March 2018

TABLE OF JUDICIAL REVIEW

(Volume 27 to present)

DecisionAppealed

11,856 Jackson v Sobol et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Doran, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; April 5, 1988, n.o.r.; aff’d 170 AD2d 718 (3d Dept 1991).

11,869 Albion CSD v Canteen Company, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Williams, J.; Judgment granted annulling decision; November 13, 1987, n.o.r.

11,881 Blake, et al. v Sobol. et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Tern; Cobb, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; May 3, 1988, n.o.r.

11,887 Swezey v Sobol, et al.; US District Court, Eastern District; Wexler, J.; Order of discontinuance entered; December 13, 1988, n.o.r.

11,893 Goodline v Bd. of Ed., Warwick Valley CSD and Sobol; US District Court, Southern District; Goettel, J.; case settled, order entered; February 12, 1990, n.o.r.

11,909 Cronin v Bd. of Ed., East Ramapo CSD and Sobol; US District Court, Southern District; Ward, J.; motion for prelim. inj. granted; 689 F.Supp. 197 (SDNY, 1988); case settled, order entered; March 17, 1989, n.o.r.

11,910 Kron v Sobol et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Connor, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; February 19, 1990, n.o.r.

11,920 Pronin v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Connor, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; September 21, 1988, n.o.r.

11,923 Engel v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Bradley, J.; Judgment granted annulling decision; November 21, 1988, n.o.r.; aff’d 161 AD2d 873 (3d Dept. 1990).

11,976 Birden v Sobol, et al.; US District Court, Eastern District; Sifton, J.; case settled, order entered; October 21, 1988, n.o.r.

1

11,979 Williamsville CSD v Sobol and Albert; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Prior, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; February 10, 1989, n.o.r.

11,980 Cardo v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Connor, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; April 25, 1989, n.o.r.; motion for reargument denied; December 7, 1989, n.o.r.

11,983 Matter of Section XI NYS Public H.S. Athletic Association, Inc. v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Hughes, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; August 24, 1988, n.o.r.

11,985 Holmes v Sobol, et al.; 690 FSupp. 154 (WDNY 1988); case settled, order entered; September 12, 1990.

11,987 Schuylerville CSD v Commissioner of Education, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Cheeseman, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; October 26, 1988, n o r.; affd 152 AD2d 241 (3d Dept. 1989).

11,995 Kron v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Connor, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; May 10, 1989, n.o.r.

12,028 Floryan v Bd. of Ed., New Paltz CSD, et al.; US District Court, Northern District; McAvoy, J.; Order of discontinuance entered; April 20, 1992, n.o.r.

12,045 Schwarz v Mt. Pleasant Cottage UFSD, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Cheeseman, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review, subnom.; Mt Pleasant Cottage UFSD v Sobol; May 2, 1989, n.o.r.; aff’d 163 AD2d 715; aff’d 78 NY2d 938 (1991).

12,066 Kron v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Connor, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; December 30, 1989, n.o.r.

12,076 Pine Plains Central School District v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Conway, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; June 7, 1989, n.o.r.

12,077 Dionisio v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Prior, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; August 17, 1989, n.o.r.

12,119 Fogelman v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; McDermott, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; November 22, 1989, n.o.r.

2

12,124 Stellato v Bd. of Ed., Ellenville CSD, et al.; US District Court, Northern District; McAvoy, J.; case settled, dismissed as against Commissioner of Education; September 10, 1991, n.o.r.

12,146 Tombler v Bd. of Ed., Brookhaven-Comsewogue UFSD, et al.; Order of discontinuance entered; June 1990.

12,155 Bd. of Ed. of Northeast Central School District v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Kahn, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; December 14, 1989, n.o.r.; mod in part 170 AD2d 80; mod and decision of Commissioner aff’d 70 NY3d 598 (1992).

12,172 Bd. of Ed., Uniondale UFSD v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Bradley, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; March 5, 1991, n.o.r.

12,216 Cargill v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Harris J.; Judgment granted annulling decision; order entered May 10, 1990; aff’d 165 AD2d 131; appeal denied 78 NY2d 854.

12,219 O’Connor v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Cobb, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; July 20, 1990, n.o.r.; aff’d 173 AD2d 74; appeal dismissed 80 NY3d 897 (1992).

12,220 Bd. of Ed., Ramapo CSD v Sobol; Supreme Court, Rockland County; Silverman, J.; Order of discontinuance entered; August, 1990.

12,230 Alexandra V.N. v Sobol, et al.; Stipulation and order dismissing petition as against Commissioner; October 9, 1990.

12,299 Frutiger v Hamilton CSD and Sobol; Case sett1ed; order of discontinuance; August 12, 1991.

12,318 Shenendehowa CSD v Bd. of Ed., Waterford-Halfmoon UFSD and Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Harris, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; January 10, 1991; aff’d 182 AD2d 944 (1992).

12,320 BOE, Malverne UFSD v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Cobb, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; May 5, 1991, n.o.r.; aff’d 181 AD2d 370 (1992).

12,395 Hable v Sobol, et al.; Application to review decision pending.

12,409 Vecchio v Sobol and Bd. of Ed., East Islip UFSD; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Cobb, J,; Judgment granted dismissing

3

petition to review; August 27, 1991; aff’d 189 AD2d 961; mot. for leave to appeal den. 81 NY2d 709, May 4, 1993.

12,438 BOE, Brentwood UFSD v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Conway, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; September 3, 1991, n.o.r.

12,484 Save Our Students v Sobol, et al.; Application to review decision pending.

12,497 Davis, et al. v Comm. of Educ. and Bd.of Ed., Roxbury CSD; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Kahn, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; February 4,1992, n.o.r.; aff’d 189 AD2d 1046 (3d Dept. 1993).

12,499 Sewanhaka CHSD v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Cardona, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; April 14, 1992, n.o.r.

12,515 Jacobs v Sobol and BOCES of Putnam / Northern Westchester; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Torraca, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; January 16, 1992, n.o.r.

12,534 Levofsky v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Travers, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; March 30, 1992, n.o.r.

12,584 Watkins v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Cardona, J.; Judgment granted annulling decision and remitting matter for further proceedings; July 23,1992, n.o.r.; appeal withdrawn; December 16, 1993.

12,594 Rosenberg v Half Hollow Hills CSD and Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Hughes, J; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; March 13, 1992, n.o.r.; appeal pending. Seligman v Sobol and Half Hollow Hills CSD; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Connor, J; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; June 16, 1992, n.o.r.

12,601 Malley v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Keegan, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; June 22, 1992, n.o.r.

12,616 Lessen v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Hughes, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; June 23, 1992, n.o.r.

4

12,637 Troy v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Khan, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; March 11, 1996, n.o.r.

12,743 Danin v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Keegan, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; March 18, 1993, n.o.r.

12,745 Impellizzeri, et al. v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; February 1995, n.o.r.

12,768 Garnett v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Harris, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; July 13, 1994, n.o.r.; aff’d 222 AD2d 850, 634 NYS2d 882 (3d Dept 1995) (December 14, 1995); mot. for lv. to appeal denied, 87 NY2d 810, 642 NYS2d 859, 665 NE2d 661 (1996) (March 28, 1996); cert denied 519 U.S. 849, 117 S. Ct. 138, 136 L. Ed. 2d 86 (1996).

12,789 Schachter v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Queens County, Special Term; Application to review decision pending.

12,796 Schachter v Sobol; Supreme Court, Queens County, Special Term; Application to review decision pending.

12,797 BOE, Beacon City School District v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Spain, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; August 17, 1994, n.o.r.; aff’d 212 AD2d 76 (1995).

12,837 BOE, City School District, City of Lackawanna v Sobol, et al.; Application to review decision pending.

12,838 Fehr v Sobol, et al.; complaint filed USDC, Northern District; March 24, 1993; Matter stayed pending administrative proceeding; reopening issued, 33 Ed Dept Rep 403.

12,858 Boron v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Toracca, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; July 20, 1993, n.o.r.; aff’d 205 AD2d 28, 617 NYS2d 243 (3d Dept 1994); mot. for lv. to appeal den. 86 NY2d 711, 635 NYS2d 947, 659 NE2d 770 (1995).

12,866 Lawrence v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Canfield, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; January 3, 1994.

12,883 Board of Education of the City of New York v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Cobb, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; July 16, 1993, n.o.r.

5

12, 937 Sewanhaka CHSD v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Toracca, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; March 4, 1994, n.o.r.; aff’d 210 AD2d 675 (3rd Dept 1994).

12,961 Silano v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Hughes, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; January 10, 1994, n.o.r.

12,969 Ulster County BOCES v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; February 17, 1994, n.o.r.

12,999 Board of Education, Sewanhaka CHSD v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Keegan, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; May 25, 1994, nor.; aff’d 213 AD2d 844 (1995).

13,013 Palyo v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Canfield, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; May 12, 1994, n.o.r.

13,020 Vaughan v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Canfield J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; March 1994, n.o.r.

13,032 Martin v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Williams, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; April 7, 1994, n.o.r.; appeal pending.

13,040 Gaffney v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Connor, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; March 3l, 1994, n.o.r.; aff’d 210 AD2d 810 (1995).

13,041 Blumenblatt v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, New York County; Lehner, J.; Judgment transferring to Albany County; November 4, 1994; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Canfield, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; June 18, 1997, n.o.r.; appeal dismissed for failure to perfect.

13,052 Friedman v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Hughes, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; May 20, 1994, n.o.r.

13,057 Merritt v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Hughes, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; May 31, 1994, n.o.r.

6

13,075 Gutilla v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Canfield, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; January 1995; appeal pending.

13,087 Cerilli v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Connor, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; October 14, 1994, n.o.r.

13,104 McMahon v Sobol et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Torraca, J.; Judgment granted annulling decision and remitting matter for further proceedings; December 20, 1994, n.o.r.; aff’d 235 AD2d 635 (3d Dept. 1997).

13,159 Bradshaw v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Torraca, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; December 20, 1994, n.o.r.; appeal pending.

13,166 Newman v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Torraca, J.; Judgment transferring to Appellate Division, Third Department; February 3, 1995, n.o.r.

13,176 Yastion v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County Special Term; Canfield, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; March 6, 1994, n.o.r.; aff’d 229 AD2d 775 (3d Dept. 1996).

13,223 Lisbon CSD v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Ceresia, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; January 27, 1995, n.o.r.; aff’d 226 AD2d 945 (3d Dept.1996).

13,275 Thomas v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Hughes, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; May 9, 1995, n.o.r.

13,290 Manning v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review.

13,323 Martin v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Williams, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; April 7, 1994, n.o.r.

13,397 Greenburgh v Sobol; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Ceresia, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; December 20, 1995, n.o.r.; aff’d 237 AD2d 721 (3d Dept. 1997).

13,430 Fiore v Sobol, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Kahn, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; March 6, 1995, n.o.r.

7

13,433 Allen, et al. v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Carpinello, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition and remanding to Commissioner for consideration of additional issues; January 15, 1996, n.o.r.

13,446 Delhi Central School District v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Hughes, J.; Judgment granting petition, annulling decision of Commissioner and remanding to Commissioner for further consideration; February 21, 1996, n.o.r.

13,501 Boyle v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Hughes, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; June 10, 1996, n.o.r.

13,505 Bd. of Ed., Monticello CSD v Commissioner of Education, et al.; Judgment granted transferring to Appellate Division, Third Department; Judgment granted annulling decision of Commissioner, 235 AD2d 734 (3d Dept. 1997); aff’d 91 NY2d 133 (1997).

13,517 Crawmer v Mills; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Hughes, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; May 17, 1996, n.o.r.; aff’d 239 AD2d 844 (1997).

13,523 Winchall v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Harris, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; May 6, 1996, n.o.r.

13,549 Nasca v Mills; Judgment granted transferring to Appellate Division, Third Department.

13.563 Mulder v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, All Purpose Term; Ceresia, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; September 25, 1996, n.o.r.

13,567 Peikon-Cotz v Mills; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Cobb, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; September 30, 1996, n.o.r.

13,583 Bradley Industrial Park, et al. v Mills; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Ceresia, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; March 31, 1997, n.o.r.; appeal never perfected.

13,589 Cadet v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Bradley, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; April 9,1997; aff’d 250 AD2d 122 (1998); mot. for leave to appeal den. 93 NY2d 803 (1999).

13,590 Akshar v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County Special Term; Cobb, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; November

8

21, 1996, n.o.r.; aff’d 249 AD2d 786 (1998); mot. for leave to appeal den. 92 NY2d 962 (1998); motion for reargument denied February 11, 1999.

13,607 Forte v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; May 7, 1998; aff’d 250 AD2d 882 (1998).

13,660 Bd. of Ed., Baldwin UFSD v Mills, et ano.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Keegan, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; October 9, 1997.

13,681 Donlon v Mills, et ano.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; April 29, 1999; 260 AD2d 971; mot. for leave to appeal den. 94 NY2d 752 (1999).

13,701 Domadeo, et al. v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Keegan, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; June 12, 1997, n.o.r.

13,730 Allen, et al. v BOE, Middle Country CSD; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; November 1997, n.o.r.

13,760 Education Alternatives, Inc. v Mills and SED; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Lamont, Acting J.S.C.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; December 18, 1997, n.o.r.

13,779 Owego-Apalachin CSD v Mills; Supreme Court, Albany County; Connor, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; March 30, 1998, n.o.r.; aff’d 257 AD2d 739 (1999).

13,807 Bd. of Ed., Northeast CSD v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Ceresia, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; November 22, 1999.

13,813 Bd. of Ed., North Tonawanda City SD v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Torraca, J.; Judgment granting petition and annulling decision of the Commissioner; May 1, 1998, n.o.r.; aff’d 263 AD2d 574 (1999); mot. for leave to appeal den. 94 NY2d 751 (1999).

13,820 Bd. of Ed., Uniondale UFSD v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Lamont, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; May 27, 1998.

13,876 Bd. of Ed., Alexandria CSD v Mills and SED; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Judgment granted dismissing petition for review; June 18, 1998.

9

13,881 Hessney v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Sheridan, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; March 4, 1999, n.o.r.

13,883 Matter of Schulman, et al. v BOE, Monticello CSD; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Malone, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; December 16, 1998; n.o.r.; appeal dismissed for failure to perfect; April 28, 1999.

13,896 Morehouse v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Bradley, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; November 5, 1998, n.o.r.; aff’d 268 AD2d 767 (2000); mot. for leave to appeal den. 95 NY2d 751 (2000).

13,910 Jordan v Mills; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Keegan, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; March 30, 1999; appeal dismissed for failure to perfect.

13,964 Chernoff v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Canfield, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; May 24, 1999, n.o.r.; appeal withdrawn.

13,994 Matter of Ogbunugafor v NYSED; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Connor, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; July 22, 1999, n.o.r.; aff’d 279 AD2d 738 (2001); mot. for leave to appeal den 96 NY2d 712 (2001).

13,999 Lilley v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Ceresia, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; August 23, 1999, n.o.r.; aff’d 274 AD2d 644 (2000).

14,143 Bojarczuk v Mills, et ano; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Connor, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; October 3, 2000, n.o.r.; aff’d 287 AD2d 82 (2001); mot. for leave to appeal granted; March 21, 2002; reversed and remitted to Supreme Court for further proceedings 98 NY2d 663 (2002); reversed, Appellate Division, Third Department; April 1, 2004.

14,144 Bd. of Ed., Oyster Bay-East Norwich CSD v Mills; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Sheridan, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; January 31, 2000, n.o.r.; appeal never perfected.

14,200 Ibrahim v Mills; Application to review decision abandoned.

14,214 Bd. of Ed., Sewanhaka CSD v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Connor, J.; Judgment granted dismissing

10

petition to review; June 7, 2000, n.o.r.; appeal dismissed for failure to perfect.

14,217 Bd. of Ed., Fairport CSD v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Hughes, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition in its entirety, June 1, 1999.

14,236 Davis v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Ferradino, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; July 3, 2000, n.o.r.; aff’d 285 AD2d 703 (2001); mot. for leave to appeal granted; November 15, 2001; aff’d 98 NY2d 120 (2002).

14,245 Mennella v Mills; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Ferradino, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; September 28, 2001, n.o.r.

14,250 Gersen, et al. v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Sheridan, J.; Judgment granting petition and annulling decision of the Commissioner; October 10, 2000, n.o.r.; rev’d 290 AD2d 839 (2002).

14,280 Bd. of Ed., Port Washington UFSD v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Stip. of discontinuance, July 5, 2000.

14,365 Weisberg v Mills, et anno; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Malone, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; November 27, 2000, n.o.r.

14,430 Bd. of Ed., Berkshire UFSD v Cate, et al.; Application to review decision filed; discontinued by stipulation; June 15, 2001.

14,450 Farago v Mills; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; McNamara. J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; May 4, 2001, n.o.r.

14,464 Bd. of Ed., City School District, City of New York v Mills; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Keegan, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; January 18, 2001, n.o.r.; mot to reargue den.; March 30, 2001; aff’d 293 AD2d 37 (2002).

14,485 Bd. of Ed., City School Dist., City of New York v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Connor, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; September 22, 2001, n.o.r.; decision withheld and matter remitted to Supreme Court for further proceedings 300 AD2d 981 (2002); remitted to Commissioner by Supreme Ct on January 21, 2003; additional decision (14,878) issued May 30, 2003; amended petition to review filed June 26, 2003; remitted to Appellate Division, Third Department, October 30, 2003; aff’d June 17, 2004; Contempt determination appealed to Appellate Division, Third

11

Department; March 15, 2005; aff’d January 19, 2006.; Third Department denied motion for leave to appeal to Court of Appeals, March 2006.

14,527 Karpoff, et al. v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Cobb, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; August 1, 2001, n.o.r.; aff’d 296 AD2d 691 (2002); mot. for leave to appeal den. 99 NY2d 501 (2002).

14,534 Finch, Pruyn & Co., Inc. v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Cobb, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; October 2, 2001, n.o.r.; aff’d 297 AD2d 406 (2002).

14,557 MacDonald v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Canfield, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; January 11, 2002, n.o.r.

14,638 McNamara v Mills; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Kane, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; January 10, 2002, n.o.r.

14,666 Boni, et al. v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Bradley, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; February 27, 2003; Appeal never perfected.

14,676 Huber, et al. v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Spargo, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; January 7, 2003.

14,677 Donato v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Stein, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; January 14, 2003, n.o.r.; aff’d April 22, 2004.

14,695 Madison-Oneida BOCES v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Kavanagh, J.; Judgment granting petition and annulling decision of Commissioner; December 20, 2002; rev’d 2 AD3d 1240 (2003); mot. for lv. to appeal granted December 31, 2003; aff’d 4 NY3d 51 (2004).

14,741 Cohn v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Lamont, J.; Judgment granting petition and annulling decision of Commissioner; April 17, 2003.

14,750 Mendez, et al. v Mills; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Cannizzaro, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; June 30, 2003.

12

14,785 Gill v Mills; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Bradley, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; October 6, 2003, n.o.r.; appeal never perfected.

14,786 Cayot v Mills; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; February 19, 2004.

14,805 American Quality Beverages, et al. v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court; Teresi, J.; Judgment denied granting respondent’s motion to dismiss; April 11, 2003; Supreme Court; Connor J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition on the merits; October 7, 2004; appealed to Appellate Division, Third Department; dismissed August 17, 2006.

14,842 Lewtschenko v Mills; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Lamont, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; October 27, 2003, n.o.r.

14,878 See, 14,485

14,961 City of Albany, et al. v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Connor, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; July 19, 2004; stipulation of discontinuance terminating appeal; October 25, 2004.

14,969 Bd. of Ed., Morristown CSD v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Bradley, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; appealed to Appellate Division, Third Department; July 2, 2004; Notice of discontinuance; August 10, 2004.

14,972 Fitch, et al. v Mills; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Connor, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition; July 9, 2004.

15,003 Klein v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Ceresia, J.; Judgment dismissing petition; December 6, 2004.

15,056 Bd. of Ed., Uniondale UFSD v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Kavanagh, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition and stay vacated; December 7, 2004; motion for order discharging surety bond granted; May 22, 2007.

15,060 Mahoney v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court., Albany County, Special Term; Canfield, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition; February 18, 2005; appealed to Appellate Division, Third Department; aff’d May 4, 2006; Plaintiff’s motion for leave to appeal to Court of Appeals denied; August 31, 2006.

15,128 Romeo, et al. v SED, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted vacating Commissioner’s decision; entered January 6, 2006; appealed to Appellate Division, Third Department; 39 AD3d 916

13

(2007); In 41 AD3d 1102 the Third Department reversed and remitted to Supreme Court for further proceedings; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Connor, J.; dismissed petition; January 8, 2008.

15,139 Kelly Services, Inc. v SED, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; December 28, 2005; appealed to Appellate Division; aff’d 40 AD3d 1349 (3d Dept. 2007).

Second Supv. Dist. of Erie, Chautauqua and Cattaraugus BOCES, et al. v SED, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; December 28, 2005; appealed to Appellate Division; aff’d 40 AD3d 1349 (3d Dept. 2007).

15,143 Quattrone v SED, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment

granted dismissing petition; November 21, 2005; appealed to Appellate Division, Third Department; aff’d February 8, 2007.

15,147 Jo v SED, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Bradstreet, J.; Judgment dismissing petition; February 8, 2005; appealed to Appellate Division, Fourth Department; appeal never perfected.

15,187 Bd. of Educ., Garrison UFSD v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; April 7, 2006; appealed to Appellate Division, Third Department; notice of appeal withdrawn; January 30, 2007.

15,192 Scott v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; January 20, 2006.

15,214 Viglietta v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; January 31, 2006; appealed to Appellate Division, Third Department; aff’d April 26, 2007.

15,294 Bd. of Educ., Spackenkill UFSD v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; May 31, 2006.

15,309 Sharp, et al. v Mills; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; June 9, 2006.

15,318 Bailey v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing stay request and petition; December 13, 2006.

15,328 Putnam-Northern Westchester BOCES, et al. v Mills; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granting petition annulling Commissioner’s decision; August 24, 2006; appealed to Appellate Division, Third Department; aff’d December 13, 2007.

14

15,422 Kelly Services, Inc. v USNY, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; May 22, 2007.

15,446 Jochnowitz v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; June 8, 2007.

15,466 Bd. of Educ., No. Rockland CSD v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Motion to dismiss granted; April 13, 2007; no appeal taken.

15,474 Andreou, et al. v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; April 30, 2008; appealed to Appellate Division, Third Department; June 23, 2008; Appeal dismissed for failure to prosecute; January 19, 2010.

15,475 Goldberg v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Commissioner’s decision vacated; remanded to district for a hearing; July 3, 2007.

15,484 Bd. of Educ. Campbell-Savona CSD v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; May 8, 2006.

15,557 Strupp v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; December 4, 2007.

15,648 Palma v SED, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; July 24, 2008.

15,650 Bd. of Educ., Lawrence UFSD v McColgan, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; December 7, 2007; appealed to Appellate Division, Third Department; January 14, 2008; appeal never perfected.

15,678 Antaki v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; May 30, 2008; appealed to Appellate Division; appeal abandoned.

15,749 Bd. of Educ., Greenwood Lake UFSD v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; February 17, 2009.

15,767 Bd. of Educ., Bay Shore UFSD v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Commissioner’s decision vacated in part, remanded to Commissioner for further proceedings; January 9, 2009; Commissioner issued Decision No. 15,935; June 26, 2009; Judgment granted on motion for reconsideration reargument, remanded to Commissioner for further proceedings; June 29, 2009; Commissioner issued Decision No. 16,131; August 13, 2010.

15

15,799 Bruning v NYSED, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; March 24, 2009.

15,802 Fourman v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; December 31, 2008.

15,803 Bobolia v Bd. of Educ., Hendrick Hudson CSD, et al.; Supreme Court Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; July 15, 2009.

15,821 Reyes v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; April 8, 2009.

15,835 Bd. of Educ., Bay Shore UFSD v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Transferred to Appellate Division, Third Department; August 18, 2009; Decision and order granting application to withdraw; September 2, 2010.

15,856 Blake v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; September 28, 2009; appealed to Appellate Division, Third Department; aff’d 79 AD3d 1347; mot. for leave to appeal den. 16 NY3d 707.

15,870 Bennett v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Decision and order granting petition, vacating Commissioner’s determination and remanding for de novo determination; August 19, 2009; Commissioner issued Decision No. 16,003 following independent investigation; December 15, 2009; petitioner filed motion for reconsideration of Supreme Court decision; December 21, 2009; denied February 3, 2010; new petition filed February 15, 2010 seeking review of Decision No. 16,003; Bennett v Steiner, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; June 30, 2010.

15,871 Bd. of Educ., Lewiston-Porter CSD v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; December 16, 2009.

15,909 Mirenburg v Mills, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; November 27, 2009.

15,953 Zalaman v Steiner, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; May 28, 2010.

15,981 Ferencik v Steiner, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; September 15, 2010.

16,003 Bennett v Steiner, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; June 30, 2010.

16

16,043 Robley v Steiner, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; March 15, 2011.

16,061 Cherry Valley-Springfield CSD v Steiner, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Petition withdrawn; April 13, 2011.

16,073 Binder, et al. v Cold Spring Harbor CSD, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; March 23, 2011; appealed to Appellate Division, Third Department; April 22, 2011; appeal was not perfected.

16,082 Dickinson v Steiner, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Decision and order granting petition, in part, vacating Commissioner’s decision, in part, and remanding for further proceedings; February 22, 2011; Commissioner issued Decision No. 16,256; July 7, 2011.

16,106 Student With a Disability v Steiner, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Decision and order transferring appeal to the Appellate Division, Third Department; May 27, 2011; aff’d. 101 AD3d 73 (3d Dept. 2012); appeal denied 20 NY3d 1032 (2013).

16,158 Marsico v Armstrong, et al.; Supreme Court, Westchester County; Judgment granted vacating Commissioner’s decision; March 24, 2015; Stipulation and Order vacating judgment and transferring to Albany County; August 19, 2015; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted denying motion to amend and dismissing petition; April 12, 2017; notice of appeal filed; May 19, 2017.

16,172 N.C. v Steiner, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; June 17, 2011.

16,297 Galperin v King, et al.; Supreme Court, Nassau County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; August 10, 2012; Notice of Appeal filed; October 8, 2012.

16,307  G.L., by C.L., his mother, on his behalf, and by G.L. on his own behalf, v John King, New York State Education Commissioner and The Renaissance Charter School; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; September 18, 2012.

16,316 Thomas C. O'Brien v King, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; July 3, 2012; affd 112 AD3d 188 (3d Dept. 2013); appeal dismissed 22 NY3d 1125 (2014); mot. for leave to appeal den. 23 NY3d 903 (2014).

16,336 Garden City UFSD, et al. v King, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany

County; Decision and Order granting petition, vacating Commissioner’s decision and remanding for further proceedings; dated

17

October 31, 2012. Underlying Education Law 310 appeal withdrawn, January 28, 2013; No further proceedings.

16,341 Students With Disabilities v King, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Decision and Order remanding for further proceedings; January 23, 2013; Commissioner issued Decision No. 16,490; June 24, 2013.

16,397 Gill v Bd. of Educ., Williamsville CSD, et al.; Supreme Court, Erie County; Decision and Order dismissing the petition; dated August 15, 2013.

16,411 de Oliveria v SED, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Application to review pending.

16,419 Kwasnik v King, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Decision and Order granting petition, vacating Commissioner’s decision; September 30, 2013; Notice of appeal filed; aff’d 123 AD3d 1264 (3d Dept. 2014).

16,439 Vestal CSD v King, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County.; Decision and Order remanding for further proceedings; September 25, 2013; Commissioner issued Decision No. 16,583; January 13, 2014.

16,478 Bugbee, et al. v King, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Application to review pending; Voluntarily discontinued; February 17, 2014.

16,481 Winslow v Malverne Union Free School Dist., et al.; Supreme Court, Nassau County; Stipulation of discontinuance as to Commissioner; March 5, 2015.

16,501 East Ramapo CSD v King, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; January 29, 2014.

16,568 Cronk v King, et al; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted vacating Commissioner’s decision; September 18, 2014; aff’d 2015 NY Slip Op 06396, (3rd Dept. 2015) .

16,572 Terwilliger v King; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granting dismissing petition; March 12, 2014, n.o.r.

16,635 Goldberg v King, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; May 13, 2015; notice of appeal filed; June 24, 2015.

16,660 Cross v King; US District Court, Eastern District; Order of dismissal; November 30, 2015.

18

16,669 Thomas v. King, et al; Supreme Court, Albany County; Decision and Order dismissing the petition; dated August 31, 2015.

16,765 Murphy v Elia, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; May 25, 2016.

16,849 Soriano v Elia, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; August 18, 2016; aff’d Appellate Division, Third Dept.; November 30, 2017; mot. for leave to appeal pending.

16,882 De Vera, et al. v Elia, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; June 8, 2016; Appellate Division, Third Department; Decision and Order reversing Supreme Court and remitting to Commissioner for further proceedings; June 8, 2017. Motion for leave to appeal granted; December 12, 2017.

16,889 New York City Department of Education v Boys Preparatory Charter School of New York, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Decision and Order dismissing petition; April 19, 2017.

16,932 Eskridge v Elia, et al; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; May 26, 2017.

16,922 Teaching Firms of America – Professional Preparatory Charter School v New York City Department of Education, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Decision and Order dismissing petition; April 20, 2017.

17,002 Murray v Lakeland CSD, et al.; US District Court, Southern District; Decision and order dismissing petition; January 8, 2018.

17,021 Caruso v Elia; Supreme Court, Albany County; Decision and Order dismissing the petition; October 31, 2017.

17,028 Bd. of Educ. of Minisink Valley CSD, et al. v Elia, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Decision and Order dismissing petition; November 20, 2017; Notice of Appeal filed; December 13, 2017.

17,052 Mindali v Elia, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Judgment granted dismissing petition; November 1, 2017; Notice of appeal filed; December 6, 2017.

17,076 Razzano v Elia, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Application to review decision pending.

17,078 Sudano v Elia, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Special Term; Decision Order and Judgment dismissing petition; December 20, 2017.

19

17,095 Carthage CSD v Commissioner of Education, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County, Special Term; Mott, J.; Judgment granted dismissing petition to review; November 28, 2017, n.o.r.

17,166 Unapanta v Elia, et al; Supreme Court, Nassau County; Application to

review decision pending.

17,263 Bd. of Educ. of Hempstead UFSD v New York State Educ. Commissioner, et al.; Supreme Court, Albany County; Notice of Voluntary Discontinuance; December 28, 2017.

20