30

Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy
Page 2: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Overview

Discussion of several options for PCMNHp Nelson Architects and MKK Engineers site visit –

December 6th and 7th

Existing facility – well maintained but near end of life cycle

Code and design issues – modifications will require compliance with new codes

Page 3: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Existing Nursing Home

12,442 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity,44 q 43 p y Original building built in 1964 –

7,560 sq. ft.12 double occupancy rooms; two rooms share toilet room 12 double occupancy rooms; two rooms share toilet room

1978 – addition added to east 4,882 sq. ft. 9 more double rooms

No central kitchen or laundry facilities

Page 4: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Site Configuration

Site is a square city blockq y Hospital and nursing home in center Expansion potential to south and southwestp p

Page 5: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Architectural Evaluation

Page 6: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Roof System

Page 7: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Windows

Page 8: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Other structural issues

Asbestos ADA Shower rooms Corridor used as receiving area Nurse’s station needs remodelingg Lack of office space

Page 9: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Mechanical System Evaluation

Resident Unit HVAC – cannot be used to provide pventilation air for resident units Need new unit

Resident unit exhaust fans Indoor environmental quality for ancillary spaces Air handling equipment in offices, common space Crawlspace ventilation Etc.

Page 10: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Electrical System Evaluation

PCMH provides entire electrical infrastructure to pserve nursing home including fire alarm phone and emergency power

All of electrical equipment nearing end of expected useful life

Page 11: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Preliminary Space Program

Allocation of types of areas and square footage yp q gneeded for project

Developed from input from Administration , staff and results of Long Term Care Market Analysis completed by CBI

Page 12: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Preliminary Space Allocation – Nursing Home Only

30 single occupancy rooms3 g p y 10 double occupancy rooms Public areas – 874 sq. ft. 74 q Nursing Home - 13,191 sq. ft. Building Support Space (offices, kitchen, laundry, g pp p ( , , y,

conference room, storage, etc.) – 9930 sq. ft. Building circulation – 2399 sq. ft. Total – 26,394 S.F. 68.2% common area; 11.8% net rentable area

Page 13: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Preliminary Space Allocation – Nursing Home and Assisted Livingand Assisted Living

Nursing Home – 50 bed 30 single occupancy rooms 10 double occupancy rooms

Assisted Living 22 unit Assisted Living – 22 unit 7 one bedroom, single occupancy (416 sq. ft.) 15 studio, single occupancy (320 sq. ft.) Public area - 748 sq. ft. Nursing Home – 11,470 sq. ft. Assisted Living – 10,996 sq. ft. Assisted Living 10,996 sq. ft. Building Support Space – 11,506 sq. ft. Building circulation – 3744 sq. ft. T t l q f t 41 185 Total square foot – 41,185

Page 14: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Option 1

Expansion and renovation of existing NH to bring it p g ginto compliance and to give staff needed space to operate efficiently

Does not include kitchen or laundry facilities Does not address additional nursing home beds,

i t d li i it assisted living units, or memory care No room to relocate residents while renovation takes

placeplace Total probable costs - $2,496,512 ($160/s.f.)

Page 15: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Option 2 – Phased Expansion

Phase I- new 50 bed nursing home to south of 5 gexisting facility

Phase II - remodeling and addition of existing nursing home facility into assisted living facility

Would include laundry and kitchen Stand-alone from hospital yet maintain campus

conceptO l h ll f b ildi b d Only shell of building can be reused

$7,132,027 ($165/s.f.)

Page 16: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Option 3 – Phased Approach

Phase I – new 50 bed nursing home to south of 5 gexisting facility

Phase II – demolition of existing facility Phase III - construction of new ALF in its place $7,460,870 ($181/s.f.)

Page 17: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Option 4

New 50 bed nursing home and 22 unit ALF in a new 5 gfacility on a new site

$7,946,166 ($193/s.f.) not including land acquisition

Page 18: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Option 5

50 bed nursing home in a new facility on a new site 5 g y(no ALF)

$5,235,163 ($198/sf)

Page 19: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Summary Options

Option1 Option 2 Option 3 Option 4 Option 5

Expand/ New 50 bed New 50 bed New 50 bed New 50 bed Expand/Renovate existing NH

New 50 bed NH

New 50 bed NH

New 50 bed NH and 22 unit ALF –new site

New 50 bed NH on new site

No kitchen, laundry or added

it

Remodel existing NH to ALF

Demolish and rebuild existing as ALF

Does not include land acquisition

capacity ALF

No relocation plan

$ illi $ illi $ illi $ illi $ illi$2.5 million($160/sf)

$7.1 million($165/sf)

$7.5 million(181/sf)

$7.9 million($193/sf)

$5.2 million($198/sf)

Page 20: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Eden Alternative or

The Green House Model

Page 21: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

“Elders exist because they show us how to make a community. As we give to them, they give us their wisdom, their experience, their affection They instruct us in the art ofaffection. They instruct us in the art of caring. There is no more precious gift than that.”

-From “In the Arms of Elders” by William H. Thomas, M.D.

Page 22: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Residential long-term care that involves a total rethinking of the philosophy of care, architecture and organizational structure normally associated with long term carenormally associated with long-term care.

Vision of Dr. William Thomas, a Harvard-educatedVision of Dr. William Thomas, a Harvard educated geriatrician. Author of “What are Old People For?

Page 23: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Loneliness vs. companionship Helplessness vs. opportunities to give care Boredom vs. variety and spontaneity

Page 24: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

◦ Living together intentionallyW◦ Warm◦ Small◦ FlatFlat◦ Rooted beliefs vs. rules◦ Smart technology

G◦ Green

Page 25: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Independent, self-contained home for six to twelve people

Designed to look like (and BE) a private home or apartment in the surrounding communityor apartment in the surrounding community

Licensed as skilled nursing facilities or ALF Each person has a private bedroom and full Each person has a private bedroom and full

bathroom, opening to a central hearth/living area and open kitchen and dining areap g

Elders share meals at a common table

Page 26: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

“Shahbazim” Core training as CNAs Provide personal care, meal preparation, and

li h h k i d l dlight housekeeping and laundry Clinical support team includes nurses, social

workers therapists physicians activities andworkers, therapists, physicians, activities and dietary professionals and pharmacists

Nurses serve each Green House on a 24-hour Nurses serve each Green House on a 24 hour basis – one nurse covers two homes during the day and evening and up to three at night.

Page 27: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Built on equality, empowerment, and mutual respect

Elders can help cook, assist with light housekeeping and laundryhousekeeping and laundry.

No predetermined routine

Page 28: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Intentional communities Recognizing and valuing individuality of

elders and staffH i d h i Honoring autonomy and choice

Providing privacy Offering meaningful activity and Offering meaningful activity and

engagements Offering comprehensive care Offering comprehensive care Creating an atmosphere of security

Page 29: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy

Quality of life and social participation for elders will be better

Improved health outcomesM i i f i l i b f Maximize functional capacity because of small-scale environment and freedom from institutional routinesinstitutional routines

Page 30: Tab 5 - Prelim Architectural Facility Evaluation · Existing Nursing Home 12,44,44 q 43 p y2 sq. ft. 43 bed capacity Original building built in 1964 – 7,560 sq. ft. 12 double occupancy