Spreading the Char- The Importance of Local Compatibility in The

8/12/2019 Spreading the Char- The Importance of Local Compatibility in The

1/137

Claremont Colleges

Scholarship @ Claremont

Pomona Senior Teses Pomona Student Scholarship

2014

Spreading Te Char: Te Importance of LocalCompatibility in the Diusion of Biochar Systems

to the Smallholder Agriculture CommunityContextLaura C. V. MunozPomona College

Tis Open Access Senior Tesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Pomona Student Scholarship at Scholarship @ Claremont. It has been

accepted for inclusion in Pomona Senior Teses by an authorized administrator of Scholarship @ Claremont. For more information, please contact

[email protected].

Recommended CitationMunoz, Laura C. V., "Spreading Te Char: Te Importance of Local Compatibility in the Diusion of Biochar Systems to theSmallholder Agriculture Community Context" (2014).Pomona Senior Teses. Paper 102.hp://scholarship.claremont.edu/pomona_theses/102
http://scholarship.claremont.edu/http://scholarship.claremont.edu/pomona_theseshttp://scholarship.claremont.edu/pomona_studentmailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://scholarship.claremont.edu/pomona_studenthttp://scholarship.claremont.edu/pomona_theseshttp://scholarship.claremont.edu/


2/137

!"#$%&'() +,$ -,%#.

+,$ '/"0#+%(-$ 01 20-%2 -0/"%+'3'2'+4'( +,$ &'115!'0( 01 3'0-,%# !4!+$/! +0 +,$

!/%22,02&$# %)#'-52+5#$ -0//5('+4 -0(+$6+

"#$%# &$'()

*+(,( -%./0,1 2#%3(4 5((,6 74,.%4#,0(4#81 9%(: ,+.0% ;.360,.#-+.8(% (9 ?%,6 @.A%.. 04 B4C0%(4:.4,#8 ?4#8D606EFGHIJHK #-#/.:0- D.#%E *(:(4# 2(88.A.E 28#%.:(4,E 2#809(%40#

5.#/.%61@%< >(;:#4 2$,,.%@%< 50-+#%/ L#)8.,,


3/137

F


4/137

?-M4(;8./A.:.4,6

D ,+#4M6 ,( :D %.#/.%6E *%(9.66(%6 >( 2$,,.% #4/ 50-M L#)8.,,E 9(% D($% #/C0-. #4/6$==(%, ,+%($A+($, ,+06 8.#%404A =%(-.660(-+#% 5.6.#%-+ 2.4,%. 9(% 3$08/04A :D 04,.%.6, #4/ .P=#4/04A :D M4(;8./A. (9 30(-+#%+#6M#% 5.//D 9(% A%#-0($68D 6+#%04AD($% ,0:.E M4(;8./A.E .P=.%0.4-.6 #4/ 0/.#6 ;0,+ :.E #4/ 9(% ,+. ;(%M D($ /(:@ O. 3H;GJ7@ P QJ7> Q: R=;A (;ACCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCDCOL

-J7K>:@ ODL. 3:=:? >; ?;H9CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCDCOS

-J7K>:@ T. 17G>;@? %F@: -;VVF=H>H:? H= >J:

&:W:9;KH=U Q;@9BCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCDDCCDTN

-J7K>:@ N. !V799J;9B:@ %U@HGF9>F@: 7=B 3H;GJ7@. QJ7> H? >J: ";>:=>H79X

QJ7> 7@: >J: 37@@H:@?XCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCDCDCDEL

-J7K>:@ NDL. 3H;GJ7@ !M?>:V +:GJ=;9;UH:? 7=B /:>J;B? J: !V799J;9B:@-;=>:Y>CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCDET

-J7K>:@ NDO. 37@@H:@? >; 3H;GJ7@ !M?>:V %B;K>H;= H= >J: !V799J;9B:@ -;=>:Y>CDCCEZ

-J7K>:@ NDT. &H7>H;= -7?: !>FBH:?CCCCCCCDCII

-J7K>:@ EDL. -7?: !>FBM L P ,7H>H ^-#'_CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCDCCCII

-J7K>:@ EDO. -7?: !>FBM O P -;?>7 #HG7 ^!:7-J7@_CCCCCCCCCCCCDCCCCCCCCS[-J7K>:@ EDT. -7?: !>FBM T P '=BH7 ^)$0_CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCDDDCCCCCCDDDZE

-J7K>:@ EDN. %=79M?H? ;< ,MK;>J:?:?CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCDCCCDCCCCCCDL\T

-J7K>:@ [. %BBH>H;=79 -;=?HB:@7>H;=?


7/137

K


8/137

T

1;@:A7@B

7, ;#6 :D 6$::.% 3%.#ME FGHFE #9,.% :D 6.-(4/ D.#% (9 -(88.A.< >$, 0, ;#6 ;04,.% 04

>%#)08U6 ,# ?,8V4,0-# W?,8#4,0- 2(#6,#8 X(%.6,YE (4. (9 ,+. ;(%8/U6 :(6, 30(/0C.%6. %.A0(46

(9 ;+0-+ (48D Z =.%-.4, 6,088 %.:#046< ?9,.% # /#DU6 ;(%M (9 9(%.6, #4/ .-(6D6,.::(40,(%04A 04 ,+. 9%#A:.4,./ %.:#046 (9 ,+. 9(%.6,E 7 ;($8/ (9,.4 60, (4 ,+. =(%-+ (9 ,+.

-#304 #4/ A#). ($, #, ,+. 8#4/6 3.9(%. :.< 7 ;#,-+./ ,+. -(;6 A%#). 4(4-+#8#4,8D (4 ,+.

3#%.E ..%08D 3.#$,09$8 +0886< 7 ,%0./ ,( 0:#A04. .C.%D,+04A ,+#, ;#6 ,+.%. ;+.4 ,+. 9(%.6, 6,088

;#6%#)08E 7 8.#%4./ # 8(, #3($, ,+. #%.#E 0,6

+06,(%DE #4/ ,+. 80C.80+((/6 (9 ,+. 8(-#8 =.(=8.< 7 .P=.%0.4-./ ,+. :#A0- (9 ,+. 80,,8. 9(%.6,

,+#, %.:#04./< 7 8.#%4./ ;+D 7 6#; :(6,8D =#6,$%.E .C.4 ,+($A+ 9#%:.%6 +#/ =%(6=.%./

9%(: -(99.. 9#%:04A (48D /.-#/.6 3.9(%.< 7 8.#%4./ ;+D ,+.%. ;.%. 30AE %.//06+ .%(60(4 #4/

8#4/680/. 6-#%6 (4 6(:. (9 ,+. +08860/.6< 7 8.#%4./ ;+D ,+. &$%0[$0 ;((88D 6=0/.% :(4M.D

;#6 #8:(6, .P,04-,0(-+#% 06 -+#%-(#8 ,+#, 06 =%(/$-./ #4/

$6./ ;0,+ 6=.-090- -(4/0,0(46 #4/ 04,.4,0(46< 7, 06

:#/. 9%(: (%A#40- :#,,.%E (% 30(:#66E ;+0-+ 06

+.#,./ 04 # -8(6./ 6=#-. ;0,+ 80,,8. #--.66 ,(

(PDA.40(-+#% 06 6+(;4 04 X0A$%. H


11/137

f

.#%,+_Y 6(086 (9 ,+. ?:#)(4 5#049(%.6, ,+#, 6$6,#04./ ,+%0C04A -0C080)#,0(46 3.9(%. ,+.

#%%0C#8 (9 ,+. Q=#406+ -(4[$06,#/(%60(-+#% 06 ,+. 3.6, #4/ (48D M4(;4 6(08 #:.4/:.4, ,+#, .4+#4-.6 6(08 [$#80,D 9(%

6$-+ # 8(4A ,.%:E 60A409D04A 0,6 A%.#, =(,.4,0#8 #6 # 60A4090-#4, ,((8 9(% .4C0%(4:.4,#8

:#4#A.:.4,.-#$6. (9 0,6 /0C.%6. #%%#D (9 $6.6 #4/ .99.-,6E

/099.%.4, 30(-+#% 6D6,.:6 :#D .:.%A. (4 /099.%.4, 6-#8.60(-+#% 06 /06-$66./ 04 9$%,+.% /.,#08 #4/ -(4,.P, 04 2+#=,.%6 H #4/ F#6./ (4 ,+. 80,.%#,$%. #4/

3#-MA%($4/ 049(%:#,0(4E 7 9(%:./ 6(:. +D=(,+.6.6 %.A#%/04A ,+. /099$60(4 (9 30(-+#%

6D6,.:6< 7 ,+.4 -%#9,./ ,+%.. -#6. 6,$/0.6 (9 30(-+#% 6D6,.: /099$60(4 =%(S.-,6 04 ,+.

/.C.8(=04A ;(%8/ 6:#88+(8/.% #A%0-$8,$%. -(4,.P,< 7 /0/ ,+06 3D 04,.%C0.;04A =.(=8.

04C(8C./ 04 ,+. =%(S.-,6 #6 ;.88 #6 A#,+.%04A =%(S.-, 049(%:#,0(4 9%(: (,+.% 6($%-.6:@ O. 3H;GJ7@ P QJ7> Q: R=;A (;A

D2$.; "$#')+ *5 ')" :-9"#5 9$?

R+. =#6, FG D.#%6 +#C. 6..4 %#=0/8D .P=#4/04A %.6.#%-+ (4 30(-+#%< *.(=8. #%.

6,$/D04A :#4D /099.%.4, #6=.-,6 #4/ =(,.4,0#86 (9 30(-+#% $4/.% ,+. $:3%.88#6 (9 6(086-0.4-.E =D%(8D606 ,.-+4(8(A0.6E #==80-#,0(4 ,.-+40[$.6E 30(8(A0-#8 04,.%#-,0(46E 809.-D-8.

#66.66:.4,6E -#%3(4 6.[$.6,%#,0(4E -80:#,. -+#4A. :0,0A#,0(4 #4/ (,+.% -#,.A(%0.6 ,*-.)$# -5 +-*2+ $59 $4#*.12'1#"

!"#$%&'? ,&'7 2'.&/07

7, 06 0:=(%,#4, ,( 8((M #, 6=.-090- .99.-,6 (9 30(-+#% (4 6(08 04 (%/.% ,( A#04

$4/.%6,#4/04A (9 ,+. #A%0-$8,$%#8 60,$#,0(46 ,( ;+0-+ 0, -($8/ 3%04A A%.#, 3.4.90,< Q,$/0.6 (4

,+. .99.-,6 (9 30(-+#% 04 6(08 :$6, 3. %.C0.;./ ;0,+ ,+. $4/.%6,#4/04A ,+#, ,+.%. 06 4(, (4.

;(%8/;0/. 6,#4/#%/ %.-0=. 9(% 30(-+#%< >0(-+#% 06 :#/. $604A /099.%.4, -(:304#,0(46 (9

9../6,(-M6E /099.%.4, ,.-+4(8(A0.6E /099.%.4, +.#,04A ,0:.6 #4/ ,.:=.%#,$%.6E #4/ (,+.%

C#%0#38.6< 74 #//0,0(4E ,+.%. 06 .P,.460C. C#%0#,0(4 04 6(08 ,D=.6 #4/ -80:#,0- -(4/0,0(46 04

/099.%.4, 8(-#,0(46 #%($4/ ,+. ;(%8/.-#$6. ,+. %.6$8,6 (9 30(-+#% $6. -#4 C#%D A%.#,8D #4/

/099.%.4, 30(-+#% 6D6,.:6 #4/ 9../6,(-M %.6($%-.6 #%. #C#08#38. 04 /099.%.4, =8#-.6E 90.8/

,%0#86 :$6, 3. =.%9(%:./ 04 (%/.% ,( ,.6, ,+. ($,-(:.6 (9 # A0C.4 30(-+#% 04 # A0C.4

8(-#,0(4< 79 =(66038.E 0, 06 #86( $6.9$8 ,( ,.6, ,+. 30(-+#%6 ,+.:6.8C.6 #4/ ,+. 6(086 ,( ;+0-+

,+.D ;088 3. #==80./< >0(-+#% #4/ 6(08 ,.6,04A ;088 4(, 3. #//%.66./ 04 ,+06 =#=.%r +(;.C.%E

$6.9$8 049(%:#,0(4 (4 ,+06 :#,,.% 06 =%(C0/./ 04 2+#=,.%6 fE HKE HT #4/ Hb 04 6%. !"#$%&'

M.,#09/"#+0(-+#%6 ?%. N(, 2%.#,./ B[$#8E L(; ,( R.88 R+.: ?=#%,1 t.%60(4

FE_ =%(C0/.6 60:=8.E 049(%:#8 -+#%J,.6,04A :.,+(/6 ,+#, #88(; 9(% ,+. /.,.%:04#,0(4 (9

6.C.%#8 M.D -+#%#-,.%06,0-6 9(% # A0C.4 30(-+#% W6.. #%,0-8. 9(% /.,#086Y< R+. #%,0-8. #86(

#990%:6 ,+. 60A4090-#4, C#%0#,0(4 04 M.D =%(=.%,0.6 (9 /099.%.4, 30(-+#%6 #4/ ,+. 0:=(%,#4-.(9 3.04A #;#%. (9 ,+. 6=.-090- -+#%#-,.%06,0-6 (9 # A0C.4 30(-+#% ;+.4 #//04A 0, ,( 6(08< 7,

.:=+#60).6 ,+#, \%.=(%,6 (9 ,+. %.6=(46.6 W;+.,+.% 9#C(%#38. (% $49#C(%#38.Y (9 =8#4,6

#4/ 6(086 ,( 30(-+#% #==80-#,0(46 #%. (9 [$.6,0(4#38. C#8$. ;0,+($, -(%%.6=(4/04A

bK?4/.%6(4E *#$8 Q< \R"g@ L#4/3((M1 @%#9, H 9(% @06-$660(4


30/137

FZ

M4(;8./A. (9 ,+. -+#%#-,.%06,0-6 (9 ,+. #==80./ 30(-+#%60(-+#% 740,0#,0C. 6,#,.6 ,+#, 30(-+#% -#4 0:=%(C. :(6, 6(086E

+(;.C.% 8(-#,0(46 ;0,+ .0,+.% 4$,%0.4,J=((% 6(086 (% 8(; %#049#88 ;088 80M.8D 3.4.90, :(6,0(-+#% L.8=6 ,+. Q(08


31/137

Ff

,0:. a +$4/%./6 ,( ,+($6#4/6 (9 D.#%6 a %.:#0404A 6$36,#4,0#88D $4-+#4A./< 7, 06

-(460/.%./ # \6(08 -#,#8D6,E_ 3.-#$6. 0, 9(6,.%6 0:=%(C.:.4,6 04 ,+. 6(08 .4C0%(4:.4,

04+#30,./ 3D =8#4,6 #4/ :0-%(3.6:@ ODL. 3:=:? >; ?;H9

&)?+*.$2 ">>".'+B G:8#-7"9 +-*2 +'#1.'1#" $59 9#$*5$4"

V!"#$%&' -"/"2&/.? ?#"0L? D%7?"$&0 5.)"$".+$".?8W a L$A+ &-"#$A+804E @0%.-,(% (9 >0(-+#%

5.6.#%-+ #, ?8,.%4# >0(-+#%-(4 74-0(-+#% L.8=6 ,+. Q(080(-+#% L.8=6 ,+. Q(08


32/137

Fd

>9/'".+/ './.+/"#+ X $&/"#+ .Y$%&+2. $&D&$"/7

?--(%/04A ,( i< w04 2+#4 #4/ O+0+(4A x$E \(4. %.#6(4 9(% ,+. #3080,D (9 ?:#)(40#4

R.%%# *%.,# 6(086s,( :#04,#04 +0A+ 9.%,080,D W-(:=#%./ ,( #/S#-.4, 049.%,08. 6(086Y 06 ,+.0%

#3080,D ,( %.,#04 4$,%0.4,60(-+#% +#6 # =%(=.%,D -#88./ -#,0(4 .P-+#4A. -#=#-0,D< R+06 -#=#-0,D #88(;6 0, ,(

%.,#04 =(60,0C. 0(46 04 # 9(%: ,+#, 06 .P-+#4A.#38.< R+.6. =(60,0C. 0(46E C0,#8 4$,%0.4,6 6$-+

#6 #::(40$: (% =(,#660$: -#,0(46E #%. :#/. #C#08#38. ,( =8#4,6 ;+.4 ,+.D 4../ ,+.:0(-+#% 0,6.89 #86( -(4,%03$,.6 3(,+ :0-%(J #4/ :#-%(J4$,%0.4,6

,+#, .4+#4-. =8#4, A%(;,+< L(;.C.%E ,+. 6=.-090- 4$,%0.4, -(:=(60,0(4 #4/ #C#08#3080,D 04 #

30(-+#% /.=.4/6 A%.#,8D (4 ,+. 9../6,(-M6 $6./ #4/ ,+. =%(/$-,0(4 -(4/0,0(460(-+#%U6

-#=#-0,D ,( 6,(%. #88 ,+.6. 4$,%0.4,6 +#6 3..4 6+(;4 ,( 04-%.#6. (C.% ,0:.0(-+#% L.8=6 ,+. Q(080(-+#% B99.-,6 (4 N$,%0.4, ".#-+04A


33/137

IG

30(-+#% :0P./ ;0,+ 6(08 /.-%.#6.6 4$,%0.4, 8.#-+04A #6 ;.88< X(% ,+06 6=.-090- =$%=(6.E

30(-+#% 06 :(6, C#8$#38. 04 6#4/D 6(086 #4/ %.A0(46 (9 +0A+ %#049#880(-+#% L.8=6 ,+. Q(08; ;? JHUJ K;@;?H>M


34/137

IH

/$%04A 8(; =%.-0=0,#,0(4 =.%0(/6 ,+#, -(::(48D D0.8/ +(,E /%D 6(08YE ,+. =%.C0($68D

#/6(%3./ :(06,$%. 06 %.8.#6./ 3#-M 04,( ,+. 6(08< R+06 .99.-, 0:=%(C.6 #88J#%($4/ :(06,$%.

%.,.4,0(4 04 6(086E ;+0-+ -#4 3. .P,%.:.8D 3.4.90-0#8 /$%04A 8(;J%#049#88 =.%0(/6 #4/

/%($A+, -(4/0,0(46< N(, (48D -#4 30(-+#% 0:=%(C. :(06,$%. %.,.4,0(4E 3$, 0, -#4 #86(

04-%.#6. ,+. (C.%#88 ;#,.% +(8/04A -#=#-0,D (9 6(086 ,( ;+0-+ 0, 06 #//./0(-+#% L.8=6 ,+. Q(08


35/137

IF

/D04A #4/ /.-(:=(604A>".'+ -> ,*-.)$# -5 $4#*.12'1#"

?6 /06-$66./ #3(C.E 30(-+#% -(4,#046 :$8,0=8. =%(=.%,0.6 ,+#, 3%04A #3($, # C#%0.,D

(9 3.4.90-0#8 -+#4A.6 ,( 6(086 04 ;+0-+ 0, 06 #==80./< >0(-+#% 0:=%(C.6 6(086 6,%$-,$%. #4/

/%#04#A.E .4+#4-04A 6(08 #.%#,0(4 #4/ :(06,$%. %.,.4,0(4r 0, 04-%.#6.6 ,+. 6(086U %.6($%-.

.990-0.4-D ,+%($A+ ,+. 9#-080,#,0(4 (9 0:=%(C./ 4$,%0.4, %.,.4,0(4 ,+($A+ -#,0(4 .P-+#4A.

-#=#-0,D #6 ;.88 #6 ,+%($A+ 0,6 #/6(%=,0(4 -#=#-0,Dr #4/ 0, =%(:(,.6 ,+. A%(;,+ (9

3.4.90-0#8 6(08 :0-%(3. =(=$8#,0(46< ?8(4A ;0,+ ,+.6. 3.4.90,6E 30(-+#% (9,.4 #86( +#6 #

80:04A .99.-, ,+#, :(/.%#,.6 6(08 #-0/0,D0(-+#% ;(%M6 04 -(:304#,0(4 ;0,+ (,+.% 6(08 -(:=(4.4,6 W04-8$/04A 6(08 :0-%(3.6Y

,( 0:=%(C. ,+. (C.%#88 6(08 /D4#:0-6 a ,+. -(4/0,0(46 04 ;+0-+ =8#4,6 A%(; a (C.% ,+. 8(4A

dF&-"#$A+804E \2+< Z1 L(; >0(-+#% L.8=6 ,+. Q(080(-+#% B99.-,6 (4 N$,%0.4, ".#-+04A


36/137

II

,.%:< R+06 #88(;6 9(% 3.,,.% =8#4, 4$,%0,0(4E 0:=%(C04A =8#4, A%(;,+ #4/ D0.8/ #4/ 3%04A04A

(C.%#%-+04A 3.4.90,6 ,( #A%0-$8,$%#8 6(08 =%(/$-,0C0,D*' $59 .$5 ," 9*>>1+"9 '- ')" +:$22)-29"# .-5'"E'/

()$' .$5 ')"? 9-/

A? &+7#+. K#'G"+2 #+ /%"? /7D. #) ?/9))N

74/../E 6(:. =.(=8. +#C. 04/../ ,$%4./ ,+.0% #,,.4,0(4 ,( 30(-+#% 6D6,.:6 9(% ,+.

=$%=(6. (9 %.:./D04A 6(:. (9 ,+. :#4D 04,.%-(44.-,./ =%(38.:6 ,+#, #%. -(::(4 04

6:#88+(8/.% -(::$40,0.6< R+. =#6, /.-#/. +#6 6..4 ,%.:.4/($6 A%(;,+ 04 04,.%.6, #4/

.P.-$,0(4 (9 6:#88.%J6-#8.E /.C.8(=04A ;(%8/ -(4,.P, 30(-+#% =%(S.-,6< 2+#=,.% T =%.6.4,6

#4/ #4#8D).6 ,+%.. /099.%.4, -#6. 6,$/0.6 (9 -$%%.4, 30(-+#% 6D6,.: /099$60(4 =%(S.-,6 04 ,+.

/.C.8(=04A ;(%8/ 6:#88+(8/.% -(4,.P,< R+.6. -#6. 6,$/0.6 8((M #, Nj`J%$4 30(-+#%J%.8#,./

=%(S.-,6 04 6:#88+(8/.% -(::$40,0.6 04 L#0,0E 2(6,# 50-# #4/ 74/0#


57/137

TK

A:$22)-29"# .-5'"E' ,*-.)$# +?+'": '".)5-2-4*"+

Q.C.%#8 ,D=.6 #4/ C#%0#,0(46 (9 30(-+#%

,.-+4(8(A0.6 +#C. 3..4 /.C.8(=./ ;0,+ 04,.4,0(4

9(% $6. 04 ,+. %$%#8 6:#88+(8/.% -(::$40,D

-(4,.P,< @$. ,( :#4D -0%-$:6,#4-.6 /06-$66./ 04

2+#=,.% IE ,+.6. ,.-+4(8(A0.6 :$6, 3. -+.#=E

.#608D :#/.E #4/ =%.9.%#38D =%(/$-038. 9%(:

8(-#88D 6($%-./ :#,.%0#86< R+06 6.-,0(4 04,%(/$-.6

# 9.; /099.%.4, ,.-+4(8(A0.6 ,+#, #%. $6./ 04 ,+.

2+#=,.% T -#6. 6,$/0.6< ?88HTI(9 ,+. ,.-+4(8(A0.6

,+#, #%. 04-(%=(%#,./ #4/ 9$4/#:.4,#8 ,( ,+.30(-+#% 6D6,.:6 04 ,+. 2+#=,.% T -#6. 6,$/0.6 $6.

R(=J"0, g=/%#9, WR"g@Y A#6090-#,0(4E ;+0-+ ;#6

/.6-%03./ 04 2+#=,.% F #4/ 06 =0-,$%./ 04 X0A$%. HK


58/137

TT

(9 ,+. 6,(C.E -%.#,04A # -8.#4 98#:. 9(% -((M04A< ?9,.% -((M04A .#-+ :.#8E ,+. 30(-+#% -#4 3.

.:=,0./ 9(% 8#,.% $6.< @099.%.4, 6,(C. /.60A46 90, /099.%.4, 30(:#66 ;#6,. :#,.%0#86 W.


59/137

Tb

A.$2$,2" D*-.)$# !HM6 J7"5+ $59 0"'-#'+

>0(-+#% (C.46 #%. $6./ 3D #88 ,+%.. Nj`6< R+.D #%. A%.#, 9(% 6-#804A $= ,+.

=%(/$-,0(4 (9 30(-+#%E 3.-#$6. ;0,+ 6(8. $6. (9 -((M6,(C.6 9(% 30(-+#% =%(/$-,0(4E 0, ;($8/

,#M. [$0,. # 8(4A ,0:. 9(% (4. 6,(C. ,( =%(/$-. # 60A4090-#4, #:($4,H G7?: ?>FBM K@;]:G>D

1HUF@: LS ^9:_. % ?G79:B FK 8H;GJ7@;W:= F?:B H= >J: -;?>7 #HG7 G7?: ?>FBM

K@;]:G>D


60/137

TZ

,+. .4-8(6./ -+#:3.% +.#,6 ,+. 30(:#66 #4/ 0,6 =D%(8D606 A#6.6 .6-#=. #4/ #%. 3$%4./

($,60/. ,+. -+#:3.%< N( (PDA.4 .4,.%6 ,+. 0460/. -+#:3.%r (48D =D%(8D606 (--$%6< Q(:.

+D3%0/ R"g@J5.,(%, :(/.86 +#C. 3..4 /.C.8(=./E -(:30404A ,+. ,;( :.,+(/60(-+#% -((M6,(C.6E %.,(%,6E #4/ A%..4 -+#%-(#8 3%0[$.,,.6 /( 4(, %.=%.6.4, #88 6:#88+(8/.%

-(4,.P, 30(-+#%J%.8#,./ ,.-+4(8(A0.6< L(;.C.%E ,+.D #%. (9,.4 -.4,%#8 044(C#,0(46 9(%

HbIL0%6,E *.,.%< \2+< HG1 X%(: 2(880.%6 ,( 5.,(%,60(-+#% 74/0# ;.360,.;;9 G7= G@:7>:

8@HeF:>>:?D

1HUF@: O\ ^8;>>;V_D /7=M U@::= GJ7@G;79 8@HeF:>>:?

7@: K@;BFG:B 7> 7 >HV: F?H=U 7 97@U:@ >;;9 H= >J:

,7H>H G7?: ?>FBMD


61/137

Tf

6:#88+(8/.% -(4,.P, /099$60(4 =%(S.-,6< 7, 06 ;(%,+ 4(,04A ,+. 04,.A%#,0C. 4#,$%. (9 ,+.6.

,.-+4(8(A0.6 #4/ ,+. ;#D6 04 ;+0-+ ,+.D -#4 -(:304. ,( #//%.66 :$8,0=8. =%(38.:6-# +:$22)-29"# .-::15*'*"+/

=+)&-"0"&'"/7 #' 0"-"/.5 G+#K0.52.

`4. (9 ,+. :(6, (3C0($6 %.#6(46 =.(=8. ;+( -($8/ 3.4.90, 9%(: 30(-+#% /(4U, $6. 0,

06 3.-#$6. ,+.D +#C. 4(J,(J80:0,./ M4(;8./A. #3($, 0,< ]+08. 6(:. -(::$40,0.6 $6. -+#%

04 6(08 #4/ +#C. 3..4 9(% -.4,$%0.6E 30(-+#% 6D6,.:6 #%. 6,088 -(460/.%./ \4.;_ ,.-+4(8(A0.6

,( ,+.6. =8#-.6 3.-#$6. ,+.D $6. /099.%.4, ,.-+4(8(AD #4/ A$0/.804.6< X(% .P#:=8.E :(6,

,%#/0,0(4#8 -+#% =%(/$-,0(4 ,.-+40[$.6 %.8.#6. +#%:9$8 .:0660(46 04,( ,+. .4C0%(4:.4, W#6

=%.C0($68D /06-$66./Y #4/ #%. -(460/.%./ 04.990-0.4, /$. ,( 8(; -+#% D0.8/6< 74 :#4D -#6.6E

,+.6. :.,+(/6 6,088 -#$6. /.9(%.6,#,0(4 #4/ 8#4/ /.A%#/#,0(4 =%(38.:6< >0(-+#% 6D6,.:6

/06-$66./ 04 ,+06 =#=.% +#C. ,+. =(,.4,0#8 ,( 3%04A #A%0-$8,$%#8E .-(4(:0-E 6(-0#8 #4/

.4C0%(4:.4,#8E 3.4.90,6 .C.4 ,( =8#-.6 ,+#, ,%#/0,0(4#88D =%#-,0-.6 #A%0-$8,$%#8 -+#%-(#8.9(%. 8#$4-+04A 04,( /099$60(4 ,+.(%DE # -($=8. :(%. =(66038. 3#%%0.%6 ,( /099$60(4

:$6, 3. #-M4(;8./A./< *(C.%,D ,%#=6E #6 /06-$66./ 04 2+#=,.% IE :#D 8.#C. =((% 9#%:.%6

$4#38. ,( #/(=, 30(-+#% =%#-,0-.6 .C.4 09 ,+.D ;($8/ 80M. ,(< ]+08. (,+.% 9#%:.%6 :#D 3.

904#4-0#88D #38. ,( #/(=,E %06M #C(0/#4-. #4/ -(46.%C#,0C. -+(0-.6 (9 9#%:.%6 80C04A (4 ,+.

:#%A04 :#D /.,.% /099$60(4< "#4/ ,.4$%. 60,$#,0(46 :#D #86( =%.6.4, # 3#%%0.% 04 6(:.

=8#-.6E 3.-#$6. 9#%:.%6 +#C. 4( 04-.4,0C.6 ,( :#M. 8(4AJ,.%: 04C.6,:.4,6 04 8#4/ ,+#,

:0A+, 4(, 3. ,+.0%6 W(% ,+.0% M04U6Y 04 -(:04A D.#%6:@ NDT. &H


64/137

bH

R+.%. #%. 9($% :#04 .8.:.4,6 04 ,+. /099$60(4 (9

044(C#,0(461 ,+. 044(C#,0(4E -(::$40-#,0(4 -+#44.86E

,0:.E #4/ # 6(-0#8 6D6,.:< ?, 0,6 :(6, .8.:.4,#%D 9(%:E

,+. /099$60(4 =%(-.66 04C(8C.6 #4 044(C#,0(4 W# 30(-+#%

6D6,.:YE # =#%,D ;0,+ M4(;8./A. (9 (% .P=.%0.4-. ;0,+

,+. 044(C#,0(4 W=%(S.-, 0:=8.:.4,.%6E #86( M4(;4 #6

\-+#4A. #A.4,6_YE # =#%,D ;0,+($, M4(;8./A. (%

.P=.%0.4-. ;0,+ ,+. 044(C#,0(4 W%$%#8 6:#88+(8/.%

9#%:04A -(::$40,0.6E 04 ,+06 -#6.YE #4/ # -(::$40-#,0(4

-+#44.8 -(44.-,04A ,+. ,;( =#%,0.6


65/137

bF

044(C#,0(4 :(%. /0990-$8,


66/137

bI

#4/ (,+.% #//0,0(4#8 #6=.-,6E 6$-+ #6 -((M6,(C. (=.%#,0(4< R+. 6=%.#/04A (9 .#-+ (9 ,+.6.

044(C#,0(46 04 ,+. \6.,_ 06 04,.%/.=.4/.4, 'VK9:V:=>7>H;= -7?: !>FBH:?

74 ,+. 8#6, /.-#/.E # 4$:3.% (9 30(-+#%J%.8#,./ =%(S.-,6 +#C. 3..4 .P.-$,./ 04 ,+.

/.C.8(=04A ;(%8/ 6:#88+(8/.% -(::$40,D -(4,.P,< R+.D $6. # C#%0.,D (9 ,.-+4(8(A0.6E

6,%#,.A0.6 #4/ 0/.#6< D (9 ,+.6. =%(S.-,6 #,,.:=, ,( -(:=%.+.460C.8D #//%.66 :$8,0=8.6:#88+(8/.% 066$.6< *%(S.-, 0:=8.:.4,#,0(4 6,%#,.A0.6 #4/ 0498$.4,0#8 9#-,(%6 6$-+ #6

8(-#,0(4E 60,$#,0(4E #4/ 8(-#8 -$8,$%. C#%D ;0/.8D ,+%($A+($, ,+.6. =%(S.-,6H ^-#'_

37GdU@;F=B

2#%3(4 5((,6 74,.%4#,0(4#8 W257Y 06 # 4(4J=%(90, (%A#40)#,0(4 9%(: Q.#,,8.E

]#6+04A,(4E gQ?< 7, ;#6 9($4/./ 04 FGHGE 3$, ,+.0% 30(-+#%J%.8#,./ ;(%ME ;+0-+ ,#M.6

=8#-. 04 %$%#8 6:#88+(8/.% -(::$40,0.6 04 4(%,+.%4 L#0,0E /#,.6 3#-M ,( FGGI:Y> P @F@79 ,7H>H

H$59 *5 K$*'*

[K+.'?%"D &+5 /.+9'.

"#4/ 06 %.8#,0C.8D .C.48D /06,%03$,./ 04 L#0,0< \&(6, +(8/04A6 #%. 6:#88

W#==%(P0:#,.8D ,+%.. #-%.6YE #4/ ,+.%. #%. C.%D 9.; 8#4/8.66 +($6.+(8/6


82/137

Zd

=%(38.:6 ,+#, %.6$8, 04 /.-%.#6./ #A%0-$8,$%#8 D0.8/6 #4/ /.C#6,#,04A 8#4/680/.6


83/137

fG

/.C.8(=04A -($4,%0.6E #4/ \#4 #C.%#A. L#0,0#4 9#:08D :0A+, 6=.4/ (C.% KGn (9 04-(:. (4

-((M04A 9$.8


84/137

fH

-.4,.% 8(-#,./ ($,60/. (9 2#=JL#0,0.4< R+. .4,.%=%06. .:=8(D6 # /.-.4,%#80)./ 4.,;(%M (9

(C.% bG 6:#88+(8/.% 9#%:.%6 #4/ .4,%.=%.4.$%6 ;+( =%(/$-. -#%3(4J%0-+ -+#% 9%(: ,+.0%

#A%0-$8,$%#8 ;#6,. W6$-+ #6 6$A#%-#4. 3#A#66.Y


85/137

fF

,+.D A., -#6+H;=

G:=>:@D


86/137

fI

W6.. /06-$660(4 3.8(;Y< >.-#$6. ,+. A(#8 9(% ,+. .4,.%=%06. 06 9(% 0, ,( 3.-(:. 904#4-0#88D

6$6,#04#38.E ,+.D :$6, 6.88 # =%(/$-, W,+. 3%0[$.,,.6Y ,( :#M. %.C.4$.< ?86(E Q(%.46.4

.P=8#04./E .C.4 ,+($A+ ,+. 6(08 =%(38.: 04 L#0,0 06 .P,%.:.8D 3#/E ,+. -+#%-(#8 -((M04A 9$.8

=%(38.: W04-8$/04A /.9(%.6,#,0(4E 9$.8 =%0-. #4/ +.#8,+ =%(38.:6Y 06 .C.4 #4 .C.4 :(%.

#-$,.E =%.6604A 4../J ,7H>Hf? 8H;GJ7@ V7@d:>

6%. +#+.Y"?/.+/ ;"#$%&' -&'G./ "+ O&"/"

Q(%.46.4 .P=8#04./ ,+#, 30(-+#% /(.64U, +#C. # %.#/D :#%M., 04 L#0,0 9(% # 4$:3.%

(9 %.#6(46< \R+. 30AA.6, %.#6(4 06 =(C.%,D #4/ ,+. 9#-, ,+#, =.(=8. 04 L#0,0 %.#88D /(4U,

6=.4/ #4D :(4.D (4 #4D 6(08 04=$,6E 6( %.#88D 4( 9.%,080).%E ;+.,+.% (%A#40- (% -+.:0-#8.-#$6. (9 ,+06E 257 -#4U, .#608D 6.88 30(-+#% ,( 6,%#4A.%6< BC.4 09 8(-#8 9#%:.%6 ;.%.

04,.%.6,./E :#4D (9 ,+.: 80C. 04 6.C.%. =(C.%,DE #4/ #--(%/04A ,( ,+. =(C.%,D ,%#=6 ,+.(%DE

,+.D ;($8/ 4(, 3. #38. (% 04-804./ ,( 6=.4/ :(4.D (4 # 8(4A.%J,.%:E $49#:080#%

04C.6,:.4,< R+. .P,%.:. =(C.%,D 60,$#,0(4 04 L#0,0 /.9040,.8D =%.6.4,6 A%.#, -+#88.4A.6 ,(

-%.#,04A /.:#4/ 9(% 30(-+#%r .P,%.:. =(C.%,D 06 /.9040,.8D # =(,.4,0#8 3#%%0.% 9(% ,+.

/099$60(4 (9 30(-+#% 6D6,.:6FBM O P -;?>7 #HG7 ^!:7-J7@_

37GdU@;F=B

Q.#2+#% 06 # 4(4J=%(90, 9%(: ]#6+04A,(4 Q,#,.E gQ?< 7, ;#6 9($4/./ 04 FGGf #9,.%

*%.60/.4, #4/ 2+#0%:#4 (9 ,+. >(#%/ ?%, @(44.88D ,%#C.8./ ,( %$%#8 *#4#:# ;+.%. +.

;0,4.66./ ,.%%038. %.6=0%#,(%D /06.#6. %#,.E .6=.-0#88D #:(4A ;(:.4E /$. ,( 04/((% #0%

=(88$,0(4 9%(: 6,(C.6< L. +#/ # 3#-MA%($4/ 04 904. #%,6 #4/ :.,#8 ;(%ME #4/ /.-0/./ ,(

/.60A4 # 6,(C. ,+#, -($8/ -((M 04 # -8.#4.% ;#D< ".66 ,+#4 # D.#% 8#,.% +. +.#%/ #3($,

30(-+#%< @(44.88D /.60A4./ # 6,(C. ,+#, $6.6 30(:#66 9(% 9$.8 #4/ =%(/$-.6 30(-+#% /$%04A

,+. -((M04A =%(-.66E #6 /.6-%03./ 04 2+#=,.% K


90/137

fZ

6"+.#*8'*-5 $59 .-5'"E' -> 8#-S".' *5 ')" !$2$:$5.$ #"4*-5 ->


91/137

ff

L(;.C.%E /06%.A#%/04A #4D %.-.4, $6. (9 30(-+#%E #88 (9 ,+#, -+#%-(#8 06 =%(/$-./ $604A

,%#/0,0(4#8 :.,+(/6E ;+0-+ -(4,%03$,. ,( /.9(%.6,#,0(4 #4/ -%.#,. +#%:9$8 .:0660(46


92/137

fd

,+#4 ,%#/0,0(4#8 6,(C.6 #4/ (=.4 -((M04A 90%.6< B:0660(46E -((M ,0:. #4/ 9$.8 %./$-,0(46 #%.

/.6-%03./ 04 2+#=,.% K


93/137

dG

(9 Ff %.:#0404A 6,$/D =#%,0-0=#4,6 +#/ -(:=8.,.8D 6,(==./ $604A ,+. 6,(C.6E #4/ :#4D

:(%. W4( .P#-, 4$:3.%Y ;.%. $604A ,+. 6,(C.6 04-(%%.-,8D W:(%. /.,#08 3.8(;Y )3-"_jB` 06 0:=8.:.4,04A R+. j((/ Q,(C.6 #4/ >0(-+#% 2(::$40,D *%(S.-, Wj>2*Y 04

6.:0J#%0/ =#%,6 (9 74/0#E :(6,8D 04 ,+. ?4/+%# *%#/.6+ Q,#,.< R+. =%(S.-, (%0A04#,./ 04

FGGd< R+.D #%. 3.04A 6$==(%,./ 3D ?-,0(4 2#%3(4.E # =%(A%#: (9 ,+. j((/=8#4.,

FfH5.//DE N< Q#0 >+#6M#%< \j((/ Q,(C.6 #4/ >0(-+#% 2(::$40,D *%(S.-,


99/137

db

X($4/#,0(42* 06 ;(%M04A ,( =%(:(,. 6$6,#04#38. 30(-+#% =%(/$-,0(4 #4/ .4-($%#A.

30(-+#% #==80-#,0(4 ;+08. 3%04A04A # =(60,0C. 6(-0#8 0:=#-, ,( %$%#8 -(::$40,0.6< Q( 9#%E

jB` +#6 /.60A4./ HK /099.%.4, M04/6 (9 \j((/ Q,(C.6_ W30(-+#%J:#M04A -((M 6,(C.6Y 04

(%/.% ,( 6$0, /099.%.4, 6,(C. 4../6 04 /099.%.4, =8#-.6H;= 7=B G;=>:Y>.

H$59 *5 G59*$

[K+.'?%"D &+5 /.+9'.

74/0# 06 :#/. $= (9 :(6,8D 6:#88 9#%:6 -$8,0C#,./ 3D 9#:08D 8#3(% #4/ 80C.6,(-M< 74

HdfGE #%($4/ +#89 (9 ,+. 9#%: +(8/04A6 04 ,+. -($4,%D ;.%. 8.66 ,+#4 H +.-,#%.E #4/ (48D K

=.%-.4, ;.%. :(%. ,+#4 HG +.-,#%.6< &(6, 9#%:.%6 =(66.66 6.-$%. %0A+,6 ,( ,+. 8#4/ ,+.D

;(%ME .0,+.% #6 9$88 (;4.%6 (% =%(,.-,./ ,.4#4,6< Q,#,.6 (C.%6.. ,.4$%. 6.-$%0,D #4/ ,+.

.6,#3806+:.4, (9 9#0% %.4,6E 6( 8#;6 C#%D 04 /099.%.4, 6,#,.6


100/137

dZ

#// .P,%# -+.:0-#86 W6$-+ #6 9.%,080).%6 #4/ =.6,0-0/.6Y ,( ,+. 6(086


101/137

df

%KK@;7GJ >; K@;89:V ?;9WH=U 7=B K@;]:G> B:?HU=

R+. j((/ Q,(C.6 #4/ >0(-+#% 2(::$40,D

*%(S.-, 04-8$/.6 ,+. .6,#3806+:.4, (9 ,+.

-(::.%-0#80)#,0(4 -+#04 (9 +0A+8DJ.990-0.4, 30(-+#%J

:#M04A -((M6,(C.6E ,+. /099$60(4 (9 0:=%(C./ 6:#88J

6-#8. (C.46E ,+. =D%(8D606 (9 #A%0-$8,$%#8 %.60/$.6 ,+#,

#%. 3$%4, (,+.%;06.E ,+. 6(08 9.%,080,DU6 .4+#4-.:.4,

#4/ ,+. 8(4AJ,.%: -#%3(4 6.[$.6,%#,0(4 ,+%($A+

30(-+#% #==80-#,0(4 04 6(086< R+. #0: (9 ,+. =%(S.-, 06

,( \.4+#4-. ,+. 80C04A -(4/0,0(46 (9 %$%#8 9#:080.6E

-($4,.%#-, /.9(%.6,#,0(4E =%(,.-,

30(/0C.%60,DE 04-%.#6. -%(= =%(/$-,0(4E

0:=%(C. #A%0-$8,$%#8 ;#6,.

:#4#A.:.4, #4/ %.:(C. -#%3(4 9%(:

,+. #,:(6=+.%. #6 # -#%3(4J4.A#,0C.

6,%#,.AD ,( 90A+, A8(3#8 ;#%:04A0(-+#% 2(::$40,D *%(S.-,+#6M#% 5.//D W*0-#6#Y;K >A; KHG>F@:? ?J;A 7 9;G79 A;V7=

AH>J J:@ ?V;dM >@7BH>H;=79 ?>;W: 7=B >J:= AH>J J:@ =:Aa G9:7=b

8F@=H=U 8H;GJ7@ ?>;W:D

1HUF@: TT ^8:9;A_ ?J;A? &@D #:BBM UHWH=U 7 ?>;W: A;@d?J;K >;

9;G79 A;V:=D


102/137

dd

&*2-'*54R #">*5*54 $59 +"22*54 ')" +'-7"+

Q04-. ,+. 3.A04404A (9 ,+06 =%(S.-,E jB` +#6 3..4 ,.6,04A C#%0($6 ,D=.6 (9 6,(C.6 ,(

904/ # 6(8$,0(4 ,( 90, ;0,+ 8(-#8 -((M04A :.,+(/6< jB` (%0A04#88D /06,%03$,./ (4. 6,(C.

:(/.8 W2&JA+Y ,( IT 9#:080.6< ]..M6 (9 ,.6,04A #6 ;.88 #6 .C#8$#,0(4 (9 $6.%6U -(::.4,6

+.8=./ jB` ,( %./.60A4 ,+. .%A(4(:0-6 (9 ,+. :(/.8 #4/ =%(/$-. # 4.;.% :(/.8 W2&J

"#P:0Y ,+#, 06 .#60.% ,( $6.< \R+06 +#6 3..4 #==%(C./ 3D $6.%6 3.-#$6. (9 0,6 8(;.% ;((/

-(46$:=,0(4E A%.#,.% .#6. (9 $6. #4/ +0A+.% [$#80,D 04 68(;J-((M04A :.,+(/6


103/137

HGG

,+. 6(08< L. .4-($%#A.6 04,.A%#,04A :#4D $6.6 04,( 30(-+#%E .6=.-0#88D ,%#/0,0(4#8 -+#%-(#8

$6.6 09 ,+.D #%. 6$6,#04#38.HJ d:M G;VVF=H>M V:V8:@? ^HD:D :7@9M 7B;K>:@?_ AH99

H=G@:7?: ;8?:@W78H9H>M ;< 8H;GJ7@ ?M?>:V 8:=:?D +JH? H=G@:7?:B ;8?:@W78H9H>M AH99

9:7B >; H=G@:7?:B 7B;K>H;= @7>: ;< >J: K@;]:G> >:GJ=;9;UH:?D

A+5"&

@%< 5.//D ,(8/ ,+. 6,(%D (9 3%04A04A 30(-+#% ,.-+4(8(AD ,( # -(::$40,D ,+#, ;#6

$49#:080#% ;0,+ $604A -+#%-(#8 #6 # 6(08 #:.4/:.4,< 5.//D ;#4,./ ,( :#M. ,+. %.6$8,6 (9

30(-+#% #==80-#,0(4 (36.%C#38. ,( ,+. -(::$40,D a +. M4.; 0, /(.64U, ;(%M ,( 60:=8D -(:.

04 #4/ ,.88 =.(=8. ,( /( 6(:.,+04A ,( ,+.0% 9#%:< L. 3$08, $= # %.8#,0(46+0= ;0,+ ,+%..

9#%:.%6 W.#%8D #/(=,.%6Y #4/ -(4C04-./ ,+.: ,( #==8D 30(-+#% ,( ,+.0% 90.8/6:@ [. %BBH>H;=79 -;=?HB:@7>H;=?


121/137

HHf

!FUU:?>H;=? H;=

R+.%. #%. :#4D ,+04A6 ,+#, -#4 3. 04,.A%#,./ 04,( 30(-+#% 6D6,.:6E #4/ #6 @%< 5.//D

4(,./E ,+. :(%. $6.6 ,+. -+#% +#6 3.9(%. 0, %.#-+.6 ,+. 6(08E ,+. :(%. C#8$. 0, +#6< ]+.4

04-(%=(%#,04A (,+.% .8.:.4,6 04,( # 30(-+#% 6D6,.:E 0, 06 0:=(%,#4, ,+#, ,+.%. 06 # 4../ 9(%

,+.6. .8.:.4,6 #4/ ,+#, ,+.D #%. -$8,$%#88D -(:=#,038.E (,+.%;06. ,+.0% /099$60(4 ;(4U, 3.

6$--.669$8E #4/ ,+.0% 04-8$60(4 -($8/ 4.A#,0C.8D #99.-, ,+. /099$60(4 (9 ,+. .4,0%. 30(-+#%

6D6,.:< `9,.4,0:.6E +(;.C.%E ,+. 04-(%=(%#,./ .8.:.4,6 (,+.% ,+#4 30(-+#% %.0D,+.

/099$60(4 (9 # 30(-+#% 6D6,.:< Q(:. .P#:=8.6 (9 ,.-+4(8(A0.6 #4/ 0/.#6 ,+#, -#4 3.

04-(%=(%#,./ 04,( 30(-+#% 6D6,.:6 #%. #6 9(88(;61

>0(-+#% -((M 6,(C.6 a 0:=%(C. 04/((% #0% [$#80,D #4/ +.#8,+E #:(4A (,+.% ,+04A6< j%..4 -+#%-(#8 3%0[$.,,.6 a 28.#4.%E -+.#=.%E :(%. 6$6,#04#38. ,+#4 ,%#/0,0(4#8 9$.8

04 :#4D =8#-.6< >0(-+#% $%04#86 a g6./ ,( 0:=%(C. 8(-#8 6#40,#,0(4r #$,(:#,0-#88D -+#%A.6 ,+.

30(-+#%0(-+#% ;#,.% 908,%#,0(4 a 2%.#,.6 #--.66 ,( -8.#4 ;#,.%< *D%(8D606 (9 04C#60C. =8#4, 30(:#66 ,( :#M. 30(-+#% a L.8=6 %.6,(%. 4#,0C.

.-(6D6,.:E =%(C0/.6 9../6,(-M< 74-(%=(%#,0(4 (9 30(-+#% 04,( 8(-#8 ,%#/0,0(46E %0,$#86E 9.6,0C#86E -$8,$%.6 .,-#,-+.6 -#4 #86( ,#M. #6 6+(%,

#6 (4. +($%< 79 D($ +#C. HT =.(=8. :#M. T 3#,-+.6 (9 30(-+#% 04 (4. /#DE D($ -#4 +#C. # ,(4

%0A+, ,+.%.< 79 (4. =.%6(4 :#M.6 (4. 3#,-+ =.% /#DE ,+.D -($8/ +#C. #8:(6, T ,(46 ;0,+04(4. D.#%< R"g@ (C.46 #%. %.#6(4#38D 6-#8#38. 3.-#$6. ,+.D #%. 6( -+.#= #4/ (=.%#,04A

,0:. 06 %.8#,0C.8D 6+(%,< R+.%. #%. #86( 4.;.%E 8#%A.% (C.4E %.,(%, #4/ +D3%0/ /.60A46 ,+#,

-#4 =%(/$-. 8#%A.% #:($4,6 (9 -+#% 04 (4. %$40(-+#% *%(/$-,0(4 g40,6


124/137

HFH

+#6M#%5.//DIHf

IHZ5(:0S4E &


125/137

HFF

Q$6,#04#3080,D 06 #4 04-%./038D 0:=(%,#4, 9#-,(% ,+#, :$6, 3. #//%.66./ 04 .C.%D

30(-+#% =%(S.-,< R+.%. #%. :#4D 6$3,(=0-6 ;0,+04 6$6,#04#3080,D ,+#, 4../ ,( 3. -(460/.%./

Documents

Spreading the Char- The Importance of Local Compatibility in The