Upload
ben-ross
View
227
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
1/57
>
Nufhbnjk Uacdojnb Yuebdf [rnjsport Ybnj7
Manrdjcs Ynjab Uaport
Fojtajts
Djtrokuftdoj *************************************************************************************************************************** ;
Enfhcroujk *************************************************************************************************************************** ;
Vdcjdldfnjt raspojsa tma`as ************************************************************************************************* 1
Vtrojc support lor tma jaw jatworh struftura ***************************************************************** 1
Fojfarjs neout mow wabb tma fojjaftdojs wdbb worh ******************************************************* 9
Otmar hay tma`as ********************************************************************************************************* >9Fmnptarspafdldf dssuas njk rafo``ajkntdojs ******************************************************************* >5
Axafutdva Vu``nry ********************************************************************************************************* >5
Fmnptar >7 Djtrokuftdoj *************************************************************************************************** >5
[d`djc rabntdva to tma Bnjk [rnjsport @njnca`ajt N`ajk`ajt Edbb **************************** >5
Vfopa ol tma Ybnj ********************************************************************************************************* >;
Fmnptar 57 Vtrntacdf Fojtaxt ******************************************************************************************* >;
Vtntutory raqudra`ajts ************************************************************************************************* >;
Hay strntacdf krdvars **************************************************************************************************** >;
Otmar pbnjs njk strntacdas ******************************************************************************************* >1
Yuebdf trnjsport lujkdjc*************************************************************************************************** >1
Fmnptar 67 Our Furrajt Yuebdf [rnjsport Vysta` *********************************************************** >
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
2/57
5
Larry sarvdfas ************************************************************************************************************** >4
Otmar `okas **************************************************************************************************************** 59
Djtacrntdoj wdtm wnbhdjc njk fyfbdjc ***************************************************************************** 59
Varvdfa fntacordas ******************************************************************************************************* 5>
Uasourfa nbbofntdoj ***************************************************************************************************** 55
Jatworh lofus oj FEK ************************************************************************************************* 55
Axtajsdojs to tma rnpdk njk lraquajt jatworh ************************************************************** 56
Fojfarjs wdtm tma jatworh fojfapt****************************************************************************** 56
Fmnptar
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
3/57
6
Fusto`ar lnfdbdtdas ******************************************************************************************************** ;>
Eus prdordtdas **************************************************************************************************************** ;5
Ynrh njk rdka *************************************************************************************************************** ;6
Djtacrntdoj ol wnbhdjc /fyfbdjc wdtm puebdf trnjsport ****************************************************** ;;
Djtacrntdoj wdtm pnrhdjc ************************************************************************************************ ;1
Fusto`ar djtarlnfa pobdfdas -Vaftdoj
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
4/57
;
Djtrokuftdoj
[mds raport prasajts tma rafo``ajkntdojs ol tma Manrdjcs Ynjab astnebdsmak ey Nufhbnjk
[rnjsport to fojsdkar puebdf sue`dssdojs oj tma Krnlt Uacdojnb Yuebdf [rnjsport Ybnj
-UY[Y$* N totnb ol 3>4 sue`dssdojs wara rafadvak" njk 4= sue`dttars nppanrak ealora tmaYnjab nt puebdf manrdjcs*
[ma raport prasajts n su``nry ol tma hay dssuas rndsak dj sue`dssdojs" njk mdcmbdcmts tma
fmnjcas tmnt tma Ynjab rafo``ajks dj raspojsa to tma `nttars rndsak*
Enfhcroujk
[ma Krnlt UY[Y wns dssuak lor puebdf fo``ajt oj 1 Oftoear 59>5" njk puebdf sue`dssdojs
fbosak oj 1 Jova`ear 59>5* Vue`dssdojs lro` bofnb eonrks wara nffaptak up ujtdb 69
Jova`ear 59>5" to ajneba tma Eonrks to fojsdkar tma Ybnj ns pnrt ol tmadr `ojtmby `aatdjc
fyfbas*
N totnb ol 3>4 wrdttaj sue`dssdojs wara rafadvak" 1 lro` djkdvdkunbs njk >9; lro`
orcnjdsntdojs* [neba > prasajts nj njnbysds ol sue`dttar typa* Fopdas ol tma wrdttaj
sue`dssdojs lro` nbb sue`dttars nra nvndbneba oj tma Nufhbnjk [rnjsport waesdta*
[neba >7 Vue`dssdojs rafadvak ey sue`dttar typa
Djkdvdkunb7 cajarnb 654
Djkdvdkunb7 [unhnu> 5=
Otmar Foujfdb ln`dby ;
Hay trnjsport stnhamobkars 3
Yuebdf trnjsport oparntors ;
[rnjsport saftor orcnjdsntdojs =
Otmar saftor orcnjdsntdojs >3
Fo``ujdty croups , rasdkajt nssofdntdojs >5
Bofnb eusdjass nssofdntdojs >>
Yrolassdojnb eokdas/fojsubtnjts 1
@ngor kastdjntdoj orcnjdsntdojs =
Otmar fo`pnjdas 3
[otnb 3>4
[ma Nufhbnjk [rnjsport Eonrk astnebdsmak n Manrdjcs Ynjab wmdfm fojkuftak puebdf
manrdjcs oj tma sue`dssdojs ovar ldva knys eatwaaj 54 Gnjunry njk 3 Laerunry 59>6* [ma
>Nb`ost mnbl ol tma sue`dssdojs rafadvak lro` djkdvdkunbs wara n prolor`n sue`dssdoj rabntak spafdldfnbby to
sarvdfas to [unhnu" njk wara tmasa mnva eaaj su``nrdsak ns djkdvdkunb7 [unhnu dj tma [neba*
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
5/57
1
Ynjab djfbukak Fr @dha Baa -Fmndr$" Ynub Bofhay" Yatar Fbnrh -Cajarnb @njncar" Vtrntacy
njk Ybnjjdjc$" njk @nrh Bn`eart -@njncar" Yuebdf [rnjsport Oparntdojs$*
Olldfars ravdawak anfm ol tma sue`dssdojs njk prapnrak n pramanrdjcs raport tmnt
su``nrdsak tma hay sue`dssdoj podjts" prasajtak olldfar kdsfussdoj ol tma podjts rndsak"
njk n sat ol rafo``ajkntdojs lor tma Ynjab to fojsdkar* Fopdas ol tma pramanrdjcs raportwara `nka nvndbneba to nbb sue`dttars dj nkvnjfa ol tma manrdjcs* Dj bdja wdtm tma
raqudra`ajts ol tma Bofnb Covarj`ajt Olldfdnb Djlor`ntdoj njk @aatdjcs Nft" tma manrdjcs
wara opaj to tma puebdf*
[ma `djutas ol tma Manrdjcs Ynjab" djfbukdjc n prfds ol tma hay podjts rndsak ey anfm ol tma
sue`dttars tmnt nttajkak" ds djfbukak nt Nppajkdx N*
Lobbowdjc tma manrdjcs" tma Ynjab `at to kabdearnta oj tma `nttars tmnt mnk eaaj prasajtak
dj sue`dssdojs" njk to fojsdkar tma fmnjcas tmnt smoubk ea `nka to tma Krnlt UY[Y ns n
rasubt* [mds raport su``nrdsas tma `nttars fojsdkarak ey tma Ynjab" njk dts fojfbusdojs njkrafo``ajkntdojs*
Vdcjdldfnjt raspojsa tma`as
Vtrojc support lor tma jaw jatworh struftura
[ma sue`dssdoj raspojsas djkdfnta n strojc bavab ol support lor tma jaw jatworh struftura
tmnt wns proposak dj tma Krnlt UY[Y* [ma sue`dssdoj raspojsa lor` djvdtak sue`dttars to
djkdfnta tma axtajt to wmdfm tmay supportak or opposak tma proposak jatworh struftura* Ol
tmosa tmnt raspojkak to tma quastdoj" 39! ol raspojkajts djkdfntak adtmar support or strojc
support lor tma jaw jatworh nppronfm -saa Ldcura >$* [mds support wns radjlorfak ey
fo``ajts dj tma wrdttaj sue`dssdojs*
Ldcura >7 Vue`dttar raspojsa to proposak jatworh struftura
9! >9! 59! 69! ;9!
Vtrojcby opposa
Opposa
Jautrnb
Vupport
Vtrojcby Vupport
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
6/57
5
Fmnptarspafdldf dssuas njk rafo``ajkntdojs
[ma ra`ndjkar ol tmds raport nkkrassas dssuas dj tma orkar dj wmdfm tmay nppanr dj tma Krnlt
UY[Y* Lor anfm topdf nran" tma hay sue`dssdoj podjts nra su``nrdsak" dbbustrntak wmara
npproprdnta wdtm axn`pbas lro` spafdldf sue`dssdojs -wdtm tmadr sue`dssdoj ju`ears$* [mdsds lobbowak ey n su``nry oltma Ynjabs raspojsa nrdsdjc lro` dts kabdearntdojs" njk tma
Ynjabs rafo``ajkntdojs -djfbukdjc" wmara npproprdnta" n`ajk`ajts to tma Krnlt UY[Y$*
Axafutdva Vu``nry
Vue`dssdojs rabntak to `nttars rndsak dj tma Axafutdva Vu``nry nra nkkrassak dj tma
rabavnjt saftdoj ol tma `ndj kofu`ajt* [ma Axafutdva Vu``nry wdbb jaak to ea n`ajkak to
ajsura fojsdstajfy wdtm otmar n`ajk`ajts tmnt nra `nka to tma `ndj kofu`ajt*
Uafo``ajkntdoj7 N`ajk tma Axafutdva Vu``nry to ea fojsdstajt wdtm n`ajk`ajts to tma `ndj
kofu`ajt
Fmnptar >7 Djtrokuftdoj
[d djc rabntdva to tma Bnjk [rnjsport @njnca ajt N`ajk ajt Edbb
Vo`a sue`dttars -jotneby Vanbdjh" 145$ mnva quastdojak tma npproprdntajass ol fojsubtdjc
oj tma Krnlt UY[Y nt tmds td`a" wmaj tma bacdsbntdoj rabntdjc to UY[Ys ds ujkar ravdaw ey
Ynrbdn`ajt* [ma sue`dttars jota tmnt tma Bnjk [rnjsport @njnca`ajt N`ajk`ajt Edbb
-B[@N Edbb$ wdbb rapanb tma Yuebdf [rnjsport @njnca`ajt Nft -Y[@N$" njk `nha fmnjcas totma wny dj wmdfm UY[Ys `ust ea prapnrak8 njk tmnt tma Vabaft Fo``dttaa profass `ny
`nha lurtmar n`ajk`ajts to tma Edbb" Vanbdjh mns proposak tmnt tma profass ea kalarrak
ujtdb tma B[@N Edbb mns eaaj pnssak*
Otmar sue`dttars -jotneby eus oparntors$ mnva succastak tmnt tma Krnlt koas jot co lnr
ajoucm to djforpornta tma fmnjcas proposak dj tma B[@N Edbb" aspafdnbby dj rabntdoj to
pobdfdas rabntak to tma katar`djntdoj ol ujdts* [may mnva proposak tmnt tma UY[Y ea
strajctmajak to lubby fo`pby wdtm tma Edbb* [ma Nufhbnjk Foujfdb mns nbso succastak tmnt tma
UY[Y ea luturaproolak to nvodk tma jaak lor lurtmar fmnjcas to ea `nka ojfa tma jaw
bacdsbntdoj ds dj pbnfa*
[ma Lubbars sue`dssdoj -1=>$ mns rndsak dssuas dj rabntdoj to tma `njjar dj wmdfm tma Krnlt
UY[Y mns kanbt wdtm axa`pt sarvdfas" pnrtdfubnrby tma Kavojport njk Sndmaha larry
sarvdfas wmdfm nra kaldjak ns axa`pt dj tma B[@N Edbb*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab nffapts tmnt so`a ol tma bnjcunca usak dj tma krnlt UY[Y `ny
mnva fnusak so`a fojlusdoj ns to wmatmar dt mns eaaj prapnrak pursunjt to tma Y[@N or
tma proposak fmnjcas dj tma B[@N Edbb* Dj pnrtdfubnr" tma usa ol tma tar` axa`pt sarvdfas
foubk ea djtarpratak ns `anjdjc tmnt Nufhbnjk [rnjsport fojsdkars tmnt tma Edbb `ust ea
ajnftak ealora Y[O@ fnj ea djtrokufak* [mds ds jot tma fnsa*
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
13/57
>6
Our nkvdfa ds tmnt Y[O@ -lubb sarvdfa fojtrnftdjc otmar tmnj sarvdfas tmnt Nufhbnjk
[rnjsport fmoosas to axa`pt$ ds sd`pby tma jn`a lor n profura`ajt lrn`aworh tmnt fnj ea
d`pba`ajtak ujkar tma axdstdjc Y[@N* [mds `anjs tmnt tmara ds jo quastdoj ol tma profass
eadjc djvnbdk eafnusa ol tma B[@N Edbb jot yat eadjc ajnftak" ns tma profass ds lobbowdjc tma
furrajt Y[@N njk koas jot raby oj tma jaw B[@N Edbb provdsdojs*
Vdjfa tma fo`pbatdoj ol tma manrdjcs profass" tma [rnjsport njk Djkustrdnb Uabntdojs Vabaft
Fo``dttaa mns raportak enfh to Ynrbdn`ajt oj tma B[@N Edbb* [ma Fo``dttaa mns
rafo``ajkak so`a n`ajk`ajts to tma Edbb" eut dt ra`ndjs ujfbanr wmaj" njk dj wmnt lor`"
tma Edbb wdbb ea ajnftak*
[ma Ynjab ds ol tma opdjdoj tmnt tma tmoroucm fojsubtntdoj profass tmnt mns eaaj lobbowak to
knta mns ajnebak Nufhbnjk [rnjsport to `nha kafdsdojs oj tma suestnjtdva dssuas rabntdjc
to jatworh struftura njk otmar supportdjc pobdfdas" ns outbdjak dj tmds raport* [ma pnssnca ol
tma jaw bacdsbntdoj ds bdhaby to raqudra so`a lurtmar n`ajk`ajts to tma UY[Y to lubby fo`pby
wdtm tma jaw raqudra`ajts" pnrtdfubnrby dj rabntdoj to profura`ajt dssuas" djfbukdjc tmakasfrdptdoj njk nbbofntdoj ol ujdts" njk tma trant`ajt ol axa`pt sarvdfas* Mowavar" tma
Ynjab eabdavas dt ds pra`ntura to `nha tmosa fmnjcas ujtdb tma bacdsbntdva raqudra`ajts mnva
eaaj ldjnbdsak*
[ma Ynjab mns tmaralora fojfbukak tmnt tma Krnlt UY[Y smoubk ea n`ajkak to ralbaft tma
kafdsdojs nrdsdjc lro` tma fojsubtntdoj profass" to provdka n ravdsak Krnlt UY[Y tmnt
fo`pbdas wdtm tma furrajt bacdsbntdoj - tma Y[@N$* [ma Eonrk fnj tmaj kafdka wmatmar dt
wdsmas to lor`nbby nkopt tmnt UY[Y" or wndt ujtdb tma jaw bacdsbntdoj ds dj pbnfa njk `nha tma
jafassnry fmnjcas to ajsura tmnt tma jaw UY[Y ds lubby fo`pbdnjt wdtm tma jawraqudra`ajts*
[ma Ynjab nbso succasts tmnt to fbnrdly tma sdtuntdoj dj rabntdoj to axa`pt sarvdfas ea
fbnrdldak" njk tmnt axa`pt sarvdfas nra ralarrak to ojby wdtmdj tma fojtaxt ol tma proposak
bacdsbntdoj* Dj otmar djstnjfas" sarvdfas smoubk ea ralarajfak ns axdstdjc fo``arfdnb
sarvdfas njk pobdfdas njk nftdojs lofusak oj jacotdntdoj wdtm tma rabavnjt oparntors to
djtacrnta tmasa sarvdfas wdtm tma wdkar racdojnb jatworh*
Uafo``ajkntdojs7
N`ajk tma djtrokuftory taxt to axpbndj tmnt tma UY[Y mns eaaj prapnrak ujkar tma
Y[@N" eut ds lutura proolak wmara npproprdnta lor tma proposak B[@N Edbb*
Ajsura tmnt tma UY[Y usas tar`djobocy lro` tma Y[@N rntmar tmnj tma B[@N Edbb* Dj
pnrtdfubnr" wmara tma furrajt krnlt UY[Y ralarajfas axa`pt# sarvdfasdt smoubk stnta
tmnt ujkar tma Y[@N tmasa wdbb ra`ndj fo``arfdnb sarvdfas" njk tmnt tmasa woubk
trnjsdtdoj to axa`pt sarvdfassmoubk tma B[@N Edbb ea ajnftak ns furrajtby krnltak*
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
14/57
>;
Vfopa ol tma Ybnj
[ma Krnlt UY[Y stntas tmnt dts sfopa ds rastrdftak to sarvdfas wdtmdj tma Nufhbnjk racdoj* N
bnrca ju`ear ol sue`dssdojs ralarrak to tma jaak lor sarvdfas tmnt axtajk eayojk tma
Nufhbnjk racdoj eoujknry" aspafdnbby djto Sndhnto -a*c* [unhnu$*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma potajtdnb lor sarvdfas tmnt axtajk eayojk tma racdojnb eoujknry-wmdfm `ny ea godjtby lujkak ey jadcmeourdjc racdojs$ smoubk ea ralarajfak dj tma UY[Y*
Nj nkkdtdojnb Yobdfy 5*4 ds rafo``ajkak ujkar tma mankdjc Djtarracdojnb sarvdfa7
[unhnu/Sndhnto wmdfm ds kdsfussak bntar dj tma raport*
Uafo``ajkntdoj7
N`ajk taxt dj saftdoj >*6 to ralar to tma wny dj wmdfm tma UY[Y kanbs wdtm djtar
racdojnb sarvdfas
Fmnptar 57 Vtrntacdf Fojtaxt
Vtntutory raqudra`ajts
Vanbdjh -145$ mns sue`dttak tmnt tma Ybnj koas jot `aat dts stntutory raqudra`ajts" eafnusa
djsulldfdajt racnrk mns eaaj pndk to tma rabntdva alldfdajfy njk allaftdvajass ol kdllarajt
`okas ol puebdf trnjsport" njk tma `ost djvast`ajt ds eadjc `nka dj tma banst alldfdajt njk
allaftdva `oka ol puebdf trnjsport" d*a* rndb*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab koas jot ncraa wdtm tmds sue`dssdoj podjt* [ma djvast`ajt dj
rndb ds fojsdstajt wdtm wabb astnebdsmak pobdfdas dj tma Nufhbnjk racdoj" djfbukdjc tma Nufhbnjk
Ybnj njk tma Uacdojnb Bnjk [rnjsport Vtrntacy* [ma UY[Y cdvas allaft to tmasa pobdfdas"njk dt ds jot npproprdnta tmnt tmay nra ravdsdtak ns pnrt ol tmds profass*
Uafo``ajkntdoj7
Jo fmnjca
Hay strntacdf krdvars
Vue`dttars fnbbak lor tmds saftdoj to ea `ora fo`pramajsdva dj nkkrassdjc tma lnftors tmnt
djlbuajfa trnjsport ka`njk dj Nufhbnjk" djfbukdjc n crantar a`pmnsds oj sofdoafojo`df
njk ka`ocrnpmdf lnftors* Lor axn`pba" @UFncjay -;
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
15/57
>1
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab ncraas tmnt tma UY[Y smoubk ralbaft tma d`pnft ol mdcm njk
rdsdjc luab prdfas njk nj ncdjc popubntdoj wmdfm wdbb `nha qunbdty puebdf trnjsport `ora
nttrnftdva njk `ora d`portnjt ovar td`a* Dt nbso ncraas tmnt tma UY[Y smoubk ralbaft tma
jaak to ea `djklub ol tma rdsh tmnt Y[ lnra djfransas foubk kn`paj ka`njk dj wmnt ds n
fbanrby prdfa sajsdtdva `nrhat* Fo`pba`ajtnry pnrhdjc pobdfy ds n strojc pusm lnftor to
puebdf trnjsport usa njk n kabdearnta pobdfy kafdsdoj*
[ma Ynjab nbso fojsdkarak dt d`portnjt tmnt tmds saftdoj ol tma UY[Y nbso `nha ralarajfa to
tma jaaks ol paopba wdtmdj tma fo``ujdty wmo nra kapajkajt oj puebdf trnjsport to `aat
tmadr nffass jaaks njk lubby pnrtdfdpnta dj sofdaty*
Uafo``ajkntdojs7
Djfbuka podjts neout furrajt pnrhdjc pobdfy" luab prdfas njk ncdjc popubntdoj `nhdjc
Y[ `ora nttrnftdva djto saftdoj 5*5
Djfbuka fo``ajtnry oj tma prdfa sajsdtdvdty ol tma puebdf trnjsport `nrhat" njk tma
jaak to tnha fnra to nvodk supprassdjc ka`njk tmroucm lnra djfransas* Djfbuka jaw Yobdfy >*1 -pnca 5
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
16/57
>5 to rank7 %[ma axdstdjc jatworh ol eus routas ds
fo`pbax" wdtm nroujk ;99 djkdvdkunb routa ju`ears a`pboyak kdllarajt routa
vnrdntdojs* @njy ol tmasa routas vnrdntdojs nra***%
Djfbuka ralarajfa to Nppajkdx >F dj kdsfussdoj ol axdstdjc jatworh
Eajaldts ol puebdf trnjsport
[ma Ajarcy Alldfdajfy , Fojsarvntdoj Nutmordty -AAFN" 163$ sue`dttak tmnt tma UY[Y
smoubk axpbdfdtby rafocjdsa dssuas ol djfransdjc trnjsportrabntak ajarcy usa njk tma roba ol
puebdf trnjsport dj rakufdjc rabdnjfa oj prdvnta otor vamdfbas wdtm nssofdntak alldfdajfy
eajaldts*
[ma @djdstry ol Akufntdoj -1;3$ raquastak n strojcar lofus dj tma ldjnb Ybnj oj tma fross
futtdjc dssuas ol ronk njk trnjsport snlaty" wdtm n spafdldf bdjh to tma Vnlar Gourjays
Vtrntacy wdtm dts snla systa` nppronfm*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab supports tmasa succastdojs* Nkkdtdojnb ralarajfas to tma
dssuas rndsak nra proposak*
Uafo``ajkntdojs7
Djsart n jaw bdja dj [neba 6*5 tmnt kdsfussas tma dssua ol ajarcy usa" njk outbdja tma
proposak raspojsa sdcjdldfnjt `oknb smdlt ojto jawar" fbanjar" wabb pntrojdsak
kdasab eusas njk abaftrdf trndjs8 njk tma djvastdcntdoj ol nbtarjntdva luab tafmjobocdas
lor eusas Djfbuka strojcar ralarajfa to snlaty nt nffass podjts to Y[" aspafdnbby wmara
fojjaftdojs nra raqudrak8 njk ns nj aba`ajt dj krdvar trndjdjc*
Fmnptar ;7 Smnt wa wnjt to nfmdava
\dsdoj" outfo`as njk oegaftdvas
@ost sue`dssdojs oj tmds Fmnptar wara dj support ol tma vdsdoj" outfo`as njk oegaftdvas*
@UFncjay -;
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
17/57
>3
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma proposak n`ajk`ajt to tma vdsdoj eattar kasfrdeas tma djtajtdoj ol
tma jaw jatworh" eut tma Ynjab lnvourak tmnt n `ora fo`pabbdjc vdsdoj tmnt ralbafts tma
kasdra lor tma puebdf trnjsport systa` to djkufa n laabdjc ol vnbua to tma puebdf*
[ma Ynjab kdk jot support tma succastdoj to rakufa tma ju`ear ol oegaftdvas" cdvaj tmaeronk bavab ol support lor tma oegaftdvas lro` otmar sue`dttars" njk tma rdsh tmnt sufm n `ova
foubk fnusa fojlusdoj* Mowavar" cdvaj tma d`portnjfa tmnt jaaks to ea pbnfak oj
djlrnstruftura" n raorkardjc ol tma oegaftdvas -njk tmaralora ol tma Yobdfy saftdojs dj Fmnptar
1$ ns lobbows7
Nj djtacrntak" alldfdajt njk allaftdva puebdf trnjsport jatworh tmntollars fntars lor n
wdkar wdka rnjca ol trdps njk ds tma `oka ol fmodfa lor nj djfransdjc ju`ear ol
vnbuak eyNufhbnjkars* Uatndj oegaftdvas" eut raorkar -bdlt Djlrnstruftura lro` Oegaftdva 1 to Oegaftdva 6" to
d``akdntaby lobbow tma jatworh oegaftdvas8 njk raorkar Yobdfy saftdojs nfforkdjcby$*
@ansuras njk tnrcats
Vo`a sue`dttars labt tmnt tma pntrojnca njk `oka smnra tnrcats dkajtdldak dj tma Krnlt UY[Y
nra too bow" fojsdkardjc tma bavab ol trnjslor`ntdojnb smdlt tmnt tma Nufhbnjk Ybnj ajvdsncas"
njk tma axtajt ol tma jatworh fmnjcas proposak* Otmars quastdojak wmy tmara ds n
kdllarajfa eatwaaj tma Nufhbnjk Ybnj njk tma lujkak tnrcat lor 5955*
Vuccastdojs wara `nka dj rabntdoj to tma tnrcats lor tma ! ol mousamobks wdtmdj 199 `atras
ol tma lraquajt jatworh* Vo`a fojsdkarak tmds tnrcat to ea too bow8 otmars wara fojfarjak
tmnt dt lofussak ojby oj tmosa rasdkajts wdtm nffass to tma lraquajt sarvdfa jatworh" eut
dcjorak otmars* [mara wns nbso support lor tma tnrcat to ralbaft a`pboy`ajt ns wabb ns
mousamobk bofntdojs*
Vo`a sue`dttars quastdojak tma pntrojnca `ansura" njk wmatmar n `ansura ol pnssajcar
eonrkdjcs ds npproprdnta cdvaj tma jaw jatworh wdbb raqudra `ora trnjslars*
Otmar outfo`as njk `ansuras succastak ey sue`dttars djfbuka7 Uakufa nvarnca njjunb trdp h`s par parsoj" racnrkbass ol `oka -Manrt ol tma Fdty
149$
! ol mousamobks wdtmdj 599 `atras ol Y[ stops wdtm nt banst 69 `djuta lraquajfy
-Nufhbnjk Kdsnedbdty Bnw" 6=3$
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab jotas tmnt tnrcats dj [neba ;> nra nbdcjak wdtm Nufhbnjk Ybnj
tnrcats* [ma pntrojnca tnrcat ->96 `dbbdoj trdps$ ds tma lujkak tnrcat wmdfm smows wmnt fnj
ea nfmdavak ensak oj furrajt lujkak progafts djfbukak dj Nufhbnjk Foujfdb#s Bojc [ar`
Ybnj* [ma Nufhbnjk Ybnj nd`s nt >;9 `dbbdoj trdps ey 5955" eut to nfmdava tmds stratfm tnrcat
wdbb raqudra nkkdtdojnb lujkdjc lor oparntdojs njk djlrnstruftura to wmnt ds nbranky nvndbneba*
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
18/57
>=
[ma Ynjab eabdavas tmnt n `ora axpbdfdt axpbnjntdoj ol tmasa kdllarajfas dj tma UY[Y woubk
ea mabplub*
[ma njjunb `ansura ol pnssajcars par fnpdtn" njk tma nffass kdstnjfa ol 199` nra
spafdldak Dj tma Nufhbnjk Ybnj* [ma UY[Y tnrcats nra nbdcjak to tma Nufhbnjk Ybnj" eut tma
nftunb bavabs `ny jaak to ea ravdawak dj tma bdcmt ol tma sarvdfa fmnjcas proposak* [maYnjab ncraas tmnt nffass to a`pboy`ajt smoubk ea djfbukak dj tma tnrcats*
Uafo``ajkntdojs7
Uavdaw tma tnrcat lor ! ol mousamobks njk a`pboy`ajt bofntak wdtmdj 199 `atras ol
tma lraquajt jatworh
Nkk n tnrcat lor nffass to tma wdkar puebdf trnjsport jatworh -jot gust tma lraquajt
jatworh$
Djfbuka lootjota to axpbndj tma kdllarajfa eatwaaj tma Nufhbnjk Ybnj njk lujkak
tnrcats*
Fmnptar 17 Hay Kdraftdojs
Ns jotak neova" `ost sue`dttars wara supportdva ol tma hay kdraftdojs dj tma Krnlt UY[Y"
njk dj pnrtdfubnr tma jaw jatworh struftura* [ma Ynjab eabdavas tmnt tma fojsubtntdoj
profass mns provdkak n fbanr `njknta lor d`pba`ajtdjc tma jaw jatworh nbojc tma bdjas ol
tmnt proposak dj tma Krnlt UY[Y* Mowavar" tmara nra so`a spafdldf nrans wmara
n`ajk`ajts wdbb ea jaakak*
Fdty Undb Bdjh
Vue`dttars nppanrak to nfhjowbakca tmnt tma lofus ol tma Krnlt UY[Y" wdtm dts >9 yanr
pbnjjdjc mordzoj" wns oj tma kavabop`ajt ol tma systa` nmank ol tma Fdty Undb Bdjh -FUB$
d`pba`ajtntdoj* Mowavar" so`a sue`dssdojs fojsdkarak tmnt tma FUB smoubk ea `ora lubby
ralbaftak dj tma Krnlt" aspafdnbby dj tma kasfrdptdoj ol tma jatworh dj 5955*
Vo`a sue`dttars wara fojfarjak tmnt ey nssu`djc tmnt tma FUB woubk ea eudbt ey tma ajk
ol tma pbnjjdjc pardok" tma Krnlt wns lbnwak*
Eus oparntors sue`dttak tmnt tma FUB foubk ea trdnbbak usdjc eusas dj tma `anjtd`a*Mowavar" otmar sue`dttars -a*c* Manrt ol tma Fdty 149" \dnkuft Mnreour Mobkdjcs 113$ wara
fojfarjak nt tma bavab ol fajtrnb fdty njk Syjynrk ^unrtar eus `ova`ajts nbranky provdkak
lor dj tma Krnlt UY[Y" njk tmadr d`pnft oj tma bofnb ajvdroj`ajt dj tmosa nrans*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma UY[Y ds lofusak oj tma d`prova`ajts jaakak to nfmdava nj
djtacrntak puebdf trnjsport jatworh ealora tma fo`pbatdoj ol tma FUB -wmdfm ds pbnjjak to ea
oparntdojnb townrks tma ajk ol tma pbnjjdjc pardok$" to ajsura tmnt jatworh d`prova`ajts
fnj ea suffasslub racnrkbass ol tma td`djc ol tma FUB" njk to dkajtdly tmosa fmnjcas tmnt nra
jaakak to `nxd`dsa tma eajaldts ol tma FUB njk to ajsura dts suffasslub d`pba`ajtntdoj
wmaj dt koas offur* Ns sufm" tma spafdldf td`djc ol tma FUB smoubk jot mnva n sdcjdldfnjtd`pnft oj tma nppronfm tnhaj dj tmds UY[Y*
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
19/57
>4
@okabbak ka`njk to njk lro` tma FEK succasts tmnt eus ensak sobutdojs wdbb jot fopa too
`njy eusas wdbb ea raqudrak rasubtdjc dj manvy fojcastdoj dj tma FEK* [ma crnka sapnrntak
Fdty Undb Bdjh wdbb ajneba tma crantar fnpnfdty raqudrak wdtmout fboccdjc up FEK ronks* Jota
tmnt tma djtard` jatworh wdbb oparnta wdtmout tma jaak lor tma FUB -dl dt ds kabnyak$* Dt ds
kdlldfubt to saa mow eusas foubk rapbdfnta tma pntrojnca potajtdnb ol tma FUB" njk njyntta`pt to ko so woubk djvobva nkkdtdojnb eus/rndb trnjslars fbosa to tma fajtrnb fdty*
Uafo``ajkntdoj7
Uatndj axdstdjc ralarajfas to FUB*
Larry sarvdfas
N ju`ear ol sue`dssdojs fojsdkarak tmnt tma krnlt UY[Y koas jot co lnr ajoucm dj rabntdoj
to tma lutura kavabop`ajt ol larry sarvdfas* [masa sue`dttars wnjt to saa n crantar roba lor
larrdas ns pnrt ol tma lraquajt njk nbb kny jatworhs* Lubbars Croup -1=>$ mdcmbdcmtak tma jaaklor puebdf trnjsport pbnjjdjc to tnha nffoujt ol tma jaaks ol tma tourds` saftor" njk tma
d`portnjfa ol prdvnta fnpdtnb lujkdjc*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab nfhjowbakcas tmnt tma Krnlt UY[Y mns jot spabbak out n fbanr
roba lor larrdas ns nj djtacrnb pnrt ol tma kavabop`ajt ol tma jaw jatworh* [mds ds kua dj pnrt
to tma spafdldf fmnrnftardstdfs ol tma furrajt larry jatworh" njk tma lnft tmnt so`a ol tma `ngor
sarvdfas -djfbukdjc Sndmaha njk Kavojport$ nra provdkak oj n fo``arfdnb ensds" wdtmout n
fojtrnft wdtm Nufhbnjk [rnjsport*
Javartmabass" tma Ynjab eabdavas tmnt tmara ds potajtdnb lor larry sarvdfas to ea `ora fbosabydjtacrntak wdtm tma wdkar puebdf trnjsport jatworh" to tnha nkvnjtnca ol tma ujdqua nttrdeutas
tmnt larry sarvdfas ollar dj n `nrdtd`a fdty sufm ns Nufhbnjk* [ma Ynjab nfhjowbakcas tmnt
tma spafdldf `anjs ey wmdfm tmds djtacrntdoj fnj offur wdbb jaak fnralub fojsdkarntdoj" njk
tmnt tmds ds bdhaby to raqudra `ora td`a tmnj ds nvndbneba ealora tma ldjnbdsntdoj ol tmds UY[Y*
Lor tmds ransoj" n pobdfy fo``dt`ajt to ravdaw tma roba ol larrdas ns pnrt ol tma djtacrntak
jatworh ds proposak*
Uafo``ajkntdojs7
Djsart n jaw pnrncrnpm dj Hay Kdraftdojs -Fmnptar 1$ oj tma roba ol larrdas8 tma
opportujdtdas to eattar djtacrnta larrdas wdtm tma wdkar puebdf trnjsport systa`8 njk nfo``dt`ajt to ravdaw mow east to nfmdava tmds* [mds smoubk nbso djfbuka ralarajfa to
tma djvastdcntdoj ol possdeba jaw larry sarvdfas" to nsfartndj potajtdnb ka`njk njk
tma lansdedbdty ol provdkdjc djlrnstruftura njk sarvdfas8 njk tma jaak lor bofnb nran
sarvdfa pbnjjdjc to ajfo`pnss larry sarvdfas njk tma roba ol laakar eusas to provdka
fojjaftdojs to larrdas*
Nkk n jaw pobdfy to Vaftdoj
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
20/57
59
Otmar okas
Vo`a sue`dssdojs axprassak n pralarajfa lor jaw puebdf trnjsport `okas to ea
djvastdcntak njk/or d`pba`ajtak dj Nufhbnjk* [mds djfbukak trn`s -aspafdnbby eatwaaj tma
Syjynrk ^unrtar" fdty fajtra njk Vt Mabdars" njk dj ^uaaj Vtraat$* Lor axn`pba" Sntarlrojt
Nufhbnjk -=34$ proposak nj axtajsdoj ol tma axdstdjc trn` lro` Syjynrk ^unrtar to
Erdto`nrt" njk dts djfbusdoj ns pnrt ol tma lraquajt sarvdfa jatworh" ajnebdjc dt to eadjtacrntak wdtm tma wdkar puebdf trnjsport jatworh* Vue`dssdojs nbso fnbbak lor n strojcar
fo``dt`ajt to abaftrdf vamdfbas -trn`s" bdcmt rndb njk abaftrdf eusas" dj nkkdtdoj to rndb
abaftrdldfntdoj$*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab jotas tmnt tma UY[Y ds n >9yanr pbnj" njk ds proposdjc to
eudbk n puebdf trnjsport jatworh tmnt wdbb `nxd`dsa tma eajaldts ol abaftrdldfntdoj njk prapnra
lor tma FUB eadjc fo`pbatak townrks tma ajk ol tma pbnjjdjc pardok* [ma Krnlt UY[Y bdsts
sarvdfas nroujk hjowj njk sdcjnbbak djlrnstruftura progafts tmnt nra proposak dj tma
Nufhbnjk Ybnj njk tma Nufhbnjk [rnjsport Uacdojnb Bnjk [rnjsport Yrocrn``a* Jaw rndb
bdjas njk nkkdtdojnb `okas nra bojcar tar` strntacdf kdraftdoj dssuas njk tmaralora eayojktma sfopa ol tma furrajt >9 yanr mordzoj ol tma UY[Y*
Mowavar" tma Ynjab fojsdkars tmnt Nufhbnjk [rnjsport smoubk nbso nkopt nj opaj`djkak
njk ajnebdjc nppronfm to succastdojs lor jaw `okas njk nbtarjntdva sarvdfa optdojs" ns
pnrt ol tma ojcodjc sarvdfa ravdaw njk d`pba`ajtntdoj profass* [ma UY[Y smoubk `nha dt
fbanr tmnt Nufhbnjk [rnjsport wdbb fojtdjua to fojsdkar tma east optdojs to sarva pnrtdfubnr
ka`njks ns pnrt ol tmds profass*
[ma Ynjab nbso jotas tmnt n lansdedbdty stuky djto n sarvdfa eatwaaj Syjynrk ^unrtar njk
Erdto`nrt -djfbukdjc n possdeba trn` axtajsdoj$ ds furrajtby ujkarwny" njk rafo``ajks tmnttma UY[Y `nha ralarajfa to tmds*
Uafo``ajkntdoj7
Djfbuka ralarajfa to fojtdjudjc to fojsdkar tma east optdojs to sarva pnrtdfubnr
ka`njks ns pnrt ol tma ojcodjc sarvdfa ravdaw njk d`pba`ajtntdoj profass*
Djfbuka ralarajfa to tma lansdedbdty stuky djto n sarvdfa eatwaaj Syjynrk ^unrtar njk
Erdto`nrt" njk tma potajtdnb -suegaft to tma outfo`as ol tma stuky$ lor tma sarvdfa to
ea djtacrntak djto tma wdkar puebdf trnjsport jatworh
Djtacrntdoj wdtm wnbhdjc njk fyfbdjc
N ju`ear ol sue`dttars labt tmnt tma hay kdraftdojs fmnptar jaakak to nkkrass tma eronkar
fojtaxt wdtmdj wmdfm puebdf trnjsport jatworh wdbb ea kavabopak" njk mow dt wdbb ea djtacrntak
wdtm otmar trnjsport `okas* Dj pnrtdfubnr" sue`dttars jotak tma jaak lor tma Fmnptar to
nkkrass djtacrntdoj wdtm wnbhdjc njk fyfbdjc*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab ncraas tmnt tma UY[Y smoubk `nha provdsdoj lor n `ora lbaxdeba
nppronfm to nffass to tma puebdf trnjsport systa`" ns n fojsaquajfa ol tma jaw jatworh
kasdcj" njk pnrtdfubnrby nfhjowbakca tma roba ol wnbhdjc njk fyfbdjc to support tma jaw
jatworh*
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
21/57
5>
Uafo``ajkntdoj7
Nkk taxt to Fm 1 Hay Kdraftdojs ns lobbows7
Dj nkkdtdoj" d`prova`ajts to tma fojjaftdvdty ol wnbhdjcnjk fyfbdjc jatworhs wdtm
proposak puebdf trnjsport djtarfmnjcas njk stops nra assajtdnb to d`prova nffass to
tma proposak sd`pbdldak puebdf trnjsport jatworh* [masa d`prova`ajts woubk axtajk
opportujdtdas to eajaldt lro` tma d`provak puebdf trnjsport sarvdfas ns pnrt ol n wdkar
wmoba gourjay nppronfm*
Varvdfa fntacordas
[ma kasfrdptdojs usak lor tma sarvdfa fntacordas fnusak fojfarjs lor so`a sue`dttars* Dj
pnrtdfubnr" tma usa ol tma tar` lraquajt dj eotm tma lraquajt sarvdfa jatworh" njk tma
lraquajt sarvdfa bnyar wdtmdj tmnt jatworh wns saaj ns fojlusdjc*
[ma kdstdjftdojs eatwaaj fojjaftor" bofnb" panh ojby njk tnrcatak sarvdfas wara nbso
quardak ey so`a sue`dttars* Vo`a -a*c* @UFncjay" ;
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
22/57
55
[ma Ynjab nbso nfhjowbakcas tmnt tma nesajfa ol panh ojby njk bofnb sarvdfas dj tma pbnjs
puebdsmak dj tma Krnlt `ny mnva fojvayak nj d`prassdoj tmnt tmasa sarvdfas nra jo bojcar
proposak* [mds ds jot tma fnsa" njk tma ldjnb UY[Y smoubk ea `ora axpbdfdt neout tma roba ol
sufm sarvdfas -a*c* ey djfbukdjc frossralarajfas dj Fmnptar 1 njk dts kdncrn`s" njk tma
sfmakubas dj Nppajkdx >N$* N `ora oevdous ralarajfa to outar nran or racdojnb sarvdfas
-njk n frossralarajfa to tma `nps ol tmasa sarvdfas dj Nppajkdx >E$ ds nbso proposak*
Uafo``ajkntdoj7
Uapbnfa ralarajfas to tma Lraquajt Varvdfa Jatworh wdtm Unpdk njk Lraquajt
Varvdfa Jatworh
Fbnrdly tma sarvdfa bnyar tar`djobocy dj `nps njk kdncrn`s
Ea `ora axpbdfdt neout panh ojby njk bofnb sarvdfas" njk racdojnb sarvdfas ey fross
ralarajfdjc tma taxt njk `nps dj Fm1 to tma sarvdfa kasfrdptdojs dj Nppajkdx >N njk
>E8 njk jota tmnt `nps ol tmasa sarvdfas wdbb ea nvndbneba ns pnrt ol tma bofnb
fojsubtntdoj profass" njk ldjnbdsak ojfa tmnt profass mns eaaj fo`pbatak*
N`ajk `nps to smow tma forraft UurnbQrenj Eoujknry
Uasourfa nbbofntdoj
[ma jaak to a`pmnsdsa tmnt proposak jatworh ds usdjc tma sn`a n`oujt ol rasourfas ns
nra usak jow" gust `ora alldfdajtby" wns dkajtdldak dj sue`dssdojs*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 Dt ds ncraak tmnt tmds ds n podjt wortm `nhdjc cdvaj tma lujkdjc fojstrndjts
njk fojfarj neout djfransak fosts njk Nufhbnjk rnta rdsas*
Uafo``ajkntdoj7 N`ajk sajtajfa oj pnca >3 ns lobbows7 [ma nppronfm outbdjak dj tma krnlt Ybnj
raspojks ey sattdjc out n jaw" djtacrntak jatworh struftura lor Nufhbnjk#s puebdf
trnjsport systa` wmdfm nbbows d`provak bavabs ol sarvdfa tmroucm eattar utdbdsntdoj ol
tma furrajt bavab ol oparntdjc rasourfas*
Jatworh lofus oj FEK
Vo`a sue`dttars wara fojfarjak tmnt tma jaw jatworh ra`ndjs strojcby FEKfajtrdf"
aspafdnbby wdtm dts lofus oj tma rndb systa`* [may jota tmnt jot avaryoja ds djtarastak dj
trnvabbdjc to tma fdty fajtra" njk ajnebdjc trnvab nfross Nufhbnjk smoubk ea n hay conb*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab jotas tmnt nbtmoucm tma jaw jatworh wdbb fojtdjua to provdka n
mdcm bavab ol sarvdfa to tma FEK" tma proposnbs mnva eaaj kasdcjak to ajneba n `ufm wdkar
rnjca ol fross towj sarvdfa opportujdtdas tmnj furrajtby axdst* [ma fojjaftak jatworh
`anjs tmnt trnvab to `ora kastdjntdojs outsdka tma FEK wdbb ea possdeba" nbeadt wdtm trnjslars
raqudrak dj so`a fnsas*
Uafo``ajkntdoj7
Nkk taxt to a`pmnsdsa tmnt wmdba tma jaw jatworh fojtdjuas to ajneba cook nffass
to tma FEK" dt wdbb nbso provdka d`provak bavabs ol sarvdfa to otmar kastdjntdojs"djfbukdjc frosstowj trnvab*
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
23/57
56
Axtajsdojs to tma rnpdk njk lraquajt jatworh
Axtajsdojs to tma jatworh7 tmara wns so`a sue`dttar support lor axtajkdjc tma abaftrdldak rndb
to Yuhahoma" nbtmoucm so`a sue`dttars succastak tmnt n `ora d`portnjt prdordty wns to
astnebdsm n rndb fojjaftdoj to @njuhnu lro` tma soutm* [ma jaak lor anrbdar procrass oj rndbto tma ndrport wns nbso dkajtdldak ey so`a* Nufhbnjk Ndrport -1;6$ sue`dttak tmnt tma Ndreus
sarvdfa" nbtmoucm n proposak axa`pt sarvdfa" smoubk ea smowj ns pnrt ol tma lraquajt
sarvdfa jatworh*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab jotas tmnt axtajsdoj ol tma abaftrdldak rndb jatworh to Yuhahoma
ds furrajtby ujkar djvastdcntdoj ey Nufhbnjk [rnjsport* Vmoubk tmds rasubt dj n fmnjca to
sarvdfa bavabs" n lutura vnrdntdoj to tma UY[Y `ny ea jafassnry -nbtmoucm tma Ynjab jotas
tmnt sarvdfa bavabs fnj axfaak tmosa stntak dj tma UY[Y$*
Nj djvastdcntdoj djto tma vdnedbdty ol n @njuhnu Voutmarj bdjh ds nbso furrajtby ujkarwny vdnNufhbnjk Foujfdb* Mowavar" sufm n fojjaftdoj woubk ea fostby" njk mns jot eaaj dkajtdldak
ns n furrajt prdordty lor Nufhbnjk [rnjsport" cdvaj otmar assajtdnb fnpdtnb worhs njk prassura
oj oparntdjc fosts* Nbb rndb stntdojs soutm ol @njuhnu ns lnr ns Ynpnhurn wdbb fojtdjua to
mnva kdraft eus sarvdfas to njk lro` @njuhnu dj fbosa proxd`dty*
[ma axtajsdoj ol rndb to tma ndrport ds njk oegaftdva ol tma Nufhbnjk Ybnj" njk wmdba tma
pralarrak routa ds dj tma profass ol eadjc dkajtdldak njk protaftak" fojstruftdoj ds bdhaby to ea
eayojk tma >9yanr sfopa ol tmds UY[Y* Mowavar" tma Ynjab nffapts tmnt tma Ndreus sarvdfa
smoubk ea ralarajfak dj tma @nps smowdjc tma lraquajt sarvdfa jatworh" ns dt `aats tma
raqudrak bavab ol sarvdfa*
Uafo``ajkntdojs7
djfbuka taxt to kasfrdea potajtdnb axtajsdojs to tma lraquajt sarvdfa jatworh8
djfbuka ralarajfa to tma Ndreus sarvdfa dj @nps
Djfbuka ralarajfa to tma djvastdcntdoj ol lutura axtajsdoj ol rndb to tma ndrport" wdtm
fojstruftdoj eayojk tma >9yanr sfopa ol tmds UY[Y*
Fojfarjs wdtm tma jatworh fojfapt
N sdcjdldfnjt ju`ear ol sue`dttars" djfbukdjc `njy wmo supportak tma ovarnbb jatworh
fojfapt" podjtak to potajtdnb kdlldfubtdas dj dts d`pba`ajtntdoj* N hay dssua wdbb ea tma jaak toajsura rabdneba" fojvajdajt njk snla fojjaftdojs wmara tmasa nra jafassnry to `nha trdps
ey puebdf trnjsport* [mds mns n ju`ear ol kd`ajsdojs" djfbukdjc tma jaak lor7
rabdneba gourjay td`as oj fojjaftdjc sarvdfas to ajneba td`ak fojjaftdojs
sulldfdajt lraquajfy oj fojjaftor routas to ajneba td`aby trnjslars
wabb kasdcjak djlrnstruftura" aspafdnbby nt djtarfmnjcas" to lnfdbdtnta snla njk
fojvajdajt fojjaftdojs
routa njk djtarfmnjca kasdcj tmnt nvodks bojc wnbhs eatwaaj fojjaftdjc sarvdfas
spafdnb nttajtdoj to tma jaaks ol kdsnebak pnssajcars wmaj fojjaftdojs nra raqudrak
n strojc lofus oj djlor`ntdoj" eotm vdsunb njk nukdo
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
24/57
5;
Dj nkkdtdoj" sue`dttars provdkak n ju`ear ol axn`pbas ol sdtuntdojs wmara tma jaw jatworh
fojfapt `ny rasubt dj kdseajaldts to axdstdjc usars" `ndjby kua to tma potajtdnb boss ol
axdstdjc kdraft sarvdfas*
Vo`a sue`dttars -a*c* G Coklray" 14>$ fnbbak lor n `ora lor`nb njk axpbdfdt fo`pnrdsoj ol
mow wabb tma jaw jatworh wdbb parlor` dj fo`pnrdsoj to tma furrajt jatworh* F Mnrbnjk-135$ labt tmnt tmds ds pnrtdfubnrby d`portnjt dj bow sofdoafojo`df nrans" to nvodk tma
possdedbdty tmnt bofnb fojsubtntdoj oj spafdldf sarvdfas wdbb eafo`a suesarvdajt to tma ncraak
fojfapt*
Otmars podjtak to tma jaak lor tma katndbak d`pba`ajtntdoj pmnsa to tnha pnrtdfubnr fnra to
ajsura tmnt fmnjcas nra fnralubby mnjkbak" cdvaj tma lnft tmnt so`a axdstdjc pnssajcars wdbb
jaak to `nha fmnjcas to wabbastnebdsmak trnvab pnttarjs* Lor axn`pba" tma Eus njk Fonfm
Nssofdntdoj -1>=$ succastak tmnt anfm djkdvdkunb sarvdfa fmnjca smoubk profaak ojby dl tmara
ds n posdtdva njswar to tma quastdoj wdbb tmds fmnjca snva fusto`ars td`a or `ojay?
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab ncraas tmnt tma dssuas rndsak ey sue`dttars wdbb ea d`portnjt to
nkkrass ns tma jaw jatworh ds d`pba`ajtak* Nbtmoucm tma dssuas wara fojsdkarak ns pnrt
ol tma jatworh pbnjjdjc profass" dt ds d`portnjt tmnt tma fmnbbajcas tmnt tma jaw jatworh
prasajts nra jot ujkarastd`ntak ey Nufhbnjk [rnjsport* @njy ol tma pobdfdas dj Fmnptar *5 to ralar to n 199 `atra wnbh wdtmdj tma Uurnb Qrenj
Eoujknry
Bnjk usa djtacrntdoj
Vo`a sue`dttars dkajtdldak tma jaak to strajctmaj tma pobdfdas rabntdjc to bnjk usa njk
trnjsport djtacrntdoj* Lor axn`pba" [rnlldf , [rnjsportntdoj Ajcdjaars Btk -;*;7 fmnjca workdjc to Ajfournca `utunbby supportdva bnjk usa njk puebdf
trnjsport kavabop`ajt pobdfdas
Yobdfy >*; jaw nftdoj %Sorh wdtm tma Nufhbnjk Foujfdb to ajsura tmnt tma Djtacrntak
[rnjsport Nssass`ajt cudkabdjas nra npproprdntaby djfbukak dj tma Qjdtnry Ybnj to
ajsura fojsdkarntdoj ol tma provdsdoj ol puebdf trnjsport ds nkaqunta*%
Yobdfy >*; nftdoj k raworkdjc %Nftdvaby ajfournca njk provdka cudknjfa to
kavabopars wdtm craajldabk njk urenj djtajsdldfntdoj proposnbs to fo`pbata nj
Djtacrntak [rnjsport Nssass`ajt to ajsura bnjk usa ds djtacrntak wdtm tma lraquajt
jatworh%
Yobdfy >*;7 nkk jaw nftdoj to worh wdtm tma Foujfdb to ajsura tmnt tma Qjdtnry Ybnj
njk tma UY[Y nra `utunbby supportdva*
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
27/57
53
Djtacrntdoj wdtm pnrhdjc pobdfdas
Vo`a sue`dttars labt tmnt tma Krnlt UY[Y jaakak to pbnfa `ora a`pmnsds oj djtacrntdoj wdtm
pobdfdas oj tma suppby njk prdfdjc ol pnrhdjc*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab ncraas tmnt n `ora lor`nb nbdcj`ajt wdtm pnrhdjc pobdfdas dj tma
UY[Y woubk ea npproprdnta" aspafdnbby dj vdaw ol Nufhbnjk [rnjsports pnrhdjc
raspojsdedbdtdas*
Uafo``ajkntdoj7
Djfbuka jaw Yobdfy >*1 -pnca 5
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
28/57
5=
Vavarnb sue`dssdojs dkajtdldak ujrabdneba rujjdjc td`as ns n potajtdnb proeba` wmara trdps
raqudrak fojjaftdojs to ea `nka* [may fnbbak lor n fo``dt`ajt to ajsurdjc tmnt sarvdfa
kasdcj woubk haap wndtdjc td`as to n `djd`u`* [ma Nufhbnjk Uacdojnb Yuebdf Manbtm
Varvdfa -NUYMV" 155$ succastak astnebdsmdjc n tnrcat `nxd`u` wndt td`a lor trnjslars*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 Ns jotak dj tma Krnlt UY[Y" katndbak routdjc dssuas wdbb ea nkkrassak nspnrt ol tma bofnb fojsubtntdoj profass* [ma Ynjab jotas tmnt djtacrntak jatworh smoubk
provdka d`provak `oedbdty opportujdtdas njk nffass to n wdkar rnjca ol kastdjntdojs" njk tmnt
tmara nra pobdfdas njk nftdojs dj bntar saftdojs ol tma Krnlt UY[Y tmnt nkkrass tma jaak to
ajsura rabdneba trnvab td`as* Lor axn`pba" nftdojs 1*> -n$ njk -e$ rafocjdsa tma d`portnjfa
ol foorkdjntak pbnjjdjc lor sarvdfas njk djlrnstruftura" njk tma jaak lor eus prdordty
`ansuras ds rafocjdsak dj pobdfy 1*;*
[ma Ynjab mns `nka so`a succastdojs tmnt wdbb cdva crantar pro`djajfa to tmasa pobdfdas"
pnrtdfubnrby dj rabntdoj to djlrnstruftura* N spafdldf lofus oj `djd`dsdjc wndtdjc td`as nt
djtarfmnjcas woubk ea npproprdnta dj Yobdfy 5*6" mowavar*
Uafo``ajkntdoj7
Yobdfy 5*6 nkk to tma nftdoj7 Kasdcj routas" djtarfmnjcas njk td`atnebas to provdka
fojvajdajt fojjaftdojs eatwaaj sarvdfas njk to `djd`dsa totnb gourjay td`a"
djfbukdjc wndtdjc td`a lor fojjaftdojs
Djfbuka n tnrcat lor `nxd`u` wndtdjc td`a
Varvdfas to jawby kavabopdjc nrans
Vue`dttars wara cajarnbby supportdva ol pobdfy 5*; njk nssofdntak nftdojs to djtrokufasarvdfas to jawby kavabopdjc nrans* N ju`ear ol crowtm nrans wdtm bdttba or jo furrajt
sarvdfa wara dkajtdldak* [ma jaak to worh `ora fbosaby wdtm kavabopars to ajsura provdsdoj
ds `nka lor puebdf trnjsport" njk tma potajtdnb usa ol tma Djtacrntak [rnjsport Nssass`ajt
-D[N$ cudkabdjas wns nbso jotak"
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 Djtacrntdoj eatwaaj trnjsport njk bnjk usa" njk tma usa ol tma D[N
Cudkabdjas" mns eaaj ralarajfak dj pravdous saftdojs* [ma Ynjab proposas nj nkkdtdojnb to
tma D[N Cudkabdjas dj tma nftdojs ujkar pobdfy 5*;*
Uafo``ajkntdoj7 Yobdfy 5*; jaw nftdoj %Nftdvaby ajfournca njk provdka cudknjfa to kavabopars wdtm
craajldabk njk urenj djtajsdldfntdoj proposnbs to fo`pbata nj Djtacrntak [rnjsport
Nssass`ajt to ajsura nkaqunta fojsdkarntdoj ds cdvaj to puebdf trnjsport
raqudra`ajts*%
Varvdfa nkgust ajts
Vo`a sue`dttars -a*c* G Gomjstoj 6=5" Yuhatnpnpn BE =41$ snw pobdfy 5*3 ns opajdjc tma
potajtdnb lor lutura futs dj sarvdfa bavabs" eut otmars fojsdkarak tmnt tma usa ol tmrasmobks to
trdccar sarvdfa ravdaws nbbows sarvdfas to ea eattar `njncak to `aat vnrdntdojs dj ka`njk*
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
29/57
54
JW Eus -169 UY[Y*
Uafo``ajkntdoj7
Uapbnfa eubbatak taxt ujkar Nftdoj -n$ wdtm tma `djd`u` njk `nxd`u` sarvdfa ravdaw
trdccars fojtndjak wdtmdj tma 59>9 UY[Y d*a* ensak upoj parfajtnca fnpnfdty trdccarsoj djkdvdkunb routas*
Djtarracdojnb sarvdfas7 [unhnu/Sndhnto
N vary bnrca ju`ear ol sue`dssdojs fnbbak lor tma UY[Y to `nha provdsdoj lor n fo``utar
rndb sarvdfa to ea axtajkak to [unhnu8 njk lor tma fojtdjuntdoj ol tma eus sarvdfa eatwaaj
[unhnu njk Yuhahoma* Dt wns jotak tmnt tma Sndhnto Kdstrdft Foujfdb mns `nka ldjnjfdnb
provdsdoj lor nj upcrnka to tma [unhnu stntdoj to lnfdbdtnta n rndb sarvdfa" ns pnrt ol tma ldrst
stnca ol n fo``utar fojjaftdoj to Mn`dbtoj* Vue`dttars nbso jotak tmnt tma furrajt rndb turj
nroujk nrrnjca`ajts soutm ol Yuhahoma provdka so`a sfopa lor n fostallaftdva axtajsdojol tma rndb sarvdfa to [unhnu*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab nfhjowbakcas tmnt `ost trdps lro` [unhnu nra jortmwnrks
townrks Nufhbnjk" njk tmnt n sdcjdldfnjt ju`ear ol axdstdjc rndb usars lro` Yuhahoma
ordcdjnta lro` [unhnu njk tma Sndhnto Kdstrdft* Eafnusa [unhnu bdas outsdka tma Nufhbnjk
racdoj" Nufhbnjk [rnjsport wdbb jaak to worh wdtm Nufhbnjk Foujfdb" Sndhnto Uacdojnb
Foujfdb" Sndhnto Kdstrdft Foujfdb njk JW[N to axpbora tma `ost fost allaftdva njk aqudtneba
`njjar dj wmdfm puebdf trnjsport sarvdfas to [unhnu foubk ea provdkak dj tma lutura*
[ma Ynjab jotas tmnt njy axtajsdoj ol tma trndj sarvdfa to [unhnu woubk jaak to ea gustdldak
tmroucm nj npproprdnta eusdjass fnsa* [mds woubk jaak to tnha djto nffoujt tma potajtdnb
abaftrdldfntdoj ol tma bdja to Yuhahoma" njk tma lansdedbdty njk fosts ol axtajkdjc tma trndj
turjnroujk bofntdoj ns proposak ey sue`dttars* *
[ma Ynjab mns fojfbukak tmnt Nufhbnjk [rnjsport smoubk fojtdjua to worh wdtm tma Sndhnto
Kdstrdft njk Uacdojnb Foujfdbs to fojsdkar tma ost npproprdnta puebdf trnjsport
nrrnjca`ajts lor djtarracdojnb sarvdfas" tocatmar wdtm tma kavabop`ajt ol nj ncraa`ajt oj
mow tmay `dcmt ea lujkak*
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
30/57
69
Uafo``ajkntdojs7
Nkk jaw pobdfy 5*47 Djvastdcnta djtarracdojnb sarvdfas8 njk nftdojs7 -n$ Sorh wdtm
Nufhbnjk Foujfdb" Sndhnto Kdstrdft Foujfdb" Sndhnto Uacdojnb Foujfdb" njk JW[N to
djvastdcnta provdsdoj ol sarvdfas to fojjaft axtarjnb nrans nkgnfajt to racdojnb
eoujknrdas -a*c* [unhnu$ wdtm tmadr janrast puebdf trnjsport djtarfmnjca njk to
katar`dja npproprdnta lujkdjc nrrnjca`ajts8 njk -e$ Sorh wdtm Nufhbnjk Foujfdb"
Sndhnto Kdstrdft Foujfdb" Sndhnto Uacdojnb Foujfdb" njk JW[N to djvastdcnta tma
lansdedbdty" fosts njk lujkdjc optdojs lor nj axtajsdoj ol rndb sarvdfas to [unhnu*
Nkk ralarajfa to [unhnu eus sarvdfas dj Nppajkdx >N" wdtm n jota tmnt tmadr
oparntdoj ds suegaft to lujkdjc ncraa`ajt wdtm Sndhnto Uacdojnb Foujfdb*
Varvdfa qunbdty pobdfdas -Vaftdoj
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
31/57
6>
smoubk djfbuka support lor n eusas co ldrst fn`pndcj" to ajfournca krdvars to cdva wny to
eusas*
[ma Nufhbnjk [rnjsport Uonk Vnlaty [an` mns succastak tmnt ralarajfas dj tma Krnlt
UY[Y to djfransdjc tma spaak ol puebdf trnjsport sarvdfas ea rapbnfak wdtm d`provdjc
gourjay td`as*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab ncraas tmnt gourjay td`a ds d`portnjt" pnrtdfubnrby oj tma
lraquajt sarvdfa jatworh* [ma succastak fmnjca lro` djfransak spaak to d`provak trnvab
td`a ds supportak* Vtop rntdojnbdsntdoj ds oja bass djtrusdva `atmok ol nfmdavdjc tmds"
tocatmar wdtm sdcjnb prdordtdsntdoj* [ma Ynjab jotas tmnt tmara ds jo pbnj nt prasajt to provdka
axprass rndb sarvdfas or to fojsobdknta stntdojs* Vtntdoj spnfdjc njk oparntdojnb fojstrndjts
`anj tmnt rujjdjc axprass rndb sarvdfas oj tma Nufhbnjk jatworh ds ujbdhaby to ea n vdneba
sobutdoj*
[ma Ynjab ncraas wdtm tma succastdoj lor n eusas ldrst fn`pndcj* [mds ds nkkrassak ns pnrtol Yobdfy 1*; eabow*
Uafo``ajkntdojs7
Uapbnfa ralarajfas to djfransdjc trnvab spaaks dj tma Krnlt UY[Y" wdtm d`provdjc
gourjay td`as
Nkkdtdojnb nftdoj -a$ dj pobdfy 6*5 -pnca 6>$ workak ns7 %Fojsdkar spafdldf `ansuras
to d`prova tma spaak ol sarvdfas" sufm ns stop rntdojnbdsntdoj or eus prdordty sdcjnca"
wmara npproprdnta%
Fusto`ar sarvdfa njk krdvar trndjdjc
Vue`dssdojs dkajtdldak tma jaak lor krdvar trndjdjc to ea ncajfy ajkorsak -UJWLE" 1;
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
32/57
65
Djfbuka snlaty ujkar Yobdfy 6*6 nftdoj f ns lobbows7 Sorh dj pnrtjarsmdp wdtm
oparntors to fojtdjunbby d`prova rabdnedbdty" pujftunbdty" snlatynjk nbb nspafts ol
fusto`ar sarvdfa
N`ajk Yobdfy 6*6 nftdoj l$ to ralar to trndjdjc to `aat tma jaaks ol pnssajcars wdtm
spafdnb jaaks
\amdfba stnjknrks
N rnjca ol fo``ajts wara rafadvak oj vamdfba qunbdty stnjknrks* Vo`a sue`dttars soucmt
nkkdtdojnb lanturas -jotneby FO5 a`dssdojs njk luab alldfdajfy stnjknrks$" njk nbdcj`ajt
wdtm tma Nufhbnjk Ybnj FO5 a`dssdoj tnrcats -a*c* Sndta`ntn BE" 499$* [ma Eus , Fonfm
Nssofdntdoj -1>=$ njk JW Eus -16
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
33/57
66
Edhas oj eusas
N ju`ear ol sue`dttars dkajtdldak tma jaak to eattar djtacrnta fyfbdjc njk puebdf trnjsport"
djfbukdjc `nhdjc provdsdoj lor fnrrydjc edhas oj eusas*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab jotas tmnt edfyfbas fnj nbranky ea fnrrdak oj trndjs njk `ost
larrdas" eut tma prd`nry lujftdoj ol puebdf trnjsport ds to trnjsport paopba* Vpnfa nbbofntak lor
fyfba fnrrdnca rakufas tma ju`ear ol pnssajcars tmnt fnj ea nffo``okntak njk `ny ea
nj dssua oj eusy panh trdps* [ma spnfa `ny nbso ea raqudrak lor pnssajcars usdjc
wmaabfmndrs* @njy stntdojs njk djtarfmnjcas nbranky provdka safura stornca" eut tma Ynjab
nfhjowbakcas tmnt tmara nra opportujdtdas lor tmasa lnfdbdtdas to ea d`provak* [ma Ynjab
jotas tmnt tma vdnedbdty ol fnrrydjc edhas oj eusas dj so`a lor` ds furrajtby ujkar
djvastdcntdoj" njk tmnt Nufhbnjk [rnjsport ds worhdjc wdtm Fyfba Nftdoj Nufhbnjk njk otmar
hay stnhamobkars to nrrdva nt tma `ost npproprdnta njswar*
Uafo``ajkntdoj7
Djfbuka nftdoj to djvastdcnta `atmoks to ajneba fyfbdsts to eattar nffass tma puebdf
trnjsport systa`" djfbukdjc provdsdoj lor edhas oj sabaftak sarvdfas" njk tma
djstnbbntdoj ol edha rnfhs nt djtarfmnjcas njk stntdojs*
V`nbbar eusas
N ju`ear ol sue`dssdojs -djfbukdjc lro` so`a bofnb eonrks$ soucmt crantar usa ol s`nbbar
eusas" pnrtdfubnrby oj bofnb laakar routas wmara tma ronk `ny jot ea sudtneba lor bnrcar
eusas" or ka`njk ds jot mdcm*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab ncraas tmnt tma jaw jatworh wdbb provdka opportujdtdas lor `ora
djjovntdva nppronfmas to sarvdfa provdsdoj" djfbukdjc s`nbbar vamdfbas sufm ns `djdeusas oj
laakar sarvdfas* Yobdfy 6*; nftdoj -a$ nbranky djfbukas tma spafdldfntdoj ol vamdfba sdza to
`ntfm bofnb routa caocrnpmy njk bonkdjcs" eut tma djtrokuftory taxt to tmds saftdoj ol tma
UY[Y smoubk djfbuka so`a ralarajfa to tmasa opportujdtdas" njk dkajtdly wmara s`nbbar
eusas `ny ea sudtak" suegaft to djlor`ntdoj oj fostallaftdvajass*
Uafo``ajkntdoj7
N`ajk tma djtrokuftory taxt to saftdoj
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
34/57
6;
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab jotas tmnt Vaftdoj 6*< fovars n rnjca ol raportdjc nrans tmnt
jaak to ea nssassak to ajsura tmnt tmara ds trnjspnrajfy njk nffoujtnedbdty ol raportdjc
ncndjst axpaftak stnjknrks* Vo`a ol tmds raportdjc ds raqudrak ey JW[N8 so`a ey Nufhbnjk
[rnjsport to mabp pbnjjdjc or fojtrnft `njnca`ajt8 njk so`a woubk ea ol usa to oparntors
to nbbow lor fojtdjuous d`prova`ajt* [ma Ynjab nffapts tmnt tma nd` ol 6*< -c$ ds ns n
fntfmnbb" eut woubk djfbuka parlor`njfa oj dssuas sufm ns UNYDK racdstrntdoj rntas"nffdkajts njk JW[N Oparntor Vnlaty Untdjc crnkas* Mowavar" n fbanrar profass lor kanbdjc
wdtm oparntor fojfarjs neout fo``arfdnb fojldkajtdnbdty ds nfhjowbakcak*
Dj bdja wdtm tma Ynjabs ovarnbb fojfbusdojs rabntdjc to fusto`ar sarvdfa" n `ora spafdldf
fo``dt`ajt to tma usa ol fo`pbndjts dj fojtdjuous d`prova`ajt ds proposak*
Uafo``ajkntdoj7
N`ajk Yobdfy 6*< nftdoj -c$ to provdka lor n profass to worh wdtm oparntors to gustdly
djlor`ntdoj raquasts njk nkkrass fo``arfdnb fojldkajtdnbdty dssuas*
N`ajk Yobdfy 6*< nftdoj -m$ to spafdldfnbby ralar to fo`pbndjts profassas
Lnras njk tdfhatdjc pobdfdas -Vaftdoj
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
35/57
61
Vavarnb sue`dssdojs oegaftak to tma axfbusdoj ol larry lnras lro` tma zoja struftura*
Vue`dttars jotak tmnt tma lnras oj larry sarvdfas wara `ufm `ora axpajsdva tmnj lor
aqudvnbajt eus or rndb gourjays" njk tmnt tmds kdk jot sdt wabb wdtm tma fojfapt ol nj djtacrntak
jatworh*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab ncraas tmnt tma podjts rndsak dj sue`dssdojs nra vnbdk" njk
mdcmbdcmt tma jaak lor tma d`pba`ajtntdoj ol tma jaw lnra systa` to ea fnralubby njnbysak
ealora njy ldjnb kafdsdojs nra `nka* [ma Ynjab jotas tmnt tma zoja struftura ralbaftak
pravdous NU[N pobdfy" njk wns djtajkak to sd`pbdly lnras dj Nufhbnjk* Mowavar" dt mns
rndsak bacdtd`nta aqudty fojfarjs" njk tma s`nbb ju`ear ol zojas `ny rasubt dj bnrca
djfra`ajts lor frosseoujknry trnvab*
[ma Ynjab jotas tmnt Nufhbnjk [rnjsport ds ujkartnhdjc n `okabbdjc axarfdsa to katar`dja
tma bdhaby ravajua njk pntrojnca d`pnfts ol tma proposak zoja struftura njk n rnjca ol
otmar optdojs" djfbukdjc tmosa rndsak ey sue`dttars* Qjtdb tma rasubts ol tmds njnbysds nrahjowj njk kafdsdojs tnhaj" tma Ynjab eabdavas tmnt dt ds pra`ntura lor tma UY[Y to djfbuka n
spafdldf proposnb lor zoja eoujknrdas* Nfforkdjcby" dt ds proposak to ra`ova tma zoja `np
dj Ldcura ujtdb lurtmar njnbysds njk tnrcatak fojsubtntdoj ds fo`pbatak* Nt tmnt stnca" n
vnrdntdoj to tma UY[Y foubk ea ujkartnhaj* Larry lnras smoubk nbso ea djfbukak dj tma
njnbysds*
[ma Ynjab jotas tmnt kdstnjfaensak lnras mnva eaaj fojsdkarak pravdousby" eut tajk to ea
fo`pbax dj struftura njk nra cajarnbby bass trnjspnrajt njk sd`pba tmnj zojnb nbtarjntdvas*
Javartmabass" tma Ynjab fojfbukas tmnt tma ravdaw outbdjak neova smoubk nbso fojsdkar tma
nkvnjtncas njk kdsnkvnjtncas ol kdstnjfa ensak lnras ealora njy kafdsdoj ds `nka*
Uafo``ajkntdojs7
Sdtmkrnw tma zoja @np dj Ldcura njk n`ajk tma taxt njk pobdfdas rabntdjc to lnra
zojas to provdka lor d`pba`ajtntdoj ol nj ncraak zoja struftura njk lnra bavabs
lobbowdjc lurtmar njnbysds njk fojsubtntdoj" wdtm tma rasubts to ea djforporntak djto tma
UY[Y tmroucm n vnrdntdoj*
Djfbuka nj nssass`ajt ol larry lnras njk kdstnjfa ensak lnras ns pnrt ol tmds njnbysds
Lnra prokuftsN ju`ear ol sue`dttars axprassak fojfarjs neout tma boss ol axdstdjc lnra prokufts"
nbtmoucm tmasa fojfarjs nppanr to mnva eaaj ollsat ey otmars wmo wara supportdva ol tma
crantar sd`pbdfdty tmnt tmds ajnebas* Vo`a -a*c* U Foup" ;>1$ succastak tmnt tma prokuft
sd`pbdldfntdoj smoubk co lurtmar" wdtm ra`ovnb ol `ojtmby pnssas -njk tmadr rapbnfa`ajt wdtm
n `ojtmby lnra fnp$*
[ma provdsdoj ol lnra prokufts njk djfajtdvas to ajfournca oll panh trnvab -aspafdnbby lor
vdsdtors$" njk to ajneba ln`dby trnvab" aspafdnbby nt waahajks" wns rndsak ey so`a
sue`dttars* Ovarsans axn`pbas ol bow prdfak ln`dby trnvab wara fdtak" njk tma optdoj ol lraa
fmdbk trnvab wdtm nj nffo`pnjydjc MOY fnrk usar wns rndsak -@UFncjay" ;;$ mdcmbdcmtak tma kdlldfubtdas nssofdntak wdtm tma ra`ovnb
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
36/57
6=$ sue`dttak tmnt tma workdjc olYobdfy ;*1 nftdoj e dj tma
Krnlt UY[Y ujjafassnrdby fojlusas wmnt smoubk ea n sd`pba nftdoj wmdfm ds wabb kaldjak dj
Nppajkdx ;* Dt succasts tmnt tma nftdoj ea raworkak to ralar to tma lor`ubn sat out dj
Nppajkdx ;*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab jotas tmnt tma lnraeox rafovary pobdfy mns eaaj kasdcjak to
ajsura tmnt lnraeox ravajua wdbb `aat n ransojneba proportdoj ol oparntdjc fosts" njk to
ajsura tmnt Nufhbnjk [rnjsport fojtrdeutas to tma nfmdava`ajt ol tma JW[N 19! jntdojnb
lnraeox rafovary tnrcat* [ma Ynjab nbso jotas tmnt tma jatworh fmnjcas mnva eaaj
kasdcjak to usa tma sn`a bavab ol rasourfas ns nt prasajt" eut `ora alldfdajtby" to provdka n
`ora fojjaftak njk d`provak jatworh tmnt wdbb nttrnft djfransak pntrojnca* [ma djtajtdoj ds
to crow ravajua tmroucm djfransak pntrojnca" rntmar tmnj tmroucm lnra djfransas" eut tma
ovarnbb fost rafovary ol tma systa` mns to ea `njncak dj nfforknjfa wdtm tma lnraeox
rafovary tnrcats*
Mowavar" tma Ynjab smnras tma fojfarj ol sue`dttars tmnt nj nccrassdva nppronfm to
djfransdjc lnraeox rafovary rdshs ujkar`djdjc pntrojnca crowtm oegaftdvas* Sa smnra tma
fojfarj tmnt lnraeox rafovary tnrcats smoubk jot ea pursuak nt tma axpajsa ol otmar
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
37/57
63
d`portnjt conbs" sufm ns pntrojnca crowtm" aspafdnbby dl tmds raqudras lnra djfransas tmnt wdbb
nkvarsaby nllaft pntrojnca* [o tmds ajk" tmara ds n jaak to katar`dja tma optd u` ravajua
enbnjfa eatwaaj lnras njk pntrojnca* [ma UY[Y smoubk mdcmbdcmt tmds enbnjfa" njk nbso
`nha dt fbanr tmnt tma jntdojnb 19! lnraeox rafovary tnrcat mns eaaj sat ey JW[N" njk `ny
ea suegaft to lutura ravdaw*
[ma Ynjab nbso rafo``ajks tmnt tma UY[Y `ora fbanrby djkdfntas tmnt tma prdordty nftdojs to
nfmdava d`prova`ajts dj lnraeox rafovary smoubk ea to djfransa pntrojnca njk fnralubby
`njnca oparntdjc fosts" wdtm lnra djfransas eadjc nfforkak n bowar prdordty* -Vaa tma
kdsfussdoj njk rafo``ajkntdojs eabow dj saftdoj
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
38/57
6=
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab ncraas tmnt lnstar eonrkdjc td`as fnj provdka n sdcjdldfnjt
eajaldt dj ovarnbb gourjay td`as lor pnssajcars* Sa nbso ncraa tmnt `nxd`u` bd`dt ol storak
vnbua kdsfoujt dj Yobdfy ;*< e$ ds ujjafassnrdby rastrdftdva* Ua`ovnb ol tma 59! fadbdjc
kdllarajtdnb ds n sajsdeba proposnb tmnt woubk saa` avdkajt absawmara ns eadjc n suffasslub
wny to rnpdkby djfransa fnrk uptnha* Mowavar" tma Ynjab jotas tmnt djtrokufdjc njd``akdnta djfransa dj tma fnsm lnra pra`du` lobbowdjc NDLV d`pba`ajtntdoj ds n rdshy
strntacy" wmaj fusto`ars wdbb gust ea cattdjc usak to `ngor sarvdfa fmnjcas*
[ma Ynjab jotas tmnt tmara nra otmar potajtdnb nftdojs tmnt foubk nssdst MOY uptnha wmdfm
nra bnfhdjc" sufm ns d`provdjc nffass to MOY dj outbydjc nrans atf* Kua racnrk smoubk ea
cdvaj to djkdvdkunb fusto`ars wmo fnjjot nffass or usa n MOY fnrk lor so`a ransoj*
Uafo``ajkntdojs7
N`ajk pobdfy ;*
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
39/57
64
lnras mnk eaaj nvndbneba kurdjc tma avajdjc panh prdor to tma djtrokuftdoj ol tma VuparCobk
sfma`a* Yobdfy ;*3 proposas n ravdaw ol nbb fojfassdoj bavabs njk abdcdedbdty frdtardn" njk n
ravdaw ol tma Nufhbnjk VuparCobk nrrnjca`ajts wdbb ea ujkartnhaj ns pnrt ol tmds profass*
[ma Ynjab mns mdcmbdcmtak tma lnft tmnt tma pobdfy dj tma Krnlt UY[Y koas jot nkvofnta lor
ra`ovnb ol furrajt nrrnjca`ajts dt ds ojby sdcjnbbdjc n ravdaw* Mowavar" tma fo``ajtsrafadvak ns pnrt ol tma UY[Y profass smoubk ea tnhaj djto nffoujt ns pnrt ol tmnt ravdaw*
[ma Ynjab fojsdkars tmnt n racubnr ravdaw ol [otnb @oedbdty suesdky rntas woubk ea
npproprdnta*
Uafo``ajkntdojs7
[nha sue`dttars fo``ajts oj fojfassdoj lnras djto nffoujt ns pnrt ol tma ravdaw ol
fojfassdoj lnras" njk fo``ujdfnta tma laakenfh rafadvak to lujkars*
Nkk nj nftdoj dj Yobdfy ;*3 to ujkartnha racubnr ravdaws ol [otnb @oedbdty suesdkdas dj
fojsubtntdoj wdtm stnhamobkars" to katar`dja wmatmar suesdkdas `aat usar jaaks*
Ollpanh prdfdjc
Vo`a sue`dttars lnvourak n strojcar lofus oj tma ajfournca`ajt ol ollpanh pntrojnca
tmroucm prdfdjc `afmnjds`s* Lor axn`pba" tma Fn`pndcj lor Eattar [rnjsport -1>;$
succastak `ora nttrnftdva prdfdjc lor croup trnvab kurdjc ollpanh pardoks" aspafdnbby lor
ln`dbdas*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma sue`dssdojs `nha n vnbdk podjt neout tma potajtdnb lor ollpanh
kdsfoujts to djfransa pntrojnca dj tma jaw jatworh struftura" wmdfm ollars sdcjdldfnjtbycrantar djtarpanh trnvab opportujdtdas* [ma Ynjab saas tmds ns nj nkkdtdojnb podjt to tma
axdstdjc pobdfy lofus oj tma potajtdnb ol ollpanh kdsfoujts to d`prova oparntdojnb alldfdajfy"
rakufa fosts to oparntors njk d`prova tma alldfdajfy ol Y[O@ fojtrnfts*
Uafo``ajkntdojs7
Ualdja workdjc ol Yobdfy ;*=7 %Yrovdka ollpanh kdsfoujts to sprank panh ka`njk"
djfransa ovarnbb systa` pntrojnca" njk dl tmasa d`prova oparntdojnb alldfdajfy%
Uapbnfa furrajt Nftdoj n* wdtm %Yardokdfnbby ravdaw optdojs lor ollpanh lnra
kdsfoujts" dl jafassnry" to sprank panh ka`njk" `nha eattar usa ol rasourfas" njk
rakufa fosts Nftdvaby djvastdcnta njk d`pba ajt ollpanh lnra kdsfoujt optdojsto sprank panh ka`njk njk ajfournca ollpanh trdp `nhdjc*%
Djlrnstruftura pobdfdas -Vaftdoj
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
40/57
;9
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab ncraas tmnt tma provdsdoj ol djlrnstruftura" aspafdnbby nt
djtarfmnjcas" ds frdtdfnb to tma ovarnbb suffass ol tma jaw jatworh* Lor tmds ransoj" tma Ynjab
proposas tmnt tma Djlrnstruftura oegaftdva njk pobdfdas ea abavntak to n `ora pro`djajt
posdtdoj*
[ma Ynjab nbso eabdavas tmnt tma lujkdjc d`pbdfntdojs ol puebdf trnjsport djlrnstruftura jaakto ea `nka `ora axpbdfdt dj tma UY[Y*
Uafo``ajkntdoj7
Vmdlt saftdoj nftdoj n$ 7 %Kavabop nj ojcodjc
procrn``a ol djlrnstruftura d`prova`ajts ensak oj bavab ol sarvdfa djkdfntors
wdtm njk upcrnkas to d`prova gourjay td`as" rabdnedbdty" snlaty" njk tma fojjaftdoj
ajvdroj`ajt lor tma fusto`ar% Nkk nj nftdoj to djforpornta puebdf trnjsport sarvdfa raqudra`ajts njk djlrnstruftura
raqudra`ajts djto forrdkor `njnca`ajt pbnjs
Djfbuka nj nftdoj tmnt provdkas lor djlrnstruftura lujkdjc to ea prdordtdsak to ajsura
tmnt progafts tmnt nra jafassnry lor tma suffasslub d`pba`ajtntdoj ol sarvdfas to ea
lujkak dj n td`aby `njjar -wdtm npproprdnta frossralarajfas to tma lujkdjc pobdfdas
dj saftdoj
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
41/57
;>
woubk nssdst* [ma UJWLE -1;=$ rndsak fojfarjs nt tma succastdoj ol nffass fmnrcas lorpuebdf trnjsport lnfdbdtdas" njk tma potajtdnb lor tmds to rasubt dj nj djalldfdajt `ojayco
roujk*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma cajarnb taxt djtrokufdjc saftdoj
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
42/57
;5
[ma Ynjab jotas tmnt tma djtrokuftdoj ol N[ MOY ds bdhaby to bnrcaby rakufa fnsm lnra
eonrkdjcs ovar td`a" eut javar fo`pbataby* Smdba olleonrk tdfhatdjc `nfmdjas nt hay stops
nra nbranky pnrt ol tma pbnjjak fnpdtnb procrn``a" tma UY[Y smoubk rafocjdsa tma potajtdnb
dssua ol fnsm lnra eonrkdjcs rasubtdjc dj sdcjdldfnjt kabnys njk ujkar`djdjc bavab ol sarvdfa
oegaftdvas*
[ma Ynjab nfhjowbakcas tmnt tma furrajt workdjc dj tma Krnlt UY[Y ds jot fbanr ns to
wmatmar nffass fmnrcas wdbb lnbb oj oparntors or tma puebdf usdjc tma`" or eotm* Dj so`a
fnsas" sufm ns Ynrh , Udka" tma fusto`ar woubk pny* Fo``arfdnb sarvdfas `ny ea raqudrak
to pny nj nffass fmnrca to usa nj djtarfmnjca or larry wmnrl njk n pnssajcar fmnrca wdbb
fojtdjua to ea bavdak oj larry pnssajcars townrks wmnrl `ndjtajnjfa fosts* [ma Ynjab mns
fojfbukak tmnt tmds nftdoj smoubk ea fbnrdldak" ey kabatdjc tma ralarajfa to fmnrcas njk
nkkdjc n jaw nftdoj -a$ tmnt ds fbanr neout njy proposak fmnrcdjc lrn`aworh*
[ma Ynjab nbso jotas tma jaak to ajsura tmnt eus stops nra fojvajdajtby bofntak" aspafdnbby
wmara lraquajt sarvdfa routas djtarsaft njk trnjslars `ny ea raqudrak* [mds wdbb raqudra nravdaw ol tma furrajt prnftdfa ol bofntdjc stops so`a kdstnjfa lro` djtarsaftdojs" to nvodk tma
jaak lor bojc wnbhs eatwaaj stops*
Uafo``ajkntdojs7
Nkk n jaw nftdoj to pobdfy 1*67 Ajsura tmnt djlrnstruftura ajmnjfas fusto`ar snlaty
njk safurdty ey `aatdjc or axfaakdjc tma snlaty raqudra`ajts sat out dj kasdcj
cudkabdjas" ns npproprdnta to tma bofntdoj*
Nkk works to pobdfy 1*6 nftdoj f$ to7 %Ajsura tmnt eus stops njk djtarfmnjca lnfdbdtdas
lofus oj provdkdjc npproprdnta n ajdty njk smabtar" wmdba `nxd`dsdjc tmadr
nttrnftdvajass ns n jatworh nffass podjt lro` n fusto`ar parspaftdva% Nkk jaw nftdoj to Yobdfy 1*6 to djvastdcnta tma raqudra`ajt lor olleonrk tdfhatdjc
`nfmdjas nt mdcm ka`njk eus djtarfmnjcas njk stops*
N`ajk pobdfy 1*6" nftdoj n$ ey kabatdjc tma works %wdtm npproprdnta nffass
fmnrcas% njk nkk n jaw nftdoj -a$ tmnt fbnrdldas tma proposak fmnrcdjc racd`a
Nkk n jaw nftdoj to Yobdfy 1*6 to bofnta eus stops dj n wny tmnt nbbows lor qudfh njk
fojvajdajt nffass" aspafdnbby lor trnjslarrdjc pnssajcars
Eus prdordtdas
Vue`dttars supportak tma pobdfdas njk nftdojs rabntdjc to eus prdordtdas" to ajmnjfa sarvdfarabdnedbdty* Vpafdldf proposnbs lor nkkdtdojnb prdordtdas wara dkajtdldak" njk U Uutmarlork -;4=$
succastak strojcar staps nra jaakak to ajneba eus prdordty progafts to procrass* [mara wns
nbso support lor n eusas ldrst fn`pndcj" to ajfournca krdvars to cdva wny to eusas banvdjc
stops*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab ujkarstnjks tmnt cudknjfa nbranky axdsts wdtmdj Nufhbnjk
[rnjsports Foka ol Yrnftdfa to cudka eus prdordty raqudra`ajts njk trdccars lor djtarvajtdoj*
[mds smoubk ea ralbaftak dj tma ldjnb UY[Y" nt banst dj su``nry lor`" to ajneba tma puebdf to
eattar ujkarstnjk wmara eus prdordtdas wdbb ea provdkak" njk wmy*
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
43/57
;6
Smaj tma ldjnb jatworh struftura ds kaldjak tmroucm fojsubtntdoj oj bofnb katndb" n lurtmar
procrn``a ol worh wdbb ea trdccarak to kaldja dj `ora katndb wmnt djlrnstruftura djtarvajtdojs
wdbb ea raqudrak dj kdllarajt bofntdojs to kabdvar rabdnedbdty* Dj so`a djstnjfas" tmds wdbb ea eus
bnjas" eut n wdkar rnjca ol djtarvajtdojs wdbb ea fojsdkarak oj n fnsaeyfnsa ensds" rntmar
tmnj n ebnjhat djlrnstrufturabak nppronfm* [mds smoubk ea djlor`ak ey tma rasubts ol sarvdfa
rabdnedbdty `ojdtordjc*
N %Eusas ldrst% nppronfm ds supportak ey tma Ynjab*
Uafo``ajkntdojs7
Djfbuka ralarajfa to tma kasdcj prdjfdpbas lor eus prdordty lnfdbdtdas dj Nufhbnjk
[rnjsports Foka ol Yrnftdfa*
Nkk n jaw nftdoj dj Yobdfy 1*; to usa rabdnedbdty `ojdtordjc rasubts to djlor` tma
kavabop`ajt ol n eus prdordty d`pba`ajtntdoj procrn``a*
Nkk n jaw nftdoj to Yobdfy 1*;7 Yro`ota n Eusas Ldrst fn`pndcj tmnt ajfourncas
`otordsts to cdva wny to n eus banvdjc n stop
Ynrh njk rdka
Vue`dttars wara cajarnbby dj lnvour ol axpnjkak pnrh njk rdka lnfdbdtdas" pnrtdfubnrby dj outar
nrans" njk n ju`ear dkajtdldak bofntdojs wmara tmay fojsdkarak pnrh njk rdka smoubk ea
provdkak or axpnjkak* [ma d`portnjfa ol safurdty nt pnrh njk rdka lnfdbdtdas wns jotak ey
so`a -a*c* @njurawn BE" =4>$*
Vo`a sue`dttars jotak n potajtdnb fojlbdft eatwaaj pnrh njk rdka njk djtarfmnjca lnfdbdtdas*
[rnlldf njk [rnjsportntdoj Fojsubtnjts -;
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
44/57
;;
lujkak nra tmosa tmnt `nha tma `ost fost allaftdva fojtrdeutdoj to tma suffasslub
d`pba`ajtntdoj ol tma jatworh*
Uafo``ajkntdojs7
Uavdsa Yobdfy 1*1 e$ ldrst njk tmdrk eubbats ns lobbows7
o %Ynrh njk Udka ds pbnjjak ns nj djtacrnb pnrt ol tma puebdf trnjsport jatworh
-djfbukdjc tma assajtdnb lujftdoj ol eus laakars$" axtajks tma puebdf trnjsport
fusto`ar ensa" njk ajfourncas puebdf trnjsport pntrojnca%
o %Ynrh njk Udka lnfdbdtdas nra bofntak sufm tmnt tmay to rabdava fojcastdoj ey
djtarfaptdjc fo``utar trnlldf" njk to ajsura tmnt vamdfbas nffassdjc tma
lnfdbdtdas ko jot worsaj bofnb trnlldf fojcastdoj %
Nkk nj nftdoj to fo`pbata n Ynrh njk rdka strntacy wmdfm fbnrdldas tma roba ol pnrh
njk rdka wdtmdj tma puebdf trnjsport jatworh" njk sats fbanr prdordtdas lor lutura
djvast`ajt" lujkdjc njk prdfdjc*
Qpknta `np ol Ynrh njk Udka bofntdojs dj Nppajkdx
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
45/57
;1
*
Djtacrntdoj wdtm pnrhdjc
Vo`a sue`dttars -a*c* JW Eus" 16
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
46/57
;=$ raquastak n strojcar fo``dt`ajt to provdkdjc sfmoob
eus sarvdfas to rakufa tma jaak lor pnrajts to krdva tmadr fmdbkraj" njk tmaraey rakufa trnlldf
fojcastdoj*
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
51/57
1>
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab eabdavas tmnt dssuas ol snlaty lor sfmoob fmdbkraj smoubk ea
nkkrassak ns pnrt ol tma djlrnstruftura pobdfdas kdsfussak neova" eut spafdldf ralarajfa ns
pnrt ol Yobdfy 3*6 ds npproprdnta* Smdbst tma Krnlt UY[Y jotas tmnt sfmoob eusas dj rurnb
nrans nra provdkak ey tma @djdstry ol Akufntdoj" dt ds sdbajt oj tma `afmnjds`s ey wmdfm
#eoujknry dssuas# nra rasobvak" njk nj nkkdtdojnb nftdoj to worh wdtm tma @djdstry oj tmasa
`nttars ds proposak*
[ma Ynjab jotas tmnt dt ds djtajkak tmnt kakdfntak sfmoob eusas wdbb ea fojtdjuak" bnrcaby ns
nt prasajt* Nj axtajsdoj to tma axdstdjc pobdfy oj sfmoob sarvdfas ns succastak ey tma Eus ,
Fonfm Nssofdntdoj ds jot supportak" ns tma rasourfas jaakak to fnrry out tmds nftdoj woubk
ea sdcjdldfnjt" njk tma raqudrak lujkdjc `ny jot ea nvndbneba* Nkkdjc jaw sfmoob eus
sarvdfas `ny ea fojsdkarak dj tma fojtaxt ol n sarvdfa ravdaw wmara racubnr sarvdfa
rabdnedbdty ds nllaftak ey bnfh ol fnpnfdty" sufm tmnt n sfmoob eus ds wnrrnjtak*
Uafo``ajkntdojs7
Nkk to nftdoj 3*6-e$ or -a$ pnca ;6 tmnt sfmoob eus pbnjjdjc wdbb tnha djto nffoujt" nslnr ns ds prnftdfneba" tma jaak to ajsura tmnt wmara sfmoob eus sarvdfas fnj ea
provdkak `ora alldfdajtby ey raqudrdjc trnjslars tmasa wdbb ea nt snla bofntdojs wmara
suparvdsdoj ds nvndbneba
Nkk nj nkkdtdojnb nftdoj to Yobdfy 3*6 tmnt ranks7 %Sorh wdtm @djdstry ol Akufntdoj to
pardokdfnbby ravdaw njy dssuas tmnt nrdsa oj tma urenj/rurnb lrdjcas ol tma Nufhbnjk
racdoj to ajsura tmnt allaftdva njk jojkupbdfntdva provdsdoj ol eus sarvdfas ds
nfmdavak*%
Fojfassdoj lnras lor trnjsport kdsnkvnjtncak[mds dssua mns eaaj kdsfussak dj katndb ns pnrt ol saftdoj
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
52/57
15
Yrofura`ajt njk fo``arfdnb sarvdfas pobdfdas -Vaftdoj =$ opposas Yobdfy =*; -k$ wmdfm provdkas lor ratajkardjc
ol ujdts nllaftak ey n jatworh fmnjca wmara ncraa`ajt fnjjot ea ranfmak wdtm nbb nllaftakoparntors* N `akdntdoj or nredtrntdoj profass ds proposak ns nj nbtarjntdva*
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
53/57
16
Oparntors nbso oegaftak to tma Yobdfy =*; -m$ raqudra`ajt to provdka djlor`ntdoj oj sarvdfa
djputs njk fost alldfdajfy" oj tma croujks tmnt tmds coas wabb eayojk tma ncraa`ajts `nka
ey Y[O@ pnrtdas*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab eabdavas tmnt tma fojfarjs rndsak dj rabntdoj to ratajkardjc nravnbdk* Dt ds jot tma djtajtdoj lor ratajkardjc ol ujdts to ea fojsdkarak nt njy stnca tmnt wns
jot n bnst rasort* [ma djsartdoj ol n `akdntdoj pmnsa ds ajtdraby npproprdnta*
[ma Ynjab nbso succasts tmnt lurtmar fojsdkarntdoj ds cdvaj ns to wmatmar tma djlor`ntdoj oj
sarvdfa djputs njk fost alldfdajfy ds n vnbdk raqudra`ajt" njk tmnt tmds ds kdsfussak wdtm
oparntors* Nj ujkartnhdjc oj kntn fojldkajtdnbdty `ny nbso ea wortm djfbukdjc*
Uafo``ajkntdojs7
N`ajk Yobdfy =*; -k$" eubbat 6 to rank7 %Dl nbb oparntors ol nllaftak Y[O@ ujdts fnjjot
ncraa n jacotdntak sobutdoj" lobbowdjc `akdntdoj" Nufhbnjk [rnjsport rasarvas tmardcmt to tajkar tma nllaftak Y[O@ ujdts*%
Cdva lurtmar fojsdkarntdoj to djlor`ntdoj raqudra`ajts dj fojsubtntdoj wdtm oparntors
njk djfbuka nj nftdoj racnrkdjc kntn fojldkajtdnbdty dj Yobdfy =*; -njk spafdldf
nrrnjca`ajts lor trant`ajt ol sarvdfa djput njk fostalldfdajfy djlor`ntdoj$
Fo``arfdnb sarvdfasLubbars Croup -1=>$ sue`dttak tmnt tma
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
54/57
1;
[ma Nufhbnjk Foujfdb [rnjsport Vtrntacy [an` -19>$ jotak so`a djfojsdstajfy dj mow tma
lnraeox rafovary tnrcats nra ralarajfak dj tma Krnlt UY[Y" njk rafo``ajkak usa ol tma
tar` npproxd`ntaby 19! dj rabntdoj to tma ovarnbb tnrcat*
Vo`a sue`dttars quardak tma mdcmar lnraeox rafovary tnrcat lor larry sarvdfas" njk jotak tmnttma fnbfubntdoj djfbukas so`a" eut jot nbb" fo``arfdnb larry sarvdfas* JW[N -114$ jotak tmnt
dj lutura" tma lnra ravajua lro` fo``arfdnb sarvdfas wmdfm nra axa`pt ujkar tma B[@N Edbb
wdbb jot ea djfbukak dj tma Lnraeox rafovary rntdo" njk tmnt tma tnrcats smoubk ea nkgustak
kowjwnrks nfforkdjcby* [mds `ny raqudra n lootjota*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 Ns jotak neova" tma Ynjab smnras tma fojfarj tmnt lnraeox rafovary
smoubk jot ea pursuak nt tma axpajsa ol otmar d`portnjt conbs" sufm ns pntrojnca crowtm"
aspafdnbby dl tmds raqudras lnra djfransas tmnt wdbb nkvarsaby nllaft pntrojnca* [o tmds ajk" wa
rafo``ajk tmnt tma UY[Y djkdfnta nj orkar ol prdordty lor tma nftdojs tmnt smoubk ea lobbowak
to nfmdava lnraeox rafovary tnrcats" wdtm lnra djfransas eadjc nfforkak n bowar prdordty tmnjpntrojnca crowtm or oparntdjc fost snvdjcs*
[ma Ynjab jotas tmnt tma raspojsa to tma fnbfubntdoj ol larry lnraeox rafovary jaaks to tnha
nffoujt ol kafdsdojs rabntdjc to axa`pt sarvdfas" ns outbdjak neova* Mowavar" n lootjota dj
tma UY[Y to dkajtdly tmds dssua woubk ea npproprdnta*
Uafo``ajkntdojs7
Nkk n lootjota to jota tmnt larry LUU wdbb ea ravdawak pajkdjc tma ldjnb katar`djntdoj
olaxa`ptsarvdfas ojfa tma B[@N Edbb ds ajnftak*
Uavdsa taxt to mdcmbdcmt tma lnft tmnt tma lnraeox rafovary pobdfy -njk tma jntdojnb19! tnrcat$ ds n raqudra`ajt ol tma JW[N*
Uavdsa taxt to ea fojsdstajt wdtm kafdsdojs oj saftdoj
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
55/57
11
Uafo``ajkntdoj7
Nkk nj nftdoj to Yobdfy 4*6 to ajsura tmnt tma nvndbneba fnpdtnb lujkdjc ds kdraftak to
tma puebdf trnjsport djlrnstruftura progafts tmnt wdbb `nha tma `ost allaftdva
fojtrdeutdoj to tma jaw jatworh struftura*
@ojdtordjc njk ravdaw pobdfdas -Vaftdoj 9$
[ma `ojdtordjc pobdfdas wara cajarnbby supportak ey sue`dttars* Vo`a `nka spafdldf
succastdojs lor nkkdtdojs or kabatdojs" ns lobbows8
Djfbuka djlor`ntdoj oj mow parlor`njfa rasubts wdbb ea `nka puebdf -N Sabbar" 531$
Djfbuka djkdfntor ol ju`ear ol goes bofntak wdtmdj x `atras ol n lraquajt sarvdfa -N
Qptoj" ;99$
Djfbuka `ansura ol td`abdjass ol sarvdfas nt djtarfojjaftdoj podjts -NUYMV" 155$
Fbnrdly wmnt ds `anjt ey rabdnedbdty njk oj td`a -NUYMV" 155$
N`ajk Jortmarj Axprass HYD to Jortmarj euswny -CS @fBaok" >9$
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 [ma Ynjab fojsdkars tmnt tmasa succastdojs mnva `ardt" njk Yobdfy >9*>
smoubk ea n`ajkak nfforkdjcby*
Uafo``ajkntdoj7
N`ajk Yobdfy >9*> to djforpornta sue`dttar succastdojs bdstak neova*
Fmnptar 37 Kasfrdptdoj ol sarvdfas
N bnrca ju`ear ol sue`dssdojs ralarrak to spafdldf sarvdfas or bofntdojs* Vo`a ol tmasa
wara usak to dbbustrnta fojfarjs wdtm tma ovarnbb jatworh fojfapt -ns kdsfussak neova dj
Fmnptar 1$8 eut `ost sue`dssdojs ol tmds jntura rabntak to raquasts lor tma lutura systa` to
ratndj" nkk or n`ajk spafdldf sarvdfas* Vo`a djfojsdstajfdas wara dkajtdldak eatwaaj tma
bdstdjcs dj [nebas 3> njk 35 njk tma katndb dj Nppajkdx >*
Ynjab Uaspojsa7 Vuegaft to npprovnb ol tma ovarnbb jatworh fojfapt" tma Ynjab jotas tmnt dt
ds djtajkak to nkkrass tmasa sarvdfaspafdldf succastdojs ns pnrt ol tma katndbakd`pba`ajtntdoj ol tma jaw sarvdfas" wmdfm wdbb ea ujkartnhaj dj stncas* Sa nra nkvdsak
tmnt sue`dttars wdbb ea fojtnftak ns pnrt ol tma bofnb fojsubtntdoj profassas lor tmds
d`pba`ajtntdoj" wmdfm wdbb ajneba tma podjts rndsak to ea fojsdkarak dj `ora katndb* [ma
td`atneba lor tmds bofnb fojsubtntdoj njk d`pba`ajtntdoj ds ns lobbows7
Nran/s Fojsubtntdoj njk D`pba`ajtntdoj
Voutm Nufhbnjk 59>6 59>;
Jortm Nufhbnjk 59>; 59>1
Fajtrnb" Anst njk Sast Nufhbnjk 59>; 59>
7/28/2019 Submitter Update - RPTP Hearings Panel Report (Post Hearings)
56/57
1