ed/AP/2012-13/45133 dated 13.3.2012.

The institution filed court case in W.P. no 36541 of 2012. The Hon’ble Court has directed to appear personally or by advocate on 21.1.2012. Accordingly, brief of the case sent to the advocate on 31.12.2012.

The institution has simultaneously preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs, New Delhi and the original file was sent to NCTE-Hqrs on 6.11.2012.

A court order has been received on 03.01.2013 from Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in WPMP No. 46399 of 2012 in WP no. 36541 of 2012 filed by Sri Venkateshwara Educational and Charitable Trust, Chittoor District, Andhra Pradesh.

The Hon’ble Court has ordered as follows: “This court, prima facie, find that the manner in which the application of the petitioner was processed by the respondent is not at all proper and fair. The petitioner submitted an application on 29.9.2011 to the respondent with a request to accord recognition for D.El.Ed course for the current academic year. It is an existing institution. Show cause notice, dated 11.6.2011, was issued to the petitioner, pointing out two deficiencies. The first was about discrepancy in the survey numbers, on which the building was constructed and the second was about non-submission of the proof of functioning of the B.Ed college for three consecutive years. The petitioner received that on 19.6.2012. on 27.6.2012, it submitted the compliance report. The certificates of affiliation of the B.Ed course for three consecutive years were enclosed and the discrepancy as to survey numbers was accordingly explained. However, the only ground on which the respondent rejected the case of the petitioner is that there was one day delay on the part of the petitioner in submitting the compliance report.

The petitioner initially approached the High Court of Karnataka by filing W.P. No. 29087 of 2012, since the office of the respondent is at Bangalore. The writ petition was rejected on 23.8.2012, requiring the petitioner to file writ petition in this court. Writ Appeal no. 5194 of 2012 was filed and the same was disposed of on 17.10.2012. It is thereafter that the present writ petition is filed.

The very objective of constituting the Council is to ensure that the institutions are established for training of teachers at various levels. There is severe shortage of trained teachers. This court would have certainly desisted from interfering, in case the respondent pointed out any deficiency as to the existence of infrastructure or non-compliance of other important aspects. A totally hyper-technical view was taken, stating that the compliance was furnished with delay of one day. As a matter of fact, the record discloses that the show cause notice, dated 11.6.2012, was dispatched two days thereafter.


222


Hence, there shall be interim direction to the respondent to pass orders forthwith, to enable the petitioner to admit the candidates for the current academic year in accordance with Rules”.

The SRC in its 240th meeting held on 9th-11th March 2013, considered the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh order Dt. 05.12.2012 and decided to process and cause inspection simultaneously, by considering all other relevant documents under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Further,

The committee decided to report the facts to the High Court, that, it is too late now for giving recognition for current year; and, in view of the Supreme Court order dt. (13.12.2012), it will not be possible to give recognition for 2013-14 also. Case will be processed according to the Regulations and the schedule now prescribed by the Supreme Court.

As per decision of SRC, a letter to the Advocate intimating the facts of the case was sent on 22.04.2013 to appraise the court accordingly.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 13thto 14th June 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 06.06.2013.


On careful perusal of the original file of the institution, reply of the institution, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(Fifty only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.

The institution to be informed to submit revalidated FDRs immediately.

A letter of intent was issued to the institution on 10.09.2013.

Meantime, a letter has been received from the institution on 09.10.2013 which is as follows:

“… I wish to bring to your notice that the NCTE in its letter no 53582 dated 10.09.2013 has issued letter of intent for grant of recognition to D.Ed course to Sri Venkateswara School of Education, Bangaruplyam, Chittoor and instructed us to complete the process of appointment of faculty, obtaining the approval/affiliation from the state government, conversion of Endowment fund/reserve fund into joint account, submission of Annexure I, II, III, launching of website with hyper link to NCTE etc., within 60 days.

In this context, we wish to furnish the fact that the entire state administration of the AP government including the dept. of Education under indefinite strike since 30 July, 2013 against separation of Andhra Pradesh into two separate states. All sections of state govt. employees are under strike and are not available.


223


As per the direction of the NCTE, we have started the process by submitted all the required document alongwith the fee with SCERT for constitution committee and to complete the approval process.

There is abnormal delay in getting the sanctions from the concern authorities due to strike in the state of AP government,

We therefore request you, kindly extend the time for another 2/3 months for submission of the documents such as staff approval, affiliation/approval orders of state govt. and to complete other formalities. An formal order in this regard is requested.

The Committee considered the matter, request of the institution vide letter dated 09-10-2013, considering the genuiness of the reason given by the institution and asking for more time for submission of LOI reply, since this will be a case only for 2014-15, the committee decided to be liberal in their approach in such LOI cases, give time till 31st December, 2013.

104.APS08528

B.EdNarayana College of Education,

Nellore District

AP

Narayana College of Education, Padarupalli, A.K.Nagar Post, Nellore-524004, Andhra Pradesh

Narayana Educational Society, Nellore, Andhra Pradesh has submitted an application to SRC of NCTE for grant of recognition to Narayana College of Education, Padarupalli, A.K.Nagar Post, Nellore-524004, Andhra Pradesh for B.Ed course of one year duration application has been received in the office of SRC on 02.04.2007.

The application was processed and the recognition was granted for offering B.Ed course with an annual intake of 100 students on 05.10.2007.

The institution has submitted its written representation on 16.09.2013 along with old documents file and new documents file and stated as follows:-

“……we are planning to shift our college premises due to the in convenience to the students’. So the shifting is from present Padarupalli Nellore to Ramalingapuram Nellore of our new premises under the same Educational Society.

I am herewith enclosing old documents file and as well as new documents file for your reference. Hence I request you to kindly permit us to pay the processing fee for existing NCTE inspection committee for shifting.

The Committee considered the matter, request of the institution vide letter dt. 16-09-2013 and advised Southern Regional Office to process the new documents submitted by the institution for shifting to new premises, and to put up in the 255th meeting.

105.APS02773

D.EdLittle

Flower Elementary Teacher

Little Flower Elementary Teacher Education Institution for Girls, Ananthpur Andhra Pradesh

An application was submitted by Little Flower Elementary Teacher Education for Girls, Ananthpur Andhra Pradesh for grant of recognition to D.Ed course in the office of SRC-NCTE, Bangalore on 03.02.2004


224


Education Institution for Girls,

Ananthpur District

AP

The application was processed as per the provisions contained in Rules and Regulation, Norms and Standards vogue at that point of time and the recognition was granted to the institution vide order dt 26.08.2005 with stipulated conditions.

Shifting proposal was submitted by the institution on 17.07.2009. Shifting inspection was conducted on 17.09.2009. The SRC in its 197th meeting held on 13th and 14th October, 2010, and the committee considered the VT Report and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice Under Section 17 of NCTE Act.

As per the decision of SRC, notice was issued on 03.12.2010. The institution has not submitted its written representation/documents.

The SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd February 2011 and considered the non-response of the institution to the Show cause notice dated 03.12.2010 and it has decided to withdraw recognition for D.Ed course (APS02773) with effect from 2012-13, in order to enable the ongoing batch of students in D.Ed course, if any, to complete their course.



Accordingly, Withdrawal of recognition order was issued to the institution on 18.03.2011.

Aggrieved by the withdrawal of recognition order of SRC, the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order No. F.No. 89-144/2011Appeal/4th meeting-2011 dated 06.07.2011 stated that “…after perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal, affidavit, VT report and after considering oral arguments advanced during hearing, the council reached the conclusion that there was no ground to accept the appeal and hence it should be rejected. Accordingly, the appeal was rejected and SRC’s order dated 18.03.2011 was confirmed. The council hereby confirms the order appealed against”.

A letter has been received from Govt. of Andhra Pradesh, School Education (PE) Department vide letter G.O. Rt. NO. 521 dated 01.07.2011. As per perusal of the above letter Private D.Ed College of Andhra Pradesh was submitted representation to the Hon’ble Minister stating that they have admitted extra students in D.Ed 1st year after completion of 3rd phase DIETCET-2010 counselling during the academic year 2010-2011. But the 4th phase counselling, the convener DIETCET-2010 have allotted students to the vacant seats of their college under category-A seats and requested to the Govt to accord permission for the extra seats for the year 2010-2011 as a special case.

After examination of the matter by the State Govt in view the interest of the students who were admitted in excess by the institutions and are at no fault of them, hence the Govt ratified the action of the Managements of (28) Private D.Ed colleges in filling of excess seats filled by them for the academic year 2010-2011 as a special case with a strict warning to the managements of such institution not to repeat such unauthorized /irregular admission.

The State Govt requested to take necessary action against the Management as per the rules in force. The present institution has got admission for 15 extra seats


225


as per the above letters of the State Government.

The SRC in its 209th meeting held on 31st July 2011 has decided to issue show cause notice to the above twenty nine institutions with regard to their admitting more than the permitted intake in their D.Ed course, which is against the NCTE norms. And also a letter be addressed to Govt. of Andhra Pradesh, as the affiliating body that in latter should not have permitted/condoned the unauthorized/irregular excess admissions. The NCTE is not in a position to approve of such unauthorized/irregular excess admissions. The institutions are liable to be derecognized for such serious commissions/omissions.

No action has to be taken for the above said State Govt. letter, the SRC in its 201st meeting taken decision i.e. Withdrawal of recognition. Accordingly, a withdrawal order was issued to the institution on 18.03.2011.

The institution filed a court case in the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh, W. P. No. 21938 of 2011 W.P.M.P. No.26719 of 2011 and the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in its order has stated as follows:-

“…The attention of this Court is drawn to the proceedings of the District Educational Officer, Ananthapur in Rc.No.5804/A4/2011 dated 20.07.2011, whereby the 1st petitioner has been permitted to shift the schools from the existing premises to another building bearing Door No. 10-214. A perusal of the Gift Settlement Deed dated 20.12.2006 shows that the subject property has been gifted in the name of the institution i.e. Little Flower Montessori Primary and Secondary School, Adimurthy Nagar, Ananthapur by one M/s Suragowni Anjineyulu and Sri Suragowni Ravindra Gowd. Therefore, the principal objections relating to the petitioner running the schools in the same premises, the right over the total extent of the land primea facie appears to have been complied with. It is true that the petitioner shifted the schools under the orders dated 20.07.2011, which is subsequent to the impugned orders dated 06.07.2011. In my view, since the proceedings dated 20.07.2011 of the District Educational Officer, Ananthapur were passed under the A.P. Education Act, which is statutory in nature, I am of the view that the same may be taken as relevant fact. Further, the petitioner – institution is a running institution and if it is not permitted to continue, the students will suffer.

In the circumstances, there shall be an interim suspension.”

The SRC in its 211th meeting held on 21st-23rd September 2011 and the committee considered the Court order and all other relevant documents and has decided to cause re-inspection under Section 17 of NCTE Act at the premises to verify the shifting of the School and adequacy of the infrastructure and instructional facilities. The institution is directed to submit inspection fee of Rs. 40,000/- for each course.

Accordingly, re-inspection of the institution letter was sent on 14.11.2011 and a letter for submission of inspection fee of Rs.40,000/- was sent to institution on 15.11.2011

In the meanwhile inspection of the institution was conducted on 20.11.2011. The VT report received was placed before SRC in its 214th meeting held on 28th

November 2011 and the committee considered the matter and has decided to get


226


the Interim Suspension order of the High Court vacated through our Advocate at Hyderabad.

Accordingly, a letter was sent to an Advocate on 14.12.2011.

In the meantime, the institution has submitted its written representation on 13.12.2011 along with D.D. of Rs.40000/- and submitted some documents.

The SRC in its 218th meeting held on 28th February 2012 consider the matter and decided that in view of condonation ordered by the State Government. SRC may warn the erring institution and require them to give an undertaking that there will be no recurrence of such a lapse.

Note: One strongly order passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in SLP NO. 14020/2009 filed by Adarsh Shiksha Mahavidalaya & others Vs Subhash Rahangdale & other. In the said judgment dt. 06.01.2012 Hon’ble Supreme Court has issued various directions for NCTE/Affiliating body/Institutions and to the state Govt. The operative part of the judgment as under:

“If any institution admits any student in violation of the Norms and Standards laid by the NCTE, then the Regional Committee shall initiate action for withdrawal of the recognition of such institution and pass appropriate order after complying with the rules of natural justice”.

As per direction of SRC, a letter was issued to the concerned institution on 21.08.2012. it is observed from the file, the institution has not submitted reply so far

A letter has been received from Director, SCERT, Hyderabad on 17.10.2013 requesting “……to inform the latest stage of the court case and confirm about the status position of recognition in respect of Little Flower College of Education for Women, Adhimurthy Nagar, Ananthapur District immediately, so as to enable this office to submit a report to the Government of Andhra Pradesh”

The Committee considered the matter, decided and advised SRO to examine the case thoroughly and to put up.

Also, the Southern Regional Office to ascertain quickly from the Lawyer regarding the latest position of the case and to be put up in the 255 th SRC meeting.

106.APS00227

B.EdLittle Rose College of Education,

East Godavari District

AP

Little Rose college of Education, Rajamundry Revenue division, Draksharama, East Godavari dist- 533 262, Andhra Pradesh

Elite Educational Society, Draksharama East Godavari District- 533 262, Andhra Pradesh submitted an application for grant of recognition to Little Rose college of Education, Rajamundry Revenue division, Draksharama East Godavari dist- 533 262, Andhra Pradesh for B.Ed course of one year duration for the academic year 2002-03 and recognition was granted to the institution vide SRC order dated 10.02.2005 (as per recognition order) with a condition to shift the institution to permanent premises.

Shifting of premises as per Regulation 2002 to permanent structure within three


227


years from the date of issue of recognition in Andhra Pradesh. The matter was placed in 178th Meeting of SRC held on 13th-14th July, 2010 wherein the committee observed from records of the institution that the institutions were accorded recognition in the rented premises and they had yet shifted to the permanent premises/building. In view of non-shifting of colleges to permanent building the committee decided to issue show cause notice under section 17 of NCTE Act and obtain shifting fees and other documents for causing inspection for shifting.

As per decision of SRC, show cause notice was issued to the institution to submit essential documents on 07.10.2009

The institution has not responded to the Show Cause Notice and not submitted fee for Shifting.

The SRC in its 201st meeting held on 22nd-23rd February, 2011 considered the matter and decided to withdraw recognition of Little Rose College of Education Rajamundry Revenue Division, Draksharama, East Godavari Dist-533262, Andhra Pradesh which failed to shift to permanent premises within the prescribed time limit of three years as per the norms, and also they had failed to respond to Show Cause Notice issued by SRC, NCTE long back on 07.10.2009.

Accordingly, the recognition accorded to Little Rose College of Education, Rajamundry Revenue Division, Draksharama, East Godavari District-533 262, Andhra Pradesh to B.Ed course was withdrawn vide order dated 07.04.2011.

A court order has been received from Hon’ble High Court of A.P. in W.P.No.10685 of 2011 dated 19.04.2011. The court order stating that “…..this writ petition is disposed of in the same terms as in the order passed in W.P.No.22090 of 2008 and batch of writ petitions dated 11.08.2009. petitioners are granted four weeks’ time to file statutory appeal under section 18 of the NCTE Act and the appellate authority shall receive the appeal by treating the same as an appeal filed within the limitation and dispose of the same after hearing both the parties in accordance with law. Till such time, the impugned orders dated 07.04.2011 shall remain suspended. No order as to costs.”

Aggrieved by the withdrawal order of SRC, the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order No. F.No. 89-227/2011Appeal/5th meeting -2011 dated 03/08/2011 stated as under:-

“After perusal of documents, memorandum of appeal , VT Report and after considering oral arguments advanced during the hearing , the council reached the conclusion that there was adequate grounds to accept the appeal and reverse the SRC’s order dt. 07.04.2011 with direction to SRC to conduct an inspection of the Institution and take necessary action thereafter. Accordingly, the appeal is accepted and the order of the SRC dt. 07.04.2011 is reversed.

The SRC in its 211th meeting held on 21st -23rd September 2011, considered the Appellate/Council order dt. 03.08.2011 and decided to cause shifting inspection at the premises Under Section 17 of NCTE Act. The institution is directed to submit shifting inspection fee of Rs. 40,000/-.

As per direction of SRC, a letter was sent to the institution on 09.11.2011


228


regarding submission of inspection fee.

The institution has submitted its written representation on 25.11.2011 enclosed Demand Draft of Rs.40,000/- bearing No.656883 vide dated 18.11.2011.

Note: it is observed from the file that after receipt of the written representation along with DD of Rs.40,000/- submitted by institution and not taken into account and not placed before SRC for further taking necessary action so far.

Now, the institution has submitted its written representation on 14.10.2013 stated as follows:-

“…… The SRC, Bangalore has withdrawn the recognized of Little Rose College of Education vide reference 1 cited above. The management of this institution was challenged the order given by SRC, Bangalore. The High Court of Andhra Pradesh has suspended the order issued the SRC, Bangalore to maintain status quo vide reference 2 cited above. Later we appealed the NCTE, Delhi, in vide reference 3 cited above.

The NCTE, New Delhi has instructed the SRC, Bangalore to reversed the withdrawal order and maintain the status quo in vide reference 4 cited above.

SRC, Bangalore has instructed the Management of Little Rose College of Education to paid Rs.40,000/- (forty thousand rupees only) towards inspection fee.

As per the instructions issued by SRC, Bangalore vide reference 5th cited, we have paid Rs.40,000/- towards the inspection fee the DD.No.656883 dated 18.11.2011 in SBI, Draksharama Branch, Andhra Pradesh.

Hence in view of the above facts, I request you withdrawn the name of our college i.e. S.No.1194 from the list of recognition withdrawn college for your website related to Andhra Pradesh.”

(As per MIS data, it shows the recognition status is Withdrawn)

The Committee considered the Hon’ble High Court order dated 19-04-2011, wherein the Hon’ble High Court suspended the withdrawal of recognition order vide letter dated 07-04-2011, advised Southern Regional Office to remove the entry from the website.

Further, it is observed that the institution has paid only Rs. 40000/- towards inspection fee, the balance of Rs. 10000/- is to be collected from the institution towards inspection.

Southern Regional Office to examine all the relevant documents of the institution and to put up in the 255th meeting.

107.SRCAP120

1D.Ed

Madasu

Madasu Bhukailasam College of Education, Sy No. 543, Chitukal Village and Post Office, Patancheru Taluka, Medak District – 506 167, Andhra Pradesh

Dharani Educational Society, Plot No. 1-3-90/C, Geetha Nagar Village, Jangoan Post Office and Taluka, Warangal District – 506 167, Andhra


229


Bhukailasam College

of Education,

Medak District

AP

Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Madasu Bhukailasam College of Education, Sy No. 543, Chitukal Village and Post Office, Patancheru Taluka, Medak District – 506 167, Andhra Pradesh for D.Ed Course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 29.09.2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 05.10.2011.

The application was scrutinized and a copy of application was sent to State Government for recommendation on 22.12.2011 followed by reminder on 05.01.2012. A deficiency letter was issued to the institution on 30.12.2011 and the institution has replied to the deficiency letter on 29.02.2012.

The SRC in its 220th meeting held on 30th –31st March 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 29.02.2102 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act, for the following:

1. Land documents of sale deed dt.17.01.2012 is registered after the on-line application, which is not permissible as per NCTE regulations 2009.

2. In the building completion certificate submitted, built up area is filled up by pen, name of the course is not mentioned in column No. 9 and type of roofing is not mentioned.

3. Notarized land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the purpose of educational institution is not submitted. Proceedings from the revenue divisional office not submitted.

4. In the affidavit submitted, point No. 6 is not duly filled up.5. FDRs of Rs.5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from a

Nationalised Bank is not submitted.6. Proof of completion of 3 academic sessions towards other courses which are

already run by the institution from the affiliating body/State Govt/examining body is not submitted.



Land documents of sale deed dt. 17-01-2012 is registered after the on-line application, which is not permissible as per NCTE Regulations 2009.

Notarized land usage certificate from the Revenue divisional office stating that the agriculture land converted to non-agriculture for the purpose of educational institution only is not submitted.

Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee has decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.El.Ed course.


Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to


230


NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority order in its order No. F.No. 89-420/2012Appeal/10th Meeting-2012 dated 11/12/2012 stated that

“…the Council taking into accounts facts and circumstances and recommendation of the State Govt of Andhra Pradesh decided that the application of the institution be processed by the SRC in accordance with the Regulations, as relaxed by the NCTE Committee and to take further decision thereafter ”.

The appellate authority order was placed before SRC in its 239 th meeting held on 26th-27th February 2013, considered the Appellate authority’s order dt. 11-12-2012 and decided to further process the application for D.Ed course as per Regulations to take further decision.

As per decision of SRC and as per appellate authority order, the application has been processed and placed before SRC in its 242nd meeting held on 14th-16th April 2013, and the committee considered the Appellate authority order dt. 11/12/2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between (27-31st May 2013) again re-scheduled on 3rd to 6th July 2013, the same was intimated to the institution on 20.06.2013.


The SRC in its 249th Meeting held on 24th-26th July, 2013 considered the VT report, VCD of the institution and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under section 14 of NCTE Act for the following deficiencies.

Original Revalidated FDRs of Rs. 5 & 3 lacs towards endowment and reserve fund from a Nationalised Bank in favour of Society/college/institution name is not submitted.

The institution has to submit fresh VCD covering front view of the building, other infrastructure & instructional facilities provided.


stating that “ the original revalidated FDR’s of Rs 5 & 3 lakhs towards Endowment and Reserve fund from a Nationalized Bank in favour of the society name is at this juncture not revalidated the FDR’s the reason is Telangana bifurcating of state and Samikhandra Bundhs and not working the public offices including Nationalized Banks not working properly in our State of Andhra Pradesh. Kindly provide 15 days time from this day. For cause no. 1&2 also complying.

The Committee considered the matter, request of the institution vide letter dated 04-10-2013, considering the genuiness of the reason given by the institution and asking for more time for submission of Revalidated FDRs of


231


Rs. 5 & 3 lacs, the committee decided to give time till 30 th Nov, 2013.

108.SRCAPP82

9D.EdRavi


Nellore District

AP

Ravi College of Education, No. 796/4, 9, 10, 762/4, 5, 8th street, Vinjamur Village, Post & Taluk, Nellore District-524228, Andhra Pradesh.

Ravi Educational Society, Vengamambanagar Road, Vinjamur Village, Post & Taluk, Nellore District-524228, Andhra Pradesh had applied for grant of recognition to Ravi College of Education, No. 796/4, 9, 10, 762/4, 5, 8th street, Vinjamur Village, Post & Taluk, Nellore District-524228, Andhra Pradesh for D.Ed course of two years duration under Section 14(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 to the Southern Regional Committee, NCTE online on 28/09/2011 and physical application has been received in the office of SRC on 30/09/2011.


The SRC in its 220th Meeting held on 30th-31st March, 2012 considered the reply of the institution dt. 27.02.2102 and all the relevant documentary evidences and it was decided to serve Show cause Notice under Section 14(1) of NCTE Act.

Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the institution on 26/04/2012. The institution has submitted written representation on 16/05/2012


1. Original building completion certificate from competent Govt. authorized engineer is not submitted.

2. In the land use certificate original seal and signature is not given, and proceedings of Revenue Divisional Officer not submitted, for conversion of land form agricultural to non-agricultural / educational society.

3. In the Encumbrance Certificate date is not clear and Sy.No.s is different. As per Encumbrance Certificate land is on lease basis and index of EC from 01/04/1983 to 13/05/2012.

Under the above grounds and with reference to the totality of information collected & based on a collective application of mind, the committee has decided as per NCTE Regulations 2009, to refuse and reject the application of the institution for recognition of D.Ed course.

Accordingly, rejection letter was issued to the institution on 27/06/2012.

Aggrieved by the rejection order of SRC the institution preferred an appeal to NCTE-Hqrs and the appellate authority in its order No. F.No. 89-461/2012Appeal/10th Meeting-2012 dated 11/12/2012 stated that “…the Council concluded that the appeal deserved to be accepted. The case is remanded to the SRC for further processing as per regulations”.

The SRC in its 239th Meeting held on 26th-27th February, 2013 considered the


232


Appellate authority’s order dt. 11-12-2012 and decided to further process the application for D.Ed course as per Regulations.As per the decision of SRC the application is processed and placed before SRC in its 244th Meeting held on 09th-11th May, 2013 considered the Appellate authority order dt. 11/12/2012 and all other relevant documents and decided to cause inspection under section 14 (1) of NCTE Act, to examine whether the institution fulfils all the requirements as per the norms, for the proposed programme, subject to the condition that the deficiencies, if any, were duly rectified by the institution, as per the norms.

Accordingly, inspection of the institution was fixed between 19th-23rd August, 2013 the same was intimated to the institution on 10.08.2013. The inspection of the institution was conducted on 22.08.2013.

The visiting team report was placed before SRC in its 253 rd Meeting held on 30th

September & 01st October, 2013 and the committee has decided to ask for another copy of the VCD.

Before issuance of letter, as per the information of NCTE website the institution has submitted a copy of VCD on 24.10.2013.

On careful perusal of the original file of the Institution, VT report, VCD, resubmission of VCD on 24.10.2013, all relevant documents and other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and guidelines of NCTE published from time to time laid on the table, the Regional Committee decided to issue Letter of Intent for grant of recognition to D.Ed course of two year duration with an annual intake of 50(fifty only)(one unit), subject to the appointment of qualified staff through duly constituted selection committee as per the Norms of NCTE/State Government/Affiliating University and be given effect before the commencement of the academic session.


233



234