The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    1/32

    2012The STaTe Were In

    a rpot Cd o Pblic edctio i Illiois

    embgod til 11/13, 12:01m

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    2/322 | The STaTe Were In: 2012

    Education is the most

    powerful weapon which

    you can use to change

    the world. Nelson Mandela

    Advance Illinois Board Members

    William M. Daley, Co-Chair

    Former White House Chief of Staff and

    Former U.S. Secretary of Commerce

    John A. Edwardson, Co-Chair

    Chairman

    CDW LLC

    Jim Edgar, Chair Emeritus

    Former Governor of Illinois

    Ellen Alberding

    President

    The Joyce Foundation

    Lew Collens

    President Emeritus

    Illinois Institute of Technology

    Miguel del Valle

    Chair

    Illinois P-20 Council

    Judy Erwin

    Managing Director

    ASGK Public Strategies Inc.

    Paul Finnegan

    Co-CEO

    Madison Dearborn Partners, LLC

    James C. Franczek Jr.

    Partner

    Franczek Radelet P.C.

    Marin Gjaja

    Senior Partner and Managing Director

    Boston Consulting Group

    Timothy Knowles

    John Dewey Director

    The Urban Education Institute

    University of Chicago

    Craig Lindvahl

    Executive Director

    Effingham County Entrepreneurship

    Course; Midland Institute for

    Entrepreneurship

    Sylvia Puente

    Executive Director

    Latino Policy Forum

    Gene Reineke

    Founder and President

    Hawthorne Strategy Group, LLC

    Edward B. Rust Jr.

    Chairman and CEO

    State Farm Insurance Co.

    Rick Stephens

    Senior Vice President, Human Resources

    and Administration, The Boeing Company

    Cheryl Watkins

    Principal

    Pershing West Middle School

    Embargoed until 11/13, 12:01

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    3/32advance IllInoIS

    Table of Contents

    2 Letter to Illinois Residents

    3 Steps to Readiness

    4 Navigating This Report

    5 Education and the Economy

    6 Illinois Student Performance Over Time

    8 Illinois Student Persistence through

    High School and Postsecondary

    10 Illinois Schools

    12 Learning from Another State: Massachusetts13 Illinois Efforts To Improve

    14 Timeline of Illinois School Reform

    16 ProleofIllinoisEducationSystem

    18 Early Education Indicators

    20 K12 Indicators

    24 Postsecondary Readiness and Success

    Indicators

    26 Endnotes

    27 MetricDenitions

    mbargoed until 11/13, 12:01am

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    4/32

    November 2012

    Fellow Illinoisans:

    The world is passing us by: At a time when a postsecondaryeducation matters more than ever and jobs increasingly

    require more than a high school diploma, fewer than three-fourths of Illinois students who begin high school willgraduate and fewer than a third will go on to complete apostsecondary degree.

    Worsestill,withoutseriouseffortandchange,wendlittle

    prospect for improvement given that Illinois academic

    performancehasremainedatformuchofthepastdecade.

    One-thirdofIllinoisstudentscomplete4thgradeprocientin

    reading, a troubling indicator given decades of research that

    suggests students who read well by this point are dramatically

    morelikelytosucceedinschoolandinlife.

    One-third of students begin high school academically on-track

    andpreparedforcoursework.

    Fewer than one-third of students leave high school with the

    college- and career-ready knowledge and skills they need to

    succeedinanincreasinglycompetitiveworld.

    In short, our schools are not getting the majority of studentswheretheyneedtogo.Notonlydowenotkeeppacewithother

    states,wearelosinggroundwithothernations.Wecannotafford

    to be a below-average state in a below-average country while

    theeconomybecomesincreasinglyglobal.Itisnotsustainable.

    The challenge ahead is clear: We must work urgently to meet the

    goal set by Illinois education, legislative, civic and business leaders

    to ensure 60 percent of students earn a postsecondary degree by

    2025.Notdoingsowouldnotbeafailingofchildren.Itwouldbe

    ourfailingafailingofadults.

    Certainly,Illinoishaschangedsignicantlyduringthepastdecade.

    NearlyhalfofIllinoisstudentsarelow-incomeand,fortherst

    time, more than half of schools statewide serve 40 percent or more

    economicallydisadvantagedstudents.However,thesechangesdo

    notmakeatacademicperformanceacceptableorinevitable.

    ThegoodnewsisIllinoisisresponding.Thestatewillbegin

    implementing the rigorous Common Core State Standards;

    accurately measuring whether students are on-track at every

    step in the academic pipeline; putting better information in the

    hands of teachers, principals and families; focusing attention

    and effort on organizing schools for improvement; strengthening

    evaluations and supports for educators; and intensifying efforts to

    improvelow-performingschools.Thebedrockfortheseeffortsis

    providing all children a strong early start in life, and Illinois leadersmust continue to enroll more young children in early childhood

    programsevenamidchallengingscaltimes.

    Weknowlastingimprovementtakestime.Muchofthework

    ahead demands careful implementation and impact on student

    achievementwillnothappenimmediately.Butifwe,asastate,do

    not work urgently to implement these and other reforms, we will

    continuetoseethemediocritywevealwaysseen.Ourstudents

    willpaytheprice.Wecannotaffordtoletthathappen.

    They can do it. Will we?

    WilliamM.Daley JohnA.Edwardson RobinM.Steans

    Co-Chair Co-Chair Executive Director

    Advance Illinois Advance Illinois Advance Illinois

    Embargoed until 11/13, 12:01

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    5/32advance IllInoIS

    Where Illinois stands today on thesteps to readiness ...

    29%

    ... Where Illinoisneeds to goBy2025,Illinoisaimstograduate60%

    ofstudentsfrompostsecondaryinstitutions.

    as stt, w wok to do if we are to

    more than double the number of students who

    persistthroughpostsecondary.

    Psist tug pstsyguti*:

    55%

    e i pstsy*:Many students enterunprepared for the

    rigors ahead.

    27%Gut ig s witg- -

    y kwg skis:

    33%cmpt 8t g y

    f ig suswk:

    33%

    cmpt 4t gprocient in reading:

    ?Stt s

    kigt-y:

    Data unavailable

    advance IllInoIS

    *Thesemeasuresreectastartingpointof9thgrade.Thatis,thisreectshowacohortofIllinois9th-gradersperformsastheyprogressthroughhighschool,enrollinpostsecondaryandultimatelygraduate.

    Analysisforthisprojectionisbaseduponthefollowingsources:NationalCenterforEducationalProgress,2011.EducationWeek,EducationCountsReferenceCenter,2009.Lichtenberger,EricJ.andDietrich,Cecile;CollegeReadinessandthePostsecondaryOutcomesofIllinoisHighSchoolStudents,IllinoisEducationResearchCouncil,2012.Lichtenberger,EricJ.andDietrich,Cecile;CollegeReadinessandtheOverlappingOutcomesofCommunityCollegeEntrants,IllinoisEducationResearchCouncil,201213.CalculationsbyEricJ.Lichtenberger,IllinoisEducationResearchCouncil,Oct.25,2012.ACT,IllinoisProleReport,2012.IllinoisInteractiveReportCard,2012.AdvanceIllinoisprovidedtheanalysisforthisprojection.

    mbargoed until 11/13, 12:01am

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    6/324 | The STaTe Were In: 2012

    The Illinois Education Research Council (IERC) tracked the class of 2003through 2010 to examine how many students enrolled and graduatedfrompostsecondaryinstitutions.Theinformationillustrateshowpowerful it is to think about student progress longitudinally and howimportant it is for high school students to be academically preparedfortherigorsofcollegeandcareer.

    Navigating This ReportTis pt sssss Iiis mi pfm fm y i tug

    pstsy, piig spst f w Iiis mps t t stts tis

    s w tiy wk t pi stuts w-ss uti. T ysis is

    ii it t pts.

    The rst section examines how Illinois public schools serve 2

    million students by spotlighting performance on key academic

    milestones such as 4th-grade reading, 8th-grade math, college

    readinessincoresubjectsandpostsecondarygraduation.

    The scod sctio examines the interlocking set of reforms

    that state education leaders, legislators and advocates have

    crafted to lay the foundation for future academic growth

    since the StateWereIn:2010. The report also illustrates how

    thevariousinitiativesttogethertolayastrongacademicfoundationforIllinoisgoingforward.

    The tid sctiocontains55datameasuresthatexamine

    Illinois standing in early education, K12 and postsecondary

    readinessandsuccess.

    Wt dt poidd?

    The report highlights more than four dozen data measures to

    illuminatehowwellwe,asastate,educatestudents.Dataforeach

    measure include:

    current performance past performance

    leading states and Illinois comparative national rank

    equity gaps by race and Latino origin, income and special

    education status when possible

    how gds ssigd?

    The report assigns a letter grade for three areas: early education,

    K12andpostsecondaryreadinessandsuccess.Gradesreect

    how Illinois ranks on every data measure, and these rankings then

    areaveragedwithineachcategory.Illinoisstandingnationallydeterminestheultimategrade.Calculationsalsoinclude

    achievementgaprankingsforladdermeasureswhenavailable.

    A = 1st10th

    B=11th20th

    C = 21st30th

    D = 31st40th

    F=41st50th

    Anincompleteisassignedifinsufcientdataexisttoreacha

    judgment.

    W kp idictos wit missig dt?

    Datadonotexistforeveryindicator.AdvanceIllinoischosetokeep

    these measures in order to highlight what data should be provided

    goingforward.Putanotherway,asastate,weknowwhatwe

    know and we know what we need to know if we are to strengthen

    schoolsandbetterservestudents.Illinoisnewlongitudinal

    data system soon will provide information to answer additional

    questionsabouthowstudentsandschoolsperformovertime.

    W s pojctios?

    In the absence of longitudinal data, this report draws on existing

    data measures and research analyses to project how many students

    progress from the start of high school through postsecondary

    graduation.Whilethedatatablesofthisreportreecthistorictrends

    and point-in-time performance on indicators that provide national

    comparability,projectionsreecthowstudentsmightperformover

    time.Thatis,weknowwhatpercentageofIllinoisstudentsgraduated

    fromhighschoolinJune2012,butitwilltakeyearstoknowhow

    many actually persist through postsecondary; so, this report uses

    historictrendstoprojectthatinformation.Thisisbynomeansa

    perfectmethodology.Butintheabsenceoflongitudinalinformation,

    it allows us to examine how students perform over time and prepare

    forthechallengesahead.Whetherasparentsorpolicymakers,thisis

    howweneedtothinkaboutoureducationalsystem.

    Sti t 2-y istituti

    hig s stuts w mt acT g-ybmks m iky t su i pstsy

    All 4 subjects 83.7%

    77.9%

    66.7%

    60.1%

    41.6%

    3%

    3.2%

    5.9%

    6.1%

    8.9%

    3.2%

    4.2%

    5.2%

    12.1%

    16.9%

    24.2%

    29.6%

    44.3%

    34 subjects

    24 subjects

    14 subjects

    None

    Source:Lichtenberger,EricJ.andDietrich,Cecile;CollegeReadinessandthePost-secondaryOutcomesofIllinoisHighSchoolStudents,IllinoisEducationResearch

    Council,2012

    n g

    e bs ig

    Sti t 4-y istituti

    O t WbRead the fullIERC report

    Embargoed until 11/13, 12:01

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    7/32advance IllInoIS

    As a state and a nation, we risk losing ouracademic edge as the rest of the worldsharpens theirs.T stgt f u stts my i, t stgt f u stt s w

    sts ixtiby t stgt f u pubi uti systm. Pstsy

    uti isigy ps t pt t mpymt i my tt gws m

    mptiti y y.

    eigt of 10 Illiois jobs tod isom dctio o tiig bod igscool.1

    Butfewerthanfourofevery10Illinoisadultsholdatwo-yearor

    four-yeardegree,2leavingthousandsofjobsunlledeveryyear

    becauseemployerscannotndemployeeswiththeskillstodo

    them.3This performance puts Illinois ahead of competitor nations,

    particularly as more young adults in their 20s and 30s pursue

    postsecondarytraining.Evenstill,Illinoislagscountriessuchas

    Canada,Israel,JapanandRussia.4 Our international standing may

    slide still further, as other industrialized countries already have

    surpassed our high school completion rate and are on-track to

    surpassourpostsecondaryattainment.

    Nowmorethanever,educationmakesallthedifferenceasU.S.

    adultswithbachelorsdegreesgained2.2millionjobssincetheGreatRecessionbegan,andadultswithnopostsecondarytraining

    lost 5.8 million jobs.5

    U.S.studentsdonotleadonanyglobalmeasureofacademic

    performance. Today, the United States ranks in the middle in math,

    just below the top third in science, and below the top quarter in

    reading, behind countries such as China, Finland, the Netherlands

    andSouthKorea.6

    Iiis cmptit ntis(G8 ag)

    Iiis s t tis, but ty

    tig upPercentage of adults with a postsecondary degree

    Age 65+ Age 2534Age 3544Age 4564

    33

    24

    44

    40

    4339

    43

    U.S. stuts ggig i mi

    pfm gbyAverage U.S. student performance

    Source:USCensusBureau,2010AmericanCommunitySurvey.EducationataGlance2011,OrganizationforEconomicCo-operationandDevelopment(OECD)

    Source:TheProgrammeforInternationalStudentAssessment,2009

    31st65Math

    65Reading

    23dScience 64

    17t

    O t WbSee which other nationshave surpassed Illinoisatadvanceillinois.org

    mbargoed until 11/13, 12:01am

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    8/326 | The STaTe Were In: 2012

    Once students fall behind, it is difcult tocatch up ...T ss f stut suss pt i y i, t wk t mk su

    stuts i t ti fust ptti tius tugut ti sig. If ws stuts y, w isk sig tm tiy.

    Illinoisenrolls20percentof3-year-oldsand29percentof4-year-

    oldsinstate-fundedpreschoolprograms,anditisaleaderamong

    states in providing access to early education.7Still, this is less than

    one-third of the youngest children and fewer still may be served

    inthecomingyears.Thestatesdeepeningscalcrisishasslowed

    theexpansionofearlyeducationaccess.Importantly,whileIllinois

    wasoneoftherststatestorequirethateligiblestudentsreceive

    bilingual early childhood instruction,8

    little data exist aboutwhether there are enough bilingual early childhood placements

    andteacherstomeettheneed.

    Beforetheyevenbeginkindergarten,4-year-oldswholivebelow

    thepovertylinearenearly14monthsbehindtheirclassmates.9By

    age9,thegapthattakesrootintheearlyyearscontinues.But

    general knowledge and cognitive skills are not the only measure

    ofhowyoungchildrendevelopandlearn.Equallyimportantare

    their curiosity, communication, emotional well-being and overall

    health.10Tothisend,Illinoisforthersttimeispilotingameasure

    of whether children are academically, emotionally and sociallyready as they enter kindergarten, information that, in time, will

    helpansweracriticalquestion.

    Fw t t i 10 i i stt-fu ps

    Source:NationalInstituteforEarlyEducationResearch

    2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

    22%

    8%

    20%

    29%

    3-year-olds

    4-year-olds

    6 | The STaTe Were In: 2012 Embargoed until 11/13, 12:01

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    9/32advance IllInoIS

    ... and Illinois progress is far too slow.aimt gps psist t tim w suss ps up w w w mt t

    s fallstuts.

    Illinoisstudentsacrossnearlyalldemographicandeconomicgroups

    improvedslightlyinreadingandmathsince2003,11 although just

    one-thirdofstudentsreadprocientlyby4thgradeandthisisone

    ofthemostpowerfulpredictorsoffuturesuccess.Students who

    do not transition from learning to read in the early grades to

    reading to learn by 4th grade fall behind and are at much greater

    riskofdroppingout.12 While all student groups improved on

    this important measure, a shockingly low 12 percent of African-

    American students, 18 percent of Latino students and 16 percent

    oflow-incomestudentsreadprocientlyin4thgrade.13

    Despitegains,thegapbetweendisadvantagedstudents and their classmates continues in most

    subjects. Illinois was one of only four states

    to narrow the gap in 8th-grade math since

    2003,14 but 17 percent of low-income 8th-

    gradersscoredprocientorbetterinmathin

    2011 compared with 47 percent of non-poor

    students.15 The performance gap is equally

    widein8th-gradereading.

    MoreAfrican-AmericanandLatinohighschoolstudentstake

    AdvancedPlacement(AP)exams.The percentage of African-American students who took an AP exam which carries the

    potential for postsecondary credit quadrupled during the past

    decade, while the percentage of Latino AP test-takers more than

    doubled.16 Increased access has not yielded increased achievement

    however.FivepercentofAfrican-Americanstudents,16percentof

    Latino students and 20 percent of white students scored at least a

    threeoutofveonAPexams.17 While improving scores is the goal,

    studentsbenetfromexposuretorigorouscourseworksuchasAP

    eveniftheydonotearnpassingscores.18

    Illiois 4t-gd dig

    Low-icom/not low-icom

    Wit/Ltio

    Wit/afic-amic

    33 pctgpoits 27 pctgpoits 33 pctgpoits5t wost 11t wost 5t wost

    Illiois 8t-gd mt

    Low-icom/not low-icom

    Wit/Ltio

    Wit/afic-amic

    30 pctgpoits 25 pctgpoits 34 pctgpoits11t wost 19t wost 9t wost

    Gps mi mg t gst i t ti

    Only 33% of Illinois 4th-graders read prociently,spit impmts ss stut gups

    Source:NationalAssessmentofEducationalProgress,200311

    45

    42

    31

    15

    14

    10

    49

    45

    33

    18

    16

    12

    Only 33% of Illinois 8th-graders are procient inmt, tug w-im lti stutsm tb gis

    Source:NationalAssessmentofEducationalProgress,200311

    4140

    29

    10

    9

    6

    47

    44

    33

    19

    17

    10

    Not low-income

    White

    All students

    LatinoLow-income

    African-American

    2003 2005 2007 2009 2011

    Not low-income

    White

    All students

    LatinoLow-income

    African-American

    2003 2005 2007 2009 2011

    O t WbSee how Illinoisstudents perform onadditional subjectsand grade levels, andndexamplesofwhatreading and mathprociencylookslike

    Source:NationalAssessmentofEducationalProgress,2011

    mbargoed until 11/13, 12:01am

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    10/328 | The STaTe Were In: 2012

    Too many students are unprepared for theopportunities and challenges ahead.Tis s tm i-quipp f g t tim w pstsy

    uti mtts m t . ny i i 10 fmiis bi it is imptt fti i t tw- fu-y g. Tys pubi uti systm, w,

    s t i t ti xpttis.

    For every100Illinoisstudentswhobegin9thgrade

    71willgraduatehigh school.

    20

    StudentS who meet3 Or 4ACt CollegereAdineSS benChmArkS

    StudentS who meet

    1 Or 2ACt CollegereAdineSS benChmArkS

    StudentS who meet0ACt College

    reAdineSS benChmArkS

    Stdts wo mt aCT Collg rdiss Bcmks

    have at least a 50 percent chance of earning a B or better in an introductory college course.

    23

    eglis: 18 rdig:21 Mt: 22 Scic: 24

    Two-thirds of them will be unpreparedfor the rigors ahead, while theremaining one-third will have thenecessaryknowledgeandskills.

    28

    Embargoed until 11/13, 12:01

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    11/32advance IllInoIS

    Analysisforthisprojectionisbaseduponthefollowingsources:EducationWeek,EducationCountsReferenceCenter,2009.Lichtenberger,EricJ.andDietrich,Cecile;CollegeReadinessandthePostsecondaryOutcomesofIllinoisHighSchoolStudents,IllinoisEducationResearchCouncil,2012.Lichtenberger,EricJ.andDietrich,Cecile;CollegeReadinessandtheOverlappingOutcomesofCommunityCollegeEntrants,IllinoisEducationResearchCouncil,201213.CalculationsbyEricJ.Lichtenberger,IllinoisEducationResearchCouncil,Oct.25,2012.ACT,IllinoisProleReport,2012.IllinoisInteractiveReportCard,2012.AdvanceIllinoisprovidedtheanalysisforthisprojection.

    9

    4

    16

    T bottom li: hig scool stdts wo mt t o mo aCTcollg-diss bcmks l 75 pct cc of

    ig two- o fo- dg. Bt stdts wo do ot mt

    benchmarks are ve times less likely to graduate postsecondary.

    21

    55willprogresstopostsecondary.

    Most of them will enteracademically unprepared andwillstruggletomakeitthrough.

    29willearnapostsecondary degree.

    More than half will be studentswho met ACT college-readinessbenchmarksinhighschool.Fewof those who were unprepared,however,willgraduate.

    17

    17

    mbargoed until 11/13, 12:01am

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    12/3210 | The STaTe Were In: 2012

    Good schools with supportive environmentscan make all the difference for students.Wt gu i s bsti, w kw tt alli t

    ig s wt ig by 4t g, ig agb i 8t g gutigg ifw, s uts, suppt p tm t i.

    Research shows that students who attend schools with ambitious

    instruction, effective and collaborative educators, supportive

    environmentsandinvolvedfamiliesperformbetteracademically.

    Putsimply,schoolsmatter.Andifwearetosupportmorestudents

    as they progress from preschool through postsecondary, we must

    createasystemofhigh-qualityschoolstocapturetheirpotential.

    Right now, no perfect measures exist to capture whether schools

    havetheessentialcomponentstohelpstudentslearn.Inthis,we

    haveahugedecitofknowledge.Butthegoodnewsisthissoon

    willchange.InJanuary2013,Illinoiswilladministerresearch-based

    school surveys of teachers and students and will share the results

    with educators and families alike provided that schools, teachers

    andstudentsparticipate.Fornow,wedrawonexistingmeasures

    thatprovidesomeinsightsintolearningconditionsandclimate.

    Schoolswithstronglearningenvironmentsare10timesmore

    likelytoimprovestudentachievementthanschoolsthatare

    notorganizedtosupportstudentlearning.19 Research gathered

    across more than 200 Chicago elementary schools over 20 yearssuggests the cornerstones of a well-organized, successful school

    include ambitious instruction, collaborative teachers, effective

    leaders,supportiveenvironmentsandinvolvedfamilies.Chicago

    researcherscalltheseTheFiveEssentialsforschoolsuccess.20

    Researchshowsschoolswithatleastthreeoftheveelementsin

    placearesignicantlymorelikelytoimprovestudentachievement

    inreadingandmath.

    1. ambitios Istctio

    MorestudentsthanevertakeadvancedmathcoursesAlgebra,

    specicallyin8thgrade.21Today,45percentofIllinois8th-graders take advanced math,22upfrom36percentveyears

    earlier.23 While not all Algebra courses are equally rigorous, this

    early exposure places students on a college-prep pathway that

    enablesthemtotakeCalculusinhighschool.24

    ThreeofeveryfourIllinoishighschoolstudentswhotakeatleast

    one semester of courses at a community college ultimately attend a

    four-yearinstitution.25 This compares with 32 percent of students

    whotakenosuchdualenrollmentcourses. 26 Admittedly, these

    studentstendtobeacademicallyinclinedattheoutset.Butschool

    leaders and educators are wise to set the expectation that all highschoolstudentsgraduatewithatleastonecollege-levelexperience

    MorethanaquarterofIllinoisgraduatingseniorstakeatleastone

    AdvancedPlacementtest,providingstudentsanotherexperienceof

    college-levelrigorwhilestillinhighschool.27Of them, 19 percent

    scoreatleastathreeoutofve,28 the minimum required for credit

    inmanypostsecondaryinstitutions.Moreover,thenumberof

    IllinoisstudentsreceivinganInternationalBaccalaureateDiploma

    climbedby75percentduringthepastdecade,althoughthe

    numberremainsquitelowat869participantsstatewide.29

    2. Collboti Tcs

    Aneffectiveteachergeneratesvetosixmoremonthsofstudent

    learning than an ineffective teacher.30 Illinois does not yet track

    teacher effectiveness or teacher retention, information that would

    answerwhetherschoolsrecruitandkeeptheirbestteachers.Nor

    does Illinois capture whether and how teachers collaborate within

    aschool.Wewilllearnmoreasthestatesnewevaluationsystem

    andschoolsurveysrolloutduringthecomingyears.Research

    suggests schools that offer feedback, recognition for work well

    doneandadvancementopportunitiesretaintop-notchteachers.31

    Ss stg i T Fi esstis signicantly more likely to improve

    Mt rig

    Percentageofsubs

    tantially

    improvingstudenttest-

    scoregrowth

    Source:ConsortiumonChicagoSchoolResearchattheUniversityofChicagoUrbanEducationInstitute,2010

    in 35

    0%8%

    12%10%

    35%

    31%

    38%

    50%

    in 12 in 12 in 35

    Wk Stog

    Embargoed until 11/13, 12:01

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    13/32advance IllInoIS |

    3. effcti Lds

    Effectiveprincipalsareanequallycriticalin-schoolfactorforstudent

    learning.32 As school leaders, principals are the linchpin to shaping

    theclimateandthedegreeofcollaborationwithinaschool.Next

    year, with the implementation of a new evaluation system, Illinois

    will have information about the effectiveness of school leaders

    forthersttime.Thenewsurveysofstudentsandteacherswillprovide principals with critical, actionable feedback they can use to

    improvethelearningenvironmentwithintheirschools.

    4. Sppoti eiomts

    TheaverageIllinoishighschoolcounselorworkswith314students,

    makingitdifculttoprovidechildrentheguidanceandsupport

    they need to succeed in the classroom.33Illinoisranks45thamong

    states in its ratio of high school counselors to students, and this

    worsenedduringthepasttwoyears.Gradeschoolstudentsare

    evenlesslikelytointeractwithacounselor.Elementaryandmiddleschool counselors typically see more than 1,400 students, a ratio

    thatranksIllinois43rdnationally.34

    Morethan66,000Illinoisstudentsmissmorethan18daysofschool

    everyyear,35makingitimprobableifnotimpossibleforthemtobe

    academicallyon-tracktosucceed.Thisworksoutto3.2percentof

    studentsstatewide.Studentscannotlearniftheyarenotinclass,

    and research suggests that high school students who show up and

    performwellarevetimesmorelikelytograduatethanstudents

    whoareoff-trackacademically.36

    OneofeveryfourofIllinoisAfrican-Americanstudentsissuspended

    at least once from school.37Illinois schools topped the national

    rankings in the disparity of K12 suspension rates between

    African-Americanstudentsandtheirwhiteclassmates25percent to 4 percent, respectively,38 as noted in the data tables

    ofthisreport.Out-of-schoolsuspensionsoftenleavestruggling

    studentsevenfurtherbehindtheirpeers.

    InChicago,halfofstudentsdonotfeelmostlysafeoutsidetheir

    schools,butstrongrelationshipswiththeadultsinsidetheschool

    can change that.39While more than 80 percent of Chicago students

    felt safe in their classrooms, students felt less safe in campus areas

    withlittleadultsupervision.40 Schools in even the most crime-

    ridden neighborhoods can provide a safe haven by cultivating

    relationships between students and teachers, administrators,

    mentors and coaches who work within the building, giving

    students a better chance to learn, according to research based on

    schoolsurveys.

    5. Iold Fmilis

    Forthersttime,morethanhalfofIllinoispublicschoolsserve

    concentrationsofdisadvantagedstudents,andthestatemust

    redouble efforts to engage the families that often need the most

    support to be involved. Thisyear,55percentofschoolsserve

    populations where at least 40 percent of

    students qualify to receive a free or reduced-

    pricelunch,anindicatorofpoverty.41 That is up

    from35percentadecadeearlier.42

    M ss s ig ptg f w-im stutsIllinois schools with more than 40 percent of students whoreceive a free or reduced-price lunch

    1,373

    2,161

    2001 20112009200720052003

    55%

    35%

    Numberandpercentageo

    fschools

    Source:IllinoisStateBoardofEducationReportCard200411.IllinoisStateReportCard200103maintainedbytheCenterforUrbanEducationLeadership,UniversityofIllinoisatChicago

    O t WbFind moreinformationabout TheFive Essentials

    S uss sp f t ti

    1,419 Stdts

    O K8 coslo

    O ig scool coslo

    314 Stdts

    Source:CommonCoreofData,StateNonscalPublicElementary/SecondaryEducationSurvey

    mbargoed until 11/13, 12:01am

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    14/3212 | The STaTe Were In: 2012

    Other states have advanced key educationreforms and made progress ...S stts tk systmi pps t s impmt ftig

    comprehensive and coherent plans to address local challenges and seen signicantimpmts. Mssustts ffs imptt xmp.

    Massachusettslegislatorsandpartnersbasedthestateslandmark

    EducationReformActof1993onagrandbargain.43 The state

    would set high standards for students at every level, raise the rigor

    of state assessments that culminate in a high school exit exam,

    hold schools accountable and, importantly, put information in the

    handsofparentsandthepublic.Inexchange,thestatepledged

    equitablefundingacrossschooldistricts.Thestatealsofocused

    on efforts to recruit, develop and support teachers and principals,recognizing the central role they play in developing a students

    potential.

    Stateleaderscraftedhighexpectationswithcollaboration.A

    40-member commission developed the 1993 Massachusetts

    Common Core of Learning during nine months, with input culled

    through16publichearingsand2,000writtencommunications.44

    The rest of the country caught up when most states adopted the

    CommonCoreStateStandardsin2010.45

    Massachusettsexpectseducatorstomasternotonlythecontent

    theywillteachbutalsothepedagogyofteaching. It is the onlystate to require a general curriculum test as well as a math

    testforelementaryteachercandidates.46 Candidates also must

    complete36semesterhoursinartsandsciencescoursework.To

    support educators already in classrooms, Massachusetts this year

    will roll out a new evaluation system for teachers, principals and

    superintendents that uses multiple measures to evaluate and

    improveinstructionalpractice.47

    Massachusettspassedthe2010EducationReformActthatprovided

    greaterexibilitytointerveneinchronicallylow-performing

    schools.48Such schools now develop innovation plans that give

    students wraparound services, allow for longer school days, and

    create a performance contract with schools, teachers, students and

    theirfamilies.

    Massachusetts students lead the nation by many measures. Math

    and reading scores on national assessments already were above

    averageandimprovedfurtherduringthepasttwodecades.In

    1992,23percentofMassachusetts8th-gradersscoredprocientor

    higherinmath,aperformancelevelthatclimbedto51percentin

    2011andleadsthenation.49 While Massachusetts demographics

    differ from Illinois one-third of students there qualify as

    low-income as compared to nearly half here Massachusetts

    low-income students outperform their peers in Illinois and other

    statesonnationalassessments.Aquarterofhighschoolstudents

    scoredatleastathreeoutofveonAdvancedPlacementexams,50

    rankingthestatefourthinoverallachievement.Andnearlyeightofevery10Massachusettsstudentsgraduatefromhighschool.51

    Massachusetts showed signicant growth afterputtig ky fms i p

    2000 2002 2006 20101998 20122004 2008

    26%

    30%33%

    51%

    38%

    34%

    46%

    35%

    Percentageofstu

    dentsatorabove

    profcientinm

    ath,

    8th-gradeNAEP

    Percentageofstu

    dentsatorabove

    profcientinr

    eading,

    8th-gradeNAEP

    Source:NationalAssessmentofEducationalProgress,19982011

    Illinois

    Illinois

    Massachusetts

    Massachusetts

    Embargoed until 11/13, 12:01

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    15/32advance IllInoIS |

    Illinois must, too.Iiis uts, piymks ts tgt wkig t stgt t

    uti systm tug it, mpsi st f fms. Wi it is t

    s t s suts, Iiis is its wy su if w bui t fms wit

    bti.

    Illiois is sttig ig, lt d l-lifstdds fo stdts b:

    Implementing the rigorous Common

    Core State Standards in math

    and English Language Arts adopted in 2010, and adjusting

    assessments to measure a wider set of skills against international

    standardsandtoincludestudentachievementgrowthovertime.

    Thenewexamsareexpectedinthe201415schoolyear.

    Raising the scores required to pass the current state exams in

    3rd through 8th grades to accurately measure whether students

    areon-track.Familieswillreceivethenewresultsin2013.

    Creating a developmentally appropriate method to gauge

    whether students are academically, emotionally and socially

    readyforkindergarten.Thepilotincludes5,000studentsin

    2012,10,000studentsin2013andastatewiderolloutin2015.

    Illiois is isig stdds d poidig

    sppots fo tcs d picipls b: Increasing expectations for new teacher candidates and

    implementing more substantive evaluations that provide

    meaningful feedback and draw on multiple measures of

    studentachievementgrowth.

    Creating a new principal endorsement that includes preschool

    andprovidesmoreeldexperienceforprincipalcandidates.

    Preparation programs must reapply for accreditation under

    thenewstandardsby2014.

    Illiois is poidig dctos d fmiliswit lt d timl dt bot stdtpfomc b:

    Developing a cutting-edge system that gives teachers real-time

    information about their students performance to use as they

    planinstruction.Thesystemwillbeshapedbyspring2013.

    Creating a longitudinal data system by summer 2013 that

    allows all involved to understand how students progress

    from birth through postsecondary, and where gaps and

    challengespersist.

    Administering research-based surveys to collect information

    about learning climate and conditions in schools statewide

    that may be used to qualitatively and quantitatively drive

    improvement.TheUniversityofChicagosUrbanEducation

    InstitutewillrolloutthesurveysstatewideinJanuary2013.

    Illiois is ctig ccotbilit sstmtt sps pscool to postscod dpttig ifomtio i tds of t pblic b:

    Revising school report cards to help families

    betterunderstandhowschoolsanddistrictsservestudents.This

    includes details about how students in every school progress

    from one stage to the next, drawing on measures such as how

    many students attend preschool before kindergarten or how

    manyfreshmenenterhighschoolacademicallyon-track.Thenewreportcardswillbereleasedin2013.

    Awaiting federal approval for a new accountability system that

    would measure schools by how well they prepare students to

    succeedincollegeandcareers.Specically,thiswouldreect

    how well a schools students achieve and reach key milestones

    suchasgraduation.

    Illiois is impoig low-pfomig scoolsd ctig dditiol scool optios d

    ccss fo fmilis b: Buildingonitscommitmenttoserve3-and4-year-oldsin

    need with early childhood programs that give them a strong

    startinschoolandinlife.

    Creating a Center for School Improvement this year to support

    chronically low-performing schools and districts as they

    stabilize the learning environment for students and provide

    oversightwherenecessary.Thisisasignicantundertaking

    andmuchridesonthequalityoftheendeavor.

    rd mo bot Illiois fom pls o pgs 1415.

    O t WbLearn more aboutthe Common Core inIllinois classrooms

    O t WbSee what the nschool report cwill look like

    mbargoed until 11/13, 12:01am

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    16/3214 | The STaTe Were In: 2012

    Stdt Stdds, assssmtsd Tsitios

    Tc d Ld effcti

    Sethigh,relevantandreal-lifestandardsforstudentsandimproveassessmentstoreectcollege-andcareer-readyexpectations.

    Raisestandardsandprovidesupportsfoteachers and principals to continually imtheir instructional practice.

    Pre-

    2012

    apt t igus cmm cStt Sts (2010)

    Ji mutistt fft t p nxtGti Si sts (2011)

    ct w piip smtt ius ps s fcompetency-based eld experienc(2010)

    2012

    Impmts ig sts f bittug g 5.

    cts STeM lig exgs

    lus Kigt Iiiudpmt Suy (KIdS) pit wit5,000 stuts

    Wks t ig sts btw K12

    mmuity g 9t-gs tk eXPlore 10t-

    gs tk Plan

    riss xpttis f ty t tpp pgms

    Tis uts i witut utis

    Bgis w piip utis

    Bgis w ut utis icig Pubi Ss

    Pits w pfm ssssm

    t its dps w ut isig s

    apps piip pgms uw sts (201214)

    2013

    Impmts t igus cmm cStt Sts

    Pts wit c t pissssmt suppt

    Raises ISAT cut score to reect college iss

    11t-gs tk WkKys (jbs skis)

    rsigs y i, m mi s t pppgms t w sts

    Bss s utis-i-fisis uti pfmtigs

    rsigs supitt pppgms t w sts

    2014 exps kigt iss pit tiu 10,000 i rsigs ig s t p

    pgms t w sts

    2015 amiists w stt xms ig t

    cmm c (spig)

    Impmts kigt-issmsu i ss sttwi

    Impmts w ut utss sttwi

    Impmts w pfm-bsstut t ssssmt

    Wit bti ,

    Iiis uts, gists

    pts ft mk

    fms t imp uti

    pptuitis f stuts.

    T itkig fms st ig

    sts f stuts, msu

    wt stuts -tk

    t y stp f t mi

    pipi, put btt ifmti

    i t s f piips

    ts, stgt ut

    utis, itsify ffts t

    imp stuggig ss,

    sig s pt s t

    gi fmiis m ifmti

    but ti is s

    istit.

    Iiis w must impmt ts

    fms tugtfuy but ugtyuig t mig ys.

    Timeline of Illinois School Reform

    O t WbLearn moreabout additionalIllinois educationreforms

    Embargoed until 11/13, 12:01

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    17/32advance IllInoIS |

    Dt d Ifomtio Tcolog accotbilit d GocScool Tsfomtios, Optios

    d accss

    uild a longitudinal data system that providesducatorsandfamilieswithtimelyinformationbouthowstudentsperformandprogresshrough the educational system.

    Improveaccountabilityfortheentireeducationsystem,fromearlyeducationthroughpostsecondary,andclearlycommunicatetheresults to the public.

    Improvechronicallylow-performingschoolsanddistricts,andcreateadditionaloptionsandaccess for families.

    ri $20 mii+ i f fus tbui gitui t systm (2009)

    Iiis P20 cui ppit (2009)

    Iiis Bugtig f rsuts cmmissippit (2011)

    cmmitt t s 3- 4-y-si wit stt-fu pspgms (2006)

    rqui tt igib stuts ibiigu y i istuti(2010)

    ct t Iiis ct Scmmissi (2011)

    ri $210 mii i f S

    Impmt Gts (201014) aw impmt gts t 28 w-

    pfmig ig ss i 10 istits(201012)

    cts g f gitui tsystm

    rsigs y i Quity cutstig systm t iu pfm

    Its i tw iy w-pfmig s istits: estSt. luis nt cig

    estbiss t ct f SImpmt

    amiists s imt suys(T Fi esstis) sttwi

    Pits S lig eimt tgi ts -tim ifmti tus i istuti

    lus S lig eimti r t t Tp istits

    lus gitui t systm

    rquis i pis t i Quity cuts s iti fisig

    rss sig pt s fss istits

    exts S lig eimt ts istits sttwi

    mbargoed until 11/13, 12:01am

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    18/3216 | The STaTe Were In: 2012

    Illinois spans from the heart of Chicago to the heartland of

    downstate, and the states public schools and students increasingly

    reectthisdiversity.

    This year, nearly half of the 2 million students enrolled in Illinois

    publicschoolsareraciallyandethnicallydiverse.MinoritystudentssoonwillrepresentamajorityofIllinoispublicschoolchildren.

    Nearly half of students enrolled in K12 49 percent are

    low-income,upfrom38percentadecadeago.Aboutonein10is

    identiedasanEnglish-languagelearnermeaningtheyhave

    notyetpassedanEnglish-competencyexam.And14percentof

    Illinois students enrolled in kindergarten through high school areidentiedashavingspeciallearningneeds.

    Student attendance at public charter schools is higher than two

    yearsago,althoughthestudentsrepresentjust2.4percentofthe

    statesK12enrollment.

    Prole of Illinois Education System

    Sits1. nuMBer OF SChOOLS

    el edctio 2012 2010 K12 2012 2010 Postscod 2012 2010

    Public* 2,157 2,187 Public 3,904 3,871 Public 2-year (communitycollege) 48 48

    Private Data unavailable Public Charter52

    (124campuses)39

    (111campuses)Public 4-year (universities) 12 12

    Private 1,131 1,135 Privatenot-for-prot(colleges/universities)

    99 94

    Public districts 868 869 Privatefor-prot(in-state) 31 35

    *Unlessotherwisenoted,publicEarlyEducationreferstoIllinoisstate-fundedPreschoolforAllprogramandfederallyfundedHeadStartprogramswithinthestate.InEarlyEducation,theNumberofSchoolsreferstothenumberofPreschoolforAllandHeadStartsites.

    eollmt2. TOTaL POPuLaTIOn

    el edctio 2012 2010 K12 2012 2010 Postscod 2012 2010

    Ages 04 835,577 Ages517 2,308,341 Ages 1824 1,245,918

    Preschool for All* 83,696 95,123 Public 2,066,692 2,064,312 Public 2 -year 277,350 242,468

    Head Start* 38,219 36,871 Public charter 53,189 35,485 Public 4-year 152,795 151,226

    Home Visiting*State-funded 22,650 Data unavailable

    Private 241,323 264,012Private not-

    for-prot138,241 139,535

    Federally funded 3,780 2,354 Private for-prot

    79,317 62,788Private Data unavailable Data unavailable

    *Datareectsthenumberofprogramslots,sofewerchildrenmay,infact,beserved,ascombinedfundingstreamscanleadtodouble-countingofprogramslots.

    3. PuBLIC SChOOL enrOLLMenT PrOFILe

    el edctio K12

    Postscod

    Public 2-year Public 4-yearPrivate not-for-

    protPrivate for-

    prot

    2012 2010 2012 2010 2012 2010 2012 2010 2012 2010 2012 2010

    Male 52%* 54%* 51% 51% 43% 43% 48% 48% 42% 42% 42% 41%Female 48%* 46%* 49% 49% 57% 57% 52% 52% 58% 58% 58% 59%

    White 33% 36% 51% 53% 57% 64% 62% 65% 61% 62% 39% 47%

    African-American 30% 30% 18% 19% 16% 17% 14% 13% 10% 10% 26% 28%

    Latino 31% 28% 24% 21% 17% 12% 9% 8% 11% 9% 11% 12%

    Asian/PacicIslander 2% 2% 4% 4% 4% 5% 7% 7% 6% 6% 2% 3%

    Low-income 70% 73% 49% 45% 27% 24% 32% 26% 26% 22%

    LimitedEnglishProcient 20% 27% 9% 8%

    Special Education 14% 15% 14% 13%

    *Dataavailableonlyforthestate-fundedPreschoolforAllprogram.

    O t WbLearn more aboutthe data measuresin this report

    Embargoed until 11/13, 12:01

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    19/32advance IllInoIS |

    Fdig

    4. GOvernMenT FunDInG Per PuPIL

    el edctio 2012 2010 K12 2012 2010 Postscod 2012 2010

    State (PreschoolforAll)

    $3,449 $3,438 Local $7,162 $6,837Public 2-year

    $5,496 $1,919 $5,693 $2,690

    Federal(HeadStart)

    $8,119 $7,730 State $4,145 $3,971Public 4-year

    $7,603 $5,854 $8,157 $6,461

    Federal $1,816 $948 Privatenot-for-prot Total:$5,014 Total: $4,906

    Privatefor-prot Notapplicable Notapplicable

    5. TuITIOn PaID Per PuPIL

    el edctio 2012 2010 K12 2012 2010 Postscod 2012 2010

    Data unavailable Notapplicable Public 2-year $2,796 $2,887

    Public 4-year $9,293 $8,434

    Privatenot-for-prot $18,269 $17,529

    Privatefor-prot Data unavailable Data unavailable

    6. InSTruCTIOn exPenDITure Per PuPIL

    el edctio 2012 2010 K12 2012 2010 Postscod 2012 2010

    Data unavailable

    $6,920

    (19thof50)

    $6,022

    (20thof50)

    Public 2-year $8,122 $7,962

    Public 4-year $17,276 $15,404

    Privatenot-for-prot $26,653 $26,013

    Privatefor-prot Data unavailable Data unavailable

    7. TOTaL exPenDITure Per PuPIL

    el edctio 2012 2010 K12 2012 2010 Postscod 2012 2010

    State (PreschoolforAll)

    $3,449(32ndof50)

    $3,438

    $11,634(15thof

    50)

    $10,246(17thof

    50)Public 2-year $10,814 $10,702

    Public 4-year $36,074 $35,395

    Federal(HeadStart)

    $8,119 $7,730 Privatenot-for-prot $42,784 $41,647

    Privatefor-prot Data unavailable Data unavailable

    mbargoed until 11/13, 12:01am

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    20/3218 | The STaTe Were In: 2012

    Illinois enrolls 20 percent of 3-year-olds and 29 percent of 4-year-olds

    in state-funded preschool programs and is a national leader in

    providingaccesstoearlyeducation.Yetthisrepresentslessthan

    one-third of our youngest children, and fewer still may be served in

    thecomingyearsbecauseofbudgetpressures.

    Access to early education improved dramatically during the past

    decade, but the rate of growth slowed recently as the economy

    worsenedandstatefundingdeclined.Illinoisserved12percentfewer

    studentsinstate-fundedpreschoolprogramsfrom2009to2011.

    Questionsofaccessaside,signicantinformationgapspersist

    aboutearlychildhoodprograms.Wedonotknowwhetherchildren

    are emotionally, academically and socially ready as they begin

    theirK12careers.Weknowlittleaboutthequalityofchildrens

    early education experience, about the demographic or economic

    backgrounds of students served in state-funded programs, and

    whether students eligible for bilingual early childhood instruction,

    infact,receivetheservicesthatstatelawnowrequires.

    Allofthisinformationwouldhelpidentifygapsandtargetresources.

    ThankstorecenteffortsbytheIllinoisStateBoardofEducation

    and partners, however, the state is piloting a developmentally

    appropriatekindergartenreadinesstoolthisfall.Wehopetohave

    dataonthisimportantmeasureinthecomingyears.

    Butbecauseofthecurrentcriticalinformationgap,thestates

    grade in early education is Incomplete,asitwasin2010.

    Early Education

    K Otcoms

    are ILLInOIS ChILDren enTerInG SChOOL reaDy?Pfomc eit Gp: Sbgop eollmt

    Current 2-YrPrior 5-YrPrior 10-YrPrior Leading State I L Rank WhiteAfrican-

    AmericanLatino

    Low-income

    SpecialEducation

    8. Cild dmosttigdiss fo kidgt

    Dataunavailable.Importantly,theIllinoisStateBoardofEducationispilotingtheKindergartenIndividualDevelopmentSurveywith5,000studentsthisfallandplanstoincludeanother10,000studentsnextyear.

    Thesurveyisexpectedtorolloutstatewidein2015.

    Lig Coditios d Ldig Idictos

    DO ILLInOIS ChILDren have aCCeSS TO hIGh-quaLITy PrOGraMS?

    Pfomc eit Gp: Sbgop eollmt

    Current 2-YrPrior 5-YrPrior 10-YrPrior Leading State IL Rank WhiteAfrican-

    AmericanLatino

    Low-income

    SpecialEducation

    9. Pct of t-iskcild d 3 witccss to pogm tticlds om isitig

    STATE-FUNDED

    23% Data unavailable Data unavailable

    FEDERALLYFUNDED

    4% 2% Data unavailable Notapplicable Data unavailable

    10. 3--olds olld ipblicl fdd pscool

    STATE-FUNDED

    20% 21% 14% 8%(2003) IL 20% 1st

    24% 70% 45% Dataunavailable

    FEDERALLYFUNDED

    9% 8% 8% 8%(2003) MS 24% 14th

    11. 4--olds olld ipblicl fdd pscool

    STATE-FUNDED

    29% 29% 23% 22%(2003) FL 76% 15th

    FEDERALLYFUNDED

    12% 11% 10% 10%(2003) MS 36% 16th

    Illiois Gd: Incomplete

    Embargoed until 11/13, 12:01

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    21/32advance IllInoIS |

    DO ILLInOIS ChILDren have aCCeSS TO hIGh-quaLITy PrOGraMS?

    Pfomc eit Gp: Sbgop eollmt

    Current 2-YrPrior 5-YrPrior 10-YrPrior Leading State IL Rank WhiteAfrican-

    AmericanLatino

    Low-income

    SpecialEducation

    12. Cild sdb licsd cildcpogm wit tiolccdittio

    15% 19% Data unavailable Data unavailable Data unavailable

    13. eglis-lggls i ppopitpogm

    Data unavailable

    are ILLInOIS ChILDren TauGhT By eFFeCTIve eDuCaTOrS?

    Pfomc eit Gp: Sbgop eollmt

    Current 2-YrPrior 5-YrPrior 10-YrPrior Leading State IL Rank WhiteAfrican-

    AmericanLatino

    Low-income

    SpecialEducation

    14. Highly qualiedistctos i stt-fddpscools*

    100% 100% 100% 100%(2003)

    IL 100% 1st of 39 Data unavailable

    15. Pctg of stt-

    fdd pscool tcswit biligl o eSLdosmt

    9% Data unavailable Data unavailable Data unavailable

    16. Tcs dmosttigffctiss

    Data unavailable

    are We PrOvIDInG STuDenTS WITh an envIrOnMenT ThaT SuPPOrTS LearnInG?

    Pfomc eit Gp: Sbgop eollmt

    Current 2-YrPrior 5-YrPrior 10-YrPrior Leading State IL Rank WhiteAfrican-

    AmericanLatino

    Low-income

    SpecialEducation

    17. Miimm lgt of d fostt-fdd pogms**

    2.5 2.5Determined

    locallyAR 7.1 27th of 39 Data unavailable

    18. qlit of iomt Data unavailable

    are We SCreenInG STuDenTS TO IDenTIFy DeLayS?

    Pfomc eit Gp: Sbgop eollmt

    Current 2-YrPrior 5-YrPrior 10-YrPrior Leading State IL Rank WhiteAfrican-

    AmericanLatino

    Low-income

    SpecialEducation

    19. el ls ciigdlopmtl scig

    41% 35% Data unavailable Data unavailable

    *Highlyqualiedisdenedasrequiringteacherstohavebachelorsdegreesandspecializedtraininginprekindergarten,requiringassistantteacherstohaveChildDevelopmentAssociate(CDA)certication,andrequiringatleast15hoursperyearofin-service.

    **Averagehoursarecalculatedbasedonthenumberoftotalhoursperyear,dividedby176,whichisthenumberofschooldaysinIllinois.

    (COnT.)

    mbargoed until 11/13, 12:01am

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    22/3220 | The STaTe Were In: 2012

    Today more than of half of Illinois public schools serve

    concentrations of disadvantaged students where at least 40

    percent of students qualify to receive a free or reduced-price

    lunch,anindicatorofpoverty.Thatsupfrom35percentof

    schools10yearsearlier.

    In the face of this demographic shift, Illinois academic performance

    improvedmodestlyinthecoresubjectsofreadingandmath.Illinois

    students across nearly all demographic and economic groups

    improved slightly during recent years, although not enough to raise

    theaggregateperformancelevel.Thestatesachievementgaps

    persistandremainamongthewidestinthecountry.

    One-thirdofIllinois4th-gradersreadprociently,whichisofgreat

    concern given the strong correlation between this early indicator

    andlatersuccess.Performanceincreasedonly2percentage

    pointsinthepastdecade.Theoveralltotalmasksthefactthat

    a shockingly low 18 percent of Latino and 12 percent of African-

    Americanstudentsreadprocientlyonthe4thgradenational

    assessment.

    Giventhesehistoricchallenges,itisprobablynotsurprising

    but nonetheless disturbing that less than one-third of Illinois

    students who begin high school will go on to earn a postsecondarydegree.

    With such grim news, it might surprise readers to see that Illinois

    improved its overall grade from a D in 2010 to a Cin2012.Two

    factorscontributed.First,duetoanabsenceofdata,Illinoiscouldnot

    be rated on the quality of learning conditions in K12 schools this

    year,anareawherethestatefaredpoorlyin2010.Importantly,the

    state will administer research-based teacher and student surveys

    this spring, which will provide useful information about learning

    andteachingconditionsinIllinoisschools.Second,byholding

    steady, Illinois standing actually improved in the national rankings

    asotherstates(facingsimilardemographicchanges)declined.

    K12

    Ky outms

    are STuDenTS On-TraCK In earLy GraDeS?

    Pfomc eit Gp: Pfomc b Sbgop

    Current 2-YrPrior 5-YrPrior 10-YrPrior Leading State IL Rank WhiteAfrican-

    AmericanLatino

    Low-income

    SpecialEducation

    20. 4th-graders procient orbo i dig o naeP

    33% 32% 32% 31% MA 50% 27th 45% 12% 18% 16% 13%

    21. 4th-graders procient or

    bo i mt o naeP

    38% 38% 36% 32% MA 58% 32nd 51% 14% 20% 20% 19%

    are STuDenTS On-TraCK aS They enTer hIGh SChOOL?

    Pfomc eit Gp: Pfomc b Sbgop

    Current 2-YrPrior 5-YrPrior 10-YrPrior Leading State IL Rank WhiteAfrican-

    AmericanLatino

    Low-income

    SpecialEducation

    22. 8th-graders procient orbo i dig o naeP

    34% 33% 30% 35% MA 46% 26th 44% 15% 23% 19% 8%

    23. 8th-graders procient orbo i mt o naeP

    33% 33% 31% 29% MA 51% 28th 44% 10% 19% 17% 10%

    24. 8t-gds olld icollg-tck mt (algb oig)

    45% 39% 36% CA 64%13th

    of 49*47% 42% 40% 38% 29%

    *Alaskanotincludedinrankingsbecauseofinsufcientdata.

    Illiois Gd: C

    Embargoed until 11/13, 12:01

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    23/32advance IllInoIS |

    are STuDenTS COMPLeTInG hIGh SChOOL reaDy FOr COLLeGe Or Career?

    Pfomc eit Gp: Pfomc b Sbgop

    Current 2-YrPrior 5-YrPrior 10-YrPrior Leading State IL Rank WhiteAfrican-

    AmericanLatino

    Low-income

    SpecialEducation

    25. Pctg of stdtsgdtig ig scoolanD dmosttig collgdiss o t lst Threesbjct bcmks o t

    aCT

    27% Data unavailable Data unavailable Data unavailable

    26. hig scoolgdtio t (CPI**mtod)

    71% 75% 76% 72% NJ 87% 34th 79% 51% 62%Data

    unavailable

    27. Pctg of stdtsdmosttig collgdiss o

    ...allFOURsubjectbenchmarksontheACT

    25% 23% 21%Data

    unavailable

    CO/IL 25% 1st of 9***

    35% 5% 10%Data

    unavailableMN 36%12th

    of 28***

    ...atleastTHREEsubjectbenchmarksontheACT

    38% Data unavailable

    ND 39% 3rd of 9***

    52% 11% 20%Data

    unavailableMN 54%13th

    of 28***

    28. Stdts dmosttigwok-diss o WokKs

    Reading

    54% 60% 62%Data

    unavailableData unavailable 65% 31% 38% 36% 17%

    Math

    57% 59% 61%Data

    unavailableData unavailable 70% 25% 42% 36% 18%

    **CPI=CumulativePromotionIndex

    ***Illinoisisoneofninestatesinwhich100percentofstudentsinthegraduatingclassof2012tooktheACTandthisprovidesthemostaccuratecomparison.Inthe28stateswhereatleast50percentofstudentstooktheACT,allofIllinoisstudentsarecomparedtoalargelyself-selectedcollege-goinggroup.

    Lig Coditios d Ldig IdictosDO ILLInOIS ChILDren have aCCeSS TO ChaLLenGInG PrOGraMS?

    Pfomc eit Gp: Pfomc b Sbgop

    Current 2-YrPrior 5-YrPrior 10-YrPrior Leading State IL Rank WhiteAfrican-

    AmericanLatino

    Low-income

    SpecialEducation

    29. hig scool stdtsolld i dcdcoswok

    ...whoeithertookatleast1APexaminhighschoolorwereenrolledintheInternationalBaccalaureateDiplomaProgramme(IBDP)

    29% 25% 22%Data

    unavailableData unavailable 27%**** 22%**** 31%**** Data unavailable

    ...successfulinadvancedclasses(receivedatleastone3onanAPexam)

    19% 17% 15% 11% MD 28% 16th 20% 5% 16% Data unavailable

    30. hig scool stdts idl-cdit coss

    7% Data unavailable Data unavailable

    31. Stdts slf-potig(o t aCT) tt ttkig collg-dciclm

    54% 52% 41% 53%

    LA 84%9thof 9

    62% 48% 48%Data

    unavailableSD&

    MN87%

    28thof

    28***

    ****EquitygapdatareectonlyAPtest-takers.However,thepercentageofIllinoisjuniorsandseniorsinIBDPislessthan0.5percentandlikelywouldnotchangetheequitygappercentages.

    (K12 continued)

    mbargoed until 11/13, 12:01am

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    24/3222 | The STaTe Were In: 2012

    are ILLInOIS ChILDren TauGhT By eFFeCTIve eDuCaTOrS?

    Pfomc eit Gp: Pfomc b Sbgop

    Current 2-YrPrior 5-YrPrior10-YrPrior

    Leading State IL Rank WhiteAfrican-

    AmericanLatino

    Low-income

    SpecialEducation

    32. hig scool tcs witdegrees in the same eld asti mi tcig ssigmt

    92% 92% Data unavailable WI 93%2nd

    of50Data unavailable

    33. Tcs dmosttigffctiss

    Datacurrentlyunavailable,willbereportedinnearfuture

    are We PrOvIDInG STuDenTS WITh an envIrOnMenT ThaT SuPPOrTS LearnInG?

    Pfomc eit Gp: Pfomc b Sbgop

    Current 2-YrPrior 5-YrPrior 10-YrPrior Leading State IL Rank WhiteAfrican-

    AmericanLatino

    Low-income

    SpecialEducation

    34. Miimm istctiolos p

    880 880 880 880 TX 1260 41st Notapplicable

    35. Iold Fmilis: T tistff bilds stog tlltiosips (Studentandteacherreported)

    Datacurrentlyunavailable,butastatewidesurveywillbeadministeredinJanuary2013.Theresearch-basedsurveyofteachersandstudentstobeadministerediscalled

    TheFiveEssentials.ThesurveywasdevelopedbytheConsortiumonChicagoSchoolResearchattheUniversityofChicagoUrbanEducationInstitutethathasbeenstudyingschoolsand

    whatmakesthemsuccessfulforthelast20years.

    36. Sppoti eiomt:T scool is sf, dmdig,d sppoti (Studentandteacherreported)

    37. effcti Lds: Piciplsd tcs implmt sd isio fo sccss (Teacherreported)

    38. Collboti Tcs:Tcs collbot to pomotpofssiol gowt (Teacherreported)

    39. ambitios Istctio:Clsss cllgig d -

    ggig (Studentandteacherreported)

    40. Tc ttio Data unavailable

    41. K12 sspsio t 9.8% Data unavailable ND 2% 41st 4% 25% 8% N/A 19%

    42. Scool coslo p K12stdts (lowvalueisbest)

    High school

    1:314 1:294 1:291 1:296 WY 1:96 45th Data unavailable

    K8

    1:1,419 1:1,421 1:1,408 1:1,371 NH 1:275 43rd Data unavailable

    Notapplicable

    are STuDenTS On-TraCK?

    Pfomc eit Gp: Pfomc b SbgopCurrent 2-YrPrior 5-YrPrior 10-YrPrior Leading State IL Rank White

    African-American

    LatinoLow-

    incomeSpecial

    Education

    43. Coic tc(studentsabsentfor18ormoreofthelast180schooldayswithoutvalidcause)

    3.2% 3.7% 2.2% 2.2% Data unavailable

    44. Fsm o-tck togdt ig scool

    Datacurrentlyunavailable,butwillbereportedinfall2013

    Data unavailableDatacurrentlyunavailable,butwillbe

    reportedinfall2013

    45. Stdts dmosttigppopit cdmic gowt

    Datacurrentlyunavailable,butwillbereportedinfall2013

    Data unavailableDatacurrentlyunavailable,butwillbe

    reportedinfall2013

    O t WbSee recent examples ofschool survey results fromChicago Public Schools

    Embargoed until 11/13, 12:01

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    25/32advance IllInoIS |

    Pjtig hw My Stuts Psist tug Pstsy

    Thisreportopenswithastatisticthatreectsanimportant

    challenge ahead: For every 100 Illinois students who enter high

    school, fewer than three-quarters will graduate and not even one-

    thirdwillcompletepostsecondary.

    Thisstartlingstatisticisaprojection.Thatistosay,theanalysisfor

    this calculation-tracked the performance of students in the class

    of 2003 through 2010 as they progressed through high schoolandpostsecondary.Forthiscohortanalysis,theIllinoisEducation

    Research Council examined everything from how prepared the

    students were in high school to how quickly they completed a

    two-orfour-yeardegree.Toreectcurrentachievementpatterns,

    Advance Illinois factored in the states updated graduation rate and

    ACT college-readiness scores to calculate how likely Illinois students

    aretomakeitthrough.

    The projection varies from the data measure listed in the tables of

    this report, where we cite the percentage of students who pursue a

    postsecondaryeducation.Hereswhy:

    The projection calculates the percentage of Illinois 9th-graders

    whopursueapostsecondaryeducationas55percentandgoes on to project that 29 percent of those same 9th-graders

    ultimatelycompletepostsecondary.Thestartingpointfor

    this calculation is high school and this includes all students

    who pursue a postsecondary degree whether they enroll

    part-time or full-time, whether they enroll immediately upon

    high school graduation or later, and whether they complete a

    degreeinfouryearsorsevenyears.Postsecondaryenrollment

    patterns suggest that students increasingly pursue additional

    educationatmyriadtimesintheirlives.

    Thedatatablesindicate57percentofhighschoolgraduatesenrollinpostsecondaryasrst-time,full-timestudentswithin

    ayearofcompletinghighschool.Thisisausefulleading

    indicator.Butthispoint-in-timemeasuredoesnotreectthe

    progressionofstudentsthroughtheyears.

    Theprojectionprovidedhereisbynomeansaperfectmethodology.

    ButatAdvanceIllinois,webelieveitmoreaccuratelyreectsoverall

    postsecondaryenrollmentandpersistenceinthestateovertime.

    When Illinois completes its new longitudinal data system in 2013,

    we will be able to track how actual students progress rather than

    relyonprojections.

    For now, in the absence of longitudinal information, this allows

    us to examine how students perform over time as they progressfromearlychildhoodthroughpostsecondary.Whetherasparents

    or policymakers, this is how we need to think about how our

    educationalsystemservesstudents.

    advance IllInoIS |mbgod til 11/13, 12:01m

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    26/3224 | The STaTe Were In: 2012

    At a time when postsecondary education matters more than ever,

    toofewstudentsnishhighschoolreadyforfurtheracademic

    studyorforwork.Thesestudentsarefarlesslikelytoenrollinthe

    rstplaceandfarmorelikelytodropoutbeforetheycompletea

    postsecondarydegree.

    Thisisreectedinlowpostsecondaryenrollmentrates(just

    40 percent of high school freshmen enroll in postsecondary),

    high remediation rates (nearly half of community college

    studentsrequireatleastoneremedialcourse)andinsufcient

    postsecondary attainment rates (38 percent of Illinois adults hold

    an associate degree or higher at a time when eight of every 10 jobs

    requiresuchtraining).Whilegraduationratesclimbedforpublic

    andprivatenot-for-protfour-yearinstitutionsduringthepast

    decade, they fell among community colleges, resulting in overall

    completion rates above the national average but still not good

    enough.

    Compounding the challenge is the increasing cost of

    postsecondary.Itcostsanaveragefamily21percentofitsincome

    to send a student to a four-year public university, making Illinois

    oneoftheleastaffordablestatesinthecountry.

    These two factors readiness and affordability continue to

    constrainthestatespostsecondaryattainment.Forthisreason,

    Illinois receives a C+ for postsecondary readiness and success, up

    slightly from a Cin2010.

    Postsecondary Readinessand Success

    K Otcoms

    are STuDenTS enTerInG anD COMPLeTInG SOMe POSTSeCOnDary eDuCaTIOn?

    Pfomc eit Gp: Pfomc b Sbgop

    Current 2-YrPrior 5-YrPrior 10-YrPrior Leading State IL Rank WhiteAfrican-

    AmericanLatino

    Low-income

    SpecialEducation

    46. Stdts wopsist fom t sttof ig scool togpostscod gdtio

    29%Data

    unavailable32% Data unavailable Data unavailable

    47. hig scoolgdts goig to

    collg

    57% 60% 55%Data

    unavailable

    MS 77% 40th Data unavailable

    48. Gdtio t

    2- istittios*

    Public**

    19% 21% 22% 22% FL 38% 18th of 38 24% 9% 13% Data unavailable

    Privatefor-prot***

    58% 59% 66% 80% WY 79% 19th of 34 69% 49% 64% Data unavailable

    4- istittios*

    Public

    63% 59% 59% 56% DE 71% 9th of 47 68% 39% 45% Data unavailable

    Privatenot-for-prot

    66% 65% 64% 62% DC 77% 17th of 38 68% 42% 60% Data unavailablePrivatefor-prot

    27% 27% 36% 36% SC 60% 17th of 30 34% 16% 28% Data unavailable

    Wigtd g fo 2- d 4- istittios

    47% 46% 46% 44% MA 58% 17th of 42 Data unavailable

    49. adlts 25 d old wit ssocit dg o ig

    38% 37% Data unavailable DC 53% 16th 40% 26% 17%Data

    unavailable

    *Graduationratescalculatedusing150percenttime,orsixyearsforfour-yearinstitutionsandthreeyearsfortwo-yearinstitutions.

    **Graduationcohortdataiscalculatedonlyforrst-time,full-timefreshmen.Thesegraduationratesaccountforonlyabout50percentofstudentsatfor-prottwo-yearinstitutions.

    ***Graduationcohortdataiscalculatedonlyforrst-time,full-timefreshmen.Thesegraduationratesaccountforonlyabout30percentofstudentsatcommunitycolleges.

    Illiois Gd: C+

    Embargoed until 11/13, 12:01

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    27/32advance IllInoIS |

    Lig Coditios & Ldig Idictos

    IS COLLeGe aFFOrDaBLe anD are STuDenTS FInIShInG On TIMe?

    Pfomc eit Gp: Pfomc b Sbgop

    Current 2-YrPrior 5-YrPrior 10-YrPrior Leading State IL Rank WhiteAfrican-

    AmericanLatino

    Low-income

    SpecialEducation

    50. Pctg of icomcss to p fo collg****

    21% 18% Data unavailable WY 9% 46th Data unavailable 77%Data

    unavailable

    51. 4- istittiosgdtig 60% of stdts i6 s (t tiol ggdtio t is 60%)

    Public

    4 / 11 2 / 11 3 / 10 2 / 10 IA 100% 9th 55% 9% 9% Dataunavailable

    Privatenot-for-prot

    22 /54

    24 /52

    19/53 21/53 DC 77% 17th 63% 17% 34%Data

    unavailable

    52. Fsm i pblic 2-collgs tkig mdilcoswok (lowvalueisbest)

    49% Data unavailable UT 23%11thof 29

    43% 63% 60% 59%Data

    unavailable

    53. yog dlts ot of scool,ot of wok(lowvalueisbest)

    15% 13%

    (changeindatacollection,

    cantcomparebefore2008)

    ND 7% 18th Data unavailable

    ****UsingmedianfamilyincomeinIllinois($66,166)andthenetcost(tuitionandroomandboardlessfederal,stateneed-andnon-need-basedaid,andinstitutionalaid)ofattendingapublicfour-yearuniversity

    are STuDenTS PerSISTInG?

    Pfomc eit Gp: Pfomc b Sbgop

    Current2-YrPrior

    5-YrPrior

    10-YrPrior Leading State IL Rank WhiteAfrican-

    AmericanLatino

    Low-income

    SpecialEducation

    54. Fsm tig 2d (2- istittios)

    Public

    54% 50% 52%Data

    unavailableNY 61%

    14th of37

    Data unavailable

    Privatenot-for-protandfor-prot

    58% 55% 57%Data

    unavailableWY 83%

    26th of28

    Data unavailable

    55. Fsm tig 2d (4- istittios)

    Public

    80% 80% 81%Data

    unavailableDE 88%

    14th of50

    Data unavailable

    Privatenot-for-prot

    78% 77% 78%Data

    unavailableCA 86%

    18th of33

    Data unavailable

    mbargoed until 11/13, 12:01am

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    28/3226 | The STaTe Were In: 2012

    1. NationalSkillsCoalition,Middle-SkillJobsState-By-State:Illinois,2011.

    2. U.S.CensusBureau,AmericanCommunitySurvey,2010.

    3. National Center for Higher Education Management Systems, A PublicAgenda for Illinois Higher Education: Planning for Career and CollegeSuccess,2008.

    4. The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, TertiaryLevelEducationalAttainmentforAgeGroups2564,2009.

    5. GeorgetownUniversityCenteronEducationandtheWorkforce,TheCollegeAdvantage,2012.

    6. The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development,TheProgramme forInternationalStudentAssessment,2009.

    7. National Institute for Early Education Research, The State of Preschool,2011.

    8. IllinoisPublicAct95793.

    9. Layzer,Jean,andPrice,Cristofer;ClosingtheGapintheSchoolReadiness of Low-Income Children, prepared for a working meeting

    onrecentschoolreadinessresearch:GuidingtheSynthesisofEarlyChildhoodResearch,2008.

    10. The Illinois Kindergarten Readiness Assessment StakeholderCommittee,ANewBeginning:TheIllinoisKindergartenIndividualDevelopmentSurvey,2011.

    11. National Center for Education Statistics, NAEP Results StateComparison,TheNationsReportCard,2011.

    12.AnnieE.CaseyFoundation,EarlyWarning!WhyReadingbytheEndofThirdGradeMatters,2010.

    13. National Center for Education Statistics, NAEP Results StateComparison,TheNationsReportCard,2011.

    14. Ibid.

    15. Ibid.

    16.TheCollegeBoard,The8thAnnualAPReportToTheNation,2012.

    17. Ibid.

    18.Doughtery,Chrys;Mellor,Lynn;andJian,Shuling;TheRelationshipBetweenAdvancedPlacementandCollegeGraduation,NationalCenterforEducationalAccountability,2006.

    19.Bryk,AnthonyS.;Sebring,PennyBender;Allensworth,Elaine;Luppescu,Stuart;andEaston,JohnQ;OrganizingSchoolsforImprovement:Lessons from Chicago, Consortium on Chicago School Research at theUniversityofChicagoUrbanEducationInstitute,2010.

    20. Ibid.

    21. National Center for Education Statistics, NAEP Results StateComparison,TheNationsReportCard,2011.AdvancedmathreferstothecoursesofAlgebraI,AlgebraIIandGeometry.

    22. Ibid.

    23. Ibid.

    24.Loveless,Tom;TheMisplacedMathStudent:LostinEighth-GradeAlgebra,TheBrownCenteronEducationPolicy,2008.

    25.Witt,Allison;Blankenberger,Bob;Franklin,Doug;andLichtenberger,ErikJ;DualCredit/DualEnrollmentandData-DrivenPolicyImplementation: Reform Initiatives and Postsecondary CredentialAttainment,IllinoisBoardofHigherEducation,IllinoisEducationResearchCouncil,2012.

    26. Ibid.

    27.TheCollegeBoard,The8thAnnualAPReportToTheNation,2012.

    28. Ibid.

    29. InternationalBaccalaureateOrganization,correspondencedatedAug.

    1,2012.

    30. TNTP, The Irreplaceables: Understanding the Real Retention Crisis inAmericasUrbanSchools,2012.

    31. Ibid.

    32. Marzano,R.J.;Waters,T.;andMcNulty,B;SchoolLeadershipthatWorksfromResearchToResults,2005.

    33.CommonCoreofData,StateNonscalPublicElementary/SecondaryEducationSurvey,201011.

    34. Ibid.

    35. IllinoisStateBoardofEducation,AnnualReport,2011.

    36.Allensworth,ElaineandEaston,JohnQ.;What MattersforStayingOnTrackandGraduatingChicagoPublicSchools,ConsortiumonChicagoSchool Research at the University of Chicago Urban Education Institute2007.

    37.Losen,DanielJ.andGillespie,Jonathan;OpportunitiesSuspended:TheDisparate Impact of Disciplinary Exclusion from School, University ofCaliforniaCenterforCivilRightsRemedies,2012.

    38. Ibid.

    39.Steinberg,MatthewP.;Allensworth,Elaine;andJohnson,DavidW.;Student and Teacher Safety in Chicago Public Schools: The Roles ofCommunity Context and School Social Organization, Consortium onChicago School Research at the University of Chicago Urban EducationInstitute,2011.

    40. Ibid.41. IllinoisStateBoardofEducationReportCard20042011;IllinoisState

    Report Card 20012003 maintained by the Center for Urban EducationLeadership,UniversityofIllinoisatChicago.

    42. Ibid.

    43.MassachusettsBusinessAllianceforEducation,EveryChildAWinner!,1991.

    44. Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education,MassachusettsCommonCoreofLearning.

    45. Massachusetts Department of Elementary and SecondaryEducation,EducationBoardAdoptsCommonCoreStandardstoKeepMassachusettsStudentsLeadersinEducation,2010.

    46. NationalCouncilonTeacherQuality,StateTeacherPolicyYearbook,2011.

    47. Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education,Overview of the New Massachusetts Educator Evaluation Framework,2011.

    48.CommonwealthofMassachusetts,SenateBill2247,2010.

    49. National Center for Education Statistics, NAEP Results StateComparison,TheNationsReportCard,19982011.

    50.TheCollegeBoard,The8thAnnualAPReportToTheNation,2012.

    51.EducationWeek,EducationCountsReferenceCenter,2009.

    Endnotes

    Embargoed until 11/13, 12:01

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    29/32advance IllInoIS |

    Prole of Illinois Education System

    1. nmb of scools i t stt. Soc: el ed: IECAM, Early Care andEducationData,2011.ISBE,2010.K12: Public and private schools:ISBE,Quickstats,2011and2009.Ct scools:ISBE,200910and201011IllinoisCharterSchoolBiennialReport,2012.Postscod(ll):IllinoisBoardofHigherEducation,Databook2011and2009.Thisnumber includes all postsecondary institutions, including those that donotofferassociateorbachelorsdegrees.

    2. Totl popltio d ollmt:The states total population of a given

    agegroup.Soc: el ed:Ages04:U.S.Census,QTP2GeographyIllinois:SingleYears,2010.PFA:ISBE,AnnualReport,2011.HeadStart(excludinghomevisiting):CLASP,IllinoisHeadStartBytheNumbers,2011and2009.HomeVisiting:State-funded:ISBE,IllinoisRacetotheTop: Early Learning Challenge application, 2011; Federally funded:CLASP,IllinoisHeadStartBytheNumbers,2011and2009.K12:200610AmericanCommunitySurveyforindividuals517,2010.Postscod:200610 American Community Survey for individuals1824,2010.

    3. Public school enrollment prole: Source: Early Ed:PFA:ISBE,2011,2009;HeadStart:CLASP,IllinoisHeadStartBytheNumbers,2011and2009.K12:Publicschools:ISBE,Quickstats,2011and2009.K12low-income,LEP,andspecialeducationpercentages:ISBEstatereportcard,2012and2010.Specialeducationfor2010:IllinoisInteractiveReportCard(IIRC).Postscod: Includesonlyundergraduateenrollment.

    Genderandrace:IllinoisBoardofHigherEducation,Databook2011and2009;Low-income:IPEDS2010.

    4. Gomt fdig p ppil: The revenue of elementary andsecondaryschoolsperpupilbyfundingsource.Forpostsecondary,thisincludesdirectfundingtoinstitutions.Soc: el ed: NIEER,TheStateofPreschool2011,2009.K12: Public Education Finances:2010,GovernmentsDivisionReports,U.S.CensusBureau,June2012.Postscod:DeltaCostProject,2010.

    5. Titio pid p ppil. Amount of tuition paid by students afteraccountingforaid.Soc: el ed:Notapplicable.K12: Notapplicable.Postscod: DeltaCostProject,2010.

    6. Istctio pdit p ppil. The institutions total spending ondirecteducationcosts.Soc: el ed: Dataunavailable. K12: Public

    EducationFinances:2010,GovernmentsDivisionReports,U.S.CensusBureau,June2012.Postscod: Ibid.

    7. Totl pdit p ppil. Soc: el ed: NIEER, The State ofPreschool,2011,2009.K12:Ibid.Postscod: Ibid.

    el edctio Idictos

    8. Cild dmosttig diss fo kidgt:ISBE,2012.

    9. at-isk cild d 3 wit ccss to pogm tt iclds omisitig: Number of home-visiting slots divided by Illinois at-riskpopulationunder3.U.S.Census,QTP2GeographyIllinois:SingleYears,2010.At-riskpopulation:OunceofPrevention.State-funded:ISBE,IllinoisRacetotheTop:EarlyLearningChallengeapplication,2011CLASP,IllinoisHeadStartBytheNumbers,2011and2009.

    10. 3--olds olld i pblicl-fdd pscool: NIEER, The State ofPreschool,2011,2009,2006and2003.IECAM,2012.

    11. 4--olds olld i pblicl-fdd pscool: Ibid.

    12. Cild sicd b licsd pogm wit tiol ccdittio:(NumberofNAEYCaccreditedslotsavailable)(TotalILpopulationof3-and4-year-oldsNumberofPFAandHeadStartslots).NAEYC.U.S.Census,QTP2GeographyIllinois:SingleYears,2010.ISBE,AnnualReport,2011.CLASP,IllinoisHeadStartBytheNumbers,2011and2009.

    13. eglis-lgg ls i ppopit pogm. DataUnavailable.Early childhood bilingual education data are collected by the state andshouldbeavailableinthefuture.Informationdoesnotexistcurrentlyabout how many early childhood bilingual students have access to

    bilingualinstructorsand/orinstruction.

    14. Highly Qualied Instructors: NIEER, The State of Preschool, 2011, 2009,2006and2003.

    15. Pct of stt-fdd pscool tcs wit biligl o eSLdosmt.ISBE,2012.

    16. Tcs dmosttig ffctiss.Dataunavailable.

    17. Miimm pogm os i stt-fdd pogms. The numbers ofhoursperdayanddaysperyearvarygreatlyacrossstateprograms.PFAprogramsarerequiredtomeet2.5hoursaday,5daysaweek,176daysayear.Rankingswereestablishedbycalculatingtheminimumrequired program hours per year in each state program and norming toIllinois2.5hours/day,176days/yearPFAschedule.NIEER,TheStateof

    Preschool,2011,2009,2006and2003.

    18. qlit of iomt.Dataunavailable.TheEarlyChildhoodEnvironment Rating Scale and Classroom Assessment Scoring Systemare two examples of tools developed to assess environments acrossdevelopmentaldomains.Nosuchassessmentcurrentlyexiststomeasurethequalityofpreschoolenvironmentsstatewide.

    19. Dlopmtl scigs:ISBE.Thisreectsthepercentof1-,2-and3-year-olds screened for motor, language and social development, animportanttooltocatchdevelopmentalproblemsearly.

    Metric DenitionsacomsCLaSP: Center for Law and Social Policy

    IeCaM: Illinois Early Childhood Asset Map

    ISBe:IllinoisBoardofEducation

    nIeer: National Institute for Early EducationResearch

    nCeS: National Center for Education Statistics

    PFa: Preschool for All (state-funded preschool)

    Pls ot: Wehavemadeeveryefforttousethemostrecentdataavailable.Dataoccasionallyislaggedhowever,when2012datawasunavailableordatacohortsneededtobekepttogetherformetricconsistency.Datasourcedatesareclearlymarkedbelow.

    mbargoed until 11/13, 12:01am

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    30/3228 | The STaTe Were In: 2012

    K12 Idictos

    20. 4th-graders procient in reading on NAEP: National Assessment ofEducationalProgress(NAEP).Low-incomeisdenedaseligibleforfreeorreduced-priceschoollunch.Soc: National Center for EducationStatistics.NAEPDataExplorer.2011,2009,2007and2003.

    21. 4th-graders procient in mathematics on NAEP. Source:Ibid. 2011,2009,2007and2003.

    22. 8th-graders procient in reading on NAEP: Source:Ibid.2011, 2009,2005and2003.

    23. 8th-graders procient in mathematics on NAEP: Source:Ibid. 2011,2009,2005and2000.

    24. 8t-gds olld i collg-tck mt. Students who take andmasterAlgebrainthe8thgradedobetterinhigh-schoolandbeyond.Dataonstudentmasterywouldbepreferable.Dataisderivedfromaself-reported survey given to students taking the NAEP grade 8 examformath.Soc: Ibid.

    25. Pctg of stdts gdtig ig scool anD dmosttigcollg diss o t lst Three sbjct bcmks o t aCT.Advance Illinois calculated this number by multiplying the mostrecently available graduation rate using the Cumulative Promotion

    Index (2009) by the percentage of students who met at least three ACTcollegereadinessbenchmarks(2012).Thegraduationrateiscalculatedby Editorial Projects in Education using the Cumulative PromotionIndex (CPI) method, which only includes students receiving a traditionaldiplomaanddoesnotcountGEDgraduates.TheCPIapproximatestheprobability that a student entering 9th grade will graduate 12th gradeontime.WevechosentheCPImethodbecauseitallowsustomoreaccuratelycomparegraduationratesacrossstates.ISBEsreportedgraduationrateusesasingle-cohortmethod.Soc:EducationWeek,EducationCountsReferenceCenter,2009,2007,2004,1999.TheACT,individualstatereports,2012,2010,2007and2003.

    26. hig-scool gdtio t. Calculated by Editorial Projects inEducationusingtheCumulativePromotionIndex(CPI)method.GraduationratesincludeonlystudentsreceivingatraditionaldiplomaanddonotcountGEDgraduates.TheCPIapproximatestheprobability

    thatastudententering9thgradewillgraduate12thgradeontime.Wechose the CPI method because it allows us to more accurately comparegraduationratesacrossstates.TheIllinoisStateBoardofEducationusesasingle-cohortmethodandreportsfour-andve-yeargraduationrates.Soc:EducationWeek, Education Counts Reference Center,2009,2007,2004and1999.

    27. Stdts dmosttig miiml tsold of collg diss o aCT.Percentage of students meeting ACTs college readiness benchmarks inall four subtests as well as the percentage of students who meet threeofthefourcollegereadinessbenchmarks.Statecomparisonsincludedonlystateswhereatleast50percentofstudentstooktheACT.Soc:ACT,individualstatereports,2012,2010,2007and2003.

    28. Stdts dmosttig wok-diss o WokKs. Illinois isone of a few states with 100 percent participation, making cross-

    statecomparisonunreliable.Soc: Illinois Interactive Report Card,2011.WorkKeysisatestadministeredbyACTandisintendedtogivestudents information about what careers they are currently preparedtopursue,basedontheirmathandreadingreadiness.Forexample,according to ACT, a student wanting to become an accountant wouldneeda6onmathanda5onreadingoutofapossible7;forapoliceofcer,its4eachformathandreading.

    29. hig scool stdts wit ccss to dcd coswok. This metricincludes students taking at least one Advanced Placement (AP) exam inhigh-school,studentsachievingascoreatleasta3outof5onatleastoneAPexam,andstudentsachievingtheInternationalBaccalaureatediploma.Soc:CollegeBoard,The8thAnnualAPReporttotheNationFebruary2012.TheIllinoissupplementtothe8thAnnualAPReport.InternationalBaccalaureatedatarequesteddirectlyfromIB.

    30. hig-scool stdts olld i dl-cdit coss. This measures thenumber of students taking courses for which they can receive both high

    schoolandpostsecondarycredit.Soc: Data requested from IllinoisStateBoardofEducation.

    31. Stdts wo pot tkig collg-d ciclm. This measureis based on self-reported data from students taking the ACT exam andandreliesuponACTsdenitionofacollege-readycurriculum.ACTdenesacorecurriculumasatleastfouryearsofEnglishandthreeyearseachofmathematics,scienceandsocialstudies.Soc: ACT,individualstatereports,2012,2010,2007and2003.

    32. High-school teachers with degrees in the same eld as their maintcig ssigmt. Teacherswhoteachineldthatis,teachthecontentareainwhichtheyarecertiedandhaveexpertisehavegreaterimpact.Thismetricnotesthepercentageofsecondaryschoolstudents taught by a teacher with an undergraduate or graduatedegreeinthesubjecttheyteach. Soc: NCES,SchoolsandStafng

    Survey,200708and200304.

    33. Tcs dmosttig ffctiss.Datanotyetavailable.

    34. Miimm istctiol os p . Amount of time on-task especiallyforat-riskstudentsmayimpactachievement.Thismetricmeasures the number of hours required by state statute to be devotedtoinstruction.Soc: Education Commission of the States, NumberofInstructionalDays/HoursintheSchoolYear, August2011.Dataunchangedsince2009.

    35. Iold Fmilis: T ti stff bilds stog tl ltiosips.(Stdt d Tc potd). Soc: Data not yet available but willbe in the future through the University of Chicago Urban EducationInstitutes research-based school surveys that will be administeredstatewidein2013.

    36. Sppoti eiomt: T scool is sf, dmdig, dsppoti. (Stdt d Tc potd). Soc: Ibid.

    37. effcti Lds: Picipls d tcs implmt sd isio fosccss. (Tc potd). Soc: Datanotyetavailable.

    38. Collboti Tcs: Tcs collbot to pomot pofssiolgowt. (Tc potd). Soc:Ibid.

    39. ambitios Istctio: Clsss cllgig d ggig (Stdtd Tc potd). Soc: Ibid.

    40. Tc ttio. Soc:Datanotyetavailable.

    41. K12 sspsio t. Soc: University of California, Los Angeles, The

    Civil Rights Project, OpportunitiesSuspended:TheDisparateImpactofDisciplinaryExclusionfromSchool,August2012.

    42. Scool coslo p K12 stdts. The American School CounselorAssociationrecommendsonecounselorforevery250students.However,thenationalaverageisonecounselorper475students.Soc: CommonCoreofData,StateNonscalPublicElementary/SecondaryEducationSurvey,201011,200809,200506and200001.

    Embargoed until 11/13, 12:01

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    31/32

  • 7/30/2019 The Advance Illinois report on Illinois schools

    32/32

    50 East Washington Street

    Suite 410

    Chicago, IL 60602

    Phone: 312-235-4531

    Fax: 312-467-1229

    www.advanceillinois.org

    About Advance Illinois

    Advance Illinois is an independent, objective voice

    to promote a public education system in Illinois

    that prepares all students to be ready for work,

    college and democratic citizenship.

    Acknowledgments

    We are grateful to The Boeing Company and the JPMorgan Chase

    Foundation, whose support made this report possible.

    We would like to acknowledge the guidance of The State Were In: 2012

    Advisory Council, a group of education experts from across the state

    who worked with us to strengthen this analysis.

    We also thank Rebecca Bunn, Bernard Cesarone, Shuwan Chiu,

    Amanda Corso, Angela Farwig, Mike Gillespie, Eric Lichtenberger and

    Matt Vanover for their expertise and guidance.

    Karisha Ewell, Lara Kattan, Dan McManus, Ani Mercedes, Stephanie

    Shear and Gabrielle Westbrook provided invaluable research and

    analysis, and we are grateful for their help.

    Lastly, we acknowledge Advance Illinois staff members Ben Boer,

    Tara Malone, Ciara Mentzer and Jim OConnor for their many efforts

    in support of The State Were In: 2012.

    KSA-Plus Communications designed this report.

    Advisory Council Members

    Al Bennett

    Roosevelt University

    Monique Chism

    Illinois State Board of Education

    Daniel Cullen

    Illinois Board of Higher Education

    Brian Durham

    Illinois Community College Board

    Pat Ford

    Steans Family Foundation

    Reyna Hernandez

    Illinois State Board of Education

    Paul Kelly

    John Hersey High School

    Emily Krone

    Consortium on Chicago School Research

    Mike McKindles

    Illinois State Board of Education

    Beverly Meek

    JPMorgan Chase Foundation

    Debbie Meisner-Bertauski

    Illinois Board of Higher Education

    Dea Meyer

    Civic Committee of the Commercial Club of

    Chicago

    Susie Morrison

    Illinois State Board of Education

    Tony Raden

    Ounce of Prevention Fund

    Elliot Regenstein

    Co-Chair, Illinois Early Learning Council

    Data, Research, and Evaluation Committee

    Ounce of Prevention Fund

    Nneka Rimmer

    Boston Consulting Group

    David Schuler

    Arlington Heights School District 214

    Sara Slaughter

    McCormick Foundation

    Harvey Smith

    Illinois Interactive Report Card

    Larry Stanton

    Independent Consultant

    Jennifer Vranek

    Education First Consulting

    Cheryl Watkins

    Pershing West Middle School

    Brad White

    Illinois Education Research Council

    Paul Zavitkovsky

    University of Illinois at Chicago