1
Platform: Protein Conformation 123-Plat Structure Refinement of Protein Low Resolution Models using GNEIMO Constrained Dynamics Method In-Hee Park 1 , Vamshi Gangupomu 1 , Jeffrey Wagner 1 , Abhinandan Jain 2 , Nagarajan Vaidehi 1 . 1 Beckman Research Institute of the City of Hope, Duarte, CA, USA, 2 Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA, USA. The challenge in protein structure prediction using homology modeling is the lack of reliable methods to refine the low resolution homology models. All- atom molecular dynamics (MD) does not serve well for structure refinement due to its limited conformational search. We have developed and tested the constrained MD method, based on the Generalized Newton-Euler Inverse Mass Operator (GNEIMO) algorithm for protein structure refinement. In this method the high frequency degrees of freedom are placed as hard holonomic constraints and a protein is modeled as a collection of rigid body clusters con- nected by flexible hinges that are torsions. This allows larger integration time step and enhances the conformational search space. In this work, we have dem- onstrated the use of GNEIMO method for protein structure refinement using no constraints, starting from low-resolution decoy set derived from homology methods. In the eight proteins with three decoys for each, we observed an improvement of ~2 A ˚ in the RMSD to the known experimental structures of these proteins. The GNEIMO method also showed enrichment in the popula- tion density of native-like conformations. In addition, we demonstrated struc- tural refinement using the ‘‘Freeze and Thaw’’ clustering scheme in the GNEIMO framework as a viable tool for enhancing localized conformational search. We have derived a robust protocol, based on the GNEIMO replica exchange method, for protein structure refinement that can be readily extended for other proteins and possibly used for high throughput protein structure refinement. 124-Plat Computing Entropies for Binding and Refinement of Protein Structures Michael T. Zimmermann, Robert L. Jernigan. Iowa State University, Ames, IA, USA. Entropy plays an important role in protein folding and binding, but is difficult to evaluate; consequently its contribution to free energy is often neglected or locally approximated. We propose a novel method for calculating the change in free energy upon binding using coarse-grained models of proteins by com- bining multi-body potentials with entropies calculated from elastic network models (ENMs). Multi-body energy potentials have been developed to account for the cooperativity in globular protein structures by an improved accounting of three dimensional interactions and residue packing. From ENM, mean square fluctuations (MSF) can be calculated using collective contributions from the entire structure. MSF are related to entropy because they represent the conformational states accessible in the native ensemble. Energies evaluated from coarse-grained multi-body potentials combined with MSF-based entro- pies improves selection of CASP9 targets, where each target has hundreds of decoys. Because the method shows improvement in decoy selection, we test its ability to identify native-like poses in protein-protein docking, showing pos- itive initial results. ClusPro was used to dock pairs of structures, resulting in 11-30 candidate poses for each pair. Our combined method chooses more native-like poses in nearly all cases. If some constraints about the residues in- volved in binding is provided to ClusPro, the most native-like pose is often identified. For a more rigorous test, we generate 2000 poses for select structure pairs using Zdock again showing significantly better discrimination compared to results using energy alone. Accounting for the entropic contributions from the entire structure represents an important step forward in protein structure evaluation. 125-Plat ANM Normal Modes Show the Directions for Protein Structure Refinement Pawel Gniewek 1 , Andrzej Kolinski 2 , Robert L. Jernigan 3 , Andrzej Kloczkowski 1 . 1 The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, USA, 2 University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland, 3 Iowa State University, Ames, IA, USA. It is well recognized that thermal motions of atoms in the protein native state, which correspond to fluctuations about the minimum of the global free energy, are well reproduced by simple Elastic Network Models (ENMs) such as Aniso- tropic Network Model (ANM). Elastic Network Models are based on the as- sumption that all nodes of the network (usually represented, according to the level of coarse graining of the model, by all heavy atoms or by C-alpha atoms only) that are sufficiently close together, based on a predefined cutoff distance, are connected by harmonic or more sophisticated springs. These models pro- vide reliable representation of the fluctuational dynamics of proteins, and indi- cate the range of various conformational changes in protein structure, e.g. upon ligand binding. the present paper we analyze the problem of protein structure refinement by using thermal motions of proteins in nonnative states. We repre- sent the conformational space close to the native state by a set of decoys generated by the I-TASSER protein structure prediction server utilizing template-free modeling. The protein sub-states were represented by decoys se- lected from the sets generated by I-TASSER by structure clustering. Based on such selected representatives some dynamical features of nonnative protein states were analyzed in detail and compared. The main finding is that for some of such substates space spanned by their thermal motions overlap signif- icantly with deformation needed to obtain the native state. These findings are used to evaluate their possible applications for protein tertiary structure predic- tion from amino acid sequence and for structure refinement of low resolution models. 126-Plat Structure-Based Design of Circularly Permutated and Frame-Shifted Photoactive Yellow Proteins Andrew Woolley, Anil Kumar, Sameer Al-Abdul-Wahid. University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada. Photoswitchable proteins are powerful tools for external manipulation and probing of complex biochemical processes. In an effort to create new families of photoswitchable proteins that undergo novel types of conformational changes, we designed a circularly permutated PYP (c-PYP) and frame- shifted PYP (fs-c-PYP) variants of photoactive yellow protein (wt-PYP), a rel- atively small blue-light sensitive protein from Halorhodospira halophila that contains a photoactive 4-hydroxycinnamic acid chromophore. The c-PYP was created by connecting the N- and C-terminal of wt-PYP with a defined linker polypeptides and introducing new N- and C-termini at G115 and S114 respectively. A fs-c-PYP was created by duplication of a beta-sheet segment in c-PYP so that it can form an alternate H-bond registry with an existing beta-sheet. The designed proteins c-PYP and fs-c-PYP are highly soluble and well folded when overexpressed in E. coli, each undergoes PYP-like photo- cycle upon exposure to blue light. The thermal relaxation of the protein to the dark-adapted state after removal of the blue light source varies considerably between the designed constructs. UV-Vis absorption data indicate that fs-c- PYP recovers much more slowly than wt-PYP whereas c-PYP recovers more quickly than wt-PYP. Fluorescence-monitored GdnMHCl denaturation experi- ments show fs-c-PYP is the least stable and wt-PYP the most stable dark-state structure, while folding/unfolding of both c-PYP and fs-c-PYP is more cooper- ative than wt-PYP. This work shows that new classes of photo-controlled conformational change can be created by altering the backbone topology of known photoswitchable proteins. 127-Plat Design Strategy for High Free-Energy States of Proteins Based on High- Pressure NMR Study: Alternatively Folded Conformation of Ubiquitin Ryo Kitahara 1 , Soichiro Kitazawa 1 , Maho Yagi-Utsumi 2,3 , Akemi Ido 4 , Makoto Urushitani 4 , Kenji Sugase 5 , Koichi Kato 2,3 . 1 Ritsumeikan University, Kusatsu, Shiga, Japan, 2 Okazaki Institute for Integrative Bioscience, Okazaki, Aichi, Japan, 3 Nagoya City University, Nagoya, Aichi, Japan, 4 Shiga University of Medical Science, Otsu, Shiga, Japan, 5 Suntory Foundation for Life Sciences, Osaka, Japan. We demonstrate a rational design for the high Gibbs-free energy conformer N2 of ubiquitin based on the solution structure of the N2 state of the wild- type protein, previously characterized by high pressure NMR spectroscopy. Using a single amino acid replacement method, we created the ubiquitin mu- tant that would favor the population of N2 conformer. Structure, dynamics and stability of the N2 state are characterized by 1H, 15N, 13C chemical shifts, 15N-spin relaxation (1H 600-950 MHz), water-amide proton exchange (CLEANEX-PM) and residual dipolar coupling experiments. All the NMR in- vestigations indicate that the ubiquitin mutant represents an open conformer suitable for enzyme recognition similar to that observed for the N2 state of the wild type protein, namely swinging out of the a-helix region with a simul- taneous reorientation of the C-terminal segment. Examinations of functional activities for the mutant protein indicate that the mutant retains abilities of the polyubiqutination through the E1-E2-E3 cascade reactions and association with the ubiquitin interacting motif UIM. Investigation of the mutant protein of ubiquitin, which is the first model of a stable high-energy state of the pro- tein N2, is useful for further structural and functional studies of ubiquitin and ubiquitin-related systems. Sunday, February 26, 2012 25a

Structure Refinement of Protein Low Resolution Models using GNEIMO Constrained Dynamics Method

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Structure Refinement of Protein Low Resolution Models using GNEIMO Constrained Dynamics Method

Sunday, February 26, 2012 25a

Platform: Protein Conformation

123-PlatStructure Refinement of Protein Low Resolution Models using GNEIMOConstrained Dynamics MethodIn-Hee Park1, Vamshi Gangupomu1, Jeffrey Wagner1, Abhinandan Jain2,Nagarajan Vaidehi1.1Beckman Research Institute of the City of Hope, Duarte, CA, USA,2Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology,Pasadena, CA, USA.The challenge in protein structure prediction using homology modeling is thelack of reliable methods to refine the low resolution homology models. All-atom molecular dynamics (MD) does not serve well for structure refinementdue to its limited conformational search. We have developed and tested theconstrained MD method, based on the Generalized Newton-Euler InverseMass Operator (GNEIMO) algorithm for protein structure refinement. In thismethod the high frequency degrees of freedom are placed as hard holonomicconstraints and a protein is modeled as a collection of rigid body clusters con-nected by flexible hinges that are torsions. This allows larger integration timestep and enhances the conformational search space. In this work, we have dem-onstrated the use of GNEIMOmethod for protein structure refinement using noconstraints, starting from low-resolution decoy set derived from homologymethods. In the eight proteins with three decoys for each, we observed animprovement of ~2 A in the RMSD to the known experimental structures ofthese proteins. The GNEIMO method also showed enrichment in the popula-tion density of native-like conformations. In addition, we demonstrated struc-tural refinement using the ‘‘Freeze and Thaw’’ clustering scheme in theGNEIMO framework as a viable tool for enhancing localized conformationalsearch. We have derived a robust protocol, based on the GNEIMO replicaexchange method, for protein structure refinement that can be readily extendedfor other proteins and possibly used for high throughput protein structurerefinement.

124-PlatComputing Entropies for Binding and Refinement of Protein StructuresMichael T. Zimmermann, Robert L. Jernigan.Iowa State University, Ames, IA, USA.Entropy plays an important role in protein folding and binding, but is difficultto evaluate; consequently its contribution to free energy is often neglected orlocally approximated. We propose a novel method for calculating the changein free energy upon binding using coarse-grained models of proteins by com-bining multi-body potentials with entropies calculated from elastic networkmodels (ENMs). Multi-body energy potentials have been developed to accountfor the cooperativity in globular protein structures by an improved accountingof three dimensional interactions and residue packing. From ENM, meansquare fluctuations (MSF) can be calculated using collective contributionsfrom the entire structure. MSF are related to entropy because they representthe conformational states accessible in the native ensemble. Energies evaluatedfrom coarse-grained multi-body potentials combined with MSF-based entro-pies improves selection of CASP9 targets, where each target has hundreds ofdecoys. Because the method shows improvement in decoy selection, we testits ability to identify native-like poses in protein-protein docking, showing pos-itive initial results. ClusPro was used to dock pairs of structures, resulting in11-30 candidate poses for each pair. Our combined method chooses morenative-like poses in nearly all cases. If some constraints about the residues in-volved in binding is provided to ClusPro, the most native-like pose is oftenidentified. For a more rigorous test, we generate 2000 poses for select structurepairs using Zdock again showing significantly better discrimination comparedto results using energy alone. Accounting for the entropic contributions fromthe entire structure represents an important step forward in protein structureevaluation.

125-PlatANMNormalModes Show theDirections for Protein StructureRefinementPawel Gniewek1, Andrzej Kolinski2, Robert L. Jernigan3,Andrzej Kloczkowski1.1The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, USA, 2University of Warsaw,Warsaw, Poland, 3Iowa State University, Ames, IA, USA.It is well recognized that thermal motions of atoms in the protein native state,which correspond to fluctuations about the minimum of the global free energy,are well reproduced by simple Elastic Network Models (ENMs) such as Aniso-tropic Network Model (ANM). Elastic Network Models are based on the as-sumption that all nodes of the network (usually represented, according to thelevel of coarse graining of the model, by all heavy atoms or by C-alpha atoms

only) that are sufficiently close together, based on a predefined cutoff distance,are connected by harmonic or more sophisticated springs. These models pro-vide reliable representation of the fluctuational dynamics of proteins, and indi-cate the range of various conformational changes in protein structure, e.g. uponligand binding. the present paper we analyze the problem of protein structurerefinement by using thermal motions of proteins in nonnative states. We repre-sent the conformational space close to the native state by a set of decoysgenerated by the I-TASSER protein structure prediction server utilizingtemplate-free modeling. The protein sub-states were represented by decoys se-lected from the sets generated by I-TASSER by structure clustering. Based onsuch selected representatives some dynamical features of nonnative proteinstates were analyzed in detail and compared. The main finding is that forsome of such substates space spanned by their thermal motions overlap signif-icantly with deformation needed to obtain the native state. These findings areused to evaluate their possible applications for protein tertiary structure predic-tion from amino acid sequence and for structure refinement of low resolutionmodels.

126-PlatStructure-Based Design of Circularly Permutated and Frame-ShiftedPhotoactive Yellow ProteinsAndrew Woolley, Anil Kumar, Sameer Al-Abdul-Wahid.University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.Photoswitchable proteins are powerful tools for external manipulation andprobing of complex biochemical processes. In an effort to create new familiesof photoswitchable proteins that undergo novel types of conformationalchanges, we designed a circularly permutated PYP (c-PYP) and frame-shifted PYP (fs-c-PYP) variants of photoactive yellow protein (wt-PYP), a rel-atively small blue-light sensitive protein from Halorhodospira halophila thatcontains a photoactive 4-hydroxycinnamic acid chromophore. The c-PYPwas created by connecting the N- and C-terminal of wt-PYP with a definedlinker polypeptides and introducing new N- and C-termini at G115 and S114respectively. A fs-c-PYP was created by duplication of a beta-sheet segmentin c-PYP so that it can form an alternate H-bond registry with an existingbeta-sheet. The designed proteins c-PYP and fs-c-PYP are highly soluble andwell folded when overexpressed in E. coli, each undergoes PYP-like photo-cycle upon exposure to blue light. The thermal relaxation of the protein tothe dark-adapted state after removal of the blue light source varies considerablybetween the designed constructs. UV-Vis absorption data indicate that fs-c-PYP recovers much more slowly than wt-PYP whereas c-PYP recovers morequickly than wt-PYP. Fluorescence-monitored GdnMHCl denaturation experi-ments show fs-c-PYP is the least stable and wt-PYP the most stable dark-statestructure, while folding/unfolding of both c-PYP and fs-c-PYP is more cooper-ative than wt-PYP. This work shows that new classes of photo-controlledconformational change can be created by altering the backbone topology ofknown photoswitchable proteins.

127-PlatDesign Strategy for High Free-Energy States of Proteins Based on High-Pressure NMR Study: Alternatively Folded Conformation of UbiquitinRyo Kitahara1, Soichiro Kitazawa1, Maho Yagi-Utsumi2,3, Akemi Ido4,Makoto Urushitani4, Kenji Sugase5, Koichi Kato2,3.1Ritsumeikan University, Kusatsu, Shiga, Japan, 2Okazaki Institute forIntegrative Bioscience, Okazaki, Aichi, Japan, 3Nagoya City University,Nagoya, Aichi, Japan, 4Shiga University of Medical Science, Otsu,Shiga, Japan, 5Suntory Foundation for Life Sciences, Osaka, Japan.We demonstrate a rational design for the high Gibbs-free energy conformerN2 of ubiquitin based on the solution structure of the N2 state of the wild-type protein, previously characterized by high pressure NMR spectroscopy.Using a single amino acid replacement method, we created the ubiquitin mu-tant that would favor the population of N2 conformer. Structure, dynamicsand stability of the N2 state are characterized by 1H, 15N, 13C chemicalshifts, 15N-spin relaxation (1H 600-950 MHz), water-amide proton exchange(CLEANEX-PM) and residual dipolar coupling experiments. All the NMR in-vestigations indicate that the ubiquitin mutant represents an open conformersuitable for enzyme recognition similar to that observed for the N2 state ofthe wild type protein, namely swinging out of the a-helix region with a simul-taneous reorientation of the C-terminal segment. Examinations of functionalactivities for the mutant protein indicate that the mutant retains abilities ofthe polyubiqutination through the E1-E2-E3 cascade reactions and associationwith the ubiquitin interacting motif UIM. Investigation of the mutant proteinof ubiquitin, which is the first model of a stable high-energy state of the pro-tein N2, is useful for further structural and functional studies of ubiquitin andubiquitin-related systems.