Upload
others
View
7
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Saifur Rahman, PhDPresident, IEEE Power & Energy Society 2018 & 2019
Professor, ECE Department, Virginia Tech, USA
Webinar 12 September 2020
How to Write an Effective Technical Paper
Webinar Speaker, Saifur Rahman, Ph.D.Professor and DirectorVirginia Tech Advanced Research Institute
9/10/20 2
EducationPh.D., Electrical Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, 1978.M.S., Electrical Sciences, State University of New York at Stony Brook, 1975.B.Sc., Electrical Engineering, Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology, Dhaka, 1972
Professional Society Activities
ØIEEE Member since 1975, Fellow 1998, Life Fellow 2014ØPresident, IEEE PES, 2018-2019ØVice president, Publications, IEEE PES, 2001-2003, 2012-2013ØVice President, Publications, IEEE, 2006ØEditor-in-Chief, IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy, 2010-2012ØEditor-in-Chief, IEEE Electrifications Magazine, 2013-2014ØLaunched, the IEEE Power & Energy Technology Systems Journal (Open Access), 2014
3
4
www.srahman.org
5
AudienceAudience
6
1.Are you writing this paper for the sake of writing a paper?
2.Or do you want to show how others can benefit from your work?
AudienceBasic Questions
7
• Whowritesscientificpapers?
• Engineers,scientists,educatorsandresearchersfrom:
Ø CorporationsØ AcademiaØ Government
• Studentstypicallywriteandpresentconferencepapersbeforesubmittingjournalarticles
AudienceScientific research publishing
8
• Contentthatisappropriate,inscopeandlevel• Clearlywrittenoriginalmaterialthataddressesanew
andimportantproblem• Extensionofpreviouslypublishedwork• Validmethodsandrationale• Illustrations,tablesandgraphsthatsupportthetext• Referencesthatarecurrentandrelevanttothesubject
AudienceWhat IEEE editors and reviewers are looking for
9
AudienceHow does the review process work?
• Editor-in-Chiefgetsthepaperafteritgoesthroughcontentmatchcheck(iAuthenticate)and“bannedauthor”check
• Ifthepaperisinscopeforthejournal,itisassignedtoaneditor(associateeditor)
• Editorassignsthepapertofiveormorereviewers• Reviewerssendtheircommentsbacktotheeditor• EditormakesarecommendationtotheEICasfollows:
o Accepto Revise&Resubmito Reject
• TheEICmakesthefinaldecisionandinformsthecorrespondingauthor
10
AudienceWhy IEEE editors and reviewers reject papers
• Thecontentisnotagoodfitforthepublication• Thereareseriousscientificflaws:
• Inconclusiveresultsorincorrectinterpretation• Fraudulentresearch
• Itispoorlywritten• Itdoesnotaddressabigenoughproblem
oradvancethescientificfield• Mostoftheworkwaspreviouslypublished• Thequalityisnotgoodenoughforthejournal• Reviewershavemisunderstoodthearticle
11
Structure
12
Title
Results/Discussions/Findings
Abstract
Keywords
Introduction
Methodology
References
Conclusion
Paper StructureElements of a manuscript
13
GoodTitle
BadTitle
VS.
Paper StructureTitle
Aneffectivetitleshould…•Answerthereader’squestion:“Isthisarticlerelevanttome?”•Grabthereader’sattention•Describethecontentofapaperusingthefewestpossiblewords
• Iscrisp,concise• Useskeywords• Avoidsjargon
Paper Structure
Title Dos and Don’ts
A Human Expert-based Approach to Electrical Peak Demand ManagementVSA better approach of managing environmental and energy sustainability via a study of different methods of electric load forecasting
14
15
What you did
Why you did it
How the results were useful,
important & move the field forward
Why they’re useful & important & move the field forward
Paper StructureAbstract
A“standalone” condensedversionofthearticle• Nomorethan250words;
canusepastorpresenttense• Useskeywordsandindex
terms
Paper Structure
Abstract Dos and Don’tsThe objective of this paper was to propose a human expert-based approach to electrical peak demand management. The proposed approach helped to allocate demand curtailments (MW) among distribution substations (DS) or feeders in an electric utility service area based on requirements of the central load dispatch center. Demand curtailment allocation was quantified taking into account demand response (DR) potential and load curtailment priority of each DS, which can be determined using DS loading level, capacity of each DS, customer types (residential/commercial) and load categories (deployable, interruptible or critical). Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) was used to model a complex decision-making process according to both expert inputs and objective parameters. Simulation case studies were conducted to demonstrate how the proposed approach can be implemented to perform DR using real-world data from an electric utility. Simulation results demonstrated that the proposed approach is capable of achieving realistic demand curtailment allocations among different DSs to meet the peak load reduction requirements at the utility level.
Vs
This paper presents and assesses a framework for an engineering capstone design program. We explain how student preparation, project selection, and instructor mentorship are the three key elements that must be addressed before the capstone experience is ready for the students. Next, we describe a way to administer and execute the capstone design experience including design workshops and lead engineers. We describe the importance in assessing the capstone design experience and report recent assessment results of our framework. We comment specifically on what students thought were the most important aspects of their experience in engineering capstone design and provide quantitative insight into what parts of the framework are most important.
16
First person, present tenseNo actual results, only describes the organization of the paper
17
UseintheTitleandAbstractforenhancedSearchEngineOptimization
Paper StructureKeywords
Appropriate
Applicable
Specific
Searchable
Logical
18
Generally known
information about the topic
Prior studies’ historical context to
your research
Your hypothesis and an
overview of the results
How the article is
organized
• Theintroductionshouldbe:• Specific,nottoobroadorvague• About1-2pages• Writteninthepresenttense
Paper StructureIntroduction
• Adescriptionoftheproblemyouresearched• Itshouldmovestepbystepthrough:
19
• Problemformulationandtheprocessesusedtosolvetheproblem,proveordisprovethehypothesis
• Useillustrations toclarifyideasandsupportconclusions:
TablesPresent representative data
or when exact values are important to show
GraphsShow relationships
between data points or trends in data
FiguresQuickly show ideas/conclusions that would require detailed explanations
Paper StructureMethodology
Fig. A
20
Discussion
Results
Paper StructureResults/discussionDemonstratethatyousolvedtheproblemormadesignificantadvances
Results:SummarizestheData• Shouldbeclearandconcise• Usefiguresortableswithnarrativetoillustratefindings
Discussion:InterpretstheResults•Whyyourresearchoffersanewsolution• Howcanitbenefitotherresearchersprofessionals
21
• Explainwhattheresearchhasachieved• Asitrelatestotheproblemstated
intheIntroduction• Revisitthekeypointsineachsection• Includeasummaryofthemainfindings
andimplicationsforthefield• Providebenefitsandshortcomingsof:
• Thesolutionpresented• Yourresearchandmethodology
• Suggestfutureareasforresearch
Paper StructureConclusion
22
• Supportandvalidatethehypothesisyourresearchproves,disprovesorresolves
• Thereisnolimittothenumberofreferences• Butuseonlythosethatdirectly
supportyourwork(about30)
• Ensureproperauthorattribution• Authorname,articletitle,
publicationname,publisher,yearpublished,volumeandpagenumber,DigitalObjectIdentifier(DOI)
Properly cited
material
Paper StructureReferences
23
AReport
Areportdocumentsindetailtheworkdoneincludingresultsforaprojectandhasaleadauthorandothermultipleauthors
ATechnicalPaper
• Ithighlightsoneormoreaspectsofareport
• Multiplepaperscancomeoutofonereport
• Includeanyandallwhohavecontributedtothewritingofthepaper
• Otherscanbeacknowledged
Who should be on the Authors’ list
24
Ethics
25
Conflict of Interest
• A financial or other relationship with the publication at odds with the unbiased presentation of data or analysis.
Plagiarism
• Copying another person’s work word for word or paraphrasing without proper citation.
Missing Author Attribution
• Must be given if you use another author’s ideas in your article, even if you do not directly quote a source.
EthicsTypes of misconduct
26
Plagiarism
• Avoidplagiarism• Citeandseparateanyverbatimcopied
material– buthowmuch?
• Paraphraseother’stextproperly,andincludecitation
• Creditanyideasfromothersources
• FamiliarizeyourselfwithIEEEPolicies
EthicsEthical publishing
Refer to our Tips Sheet http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/authors/plagiarism_and_multiple_submissions.pdf
27
Duplication, Redundancies & Multiple Submissions
• Authormustsubmitoriginalworkthat:• Hasnotappearedelsewhereforpublication
• Isnotunderreviewforanotherrefereedpublication
• Citespreviouswork
• Indicateshowitdiffersfromthepreviouslypublishedwork
• AuthorsMUSTalsoinformtheeditorwhensubmittinganypreviouslypublishedwork
EthicsEthical publishing
Refer to our Tips Sheet http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/authors/plagiarism_and_multiple_submissions.pdf
28
Where to Publish?
TraditionalJournals-Articlesavailablethroughsubscription
OpenAccessJournals–Authorpays,freedownload
HybridJournals–Mostarticlesaretraditional,someareopen
access(authorpreference)29
30
Open AccessPublications
Next Steps
Open Access Opportunity for IEEE Authors (Author pays model)
IEEEprovides3openaccesspublishingoptionstomeetthevaryingneedsofauthors:
• Newmultidisciplinaryjournal,IEEEAccess
• 100+Hybridjournals• Fullyopenaccesstopical
journals
31
http://open.ieee.org/More Information
PES Full Open Access Option #1
IEEE Open Access Journal of Power and Energy– WillstartpublishingarticlesfromJanuary2020– ExistingOAJournalofPowerandEnergyTechnologySystemswillbe
rebrandedwiththisnewname, scopecoveringtheentirefieldofPESforbothpractice-orientedandacademicarticles
– ArticleprocessingchargesubsidisedatUS$1350– Between10-15articleseachyearwillreceivefurthersubsidydepending
onauthors’affordability/circumstances
32
PES Full Open Access Option #2
AdedicatedsectiononPower&EnergyforpublishingpapersinthePESfieldinIEEEAccess
– ThesectionwillstartfromJanuary2020,submissionsstartedinSeptember2019
– Paperwillbehandledby3PES-appointedEditors– APC:US$1750
33
34
Impact Factor
35
Are we depending too heavily on Impact Factors?
36
Impact Factor from Journal Citation Reports
37
Impact Factor is not necessarily enough of a metric
Other attributes:
• Journal’sreputationinthecommunityisimportant
• Fornewandlesserknownjournals–lookattheeditorialboard,theirreputation
38
Other ways of judging a journal’s value to the engineering community
1. NumberofDownloads(IEEEusesthisinformationforrevenuedistribution)
2. PatentCitations(AvailablefromIEEE)
39
Follow-up Steps
40
DiscussthecontentamongteammembersLiteraturesearch– ReferenceListDescriptionoftheExperiment/ModelResults/DiscussionWritetheConclusionCollectthecomponents– PreparethedraftAllmemberscommentonthedraftProducethefinalcopy
Process of Writing the Paper
IwouldliketoseeabroaderIEEEWeneedtoensurethatweare“READYFORRECOVERY”,whenwegetbacktothe“NEWNORMAL”afterCOVID-19.Letusenhancecooperation,collaborationandcommunityspirit.
ForthisweneedtomakeIEEEbroadersothatIEEEismorerelevanttotheworkourmembersdoregardlesswheretheywork.
WeneedmoreparticipationfromvolunteersgloballyinIEEEgovernance.AbroaderbasedIEEEwillmaketheInstitutemorerelevanttotechnologistsandacademicsfromallpartsoftheworld.
9/10/20
42
IEEEPresident-electCandidate2020
Past-PresidentofIEEEPower&EnergySocietyPast-Chair,IEEEPublicationServices&ProductsBoard
PESaccomplishments:PESUniversityPESCorporateEngagementProgramPESChapters’CouncilsinChina,India,AfricaandLatinAmerica
website: https://www.srahman.org.
Vote at www.ieee.org/elections