Students’ Perceptions of Classroom Activities: Are _Gab · Students’ Perceptions of Classroom Activities:…

  • Published on
    05-Jun-2018

  • View
    212

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Transcript

  • Students Perceptions of Classroom Activities:Are There Grade-Level and Gender Differences?

    Marcia GentryMinnesota State University, Mankato

    Robert K. GableUniversity of Connecticut

    Mary G. RizzaBall State University

    The authors investigated whether differences existed in perceptions of class activities for students inGrades 38 and between genders. Specifically, the frequency that students perceived opportunities forinterest, challenge, choice, and enjoyment in their classrooms was assessed using the affective instru-ment, My Class Activities (M. Gentry & R. K. Gable, 2001). Significant main effects existed for gradelevel and gender, with no interaction of the 2 variables. In general, middle school students found theirclassroom activities less frequently interesting and enjoyable, with fewer opportunities for choice, thandid elementary students. These variables declined steadily from lower to upper grades. Girls indicatedthat their class activities were more frequently interesting and enjoyable than did boys, which contributedto the significant gender differences.

    There has been tremendous interest in student motivation, spe-cifically concerning changes in motivation, as students progressfrom elementary school to middle school. Well documented are thechallenges related to educating adolescents, which must take intoaccount the developmental needs for this age group. Adolescentachievement and motivation can be highly influenced by peergroup, self-esteem, and self-image (E. M. Anderman & Maehr,1994; Eccles & Midgley, 1989; Hootstein, 1994). Further, thereare often negative changes in achievement, attitude, motivation,and behavior as students progress from elementary to middlegrades, with such changes influenced by classroom environments,peer groups, and teachers (Eccles et al., 1989; Feldlaufer, Midgley,& Eccles, 1989; McKenna, Kear, & Ellsworth, 1995; Midgley,Anderman, & Hicks, 1995; Roeser & Eccles, 1998; Wigfield &Eccles, 1994). Eccles, Wigfield, Midgley, and Reuman (1993)found that middle school students viewed their teachers as morecontrolling and allowed fewer student decision-making opportu-nities. Efficacy levels and motivation decreased for these studentsas they progressed through middle school. L. H. Anderman andMidgley (1997) contended that teachers hold great influence overthe students they encounter each day and the classroom environ-ment plays a significant role in the attitudes adopted by students inmiddle school.

    Gender differences among children and adolescents have beenfrequently studied, with girls often reported as typically moremotivated than boys (e.g., Burke, 1989; McKenna, Kear, & Ells-worth, 1995; Sadker & Sadker, 1994). There is a wide array ofliterature that describes the differences between boys and girls ona variety of variables including achievement, attitude, locus ofcontrol, and self-concept. Burke (1989) found that there weregeneral differences in academic performances between boys andgirls but suggested more research is needed to understand thereasons for these differences. Some researchers have suggestedachievement differences are due to differences in self-esteem(Allgood-Merten & Stockard, 1991; Orenstein, 1994), whereasothers believe locus of control is a primary reason (Boss & Taylor,1989; Mullis & McKinley, 1989). The different manner in whichboys and girls experience school has been suggested as perpetu-ating differences in achievement (Brutsaert & Bracke, 1994;Grossman & Grossman, 1994). Some have argued that schools areinherently unfair to girls, and differences in motivation andachievement are the result of differences in the opportunities andexperiences afforded to each group and not to innate gendercharacteristics (American Association of University Women,1992, 1999; Sadker & Sadker, 1994).

    The apparent decline in motivation and the differences inachievement, perception, and attitudes between genders from ele-mentary to middle school are complex and multifaceted issues thatwarrant continued investigation. Considering previous work inthese areas, we thought it was reasonable to expect differences toexist in this investigation in which an affective instrument, MyClass Activities (Gentry & Gable, 2001), was administered to anational sample of students in Grades 38. This instrument wasused to assess student perceptions of interest, challenge, choice,and enjoymentdimensions clearly tied in the literature to both

    Marcia Gentry, Department of Educational Studies: Special Populations,Minnesota State University, Mankato; Robert K. Gable, Department ofEducational Psychology, University of Connecticut; Mary G. Rizza, De-partment of Educational Psychology, Ball State University.

    Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to MarciaGentry, 25755 Zachary Avenue, Elko, Minnesota 55020. E-mail:marcia.gentry@pressenter.com

    Journal of Educational Psychology Copyright 2002 by the American Psychological Association, Inc.2002, Vol. 94, No. 3, 539544 0022-0663/02/$5.00 DOI: 10.1037//0022-0663.94.3.539

    539

  • motivation and learning (e.g., Ames, 1992; Csikszentmihalyi,1990; Deci & Ryan, 1985; Schiefele, 1991; Vygotsky, 1962). Bystudying schools and classrooms from the perspectives of thestudents, researches can gain insight concerning how students viewtheir classroom activities, instruction, and curriculum, and theseviews can be considered when working toward improving achieve-ment and motivation and, ultimately, schools. Evaluation of class-room activities from the students perspectives is infrequentlyconsidered in educational research, school-improvement efforts,and evaluation. Such information, as presented in this research, canoffer insights into both grade-level and gender differences byhighlighting differences in student perceptions as they progressfrom elementary school to middle school as well as differences ateach grade between boys and girls. This information can helpeducators and researchers better understand what students perceiveand therefore design instructional and motivational interventions.

    Method

    The objectives of the present study were twofold. The first was toinvestigate whether student perceptions of their class activities were dif-ferent for students in Grades 38. Specifically, the frequency studentsperceived that they were offered opportunities for interest, challenge,choice, and enjoyment in their classrooms was assessed and then compar-isons were made among grade levels. Second, comparisons of studentattitudes in each grade level were made to examine gender differences.

    Participants

    The researchers used school districts collaborating with the NationalResearch Center on the Gifted and Talented (NRC/GT) at the University ofConnecticut. The advantages of using these schools were many: They havevolunteered to cooperate with the NRC/GT in data gathering efforts, theirdemographics are on file, they exist in every state, and they represent everyform of school district including rural and urban. Schools included in thestudy were purposively selected to help ensure a nationally representativesample of diverse students from various regions and communities. TheGrade 38 sample (n 3,744) included 163 classrooms from 24 schools(16 elementary schools and 8 middle schools) in 7 states (i.e., Connecticut,Colorado, Michigan, Minnesota, New York, Ohio, and Virginia) from theeastern, northeast, midwest and western United States. Approximately onethird of the students attended rural, suburban, and urban schools. Theseschools represented a variety of socioeconomic communities, includingurban (n 4) and rural schools (n 6) that were Title 1 schools where the

    majority of students received free lunches, more affluent suburban sites(n 7), and schools in communities of average income (n 8). Seventy-six percent of the students were Caucasian, 10% were African American,10% were Asian American, and 3% were Hispanic American (1% wereother). Forty-nine percent of the sample was female.

    Instrumentation

    The My Class Activities instrument contains 31 statements assessingfour dimensions (interest, challenge, choice, and enjoyment), using a5-point Likert-type response format (never, seldom, sometimes, often,always). In the initial development of this instrument, we investigated itemcontent validity evidence through an extensive review of the literature andthen wrote items to address the constructs. These items were submittedto 16 content experts who were asked to assign them to respective cate-gories and then indicate how confident they were with these assignments.On the basis of this judgmental feedback, items were selected for a pilotinstrument (Gentry, Maxfield, & Gable, 1998). After study of the pilotinstrument, we made revisions, and a confirmatory study was undertakenfor a national sample described in the following section. Validity evidencefor construct interpretation was investigated through confirmatory factoranalysis. A goodness of fit index of .95 and a root mean square residual of.04 were judged supportive of model fit. Item response theory was used toexamine the adequacy of the definition of each construct including howwell the 5-point frequency response scale worked for the items and re-spondents. Respondents used the entire response continuum, and the meanlogit fit statistics for all dimensions increased with each higher responsecategory (Gentry & Gable, 2001). The Appendix contains the items in theinstrument that together measure each construct.

    Figure 1. Interest Gender Means Grade Level. Responses ranged from 1 (never) to 5 (always).

    Table 1Alpha Reliability Internal Consistency Estimates by Grade Level

    Grade Interest Challenge Choice Enjoyment

    3 .72 .60 .59 .864 .80 .61 .63 .895 .77 .66 .70 .876 .86 .79 .76 .927 .89 .75 .73 .928 .89 .74 .73 .91

    Total sample .84 .70 .69 .91

    540 GENTRY, GABLE, AND RIZZA

  • Design and Procedure

    Data collection. To ensure uniformity in the administration of theinstrument, school contact persons followed the same set of directions andadministered the instrument in classrooms, resulting in a 100% return ratefor all students present during the administration. By using contact persons,who informed students that their teachers would not see their responses,students were more likely to answer honestly than if their teachers hadadministered the instrument. Student demographics were collected fromclassroom teachers and included gender, ethnicity, special programming,and achievement levels.

    Data analyses. Descriptive statistics, alpha reliability indices, and atwo-way multivariate analyses of variance (MANOVA; Grade Level Gender for the set of variables: interest, challenge, choice, and enjoyment)were generated using SPSS software (SPSS, 2000).

    Results and Conclusions

    Total sample alpha reliability estimates for the four dimensionswere as follows: interest, .84; challenge, .70; choice, .69; enjoy-ment, .91. Individual ranges for Grades 38 were as follows:interest, .72.89; challenge, .60.83; choice, .59.78; and enjoy-ment, .86.92. No gender differences existed on the reliabilityestimates for the sample. The internal consistency reliability co-efficients for each grade level of students from the sample are inTable 1.

    There were significant differences for the two-way MANOVAmain effects of grade level, F(20, 12322) 26.64, p .001, andgender, F(4, 3715) 20.55, p .001, with no significant inter-

    action of grade level and gender. Because a large sample can moreeasily yield statistical significance, effect sizes for these resultswere examined by subtracting Wilkss lambda from 1.0 to deter-mine R2 (Cohen, 1988; Tabachink & Fidell, 1996). Although thegrade level differences were associated with a medium effect size(R2 .14), the gender differences were at best a small effect size(R2 .02; Cohen, 1988).

    We conducted univariate (Scheffe) follow-up analyses to ex-plain the main effect for grade level. In general, students in Grades68 found that their classroom activities were less frequentlyinteresting and enjoyable, with fewer opportunities for choice thandid students in Grades 35. There was a steady decline on thesevariables from lower to upper grades (see Figures 1, 2, and 3).Means and standard deviations for each dimension by gender andgrade level are contained in Table 2. There are fewer variationsreported by students in different grade levels concerning the fre-quency that they perceived their class activities as challenging,with grade level means consistently near 3.50 or between some-times and often challenging (see Figure 4).

    Student interest, choice, and enjoyment decreased as grade levelincreased consistent with other outcomes in early adolescentsattitudes when they enter and progress through the middle school(Eccles et al., 1989; Feldlaufer, Midgley, & Eccles, 1989; Midg-ley, Anderman, & Hicks, 1995). It is important to note thatalthough the literature suggests offering a wide variety of choices,the 1,524 middle school students in this study indicated they

    Figure 2. Enjoyment Gender Means Grade Level. Responses ranged from 1 (never) to 5 (always).

    Figure 3. Choice Gender Means Grade Level. Responses ranged from 1 (never) to 5 (always).

    541CLASS ACTIVITIES: GRADE LEVEL GENDER

  • perceived significantly less choice than their 2,220 elementaryschool counterparts.

    Although the effect size for gender differences was small, mul-tiple regression was used for each grade to examine which of theinterest, challenge, choice, and enjoyment variables contributed tothe gender differences. Significant contributors to the gender dif-ference were as follows: Grade 3enjoyment, .19, p .0001; Grade 4interest, .12, p .05; Grade 5enjoyment, .18, p .01; Grade 6no variables were significant; Grade7enjoyment, .17, p .01; Grade 8enjoyment, .23,p .001. In all of these cases, across grade levels, female studentsconsistently perceived their classroom activities to be frequentlymore enjoyable than did the male students.

    Implications

    Student views and perceptions are important areas to considerwhen designing effective educational experiences. In schoolreform efforts, emphasis is often placed on achievement mea-sures, whereas student attitude also plays a large role in schoolsuccess. We have provided student insights concerning theirviews of their class activities regarding affective areas tied tolearning. Findings of grade level and gender differences in theseareas add valuable data to consider when developing studentprograms. Middle grade educators should take note of these

    findings and investigate whether increasing opportunities forand emphasis on interest, choice, and enjoyment would increasestudent motivation and satisfaction with their class activities.Incorporating more interest, choice, and enjoyment in curricularand instructional planning especially at the middle school levelmight serve to increase satisfaction with school, motivation,and, in turn, achievement. Additional attention might be paidto the overall and consistently lower scores of boys than girlsin...