60
SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012 PRESENTATION TO THE SELECT COMMITTEE ON LAND AND ENVIRONMENTAL AFFAIRS 29 May 2012 1

SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

  • Upload
    gamba

  • View
    42

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012. PRESENTATION TO THE SELECT COMMITTEE ON LAND AND ENVIRONMENTAL AFFAIRS 29 May 2012. OUTLINE OF PRESENTATION. DEFINING SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT PROBLEM STATEMENT SEARCH FOR A SOLUTION SPLUMB POST-2010 OVERVIEW OF SPLUMB - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Citation preview

Page 1: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

PRESENTATION TO THE SELECT COMMITTEE ON LAND AND

ENVIRONMENTAL AFFAIRS29 May 2012

1

Page 2: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

OUTLINE OF PRESENTATION

• DEFINING SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT

• PROBLEM STATEMENT• SEARCH FOR A SOLUTION• SPLUMB POST-2010• OVERVIEW OF SPLUMB• SPLUMB AREAS OF CONCERN• DRAFTING PROCESS AND CONSULTATION

2

Page 3: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

DEFINING SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT

3

Page 4: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

DEFINING SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT

SPATIAL PLANNING• Spatial planning involves ‘critical thinking about space and critical thinking about space and

places as the basis for action or interventionplaces as the basis for action or intervention’ (RTPI, 2007).

• Spatial planning goes beyond traditional land use planning to bring together bring together and integrate policies for the development integrate policies for the development and use of land with other policies and programmesand use of land with other policies and programmes which influence the nature of places and how they can function’. (UK Planning Policy Statement 1: Delivering Sustainable Development, 2005)

4

Page 5: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

DEFINING SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT

SPATIAL PLANNING• The implementation of the spatial objectives contained within

planning policy is:• highly dependent upon the coordinating role of national

government;• local discretion over the interpretation of such policy

guidance and the resources and action of developers and other stakeholders;

• degree of consistency between broad policy objectives (and governance structures associated with their delivery) across different sectoral interests.

• The reality is that there remain complex relationships between policies, and even high-level policy outcomes may be contradictory

5

Page 6: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

LAND USE MANAGEMENT• Land resources are used for a variety of purposes variety of purposes which

interactinteract and may competecompete with one another; therefore, it is desirable to plan and manage all uses in an integrated mannerintegrated manner.

• Land-use management examines all uses of land in an integrated manner, it makes it possible to minimize conflicts, to make the most efficient trade-offs and to link social and economic development with environmental protection and enhancement, thus helping to achieve the objectives of sustainable development.

• The essence of the integrated approach finds expression in the coordination of the sectoral planning and management coordination of the sectoral planning and management activities activities concerned with the various aspects of land use and land resources.

DEFINING SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT

6

Page 7: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

LAND USE MANAGEMENT

• Integration should consider all environmental, social and economic factors.

• Integrated consideration facilitates appropriate choices and trade-offs, thus maximizing sustainable productivity and usemaximizing sustainable productivity and use.

• The broad objective broad objective is to facilitate allocation of land to the uses that provide the greatest sustainable benefits greatest sustainable benefits and to promote the transition to a sustainable and integrated management of land resources.

DEFINING SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT

7

Page 8: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

PROBLEM STATEMENT

8

Page 9: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

PROBLEM STATEMENTPRE-1994 PHYSICAL PLANNING AND LAND USE OBJECTIVES

• Pre-1994 Planning was designed to serve a different political idea – segregation, differentiation, and privilege;

• Multiple laws, multiple institutions and parallel processes instituted by the pre-1994 pieces of legislation;

• Planning laws were fragmented across the old boundaries of the then four (4) provincial administrations, homelands, and Self-Governing Territories (SGT);

9

Page 10: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

PROBLEM STATEMENTOUTCOMES OF THE PRE-1994 PLANNING SYSTEM

• In 1994, South Africa inherited complex and disjointed planning systems which manifest in unequal, incoherent and inefficient settlement patterns;

• The Development Facilitation Act, 1995 (Act No. 67 of 1995) (“the DFA”) was promulgated as an interim measure to deal with this legacy.

• SPLUMB emerged through the Green Paper and White Paper processes to replace the DFA as the legislative instrument to regulate spatial planning and land use management in the country.

10

Page 11: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SYMPTOMS OF THE PRE-1994 PLANNING SYSTEM• Long approval processes with too many objections/ slow pace of

development application approvals;• Lack of shared vision and coordinated initiative in respect of what

is needed to modernize and rationalize planning and land use management in South Africa and in respect of the interconnections between different kinds of planning in South Africa.

• High degree of legal and procedural complexity in the many land use management processes in South Africa.

• Poor linkages between sectoral policies (from all spheres) and spatial planning (by all spheres) on the one hand and land use management mechanisms and processes on the other.

• Several parallel approval processes involving substantial duplication and complexity with respect to land use, environment, heritage, agriculture, transport, etc.

PROBLEM STATEMENT

11

Page 12: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

PROBLEM STATEMENTCURRENT LAND USE REALITIES IN URBAN SOUTH AFRICA

• Economic factors/engines of growth

• Best practices for weaker municipalities

• Exclusion and inclusion

• Value capture and 'irregular' land uses

• Formality and informality

• Growth Management Strategies

• Irregular land use and evictions strategy

• Planning Laws & Embedded Power Relations (criminalisation of poverty)

12

Page 13: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

PROBLEM STATEMENTCURRENT LAND USE REALITIES IN RURAL SOUTH AFRICA

• State land• Unresolved tenure issues• Communal ownership and titling vs Freehold• Traditional Leadership and 'weak' linkages with formal

municipal governance (section 81 of the Municipal Structures Act)

• Community participation and alternative 'democratic' expression

• Spatial datasets, cadastre, and land use schemes• Enforcement

13

Page 14: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SUMMARY OF THE PRE-1994 PLANNING SYSTEM

• Economically: it impedes investment in land development and fails to establish sufficient certainty in the land market;

• Spatially: it fails to address the segregated and unequal spatial patterns inherited from apartheid; and

• Environmentally: it does not balance the country’s socio-economic needs with those of environmental conservation.

PROBLEM STATEMENT

14

Page 15: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SEARCH FOR A SOLUTION

15

Page 16: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SEARCH FOR A SOLUTIONTHE DEVELOPMENT FACILITATION ACT OF 1995

• The Development Facilitation Act (DFA), 1995 is the only post-1994 planning law enacted by parliament.

• The DFA was promulgated as an interim measure to bridge the gap between the old apartheid era planning laws and a new planning system reflecting the needs and priorities of the democratic South Africa

• The Act, however, did not wipe the slate clean with the result that national and provincial laws relating to planning promulgated before 1994 are still in existence

• The DFA thus operates parallel to the existing laws, until such time as it is repealed (as intended by this Bill)

• The key features of the DFA are: – Development Principles– Land Development Objectives– Development Tribunals

16

Page 17: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SEARCH FOR A SOLUTIONGREEN PAPER

• In 1997 the government appointed the Development and Planning Commission to, amongst other things, advise on how best to streamline the various policy, legislative and regulatory frameworks

• In 1999, after extensive national consultations, the Commission produced the Green Paper on Development and Planning

• The Green Paper emphasised the importance of a shared vision as the basis for planning in the country

• The Green Paper recommended national assistance to Provinces in repealing provincial legislation and replacing this with a single national law on spatial planning and land use management

17

Page 18: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SEARCH FOR A SOLUTIONWHITE PAPER AND “LUMB” 2001

• Cabinet approved the White Paper on Spatial Planning and Land Use Management in June 2001

• It was published in Gazette No. 22473 of 20 July 2001, together with a Draft Land Use Management Bill 2001

• The White Paper provides for rationalisation of the existing planning laws into one national system

• The White Paper proposed Spatial Development Frameworks (SDFs) as the primary instrument of spatial planning and Land Use Schemes (LUSs) as the primary instrument of land use management

18

Page 19: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SEARCH FOR A SOLUTIONTRANSFORMATION OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT

• During the period of the publishing of the Green Paper and the White Paper together with “LUMB” 2001, the process of local government transformation had entered its final phase

• The Municipal Structures Act was promulgated in 1998 (Act 117 of 1998)

• This was followed in 2000 by the Municipal Systems Act (Act 32 of 2000)

• The Municipal Systems Act introduced Integrated Development Plans (IDPs) as the principal planning instrument of municipalities, and made provision for municipal SDFs to be part of municipal IDPs

19

Page 20: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SEARCH FOR A SOLUTIONDFA OBJECTIVES AND APPLICATION

• To introduce extraordinary measures to facilitate and speed up the implementation of reconstruction and development programmes and projects in relation to land

• DFA is a single law with general applicability• It created common procedures which could apply nationally

and provided fast track processes to expedite development • The DFA could provide urgent, short term development

solutions and deal with complex applications• The use of the DFA as an alternative to the Provincial

Ordinances therefore became widespread in Eastern Cape, Gauteng, KwaZulu-Natal, Limpopo, Mpumalanga and North West Provinces (where the DFA was applied)

20

Page 21: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SEARCH FOR A SOLUTIONDFA SUCCESSES AND LIMITATIONS

• The DFA has contributed to tenure security, tourism, and high income rates base in towns and cities

• The DFA has brought development to areas where other legislation may not have enabled it.

• Criticism that the DFA has been “abused” for high-income private development.

• DFA cannot be a mainstream process because it is labour intensive and requires high levels of expertise:

- need attorneys and advocates to represent applicants;- municipalities in particular noted the need to have counsel at

every hearing with the associated cost factor;- requires considerable expertise in decision-making and in writing

the conditions so that outcomes are effective; and- legal participation means that most clauses in the DFA have had

their interpretation tested21

Page 22: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SEARCH FOR A SOLUTION“LUMB” PARLIAMENTARY PROCESS 2007-2008

• 5 June 2007: Cabinet Committee on Governance & Administration considered concerns regarding the Bill.

• 13 June 2007: Cabinet approved the recommendations of the Cabinet Committee on Governance & Administration on the Bill.

• 15 April 2008: The Bill was officially introduced to the public with call for comments by publication of explanatory summary of the Bill in the Government Gazette No 30979 of 15 April 2008.

• 18 May 2008: Bill introduced in Parliament by the Minister for Agriculture and Land Affairs, at the time.

• Between May and July 2008: Portfolio Committee on Agriculture and Land Affairs, and in a number of instances, including members of the Portfolio Committee on Provincial and Local Government, had engagements with the then Department of Land Affairs on the Bill.

22

Page 23: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SEARCH FOR A SOLUTION“LUMB” PARLIAMENTARY PROCESS 2007-2008• In addition to its call for and receipt of public comments on the Bill,

the Portfolio Committee conducted public hearings on the Bill between 30 and 31 July 2008. • During August 2008 other members of civil society and constitutional

institutions supporting democracy, such as the Commission for Gender Equality, were afforded opportunity to brief the Portfolio Committee on the Bill. • Legal opinions were obtained from the Parliamentary Legal Counsel to

confirm the constitutional validity of both the substance and content of the Bill.• Based on written submissions and representations made to the

Portfolio Committee by several State and non-State actors, including provincial governments and municipalities, various improvements were suggested to the version of the Bill originally submitted to the Parliament.

23

Page 24: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SEARCH FOR A SOLUTION“LUMB” PARLIAMENTARY PROCESS 2007/8

• 13 August 2008: Portfolio Committee passed the Bill with the support of all the political parties on the Committee.

• Parliament did not complete the process of passing the Bill into law before the change of Government in May 2009.

• The proceedings that preceded the confirmation application also had a bearing on the approach that was taken by Government in finalising the Bill, as proceedings were pending before the Supreme Court of Appeal which had to consider the constitutionality of the impugned provisions of the DFA.

• It was felt at the time that the judgment of the Supreme Court of Appeal regarding the matter pending before it would have a significant bearing on some of the provisions contained in the Bill.

• The Bill thus lapsed with the last Parliament and the Executive Arm did not seek a revival of the Bill until the judgment of the Supreme Court of Appeal was delivered.

24

Page 25: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SEARCH FOR A SOLUTIONCONSTITUTIONALITY OF THE DFA

• The DFA was intended to be an interim measure, and was to be repealed by SPLUMB (in its current and earlier versions).

• In June 2010, the Constitutional Court found Chapters 5 and 6 of the DFA to be invalid on grounds of unconstitutionality.

• The order of invalidity was suspended for 2 years, i.e. until June 2012, to allow the defects in the DFA to be remedied.

• Government’s intended remedy is to repeal the DFA in its entirety and replace it with the Spatial Planning and Land Use Management Act (currently still a Bill).

25

Page 26: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SEARCH FOR A SOLUTIONTHE JUDGMENT OF THE COURT IS SIGNIFICANT FOR THE FOLLOWING REASONS:

•The Order of Invalidity of Chapter 5 and Chapter 6 of the DFA has been suspended for 24 months from the date of the judgment (18 June 2010). A definite and critical timeline has therefore been established for the Spatial Planning and Land Use Management Bill to be enacted, i.e. by 17 June 2012.•The Constitutional Court found that municipal planning includes the powers and functions necessary to determine re-zoning and township establishment applications, and concluded that municipal planning is the exclusive competence of municipal government.

26

Page 27: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SEARCH FOR A SOLUTIONTHE JUDGMENT OF THE COURT IS SIGNIFICANT FOR THE FOLLOWING REASONS:

•While not providing specific definitions for the concepts, the court also found that “provincial planning,” “regional planning” and “urban and rural development” were to be narrowly defined, so that the manner of their interpretation would not limit the powers and functions of municipalities in respect of municipal planning.•These findings have implications for the institutions and structures created by the Spatial Planning and Land Use Management Bill, as well as their composition, legal status and powers and functions

27

Page 28: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SEARCH FOR A SOLUTIONCURRENT APPLICATION TO CONSTITUTIONAL COURT FOR EXTENSION OF DFA

• Applicants seek order for the further extension of the period of suspension of the declaration of constitutional invalidity of Chapters V and VI of the Development Facilitation Act, by 24 months until 16 June 2014, or until the date of the enactment of the Spatial Planning and Land Use Management Bill and its transitional provisions or any similar legislation.

28

Page 29: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB POST-2010

29

Page 30: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB POST-2010OBJECTS OF THE BILL

• Provide for a uniform, effective and comprehensive system of spatial planning and land use management for the Republic

• Ensure that the system of spatial planning and land use management promotes social and economic inclusion

• Provide for development principles and norms and standards• Provide for the sustainable and efficient use of land• Provide for cooperative government and intergovernmental

relations amongst the national, provincial and local spheres of government

• Redress the imbalances of the past and to ensure that there is equity in the application of spatial development planning and land use management systems

30

Page 31: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB POST-2010DEVELOPMENT PRINCIPLES

•Used to Guide Spatial Planning, Land Use Management and Land Development in terms of this Bill;

•Applied through Spatial Planning Tools i.e. SDF’s and Land Use Schemes and also guide decision making by Tribunals;

•Applied by National / Provincial Governments and Municipalities in developing their SDF’s and Spatial Planning policies.

31

Page 32: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB POST-2010NORMS AND STANDARDS

• The terms “norms and standards” are commonly used interchangeably but are two different concepts:- Norms may be the usual or the average level of performance. - Standards, on the other hand, are the desired and achievable level of performance.

• Setting norms and standards is a complex operation consisting of 4 components:- Level of service to be attained (policy directive)- Quantity to be provided (policy directive)- Quality required (often legislated)- Technical specifications (legislated)

32

Page 33: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB POST-2010NORMS AND STANDARDS

• Norms and standards are important in Planning for:•Assessment of needs;•Quality Management; •Management tool; and•Transformation tool/change management.•Limitations•Rigidity and inflexible;•Prescriptive.•Examples•Norm – Planning considerations in Rural Areas;•Use and Protection of Agricultural Land;•Standards – Mapping Standards, Density Guidelines, etc.

33

Page 34: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB POST-2010

NORMS AND STANDARDS

•i.t.o. Clause 8 of the Bill the Minister may prescribe Norms and Standards on land use management;

•i.t.o. Clause 8(3) of the Bill the Minister is able to prescribe Norms and Standards at the request of another Minister (e.g. Norms & Standards for Inclusionary Housing in Human Settlements).

34

Page 35: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB POST-2010

REGULATIONS

• Section 54 of the Bill makes provision for the Minister to prescribe Regulations

• Areas for Regulations include:– Norms and Standards– Spatial Planning (SDFs)– Land Use Management (LUSs)– Land Development Management

35

Page 36: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB POST-2010

GUIDELINES

• The Department of Rural Development and Land Reform (DRDLR) is preparing guidelines on various matters to support implementation of the Bill:

– Integrated Spatial Planning and Land Use Management– Interim and Transitional Measures– Spatial Development Frameworks– Municipal Land Use Management– Electronic Land Use Management Systems

36

Page 37: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB POST-2010INTERGOVERNMENTAL RELATIONS, SUPPORT AND MONITORING

• National Government is required to:– provide support to Provinces and Municipalities in the

execution of their duties in terms of the Bill– monitor capacity of Provinces and Municipalities to

implement the Bill– monitor compliance of Provinces and Municipalities with

the Bill

37

Page 38: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB POST-2010INTERGOVERNMENTAL RELATIONS, SUPPORT AND MONITORING

• Provincial Government is required to:– provide support to Municipalities in the preparation,

adoption and amendment of their Land Use Schemes– Facilitate the coordination and alignment of land use

schemes of different municipalities within a Province– Facilitate the coordination and alignment of land use

schemes of different municipalities with plans of National and Provincial organs of state

– Strengthen the capacity of municipalities to implement spatial planning and land use legislation

38

Page 39: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB POST-2010ROLE OF NATIONAL GOVERNMENT

• National Government is responsible for:– the compilation, approval and review of spatial

development plans and policies or similar instruments, including a national spatial development framework;

– the planning by the national sphere for the efficient and sustainable execution of its legislative and executive powers insofar as they relate to the development of land and the change of land use;

– the making and review of policies and laws necessary to implement national planning, including the measures designed to monitor and support other spheres in the performance of their spatial planning, land use management and land development functions.

39

Page 40: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB POST-2010ROLE OF PROVINCIAL GOVERNMENT

• Provincial Government is responsible for:– the compilation, approval and review of a provincial spatial

development framework;– monitoring compliance by municipalities with this Act and

provincial legislation in relation to the preparation, approval, review and implementation of land use management systems;

– the planning by a province for the efficient and sustainable execution of its legislative and executive powers insofar as they relate to the development of land and the change of land use;

– the making and review of policies and laws necessary to implement provincial planning.

40

Page 41: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB POST-2010ROLE OF MUNICIPALITIES

• Municipalities are responsible for:– The compilation, approval and review of integrated

development plans;– the compilation, approval and review of the components

of an integrated development plan prescribed by legislation and falling within the competence of a municipality, including a spatial development framework and a land use scheme;

– the control and regulation of the use of land within the municipal area where the nature, scale and intensity of the land use do not affect the provincial planning mandate of provincial government or the national interest.

41

Page 42: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB POST-2010SPATIAL DEVELOPMENT FRAMEWORKS (SDFs)

• All three spheres must prepare SDFs to give effect to National, Provincial or Municipal Planning respectively

• There must be alignment and consistency between the Frameworks of all spheres

• Provision for the Minister and Premier to see to the preparation of Regional SDFs where required

• SDFs are reviewable every 5 years or less

• Must involve public participation.

42

Page 43: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB POST-2010LAND USE MANAGEMENT

• Municipality is responsible for Land Use Management• Primary instrument is the Land Use Scheme (LUS)• Municipality must, after public consultation, prepare, adopt

and implement a LUS within 5 years of the Bill being enacted• LUS must be consistent with and give effect to Municipal SDF• All land development applications must be determined within

context of the LUS• An approved and adopted LUS has the force of law and binds

all owners and users of land

43

Page 44: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB POST-2010LAND DEVELOPMENT MANAGEMENT

• Land development applications are determined by Municipalities as the authority of first instance

• Municipalities are required to establish Municipal Planning Tribunals to discharge this function

• Municipalities may co-operate to establish Joint Municipal Planning Tribunals

• The Tribunals consist of municipal officials and suitably qualified external persons appointed by Municipal Councils

44

Page 45: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB POST-2010DEFINING NATIONAL INTEREST

• A land development application must be referred to the Minister where the outcome of the application affects the National interest

• The National interest includes:– matters within the exclusive functional area of the national

sphere in terms of the Constitution;– strategic national policy objectives, principles or priorities,

including food security, international relations and co-operation, defence and economic unity; or

– land use for a purpose which falls within the functional area of the national sphere of government.

45

Page 46: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

CHAPTER OVERVIEW OF SPLUMB, 2012

46

Page 47: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

CHAPTER OVERVIEW OF SPLUMBCHAPTERS 1 - 4• Chapter 1 (Clauses 1 to 5): provides for definitions, the application of the

Act, objects of the Act, an outline of the system of planning in South Africa and the categories of spatial planning.

• Chapter 2 (Clauses 6 to 8) provides an outline of key principles that are applicable to the spatial planning system and will also guide land development in general. It provides scope for the Minister of Rural Development and Land Reform to develop more comprehensive principles. The chapter also provides for the Minister to set out compulsory norms and standards for land use management.

• Chapter 3 (Clauses 9 to 11) outlines the mandates of national and provincial spheres in monitoring and support provision to ensure effective spatial planning and land use management processes. It also provides for a differentiated approach to municipalities.

• Chapter 4 (Clauses 12 to 22) provides for the preparation and contents of national, provincial, regional and municipal spatial development frameworks, as well as the status of spatial development frameworks.

47

Page 48: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

CHAPTER OVERVIEW OF SPLUMBCHAPTERS 5 - 7• Chapter 5 (Clauses 23 to 32) provides for the adoption of municipal land

use schemes, including their purpose, content, status, review and relationship with existing land use schemes. The section also provides for the amendment of land use schemes and the alignment of authorisations in terms of other applicable legislation.

• Chapter 6 (Clauses 33 to 52) provides for the establishment, composition, powers and functions of Municipal Planning Tribunals, as well as for internal appeals against the decisions of Municipal Planning Tribunals. It also deals with possible municipal cooperation in adopting land use schemes and joint consideration of development applications that affect the national interest.

• Chapter 7 (Clauses 53 to 61) contains general provisions relating to commencement of registration of ownership, regulations, powers of the Minister to grant exemptions from provisions of the Act, delegations by the Minister, Premiers and municipalities to officials, non-impediment of function, offences and penalties, repeal of legislation, transitional provisions, and short title and commencement.

48

Page 49: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB AREAS OF CONCERN

49

Page 50: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB AREAS OF CONCERNMajor Issues (Including Constitutional Issues) Emerging from the Public Consultation Process: •Municipal Planning [in the wider context of the planning roles and responsibilities of each sphere of government]•Definition of the roles and responsibilities of each sphere of government with regard to spatial planning and land use management•Capacity of municipalities to comply with requirements in terms of legislation•Municipal differentiation•Support and monitoring of municipalities•Multiple Jurisdiction Over Spatial Planning and/or Land Use Management and alignment of authorisations

50

Page 51: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

SPLUMB AREAS OF CONCERNMajor Issues (Including Constitutional Issues) Emerging from the Public Consultation Process: •Parallel Processes – departments dealing with spatial planning and land development applications•Planning Tribunals and role of Councillors / officials•Appeals (internal –to Council - and external – to Province)•Repeal of Old Order Legislation•Non-impediment of Function •National / Provincial participation in Municipal SDFs and LUSs•Parallel public participation processes •Challenges of Provincial differences•National framework of prescriptive law

51

Page 52: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

DRAFTING PROCESS AND CONSULTATION

52

Page 53: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

DRAFTING PROCESS AND CONSULTATION

DRAFTING OF THE BILL INFORMED BY:• The fundamental role of the Bill, which is to promote and facilitate the

achievement of national strategic socio-economic and related spatial outcomes. – In this regard, the Bill must be able to support many other initiatives of

government, as well as the private sector.– Proposed amendments to the Bill cannot detract from this

fundamental role in any way.• The nature of the Bill, which is framework legislation

– Integrates and articulates national planning, national interest and national directives.

– Beyond this, the Bill begins to stray into the realm of provincial legislation

• The Bill must support the effective functioning of all three spheres of government concurrently, and not give greater weight to the governance role of any single sphere of government.

53

Page 54: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

DRAFTING OF THE BILL• The drafting of the Bill was executed under the guidance

of an Inter-Ministerial Committee (IMC) composed of the following Ministries:– National Planning Commission;– Rural Development and Land Reform; – Co-operative Governance and Traditional Affairs;– Human Settlements; and – Environmental Affairs

DRAFTING PROCESS AND CONSULTATION

54

Page 55: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

DRAFTING OF THE BILL• The IMC directed that an Interdepartmental Technical Team (IDTT) be

established to consolidate the efforts of the DRDLR and The Presidency.• This work was done in conjunction with the National Planning

Commission.• The IDTT was expanded at the end of 2010 to include representatives

from the following Departments:– Cooperative Governance – Human Settlements– Economic Development – Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry– Transport– Environmental Affairs– National Treasury

• The work of the IDTT resulted in a version of the Bill that was approved by Cabinet for public consultation in May 2011.

DRAFTING PROCESS AND CONSULTATION

55

Page 56: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

DRAFTING PROCESS AND CONSULTATION

•The Draft Bill was gazetted on 6 May 2011 [NOTICE 280 OF 2011, Gazette No. 34270]. The gazette notice provided a list of e-mail addresses and facsimile numbers where submissions could be

sent. •The Bill was also made available for downloading from the

department website [www.ruraldevelopment.gov.za] as well as the national government website[www.gov.za].•A notice was placed in nationally distributed newspapers,

namely the Sunday Times and the Mail & Guardian on 15 May 2011 and 13 May 2011 respectively, inviting interested and affected parties to download the draft Bill from the government or departmental websites and to submit comments via the contact details as per the notice.

56

Page 57: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

DRAFTING PROCESS AND CONSULTATION

•In response to this call a total of 101 comments were received from all sectors.•In order to deal with sector specific, provincial specific and municipality specific issues the Department arranged and held a number of bilateral meetings to ensure that all

relevant stakeholders were comprehensively consulted.•In addition to the bilateral meetings above a number of

workshops held with national departments, provincial departments and municipalities were also held.• A Regulatory Impact Assessment of the Bill was also

concluded in June 2011.

57

Page 58: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

DRAFTING PROCESS AND CONSULTATION

• In addition to the consultation as detailed above, the Department has engaged with key stakeholders, including:– SAPOA– SALGA– SACN– DBSA– NHOTL– MUNICIPALITIES, PROVINCES AND GOVERNMENT

DEPARTMENTS

58

Page 59: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

DRAFTING PROCESS AND CONSULTATION

ONGOING CONSULTATION WITH NEDLAC• In June 2011, the National Economic Development and

Labour Council (NEDLAC) initially requested that the Minister table the SPLUMB for discussion and engagement at the Council.

• The initial briefing with NEDLAC was held on 22 June 2011. • NEDLAC requested that the SPLUMB be tabled, debated and

negotiated at a Task Team level of NEDLAC. • The interactions with NEDLAC have been on-going at a

technical task team level since October 2011. • These interactions are yet to be concluded.

59

Page 60: SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BILL, 2012

THE ENDTHANK YOU

60