State of implementation

2nd Steering Committee meeting, Belgrade 24 April 2012

PROMITHEAS – 4PROMITHEAS – 4

State of implementationState of implementation

Dr. Popi KONIDARI Dr. Popi KONIDARI

Assistant to the Project CoordinatorAssistant to the Project Coordinator

- 2 -

PROMITHEAS - 4PROMITHEAS - 4

StructureStructure

• Initial Work plan

• Policy portfolio development

• Research needs and gaps

• Knowledge transfer

• Dissemination (Socio-economic impact)

• Contingency actions

• Forthcoming activities

- 3 -


Work PlanWork Plan

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

Research needs and gaps

TrainingPreparation

DatabaseMapping

Overview

Seminar

Overview


SeminarTrainingPreparation

SelectionOverview

Overview



National

Overview

Management



WP1

WP2Scenario devel. Run models

WP3Evaluation

WP4

National workshops

Rep. WP5

Newsletter, Web-site, Ad hoc visits, Editions, Conference WP6WP7



Policy portfolios developmentPolicy portfolios developmentPolicy portfolios developmentPolicy portfolios development

Research needs and gapsResearch needs and gapsResearch needs and gapsResearch needs and gaps

Socio-economic impactSocio-economic impact

Knowledge transferKnowledge transferKnowlegde transferKnowlegde transfer

Socio-economic impactSocio-economic impact

Pol.Port.Pol.Port. Effect. Pol.Effect. Pol.

- 4 -


Policy portfolio developmentPolicy portfolio development

• 1st step: International level (Completed)Theoretical background, 5 reportsComments: Delays, quality-plagiarism

• 2nd step: National level (Delayed – Pending)Mapping national procedures, sources, available data and information

National M/A policy instruments Comments: Delays, no comments by SC, heterogeneity - format,

quality – references, content

• 3rd step: Portfolio development (Delayed) Models, database, scenariosComments: Delays, choice of model (unfamiliarity), quality of database, credibility of sources, reliability of data – units.

- 5 -


Actual Work Plan – Policy Portfolio DevelopmentActual Work Plan – Policy Portfolio Development

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

Database

Mapping

Overview

Overview

Selection

Overview

Overview

National

WP1

WP2

Scenario devel.

Run models

WP3

Evaluation WP4

Pol.Port.Pol.Port.

Effect. Pol.Effect. Pol.

National workshops WP6

5 months5 months

7 months7 months

6 months6 months

5 months5 months

3 months3 months

5 months5 months

5 months5 months

6 months6 months

2 months2 months

6 months6 months

- 6 -


Delays by partnerDelays by partner

Overview -1 Mapping Database Overview -2 Selection Overview - 3 National Scenario devel. Overview-4

NKUA-KEPA XX

NOA XX XX

IHS * XX XX X

TUBITAK MAM * X * *

SRIE - ESC X X

UB-FMG

IPE ASM X XX X X * XX XX *

AUT-LHTEE * * X XX

FA * XX XX * * * XX *

ISPE X XX XX

PUT X X

GPOGC XX * XX *

BSREC * *

ESEMI * * * XX XX

KAZHIMINVEST * XX XX * * * XX *

TUT XXXXXX - delay of work, - delay of work, X X – delayed comments, – delayed comments, * * - No comments- No comments

- 7 -


Knowledge transferKnowledge transfer

• 1st step: Preparation (Completed)Syllabus, timetable, material, instructors, traineesComments: Delays in preparation, low level responses

• 2nd step: Training 6 modules

Comments: High initial participation, plagiarism

• 3rd step: Seminar Case study

- 8 -


Actual Work Plan – Knowledge transferActual Work Plan – Knowledge transfer

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

TrainingPreparation

Database

Mapping

Overview

Seminar

Overview


Selection

Overview

Overview


National



WP1

WP2

Scenario devel.

WP3

WP4

Effect. Pol.Effect. Pol.

WP6

5 months5 months

7 months7 months

6 months6 months

5 months5 months

3 months3 months

5 months5 months5 months5 months

6 months6 months

5 months5 months

- 9 -


Delays by partnerDelays by partnerPreparation –

Syllabus, Time tablePreparation - Instructors

Preparation - Material

Preparation - Applications

Training

NKUA-KEPA XX XX

NOA X XX

IHS * XX

TUBITAK MAM * O

SRIE - ESC * O

UB-FMG *

IPE ASM * XX

AUT-LHTEE * XX

FA * XX O

ISPE *

PUT * XX

GPOGC * XX O

BSREC * Ο

ESEMI *

KAZHIMINVEST * Ο

TUT * XX

XXXX - delay of work, - delay of work, XX – delayed comments, – delayed comments, * * - No comments, - No comments, OO – No activity – No activity

- 10 -


Knowledge transfer procedure – 1Knowledge transfer procedure – 1stst step (3/3) step (3/3)Submitted

applicationsMod. 1 Mod. 2 Mod. 3 Mod. 4 Mod. 5 Mod. 6 Total

Albania 8 3 2 1 2 3 1 1

Armenia 4 1 0 0 1 0 1 0

Azerbaijan 7 0 0 0 0 0 1 0

Bulgaria 8 2 0 0 0 1 0 0Estonia 4 2 1 2 2 2 2 1

Kazakhstan 7 0 0 0 1 1 0 0

Moldova 6 3 2 1 2 3 2 1

Romania 9 4 3 4 4 5 6 3

Russia 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Serbia 4 3 2 2 3 3 3 2

Turkey 10 2 0 1 1 2 1 0

Ukraine 11 5 3 3 4 4 4 3

Total -1 82 25 13 14 20 24 21 11

Others 28 6 6 5 6 8 6 3

Total 110 33 19 19 23 32 27 14

Inadequate number of trainees - 60 registered,19 - 33 submit assignments

- 11 -


Research needs and gapsResearch needs and gaps

• 1st step: International level (Completed)Funding mechanisms, 1 reportComments: Delay

• 2nd step: National level (Delayed – Pending)

Funding mechanisms (12 contributions), data, models, national policies, policy portfolios, training, assessment, national workshops

Comments: Delay

- 12 -


Actual Work Plan – Research needs and gapsActual Work Plan – Research needs and gaps

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36


Database

Mapping



National

Overview


WP1

WP2Scenario devel.

WP3

Evaluation

WP4

Rep. WP5



Selection

WP6

7 months7 months

6 months6 months

3 months3 months

7 months7 months6 months6 months

5 months5 months

- 13 -


Delays by partnerDelays by partnerOverview Data Models National

policiesPolicy

portfolios

NKUA-KEPA XX

NOA XX

IHS * XX XX

TUBITAK MAM *

SRIE - ESC

UB-FMG

IPE ASM *

AUT-LHTEE

FA *

ISPE XX

PUT

GPOGC

BSREC XX XX XX XX XX

ESEMI

KAZHIMINVEST *

TUTXXXX - delay of work, - delay of work, X X – delayed comments, – delayed comments, ** - No comments - No comments

- 14 -


Dissemination (Socio-economic impact)Dissemination (Socio-economic impact)

• 1st step: International level Newsletter, Website, Ad hoc visits, Final ConferenceComments: BSEC-PERMIS, BSEC-BC, UN, UNAI, BSEC Ministerial Meetings (Sofia, Nafplion, Belgrade), cooperation with Lebanon and Georgia

• 2nd step: National level National Workshops

Comments: Low level of engagement, Workshop in Tirana (27/4/2011)

• 3rd step: Scientific level Special editions, Scientific papers Comments: Delay, additional work, ongoing efforts

- 15 -


Actual Work Plan - DisseminationActual Work Plan - Dissemination

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

National workshops

Newsletter, Web-site, Ad hoc visits, Editions, Conference WP6

- 16 -


Contingency actionsContingency actions

• Chain of activities for concluding with policy portfolios: Decision for unscheduled training – Vienna (5-8/9/2011)

• Decision to lead Task W.P.3.3 and linked tasks (Novem. 2011) – LEAP tree, outline of scenarios, content of database

• Decision to delay by one month e-class trainning• Decision about Modules 2, 3 and 5• Proposals for increased credibility and reliability of

database– Official letter from partners regarding unavailability of data –

Dissemination to relevant ministries– Full links for data sources– Full justification of any performed calculations

- 17 -


Forthcoming tasksForthcoming tasksNKUA - KEPANKUA - KEPA

• Finalization of policy portfolios (scenarios)• Running of LEAP model for 12 countries• Assessment• Seminar (organization – teaching)• Special editions• National Workshops• Final Conference• Interim and Final reports• Comments on reports

- 18 -


Forthcoming tasksForthcoming tasksNOANOA

• Finalization of 12 reports Mapping national procedures, sources, available data and information

• Finalization of datadase and manual• Finalization of D2 (Delayed - Pending)

• Teaching e-class and seminar• Contribution to research needs and gaps• Participation to Final Conference - 3rd Steering

Committee meeting• Commenting reports

- 19 -


Forthcoming tasksForthcoming tasksIHSIHS

• Teaching in e-class

• Participation to Final Conference -3rd Steering Committee meeting

- 20 -


Forthcoming tasksForthcoming tasksAUT - LHTEEAUT - LHTEE

• Teaching in e-class


• Commenting on reports

- 21 -


Forthcoming tasksForthcoming tasksBSRECBSREC

• Prepare report W.P.5.2

• Prepare D.6


• Commenting on reports

- 22 -


Forthcoming tasksForthcoming tasksTUBITAK MAM, SRIE – ESC, BSREC, IPE ASM, ISPE, FA, TUBITAK MAM, SRIE – ESC, BSREC, IPE ASM, ISPE, FA,

GPOGC, PUT, ESEMI, KAZIMINVEST, TUTGPOGC, PUT, ESEMI, KAZIMINVEST, TUT

• Modifications in report “Mapping national procedures, sources, available data and information”

• Participation in e-class, seminar• Assistance in finalization of scenarios• Parallel running of LEAP model• Engagement of stakeholders

– List of national stakeholders– Dissemination to them of material

• Organization of national workshop• Contribution to research needs and gaps • Participation to Final Conference - 3rd Steering Committee

meeting• Commenting reports

- 23 -


See you in Athens

- 24 -


Thank you

Contact point

Dr. Popi KONIDARITel.: 0030 72 75 830

E-mail: [email protected]

Documents

State of implementation