Upload
morgan-houston
View
214
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
Outcomes-Based Funding & the
Student Completion Agenda
Presented by:Jimmy Clarke, Ph.D.
& Martha Snyder
HCM Strategists, LLCDecember 7, 2015
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org 2
Supported by Lumina Foundation
Open platform for leaders and influencers in all 50 states to share research and data, encourage peer learning and professional experiences to advance Goal 2025.
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
State Policy Agenda
3
Create Smarter Pathways
Improve Student Outcomes
Align Investments
• Attainment and Equity Goals
• Strategic Plans• Data systems
• “Affordability”• Need-based financial
aid & design• Outcomes-based
funding
• Transfer policies• Accelerated programs• K-12 CCR alignment• Returning Adults
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
Objectives
• Introduce non-partisan research to a broad group of state stakeholders
• Improve awareness of data, the needs of the state, and policy options; and
• Build understanding to inform adoption, enhancement and sustainability of public policies that can help improve student outcomes.
4
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
Support and Resources Provided• Non-partisan, evidence-based policy expertise
– Writing, webinars, on-site support– Speakers and discussants at meetings
• Convening and Facilitation– Peer learning engagements in states to share lessons, challenges– Multi-state discussions to explore ideas with researchers and experts– Meeting preparation and facilitation (board meetings, workshops)
• Advising Policymakers– Non-partisan testimony– Individualized briefings
• Research– Original data collection and analysis– Written analysis of policy alternatives and alignment to research-
informed best practices– Translational research
5
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
ALIGNING INVESTMENTS TO SUPPORT STUDENT COMPLETION: OUTCOMES-BASED FUNDING
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
Policy Rationale for Performance Funding
7
Align funding method with state/system prioritiesCompletion/Attainment
Jobs/Economic Development
Align institution priorities Support Scaling of Proven Student Success
Practices
Programmatic Evaluation and Change
Improve Efficiency & Reward Outcomes
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
State Funding Models
8
• Allocation based on prior levels of funding• Adjusted +/- based on available funds• Goal: Institutional fiscal stability• Challenge: Equity in institutional funding
Historic
• # of students enrolled at census date• Recent shift to course completion• Goal: expand access• Challenge: Incentive on prolonged persistence/retention
Enrollment
• Reward for reaching performance milestones or goals• Completion not necessarily key objective• Often ‘bonus’ (new allocation) or small % of general allocation• Challenge: Sustainability and funding
Early Performance
• Funding based on student success and completion• Significant portion of general allocation to institutions (not
reliant on new money-only/separate allocation)• Challenge: College’s ability to respond
Outcome-Based
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
Outcomes-Based vs. Performance-Based Funding: What’s the Difference
• Performance Funding: Broad set of policies linking allocation of resources to accomplishment of certain desired goals. Historically:– Often add-ons or bonuses to institution core state funding or small amounts of
reallocated dollars;– Metrics: broad, contradicting, not tied to state’s completion or attainment goals
(e.g., increased access, diversity in faculty higher expenditures on research)– Design: One-size fits all, vague measures, target-oriented
• Outcomes-Based Funding: Evolved form of performance-based funding– More explicit connection to state needs
• Focus on student progress and completion• Closing gaps in student outcomes (at-risk students prioritized)• More money at stake; part of core allocation to institutions
– Refined development & modeling approaches: all institutions included with differentiation to reflect mission
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
Arkansas Goals & Finance Policies
Goals & Priorities• Support 2025 Goal of 60%
attainment– Increase number of postsecondary
credentials by 50%– Increase enrollment of adult
students– Raise attainment rate of
underserved students– Affordability/reduce time to degree
• Strategies– Course redesign (remedial &
gateway)– Guided pathways– Student service innovations
Current Funding Model• Primarily enrollment + cost based• Performance component based on
predetermined targets (punitive)• Disconnected from broader
attainment and completion priorities– Does not promote wide-scale
adoption of identified strategies– Limited focus on priority
populations (adult and underserved)
10
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
Design Principles for Outcomes-Based Funding
Begin with a state goal/clear policy priorities
Use a simple approach
All public institutions
included, reflect mission
Incent success of typically
underrepresented students
Make the money
meaningful
Seek Stakeholder
Input
Phase-in (≠ Hold
Harmless)
Include only measurable
metrics
Plan to evaluate
11
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
Common Measures
12
Type of Measures ExamplesStudent Progression and Momentum Intermediate outcomes/key milestones important to student’s progression toward completion
• Remedial education success• Completion of first college-level mathematics
and English courses• Credit accumulation (e.g. 15, 30 credit hours)
Completion & OutcomesPromote certificate, degree completion, transfer
• Number or rate of program completers• Number of transfers• Job Placement
Productivity & Institution MissionPromote efficiency, affordability and focusing dollars on core mission functions
• Degrees per 100 FTE• Research• Workforce Training
Priority Student categories and/or degree types that are a priority for the state to meet attainment and job needs. Student focus is on progression and completion, not just access.
• Adult students• Academically underprepared students• Low-income (Pell-eligible) students• Minority students• STEM-H degreesNote: often reflected by providing an extra weight to progression and completion metrics
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
FY 2015: Implementation of Performance/Outcomes-Based Funding Models
13
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
Outcomes/Performance-Based Funding as % of Institution Funding Support
* ND and WY formulas are based on course-completions only; no other measures such as degree completions, are used. Nevada’s formula is about 96 percent course completion, with approximately 3.8 percent distributed on degree completion and student progression measures.
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
Outcomes-Based Funding: Research & Impacts• Focused mostly on early performance funding
policies; beginning to track effect of more robust outcomes-based funding policies
• Research is almost entirely focused on intermediate (institutional change) impacts
• Limited information/ability to understand ultimate impact (scarce research)
15
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
Research and Impacts
⁺ Change in colleges’ awareness of state priorities & own performance
⁺ Reported increase in use of data in institutional planning• identify student barriers• align institution policies/investments
⁺ Academic program improvements• Academic departments: staffing and structure changes• Academic delivery: program structure (remedial education)
16
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
Research and Impacts
⁺ Student Services• Registration, graduation procedures, financial aid• First-year retention programs• Targeted student advising, tutoring and supplemental services• Job placement services
⁻ Concern over⁻ Quality⁻ Instability of funding ⁻ Uneven knowledge of performance funding across and within colleges
17
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
Considerations for Boards of Trustees in Outcomes-Based Funding Environment
• Focus on the Data– Student enrollment– Student progression – Student Completion– Disaggregated
• Support a culture of completion and success– Engage leadership on priorities– Evaluate all aspects of institutional operations– Help communicate support and engage all campus
stakeholders in conversation
18
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
StrategyLabs.LuminaFoundation.org
19