1
133 The Analysis of Infant Habituation Data Distributional Problems and Solutions William Gardner, University of Virginia The repeated measures analysis of variance is sensitive to problems concerning the distribu- tion of the residuals. These problems are pervasive in infant habituation data, but the solutions proposed in the methodological literature are usually inadequate. First, the variances of the residuals must be equal across groups. This is of particular concern in infant habituation studies, where there are often substantial differences in the variabi- lityof looking-time data at different ages. Second, the residuals are assumed to be normally distributed. The distributions of looking times, however, are always truncated at the bottom. The effects of these Violations on the repeated measures design are investigated using monte-carlo simulations reflecting distributional problems found in the analysis of real habituation data. The commonly known remedies (e.g., MANOVA) for such problems are of little help here. An alternative solution is nonparametric analysis using Efron's boot- strapping algorithm, a technique which requires no assumptions about the distributional properties of the data. Unlike classical non- parametric analyses, however, the data are not converted to ranks and no information is lost. Infant habituation data sets exhibiting non-normality and heterogeneous residual variance are reanalyzed using the bootstrapping algorithm, and the reSUlts of bootstrapped and conventional analyses are compared.

The analysis of infant habituation data distributional problems and solutions

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

133

The Analysis of Infant Habituation DataDistributional Problems and Solutions

William Gardner, University of Virginia

The repeated measures analysis of variance issensitive to problems concerning the distribu­tion of the residuals. These problems arepervasive in infant habituation data, butthe solutions proposed in the methodologicalliterature are usually inadequate. First, thevariances of the residuals must be equalacross groups. This is of particular concern ininfant habituation studies, where there areoften substantial differences in the variabi­lityof looking-time data at different ages.Second, the residuals are assumed to benormally distributed. The distributions oflooking times, however, are always truncated atthe bottom. The effects of these Violations onthe repeated measures design are investigatedusing monte-carlo simulations reflectingdistributional problems found in the analysisof real habituation data. The commonly knownremedies (e.g., MANOVA) for such problems areof little help here. An alternative solutionis nonparametric analysis using Efron's boot­strapping algorithm, a technique which requiresno assumptions about the distributionalproperties of the data. Unlike classical non­parametric analyses, however, the data are notconverted to ranks and no information islost. Infant habituation data sets exhibitingnon-normality and heterogeneous residualvariance are reanalyzed using the bootstrappingalgorithm, and the reSUlts of bootstrapped andconventional analyses are compared.